Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNCWRC Comments - MVP Southgate IP - Rockingham Co North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission M. Kyle Briggs, Executive Director Mailing Address: Habitat Conservation • 1721 Mail Service Center • Raleigh, NC 27699-1721 Telephone: (919) 707-0220 • Fax: (919) 707-0028 Via email 12 September 2025 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC Attn: Mr. Jeffrey Klinefelter 2200 Energy Drive Canonsburg, PA 15317 SUBJECT: Individual Permit Application for the Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC – MVP Southgate Amendment Project in Rockingham County, North Carolina. NCDEQ No. 20181638v4. Dear Mr. Klinefelter, Biologists with the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission (NCWRC) have reviewed the subject document. Comments are provided in accordance with provisions of the Clean Water Act of 1977 (as amended) and Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Wildlife Coordination Act (48 Stat. 401, as amended; 16 U.S.C. 661 et seq.). On behalf of Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC (MVP), BMCD EGS, P.C. has submitted an Individual Permit Application (IP) for the MVP Southgate Amendment Project (Project) that runs from the Virginia border to interconnect points south of the Dan River in Rockingham County, North Carolina. The NCWRC provided an environmental review (14 February 2025) of the Project in which we submitted preliminary comments (attached). In addition to those comments, the NCWRC offers the following comments and/or recommendations: 1.We have concerns about the increase in environmental disturbance to aquatic and terrestrial resources because of overlapping or similar construction periods and locations with other pipeline projects. Impacts include increased sedimentation, turbidity, erosion and the disruption of wildlife behavior due to noise, lights, pollution, water withdrawal, and habitat loss. 2.We understand that MVP has minimized its effects to forested areas to the extent practicable (Section 4.4.1); however, we recommend aligning the pipeline and/or roads in some locations to further minimize forest fragmentation, specifically riparian forests, with the highest areas of concern noted below. a.Figure 3: Detailed Map, Page 63, CL-063 – Consider moving the extended workspace near NC Highway 70 into the pasture/existing ROW. 12 September 2025 Page 2 NCWRC Comments MVP Southgate Rockingham County b. Figure 3: Detailed Map, pg. 68, CL-068– Consider moving the workspace adjacent to W- B052a (crossing #094) to outside the riparian forested area, or if possible, into the existing ROW. c. Figure 3: Detailed Map, pg. 69, CL-069– Consider moving the workspace adjacent to S- B008 on the other side of the pipeline ROW. We also recommend moving the pipeline ROW closer to the existing ROW to minimize the area of forest that will be fragmented. d. We recommend co-locating the road (TA-RO-080A) and ROW, if possible. 3. Clearly mark wetlands that will be avoided to prevent accidental impacts by construction crews. Conduct manual clearing of vegetation in wetlands and disallow the use of heavy, tracked equipment. Leave vegetation where it falls rather than using heavy equipment to remove trees and other downed vegetation, which can further damage wetlands. Clearly mark the boundary for hand clearing. 4. Section 4.4.13 Water Quality: We have concerns with the potential water quality impacts associated with the in-stream construction. MVP cites literature indicating that the increased sedimentation from open-cut crossings would be “mostly” short-term and remain near the crossing location (i.e., a few hundred feet); however, many of these streams have already or will be impacted by other pipeline projects. Extensive research has been conducted on the negative impacts of sediment and turbidity on aquatic resources, including various time scales and extent of impacts. Impacts on aquatic species include habitat degradation, suffocation of eggs, respiratory and physiological stress, clogging of gills, and reduced food sources. To minimize impacts on aquatic species, particularly with threatened and endangered species downstream of some crossings, we recommend at least the following: a. Open-trench crossings have been found to increase the likelihood for future lateral movement of the stream (which could undercut or erode around the utility line), and the correction of such problems could result in costly future maintenance and devastating impacts to natural resources. Therefore, as much work as possible should be accomplished in the dry, and the amount of disturbance should not exceed what can be successfully stabilized by the end of the workday. In-stream work should consider forecasted high-flow events. b. Erosion and sediment control measures should conform to the High Quality Water Zones standards stipulated in the NC Department of Environmental Quality Erosion and Sediment Control Plan (https://deq.nc.gov/about/divisions/energy-mineral-land- resources/energy-mineral-land-permit-guidance/erosion-sediment-control-planning- design-manual). Sediment and erosion control measures should use advanced methods and installed prior to any land-disturbing activity. c. The natural dimension, pattern, and profile of the streams above and below the stream crossing should not be modified, including the width and depth of the stream channel. Consider using state-of-the-art natural channel design and restoration techniques, including instream structures to minimize bank erosion. We prefer natural materials such as coir fiber rolls, biodegradable erosion-control blankets, and vegetation instead of riprap where practical. d. Monitoring is recommended to ensure successful channel and bank stabilization and vegetation growth, especially since state and federal threatened and endangered species occur in the project area. Native vegetation and bioengineered structures should be used for stream stabilization where possible. Invasive species control should occur regularly, 12 September 2025 Page 3 NCWRC Comments MVP Southgate Rockingham County including prior to construction if present. Invasive species outcompete native plants and provide minimal benefit to wildlife. Monitoring the site should occur once per year during the growing season for three years or three bankfull events. 5. Tricolored bats (Perimyotis subflavus) are documented in Rockingham County. Tricolored bats are a state endangered species. Therefore, we recommend not clearing trees during critical periods of vulnerability for bats, specifically pup rearing months (April 15-July 31) but also the coldest days within the winter months (December 15 to February 14). 6. MVP intends to withdraw 1,853,000 gallons of water from the Dan River. The following are comments on the water withdrawal: a. The water intake screen system must be incorporated into the intake design to minimize entrainment and impingement of eggs, larvae, and juveniles. This includes a maximum intake velocity of 0.25 ft/sec through a mesh or slotted surface with openings not to exceed 1.0 millimeter. Methodology to clean the screen system must also be designed and discussed to minimize impacts to eggs, larvae, and juveniles. b. The intake structure should be marked in a manner that will reduce hazards to navigation. c. Water withdrawals should occur in the winter months and especially not from April-July or if there is a drought. The maximum withdrawal amount from any stream is 20% of the 7Q10 flow. For the Dan River, the NCWRC estimated that 20% of the 7Q10 for the Dan is about 14.9 cfs (9.6 million gallons per day). 7. We appreciate MVP minimizing the degradation of habitat by implementing invasive species management practices by revegetating disturbed areas with weed-free seed mixes (Section 4.3.26). Please ensure those seed mixes are of native species found within Rockingham County. This should include the replacement of native vegetation not only in riparian and wetland areas, but also upland areas in areas not bound by agreements with landowners. Use a grain, such as oats, wheat, or rye for temporary cover and native seed mixes for permeant seeding throughout the project. We recommend integrating some flowering herbaceous species (i.e., goldenrod, tickseed, and beebalm) to create pollinator habitat within the project boundary. Please note that we do not recommend seeding with tall fescue, Kobe lespedeza, sericea lespedeza, Sudangrass or Kentucky bluegrass even though NC Department of Environmental Quality has these species on their seeding specifications. 8. Erosion control matting made of plastic mesh or twine should not be used in the project area, including in uplands, because it can injure or kill wildlife. If I can provide further assistance, please call (336) 269-0074 or email Olivia.munzer@ncwildlife.gov. Sincerely, Olivia Munzer Western Piedmont Habitat Conservation Coordinator Habitat Conservation Program 12 September 2025 Page 4 NCWRC Comments MVP Southgate Rockingham County Ec: Sue Homewood, NCDWR Dicky Harmon, USACE Vann Stancil, NCWRC John Tessier, NextEra Energy Lori Ferry, Burns & McDonnell North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission M. Kyle Briggs, Executive Director Mailing Address: Habitat Conservation • 1721 Mail Service Center • Raleigh, NC 27699-1721 Telephone: (919) 707-0220 • Fax: (919) 707-0028 Via email 14 February 2025 Ms. Lori Ferry BMCD EGS, P.C. 1431 Opus Place, Suite 400 Downers Grove, IL 60515 SUBJECT: Environmental Review for the Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC – MVP Southgate Amendment Project in Rockingham County, North Carolina. Dear Ms. Ferry, Biologists with the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission (NCWRC) have reviewed the subject document. Comments are provided in accordance with provisions of the Clean Water Act of 1977 (as amended) and Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act Wildlife Coordination Act (48 Stat. 401, as amended; 16 U.S.C. 661 et seq.). On behalf of Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC, BMCD EGS, P.C. is requesting information on the potential impacts to threatened and endangered species and critical habitats from the MVP Southgate Amendment Project in Rockingham County. The MVP Amendment project will cross the Dan River, Cascade Creek, Dry Creek, Rock Creek and potentially Machine Creek and/or other unnamed tributaries in the Roanoke River Basin in North Carolina. As listed in the NC Natural Heritage Program database (NHP), several federal and state listed rare, threatened, and endangered species occur within the federal action areas, as well as Natural Heritage natural areas, managed areas, and natural communities; the NCWRC shares all its occurrence data with the NHP. The lack of records from the site does not imply or confirm the absence of federal or state-listed species. An on-site survey is the only means to determine if the proposed project may impact federal or state rare, threatened, or endangered species. We offer the following preliminary recommendations to minimize impacts on aquatic and terrestrial wildlife resources: 1.Aquatic species surveys are not necessary because recent surveys have documented state and federally listed species, specifically in the Dan River and Cascade Creek. However, we 14 February 2025 Page 2 NCWRC Comments MVP Southgate Rockingham County recommend directional drilling for the stream crossings, especially Dan River and Cascade Creek, to minimize potential impacts to state and federal rare, threatened, and endangered aquatic species. Any activities within these streams should be avoided from spring to early summer (April-July), including water withdrawals. 2. To minimize impacts to all tree-roosting bat species, we recommend not clearing trees during the coldest winter months (December 15 to February 14) and pup rearing months (April 15-July 31). Tricolored bats are known to roost in culverts and in bridges, including in the winter in the Piedmont of North Carolina. Therefore, any existing culverts greater than 3 feet wide and bridges within or adjacent to the project should be surveyed for bats within 15 days of construction. Surveys should be conducted in accordance with the National White-nose Syndrome Decontamination Protocol and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Range-wide Indiana Bat & Northern Long-Eared Bat Survey Guidelines. If culverts surveys are negative and construction in or around culverts may continue into winter, we recommend immediately screening the culverts to prevent bats from potentially using the culvert as a hibernaculum. 3. The work area and equipment should remain outside the riparian buffer. If the riparian buffers are disturbed, we recommend replanting the riparian areas with native vegetation. Disturbed stream banks and wetlands should be restored to original contours and re-vegetated with native plant materials. 4. Maintain or establish a minimum 100-foot native, undisturbed forested buffer along each side of perennial streams and 50-foot native, undisturbed forested buffer along each side of intermittent streams and wetlands. Forested riparian buffers protect water quality by stabilizing stream banks and filtering stormwater runoff. 5. We recommend directional drilling at large, perennial streams and streams with listed aquatic species, such as the Dan River and Cascade Creek. If open-trench crossings are determined to be the only viable method to cross perennial streams, every effort should be made to ensure that impacts to in-stream features are minimized and stable upon completion of the project. Overall, open-trench crossings have been found to increase the likelihood for future lateral movement of the stream (which could undercut or erode around the utility line), and the correction of such problems could result in costly future maintenance and devastating impacts to natural resources. Therefore, as much work as possible should be accomplished in the dry, and the amount of disturbance should not exceed what can be successfully stabilized by the end of the workday. In- stream work should consider forecasted high-flow events. Stream crossings should be near perpendicular (75⁰ to 105⁰) to stream flow and should be monitored at least every three months for maintenance needs during the first 24 months and then annually thereafter. 6. Trenches left open during project construction can trap or injure wildlife. We recommend closing trenches at the end of each day or conducting sweeps of trenches to clear wildlife at least once in the morning prior to construction. 7. Non-native plants should not be used for seeding disturbed areas. Specifically, avoid using Bermudagrass, redtop, tall fescue, and lespedeza, which are invasive and/or non-native. A list of alternatives to non-native species has been attached. Alternatively, use grains, such as oats, wheat, or rye for temporary cover and native seed mixes for permeant seeding. We recommend planting native, wildflower seed mixes that will create pollinator habitat within the project boundary. 8. Erosion control matting made of plastic mesh or twine should not be used throughout the project area because it can injure or kill wildlife. 14 February 2025 Page 3 NCWRC Comments MVP Southgate Rockingham County Thank you for the opportunity to provide input during the early stages of this project. If I can provide further assistance, please call (336) 269-0074 or email olivia.munzer@ncwildlife.org. Sincerely, Olivia Munzer Western Piedmont Habitat Conservation Coordinator Habitat Conservation Program Ec: John Tessier, NextEra. Cory Chambers, EQT Vann Stancil, NCWRC Thomas Russ, NCWRC Byron Hamstead, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service RECOMMENDED NATIVE ALTERNATIVES FOR NON-NATIVE GRASSES IN NORTH CAROLINA** (Species are appropriate for all geographic regions unless otherwise indicated) NON-NATIVE SPECIES NATIVE SPECIES Big bluestem Andropogon gerardii Little bluestem Schizachyrium scoparium Indiangrass Sorghastrum nutans Crownvetch Switchgrass Panicum virgatum Centipede Beaked panicgrass Panicum anceps Bermuda Purpletop Tridens flavus Roundheaded bushclover Lespedeza capitata Deer tongue Dicanthelium clandestinum Sensitive partridge pea Chamaecrista nictitans Partridge pea Chamaecrista fasciculata Big bluestem Andropogon gerardii Little bluestem Schizachyrium scoparium Indiangrass Sorghastrum nutans Switchgrass Panicum virgatum Kentucky bluegrass Beaked panicgrass Panicum anceps Tall fescue Purpletop Tridens flavus Sudangrass Broomsedge Andropogon virginicus Deer tongue Dicanthelium clandestinum Canadian wildrye Elymus canadensis Virginia wildrye Elymus virginicus Sensitive partridge pea Chamaecrista nictitans Partridge pea Chamaecrista fasciculata Switchgrass Panicum virgatum Splitbeard bluestem Andropogon ternarius Sericea lespedeza Beggarlice Desmodium spp. Kobe lespedeza Deer tongue Dicanthelium clandestinum Sensitive partridge pea Chamaecrista nictitans Partridge pea Chamaecrista fasciculata NC Native Plant Recommendations **A recommended revegetation/stabilization mix would ideally include a combination of the species listed in this table. In addition, please note that additional consideration may be needed in areas that are (highly) erodible and/or have sloped terrain. The following species could be included in all regions for additional stabilization and wildlife benefit: Black-eyed susan: Rudbeckia hirta Plains coreopsis: Coreopsis tinctoria Lance-leaved coreopsis: Coreopsis lanceolata Narrow-leaved sunflower: Helianthus angustifolius Created October 2018