Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20100358 Ver 1_Complete File_20070807V l? Wetland Mitigation Monitoring Report Evaluations: Information Table r? NC Division of Water Quality ?3 March 29, 2007: Version 1.1 j ?- Evalua or's Name(s): Date of Office Review: Report Prepared by: Date of Report: Monitoring Report for Year: 1. Office Review Information: J j ea z DWQ 401 Number: Site Name: DaL? ca?-ut County(ies): ) Basin & Subb s 030300 Nearest Stream WO : ELUo Mitigator: EE Private Mit. Bank Other al Mitigation on Site Wetland: L C) I G_L ?t A--\ M4-. Stream: Buffer: Project Type & Size:?ib .U 5b cc ) 1_o L-9 c-c- c,.W?-00 CoO1.2Co c-c. Location on Site: Goal(s) of Mitigation (wetland type(s) & details): roiect History: r-?dn ?,n?? ?•? ?g ? Vko 32D Cic- Event Date c? rrl??br. 2l? 1 Cp C ?c > > pv). A- 19gb (Awe-, COb C?-C. -?- L)-Pb -r d IIDI V . -O Cale-' C (? C Monitoring Clock Start Date: /zw Approved Mitigation plan available? Yes No Problem areas identified in reports? Yes No *Add significant project-related events that occurred Problem areas addressed on site? Yes No this year: construction, planting, grading, etc.* II. Success Criteria Evaluation: 3 Note dominant species & other success-related information in the appropriate sections. ¦ Assess trends over time (i.e. compare with previous years' results) and correlate between J hydrology, vegetation, and soils. ¦ Verify presence of site maps detailing different wetland types, problem areas, monitoring and photo point locations. S? HYDROLOGY - Ap roved Success Criteria: Cr SCE' r Wetland Hydrology Indicators: ?2 • J _ Inundated Saturated in upper 12 inches for appropriate 36 o t CU_VL G,,,_? 7 Monitoring report indicates success. Yes No % of growing season based on mitigation plan? Yes No based on wetland type? Yes No Max period of inundation/saturation: met for entire project Yes No days = % of growing season Monitoring wells: _ Comparison with reference wetland (esp. functioning properly? Yes No during years with abnormal precipitation) data in tabular & graphic form? Yes No List any remaining hydrolo y issues to address e.g. excessive water, upland plant species, etc.): - C,(+ ) t `Q X- UMx)- rR -1 'e . - _ r . , -c amu 1 `1 Ct ° /o Cb T -uD?-OONS- V2. G `h, 6-S (-2A-Jo M (l y l.C+ Qv-e,? (.E 1. .?-e_C?:?n-S ? ?jl.lvD?o ?'1,?-?' 12??o C?i?.??h- C 112 2 b CcaC,"C ns l? -5 4 e. #?s +o Lob y, SU :2? ? C. CICSS ?- s uCC k2 . ,?? 9 tea, ?? ?, 3cc P 1 f 2 - CUP-- ag tip- ob ( o e Wetland Mitigation Monitoring Report Evaluations: Information Table NC Division of Water Quality SOILS - Approved Success Are soils hydric or becoming hydric? Yes No Indicators of hydric soils: List any remaining soil issues to address (e.g. erosion, upland areas, etc.): VEGETATION - Approved Success Criteria: .? ;t?Q ' T t om- 6 CVLG.n - nco ? --?' a_o /o L-Qx es-0- X`A11- Sampling date(s): f0 MR-t--"tGJ to b -WA rcc?juA-k-r)?--Q Monitoring report indicates success? Yes No based on community composition? Yes No based on TPA and/or % cover? Yes No Supplemental planting this year? Yes No Planting date(s): C ? Dc -? a blcv Y-0-n_c Vegetation growing successfully? Yes No I Average trees per acre for Specific vegetation plots or site locations with little to no vegetation: Estimated acreage or site percentage of unvegetated areas: Invasive species on site (species, location(s), % cover, and control measures): -u-?A c 4w IOt , vs? ? l_A.? List any remaining vegetation issues to address (e.g. plant survival, concerns, etc): ?- tfo _*?"s -f?c v1)1- '!SA?c`:? NCWAM - Approved Success Criteria: NCWAM Wetland Type on Site: Coastal Riverine Monitoring report indicat ss' es No _ - Riparian _ Non-riparian (wetter) Attach NCWAM analys o this report. _Non-riparian (drier) List any remaining NCW issues to address (e.g. functionality, developing wetland type, etc.): MITIGATION SUCCESS: Compared to the mitigation plan, the site is: successful partially successful not successful List specific reasons for any lack of success for this site: Additional Comments (e.g. DWQ follow-up actions, recommendations, etc.): Schedule Site Visit? Yes No Page 2 of 2 Wetland Mitigation Site Evaluations: Information Table NC Division of Water Quality March 8, 2007: Draft Version 4.3 (form produced via database report) Evaluator's name(s): Date of Office Review: - - Other individuals/agencies present: :c?A C.? Weather conditions (today & recent): Directions to Site: 1. Office Review Information: 401 Permit Number: Site Name: i1.od 'U)Q-Ut J Countyoes): 'bLp,_G r) Basin & Subbasm? C ? 03D-?:)DCOD Nearest Stream / WQ class: 7 fiLW Mitigator Type: Total Mitigation on Site Wetland: U D v , TU. CL-c- mskuy- Stream: Buffer: Project Type and Size: (.r C)1.2,4 &-c- -6k-i7A Location on Site: Goals of Mitigation (wetland type(s), details): Project History: Ca kUtA-I?A Event Date Year of monitoring: ?p Approved Mitigation plan available? Yes Problem areas identified in reports? Yes Problem areas addressed on site? Yes o - Prior to site visit, note dominant species and monitoring report success results in appropriate areas of Section II. - During site visit, document both representative conditions and areas of concern. Label and attach photos to this report. - Additional information found during office review and/or to be obtained during site visit: II. Data reported from site visit HYDROLOGY - Approved Success criteria: Wetland Hydrology Indicators: _ Inundated _ Saturated in upper 12 inches Monitoring report indicates success? Yes No _ Drift lines Observational field data agrees? Yes No _ Drainage patterns in wetlands based on mitigation plan? Yes No _ Sediment deposits based on wetland type Yes No _Watermarks List any remaining hydrology issues to address (e.g. remaining ditches, excessive water, etc.): Evaluator's Agency:_ Date of Field Review: Page 1 of 2 Wetland Mitigation Site Evaluations: Information Table NC Division of Water Quality SOILS - Appr ed Success Criteria: I , ?, Are soils hydric or becoming hydric? of Vco '?1 Yes No List indicators of hydric soils: G ? C +'C?'lC? 1t1? ? ?Cli oak Q) &4 List any remaining soil issues to address (e.g. erosion, upland areas, etc.): V\Ju ? VEGETATION -Approved Success Criteria: `? TP!"? ` G 1? j W Dominant Plant Species (per monitoring report) S ecies Story TPA or % cover roec???o`??x. A Monitoring report indicates success? Y/es do (? Observational field data agrees? Yes No t) A rnm? I'D based on community composition? based on TPA and/or % cover? Yes No Y s No Vegetation planted on site? No Vegetation growing successfully? No UK o G1 SLY ? Average trees per acre for entire site: Specific vegetation plots or site locations with little to no vegetation: Estimated acreage or site percentage of unvegetated areas: Invasive species on site (species, location(s), and % cover): List any remaining vegetation issues to address (e. . plant survival, concerns, etc.): ve_. 0a_ _V'LC.C_ UO . <?C._Q_r, (-S. ?? Cq 0 b L?? NCWAM - Approved Sua ss Crite ia: C ?eC = Gush Monitoring report indicates suc ess? Yes No S Observational field data agree Yes o? Attach NCWAM analysis res is t th rt. N WAM Wetland Type on Site: -Coastal _ Riverine _ Riparian _ Non-riparian (wetter) Non-riparian (drier) List any remaining NCWA ' sues to address (e.g. functionality, developing wetland type, etc.): MITIGATION SUCCESS: Compared to the mitigation plan, this project is: successful partially successful not successful List specific reasons for lack of success for this project: Additional Comments (e.g. DWQ follow-up actions, reco mendations, etc.): re C, f&- C? pQCLO : u?A4C cy t? s-ec are o?a_. v3 tR-Sk OK . Page 2 of 2 o V W) 0 0 40 m 0 0 0 G- N N N N N N a d d n N M ? 00 (D U 0) 0 4) } } E } 0 }}} F 0. m t a mm mOm C C C C C c . 2 O 0 0 r- 0 0) ' 0 ' ' ' ' ' • d C C c c c c M 202 MMMMM 0 O C N c m c ?a LO 4) a c o LL 0) °O - 4) V5,g N O O E- cn to M O UU(na0 N C ' c o o f O d W N U D O F- L 2 U u? C > a °' .. m 2 2 o 0 CM O y> O D O O M mdW a 0 O 0 ivw C N ' E 3 a8 N y m 2 C O N o0 0 m o C C a a? m m -W o C) } R a? } o?m3 >Ln • L E CL Z a y W fc0 W z g U) AD , .29 LLJ a`wU a`U on ° Sp b U ao > .m q ` ' 0 0 W?° b'b ? 3 ; o C o .? ao 3 on '" .? '? 00 ?• a p v O m a ? a a? Q' b O O N C1r y • .+ bq ... U y^, aU? ? N 3 F °" b 0 o O `o `n ti N U 4a O p N a?'i c ° O ? O. l? ?i11 t? '? 3 ?• o cn o O A. U r. ° ° a1 'C? c 3 .4 0? yU, ? ? U 3 N b ? ? at ? a?• q ? > ood ? ? U U S2 N ^? C.' N 00 c ?t7 _ C E E CO c C L t C o W W W U t?0 4- '0 O N N N ID - N 2'6 e) ?3: 6?3? a n u ° ° n u aWww0IL m E 0 L W c _ C c c Q 7 0 '?m?i° Brno ?a 0.2 o W ) O? c 0 :2 MEW EW 2 C.La _ _ m c tI Z? MZ0 .a a `3: a 00 CL `aa` n n n u > > w aan". via V r- °1 a °-- '- m ° ° M ° o or i o ?OLOMN 3 ~ Z ooo N ? M N N m N O 0 O 0 O 0 N r ?a-NMtO H 3 3 ? 0 0 0 a L. v N ? co V N O 0 O 0 O 0 ? >d? W Ua a 0 J 0 0 0 0 0 +-+ Q? y+ 0 O 0 M M 0 eeee {6 A 10 10 C 7 y y ? ? ? N o o N o 0 3333 +? > a W U a R V J W O V e ° a ° a ° C o o O +' e 2 emu 2 ! C L O r N O E E Q m m V LA ` a n r: r ZZZ ? "' r ?t b r s: Cl) i t k ?," r ? ?" ? g V a?o 'Y A D (3 0 (a CL <> ? G ff 'lm' '? fg 4 -? g ci f Yl 'G a ?? ? a m ° v YG ° < ^ ? ? r B ti ? 'e m F t2 2 S 0 2 8 8 !7 ?x W x j N cc X X % X % x x % X x x x X X X X x x % % X x % x x x x x z ? x s' l I I I I I I I I I Ix ma x x e.Y N N t N M Y f • p9 ' - d b ? ? S_ 0 e ? m E 777'ppp 777 • ty M + e ? m 3 S 2 2 1 ?' ? 0 LL 0 O , ] 0 $ ° O LL li li. o D ° o 2 ° 2' o 2 o 2 ° Y a ? LL o LL 0 4. 0 Ii. 0 4. 0 IL 0 li. 0 U. ° 'LL 2? o o O ° D D . ° ° ° } r r ll ' ?I x xx a pp?; g{ ? xx ?i "3 s o0 I yyyi3 H ; W V O 111 c C7 w m y« 0 W a F- > E ,arr Z O i' . CO= ?@ u? ?h C y. c x o ?$ `n N Cgg" k 3 L'? ? N ` t! ?' ? G ? ? ? ? ?"o? W N W ^1 : i lY S".I fD ? I? 1? ? M ? C ? f0 ? ?.j UI ? C 10 l"! ? Q ? W ? N qq y y y y y q N a q q q q q q q q i? v} q q y y yy y ? O d= b N ? ? N 1N O IA Ip IN .- 6 ID IN N Q C! YI D tO O Yl aG W aC a? tG (O A SO ?! N N N O OI ?- f0 t?f 1? l? .- 1u fO N ? N N N OD Oi .- W N - V GO N N YI N ? ?G .- N fG ?- M ? V V ?- O W ? N ap ? rRr JJ N a ? Y C C7 N ( ?f ( Y U' N U' ip l.. tq ' W ? ? ? ? ? W fr m Q O :- ? I+I O N iD 1? N N t? (n m ?f W 11 +p ? M ? 4. ? LL 7 W IL IL y_ (7 LL V IL (7 IL (? LL (? LL ? IL C! IL n ` T l? (J IL L ? LL LL LL LL LL L . L 11 L LL LL LL LL n 'T LL 4? L [ !9 , LL ? 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 $ O p O O D D O O D D O O I D D p O O D D l O 11 D I O I O p O O D O . O I p `? 0 0 I L ? 0 0 0 0 0 D p O D O O p D O D 0 0 0 0 D O O D p O O p ?P 11-1I t .6 2 ? ? A' 'O`ff ? `m? c7 Sc ff 6fQ f?Qf .?Q d f f ?n `??n ? ?if ?22222 N F J 7 N C Z Z O U OA U' O C X ys V-1 x x g N S 0 t ?t ?m v ?i mL?L?L?L?+.mmLum m? ?umm?ru?urumruru?i?`^°'?m?u Lu?u.omm°1 o ¢0000 0ou g o 000 00 ?? o Go??ou? ?? ;, m m m ao w n nn n_ o?ng ^io comma drimoOOn?ri??,?'a g{RQ°ao °o ?'io ?*,?jPdNao?$j m? Qo7e X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X. x x x x x x x x X X X X X X X X X X X 5 0cso3o co°o00co000 0 0 0 0 0$ 0 o a 0 0 0 $ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ? o 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 c ? m UI ? rv m ryry Ny C (O 2' N 2?p c ?Q 2`? N N? ? N C) NOi ? RYf N cif Z ? N C ? N m m ?yy O p C ? N N C ? Q r j 5 - 5 _ ? 5 M 5 {F fi 5 i ? ? ? tOa ?- fi° ? 5 ? 5 { t g _ fi ? ? 7i s ? i 3 A tl Q ? ? O O Ol 1 ? f 17 Of HI OI ?(1 ?A ? ? M ? I? N V ELI O N N ? Of ? N - ? ii5 ?(1 W 10 lD O t?'1 q ? - A V fV ( ( ?? N O ? N Y d V N m lH a p ( O G N ? d N ? N < O w N O p p?? N N O M ? W (V ?(1 N b N /?+ A X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X i X X M ' X X X X fi in r a> ?i o rv n a u+ m r ? ?i o ? rv ?n r w + - C? LL 0 o C? li 0 o U?' li 0 o .t c7 LL. 0 a ? Ii 0 o 6 LL 0 o C LL 0 o ?Q Y LL 0 o C7 LL 0 o C7 ?. O 0 (7 u: D 0 C7 4. 0 0 'U' LL 0 0 t7 LL O 0 U O 0 (7 LL 0 0 'G LL 0 0 (? LL O 0 C?' LL O 0 ? LL O 0 CN9 LL 0 ? CN7 IL 0 o (N7 LL a o NU' IL 0 o C7 LL 0 o tN'i1 LL 0 o NU' LL. 0 0 CN'j LL ? 0 C7 Y. 0 0 C?7 IL 0 0 C?'j LL 0 0 (?J LL 0 0 t? LL 0 0 (?7 LL. 0 0 C7 ?. 0 0 C7 W 0 0 M LL 0 °q LL 0 $ 7 $g 3 m ag 8? ' : j. aD I , I e? i I C loa ^ a aA?aa o . ai . '. I a t a a D aas' as e ^ I iG N b I g 1 Y m a?a???a??'a ' a 5a e ro . 'V. rye ,a z mw0lI. q.eSl IIIKFI 1 I I j 0 O O O b fC y I O iO N ?,j n I N b b OD ? n Q ry . u rn',v m ro. ? ?o aR. o a. NN 'n " N m'. q Iq lo. n. C'. n. 11 R q ?Q -R • Y ? ? p, Y Yff t t? 0 p t Op . O.Y ??. c?t+l e7' OYNO °1 ?i ?. ?Y?Ntnv+?i00 mOxs N l?.N pj ON.N-: s4i? xx xxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx x xx I Pt? x. x _`. x x to x x x x x x ? ??????.^???ONt7YYf iDnoD O10 YNfDn WOO N ?$j : f0 n'oD OIC LjSS p 000 0 O O Doc n o n 0 O aO 0000000000c) [ F = C? C0 'IT 0 T Cl) N N M O O 00 M ( M - C O C O co co 00 1- t- 0 co C) Cl) V O V ? V M O co 00 (Y) V C O co (0 V 'T O 00 O M CO N CO ' (D - M m N N 0 co (O U ) 'IT M C CO LO U-) co to co '0 " M l LO O l IT ? m N N N 1 N t L W) q Co 00 0 00 Ce) U) U-) CO) f ? l co co 1 M N th M V) LO co t LO "t F V) 0 0 0 0 co M ? M , M O O O O , C O C O C O C O r 000 ONO ONO 0) M CD N ~ N Co .T O - M to - 4 O O O (O (0 M 00 M (O LO M M M M M M ? ? v to O O O O O O 00 co to to to a r O 00 co M L tf LO ? ? ( O co coo c o (0 t O "t Lo Lf) o o 0) C) f- O = d O 0 O N u G G- . V d LO LO 0- . M t 'T ? N 0 O I- ? co co 07 0 0 C O N - N W LO V' mil' M M t0 'q v V "r 0 N ? to n ? 0 0 0 (0 P- 0 00 O co co M M N Co 0 0 M V' M 'q 'r ^ C to U l U) M N O 0 O 0 p C O C 0 (O C O ( 0 V CO 0 O O N O 0 0 0 M (O M ( 0 co co co co co ( 0 N LO - O M O O 0 0 0 0 U) L co M Co N (N co co N O co 0) - 0 CD cv) t- P- 00 - le Od' OD to Cl) CO COO COO N 0 M M (00 M O M O 0 0 M ? M U) ( M N ( M 0 0 CO IT N M N N (O CO Co (O M 0 0 O 0 O O N to 0 0 0 0 N 0 0 O CO * O O (O (0 (0 (0 (0 to - LO ? O M M ; N N N to 'T V' It N N N N N 41 O to Of ?!' t ? h Q ? ? ? ? } M p 0 0 0 0 I 8 } M 0 O 0 0 0 8 ( 0 0 0 0 0 0 V m O O O O O N N N N N N N N N N r N co v l(7 O .- N M V to co ('0 J IIN A VCJ J O_ r (7 1 ?' rn CC T A ? x a a Y R 3- 9 ? ax U} ?? m o C _ ° 6 wVm" c X65 I z 7 (? m a g V ?- m 3 N 0 d r // 2 ?3 _x a O m a F- _{6JJ lp J n r 4 o 5 c ?o i ame z. ve eiazion monitorinresuns. ZONE PLOT SPECIES' = TOTALS DENSITY CO CO L 'a € Year Initial Y m 0 C En a) i O i rn CO O m O Y L Q m O W m O a a 0) a .? C -, C 2 D >1 0 3 6 Planting CL :3 cc __ 3 t 3 m 3 m rn N o O a m -0 a m U f9 U f6 y Q 1 1 0 0 8= 1 0 0 6 11 s 0 0 0 0 26 37 3 4 0 6= 0 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 0= 13 40 - - - --- ---------- --- 4 3 3 1= 0 0 0 1 19 -- 0 0 ~0 0 - _...----- 27 1 28 -- ------.-- 5 --- 0 7 _ 3= ._......._._......, 2 2 1 12 9 0 0 0 0 36 - 39 8 4 0 3 0 3 1 ~7 - 0. 0 L p 0 0 18 38 14 5€ 1 6 5 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0= 18 39 15 1 2 8 0. 0 0 0 0. 0 0 0 0 11 f 32 --.... -_....... . 17 _ 13 2 ..... 1 .......... 4 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 . 0. . 21 41 --,.... _._......... .. 19 .............. ..... -- . ....... 3 ..... , 0 ?. . .._.-_. 0 ...................... 1 0 --- 0 -- € 0 0 ? . 0 . -- _ - - ...: 8 ; 5 - - - _ _..._._ :r 28 = 2 0 10 1. . 0 i 3- 0 7 4 1 0 0 0 0 26 1 37 29 4___ 2 _ 2 i_.._0._.._. 0 0 6 1 18 0 0 1 0 0 32 41 -__s...._...30 0 6 7= 0 0 0 19 2 1 0 0 0 0 34 = 39 31 15 0 1= 0 0 0 6 5 0 0 0 ---------- 0 27 37 ---- --- --- -- 32 --- -• .................... .... 3 ...__<_ __ O s _. 3 _... ? 0 ................... 0 0 1 - 13 3 - 0 ? 0 0 1 - -- 0 - ..._ .... 22 . ..... ..._.... - 38 33 ---...... ............. __......... 0 ... _..< 0 __ 1 ._.._._..._< 1 ................. 5 0 22 9 0 0 0 _.--- 0 E ._.. ....... 38 ........ ...... 44 34 ? 4 0 1 0 0 0 7 9 0` 0 0 E E 0 21 39 one Average 2 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 00 21 0 0 0 0 22 25 12 0 0-- T--2 ....6-. 0 1 1 u I - 0] 0 0 0 _ 0 1 "M' ^9 W 26 Zone Average 3 = 6 0 2 2 = 4€ 0 2 2 € 3 ._..-- 0 0 5 - 7 --_.......... ........ 27 .............. .. 30 -------- - --- .._ ............... 7 ----- ..................... ... 0 ...... - - 0 .... ---? 0 -......... . ........_....._ 0 ............. ........ ? 0 0 ? 9 T __. 2 0 0 18 0- 29 40 9 , 0 1 3' 1 0! 0 0 O 0 0 0 9. 1 4- 17 34 10 . 0 ; _ _ _ . 6 _ 2 -. -- 3 .. . .... . .... ... 0 0= 0 9 -- - 0 0 10 1 1 --- - . 31 ................ 44 .......... _......... _ --._.. 11 ...... . 0 ? 1 s n 14 . . . . . . 1 ? 0 0 0 4€ 0 0 s 7 1 ---.._: 28 28 ------ ......... ........ _ 20 ........ ,_ 0 .. 0 _._._? 3 ...._.....__..... 0 0 - - 0 10 - ..._._._, 0 0 0 0 , 0 13 37 24 0 0 7 0 0 0 1 - 0 µ 0 0 4 0= 12 34 25 _. . . 0 . .. - 0 3 3 1 0 0 5 5 0 - 0 1 4 21 ; - 31 ---- . _._.. . ...... ..... 26 . ... .__ 0 . . : 0= 2= ? 0 ...._ 0 0 20 1 0 1 0 4 1 3_ 30. 35 _._ ..... ......... 27 _ " _ _. 0 3 2- 0 0 0 0 10 0 0 1 4 0 19 36 - -._.......---_.._.. E 35 ---.._,.......... _.._ ...... .. ..., 0 1 ...... _;_ .. 0 _---- _ 0 _..__.? ....._......._... 1 ............._....' 4 0 - -- 6 2 - 0 0 0 ---.. 0 __. _ 13 ..._.....-- 37 -----._... - .._. 36 ? 0 4 4 . 0 0 0 4 0 1 0: 2 0 15 36 Zone Average (trees/acre) 520 260 540 720 360 22 420 160 L?- 520 640 680 540 440 760 420 440 310 540 580 340 620 560 240 °? 420 600 380 260 _ 300 5 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 17 ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY o v Year Initial Y Y Y M O O Y S Y N N E N N m U (trees/acre) f O O Y O CL w f6 U 0 m O n c a O a a 0 "- a m a 3 6 Planting i U 7 - 3 ?' r N 3 N 3 0) O O CL f6 U 5 E i _ O U o = I N Q - 4 16 4 1 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 12 0 22 31 440 18 7 4 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0- 10 0 23 35 4 Zone Average 450 5 0 1 3 . 2 . 0 = 4 3 - 0 -- 0 0 0 13 24 260 0 -- -- - 0 ' O s F 4 '. .. ? --- 0 0 . 0 ' 0 0 4 - - 0 16 . 0 -- - 24 .... _. -- - 29 - ....- .._ - 0 ._ ..............__.... --- - _ _ 2 0 . 2 .... ............ .... 0 ..._.... . ... 3 _ 0 -- 0- 0 0- 0^ 8 = 0 _ 15 - 27 30 _ - 2 1 0 9€ 0 4 0 0- 0 5 0 13 0 32 640 38 1 0 0= 0 0 0 0 1 0 14 . 0 33 - 47 660 9 2 1 14 0- 0 0 0 4 2 14 3 0 58 . 50 1160 ' 20 Zone Average 583 Total Average for all Zones 448 white oak, longleaf pine, black walnut, and tulip poplar were not observed during year 2006 monitoring activitti and are not included in this table Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 18 c - r .y •+M T V ?' J ii 1 ?„ '`? '.pl j,f 4?li .e if ?ti-.i N \ + •? '? 61 for I s a ' r ? 4 3a.e •i2 of ' i _.,;,._ 4,4 Y l[ i Y? gg ? Bg z 1 i ' •r???. ? d e r3? F - J! i A .t l a?. v... \ 7'1f ANNUAL REPORT FOR 2006 Dowd Dairy Farm Mitigation Site Bladen County Project No. 8.1241802 TIP No. R-2204WM r~ s ?11IMR- C'1I1 .a<11t rROGRAM Prepared By: Ecosystem Enhancement Program Raleigh, North Carolina November 2006 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................ 1 1.0 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................... 2 1.1 Project Description .............................................................. 2 1.2 Purpose ............................................................................ 2 1.3 Project History .................................................................... 4 2.0 HYDROLOGY ............................................................................. 5 2.1 Success Criteria ................................................................. 5 2.2 Hydrologic Description ......................................................... 5 2.3 Results of Hydrologic Monitoring ............................................ 7 2.3.1 Site Data ................................................................ 7 2.3.2 Climatic Data ........................................................... 10 2.4 Conclusions ....................................................................... 10 3.0 VEGETATION ............................................................................ 13 3.1 Success Criteria ................................................................. 13 3.2 Description of Species ......................................................... 13 3.3 Results of Vegetation Monitoring ............................................ 15 3.4 Stems Site otes of Observed Herbaceous Cover and Volunteer Woody 19 3.5 Conclusions ....................................................................... 19 4.0 OVERALL CONCLUSIONS/ RECOMMENDATIONS .......................... 23 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page ii TABLES Table 1 - 2006 Hydrologic monitoring results ......................................... 8 Table 2 - 2006 Vegetation monitoring results ......................................... 17 Facill :1 *1 Figure 1 - Site location map ................................................................ 3 Figure 2 - Monitoring gauge location map .............................................. 6 Figure 3 - 2006 hydrologic monitoring results .......................................... 9 Figure 4 - 30-70 percentile graph ......................................................... 11 Figure 5 - Mean saturation percentage for monitoring gauges ................... 12 Figure 6 - Vegetation sampling points and cover types ............................ 16 Figure 7 - Mean site density values ...................................................... 21 Figure 8 - Mean site species composition ............................................. 22 APPENDICES Appendix A - Gauge data graphs ................................................................. 24 Appendix B - Site and vegetation plot photos ............................................. 63 Appendix C - Annual hydrological monitoring activities summary ................ 73 Appendix D - Annual vegetation monitoring activities summary .................. 79 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page iii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The following report summarizes (1) 2006 monitoring activities at the Dowd Dairy Farm Mitigation Site and (2) overall results and conclusions based on six years of monitoring data. Phase I of this site was constructed in 1998 and Phase II was completed in 2000. Monitoring of the site began in 1999 following Phase I site construction. The monitoring activities in 2006 represent the sixth, and final, official year of monitoring following completion of activities during Phase II. The site demonstrated hydrologic and vegetation success after six years and could be deemed successful. The site was being monitored with 39 groundwater-monitoring gauges, two rain gauges, and 38 vegetation plots. Rainfall data has been acquired from onsite rain gauges. Also, monthly rainfall data recorded from a rain gauge maintained by the North Carolina State Climate Office in Elizabethtown was used for the historical data. Hydrological monitoring for year 2006 found 79% of the all gauges met jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season; conversely, 21% did not meet jurisdictional hydrologic success. Overall mean hydrological monitoring results from the past six years show that 81.6% of all site monitoring gauges met the jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season, of which more than half recorded periods of inundation between .25% and 50% of the growing season. The 2006 vegetation monitoring of the 619 acres of planted areas revealed an average density of 448 trees per acre, which is above the minimum requirement of 320 trees per acre. Overall mean annual site density for each of the six monitoring activities was greater than the minimum 320 trees per acre, averaging 503 trees per acre. The number of character tree species in each of the five Zones was greater than the minimum requirement of five species, ranging from seven to 13 species. Only three of the 13 species exceeded the established 20% composition limit in their respective planted areas. As per the letter dated August 25, 2004 to the NCDOT, Ecosystem Enhancement Program (EEP) has accepted the transfer of all offsite mitigation projects. As a result, EEP is responsible for fulfilling the remaining monitoring requirements and any future remediation for this project. This report summarizes the sampling activities for the sixth and final (close-out) year of monitoring. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page I 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Project Description The Dowd Dairy Farm Wetland Mitigation Site is located 7 miles north of Elizabethtown and 2 miles east of White Oak in Bladen County (Figure 1). It is bounded by SR 1324 (Dowd Dairy Farm Road) to the north, SR 1332 (Oak Grove Church Road) to the west, and dense forest to the south and east. The site represents a Coastal Plain interstream divide converted for agricultural use. The site receives drainage from elevated sandy terraces and discharges into Ellis Creek and Panther Branch, tributaries of the Cape Fear River. The site encompasses approximately 658 acres and is designed as a mitigation site for the Cape Fear River Basin (HUC#: 03030005). 1.2 Purpose In order to demonstrate successful mitigation, hydrologic and vegetative monitoring must be conducted for a minimum of five years or until success criteria are fulfilled. Success criteria are based on federal guidelines for wetland mitigation. These guidelines stipulate criteria for both hydrologic conditions and vegetation survival. The following report details the results of hydrologic and vegetative monitoring during 2006 on the Dowd Dairy Farm Mitigation Site. Activities in 2006 reflect the sixth year of monitoring following the construction of Phase II at the site. Included in this report are analyses of both hydrologic and vegetative monitoring results, as well as local climate conditions throughout the growing season. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 2 1 I ,1 , o m m> yI/ Z a 'Elk, LL, ?' -"'1 i ? ? F ti It - 1? I ? t ?,j; 13'^? cf, •I ?. '• , ary rt N .?? ?, ?. , t ?4?'1C ?j4 -'? o '? L r )/ 1 y .u ,i yf yT co tale / / - `._~^_,., C,J --? ),\F- ,C,1?.R. ` •M M-'f" -?. N: f Ol N? E Z N f\t Il,K \ J! i J I 11 1 r (A t0 ?? Iy l f ? ? z k- l ? LJ- COO N ,'L U t C t r 1 t° ?1 !.t ,'T I 7 D33NZ)Z i dam' ?. R ). 1s' "° 4 aj j r ~•° ?i"J t 1f Y I?iq;e;? ',??. `k. Y 1. ??. r tI)'. 1.3 Project History Summer 1998 Construction - Phase I Spring 1999 Tree Planting - Phase I February - April 1999 Installation of Monitoring Gauges March - November 1999 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 1) September 1999 Construction Begins - Phase II November 1999 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 1) March - November 2000 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 2) June 2000 Construction Completed - Phase II November 2000 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 2) February 2001 Tree Planting - Phase II March - November 2001 Hydrologic Monitoring (Restart Year 1) October 2001 Vegetation Monitoring (Restart Year 1) August 2002 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 2) March - November 2002 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 2) May 2003 Onsite Agency Meeting August 2003 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 3) March - November 2003 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 3) July 2004 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 4) March - November 2004 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 4) October 2005 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 5) March - November 2005 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 5) September 2005 Vegetation Monitoring (Year 6) March - October 2006 Hydrologic Monitoring (Year 6) Phase I construction consisted of clearing, grubbing, ripping, filling lateral ditches, and adding ditch plugs. Phase II construction consisted of filling in the central canal. Completion of the site was delayed to June 2000 due to the saturated conditions from the hurricane activity in the fall of 1999. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 4 2.0 HYDROLOGY 2.1 Success Criteria In accordance with federal guidelines for wetland mitigation, the success criteria for hydrology state that the area must be inundated or saturated (within 12" of the surface) by surface or groundwater for at least 12.5% of the growing season. Areas inundated less than 5% of the growing season are always classified as non- wetlands. Areas inundated between 5% - 12.5% of the growing season can be classified as wetlands depending upon other factors, such as the presence of hydrophytic vegetation and hydric soils. The growing season in Bladen County begins March 16 and ends November 14. The dates correspond to a 50% probability that temperatures will drop to 28° F or lower after March 16 and before November 14.' The growing season is 244 days; therefore the optimum duration for wetland hydrology is 31 days. Also, local climate must represent average conditions for the area. 2.2 Hydrologic Description Historically, wetlands on the tract were created by a combination of radial groundwater and surface water flow from adjacent terraces, as well as precipitation and vertical groundwater fluctuations maintained within the site. After an extensive study of the site's hydrology, it was concluded that blocking and filling the drainage ditches within the site would elevate the groundwater to a level that would saturate the soil stratum within the required twelve inches. It was predicted that this, in addition to surface water and runoff, would be sufficient to restore wetland hydrology. Thirty-one groundwater-monitoring gauges and 2 rain gauges were installed in 1999 +----FFigure 2). Five additional gauges were installed in transects along the main channel in 2001 to examine potential drainage effects of the large remaining canal. In June 2003, two additional groundwater gauges were installed. The rain gauges cpj" and groundwater monitoring gauges record daily readings of rainfall and depth to S groundwater, respectively. Natural Resources Conversation Service, Soil Survey of Bladen County. North Carolina, p. 123. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 5 2.3 Results of Hydrologic Monitoring 2.3.1 Site Data The maximum number of consecutive days that the groundwater was within twelve inches of the surface was determined for each groundwater gauge. This number was converted into a percentage of the 244-day growing season. Table 1 presents the hydrologic monitoring results for 2006. Figure 3 provides a graphical representation of the hydrologic results. Gauges highlighted in blue indicate wetland hydrology for more than 12.5% of the growing season. Gauges highlighted in red show hydrology between 8% and 12.5% of the growing season, while those in green indicate hydrology between 5% and 8%. Gauges highlighted in black indicate no wetland hydrology (less than 5% of the growing season). Appendix A contains a plot of the groundwater depth for each monitoring gauge. Daily rainfall is included on each graph as bars (recorded by rain gauges located on the site). The maximum number of consecutive days that the groundwater was within 12 inches of the surface is noted on each graph. Hydrological monitoring for year 2006 found 79% of the all gauges met jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season; conversely, 21 % did not meet jurisdictional hydrologic success. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 7 Table 1. Hydrological monitoring results for year 2006. % of Growing Season at Saturation Monitoring (< 12" below surface) Dates Meeting Gauge < 5% 5-8% 8-12.5% >12.5% Actual Success DD1 ..... _.._.. X _------- 17.6 -------- 4/18 - 5/30 DD2 X 4.9 DD3 X 7.8 DD4 X . 1.6 ..... ._._._... ......... _.___ _._ DD5 X _............ 18.9 3/16 - 4/15; 4/18 - 6/2 . _ _.... DD6 .. __ ..... X ..._.. 41.4 3/16 - 6/24; 9/1 - 11/6 ------ . DD7 X 11.1 DD8 X ------------- ------ 32.8 --- ---- - -- 3/16 - 6/3 DD9 - -- X 33.6 3/16 - 6/5 DD10 - -- ---- ------ X - ---- - 35.2 -- - - - 3/16 - 6/9; 9/1 - 8/6 _ ......... DD12 -- - -- X 33.6 3/16 - 6/5; 9/1 - 8/3 DD13 X ---.----- 1.2 . - ---- ----- ------- DD14 - X 16.4 3/16 - 4/24 DD15 X 42.2 3/16 - 6/26 DD16 X 27.5 - 3/16 - 4/16; 4/18 - 6/7; 9/1 - 11/6 DD17 X 42.6 .. 3/16 - 6/27 --- ---- ------ -- DD18 X 49.6 3/16 - 7/14; 7/16 - 8/29; 8/31 -11/8 DD19 X 28.3 9/1-11/8 DD20 X 54.5 7/28 - 11/7 DD21 - ------ --- ------ - -- X 68.4 - 3/16 - 8/29; 8/31 - 11/7 DD22 .._... _ X _--... 14.8 4/18 - 5/23 --- - DD23 X 51.2 3/17 - 7/19; 7/21 - 11/8 DD24 X 27.9 3/16 - 4/23; 9/1 - 11/7 DD25 X 43.9 - 3/16 - 7/30 - --- - ---------- ...._ DD26 X ------ 50.8 -------- 3/17 - 7/18; 7/21 - 8/26; 9/1 - 11/8 DD27 X 48.8 3/16 - 7/12; 7/21 - 8/20; 9/1 - 11/7 ------ DD28 -- --- X -- ---- - - -- 48.0 -- - -- - 3/18 - 7/12; 7/21 - 8/25; 9/1 - 11/7 - ------------ -- DD29 X 67.6 3/17 - 8/28; 9/1 - 11/7 DD30 X ... -- - 18.0 3/17 - 4/16; 4/18 - 5/31; 9/1 - 10/5; 10/8 - 11/7 -- .. DD31 ....... --- X 34.0 3/17 - 6/7; 7/21 - 8/20; 9/1 - 11/6 .. DD32 _._._.._. X 21.3 7/9 - 8/29; 9/1 -10/3 DD34 X 7.8 DD35 .... _.... ..- X _. ............. .... 15.6 - 4/18 - 5/25 - DD36 X 3.7 DD37 X -- ----- ---- - 16.4 3/16 - 4/24 DD38 X ----- 12.7 - .-- 3/16 - 4/15 - DD39 X 12.3 DD40 X 14.3 4/26 - 5/30; 9/1 - 10/3 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 8 r ?. Y R '? 4 e ? In "' rf ? w -A N d Q n U r / / c K ? R r x r! f/.3x r .000 A O N r a° = c k' N °a vxx Za 0 $? g i = LL E- °°ei g ) c d 13 ?'I' a Y F: a rn o N Omai= I" .._ z a Y g n la. w z = r t'y7'? ?, J n ? IIQ ktt to x. ? 2.3.2 Climatic Data Figure 4 represents an evaluation of the local climate in comparison with historical data in order to determine whether 2006 was "average" in terms of climate conditions. The two lines represent the 30th and 70th percentiles of monthly precipitation for Elizabethtown, NC. The bars are monthly rainfall totals for 2006. The historical data was collected from the State Climate Office of North Carolina. The site experienced above average rainfall during April, May, and June of 2006. Average rainfall was observed during the months of January, February, July, August, September, and October. Below average rainfall was observed for March. Overall, 2006 experienced an average to above average rainfall year. 2.4 Conclusions Hydrological monitoring for year 2006 found 79% of the all gauges met jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season; conversely, 21 % did not meet jurisdictional hydrologic success. Overall mean hydrological monitoring results from the past six years show that a majority of all site monitoring gauges met the jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season (Figure 5). Monitoring gauges, and indirectly the areas in which the gauges were installed, were characterized using the Army Corps of Engineers (ACOE) zonal criteria (Table 2): Table 2. Hydrologic zones in nontidal areas. Zone Name Duration' Comments 12 Permanently inundated 100 percent Inundation >6.6 ft. mean water depth _..-.-.. -- ._.. II Semipermanently to nearly >75 - <100 percent Inundation defined as <6.6 ft. mean - _ permanently inundated or saturated _ water depth - III Regularly inundated or saturated >25 - 75 percent .... ....... ............ ..._............ ... -............_....-................._...... . IV Seasonally inundated or saturated >12.5 - 25 percent -- V Irregularly inundated or saturated .... ..... .......... ............. >5 - 12.5 percent - .?- Many areas having these hydrologic characteristics are not wetlands VI Intermittently or never inundated or < 5 percent Areas with these hydrologic saturated characteristics are not wetlands ' Refers to duration of inundation and/or soil saturation during the growing season. 2 This defines an aquatic habitat zone. Of the 38 monitoring gauges on site, 81.6% of all monitoring gauges (31) met the jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season, of which more than half recorded periods of inundation between 25% and 50% of the growing season. Areas where three of the monitoring gauges (DD3, DD34, and DD39) recorded periods of inundation between 5% -12.5% of the growing season could be considered wetlands because of the observed presence of hydrophytic vegetation. Based on analysis of past data, the remaining four monitoring gauges Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 10 m CD v ` m D ? co ` I 0 > Z co 0 ++ V O co 0 M d co O Q ? i c? 0 3 ? r+ o ? 0 C 7 r O O R O O L CL Q t C. L cm 4) C m L d Q. O ti O M d' d L O O O m 00 I` d \-? o m yr y.r i C O ?p d ? 0) IL LL S i / to O C R O O O O O O O W w IV M N T- O (•ui) uoi4e4idi3aad 0) c m L a s w 0 ti I a? w C Q) V L 0) a t w 0 M I C O O O N Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 11 6Z00 9200 8Z00 L 600 900 5600 6Za4 8 600 £Z00 OZ00 6£44 Z 604 17Z00 CJ7.00 9MG 644 N LZ00 7 6640 600 0£00 •` 000 w C Z£QO O 800 500 17600 8£00 01700 ZZ00 L00 CJ£00 L£00 17£00 6£00 £00 Z00 1700 £600 9£00 ? o 0 d LO L Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 12 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 LO C) V) o LO C) LO C) LO o ?t a M M N N (??o) uoi;epunul uoseeS BuimoaE) (DD2, DD4, DD13, and DD36) appear to have been installed in isolated areas of upland topography. 3.0 VEGETATION: DOWD DAIRY MITIGATION SITE (YEAR 6 MONITORING) 3.1 Success Criteria Success criteria state that there must be a minimum of 320 trees per acre for at least three consecutive years. A minimum of five character tree species must be present, with no more than 20% of any one species present, with the exception of Atlantic White Cedar, which may comprise up to 75% of the swamp forest restoration. Loblolly Pine cannot comprise more than 10% of the 320 trees per acre requirement. 3.2 Description of Species The following tree species were planted in the Wetland Planting Areas: Zone 1: Non-Riverine Wet Hardwood Forest (320.25 acres) Fraxinus pennsylvanica, Green Ash Nyssa aquatica, Water Tupelo Quercus falcata var. pagodaefolia, Cherrybark Oak Quercus laurifolia, Laurel Oak Quercus lyrata, Overcup Oak Quercus michauxii, Swamp Chestnut Oak Quercus nigra, Water Oak Quercus phellos, Willow Oak Zone 2: Pine/Oak/Hickory (17.68 acres) Juglans nigra, Black Walnut Nyssa sylvatica var. sylvatica, Blackgum Pinus palustris, Longleaf Pine Liriodendron tulipifera, Tulip Poplar Quercus alba, White Oak Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 13 Quercus falcata var. falcata, Southern Red Oak Quercus lyrata, Overcup Oak Quercus nigra, Water Oak Quercus phellos, Willow Oak Zone 3: Non-Riverine Swamp Forest (201.2 acres) Chamaecyparis thyoides, Atlantic White. Cedar Fraxinus pennsylvanica, Green Ash Taxodium distichum, Bald cypress Nyssa aquatica, Water Tupelo Quercus falcata var. pagodaefolia, Cherrybark Oak Quercus laurifolia, Laurel Oak Quercus lyrata, Overcup Oak Quercus nigra, Water Oak Quercus phellos, Willow Oak Zone 4: Headwater (Slope) Swamp (12.05 acres) Liriodendron tulipifera, Tulip Poplar Quercus falcata var. pagodaefolia, Cherrybark Oak Quercus laurifolia, Laurel Oak Quercus lyrata, Overcup Oak Quercus michauxii, Swamp Chestnut Oak Quercus nigra, Water Oak Quercus phellos, Willow Oak Taxodium distichum, Bald cypress Zone 5: Atlantic White Cedar Slope (67.76 acres) Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 14 Chamaecyparis thyoides, Atlantic White Cedar Fraxinus pennsylvanica, Green Ash Nyssa aquatica, Water Tupelo Liriodendron tulipifera, Tulip Poplar Pinus serotina, Pond Pine Quercus falcata var. pagodaefolia, Cherrybark Oak Quercus laurifolia, Laurel Oak Quercus lyrata, Overcup Oak Quercus michauxii, Swamp Chestnut Oak Quercus phellos, Willow Oak Taxodium Distichum, Bald cypress 3.3 Results of Vegetation Monitoring Thirty-eight plots measuring 0.05-acres in size were established in year 2000 to represent a 0.3% sample of the planting area (Figure 5). Overall plot and zone densities, tree counts for individual plots and zones, and species counts are all presented in Table 2. Overall average tree density for all Zones was 448 trees per acre. Plots with densities below the minimum requirement of 320 trees per acre were observed in all but one of the zones (Zone 4), ranging from 160 trees/acre (Zone 1) to 300 trees/acre (Zone 5). Nearly half of the plots with densities below the minimum requirement were observed in Zone 3. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 15 3.4 Site Notes of Observed Herbaceous Cover and Volunteer Woody Stems Zone 1: Herbaceous cover ranged between 60 and 100% and consisted of the following observed species: blackberry (Rubus), goldenrod (Solidago), sedges (Carex), broad-leaved cattails (Typha latifolia), trumpet creeper (Campsis radicans), smartweed (Polygonum), fennel grass (Foeniculum), rush (Juncus), marsh fleabane (Pluchea), cane (Arundinaria gigantea), aster (Aster), and bluestem (Andropogon virginicus). Volunteer woody species observed included: black willow (Salix nigra), red maple (Acer rubrum), loblolly pine (Pinus taeda), sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua), staghorn sumac (Rhus typhina), winged sumac (R. copallina), and groundsel bush (Baccharis halimifolia). Zone 2: Herbaceous cover averaged 90% and consisted of the following observed species: broomsedge, bluestem, goldenrod, and blackberry. Volunteer woody species observed included tulip poplar (Liriodendron tulipifera). Zone 3: Herbaceous cover ranged between 25 and 100% and consisted of the following observed species: blackberry, goldenrod, sedges, inkberry (Ilex glabra), cattails, rush, aster, southern bayberry (Myrica heterophylla), cane, marsh fleabane, bluestem, peashrub (Caragana), broomsedge bluestem, and woolgrass (Scirpus cyperinus). Volunteer woody species observed included: black willow, red maple, baccharis, groundsel bush sweetgum, staghorn sumac, and water tupelo (Nyssa aquatica). Zone 4: Herbaceous cover averaged 90% and consisted of the following observed species: trumpet creeper, blackberry, goldenrod, and rush. Volunteer woody species observed included red maple, sweetgum and loblolly pine. Zone 5: Herbaceous cover ranged between 90 and 100% and consisted of the following observed species: blackberry, goldenrod, trumpet creeper, cattail, rush, woolgrass, sedges, marsh fleabane, and smartweed. Volunteer woody species consisted of black willow, staghorn sumac, red maple, and loblolly pine. 3.5 Conclusions Of the 658 acres on this site, approximately 619 acres involved tree planting. Thirty- eight test plots were established throughout the planting areas, covering all plant communities. Vegetation monitoring of the planted areas for monitoring year 6 revealed an average density of 448 trees per acre, which is above the minimum requirement of 320 trees per acre. It should be noted that since this was a phased project, the majority of the plots contain 6-year old trees. The site was wet at the time of monitoring. Field observations noted that natural recruitment of pioneer species such as red maple, sweetgum, and loblolly pine has occurred around the periphery of the site Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 19 that border existing forest and in the cut-over area. Stem densities of these species varied, but in at least three locations, sweetgum and loblolly pine formed dense, pole-stage stands. These areas are not particularly extensive within the site. Natural succession patterns will, in time, result in a more diverse stand of tree species in these areas. No additional management activities are recommended in these areas. Overall mean annual site density for each of the six monitoring activities was greater than the minimum 320 trees per acre, averaging 503 trees per acre (Figure 7). Site density appeared to peak in monitoring year 2 (2002) and then decrease every year as expected. Total percent change in tree density from monitoring year 2 to monitoring year 6 was 11.9 percent, with annual decreases ranging from 0.6 to 5.0 percent. For all six monitoring activities (Appendix D), the number of character tree species in each of the five Zones was greater than the minimum requirement of five species, ranging from seven to 13 species. Changes in the number of character tree species did not vary significantly since planting activities were completed. Pond pine (Zones 3 and 5) and black gum (Zone 5) were the only two species not originally identified as `planted'. Three species significantly exceeded the established 20% composition limit in their respective planted areas: swamp chestnut oak, overcup oak, southern red oak, and bald cypress (Figure 8). Species misidentification, site adaptability, and overplanting could explain the discrepancies in site composition. Species identification relies heavily on leaf morphology. The presence or absence of leaves could affect species identification dependent on when annual monitoring activities were completed. In addition, leaves of tree species within certain families may appear similar to leaves of other family members, such as oak. Southern red oak and overcup oak percent composition values appeared to increase as other oak species values decreased, even when the total number of surviving trees remained relatively constant. This could suggest that certain oaks were misidentified as southern red or overcup, artificially elevating their respective percent composition values. Percent composition of bald cypress in zones 3, 4, and 5 appeared to increase after monitoring year 3 (2003), during which the site experienced the longest recorded period of inundation. Past recorded data indicates that initial percent composition values for bald cypress were high, which could imply overplanting. Coupled with the ability to tolerate extended periods of inundation, expected decreases in bald cypress populations were not as evident when compared to other planted species. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 20 O 0 O N In O O N 'IT O O N N L N 0) C L O yr O M O O N ti d L a? LL i i Ii II O O co N O O N O O N O N 'a cc a C f0 +1 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 21 O O O O O O O O f? co LO It CO N (aaoe/sem) Amsuea U L C U LO Y Q L N I N U I 1. 'O i m n a 0 c 3 m L a 0 L d Q. L C 0 E a? x •L 0 ?F+ .N 0 CL E 0 0 U) d Q 0 .0 C Sd wW W L a? E m m a n v c c I ° n I v d ` Y O O f0 a O N t0 c m Ili I I L Y O L I o n w 3 Y Y ° I Y l0 O 3 0 3 i ? ° I O O O O O O O O Ln O Ln O Lr; O M M N N (??o) uoi4!sodwo3 e4jS ueeW Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) n5 0 CO E .. Y N ° _r 1 LO C) Page 22 N AD .0 d CL d M n CV U J 4.0 OVERALL CONCLUSIONS/ RE OMMENDATIONS Hydrological monitoring for yea fou d 68% f the all gauges met jurisdi n hydrologic success of at least C2.59%lo duri th growing season; converse) 31 did not meet jurisdictional hydr succes s. Areas where three of the monit g gauges (DD3, DD34, and DD3orded periods of inundation between 5% and 12.5% of the growing season could be considered wetlands because of the observed presence of hydrophytic vegetation. Replacing three of the latter monitoring gauges (DD7, 20, and 25) during late June monitoring activities resulted in incomplete data and preventing an overall accurate description of the hydrological tb conditions of portions the site. Overall mean hydrological monitoring results from the past six years show that 81.6% of all site monitoring gauges met the jurisdictional hydrologic success of at least 12.5% during the growing season, of which more than half recorded periods of inundation between 25% and 50% of the growing season. An additional three gauges indicated soil saturation between 5% and 12.5% of the growing season. Consistent with field observations of hydrophytic vegetation, these areas could also be considered wetlands. Only four gauges consistently had soil saturation for less than 5% of the growing season. The 2006 vegetation monitoring of the 619 acres of planted areas revealed an average density of 448 trees per acre, which is above the minimum requirement of 320 trees per acre. It should be noted that since this was a phased project, the majority of the plots contain 6-year old trees. Field observations noted that natural recruitment of pioneer species such as red maple, sweetgum, and loblolly pine has occurred around the periphery of the site that border existing forest and in the cut-over area. Stem densities of these species varied, but in at least three locations, sweetgum and loblolly pine formed dense, pole-stage stands. However, as the areas where these species were noted are not extensive in size, it is probable that natural succession patterns will, in time, resulting in a more diverse stand of the species in these areas. No additional management activities are recommended in these areas. Overall mean annual site density for each of the six year monitoring period was greater than the minimum 320 trees per acre, averaging 503 trees per acre. The number of character tree species in each of the five Zones was greater than the minimum requirement of five species, ranging from seven to 13 species. Only three of the 13 species exceeded the established 20% composition limit in their respective planted areas. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 23 Appendix A (Click here) APPENDIX A GAUGE DATA GRAPHS Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 24 SZ and (9002) 916 9 .rndA 111..lopljoK i 0 c 0 Q d m c CD a v CD 0 72. v o' 0 A O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 CCD O 18-Jun-06 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-00 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O CO O o cQ 5 (n (0 CD o M C o_ I- 0 v w G) ? c o' Cn CD v 0 V7 CD 2) Z M o o? o Q- o 00 c? v? m * rn 0 N ? 0 (n n cD cn m CD =) W Q `n o o 0 7 Cn 0 7' ca O N N W W ? Cn O cn O Ul O Cr O O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) Depth to Groundwater (in.) C n W N N O CIl O Cl7 O (P O Ul gi a nd i 0 c a m CD CD i z co m Q v CD N 0 S r.. o' CIl O (P O O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v v 4-Jun-06 O 0 18-Jun-06 9 y 2-Jul-06 Cn 16-Jul-06 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 E 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 .... 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O CD O O (900,7) 9 ) 9 _rna t Depth to Groundwater (in.) W N N O CJ1 O (P O CP O CJi O O O O O O O O O O 71 N N O Cn O CJi O O O O Precipitation (in.) W W O Cr O O o CD cn N 0 CD 0 CD c 0 0 v M0 m ? v a? v ?N Z O o ? o Q- o ? 0 o co ci? v? -4 0' 4 7 Cn .p _ cn M CD 0 N C1 cn o o Z 0 A O O L Z a<5nd (900Z) 9.1b 9 .roa,{ 111 MITI IV i 0 C m C co co m a v A S v m R m o' N CJi O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 d 4-Jun-06 00 18-Jun-06 3 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 CCD 3 30-Jul-06 O 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O N N M O Cn O U1 O O O O O Precipitation (in.) P O v o G) Q m ?. Cy va w? m M. m iv - a? Z O O Q. N 3 a o? co cn CD CD Cl 0 0 w w ? O CJT O O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N ? O Cn O U7 O O O O O O ,'C' e,','11,1 (900c") 9.1n 9 .rv,)A I?ui.ropuopv Depth to Groundwater (in.) i 0 c 0 O. v 0 0 c. a v 0 0 M S o' A Ui O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 y 2-Jul-06 S 16-Jul-06 m 30-Jul-06 rt 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O .A W W N N ? O (Jl O U1 O U7 O (Jl O O O O O O O O O O O N N cn O CT O Cn O O O O O Precipitation (in.) P w Pl O Cn O O O O v O c ? c? . c? v va C c? ?. O iv Z O O Q- N -? 00 W o. N ? Cn m a.Ynd 6E (900Z) 9.1o 9 Iv,),( ;Yuj.rolruoPv i I 0 c CL v m e I X c CL v m a S 0 m -o' ;v 0 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 o CD 12-Feb-06 ?. D. 26-Feb-06 0 o 12-Mar-06 0 26-Mar-06 ?- - 9-Apr-06 rn 23-Apr-06 v l< CS 7-May-06 0 21-May-06 ? 4I A 4-Jun-06 j 0 0 18-Jun-06 3 CD 2-Jul-06 to 16-Jul-06 CD M3 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 (n m M D 8-Oct-06 W n. 0 0- 22-Oct-06 D 0 5-Nov-06 5' 19-Nov-06 ---------------------------------------- 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 ?- - O O N N W W J? O Gl O <n O cn O cn O O O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) v O CL c ? to _ CD ?. v-n 00 tr -I m Z 3 O 0- w ?. -n V ,O.r V O n O Depth to Groundwater (in.) W W N N ? Ul O Ul O Ul O Ul O C77 O O O O O O O O O 0£ a<v,/ I G7 0 c O. v N C CD CCD O. v 3 v N 0 M 0 O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 d 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 m 2-Jul-06 CA E 16-Jul-06 tD 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-OO 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O N N Cn O CJ7 O (P O O O O O Precipitation (in.) (9000 9.16 9 .It,-)A 3u.1.161ruopv O O O O 0- M cn 0 I? - 7- 0 Q 0 v 0 ^ Q V' 0 Cl) y v . c m ? ' v-n rn mm M. m m -? Z O O o. H ? m 00 rn Cn a m m < 0 U) v c Omm v 0 0 c ? 0 0 m a 0 o 0 o (C) w ? CJ7 O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) W W N N i U1 O (P O CI1 O CJ1 O (T O O O O O O O O O 1F X?ncl i O C O. m CD M CD CD Q v W M 0 S o' W CI1 O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 0 18-Jun-06 3 CD 2-Jul-06 (n E S, 16-Jul-06 CD E: C3 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 0 O O O N N (J7 O Cn O Cn O O O O O Precipitation (in.) (9000 91b 9 .?na { ??tq.lol/un/N O O o ca O ?. N (Q CD o U 0 v C) ? C Q C v v? 4 -n N ? m 3 Z o ? 03 CD Q- o 0 0 m cQ v rt ?O O O V O -1 U) 00 _ (n M (D z) CU 0- 0 O 0 ? 0 W W A O CP O O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) W N N ? ? ? O Ul O (J1 O U7 O (J1 O O O O O O O O Z£ a<4r?d (9002) 9.10 9 .10,)A M.1.1011uo/N i 0 0. f d C CD m c c. v m v N R v o' N C7i O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 fu I 4-Jun-06 0 18-Jun-06 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 m m 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 T 31-Dec-06 O O O O N N CJt O Cn O fJ? O O O O O Precipitation (in.) U9 O I w w ? O CT O O O O v O c ? c? v v? CO -+ m co d' zo O Q (n im cn CD W nA. N O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N i O Ul O CJl O O O O O O cc a<Yod (9002) 9./o y .rna,( Yuuojruoyp Depth to Groundwater (in.) O U1 O CT O U1 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 I 29-Jan-06 CO C M o G) 12-Feb-06 o 26-Feb-06 C° cQ CD 0 a ? 0 o' 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -------------------- ---- -- 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 O 7 M 06 M Q - ay- . 21-May-06 L a). ? 4-Jun-06 O -* 18-Jun-06 cD ? CD v 3 N 2-Jul-06 v E 0 ? ?. CD S 16-Jul-06 o Z tD O O. 3 CD 30-Jul-06 (q .? cn w 13-Aug-06 a) n ,f 27-Aug-06 n = 10-Sep-06 Cn CD 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 V) m CD a 0 7 0 ° m 22-Oct-06 C 0 72 5-Nov-06 ° 19-Nov-06 --- ---------------------------------- --- --- 3-Dec-06 , 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O N N W W A O O M O Ui O m O O O O O O O CT O O O Precipitation (in.) (yo(u) 9.1b 9 .loaf Yuuo1ruoj1v Depth to Groundwater (in.) i I 0 c C. 0 I X CD c N Q. v 0 M 0 R as 0 w O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 C 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 0 18-Jun-06 CD 2-Jul-06 N C" 16-Jul-06 CD m 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O N N ? i C.J1 O (Jl O U7 O CJi O O O O O O O O N N CT O U? O Ch O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O O O Cr o ? 7 73 cn Z; . (n (a CD o E o v O ? v C; v2) o" co ? Z O O W ? a co 0 CO = N m N CD (D v a 0 O o 0 -I- cc P w -P, O U1 O O O O SF ),Md (9002) 9.10 9 .m,),t .Yt1i..1oJtuolN i 0 c c. CD m c m a v CD 13 S 0 N R rt 01 0 w O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 Q ? 4-Jun-06 O -? 18-Jun-06 3 CD 2-Jul-06 Cn 16-Jul-06 CD m 30-Jul-06 Q 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 - O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N N ? (J1 O Ul O CJ1 O CJ1 O O O O O O O O N N Cr O (P O Cn O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O O o CD ? Z3. Cn CD o v 0 cnl v O CL ? v cc ?, v? v „ ? Q N ? ?. CD a? = _2) Z 7 O Q. (n 3 4?h ': n ?. v? n= C) O m:; C/) M cn W CD z; CU a U o o D 0 w w ? O Cn O O O O 9F d ?nd (9000 9.10 9 aVdA 1'1lLl01!/UO V i 0 c CL m 0 X CD N C v CD a 3 N -a 0 o' Ui O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 CD 4-Jun-06 0 ? 18-Jun-06 3 m 2-Jul-06 = 16-Jul-06 m C3 30-Jul-06 r« 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 31-Dec-06 (C O O o (Q Cn cc CD o a) 0 24-Sep-06 cn CD CD z) 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 0 C° 0 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 - - - - 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 v O 0 a c v LO m m ?. v n vW W C z? o Q' 3 V C71 ? O -P6 :3 Cn m O O N N W W 01 O Cn O Cn O Ul O CP O O O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) Depth to Groundwater (in.) P W W N N ? O U1 O U1 O C11 O Ul O O O O O O O O L f a.Yvd I G7 1 0 C 7 Q m C CD C CD s c m CL v N a S 0 -o ? o' 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 CD 2-Jul-06 N Sl 16-Jul-06 CD ? 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O 19000 9.16 9 .Ina, M..10j11l6W Depth to Groundwater (in.) N O 00 ? A N O N ? O O O O O O O O O O N N M O Ul O Cn O O O O O Precipitation (in.) 0 Q v U) I 0 v C E3 0 v O CL ? v m ?. v? Cp CD 2) Z 3 O Cl) CA) V VI 'Y cD O N CCD cn (D M z) N O. U o o 7 cc 0 - CO w w 41 O 01 O O O O RE )If"d (9002) 9.16 9 .rv6A ?111.161iuuyv i 0 c 0 Q v X CD c O. v CD CCD S 0 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 m 3 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 - O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N O PO 6) N O N A O O O O O O O O O O N N W vl O Ul O U1 O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) 0 W v ° 0 v ? Q o p1 = v v to a? v vl< sv ? cn I CCD CD - iv O Q. w 3 (Q c D = `° n Cl) M M I --- ,? CD 0 m W D 0 o Z) CO W ? Cn O O O 6 f ),?nd i 0 c 7 CL d m e CD c M L2 v 0 3 -D N -o ? 0 w CT w O O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 3 y 2-Jul-06 N 16-Jul-06 0 30-Jul-06 'Y 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O Cn O (9000 9 ) 9 •ina,( 'ur.1oj.luoK O O D C7 3 ,R 7 5* n co D 0 D ? n D 7 n CO U N Q N 5o v 0 Q. c v G1 to 0 ?. v n vW ch CD Zo O O. 4 CD O m O cn 0 » (D 'D 7 D C)- n ? 7 CQ 0 N N W W ? O cn O Ln O Ln O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) Depth to Groundwater (in.) N N CJt O Cn O CJi O CJ1 O O O O O O O Ob and i 0 c O. f m fD X c CD a v CD S m 0 -6. v 0 A 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v m 4-Jun-06 o18-Jun-06 3 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 m 30-Jul-06 O 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O (9o0Z) 9 i0 9 -10.)A <Y111.1ol.uow Depth to Groundwater (in.) N O m O- A N O N A P O N N CJi O cn O U1 O O O O O Precipitation (in.) W O O v O Q c v to v vT M V ? .. 3 0 CD o Q. w ^? G cQ a? (DD v 0' m? E U) m D ,1--- U) O 0 m Vii ?. a 0 o w ? M O O O lb-tw (9(IOZ) 9.16 9 -'o,)A ?lu.I.i6liu66'V i 0 c Q m CD I M CD c m C. v m m 0 v' v o' N O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 3 0) 2-Jul-06 N S v CD 3 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) (.J1 O U'1 O CT O O O O O O N N Cn O Ui O U1 O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O O cc 07 o CD CD 0 0 0 N v cn 0 Cn v v o' v ? O. c? v CD ?. v? 00 n CD is A.. Z °' = O Q (1) M M m n C o C) 7 cc 0 w w ? O U1 O O O O Cf) 9 Ln - n v 0 Fl o 00 Ln CCD ,7 .P a, i 0 C Q. 0 e I m c m O. v m m 'a d o' 3 W O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 0 18-Jun-06 m 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 m 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O (9002) g1n9.resat 2ut101.1110N Depth to Groundwater (in.) CP O U1 O U'i O U1 O O O O O O O O N N Cn O Ul O (n O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O O o ? cn ?. cn cc CD o m o v O G Q. ? v co 0 m ?. v v-n m 3 cCn z? o Q- w c o. CO 3 Cn m cn CD M 7 n) Q cn o o Z 0 w w ? O U1 O O O O EP a,1nd (9002) 9.10 9 -rna t ??111.mj.uopv I 0 c 0 Q v C 0 .C c m C- v m m 0 S m o' m O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v a? 4-Jun-06 O 0 18-Jun-06 3 CD 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 CD CD 30-Jul-06 O 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O Ui O O N N O cn O Ul O O O O Precipitation (in.) W O O 0 O cc o cQ W (C) co 0 U o v O 0 Q. c v co 2) O ?. v-n N o3 N M Z O O Q. w O a . v rr v ro -n o 7 Cn 19 cD 0 m W En ?. a o :3 0 D cc --„ S" P, cn O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) o cn o cn 0 0 0 0 tt d<Ynd (9002) 9.M 9 -?",)A "Yu.1aO1iuo6N i 0 C 3 Q d I CD c CD Q 0 N 3 v m 0 R a? o' 0 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v CD 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 9 y 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 CD 30-Jul-06 rt 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 w 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O 6 O N N O Ul O CP O O O O Precipitation (in.) W O O 0 O (a o cQ W (C) M o N U O U c CZ v v 0 m 0 =3 o (n rn v CD C C1 E3 0 ? o o M U 0- 0 7 0 ? aa 0 W ;N. Cn O O O v O G c v CD ?. v n N_ .z N C CD. m 2 Z O O ? N OD D cc O CO N m Depth to Groundwater (in.) o to o cn 0 0 0 0 sp d,*),j WOE) 9.i0 9 .Ina t 8ul.101ru%y i 0 c Q N I M m C N v m -o m -a' a, o' W CJ1 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v 4-Jun-06 O18-Jun-06 3 m 2-Jul-06 CA 16-Jul-06 O CD 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O 1 O N N Cn O cn O cn O O O O O Precipitation (in.) W O O O CC o ca M o CU - ol D W 6> C2 v 0 v O G? Q a? ? v CD v? vm N 01 N 0 C fD iv Z O O O. W vo m 3 ?cn CD CD o CD v * D V) sz o :3 O O W 41 Cn O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) W N N ? i O Cn O Cn O Cn O Cn 96 a>n?/ (9000 9.1) 9 .Inat <Yu..ro/!unyy i 0 O. m N M c m Q. v m 0 n R r: v 0 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 o <D 12-Feb-06 w 26-Feb-06 ° 12-Mar-06 ° 26-Mar-06 j 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 „ N ll ? v 21-May-06 Y 4-Jun-06 3 0 9, 18-Jun-06 3 y 2-Jul-06 N S; 16-Jul-06 O 3 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 (n CD 24-Sep-06 r z 8-Oct-06 n 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 ---------------------------------------- 3-Dec-06 m o CD 17-Dec-06 cn *. Q ° o 31-Dec-06 O O N N W W ? O Cn O U7 O Ln O CTl O O O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) v O m ? c v ca a? CD ?. v-n N ? w 3 N m 2) Z O co 3 v M U2 w o m= cn m Depth to Groundwater (in.) cn ? w N -? O O O O O O o L 6 aYnd (900,7) g fo 9 ?Tur.101icuo/N i 0 c Q CD CD Cl) Q v 0 S CD -a' rt 01 0 3 (P A O O O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 0 18-Jun-06 3 CD 2-Jul-06 Cl) = 16-Jul-06 CD C3 30-Jul-06 7 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O CT O O O O w n y y ' v O 0 Q. ? v U2 a? vT N ? ?3 M Z 0 Q n cn 0 N n O N ? N CD W ?a o ? M s 19 0 ? N N W W A O 61 O CT O CJ1 O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) Depth to Groundwater (in.) W N O O O O O O O O .4u?.u??iuoy? 8f aYr'd (900,7) 9.10 9 -111d A Depth to Groundwater (in.) A N O O O A N O N A 07 O O O O O O O O O O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 I 29-Jan-06 CD 12-Feb-06 o C U) (C] 26-Feb-06 0 Q f 12-Mar-06 m ------------------------------ ---------- 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 v 23-Apr-06 0 7-May-06 Q' c v 21-May-06 m' v 4-Jun-06 v CD a) N a) CL 3 18-Jun-06 m CD v m 2-Jul-06 ?. ce N o fli 16-Jul-06 a Z Q CD o ' 30-Jul-06 in w .? 13-Aug-06 v m a) c a) 27-Aug-06 o M = 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 R 5-Nov-06 o' 19-Nov-06 -------------------------------------------- 3-Dec-06 ? m 0 m 17-Dec-06 • (n ?. a o o 0 31-Dec-06 O O N N W W A O U1 O CI1 O Ln O U1 O O O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) 6t' a ny/ (9000") Ob 9 -It-A .Yur.101ruo/N i 0 C C CD e e I CD co a 0 CD S 0 m o' 3 N O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 °) 4-Jun-06 i9 Oe 18-Jun-06 3 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 fD CD 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O Ul O O O -? N N W Ul O Un O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O D :1 = D ?. n cn D O nl N p Q v O_ v v 0 Q v 0 v v 0 Z) v 0 aG)i Q. ? v v? va) rn ?. 3 m ?. m - a? Z fl. O co v =? m 0 4 W Ln = Do W 0 N m o m v O 7 O D O W P, cn O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) i U1 O Ut O Ul OS vd (900,7) 9./n 9 anal 2uiaejijjo/N i O C O. M m c CD a CD v m 0 R rt fl7 O 7 W O N Cn O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 Oo 18-Jun-06 3 y 2-Jul-06 N 16-Jul-06 i? 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O Cn O N N W O Cr O Ul O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O O Q o fl ?. Cn CQ m o c o Q0 sz v O o :E m Q v to v CD C) c) v -n N ? ti N - Sv CL Z Q O o cn v n to v? v D o N rn m Cp Q v ch 0 0 v c v o' m (D a cD C ( ?. Q /) 0 = o W cn O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N O CJ1 O Ul O CJi O O O O O O I S a<5v,/ (9002) 9./0 9 ava,t NU.IJoJ/uoj1v I L7 0 0 a m m m a. v (D 3 CCD 0 -a 2) o' 3 o 0 0 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 0 18-Jun-06 3 (D 2-Jul-06 N cC 16-Jul-06 CD 30-Jul-06 'Y 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O cn O N N O CJl O M O O O O Precipitation (in.) W O O 0 0 O 0 ca 9. 5 Cn CD 0 N c 0 1- ri -T-- m(9 cD 0 m v 7 U) 8- 0 0 :3 O P ? Cn O O O v 0 Q- c v 0 ?. vT N ? ao 3 cn m m iv Z 0 Ln 00 W 0 CD Depth to Groundwater (in.) cn o cn o cn 0 0 0 0 0 ZS dYn,l (9002) 9.10 9 a,a,t ??11i.101iun/v i 0 a CD I CD m Q. v CD m S CCD R m o' 0 N O U7 O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O ? 18-Jun-06 3 M 2-Jul-06 Cn 16-Jul-06 fD 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O Cn O O O O O O o CD CD 0 C o ?- a o_ v c v oO 00 n. v 0 v ;v 0 ------------------------- c? m 0 cn Cn ?. a 0 0 Z3 (0 0 N N W W ? (Ji O cn O Cn O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) v O Q. ? v L4 m ?. v v-n N O 3 in - sv Z O O Q. c cn ^? v, La n-4 2 00 m= ?cn Depth to Groundwater (in.) O U7 O Ul O O O O f-S d.4nd (9002) 9.10 9 ava,{ .Yu1.101iuow i 0 C 7 Q m N C CD m O. v m v m n -a r.: ? o' W N O Ul O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 3 y 2-Jul-06 N S 16-Jul-06 O 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O cn O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N O U1 O CJ1 O U1 O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) W Cn O v O aC)i ? ? v v? v- o ? ?. m z O O Q N cn W O Cn N N W A O CT O Ut O O O O O O O O PS d ftl l 0 C Q. m CD c m O. v 0 a 3 v N 0 S r: 0 7 W O N Vl O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v 4-Jun-06 0 0 18-Jun-06 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O cn O (goo,Z) 9./b 9 -1m) A IYut.to!/t1opv N N W O U1 O Ln O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) O O o m (n (0 (D 0 N 0 cnl X) P O0 U Q - c v vT w C a ?. CD* z a o n to w P. o 00 m N Q C v CD m 0 v v 0 cD 0 m ?. Q 0 o 13 (0 W A Ul O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) O CJ1 O CT O CJ1 O O O O O O SS a?i?d I G7 0 c Q m C CD m c m Q 0 CD S v m 0 72 m o' z ? W O (n O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 v 4-Jun-06 00 18-Jun-06 3 2-Jul-06 = 16-Jul-06 m c(o 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O U, O O (900j) 9.i0 9 -lv,)A ?Yui.1o/iiroW Depth to Groundwater (in.) W N N i O Ul O CJl O Ui O CJi O O O O O O O O O O a N N O Ui O CP O O O O Precipitation (in.) cc 0 7 NCO CD 0 N - c 0 v 0 Q a) CD ?. v vn w0 N ? 3 U) ? CD Z0 o Q. to 3 ?La w p 0 n N cn W o CD U) m m o' 7 m aD CD o m ? ?. Q o 0 cc o w W .1 O U1 O O O O 9S 6*),j I 0 c 0 O. v CD I m c m O. 0 CD 0 N 0 -a m o' 0 O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 m 4-Jun-06 00 18-Jun-06 3 y 2-Jul-06 c 16-Jul-06 M3 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 $ 31-Dec-06 O O O (9002) 9.16 9 -1-A l u.1.uoj.lu6/N Depth to Groundwater (in.) W W N N i U1 O U1 O CJ1 O U't O U1 O O O O O O O O O O N N Cn O (J1 O m O O O O O Precipitation (in.) W W O CJi O O O O o- 0 0 m o v 00 v 0 0 CL c v to 2) 0 ?. v-n w in _ C z' o CL 00 00 _ n 0' 3 N N cn (D (D 7 O) Q cn o o 0 7' O O O L S a'Ity (9002) 9.1b 9 .1-A ?Yu.1..1ojiuoW i 0 7 Q a, CD M m c CD Q. v CD v 3 0 0 .a m 0 m 41 W W O Ul O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 CD 0+ 18-Jun-06 CD 2-Jul-06 C 16-Jul-06 fD 30-Jul-06 rt 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O Cn O O O O O o (6 0 to co 0 v 0 DO a_ y n D n v y Cn M CD :3 N C2 Cn 0 0 - 0 9 0 5N N W W A 71 CT O Ui O U1 O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) v O C) :E CL ? v CQ G1 C) vm w? coo ? - a? Z O O t0 v =? m to w ^? a, 0 W 3 CD Depth to Groundwater (in.) N N -I -I I Cr O C71 O (J1 O Ul 19000 9/n q.?na{ Yu?.?o?ruolV I 0 c 3 Q m X CD CD 0. v M S v N 0 R r.: o' CJl O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 0 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 0 18-Jun-06 2-Jul-06 16-Jul-06 CD m 30-Jul-06 0 'Y 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O O o m 0 :1 n (C =$ . Cn (a CD o N - c O v 0 Q- c v to 2) m =;- 0 l< C, v -n rn 3 N m Z O O Q. w ? cs? N a 0 = to 0 co 7 .? fn m (n CD (D :3 W Q- (n o o 0 cc O N N W W A Ln O Ul O Un O Up O O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) Depth to Groundwater (in.) A W W N N O C.T? O CJ1 O Ul O C.7i O U1 O O O O O O O O O O 6S -&t"I (900,7) 9./o y Depth to Groundwater (in.) i 0 c Q a? C CD m c m a v m s N -a' m 0 A O w w CIl O O O O 1-Jan-06 dog 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 O 2-Jul-06 S, 16-Jul-06 CD 3 M 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O CJI O O O CT O CIl O O O O O N N Cn O CJ1 O O O Precipitation (in.) v O 0 CL c v CD ?. v-n w ?3 C m.:? Z? O Q. rn °r 00 _ V O -j = Cn W (.J .4 O CT O O O O CJ1 O CT O O O 09 d. Vj (9000 g ) y .?na t ?Yut.u??iuo/N Depth to Groundwater (in.) i 0 c 3 Q G1 C CD I CD c m Q- v CD m 0 -o o' 7 W U'i W O O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 0 4-Jun-06 O 18-Jun-06 3 F - y 2-Jul-06 I 16-Jul-06 CD B 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O cn O N U1 O U1 O Ul O (Ji O O O O O O O v O CL c v to 2) m v ?. v-n w W .? 0 N m Z O O Q. C/) co rn ca _ -? O W ? fn m 0 N N W W -P O Gi O U1 O Ui O O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) 19-n,/ (900Z) 9./0 9 .ma,{ <Yfjj. ram/N I 0 c 0 Q m 0 I M CD c CCD a v CD S CCD 0 -a. o' 3 w O O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 v 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 0 18-Jun-06 2-Jul-06 Cn 16-Jul-06 C--I D CD 30-Jul-06 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O O N N 71 CIi O m O Ul O O O O O Precipitation (in.) P, O cc o m o N - cn 0 v 0 0 Q. c v 0 ?. v? v w c0 ? c zC 0 Q' 3 ? w0 cn (n M M z) W 0- cn o o 0 7' P w 01 O Ui O O O O Depth to Groundwater (in.) N N Cn O (J1 O CJ1 O O O O O O O Z9 a,?vw I 1 0 O. v CD C CD .0 m Q. v N v N 0 R ? 0 w CJl O 1-Jan-06 15-Jan-06 29-Jan-06 12-Feb-06 26-Feb-06 12-Mar-06 26-Mar-06 9-Apr-06 23-Apr-06 7-May-06 21-May-06 4-Jun-06 00 18-Jun-06 CD 2-Jul-06 N 0 16-Jul-06 CCD 30-Jul-06 0 rt 13-Aug-06 27-Aug-06 10-Sep-06 24-Sep-06 8-Oct-06 22-Oct-06 5-Nov-06 19-Nov-06 3-Dec-06 17-Dec-06 31-Dec-06 O O O (900Z) 9.10 9 -loaf <*q.1oj.uoyy Depth to Groundwater (in.) W N N -? ? O CTl O Ul O Cn O C71 O O O O O O O O O N N W Cn O cn O Cn O O O O O O O Precipitation (in.) CT m 0 v 0 C) Q. C v co ? m ?. vl< v-n o ? N CD - iv Z 0 o Q. CA) w D 0 N W o CD m v c v 0 m 0 m ? ?. Q 0 W -rl UI O O O Appendix B (Click here) APPENDIX B SITE PHOTOS PHOTO AND VEGETATION PLOT LOCATION Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 63 DOWD DAIRY E f' Yt / s: fy' Spa it _ r "i A- Y d-:' Monitoring Year 6 ol'6 (2006) Page 64 Photo Location 1-2 (a). Photo Location 1-2 (b). Photo Location 3. Photo Location 5. Photo Location 6. DOWD DAIRY Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 65 Photo Location 8. Photo Location 12. Photo Locations 13. Photo Location 14. DOWD DAIRY Monitoring Year 6 0l'6 (2006) Page 66 Vegetation Plot 1. Vegetation Plot 3. Vegetation Plot 2. Vegetation Plot 4. Vegetation Plot 5. DOWD DAIRY Monitoring Year 6 ol'6 (2006) Page 67 Vegetation Plot 7. Vegetation Plot 6. Vegetation Plot 8. Vegetation Plot 9. Vegetation Plot 10. Vegetation Plot 11. DOWD DAIRY IL Monitoring Year 6 o '6 (2006) Pa,c 68 Vegetation Plot 13. Vegetation Plot 12. Vegetation Plot 14. Vegetation Plot 15. Vegetation Plot 17. Vegetation Plot 16. DOWD DAIRY Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 69 Vegetation Plot 18. Vegetation Plot 19. Vegetation Plot 21. Vegetation Plot 20. Vegetation Plot 22. Vegetation Plot 23. DOWD DAIRY Monitoring Year 6 0/'6 (2006) Page 70 Vegetation Plot 25. Vegetation Plot 24. Vegetation Plot 26. Vegetation Plot 27. Vegetation Plot 28. Vegetation Plot 29. DOWD DAIRY Monitoring Year 6 0l'6 (2006) Page 71 Vegetation Plot 30. Vegetation Plot 31. Vegetation Plot 33. Vegetation Plot 32. Vegetation Plot 35. Vegetation Plot 34. DOWD DAIRY ,?T7 Monitoring Year 6 ol'6 (2006) Page 72 Vegetation Plot 36. Vegetation Plot 37. Vegetation Plot 38. Appendix C (Click here) APPENDIX C ANNUAL HYDROLOGICAL MONITORING DATA SUMMARY (2001 - 2005) Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 73 Monitoring Year 1 (2001) Percentage of Growing Season at Saturation Monitoring (< 12" below surface) Dates Meeting Gauge < 5% 5-8% 8-12.5% > 12.5% Actual Success DD1 X 21.0 DD2 X 2.9 DD3 X 7.8 DD4 X 1.6 DD5 X 14.0 DD6 X 18.1 DD7 X 8.2 DD8 X 12.3 DD9 X 17.3 DD10 X 20.2 DD12 X 18.1 DD13 X 1.2 DD14 X 17.3 DD15 X 19.3 DD16 X 17.3 DD17 X 17.7 DD18 X 19.8 DD19 X 15.6 DD20 X 19.8 DD21 X 19.3 DD22 X 11.1 DD23 X 20.2 DD24 X 17.3 DD25 X 19.8 DD26 X 18.9 DD27 X 18.9 DD28 X 19.3 DD29 X 21.0 DD30 X 18.5 DD31 X 17.3 DD32 X 13.6 DD34 X 13.2 DD35 X 14.0 DD36 X 0.0 DD37 X 10.7 DD38 X 14.0 DD39 - DD40 - Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 74 Monitorina Year 2 (2002 Monitoring Percentage of Growing Season at Saturation " Dates Meeting (< 12 below surface) Gauge < 5% 5-8% 8-12.5% > 12.5% Actual Success DD1 X 16.0 March 16 - April 23 DD2 X 2.5 DD3 X 2.1 DD4 X 1.6 DD5 X 15.2 March 16 - April 21 DD6* X 25.0 March 16 - May 15 DD7* X 15.6 March 16 - April 22 DD8* X 16.1 March 16 - April 23 DD9* X 15.6 March 16 - April 22 DD10 X 18.5 March 16 - April 29 DD12 X 15.2 March 16 - April 21 DD13 X 0.4 DD14 X 14.8 March 16 - April 20 DD15 X 18.5 March 16 - April 29; August 26 - October 7; October 11 - November 14 DD16 X 18.5 March 16 - April 29 DD17* X 26.8 March 16 - May 19 DD18* X 19.8 March 16 - May 2 DD19 X 15.6 March 16 - April 22 DD20* X 25.5 March 16 - May 16 DD21* X 19.8 March 16 - May 2 DD22 X 13.6 March 16 - April 17 DD23* X 17.7 March 16 - April 27 DD24* X 16.1 March 16 - April 23 DD25* X 15.6 March 16 - April 22 DD26* X 25.5 March 16 - May 16 DD27* X 19.8 March 16 - May 2 DD28 X 16.9 March 16 - April 25 DD29 X 28.4 March 16 - May 23 DD30 X 25.5 March 16 - May 16 DD31 X 16.1 March 16 - April 23 DD32 X 16.5 March 16 - April 24 DD34 X 3.3 DD35* X 14.4 March 16 - April 19 DD36 X 0.0 DD37 X 11.9 March 16 -April 13 DD38* X 18.5 March 16 - April 29 DD39 - DD40 - * Gauge malfunctions at the beginning of the growing season. These gauges experienced data loss, but appeared to be inundated or saturated for more than 12 inches. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 75 Monitoring Year 3 (2003) Percentage of Growing Season at Saturation Monitoring (< 12" below surface) Dates Meeting Gauge < 5% 5 - 8% 8 - 12.5% > 12.5% Actual Success DD1+ X 43.0 March 17 - June 28 DD2 X 8.3 March 17 - April 5 DD3 X 7.4 March 17 - April 3 DD4 X 4.1 DD5+ X 38.4 March 17 - May 17; May 23 - August 23 DD6+ X 69.8 March 17 - September 1 DD7"+ X 14.5 March 17 - April 20 DD8 X 24.0 March 17 - May 13; May 18 - June 23 DD9+ X 42.6 April 25 - August 9; September 14 - November 12 DD10+ X 17.8 July 15 - August 26 DD12+ X 68.2 March 17 - August 28 DD13 X 2.5 DD14+ X 21.9 May 24 - June 26; July 21 - August 22 DD15+ X 65.7 March 17 - August 22; September 19 - November 13 DD16+ X 66.9 March 17 - August 25 DD17+ X 76.4 March 17 - September 17 DD18+ X 79.3 March 17 - September 24 DD19+ X 41.3 May 23 - August 30 D D20* - DD21+ X 61.5 April 29 - September 25 DD22+ X 20.5 March 17 - April 23; July 2 - August 20 DD23+ X 75.5 March 17 - September 14 DD24+ X 69.7 March 17 - September 1 DD25+ X 44.3 March 17 - June 4; June 7 - September 22 DD26+ X 91.0 March 17 -October 23 DD27+ X 32.0 March 18 - June 3 DD28+ X 100.0 March 17 - November 14 DD29+ X 100.0 March 17 - November 14 DD30+ X 43.0 March 17 - June 28; July 1 - September 1 DD31+ X 73.4 March 17 - September 10 DD32+ X 27.5 March 17 - May 21; July 1 - August 31 DD34 X 23.4 March 17 - May 11 DD35* - DD36" - DD37 X 15.6 March 17 - April 22 DD38 X 24.6 March 17 - May 14; July 3 - August 11 DD39 X 7.8 DD40 X 7.8 " Gauges have been replaced or misplaced without proper documentation. Gauge data may not be available + Gauges met the success criterion during an average rainfall month (May, August, and September). Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 76 Monitorina Year 4 (2004 Percentage of Growing Season at Saturation Monitoring (< 12" below surface) Dates Meeting Gauge < 5% 5 - 8% 8 - 12.5% > 12.5% Actual Success DD1+ X 42.6 March 16 - June 26 DD2 X 5.0 DD3 X 5.0 DD4 X 2.9 DD5+ X 22.3 April 11 - June 3 DD6+ X 46.3 March 16 - July 5 DD7+ X 16.9 April 11 - May 21 DD8+ X 22.3 April 11 - June 3 DD9+ X 40.9 March 16 - June 22 DD10+ X 47.5 March 16 - July 8; August 30 - October 4 DD12+ X 47.5 March 16 - July 8; August 30 - October 6 DD13 X 2.5 DD14+ X 33.1 March 16 - June 3 DD15+ X 48.3 March 16 - July 10; August 13 - November 14 DD16+ X 28.1 March 16 - May 22; August 15 - October 18 DD17+ X 51.7 March 16 - July 18 DD18+ X 20.2 August 15 - October 2 bD19+ X 38.4 April 6 - July 7; August 14 - October 3 DD20+ X 45.5 April 6 - July 24; August 12 - October 9 DD21+ X 25.0 March 16 - May 15; August 14 - October 5 D D22 X 10.2 DD23+ X 24.2 May 1 - June 28 DD24+ X 45.1 March 16 - July 3 DD25+ X 45.9 March 16 - July 5 DD26+ X 36.5 March 16 - June 12 DD27+ X 27.5 March 16 - May 21 DD28+ X 47.1 March 16 - July 8 DD29+ X 29.1 March 25 - June 3 DD30+ X 20.5 March 16 - May 4 DD31+ X 45.5 March 16 - July 4 DD32+ X 32.8 March 16 - June 3 DD34+ X 15.6 April 11 - May 18 DD35 X 8.6 DD36 X 2.0 DD37 X 5.3 DD38+ X 27.0 March 16 - May 20 DD39 X 6.1 DD40+ X 21.7 April 11 -June 2 + Gauges met the success criterion during an average rainfall month (May, June, July, September, October, and November). Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 77 Monitoring Year 5 (2005) Percentage of Growing Season at Saturation Monitoring (< 12" below surface) Dates Meeting Gauge < 5% 5-8% 8-12.5% > 12.5% Actual Success DD1* X 0.0 DD2 X 3.7 DD3 X 16.0 March 16 - April 23 DD4+ X 0.0 DD5+ X 0.0 DD6+ X 0.0 DD7-- X 2.9 DD8 X 26.2 March 16 - May 18 DD9 X 29.1 March 16 - May 25 DD10* X 0.0 DD12 X 28.7 March 16 - May 24 DD13 X 2.0 DD14 X 26.6 March 16 - May 19 DD15 X 63.5 March 16 - June 21; June 26 -August 21 DD16 X 29.5 March 16 - May 26 DD17* X 0.0 DD18 X 39.3 March 16 - June 19 DD19 X 29.5 March 16 - May 26 DD20 X 70.1 March 16 - June 24; June 26 - September 3 DD21* X 0.0 DD22* X 0.0 DD23* X 0.0 DD24 X 29.5 March 16 - May 26 DD25-- X 4.1 DD26* X 0.0 DD27+ X 0.0 DD28 X 45.5 March 16 - May 29; July 14 - August 18 DD29 X 39.3 March 16 -June 19 DD30 X 36.5 March 16 - May 9; May 23 - June 25 DD31 X 29.1 March 16 - May 25; July 14 - August 19 DD32 X 26.2 March 16 - May 18 DD34 X 2.5 DD35* X 0.0 DD36 X 0.8 DD37 X 17.6 March 16 -April 27 DD38 X 25.8 March 16 - May 17 DD39 X 16.0 March 16 - April 23 DD40 X 20.1 March 16 - May 3 * Gauges have been determined to be non-functional as of July 2005. + Gauge data for growing season absent due to gauge failure after July 2005 - Gauge data for growing season absent due to gauge failure prior July 2005 Note: Gauges DD11, and DDRG-2 located near DD29, are rain gauges. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 78 Appendix D (Click here) APPENDIX D ANNUAL VEGETATION MONITORING DATA SUMMARY (2001 - 2005) Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 79 Monitorina Year 1 (2001) ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY Y o Y Co E _ ?°' 5 Y Y U Y L N a N N U Year Initial (trees/acre) CL U) 0 o m 10 a Y Co a T s o 3 m 1 Planting _ U a? U 7 0 = ? w m `y L p N U a -a U E 3 3 3 °) o a w c 3 U U Q U 1 1 0 0 7 1 0 0 6 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 24 37 480 _ 3 O 0 6 1 4 0 1 0 0 3 0 0 0 00 0 15 40 300 _ 4 H 2 2 2 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 24 28 480 5 0 3 31 410 1317 00 00 0 00 31 3 39 620 -.._.__.._.__....? 1 8 40 1 1 3` 1 ° 5 018 1 0 O 0 0 ` 0 0°0' -?_-0 - -o...._........_' 22 38 440 14 1 5 1 1 1 6 1101 0 1 0 0= 0; 0 0= 0 1 0 0' 0' 0; 22 39 1 440 15 1 3; 4 1101 4: 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 i 0 1 0 i 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1. 22 1 32 1 440 17 1 14 : 3; 1 1 9 1 3 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 31 41 ; 20 ...... _ 19 ... 28 411 2 0 0 010,3000 0 010 0 t - - - ._.......__ # ...... I - .._.. i -_ ...... 3 0 9 0 3 0 7 4 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 35 _ 26 37 200 520 -- - 1 29 30 - 5 1! 1 0 0....I 6? 18 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 + 0. 3 9 0 0 f 0 18 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 31 41 32 39 620 640 I 31 14 O s 0 1 1: 0 6 4 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0' 0 26 1 37 1 520 32 1 - - ---------- i 1 4 4 1 1 1 0 8 3 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 s 28 38 560 33 0 4 4 5 0 0 25 s 8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 46 44 920 34 7 1 1 1 7 0 7~ 8 0 0 0 10 0 0- 0 32 39 640 Zone Average 528 2 2 0 0 1 3 0 0 0 20 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 25 25 500 12 0 0 4 0 0 2 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 26 260 Zone Average 380 _ 3^ 6 ? 0 4 1 1 ; 4 0; 1 2 2_? 0 0 0 0 14 30 280 _ -1- 1 i 1 ' 1 31 40 a 620 2! 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 O i j 0 ? 9 ? 0 0 1, 0 f 7 g.._ ...... .... . ._ ..._..___ .._. .. _ .._. -- --- -- -- 9 ; 0± 0; 3 1 1 O 10;010 0 0 0 0; 0110 8- 22 I 34 I 440 10 1 01 30 51020110!010101 010121 0 32 44 640 1 _ ........._._.....__...... q _._.....---.._._.. 11 X011 15.1 0!0!03,01010 0? 0 7 1 28 28 560 _._...- -._._._._.. _ i . _.........._.._._....- ._...3 - . __ ................. 10100 0 0 000 0 12 s 37 240 1 20 X 0[ 11 1 0 0;01 . 24 010`514 0101311 0 i0 "010 4 51 22 34 440 25 1 0' 1 1 6 1 6 0 1 0 1 7; 5 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 j 1 5 31 31 620 k 010 635? 31 35 620 [ 26 €0x01 2€Os010171 1 1000 27 0 1 11 1 1 0 0 1 9 0 0 0 0 0 0= 4 27 36 540 35 0 0 0 2 4 0 6 1 0 0- 0 0- 0 0= 2- 15 = 37 300 36 0€ 6; 5; 0; 0 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0?2ro0 15 - 36 300 Zone Average 467 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 80 Monitorinq Year 1 (2001) continued ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY Y O Y a Y Y O Y L O N j E ' Cn (6 (D Year Initial (trees/acre) N o o O a) 0 Y a o O c z fl 2 2 1 Planting r m o • co `5 v Y 3 ? , m ° 8 3 E 3 - L) m 2 y o L 3 3 °' o ° ° a r c U c 3 w Q 4 16 3010 3;030050 010010 12; 0, 23 : 31 ! 460 , 18 6:0.3 0 , 0 0 0 1 i 0 0 0 0 2 9 0 21 35 420 Zone Average 440 5 13 0. 2 2 5 0 0 5 3 0 0 0 0 0. 0 0 17 24 340 21 0 1 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0? 10 ? 0. 0 _.._ ...... ..... ... 0 15 .... .... 0 29 29 580 22 9= 0 3 ---: ' .10 . 0 3 0.00 0 0 ??....... __._ ............. ...a... 0 8 __,_....; 3- 27 27 540 23 1- 0 9 0 2 0 0 0 0 6 0. 0 0112 0 30 38 600 37 130 8 080 00:0 5 0 0 0 ° 13 0 € 47 47 940 38 210€9 000 0 4 0 013€0 1 2 0 50 50 1000 Zone Average 667 Total Average for all Zones 496 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 81 Monitorina Year 2 (2002) ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY Y O Y O c m o ,e O c Y ? Year Initial (trees/acre) v?, o o a o m ° m m a a? 0 CL 2 Planting z o c a?i ' E Y ,e a > 3 E, CL E m 3 3 3 o c ° ??-Oc 3 U N m Q ? 1 1 0 0 8 1 0 0 6 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 37 500 3 0 0 0 7 11 6 0 1 0 0 3 0 0 0 LO 18 40 360 _ 4 _ 2 22 0 1 0 1 18 0 0 0 00' 26 28 520 1 5 0? 6 3 0 4 1 x 9 1,121 0 1 0 1 01 0_1 0 1 0 0 :_ e....._...._ 35 39 -? 700 --.._..._._._._..s 8. __.. 1_- 3 5 ;..._0-._ -.8..._2 _ 9 0 0, i 0 I 0 0! L LU "L -0 22 3 38 440 : 14 - 1 5 3= 6 1 8 1 0 10 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 _ 0 i X22 39 I 440 1 15 3 1 4 1 10 : 4 1 1 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 32 440 .._ ... 17 - -._-_.....19. 1 28 1 13 ..._3.._.' 1 's 11 `....0... I_...0......'.....0.....? 0 ! 0 ! 0 _.1-..0_...( 0 0 ` 0 41._2..-.3 2 0 1 0 0 1 3 p? 0 1 0 1 0__ 1 0 0 .....0..... .. ' i....__...... -. ?_ ...._ _` 3 0 9 0, 3 1 0 7 1 4 e 0 i 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 28 i 41 I 12 t 35 26 1 37 ? 560 ?- 520 3 1 0000 ' 32 41 640 -1 1 '5 910 00 0 0._ 6 ' _- 30 03100_ 00?182i000000¢.0 33 39 660 .- 31 :15 15€ 0 0 1 1 2 2 0 6 5 0 0 3 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 x 0 -'---' 1- 1 29 37 580 32 7 0 5 0 2 0 8 3 0 0 O O i 0 1 0 0 25 1 38 500 33 0 5 0 1 0 25 1131 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 44 44 880 34 7 3 1 0 6? 0 6' 10 0 0 0= 0 0 0 0 33 39 660 Zone Average 540 2 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 21 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 25 25 500 12 0 0 4 0 0 1 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 14 26 280 Zone Average 390 580 11 3 1 6 O 5_ 1 1 4 1 0 1 _1_.._ 2 "01 0 11 0,- 0! 0 7 1 29 ° 30 -_ --+ -I- -.- - : -1........-..... 1 7 010 1 010120 0 00`19 .0 32 40 1 640 ............... .............. _..._._........_.._ ---"_._.-----?---.............- { 9 ?0 0 3110i00101010i010i0107 21 34 420 i 10 0510(2I012401100?0 01.0 ] 02 1 32 44 1 640 1 11 0 1 2 1 13 1 1 0 0 0 1 4 1 0 1 0? 0 0 0 7 1 28 28 560 20 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 12 37 240 s 24 1 0 1 1 5 1 4' 0 0 1 3 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 5 23 34 460 25 1 0 1 1 1 6 1 6: 0 1 0: 7: 5 0 0 0 4 1 5 31 31 620 26 0 0€ 2 0€ 0 0 19 s 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 6 5 33 35 660 27 0'1 34`1 0 0 y1 9 0 0 0 0 0 4 30` 20 36 1 400 ; 35 0 0 0 1 3 0 6 4 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 15 37 300 1 _ -- 36 0 3 5 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 O Y O 0 2 0 13 36 260 Zone Average 482 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 82 Monitorina Year 2 (2002) continued ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY -he O O Y Y ? "O Y Y 0 O Y t m O O j E m Year Initial (trees/acre) y o o = o m a a m o a °-' 2 Planting L o n a? aCi E Y cTi 3 E m 3 t 3 3 o :3 ° w c U 3 N 0 Q 4 € 16 30 0 3 00 06°00 0`0 i 0'=.=.12'0 f 24 i i 31 480 18 1 6 1 3 1 0 0 0€ 0 1 0 0 0€ 0 2' 9 0 22 35 440 Zone Average 460 5 13 0 3 Y 1 1 4 3 0 0 0 0 6 0 1: j: 0 0 0 18 24 360 21 1 0 0 -.... 6 0° 0~ 0 0 0 0 i 10 0 0 0' 131 0 29 29 580 22 . y 8103` 0 _3 0 0 0 0 1 0-0- 0 8 2 25 27 500 23 1= 0 9 0 2 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 :12: 0 30 38 600 37 1 12 1 0 9 0' 4 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 0 `` 15 ' 0 46 47 920 38 € 21 1 0 1 12 ' 0 0 0 0 4 0 1 8 0 1 3 3 0 1 50 1 50 1 1000 Zone Average 660 Total Average for all Zones 506 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 83 Monitorina Year 3 (2003) ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY Y ? O Y 'd o m o Y o ? m ear nitial trees/acre) m Y o m N 3 a? 3 w o c a 3 a T J- ? o 3 Planting a i m m N N a v ?e n 3 -O Z a) o m a m 3 s 3 a? o o c 3 3 U N 1 1 0 0 8 1 0 0 6 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 37 500 1 3 5 0 5 0 1 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 J -- - - ---- - - 15 40 300 _.__ 4 3 1 2 0 2 0 1 _119 ?? 0 0 0 0 0 6 1119 0 1 a _28 28 560 5 . 12 0 1 0 j 0' 0 0 1 0 0 `x € 0 14 53 9 4 0 34 39 680 I .. 8 _ . ,._ _. _ _ . 4 1 3 1 0 x 4 0 9-. L. 0 i _? __ 0 0' 0 0! 0 1 0 21 38 .... 420 ---- - 1 14 1 5131 6fr9s0's0101 0?01040 0 0'0 0 23 39 460 ! 15 i 2 i2 10 1 1 050 0 0°010!0€0 0+0 16 1 32 ! 320 17 1 141 3 0 7 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 25 41 500 19 ' 4 2 2) 0 1 0€ 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 _ - - 11 35 220 28 x 3 0 x 101 0 3 0 8 3! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 37 540 29 ' _ 4 2 `2!0 0 06;19 0001 F0000 33 41 660 ' 30 03 10,0 00 18=2{000?000t0 33 39 660 -- 31 : 14 ; 0 0 1 2 1 0 5 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 37 540 32 0; 0 0' 0 0} 0; 0 6? 0 5 0 2 0 9 3 25 38 500 - 3 33 X 5 ------- -- - ----- 050=1010'24;140001030 0s 0; 44 44 880 34 ! 7 3. 1 0 6 0 6 10 0? 0? 0_ 0 3 0 0 0 33 39 660 Zone Average 525 2 2 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 21 0 0 1 [ 1 1 0 [ 0 25 25 500 12 0 0 4 0 0 1 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 14 26 280 Zone Average 390 _. 3 -..._. .......6............_.. 0.-I -5 -1 _1._.._ -5 1....0..._1 1 1 2 ! 3 ,10 ,10 J 0 ! 0 ...._0...... 8 5 30 ! 30 i 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 2 0 0 0 0 0 20 0 32 40 9 _0 0 1 4 0 0, 0 3 .0 1 0! 0. 0 0 0 10 5 19 34 ........... 600 640 380 10 015 0331 012!01101 Ox010!0 0`1211 ! 33 i 44 660 --- r......- ....._......__..__.__... _ _; r _ s...... --------- . ?- ........ t--- ?-4 - 11 0 2 12:2 0 0 - 0 = 4 0 ! 0 0' 7 ! 1 . . ... .. : - - ...-- - 28 -- ---- 28 ?- 560 - 20 1 ... ... . . - 0 1 2 0 1 0 11 0 810:0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 37 260 1 24 011 410 0 3 0 0 0 x0 0=014 5 18 - 34 - 360 25 - 31 s 00 66 00 6 6! 010 0 0`011'6 - - - - - - - - - - - 1 31 620 26 1 00 x2000201 =0 0x010=0x6 5 34 I 35 680 27 ; 0x1 x6'010011 100 0 0 00-4 0 22 36 440 35 0 x 0€ 0` 1' 3' 0 6 3 0 0 0 0 0 1- 0 } 14 37 280 36 1 0 0' 0 2 0 0 14 6 1 1 1 0 1 0 3 0 0- 0 16 36 320 Zone Average 483 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 84 ZONE I PLOT monitoring Year 3 ZUU3 continued SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY Y O Y N 'O Y Y 10 O Y L O 5 0 Year Initial (trees/acre) Cu o Y o o Cn ° m fl ° CD 3 Planting m U - o Z m N N v ?e n 3 CL m a? o m - U 3 ? 0 Q 4 1 16 ( 3 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 5 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 12 1 0 1 21 1 31 1 420 18 7 3 1 0 6 ... ..0 0 1 0 0 0 u 1 1 9 0 22 35 440 Zone Average 430 5 13 .10 2 1 7 00. 4x3,0 0 0 0€ 0;0 `0; 27 24 540 21 - _ 1 0 _. 6 0 _...... 0 0 0. 0 0 10 0. 0 ---? 0 13 0 30 29 ..- 600 22 6 0 2 0 4 0 0 0 0 1 :0.0 08 2 23 ? 27 460 23 6 0 9 0 50 00060 0 013 0 39 38 780 37 2 0 9 0 50. 00060 0 015 0: 37 47 740 _._.......... .. 38 21 0 12 0 0 € 0 0 4028 0 ' 03 0 1 50 50 1000 Zone Average 687 Total Average for all Zones Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 85 Monitorina Year 4 (2004 ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY Y L O 'a m o Y o Year Initial (trees/acre) C - - O O Y L W N E C (p V a a a? 4 Planting mmle o o a a CO u?i 3 Y 3 a r E 3 r 3 3 °' o a n y n c 3 U C ? Q 1 i 1 0` 0j 8 2 0 0 6 1101 0 0 0 0 i 0 i 0! 0 26 37 520 1.. 4- 0161011 .0 01_310i0?0 010010 1.4 40 i 280 3 4 I3?13 0 2 011810 0 010 0`010 28 i 28560-- _ _ rr - -- -- 5 0 1.6 13 . 0- 4 ..1_ l 9. _12 0 1. 0 10_. 0 0. L 0 0 35 39 -- 700 - - 8 4 1 3 0 4 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 21 38 420 . . . - .... ---_. - .. -- 14 5 3 6 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 39 460 .............. 15 1 2 10 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 14 32 280 .. - -- I 17 13 3 1 6 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 L 0 0 24 41 480 19 4 2 2 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 L 0 0 10 35 200 28 2 0 10 0 3 0 8 1 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 27 37 540 ... __ _.. _..-- - 29 4 2 2 0 0 0 5 18 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 31 41 620 ...... __ ........ 30 0 3 10 0 0 0 18 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 33 _ 39660 31 16 0 0 1 1 0 5 5 0 0 0_. 0 0 0 0 28 37 560 32 6 0 3 0 1 0 10 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 23 38 460 33 0 3 0 4 0 0 23 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 44 44 880 34 4 3 1 0 5 0 7 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 30 39 600 Zone Average 514 ;0:0'1 i 1 0 s0 0121,0001; 1'0;0 25 , 25 ? 500 2 2 12 0 0 4 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 (9 0 0 8 0! 0 0 0, 14 1 26 280 Zone Average 390 3 6 0 _2? 1 5 i 0 .1. 4_. _i..,0 . t. 0 _i.. 0 8 7 ..30......-_30 600 _. ---- . 7 1 0= 0 0 0 0 0= 10 3 0€ 0 0 0 0 20 0 33 40 660 9 0'0 40 00 0;000 0 Oµ0 10 4 18 34 360 _ --- - - --- -....._..d _ .- _- . - _ ------ -_ 10 0 5 0; 3 0 2 0 10 0 0 0 0 12_[ 1 33 44 660 - -- 11 0 2 12 1 2 0 0 0 4 10 0 i 0 0 i 0 7 1 28 28 560 ----- --- --?- 20 0 1 , 2 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 13 37 260 s _.. 24 01 :4;0;0 0 3:0:0€0;0:0`0;4:0: 12 34 240 25 00=4 5=006.5 0 0 O OO 16 27 31 540 .._..... 26 0 0 2 0 0 0 20 ° 1_ <. 0 0.._6 0 0 6 2 31 35 620 - ... , __.. .5----5 . _- i .... .._.__. E 27 0 1 5. 0 0- 0 1 10 _0 0 ,_.0..? 0 0 4 0 21 _ 36 _._420 - 35 0 0 0 1 4 _0 612 010,040 0 1 0 14 37 280 36 €0 4 5 1 0 013.0 0€010 0`0.210` 15 36 300 Zone Average • 458 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 86 Monitoring Year 4 (2004) continued ZONE PLOT SPECIES TOTALS DENSITY y O y a ? y y Co o ,e o N mV y L f4 ? ? _ (p (? O Year Initial (trees/acre) .- O o ? Y CL o m o ? a m o o ? 4 Planting -6 3r, CL E m 3 C ML) 0 .2 z 3 °' o ° y c U 0 3 Q ? 4 16 3:0:0: 1 010;0; 50000=0.120: 21 31 420 18 73 1 00-00`2 `0`0;0:0 0 90 22 35 440 Zone Average 430 5 13 T , 0 1 1 - -_ 5 0 0 4 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .. _T .? Y -- 14 _ 24 .--- -- - 280 : 21 0 0 .4 0 .0 [ 01 0 00'.60 0 0 =16F 0 1 26 29 520 22 2 0- 2 0. 3 0. 0 6 0:0000 0.8 15 27 300 23 1 10,9; 0,51010?0?0 510 0 0 13 0 33 3 38 i 660 ---_.._.... 37 _.._.-- - 12010? - 0 !4;0:0 0! 0! 2! 03010E 15!0 43 l_...._.._.- _ . 1 47 ! 860 38 ; 21 1 0= 12 0 0 1 0 0 4 0 2 1 8 1 0 0 3 0 50 50 i 1000 Zone Average 603 Total Average for all Zones 479 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 87 Monitorina Year 5 (2005 ZONE PLOT SPECIES' TOTALS DENSITY m m O Y CO o Y -O 4) Year Initial (trees/acre) in o m O Y Cu 0 o m a a 3 n •. 5 Planting N U p ?' w N U f U T 3 E 3 =_ 3 3 0 2 N 3 rn o O a U E U m fA Q 1 1 _ _..... -• 8 -- -?._ 1 ......._.... 6 11 _ - 26 37 - --- - ........... 520 - 3 -----....._.._..._....._.....__ 4 6 1 __.... ....... .. ...... 1 .. 3 = 14 ................... 40 - -- - 280 , 4 3 3 1 , 1 19 27 28 540 5 7 3 2 2 1 12 10 37 39 740 8 4 1 3_ 3 9 _.. 20 . 38 -- 400 - 14 5 2 7 9 s , 23 39 460 15 1 3 9 13 32 _ 260 17 __: 13 1 1 ... - 6 ...._.......... .. 1 1 ....__.._.._R --- -.-._.._ 23 ................ T 41 460 19 -- - .......... ...... _.. - 4 1 - ? 1 ... ---- ....._._...... 1 .. 2 -- - - --._ 9 ................ 35 _ 180 28 -._. .._........_._....__ 2 .` .. t 10 _._.- ... ..__,... _ 3 .. 7 4 --- _.. -- - --- 26 .................. 37 ------ 520 , 29 - -----,.... _...... ....._......__, 4 ? 2 . _ 1 = .---_ .. ................ ... 5 18 - --- .- - 30 .. ......... .. .... - 41 ----- 600 - - - 30 5 18 2 s l 25 39 500 31 15 8 1 1 6 5 36 37 720 32 .... _...__............ - 5 - 3 .. -__ 1 ................ 1 .. 14 2 -- - _.. - - - 26 38 _.._.. _ - 520 - -- , 33 .... _..._ 1 - , 2 --__,_ 9 .._..._. . 4 25 3 44 ' 44 880 34 4 1 2 5 10 22 39 440 Zone Average 501 2 2 ' 1 1 ? 21 . 23 25 460 12 1 2 9 1 13 26 260 Zone Average 360 3 6 2 2= 6 2 2 2 , 8 7 31 30 620 7 _..... . -. _ . _....._. ----------- - 9 E 2 i 18 s ...._.__..._4... .. 29 1 _ 40 _._-_ ' 580 s e 1 2 ! 6 - 2 ' X10 3 4 4 18 33 1 34 44 1 360 660 j Q.......___ -- - g .................. i i.... ...... ..__3..... .. ? ..... ._._._._ ................ ..... .._. ....j._.. ..__..__. ..-.......... ._ - 11 = 1 12 1 1 4 I 7 i 1: 26 : 28 520 ..... .......... 20 3 ...---- _ _ 10 -- ..... _..._.. 13 37 260 24 1 4 3 2 4 11 34 220 - 1 25 I 1 3 4 6 4 1 4 22 31 440 26 2 20 1 31 35 620 27 2 3 t Y 1 10 ; i 4 i 20 36 F 400 35 : a 2 , 6 i 1 ? 12 37 i 240 _ ....... ..... ............ ..... - i 36 -r 4 --._ 5- ........... . 1 .. i 4! s--- I -- ----... 2 . 16 -i----_ _ - 36 -r 320 Zone Average 437 Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 88 Monitoring Year 5 (2005) continued ZONE PLOT SPECIES' TOTALS DENSITY Y co t0 N O - 0) Year Initial (trees/acre) Y Y O O Y n Co O O O N C E N w O 4) N O o Y fl. w o nz a a O 0) 0. 5 Planting U o .0 7 m = 3 ) 03 N N 3 3 0{ O C. -O U E o f0 Co 0 a N 4 16 ......................... 4 -. ............. ... 6 : ..... - 12 22 31 440 -- . 18 7 3 1 , = ? 2 9{ 22 35 440 Zone Average 440 5 13 1 3 4 3 .. 11 24 220 3 21 { 4 I s : 4 ; 16 s 24 29 480 _ 22 ° 2 2 e 3 i ? 8 15 r 27 300 ...... ------ _.__.._.._......_ ......; f .23 1 ,.._.__. ! 9 _,.. ..._....... € ......?? - - _ - .....? i 4! ! 1 5 F i T- ,.... i 13 t ._..., .................._....... 32 _...._.._._.._._..._............_......_..........._...................... _ i 38 640 x..._._...37......_..; 23 -- .._._...._. 4 ? ............... = .....?- - - , .._......... , $ t 2 i 2 ? r ........_._, 8 ^- ..._..._.._.._......_ 39 .r.................-_._._..__._ € 47 r.-._._ 780 38 z 21 12 = 4 2 8 - 3 50 50 1000 Zone Average 570 Total Average for all Zones 462 white oak, longleaf pine, black walnut, and tulip poplar were not observed during year 2005 monitoring activities and are not included in this table 2 vegetation plot 38 could not be located; data presented reflects year 4 values. Monitoring Year 6 of 6 (2006) Page 89