Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNCDEQ_AddInfoRequest2-Letter Response 09.12.2025September 12, 2025 Samantha Wooten 401 & Buffer Permitting Branch North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality Division of Water Resources 512 North Salisbury Street Raleigh, NC 27699 RE: Response to North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality Request for Additional Information Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC – MVP Southgate Amendment Project DWR #20181638 v4 Dear Ms. Wooten: Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC (Mountain Valley) submits the enclosed responses to the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), Division of Water Resources (Division) Request for Additional Information dated 21 August 2025 regarding the Individual Water Quality Certification Application for the MVP Southgate Amendment Project. Division Information Request No. 1: The Division received a comment expressing concern over the potential for pollutants to be discharged to surface waters from the hydrostatic testing of the pipeline. Please provide any historical testing documentation or studies to address this concern. [15A NCAC 02H .0506(b)(3)] Mountain Valley Response to Information Request No. 1: Hydrostatic test water will be utilized to test only new or cleaned and certified PCB-free pipe. If chemical methods are used to clean pipes, chemical-laden water would be collected and disposed of at an approved waste facility. Mountain Valley will adhere with the sampling and monitoring requirements of representative North Carolina NPDES individual permits that include provisions addressing hydrostatic test water discharges. This includes sampling the water for Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons, Oil and Grease, Total Organic Carbon, Total Suspended Solids, pH, Turbidity, and Total Residual Chlorine prior to discharge. If Mountain Valley utilizes an approved waste facilty for disposal of hydrostatic test water, it will adhere to the sampling requirements imposed by that facility. To minimize environmental impacts during hydrostatic testing of pipeline segments, discharge water will be managed to avoid direct release into surface waterbodies. All dewatering activities associated with hydrostatic water will occur through the use of a dewatering structure which will be constructed in a stabilized, well vegetated area, away from waterbodies and wetlands, and sized according to the intended use. Discharge activities will be carefully monitored to prevent erosion and flows into any waterbody. If a surface water discharge is unavoidable, Mountain Valley will apply for a discharge permit prior to discharging hydrostatic test water. The test water will be collected and routed to upland areas with sufficient infiltration capacity, utilizing temporary containment structures and energy dissipation devices to prevent erosion. Discharge will occur over vegetated surfaces to promote natural filtration, and sediment control measures such as silt fences and straw wattles will be installed as needed. Division Information Request No. 2: The Division received numerous comments expressing concern over potential sedimentation and turbidity from the construction of the pipeline. In particular, the concerns note that most of the proposed stream crossings within the project limits are on unnamed tributaries that drain to the Dan River. As noted in the application, the Dan River supports multiple federal and state species of concern. The Division recognizes that the Division of Energy, Mineral and Land Resources (DEMLR) will review and approve the Sediment and Erosion Control Plan for the proposed project. Please identify any construction sequencing, or additional measures you will employ above the minimum requirements to address this concern. [15A NCAC 02H .0506(b)(3)] Mountain Valley Response to Information Request No. 2: In addition to implementing the controls outlined in the North Carolina Erosion and Sediment Control Planning and Design Manual, other sequencing and construction methods will be applied to further protect aquatic resources. For every waterbody, a buffer will be added to both sides of each crossing to ensure that any transitional area is also treated as an environmentally sensitive area. Buffers will extend 50 feet where possible, or as far as topographic conditions permit, along the right-of-way from where the trench centerline enters the waterbody. Also, to minimize impacts to waterbody crossings, they will be treated as separate construction entities, except during clearing activities, and efforts will be made to cross these areas during low flow conditions. Once grubbing and grading starts at a waterbody crossing, it will be actively conducted for consecutive days until the crossing is completed and the work area restored. And finally, both the Dan River and Cascade Creek mainstems will be crossed using trenchless construction methods to avoid impacts to protected species. Division Information Request No. 3: The Division received numerous comments expressing concern over potential sedimentation and turbidity during construction of the pipeline when considered as a cumulative impact with other proposed pipeline construction projects within the same watersheds. In particular, the concerns note that most of the proposed stream crossings within the project limits are proposed to be impacted by the adjacent Transco SSEP project which appears to have a similar or overlapping proposed construction schedule. A secondary and cumulative analysis was provided with the application materials, however it is based on “post construction” long term impacts to the watershed and does not address the very specific concerns submitted to the Division regarding cumulative impacts during construction. Please provide a response to this concern. [15A NCAC 02H .0506(b)(3)] Mountain Valley Response to Information Request No. 3: The “overlapping” construction schedules for the Amendment Project and SSEP do not present a material risk of cumulative impacts to streams crossed by both projects. The dry ditch, open cut crossing method is a mature practice. Instream impacts from the use of this crossing method are generally limited in both duration and area.1 The primary effects associated with temporary instream work—increases in suspended particulates and turbidity levels—generally dissipate within one to four days. Suspended particulate and turbidity levels in the water column attenuate not only with time but also with distance. Elevated suspended particulate and turbidity levels in the water column tend to approach background levels within a few hundred feet downstream of a crossing. To create the potential for additive, synergistic, antagonistic, or other cumulative effects on water quality in a stream crossed by both projects, the parties’ respective crossings would have to be completed roughly contemporaneously (within the span of a few days) and at locations no more than a few hundred stream-feet apart. That scenario is highly unlikely. First, many of the projects’ crossings of common streams are much farther apart. Second, the instream work for an open cut crossing typically lasts from 1 to 7 days, and these crossings will be installed over the course of approximately one year. Even if the overall construction schedules align, it is very unlikely that the Amendment Project and SSEP will happen to cross the same stream at the same time. In the unlikely event that Amendment Project and SSEP commence open cut crossings of a single stream at the same time, the magnitude of the potentially “cumulative” short-term effect on water quality will be minimal. The increase in turbidity levels downstream from an open cut crossing are “small and considered to be minimal compared to increased turbidity associated with natural runoff events.”2 Given that the increase in turbidity levels downstream from a single open cut crossing would be less than the increase that would be expected from a natural runoff event, and given the wide range of storm intensities that cause runoff events, it is reasonable to conclude that the additive effect of two open cut crossings would not be produce turbidity levels that are outside the wide range of natural variability. Furthermore, the projects’ respective crossing points are never less than 70 feet apart, meaning that the magnitude of turbidity increases from the upstream crossing would be attenuated to some degree before they could combine with increases from the downstream crossing. Lastly, it is important to bear in mind that even the “worst-case” conditions resulting from simultaneous crossings of the same stream would return to normal within one to four days. Nevertheless, Mountain Valley is coordinating with Transco to minimize the potential for cumulative impacts and other issues during construction. Mountain Valley will implement the following measures for this purpose: 1. Construction Scheduling Coordination Mountain Valley is actively coordinating with the Transco SSEP project team to coordinate and stagger construction activities within shared workspaces. Where practicable, Mountain Valley and Transco may utilize the same crew to perform certain work activities for both projects in areas that utilize the same workspaces. This approach is intended to minimize simultaneous earth-disturbing activities in close proximity, thereby reducing the potential for compounded sedimentation and turbidity impacts to aquatic resources. 1Refer to Sections 4.4.13 and 5.1.13 of Mountain Valley’s Joint Permit Application and the sources cited therein. 2 FERC, 2020 FEIS at 4-92. 2. Enhanced Erosion and Sediment Controls (ESCs) In addition to the measures outlined in the Question #2 response, Mountain Valley will deploy enhanced ESCs at stream crossings and sensitive areas, including: a. Reinforced or enhanced ESCs, where appropriate. For example, super silt fence or triple-stack compost filter sock; b. Temporary sediment basins; c. Rapid stabilization techniques (e.g., hydroseeding, erosion control blankets). These measures will be maintained and monitored throughout construction to ensure effectiveness. 3. Contingency Planning and Adaptive Management Mountain Valley will be prepared to deploy supplemental ESC measures and implement temporary work stoppages if cumulative impacts are observed. Adaptive management strategies will be employed based on field conditions. 4. Agency Coordination and Reporting Mountain Valley will provide regular updates to the Division on construction progress and ESC performance. This will include documentation of coordination efforts with the Transco SSEP project to demonstrate proactive management of cumulative impacts. We are committed to minimizing environmental impacts during construction and ensuring that cumulative effects are effectively managed through coordination, monitoring, and adaptive mitigation strategies. *** Mountain Valley appreciates the opportunity to provide this additional information and looks forward to continuing to work with DEQ regarding the Project. Sincerely, Jeffrey Klinefelter Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC cc: Dicky Harmon, USACE Raleigh Regulatory Field Office Olivia Munzer, NCWRC DWR WSRO DWR 401 & Buffer Permitting Branch File John Tessier, Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC Cory Chalmers, Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC Lori Ferry, Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc. Christian King, Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc.