NC0089168_Comments_Binder_after 5pm_20241120_20241210

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Joe Bartlet5
Date Wed 11/20/2024 7:23 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Joe Bartlett
Blounts Creek Resident
Joe Bartlet5
Chocowinity ,, North Carolina-

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Chuck Beatty
Date Sat 11/23/2024 3:34 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nurserkj; altwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw for fisherfoik and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
I am a capitalist but also a conservationist deeply concerned about coastal Carolina ecology.
Please adhere to the science in your decision making.
Thank you,
Chuck Beatty
Winterville, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Fw: MMM Vanceboro Quarry Permit- Bobby Bowser
From Bowser, Bobby
Date Thu 11/21/2024 150 PM
To SVC_DEQ.publiccommentsDWR <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
I sent these comments yesterday at 3:20pm, but I didn't get a return on the failed delivery until now.
Please ar; : ;: Iffiese comments that were dated 11/20/2024 at 3:20pm
Thank you,
-Bobby Bowser
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Get Outlook for Android
From:
Sent: Wednesday, November 20, 2024 3:20:00 PM
To: [e-mail] <[e-mail]>
Subject: MMM Vanceboro Quarry Permit- Bobby Bowser
Blounts Creek is a creek with swamp waters characterization with low stream velocity, low dissolved oxygen, and
lower pH ranges.The proposed permit renewal for the MMM Vanceboro Quarry lists the wastewater as not
containing oxygen-demanding waste and does not account for the Sediment Oxygen Demand and Biological
Oxygen Demand increase due to resuspension of sediment into the water column (Veenstra and Nolen 1991;
Spieckermann et al., 2022). Resuspension can lead to the release of nutrients and organic substances into the
water column which can exacerbate low oxygen levels during warmer months. Furthermore, resuspension will
impact water clarity through increased total suspended solids and increased phytoplankton biomass creating
more competition for natural benthic algae(Jin, van Leeuwen,Temmink, & Bakker, 2022;). Limestone mining can
have various impacts on surface and ground water including, but not limited to, alteration of flow, increased flood
recurrence intervals, reduced water quality, increased run-off, etc. (Ganapathi, Phukan, 2020).Among these
impacts,the alteration of flow, increased run-off, and increased pH could be potentially harmful to local_bectbic
insect populations that are adapted to acidic water chemistry, and intermittent flow. Blounts Creek like..
other coastal plain streams in North Carolina are classified as swamp waters or tidal salt waters. I am co"gad
that introducing these effects will make Blounts Creek more representative of a Piedmont stream and the lack of
Piedmont habitat nearby Blounts Creek to supply populations of benthic species fitting Piedmont stream
ecosystems will negatively affect the benthic ecosystem overall. These benthic invertebrates are useful indicators
of the health of any given system because they have limited mobility and cannot escape stressors that they are

exposed to.Their lifespans can be ranged from several weeks to several years, and the perm is requirem ant of
one Benthic Survey at the end of 5-year perm t with the last survey being conducted in 2018 would not be useful
for determ hing if biological integrity of the system is m antained. Following standard procedure for benthic
collection, Swam pwaters are sam Oed during the winter m cnths (Feb-M arch) when flowing waters are present
and when detecting differences in the com m unity is natural.To adequately gauge biological integrity, surveys
should be conducted on a yearly or once every other year and before operations begin discharging.
This undisturbed and natural wetland system likely provides a host of ecosystem services such as erosion
m tigation, sedim ant trapping, carbon storage, and natural flood defense as well as providing unique habitat for
fish, benthic organism 4 and birds (Liu, Fagherazzi, Cui, 2021), which is at risk from nearby m hing operations and
discharge. Additional surveys and assessm efts need to be done to adequately determ he the potential im fact of
these operations.
Bobby Bowser Ph.D
Lab and Field M anager, Water Resources Center
East Carolina University
G ieenville NC 27858

J ' Outlook
[External] Publ� : NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Jimmy R BriOf
Date Wed 11/20/2024 8:04 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r' '
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo p?,iU- jot taY i%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulafe vo�--.- kMeei'�^.°�.,Nater chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Jimmy R Bright
=Mo
Oriental, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Crystal brown
Date Wed 11/20/2024 8:13 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Crystal brown
MMM
Williamston , North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Arron Bryant
Date Thu 11/21/2024 6:52 AM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Arron Bryant
Powhatan , Virginia

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From John Callahan
E 0
Date Wed 11/20/2024 5:42 PM
To Derr £ trek <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CACCROO: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the Report
NK%,*'button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denard,
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES permit to Martin Marietta Materials for its Vanceboro
Quarry.
The discharge of up to 12 million gallons of groundwater per day headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pH of the stream system, a change that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulations. Such a change in the water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granfing Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit f4llb,
}
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining 11-1;%l���ti{+�
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
John Callahan
Chocowinity ,, North Carolina

J , Outlook
[External] MMM Vanceboro Quarry Permit
From George Carr
Date Wed 11/20/2024 5:01 PM =
To SVC_DEQ.pub1iccomment5D*,#X <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
My name is George Carr and I am resident 4. a
I
I am writing to strongly encourage the NC� fiq�Cl tFl =y,4bi*4��equest for Martin-Marietta as it
relates to Blount's Creek.
NC DEQ's webs ite as of this writing today +
"The North Carolina Department of Envir J. ' ` � 1, it `i;he lead stewardship agency for the
protection of North Carolina's environmer
"The organization, which has offices from wd , :r �si;i � fi '�® �°�t, administers regulatory programs
designed to protect air quality, water quality..."
"DEQ also offers technical assistance to .... encourages responsible behavior with respect to the
environment..."
"DEQ touches the lives of all North Carolinians in many ways to enhance and ensure our quality of life."
The "Our Mission" site of NC DEQ's webpage reads, "Providing science-based environmental
stewardship for the health and prosperity of ALL North Carolinians."
The word steward is generally accepted to mean to take care of, be responsible for, act in the best
interests of, protect, and conserve something, and in the case of the DEQ, NC's environment first and
foremost for its citizens.
There is no version of allowing Martin-Marietta to do what they say they will do and yoL. ; f - they will
do without entirely destroying the current ecosystem of Blount's Creek as it has evolved over thousands
of years or more. This would likely permanently negatively affect not only the current carefully evolved
ecosystem but also all of the recreational opportunities including fishing, crabbing, paddling, boating,
wildlife viewing, and birding.
My sons, my friends, my fellow paddlers in the Lumber River Canoe Club and Friends of Sampson County
Waterways, and myself believe the current ecosystem of Blount's Creek rich in natural life and natural
and economic value is worth more than some limestone and Martin-Marietta's stock price.
Consider the economic negative impact to the local econo because of the loss of everyone who stop
coming to or never come to a dead creek to fish, crab, br `-view wildlife, paddle, and/boat, and
subsequently support local shops, restaurants, accommodations, and more.

Once the perm f is issued, the m cnitoring is irrelevant because the ecosystem will be destroyed before
any enforcem Ent m Easures could be enacted to prevent its destruction. M artin-M arietta will not be
able to corn Oy with perm it lim is in the events of hurricanes and other excessive rainfall.
The only entity that gains anything from the issuance of this perm f is M artin-M arietta. Everyone who
lives and does business in the Blount's Creek area, and everyone who does and ever would have
engaged in any recreation activities in the Blount's Creek area, and everything that currently lives and
will definitely die in Blount's Creek unnecessarily loses m cre.
The DEQ's website says, "The North Carolina Departm Ent of Environm Ental Quality (DEQ) is the lead
stewardship agency for the protection of North Carolina's environm ental resources"
I strongly encourage the N.C. Dept of Environm ental Quality to not issue this perm t.
George Carr
Faison, NC

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments V Vkftestewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Allen Cashion
Date Thu 11/21/2024 7:52 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Allen Cashion
Cleveland N.0 , North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From James Chitmon
Date Thu 11/21/2024 7:32 AM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
James Chitmon
Grimesland , North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] MMM Vanceboro Quarry Permit
From Rebekah Clubbs
Date Thu 11/21/2024 151 PM =
To SVC_DEQ.publiccomment51)*,#X <[e-mail]>
[You don't often get email from
hops://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldentification ]
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails
with the Report Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
Vote NO to M M M
Rebekah Clubbs
M.S. Environmental Toxicology
Blounts Creek Resident
Sent from my iPhone

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Megan Daniels
Date Thu 11/21/2024 9:12 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, •• M •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, + ' ' ' '
,,—off.' � .J , , -��.
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES *- ' 0,';l'Mae, � aterials for its Vanceboro
ai •. .-.—.._—�«..... GA A
.. _
Quarry. .'a!: ',4;',_-'•: �.�Q
The discharge of up to 12 million gall4A&5* r -into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the plrI'afb-�*5t; ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulafe 111. is « water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Megan Daniels
Megan Daniels
Liberty, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Jesse Davis
Date Wed 11/20/2024 5:47 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Jesse Davis
Chocowinity, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Barbara Dennis
Date Thu 11/21/2024 2:52 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Barbara Dennis
==I=Greenville, North Carolina

11 Outlook
[External] Estes- MMM Vanceboro Quarry Permit
From Faithe Ann
Date Wed 11/20/2024 6:36 PM
To SVC_DEQ.publiccommentsLWt <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
Hello,
I am veryconcerned with th '� .L..rk ''y . �i@ , t' f Martin Marietta Materials having tIZ€ t *er permit
renewed. They have absolut ? 'r i pollute our waterways, destroying * huting
wildlife and people.To do sli+ ;r i ' ' should be punishable and the com�en ni" v r,*Wsry for
such a grave and long-term destruction. In no way should they be given PERMISSION to harm our
mutual and communal wildlife.
The impact that this level of pollution would have is massive and long term-impacting the health of
animals, humans,and the environment at large.I implore you to do right by your constituents for the
short and long-term by denying this permit.
Thank you,
Faithe Estes

J ' Outlook
[External] Martin Marietta Permit
From Llnda Foster
Date Wed 11/20/2024 5:03 PM
To SVC_DEQ.publiccommentsDWR <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the 7epcI
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
Please do not grant renewal of this permit as it will kill Blounts Creek and will have a major longterm
effect on Beaufort County!!!!!
There should be an alternative process for handling this waste water!
Sincerely.
Linda Foster
Yahoo Mail: Sea rch,Qrganize, Conquer

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From June Grimsley
Date Thu 1112112024 1 1:46 AM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
June Grimsley
Winterville , North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Jason Hancock
Date Wed 11/20/2024 6:20 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i'� utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• °r'
Dear Mr. Denard, ,�, ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gall6i!Aki r E='��.r� -into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the plri*atrY,,` q +, ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate® '.� rit ' ' ,`water chemistry would change
r 0 u f�f-
which aqL3 "� "� .t�usou� r ! ncf atfs� E*aa-is
clear: a di 1 4 �'P.r.�0AVV't,od4's=rlCosi6n of a stream from its natural
state. - - � .
Blountss' .fStt- n PVifd ter saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for as crd!+.4�arf+ e� b�kaF�d wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting == _ -. • � i �im ; : �' !ti mire ecosystem at risk.
We are g ` �..r . B'W-i6e:'aen0—rgl of,%44dt!t Marietta Materials' permit for
the Van ... �:'a fiE;i°C."o�a:ac; go'tl':-&x{ se affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
I have long fished these waters and this will utterly this fishery, in a time where we
cannot afford to lose any more fisheries. Please de; uA� Hpermit.
>tl
Thank you,
Jason Hancock
Ne :. ,; , North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Justin Hancock
Date Wed 11/20/2024 7:11 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denadc 'I'''.,
NCDEQ should i'i sue a h. . permit to Martin Marietta M{,�t�for its Vanceboro
Quarry.
The discharge of up to 12 milli `o '' `Silbns of groundwater per day into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pH of the stream system, a change that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulations. Such a change in the water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
;;e,un�
Additionally, as local N(a",,., . ter game fish, which use these waters regularly for all portions of
their lifecycle, it seems;' fto drastically change the water quality and makeup of Blounts
creek and the Pamlico River. With record red drum being caught as far upriver as Washington,
NC, to dump millions of gallons of freshwater into the ecosystem will undoubtedly change that for
the worse.As a person whose family ties to Beaufort County go back hundreds of years, this
gives me great cause for concern at the potential to permanently and negatively change our
ecosystem for the worse. Do not allow this nonsense.
Ti-,:[,k you.
Very Respectfully,
Justin I I ncock

Justin Hancock
Kinston, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Joshua Hancock
Date Wed 11/20/2024 7:47 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Joshua Hancock
Laurinburg, North Carolina_

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Chad Hardee
Date Thu 11/21/2024 3:15 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Chad Hardee
Washington , North Carolina-

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Kaylee Hardee
Date Thu 11/21/2024 9:08 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
glee Hardee
Washington , NC

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Cory Hervey
Date Tue 12/10/2024 5:47 AM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denard,
I hope you can listen to the people in the community rather then the big corporation that is
obviously not concerned with the impact this permit could have. NC is a beautiful place and we
would like to keep it that way.
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES permit to Martin Marietta Materials for its Vanceboro
Quarr
y.
The discharge of up to 12 million gallons of 001- ",water per day into the headwaters of Blo
Creek would significantly raise the pH of the'' tvtdm system, a change that is not allowable u
North Carolina's water-quality regulations. Such a cl-vjaryge in the water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized l � tate as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic spec ,4zdraw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
A are grateful that a.public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
r ' Vanceboro "#gill be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
ess can voicconcerns.
Thank you,
Cory Hervey
g
Herve
Clayton, North Carolina 6

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Douglas Hill JR
Date Sun 11/24/2024 156 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dxenard,
PI6 n't allow Martin Marietta to discharge wastewater into Blounts creek by reissuing their
permit. The discharge of up to 12 million gallons of water upstream in the creek would drastically
alter the PH of the creek, eliminating and harming many different fish and wildlife species. The
state law is clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from
its natural state.The creek is a designated nursery area for many saltwater fish species like trout,
flounder, drum, spot, croaker, and more. Our fisheries are a public trust recourse and this creek
should be protected as the nursery area it is designated by the state. As someone who often
fishes in and enjoys the beauty of this creek it would be terrible to see this fishery be destroyed
and the habitat altered for the worse. NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES permit to Martin
Marietta Materials for its Vanceboro Quarry.
Thank you for your time,
-Doug Hill Jr
Douglas Hill JR
Gr , North Carolin

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Nancy Hodges
Date Wed 11/20/2024 9:20 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Nancy Hodges
Chocowinity, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Courtney Holton
Date Thu 11/21/2024 3:19 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denard,
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES permit to Martin Marietta Materials for its Vanceboro
Quarry.
The discharge of up to 12 million gallons of groundwater per day into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pH of the stream system, a change that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulations. Such a change in the water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Courtne Holton
Greenville, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Alex Jones
Date Wed 11/20/2024 9:34 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M� •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process caris.lO a ch+V,,c;Lmc,­xis,
Thank yot:,
0
Alex Jond`
a
Greenville Sc. 4,�

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Jordan Jones
Date Wed 11/20/2024 9:35 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Jordan Jones
Greenville, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Nancy Hodges
Date Wed 11/20/2024 9:20 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Nancy Hodges
Chocowinity, North Carolina-

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comment + 5:'�tewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Steve Mason
Date Thu 1112112024 1 0:02 AM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CACCROO: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the Report
NK%,*'button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denard,
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES permit to Martin Marietta Materials for its Vanceboro
Quarry.
The discharge of up to 12 million gallons of groundwater per day headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pH of the stream system, a change that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulations. Such a change in the water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granfing Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit f4llb,
}
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining 11-1;%l���ti{+�
process can voice their concerns.
1"�ank you,
>ve Mason
Pinnacle, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comment + 5:'�tewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Eric Money
Date Wed 11/20/2024 6:56 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo p?bU-r- ta�.r� i'��into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Eric Money
Eric Money
MMM
Greenville, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Publ'-�,�. ii+' : NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Brian Neweir Y
Date Thu 11/28/2024 6:30 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Brian Newell
MM
Ayden , North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Erik Paulson
Date Wed 11/20/2024 9:09 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallop?b'rr, ta�.r� i'��into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is clear: a discharge of waste
cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw for fisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Changes in nursery productivity could also have negative long term impacts on commercially
valuable fisheries.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Erik Paulson
Erik Paulson
Wilmington, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Publ,' of ts: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Sara Prescott'
Date Sat 11/23/2024 6:50 AM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GAM
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallop?b'rr E=�:Yi%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Sara Prescott
Farmville, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From William Riddick
Date Fri 11/29/2024 2:48 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denard,
I am writing to express my concerns regarding the reissuance of an NPDES permit allowing
Martin Marietta to discharge up to 12 MGD of untreated water from it's planned Vanceboro
quarry into the upper reaches of Blounts Creek, a pristine waterway designated as a "primary
nursery area" by the State of NC for important aquatic species.
I am a licensed professional engineer in NC with nearly 50 years as a consulting engineer
representing both public and private clients in NC. I have prepared numerous environmental
assessments and two full environmental impact statements (EIS) in support of NPDES Permit
requests. In each case, requirements include evaluation of alternative actions and frequently
form the basis for special conditions which balance the needs of the permittee with those of the
citizens of NC as NPDES Permits are issued.
There can be no doubt that the discharge of up to 12 MGD of untreated groundwater into the
upper reaches of Blounts Creek will permanently alter the ecosystem of this primary nursery
area. Thus, as NC DWQ reviews this Permit request, there are a number of special conditions
that I believe will allow Martin Marietta to proceed with the development of the mine in a
responsible way.
These conditions are summarized below:
1) It is likely that Martin Marietta's requirements for groundwater withdrawal will be less that 12
MGD in the early years of operation of the mine. Thus on an annual basis, Martin Marietta
should be required to submit it's projected groundwater withdrawal volumes for the ensuing year
to the Division's Chief Hydrologist for approval.
2)The maximum daily rate of discharge of groundwater into the upper reaches of Blounts Creek
should be limited to no more than 1.0 times the average annual daily (365 day basis)
groundwater withdrawal, not to exceed 12 MGD. This may require Martin Marietta to add onsite
retention ponds prior to discharge but should not be an unreasonable imposition on a 650 acre
site.
3) Martin Marietta should be required to complete and submit a full Environmental Assessment of

the ecosystem of Blounts Creek prior to allowing any discharge from it's planned m ning
operation.As a m him u mthis assessment should discuss all relevant water quality parameters
and how changes from "unnatural" causes, including the intentional discharge of groundwater,
will im pact aquatic species. A com Mete inventory of plants, invertebrates, m dlusks, shellfish and
fin fish along with all m a m mIs and birds that currently depend on a healthy Blounts Creek for
existence shall be identified.All species that are on the State's listing of endangered or protected
species shall be identified. The Assessm ent shall address the potential changes water quality will
have on any listed species.
4) M artin M arietta should be required to subm I annually a reassessm ent of the ecosystem of
Blounts Creek by a qualified environmental scientist who shall identify any changes in the
ecosystem attributable to the m ning discharge. When any such changes are identified (and
there will be changes), M artin M arietta shall be required to subm it a plan of action to address
these changes.
In addition, while not a requirem ent for an NPDES Discharge Perm t, M a-tin M arietta should be
required to address the potential im pacts of it proposed groundwater withdrawals on public and
private wells that m jht be affected.
I respect the duty NC DWQ has to balance the needs of industry while protecting the interests of
citizens in m anaging the public trust waters of North Carolina. I sincerely believe that appropriate
Special Conditions im posed on M atin M arietta can be the basis for a responsible path forward.
If you have any questions! I can be reached at
Thank you for your consideration.
Thank you,
William S Riddick, Jr
William Riddick
Chocowinity, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From
Date Sun 12/1/2024 3:36 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard,
Dear Mr. Denard,
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES permit to Martin Marietta Materials for its Vanceboro
Quarry.
The discharge of up to 12 million gallons of groundwater per day into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pH of the stream system, a change that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulations. Such a change in the water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Will Riddick
==
Lewisville, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From David Rouse
Date Fri 11/22/2024 3:37 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES kt)—, ;%; 4';1' �; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
David Rouse
MAyden, North Carolina

J ' Outlook
[External] Publk.,,�Y—ai- y �!'`4�stewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Michele Shelton,"
Date Wed 11/20/2024 9:48 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�i> utton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ; aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process c;y, vo3i x f,h.8'r ful"FIA 4F
+ , r
Thank yov,,
Michele
hTI LV
BIount's cn l:? Nojjh'�Itf1a

J , Outlook
[External] MMM Vanceboro Quarry Permit
From Veith, Charles
Date Thu 11/21/2024 2:29 PM
To SVC_DEQ.publiccommentsDWR <[e-mail]>
You don't often get email from
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Report suspicious emails with the Report
Message button located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
Hello Staff of the DEQ,
Please do not allow a mining company access to our wonderful and diverse watershed in the Pamlico
River and sound. Many companies like this either underreport the amount of pollutants they release or
simply pay the fine on the chin and get off scoff free.
As someone who has worked with and for the Division of Marine fisheries (see Ami Staples), I would
like to preserve this crucial habitat for our native gamefish and other charismatic species.
This move will disrupt the salinity of a crucial spawning and wintering ground for many inshore
species , which can lead to further trophic consequences that will bring more harm than good.
As someone invested in the future -' ,N:g�:tth Carolina's ecosystems and natural resources, I appreciate
the time taken to read my email.
Best,
Charles Veith
M.S Student I Fisheries Oceanography
Asch Lab I East Carolina University

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Lisa Wood
Date Thu 11/21/2024 9:40 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAA I'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, •• M• •r
Dear Mr. Denard,
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES +* ;�, + 4'; � 9aterials for its Vanceboro
Quarry.
The discharge of up to 12 million gall&>>xYtr`rr t=" - O%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pFViC*f"W 6�a; ' v range that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality re ulatri '. , + hre �q y g o��� ���ri{`�*�'�;, �vater chemistry would change
r ui ,'r 1,°' s Itt,� � n , -
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nurserlaltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw for fisherf k and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
As;gin-em;j y ;at a marina store on Blounts Creek, this could devastate the fishing in our creek
and in:tr.tr i cause stores like ours to have to close our doors due to the huge decrease in
revenue. PI consider the busines, t " k°�a;ks Creek that this would affect as well as the
residents.
I know there are other options that coWrri'�l;�esides dumping the water into Blounts Creek.
Please go with another option so that,0,0-,0*0 our creek, the fishing, the wildlife, etc as it is
now. We love our creek!!
Thank you,
Lisa Wood
Lisa Wood
Chocowinity, North Carolina

_
| ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDESVVastemater Permit NCD089168-VanceboroQuany
From,Wtchel I Wood
CAUION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
Dear Mr. Denard,
for its Vanceboro
GA A
The discharge of up to 12 million
�:Y:;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pFi.MA*v�-PA,4-
�61-4ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulatie&$V� kMeeik,k.,Nater chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic spaoias, a draw forfisharfo|k and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Very Concerned Fisherman of8|nuntsCreek
Mitchell Wood
Mitchell Wood

J ' Outlook
[External] Public Comments: NPDES Wastewater Permit NC0089168-Vanceboro Quarry
From Kelly Yeats
Date Sat 11/23/2024 11:18 PM
To Denard, Derek <[e-mail]>
CAU71'ON: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified.Report suspicious emails with the Report
f�iutton located on your Outlook menu bar on the Home tab.
US Derek Denard, ••« M• •r'
Dear Mr. Denard, , , ;i�•
NCDEQ should not reissue a NPDES ki)—, ;%; 44 ;e aterials for its Vanceboro
GA A
Quarry. m•` - •: �'•°
The discharge of up to 12 million gallo b'r r E=':: :;�-A%into the headwaters of Blounts
Creek would significantly raise the pF.MA* a E PA,4 +, •ange that is not allowable under
North Carolina's water-quality regulate ,water chemistry would change
which aquatic species can survive in those waters, and state law is
clear: a discharge of waste cannot change the species composition of a stream from its natural
state.
Blounts Creek has been recognized by the state as nursery for saltwater species, and is a critical
habitat for fish and other aquatic species, a draw forfisherfolk and wildlife enthusiasts.
Granting Martin Marietta Materials the NPDES permit puts this entire ecosystem at risk.
We are grateful that a public hearing about the renewal of Martin Marietta Materials' permit for
the Vanceboro quarry will be held in Beaufort County, so that those affected by the mining
process can voice their concerns.
Thank you,
Kelly Yeats
==
Corbin City, New Jersey