Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout19951275 Ver 1_COMPLETE FILE_19960207 ~~ .}'Y>,... ,-,. State of North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources DivisiQ[1of Environmental Management James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor , Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary t A. Preston Howard, Jr., P.E., Director February 19, 1996 MEMO " >'i't:& ' Johp~~er,ICM f , Jthn ~~rne:-~g~ 1 Water Quality comments "'., Jink's Creek dredging project Brunswick County DEM # 951275, COE# 1995017,98 To: From: 'Re: DEM is opposed to this project which pl,a,nsto dredge 2.9 acres of Primary Nursery Area bottom since it is not for maintenance p@.Poses. We believe that this existing use will be removed by this extensive dredging projecC;:Therefore we recommend that DCM deny the permit for this activity. Pleas call me at 733-1786 if you have any questions. cc: Wilmington DEMReglonal Office Central Files 951275.dcm , , .J',""h_~""'''.'~';'''-';'':-'''''''''': Fax # " ' '~ Environmental Sciences Branch, 4401 Reedy Creek Rd" Raleigh, NC 27607 Telephone 919-733-1786 FAX # 733-995S An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer' 50% recycied/10% post consumer paper ."p", ~":~'.' ,":t.:' .~- ~ l~':trl1'i~"':~"'~' --,~~.; To: "John Dorney ',Pl~g Branch DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT CAMA MAIOR PERMIT APPLICATION REVIEW REGIONAL OFFICE STAFF REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS REVIEWER:GREGSO~~ WQ SUPERVISOR: ADKIN~ DATE: January 18, 1996 , ...c-; t:z5S , - WETLANi>INFO~TIQN F:OR CENTRAL OFFICE TRACKING PERMITYR: 9S:L'PIR1VqTNO.:951275 COUNTY: Brunswick PROJECT NAMf;: Tlwn.9fSuilset Beach I Jink,s Creek Dredging Project PRO~CT TYfE:,Rr~dg~PEJlMIT TYPE: CAMA COE I,: N/A '/i\j, ;,; DOT#:.N/A RCD FROM ~DAit>CM DATtl?ROM CDA: December 15, 1995 ~G OFFICE: WillO tUVER AND; SUB BASIN#: 030759 *STREAM OR ADJACENT WATER BOI)Y: AIWW CLASS: SA STREAM INDEX #: 15-25 *OPEN OR CLOSED: Closed WL IMPACT: No WL TYPE: N/A WL REQUESTED: N/A WL ACR EST: '.', WL SCORE: N/A ,;':,~'; MITIGATION: N/A MITIGATION TYPE:N/A' MITIGATION SIZE: N/A it RATlNG$liEE1,1.!\TTACHED?: N/A RECOMMENDATION: Deny , ";,'!,,~,.~,'.,,, STORMW ATER PLAN REQ'D: No,' 0, IF YES, DATE APPROVED:" "..' , '" PROJECT DESCRIPTION: l'he'app}icantproposest<> dredge a channel parallel to the waterway between Mary's Creek and Turtle. Cr.ook to'pto.:vide boating access to their property. WATER OUALITY CERT. (4Qn CERT. REQ'D: Yes IF YES, TYPE: General Certification #3025 SEWAGE DISPOSAL , TYPE OF DISPOSAL PROPOSEI'>: N/A TO BE PERMI'ITED BY: N/A , , IF BY DEM, IS SITE AVAILABLE AND ,PERMIT ISSU.ANCE PROBABLE: N/A WATERlWETLAND FILL AREA OF FILL - WATER: N/A WETLAND: N/A IS FILL ELIMINATING A SIGNIFICANT USE? N/A DREDGING," IS DREDGING ACTIVITY EXPECTED TO CAUSE A SIGNIFICANT LOSS OF RESOURCE? Yes' , ',i IS SPOIL DISPOSAL ADEQUATEL YADDRESS~P? Yes """r~:;~, .-; .^.... ~, ',' '.. I," . , ",' '" ,:if.;..~-':'';: ' 1><.<,) ~ t"l<y- ~ ~iJ ~ ~o~ J' ~~ ~ "~OJ ~; Q-~ :-y~ IMPORTANT To ! 1 c9 Time . //i/ WHILE YOU~RE OUT M ".~~Oh!7 l-/QA J( LA.. of AREA CODE NUMBER . Phone TELEPHONED CAllED TO SEE YOU WANTS TO SEE YOU PLEASE CAll Will CAll AGAIN URGENT: RETURNED YOUR CAll Me,,,g~~1~~~ ~~ jCh o pflOC' ().fL/J - {'yyIO 11 A_ pfLuvY\: '( N,C, Dept. of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources ~ PrintAn nn RAr.vdAd Paoer ~', ':".~ 9S1275.Jah P~8;~,T\Vo ' MARINA..., ARE THE FOLLOWING AD~QUATEL Y ADDRESSED? SEWAGE DISPOSAL: N/A MARINA SERVICES: N/A OXYGEN IN BASIN: N/ACLOSURE OF SHELLFISHING WATERS: N/A (ATTACH A MARINA USE ATTAINABILITY EV AL.) The proposed project will result in th~ loss of 126,324 sq. ft. of Primary Nursery Area shallow bottom habitat. Such a proposaLis inconsistent with 15A NCAC 2B .0201. It is therefor recomm~nded that the project and' }he 401 Certification be denied. .f-;c cc: Central Files Wilmington Regional Office Files DCM-Brooks John Parker .."':' DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY WILMINGTON DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS po, BOX 1890 WILMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402-1890 q Cjl3CJ IN REPLY REFER TO March 21, 1995 -"- ~ ~ r~ ~ , ~ % ~ 'r> () ~~ ~ '\..1' a' y'tJ ~ ~ Regulatory Branch Action ID No. 199501798 Mr. John Dori1~y" Division of Environmental Management North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and' Natural Resourc~s 4401 Reedy Creek Road 'Raleigh, North Carolina 27607 Dear Mr. Dorney: Enclosed is the application of the Town of Sunset Beach, represented by Ms. Linda Fluegel, for Departme~t,of the;Army (DA) authorization and a State Water Quality Certification to ~a~'tain a Ghannel and basin on Jinks Creek, off the Atlantic IntracoastalWateay (AIWW) , Sunset Beach, Brunswick County, North Carolina. Your receipt of, th,s letter verifies your acceptance of a valid request for certification ih.a~cordance with Section 325.2(b) (ii) of our administrative Fegulations. ~~~ We are considering author:i.:iing the proposed activity pursuant to Section, 404 of the Clean Water Act, a~d we have det~rmined that a water quality certification is required un9~r the provisi6~s of Section 401 of the same law. A Department of the Army :permit will not be granted until the certification has been obtained or waived>,', . ' , '. ~ . . .'...'. . <, In accordance with our administrative regulations, in most cases, 60 days after receipt of a request'~c>:rcertification is a reasonable time for State action. Therefore, if YOll'ha.:ve,not acted on the request, or asked for an extension of time, by April 21, 1995, -the District Engineer will deem that waiver has occurred. Questions or comments may be addr~ssed to Mr, Michael Hosey, Wilmington Field Office, Regulatory Branch, telepl10ne (9';J,Ol 251-4441. Sincerely, ~ , Regulatory Branch Enclosure Copies Furnished (without enclosure),: Mr. John Parker bivision of Coastal Management North Carolina Department of ' Environment, Health and Natural Resources ~ost Office Box 27687 , "Raleigh, N,?rthCp.roliIlCl.."~76J.1,-.7,6a7~".,,,) Mr. C. Robert Stroud, Jr. Wilmington Regional Office North Carolina Division of Coastal Management 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, North Carolina 28405 .' ~,~, ' ,~}/7r:~( , ./ o ~\O~. ,. . ~ \\s\'<:: . s\1>-\\o e ~e \e~\ ^.\s o~ '~e~e\' ' ~e ~c.:~\ co~e~ ' ~\C1>-\\o~ ~\s 1>-~~ .... " ~O~ pS' .' ~~\C~ ^ ."'.,, ili .' - &.\P ~ \1'< I'>~~I'> " -p~"" y S'\ 1'>'-' . ~\'\S ,\0 r-:S COr-.: . ~O~ ~~-y; CI'>~O\.-~ . ~0~'\<0- /'iCfc90/7,'t 'f() Lt,.." ,. ".., ..~."'" .. ',~ ,'~-: ~.:; ..~-.~:. 0/ . _.':...C n:B 2 ~' :,,' r-::rr.. ' ,.' ,...(::.h..Afr;p;-, Pc . /"';:(.;1 ." ..:(.:.... . . ,';';'1 . ~,: ;~','''., ;::~.:~:::"> "' s~ ().~~ " ",:~t>--')' t>-C\ \.c~ ' 1>-oe~e~\ , ' ,,' ," t>--~e1>- '^"~ ~ ' co~S\1>-\ \ \,t>---\ \ ~ c.G5. . ~o ~\-v,. \)~o~e \\,_1-1-C) ,... ,./ ," , ",.c.GS' . O:~.\<vc:>"'~?c""'" · ~-.>?>.\\\'i '." ~~_". '. ,~\o~ ...~,"'\e~~ A '1._1-\':>" ,<",'.,.' ....... '2>.\"~~ ." .,' ~ t>--O~>' ~.c.O.; <pe~\' 0 .,...' ,0 ~~ '. ,. .... ...'1i'\.'e~~ <<-.se"" \~f/l. 7. .. ~C,,<tJi> ",.c.GS' ~",(\..,oV ~1>-\e~ .' ' ",.,i\..~\e 16.AO . 1 ~.C.O~. ' ~e~\ ~ ,^~?;e ~~\\ro' . ot co?s ~~o~~e~\' O . ''i>\O~ ~~~~V ~\<l\c \>cV\.o o-.><.ce'i> ~~~O~~\~~:Js-\ ~o~ ~ \cf~\ ~ ,,~~~ . ff:.Qf:.f(..~\. "f~\o'1.' 0< ~~ . -P"'~~O'" ~.,e" ~c' 0' \~ ~c;'oo: ~..\...'o\e .t> ~.{<i>" co~S ~o~ \~ ~'-le~'i> 'b: o~e~ \oo,~ "v..,e~'" SCC\\o~ eO o{~\)> .l. 'Q~eO~ _..., ~~us .....c\ . ~1>-~'be c:.o~"'I'le ~~\C~ p \)\sc ~1>-\e<' 'o.e1>-~ , \~\o ~~ b.f::f o~ ~e '. r.ee~ seC\\O~ ' ''i> o~~~'b\ co~ S. t>--~~ \)\c:.\~C\ U. . (1\0~ ~\\{t\\~::> f~ .' .... .. . . .,... ..., o' ., Division of Coastal Management Raleigh Headquarters POBox 17687 "~leigh,NC 27611-7687 (919) 733-2293 Eliza beth City District 1367 US 17 South Elizabeth City, NC 27909 (919) 264-3901 '-,,, .' :~ t i .'-.~-....._. .' "'.. ,.".' , , , , , ... He rtfo rd , ' , ~..-._-_._._.-.--_. .' " . . , , . .' " ....,... '", . '----.', .": ..--, ,..: ,,' ~ .. , ,.., , '",' j' W h' ton / Tyrrell " as m9 " , ' . , I , . '. _,--"----.--..-"..-----.4-----, ,,. ...... , , , , , , , . , .._..... -.-1 Bertie Washington District PO Box 1507 1424 Carolina Avenue Washington,NC 27889 (919) 946-6481 ' , . , . " . ,..- '-_......-._--~ ,I' " , , , , , , , . " Pender .. ,~ " , . <'.,~ .'. ,--,,''', ~.. ...." .. .' ..~ New', ,.. · Hanover , , " ,." , ,---.,' , , , " ,,' , ",: " ", .--.."--. ". ..,'-",....... , . . , , . . /' Reserve Education PO Box 1040 Beaufort, NC 28516 (919) 728-2170 Morehead City District 3441 Arendell Street Morehead City, NC 28557 (919)726-7021 or 1~$OO-682-2532 Wilmington District 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405-3845 (910)395-3900 , , .. "'. ReServe Coordination 7205 Wrightsville Avenue Wilmington, NC 28403 (910}256-3721 .~ .".~ , /CJ950179g '--~~" --~ ~'-""""'H-;' r--=-~~ ' 1""1< "" ~...I .~ Please type or print. Carefully describe all anticipated ~ . - , '- ,- '-,- . development activities, including construction, excava- ;::-', _, .~:: ,:;tiqn, filling, paving,l~d clea~ng,. and stonnwater con- , ,-' 'If YO!1pl~ to build a marina, also complete and trol. If the requested info~ation IS not relevant to yout:'::;',;:-:-r'inathForm DCM-l\1P-2. project, write N/A (not apphcable). Items 1.4 and 8-9 must be completed for all projects. t:APPLICANT a. Name" Town of Sunset Beach Address 220 Shoreline Drive West City Sunset Beach State NC Zip 28459 Dayphone (910) 579-6297 Landowner or X Authorized agent b. Project name (if any) Maintenance Dredging of Jinks Creek c. If the applicant is not the landowner, also give the owner's name and address. N/A 2 LOCATION OF PROPOSED PROJECT a. Street address 'or secondary road number Shoreline Drive East b. City, town, community, orlan6mark Sunset Beach c. County Brunswick d. Is proposed work within city limits or planning jurisdiction? Sunset Beach e. Name of body of water nearest proiect Intercoastal Waterway Hetween MMl05 & Sunset Beach Bridge 3 DESCRIPTION AND PLANNED USE OF PROPOSED PROJECT a. Describe all development activities you propose (for example, building a home, motel, marina, bulkhead, or pier). Maintenance Dredsdng of Jinks Creek 3191 b. Is the proposed activity maintenance of an existing project, new work,or both? Maintenance c. Will the project be for community"private, or commercial use?' Communi ty , d. Describe the planned use of the project. Communitv Boating Access 4 LAND AND WATER CHARACTERISTICS a. Size of entire tract 42 Acres b. Size ~findividuallot(s) ,17 Lots ~f l02~p~~g~OO' ;\ C. Elevation of tract above mean sea level or National Geodetic Vertical Datum ,seaLevel d. Soil type(s) and texrure(s) of tract S~rtd - Mar!';h Mud ..:;; " e, Ve~etation on tract None f. Man-made fearures now on tract Dock!'; g. What is the,CAMA Land Use Plan Classification of the site? (Consult the local land use plan.) _ ConseI:Vation _Developed _Rural _ Transitional ~ Community _ Other h. How is the tract zoned by local government? Residential District ,v i. How are adjacent waters classified? Intercoastal Waterway j. Has a professional archaeological survey been carried out for the tract? If so, by whom? . . .. . T ,5 UPLAND DEVELOPMENT :-.- '-I , ,'Gorppletethis section if the project includes any land develop~ent. a:' Type:~rid number of buildings, facilities, ot 'stl11cNresproposed' N I A ' b. Number oflotsor parcels c.: Density '(Oivethe number of residential units and the units per acre.) d. Siz~ of area to be graded or disturbed e. If the proposed project will disturb more than one acre ofland: the Division of Land Resources must receive an erosion and sedimentation control plan at ' least 30 days before land disturbing activity begins. If applicable, has a sedimentation arid erosion control plan been submitted to the Division of Land Resources? f. Give the percentage of the tract within 15 feet of ' mean high water to be covered by impenneable surfaces, such as pavement, buildings, rooftops,. g. List the materials, such as marl, paverstOI1e,.asphalt, or concrete, to be used for paved surfaces(' h. If applicable, has a stonnwater management plan been submitted to the Division of Environmental, Management? i. Describe proposed sewage disposal and/or waste water treatment facilities. j. Have these facilities received state or local approval? k. Describe existing treatment facilities. 1. Describe location and type of discharges to waters of the state (for example, surface I11noff, sanitary wastewate,r, industrial/commercial effluent, "wash. down").' , ,2 , ',' m. Water supply source n. If the project is oceanfront development, describe the steps that will be taken to maintain established public beach access ways or provide, new access. o. If the project is on the oceanfront, what will be the elevation above mean sea level of the first habitable floor? 6 EXCAVATION AND FILL INFORMATION a, DeScribe below the purpose of proposed excavation or fill activities (excluding bulkheads, which are covered in Section 7). Length Width Depth Access channel (ML W) or (1'.T\VL) 3100' 40' 6' Boat basin 1000 ' 60' 3' Gthtr (break- :0:: '. water, pier,< boat ramp, rock jetty) Fill placed in' ' wetland or below MHW Upland fill areas b. Amount of material to be excavated from below water levelin cubic yards 95,000 cu. yd. c. Type of material Beach Sand & Marsh Mud ,d. Do~s the area to be excavated inch:de marshland, , swamps, or other wetlands? ,'. No' - Crppk' e. High ground excavation, in cubic yards N/A 3191 . . . ~ .. '... . f:. Dimensions of sJ)9il disposal area Approx. 1200' x 200' c. Shoreline erosion during preceding 12 months. in feet , g. Locationofspoil disposal area Across Intercoastal d, Type of bulkhead material Waterway from Site h, 'Doyoudaimtitleto the disposalarea? .,No ,'If not, attach a letter granting permission from the ,owner. Ed .Gore , Sr. i. Will a disposal area be available for future maintenance? Yes If so, where? ' j. Does the disposalarea include any marshland, swamps, or water areas? k. Will the fill material be placed below mean high water?' N/ A 1. Amount of fill in cubic yards m. Type offIll material n. Source of fill material "" o. Will fill material be placed on marsh or other wetlands? p. Dimensions of the wetland to be filled q. How will excavated or fill material be keptonsite and erosion controlled? Dike - Drawing attached. r.. What type of construction equipment will be used , (for example, dragline, backhoe, or hydraulic dredge)? Dredge s, Will wetlands be crossed in transporting equipment to project site? No If yes, explain steps that will be taken to lessen environmental impacts. Enter 'from Intercoastal Waterway 7 SHORELINE STABILIZATION a. Length of bulkhead or riprap N / A b. Average distance waterward of mean high water or normal waterlevel .....,." . .'.~' 3/91 e. Amount of fill, in cubic yards. to be placed below mean high water f. Type offill material 8 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ,In addition to the completed application form, the follow- ing items must be submitted: A copy of the deed (with state application only) or other instrument under which the applicant claims title to the affected property. If the applicant is not claiming to be the O\\'I1er of said property. then forward a copy of the deed Or other instrument under which the owner claims title. plus written permission from the owner to carry out the project. An accurate work plat (including plan view and cross sectional drawings) drawn to scale in black ink on an 8 1/2 x 11 white paper. (Refer to Coastal Resources Commission Rule 71.0203 for a detailed description.) Please note that original drawings are preferred and only high quality copies will be accepted. Blue-line prints or other larger plats are acceptable only if 18 high quality copies are provided by applicant. (Contact the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers regarding that agency's use of larger drawings.) A site or location map is a part of plat requirements and it must be sufficiently detailed to guide agency personnel unfamiliar with the area to the site. Include county road (SR) numbers. landmarks, and the like. A stormwater management plan,if applicable, that may have been developed in consultation with the Division of Environmental Management. A list of the names and complete addresses of the adjacent waterfront (riparian) landowners. These individuals have 30 days in which to submit comments on the proposed project to the Division of Coastal Management and should be advised by the applicant of that opportUnity. .. . ... oJ ,.. , Name Address ~a.rne .' Address' Name Address 9 CERTIFICATION AND PERMISSION TO ENTER ON '-AND Any permit issued in response to this application will allow only the development described in the application. The project will be subject to conditions and restrictions contained in the permit. I certify that to the best of my knowledge, the proposed activity complies with the State of North Carolina's ap- ploved Coastal Management Program and will be con- ducted in a manner consistent with such program. ,:'. A list of previous state or federal permits issued for workon the projecnract.lnclude peonit numbers, pemiinee, and issuing dates~ I further certify that I am authorized to grant, and do in 1. Original Permit - 1972 fact, grant permission to representatives of state and 2. East Entrance to Creek- March 10, 1987 federal review agencies to enteron the aforementioned 3 W E' C k R. S. Adams Joel d . ., hi' "nfi . I d . est ntrance to ree - Oct. L 1987PEED an s In connection wit eva uaung 1 ormation re ate Renewed Feb. 10, 1992 - (Attached) 241'-8710 this permit application and follow-up monitoring of' A check for $250 made payable to the pepanrnent of proj~ct. Environment, Health, and Natural Resources to cover the costs of processing the application..... r;) , A $ignedAEC hazard notice for projects in oceanfront and inlet areas. ' A statement on the use of public funds. If the proje~t involves the expenditure of public funds, attachastat-e- ment documenting compliance with the North~arolina Environmental Policy Act (N.C.G.S. 113A-l to 10); OWNERS LOTS 302 Shoreline Drive East 224" "" 222 ,. " "'II 220 II "" 218 II II II 216" "" 214" "" 212" "" 210" "" 206 & 208 Shoreline Drive East 114 Shoreline Drive East 112 II "" 110 II "" 108" "" 106" "" 104 &,102 Shoreline Drive East Joe Peed Shoreline Drive East 4 ~ ., 10 Thisls the ~day of ..!},,!-1N7<V~ ,19~, ~~Uth~1nda Fluegel - Administrator ;ADJOININGLOTS ,401 Stokes Drive ~09 " " 311 " " 313 " " 315 " " ,317 " II 300 Shoreline Drive East 302 Sunset Blvd. 3191 --- . , . ~ ' ':"1 .+ , '\' , ~ '\ --.- - . .~ , . ~ .. , Proposed Maintenance of Jinks Creek "Channel Map Copy Prom Tax Map Original Copy at Town Hall ~' ~ 'f' Town of Sunset Beach 220 Shoreline Drive West Sunset Beach, NC 28459 ,,' ~' ......,:..-:-....~:...~ :"".~~" :.... .,..~. .~...,.t'?:~ .: :,~~-:.~,A 1lANT1C~ . .\'. ....:..::.. . ...., ..~. ....... ;:. . ;~.: ~,',;' Proposed Vicinity Map Town of Sunset Beach Publication 1992 Town of Sunset 220 Shoreline Sunset Beach, DSA NC-3820 Beach Drive West NC 28459 2/20/1995 . t \- _.~' . :\" . '. , , Proposed Maintenance of Jinks Creek Location of Intercoastal Waterway Copy of Nautical Chart 11534 May 27 , 1989 Town of Sunset Beach 220 Shoreline Drive West Sunset Beach, NC 28459 DSA NC-3820 2/20/1995 T' ll.. fl... I. ~".',"~'\;': '. ~J ~ {7","./ " " .. ;4ir f~ , , . -.;..;..-......."""-..........~ (j,"'{~'j;o-..'.i' ' ...'.L~.\' ',' '.". .., .,'r.. Town of Sunset Beach Application to Dredge Canals A,B,C,&D Water flow to dredged a 6/ ",.~'--J~ \ , --- ..-. -.. - Dike De1:ail . ft~~~ ',~ ,.- ~-~ 4/1r, fJ3 1985 ' OfFICE OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT WllMI~GTON REGIONAL OFfICE: ------- .- . ... ,\ . . ' .. ... . .- '- M H W f 3.~ feet /" I ;1 I ,I I .l:! L W. " 16 ... -.' 40 - 1) ,,' Proposed channel bottom -6 feet HLW ......-.-.-... -..--. '. ..,. . , t<- ~ ~ ------,~-=~._~_.. - ._~-::..~-;", ---.--. .--...-- .'.:,.,-.) Cross Section of channel of Jinks Creek Proposed Maintenan~e Dike Detail and Cross Section of Channel Copy Prom Permit 12/11/85 Number 211-85 Town of Sunset Beach 220 Shoreline Drive West Sunset Beach, NC 28459 n~4 N~-~A?n ?1?n/1QQ~ :j_~tJt January 16, 1996 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY WILMINGTON DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P.O. BOX 1890 WilMINGTON, NORTH CAROLINA 28402.1890 REPLY TO ATTENTION OF ID No. 199501798 " Mr. John Dorney Division of Environmental North Carolina Department Environment, Health and Natural Resources 4401R,eedy Creek Road Raleigh,-North Carolina Dear Mr. Ddrgey: EnclosedJ.s the application of Town of Sunset Beach for Department of the Army authorization and a State Water Quality Certification to dredge approximately 2.9 acres of non-vegetated shallow bottom on Jink's Creek, in Sunset Beach, Brunswick County, North Carolina, for the purpose of providing boating access for,private property owners. Your receipt of this letter verifies your acceptance of a valid request for certification in accordance with Section 325.2(b}(ii) of ouradministrative regulations. Management of 27611-7687 "'......t' ". . -,;c' We are conside;-ing authorizing the proposed activity pursuant to Section 404 of the Clean Wate.r Act,artd we have determined that a water quality certification is required under the provisions of Section 401 of the' same law. A Department of the Army perm:i.t will not be granted until the certification has been obtained or waived. ' , According to our administrative regulations, 60 days is reasonable for State action. Therefore, ifyouh!i.\fe not acted on the request, or asked for an extension of time, by March,15cj1.99G, the District Engineer will deem that waiver has occurred, Questions or cOlTlments may be addressed to Mr. Jeff Richter, Wilmington Field Office, Regulatory Branch, telephone (910) 251-4636, Sincerely, (;,r ~~, G. Wayne Wright Chief, Regulatory Branch Enclosure Copies Furnished (without enclosure) : \~ ~ " ,q, '\ ...D "<? ;A "1~ 1'- -::Q t. ~ ::i:) \cr (fl ~ a ~ ~ Mr. John Parker Division of Coastal Management North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources Office Box 27687 North Carolina 27611-7687 ,r., Printed on . Recycled'Paper --t""~: .....---- -- ------ ----------. ., ,Hefih and Natural Resources 1l-(L(!:> 0 l ri 0 Wilmington Regional Office Div:sion of Coastal Management ,jarile~~un'~^Jr., Governor Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary Roger N. Schecter, Director " _~il~ DEHNR. December 13, 1995 Or.-.......r- r l.<'i~\....t:.j V ED ~;: "-'" . - '.. ' .'-','\:Town'of Sunset Beach ,(:'~;'i:J oLinda Fluegel t;-v"r' '-'.,220 Shoreline Dr. , Sunset Beach, NC 28468 ill ': rEI~@f, ~ Wr:W rn f;,'l dl! 'i ? 3 .--"'\ ~ . · ."'-. ~ 0, ,......nJ: I.J i.. oJ · .; f')j"~ r;E'''' " .-~ 1\ utJUt'U~IV e"H.cr~ , . . L.onlil~' rf Dear M.~.)~~4egel: >' ,," ,-, i.:t:,'i; : ,theDivi~ioJ.?,ofCb~st31 ~anagement hereby acknowledges receipt of your application for State appro'la,Lfor developmentofprop~rty located along the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway, adjacent to Shoreline Dr. East, in Sunset Beach, NC.; in Brunswick County. It was received on November 29, 1995, and appears to be adequate forprcicessing at thistime. The projected deadline for making a decision is February 12, 1996,. An additiona175-day review period is provided by law when such time is necessary to complete tll~reYiew. If you have not been notified of a fmal action by the initial , deadline stated above, you should consider the review period extended. Under those circumstances, this letter will serve as your l}.oiic@ of an extet;1de<ireview. However, an additional letter will be provided on or about the 75th day. " NCGS,1l3A-119(b) requires that ~~ticeof an application be posted at the location of the proposed'development. ,Enclosed you wp;t..fmd a "Notice of Permit Filing" postcard which must be posted at the property"of your'propose,ddevelopment. You should post this notice at a conspicuous point along your property where it can be observed from a public road. Some examples would be: Nailing the notice card to a telephone pole or tree along the road right-of-way fronting your property; or at a point along the road right-of-way where a private road would lead one into your property. Failure to post this notice could result in an incomplete application. , , A field report has been preparedaiid is in the process of being circulated to the various state and federal review agencies for their comments. ,If additioria].infonnation is required based on this review, the agencies may contact you <fuectly. " Sincerely, . c: (J-. BlODk Q) E.,F. Brooks s)r@ Field Representative ill Enclosure John Parker Bob Stroud 'David Franklin, COE 27 Cardinal D,rive ~ension, Wilmington, N.C. 28405-3845. Telephone 910-395-3900 · Fax 910-350-2004 - An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer ",,' Aug. 8 CS P.A. AND ASSO . HOUSTON 754-2121 FAX 1-910- P. 2 '~~'-. ' i . f~ -I ~ ,. r;,. . ....., . ~ ~... ,~.,' Uti " :. ~. ...: ,- __J I' , ,',' , "":,,-, --'-'-~ .- ! , I l . ~:~' /~il ~ '// -- L.. ,.-...-- ~ ~,(.l -- .. . I \IOlSW'C1C ce" tI P-:::-(":'~j :~;;T~..!- -,--r-- . Ir~~~~::9~ill) DIVISION ut= T ~ ~""A.L MANAGEMEN CO.""....l. ,I ,V-!r....r. ! i l l I. ,. .1.. 5..~_ ..~~.;- .e =:.=---- ':I~' ~~_. :~~~.. r '~' '"...~- .."<,,,,~ --,' '''', ','" . ''':' i \f' ' .; It 8u9} 8 '95 8:09 i~""""",'~ ,'.. .".."'i:,',::"~"t ';j:ikit~' ". ' ",';T411ePhone (91 of 754.6324 ~~lmllQ (910) 754.,121 HOUSTON AND ASSOCS. P.A. f=AX 1-910-754-2121 ~~~ie9 HOUSTON and ASSOCIATES, P.A. Consultinlt Enll1neen SHALL011E. NORffi C~OUNA 28459 117 Pine StrQQt Post Office Box 2927 )~ nr~~~ID.lftn(~ Monday, August 7. 1995 ,.~Mr. Edward Gore " StUlset Beach Be Twin Lakes. Inc. "502,.2 North Sunset Boulevard Sunset Beach, North Carolina 28459 Subj~Ct: Jink's River Dredging Project DridgeOSpoH Area Dear Mr. Gore:" ~rn; CC mmWJE TfJ1 NOV 1 3 1995 JlV DIVISIUi-. vf COASTAL MANAGEMENT As per our converl)ation th1s morning, it Is proposed to use the spoil area that was used for the dredging project tor Joe Peed for the Jink's Creek dredging project. This area Is located across the Intercoastal Waterway from the Jink's 'Creek project (see attached map). According to county tax records, this land belongs to your company and we would like to obtain permission from you to use this land for the,spoll area. We understand that the Corps of Engineers has an easement to the property and we would also need their approval to use thJs area. By ~1@111g below, you iSSue perml~Slon to use the area indicated on the attached mapfo1; disposing of spojl,~~ter1al from dredging activities assodated with the propos~d Jink's Creek 'project We also request permission to have the property surveYQdand requls1t.1onany improvements to the dike and outlet structures as nlay be necessary. Please sign below and return this letter to our ofTfce so that we may proceed with thJs proJect. Please contact us at your convenience If there are any questions or if we can provide addltlonalinformation. Sincerely. <:~~-y':~,~,::" f' 'y. L~~. ,-\;Jt.~.., Shannon M. Houston, E.I.T. Houston anel Associates, PyA. 't;, "i "~ i, , ,: ,1-' '.~~':t~ttachment :,,;, pc: File: 95-0350 (Sunset Beach DredgIng Project) t, .. ,41.;), ", .,:} .Jr: ::'\~'Si' , ,i~l' ',. .'tilfjl." :.i:J(.:. ,:':" " " " ,,\,<' 1'.\ '.i. TOWN OF SUNSET BEACH .JINKS CREEK DREDGING PROJECT Proiect Narrative 'riparian landowners to Jinks Greek have petitioned the Town of Sunset Beach to t>btainthe permits necessarytore-predge the channel along Jinks Creek in order to provide boating access to theirprdpertY during low tide. This channel was originally dredged in 1972 and the east and west entrances were maintained in 1987. Appro?<imately 30,000 cubic yards of material will need to be dredged in order to provide sufficient depth for boating access during low tide. This material is proposed to be disposed of in a spoil area located directly across the Intracoastal Waterway from the project. Permission has been obtained from the landowner, Mr. Edward Gore, to use the spoil site. Iw~~rrvwill) NOV 13 1995 DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT . l' ,". . " " DMSION OF COASTAL l\1ANAGElVIENT q 600 '17 FIELD INVESTIGATION REPORT -~'i, :~LICANT'S NAME: Town of Sunset Beach/Jink's Creek Dredging Project ):LOCATlON OF PROJECT SITE: AlWW adjacent to Shoreline Dr. East, between Mary's Creek and Turtle Creek, in Sunset Beach. Photo Index - 1989:' ~?,"~,N:-O; 3-10 ,State 'Plane Coordinates .;.X: 2176600 1984: 8-68, O-Q, Y: 55400 D ~,. ,., @ 7y.~..m.'. r"'~""-"'" , JAN 2 3 L~=""."......,,,.. ,,' WHLPtNDSGrmiirl -._~, ~JATER UAL/TY sr:Ci'iCN .'....! C~,&D&F A:,:,;~',:'i/ INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDUREi'Dates of Site Visit - 11-27-95 Was Applicant Present - 5. PROCESSING PROCEDURE: Application Received - 11-29-95 Office - Wilmington ,7. HABITAT DESCRIPTION: [AREA] DRm2GED FlIT 1m QTHER .. , , , .. , (A) Vegetated'Wetlands " " .1., (B) Non-Vegetated Wetlands 2.~acres Shallow bottom (C) Other 15.6 acres Spoil Area " " ~ (D) Total Area Disturbed: 18.5 acres (E) Primary Nursery Area: YES <F,') Water Classification: SA Open: Closed , P~OJECT SUMI.\1ARY: The riparian property owners adjacentto the AlWW, in the area ktlown as Jink',s Creek, have petitioned the'Town of SunsetBeach, to apply for the necessary permits to dredge a channel, parallel to the waterway. between Mary's Creek and Turtle Creek, to provide boating access to their property. I i,.I,.' Page 2 , . .,.. o ECTDESCRIPTION tsite is on the north side of the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway, adjacent to one existing d 24 private residences or residential lots, on Shoreline Drive East and Hickory and Stokes . Sunset Beach, in Brunswick County, North Carolina. The property owners have petitioned ", nof Sunset Beach, to apply for the necessary pennits to dredge a channel, parallel to the ,;.W#t$l1Vay, between Mary' 2?-d Turtle Creek, to provide boating access to their property. The Jltojectarea consists of ',' "';a, 30 acre ~a of coastal mars~ and shallow bottom, with. three " ' ~ along the shore , were ongmally natural drainage features from the adjacent '. 'darea,but none of them are n ,ore.than several hundred yards long and all of them dead end ~,:'(:':~;;!i'i.;!~.eleyated(;ulverts on either Nt '\" ":~tqr Shoreline Drive East. Mary's Creek, to the west, has "';jite\rlouslybeen dredged (State permitU2411l:pto access Bill's Seafood Market and Restaurant located , at the corner of the above referenced s~~;!Y Turtle Creek, on the east side of the project, was tiginaUy excavated to create'a canal, from Shoreline Dr. E. tO,the AIWW. Maintenance dredging, on i~ southern half of that channel, was completed in 1987 (State Pennit #73-87). Jink's Creek, located 1ntb.~c~Ilter of the project area islittle more than a marsh cove, with a narrow channel, 3-6 feet wide, IU1lni1ig through the, Smooth Cordgrass (Spartina alterniflora) marsh. There is a border of Smooth 'Cordgrass along the entire length of the proposed project's shoreline, ranging in width from 20 to 70 feet. At, it's transition to high ground, this regularly flooded' wetland border is fringed with high marsh species, including; Saltwart (Salicorniaspp.), Sea Lavender CLimonium, spp.), Sea Oxeye CBorrichia .' friitescens), and Salt Meadow Grass (Spartinapatens).W aterward of the shoreline's marsh fringe there is an unvegetated shallow water flat that is',basically dry at low water. The applicants report that a channel was dredged through this area ip. 1972, however, no documentation was included in this application. An island-like expanse of Smooth Cordgrass marsh, 50 to 280 feet wide, separates this area from the open water of the AIWW. The waters in the project area are classified SA., by the NC Division of Environmental Management, and are CLOSED to the harvest of shellfish. The area is designated as a Primary Nursery Area (PNA) by the NC Division6fMarine Fisheries. The 'Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway is approximately 500 feet wide at this location. The applicants propose to excavate aU-shaped channelfroril theAIWW at Mary's Creek, then parallel to the shoreline through the shallow water flat, and return to the waterway at Turtle Creek. The channel would be 2875 feet long and 30 ft. wide, ex;c~t it would expand to a 40 ft. width through the corners where the channel turns parallel to the shoreline:'The ,proposed d~th is -8 feet at Jv!LW. The applicants predict that the side slope stabilization of the' 30-40 feet qox cut would produce a 55-65 feet top width of the channel. The excavation would be, done by hydntulicdredge, and the excavated material pumped to an existing spoils disposal area located directly across the waterway. The diked disposal area is approximately 1700 feet long and 400 feet wide. 10. ANTICIPATED IlVIPACTS t: The proposed project would disturb approxirnately,127, 125 square feet (2. 9 acres) of shallow water bottom in Primary Nursery Area. There would be s9me short-tenn turbidity associated with the dredging activity. Approximately 30,000 cubic yald~ of spoil material would generated from the channel , exsavation, and deposited over a 680,000 square feet(15.6 acres) hi~hground disposal site. Although ".',;' t. nset' B,each/Jink's Creek Dredging Project d channel has been aligned to avoid coastal marsh, if the projected top channel width has areas of the adjacent Smooth Cordgrass marsh may be impacted by '\oEes.,,~The project would provide better boating access for 24 private us"s~,:;, , \; , :L'~~\: .i,,',~. ,,; ...... l;>,'t;. ;Submitt~dby:E.F. Brooks Date: 12/13/95 Office: Wilmington ". ~-; ., . ~ t ~~ICATION ,,{(fO'be CO~:plcied by all applicants) , -, b. City. town. community or landmark sunset Beach "~ ~',~ ~ ji'<0,7'-W: '", i'0. 1 P, \ \~"C,~\l'V! II \'j~ \, \. ' . "\ ~\, .. . .... ..... - . c. W~s:~~"t~:; ~~~"la:ad DUmber J.1\J3 NOV., 13 1995 J'~ d. Is proposed work within city limits or planning ~;''J'::ION OF jurisdiction? X Yes No COASTAL MANAGEMENT . e. Name of body of water nearest project (e.g. river. creek. sound. bay) Jink's Cr2ek '-:,',' . . ',,";;"'''':.,'' : . 'AP~Lt,(:ANT ,e c1. ' I ~O,wner: ",," "Y': 1 ,arne': PublicTrust .". Ad.dress 'ii>: .F~t~f": ' ".'1...',.,' r. ' t'."':'zIp'i ' State .;,' Day Phone , 3. DESCRIPTION AND pLANNED USE OF PROPOSED PROJECT Fax b. Authorized Agent: 'i,c; a. List all development activities ~u" propose (e.g. building a home. motel. aiarlna. bulkhead, pier, and excavation and/or filling activities. Maintenance dredqinq of the channel in Jink I s creek, as shown on the plans. Name TO\m ,of Sunset Beach Address 220 Shoreline Drive, West' ' Sunset Beach State NC City Zip 2R468 Day Phone (910) 519-62<3:7'; , b. Is the proposed activity maintenance of an existing project, new work, or both? Maintl:mance Fax (910) 579-1840 , c. Will the project be for public. private or commercial use? Public c. Project name (if any) Sunset Beach Dredging Project " NOTE: Pcfrtrit wiU b~ issued in tlCUfI< ,ofl4ndowner(s), and/or project _me. d. Give a brief description of purpose. use, methods of coastrUction and daily operations of proposed project. If more spaCe is needed. please attach additional pages. Provide access to ad j acent property from waterway. .'; 2. L.oCA'rION' .oF PROPOSED pR.OJECT ,a.Courlty '.Bruns't..riclc .' ,~\ TL:;-; /:-~-:1!j", TI';~?'-'-::-,:' ~\ ~ ~t~~' '- ,.'.." J~J ,...' \ )) ll\~) NOV 1 3 1995 ~/ '., ,,:~'~iJ'_, Uli ;':';ONOF q,l. Oescribe existing wastewater treatment facilities. T~D""'j, ~i.,," l' ~'f\ilA'NAGr-ll;\C:.\l-'. . ,....'",(;,'.',.,...,:,,'.;...:,i,;,.i. 'A ;..'.,.,:..'.,;J;\..,..,'..~e~.''''" " . ". Not' a"ol1cable , '.' '!(iW:ERlST'CS '- ' ':_:,:.'j:~;:;~f'::-d'<<":", . ,.:i. A"Onrnx., 10;::!("rpc:: c. 'Appibfimate elevation .()f tt'aa aboveMH'W or t-lWJ",." -1 MSL \~1i~, ' .'. ' d. s;-i' e(s) and tex.ture(s) of tract )3' ,cket s~lty clay loam :-.,,',:....., . e. ''1~getation on tract Marsh grass . I;. '" ',f:,<lff4I1....made features now on tract Piers and ,;.,., docks. .. - ,- " ,. ~- ,':}f;t:. ..... '-. 1,- g. What is the CAMA."L:and~ Use?lan ]a:nd classification of the site?"~ ~ fD'azr IaNJ use plan.) ----. --." ~ .....- ...'----_-."._~..:.._,--.- _---..~---.........,:--" ,", /I '. ".r. Conservation Transitional . i~' ------ I' .. " ,'rDev'eloped' .' -::"~7' 'X co_nity _ Rurai"..' ,d;, ' '~ ,. ".. Oth~, .. ; ,. -, ~ .." .... " . ." h. How is thetiact~n'edby'local government? Residential' -, 1. Is the proposed project co nsistent with the applicable zoning? ~ Yes _No..', (Attach zoning compJi.aTltx cir;njicate, ifapplia:zb~) j. Has a professional archaeological assessment been done for the tract? . :..y es' ,x No ----- -. --HIf yes? by' whom?...-..~ - ... " ,k. Is the' projealoCated iI1:_' a National Registered ", Historic Distrid',O'c does it involve a National ," '. Register 'listed or\;rigibre-property! '-,..._'~'~e:.:~:::~l,.~~'~~1~,:; ; , " '~ . --- --...:....._, ;".. "~ l. . Are'there wetlands on the site? X Yes _ No Toasut.(marsh) 'J{'. _.. Other - -If yes; has a delineation' been conducted? Yes lAtrad1tkJcwncnuziion. if awrilabk) " ~ . ~'.; ,;. ", '~.' n. Describe location and type of discharges to waters of the state. (For example, surface runoff, sanitary wastewater, industrial/commercial effluent, "wash down" and residential discharges.) Not aonlicable ,0. Describe existing drinking water supply source. Not aoplicabl e 5~ ADDITIONAL INFOR.i\1ATION In addition to the completed. application formy the following items must be submitted: " .' ' . , '..." ,i: ".' A copy ,or ~e deed (with state application only) or other instrument under which the applicant claims title to the affected properties. If the appI'icant is not ' ._daiming t~ _.bethe owner of said property, then forward a copy of the deed or other instrUment under whi<:h the owner claims title, plus written permission from the owner to c:Jrr':f out the project. , '-'. ..,. '. , ,Nt_.a~r..a-te, ~~e4 work plat (including plan view , ,and cross-sectional drawings) drawn to scale in black ink on an 8 1/2" by 11" white paper. (Refer to Co:istal Resources C<:'mmission Rule 71.0203 for a detailed description.) . ,":':~:--~-.'::{ . ..,. ..:",.' .,q. ...., Please' note that original drawings ~: preferred and '". only high- qualitY cop~es will be a~te.d~_'-.'J?!tie..lin~ , 'prints or ather larger :plats are accepubr~ 'amy' if, an: , adequate number.' of quality copies arep'roytg~,',!>f, appl~c:ult. (Contact the U .S. Army':::'Co~S(~!: Engtneers regarding' that agency's use, of, ~ger drawings.) A site or lo~tion, map is a part of plat, requirements and it must be sufficientl'j detailed to guide ~get1cy personnel unfamiliar with the area to the .':1,0,:; W)IECC1E:TIVlEJr'n ~~~\JNOV 131995 W '\ 'D1VISIUN ur highway or~eCondaryC@~1S'tt,MANAGI=Mt:1\IT 'k:.s, and the like. "6. CERTIFICATION AND PERl\1lSSION TO ENTER ON LAND . A list of previous state or federal permits iSsued for , work on the project tract. Include permit numbers, permittee, and issuing dates. Original Permit - 1972; East entrance to creek - March 10, 1987 by R.S~ 'Adams; West entrance to creek - October, 1, 19A7 by Joe Peed. .. Certification, if orieis necessary. :~ . A list tie names and compleH~~ddresses .of the adja~twaterfront (riparian) La.h'doWnerSand sign~ return receipts as proofllth.atsuch ()wnef"S -'rtrf' hav'T:~ved a copy of the application~d plats by ~lied mail., Such landowners mustb~~\ti;ed th~(they have 30 days in which to submitc6rnments on;;~e proposed project to the Division of Coastal '~;n~gement. Upon signing this Jorm,the, applicant 'm~er certifies.that such notice has been provided. " ..t,":",. ,~jfue See Attached List ,',~ddress Phone 'Name Address phone Name Address Phone ;', ,'" ,. A check ror $250 made payable to the Department of .' Environment. Health. and Natural Resources (DEHNR) to' cover the costs. of processing the 'appIi~tion_' . ' :..1'." ......-.-. ,:'~ '~-~~> . A s~tement oCcompliance with the N.C. Environmental Policy Act (N.C.G~S. 113A - 1 to ,lO)If,~~Pl'()ject involves the expenditure of public .,fund's'dr: use, of public lands, attach ,a statement 'do<:4menting compliance with the North Carolina Environmental Policy Act. 1 understand that any permit issued in respO~~tO this-<~;-j application will allow only the development described in.",' , ,the application. The project will be subject to'conditio~'i"~ anO restrictions coDtained ;"1 the permit. ,-;,: ,. ",'C '. I ~fy that to. the ~t of my knowledge~ the: Pr?~sed actIVIty compltes WIth the State of North Carolina"s:." approved Coastal Management Pro~~_~~;rilr"b~'::: .~.nducted in a manner consistent with sucli~;o~:;;~t' ." ,.'.. , .~:'il ~ ", ,::-o'~i.L._ II certify that I am authorized to gran~':';"~:6ct~:_.: ':,grant permission to representatives 51! , iiit'j: .. :!:,;~:~~ to:.;::r.,: ':f:~ . '~ permit application. and, foIIow .>I'>'F,! - :~;' Proiect ' , ~:';;~;~~itt~ :J . ,,:'~'::-"('~"iJ" '~:',~'~' :;,;~~~:.,~:;~~~~":., I . further' certify that;~~~ti:f6~o application is truthfutro the'best.'~f'm '.':<,[1jl1-ij~~!f~; This is the ~ day' ~f .~ No j'.,'~~ . ..l,...'..Fi'~~i~t.,; Print Name ,,' "" ..,(. .. ..t_~",'.:~.>~-:~~ L DeM MP.2 Ex~~Ott,~~ , .;,......... OCMMP-3 Upland. Dev,c;19 m ~' OeM. MP-4- StrUc:arr-~iIJfi]; ...:.- 'DCM MP-5 Bridges.'arKfCu'N _ DCM MP~ Marina: De.Veiopri1~t.~., ' ~ " ..:: '-.--: <'....:.,.~:~(ff~,:~1~ __. NOTE: Please sign and dare eacfraaachmenr in: the space provided ar the bocrom of eacfr fonn. . I .\,. :<1'1, ~':"~; }. Ul -"'l;,!' UJ ~'~1'~ 1 t. . ~':f'; .',:;1\, 'k , , ,': ~ ~, . ~it' 'i;' ,,~ ~~, .o- r :.~ J~. " , ~f;\~j 1";\ ' H,' .;,'1.;..., t,'.', to, ';"'1'" ti;'tfri , r.l' ~,)- . (-.-. .."..,{. ~ f'l.t, ' ,.,"11 'f : i~~ 1 .~~' .... !: 'i< z o ~ ~ ..""".., .~ ;:$' ~",~ ~""i "'0 c: " ,,~ ' ~.~~t. ~..~ ~ ~'.I . . ~ . . ~:"-' ~ _' VI, o -t .-- .=~, -5<:' ~ ,,', ~~s .~~'~ <81! u .~ ~9-S ~ v c:: ~ g o =' .- ._ \II ~ ~ V U u' n'\ .- . - .... ..- _ 0. 0. c- o. .< <..... ... Po c:: .S ~'o o I '""' '""' "" oU , o.,c.-s ... U . ~'o ..... tJ t: 0 oU '0", r:: 111.',0 lf4 t: c: ~ ~;:!~S tij~,:~ . 4), l\) ... ...' V,T'Vl .....- "'"0 ~. r:: b 0. P t: ~,:' 0 oU-.;:lw <0..00; ~ Q o c:: o .~ 5 · , ~ ,]1 1J~ \II'" &~u e .~ 0. t>I) ..... ~ 0.0 ~ S e.~ =' :) 0.-; V > .s'::: ~' ..( o . Q) ~ .D- .- :nf~;: ~~:;;, .c,~,., u') V?'.. i)' ::: Ct l:: , ~ . N ~,.g .'.~' ].", g sE lIlt :~ ~. ~ -< ' : I ~ ! 1 ~' :00 (Yl~ .g ;- '~ to J,,: ;r- ~ ,co ,N : ~ ~ - .. ; oU 0 :: ! ti ,~,~ , ,I -< '5 ~ t- . . ~ ia ~. Ul , " ,',j' -d , ' c:: .,;,,'- ~ ~ ,CO .Q 0.1 ~'el CO , c:: ~ I- . U 0 -0'"' ; ~ llA) I . ;u ... ......,if't ': " :t .w.~', g '"' '" ",~.If' ; c " 0 ;" .~.(~ _ I.. ]i]. g~ t ~ rl . :/1' t ' ~ ;.1 (, ...,~":":