HomeMy WebLinkAboutMVP Southgate Amendment Project_USFWS Comment LetterUnited States Department of the Interior
FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE
James Martin, PhD
Chief, Gas Branch 3
Office of Energy Projects
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Washington, DC 20426
Dear James Martin:
Virginia Field Office
6669 Short Lane
Gloucester, VA 23061
December 11, 2025
Re : Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC -Mountain
Valley Pipeline Southgate Amendment
Project, Pittsylvania County, VA and
Rockingham County, NC; Docket No. CP25-
60-000, § 375.308(x); Project# 2025-0003478
and 2025-0003471
On November 20, 2025, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) sent a letter to the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) reinitiating consultation under the Endangered Species Act (16 USC
1536), as amended, for the referenced project. Reinitiation was requested due to the time elapsed since
the consultation on the original project, Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC (Mountain Valley) Southgate
Project 1, and modifications proposed in the MVP Southgate Amendment Project (Amendment Project).
Currently pending before FERC is Mountain Valley's request that FERC issue an Order amending the
Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity for the Southgate Project and authorizing the
Amendment Project. The Amendment Project is the construction and operation of an approximately
31.3-mile, 30-inch-diameter natural gas pipeline from Pittsylvania County, Virginia, to Rockingham
County, North Carolina. Mountain Valley also proposes to construct, operate, and maintain access roads
and aboveground facilities.
FERC provided Section 7 determinations for federally listed species and critical habitat in their
Environmental Assessment (EA), issued October 3, 2025, and November 20, 2025 letter. In their
November 20, 2025 letter, FERC requested concurrence on their effects determinations for federally
listed species and critical habitat. To assist with our evaluation of the determinations, the Service is
providing a list of recommendations and information/data needs below.
1. Mountain Valley indicated that they would implement a large number of conservation measures
to avoid and minimize potential impacts to waterbodies, wetlands, riparian habitats, federally
listed bats, federally listed aquatic species , and critical habitat from the Amendment Project in
their Biological Assessment for the MVP Southgate Amendment Project. Not all of these
1 On June 18, 2020, FERC authorized the Southgate Project. Since then, the Service listed new species, designated critical
habitat, and changed listing status of another species, which are triggers for reinitiation (50 CFR 402.16).
conservation measures are referenced or incorporated in the EA. Please clarify which of
Mountain Valley's conservation measures FERC intends to impose as conditions of its Order and
authorization for the Amendment Project. (The Service understands that MVP intends to
implement all of its conservation measures regardless of whether those conservation measures
are required by FERC.)
2. The Dan River and Cascade Creek are proposed to be crossed using the horizontal directional
drilling method. Please provide information on the risk of inadvertent return of drilling fluids
within the waterbodies at these sites.
3. Please provide a description of water withdrawals for the horizontal directional drilling
operations at Dan River and Cascade Creek and any conservation measures to avoid or minimize
impacts associated with this activity, along with an analysis of effects of this proposed activity
on each federally listed species and critical habitat.
4 . The rationale provided in the EA and the November 20, 2025 letter for the Section 7
determination regarding Atlantic pigtoe (Fusconaia masoni) critical habitat does not fully
address potential impacts to the four physical or biological features identified in the final critical
habitat rule (see 86 FR 64000). Please provide additional explanation to support the
determination.
5. In a February 7, 2025 letter that the Service sent to Mountain Valley, the Service noted that
northern long-eared bat presence would be assumed from milepost 5.7 to 7.9 because the project
intersects the 1.5-mile inner tier of a post-white-nose syndrome acoustic detection of the species.
FERC's EA, however, incorrectly identifies the inner tier as extending only from milepost 5 .7 to
7.8. We recommend that FERC correct this information and the associated conservation
measures to accurately reflect the assumed presence of the northern long-eared bat within the
action area (i.e., milepost 5.7 to 7.9).
The Service requests that all responses to recommendations and requests for information/data be
provided to:
Jennifer Stanhope
Fish and Wildlife Biologist
Virginia Ecological Services
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
6669 Short Lane
Gloucester, VA 23061
Phone (804) 905-9781
jennifer stanhope(a),fws.gov
Kathy Matthews
Fish and Wildlife Biologist
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Raleigh Ecological Services
3916 Sunset Ridge Rd.
Raleigh, NC 27607
Phone 984-308-0852
kathryn matth ews(a),fws .gov
2
If you have any questions regarding this request, please contact Jennifer Stanhope of this office at (804)
804-905-9781 or Jennifer_ stanhope@fws.gov .
Sincerely,
6'"1111 ~
Troy Andersen
Field Supervisor
Virginia Ecological Services
~Slk
-to l' Jennifer Archambault, PhD
Acting Field Supervisor
Raleigh Ecological Services
cc: FERC, Washington, DC (Attn: Olivia Yu)
U.S. Corps of Engineer, Norfolk, VA (Attn: Steven VanderPloeg)
U.S. Corps of Engineer, Wilmington, NC (Attn: Richard Harmon)
VDWR, Richmond, VA (Attn: Hannah Schul)
VDCR-DNH, Richmond, VA (Attn: Rene' Hypes)
NCWRC, Raleigh, NC (Attn: Olivia Munzer)
NCDWR, Raleigh, NC (Attn: Paul Wojoski)
MVP, Pittsburgh, PA (Attn: Cory Chalmers)
MVP, Pittsburgh, PA (Attn: Megan Neylon)
3