HomeMy WebLinkAbout20181638 Ver 4_MVP Southgate Amendment-JPA Narrative_April2025_20250530MOUNTAIN VALLEY PIPELINE, LLC
MVP SOUTHGATE
AMENDMENT PROJECT
INDIVIDUAL PERMIT APPLICATION
PREPARED FOR:
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
2200 Energy Drive, Canonsburg, PA 15317
SUBMITTED TO:
United States Army Corps of Engineers —Wilmington District
69 Darlington Ave, Wilmington, NC 28403
United States Army Corps of Engineers — Norfolk District
803 Front Street, Norfolk, VA 23510
Virginia Marine Resources Commission
380 Fenwick Road, Fort Monroe, VA 23651
Virginia Department of Environmental Quality
1111 E Main Street, Richmond, VA 23219
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
217 West Jones Street, Raleigh, NC 27603
APRI L 2025
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
CONTENTS
1.0 PROJECT INFORMATION.......................................................................1-1
1.1 PRELIMINARY JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION AND
USACE INDIVIDUAL PERMIT APPLICATION FORMS ...........................1-1
1.2 AMENDMENT PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND HISTORY .......................1-1
1.3 GENERAL CONSTRUCTION INFORMATION.........................................1-3
1.3.1 Pipeline Construction Description............................................................... 1-3
1.3.2 Access Road Construction Description...................................................... 1-4
1.4 AMENDMENT PROJECT LOCATION.....................................................1-4
1.5 WATERSHEDS AND HYDROLOGIC UNIT CODES................................1-4
1.6 PROPERTY OWNERS.............................................................................1-5
1.7 DIRECTIONS TO SITE.............................................................................1-5
1.8 AMENDMENT PROJECT AUTHORIZATIONS........................................1-7
1.8.1 Authorizations and Approvals..................................................................... 1-7
1.8.2 Clean Water Act § 401 Water Quality Certification ..................................... 1-7
1.8.3 National Historic Preservation Act § 106 Consultation ............................... 1-7
1.8.4 Endangered Species Act § 7 Consultation ................................................. 1-8
1.8.5 Inapplicable Authorizations and Approvals ................................................. 1-8
1.9 AMENDMENT PROJECT SCHEDULE....................................................1-9
2.0 AMENDMENT PROJECT PURPOSE AND NEED...................................2-1
2.1 BASIC AMENDMENT PROJECT PURPOSE..........................................2-1
2.2 OVERALL AMENDMENT PROJECT PURPOSE.....................................2-1
2.3 OVERALL AMENDMENT PROJECT NEED............................................2-1
3.0 ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS....................................................................3-1
3.1 FERC'S NEPA DOCUMENT....................................................................3-1
3.2 ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS....................................................................3-2
3.2.1 No Action (No Build) Alternative................................................................. 3-3
3.2.2 No Action (No Permit) Alternative............................................................... 3-4
3.2.3 Natural Gas Transportation Method Alternatives Analysis ......................... 3-5
3.2.4 System Alternatives.................................................................................... 3-6
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
3.2.5 Route Alternatives...................................................................................... 3-8
4.0 AFFECTED ENVIRONMENT AND ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
FACTORS.................................................................................................4-1
4.1 PROPOSED AQUATIC IMPACTS............................................................4-1
4.1.1 Jurisdictional Impacts................................................................................. 4-1
4.1.2 Section 10 Waters...................................................................................... 4-1
4.1.3 Wetland Delineation and Stream Identification ........................................... 4-1
4.1.4 Water Withdrawals..................................................................................... 4-2
4.2 SENSITIVE STREAM RESOURCES........................................................4-2
4.2.1 National Wild and Scenic Rivers................................................................
4-2
4.2.2 Tier 3 Protection.........................................................................................
4-2
4.2.3 Trout Waters...............................................................................................
4-2
4.2.4 Warmwater Fishery....................................................................................
4-3
4.2.5 Anadromous Fish Use Areas......................................................................
4-3
4.2.6 Aquatic Life Movements.............................................................................
4-3
4.2.7 Spawning Areas.........................................................................................
4-3
4.2.8 Submerged Aquatic Vegetation..................................................................
4-4
4.2.9 Freshwater Mussels...................................................................................
4-4
4.2.10 Designated Critical Resource Waters .............................................
4-5
4.3 404(B)(1) GUIDELINES TECHNICAL EVALUATION FACTORS
............ 4-5
4.3.1 Substrate (§ 230.20)...................................................................................
4-5
4.3.2 Suspended Particles/Turbidity (§ 230.21)..................................................
4-5
4.3.3 Water (§ 230.22).........................................................................................
4-5
4.3.4 Current Patterns and Water Circulation (§ 230.23)....................................
4-5
4.3.5 Normal Water Fluctuations (§ 230.24)........................................................
4-6
4.3.6 Salinity Gradients (§ 230.25)......................................................................
4-6
4.3.7 Threatened and Endangered Species § (230.30)......................................
4-6
4.3.8 Fish, Crustaceans, Mollusks, and Other Aquatic Organisms in
Food Web (§ 230.31)..................................................................................
4-6
4.3.9 Other Wildlife (§ 230.32).............................................................................
4-6
4.3.10 Sanctuaries and Refuges (§ 230.40)..............................................
4-6
4.3.11 Wetlands (§ 230.41).......................................................................
4-7
4.3.12 Mud Flats (§ 230.42).......................................................................
4-7
4.3.13 Vegetated Shallows (§ 230.43).......................................................
4-7
4.3.14 Riffle and Pool Complexes (§ 230.45)............................................
4-7
4.3.15 Municipal and Private Water Supplies (§ 230.50)...........................
4-8
4.3.16 Recreational and Commercial Fisheries (§ 230.51)........................
4-9
4.3.17 Water -Related Recreation (§ 230.52).............................................
4-9
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
4.3.18 Aesthetics (§ 230.53)......................................................................
4-9
4.3.19 Parks, National and Historical Monuments, National
Seashores, Wilderness Areas, Research Sites and Similar
Preserves (§ 230.54)..................................................................................
4-9
4.3.20 General Evaluation of Dredged or Fill Material (§§ 230.60,
230.61).......................................................................................................
4-9
4.3.21 Actions concerning the location of the discharge (§ 230.70) ........
4-10
4.3.22 Actions concerning the material to be discharged (§
230.71).....................................................................................................
4-10
4.3.23 Actions controlling the material after discharge (§ 230.72)...........
4-10
4.3.24 Actions affecting the method of dispersion (§ 230.73)..................
4-10
4.3.25 Actions related to technology (§ 230.74)......................................
4-10
4.3.26 Actions affecting plant and animal populations (§ 230.74) ...........
4-10
4.3.27 Actions affecting human use (§ 230.76).......................................
4-11
4.3.28 Other actions (§ 230.77)...............................................................
4-11
4.4 PUBLIC -INTEREST REVIEW FACTORS...............................................4-11
4.4.1 Conservation (§ 320.4(a)).........................................................................
4-11
4.4.2 Economics (§ 320.4(a))............................................................................
4-11
4.4.3 Aesthetics (§ 320.4(a)).............................................................................
4-12
4.4.4 General Environmental Concerns (§ 320.4(a)).........................................
4-12
4.4.5 Wetlands (§ 320.4(a) & (b))......................................................................
4-12
4.4.6 Historic, Cultural, Scenic, and Recreational Values (§ 320.4(a) &
(e)) 4-13
4.4.7 Fish and Wildlife Values (§ 320.4(a) &(c))...............................................
4-13
4.4.8 Floodplain Hazards, Values, and Management (§ 320.4(a) & (1)) ............
4-14
4.4.9 Land Use (§ 320.4(a))..............................................................................
4-14
4.4.10 Navigation (§ 320.4(a) & (o))........................................................
4-14
4.4.11 Shore Erosion and Accretion (§ 320.4(a))....................................
4-14
4.4.12 Water Supply and Conservation (§ 320.4(a) & (m))......................
4-14
4.4.13 Water Quality (§ 320.4(a) &(d))....................................................
4-15
4.4.14 Energy Needs, Energy Conservation and Development (§
320.4(a) & (n))..........................................................................................
4-16
4.4.15 Safety (§ 320.4(a))........................................................................
4-16
4.4.16 Food and Fiber Production (§ 320.4(a))........................................
4-16
4.4.17 Mineral Needs (§ 320.4(a))...........................................................4-16
4.4.18 Consideration of Property Ownership (§ 320.4(a) & (g)) ..............
4-16
4.4.19 Needs and Welfare of the People (§ 320.4(a)) .............................
4-17
4.4.20 Effects on Limits of the Territorial Sea (§ 320.4(f)) .......................
4-17
4.4.21 Activities Affecting Coastal Zones (§ 320.4(h)).............................
4-17
4.4.22 Activities in Marine Sanctuaries (§ 320.4(h))................................
4-17
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
4.4.23 Other Federal, State, or Local Requirements (§ 320.4(j))............. 4-17
4.4.24 Safety of Impoundment Structures (§ 320.4(k))............................ 4-17
4.4.25 Environmental Benefits (§ 320.4(p))............................................. 4-17
4.4.26 Mitigation (§ 320.4(r))................................................................... 4-18
5.0 MITIGATION.............................................................................................5-1
5.1 AVOIDANCE.............................................................................................5-1
5.1.1 Avoidance and Minimization by Selection of Pipeline Crossing
Method........................................................................................................ 5-1
5.1.2 Avoidance Through Alignment Selection .................................................. 5-12
5.1.3 Avoidance Through ROW Configuration.................................................. 5-12
5.1.4 Avoidance Through Access Road Siting and Design ............................... 5-12
5.1.5 Site -Specific Onsite Avoidance Measures ................................................ 5-14
5.1.6 Avoidance Actions Dictated by Other Authorities ..................................... 5-14
5.2 MINIMIZATION.......................................................................................5-14
5.2.1 Instream Pipeline Construction Practices .................................................
5-14
5.2.2 Wetland Pipeline Construction Practices ..................................................
5-15
5.2.3 Duration of Pipeline Construction Activities in Waters ..............................
5-15
5.2.4 Construction Practices Adjacent to Aquatic Resources ............................
5-15
5.2.5 Stream Crossing Geometry......................................................................
5-15
5.2.6 Time -of -Year Restrictions.........................................................................
5-16
5.2.7 Wetland and Stream Crossings in ATWS.................................................
5-16
5.2.8 Restoration of Temporary Wetland Impacts .............................................
5-16
5.2.9 Restoration of Temporary Stream Impacts (Pipeline) ...............................
5-17
5.2.10 Long -Term ROW Maintenance in Wetlands .................................
5-17
5.3 COMPENSATION...................................................................................5-18
6.0 PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT..........................................................................6-1
7.0 ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE...................................................................7-1
FIGURES
TABLES
ATTACHMENTS
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
FIGURES
Figure 1 Amendment Project Overview Map
Figure 2 U.S. Geological Survey Amendment Project Location Map
Figure 3 Detail Map
Figure 4 USACE Norfolk District Wetland and Waterbodies Overview Map
Figure 5 USACE Wilmington District Wetland and Waterbodies Overview Map
TABLES
Table 1 Section 10 River Crossings
Table 2 Stream Impacts
Table 3 Wetland Impacts
Table 4 Stream Impacts Summary
Table 5 Wetland Impacts Summary
Table 6 Counties and Towns Crossed by the Amendment Project
Table 7 Watersheds Crossed by the Amendment Project
Table 8 List of Affected Landowners
Table 9 State and Federal Permit Status
Table 10 Dry -Ditch Open -Cut Crossing Method Cost
Table 11 Bore Crossing Method Cost
Table 12 Crossing Method Determination Summary
Table 13 Access Roads with Stream/Wetland Crossings
Table 14 Streams and Wetlands Avoided at the Direction of Other Federal or State Authorities
Table 15 Compensatory Wetland Mitigation
Table 16 Compensatory Stream Mitigation
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
ATTACHMENTS
Attachment A
VA DEQ 401 Water Quality Certification Information and Virginia Water Protection
Permit Application
Attachment B
NC DEQ 401 Water Quality Certification Information
Attachment C
Virginia Marine Resources Commission Permit Request
Attachment D
USACE Norfolk District ENG Form 4345
Attachment E
USACE Wilmington District ENG Form 4345
Attachment F
USACE Norfolk District Standard JPA Form
Attachment G
Cumulative Impacts Analysis
Attachment H
Plan and Profile Crossing Drawings and Inadvertent Return Plan
Attachment H-1
Section 10 Waters Plan and Profile Crossing Drawings
Attachment H-2
Virginia Plan and Profile Crossing and Culvert Drawings
Attachment H-3
Inadvertent Return Plan
Attachment I
Wetland and Stream Data Forms and Photographs
Attachment 1-1
USACE Norfolk Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-2
USACE Norfolk Wetland Data and Attribute Forms
Attachment 1-3
USACE Wilmington Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-4
USACE Wilmington Wetland Data and NC WAM Field Assessment Forms
Attachment J
Construction Details (Typicals)
Attachment K
Economic Benefit Analysis
Attachment L
Supplemental Public Interest Comments
Attachment M
Compensatory Mitigation
Attachment M-1
USACE Norfolk Stream USM Forms
Attachment M-2
Mitigation Affidavits and Purchase Agreements
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
List of Abbreviations
List of Abbreviations
Abbreviation
Term/Phrase/Name
2020 EJ Act
Virginia Environmental Justice Act
Amendment Project
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
APE
Area of Potential Effect
ATWS
additional temporary workspace
BA
Biological Assessment
BMP
best management practice
Certificate
Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity
CFR
Code of Federal Regulations
CO2
carbon dioxide
CWA
Clean Water Act
Duke
Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC
Dth/d
dekatherms per day
East Tennessee
East Tennessee Natural Gas, LLC
EJ
Environmental Justice
EJ Council
[North Carolina] Governor's Environmental Justice Advisory Council
EPA
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
ESA
Endangered Species Act
ESCP
Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
FEIS
Final Environmental Impact Statement
FERC
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
HDD
horizontal directional drill
HUC
hydrologic unit code
IP
Individual Permit
IPaC
Information for Planning and Consultation
IR
inadvertent return
JPA
joint permit application
LEDPA
Least Environmentally Damaging Practicable Alternative
LNG
liquefied natural gas
LOD
limits of disturbance
Mainline Project
Mountain Valley Pipeline Project
Mountain Valley
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MP
milepost
North Carolina Community Mapping System
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
North Carolina Division of Mitigation Services
NCCMS
NC DEQ
NCDMS
NCWRC
North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
List of Abbreviations
Abbreviation
Term/Phrase/Name
National Environmental Policy Act
NEPA
NLEB
northern long-eared bat
NRHP
National Register of Historic Places
NWP
Nationwide Permit
OEJ
Office of Environmental Justice
PA
Programmatic Agreement
PEM
palustrine emergent wetland
PFO
palustrine forested wetland
PHMSA
Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration
PJD
Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination
Plan
FERC Upland Erosion Control, Revegetation, and Maintenance Plan
Procedures
FERC Wetland and Waterbody Construction and Mitigation Procedures
PSNC
Public Service Company of North Carolina, Inc. (d/b/a Enbridge Gas
North Carolina
Original Certificated Project
MVP Southgate Project, as certificated by FERC on June 18, 2020
PSS
palustrine scrub -shrub wetland
RHA
Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899
RLP
Roanoke logperch
ROW
right-of-way
SSE
Southeastern Supply Enhancement
SHPO
State Historic Preservation Office
SPCC
Spill Prevention, Control and Countermeasure
TOYR
time -of -year restriction
Transco
Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Company, LLC
UNT
unnamed tributary
U.S.
United States
USACE or Corps
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
USC
U.S. Code
USFWS
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
USM
Unified Stream Methodology
VA DEQ
Virginia Department of Environmental Quality
VDCR
Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation
VDGIF
Virginia Department of Game and Inland Fisheries
VDWR
Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources
VMRC
Virginia Marine Resources Commission
VWP
Virginia Water Protection Permit Program
WOTUS
Waters of the U.S.
WQC
Clean Water Act § 401 Water Quality Certification
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Project Information
USACE Individual Permit Application
1.0 Project Information
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC (Mountain Valley') is seeking an Individual Permit (IP) from the United
States (U.S.) Army Corps of Engineers (USACE or Corps) Norfolk and Wilmington Districts to conduct
regulated activities below the ordinary high-water elevation of navigable waters under Section 10 of the
Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (RHA) and for the discharge of dredged and fill material into Waters of
the U.S. (WOTUS) under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (CWA) for the MVP Southgate Amendment
Project (Amendment Project). In addition to the USACE IP Application, Mountain Valley will be requesting
CWA § 401 Water Quality Certification (WQC) from the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality
(VA DEQ) and North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (NC DEQ) for portions of the
Amendment Project within their respective jurisdiction (see Section 1.8.2 below).
Additionally, this application package provides information to support WQC determinations by Virginia
(Attachment A) and North Carolina (Attachment B). This package also includes an application for a
Virginia Water Protection (VWP) permit (included in Attachment A) and an application for the Virginia
Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) permit (included in Attachment C).2
1.1 Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination and USACE
Individual Permit Application Forms
Mountain Valley previously submitted Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination (PJD) requests to the
USACE Norfolk and Wilmington Districts confirming the presence of WOTUS in the Amendment Project
limits of disturbance (LOD) located in their respective USACE Districts. The PJD requests are included in
Attachment A for the Norfolk District and Attachment B for the Wilmington District. As of the date of this
application, PJD approval letters are still pending. The approvals will be provided to VDEQ and NCDEQ
upon receipt by Mountain Valley.
The completed applications for Department of the Army Permit (ENG Form 4345) for the Amendment
Project are included in Attachment D for WOTUS within the USACE Norfolk District and Attachment E for
WOTUS within the USACE Wilmington District. The USACE Norfolk District Standard Joint Permit
Application (JPA) form is included in Attachment F.
Additional Amendment Project information is provided below and in the attached documents.
1.2 Amendment Project Description and History
The Amendment Project is a 31.3-mile, 30-inch-diameter natural gas pipeline between Pittsylvania
County, Virginia, and Rockingham County, North Carolina, to provide timely and affordable access to
natural gas, which is in growing demand. The Amendment Project begins at the proposed Lambert
Interconnect in Pittsylvania County, Virginia (milepost [MP] 0.0), extends to the proposed receipt
interconnect point (LN 3600 Interconnect; MP 28.9) in Rockingham County, North Carolina, and ends at
' Mountain Valley is a joint venture between EQT; NextEra Energy, Inc.; Consolidated Edison, Inc.; AltaGas Ltd.; and
RGC Resources, Inc.
2 Mountain Valley reserves all rights to amend, withdraw, or supplement the IP or any of its Attachments (including
the Attachments thereto), and/or to object to, contest, or hold out as optional/ unnecessary any permit, request,
approval, or certification applied for, denied, or received pursuant to the IP or its Attachments, pursuant to any
Presidential Executive Order or any governmental action taken as a result of or related to any Presidential Executive
Order.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Project Information
the proposed delivery interconnect points (Dan River Interconnect #1 and Dan River Interconnect #2;
MP 31.3) in Rockingham County, North Carolina (Figure 1).
The Amendment Project crosses portions of the USACE Norfolk District and USACE Wilmington District.
Approximately 26.1 miles of the pipeline and 10.8 miles of access roads are sited within the USACE
Norfolk District. Approximately 5.2 miles of the pipeline and 4.5 miles of access roads are sited within the
USACE Wilmington District.
On June 18, 2020, in Docket No. CP19-14-000, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)
issued a Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity (Certificate) pursuant to Section 7(c) of the
Natural Gas Act to Mountain Valley, authorizing Mountain Valley to construct and operate the MVP
Southgate Project (Original Certificated Project).3 A Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) was
issued by FERC on February 14, 2020.4 The Original Certificated Project was placed on hold due to
litigation -related delays with respect to the Mountain Valley Pipeline Project (Mainline Project). With the
Mainline Project completed and in service as of June 14, 2024, Mountain Valley is seeking to amend the
MVP Southgate Project (i.e., Amendment Project) by truncating the Original Certificated Project to
approximately 31 miles, incorporating certain route deviations, increasing the diameter of the pipeline,
removing compression facilities, and modifying the proposed interconnects. Mountain Valley filed its
Amendment Application with FERC on February 3, 2025 (FERC Docket No. CP25-60-000).5
A JPA for USACE Section 404 and VA DEQ/NC DEQ Section 401 authorization pursuant to Nationwide
Permit (NWP) 12 was previously submitted to the USACE Norfolk and Wilmington Districts, VA DEQ, and
NC DEQ in November 2018 for the Original Certificated Project (NAO-2018-1574). Following
modifications that were incorporated based on the FERC review and stakeholder/agency comments,
Mountain Valley submitted an addendum to the JPA to the respective federal and state agencies in
August 2019. The Original Certificated Project was subsequently placed on hold due to the
aforementioned Mainline Project delays, and the JPA was withdrawn.6 Following the Mainline Project's
completion, Mountain Valley has resumed the permitting process for the Amendment Project.
A pre -application meeting regarding this IP application and the Amendment Project was held between
representatives of Mountain Valley and representatives from both the USACE Norfolk and Wilmington
Districts on September 5, 2024. Informal pre -application consultation with the USACE continued after the
initial meeting for the purpose of coordinating surveys and technical issues with the nearby
Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Company, LLC (Transco) Southeastern Supply Enhancement (SSE)
Project (FERC Docket No. CP25-10-000).
Pre -application meetings regarding this IP application and subsequent state applications were held with
representatives from the NC DEQ (September 19, 2024) and VA DEQ (September 20, 2024, and April 3,
2025).
3 See FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20200618-3159.
4 FERC. 2020. Southgate Project. Final Environmental Impact Statement. Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC. FERC
Docket No.: CP19-14-000. February 2020 (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20200214-3010).
5 Mountain Valley. 2025. Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC submits Abbreviated Application forAmendment to the
Certificate of Public Convenience and Necessity re the MVP Southgate Project under CP25-60. Available at:
https://elibrary.ferc.gov/eLibrary/filelist?accession_number=20250203-5192. Accessed February 2025.
6 The JPA (NWP 12) was withdrawn from the USACE Wilmington and Norfolk Districts in November 2018 and August
2019, respectively.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Project Information
USACE Individual Permit Application
1.3 General Construction Information
1.3.1 Pipeline Construction Description
In uplands, the pipeline will generally require a 100-foot-wide construction right-of-way (ROW), which
includes a 50-foot-wide permanent ROW. The additional temporary ROW is necessary for the safe travel
of construction and maintenance vehicles and equipment, stockpiling of topsoil and subsoil, and
installation and maintenance of erosion and sediment controls. Cathodic ground beds and mainline
valves will also be within the Amendment Project's permanent ROW.
Additional temporary workspace (ATWS) areas will be required for construction activities, requiring space
outside the 100-foot-wide construction ROW. The ATWS will be utilized during construction for material
storage, storage of excess spoil at crossings, parking, and equipment turning radius.
The availability of previously used roads and other existing roads is sufficient to provide access to most
work areas. However, new access roads are required in several locations that do not parallel existing
road infrastructure. Maintenance will be required on some of the existing roads prior to hauling
construction equipment and materials. Maintenance is considered to be the placement of additional
gravel or stone on the existing road and the replacement of ineffective or undersized culverts. Some
leveling may be required to eliminate ruts on existing access roads.
Mountain Valley will use contractor yards during construction to stage equipment, store materials, and set
up temporary construction offices. These yards are already -disturbed areas but may require some surface
grading, drainage improvements, placement of surface materials (e.g., crushed rock), and establishment
of internal roadways.
Pipeline construction through regulated waters will be accomplished using conventional dry -ditch open -
cut or trenchless methods. Where the dry -ditch method is employed, flowing water will be diverted around
the crossing through the installation of a dam -and -pump or flume, with the specific water diversion
method to be decided during construction by the construction supervisor and/or the Mountain Valley
representative based on conditions at the time of the crossing. Where trenchless methods are employed,
the pipe will be installed with specialized equipment that bores or tunnels under aquatic resources using
either conventional bore or horizontal directional drilling (HDD), as specified in this JPA. Wetlands within
the construction corridor that will not be crossed by the pipeline will be avoided where practicable and
demarcated with signage and erosion and sediment controls (or other visible barriers). Where avoidance
is not practicable, timber mats will be installed to minimize impacts from compaction and ground
disturbance. Once construction is complete, timber mats will be removed as soon as practicable, and the
affected areas will be decompacted and returned to pre -construction elevations.
Mountain Valley will implement the FERC Upland Erosion Control, Revegetation, and Maintenance Plan
(Plan) 7 and Wetland and Waterbody Construction and Mitigation Procedures (Procedures)8 and its
project -specific Erosion and Sediment Control Plan (ESCP) that complies with state -specific regulations
to minimize impacts during construction. Cleanup and restoration will commence as soon as practicable
following the completion of backfilling and testing. Cleanup and restoration activities include restoring
grade cuts to preconstruction contours, with stockpiled topsoil re -spread and decompacted, followed by
seeding with a regional native seed mix, fertilizing, and mulching to restore ground cover, minimize
erosion, and stabilize stream banks for their natural reversion toward their previous state. Completed
FERC. 2013. Upland Erosion Control, Revegetation, and Maintenance Plan. May 2013 Version.
$ FERC. 2013. Wetland and Waterbody Construction and Mitigation Procedures. May 2013 Version.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Project Information
stream crossings using the flume or dam -and -pump water diversion methods will be stabilized before
returning flow to the channel. Where the flume technique is used, stream banks will be stabilized before
removing the flume pipes and returning flow to the stream channel. For the dam -and -pump method, the
dams are removed prior to restoring and stabilizing the stream banks. Stream banks and beds will be
restored as described above for surface water and groundwater flow, and mulch, jute thatching, or
bonded -fiber blankets will be installed on the stream banks.
A more detailed description of the stream and wetland restoration can be found in Sections 5.2.8
(Restoration of Temporary Wetland Impacts [Pipeline]) and 5.2.9 (Restoration of Temporary Stream
Impacts [Pipeline]).
1.3.2 Access Road Construction Description
Mountain Valley will utilize existing roads and newly constructed roads to facilitate construction. Typical
road widths will vary but may require additional temporary widening to facilitate use by large equipment,
pipe delivery trucks, and installation of erosion and sediment controls. Existing roads will be maintained
with minor grading and gravel dressing (as needed) to maintain the road surface. Temporary erosion and
sediment controls will be installed in accordance with the state -approved ESCP. For existing roads that
will need to be temporarily widened for use or that have inadequate or failed culverts at waterbody
crossings, Mountain Valley will either span the waterbody to avoid impact or, where necessary, install a
culverted crossing. Newly installed and replaced culverts will be countersunk and will be sized and
installed in a manner to maintain low flows to allow the passage of aquatic life and to freely pass bankfull
flows.
Following the completion of Amendment Project construction, existing roads that were temporarily
widened will be returned to preexisting contours and conditions unless landowners have requested the
widening to remain and any necessary agency approvals have been issued. Any drainage culverts
damaged during construction will be repaired as needed and returned to preexisting conditions (or better).
Areas of temporary widening will have the temporary road surface reclaimed and the disturbed areas
revegetated. The road surface will be returned to the preexisting width, and a topcoat of gravel applied
(where necessary). Once disturbed areas are permanently stabilized with vegetation or other measures
(e.g., gravel, where applicable), temporary erosion and sediment controls will be removed and properly
disposed of.
1.4 Amendment Project Location
The location of the proposed Section 10 navigable water crossing of the Dan River included in this permit
application is listed in Table 1. The locations of the proposed stream and wetland WOTUS impacts
included in this permit application are listed in Tables 2 and 3, respectively, and summaries of these
proposed stream and wetland WOTUS impacts are included in Tables 4 and 5, respectively. Counties
and towns crossed by the Amendment Project are listed in Table 6. Figure 3 shows the locations of the
crossings included in this permit application.
1.5 Watersheds and Hydrologic Unit Codes
The watersheds and hydrologic unit codes (HUCs) for the proposed Amendment Project crossings
included in this permit application are provided in Table 7. Additional information describing past, present,
and planned projects within the 12-digit HUC watersheds (i.e., HUC-12) associated with the Amendment
Project is included in the Cumulative Impacts Analysis in Attachment G.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Project Information
1.6 Property Owners
A list of property owners for the portions of the Amendment Project included in this permit application is
included in Table 8. Mountain Valley has acquired approximately 97 percent of its easements in Virginia
and 100 percent of its easements in North Carolina. These easements afford Mountain Valley the right to
grant access to regulatory and permitting agencies without further approval from the underlying
landowner. Mountain Valley is continuing to coordinate with landowners along the Amendment Project
route with respect to its easements and the timing of construction.
1.7 Directions to Site
Directions are provided from the USACE Norfolk District, 803 Front St, Norfolk, Virginia 23510 to:
The northern extent of the Amendment Project, MP 0.0, in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, located at
36.830743' N, 79.344083' W.
• Travel east on Front Street toward Colley Avenue for approximately 0.2 mile
• Turn left onto Colley Avenue and continue for approximately 0.2 mile
• Turn left onto W Brambleton Avenue (US-58W) and continue for approximately 0.3 mile
• Continue on US-58W/Raleigh Avenue for 0.2 mile
• Take the US-58W ramp to 1-294/Midtown Tunnel/Portsmouth and continue onto US-
58W/Midtown Tunnel for 1.4 miles
• Merge onto US-58W using the ramp to Downtown/Portsmouth and continue for 1.3 miles
• Continue onto VA-164 for 0.6 mile then
• Take the exit onto 1-264W toward Suffolk and continue for 4.7 miles
• Take the 1-664 exit toward US-13/US-58/US-460/Bowers Hill/Suffolk/Richmond and continue
onto 1-664 N for 0.7 mile
• Take exit 13A-13B for US-13N/US-58E/Military Highway toward US-460E/VA-191 N/Suffolk
• Take the ramp onto US-13S/US-58W and continue for 14.4 miles
• Continue on US-58W for 116 miles
• Take the US-58W/US-15S/State Route 49S to S Boston/Danville and continue for 0.4 mile
• Merge onto US-58W and continue for 21.6 miles
• Turn right onto US-360 E/John Randolph Boulevard and continue for 0.6 mile
• Turn left onto Seymour Drive and continue for 0.7 mile
• Turn right onto Broad Street and continue for 1.1 miles; Broad Street turns right and becomes
Wilborn Avenue, continue for 0.5 mile
• Continue onto US-501 N/Halifax Road for 2.0 miles
• Turn left onto State Route 654/Green Folly Road and continue for 0.7 miles
• Turn right onto State Route 654 and continue for 2.0 miles
• Turn left onto VA-360W and continue for 1.5 miles
• Turn right onto State Route 832/VA-57W and continue for 23.8 miles
• Turn left onto Sheva Road and continue for 0.1 mile
• Turn left onto Transco Road and continue for 1.2 mile
• Turn left and continue for 413 feet
• Turn left and continue for 0.2 mile to reach the northern extent of the Amendment Project.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Project Information
The Virginia -North Carolina border crossing for the Amendment Project, MP 26.8, at coordinates
36.541942°N,-79.632372 'W.
• Travel east on Front Street toward Colley Avenue for approximately 0.2 mile
• Turn left onto Colley Avenue and continue for approximately 0.2 mile
• Turn left onto W Brambleton Avenue (US-58W) and continue for approximately 0.3 mile
• Continue on US-58W/Raleigh Avenue for 0.2 mile
• Take the US-58W ramp to 1-294/Midtown Tunnel/Portsmouth
• Continue onto US-58W/Midtown Tunnel for 1.4 miles
• Merge onto US-58W using the ramp to Downtown/Portsmouth and continue for 1.3 miles
• Continue onto VA-164 for 0.6 mile
• Take the exit onto 1-264W toward Suffolk and continue for 4.7 miles
• Use the right two lanes to take the 1-664 exit toward US-13/US-58/US-460/Bowers
Hill/Suffolk/Richmond and continue onto 1-664N for 0.7 mile
• Take exit 13A-13B for US-13N/US-58E/Military Highway toward US-460E/VA-191 N/Suffolk
• Using the left two lanes, take the ramp onto US-13S/US-58W and continue for 14.4 miles
• Keep left to continue on US-58W, following signs for Fran klin/Emporia/US-58
BUS/Downtown/Suffolk, and continue for 116 miles
• Take the US-58W/US-15S/State Route 49S to S. Boston/Danville and continue for 0.4 mile
• Merge onto US-58W and continue for 50.4 miles
• Use the right lane to take the US-29S/US-58W/Danville Expressway ramp to
Greensboro/Martinsville; merge onto US-29S/US-58W and continue for 7.4 miles
• Keep right to stay on US-58W and continue for 6.5 miles
• Take the exit onto US-58 BUS E toward Danville and continue for 0.7 mile
• Turn right onto US-311, entering North Carolina, and continue for 7.6 miles to reach the Virginia -
North Carolina border crossing for the Amendment Project
The southern extent of the Amendment Project, MP 31.54, in Rockingham County, NC, at coordinates
36.491436°N,-79.682773°W.
• Travel east on Front Street toward Colley Avenue for approximately 0.2 mile
• Turn left onto Colley Avenue and continue for approximately 0.2 mile
• Turn left onto W Brambleton Avenue (US-58W) and continue for approximately 0.3 mile
• Continue on US-58W/Raleigh Avenue for 0.2 mile
• Take the US-58W ramp to 1-294/Midtown Tunnel/Portsmouth and continue onto US-
58W/Midtown Tunnel for 1.4 miles
• Merge onto US-58W and continue for 1.3 miles
• Continue onto VA-164 for 0.6 mile
• Take the exit onto 1-264W toward Suffolk and continue for 4.7 miles
• Take the 1-664 exit toward US-13/US-58/US-460/Bowers Hill/Suffolk/Richmond and continue
onto 1-664N for 0.7 mile
• Take exit 13A-13B for US-13N/US-58E/Military Highway toward US-460E/VA-191 N/ Suffolk
• Take the ramp onto US-13S/US-58W and continue for 14.4 miles
• Continue on US-58W, following signs for Fran klin/Emporia/US-58 BUS/Downtown/ Suffolk, and
continue for 116 miles
• Using the left lane, take the US-58W/US-15S/State Route 49S to S. Boston/Danville and
continue for 0.4 mile
• Merge onto US-58W and continue for 50.4 miles and
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Project Information
• Take the US-29S/US-58W/ Danville Expressway ramp to Greensboro/Martinsville; merge onto
US-29S/US-58W and continue for 7.4 miles
• Merge onto US-29S toward Greensboro, entering North Carolina, and continue for 1.5 miles
• Take the NC-700 exit toward Eden and continue for 0.2 mile
• Turn right onto NC-70OW and continue 13.7 miles to arrive at the southern extent of the
Amendment Project.
1.8 Amendment Project Authorizations
1.8.1 Authorizations and Approvals
A complete list of all authorizations required by federal, interstate, state, and local agencies for the
Amendment Project, including all approvals received or denials already made, is provided in Table 9.
1.8.2 Clean Water Act § 401 Water Quality Certification
To ensure compliance with 33 U.S. Code (USC) § 1341(a) and 40 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)
§ 121.2, Mountain Valley will be submitting new WQC requests to Virginia and North Carolina. On July
22, 2024, Mountain Valley sent letters to VA DEQ and NC DEQ notifying them of the Amendment Project
and Mountain Valley's intent to submit a WQC request. Mountain Valley met with NC DEQ and VA DEQ
on September 19 and 20, 2024, respectively. Formal WQC requests will be submitted to the VA DEQ and
NC DEQ in coordination with this JPA.
State -specific information relevant to the VA DEQ § 401 WQC and NC DEQ § 401 WQC reviews is
provided in Attachment A and Attachment B, respectively.
1.8.3 National Historic Preservation Act § 106 Consultation
As part of the Natural Gas Act pipeline certification process, FERC developed a Programmatic Agreement
(PA) for the Original Certificated Project in consultation with the USACE, State Historic Preservation
Offices (SHPOs), and other parties to resolve adverse effects to affected historic properties in accordance
with 36 CFR § 800.14(b)(3).9 The PA was fully executed for the Original Certificated Project on May 19,
2020; it is scheduled to expire on May 18, 2026, but includes provisions for possible extension of the
expiration date.
Construction for the Amendment Project will not have commenced prior to the expiration of the PA.
Accordingly, in consultation with the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation and respective SHPOs, the
PA will be amended to extend the expiration date and to address any historic resources that would have
been affected by the Original Certificated Project and now will be avoided by the Amendment Project.
Mountain Valley will adhere to the requirements of the PA for all work conducted under the proposed
permit authorization, including previously approved plans for unanticipated historic properties and human
remains.
There are no potential direct or indirect effects to historic properties subject to USACE's presumed permit
area that warrant reinitiating consultation under Section 106. The Amendment Project's direct Area of
Potential Effect (APE) and indirect APE were defined in consultation with FERC and the respective
9 Programmatic Agreement Among the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the Virginia State Historic
Preservation Office, and the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office, Regarding the Southgate Project
(March 18, 2020) (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20200310-4002).
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Project Information
USACE Individual Permit Application
SHPOs.10 Surveys were conducted for the entirety of the direct and indirect APE. Although the USACE
has not yet defined a "permit area" as that term is defined in 33 CFR Part 325, Appendix C, Mountain
Valley assumes the surveys of the direct and indirect APE were conducted in areas that are broader than
and inclusive of portions of the Amendment Project that will fall within the USACE's permit area. No new
effects to eligible or listed historic properties beyond those identified for the Original Certificated Project
will occur as a result of any USACE permit issued in connection with this application. Furthermore, the
activities for which Mountain Valley is seeking authorization in this application (i.e., open -cut crossings of
jurisdictional streams and wetlands) were considered and addressed in the process of developing the PA.
1.8.4 Endangered Species Act § 7 Consultation
On July 25, 2024, Mountain Valley submitted letters introducing the Amendment Project to the Virginia
Department of Wildlife Resources (VDWR) and the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission
(NCWRC). Mountain Valley held a teleconference call with the USFWS Virginia Field Office on October 3,
2024, and with the USFWS Raleigh Field Office on October 29, 2024, to introduce the field offices to the
Amendment Project. The purpose of these calls was to provide updates, identify differences between the
Amendment Project and the Original Certificated Project, discuss the results of the Information for
Planning and Consultation (IPaC) request, and discuss the components of Biological Assessment (BA)
that is being developed by Mountain Valley for submittal to FERC in 2025.
USFWS indicated the Amendment Project is within the range of the federally endangered northern long-
eared bat (NLEB) (Myotis septentrionalis) and the proposed federally endangered tricolored bat
(Perimyotis subflavus). Furthermore, the Amendment Project will traverse multiple protective capture,
roost, and hibernacula buffers associated with both species. USFWS specified that clearing of any trees
>_7.6 centimeters (3 inches) diameter at breast height between April 1 and November 15 would require
formal consultation under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA) between USFWS and FERC
due to the known occurrences of NLEB and tricolored bats.
USFWS indicated the Amendment Project will cross one stream (Sandy River) in Virginia that is inhabited
by the federally endangered Roanoke logperch (RLP) (Percina rex). The Amendment Project will cross
two streams (Cascade Creek and Dan River) in North Carolina that are currently inhabited by the RLP.11
USFWS, NC DEQ, and NCWRC did not recommend surveys as RLP presence is assumed in these
streams. The Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation (VDCR) did not comment on RLP.
Critical habitat has been designated for the federally endangered Atlantic pigtoe (Fusconaia masoni) and
proposed for green floater (Lasmigona subviridis) within the Dan River. USFWS further stated that
crossing the streams using any method other than trenchless methods would require formal consultation
under ESA Section 7.
1.8.5 Inapplicable Authorizations and Approvals
The following authorizations, approvals, or consultation requirements listed in 33 CFR §§ 320.3 and
325.2(b) as potentially relevant to the USACE permit application review process are inapplicable to the
Amendment Project:
10 The indirect APE, as defined in the FERC FEIS for the Original Certificated Project, was based on visual,
atmospheric, and audible effects. Current guidance from the Advisory Council on Historic Properties now suggests
that those effects should be part of the direct APE. However, for consistency, this JPA continues to refer to the direct
and indirect APEs as defined in the FERC FEIS.
11 As indicated by geospatial data provided by the North Carolina Natural Heritage Program (NC NHP) in August
2024.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Project Information
• Civil Works Projects — the Amendment Project will not alter or temporarily or permanently occupy
or use a federally authorized USACE Civil Works project; therefore, Mountain Valley will not
require permission for the Amendment Project from the USACE pursuant to 33 USC § 408.
• Section 302 of the Marine Protection, Research, and Sanctuaries Act — the Amendment Project
is not in the vicinity of a designated marine sanctuary.
• Section 307(c) of the Coastal Zone Management Act — the Amendment Project is not located in
or near a coastal zone.
• Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act — the Amendment Project does not involve the control or
modification of any body of water.
• Federal Power Act — no Amendment Project activities involve the construction, operation, and
maintenance of dams, water conduits, reservoirs, power houses, transmission lines, or other
physical structures of a hydropower project.
• Interstate Land Sales Full Disclosure Act — the Amendment Project does not involve the sale or
lease of land.
• Deepwater Port Act of 1974 and Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion Act — the Amendment
Project is not located in or beyond the territorial seas.
• Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972 — the Amendment Project is not expected to affect any
marine mammals.
• Wild and Scenic Rivers Act — the Amendment Project does not cross any designated Wild and
Scenic Rivers within North Carolina or rivers designated by Congress as a "study river" under
the National Wild and Scenic Rivers Act. Virginia has no designated Wild and Scenic Rivers or
"study rivers."
• Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion Act of 1980 — the Amendment Project does not involve an
ocean thermal energy conversion facility or plantship.
1.9 Amendment Project Schedule
The order in which each facility will be constructed may vary, depending upon numerous factors,
including the receipt of necessary authorizations, the capabilities of each contractor, available workforce,
and optimized logistics. Mountain Valley anticipates clearing to start in the fourth quarter of 2026,
contingent upon receipt of necessary approvals, and pipeline construction will begin in late 2026 or early
2027 to achieve a target in-service date of mid-2028. The proposed crossings included in this permit
application will be completed by late 2027 or as soon as practicable. Once all stream and wetland
crossings are completed, permanently disturbed areas and crossings will be stabilized throughout the
entire Amendment Project. Once final stabilization of the Amendment Project is complete, the
corresponding protection of the sensitive resources crossed by the Amendment Project will be achieved.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Amendment Project Purpose and Need
USACE Individual Permit Application
2.0 Amendment Project Purpose and Need
2.1 Basic Amendment Project Purpose
The Amendment Project's basic purpose is to transport natural gas. The Amendment Project is not water -
dependent.
2.2 Overall Amendment Project Purpose
The purpose of the Amendment Project is to transport natural gas from an interconnection point with the
Mountain Valley Pipeline in southern Virginia to an interconnection point with the East Tennessee Natural
Gas, LLC system (East Tennessee) in North Carolina, and then to two new delivery points in Rockingham
County, North Carolina, in order to meet the specific requests for natural gas transportation service of
Foundation Shippers Public Service Company of North Carolina, Inc. (d/b/a Enbridge Gas North Carolina)
(PSNC), a local natural gas distribution company serving customers in North Carolina
(300,000 dekatherms per day [Dth/d]), and Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (Duke), an electric utility in North
Carolina (250,000 Dth/d). The Amendment Project will provide firm natural gas transportation services for
PSNC and Duke to meet growing supply and resiliency needs via the interconnections referenced above.
The Amendment Project is expected to be in service by mid-2028. The Amendment Project is a separate
project from the 303-mile Mountain Valley Pipeline (i.e., the Mainline Project) that began operation on
June 14, 2024.
The Amendment Project is not designed to provide natural gas to any liquefied natural gas (LNG) export
terminal. The Amendment Project terminates at an inland location more than 185 miles from the nearest
coastal Virginia port, 225 miles from the nearest coastal North Carolina port, and even farther from the
nearest LNG export terminal.
2.3 Overall Amendment Project Need
The need for the Amendment Project is to meet the specific requests for natural gas transportation
service of its Foundation Shippers, PSNC and Duke. The Amendment Project will provide additional firm
natural gas transportation services for PSNC and Duke to meet growing supply and resiliency needs via
interconnections with the Mainline Project in southern Virginia and the interstate pipeline of East
Tennessee in North Carolina to two new delivery points in Rockingham County, North Carolina. The
North Carolina Public Utility Commission is supportive of PSNC's need to acquire incremental
transportation to meet growing demand and a diversified gas supply. The Amendment Project will support
Duke's growing electric demand and support coal retirements, as stated in their Integrated Resource
Plans.12,13 As a result, the Amendment Project will contribute to Duke's carbon dioxide (CO2) emission
reductions.
12 Duke. 2023. Carolinas Resource Plan. Available at: https://www.duke-energy.com/our-company/about-us/irp-
carolinas. Accessed July 2024.
13 North Carolina Utilities Commission. 2024. Verified Amended Petition for Approval of 2023-2024 Carbon Plan and
Integrated Resource Plans. Available at:
https://starwl .ncuc.gov/NCUC/PSC/PSCDocumentDetailsPageNCUC.aspx?Documentld=2b7f861 a-2c48-404d-9e75-
f4e6d7142702&Class=Filing. Accessed July 2024.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Alternatives Analysis
USACE Individual Permit Application
3.0 Alternatives Analysis
The Original Certificated Project route underwent extensive scrutiny by FERC, North Carolina and Virginia
state environmental agencies, cultural resource agencies, landowners directly affected by the proposed
route, and numerous stakeholders in the Mid -Atlantic and southeastern United States. In addition,
Mountain Valley has conducted its own engineering work and extensive field surveys for the Original
Certificated Project route —including civil, environmental, cultural resource, geotechnical, and
constructability assessments. Mountain Valley filed for an amendment to the approved FERC Certificate
Order in February 2025 (FERC Docket No.: CP25-60-000).14 Additional engineering work and field
surveys have been completed or are being completed as required for the Amendment Project route.
Mountain Valley has summarized below the principal reasons why no practicable alternatives to the
proposed Amendment Project would be less environmentally damaging under the Section 404(b)(1)
Guidelines.15 Where present factual circumstances would have a bearing on whether an alternative is the
least environmentally damaging practicable alternative (LEDPA), those facts have been referenced in the
alternatives analysis. At the bottom, this analysis demonstrates that the proposed Amendment Project is
the LEDPA. This analysis will also inform the Corps' public interest review.16
3.1 FERC's NEPA Document
The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requires federal agencies to consider reasonable
alternatives to the proposed action. "Reasonable alternatives must be those that are feasible, and such
feasibility must focus on the accomplishment of the underlying purpose and need (of the applicant or the
public) that would be satisfied by the proposed federal action (permit issuance)."17
To prevent the duplication of efforts by federal agencies and encourage information sharing and
integration of agency processes, NEPA allows for the designation of a lead federal agency for
environmental review. Other agencies that have authorities related to the same project may serve as
cooperating agencies for the environmental review. USACE regulations provide that district engineers will
coordinate with the lead agency "to ensure that agency's resulting EIS may be adopted by the Corps for
purposes of exercising its regulatory authority.,,18 Although the USACE must exercise its independent
judgment while carrying out its regulatory responsibilities, it has entered into an agreement with FERC
committing the USACE to "give deference, to the maximum extent allowable by law, to the project
purpose, need, and alternatives that FERC determines to be appropriate."19
14 See FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20250203-5192, 20250203-5193, and 20250203-5195.
15 40 CFR Part 230.
16 33 CFR § 320.4(a)(2). Refer also to Section 4.4 for a discussion of each public interest review factor.
7 33 CFR Part 325, Appendix B ¶ 9(b)(5)(a).
8 33 CFR Part 325, Appendix B ¶ 8(c).
9 See Memorandum of Understanding between United States Army Corps of Engineers and the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission, Supplementing the Interagency Agreement on Early Coordination of Required
Environmental and Historic Preservation Reviews Conducted in Conjunction with the Issuance of Authorizations to
Construct and Operate Interstate Natural Gas Pipelines Certificated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
(June 30, 2005), at ¶ 5, see also Hoosier Environmental Council v. U.S. Army Corps of Eng'rs, 722 F.3d 1053, 1061
(7th Cir. 2013) (stating, in the context of the USACE's alternatives analysis for a highway project that "[a]lthough the
Corps has an independent responsibility to enforce the Clean Water Act and so cannot just rubberstamp another
agency's assurances concerning practicability and environmental harm, it isn't required to reinvent the wheel").
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Alternatives Analysis
USACE Individual Permit Application
FERC is the lead agency for the Amendment Project. An FEIS was issued by FERC on February 14,
2020, for the Original Certificated Project.20 Consistent with NEPA requirements and FERC policy, FERC
completed a detailed evaluation of a range of reasonable alternatives and considered other alternatives
that were ultimately eliminated from detailed review because they were not reasonable or practicable for
the Original Certificated Project. The alternatives evaluated were provided by Mountain Valley,
cooperating and other governmental resource agencies, affected landowners, the public, and FERC staff
FERC, as the lead agency, reviewed the No Action (No Build) alternative, alternative modes of
transportation, system alternatives, a number of major route alternatives, and over 120 route variations in
the FERC FEIS. Based on its technical analysis and comments received, FERC concluded that the
Original Certificated Project was the preferred alternative that could meet the project purpose.
Mountain Valley has submitted an application to FERC for an amendment to its issued Certificate to
authorize the Amendment Project. FERC is required to perform an environmental analysis on the
Amendment Project, which will supplement the analysis previously conducted in the FERC FEIS.
During the route development process for the Amendment Project, and in accordance with FERC policy,
Mountain Valley made all practicable efforts to avoid and minimize impacts to Section 10 waters and
regulated waters. As part of FERC's environmental review process, Mountain Valley considered
alternatives to natural gas delivery and evaluated major route alternatives, as well as route variations that
could accomplish all or a portion of the Amendment Project's overall purpose. As part of this analysis,
Mountain Valley reviewed over 70 miles of pipeline route alternatives and over 7 miles of pipeline route
variations before identifying the proposed pipeline route.21 In response to comments received from the
public and commenting agencies, Mountain Valley has also incorporated more than 11 route variations to
the proposed pipeline route to avoid or minimize potential impacts on resources, including, but not limited
to, wetlands and waterbodies.
The Amendment Project route will follow the Original Certificated route, with the exception of minor route
variations and changes to the proposed aboveground facilities. Since the Amendment Project generally
follows the same route as the Original Certificated Project, Mountain Valley anticipates the information
presented in its February 2025 Amendment Application to FERC (FERC Docket No. CP25-60-000) will
result in similar conclusions identifying the Amendment Project route as the preferred alternative to meet
the Amendment Project's purpose and need.
3.2 Alternatives Analysis
The CWA requires that the location of discharges authorized under Section 404 be determined through
the application of guidelines developed by the USACE and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA).22 The guidelines required by Section 404(b)(1), which are set forth at 40 CFR Part 230, require
that an applicant demonstrate that the proposed discharge of dredged or fill material is the LEDPA.23
The 404(b)(1) Guidelines allow rejection of alternatives that are not practicable. An alternative is
practicable if it is "available and capable of being done after taking into consideration cost, existing
21 FERC. 2020. Southgate Project. Final Environmental Impact Statement. Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC. FERC
Docket No.: CP19-14-000. February 2020 (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20200214-3010).
21 Route alternatives and route variations presented within this JPA refer only to alternative routes and variations
within the first 31.3 miles of the Original Certificated Project route.
22 33 USC § 1344(b).
23 40 CFR § 230.10(a) ("no discharge of dredged or fill material shall be permitted if there is a practicable alternative
to the proposed discharge which would have less adverse impact on the aquatic ecosystem, so long as the
alternative does not have other significant adverse environmental consequences").
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
technology, and logistics, in light of overall project purposes."24 Among practicable alternatives, the
404(b)(1) Guidelines allow rejection of an alternative when it has impacts to the aquatic ecosystem,
including wetlands and streams, that are greater than the proposed alternative.25 Furthermore, practical
alternatives may be disqualified if they present other significant environmental consequences. Such
environmental consequences encompass a full range of resources, including, for example, effects on
threatened or endangered species, effects on cultural resources, and impacts on viewshed, air quality, or
the human environment. Lastly, any potential alternative that does not satisfy the project purpose is not a
"true" alternative and may be dismissed from further consideration.
For actions subject to both CWA § 404 and NEPA, the analysis of alternatives under one statute will, in
most cases, provide sufficient information for the evaluation of alternatives under the other.26 The analysis
of alternatives to address the 404(b)(1) Guidelines and NEPA will also normally satisfy the requirements
of the USACE's public interest review.
Consistent with the June 2005 Memorandum of Understanding the USACE entered into with FERC and
the goals of NEPA to prevent duplication of efforts by federal agencies and encourage information
sharing and integration of agency processes, the following alternatives analysis draws from the
comprehensive analysis conducted by FERC in its FEIS and provides additional information for the
USACE's evaluation under NEPA and the 404(b)(1) Guidelines. The alternatives evaluated include
alternative transportation methods, route alternatives, and alternative crossing methods for each crossing
included in Mountain Valley's JPA. Each alternative was evaluated based on its adverse environmental
consequences and practicability, and the LEDPA was identified.
The Amendment Project, as proposed by Mountain Valley, should be considered the LEDPA for the
purposes of the USACE's Section 404(b)(1) evaluation. The other alternatives proposed and evaluated to
date are either not practicable in implementation, do not satisfy the project purpose, or pose significantly
greater aquatic and overall environmental impacts than the Amendment Project's proposed route, as
demonstrated below.
3.2.1 No Action (No Build) Alternative
Under the No Action (No Build) Alternative, the USACE would not authorize the proposed activities, and
the Amendment Project would not be constructed. If the Amendment Project is not constructed, Mountain
Valley would not be able to meet the specific requests for natural gas transportation service of Foundation
Shippers PSNC and Duke. On a broader scale, implementing the No Action (No Build) Alternative would
not support the goal of increasing consumer access to stable and reliable natural gas supplies in the
southeastern United States, and other alternative means of transporting the proposed volumes of natural
gas from production areas would be used. This may result in the expansion of existing natural gas
transportation systems or the construction of new infrastructure, both of which may result in equal or
greater environmental impacts in comparison to the Amendment Project. It could also limit the economic
growth of these regions by not providing improved access to a natural gas supply. Thus, the No Action
(No Build) Alternative would have both adverse environmental and economic consequences and would
likely not offer a significant environmental advantage if another similar project took its place.
The Amendment Project will bring lower emissions and domestically produced natural gas supplies to
support the demand for natural gas, provide increased supply diversity, and improve supply reliability in
24 40 CFR § 230. 1 0(a)(2).
2140 CFR § 230.10(a).
21 See 40 CFR § 230.10(a)(4); Corps Standard Operating Procedures for the Regulatory Program, § 12 (stating that
the "analysis of alternatives, pursuant to the Guidelines will also satisfy NEPA").
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
the region. Mountain Valley has signed 20-year firm transportation precedent agreements to provide
550,000 Dth/d to its Foundation Shippers. PSNC has a need to acquire incremental transportation to
meet growing demand and a diversified gas supply. The Amendment Project will also support Duke's
growing electric demand and coal retirements, contributing to Duke's CO2 emission reductions.
If the purpose and need of the Amendment Project are to be met without the construction of the
Amendment Project facilities, other projects and activities would be needed, resulting in their own
environmental impacts. This would result in the transfer of environmental impacts from one project to
another but would not necessarily eliminate or reduce impacts.
The No Action (No Build) Alternative is not a practicable alternative because it does not meet the purpose
of the Amendment Project, including the objectives of its Foundation Shippers.
3.2.2 No Action (No Permit) Alternative
Under the No Action (No Permit) Alternative, the USACE would not authorize the proposed activities, and
Mountain Valley would construct the Amendment Project in a manner that avoids all activities that require
a permit from the USACE under CWA § 404 and RHA § 10. In any conceivable pipeline routing scenario,
there are hundreds of streams and wetlands subject to the USACE's Section 404 jurisdiction between the
Amendment Project starting point in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, and its terminus in Rockingham County,
North Carolina, which would need to be crossed by the pipeline and access roads. Constructing the
Amendment Project without USACE authorization would necessitate that the Amendment Project avoid
each jurisdictional water through a combination of routing the pipeline around resources, installing the
pipeline underneath resources using trenchless crossing methods, and/or bridging over resources.
Furthermore, because authorization from the USACE would be necessary to cross any navigable water
under RHA § 10 using any of the available crossing methods, the only option to bypass Section 10 waters
without USACE authorization is to avoid those waters altogether.
Mountain Valley could not implement a No Action (No Permit) Alternative using its proposed route, which
crosses the Dan River, which has been identified by USACE as presumptively "navigable" for
administrative purposes under RHA § 10. The Dan River would serve as a barrier to the development of
any potential no -permit route and obstruct any reasonably direct path between the Amendment Project
termini. A potential no -permit route would be substantially longer than the current route and result in a
proportionate increase in upland environmental impacts, landowner impacts, and costs.
Constructing a pipeline without Corps authorization is not practicable. Mountain Valley attempted to avoid
stream and wetland resources whenever practicable in the development of its proposed route, and there
are unavoidable crossings. A longer, no -permit alternative route would be no different. There is no
feasible, much less practicable, way to wholly avoid hundreds of resources when constructing a 30-inch
pipeline through and across the southeastern United States. Bridging a 30-inch natural gas pipeline over
streams and wetlands is not practicable due to safety and maintenance concerns.27 Accordingly,
crossings would have to be installed with trenchless crossing methods. Mountain Valley performed site -
specific analyses of every crossing along the proposed route.28 That exercise demonstrated that there are
many common circumstances under which crossings cannot be practicably completed with trenchless
methods. Assuming it would be impracticable to cross a comparable percentage of streams and wetlands
along a no -permit route with trenchless methods, constructing a no -permit alternative is not practicable on
its face.
2' Refer to Section 5.1.1.1.3 (Bridging) for more information.
28 See Sections 5.1.1.2 (Pipeline Crossing Constraints) and 5.1.1.4 (Determination of Proposed Crossing Methods).
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
Furthermore, the no -permit alternative may not be constructible. Geotechnical conditions such as hard
rock do not allow trenchless crossings to be attempted in all areas. Even when geotechnical conditions
appear to be favorable to boring, there always remains a small but material risk that unexpected
conditions will be encountered that prevent a bore from being completed —thereby requiring the crossing
to be completed through the open -cut method. Lastly, the site -specific crossing analysis showed that
trenchless crossings are impracticably expensive in many situations. Assuming the costs to utilize
trenchless methods on the No Action (No Permit) Alternative route are comparable to the preferred
alternative, then utilizing such methods for every crossing would make the cost of Amendment Project
construction prohibitive.
Avoiding all stream and wetland impacts would have other logistical impacts on the Amendment Project.
Building construction access roads and upgrading existing access roads would present significant
technical challenges (and costs) if Mountain Valley could not install, repair, or replace culverts. In many
cases on the previously authorized Mainline Project, Mountain Valley found it necessary to install, repair,
or replace culverts to allow construction equipment to safely access the work area. Similarly, despite best
efforts, Mountain Valley was unable to construct access roads to the ROW and travel lanes within the
ROW that would have avoided all impacts to wetlands. Mountain Valley inevitably would face the same
challenges for this Amendment Project and likewise would have no practicable options, in attempting to
construct a No Action (No Permit) Alternative.
This section highlights several specific engineering, logistical, and cost challenges that Mountain Valley
would face attempting to construct the Amendment Project without Corps authorization. Those
challenges —and many others that undoubtedly would arise if this unprecedented approach to
construction is attempted —would be experienced by Mountain Valley cumulatively. In sum, the No Action
(No Permit) Alternative is neither practicable nor a less environmentally damaging alternative.
3.2.3 Natural Gas Transportation Method Alternatives Analysis
Other methods of natural gas transportation, besides the transportation of natural gas via underground
steel pipelines, were considered, including transportation by ships, trucks, and railroads. These
alternative methods of transportation require the natural gas to be converted to LNG by cooling the gas to
approximately -260 degrees Fahrenheit (-162 degrees Celsius). As a liquid, LNG is approximately 600
times more compact than its gaseous phase. Once liquefied, it can be stored in cryogenic containers and
transported via ship, truck, or train. After receipt at a reception terminal, the LNG can be warmed and
vaporized back into a gaseous state and put into pipelines for further distribution.
Mountain Valley did not design the Amendment Project facilities to transport natural gas to an LNG export
terminal. While the option of LNG delivery was evaluated in the FERC FEIS for the Original Certificated
Project and environmental resource reports, it is worth noting that any of the environmental impacts that
would result from implementing these alternatives would be in addition to the environmental impacts of
the Amendment Project, including tree clearing and WOTUS crossings.
3.2.3.1 LNG Delivery
An alternative to transporting natural gas by the proposed pipeline is for LNG to be transported by water
to import/export terminals via specially designed ships. The closest LNG import/export terminal to the
Amendment Project is the existing Cove Point terminal on the Chesapeake Bay in Calvert County,
Maryland, located approximately 200 miles away. There is no direct connection from the Amendment
Project to the Cove Point Terminal; therefore, Mountain Valley does not intend to seek permission to
export natural gas overseas as LNG.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Alternatives Analysis
USACE Individual Permit Application
Another potential transportation alternative would involve using trucks to transport LNG on existing
roadways. LNG in relatively small volumes is already transported via trucks in many locations throughout
the United States. Converting the 550 million cubic feet per day of natural gas volumes that the
Amendment Project will deliver to its Foundation Shippers in North Carolina to LNG would require the
production and transportation of approximately 6.6 million gallons per day. Transportation of the LNG for
the Amendment Project would involve trucking on local and interstate highways to a centralized delivery
point and transporting to regasification facilities at the delivery points along the pipeline. Given a truck
tanker capacity of 10,850 gallons and a load rate limit of approximately 300 gallons per minute,
transporting 6.6 million gallons per day would require approximately 613 truckloads daily. Accommodating
this volume over a continuous 24-hour period would necessitate simultaneous loading of roughly 15
trucks.
Any additional natural gas volume increase would result in an incremental increase in the number of
trucks per day. Truck transportation options are not as safe and reliable as pipelines, and the installation
of processing facilities to liquefy and subsequently re -gasify natural gas would require extensive
permitting. Additionally, truck transportation of LNG would require large tracts of land for a regasification
facility and result in associated air emissions from the liquefaction/regasification process and truck traffic.
LNG could also be transported by railroad tanker cars along existing tracks. New liquefaction facilities
would need to be constructed in the production area, and new regasification facilities would be
constructed at the delivery points. Currently, there are no approved LNG rail tankers, and shipment of
LNG in the International Organization for Standardization containers by rail is very limited due to
regulatory constraints. Furthermore, the Department of Transportation's Pipeline and Hazardous
Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) suspended its prior rule authorizing the transportation of LNG
by rail in 2021, and a federal appeals court vacated the suspended rule on January 17, 2025, meaning it
is not likely to be reinstated.29 Therefore, new regulatory processes and approvals would be required
before LNG rail shipments would be possible. Since the LNG by rail alternative would not be available to
meet the timeframe required for energy demands by the market, the use of this alternative is not a viable
alternative to the Amendment Project.
3.2.4 System Alternatives
System alternatives to the proposed action would make use of existing or other proposed natural gas
transmission systems/facilities to meet the overall purpose of the Amendment Project. Implementing a
system alternative would make it unnecessary to construct all or part of the Amendment Project, although
some modifications or additions to an existing transmission system/facility or other proposed transmission
system/facility may be necessary.
Several existing natural gas transportation systems were considered in FERC's review of the Original
Certificated Project, including those operated by Transco and East Tennessee. FERC included a
thorough analysis of the system alternatives in the FERC FEIS, which are also applicable to the
Amendment Project, which generally follows the same route. The following existing systems were
included in this review:
Transco Pipeline System Alternative
East Tennessee Pipeline System Alternative
29 Sierra Club v. U.S. Dep. of Transp., 125 FAth 1170 (D.C. Cir. 2025).
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
Additional information for each system pertaining to USACE's alternatives evaluation under the Section
404(b)(1) Guidelines of the CWA (40 CFR § 230.10(a)) and for the USACE Public Interest Review
(33 CFR § 320.4(a)) is presented below. As described below, these system alternatives either have
similar or greater environmental impacts than the proposed Amendment Project or are not practicable
alternatives for the following reasons.
• System volume constraints did not allow for the increased volume proposed in the Amendment
Project without significant system upgrades and retrofits;
• The construction footprint necessary to retrofit or upgrade the existing systems would result in a
similar or greater environmental impact than the Amendment Project;
• Significant additional costs and Amendment Project delays would result from multiple years to
design, permit, and build new system alternatives; and
• Neither option would satisfy the project purpose by allowing Mountain Valley to fulfill its
contractual obligations to deliver gas to its Foundation Shippers.
3.2.4.1 Transco Pipeline System Alternative
The Transco pipeline system consists of various diameter pipelines totaling approximately 10,200 miles
between South Texas and New York City. The system has a peak design capacity of almost 15 million
Dth/d to markets in the Northeast, Mid -Atlantic, and Southeast regions of the United States. The Transco
pipeline currently transports nearly all of the natural gas supply entering North Carolina. The Amendment
Project is located adjacent to the Transco system in Virginia and North Carolina from MPs 0.4 to 31.3.
Transco filed an application with FERC in October 2024 for the proposed SSE Project (FERC Docket No.
CP25-10-000). The SSE Project includes the construction and operation of approximately 50.4 miles of
new, 42-inch diameter natural gas pipeline (Eden Loop and Salem Loop) along the existing Transco
Mainline in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, and Rockingham, Guilford, Forsyth, and Davidson counties,
North Carolina; expansion of one existing compressor station in Virginia (Station 165); expansion of three
existing compressor stations in North Carolina (Stations 145, 150, and 155); and modification of four
existing facilities in South Carolina, Georgia, and Alabama. The Eden Loop portion of the SSE Project
originates at Transco's Station 165 pool and generally runs parallel to the Amendment Project pipeline
route in both Virginia and North Carolina, terminating at the Dan River Interconnect.
Overall, the Amendment Project cannot use the SSE Project as a system alternative due to differences in
scope, capacity, and tariff specifications and the need for significant infrastructure modifications.
Additionally, Transco's SSE Project would not meet several of the Amendment Project objectives that
Foundation Shippers considered prior to contracting for capacity on the Amendment Project, specifically
regarding increased resiliency, hourly flexibility, operational considerations, risk diversification, the
addition of competitive gas supplies to the region, and an additional pipeline system bringing that supply.
Although the SSE Project provides access to the Appalachian gas region, it increases the reliance on a
single pipeline to provide gas to customers in North Carolina. Therefore, this alternative would not meet
the goal of the Amendment Project of diversifying supply and enhancing the reliability and resiliency of
the state's existing pipeline infrastructure.
Lastly, it is well -established that if an applicant's stated purpose is "legitimate," it would be inappropriate
to "override and redefine" that purpose.30 This statement is no less true where the applicant's purpose is
to engage in profitable business activities, and the project reflects the applicant's conclusions about how
to accomplish its "genuine and legitimate" economic objectives.31 Mountain Valley has a legitimate
31 Crutchfield v. Hanover Cnty., 325 F.3d 211, 222 (4th Cir. 2003).
31 Sylvester v. U.S. Army Corps of Eng'rs, 882 F.2d 407, 409 (9th Cir. 1989).
3-7 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
financial interest in fulfilling its economically valuable contracts with its Foundation Shippers. The SSE
Project represents a third -party project by a business competitor. Mountain Valley's legitimate financial
and economic interests in the Amendment Project cannot be satisfied by a competitor's project.
Accordingly, the SSE Project is not a true alternative.
3.2.4.2 East Tennessee Pipeline System Alternative
The East Tennessee pipeline system consists of approximately 1,536 miles of pipeline in the Southeast
and Mid -Atlantic regions of the United States, with the capacity to transport 1.9 bcf/d of natural gas. The
system begins in Tennessee and extends to an area just south of Roanoke, Virginia. A segment of the
system extends into southwest Virginia and northern North Carolina through a 95-mile natural gas
pipeline that interconnects with the Transco system near Eden, North Carolina. This segment of the East
Tennessee system also exclusively services Saltville Gas Storage Company LLC, the only underground
natural gas storage in Virginia and the Carolinas. Both Amendment Project Foundation Shippers utilize
this storage facility, and access to it plays an important role in both operational balancing and fuel supply
security during peak periods.
While East Tennessee interconnects with the Amendment Project at the LN 3600 Interconnect (at MP
28.95), it cannot be considered a viable system alternative as it would need to build similar facilities as
proposed by the Amendment Project to meet the Amendment Project objectives. Significant modifications
to the East Tennessee system (and the existing pipelines interconnected to East Tennessee), including
the construction of new pipeline facilities, would be needed to provide the necessary design pressure and
capacity to serve the Amendment Project's larger natural gas commitment to its Foundation Shippers.
Therefore, Mountain Valley does not consider this pipeline system to be a reasonable alternative to the
Amendment Project.
3.2.5 Route Alternatives
3.2.5.1 Development of Route Alternatives
As described further below, the Amendment Project's final route was produced through a methodical
refinement process. The evaluation proceeded in a logical fashion from (1) major route alternatives (and
offsite and non-structural alternatives) to (2) smaller -scale route adjustments and refinements to the
selected route, and finally to (3) onsite avoidance and minimization measures (e.g., crossing -method
alternatives) within the refined route. This approach is ideally suited to developing a large interstate
pipeline in compliance with the spirit and letter of the 404(b)(1) Guidelines.
During the development of the Original Certificated Project and the Amendment Project, Mountain Valley
conducted an extensive review of potential pipeline routes to identify reasonable pipeline corridors and
then evaluated these reasonable pipeline corridors to identify the LEDPA route within a practicable
corridor. One of Mountain Valley's primary objectives during pipeline routing was to avoid, where
practicable, and minimize crossings of major population centers, impacts to landowners, and significant
natural resources, with particular attention to aquatic resources. Mountain Valley also attempted to route
its pipeline adjacent to existing ROWS, where feasible. Mountain Valley used field reconnaissance, aerial
photography, topographic maps from the U.S. Geological Survey, National Wetland Inventory maps, and
the National Hydrography dataset during the route identification and evaluation processes.
A straight line from the Amendment Project's starting point, the Lambert Interconnect (MP. 0.0) in
Pittsylvania County, Virginia, to each of the three delivery points in Rockingham County, North Carolina
(LN 3600 Interconnect (MP 28.9), Dan River Interconnect #1 (MP 31.3), and Dan River Interconnect #2
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
(MP 31.3) would result in the shortest route and lowest possible footprint of disturbance. While a straight-
line route does not allow for consideration of engineering and constructability issues or avoidance of
sensitive areas and resources (both primary criteria for Mountain Valley), the shortest practicable length
of pipeline is generally preferred in order to reduce the footprint of environmental and land use impact in
addition to overall cost. Therefore, pipeline route length was used as a siting criterion and proxy for
general environmental impact during the initial route selection.
Collocation with existing utility corridors is generally preferable as a means to reduce environmental and
land use impacts and is encouraged by FERC in the siting of new natural gas pipelines. Mountain Valley
evaluated existing linear utilities and highways in the region to determine if these existing ROWS would
provide collocation opportunities for the Amendment Project and avoid the creation of new linear ROW.
An existing pipeline corridor runs from the southwest -to -northeast and provides suitable opportunities to
take advantage of collocation. Accordingly, the collocation was employed as a siting criterion and proxy
for general environmental impact during the initial route development.
Other relevant criteria and considerations were also incorporated into the process for developing the
major route alternatives for the Original Certificated Project. These included fact- and site -specific
evaluations of environmental and land use impacts, as well as permanent easement acquisitions and
overall costs. In summary, the primary objective in performing this analysis is to develop the most direct
route that could connect customers to the available supply system while avoiding or minimizing potential
adverse environmental impacts and engineering constraints to the greatest extent practicable.
The process outlined above for the development of major pipeline route alternatives for the Original
Certificated Project remains valid for the Amendment Project because the Amendment Project closely
follows the Original Certificated Project route. The beginning and ending points of the Amendment Project
were crossed by the Original Certificated Project route. For the purposes of the Amendment Project,
Mountain Valley reevaluated the previously identified alternative routes to reaffirm and, as necessary,
update the analysis to reflect current information. This reanalysis confirmed the majority of the routing
determinations made for the Original Certificated Project. However, as described below, several minor
route adjustments have been made based on the updated analysis.
Following the screening process summarized above, three major route alternatives were identified and
subjected to more detailed analysis as part of the Original Certificated Project. Those alternatives include
the Berry Hill Alternative, Lake Cammack East Alternative, and the North -South Alternative. These three
major route alternatives were re-evaluated as part of the Amendment Project and are described in detail
below in Section 3.2.5.2.
Four minor route variations located between MP 0.0 and MP 31.3 were evaluated as part of the Original
Certificated Project.32 Of these, three were determined to not be the LEPDA; however, the Robert Pollok-
Hill View Farms route variation requested by FERC at approximately MP 15.0 in Pittsylvania County,
Virginia, has been incorporated as described in the FERC FEIS. The four minor route variations
evaluated as part of the Original Certificated Project are summarized in Sections 3.2.5.2.4 and 3.2.5.3
below. Additional details and maps for these alternatives can be found in the FERC FEIS § 3.4.2.
Based on the reevaluation of the previously completed alternatives analysis, Mountain Valley evaluated
an additional six minor route variations that were not individually analyzed for the Original Certificated
Project. These variations include the Lambert Interconnect Variation (new aboveground facility), MP 9.9
32 Six additional minor route alternatives were evaluated as part of the Original Certificated Project; however, these
six were located beyond MP 31.3 and are no longer applicable to the Amendment Project route.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
to MP 10.3 Variation, Sandy River Variation, MP 19.9 Variation, MP 23.9 to MP 25.4 Variation, and the
Dan River Variation. These six new minor route variations are discussed in Section 3.2.5.3.
3.2.5.2 Route Alternatives and Variations Determined Not To Be the LEDPA
and/or Considered Impracticable
3.2.5.2.1 Berry Hill Alternative
The Berry Hill Alternative proposed during the Original Certificated Project and within the FERC FEIS
included routing away from the Eden and Reidsville areas due to stakeholder suggestions. For the
Amendment Project, the alternative would deviate from the proposed route at MP 24.2, extend 6.5 miles
southeast, and rejoin the Amendment Project at MP 31.0 in Rockingham County, North Carolina. This
alternative would also require a 5.4-mile lateral from the Dan River Interconnect #1.
The Berry Hill Alternative is not less environmentally damaging. This alternative would impact 0.6 acre
less wetlands and 0.9 acre less forested wetlands; however, it would cross three more perennial streams
as compared to the Amendment Project route. This alternative is 4.7 miles longer and would result in
greater upland impacts compared to the Amendment Project route (144.1 acres vs. 86.5 acres
construction impacts and 73.6 acres vs. 36.7 acres forested land impacts) and would affect five more
residences within 50 feet of the workspace and one additional environmental justice (EJ) area. The Berry
Hill Alternative also is impracticable due to unreasonable expense, with an additional estimated $49.35
million required for the additional 4.7 miles.33
3.2.5.2.2 Lake Cammack East Alternative
The Lake Cammack East Alternative proposed during the Original Certificated Project and within the
FERC FEIS included routing the pipeline around the east side of Lake Cammack away from the Eden and
Reidsville areas based on stakeholder suggestions. For the Amendment Project, the alternative would
deviate from the proposed route at MP 24.2, extend 8.3 miles southeast, and rejoin the original proposed
pipeline configuration at MP 31.0 in Rockingham County, North Carolina. This alternative would also
require an 8.8-mile lateral from the Dan River Interconnect #1.
The Lake Cammack East Alternative is not less environmentally damaging. This alternative would impact
0.8 acre less forested wetlands but would cross seven more perennial streams and impact an additional
0.2 acre of non -forested wetlands. This alternative is 9.9 miles longer and would result in greater upland
impacts as compared to the Amendment Project route (207.2 acres vs. 86.5 acres construction impacts
and 98.2 acres vs. 36.7 acres forested land impacts) and would also affect three more residences within
50 feet of the workspace. The Lake Cammack East Alternative also is impracticable due to unreasonable
expense, requiring an additional estimated $103.95 million for the 9.9 additional miles.34
3.2.5.2.3 North -South Alternative
The North -South Alternative proposed during the Original Certificated Project and in the FERC FEIS
included developing a straight line alternative routed east of Danville, Virginia, based on stakeholder
suggestions. The alternative would deviate from the proposed route at MP 6.4, extend 24.7 miles south,
33 See FERC FEIS § 3.4.1.1 for additional information on the Berry Hill Alternative. Note that estimated additional
costs are high-level approximations based on preliminary assessments.
34 See FERC FEIS § 3.4.1.2 for additional information on the Lake Cammack East Alternative. Note that estimated
additional costs are high-level approximations based on preliminary assessments.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
and rejoin the original proposed pipeline configuration at MP 31.0 in Rockingham County, North Carolina.
This alternative would also require a 16.6-mile lateral from the Dan River Interconnect #1.
The North -South Alternative is not less environmentally damaging. It would impact an additional 4.6 acres
of wetlands, cross six more streams, and result in greater upland impacts compared to the Amendment
Project route (500.6 acres vs. 302.1 acres construction impacts and 283.0 acres vs. 140.6 acres forested
land impacts). This alternative is 16.4 miles longer, and while it would cross one less potential National
Register of Historic Places- (NRHP-) eligible historic resource and two fewer NRHP-listed historic
properties, it would also affect 20 more residences within 50 feet of the workspace. The North -South
Alternative also is considered impracticable due to unreasonable expense, requiring an additional
estimated $172.20 million for the 16.4 extra miles.35
3.2.5.2.4 Route Variations
As noted above, four minor route variations located between MP 0.0 and MP 31.3 were evaluated as part
of the Original Certificated Project. Three of these variations were found to have greater adverse
environmental impacts compared to the Original Certificated Project and are summarized in the table
below. The FERC-requested Robert Pollok-Hill View Farms route variation at approximately MP 15.0 in
Pittsylvania County, Virginia, has been incorporated as described in the FERC FEIS and is described in
Section 3.2.5.3. Additional details and maps for these alternatives can be found in the FERC FEIS §
3.4.2.
Summary of Variations Not Adopted into the Amendment Project Route
Variation
Key Rationale for Determining that Variation is Not the LEDPA
or is Considered Impracticable
The Nicholson Variation was evaluated in the FERC FEIS for the Original Certificated
Project. Neither alternative impacts wetlands nor streams, so the LEDPA analysis does
Nicholson Variation
not apply to the evaluation of this variation. However, while the Nicholson Variation
affects 0.1 less acre of forested land in comparison to the proposed route, it crosses one
additional parcel, is 0.3 mile longer, affects an additional 4.2 acres of agricultural land,
and requires 4.2 more acres of construction ROW than the proposed route.
The Whitehead Variation was evaluated in the FERC FEIS for the Original Certificated
Project and crosses one less waterbody in comparison to the proposed route. However,
Whitehead Variation
the variation is 0.3 mile longer, crosses two additional parcels, and impacts an additional
5.7 acres of agricultural land. It also affects an additional 0.2 acre of wetland and 2.7
acres of forested land in comparison to the proposed route. Considering these factors,
the Whitehead Variation is not less environmentally damaging.
The Taylor East and Taylor West Variations were evaluated in the FERC FEIS for the
Original Certificated Project. The Taylor East Variation crosses four fewer parcels and
0.4 acre less agricultural land. However, the variation requires an additional 0.3 acre
construction ROW and 0.1 acre permanent ROW, crosses two more waterbodies, and
impacts 0.4 additional acre of forested land in comparison to the proposed route. Neither
Taylor East and Taylor
alternative impacts wetlands. Because the Taylor East Variation would have greater
West Variations
impacts to aquatic sites, it is not less environmentally damaging.
Neither the Taylor West Variation nor the proposed route impacts wetlands or streams,
so the LEDPA analysis does not apply to the evaluation of this variation. However, while
the Taylor West Variation crosses one less parcel, it requires 1.1 acres of additional
construction ROW, is not collocated with existing ROW, and affects an additional 0.2
acre of agricultural land and 0.9 acre of forested land.
35 See FERC FEIS § 3.4.1.3 for additional information on the North -South Alternative. Note that estimated additional
costs are high-level approximations based on preliminary assessments.
3-11 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Alternatives Analysis
USACE Individual Permit Application
3.2.5.3 Route Variations Determined to be the LEDPA and/or Practicable and
Adopted into the Proposed Route
As noted above, based on the reevaluation of the previously completed alternatives analysis, Mountain
Valley has evaluated an additional six minor route variations for the Amendment Project that were not
individually analyzed for the Original Certificated Project. These variations include the Lambert
Interconnect Variation (new aboveground facility), MP 9.9 to MP 10.3 Variation, Sandy River Variation,
MP 19.9 Variation, MP 23.9 to MP 25.4 Variation, and the Dan River Variation. In addition, the Robert
Pollok-Hill View Farms route variation at approximately MP 15.0 in Pittsylvania County, Virginia, was
retained for the Original Certificated Project. These variations are summarized in the table below.
Summary of Variations Adopted into the Amendment Project Route
Variation
Key Rationale for Determining that Variation is the LEDPA and/or Practicable
The variation was evaluated in the FERC FEIS for the Original Certificated Project. Neither
alternative impacts wetlands nor streams, so the LEDPA analysis does not apply to the
evaluation of this variation.
Robert Pollok-Hill
However, this variation affects 0.5 acre less forested land, is collocated along 1.0 mile more
View Farms
of existing ROWs in comparison with the proposed route, affects 0.4 acre less agricultural
Variation
land, and crosses one less property. Mountain Valley incorporated certain workspace
adjustments at the landowner's request to avoid a sediment catch area and a pond on the
property. As incorporated, this variation eliminated approximately 1,300 feet of access road
and 0.3 acre of temporary workspace between MPs 14.7 and 15.7.
The Lambert Interconnect Variation was evaluated in the FERC Amendment Application
Lambert
and reduces the overall length of the pipeline, permanent ROW, and construction
Interconnect
workspace compared to the Original Certificated Project. Neither alternative impacts
Variation
streams nor wetlands, so the LEDPA analysis does not apply to the evaluation of this
variation. However, this variation crosses one fewer parcel, 0.9 less acre of agricultural
land, and 0.1 less acre of forested land.
The MP 9.9 to MP 10.3 Variation was evaluated in the FERC Amendment Application.
While this variation requires 0.3 acre more of construction ROW and 0.1 acre more of
MP 9.9 to MP 10.3
permanent ROW and affects an additional 0.5 acre of agricultural land and 0.1 acre of
Variation
forested land, it affects 7.8 acres fewer wetlands and avoids a forested wetland at the
request of the VA DEQ. Because the variation has less impacts to aquatic resources and
does not result in other significant environmental impacts, it was adopted as the LEDPA.
The Sandy River Variation was evaluated in the FERC Amendment Application and avoids
two pre -contact archaeological sites (one of which is NRHP-eligible) and instream
construction -related impacts to protected species through realignment to accommodate an
HDD crossing method rather than a dry ditch open -cut crossing method. This variation
affects 0.3 acre more agricultural land and crosses one additional parcel. However, this
Sandy River
variation results in 4.7 fewer acres of construction ROW, 1.7 fewer acres of permanent
Variation
ROW, and 2.8 fewer acres of forested land.
This variation also results in the same number of wetland and stream crossings compared
to the Original Certificated Route. However, the Sandy River Variation allows one of those
crossings to be converted from an open -cut to a trenchless crossing. The variation also
reduces upland land disturbance. Accordingly, the Sandy River Variation has been adopted
because it is less environmentally damaging.
3-12 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Alternatives Analysis
Variation
Key Rationale for Determining that Variation is the LEDPA and/or Practicable
The MP 19.9 Variation was evaluated in the FERC Amendment Application and provides
additional separation from the Transco SSE Project pipeline, reducing the potential for
conflicting workspaces.36 Neither alternative would impact streams or wetlands, so the
MP 19.9 Variation
LEDPA analysis does not apply to the evaluation of this variation.
This variation affects 0.1 acre more forested land and requires 0.1 acre more construction
ROW. However, this variation crosses one less parcel and 0.1 acre less agricultural land.
The MP 23.9 to MP 25.4 Variation was evaluated in the FERC Amendment Application and
satisfies a request from the Danville Industrial Development Authority in connection with its
development plans. This variation requires 1.6 acres more of construction ROW and 0.8
MP 23.9 to MP
acre more of permanent ROW, crosses four additional parcels, and affects 5.3 acres more
25.4 Variation
forested land.
This variation crosses two fewer waterbodies and still avoids all impacts to wetlands.
Because the MP 23.9 to MP 25.4 Variation has fewer impacts to the aquatic ecosystem and
does not have other significant environmental consequences, it was adopted.
The Dan River Variation was evaluated in the FERC Amendment Application and provides
additional separation from the Transco SSE Project pipeline, reducing the potential for
conflicting workspaces (see MP 19.9 Variation footnote). This variation affects an additional
0.4 acre forested land and 0.1 acre agricultural land and crosses eight additional parcels. It
Dan River Variation
also requires 1.3 acres more construction ROW and 0.6 acre additional permanent ROW.
This variation would not result in more stream crossings compared to the Original
Certificated Project and would still avoid all wetland impacts. Because the variation's
impacts to aquatic sites are the same as the Original Certificated Project and it does not
have other significant environmental consequences, the adoption of the variation is
consistent with the LEDPA requirements.
36 Additional separation reduces the potential for conflicting workspaces. Mountain Valley proposes to use up to
25 feet of temporary workspace within the adjacent ROW dependent on successful negotiation with the easement
owner. Should construction of both the Transco SSE Project and the Amendment Project commence concurrently,
overlapping workspaces would present prohibitive constraints for the construction of either pipeline as well as
considerable or unnecessary risk to the integrity of adjacent pipelines.
3-13 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
4.0 Affected Environment and Environmental Review
Factors
The beneficial and adverse environmental effects of the Amendment Project are fully described in the
sections below.
4.1 Proposed Aquatic Impacts
4.1.1 Jurisdictional Impacts
Tables 2, 3, 4, and 5 identify the location and size of anticipated individual and cumulative wetland and
stream impacts. Figure 3 shows the location and extent of wetland and stream impacts identified at the
Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application.
For wetlands and streams crossed by the pipeline, a 10-foot depth of fill was used for temporary fill
volume calculations. The 10-foot depth of fill includes the 30-inch-diameter pipe, padding, and backfill.
For anticipated temporary stream impacts, temporary palustrine emergent (PEM) wetland impacts, and
conversion impacts to palustrine forested (PFO) and palustrine scrub -shrub (PSS) wetlands not crossed
by the pipeline, a 3-foot depth of fill was used for temporary fill volume calculations to account for the
placement of timber mats in these streams and wetlands during construction activity. In Table 3, PFO and
PSS wetland conversion with temporary fill impacts are identified separately from PEM wetlands with
temporary fill impacts and from all wetlands with permanent fill impacts. For anticipated permanent
impacts to streams along permanent access roads, the depth of fill for permanent fill volume calculations
was equal to the culvert diameter plus 0.5 foot.
Plan and profile views for each proposed jurisdictional impact are found in Attachment H.
4.1.2 Section 10 Waters
Dan River (S-113002) (Rockingham County, North Carolina)
As shown in Table 1 and Table 13, the Amendment Project crosses one waterbody (Dan River) that has
been determined to be, or is assumed to be, a traditionally navigable water under Section 10 of the RHA
(33 USC § 403). The plan and profile for the Section 10 crossing are provided in Attachment H. Mountain
Valley proposes to cross the Dan River using the HDD method, thereby avoiding all instream impacts.
Permanent and temporary impacts to the Dan River would be avoided by the proposed trenchless
crossing.
An Inadvertent Return (IR) Plan is included in Attachment H. The pipeline will be installed at a minimum
depth of 39 feet below the streambed to avoid any impact to the navigability to the river.
4.1.3 Wetland Delineation and Stream Identification
Wetland delineation and stream identification surveys were performed for the Amendment Project at the
crossings included in this permit application. Wetlands were delineated using the procedures identified in
the USACE 1987 Wetland Delineation Manual and the Regional Supplement to the Corps of Engineers
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
Wetland Delineation Manual: Eastern Mountains and Piedmont Region.37,38 Physical, chemical, and
biological characteristics of streams identified in the field were evaluated to determine flow regime
(USACE NWPs Section F — Definitions 2021), USACE Water Type,39 Cowardin classification'40 and
baseline water quality standards. Physical characteristics evaluated included but were not limited to
channel geomorphology, substrate size/type, and base flow conditions. Chemical characteristics
evaluated included, but were not limited to, dissolved oxygen, specific conductivity, and pH. Biological
characteristics evaluated included, but were not limited to, the presence of fish, aquatic
macro irive rtebrates, and vegetation rooted within the ordinary high-water mark.
Figure 3 shows the location and extent of wetlands and streams identified within the Amendment Project
LOD at the crossings included in this permit application. Data forms and photographs for wetlands and
streams identified within the Amendment Project LOD at the crossings included in this permit application
are provided in Attachment I. As of the date of this application, the PJD approval letters are pending
receipt.
4.1.4 Water Withdrawals
Mountain Valley will use water withdrawn from the Dan River, if approved by the USFWS, for hydrostatic
testing of the pipeline, dust suppression, and HDD drilling operations. If approved, a total of 3,300,000
gallons of water will be used for hydrotesting. Municipal water sources will be used as a secondary
source, if necessary. Mountain Valley will obtain water from the Dan River for the purposes of water use
during HDD drilling operations of the Dan River and Sandy River. A total of 1,853,000 gallons from the
Dan River will be required for drilling operations.
4.2 Sensitive Stream Resources
4.2.1 National Wild and Scenic Rivers
No stream crossings included in this permit application are National Wild and Scenic Rivers or rivers
officially designated by Congress as a "study river" under the National Wild and Scenic Rivers Act.
4.2.2 Tier 3 Protection
No Tier 3 Protected Waters are crossed by the Amendment Project in Virginia4l or North Carolina.42
4.2.3 Trout Waters
No trout waters were identified in the Amendment Project Area in Virginia or North Carolina.
37 Environmental Laboratory. 1987. Corps of Engineers Wetlands Delineation Manual. Technical Report Y-87-1. U.S.
Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, Mississippi.
38 USACE. 2012. Regional Supplement to the Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual: Eastern Mountains
and Piedmont Region (Version 2.0), ed. J.F. Berkowitz, J. S. Wakeley, R. W. Lichvar, and C. V. Noble.
39 USACE. 2007. Jurisdictional Determination Form Instructional Guidebook.
40 Cowardin, L. et al. 1979. Classification of Wetlands and Deepwater Habitats of the United States. U.S. Department
of the Interior Fish and Wildlife Service Office of Biological Services Washington, D.C.
41 VA DEQ. 2024. Exceptional State Waters (Tier III). Available at: https://www.deq.virginia.gov/our-
programs/water/water-quality/standards/exceptional-state-waters-tier-iii. Accessed November 2024.
42 NC DEQ. 2024. High Quality Waters & Outstanding Resource Waters. Available at:
https://www.deq.nc.gov/about/divisions/energy-mineral-land-resources/hqw-orw/. Accessed November 2024.
4-2 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
4.2.4 Warmwater Fishery
All waterbodies crossed by the Amendment Project are warmwater fisheries.
4.2.5 Anadromous Fish Use Areas
The Amendment Project does not cross any Anadromous Fish Use Areas.
4.2.6 Aquatic Life Movements
Amendment Project activities will not substantially disrupt the necessary life cycle movements of aquatic
life indigenous to the waterbodies in the Amendment Project area. Permanent and temporary crossings of
waterbodies will be suitably culverted, bridged, or otherwise designed and constructed to be countersunk
as appropriate and to maintain low flows to sustain the movement of aquatic species. During the open -cut
stream installation process, stream -flow connectivity will be maintained between the upstream and
downstream segments of the crossing through flumes and/or water pumps. The crossings will also be
installed as a continuous process, thereby reducing the overall time to complete the installation. Culverts
were sized using the Rational Formula for a 24-hour 10-year storm and Manning's Equation. In Virginia,
culverts will conform to the 2024 Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook (V1.1) and the standard
Norfolk District conditions to countersink all pipes and culverts below the bed of the stream. Culvert sizing
shall be in accordance with the Amendment Project's VA DEQ-approved Standards and Specifications,
which incorporate the 2024 Virginia Stormwater Management Handbook (V1.1). In North Carolina,
culverts will conform to the North Carolina Erosion and Sediment Control Planning and Design Manual.
Culvert sizing shall be in accordance with the Amendment Project's NC DEQ-approved ESCPs, which
incorporate the North Carolina Erosion and Sediment Control Planning and Design Manual. As such,
culverted crossings will be sized and installed in a manner to allow the passage of aquatic life and freely
pass bankfull flows.
4.2.7 Spawning Areas
According to the IPaC database, three federally listed aquatic species (James spinymussel [Parvaspina
collina], Atlantic pigtoe, and RLP) and one aquatic species proposed for listing (green floater) could
potentially occur in relevant proximity to portions of the Amendment Project area. The Amendment
Project does not cross or occur in relevant proximity to any waterbodies identified as essential fish habitat
(EFH).43 Activities in spawning areas during spawning seasons will be avoided to the maximum extent
practicable.
Mountain Valley consulted with the VDWR, formerly named the Virginia Department of Game and Inland
Fisheries (VDGIF44), for the Original Certificated Project regarding time -of -year restrictions (TOYRs) for
waterbodies crossed by the Amendment Project in Virginia. Based on the results of the consultation and
the results of aquatic surveys (provided to VDGIF in May 2019), Mountain Valley intends to adhere to the
VDWR warmwater fishery in -stream restrictions (April 15—July 15).
Mountain Valley consulted with the NCWRC regarding TOYRs for waterbodies crossing by the
Amendment Project in North Carolina. Based on the proposed stream crossing methods and anticipated
43 The Magnuson -Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act (Public Law 94-265 as amended through
October 11, 1996) defines EFH as "those waters and substrate necessary to fish for spawning, breeding, feeding or
growth to maturity."
44 VDGIF became the VDWR, effective July 1, 2020.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
best management practices (BMPs), the NCWRC is not imposing any TOYRs at any waterbody
crossings.
In -stream work, except that required to install or remove equipment bridges, must occur during the
following time windows:
a. Coldwater fisheries — There are no coldwater fisheries habitat streams affected by the
Amendment Project— Not Applicable
Warmwater fisheries
Virginia — July 16 through April 14. If in -stream work in Virginia is necessary outside of
this construction timing window, Mountain Valley will obtain approval from the VDWR
prior to initiating the in -stream work.
• North Carolina — permitted in -stream activities can occur at any time of year within the
waterbodies crossed by the Amendment Project in North Carolina.
Mountain Valley is continuing to coordinate with USFWS, VDWR, VDCR, and NCWRC regarding
sensitive stream resources.
4.2.8 Submerged Aquatic Vegetation
The Amendment Project does not cross any Submerged Aquatic Vegetation areas.
4.2.9 Freshwater Mussels
Mussel surveys were conducted for the Original Certificated Project in coordination with USFWS, VDWR,
and NCWRC. No federally or state listed species were encountered during any mussel survey or salvage
efforts along the route in Virginia or North Carolina. Consultation with the USFWS, VDWR, VDCR and
NCWRC for the Amendment Project is ongoing.
Based on initial coordination with the USFWS, as well as a review of the IPaC database, the federally
threatened Atlantic pigtoe may occur in relevant proximity to portions of the Amendment Project area in
Virginia and North Carolina. In North Carolina, the USFWS, IPaC database, and NCWRC indicated that
the Atlantic pigtoe and the federally endangered James spinymussel may occur in relevant proximity to
the Amendment Project area near the Dan River crossing. Mountain Valley is proposing to use the HDD
method at this crossing to avoid direct instream impacts to listed aquatic species. Nevertheless, any
federally listed mussels that occur in relevant proximity to the Amendment Project potentially might
experience sedimentation -related impacts from upland construction activities. Mountain Valley is
analyzing the potential for such impacts in coordination with the USFWS for the forthcoming BA that is
being developed for the Amendment Project. In addition, and in coordination with USFWS, Mountain
Valley will complete habitat suitability assessments in order to identify areas of potential suitable habitat
for federally listed mussels. After conferring with the USFWS, Mountain Valley may complete mussel
surveys in areas of suitable habitat if warranted; however, coordination regarding protected species is
ongoing. Upon completion of any surveys, a report documenting the results of the surveys and providing
recommendations for impact avoidance and minimization, if necessary, will be submitted to the USFWS
and filed with FERC as part of the ESA Section 7 consultation process.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mountain Valley continues to coordinate with USFWS, VDWR, and NCWRC and will adhere to
recommended TOYRs and mussel relocations, as required, for crossings of streams with freshwater
mussels. Refer to the FERC FEIS § 4.7.4 for additional information.
4.2.10 Designated Critical Resource Waters
No Designated Critical Resource Waters occur in the Amendment Project area.
4.3 404(b)(1) Guidelines Technical Evaluation Factors
The following summarizes information relevant to the 404(b)(1) Guidelines' Technical Evaluation Factors
(40 CFR Part 230, Subparts C, D, E, F, and H).
4.3.1 Substrate (§ 230.20)
Prior to installing a crossing, the top foot of a streambed substrate or wetland soil (where hydrologic
conditions allow) will be segregated and stockpiled separately from subsoils. Following installation of the
pipe in a stream, the substrate will be replaced last to restore the streambed's armoring layer, and the
surface will be returned to preconstruction contours. Following installation of the pipe in a wetland, the
wetland topsoil will be restored, decompacted, and returned to preconstruction contours. Refer to
Sections 5.2.8 and 5.2.9 for additional details.
4.3.2 Suspended Particles/Turbidity (§ 230.21)
Mountain Valley will use the dry -ditch open -cut method to install the pipeline in streams included in this
application, except for the Dan River, Dry Creek, Cascade Creek, Trayner Branch, Sandy River, Sandy
Creek, Banister River, Cherrystone Creek, and 10 unnamed tributaries (Table 12). This method involves
the use of cofferdams, flumes, pumps, or other measures to dewater the construction site and divert flow
around the site for the duration of the crossing. Erosion and sediment control measures are implemented
during this activity in accordance with the FERC Procedures and ESCPs approved by the NC DEQ and
VA DEQ. These measures reduce the potential for suspended particle and turbidity impacts during
construction and immediately after flow is restored to the site. Refer to Section 5.2.1 and Attachment J
(Construction Details) for additional details.
The installation of culverts will cause a similarly minimal and short-term increase in suspended particle
and turbidity in streams with flowing water.
4.3.3 Water (§ 230.22)
Due to the dry -ditch open -cut construction practices discussed in Section 4.3.2, impacts to water quality
will include minimal, short-term increases in sediment loads and turbidity level. The discharges would not
be expected to materially affect water odor, taste, biochemical oxygen demand, dissolved oxygen, or
nutrient loads.
4.3.4 Current Patterns and Water Circulation (§ 230.23)
Water current patterns and circulation will be temporarily affected only during the period of active
construction within a waterbody for an open -cut crossing. As noted above, water flow will be maintained
by the use of diversions, flumes, and/or pumps to divert flow around the work site. To minimize the
duration of such disturbances, stream crossings are completed on consecutive days until the crossing is
complete and the stream is restored. Following pipe installation, the stream is restored to its
preconstruction contours to avoid any changes to current patterns or water circulation.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
As discussed in Section 4.2.6, culverts will be installed to maintain water flows and circulation patterns.
4.3.5 Normal Water Fluctuations (§ 230.24)
As discussed above, the Amendment Project's stream impacts will be primarily temporary before being
restored to preconstruction contours. Additionally, Mountain Valley will install permanent trench breakers
adjacent to all waterbody crossings so that the disturbed trench soil will not create a preferential pathway
for subsurface flow that could alter stream and wetland hydrology. These measures should prevent any
long-term changes to the normal water fluctuations of impacted streams.
As discussed in Section 4.2.6, culverts will be installed to maintain water flows and circulation patterns
and, therefore, should have no effect on normal water fluctuations.
4.3.6 Salinity Gradients (§ 230.25)
Because the Amendment Project will not materially affect stream flows, there is no foreseeable possibility
of downstream changes to salinity gradients.
4.3.7 Threatened and Endangered Species § (230.30)
Mountain Valley is engaged in ongoing coordination with the USFWS and state agencies to avoid and
minimize impacts to sensitive species. Refer to Section 1.8.4 for additional information.
4.3.8 Fish, Crustaceans, Mollusks, and Other Aquatic Organisms in
Food Web (§ 230.31)
As discussed above, the Amendment Project will employ mitigation measures to minimize the sediment
and turbidity impacts from stream crossings. Mountain Valley will continue to consult with relevant federal
and state authorities for potential impacts to protected fish and mussels and will adhere to TOYRs when
required by relevant federal or state authorities. Refer to the FERC FEIS § 4.6.5.2 for additional
information on fish and mussel relocation measures.
4.3.9 Other Wildlife (§ 230.32)
Mountain Valley is not aware of any adverse effects on other wildlife associated with aquatic ecosystems,
including migratory bird breeding areas, resulting from the discharge of dredged or fill material during
stream and wetland crossings.
4.3.10 Sanctuaries and Refuges (§ 230.40)
The Amendment Project does not directly impact any estuarine or marine sanctuaries or designated
wildlife refuges.
A portion of the Amendment Project is located in the vicinity (within one mile) of the White Oak Mountain
Wildlife Management Area in Virginia between MP 0 and MP 1.3. The White Oak Mountain Wildlife
Management Area's western boundary borders the Banister River and is downstream of the proposed
Banister River crossing. Mountain Valley will implement a project -specific ESCP and Spill Prevention,
Control, and Countermeasure (SPCC) Plan45 to mitigate potential impacts downstream of the crossings of
45 Mountain Valley's Spill Prevention, Control and Countermeasure Plan and Unanticipated Discovery of
Contamination Plan for Construction Activities in Virginia and North Carolina was included as Appendix 1-G to
Resource Report 1 (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20250203-5193) in its February 3, 2025 Amendment
Application.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
the Banister River and its tributaries. Mountain Valley will also restore temporary impacts to the Banister
River and its tributaries to pre -construction conditions. Additionally, Mountain Valley will adhere to all
applicable TOYRs imposed by state and federal agencies to protect the integrity of aquatic habitat. Due to
the proposed mitigation measures and the distance from a designated wildlife refuge, adverse effects to
designated estuarine or marine sanctuaries or wildlife refuges are not anticipated as a result of this
Amendment Project.
4.3.11 Wetlands (§ 230.41)
The loss of wetlands has been avoided and minimized to the maximum extent practicable in accordance
with the 404(b)(1) Guidelines. Notwithstanding the size of the Amendment Project, it has been carefully
designed to cause no permanent loss of wetland area.
4.3.12 Mud Flats (§ 230.42)
The Amendment Project does not affect any mud flats.
4.3.13 Vegetated Shallows (§ 230.43)
Mountain Valley is not aware of any impacts to vegetated shallows.
4.3.14 Riffle and Pool Complexes (§ 230.45)
As part of the stream restoration process, Mountain Valley will replace the stream substrate and restore
the streambed to preexisting contours. These measures would reestablish any riffles and pools affected
by construction.
Riffle -pool complexes are bedform undulations developed in either supply- or transport -limited systems
with gravel beds and slope gradients less than 0.02.46 Pools offer deeper water habitat during periods of
ice cover or low flow, riffles provide spawning gravels and primary food -production areas, and riffle -pool
complexes encourage hyporheic exchange.47 After performing geomorphic stream field surveys for each
site, the following screening criteria were used to determine the possibility of riffle -pool complex
characteristics.
1. The slope of all perennial and intermittent streams was assessed using geomorphic stream field
survey data to determine the potential for riffle -pool complexes. Slopes between 0.02 and 0.001
foot/foot (2 and 0.1 percent) were identified for further desktop evaluation.
A desktop evaluation using aerial imagery was conducted to assess a laterally oscillating bedform
pattern with less than 2 percent slope and plan view pattern for streams classifying as C, DA, E,
or F based on the Rosgen classification methodology.48 Stream classification was determined
from data collected during the geomorphic stream field survey.
41 Montgomery, D.R., and J.M. Buffington. 1997. Channel -reach morphology in mountain drainage basins. Geological
Society of America Bulletin 109(5), pp. 596-611. May 1997. doi: 10.1130/0016-
7606(1997)109%3C0596:CRMIMD%3E2.3.00;2.
47 Tonina, D., and J.M. Buffington. 2007. Hyporheic exchange in gravel bed rivers with pool -riffle morphology:
Laboratory experiments and three-dimensional modeling. Water Resources Research 43, W01421,
doi:10.1029/2005WR004328.
48 Rosgen, D.L. 1996. Applied River Morphology. Wildland Hydrology, Pagosa Springs, Colorado. Very generally,
C streams are wider and shallower meandering alluvial channels with well -developed floodplains and riffle -pool
formations, DA streams are stable systems with multiple channels with expansive well -vegetated floodplains and
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
3. Streams determined to have laterally oscillating bedform patterns were reviewed with a specific
focus on photos, longitudinal profile data, and the presence of course -grain size (gravel) in riffles
by examining data collected from the geomorphic stream field survey. Streams with the potential
for riffle -pool complexes were flagged and summarized in the following table.
After the screening criteria were applied to all 130 streams assessed within the ROW, the following 18
streams show riffle -pool complex characteristics. For the purposes of the alternatives analysis, Mountain
Valley has assumed these streams to be riffle -pool complexes.
Probable Riffle -Pool Complexes
Milepost
Stream ID
Stream Name
1.7
S-AO09
Unnamed tributary (UNT) to Cherrystone Creek
3.9
S-AO19
UNT to Banister River
5.3
S-A021
White Oak Creek
5.4
S-A022
White Oak Creek
7.3
S-A026
UNT to White Oak Creek
8.9
S-A029
UNT to White Oak Creek
10.3
S-A033a
UNT to White Oak Creek
11.7
S-A042
UNT to Sandy Creek
13.1
S-A045
Sandy Creek
13.8
S-A046
UNT to Sandy Creek
15.1
S-A048
UNT to Sandy Creek
16.1
S-A051
UNT to Silver Creek
16.6
S-A054
UNT to Silver Creek
29.1
S-BO15
UNT to Dan River
23.6
S-B029
Trotters Creek
28.2
S-B034
UNT to Dan River
28.2
21.4
S-B035
S-B043
UNT to Dan River
Trayner Branch
4.3.15 Municipal and Private Water Supplies (§ 230.50)
A total of 17 private wells are located within 150 feet of the Amendment Project, nine of which are located
within the proposed construction workspace. All 17 of the private wells are located within Virginia, and
none are located within North Carolina. All easements required for the Amendment Project in North
Carolina have been fully acquired, 97 percent of easements (by tract) required for the Amendment Project
in Virginia have been acquired, and discussions have occurred with landowners regarding the status and
use of their wells. Further confirmation of the location of each well will be conducted with the landowner
prior to construction.
For all private wells identified within the construction workspace, Mountain Valley will clearly mark the
wellhead and surround it with silt fence and/or safety fence as a precaution for construction equipment
associated wetlands, E streams are narrow and deep with well -developed floodplains with efficient sediment
transport, and F streams are wide and shallow with entrenched meandering channels and little to no developed
floodplain.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
and activities. The Amendment Project will also implement the FERC Plan and Procedures for
stormwater-runoff control and control of petroleum and hazardous materials to further mitigate the
potential for pipeline land disturbance impacting a water resource. Pre -construction testing and post -
construction testing, if requested, will be conducted for all private wells located within 150 feet of the
construction workspace.49 In the unlikely event that a private well is impacted by Amendment Project
construction, Mountain Valley will work with the landowner to remedy any impacts, which will include a
temporary water supply to affected homeowners while their well is being repaired or replaced.
No municipal or public water supplies are located within 150 feet of the Amendment Project. Nor are any
known public water supply intakes located within 3 miles downstream of any waterbody crossings.
4.3.16 Recreational and Commercial Fisheries (§ 230.51)
Other than making small stream segments temporarily unavailable during the period of active instream
construction, Mountain Valley does not anticipate any material impacts on commercial and recreational
fishing. If necessary, Mountain Valley will request TOYR waivers from the appropriate agency. See
Section 4.2.4 for additional information on TOYR waivers.
4.3.17 Water -Related Recreation (§ 230.52)
Other than making small stream segments temporarily unavailable during active instream construction,
Mountain Valley is not aware of any material impacts on water -related recreational activities. River -based
recreation in the Dan River will not be affected during the HDD installation.
4.3.18 Aesthetics (§ 230.53)
With the exception of minor permanent impacts associated with culvert repair and replacement and the
permanent conversion of PFO and PSS wetland to PEM wetland habitat within the pipeline ROW, all
aquatic impacts will be restored to preconstruction conditions. After the period of active construction and
restoration, Mountain Valley does not foresee any effects on aesthetics associated with restored aquatic
ecosystems. Refer to the FERC FEIS §§ 4.3.2.8 and 4.4.5 for additional information.
4.3.19 Parks, National and Historical Monuments, National
Seashores, Wilderness Areas, Research Sites and Similar Preserves
(§ 230.54)
The Amendment Project does not cross any National or Historical Monuments, Wilderness Areas,
National Seashores, or research sites.
4.3.20 General Evaluation of Dredged or Fill Material (§§ 230.60,
230.61)
Mountain Valley is not aware of factors listed in 40 CFR § 230.60(b) that would indicate that any potential
dredge or fill material handled by Mountain Valley is a carrier of contaminants. If suspected contaminants
are encountered, Mountain Valley would initiate the procedures outlined in the project -specific SPCC and
Unanticipated Discovery of Contamination Plan (as required by FERC) and coordinate with the
appropriate state and federal agencies.
49 Mountain Valley's Water Resources Identification and Testing Plan was included as Appendix 1-G to Resource
Report 1 (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20250203-5193) in its February 3, 2025 Amendment Application.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
4.3.21 Actions concerning the location of the discharge (§ 230.70)
All discharges of fill material will be for the purpose of returning wetland soils and stream subsoil and
substrates removed during construction to their original location and contours.
4.3.22 Actions concerning the material to be discharged (§ 230.71)
All discharges of fill material will be for the purpose of returning wetland soils and stream subsoil and
substrates removed during construction to their original location and contours.
4.3.23 Actions controlling the material after discharge (§ 230.72)
As discussed in Section 4.3.1, Mountain Valley will use segregated stream substrates and the upper
12 inches of the wetland to restore stream and wetland crossings. The purpose of this practice is to
reduce erosion of the streambed after flow is restored and to restore hydric soils and wetland seed beds.
Mountain Valley does not expect excessive erosion or soil loss from restored wetlands.
4.3.24 Actions affecting the method of dispersion (§ 230.73)
The Amendment Project will not be dispersing any dredged material.
4.3.25 Actions related to technology (§ 230.74)
Mountain Valley employs experienced construction crews and appropriate industry -standard construction
equipment to complete stream and wetland crossings as required by the FERC Procedures, VA DEQ
Standards and Specifications, and NC DEQ Erosion and Sediment Control Planning and Design Manual.
Industry -standard construction practices include but are not limited to using stream diversions to create
dry working areas, operating from equipment mats, using low -ground -pressure equipment, refueling at
least 100 feet from streams and wetlands, training Mountain Valley workers on environmental protection
requirements, and designing and installing erosion control devices to protect the adjacent resource.
As discussed in Section 5.1.1, Mountain Valley conducted a site -specific evaluation of available crossing
method technologies to identify the method that would minimize the impact to the extent appropriate and
practicable for each crossing.
Permanent and temporary crossings of waterbodies will be suitably culverted, bridged, or otherwise
designed and constructed to be countersunk as appropriate and to maintain flows to sustain the
movement of aquatic species. As such, culverted crossings will be sized and installed in a manner to
allow the passage of aquatic life and freely pass bankfull flows.
4.3.26 Actions affecting plant and animal populations (§ 230.74)
Mountain Valley minimizes impacts to aquatic habitat by restoring all temporary impacts to
preconstruction conditions. Impacts to aquatic habitat within and downstream of the Amendment Project
will be mitigated by the implementation of an ESCP approved by state and local program authorities, the
project -specific SPCC Plan, and an HDD Contingency Plan.50 The Amendment Project will result in the
permanent loss of forested area to provide for the construction and safe operation of the pipeline;
however, the pipeline has been routed adjacent to existing pipeline ROWS and through previously
disturbed land (i.e., pastures) to the greatest extent practicable to minimize cumulative loss of forested
so Mountain Valley's Horizontal Directional Drill Contingency Plan was included as Appendix 1-G to Resource Report
1 (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20250203-5193) in its February 3, 2025 Amendment Application.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
habitat and impacts to contiguous forests via fragmentation. Mountain Valley will minimize the
degradation of existing habitat by implementing invasive species management practices and by
revegetating disturbed areas with weed -free seed mixes, subject to landowner agreements. The 2025 BA
that is being developed includes mitigation measures to minimize harm to threatened and endangered
species. Mountain Valley will adhere to all applicable TOYRs imposed by federal or state resource
agencies for the protection of aquatic and terrestrial species. Due to the mitigation measures listed above
and the limited scope of aboveground permanent impacts, the Amendment Project is unlikely to have
population -level impacts on plant or animal species.
4.3.27 Actions affecting human use (§ 230.76)
The Amendment Project's impact on human use of streams and wetlands will be minimal and solely
limited to the period of active instream and wetland construction. As noted in Section 4.3.13, dredged
material will not be discharged in proximity to any public water supply intakes.
4.3.28 Other actions (§ 230.77)
The Amendment Project does not include any of the activities addressed in this evaluation factor.
4.4 Public -Interest Review Factors
Pursuant to 33 CFR § 320.4(a), the USACE must conduct a public -interest review that considers the
"probable impacts ... of the proposed activity and its intended use on the public interest." This review must
balance the "benefits which reasonably may be expected to accrue from the proposal ... against its
reasonably foreseeable detriments." This section provides a summary of information relevant to each of
the 21 public -interest review factors listed in § 320.4(a) and, where appropriate, the additional policies
described in § 320.4(b) through (r).
4.4.1 Conservation (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on conservation.
The vast majority of the pipeline and related facilities will be buried. The land surface will be restored and
returned to preconstruction uses. The Amendment Project impacts, therefore, will be predominantly
temporary in nature.
The most significant long-term Amendment Project -related effect on conservation will stem from the
maintenance of the permanent ROW. In areas that were forested prior to construction, maintenance of
the ROW will cause a loss to the environmental service benefits of forest cover, as well as the aesthetic
impacts of the same.
Mountain Valley has minimized its effects to forested areas to the extent practicable and has voluntarily
committed to working with VDCR, the Virginia Forest Conservation Partnership, and NCWRC regarding
mitigation for clearing interior forest.
4.4.2 Economics (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a beneficial effect on the local and regional economy.
According to Mountain Valley's Amendment Project need assessment, the Amendment Project will
alleviate some of the constraints on the Piedmont Region's natural gas production by adding
infrastructure to transport lower -priced natural gas to industrial users and power generators in the
4-11 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mid -Atlantic and southeastern United States, as well as to local distribution companies. Per Section 5.1.9
of its FEIS, FERC concluded that the Original Certificated Project would have temporary and minor
positive economic impacts on the state and local economies from payroll expenditures, local purchases of
consumables for project -specific materials, room rentals, and sales tax. The long-term socioeconomic
effect of the Original Certificated Project was likely to be beneficial due to the increase in tax revenues.
Based on the economic benefits analysis (included in Attachment K) presented in Mountain Valley's
Amendment Application to FERC, the Amendment Project is anticipated to have similar socioeconomic
effects and will not have a significant adverse effect on the socioeconomic conditions of the Amendment
Project area. During the five-year construction period, the Amendment Project will generate $75.4 million
in labor income and $10.8 million in state and local tax revenues. In addition, the Amendment Project will
pay approximately $1.5 million in ad valorem tax revenues annually, on average, for the first 10 years of
operation.51 As such, Mountain Valley anticipates that, overall, the Amendment Project will have a
positive effect on economics.
4.4.3 Aesthetics (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on aesthetics.
As discussed in Section 4.1.1, Mountain Valley will have a minimal and temporary detrimental effect on
aesthetics in most areas of the Amendment Project during construction activities. After Amendment
Project restoration, these effects will be eliminated in most areas as the ROW is restored to
preconstruction conditions.
4.4.4 General Environmental Concerns (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on general environmental concerns.
The FERC FEIS for the Original Certificated Project provides a comprehensive evaluation of all relevant
environmental concerns. FERC concluded: "Construction and operation of the MVP... would result in
limited adverse environmental impacts... but some long-term and permanent environmental impacts would
occur on forest and wetlands... As part of our review, we developed specific mitigation measures that we
determined would appropriately and reasonably reduce the environmental impacts resulting from
construction and operation of the projects."52 Mountain Valley anticipates similar conclusions will be
issued with the Amended Certificate from the information provided within Mountain Valley's February 3,
2025, Amendment Application.
4.4.5 Wetlands (§ 320.4(a) & (b))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on wetlands.
The loss of wetlands has been avoided and minimized to the maximum extent practicable in accordance
with the 404(b)(1) Guidelines. Notwithstanding the size of the Amendment Project, it has been carefully
designed to cause no permanent loss of wetlands. Proposed impacts are summarized in Section 4.1.1.
Compensatory mitigation will be provided for the wetland conversion impacts as stated in Section 5.3
(Mitigation). Furthermore, in Section 4.4.5 of its FEIS, FERC concluded that impacts of the Original
Certificated Project on wetlands would be less than significant. Fewer impacts to wetlands are expected
51 The economic benefits analysis included as Attachment K contains projections as of August 2024 and
is subject to change.
52 FERC FEIS § 5.1.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
from the Amendment Project as a result of the pipeline length having been truncated to approximately 31
miles.
4.4.6 Historic, Cultural, Scenic, and Recreational Values (§ 320.4(a)
& (e))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on historic, cultural, and recreational values.
FERC developed a PA for the Original Certificated Project, in consultation with the USACE, the Virginia
Department of Historic Resources (VDHR), and the North Carolina Historic Preservation Office (NC
HPO), to resolve adverse effects to affected historic and cultural properties in accordance with 36 CFR §
800.14(b)(3). The PA was executed on May 17, 2020, and it is proposed to be renewed for the
Amendment Project. Based on the Amendment Project adherence to the tenets and conditions of the PA
between FERC, VDHR, NC HPO, and other federal permitting agencies, Mountain Valley anticipates that
the Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application will have an insignificant (mitigated)
effect on historic and cultural values.
In Section 4.8.3 of its FEIS, FERC concluded that impacts of the Original Certificated Project on scenic
and recreational values would be adequately minimized with the adherence to the measures committed
by Mountain Valley, FERC's recommendations, and other agency permitting conditions. Mountain Valley
anticipates similar conclusions will be issued with the Amended Certificate from the information provided
within Mountain Valley's application to FERC filed in February 2025. Accordingly, Mountain Valley
anticipates that the Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application will also have an
insignificant effect on scenic and recreational values
The Amendment Project does not cross any federally designated Wild and Scenic Rivers, National
Rivers, National Wilderness Areas, National Seashores, National Recreation Areas, National Lakeshores,
National Monuments, National Park Service resources, or estuarine and marine sanctuaries.
Additional information on recreational and special interest areas crossed by or in the vicinity of the
Amendment Project can be found in the FERC FEIS § 4.8.4.
4.4.7 Fish and Wildlife Values (§ 320.4(a) & (c))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on fish and wildlife values.
Mountain Valley initiated consultation with USFWS, VDWR, and the NCNHP in July 2024 regarding
records of known federally listed, state -listed, or rare species within the Amendment Project area.
Consultations with these agencies are ongoing. Prior to coordination with these agencies, qualified
biologists conducted surveys for potential rare, threatened, and endangered species within the Original
Certificated Project area between 2018 and 2020.
Mountain Valley is currently conducting fieldwork and preparing analyses to inform an independent BA to
submit to FERC for purposes of Section 7 consultation with USFWS on the Amendment Project. Based
on previous species surveys and initial information received from USFWS and the state agencies, several
federally listed species could occur in relevant proximity to the Amendment Project: NLEB, RLP, Atlantic
pigtoe and its designated critical habitat, and James spinymussel. In addition, several other species that
could occur in relevant proximity to the Amendment Project have been proposed for listing: tricolored bat,
green floater along with proposed critical habitat for the species, and monarch butterfly (Danaus
plexippus). While analysis for the BA is underway, based on initial information, it is reasonable to
anticipate at this time that the Amendment Project may affect one or more of the listed species and/or
4-13 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
proposed species. Numerous avoidance and minimization measures will be included in the 2025 BA and
other relevant agency documents to protect sensitive species.
In Section 4.6.1.1 of its FEIS, FERC concluded that impacts of the Original Certificated Project on wildlife
would not be long-term or significant. In Section 4.6.6 of its FEIS, FERC concluded that impacts of the
Original Certificated Project on fisheries and aquatic resources would not be significant. Based on the
evaluation from FERC, Mountain Valley anticipates that the Amendment Project crossings included in this
permit application will have an insignificant effect on fish and wildlife, including migratory bird breeding
areas.
4.4.8 Floodplain Hazards, Values, and Management (§ 320.4(a) & (1))
The Amendment Project will have no effect on floodplain hazards, values, and management.
As shown on the Section 10 River Crossing Plan (Attachment H) and the project -specific ESCP, the
Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application will not result in the permanent alteration
of Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)-delineated 100-year floodplains. As such, Mountain
Valley anticipates that the Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application will have no
material effect on FEMA-delineated 100-year floodplains.
4.4.9 Land Use (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a minor detrimental effect on land use.
As discussed above, the vast majority of the pipeline and related facilities will be buried. The land surface
will be restored and returned to preconstruction uses to the extent practicable. Landowners subject to the
ROW will be restricted from planting trees or building structures on the ROW but otherwise may resume
any preconstruction activities on the land.53
4.4.10 Navigation (§ 320.4(a) & (o))
The Amendment Project will have no material effect on navigation.
Mountain Valley is proposing that the Section 10 water crossing of the Dan River be completed using
HDD (Table 1). Neither temporary nor permanent instream impacts to the Dan River are anticipated.
4.4.11 Shore Erosion and Accretion (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have no material effect on shore erosion and accretion.
4.4.12 Water Supply and Conservation (§ 320.4(a) & (m))
The Amendment Project will have a negligible effect on water supply and conservation.
The Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application will not involve the permanent
alteration of streambeds or the placement of any permanent structure or within a WOTUS that will impede
or alter stream flow. The pipe will be below grade and will not impede or alter stream flow. Upon
completion of stream crossing activities, cleanup and restoration activities will commence as soon as
practicable to replace grade cuts to preconstruction contours, restore streambank ground cover, minimize
erosion, and stabilize stream banks for their natural reversion toward their previous state.
13 See FERC FEIS § 4.8.1.1 for additional information.
4-14 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
A total of 17 private wells are located within 150 feet of the Amendment Project, nine of which are located
within the proposed construction workspace. All 17 of the private wells are located within Virginia, and
none are located within North Carolina. Mountain Valley is currently working with landowners to identify
the status and use of the wells within 150 feet. The status and type of well will be determined during
easement negotiations with the landowner.
For all private wells identified within the construction workspace, Mountain Valley will clearly mark the
wellhead and surround it with silt fence and/or safety fence as a precaution for construction equipment
and activities. The Amendment Project will also implement the FERC Plan and Procedures for
stormwater-runoff control and control of petroleum and hazardous materials to further mitigate the
potential for pipeline land disturbance impacting a water resource. Pre -construction testing and post -
construction testing, if requested, will be conducted for all private wells located within 150 feet of the
construction workspace. In the unlikely event that a private well is impacted by Amendment Project
construction, the Amendment Project will negotiate a settlement with the landowner that will include a
temporary water supply to affected homeowners while their well is being repaired or replaced.
No municipal or public water supplies are located within 150 feet of the Amendment Project. Nor are any
public water supply intakes located within 3 miles downstream of any waterbody crossings.
The Amendment Project will use relatively modest quantities of water for dust suppression, hydrostatic
testing, drilling, and other construction activities. The Amendment Project water use is not expected to
have any appreciable effect on local water supplies.
4.4.13 Water Quality (§ 320.4(a) & (d))
The Amendment Project will have a minor and temporary adverse effect on water quality.
Upland Construction Stormwater. Potential short-term adverse water quality impacts from upland
construction activities (including bore pits associated with trenchless crossings) will be minimized by
compliance with the ESCPs approved in accordance with the requirements of VA DEQ and NC DEQ.
Refer to Section 5.2.4 for additional details. Mountain Valley has engaged in a comprehensive modeling
effort, using the best available science, to produce a conservative estimate of the total sediment loads
from Amendment Project construction.
Post -Construction Stormwater. Mountain Valley must implement post -construction stormwater
management measures in accordance with requirements from the FERC Plan. Compliance with these
requirements and applicable state requirements ensures that post -construction stormwater runoff from
the Amendment Project area will not cause downslope or downstream erosion or other adverse water
quality impacts.
In -Stream Construction. Potential water quality impacts associated with instream construction will be
minimized through the use of dry -ditch open -cut crossing techniques in conjunction with erosion and
sediment control measures required by FERC, VA DEQ, and NC DEQ. Refer to Section 5.2.1 for
additional details. FERC evaluated dry -ditch open -cut crossing methods in its FEIS, stating:
A study conducted by the [U.S. Geological Survey] (Moyer and Hyer, 2009) investigating
the effects of dry open -cut waterbody crossings on downstream sediment loading found
that short-term increases in turbidity downstream of construction did occur, but the
magnitude of the increase was small and considered to be minimal compared to increased
turbidity associated with natural runoff events. Other literature (e.g., Reid et al., 2004)
assessing the magnitude and timing of suspended sediment produced from open -cut dry
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
crossing methods indicates the duration of increased sedimentation would be mostly short-
term (i.e., less than 1-4 days) and remain near the crossing location (i.e., an approximate
downstream distance of a few hundred feet). (FERC FEIS 4-92).
Hydrostatic Test Water Discharges. In accordance with FERC and state discharge permit
requirements, hydrostatic test water would be discharged through sediment filters in vegetated upland
areas.
4.4.14 Energy Needs, Energy Conservation and Development (§
320.4(a) & (n))
The Amendment Project will have a major beneficial effect on energy needs and development.54
As described in Section 2.0, the Amendment Project will provide natural gas transportation services for
Foundation Shippers PSNC and Duke to meet their growing supply needs. The Amendment Project will
also provide gas to two new delivery points in Rockingham County, North Carolina.
4.4.15 Safety (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have no material effect on safety.
Pipeline maintenance and operation is a highly regulated activity. The Amendment Project will comply
with all applicable regulatory requirements of PHMSA to ensure the safe operation of the pipeline. Refer
to the FERC FEIS § 4.12 for additional information.
4.4.16 Food and Fiber Production (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a negligible effect on food and fiber production.
The Amendment Project crosses a number of parcels in active agricultural use. The landowners' use of
those parcels may be affected temporarily during Amendment Project construction. After the completion
of construction, these areas may return to their preconstruction agricultural uses.
4.4.17 Mineral Needs (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have no effect on mineral needs.
4.4.18 Consideration of Property Ownership (§ 320.4(a) & (g))
The Amendment Project will have a neutral (mitigated) effect on property ownership.
Natural gas companies must obtain easements from landowners along the route of their pipelines to
construct and operate authorized facilities. Easements can be temporary, meaning they grant the
company the use of the land during construction (e.g., extra workspaces, temporary access roads, yards),
or permanent, meaning they grant the company the right to operate and maintain the facilities once
constructed. The majority of landowners (98 percent) along the ROW were willing sellers. Mountain Valley
is coordinating with three remaining landowners for easements and anticipates negotiations will continue
into mid-2025. In either case, the landowner has been or will be compensated for the fair market value of
the easement.
sa The USACE's regulations state: "Energy conservation and development are major national objectives. District
engineers will give high priority to the processing of permit actions involving energy projects." 33 CFR § 320.4(n).
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
4.4.19 Needs and Welfare of the People (§ 320.4(a))
The Amendment Project will have a beneficial effect on the needs and welfare of the people.
FERC developed a "Certificate Policy Statement" that established criteria for determining whether there is
a need for a proposed project and whether the proposed project would serve the public interest. The
Amendment Project's public interest is detailed in Section 2.3 above. As FERC recognized in the Original
Certificated Project's Certificate, Congress articulated that the transportation and sales of natural gas in
interstate commerce for ultimate distribution to the public is in the public interest. In issuing that
Certificate, FERC concluded that Mountain Valley has sufficiently demonstrated that there is market
demand for the Original Certificated Project and that the pipeline is in the public interest (171 FERC ¶
61,232, P 19). Mountain Valley anticipates similar conclusions will be obtained as part of FERC's review
of Mountain Valley's Amendment filing application in February 2025. Public comments to the February
2025 filing in support of the Amendment Project were filed by landowners, local non -profits, state
agencies, and state and federal elected officials from both Virginia and North Carolina (included in
Attachment L). Benefits highlighted in the public comments include significant advances in business and
economic growth, reducing carbon emissions, maintaining affordable energy, enhancing public safety due
to reliable energy infrastructure, and providing an additional interstate supply source of natural gas.
4.4.20 Effects on Limits of the Territorial Sea (§ 320.4(f))
The Amendment Project is not located in and will have no effect on coastal waters or territorial seas.
4.4.21 Activities Affecting Coastal Zones (§ 320.4(h))
The Amendment Project is not located in and will have no effect on any coastal zones.
4.4.22 Activities in Marine Sanctuaries (§ 320.4(h))
The Amendment Project is not located in and will have no effect on any marine sanctuaries.
4.4.23 Other Federal, State, or Local Requirements (§ 320.4(j))
Table 9 lists all required federal, state, and local permits or authorizations necessary for the construction
of the Amendment Project. Mountain Valley has not yet obtained any permits or authorizations at the time
of this application.55
4.4.24 Safety of Impoundment Structures (§ 320.4(k))
The Amendment Project does not involve the construction or maintenance of any permanent
impoundment structures.
Instream diversions will be temporary in nature and can be removed if severe weather is imminent. As
such, the Amendment Project crossings included in this permit application will not imperil the safety of
impoundment structures.
4.4.25 Environmental Benefits (§ 320.4(p))
Although there will be temporary environmental impacts to streams and wetlands from the construction of
the Amendment Project, those impacts are either insignificant or negligible. The Amendment Project is
55 FERC. 2020. 171 FERC 161,232 Order Issuing Certificate re Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC under CP19-14.
(FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20200618-3159).
a-17 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Affected Environment and Environmental Review Factors
USACE Individual Permit Application
less impactful than other alternative means of transporting the proposed volumes of natural gas from
production areas in the Appalachian Basin to markets in the Mid -Atlantic and southeastern United States.
If the Amendment Project is not authorized or not constructed, this may result in the expansion of existing
natural gas transportation systems or the construction of new infrastructure, either of which would likely
result in greater environmental impacts in comparison to this Amendment Project.
4.4.26 Mitigation (§ 320.4(r))
The Amendment Project's impacts will be avoided and minimized to the extent practicable. Compensation
will be provided for unavoidable permanent impacts. Please refer to Section 5.0 for a detailed discussion
of mitigation.
4-18 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigation
USACE Individual Permit Application
5.0 Mitigation
Mountain Valley proposes to avoid impacts to jurisdictional features to the greatest extent practicable,
minimize unavoidable impacts, and provide compensation for resulting impacts that are not de minimis,
given the Amendment Project's purpose and need. Complete avoidance of WOTUS is not possible due to
the linear nature of the Amendment Project; location of the beginning, terminal, and intermediate
interconnection points; and the necessity to construct access roads and ATWS where needed. The
information in this section is provided in accordance with the application requirements identified in 33
CFR § 325.1(d)(7)56 and to document Mountain Valley's compliance with the 404(b)(1) Guidelines and the
USACE and EPA's mitigation sequence guidance.57
5.1 Avoidance
5.1.1 Avoidance and Minimization by Selection of Pipeline Crossing
Method
There are several commonly accepted methods available for installing the pipeline across stream and
wetland resources. Any specific crossing method may not be suitable for every crossing situation. The
process of selecting an appropriate crossing method must account for various site -specific circumstances,
such as the size of a stream, steepness of the approach slopes, available workspace, time required to
complete the crossing under the various methods, local geology, and proximity to residences, roads, or
sensitive environmental resources. For each pipeline crossing of a stream or wetland included in this
application, Mountain Valley evaluated potential crossing methods using these factors. Through this
analysis, Mountain Valley carefully evaluated available onsite alternatives consistent with the Section
404(b)(1) Guidelines in order to avoid or minimize stream and wetland impacts to the extent practicable.
More specifically, this section is provided to document that "appropriate and practicable steps have been
taken which will minimize potential adverse impacts of the discharge on the aquatic ecosystem" in
accordance with 40 CFR § 230.10(d) and 40 CFR Part 230, Subpart H.58
5.1.1.1 Pipeline Crossing Methods
Mountain Valley evaluated three alternative stream and wetland pipeline crossing methods that are
accepted by industry standards for pipelines of this size. The crossing methods can be generally
categorized as either (1) open -cut methods —meaning that a trench is excavated in the stream or wetland
to install the pipe —or (2) trenchless methods —meaning the pipe is installed with specialized equipment
that bores or tunnels under or bridges over the resource.
51 With respect to aquatic impacts in Virginia, this section also documents compliance with the applicable mitigation
provisions of the VWP permit regulation, including 9VAC25-210- 80.B.1.g and -116. The avoidance, minimization,
and compensation requirements of the 404(b)(1) Guidelines and VWP permit regulation are consistent in most
material respects. To the extent there are any minor differences, Mountain Valley will comply with both regulations.
57 USACE and EPA, Memorandum of Agreement regarding Mitigation under CWA Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines (Feb.
6, 1990).
58 The on -site alternative for each stream crossing selected through this analysis also would constitute the least
environmentally damaging practicable alternative. So, to the extent applicable, this section also demonstrates
compliance with 40 CFR § 230.10(a).
5-1 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigation
USACE Individual Permit Application
Open -Cut Crossing Methods
Dry -Ditch Open -Cut
Trenchless Crossing Methods
Horizontal Directional Drilling
Conventional Bore
Each of these crossing methods is described further below.
5.1.1.1.1 Dry -Ditch Open -Cut
Dry -ditch open -cut crossings combine traditional trench construction techniques with ESCP BMPs (e.g.,
silt fence, compost filter socks, turbidity curtains, pumped water filter bags) and water management
techniques/diversion structure (cofferdam, flume pipe, and dam -and -pump) to install pipeline across
waterways. This method involves isolating the work area from the stream so construction can be
performed in a controlled, "dry" condition. However, Mountain Valley does not anticipate using the flume
crossing method on streams with possible proposed or listed threatened or endangered species or
proposed or designated critical habitat —instead, Mountain Valley would utilize the dam -and -pump
method at these locations.
During construction, the section (or sections of pipe) to be installed in the waterway will be prepared and
readied for installation. After the flow is diverted around the crossing area, the work area will be
dewatered by pumping standing water into an energy -dissipating dewatering structure (including filter
bags, where necessary) in a well -vegetated upland area to minimize erosion and sedimentation, as
required by the ESCP. The trench will then be prepared for receiving the pipe. The top 12 inches of
streambed substrate will be segregated and stockpiled to prevent mixing with other materials and to be
used during restoration. In wetlands, the top 12 inches of topsoil (if unsaturated) will be removed from the
ground surface, segregated, as appropriate, from subsoil, and replaced in the proper order during
backfilling and final grading. Where topsoil is less than 12 inches deep, the actual depth of the topsoil will
be removed and segregated. Segregated topsoil will be placed in the trench following subsoil backfilling.
Topsoil segregation may not be practical in saturated wetlands with standing water.
The pipe will be placed in the trench to a length of at least 10 feet beyond the high bank of the stream and
will be installed to provide a minimum of 3 feet of cover from the waterbody bottom to the top of the
pipeline. In areas of consolidated rock, Mountain Valley will excavate rock using hydraulic hammers (to
the extent feasible) or blasting (only when necessary) to maintain the minimum depth of cover at 3 feet at
waterbody crossings.59
Stream impacts within the pipeline LOD using the dry -ditch open -cut method would be temporary and
occur during pipeline construction activities only.60 With the use of diversion structures, the risk of
increased levels of sediment and turbidity is largely reduced and limited to the work associated with
installing and removing the cofferdam or other diversion structure, which is the only time work within the
flowing stream is necessary. Once installed, the presence of a diversion structure within a stream does
not materially cause ongoing sediment or turbidity increases downstream of the crossing —meaning there
59 In addition to observing the general minimum depth -of -cover requirements, Mountain Valley will implement any
scour mitigation requirements detailed in the FERC FEIS.
10 See Reid, S.M., S. Metikosh and J.M. Evans. 2008. Overview of the river and stream crossings study. Pages 711-
721 in Elsevier, ed. Proceedings of the symposium at the 8th international symposium of environment concerns in
rights -of -way management. Saratoga Springs, NY.
5-2 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigatioi
USACE Individual Permit Application
is little difference in potential water quality impacts regardless of the temporary diversion's duration. While
the diversion structure is in place, the excavation, installation, backfilling, and streambed restoration are
isolated from the flowing river and performed under dry conditions. Temporary stream crossings would
not result in a long-term impact to water quality, physical habitat, or aquatic species within the
Amendment Project area due to the short duration of stream -crossing construction activities and the
implementation of the ESCP BMPs.61
Wetland impacts within the pipeline LOD using the dry -ditch open -cut method would mostly be temporary
impacts to PEM wetlands that would occur during pipeline construction activities only. However, the dry -
ditch open -cut crossing method would result in some permanent conversion of PFO and PSS wetlands to
PEM wetlands within the permanent pipeline easement.
5.1.1.1.2 Horizontal Directional Drilling
HDD is a method that allows for trenchless construction across an area by pre -drilling a pilot (or guide)
hole below the depth of a conventional pipeline and then pulling the pipeline through the pre -drilled
borehole. The HDD method has been in use since the 1970s to install pipelines across rivers and at
shore approaches to eliminate pipeline exposure from erosion and scour. Pipelines up to 60 inches in
diameter have been successfully installed using this method. The length of pipeline that can be installed
by HDD depends upon soil conditions and pipe diameters and is limited by available technology and
equipment design capacity limits.
A steerable drill assembly is used to drill the pilot hole using a combination of tracking wires and bit
sensors to maintain the drill path determined during the design phase. Once the pilot hole is completed, it
is enlarged using reaming tools to provide access for the pipe. The reaming tools are attached to the drill
string at the exit point of the pilot hole and then rotated and drawn back to the drilling rig, thus
progressively enlarging the pilot hole with each pass. During this process, drilling fluid is continuously
pumped under high pressure into the hole to remove cuttings and maintain the integrity of the hole.
Drilling fluid typically consists of bentonite clay, drilling additives, and water. Once the hole has been
sufficiently enlarged, a prefabricated segment of pipe is attached behind the reaming tool on the exit side
of the crossing and pulled back through the drill hole to the drill rig, completing the crossing.
Although the HDD method is a proven technology for pipe installation, the potential exists for an HDD
installation to fail. Reasons for failure include encountering soil conditions that are not conducive to
boring, caving of the borehole, losing the drill string in the borehole, loss of drilling fluid return or IR to
surface, and pullback refusal. Specific geology —such as karst, fractures, or fissures —and the presence
of subsurface preferential groundwater flow paths can increase the potential for an IR to occur. Proximity
to public drinking water sources, private wells, and mining activities (both active and abandoned) also
should be considered during the HDD feasibility analysis. Many of these potential failures, such as cave-
ins, pullback refusal, and unstable rock, may be avoided or mitigated by making appropriate adjustments
to the operation of the HDD equipment or HDD location. However, impacts on aquatic resources, water
supplies, and sensitive species in the event of a loss of drilling mud and/or IR are possible.
In addition to the potential for an IR, the minimum bend radius of the pipe must also be considered in the
design. Commonly accepted industry practice for initial HDD feasibility analyses is to use a minimum
allowable bending radius of 100 times the pipe's outer diameter, or 3,000 feet, for Mountain Valley's
proposed 30-inch diameter pipeline. In practice, this radius can be reduced if a detailed engineering
analysis determines the associated stresses the pipe string would be subjected to are acceptable. Using
a tighter bend radius may be warranted to accommodate various factors, including differences in
61 See FERC FEIS § 4.3.2.8. See also Reid (2008).
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigatioi
USACE Individual Permit Application
elevation between the entry and exit points, desired clearance below the resource being crossed, desired
entry and exit angles, and changes in subsurface geology. In addition, the bend radius will affect the
catenary, or the curve formed where the pipe is hanging at the pullback point. Topography, bend radius,
and entry/exit angles are all factors that determine the catenary height from the ground and whether HDD
is a practicable crossing method. A bend radius as aggressive as 2,000 feet may be acceptable with
respect to the material strength of the pipe proposed to be used on this project. However, as the bend
radius is reduced, there is a corresponding increase in the risk of bore failure. The terrain crossed by the
Amendment Project does not require the use of bending radii so small, as most of the crossings are in
relatively flat terrain. Mountain Valley has included HDD in its site -specific analysis of appropriate
crossing methods.
5.1.1.1.3 Conventional Bore
Conventional bore is a technique commonly used in pipeline construction to avoid impacting a sensitive
resource, road crossing, or railroad crossing. When using a conventional bore, the pipe is installed
beneath the waterbody or wetland, thereby avoiding open trenching across waterbodies and wetlands
and avoiding the aquatic impacts associated with working directly within waterbodies and wetlands.
Conventional bores allow for uninterrupted existing streamflow and undisturbed wetland vegetation,
thereby minimizing impacts to aquatic resources, preserving wetland and wildlife habitat, and minimizing
areas of permanent wetland conversion.
The conventional bore method, or auger bore, requires the excavation of launching and receiving pits
located in workspace in uplands on each side of the feature being crossed. The bore -pit excavations are
sloped or shored to comply with all local, state, and federal safety regulations. Prior to construction,
wetlands and waterbodies adjacent to each work site are protected using erosion and sediment control
devices and BMPs appropriate to the specific site. Bore pits produce spoil piles from the excavated
material to create the pit, which is monitored and managed until the bore is complete and the bore pits
are backfilled. The volume of spoil generated during boring operations is generally comparable to that
generated during open -cut crossings —although the pits may be deeper, an open trench is longer. The
cuttings from the bore may also be stockpiled on -site and are used to backfill the bore pits. Any spoil
remaining is spread evenly over the ROW or hauled away.
Bore -pit dewatering may be required and, if so, is accomplished in accordance with the Amendment
Project's applicable ESCP and FERC requirements. Bore -pit dewatering may be required 24 hours per
day. The specific need for, and amount of, dewatering required for any given waterbody or wetland
crossing can vary over short periods of time due to recent precipitation and other factors. It cannot be
determined until each individual trench or bore -pit excavation begins.
In general, construction activities will occur six days per week from 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. or daylight
hours, except where the pipeline would be installed using HDD and conventional bore methods, which
require around -the -clock operations and typically last a few days to a few weeks.
Conventional boring's major advantage over some other boring technologies is that the drill pipe is
installed as the boring is advanced, and the line pipe is installed immediately behind the bore pipe once
the boring is completed, leaving no unsupported hole that could potentially collapse. Because the
borehole is continuously supported by pipe throughout the process, the risk of bore collapse is minimal.
Conventional boring typically requires the least amount of areal footprint (workspace) of the mechanical
trenchless technologies because drilling fluid tanks and mud -mixing systems are not required. Cuttings
(spoil) generated by boring operations may be stockpiled temporarily at the site but would ultimately be
reused as backfill in the pipeline ROW or transported offsite to an appropriate disposal site. Unlike some
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi .
bore methods that use drilling fluids under pressure as a slurry to convey cuttings to the surface, a
conventional bore conveys cuttings to the surface mechanically using a screw auger. Because a
conventional bore does not convey cuttings using a high-pressure drilling fluid slurry, this method avoids
the potential for an IR during the crossing. However, in some situations, particularly in longer bores or in
bores through mixed ground or clay, small quantities of water, bentonite, or polymer -based lubricant may
be applied to the cutting head and exterior of the casing to reduce friction and increase the likelihood of
success of the crossing. Any lubricants used will be non -petrochemical based, non -hazardous, and NSF-
60 compliant.
Mountain Valley has included conventional bore in its site -specific analysis of appropriate crossing
methods.
5.1.1.2 Pipeline Crossing Constraints
Mountain Valley gained a wealth of experience with the real -world performance of various crossing
methods in the region during the construction of the Mainline Project. Although the methodology used for
the Amendment Project is materially similar to the methodology that was approved by the USACE and
VA DEQ for the Mainline Project, the pipeline crossing constraints relevant to bore -pit depths, stream
depths, and potential for bore failure have been updated due to situations encountered installing
crossings for the Mainline Project.
To determine the preferred crossing method for each crossing, Amendment Project engineers must
consider a number of factors. Mountain Valley considered the following technical, logistical, and cost
criteria in its evaluation of the appropriation and practicable crossing methods proposed in this
application:
1. Crossing Length
2. Bore -Pit Depth
3. Stream Depth
4. Cost
5. Steep Slopes Adjacent to Stream/Wetland Crossings
6. Potential for Bore Failure
7. Unique Site -Specific Circumstances
To analyze each crossing, these criteria were applied to the relevant stream and wetland characteristics
to determine the proposed method for each crossing. Some of the constraints are more rigid —for
example, the manufacturers' specifications dictate maximum crossing lengths for trenchless crossings.
With other criteria, such as bore -pit depth and steep slopes, the technical and logistical difficulties, as well
as costs, may increase proportionally. To determine the appropriate and practicable crossing method,
Mountain Valley's Amendment Project engineers must consider each relevant factor in light of site -
specific conditions. The result is a site -specific assessment of practicable alternatives for each proposed
stream and wetland crossing included in this permit application. This section discusses seven crossing
constraints that generally are common considerations for every pipeline crossing. However, there are a
host of other potential circumstances that could affect which crossing method or methods are available,
appropriate, and practicable at any given location. Those site -specific criteria are addressed in this
section as well.
5.1.1.2.1 Crossing Length
There generally are no technical or logistical constraints on crossing length for the dry -ditch open -cut
crossing method. However, there are technical constraints on crossing length for conventional bore
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigatioi
USACE Individual Permit Application
methods. Based on generally accepted standard industry engineering practices and professional pipeline
engineering experience, the maximum crossing length for a conventional bore using the auger machines
available for 30-inch pipe is generally considered to be 300 feet. HDDs have regularly achieved lengths in
excess of 6,000 feet under certain conditions. Given the nature of the installation, however, this technique
is constrained not solely by length but more by the combination of factors that go into the design, which
also include pipe size, geology, bore geometry, and rig size. Additionally, an HDD path must be long
enough to accommodate the distance it takes to drill to the desired depth, bend the pipe through an
allowable radius without overstressing it, and return to the surface along a similar trajectory. As such, a
crossing must be long enough to be considered a candidate for HDD installation.
5.1.1.2.2 Bore -Pit Depth
There are technical, logistical, and safety constraints on the maximum depth of bore pits. Deeper bore
pits present substantially greater challenges and logistical difficulties for trenchless crossings.62 Those
challenges can be compounded or otherwise affected by other site conditions. Based on generally
accepted standard industry construction practices and professional pipeline construction experience (and
subject to other site -specific conditions), the logistical challenges, site geometric constraints, and costs
associated with successfully completing a trenchless crossing materially and substantially increase with
depth.
Bore pit depth is limited by the reach of excavators. Bore pit depths less than 20 feet are usually possible
unless other site constraints are significant. At bore pit depths between 20 and 24 feet, logistical
challenges are greatly increased and compounded by other site constraints. Additionally, Occupational
Safety and Health Administration requirements mandate site -specific engineered shoring plans or
significant sloping or benching for excavations exceeding 20 feet deep. Depths over 24 feet can be
conducted only with extraordinary measures and costs in sites with close to optimal conditions.
Mountain Valley has identified 24 feet as the threshold for severe logistical challenges because that is the
maximum reach extent of a CAT 336 or 349 excavator, which are the most common pieces of excavating
equipment that are expected to be available for Amendment Project construction. To go deeper,
extraordinary measures must be implemented to allow the excavators to operate below the surface,
within the bore pit. Those measures typically include an interim ramp and bench that must be excavated,
which dramatically increases the space occupied by the bore pit and spoil pile in the constrained ROW.
Several factors contributed to reducing the practicability threshold for bore pit depths from 40 feet on the
Mainline Project to 24 feet on the Amendment Project. First, as stated above, 24 feet is the maximum
reach of excavators when stationed on flat ground, which also applied to the Mainline Project. However,
the Mainline Project indicated a 40-foot pit depth could be constructed by building out interim benches,
which were premised on having a wider construction ROW of 125 feet wide. The Amendment Project has
a narrower construction ROW compared to the Mainline Project (100 feet versus 125 feet), which hinders
the ability to build out interim benches and maintain safe access to the ROW. While it may be technically
possible to create 40-foot pit depths in the workspace of the Amendment Project (if no other constraining
factors, such as steep slopes, are present), it would require extraordinary engineering and construction
measures for shoring and excavating. The scale of the Amendment Project, in terms of footprint,
equipment power available, and budget, is smaller than the Mainline Project, which makes these types of
extraordinary measures more prohibitive. Another factor that contributed to reducing the practicable
threshold for bore pit depths was groundwater infiltration complications with deeper bore pits. Bored
stream crossings that were near or within a wetland complex on the Mainline Project proved difficult in
effectively removing water that infiltrated the bore pit, which was compounded with deeper excavations.
62 Neither the dry -ditch open -cut crossing method nor the HDD method requires the use of bore pits.
5-6 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigatioi
USACE Individual Permit Application
The Amendment Project has revised the practicable threshold for bore pit depths to 24 feet to avoid these
complications in a more limited workspace with generally smaller construction equipment due to the
diameter of the pipe.
The Amendment Project generally utilizes a 100-foot-wide construction ROW, narrowing to 75 feet within
50 feet of aquatic resource crossings, to preserve the maximum amount of riparian vegetation, which
leaves a limited amount of space for bore pits, pipeline trench, work areas, spoil piles, travel lanes, and
staging areas. Because the cost of trenchless crossing methods is directly proportional to their length, the
bore pits from which they are constructed are typically placed close to the aquatic resource while allowing
room for erosion and sediment control measures. The material excavated from a bore pit must be
stockpiled within the limited space available in ROW, in close proximity to the pit. As the volume of
material in spoil pile increases, the area available for construction crews to operate decreases. Bore pits
greater than 20 feet in depth typically require more space than is typically available in the 75-foot-wide
ROW to accommodate bore pits, pipeline trenches, work areas, spoil piles, travel lanes, and staging
areas while also maintaining a safe working environment. Safety for construction personnel is a
paramount concern. To minimize the risk of pit collapse and allow equipment to reach the bottom of the
bore pit, pit walls may need to be set back and/or shored. The setback width for deeper bore pits
becomes increasingly constrained by the available workspace in the ROW. Shoring pits can increase
safety for workers operating in and around bore pits, but it increases the logistical challenges and may
substantially increase the crossing duration. These factors are of particular concern because the width of
the ROW at crossings is narrowed for stream protection requirements on this project as discussed above.
Deeper pits result in increasingly large spoil piles. Unless site conditions provide sufficient and suitable
additional temporary workspace, there may not be sufficient space onsite to manage the spoil piles from
deeper pits without multiple movements of said material away from the bore pit areas, which become
more costly and logistically challenging if other sites condition constraints such as steep slopes and rock
(which has a much higher swell factor than soil and thus requires more stockpile volume) are present.
Such compounding factors will greatly increase the duration of the crossing.
For each crossing, Mountain Valley determined the depth of the two bore pits that would be necessary to
complete the crossing. That determination accounted for the depth below the stream or wetland, the
steepness of the two slopes, and the difference in elevation between the launching and receiving bore
pits. Mountain Valley also evaluated the volume of material to be excavated against the available working
area to determine the approximate available workspace.
As discussed in the following section, the compounding effect of limited workspace for material storage
and site access hindered by steep slopes evaluated with respect to its impact to the overall construction
time and potential safety concerns. Trenchless crossing methods are generally considered technically
and logistically practicable for any crossing that would require bore pits less than 20 feet in depth unless
other significant site logistical challenges exist.
5.1.1.2.3 Steep Slopes Adjacent to Stream/Wetland Crossings
There are compounding technical, logistical, and safety limitations for the use of conventional bore on
steep slopes.
Mountain Valley evaluated each crossing to determine if steep slopes on one or both approaches to the
stream or wetland make trenchless crossing methods impracticable. That evaluation primarily accounted
for the maximum average slope criteria. Slopes with grades 30 percent or greater require winching of
equipment to work safely on the slope. Winching can be utilized on shorter slopes to conduct many
pipeline construction activities. As slope lengths increase, additional pieces of heavy machinery must be
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigatioi
USACE Individual Permit Application
winched together and anchored to the top of the slope in a daisy -chain fashion down the hillside. Based
on generally accepted standard industry construction practices and professional pipeline construction
experience, operating the equipment necessary to excavate a bore pit on slopes that require winching
presents additional complicating factors. In particular, operating excavation equipment on the edge of the
bore pit, while winched to multiple pieces of equipment, presents a heightened safety risk to equipment
operators and other crew members. In general, Mountain Valley's review identified few crossings that
featured prolonged slopes of this sort. While no crossings were immediately determined to be
impracticable because of this metric, it was still utilized as a tool to measure the overall feasibility of a
trenchless crossing.
Similarly, moving and storing spoil piles on steep slopes presents an additional layer of logistical
challenges, as well as compounding safety and environmental risks. An evaluation of sufficient stockpile
size needed for spoil storage is provided in Table 12. If there was not sufficient workspace adjacent to the
crossing to store excavated materials, Mountain Valley evaluated the logistics of hauling materials to a
suitable location for staging. While prolonged winch hills of this sort were not identified along the
approaches to resource crossings, slopes of this degree at or in the vicinity of the bore pits present other
challenges. Steep terrain around the bore pit can require additional benching and sloping of the
excavations to ensure the stability of the pit walls. Additional erosion and sedimentation control measures
may be required to reduce the risk of upland erosion impacting the waterbodies and excessive runoff into
the pits, further reducing the available workspace. Finally, even if winch hills are not a challenge,
stockpiling material immediately adjacent to bore pits on sloped terrain poses challenges and is
undesirable for the reasons stated above, which may require tramming the material farther upland. This,
in turn, increases the duration of the crossing.
Therefore, Mountain Valley considered excavating bore pits on steep slopes greater than 30 percent to
be generally possible but to cause additional safety and environmental risk. However, the compounding
effect of unavailable storage space for bore pit excavation materials and steep slopes generally makes a
bored crossing impracticable.
5.1.1.2.4 Stream Depth
Stream depth may be a limiting factor in the use of the open -cut method. The technical, logistical, and
safety challenges for the open -cut crossing method increase with stream depth. Based on generally
accepted standard industry construction practices, professional pipeline construction experience
(including experience gained on the Mainline Project), and the limited workspace available for
Amendment Project crossings, it is not practicable in most cases to use the dry -ditch open -cut crossing
method for streams deeper than 24 inches.
A dry -ditch, open -cut crossing can be accomplished using dam -and -pump, flume pipe diversion, or
cofferdam methods to dewater the stream for pipeline installation. With any of these methods, a dam
structure is needed to keep the stream from flowing through the workspace. The LOD for stream
crossings is reduced from the normal 100-foot width to 75 feet, and there must be sufficient room for the
dam, pump, and construction activities. The dam must be at least as tall as the depth of the stream, plus
a minimum amount of freeboard to ensure safe working conditions. For deeper streams, such as those
greater than 24 inches, the most common and commercially available type of dam utilized is a bladder
dam. Based on manufacturers' specifications and experience gained on the Mainline Project, a 4-foot-tall
dam can support a maximum water depth of 24 inches. The footprint and manufacturer -recommended
clearance for a dam this size is 22 feet. In a non -cofferdam installation, the dam on the back side can
usually be lower and constructed with sandbags and is estimated to occupy a 9-foot-wide footprint. After
allowing for space for a pump and discharge structure, a 34-foot workspace remains within the reduced
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
75-foot-wide LOD to install the pipe. Assuming the pipe is installed a minimum of 5 feet deep, type C soil
conditions, and installation with equipment from an adjacent bridge, this workspace is just sufficient to
excavate a trench and lower in pipe. For water depths greater than 24 inches, a larger dam would be
necessary, which increases the footprint and manufacturer -recommended clearance —further intruding
into the limited workspace available.
Consequently, in most circumstances, the open -cut crossing method is not a practicable alternative for
crossings with stream depths greater than 2 feet. Stream depth is not a relevant consideration for
trenchless crossing methods.
5.1.1.2.5 Cost
Stream and wetland crossings are costly elements of a pipeline construction project. Regardless of the
method utilized, crossings are significantly costlier on a per -foot basis than construction in typical uplands
due to, among other things, the need to procure and transport specialized equipment and personnel to
the site, implementation of increased erosion and sediment and related environmental measures,
constraints associated with working within a narrower LOD, and necessary post -construction restoration
activities.
There is no fixed threshold at which the cost of a specific crossing method exceeds a level that is
"appropriate and practicable.1163 Corps guidance states, "If an alleged alternative is unreasonably
expensive to the applicant, the alternative is not `practicable."' 45 Fed. Reg. 85336, 85343 (Dec. 24,
1980). The Corps has further clarified an acceptable approach to determining if a cost is unreasonably
expensive:
The determination of what constitutes an unreasonable expense should generally
consider whether the projected cost is substantially greater than the costs normally
associated with the particular type of project. To the extent the Corps obtains
information on the costs associated with the project, such information may be
considered when making a determination of what constitutes an unreasonable
expense...
It is important to emphasize, however, that it is not a particular applicant's financial
standing that is the primary consideration for determining practicability, but rather
characteristics of the project and what constitutes a reasonable expense for these
projects that are most relevant to practicability determinations.64
Measures implemented to avoid and minimize project impacts should also be "appropriate," considering
the reduction in impact that would be achieved.65 Each stream and wetland impact evaluated in this
analysis is a short -duration, temporary impact that will be restored immediately upon completing the
crossing. Incurring an unreasonable cost to avoid a short -duration, temporary impact to an individual
crossing is not appropriate and practicable.
Consistent with the 404(b)(1) Guidelines and the guidance noted above, Mountain Valley has
incorporated cost into its evaluation of alternative crossing methods. As detailed below, Mountain Valley
has prepared detailed, site -specific cost estimates for each pipeline crossing. The cost of individual
stream crossings can be extremely variable based on site -specific factors. Individual crossing alternative
63 40 CFR § 230.10(d).
64 USACE and EPA, Memorandum: Appropriate Level of Analysis Required for Evaluating Compliance with the CWA
Section 404(b)(1) Guidelines Alternatives Requirements (Aug. 23, 1993).
6145 Fed. Reg. at 85,344 (citing 40 CFR § 230.10(d)).
5-9 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigation
cost estimates for this analysis ranged from $12,960 to $5.9 million. For individual crossings, the
difference in cost between methods, in some cases, exceeds an order of magnitude. These crossing -by -
crossing estimates provide a reasonable basis for comparing the relative costs of alternative crossing
methods for a given resource to determine if a trenchless crossing is an "appropriate and practicable"
minimization measure to avoid a particular temporary impact or, conversely, whether the cost is "clearly
exorbitant."
To compare alternative stream -crossing methods, Mountain Valley developed (1) an open -cut cost
estimate and (2) a trenchless crossing method cost estimate for every stream and wetland crossing in this
application.66 The estimates were prepared by Mountain Valley's construction and engineering staff. For
each of the crossing methods evaluated in this analysis, Mountain Valley calculated average cost
parameters based on several factors.
To estimate open -cut costs, staff used actual Amendment Project costs and bids. These costs vary
somewhat based on the crossing width, with longer stream crossings typically incurring greater time and
materials costs per linear foot than shorter crossings. Because flowing water does not need to be
managed, the cost per linear foot of open cutting non -inundated wetlands and riparian buffer areas is
significantly less than streams. Average costs per linear foot of installed pipeline were developed for four
stream crossing scenarios (based on the size of the stream) and one scenario for wetlands and riparian
buffer areas. The estimated open -cut cost for each stream and wetland in the analysis was calculated as
the product of the crossing length and the applicable cost per linear foot.
Estimating the costs for trenchless crossings is more complex. First, the cost of excavating the entry and
receiving bore pits was estimated based on actual costs drawn from contractors specific to the
Amendment Project. For the reasons reflected in Section 5.1.1.2.2, the cost per foot (depth) of excavating
a bore pit increases substantially for larger pits. The relevant cost per foot was then multiplied by the
depth of each bore pit, as determined through the site -specific engineering analysis, to develop an
estimated bore -pit cost for each crossing. Second, staff drew from estimated construction costs from
recent experience on the Mainline Project and bids of prospective contractors to develop an estimated
cost per linear foot for conventional bores. The relevant cost per linear foot was then multiplied by the
length of the crossing (bore pit to bore pit). The two costs (bore pit and crossing length) were then
summed to generate an estimated trenchless crossing cost for the resource. Lump sum bids were
provided for the two proposed HDD crossings.
Table 10 provides a detailed breakdown of the per -foot costs for the dry -ditch open -cut crossing method.
Table 11 provides a detailed view of the fixed and per -foot costs for the trenchless crossing methods.
5.1.1.2.6 Potential for Bore Failure
As a practical matter, Mountain Valley's engineers do not generally propose trenchless crossings in areas
with known geotechnical conditions that present an unacceptable risk to the success of the crossing.
There is a risk that any given trenchless crossing will be unsuccessful due to unforeseen subsurface
conditions. If insurmountable issues are encountered during the trenchless crossing process, Mountain
Valley will implement a contingency plan. Examples of issues that could precipitate implementation of the
plan include the following.
Excessive torquing that includes multiple "twisting off' events or failure of the gearbox.
Poor cutting returns.
66 Mountain Valley's Amendment Project engineers selected the preferred trenchless method for each crossing based
on their professional judgment and the site -specific conditions.
5-10 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
Mechanical failures of drill string or bit assembly. If a bit assembly or drill string fails, it will be
pulled out and repaired. If the damaged bit cannot be withdrawn from the bore repair, the bore
attempt will be considered unsuccessful.
Deviation from planned bore path. If the deviation from the bore path is significant enough that
the field engineer determines it cannot be corrected or made up in the remaining bore length, the
bore attempt will be considered unsuccessful. These deviations could be vertical, whereby the
pipe would deflect upward and not maintain sufficient clearance beneath the feature being
crossed or deflect downward and not resurface along the planned bore path. These deviations
could also be horizontally left or right, whereby the pipe could travel outside the permitted
permanent easement or end up misaligned with the receiving bore pit. The amount of acceptable
deviation is dependent upon the angle of deflection and the remaining distance to be drilled.
Unanticipated geological or hydrological conditions in which ground or surface water affects
construction or the geologic materials become unstable or collapse.
If the bore is determined to be unsuccessful based on encountering one or more issues identified above,
Mountain Valley intends to first shift the bore entry 10 feet to either side of the original bore entry and
attempt another bore. Should the failed bore involve a stuck pipe, following an attempt at standard
recovery techniques, the pipe from the failed bore will be abandoned in place and backfilled with grout. In
the event of a bore failure, Mountain Valley would seek any necessary approvals to revise the proposed
crossing method —typically to the dry -ditch open -cut method.
5.1.1.2.7 Unique or Site -Specific Circumstances
The factors discussed in this section are useful to evaluate alternative crossing methods based on factual
circumstances —such as slope steepness, stream depth, and cost —that are common to every crossing on
the Amendment Project. However, those factors do not account for every unique or site -specific
circumstance that could materially affect the practicability of a given crossing method.
In addition to considering the common factors, Mountain Valley's engineering and construction staff
conducted a detailed evaluation of every crossing on the Amendment Project to determine if there are
any unique or site -specific circumstances that must be accounted for when evaluating alternative crossing
methods for a given crossing. The unique or site -specific circumstances incorporated in the analysis are
documented in the crossing method determinations (Table 12). In addition to the engineering and
construction factors, numerous environmental, safety, and landowner circumstances were considered at
each crossing. The environmental factors included but were not limited to potential presence of
threatened or endangered species, duration of crossing, and stream channel stabilization. Some of the
main safety topics were focused on worker safety and considered the depth of the bore pit, available
workspace, and access through the area. Landowner inconvenience was also evaluated at the crossings,
which considered such issues as construction duration, private property access, proximity to the crossing,
and proximity to homes and businesses.
5.1.1.3 Comparison of Environmental Effects
An important step in evaluating alternative crossing methods is to consider the relative environmental
impacts.
As is detailed in various places in this application, crossing a stream or wetland with the open -cut method
is a temporary impact of short duration. Wetland impacts are restored to preconstruction contours
immediately after construction is completed, and 12 inches of topsoil (when available) are replaced to
allow the seedbank to regenerate the existing vegetation. The same knowledge of wetland science that
allows wetlands to be created and restored for the purpose of creating mitigation banks can be applied to
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigation
USACE Individual Permit Application
restoring wetlands impacted by construction. Thus, the diminished function of these wetlands can be
quickly and reliably restored. Stream crossings create temporary disturbances for the duration of
construction. After construction, the bed and banks are restored to preconstruction contours, and the
stream substrate is replaced so that the stream can rapidly return to its preconstruction function. Instrearr
construction causes additional sediment and turbidity to be released into the water column, primarily
when the crossing is first commenced (before dewatering) and when the crossing is complete, and flow is
restored through the site. However, the magnitude of sediment and turbidity is "minimal compared to
increased turbidity associated with natural runoff events;" it is short in duration, typically lasting between
one and four days; and the area of effect is small, generally being confined to no more than a few
hundred feet downstream.67
Notwithstanding the short-term, low -magnitude impacts associated with individual crossings, there are
environmental considerations that may favor avoidance of the open -cut method for a particular crossing
First, the 404(b)(1) Guidelines presume that any discharge to an aquatic resource is an environmentally
damaging activity. Second, some aquatic species are particularly sensitive to increases in turbidity and
sedimentation associated with open -cut crossings.
Trenchless crossing methods generally have similarly minimal environmental effects. Most importantly, for
the purposes of the 404(b)(1) Guidelines, the selection of trenchless crossings typically results in the
minimization of aquatic impacts at the crossing site, as well as the minimization of impacts to riparian
vegetation. However, due to site logistics, trenchless crossings sometimes necessitate that timber mats or
other structures to be placed in aquatic resources (temporary fill) for the duration of the crossing to
support the construction equipment crossing. Furthermore, trenchless crossings typically take longer to
complete than open -cut crossings, which in turn prolongs the state of construction/temporary stabilization
and may also result in increased air emissions and noise compared to open -cut crossings.
In addition to the environmental effects generally associated with the open -cut method and trenchless
methods, there are site -specific circumstances at a number of crossing locations that bear on the
determination of which method is less environmentally damaging and/or whether avoidance of an aquatic
impact through a trenchless method is an "appropriate and practicable" minimization measure.
Any general or site -specific environmental effects that affected the determination of a crossing method for
any stream or wetland included in this application are documented in Table 12.
5.1.1.4 Determination of Proposed Crossing Methods
The results of Mountain Valley's evaluation of onsite crossing method alternatives to avoid and minimize
aquatic impacts from pipeline crossings to the extent practicable are summarized in Table 12.68 The table
includes a list of designated "Crossing Numbers," with the first letter (i.e., A through 1) indicating the
construction spread and the number indicating the order in which that crossing occurs along the ROW
beginning at the terminus in Transco Village, Virginia. Where appropriate, Mountain Valley has combined
stream and/or wetland features that are in very close proximity —such as streams and their adjacent
67 FERC FEIS § 4.6.5.3.
68 Table 12 was prepared to summarize the relevant logistical, technical, and environmental information and provide a
plain explanation of each crossing method determination. However, for practical purposes, Table 12 cannot and does
not reflect all information that is relevant to the analysis. Additional crossing -specific environmental resource
information supporting the determinations can be found in Table 2 (Stream Impacts) and Table 3 (Wetland Impacts).
Plan and profile views for each proposed crossing are in Attachment G.
5-12 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
riparian wetlands —into a single "crossing" for the purpose of the alternatives analysis.69 This was done
because, as a practical matter, the crossing of closely grouped features would be conducted as a single
undertaking.
For each crossing, Mountain Valley's engineering and construction staff identified the proposed
trenchless crossing method (i.e., conventional bore or HDD) based on the site conditions. The selected
trenchless crossing method and the open -cut crossing method were then assessed based on the factors
discussed above. The rationale for the proposed crossing method is summarized in the last column of the
table.
5.1.2 Avoidance Through Alignment Selection
The final proposed pipeline route and access roads are the result of an iterative process involving
numerous environmental considerations and consultation with landowners and federal, state, and local
agencies. Between when the route was initially proposed in December 2017 and when the Amendment
Application was submitted to FERC in February 2025, there were hundreds of route revisions to avoid or
minimize impacts to specific resources. As a result of this process, FERC concluded that the pipeline
route was designed to avoid stream and wetland impacts to the maximum extent practicable.70
5.1.3 Avoidance Through ROW Configuration
The pipeline generally requires a 100-foot-wide construction ROW, which includes a 50-foot-wide
permanent ROW. Where streams and wetlands cannot be avoided through the alignment selection,
Mountain Valley has, wherever practicable, avoided impacts by reducing the width of the ROW to 75 feet
for a distance of 50 feet on either side of the crossing. This practice allows an additional 50 linear feet of
undisturbed vegetative buffer to be maintained between land -disturbing activities and aquatic resources
as compared to typical pipeline construction practices, which do not employ a reduced ROW in such
areas as they increase construction costs due to increased inefficiencies from dealing with this limited
access area. The construction ROW reduction to 75 feet at WOTUS crossings has reduced overall
stream and wetland impacts when compared to a 100-foot-wide construction ROW at WOTUS crossings.
5.1.4 Avoidance Through Access Road Siting and Design
During the design of the Amendment Project, Mountain Valley reviewed existing infrastructure that would
facilitate transportation of materials, equipment, and workers to the Amendment Project site without the
need to construct new roads. Mountain Valley made use of existing public and private roads (including
driveways, logging roads/trails, farm roads, and other existing corridors that would provide adequate
areas for access) for Amendment Project access to the extent practicable. The use of existing roads
minimized or avoided impacts to streams, wetlands, and upland areas. Existing public and private roads
69 The number of unique identifiers included in each crossing alternative is largely a function of Mountain Valley's
naming system; it is not indicative of the number of "unique waterbodies" crossed. Nor is it indicative of the
importance, value, area, or function of the aquatic resources. Mountain Valley assigned each stream channel a
unique identifier, including branching channels of the same stream. Additionally, a single same stream channel may
be assigned more than identifier if different segments have different Cowardin classifications (e.g., R3, R4). A similar
naming system was used for wetlands. Mountain Valley assigned each discrete wetland polygon within the right-of-
way a unique identifier, notwithstanding that they may be adjacent or have a surface connection outside the survey
corridor. In some cases, a contiguous wetland could be assigned multiple identifiers if areas of the wetland reflect
more than one Cowardin classification (i.e., PFO, PSS, PEM). As a result of this naming system, there may be
multiple unique identifiers listed under a single crossing —but characterizing them as "unique waterbodies" is
generally a misnomer because they are typically part of the same aquatic system and are treated together by the
Corps as a single and complete crossing.
70 FERC FEIS 4-56.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
are sufficient to provide Amendment Project access to most work areas. Minor upgrades (i.e., temporary
widening, grading, gravel placement, etc.) will be necessary on some existing roads prior to Amendment
Project use to make them suitable for heavy construction equipment. However, the construction of new
access roads is required in some locations to overcome inadequate access.
Mountain Valley has considered the avoidance of potential impacts to wetlands and waterbodies in
selecting and locating the proposed access roads. In areas where these resources are present, Mountain
Valley minimized impacts by reducing the construction limit of disturbance and by spanning the resource
through the use of temporary wetland and waterbody crossing structures (timber mats, prefabricated
bridges, or railcar bridges) during construction activities. To further minimize impacts, Mountain Valley will
not utilize temporary placement of earthen fill material within waterbodies or wetlands during use of
Amendment Project access roads. Mountain Valley has taken all practicable measures to avoid impacts
to streams and wetlands associated with its temporary and permanent access roads.
Table 13 summarizes the access roads that have resource impacts and provides information on how
impacts were fully minimized to the extent practicable.
5.1.5 Site -Specific Onsite Avoidance Measures
For the sake of being comprehensive, Mountain Valley notes that there are various stream and wetland
resources within its construction ROW that will not be directly impacted by Amendment Project
construction. Those resources generally fall into one of two categories. First, where practicable, Mountain
Valley has avoided impacts to resources that partially overlap the Amendment Project area by narrowing
or carving out small sections of the ROW. To ensure those resources are not inadvertently impacted,
Mountain Valley identifies the resource with signage and uses erosion and sediment controls (e.g., silt
fence) to protect the resource from stormwater runoff and clearly mark the boundary of the work area for
construction crews. Second, where practicable, streams within the ROW that may be impacted by
construction equipment are avoided by bridging the resource from streambank to streambank and
employing appropriate signage and erosion and sediment controls. The Detail Map (Figure 3) includes
tags identifying WOTUS within the Amendment Project area that will not be impacted.
5.1.6 Avoidance Actions Dictated by Other Authorities
The USFWS has indicated the presence of the federally endangered RLP in several stream crossings
and has recommended Mountain Valley avoid instream impacts to these resources. Mountain Valley has
agreed to follow this recommendation. Accordingly, the streams identified in Table 1 are within the
Mountain Valley's ROW but will not be impacted by Amendment Project construction as these features
would be crossed utilizing trenchless crossing methods.
5.2 Minimization
While significant effort was made to avoid stream and wetland impacts through routing decisions and
construction practices, temporary and permanent impacts to WOTUS are unavoidable due to the
constraints of siting and constructing a 31.3-mile linear project. Mountain Valley has and will employ
various measures summarized in this section to ensure those impacts are minimized to the extent
appropriate and practicable.
5.2.1 Instream Pipeline Construction Practices
To minimize temporary stream impacts, dry -crossing techniques will be used to conduct open -cut stream
crossings in relatively dry working conditions. Wet -cut techniques can have high sediment release as well
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Mitigatioi
USACE Individual Permit Application
as the potential to interrupt streamflow during construction activities. Accordingly, wet -cut techniques are
not proposed for any stream crossings. Dry -crossing techniques will be utilized over wet -cut because they
limit the release of sediment to downstream areas while maintaining stream flow and minimizing stream
impacts. All instream pipeline installation activities will be completed in accordance with the FERC
Procedures, any environmental conditions that may be imposed by FERC, and applicable state
requirements, whichever is more protective. Additional measures to minimize the impacts associated with
open -cut stream crossings are discussed in Section 5.1.1.1.1 (Dry -Ditch Open -Cut).
5.2.2 Wetland Pipeline Construction Practices
To minimize temporary wetland impacts, all pipeline installation activities within wetlands will be
completed in accordance with the FERC Procedures, any environmental conditions that may be imposed
by FERC, and applicable state requirements, whichever is more protective. Additional measures to
minimize the impacts associated with wetland crossings are discussed in Section 5.1.1.1.1 (Dry -Ditch
Open -Cut).
5.2.3 Duration of Pipeline Construction Activities in Waters
To minimize impacts to waterbody and wetland crossings, they will be treated separately from upland
construction activities except during clearing activities, and efforts will be made to cross these areas
during periods of low flow. Once grubbing and grading start at a waterbody or wetland crossing, work will
proceed continuously and as quickly as practicable until the crossing is completed and the work area
restored. This practice ensures that the duration of temporary impacts to streams and wetlands from
pipeline installation work is minimized.
5.2.4 Construction Practices Adjacent to Aquatic Resources
Mountain Valley will implement the construction practices summarized in this section in all upland areas,
including areas adjacent to aquatic resources, to ensure that those resources are not adversely impacted
by erosion and sedimentation. All Amendment Project construction activities will adhere to the FERC
Plan, any environmental conditions that may be imposed by FERC, and state -specific requirements for
pipeline construction. In Virginia, Amendment Project construction must comply with Standards and
Specifications, site -specific ESCPs, and site -specific post -construction stormwater management plans
approved in accordance with VA DEQ's regulations. In North Carolina, the Amendment Project
construction must comply with the Stormwater Design Manual, which follows the Minimum Design Criteria
outlined in the North Carolina Stormwater Rules and Regulations. Due to the location of the Amendment
Project, post -construction stormwater requirements in North Carolina do not apply. The proposed ESCPs
will be provided during the stormwater permitting submittals to VA DEQ and NC DEQ. Construction
Details are provided in Attachment J.
5.2.5 Stream Crossing Geometry
Mountain Valley will minimize the impacts of instream construction by installing the pipeline as close to
perpendicular to stream courses as practicable. Furthermore, where site conditions require that the ROW
cross a stream at a relatively shallow angle, field adjustments to the placement of pipeline within the
approved ROW will be made to increase the crossing angles for these streams to the maximum extent
practicable in light of the site conditions, thereby reducing or eliminating low -angle crossings.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
5.2.6 Time -of -Year Restrictions
After conferring with USFWS and the state agencies, Mountain Valley is committing to implementing the
TOYRs identified in Table 2 during instream construction activities. If necessary, Mountain Valley will
coordinate with the state or federal agency, as appropriate, to complete instream construction activities
within the TOYR period.
5.2.7 Wetland and Stream Crossings in ATWS
Where practicable, ATWS were located and designed to avoid stream and wetland impacts. Many
streams in ATWS that need to be crossed during construction will be spanned entirely by temporary
stream -crossing structures. However, some temporary impacts to wetlands in ATWS are unavoidable. In
those situations, timber mats will be utilized during construction to cross wetlands in ATWS, resulting in
minimized temporary impacts to PEM wetlands.
5.2.8 Restoration of Temporary Wetland Impacts
Mountain Valley will restore all temporarily impacted wetlands to their preconstruction contours, with
wetlands topsoil replaced when temporarily removed or decompacted when crossed with mats for access.
Restoration and monitoring of wetland crossings will be conducted to ensure successful wetland
revegetation in accordance with the FERC Procedures and approved ESCP."
Wetland soils (hydric soils) are susceptible to compaction with the operation of construction equipment
over wet soils, thereby reducing the porosity and moisture -holding capacity of the soils and interfering
with the hydrology of the wetland. To facilitate successful wetland revegetation, Mountain Valley will
segregate the topsoil up to 1 foot in depth in wetlands. Any excavated material stockpiled in vegetated
wetland areas will be placed on a matted straw layer for use as a semi -permeable surface. Segregated
topsoil will be placed in the trench following subsoil backfilling. In order to minimize compaction, Mountain
Valley will limit construction traffic to only that required to accomplish the task. Low -ground -pressure
equipment will be used, or temporary equipment mats will be installed to allow passage of equipment with
minimal disturbance of the surface soils and vegetation. Compacted areas will be tilled as necessary to
meet decompaction standards.
Original surface hydrology will be reestablished in wetlands by (1) installing a low -permeability trench
breaker at the wetlands/upland boundary to prevent the pipe bedding material from acting as a drain and
(2) backfilling the pipe trench and grading the surface with equipment operating from equipment mats or
low -ground -pressure tracked vehicles working in the spoil pile, depending upon the ambient water level,
degree of soil saturation, and the bearing capacity of the soils. All excess excavated material will be
removed from the wetland within 30 days. Roots and stumps will have been removed only in the areas of
the pipe trench, allowing existing vegetation to recover more rapidly in the remainder of the ROW once
the equipment mats and spoil piles have been removed.
Wetlands along the proposed pipeline are expected to exhibit varying degrees of saturation and water
elevation, requiring a variety of plant species to be reestablished. In unsaturated wetlands, most
vegetation will be replaced by seeding when necessary. To maximize the growth of the wetland plants
suited for these specific impact areas from the seeds and rhizomes typically present and dormant in
stockpiled wetlands soils, saturated wetlands will typically be allowed to re -vegetate naturally. Wetland
revegetation will be considered successful when the cover of herbaceous species is at least 70 percent of
" For construction in Virginia, Mountain Valley's Annual Standards and Specifications detail additional stream and
wetland restoration measures mandated by the VA DEQ.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
the cover of the vegetation in adjacent wetland areas that were not disturbed by construction.
Revegetation efforts will continue until wetland revegetation is successful, with supplemental seedings
with native wetland seed mixes added as necessary to achieve success.
As required by the FERC Procedures, wetland vegetation will be monitored on at least an annual basis
for three years or until wetlands have been successfully revegetated. Additionally, the VA DEQ imposes
independent wetland vegetation success criteria and monitoring requirements— for a minimum of two full
growing seasons in Virginia (Standards and Specifications 38).
5.2.9 Restoration of Temporary Stream Impacts (Pipeline)
Mountain Valley will restore all temporarily impacted streams to their preconstruction bed and bank
contours in accordance with the FERC Procedures and approved ESCPs.
To facilitate successful restoration of streams, the top 1 foot of the streambed substrate (armoring layer)
will be segregated and stockpiled separately from subsoils. Following pipe installation, normal backfill
cover requirements will be met. Only materials native to the waterbody will be used. Compaction
percentage of backfill will be equal to or above that of the adjacent undisturbed areas. Trench breakers of
clay, earthen fill, sand, or concrete -filled sacks may also be used to keep backfill from sloughing in toward
the center of the stream and to prevent the pipeline bedding material from acting as a French drain.
Stream banks will be restored to preconstruction contours; restored stream bed substrate patterns,
profiles, dimensions, and embeddedness will be similar to preconstruction conditions using native
material excavated at stream crossings, and foreign objects will be removed from the stream. Excavated
material not required for backfill will be removed and disposed of at an upland site.
Cleanup and restoration will commence as soon as practicable following the completion of backfilling and
testing. Cleanup and restoration activities include restoring grade cuts to pre -construction contours and
seeding, fertilizing, and mulching to restore ground cover, minimize erosion, and stabilize stream banks
for their natural reversion to their previous state. Completed stream crossings using the flume or dam -
and -pump methods will be stabilized before returning flow to the channel. Where the flume technique is
used, stream banks will be stabilized before removing the flume pipes and returning flow to the stream
channel. For the dam -and -pump method, the dams are removed prior to restoring and stabilizing the
stream banks. Stream banks and bed will be restored as described above for surface water and
groundwater flow, and mulch, jute thatching, or bonded -fiber blankets will be installed on the stream
banks.
Seeding of disturbed stream approaches will be completed in accordance with the FERC Procedures
after final grading, weather, and soil conditions permitting. Seed mixes for riparian and wetland area
restoration are provided in the approved ESCPs. Permanent slope breakers (waterbars) will be installed
adjacent to stream banks to minimize the potential for erosion. Erosion and sediment control barriers,
such as silt fence and/or compost filter sock, will be maintained across the ROW until permanent
vegetation is established. Temporary equipment bridges will be removed following construction.
5.2.10 Long -Term ROW Maintenance in Wetlands
Maintenance of a ROW is critically important to the safe operation of a natural gas transmission pipeline.
Proper management of vegetation through periodic clearing in the permanent ROW is required by FERC
and PHMSA regulations to facilitate the inspection, maintenance, and repair of the pipeline.72 Woody
vegetation cannot be allowed to grow in close proximity to the pipeline because roots may damage the
72 18 CFR § 380.15(f); 49 CFR § 192.705(a).
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigatioi
coating and adversely affect pipeline integrity. The industry standard for maintaining a ROW generally is
25 feet on both sides of a natural gas pipeline (i.e., a 50-foot-wide corridor).73
To minimize permanent impacts to PFO and PSS wetlands, however, Mountain Valley will not conduct
vegetation mowing or clearing for the full width of the ROW in these resources. In order to facilitate
periodic inspections, a corridor centered over the pipeline up to 10 feet wide may be cleared at a
frequency necessary to maintain the 10-foot-wide corridor in an herbaceous state. In addition, trees within
15 feet of the pipeline with roots that could compromise the integrity of the pipeline coating may be
selectively cut and removed from the permanent ROW.
5.3 Compensation
Unavoidable losses will be compensated in accordance with 40 CFR § 230.93 to ensure that the
Amendment Project does not result in a net loss of streams or wetlands.
Anticipated unavoidable permanent impacts will result from stream culverting along permanent access
roads and the conversion of PFO and PSS wetlands to PEM wetlands along the pipeline ROW. Tables 2,
3, 14, and 15 identify the location and size of anticipated wetland and stream impacts associated with the
Amendment Project.
No single proposed permanent PFO or PSS wetland conversion to PEM wetland exceeds 1.8 acres, and
no single proposed permanent stream loss exceeds 17 linear feet (Tables 14 and 15). Mountain Valley
proposes to minimize the individual and cumulative effects of the Amendment Project by implementing
compensatory mitigation for all proposed permanent impacts, including stream losses less than 300 feet
and any permanent conversions of PFO or PSS wetlands to PEM wetlands. As described below,
Mountain Valley proposes to mitigate all proposed permanent stream fill and wetland conversion impacts
in Virginia through the purchase of mitigation bank credits that are anticipated to become available prior
to and during the construction of the Amendment Project (Attachment M). Coordination with prospective
mitigation banks regarding credit purchase agreements and credit release timing is ongoing. Prospective
mitigation banks that have been contacted for the Amendment Project include Copper Hill and
Beaverdam mitigation banks, both of which anticipate having initial credit releases in late 2025/early
2026.
Credit reservation letters for these banks are provided in Attachment M. Mountain Valley requests to
phase the purchase of mitigation bank credits as they become available. Credit purchase agreements will
be provided to VA DEQ prior to initiating any authorized impacts of a particular phase for which credits
are secured. Following the approval of a compensation phasing approach, Mountain Valley will provide
biannual Construction Status Update forms for each phase that clearly indicate impact numbers across
each phase as well as status and accounting updates of the compensatory mitigation completed to date.
Mountain Valley will also submit a schedule for completing the compensatory mitigation for each phase of
the Amendment Project and a 10-day notice prior to the construction of each phase. Mountain Valley
proposes to mitigate all proposed permanent stream and wetland conversion impacts in North Carolina
through the purchase of statewide In -Lieu Fee program credits through the North Carolina Division of
Mitigation Services (NCDMS). Coordination with the NCDMS is ongoing, and Mountain Valley anticipates
submitting the request for credit acceptance in late 2025 or early 2026 to secure mitigation credits in
North Carolina.
73 See Pipelines and Informed Planning Alliance Recommended Practice BL12.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Mitigation
All permanent PSS and PFO impacts in the USACE Norfolk and Wilmington Districts are anticipated to be
conversion impacts. In accordance with USACE Norfolk and Wilmington Districts, VA DEQ guidance, and
NC DEQ guidance, a one-to-one ratio is used for all proposed wetland mitigation credits in the USACE
Norfolk and Wilmington Districts. For permanent stream impacts in the USACE Norfolk District, credit
requirements were determined using the Unified Stream Methodology (USM) assessment tool, as
presented in Table 1. USM forms for individual streams are provided in Attachment M.
5-19 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Public Involvement
USACE Individual Permit Application
6.0 Public Involvement
An extensive public notification and outreach process was undertaken for the Original Certificated Project,
beginning in 2018, and continues for the Amendment Project. Outreach has been done in accordance
with the FERC and state agency review processes, to meet or exceed requirements. This process
provided notification to all landowners potentially affected by the Amendment Project, as well as the
general public.
Mountain Valley is committed to the early identification and resolution of stakeholder issues and
concerns. Consistent therewith, Mountain Valley first initiated contact with stakeholders for the Original
Certificated Project in April 2018, and, as part of the Original Certificated Project application, Mountain
Valley developed a Public, Stakeholder, and Agency Participation Plan. Mountain Valley has continued
stakeholder outreach activities for the Amendment Project and provided FERC with its updated Public,
Stakeholder, and Agency Participation Plan.74 As fully explained in the Public, Stakeholder, and Agency
Participation Plan, Mountain Valley established a project -specific website (www.mvpsouthgate.com) that
provides project information, updates on regulatory proceedings, copies of regulatory filings, and contact
information for the public to use to raise questions and concerns.
Efforts to identify stakeholders were focused on federal, state, and local elected officials; federal, state,
and local regulatory agencies; Native American tribes; landowners; economic development
agencies/chambers of commerce; local law enforcement agencies; local media outlets; non -governmental
organizations, and the communities at large. Mountain Valley also compiled information for the public to
use to raise questions and concerns. Mountain Valley filed a comprehensive stakeholder list with
FERC.75 Mountain Valley has continued to develop and maintain a contact management system to track
contact with these stakeholders in a manner that assists in the identification and resolution of emerging
issues and concerns.
Mountain Valley sent letters to permitting agencies and agencies that require consultation in July 2024,
notifying them of its plan to file an application with FERC for the Amendment Project facilities. Mountain
Valley also contacted stakeholders in October 2024, including landowners, to inform them of the filing
process timeline. Landowners were notified again in November 2024, including those properties in North
Carolina that were crossed by or abutted the Original Certificated Project route and are no longer
impacted by the Amendment Project.
As part of its commitment to keeping stakeholders informed, Mountain Valley has committed to
maintaining contact with local government officials, non -governmental organizations, and other interested
stakeholders in the Amendment Project area. This activity began when the Original Certificated Project
was announced in 2018 and has continued through the present. Mountain Valley is committed to creating
and distributing informational collateral materials to stakeholders and the general public via traditional and
electronic technologies. Mountain Valley has provided and will continue to provide various project
updates, including periodic newsletters and other communications from the project team that inform
stakeholders about what has recently occurred and what to expect next with the Amendment Project. The
74 Mountain Valley's Public, Stakeholder, and Agency Participation Plan was included as Appendix 1-G to Resource
Report 1 (FERC eLibrary Accession Number 20250203-5193) in its February 3, 2025 Amendment Application.
75 Mountain Valley's stakeholder list was included as Appendix 1-J to Resource Report 1 (FERC eLibrary Accession
Number 20250203-5193) in its February 3, 2025 Amendment Application.
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Public Involvement
first newsletter for the Original Certificated Project was distributed in August 2018 and the most recent
was distributed for the Amendment Project in April 2025.
Mountain Valley will continue to work with local news media to facilitate accurate and informed reporting
on the Amendment Project and with local government and non -governmental organizations to provide
project updates and answers to questions as they arise in the community. Mountain Valley has also
engaged with various civic groups and non -governmental groups through event and program
sponsorships and ongoing efforts to raise the Amendment Project's visibility and introduce the
Amendment Project to the public. Mountain Valley distributed the most recent project update flyer in
August and September 2024. Mountain Valley anticipates continuing these efforts to build relationships,
engage meaningfully with the community, and ensure stakeholders have ample opportunity to learn about
the Amendment Project and receive answers to their questions.
In addition, Mountain Valley has continuously shared and intends to continue to share information with
stakeholders in the local Amendment Project area, including by providing and posting copies of updated
Amendment Project information at businesses, facilities, and other sites that are part of recognized EJ
communities or otherwise frequented by stakeholders from historically underrepresented groups.
Mountain Valley has provided and will continue to provide copies of the filing materials, including resource
reports, to participating federal agencies, county offices, and public libraries along the proposed pipeline
route and certain state offices so stakeholders and the public will have the opportunity to view the
materials and to provide comments. Copies will be provided to the following libraries in the Amendment
Project area:
Pittsylvania County Public Library -Chatham, Virginia, and
Eden Public Library — Eden, North Carolina
In addition to previous public outreach and notification efforts, there will be additional opportunities for
public involvement during the public notification process as part of this JPA.
6-2 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Environmental Justice
USACE Individual Permit Application
7.0 Environmental Justice
The environmental justice analysis conducted for the Amendment Project in 2024 (as described in detail
below) may no longer be applicable due to the revocation of certain Executive Orders, particularly
Executive Order 12898. These orders, which previously mandated comprehensive reviews of impacts on
and considerations for disadvantaged communities, have been rescinded. As a result, the regulatory
framework and priorities guiding federal agencies' environmental justice assessments have shifted. The
information provided below has been provided for transparency purposes and can be further considered
as deemed appropriate by federal and state agencies.
Following the prior recommendations set forth in EPA guidance, FERC has been utilizing the 50 percent
and the meaningfully greater analysis methods to identify minority populations. Minority populations are
composed of individuals who are American Indian or Alaskan Native; Asian or Pacific Islander; Black, not
of Hispanic origin; or Hispanic. Using this methodology, minority populations were defined where either
(a) the aggregate minority population of the block groups in the affected area exceeds 50 percent or (b)
the aggregate minority population in the block group affected is 10 percent or more than the aggregate
minority population percentage in the county (i.e., at least 1.1 times the county percentage).76 The
previous guidance also directed low-income populations to be identified based on the annual statistical
poverty thresholds from the U.S. Census Bureau (i.e., low-income households are those living below the
federal poverty level). Utilizing this method, low-income populations were identified as block groups
where the percentage of low-income households in the identified block group is equal to or greater than
that of the county. Pittsylvania County, Virginia, and Rockingham County, North Carolina, were
considered the comparable reference communities when identifying EJ communities along the
Amendment Project.
Based on the analysis described above, a total of seven census block groups crossed by the Amendment
Project or within one mile of the Amendment Project facilities satisfy the minority population criterion, and
six census block groups crossed by the Amendment Project or within one mile of the Amendment Project
facilities satisfy the low-income threshold criterion. Active coordination with federal tribes that are
cooperating agencies in the FERC process has been completed and is ongoing for the Amendment
Project. The Amendment Project has also conducted outreach with state tribes and coordinated directly
with interested tribal representatives.
Shortly after the FERC FEIS was issued in 2020 for the Original Certificated Project, Virginia enacted the
Virginia Environmental Justice Act (Va. Code 2.2-234 to 2.2-235) (2020 EJ Act). The act states, "It is the
policy of the Commonwealth to promote EJ and ensure that it is carried out throughout the
Commonwealth, with a focus on EJ communities and fenceline communities." The 2020 EJ Act defines
EJ communities to include (1) geographically distinct areas where the "population of color" is greater than
the state average and (2) census block groups in which at least 30 percent of the population qualifies as
"low income." The statute defines "low income" as "having an annual household income equal to or less
than the greater of (i) an amount equal to 80 percent of the median income of the area in which the
household is located, as reported by the Department of Housing and Urban Development, and (ii) 200
percent of the Federal Poverty Level" (Va. Code 22-234). Additionally, in 2020, the state's Environmental
Justice Advisory Council became a permanent advisory body in the executive branch. The Environmental
76 FERC. April 21, 2023. Order on Remand, Texas LNG Brownsville LLC. Docket No. CP16-116-002; 183 FERC ¶
61,047.
7-1 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Environmental Justice
Justice Advisory Council had previously been established in 2017 by Executive Order 73 (and
reestablished in 2019 by Executive Order 29).
To date, Virginia has not finalized any regulations or authoritative guidance to implement the 2020 EJ Act
or related legislation directing the VA DEQ to "further environmental justice ... in the regulatory and
permitting processes" (Va. Code 10.1-1183(B)(4)). However, VA DEQ has taken steps to implement the
statutes. In April 2021, VA DEQ established an Office of Environmental Justice (OEJ) to ensure the fair
and meaningful involvement of all people in the development, implementation, and enforcement of
environmental laws, regulations, and policies across all VA DEQ programs. The OEJ includes a Program
Manager and four regional Environmental Coordinators. Further, on May 1, 2023, VA DEQ published a
draft guidance memorandum to formalize the OEJ's procedures for incorporating EJ into the agency's
regulatory and permitting decisions. Following a public comment period, VA DEQ's draft EJ guidance
remains under internal review and has not been finalized.
To facilitate voluntary EJ efforts, VA DEQ maintains an online mapping tool, Virginia EJ Screen+, that
identifies areas that meet the 2020 EJ Act's definition of an EJ community." Mountain Valley evaluated
the Amendment Project using VA DEQ's mapping tool to determine if any previously unidentified
communities within one mile of the Amendment Project facilities meet the state's EJ community definition.
VA DEQ's mapping tool did not identify any new census block groups that qualify as EJ communities due
to minority populations that were not already identified by the federal screening efforts. However, two
additional census block groups were identified that would qualify as EJ communities under the 2020 EJ
Act's definition of low-income communities.
In 2022, North Carolina's Governor signed Executive Order No. 246, which directed cabinet agencies to
incorporate EJ and equity considerations as they implemented certain climate change -related directives.
In October 2023, the governor signed Executive Order 292, which established the Governor's
Environmental Justice Advisory Council (EJ Council). The EJ Council is a reestablishment of the
Secretary's Environmental Justice and Equity Advisory Board, which had earlier been established by the
Secretary of the INC DEQ in 2018. The mission of the EJ Council is to "advise the Governor and state
agencies on incorporating EJ into policies and programming, to provide clarity and consistency to [North
Carolina's] approach to EJ, and to collaborate on, develop, and enhance state strategies to advance
EJ.1178 The EJ Council's powers include identifying sources of expertise about existing and potential EJ
research projects and topics; developing government research projects focused on EJ; developing
guidance for state agencies on best practices for identifying EJ communities and for the use of mapping
tools and data; providing EJ-related recommendations to the Governor, including with respect to
legislation, regulation, and policies; taking a series of actions respecting EJ to be taken across state
agencies; and soliciting input from communities with EJ concerns.
Further, under Executive Order No. 292, the EJ Council is required to publish annual reports describing
its EJ-related activities and making recommendations for advancing EJ in the state. The first report was
published on October 15, 2024, and included recommendations for the state to continue building out its
EJ policy, including further development of the state's mapping tool.79
77 VA DEQ. 2024. VA EJScreen+ and Overview. Available at: https:Hgeohub-vadeq.hub.arcgis.com/pages/v-a-e-j-
screen. Accessed November 2024.
78 North Carolina. 2023. Executive Order No. 292. Available at: https://governor.nc.gov/executive-order-no-292/open.
Accessed January 2025.
79 North Carolina. 2024. Governor's Environmental Justice Advisory Council Final Report. Available at:
https://www.ejhub.nc.gov/documents/governors-environmental-justice-advisory-council-final-report/open. Accessed
January 2025.
7-2 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project Environmental Justice
USACE Individual Permit Application
North Carolina launched version 1.0 of the North Carolina Community Mapping System (NCCMS) in
March 2020. NCCMS incorporated public feedback from a previously released beta version, and the tool
was created "to provide North Carolinians with permitting and other environmental information for the
purpose of increasing knowledge, understanding, local outreach, and public participation.,,80 NCCMS
displays census data for identified areas and incorporates the Environmental Justice Tool, which shows
demographic and health information for the selected area. Similar to the EPA's EJScreen, NCCMS and
the embedded Environmental Justice Tool are information -gathering tools that provide certain
demographic and environmental information rather than specifically designating a particular area as an
EJ community under state standards. INC DEQ has also implemented an Anonymous Comment Tool,
which "allows members of the public to provide anonymous suggestions or complaints about an
environmental concern or an incident of discrimination involving an environmental concern." Mountain
Valley has evaluated NCCMS and has not identified any additional block groups that are EJ communities.
Mountain Valley will continue to coordinate with the INC DEQ and consider state policies and guidelines it
develops to address EJ.
80 North Carolina. 2019. Community Mapping System and Environmental Justice Tool (Version 1.0). Available at:
https://www.deq.nc.gov/ej/nccros/deq-nc-communitymappingsystemej-tool-1finaI/download. Accessed January 2025.
7-3 Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
FIGURES
Figure 1 Amendment Project Overview Map
Figure 2 U.S. Geological Survey Amendment Project Location Map
Figure 3 Detail Map
Figure 4 USACE Norfolk District Wetland and Waterbodies Overview Map
Figure 5 USACE Wilmington District Wetland and Waterbodies Overview Map
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
TAB L - -
Table 1 Section 10 River Crossings
Table 2 Stream Impacts
Table 3 Wetland Impacts
Table 4 Stream Impacts Summary
Table 5 Wetland Impacts Summary
Table 6 Counties and Towns Crossed by the Amendment Project
Table 7 Watersheds Crossed by the Amendment Project
Table 8 List of Affected Landowners
Table 9 State and Federal Permit Status
Table 10 Dry -Ditch Open -Cut Crossing Method Cost
Table 11 Bore Crossing Method Cost
Table 12 Crossing Method Determination Summary
Table 13 Access Roads with Stream/Wetland Crossings
Table 14 Streams and Wetlands Avoided at the Direction of Other Federal or State Authorities
Table 15 Compensatory Wetland Mitigation
Table 16 Compensatory Stream Mitigation
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
MVP Southgate Amendment Project
USACE Individual Permit Application
Attachment A
Attachment B
Attachment C
Attachment D
Attachment E
Attachment F
Attachment G
Attachment H
Attachment H-1
Attachment H-2
Attachment H-3
ATTACHMENTS
VA DEQ 401 Water Quality Certification Information and Virginia Water Protection
Permit Application
NC DEQ 401 Water Quality Certification Information
Virginia Marine Resources Commission Permit Request
USACE Norfolk District ENG Form 4345
USACE Wilmington District ENG Form 4345
USACE Norfolk District Standard JPA Form
Cumulative Impacts Analysis
Plan and Profile Crossing Drawings and Inadvertent Return Plan
Section 10 Waters Plan and Profile Crossing Drawings
Virginia Plan and Profile Crossing and Culvert Drawings
Inadvertent Return Plan
Attachment I Wetland and Stream Data Forms and Photographs
Attachment 1-1 USACE Norfolk Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-2 USACE Norfolk Wetland Data and Attribute Forms
Attachment 1-3 USACE Wilmington Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-4 USACE Wilmington Wetland Data and NC WAM Field Assessment Forms
Attachment J Construction Details
Attachment K Economic Benefit Analysis
Attachment L Supplemental Public Interest Comments
Attachment M Compensatory Mitigation
Attachment M-1 USACE Norfolk Stream USM Forms
Attachment M-2 Mitigation Affidavits and Purchase Agreements
Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC
ATTACHMENT A - VA DEQ 401 WQC INFORMATION
AND VIRGINIA WATER PROTECTION PERMIT APPLICATION
ATTACHMENT B - NC DEQ 401 WQC INFORMATION
ATTACHMENT C - VMRC PERMIT REQUEST
ATTACHMENT D - USACE NORFOLK DISTRICT
ENG FORM 4345
ATTACHMENT E - USACE WILMINGTON DISTRICT
ENG FORM 4345
ATTACHMENT F - USACE NORFOLK DISTRICT
STANDARD JPA FORM
ATTACHMENT G - CUMULATIVE IMPACTS ANALYSIS
ATTACHMENT H - PLAN AND PROFILE CROSSING
DRAWINGS AND INADVERTENT RETURN PLAN
Attachment H-1 Section 10 Waters Plan and Profile Crossing Drawings
Attachment H-2 Virginia Plan and Profile Crossing and Culvert Drawings
Attachment H-3 Inadvertent Return Plan
Attachment H-1
Section 10 Waters Plan and Profile Crossing Drawings
Attachment H-2
Virginia Plan and Profile Crossing and Culvert Drawings
Attachment H-3
Inadvertent Return Plan
ATTACHMENT I - WETLAND AND STREAM DATA
FORMS AND PHOTOGRAPHS
Attachment 1-1 USACE Norfolk Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-2 USACE Norfolk Wetland Data and Attribute Forms
Attachment 1-3 USACE Wilmington Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-4 USACE Wilmington Wetland Data and NC WAM Field Assessment Forms
Attachment 1-1
USACE Norfolk Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-2
USACE Norfolk Wetland Data and Attribute Forms
Attachment 1-3
USACE Wilmington Stream Data Forms
Attachment 1-4
USACE Wilmington Wetland Data and
NC WAM Field Assessment Forms
ATTACHMENT J - CONSTRUCTION DETAILS (TYPICALS)
ATTACHMENT K - ECONOMIC BENEFIT ANALYSIS
ATTACHMENT L - SUPPLEMENTAL PUBLIC
INTEREST COMMENTS
Attachment M-1
ATTACHMENT M - COMPENSATORY MITIGATION
USACE Norfolk Stream USM Forms
Attachment M-2 Mitigation Affidavits and Purchase Agreements
Attachment M-1
USACE Norfolk Stream USM Forms
Attachment M-2
Mitigation Affidavits and Purchase Agreements