Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDuke_DanRiver_AshBasin_CCR_SoilSampling_TechMemo_20190816(> DUKE ENEnNt�%v%,.7 August 16, 2019 North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality Division of Waste Management Attn: Mr. Ed Mussler 217 W. Jones Street Raleigh, NC 27603 3195 Pine Hall Road Belews Creek, NC 27009 Subject: Ash Basin Closure Soil Sampling Metals Analysis, Dan River Steam Station Dear Mr. Mussler: In general accordance with the CCR Surface Impoundments Closure Guidelines for Protection of Groundwater provided by the Division of Water Resources on November 4, 2016, Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (DEC) has completed the removal of CCR at the Dan River Steam Station. On July 31, 2019, Duke Energy provided the CCR Visual Removal Verification Report, which included visual observation of CCR removal and the PLM sampling results. The attached technical memorandum provides the results of the ash basin closure soil sampling that was completed concurrently with the visual observations and PLM sampling. If you have any questions or need any clarification regarding the information provided, please contact me at melonie.martin@duke-energy.com or (336) 445-0610. Respectfully submitted, } Melonie Martin Lead Environmental Specialist — EHS Groundwater & Waste Programs Attachment: Closure Soil Sampling Summary Technical Memorandum L� synTerra TECHNICAL MEMORANDUM Date: August 15, 2019 File: 1026.19 To: Melonie Martin (Duke Energy) Cc: Matt Craig (SynTerra) Jerry Wylie (SynTerra) From: Erin Kinsey (SynTerra) Subject: Closure Soil Sampling Summary Dan River Steam Station — Eden, NC SynTerra performed soil sampling at the Duke Energy Dan River Steam Station (Dan River, the Site) during 2019. Sampling was conducted in areas of formerly deposited ash to characterize Site conditions after ash was removed from the former ash basins. The sample collection was conducted in accordance with the "Excavation Soil Sampling Plan, Dan River Steam Station Ash Basin System," Rev. 2, dated December 2018, developed by Duke Energy and submitted to and approved by the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality (NCDEQ). The project entailed conducting soil boring operations by direct -push technology (DPT) methods and equipment to obtain soil samples on a one -acre grid within the ash basins. Soil samples were collected at 52 locations across the Site. Within each one -acre grid, soil samples were collected at five (5) depth intervals to a maximum depth of 17.0-17.5 feet below ground surface (bgs), unless the water table or rock was encountered. NC licensed well drillers performed the soil boring operations and properly abandoned the borings upon completion. SynTerra personnel provided soil boring operations oversight, including coordinating field activities with Dan River personnel, selecting boring locations, logging soil sample descriptions, and performing soil sampling. Soil samples were analyzed for total inorganics and synthetic precipitation leaching procedure (SPLP) analyses. This memorandum provides a summary of soil sample analytical results. CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING AND ANALYSIS Due to the sequential process of final ash excavation and dewatering, the Dan River closure soil sampling occurred during four mobilization events: • April 17-18, 2019 • May 14-15, 2019 • May 22-23, 2019 • June 20, 2019 P: \ Duke Energy Carolinas \ 19. DAN RIVER \ How Clean is Clean - Ash Basin \ Solid Waste Submittal \ Dan River Closure Soil Sampling Tech Memo_8-13-19.docx Ash Basin Closure Soil Sampling Summary August 15, 2019 Dan River Steam Station Page 2 of 2 A total of 280 basin closure ("BC-" or "NC-") soil sample locations were designated as part of the Site half -acre grid system for visual ash verification, polarized light microscopy (PLM) sampling, and analytical analysis in accordance with the sampling plan. Analytical sampling was performed at fifty two (52) locations. Samples were not collected at eight (87) locations where ash was never historically deposited, as shown on Figure 1. Soil samples were collected from a total of 52 'BC-" or "NC-" locations, meeting the sampling plan protocol to collect one soil sample for each acre of excavated ash basin at the Site (approximately 53 acres). Figure 1 shows the half -acre grid system and soil sample locations for each acre. At locations where borings were drilled, soil samples were collected from the following five (5) intervals for laboratory analyses, unless the water table or rock was encountered: 0 0 to 0.5 feet bgs, • 2 to 2.5 feet bgs, • 7 to 7.5 feet bgs, • 12 to 12.5 feet bgs, and • 17 to 17.5 feet bgs. Soil samples were submitted to the Duke Energy Analytical Laboratory for total inorganics and SPLP analyses. Table 1 and Table 2 provide the basin closure soil sample analytical results. Notes for Table 1 and Table 2 are provided in Table 3. Evaluation of analytical data is not provided in this technical memorandum. It is anticipated that evaluation of the soil sampling data will be included in the forthcoming Corrective Action Plan (CAP) Update or assessment update for the Site. LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1— Basin Closure Soil Sampling Location Map LIST OF TABLES Table 1— Closure Soil Sample Analytical Results — Total Inorganics Table 2 — Closure Soil Sample Analytical Results — SPLP Table 3 — Closure Soil Sample Analytical Results — Notes P: \ Duke Energy Carolinas \ 19. DAN RIVER \ How Clean is Clean - Ash Basin \ Solid Waste Submittal \ Dan River Closure Soil Sampling Tech Memo_8-13-19.docx I II II II i i i >,r,' FORMER SECONDARY ASH BASIN � �� ` •� � � � � e � �'%'/ / it � / // FORMER PRIMARY ASH BASIN /l \ 1 r IV � � �� LEGEND 10 / f CLEARED SAMPLE LOCATION \ NO ASH HISTORICALLY PLACED ASH WASTE BOUNDARY ,1111pp- GRAPHIC SCALE ✓ep / / /'F pP� %' DUKE 150 0 150 300 ENERGY IN FEET FIGURE 1 DRAWN BY: C. NEWELL DATE: 7/30/2019 CAROLINAS REVISED BY: C.NEWELL DATE:7/30/2019 BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE LOCATION MAP CHECKEDBY:E.KINSEY DATE: 7/30/2019 TOTAL METALS AND SPLP LOCATIONS APPROVED BY: E. KINSEY DATE: 7/30/2019PROJECT MANGER: E. KINSEY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION LAYOUT: FIGURE (METALS AND SPLP) EDEN, NORTH CAROLINA S�/r1Te www.synterracorp.com TABLE 1 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - TOTAL INORGANICS ASH BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING SUMMARY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC Sample ID Associated Unit Sample Media Depth Interval (Feet BGS) Sample Collection Date Percent Solids pH Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Barium Beryllium Boron Cadmium Calcium Chloride Chromium (VI) Chromium Cobalt Copper Iron Lead Magnesium Manganese Mercury Molybdenum Nickel Nitrate (as N) Potassium Selenium Silver Sodium Strontium Sulfate Thallium Vanadium Zinc BC-02D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 83.3 6.2 22000 <0.49 2.3 120 0.98 <2.5 0.031 j 1900 2.2 j 0.59 j 34 11 19 24000 7.3 3700 380 <0.098 <2 20 <0.24 2000 0.74 j <0.25 63 j 19 160 0.25 56 49 BC-02D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 82 6.5 23000 <0.52 0.65 130 1 <2.6 0.04 j 1600 3.1 j 0.47 j 33 12 18 25000 7.8 3800 480 <0.098 <2.1 21 0.14 j 1900 0.61 j <0.26 73 j 13 74 0.23 57 50 BC-02D (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 78.7 6.5 31000 <0.56 0.82 160 1.3 2.4 j 0.041 j 1800 4.3 j 0.33 j 45 15 5.1 31000 11 4400 570 <0.097 <2.2 26 0.16 j 2100 0.87 j <0.28 91 j 15 63 0.32 70 63 BC-02D (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 77 6.6 21000 <0.57 0.49 j 120 0.87 <2.9 0.041 j 1600 5.4 j 0.44 j 32 11 20 25000 6.4 4000 350 <0.098 <2.3 20 0.15 j 2000 <1.5 <0.29 66 j 11 70 0.22 1 60 49 BC-02D (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 75.4 5.9 19000 <0.45 0.47 100 0.74 2.7 0.037 j 1500 6.2 j 0.31 j 29 10 22 22000 5.9 3700 320 <0.1 <1.8 18 0.16 j 2100 0.55 j <0.22 84 j 10 79 0.23 51 46 BC-04B (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 87 5.3 19000 <0.42 1.6 87 1.5 <6.4 0.03 j 820 7.3 j 0.35 j 46 9.3 23 51000 16 1700 280 <0.089 2.7 24 <0.23 1200 0.44 j <0.21 57 j 14 41 0.13 42 43 BC-04B (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 88 6.0 22000 <0.46 2.8 130 1.2 <7 0.028 j 1400 4.1 j 0.34 j 37 11 27 37000 13 2800 390 <0.091 0.86 j 29 <0.23 1600 <1.2 <0.23 60 j 22 <11 0.13 38 54 BC-04B (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 94.3 5.8 12000 <0.4 4.4 73 0.54 <2 0.038 j 1800 2.9 j 0.25 j 13 5.3 6.7 17000 18 2400 300 <0.084 <1.6 11 <0.21 530 0.43 j <0.2 48 j 28 18 0.028 j 40 28 BC-04C (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 86.6 6.3 39000 <0.48 0.88 250 1.6 2.1 j 0.085 j 1700 7.5 j 0.7 j 53 49 38 42000 29 4000 2800 <0.086 <1.9 40 0.39 B 2500 0.87 j <0.24 100 j 22 66 0.4 76 74 BC-04C (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 82.8 6.3 44000 <0.46 1.1 220 1.5 <6.9 0.068 j 1900 7.6 j 0.92 j 60 26 44 51000 17 5100 1500 <0.099 <1.8 44 0.68 B 1900 1.1 j <0.23 110 j 21 60 0.35 110 90 BC-04C (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 80 6.4 38000 <0.48 0.76 130 1.2 <4.8 0.055 j 1800 5.1 j 0.49 j 77 13 30 38000 11 4200 290 <0.1 <1.9 34 <0.25 1500 0.89 j <0.24 93 j 18 27 0.24 83 68 BC-04C (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 79.8 6.3 36000 <0.53 0.98 140 1.3 <5.3 0.076 j 1900 3.2 j 0.63 j 59 17 29 40000 12 4500 460 <0.094 <2.1 33 <0.25 1600 0.84 j <0.26 99 j 19 <13 0.27 89 69 BC-04E (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 86.8 6.0 27000 <0.47 0.56 130 1.2 <4.7 0.031 j 1100 2.7 j 0.55 j 39 16 5 29000 8.9 4400 620 <0.084 <1.9 23 0.14 j 2000 0.82 j <0.24 60 j 11 49 0.28 64 56 BC-04E (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 83.3 6.1 28000 <0.5 0.66 170 1.3 <5 0.039 j 1300 4.2 j 0.41 j 39 14 4.5 29000 9.5 4600 560 <0.093 <2 25 0.14 j 2200 0.9 j <0.25 72 j 12 42 0.29 66 60 BC-04E (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 78.1 6.1 27000 <0.55 0.61 140 1 <5.5 0.045 j 1300 4.3 j 0.52 j 39 14 5.4 30000 8.4 4900 440 <0.11 <2.2 26 0.15 j 2500 0.65 j <0.27 66 j 10 73 0.3 73 62 BC-04E (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 74.2 6.8 20000 <0.48 0.55 99 0.75 <2.4 0.048 j 2100 3.6 j 0.37 j 30 11 18 23000 5.9 3800 350 <0.11 0.62 j 18 0.16 j 1900 0.55 j <0.24 77 j 12 83 0.21 57 47 BC-04E (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 77.2 7.2 11000 <0.44 0.22 j 49 0.42 <2.2 0.041 j 1500 4.8 j 0.36 j 20 5.7 8.4 14000 3.5 2100 220 <0.11 4.6 9.7 0.14 j 1000 <1.1 <0.22 70 j 10 140 0.1 j 33 25 BC-04F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 87.7 8.1 18000 <0.5 0.65 97 0.81 1.8 j 0.033 j 1800 2.1 j 0.46 j 28 10 15 21000 6.3 3300 350 <0.093 3.5 17 0.13 j,M 2500 <1.3 <0.25 65 j 54 96 0.2 45 42 BC-04F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 88.3 7.7 16000 <0.48 9 100 0.73 2.4 0.04 j 2600 2.1 j 0.39 j 25 8.4 12 18000 5.4 3100 340 <0.093 <1.9 14 0.12 j 2200 1.1 j <0.24 76 j 65 91 0.17 43 38 BC-04F (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 82.6 8.1 22000 <0.45 24 130 1.1 3.4 j 0.045 j 2100 2.9 j 0.25 j 33 11 18 23000 8.1 3700 440 <0.096 0.7 j 20 0.16 j 2600 2.1 0.059 j 71 j 53 72 0.23 58 50 BC-04F (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 78.6 8.2 41000 0.56 j 39 220 1.7 5.4 j 0.11 j 6200 4.2 j 0.39 j 54 20 38 41000 14 5300 830 0.031 j <2.3 35 0.24 j 4000 12 <0.29 91 j 110 29 0.41 160 82 BC-04F (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 76.8 7.7 27000 <0.46 0.76 150 1.1 2.2 j 0.069 j 2600 5.4 j 0.43 j 35 12 23 28000 10 4300 610 <0.1 9.1 22 0.17 j 2400 0.86 j <0.23 65 j 28 31 0.3 63 60 BC-06C (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 82.7 7.5 38000 <0.52 5.5 200 1.5 4.4 j 0.041 j 2900 4.3 j 0.26 j 54 14 37 48000 12 4800 530 <0.096 0.99 j 36 0.31 B 1900 1.2 j <0.26 140 j 47 61 0.29 98 75 BC-06C (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 79.3 6.7 39000 M <0.52 M 0.67 M 150 1.2 3.3 j 0.04 j 2000 5 j 0.27 j 61 M 21 M 31 43000 M 10 5300 M 340 M <0.1 <2.1 M 32 0.32 B 1300 0.95 j <0.26 140 j 20 39 0.24 98 77 BC-06C (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 78.8 6.5 37000 <0.58 0.82 110 1.1 7.2 0.049 j 2000 6.1 j 0.61 j 51 19 31 43000 8.6 4900 750 <0.1 <2.3 31 <0.25 1700 0.75 j <0.29 87 j 20 63 0.28 86 71 BC-06C (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 75.3 6.4 30000 <0.47 0.21 j 96 0.95 1.6 j 0.1 j 2000 7.1 j 0.36 j 62 16 30 19000 7.4 4700 280 <0.098 <1.9 29 0.35 B 2400 0.57 j <0.24 70 j 16 32 0.25 77 80 BC-06E (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 91.7 7.3 34000 <0.44 13 180 1.4 7.4 0.041 j 2300 2.9 j 0.52 j 43 17 34 36000 13 3800 710 <0.085 2.5 26 0.42 B 2500 1.5 <0.22 83 j 55 47 0.37 73 58 BC-06E (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 84.5 7.3 44000 <0.5 2.3 170 1.4 11 0.04 j 2000 <12 0.43 j 48 18 36 46000 14 3800 570 0.041 j 18 29 <0.24 2900 1.2 j <0.25 60 j 68 12 0.4 94 71 BC-06E (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 76.1 6.6 41000 <0.48 8 180 1.4 8.4 0.045 j 2800 3.7 j 0.39 j 48 16 35 44000 12 4100 520 0.032 j 7.4 29 0.13 j 2600 1.3 <0.24 73 j 64 68 0.35 87 65 BC-06E (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 74.1 7.1 18000 0.22 j 0.41 j 110 0.9 6.5 0.048 j 1800 6.2 j 0.4 j 33 8.3 19 22000 6.1 3400 290 <0.1 2.2 18 0.17 j 3300 1 j <0.26 45 j 83 54 0.2 64 51 BC-06G (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 90.1 7.0 12000 <0.45 61 93 0.64 1.2 j 0.03 j 2500 1.8 j 0.35 j 21 6.7 10 14000 4.4 2300 240 <0.09 <1.8 11 0.11 j 1500 2.5 <0.23 59 j 46 130 0.2 37 26 BC-06G (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 87.2 8.3 15000 <0.52 0.45 j 85 0.72 1.7 j 0.031 j 1500 1.8 j 0.31 j 23 8.4 11 17000 5 3100 300 <0.094 <2.1 14 <0.23 M 2100 2.5 <0.26 59 j 37 32 0.16 52 37 BC-06G (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 82.8 8.2 23000 0.52 8 120 1 2.9 0.047 j 3900 4.2 j 0.45 j 32 12 19 25000 8.5 4000 460 <0.095 <2 21 <0.24 2800 6.9 <0.25 77 j 66 80 0.25 110 50 BC-06G (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 79.6 8.2 30000 M 0.67 M 9.1 160 1.2 6.8 0.057 j 3200 4 j 0.33 j 37 14 26 33000 M it 4400 M 500 M <0.1 0.53 j,M 25 0.14 j 3500 15 <0.21 78 j 68 46 0.3 120 M 60 BC-06G (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 71.2 8.2 36000 1.1 9.6 210 1.4 4.8 j 0.085 j 5900 8 j <1.4 49 17 32 37000 13 5600 710 <0.11 0.95 j 31 0.22 j 4400 19 <0.33 150 j 95 55 0.39 170 80 BC-08C (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 79.6 10.0 36000 <0.55 4.6 170 1.7 5.4 0.036 j 15000 6.4 j 0.56 j 43 13 33 26000 13 3200 330 <0.1 0.93 j 26 0.38 2100 1.2 j <0.28 110 j 52 22 0.34 69 54 BC-08C (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 75.7 6.4 37000 <0.54 3.2 170 1.7 5 0.03 j 12000 6.5 j 0.36 j 44 17 33 26000 18 2900 700 <0.098 <2.2 27 0.14 j 2100 0.89 j <0.27 110 j 45 130 0.33 71 53 BC-08C (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 75.9 5.6 16000 <0.5 <0.5 59 0.58 2 j <0.13 480 13 0.32 j 32 11 18 10000 5.7 1900 75 <0.098 <2 16 0.141 1300 0.55 j <0.25 <250 6.1 58 0.14 60 38 BC-08C (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 83.6 6.3 18000 <0.42 <0.42 160 1.7 2.5 j 0.025 j 1700 6.6 j <1.2 26 7.4 11 37000 24 2300 220 <0.098 <1.7 19 0.15 j 4300 0.63 j <0.21 73 j 14 19 0.33 28 57 BC-08C (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 90.5 6.5 18000 <0.42 <0.42 120 1.6 2.2 j 0.038 j 2600 5 j <1.1 15 11 25 34000 19 4100 670 <0.091 <1.7 23 0.14 j 3100 0.69 j <0.21 64 j 20 12 0.19 19 71 BC-08E (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 75.5 5.8 45000 <0.57 0.93 200 1.7 4.7 j 0.072 j 2000 7.3 j 0.53 j 62 18 42 50000 15 5900 770 0.032 j <2.3 43 0.13 j 2500 1 j <0.29 100 j 22 120 0.35 120 85 BC-08E (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 80.1 6.4 39000 <0.45 0.77 230 1.5 2.7 j 0.044 j 1800 8.1 j 0.5 j 59 16 38 43000 12 5800 550 <0.094 <1.8 38 0.6 B 2400 0.88 j <0.23 110 j 20 80 0.34 95 82 BC-08E (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 73.9 5.7 43000 <0.58 1.2 170 1.7 8.1 j 0.044 j 1500 8 j 0.55 j 62 14 42 66000 13 5200 650 <0.099 <2.3 36 0.46 B 2300 1 j <0.29 99 j 18 130 0.33 120 83 BC-08E (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 74.8 6.2 48000 <0.48 0.55 220 1.7 <7.2 0.082 j 1700 8.8 j 0.86 j 64 18 46 30000 15 5500 160 0.025 j <1.9 35 0.4 B 3300 0.69 j <0.24 110 j 17 32 0.4 110 88 BC-08G (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 78.3 6.6 28000 <0.52 34 160 1.3 3.7 j 0.032 j 2600 <13 0.51 j 35 14 28 28000 11 3700 410 <0.094 1 j 22 0.38 B 2600 2.6 <0.26 120 j 50 <13 0.33 63 54 BC-08G (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 83.5 6.9 30000 <0.5 0.83 140 1 3.4 j 0.047 j 1700 3.8 j 0.62 j 37 13 24 31000 9.4 4100 520 <0.091 <2 23 0.31 B 2600 0.66 j <0.25 79 j 32 21 0.29 60 58 BC-08G (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 82.5 7.2 36000 <0.44 0.86 180 1.2 3.7 j 0.09 j 2100 3 j 0.63 j 45 16 34 37000 11 4800 670 0.022 j 12 29 0.3 B 3200 0.72 j <0.22 86 j 50 11 j 0.34 80 71 BC-08G (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 69.7 7.7 24000 0.23 j 0.62 98 0.75 3 0.056 j 1700 3.6 j 0.36 j 31 10 24 23000 6.5 3100 300 <0.1 1.6 j 21 <0.29 2300 0.64 j <0.27 79 j 46 15 0.21 52 45 BC-10B (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/18/2019 89.7 6.3 26000 <0.46 3.4 190 1.5 2.6 j 0.054 j 2300 5.3 j <1.1 28 11 26 31000 18 5100 480 <0.089 <1.9 24 0.12 j 5000 0.8 j <0.23 110 j 45 37 0.33 40 73 BC-10B (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/18/2019 86.6 5.8 28000 <0.49 0.29 j 190 1.7 2.7 j 0.053 j 2600 4.2 j <1.2 34 20 20 44000 24 7100 730 <0.093 <1.8 31 0.14 j 5900 1.1 j <0.24 110 j 48 23 0.52 36 110 BC-10B (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/18/2019 91 5.9 36000 M <0.39 M <0.39 M 270 1.5 4 j 0.1 2600 1.8 j <1.1 31 16 59 44000 M 13 7400 1800 M <0.091 <1.8 M 31 0.23 8600 M 0.88 j 0.11 j 130 j 37 8.2 j 0.56 36 M 110 BC-10C (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/18/2019 82.6 10.0 29000 0.55 4.7 110 1.1 9.7 <0.13 4500 5.9 j <1.2 31 15 35 34000 7.6 3300 380 <0.091 5.3 22 0.22 j 2600 0.83 j <0.25 63 j 74 150 0.24 120 55 BC-10C (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/18/2019 87.7 7.3 34000 <0.43 <0.43 230 1.9 3.1 j 0.058 j 2300 4.1 j 0.25 j 32 17 46 42000 6.5 7300 1100 <0.085 <1.5 34 0.14 j 6200 1.2 <0.21 78 j 34 13 0.52 42 100 BC-10E (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 04/18/2019 78.7 5.4 48000 <0.57 1.3 160 1.8 6.8 j 0.031 j 1900 9.6 j 0.85 j 70 18 54 53000 13 4900 600 0.048 j 9.4 38 0.13 j 3100 1.5 <0.28 69 j 35 220 0.35 110 87 BC-10E (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 04/18/2019 78.3 5.1 41000 <0.55 0.96 230 1.7 5 j 0.067 j 1700 13 0.58 j 74 53 43 43000 15 4900 770 <0.1 <2.3 37 0.14 j 2400 1.2 j <0.28 56 j 20 160 0.37 100 81 BC-10E (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 04/18/2019 76.7 5.3 33000 <0.55 0.76 170 1.4 3.9 j 0.058 j 1300 13 0.38 j 49 13 35 39000 11 4500 360 0.23 <2 32 0.14 j 2900 0.92 j <0.27 41 j 14 120 0.3 88 73 BC-10E (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 04/18/2019 71 5.3 14000 <0.54 0.36 j 71 0.99 2.9 j 0.035 j 960 12 j <1.4 47 7.8 9.5 29000 5.1 2300 170 <0.11 <2.5 15 0.24 j 1700 0.67 j <0.27 <310 9.4 140 0.13 j 54 32 BC-10G (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 79.1 8.7 36000 <0.6 5.9 160 0.33 2.7 j <0.16 1100 4 j <1.3 32 11 36 39000 17 4200 330 0.034 j <2.4 22 0.24 j 3200 0.81 j <0.3 140 j 29 100 0.29 47 70 BC-10G (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 74.4 6.0 38000 <0.62 6.4 220 0.34 9.5 0.053 j 3400 6.4 j <1.3 47 16 36 39000 14 4500 610 <0.1 <2.5 27 0.24 j 3200 1.3 j <0.31 180 j 44 36 0.38 68 71 BC-10G (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 69.7 5.4 34000 <0.55 1.5 240 0.28 1.9 j 0.097 j 1700 6 j <1.4 53 19 31 36000 14 4300 1400 0.032 j <2.2 28 0.26 j 2400 1.2 j <0.28 120 j 20 8.1 j 0.33 67 70 BC-10G (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 77.7 5.9 23000 <0.49 1.1 150 0.13 1.3 j 0.057 j 900 5.5 j <1.3 46 11 17 34000 5.1 4600 410 <0.1 <1.9 21 0.24 j 5100 <1.3 <0.24 78 j 8.9 <13 0.54 44 68 BC-10I (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 72.7 6.1 35000 M <0.49 M 3.5 170 0.23 M 8.2 0.085 j 2500 6.6 j <1.4 47 19 M 33 36000 M 14 4100 M 1100 M 0.055 j 0.97 j,M 28 0.19 j 2600 M 0.93 j 0.095 j 150 j 54 480 0.35 75 M 67 BC-10I (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 76.3 6.6 25000 <0.45 4 150 0.19 4.6 0.034 j 1500 6 j <1.3 38 10 23 26000 7.5 4200 260 <0.097 <1.8 20 0.3 2700 0.54 j <0.23 130 j 23 78 0.24 49 50 BC-10I (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 77.9 6.4 25000 <0.52 0.43 j 170 0.23 3.3 0.11 j 1200 4 j <1.3 41 11 23 26000 7 4500 390 <0.097 <2.1 22 0.44 1800 0.71 j <0.26 140 j 13 <13 0.29 46 57 BC-10I (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 74.9 5.0 21000 <0.52 2.7 140 0.19 2 j 0.033 j 910 4.8 j <1.3 35 8.7 18 19000 6.6 3800 200 <0.1 <2.1 18 0.2 j 2000 <1.4 <0.26 96 j 11 17 0.19 39 47 BC-12B (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 85.8 8.8 27000 <0.54 18 200 0.24 2.5 j 0.036 j 5400 8.8 j <1.2 32 12 30 32000 14 4000 630 <0.088 <2.2 23 0.48 3400 0.76 j <0.27 130 j 54 130 0.29 42 59 BC-12B (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 84.3 9.6 23000 <0.5 9.3 160 0.2 2.1 j 0.033 j 6000 4.5 j <1.2 24 9.6 20 27000 14 3400 630 <0.093 0.86 j 18 0.34 2300 0.7 j <0.25 120 j 60 130 0.18 47 45 BC-12D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 84.6 7.0 18000 <0.49 0.85 120 0.21 6.5 <0.13 1100 4 j <1.2 33 16 14 19000 13 1200 420 <0.092 2.1 13 1.9 1100 0.47 j <0.25 100 j 24 54 0.18 34 30 BC-12D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 81.7 6.9 17000 <0.44 0.85 160 0.19 3.6 <0.11 1200 6.1 j <1.2 27 12 15 25000 14 2600 1100 <0.098 <1.8 15 0.4 2700 0.41 j <0.22 74 j 16 <12 0.21 28 40 BC-12D (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 81.3 7.0 19000 <0.5 <0.5 140 0.21 1.6 j <0.13 1500 3.4 j <1.2 20 7.9 21 24000 5.7 6400 1000 <0.089 <2 19 0.28 3000 <1.3 <0.25 76 j 25 <12 0.16 34 52 BC-12F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 67.1 5.5 38000 <0.51 1.6 230 0.27 1.4 j 0.061 j 1600 8.2 j <1.5 53 20 33 48000 13 4800 1200 <0.12 <2 32 0.43 2700 1.1 j <0.26 120 j 19 9.1 j 0.38 70 73 BC-12F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 74.1 5.5 18000 <0.59 2.6 100 0.39 <3 0.039 j 1600 6.4 j <1.4 50 20 17 46000 19 1600 1900 0.053 j <2.4 14 0.82 1600 0.61 j <0.3 67 j 13 13 j 0.16 40 38 Page 1 of 3 TABLE 1 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - TOTAL INORGANICS ASH BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING SUMMARY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC Sample ID Associated Unit Sample Media Depth Interval (Feet BGS) Sample Collection Date Percent Solids pH Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Barium Beryllium Boron Cadmium Calcium Chloride Chromium (VI) Chromium Cobalt Copper Iron Lead Magnesium Manganese Mercury Molybdenum Nickel Nitrate (as N) Potassium Selenium Silver Sodium Strontium Sulfate Thallium Vanadium Zinc BC-12F (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 71.5 5.2 11000 <0.64 0.64 94 0.27 <3.2 <0.17 730 6.5 j <1.4 22 5.4 11 11000 6.7 1300 290 <0.12 <2.5 8.8 0.26 j 920 <1.7 <0.32 42 j 9.6 19 0.096 j 23 24 BC-12H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 78.6 5.9 30000 <0.51 9.7 180 0.23 2.7 0.069 j 2400 2.9 j <1.3 41 13 25 34000 9.2 5200 730 <0.098 4.2 26 0.56 3500 0.56 j <0.25 170 j 62 24 0.29 59 66 BC-12H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 78.4 7.8 33000 <0.46 11 190 0.19 2.8 0.065 j 2500 3.9 j 0.36 j 46 13 29 37000 9 5500 740 0.025 j 5.3 30 0.69 3600 0.46 j <0.23 160 j 62 13 0.29 69 70 BC-12H (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 75.1 7.7 33000 <0.5 0.81 150 0.2 2.9 0.051 j 2700 3.8 j <1.3 43 12 28 34000 7.3 5000 540 <0.11 7.5 27 0.26 j 2400 <1.3 <0.25 140 j 67 <13 0.24 66 59 BC-12H (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 73.9 7.5 25000 <0.55 0.73 110 0.25 2.6 j 0.059 j 2100 6.4 j 0.32 j 54 8.9 23 38000 5.1 4300 230 <0.11 <2.2 24 0.45 2200 <1.4 <0.28 120 j 18 23 0.23 61 52 BC-14B (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 97.7 8.7 15000 <0.41 2.8 79 0.11 0.97 j 0.032 j 4400 2.6 j <1 15 6.6 18 21000 12 4500 520 <0.085 <1.7 12 0.33 1700 0.4 j <0.21 110 j 32 48 0.11 23 40 BC-14B (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 92.8 6.9 18000 <0.46 1.2 110 0.16 1.2 j 0.029 j 5000 <11 <1.1 20 7.6 20 21000 5.1 5600 500 <0.078 <1.8 18 0.27 3300 0.44 j <0.23 140 j 38 <11 0.2 24 46 BC-14D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 77.3 5.5 38000 <0.53 11 200 0.21 3 <0.14 1700 13 <1.3 30 7.7 26 33000 12 2700 370 0.036 j 21 19 0.89 3200 <1.4 <0.27 140 j 30 88 0.51 52 62 BC-14D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 84.9 5.1 29000 <0.49 2 190 0.25 1.6 j 0.037 j 1400 7.9 j <1.2 24 16 34 38000 23 5000 1200 <0.092 <1.9 26 0.27 3300 0.52 j <0.24 110 j 22 50 0.26 34 77 BC-14F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 77.2 4.5 35000 M <0.49 M 5.1 100 0.23 M 3.9 0.042 j 910 4.5 j <1.3 52 M 11 M 22 M 33000 M 14 1900 M 270 M 0.049 j <1.8 17 0.41 1600 M 0.58 j <0.25 92 j 13 51 0.57 61 37 BC-14F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 78.6 5.2 33000 <0.58 2.6 150 0.23 1.6 j <0.15 1300 5.3 j <1.3 51 16 24 61000 12 2500 810 <0.1 <2.3 19 0.77 1400 0.8 j <0.29 110 j 19 7.3 j 0.26 56 44 BC-14F (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 79.3 5.7 37000 <0.51 0.75 160 0.24 <2.5 <0.13 1900 8.6 j <1.3 63 7 30 34000 14 4700 200 <0.1 <2 24 0.45 1500 <1.3 <0.25 250 26 <13 0.3 67 66 BC-14F (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 80.2 6.1 26000 <0.57 0.24 j 160 0.17 1.5 j 0.035 j 1600 6.3 j 0.42 j 46 4 19 17000 7.5 3500 110 0.049 j <2.3 20 1 1500 <1.5 0.14 j 100 j 19 17 0.2 41 52 BC-14F (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/23/2019 74.2 6.1 34000 <0.58 1.7 170 0.3 1.2 j <0.15 2000 11 j 0.5 j 50 19 35 26000 10 5700 290 0.029 j <2.3 32 0.63 3400 <1.5 <0.29 110 j 20 13 0.3 86 78 BC-14H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 77.2 5.8 38000 <0.63 2.2 190 0.29 4.1 0.078 j 2300 3.1 j <1.3 51 16 33 40000 14 4800 1100 0.049 j <2.5 27 0.26 3300 1.2 j 0.086 j 140 j 24 19 0.34 72 69 BC-14H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 76.2 6.3 37000 <0.53 0.72 390 0.28 1.8 j 0.13 j 2500 5.3 j <1.3 60 17 33 36000 9.5 6100 1100 <0.098 <2.1 36 0.25 j 3000 0.98 j 0.11 j 160 j 26 17 0.34 67 94 BC-14H (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 80 7.0 38000 <0.47 1 230 0.23 2.5 0.036 j 1800 <12 <1.2 54 12 32 39000 10 5900 630 0.027 j <1.9 31 0.61 3400 0.57 j <0.24 130 j 18 <12 0.35 74 72 BC-14H (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 80.2 6.3 42000 <0.61 1.4 270 0.27 1.3 j 0.064 j 1800 3.4 j 0.3 j 53 19 35 43000 13 6200 1200 <0.089 <2.5 35 0.25 3600 0.61 j <0.31 110 j 19 15 0.38 84 82 BC-14H (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/23/2019 80.9 6.6 33000 <0.44 M 1.2 120 0.19 M 2.4 j 0.046 j 1200 4.8 j 0.27 j 34 13 27 33000 8.3 3800 M 390 M <0.099 <1.9 22 0.22 j 1700 <1.2 <0.22 <240 9.9 16 0.22 66 49 BC-143 (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 82.9 6.7 25000 <0.51 1 210 0.27 3.1 j 0.068 j 2600 4.2 j <1.2 42 13 28 28000 7 4700 630 <0.087 <2.1 25 0.36 1600 0.75 j 0.069 j 100 j 21 <12 0.27 51 60 BC-141 (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 82.5 6.1 36000 <0.48 0.93 210 0.29 4.1 j 0.074 j 1800 3.7 j <1.2 52 16 42 36000 9.4 5200 590 <0.092 <1.9 31 0.34 2300 0.82 j <0.24 120 j 27 42 0.37 76 73 BC-141 (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 81.9 7.1 34000 <0.57 1.3 220 0.31 3.7 j 0.085 j 2300 2.8 j 0.36 j 51 14 32 32000 9.3 5200 680 <0.099 0.92 j 28 0.43 2300 0.68 j <0.28 110 j 34 8.9 j 0.32 75 68 BC-143 (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 80.8 7.2 29000 <0.45 2.2 160 0.24 3.2 j 0.049 j 1800 3.7 j <1.2 37 12 27 31000 7.7 4400 490 <0.1 1.3 j 23 0.43 2500 0.5 j <0.22 72 j 45 15 0.27 61 56 BC-14J (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 80.1 7.4 31000 <0.55 0.98 120 0.24 1.3 j 0.045 j 2300 1.7 j 0.34 j 43 15 25 26000 8.9 4700 650 <0.094 <2.2 24 0.25 1800 0.55 j <0.27 57 j 30 <12 0.3 53 60 BC-16B (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 83.6 6.3 46000 <0.56 1.1 140 0.18 3.4 <0.15 920 5.1 j <1.2 38 3.1 15 21000 17 1800 100 0.057 j <2.2 12 1.4 1600 0.79 j <0.28 120 j 18 170 0.39 53 34 BC-16B (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 81.9 5.5 43000 <0.5 0.99 130 0.14 3 <0.13 990 5.8 j <1.2 34 2.9 17 12000 19 1700 95 0.064 j <2 11 0.36 1400 0.62 j <0.25 140 j 15 73 0.37 43 32 BC-16B (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 82.9 5.1 33000 <0.57 <0.57 310 0.73 <2.8 0.078 j 3200 4.7 j <1.2 34 15 36 35000 9.7 4600 230 <0.087 <2.3 34 0.76 5500 1.5 <0.28 170 j 62 37 0.46 30 85 BC-16B (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 74.9 8.5 34000 <0.6 13 270 0.33 5 0.06 j 17000 6.2 j <1.3 39 14 33 32000 18 3900 530 0.084 j 1 j 25 0.4 3700 1.4 j <0.3 250 j 76 62 0.45 51 55 BC-16D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 85.8 5.3 11000 <0.48 0.28 j 44 0.17 <2.4 <0.12 430 3.1 j <1.2 15 4.9 12 14000 14 1600 210 <0.086 <1.9 7.1 <0.23 690 <1.2 <0.24 73 j 8.2 23 0.053 j 20 21 BC-16D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 90.8 5.0 26000 <0.43 0.71 290 0.27 1.2 j 0.038 j 2000 3.5 j <1.1 23 11 20 36000 25 5200 550 <0.084 <1.7 26 0.18 j 2800 0.63 j <0.21 140 j 27 14 0.11 23 67 BC-16D (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 83.8 5.1 28000 <0.44 0.35 j 220 0.2 1 j 0.028 j 3000 <12 <1.2 25 14 35 41000 22 6700 730 <0.089 <1.8 29 0.28 3000 0.45 j <0.22 170 j 42 13 0.11 23 92 BC-16F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 76.5 5.2 40000 <0.56 1.2 85 0.08 j <2.8 <0.15 370 12 j <1.3 M 28 4.4 15 22000 13 1700 70 0.1 <2.2 11 0.34 1600 <1.5 <0.28 <280 12 <13 0.4 49 36 BC-16F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 81.4 4.7 17000 <0.51 2 45 0.2 <2.6 <0.13 430 5.9 j <1.2 15 4.2 12 22000 12 1400 100 <0.093 <2.1 7.2 0.51 920 <1.3 <0.26 <260 11 <12 0.17 25 23 BC-16F (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 82.8 7.4 18000 <0.54 1.2 65 0.21 <2.7 <0.14 1200 2.5 j <1.2 19 14 13 15000 6.6 1800 240 <0.095 <2.1 10 0.76 1000 <1.4 <0.27 140 j 20 <12 0.16 33 27 BC-16F (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/22/2019 83.7 7.0 19000 <0.45 0.48 110 0.16 <2.3 <0.12 1400 5.1 j <1.2 20 5.6 17 15000 12 1800 180 0.023 j <1.8 15 1 1100 1 j <0.23 46 j 22 <12 0.17 26 45 BC-16F (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/22/2019 81.3 7.3 28000 <0.53 0.58 130 0.26 <2.6 0.097 j 1800 6.2 j 0.35 j 44 9.7 31 14000 13 3400 190 0.021 j <2.1 25 0.6 2200 1 j 0.065 j <260 25 9.3 j 0.28 50 99 BC-16H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 82.4 6.7 42000 <0.49 1.4 230 0.32 5.4 j 0.032 j 1500 2.6 j <1.2 54 19 38 41000 13 5400 940 <0.1 <2 36 0.22 j 2800 0.87 j <0.24 <240 24 6.1 j 0.41 84 90 BC-16H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 82.8 7.1 38000 M <0.6 M 1 150 0.3 M 3.9 j <0.16 1400 3.7 j <1.2 52 17 42 40000 M 10 4500 1500 M <0.09 <2.3 M 28 0.19 j 2200 0.66 j <0.3 44 j 13 <12 0.35 76 69 BC-16H (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 84.4 8.0 33000 <0.42 10 160 0.24 4.2 0.038 j 2700 3.2 j <1.2 46 17 26 35000 12 3500 670 <0.091 0.52 j 23 0.22 j 1700 0.73 j <0.21 <210 28 90 0.3 70 61 BC-16H (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 78.8 7.4 30000 <0.43 1 98 0.24 2.9 j <0.11 950 2.8 j <1.3 30 9.9 18 28000 6 2600 280 <0.1 <1.7 19 0.19 j 1100 <1.1 <0.21 <210 9.1 li j 0.18 58 44 BC-16H (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 82 7.0 38000 <0.53 1.6 150 0.3 4.2 j <0.14 1400 1.5 j 0.41 j 50 21 43 40000 12 4500 1400 <0.094 <2.1 28 0.24 2200 0.59 j <0.27 52 j 14 <12 0.34 87 70 BC-161 (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 81 6.3 35000 <0.5 0.89 270 0.3 8.1 0.16 2200 3.8 j <1.2 M 52 16 33 34000 9.4 5100 620 <0.088 <2 30 0.18 j 2500 1.1 j 0.084 j 110 j 25 8.1 j 0.36 70 75 BC-161 (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 81.2 7.0 37000 <0.44 0.57 210 0.26 3 j 0.067 j 2100 1.6 j 0.25 j 48 16 34 36000 10 5100 730 <0.089 <1.8 30 0.18 j 2300 0.69 j <0.22 130 j 18 <12 0.38 72 73 BC-161 (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 82.1 6.6 33000 <0.52 0.94 200 0.29 2.6 j 0.051 j 2200 3.5 j 0.24 j 44 14 30 35000 9.7 5300 650 <0.097 <2.1 29 0.29 2200 0.65 j <0.26 <260 17 12 0.3 71 70 BC-163 (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 79.4 6.8 29000 <0.47 1.7 140 0.24 3.5 j 0.039 j 1900 4.1 j <1.3 37 13 25 30000 8.4 4400 450 <0.1 <1.9 22 0.23 j 2000 0.66 j <0.24 69 j 18 35 0.28 62 55 BC-163 (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 75.1 6.1 47000 <0.48 1.5 180 0.28 <7.2 0.074 j 1800 13 0.39 j 53 12 42 45000 13 5700 520 <0.11 <1.9 33 0.34 2900 0.72 j 0.074 j 100 j 17 37 0.42 84 81 BC-18D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 85.4 7.1 27000 <0.56 1.2 290 0.51 4.5 j <0.15 2600 5.1 j <1.2 32 10 16 38000 16 5700 410 <0.088 <2.3 24 0.22 j 6200 <1.5 <0.28 83 j 38 23 0.43 34 74 B BC-18D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 91.6 7.5 25000 <0.46 0.83 230 0.21 4.2 j 0.046 j 5800 1.2 j <1.1 32 13 92 40000 30 8400 620 <0.089 <1.9 31 0.14 j 6800 <1.2 <0.23 76 j 45 <11 0.38 31 90 B BC-18F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 80.6 5.7 29000 <0.5 0.26 j 270 0.46 3.3 j 0.03 j 2000 7.5 j <1.2 29 15 26 36000 15 4900 640 <0.091 <2 26 0.2 j 4700 1 j <0.25 110 j 36 40 0.42 30 81 B BC-18F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 84.2 6.9 23000 <0.54 0.22 j 230 0.32 3 j 0.038 j 2500 5.5 j <1.2 24 9.9 27 31000 13 4400 470 <0.09 <2.2 24 0.15 j 4400 <1.4 <0.27 100 j 41 14 0.3 27 75 B BC-18F (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 89.3 7.2 23000 <0.5 0.37 j 150 0.26 3.3 j 0.026 j 2900 3.5 j <1.1 27 12 42 33000 17 4700 570 <0.081 <2 22 0.21 j 4700 0.61 j <0.25 88 j 43 <11 0.35 29 80 B BC-18H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 78.8 6.8 48000 <0.56 1.5 220 0.35 3.8 j <0.14 1400 2.8 j <1.3 66 24 45 48000 14 5500 2400 <0.091 <2.2 41 0.35 2600 1.3 j <0.28 <280 20 <13 0.45 88 100 BC-18H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 80.2 6.3 44000 <0.58 0.75 190 0.26 3.3 j <0.15 1300 4.9 j 0.38 j 65 16 34 34000 13 4700 940 0.092 j <2.3 35 0.27 2100 0.82 j <0.29 <290 16 22 M 0.43 76 83 BC-18H (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 79 6.2 35000 <0.51 0.77 140 0.37 <5.1 <0.13 1400 4.5 j 0.34 j 53 23 27 40000 8.3 3900 740 <0.1 <2.1 25 0.24 j 1300 0.76 j <0.26 <260 14 14 0.24 81 68 BC-18H (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 77.6 5.8 31000 <0.52 1.3 160 0.31 <5.2 0.033 j 1600 2 j 0.41 j 49 16 24 38000 8.8 4400 520 <0.1 <2.1 28 0.22 j 1600 0.7 j <0.26 <260 16 <13 0.25 71 75 BC-181 (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 77.5 6.8 45000 <0.45 64 260 0.27 5.6 j 0.092 j 2300 1.3 j <1.3 56 22 40 47000 13 5200 730 <0.096 9.6 37 0.18 j 3100 1.1 j 0.099 j 150 j 61 <13 0.43 89 85 BC-181 (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 76.1 6.6 46000 <0.48 23 220 0.27 4.2 j 0.058 j 2000 3.4 j 0.29 j 57 20 51 45000 13 5400 870 <0.099 5.1 34 0.34 3000 1 j <0.24 160 j 39 <13 0.45 92 82 BC-183 (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 79.7 7.5 42000 <0.51 4.3 210 0.28 4.1 j 0.043 j 2000 3.6 j 0.28 j 52 17 38 42000 13 5300 810 <0.1 0.57 j 32 0.31 3000 0.78 j <0.25 130 j 28 21 0.45 86 81 BC-183 (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 75.2 6.6 49000 <0.62 1.9 250 0.33 3.4 j 0.067 j 1600 2.5 j 0.37 j 59 17 41 45000 15 5900 680 <0.1 <2.5 36 0.28 3000 0.79 j <0.31 170 j 17 8.5 j 0.46 98 85 BC-18J (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 74.7 6.6 38000 <0.47 21 210 0.26 4 j 0.064 j 2700 4.3 j 0.34 j 52 16 38 38000 13 4400 570 <0.11 2 29 0.35 2600 1.1 j 0.063 j 160 j 38 53 0.41 78 67 BC-20D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 94.2 7.3 20000 <0.45 3.4 110 0.14 3.3 j 0.052 j 3600 1.9 j <1.1 23 9.8 34 30000 5.4 4700 540 <0.077 1.1 j 23 0.16 j 3500 <1.2 <0.22 70 j 50 <11 0.23 28 65 B BC-20D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 95.8 7.4 14000 M <0.44 M 0.35 j 65 0.092 M <10 M 0.035 j 3200 M 1.4 j <1 15 8.8 17 M 24000 M 20 M 3600 M 480 M <0.078 0.73 j 18 0.16 j 1800 M 0.55 j <0.22 <210 34 <10 0.12 20 M 49 BC-20F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 90.1 7.6 25000 <0.47 0.41 j 190 0.26 3.6 j 0.044 j 3300 <11 <1.1 27 17 43 40000 24 5300 810 <0.086 <1.9 32 0.14 j 5100 0.61 j <0.24 110 j 37 <11 0.32 28 90 B BC-20F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 90.2 6.1 28000 <0.51 0.2 j 160 0.23 3.9 j <0.13 5300 1.6 j <1.1 31 15 18 42000 14 7300 640 <0.089 <2 32 0.16 j 5500 0.58 j <0.26 110 j 39 <11 0.35 29 100 B BC-20H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 79.7 4.3 38000 <0.57 <0.57 83 0.079 j <2.9 <0.15 640 15 <1.3 36 2.7 14 16000 13 1100 50 0.18 <2.3 9.7 0.69 980 <1.5 <0.29 <290 10 <13 0.33 39 28 BC-20H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 81.8 4.8 19000 <0.52 <0.52 41 0.13 <2.6 <0.14 790 12 <1.2 27 1.7 6 7600 8.7 760 22 <0.09 <2.1 5.8 0.22 j 440 <1.4 <0.26 34 j 12 <12 0.2 25 14 B BC-20H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 84.6 4.0 21000 <0.44 0.23 j 52 0.088 <2.2 <0.11 540 5.9 j <1.2 25 1.4 9.8 5100 11 690 23 <0.085 <1.8 5.5 0.21 j 540 <1.1 <0.22 <220 9.6 <12 0.23 24 14 BC-20H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 79.9 4.8 23000 <0.56 <0.56 55 0.13 <2.8 <0.15 1000 4.3 j <1.3 38 3.2 11 20000 it 1300 26 <0.091 <2.3 10 0.52 680 <1.5 <0.28 38 j 14 <13 0.22 50 23 B BC-20H (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 84.9 4.1 23000 <0.57 0.39 j 78 0.2 <2.8 <0.15 1200 3.6 j <1.2 40 3.9 13 15000 11 1700 26 <0.096 <2.3 12 1.1 580 <1.5 <0.28 <280 16 8.9 j 0.24 51 36 BC-20H (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 74.9 5.5 34000 <0.6 0.49 j 210 0.42 <6 0.088 j 2100 3.7 j <1.3 64 14 35 30000 11 4400 92 0.024 j <2.4 33 0.61 1100 0.91 j <0.3 100 j 23 <13 0.31 83 100 B BC-20H (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 83 7.0 19000 <0.42 2.4 89 0.17 <2.1 <0.11 1900 2.9 j 0.33 j 36 4.3 16 15000 9.8 1500 75 <0.095 0.69 j 12 0.31 670 <1.1 <0.21 <210 17 13 0.2 44 33 BC-20H (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/22/2019 77.9 6.2 19000 <0.49 1.5 110 0.19 1.4 j 0.11 j 1500 3.7 j 0.39 j 34 16 15 15000 5.7 3700 140 <0.1 <2 21 0.33 1800 <1.3 <0.25 77 j 13 <13 0.22 44 58 B Page 2 of 3 TABLE 1 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - TOTAL INORGANICS ASH BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING SUMMARY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC Sample ID Associated Unit Sample Media Depth Interval (Feet BGS) Sample Collection Date Percent Solids pH Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Barium Beryllium Boron Cadmium Calcium Chloride Chromium (VI) Chromium Cobalt Copper Iron Lead Magnesium Manganese Mercury Molybdenum Nickel Nitrate (as N) Potassium Selenium Silver Sodium Strontium Sulfate Thallium Vanadium Zinc BC-20H (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 79.1 5.7 9300 <0.49 0.28 j 46 0.13 <2.4 0.031 j 860 5 j <1.3 17 7.9 8.2 7000 3.1 1800 93 <0.093 <2 11 0.28 870 <1.3 <0.24 <240 8.6 21 0.091 j 24 33 BC-20H (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 05/22/2019 73.9 6.1 12000 <0.5 1.4 53 0.15 <5 0.034 j 860 4.1 j 0.29 j 22 8.5 9.6 10000 3.7 1500 79 <0.11 <2 11 0.38 780 <1.3 <0.25 32 j 8.3 12 j 0.12 j 38 33 B BC-20J (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 75.9 6.9 51000 <0.53 1.7 210 0.31 3.8 j <0.14 1600 2.7 j 0.39 j 62 21 45 51000 15 5800 780 <0.1 <2.1 37 0.34 3000 0.86 j <0.27 150 j 18 <13 0.49 100 85 BC-20J (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 81 6.3 43000 <0.53 3.9 200 0.31 2.8 j 0.029 j 1500 1.6 j 0.52 j 54 14 37 41000 13 5200 610 <0.091 <2.1 33 0.17 j 2600 0.89 j <0.26 170 j 17 <12 0.39 88 75 BC-203 (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 80.4 6.2 44000 <0.53 1.3 210 0.29 2.4 j 0.056 j 1500 1.7 j 0.39 j 60 13 42 42000 12 5800 560 <0.098 <2.1 34 0.36 2500 0.79 j <0.26 200 j 13 <12 0.4 93 80 BC-203 (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 71.6 6.6 26000 <0.64 0.91 130 0.29 <3.2 0.042 j 1500 3.2 j 0.35 j 36 12 26 28000 7 4500 470 <0.11 <2.5 24 0.3 2100 <1.7 <0.32 240 j 11 <14 0.24 63 55 BC-22D (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 93.3 4.6 23000 <0.48 15 180 0.52 2.5 j <0.13 4700 2 j <1.1 29 9.8 53 39000 41 4400 240 <0.087 3.6 27 0.15 j 6800 0.96 j <0.24 <240 40 160 0.51 48 78 BC-22D (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 88.9 4.3 29000 <0.45 0.74 180 0.27 3.3 j 0.023 j 3900 2 j <1.1 32 12 50 43000 12 6300 410 <0.084 <1.8 31 0.13 j 7100 0.55 j 0.059 j <230 36 150 0.53 41 93 BC-22F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 89.9 7.8 20000 <0.47 0.4 j 170 0.31 <4.7 0.048 j 2000 5.6 j <1.1 18 11 20 27000 13 4100 470 <0.083 <1.9 24 0.22 2300 0.58 j <0.24 <240 43 50 0.13 20 72 BC-22F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 75.1 5.9 16000 <0.61 <0.61 120 0.28 <3 0.038 j 1600 4.9 j <1.3 14 7 19 19000 6.3 3300 360 <0.11 <2.4 16 0.21 j 2100 <1.6 <0.3 <300 38 20 0.099 j 21 45 BC-22F (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 92.9 7.0 20000 <0.48 0.34 j 130 0.2 <7.3 0.043 j 1900 2.6 j <1.1 20 14 23 37000 32 4800 770 <0.079 <1.9 26 0.18 j 2200 0.67 j <0.24 <240 39 33 0.14 23 77 BC-22H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 92 7.0 19000 <0.46 0.98 160 0.21 <4.6 0.029 j 1400 2.4 j <1.1 17 7.9 14 26000 14 2300 290 <0.078 <1.8 16 0.22 3600 <1.2 <0.23 <230 28 it 0.3 24 46 BC-22H (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 91.9 6.6 19000 <0.48 27 130 0.18 <2.4 0.042 j 1600 2.2 j <1.1 19 16 21 23000 20 3700 580 <0.084 1.8 j 21 0.21 j 2900 <1.2 <0.24 <240 34 11 0.27 34 59 BC-221 (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 77.8 6.3 39000 <0.57 1.2 210 0.31 5 j 0.031 j 1300 2.2 j <1.3 58 22 37 39000 12 4800 600 <0.1 0.67 j 35 <0.26 2400 1 j <0.28 <280 30 37 0.37 86 79 BC-223 (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 83.4 6.8 36000 <0.55 1.3 160 0.28 4.5 j <0.14 1200 3.2 j <1.2 52 18 31 38000 11 4500 530 <0.089 0.69 j 30 0.19 j 2100 0.64 j <0.27 <270 26 <12 0.34 83 73 BC-221 (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 77.4 6.8 35000 <0.48 1.8 130 0.2 3.8 j 0.024 j 1700 2.8 j <1.3 52 9.1 25 31000 9.2 4100 490 <0.1 0.91 j 26 0.31 1700 0.7 j <0.24 <240 33 22 0.24 71 68 BC-223 (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 70.6 7.1 14000 <0.48 <0.48 70 0.17 <2.4 0.027 j 1200 8.7 j <1.4 23 4.2 10 13000 3.8 2600 120 <0.1 <1.9 12 0.34 1100 <1.3 <0.24 <240 12 85 0.12 j 29 36 BC-24F (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 94.7 5.9 22000 <0.46 0.5 180 0.13 <4.6 0.048 j 4700 <11 <1.1 24 12 27 28000 9 7300 750 <0.076 <1.8 25 0.151 3400 0.43 j <0.23 <230 46 49 0.24 40 69 BC-24F (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 94.1 5.8 22000 <0.47 1.1 180 0.21 <4.7 <0.12 4000 <11 <1.1 22 12 24 31000 5.3 7100 570 <0.086 0.77 j 29 0.17 j 4700 0.68 j <0.23 <230 34 22 0.31 35 75 BC-24H (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 95 7.2 29000 <0.49 15 230 0.25 2.3 j <0.13 4700 <11 <1.1 30 15 17 41000 46 6800 550 <0.084 0.74 j 32 0.19 j 8000 0.62 j <0.25 <250 44 12 0.54 42 82 BC-241 (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 85.4 5.8 17000 <0.43 7.2 120 0.25 <4.3 <0.11 2200 4.2 j <1.2 20 9.5 15 23000 16 2900 410 <0.094 2.4 13 0.27 1900 0.51 j <0.21 <210 32 19 0.16 24 36 BC-241 (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 90.7 5.4 15000 <0.44 0.37 j 86 0.18 <2.2 0.023 j 2400 2.9 j <1.1 16 6 8.5 22000 19 3700 320 <0.091 <1.8 13 0.33 1600 <1.1 <0.22 <220 33 6.1 j 0.077 j 19 44 BC-243 (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 81.9 5.8 20000 M <0.51 M 21 M 110 0.13 M 1.1 j 0.026 j 1300 2.2 j <1.2 22 7.5 13 21000 M 9.8 1700 200 <0.09 13 13 0.45 1300 M <1.3 <0.26 <220 25 21 0.15 33 M 27 BC-26G (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 84.7 6.6 19000 <0.43 2 140 0.84 <4.3 <0.11 1100 3.6 j <1.2 19 12 15 29000 28 1500 540 <0.09 <1.7 8.6 0.27 1300 0.52 j <0.22 110 j 19 39 0.21 31 27 BC-26G (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 88.7 6.2 30000 <0.43 0.69 400 2.3 <6.4 0.17 3000 2.4 j <1.1 30 31 60 40000 8.2 5300 2100 <0.085 <1.7 31 0.32 4600 1.4 <0.21 150 j 42 33 0.35 33 88 BC-26G (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/14/2019 91.1 6.7 21000 <0.46 <0.46 230 1.3 <4.6 0.051 j 2600 3.2 j <1.1 22 8.1 24 32000 8.1 4000 770 <0.083 <1.8 25 <0.22 4600 0.63 j <0.23 110 j 31 22 0.3 24 62 BC-26I (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 93.9 6.9 15000 <0.46 9.2 170 1.1 <2.3 0.03 j 1800 2.6 j <1.1 15 7.7 20 19000 12 2500 1200 <0.085 2.2 13 0.4 1600 0.83 j <0.23 40 j 30 31 0.093 j 28 38 BC-26I (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 93.2 6.0 30000 <0.46 11 280 2 <7 0.029 j 2000 2.1 j 0.33 j 30 15 31 47000 18 4200 830 <0.077 1.6 j 24 0.21 5600 1.1 j <0.23 84 j 34 22 0.33 35 70 BC-26K (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 92.3 6.4 38000 <0.43 7.9 360 2.6 <6.4 0.056 j 2300 5.3 j <1.1 35 14 23 46000 23 5800 620 <0.084 0.98 j 29 0.14 j 7500 0.83 j <0.21 69 j 49 11 0.49 41 82 BC-26K (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 89.7 5.6 37000 M <0.43 M 17 360 2.4 <7 0.062 j 2400 2.7 j <1.1 35 14 24 48000 M 24 6200 700 M <0.091 1.1 j,M 31 0.17 j 7200 M 0.79 j <0.21 86 j 51 13 0.52 40 M 88 BC-28I (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 90.9 5.5 14000 <0.37 20 140 1.6 0.89 j 0.05 j 940 2.3 j <1.1 16 27 7.3 13000 13 1000 660 <0.08 0.75 j 24 0.22 1600 0.84 j <0.18 41 j 22 28 0.26 25 35 BC-28I (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 91.9 6.5 19000 <0.47 0.19 j 280 2.3 <4.7 0.064 j 2000 2.6 j <1.1 26 19 11 36000 29 3800 1200 <0.079 1.1 j 32 <0.22 4600 0.87 j <0.23 98 j 38 8.9 j 0.39 26 78 BC-28I (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/14/2019 90.1 6.1 18000 <0.46 5.8 240 1.8 <4.6 0.067 j 1900 <11 0.26 j 21 17 25 32000 21 3700 1300 <0.09 <1.8 28 0.17 j 4300 0.77 j <0.23 94 j 39 18 0.37 31 72 BC-28K (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 89.5 6.1 30000 <0.44 25 300 2.1 <6.5 0.039 j 2700 2.2 j <1.1 27 14 110 44000 20 4500 740 <0.088 2.9 29 0.25 4700 4 <0.22 83 j 46 30 0.27 68 80 BC-28K (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 81 7.2 38000 <0.5 2.6 420 2.2 <5 0.043 j 3100 <12 0.27 j 34 20 51 44000 12 5800 1300 <0.09 0.73 j 48 0.17 j 7600 1.5 <0.25 93 j 58 91 0.5 50 99 BC-28M (0) Ash Basin Soil 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 86.4 7.2 33000 <0.44 54 52 0.7 <4.4 <0.12 830 <12 <1.2 26 7.3 16 30000 10 1000 180 <0.085 2.8 13 <0.23 860 1.4 <0.22 <220 23 110 0.14 57 28 BC-28M (2) Ash Basin Soil 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 80.3 6.8 43000 <0.57 5 100 1.1 <5.7 <0.15 950 <12 <1.2 40 13 27 41000 20 1500 260 <0.1 2.1 j 22 0.22 j 1800 <1.5 <0.28 41 j 17 38 0.34 80 75 BC-28M (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 05/14/2019 77.1 7.4 42000 <0.5 160 120 1.3 <5 <0.13 1400 <13 <1.3 21 18 21 33000 15 3700 340 <0.1 3 18 0.22 j 2500 <1.3 <0.25 33 j 41 75 0.23 32 41 BC-28M (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 05/14/2019 78.2 7.1 52000 <0.46 47 160 1.5 <6.8 0.028 j 1700 <13 0.47 j 51 18 32 46000 15 2700 330 0.038 j 8.7 23 0.27 3600 1.2 <0.23 44 j 36 67 0.42 64 55 NC-OC (7) Ash Basin Soil 7 - 7.5 06/20/2019 72.6 6.6 40000 <0.68 M 1.4 170 1.6 4.1 0.063 j 1600 4.5 j 0.34 j 44 21 M 27 35000 17 4300 450 M 0.044 j <2.2 M 28 0.22 j 2600 0.85 j <0.34 150 j 16 10 j 0.5 99 M 63 NC-OC (12) Ash Basin Soil 12 - 12.5 06/20/2019 73.8 6.0 35000 <0.5 1.1 170 1.1 2.1 j 0.046 j 920 6.2 j 0.29 j 49 17 24 31000 13 2800 1100 0.045 j <2 28 0.37 1800 0.54 j <0.25 120 j 11 <14 0.32 64 60 NC-OC (17) Ash Basin Soil 17 - 17.5 06/20/2019 73.4 6.4 39000 <0.66 2.9 150 1.8 2.7 j <0.17 600 4.5 j 0.33 j 80 29 33 65000 16 2900 950 0.051 j <2.7 36 0.36 2000 <1.7 <0.33 120 j 7.8 19 0.3 120 64 Prepared by: BER Checked by: ENK Page 3 of 3 TABLE 2 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - SPLP ASH BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING SUMMARY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC Sample ID Associated Unit Sample Media Depth Interval (Feet BGS) Sample Collection Date Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Barium Beryllium Boron Cadmium Calcium Chloride Chromium (VI) Chromium Cobalt Copper Iron Lead Magnesium Manganese Mercury Molybdenum Nickel Nitrate (as N) Potassium Selenium Silver Sodium Strontium Sulfate Thallium Vanadium Zinc BC-02D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 9800 <2 <2 52 0.42 70 <0.5 3.6 j 0.24 j <20 12 3.2 j 5.9 j 11000 3.9 <5 140 <0.2 <40 6 j 4.9 0.7 j <5 <1 4.6 j 32 15 <0.5 27 15 j BC-02D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 16000 <2 <2 86 0.69 67 <0.5 2.5 j 0.22 j <20 18 5.5 9.6 j 18000 6 0.93 j 310 <0.2 <40 10 j 4.8 0.8 j <5 <1 4.3 j 23 11 <0.5 45 21 BC-02D (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 31000 <2 <2 150 1.3 99 <0.5 2.9 j 0.35 j <20 43 8.6 23 33000 12 2 j 480 <0.2 <40 22 j 9.9 1.4 j <5 <1 5 30 13 0.15 j 81 42 BC-02D (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 1300 <2 <2 14 j <0.4 68 <0.5 1.6 j 0.35 j <20 <10 <5 <10 1000 0.3 j <5 38 <0.2 <40 <40 2.8 <5 <5 <1 4.1 j 7 j 7.4 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-02D (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 2800 0.8 j <2 21 j <0.4 47 j <0.5 1.9 j 0.26 j <20 2.5 j <5 2.4 j 2300 0.72 j <5 62 <0.2 <40 <40 3.5 <5 <5 <1 4.9 j 9.5 j 4.1 <0.5 3.9 j 8 j BC-04B (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 <400 <2 <2 <25 <0.4 32 j <0.5 <5 0.5 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 21 <0.2 <40 <40 0.24 <5 <5 <1 1.5 j 9.9 j 3.4 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-04B (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 140 j <2 <2 32 <0.4 71 <0.5 0.78 j 0.29 j <20 <10 <5 <10 130 <1 <5 2.7 j <0.2 <40 <40 2.6 <5 <5 <1 12 3.4 j 0.4 j <0.5 <5 <20 BC-04B (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 960 <2 <2 14 j <0.4 43 j <0.5 <5 0.24 j <20 <10 <5 <10 760 1.5 <5 13 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.043 <5 <5 <1 5.7 3.4 j 1.7 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-04C (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 39000 <2 <2 120 1.5 84 <0.5 2.3 j 0.33 j <20 67 4.3 j 24 32000 7.9 2.3 j 250 <0.2 <40 37 j 0.19 1.7 j <5 <1 7.4 25 4.2 0.19 j 67 47 BC-04C (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 28000 <2 <2 95 1.1 100 <0.5 1.7 j 0.41 j <20 62 3.7 j 17 25000 5.6 1.5 j 260 <0.2 <40 27 j 3.3 0.9 j <5 <1 6.1 16 3.5 <0.5 66 33 BC-04C (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 41000 <2 <2 110 1.3 91 <0.5 2.3 j 0.37 j <20 89 5.5 18 36000 9.5 2.2 j 200 <0.2 <40 34 j 2.7 1.4 j <5 <1 7.7 21 2.3 0.17 j 88 42 BC-04C (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 96000 <2 2.6 270 3.6 66 <0.5 4 j 0.35 j <20 200 27 58 100000 30 4.6 j 1200 0.15 j <40 89 1.2 2.5 j 2.1 j <1 7.5 39 2.6 0.38 j 260 110 BC-04E (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 38000 <2 1.3 j 140 1.6 69 <0.5 1.7 j <1 <20 52 13 25 43000 16 2.5 j 680 0.099 j <40 26 j 2.2 1.5 j <5 <1 5.3 14 4.9 0.2 j 89 44 BC-04E (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 41000 <2 <2 170 1.8 60 <0.5 1.4 j 0.26 j <20 50 14 25 46000 16 2.5 j 800 0.12 j <40 30 j 0.18 1.6 j <5 <1 6.3 11 3.6 0.21 j 94 51 BC-04E (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 19000 <2 <2 91 0.58 79 <0.5 1.3 j 0.3 j <20 23 5.2 12 20000 6.2 1.4 j 260 <0.2 <40 12 j 1.8 0.93 j <5 <1 5.4 7.9 j 4.2 <0.5 43 26 BC-04E (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 9300 <2 <2 39 0.21 j 110 <0.5 3.3 j 0.28 j <20 9.21 2.5 j 5.2 j 7700 2 <5 92 <0.2 9.1 j <40 1.8 <5 <5 <1 6.1 9.9 j 5.8 <0.5 19 9.6 j BC-04E (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 7600 <2 <2 34 0.15 j 51 <0.5 3.2 j <1 <20 6.6 j 1.3 j 3.9 j 5700 1.4 <5 59 <0.2 28 j <40 0.95 <5 <5 <1 3.3 j 12 5.2 <0.5 12 6.2 j BC-04F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 21000 0.66 j 1.9 j 90 0.73 110 <0.5 5 <1 <20 23 8 15 22000 7.5 0.66 j 410 0.11 j 150 13 j 1.7 2.1 j <5 <1 6.3 120 5.4 <0.5 51 22 BC-04F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 17000 1.4 j 51 95 0.68 140 <0.5 5.9 0.32 j <20 18 7.7 20 17000 6.5 0.8 j 350 0.11 j 7.4 j it j 0.18 1.9 j 7.2 <1 7.2 180 4.7 <0.5 89 20 BC-04F (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 53000 2.5 58 260 2.4 110 <0.5 7.8 <1 <20 66 15 53 56000 18 2.9 j 960 0.16 j 16 j 39 j 5.4 3 j 10 <1 4.7 j 190 4.3 0.21 j 190 72 BC-04F (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 64000 3.4 130 300 2.8 130 0.25 j 12 0.24 j <20 79 23 75 64000 24 3.2 j 1400 0.16 j 15 j 46 0.096 3.8 j 42 <1 4.8 j 260 1.5 0.36 j 520 81 BC-04F (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 10000 <2 <2 79 0.55 130 <0.5 4.3 j 0.29 j <20 it 3.1 j 7.4 j 8300 2.2 <5 230 <0.2 86 6 j 7.4 <5 <5 <1 4.9 j 67 2.6 <0.5 22 15 j BC-06C (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 52000 0.53 j 4.1 210 1.9 140 <0.5 4.4 j 0.3 j <20 82 8.4 28 57000 11 3.3 j 310 <0.2 5.4 j 43 6.5 1.3 j 1.5 j <1 7.6 53 5.2 0.19 j 130 58 BC-06C (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 71000 <2 <2 200 1.7 100 <0.5 3 j 0.32 j <20 150 9 32 60000 13 3.5 j 280 0.23 <40 51 11 1.6 j 1.4 j <1 4 j 29 4.9 0.29 j 130 69 BC-06C (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 41000 <2 3 100 1.3 170 <0.5 3.5 j 0.34 j <20 68 5.9 20 35000 7 2.2 j 300 <0.2 <40 31 j 4.8 1.4 j <5 <1 6.2 35 6.6 0.16 j 81 42 BC-06C (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 20000 <2 <2 52 0.94 37 j <0.5 1.7 j 0.54 j <20 68 2.5 j 12 14000 3.8 0.93 j 37 <0.2 <40 16 j 6.6 0.64 j <5 <1 3.6 j 12 6 <0.5 58 23 BC-06E (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 5900 1.3 j 3.1 41 0.23 j 140 <0.5 7.8 0.28 j <20 6.6 j <5 3.5 j 4700 1.2 0.96 j 46 <0.2 40 <40 6 0.78 j <5 <1 5.4 100 8.6 <0.5 14 12 j BC-06E (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 6000 0.56 j <2 87 0.27 j 190 <0.5 5.4 0.25 j <20 5.6 j 1.5 j 4 j 4700 1.2 <5 82 <0.2 130 <40 11 1.6 j <5 <1 5.2 140 5.9 <0.5 15 12 j BC-06E (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 5400 0.57 j <2 32 0.2 j 140 <0.5 6.1 0.27 j <20 6.4 j <5 6.3 j 4300 1.1 <5 41 <0.2 300 <40 2.8 <5 <5 <1 2.6 j 82 6.3 <0.5 12 8.3 j BC-06E (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 4200 1.6 j <2 31 0.23 j 300 <0.5 6.5 0.33 j <20 8.8 j <5 3.9 j 6200 1 <5 39 <0.2 260 <40 9 <5 1.4 j <1 2.4 j 280 4.5 <0.5 18 8.3 j BC-06G (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 8400 1.3 j 88 91 0.27 j 67 <0.5 9.6 <1 <20 8.5 j 2.1 j 4.7 j 5600 1.9 1.7 j 100 <0.2 5.5 j <40 2.7 1.4 j 2.9 j <1 3.6 j 170 11 <0.5 26 10 j BC-06G (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 26000 4.9 <2 120 1.3 84 <0.5 5.7 <1 <20 28 8.8 21 25000 8.9 1.5 j 490 <0.2 5.2 j 16 j 0.73 1.9 j 12 <1 4.2 j 130 1.3 <0.5 210 28 BC-06G (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 26000 4.3 20 110 1.1 100 <0.5 8.4 0.25 j <20 26 8.7 24 24000 8.1 1.7 j 450 <0.2 <40 16 j 8.3 2 j 14 <1 4.5 j 190 4 <0.5 170 28 BC-06G (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 40000 5.9 18 200 1.9 130 <0.5 9.9 0.24 j 1 <20 43 12 39 37000 13 2.3 j 820 <0.2 8.8 j 26 j 9.2 2.6 j 22 <1 8.5 220 2.9 0.18 j 290 45 BC-06G (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 54000 8.2 24 260 2.3 130 <0.5 11 0.35 j <20 58 18 58 50000 19 2.8 j 1100 0.12 j 14 j 38 j 0.15 3.2 j 38 <1 5.4 240 2.3 0.27 j 420 69 BC-08C (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 5900 0.51 j 2.3 16 j <0.4 36 j <0.5 69 0.41 j <20 1.9 j <5 2.5 j <100 <1 <5 <15 <0.2 44 <40 0.058 <5 3.3 j <1 1.1 j 130 3.7 <0.5 60 <20 BC-08C (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 5100 0.95 j 2.5 13 j <0.4 54 <0.5 55 0.45 j <20 1.6 j <5 2.3 j <100 <1 <5 <15 <0.2 28 j <40 5.5 <5 2.8 j <1 1.4 j 110 4.5 <0.5 68 <20 BC-08C (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 9100 0.89 j <2 38 0.26 j 49 j <0.5 0.79 j 0.26 j <20 15 2.3 j 3.9 j 1900 1.3 0.64 j 10 j <0.2 <40 6.1 j 1 0.21 <5 <5 <1 2.8 j 6.9 j 2.5 <0.5 13 9.9 j BC-08C (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 1500 <2 <2 49 0.15 j 26 j <0.5 1.5 j 0.31 j <20 <10 <5 2 j 1500 2.9 <5 110 <0.2 <40 <40 4.5 0.66 j <5 <1 4.2 j 6 j 1.6 <0.5 <5 3.8 j BC-08C (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 04/17/2019 11000 <2 <2 140 0.57 29 j <0.5 2.1 j 0.54 j <20 14 2.8 j 6 j 12000 8.3 1 j 110 <0.2 <40 5.5 j 3.8 2.8 j <5 <1 3.7 j 11 2.3 <0.5 14 27 BC-08E (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 19000 <2 <2 71 0.61 200 <0.5 1.3 j 0.36 j <20 26 1.8 j 8.9 j 15000 3.1 1.1 j 67 <0.2 <40 15 j 1 0.73 j <5 <1 4.8 j 13 5.8 <0.5 38 19 j BC-08E (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 25000 0.74 j <2 93 1.2 170 <0.5 1.5 j 0.35 j <20 42 2.8 j 15 25000 5.5 1.4 j 150 <0.2 <40 23 j 0.079 0.81 j <5 <1 5.9 1 14 4.7 <0.5 65 32 BC-08E (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 <400 <2 <2 4.6 j <0.4 190 <0.5 0.72 j 0.39 j <20 <10 <5 <10 71 j <1 <5 61 <0.2 <40 <40 0.4 <5 <5 <1 2.9 j 7 j 10 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-08E (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 57000 0.54 j <2 170 3 88 0.13 j 2.9 j 0.59 j <20 110 10 48 30000 16 2.5 j 72 0.18 j <40 45 0.45 1.4 j <5 <1 5.8 27 3.4 0.2 j 160 70 BC-08G (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/17/2019 18000 0.73 j 13 86 0.92 70 <0.5 3.5 j 0.24 j <20 22 5.9 11 18000 6.7 1 j 320 <0.2 9.2 j 11 j 3.5 1.2 j 1.4 j <1 4.8 j 52 3.8 <0.5 46 20 BC-08G (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/17/2019 22000 <2 <2 80 1.2 87 <0.5 2.9 j 0.24 j <20 24 7.2 14 22000 8.3 0.67 j 450 <0.2 <40 14 j 2.5 1.3 j <5 <1 5.4 47 2.2 <0.5 52 26 BC-08G (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/17/2019 36000 <2 2.3 130 1.7 100 <0.5 5.1 0.21 j <20 45 10 27 35000 12 1.1 j 710 <0.2 130 24 j 1.2 2.2 j 1.4 j <1 5.3 110 2.2 0.15 j 90 42 BC-08G (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/17/2019 14000 1.3 j <2 41 0.48 49 j <0.5 2.8 j <1 <20 11 2.8 j 16 11000 3 <5 150 <0.2 13 j 7.7 j 4.4 1.2 j <5 <1 2.4 j 77 1.1 <0.5 37 13 j BC-10B (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/18/2019 1500 <2 <2 13 j <0.4 25 j <0.5 4.7 j 0.29 j <20 1.5 j <5 <10 750 0.29 j 1.6 j 17 <0.2 <40 <40 0.15 0.88 j <5 <1 3.4 j 55 2.7 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-10B (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/18/2019 7600 <2 <2 51 0.31 j 63 <0.5 0.93 j 0.26 j <20 7.5 j 1.4 j 2.9 j 6300 1.6 0.63 j 110 <0.2 <40 <40 1.8 1 1.5 j <5 <1 6 11 2 1 <0.5 8.1 8.5 j BC-10B (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/18/2019 7700 <2 <2 88 0.37 j 140 <0.5 1 j <1 <20 6.5 j <5 5.6 j 4700 0.6 j 0.88 j 98 <0.2 <40 <40 3.8 2.6 j <5 <1 10 8.4 j 1 <0.5 6.2 10 j BC-10C (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/18/2019 940 4.1 7.7 <25 <0.4 200 <0.5 10 0.28 j <20 <10 <5 2.3 j <100 <1 <5 <15 <0.2 130 <40 0.63 1.4 j 3.2 j <1 1.4 j 130 5.2 <0.5 160 <20 BC-10C (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/18/2019 2200 0.82 j <2 23 j <0.4 <50 <0.5 <5 0.27 j <20 1.7 j <5 <10 930 <1 <5 12 j <0.2 <40 <40 1.9 0.96 j <5 <1 3.5 j 4.5 j 1.1 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-10E (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 04/18/2019 <400 <2 <2 4 j <0.4 110 <0.5 1.8 j 0.4 j <20 <10 <5 <10 58 j <1 0.65 j 84 <0.2 <40 <40 0.52 <5 <5 <1 2.5 j 20 11 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-10E (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 04/18/2019 <400 <2 <2 9.1 j <0.4 90 <0.5 2.1 j 0.54 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 1.4 j 54 <0.2 <40 <40 2.7 <5 <5 <1 2.5 j 18 6.6 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-10E (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 04/18/2019 980 <2 <2 8.1 j <0.4 56 <0.5 0.97 j 0.56 j <20 <10 <5 <10 450 <1 0.64 j 8.3 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.17 <5 <5 <1 1.9 j 8.3 j 5.7 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-10E (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 04/18/2019 36000 <2 <2 95 1.4 27 j 1.9 1.9 j 0.52 j <20 120 5.7 39 11000 15 1.6 j 27 <0.2 <40 29 j 1.3 0.96 j 10 <1 4.5 j 16 2.9 <0.5 110 27 BC-10G (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 1600 1.8 j <2 28 <0.4 160 <0.5 18 0.39 j <20 <10 <5 2.9 j 1200 0.6 j 1.9 j 50 <0.2 15 j <40 0.52 0.9 j <5 <1 3.7 j 110 14 <0.5 4 j 4.6 j BC-10G (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 5700 0.57 j <2 80 0.24 j 320 1 <0.5 9.8 0.48 j <20 4.6 j 2 j 4.1 j 3400 1.4 0.77 j 1400 <0.2 <40 <40 7.8 2.6 j <5 <1 4.4 j 85 8.9 <0.5 8.3 9.6 j BC-10G (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 37000 <2 2.2 170 1.7 170 <0.5 2.6 j 0.44 j <20 36 13 22 23000 9.8 1.9 j 540 <0.2 <40 23 j 3 2 j <5 <1 8.4 21 2.2 0.17 j 53 46 BC-10G (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 51000 <2 2.9 230 2 110 <0.5 1.8 j 0.36 j <20 58 11 38 43000 12 2.2 j 480 <0.2 <40 33 j 0.54 2.3 j <5 <1 4.7 j 20 1.2 0.18 j 71 61 BC-10I (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 38000 0.66 j 7.2 130 0.49 180 <0.5 9.7 0.26 j <20 41 10 33 31000 16 1.5 j 750 <0.2 <40 24 j 3.1 3.6 j 1.7 j <1 4.6 j 200 25 <0.5 77 38 BC-10I (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 22000 <2 3 71 0.39 j 120 <0.5 2.4 j 0.27 j <20 22 5 23 17000 7.8 <5 160 <0.2 <40 12 j 3.7 1.8 j <5 <1 5.4 41 5.2 <0.5 47 21 BC-10I (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 59000 <2 1.9 j 220 1.1 120 <0.5 1.6 j <1 <20 91 13 55 55000 17 2 j 530 <0.2 <40 45 0.23 1.4 j 2.3 j <1 8 18 1.5 0.21 j 150 67 BC-10I (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 38000 1.1 j 2.8 200 0.7 46 j <0.5 0.87 j 0.26 j <20 52 8.4 23 22000 13 1.3 j 330 <0.2 <40 24 j 2.9 1.3 j 1.6 j <1 3 j 20 5.2 0.15 j 72 37 BC-12B (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 1800 0.66 j 8.5 12 j <0.4 59 <0.5 12 0.33 j <20 1.4 j <5 <10 1100 0.55 j <5 9.8 j <0.2 46 <40 0.19 <5 1.8 j <1 5.8 69 7.8 <0.5 48 <20 BC-12B (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 2300 0.55 j 15 3.6 j <0.4 40 j <0.5 20 0.23 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 <15 <0.2 88 <40 0.27 <5 3 j <1 1.4 j 85 4.9 <0.5 98 <20 BC-12D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 51000 <2 2.6 250 0.67 190 <0.5 4.9 j 0.21 j <20 70 38 35 58000 25 1.2 j 950 <0.2 28 j 32 j 0.33 4 j <5 <1 5.2 88 2.1 0.34 j 110 58 BC-12D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 27000 <2 <2 170 0.56 99 <0.5 2 j 0.24 j <20 29 14 28 26000 13 1 j 1900 <0.2 <40 16 j 0.25 2.5 j <5 <1 3.1 j 25 1.3 0.19 j 47 33 BC-12D (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 6000 <2 <2 42 0.18 j 99 <0.5 <5 <1 <20 5.8 j 2 j 6.8 j 3900 2.2 <5 310 <0.2 <40 <40 2.4 0.69 j <5 <1 4.5 j 9.7 j 1.3 <0.5 13 6.6 j BC-12F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 41000 0.58 j 2.7 140 1.8 63 <0.5 1.2 j 0.35 j <20 41 15 27 36000 12 1.3 j 220 <0.2 <40 20 j 1 4.3 1.8 j <5 <1 7.2 15 1.8 0.19 j 79 39 Page 1 of 3 TABLE 2 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - SPLP ASH BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING SUMMARY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC Sample ID Associated Unit Sample Media Depth Interval (Feet BGS) Sample Collection Date Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Barium Beryllium Boron Cadmium Calcium Chloride Chromium (VI) Chromium Cobalt Copper Iron Lead Magnesium Manganese Mercury Molybdenum Nickel Nitrate (as N) Potassium Selenium Silver Sodium Strontium Sulfate Thallium Vanadium Zinc BC-12F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 64000 <2 3.6 170 1.5 30 j <0.5 2.3 j 0.3 j <20 94 14 35 39000 20 3 j 270 <0.2 <40 31 j 2.9 3.4 j <5 <1 4 j 27 1.5 0.39 j 94 65 BC-12F (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 8300 <2 <2 44 0.43 40 j <0.5 0.73 j 0.36 j <20 6.8 j 2.1 j 3.9 j 3800 2.1 <5 130 <0.2 <40 <40 3.2 0.72 j <5 <1 2.4 j 5 j 2 <0.5 15 11 j BC-12H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 65000 <2 26 220 3.3 60 0.22 j 6.5 <1 <20 69 16 61 70000 24 2.7 j 1400 0.11 j 130 38 j 9.6 3 j 1.5 j <1 5.1 160 4.1 0.22 j 170 72 BC-12H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 82000 <2 76 300 3.8 63 0.26 j 7.7 <1 <20 99 21 84 92000 31 3.5 j 2000 0.18 j 150 50 0.21 3.4 j 1.8 j <1 4.4 j 180 1.5 0.34 j 220 98 BC-12H (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 25000 0.63 j 2.3 61 0.84 45 j <0.5 4 j <1 <20 28 6 21 21000 5.3 0.97 j 360 <0.2 170 13 j 0.16 0.71 j <5 <1 4.2 j 78 0.84 j <0.5 59 22 BC-12H (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 34000 <2 2.6 78 1.3 51 <0.5 3.5 j 0.25 j <20 41 6.1 22 33000 6.7 1.3 j 370 <0.2 19 j 20 j 0.12 0.87 j <5 <1 3.8 j 35 1.8 <0.5 75 35 BC-14B (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 2300 0.54 j 13 <25 <0.4 24 j <0.5 14 <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 <15 <0.2 it j <40 0.12 <5 1.5 j <1 3.4 j 36 3.5 <0.5 25 <20 BC-14B (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 3200 <2 <2 26 0.21 j 21 j <0.5 0.77 j <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 2300 2.7 <5 120 <0.2 5 j <40 2 0.87 j <5 <1 3.7 j 11 1 <0.5 7.8 4.2 j BC-14D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 <400 <2 <2 <25 I <0.4 57 <0.5 0.73 j 0.39 j <20 2.8 j <5 I <10 260 <1 <5 27 <0.2 <40 <40 0.1 0.97 j <5 <1 3 j 7.6 j 6.1 <0.5 <5 2.6 j BC-14D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 <400 0.55 j <2 4 j <0.4 35 j <0.5 <5 0.42 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 22 <0.2 <40 <40 0.5 0.9 j <5 <1 2.6 j 14 5.2 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-14F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 5400 <2 <2 17 j 0.2 j 87 <0.5 <5 0.33 j <20 5.6 j <5 3 j 2900 1.1 <5 44 <0.2 <40 <40 0.12 0.64 j <5 <1 2.9 j 3.8 j 1.5 <0.5 8.3 7.1 j BC-14F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 330 j 0.61 j <2 21 j <0.4 36 j <0.5 1.8 j 0.27 j <20 <10 1.4 j <10 210 <1 1.5 j 590 <0.2 <40 <40 4.2 <5 <5 <1 2.4 j 17 0.44 j <0.5 <5 4.3 j BC-14F (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 170000 <2 4.8 500 5.2 24 j <0.5 8.2 0.48 j <20 260 19 110 170000 43 14 230 <0.2 <40 100 0.3 5.3 <5 <1 6.5 99 0.96 j 1.5 230 240 BC-14F (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 110000 <2 <2 380 3.8 42 j <0.5 4.6 j 0.36 j <20 210 9.6 64 72000 32 7.1 150 0.19 j <40 80 0.54 2.9 j 2.2 j <1 3.9 j 58 1.5 0.46 j 180 120 BC-14F (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/23/2019 56000 <2 3.4 130 2.5 26 j <0.5 2.3 j 0.4 j <20 86 11 31 14000 17 2.2 j 59 0.099 j <40 35 j 0.41 1.4 j <5 <1 3.4 j 26 1.3 0.2 j 88 48 BC-14H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 78000 <2 5.7 210 2.4 95 0.15 j 2.9 j 0.25 j <20 81 20 57 53000 27 2.8 j 260 <0.2 <40 42 1.2 5 1.9 j <1 3.7 j 38 3.2 0.29 j 130 82 BC-14H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 36000 <2 1.9 j 200 1.6 26 j <0.5 1.8 j 0.29 j <20 43 11 30 26000 8.5 2.4 j 210 <0.2 <40 26 j 0.67 2.6 j 1.3 j <1 2.9 j 19 2.5 0.18 j 62 54 BC-14H (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 96000 <2 4.3 410 3.9 61 <0.5 4.1 j <1 <20 120 20 73 110000 28 6.2 1400 <0.2 <40 68 0.16 3.7 j 2.3 j <1 3.5 j 33 1 0.41 j 210 130 BC-14H (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 100000 <2 4.7 450 3.9 27 j 0.13 j 3.7 j 0.27 j <20 140 15 79 110000 31 6.5 980 <0.2 <40 74 0.11 4 j 1.7 j <1 2.3 j 34 2.6 0.52 220 140 BC-14H (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/23/2019 18000 MO <2 <2 60 0.49 28 j <0.5 1.4 j 0.38 j <20 20 2.5 j 10 13000 MO 3.6 1.5 j 82 <0.2 <40 it j 0.36 0.8 j <5 <1 2.1 j 8.6 j 2.8 <0.5 27 23 BC-14J (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 17000 <2 <2 130 0.46 75 <0.5 2.6 j 0.27 j <20 27 5 19 16000 4.1 1.1 j 670 <0.2 <40 13 j 0.75 1.3 j <5 <1 4.5 j 27 1.3 <0.5 38 32 BC-143 (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 42000 0.7 j 2.5 230 0.89 73 <0.5 2.7 j 0.33 j <20 65 10 51 42000 13 2.1 j 810 <0.2 <40 34 j 2.8 2.5 j <5 <1 4.5 j 48 5.9 0.25 j 120 54 BC-14J (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 59000 <2 4 290 1 70 0.2 j 4.9 j 0.26 j <20 82 12 59 61000 18 2.5 j 1100 <0.2 17 j 43 1.4 2.1 j 1.7 j <1 3.4 j 74 1.5 0.22 j 180 72 BC-141 (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 44000 <2 10 210 0.81 64 <0.5 4.6 j 0.27 j <20 58 8.9 49 47000 16 1.7 j 740 <0.2 28 j 30 j 1.8 2.3 j 1.3 j <1 2.8 j 140 2.5 0.16 j 150 49 BC-143 (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 8500 <2 <2 35 0.3 j 45 j <0.5 2.4 j <1 <20 11 2.3 j 3.7 j 8600 2.2 <5 280 <0.2 <40 <40 4.6 <5 <5 <1 4.1 j 31 2 <0.5 23 10 j BC-16B (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 550 1.2 j 3.2 13 j <0.4 67 <0.5 23 0.21 j <20 <10 <5 <10 160 0.27 j <5 2.5 j <0.2 15 j <40 0.38 1 j 2.5 j <1 2.8 j 89 13 <0.5 5.5 <20 BC-16B (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 8400 <2 <2 24 j 0.26 j 52 <0.5 <5 <1 <20 6.3 j <5 3.1 j 1900 2.1 <5 23 <0.2 <40 <40 0.13 <5 <5 <1 3.5 j 4.1 j 4.3 <0.5 9.8 7.4 j BC-16B (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 58000 <2 6.3 330 3.6 45 j <0.5 3.9 j 0.21 j <20 43 15 38 29000 7.9 3.4 j 140 <0.2 <40 39 j 0.18 5.4 <5 <1 5.4 62 4.7 0.38 j 37 75 BC-16B (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/23/2019 2800 1.3 j 18 12 j <0.4 60 <0.5 22 0.46 j <20 <10 <5 3.8 j <100 <1 <5 <15 <0.2 25 j <40 0.22 1.3 j 4.6 j <1 2.1 j 72 8.7 <0.5 57 <20 BC-16D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/23/2019 2500 <2 <2 12 j 0.17 j 28 j <0.5 <5 <1 <20 1.7 j <5 2.4 j 1300 0.79 j <5 12 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.82 <5 <5 <1 5.6 <10 2.3 <0.5 4 j 5.3 j BC-16D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/23/2019 9400 0.73 j <2 60 0.69 28 j <0.5 1 j 0.22 j <20 6.9 j 1.4 j 4.3 j 6100 5.5 <5 57 <0.2 <40 <40 0.62 1.3 j <5 <1 7.1 9 j 1.9 <0.5 8.1 12 j BC-16D (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/23/2019 <400 <2 <2 4.7 j <0.4 21 j <0.5 1.4 j 0.22 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 27 <0.2 <40 <40 2.7 <5 <5 <1 4.2 j 15 1.9 <0.5 <5 3.2 j BC-16F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 5700 0.79 j,S1 <2 20 j <0.4 23 j <0.5 <5 1.1 <20 3 j <5 <10 1900 0.98 j <5 21 <0.2 <40 <40 7.4 <5 <5 <1 3.7 j 3 j 0.52 j <0.5 10 4.5 j BC-16F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 50000 <2 2 130 0.48 28 j <0.5 0.91 j 0.3 j <20 37 7 S1 22 38000 13 2.6 j 130 <0.2 <40 14 j 5.5 3.2 j <5 <1 3.7 j 58 3.8 0.48 j,S1 47 45 BC-16F (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 140000 <2 2.3 350 0.69 36 j <0.5 7.6 <1 <20 150 70 S1 74 88000 24 9.7 1400 <0.2 <40 65 3.7 6.6 1.7 j <1 9.5 110 1.3 0.73 S1 120 170 BC-16F (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/22/2019 120000 <2 2.9 410 0.61 47 j <0.5 6.8 0.28 j <20 120 13 S1 64 79000 25 7 410 0.092 j <40 80 2.3 5.2 1.5 j <1 7.2 99 1.6 0.57 S1 93 160 BC-16F (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/22/2019 100000 <2 2.1 310 1 50 0.13 j 5.7 0.36 j <20 170 16 S1 100 43000 NA 5.7 410 NA <40 76 6.3 4.5 j NA NA 7.6 78 1.9 NA NA 160 BC-16H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 66000 <2 3.8 260 1.3 93 <0.5 2.8 j 0.21 j <20 76 20 56 62000 20 3.2 j 1700 0.095 j 1 <40 52 0.078 4.4 j 1.7 j <1 1.7 j 50 5.8 0.46 j 130 90 BC-16H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 20000 <2 <2 70 0.33 j 61 <0.5 1.9 j 0.23 j <20 20 4.2 j 14 16000 3.1 1 j 410 <0.2 <40 12 j 0.13 0.65 j <5 <1 3.9 j 12 1.3 <0.5 79 26 BC-16H (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 1600 0.72 j 1.9 j 18 j <0.4 74 <0.5 17 0.21 j <20 1.3 j <5 2.5 j 960 0.29 j 1.5 j 33 <0.2 8.5 j <40 0.1 <5 <5 <1 0.89 j 74 6.4 <0.5 6.3 <20 BC-16H (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 6500 <2 4.3 33 0.18 j 56 <0.5 14 0.23 j <20 5.6 j 2.1 j 4.9 j 5200 1.5 1.7 j 55 <0.2 16 j <40 0.022 <5 <5 <1 3.6 j 61 4.6 <0.5 110 8.2 j BC-16H (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 31000 <2 <2 100 0.29 j 64 <0.5 2 j 0.23 j <20 28 3.6 j 14 22000 4.4 1.8 j 240 <0.2 <40 17 j 2.8 0.94 j <5 <1 5 13 1.6 0.17 j 43 38 BC-161 (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 21000 <2 <2 100 0.46 140 <0.5 1.3 j 0.27 j <20 27 5.4 19 18000 5.1 0.72 j 310 <0.2 <40 14 j 0.6 2 j <5 <1 2.6 j 22 2.3 <0.5 36 26 BC-161 (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 35000 <2 1.6 j 230 0.81 57 <0.5 3.6 j 0.25 j <20 52 9.8 35 37000 9.2 2 j 1200 <0.2 <40 26 j 5.8 1.2 j <5 <1 2.7 j 31 2 0.16 j 78 50 BC-163 (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 55000 <2 2.8 230 1.1 40 j <0.5 2.3 j 0.22 j <20 71 16 47 61000 19 2.4 j 1000 <0.2 <40 44 0.038 1.3 j <5 <1 <5 20 1.3 0.26 j 130 66 BC-16J (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 47000 <2 3.9 160 0.8 42 j <0.5 2.4 j 0.24 j <20 60 14 37 55000 15 2 j 980 <0.2 <40 32 j 0.41 1.2 j <5 <1 2.1 j 20 2.1 0.19 j 140 53 BC-163 (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 14000 <2 1.8 j 53 0.35 j <50 <0.5 1.2 j 0.37 j <20 18 2 j 8.3 j 13000 3.4 <5 100 <0.2 <40 7.3 j 2.7 <5 <5 <1 3 j 9.9 j 3 <0.5 29 16 j BC-18D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 6 j <0.4 <50 <0.5 1.7 j 0.4 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 160 <0.2 <40 <40 0.82 B <5 <5 <1 <5 25 2.2 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-18D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 1400 <2 <2 29 <0.4 20 j <0.5 1.3 j <1 <20 <10 <5 2.2 j 700 0.68 j <5 58 <0.2 <40 <40 13 <5 <5 <1 1.7 j 12 4.2 <0.5 <5 2.5 j BC-18F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 200 j <2 <2 4.3 j <0.4 <50 <0.5 <5 0.4 j <20 <10 <5 2 j 86 j <1 <5 21 <0.2 <40 <40 0.6 B <5 <5 <1 1.7 j 7.7 j 5 <0.5 <5 6.9 j BC-18F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 680 <2 <2 9 j <0.4 28 j <0.5 <5 0.28 j <20 <10 <5 1 2.5 j 350 0.28 j <5 16 <0.2 I <40 <40 6.9 B <5 <5 <1 2.3 j 7.4 j 5.8 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-18F (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 2100 <2 <2 16 j <0.4 49 j <0.5 0.73 j <1 <20 1.5 j <5 3.9 j 2200 0.97 j <5 34 <0.2 <40 <40 3.4 B <5 <5 <1 4.5 j 8.1 j 1 <0.5 <5 2.5 j BC-18H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 51000 <2 2.9 180 0.95 59 <0.5 2 j 0.23 j <20 55 15 43 40000 10 2.3 j 2000 <0.2 <40 38 j 3.8 1.7 j 1.6 j <1 0.67 j 25 1.2 0.4 j 140 70 BC-18H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 46000 <2 <2 150 0.57 65 <0.5 1.5 j 0.21 j <20 47 7.5 27 27000 7 2.2 j 770 <0.2 <40 33 j 0.28 1.6 j <5 <1 1.9 j 18 1.9 0.28 j 55 58 BC-18H (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 72000 <2 2.7 190 0.92 23 j <0.5 1.6 j 0.26 j <20 100 9.9 32 69000 13 2.8 j 410 0.11 j <40 48 0.068 1.3 j 1.3 j <1 0.89 j 21 1.4 0.32 j 140 80 BC-18H (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 130000 <2 6 380 1.4 22 j <0.5 3.8 j 0.26 j <20 200 38 70 160000 32 5.8 1800 0.16 j <40 110 1.7 2.6 j 2.7 j <1 <5 43 1.3 0.58 320 170 BC-183 (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 72000 0.77 j 110 420 0.79 120 0.18 j 7.5 0.21 j <20 100 20 80 74000 18 4.4 j 950 0.13 j 73 62 3.8 4.8 j 2.4 j <1 3.5 j 200 2.9 0.38 j 200 100 BC-18J (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 16000 <2 9.5 110 0.43 120 <0.5 3.8 j 0.24 j <20 20 4.5 j 13 15000 3.5 0.99 j 630 0.11 j 12 j 9.6 j 11 B 1.1 j <5 <1 5.4 61 6.8 <0.5 36 21 BC-183 (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 7400 <2 3.7 110 0.37 j 120 <0.5 7.8 0.27 j <20 8.9 j 2.3 j 5.2 j 7200 2 1.2 j 410 <0.2 <40 <40 16 B <5 <5 <1 7.8 52 15 <0.5 19 11 j BC-183 (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 8300 <2 <2 58 0.19 j 82 <0.5 0.97 j 0.26 j <20 10 <5 4.6 j 7000 2.2 <5 77 <0.2 <40 <40 6.6 <5 <5 <1 6.9 7.7 j 5.3 <0.5 29 13 j BC-18J (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 39000 <2 11 150 0.54 100 <0.5 5.9 0.34 j <20 52 7.2 27 35000 9.7 2.6 j 370 <0.2 10 j 26 j 4.4 1.3 j 1.4 j <1 4.5 j 47 6.7 0.16 j 110 43 BC-20D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 860 <2 <2 10 j <0.4 39 j <0.5 1.5 j <1 <20 <10 <5 2.5 j 680 <1 <5 22 <0.2 18 j <40 4.3 B <5 <5 <1 2.7 j 18 3.3 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-20D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 2200 <2 <2 18 j <0.4 43 j <0.5 0.86 j <1 <20 1.6 j <5 4.2 j 3900 0.73 j <5 46 <0.2 13 j <40 2.7 B <5 <5 <1 4.5 j 8.4 j 0.93 j <0.5 4 j 3.5 j BC-20F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 660 <2 <2 11 j <0.4 23 j <0.5 <5 <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 360 0.31 j <5 6.3 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.77 B <5 <5 <1 3.7 j 4.4 j 0.76 j <0.5 <5 <20 BC-20F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 <25 <0.4 <50 <0.5 1.6 j <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 8.3 j <0.2 <40 <40 4.4 B <5 <5 <1 0.98 j 21 3 <0.5 <5 2.5 j BC-20H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 <400 <2 <2 <25 <0.4 <50 <0.5 <5 0.81 j <10 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 11 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.085 <5 <5 <1 <5 <10 1.4 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-20H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 9900 <2 <2 47 0.15 j 75 <0.5 1.8 j 0.86 j <20 13 <5 6.9 j 4700 1.9 0.74 j 9 j <0.2 <40 <40 10 <5 <5 <1 10 17 2.2 <0.5 15 11 j BC-20H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 110000 <2 <2 240 0.47 <50 <0.5 2.1 j 0.63 j <20 110 6.6 58 34000 28 3 j 50 <0.2 <40 28 j 0.23 3.2 j <5 <1 <5 37 0.49 j 0.85 100 BC-20H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 62000 <2 1.3 j 140 0.36 j 41 j <0.5 3.1 j 0.45 j <20 110 6.1 S1 28 50000 15 2.8 j 22 <0.2 <40 23 j 8.6 1.4 j <5 <1 3.5 j 40 4.1 0.36 j,Sl 130 L77 49 BC-20H (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 180000 <2 3.1 460 0.85 <50 <0.5 6.4 0.37 j <20 270 23 110 100000 44 7.8 72 0.13 j <40 86 0.22 4.3 j <5 <1 <5 91 0.94 j 1.2 320 240 BC-20H (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 24000 0.77 j,S1 <2 120 0.61 69 <0.5 2.2 j 0.31 j <20 43 5.1 S1 19 18000 7.5 1.4 j 17 0.12 j <40 16 j 16 <5 <5 <1 8.1 21 6.1 <0.5 50 33 Page 2 of 3 TABLE 2 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - SPLP ASH BASIN CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLING SUMMARY DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC Sample ID Associated Unit Sample Media Depth Interval (Feet BGS) Sample Collection Date Aluminum Antimony Arsenic Barium Beryllium Boron Cadmium Calcium Chloride Chromium (VI) Chromium Cobalt Copper Iron Lead Magnesium Manganese Mercury Molybdenum Nickel Nitrate (as N) Potassium Selenium Silver Sodium Strontium Sulfate Thallium Vanadium Zinc BC-20H (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 150000 <2 7.1 610 1.6 <50 <0.5 9.5 0.25 j <20 250 31 130 99000 59 9.2 150 0.2 <40 94 0.38 4.6 j 2.7 j <1 1.6 j 110 2 1.2 380 240 BC-20H (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 20 j <0.4 <50 <0.5 1.4 j 0.2 j <20 <10 2.3 j,S1 <10 <100 <1 0.69 j 24 <0.2 <40 <40 3.4 B <5 <5 <1 <5 17 4.1 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-20H (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/15/2019 21000 <2 2.9 60 0.41 <50 <0.5 1.3 j 0.27 j <20 29 5.9 12 11000 5.5 0.72 j 58 <0.2 <40 12 j 0.5 <5 <5 <1 <5 15 1.6 <0.5 43 24 BC-20H (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 05/22/2019 2300 <2 <2 11 j <0.4 33 j <0.5 0.74 j 0.2 j <20 2.6 j <5 3.2 j 1200 0.42 j <5 7.6 j <0.2 <40 <40 2.5 B <5 <5 <1 3.3 j 5.6 j 1.7 <0.5 4.6 j 3 j BC-203 (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 45000 <2 2 190 0.72 74 <0.5 3.2 j <1 <20 55 8.1 37 41000 9.5 2.6 j 550 <0.2 <40 35 j 8.9 B 1.7 j <5 <1 3.5 j 30 5.1 0.25 j 80 54 BC-20J (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 28000 <2 1.5 j 140 0.56 65 <0.5 2.1 j <1 <20 40 4.2 j 19 23000 7.2 1.9 j 250 0.099 j <40 20 j 5.7 0.91 j <5 <1 5.7 17 2.3 <0.5 51 33 BC-201 (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 10000 <2 <2 63 0.28 j 70 <0.5 1.2 j <1 <20 16 2.2 j 9.7 j 10000 2.7 0.8 j 140 <0.2 <40 11 j 6.3 <5 <5 <1 6.5 7.6 j 3.2 <0.5 26 18 j BC-20J (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 12000 <2 <2 49 0.26 j 89 <0.5 0.83 j 0.22 j <20 14 3.9 j 11 12000 2.9 <5 250 <0.2 <40 7.5 j 5 <5 <5 <1 5.4 7.9 j 2.7 <0.5 29 15 j BC-22D (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 9.4 j 0.26 j <50 <0.5 2.3 j <1 <20 <10 2.3 j,S1 2.2 j 660 <1 <5 80 <0.2 <40 <40 0.37 B 2.1 j <5 <1 <5 45 14 <0.5 <5 2.7 j BC-22D (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 5.6 j <0.4 M <50 <0.5 2 j <1 <20 <10 2.2 j,S1 <10 390 <1 <5 170 <0.2 <40 <40 0.63 B 1.4 j <5 M <1 <5 32 12 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-22F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 7 j <0.4 <50 <0.5 10 0.34 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 0.77 j <15 <0.2 25 j <40 1 B <5 <5 <1 <5 92 4.9 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-22F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 <400 <2 <2 <25 <0.4 <50 <0.5 <5 0.27 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 2.1 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.58 B <5 <5 <1 <5 9.7 j 1.5 <0.5 <5 4.3 j BC-22F (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/22/2019 <400 0.73 j,S1 <2 <25 <0.4 26 j <0.5 <5 <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 49 j <1 <5 3.7 j <0.2 <40 <40 1 0.15 <5 <5 <1 5.1 14 4.1 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-22H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 870 0.58 j,S1 <2 8.8 j <0.4 32 j <0.5 1.3 j <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 570 0.35 j <5 15 <0.2 16 j <40 2.1 0.7 j <5 <1 4.5 j 19 1.9 <0.5 4 j 8.3 j BC-22H (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 2500 0.75 j,S1 11 12 j <0.4 35 j <0.5 <5 <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 2300 1.3 <5 29 <0.2 35 j <40 2 <5 <5 <1 6.1 10 2.1 <0.5 10 2.6 j BC-22J (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 51000 0.81 j 5.9 230 0.64 110 <0.5 3.3 j 0.2 j <20 61 13 48 44000 16 2.5 j 800 <0.2 32 j 54 0.16 5.2 1.5 j <1 1.1 j 79 9.9 0.35 j 160 63 BC-22J (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 31000 <2 <2 110 0.52 92 <0.5 2.2 j 0.23 j <20 35 6.1 22 22000 7.2 1.5 j 560 <0.2 <40 26 j 0.098 3.1 j <5 <1 1.1 j 51 2.1 0.2 j 52 40 BC-22J (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 73000 <2 6.6 240 0.71 54 <0.5 3.9 j <1 <20 100 9.7 65 56000 19 3.6 j 1200 0.17 j 11 j 50 0.013 j 3.7 j 1.5 j <1 1.3 j 81 1.6 0.38 j 180 80 BC-223 (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/15/2019 22000 <2 6.5 66 0.47 30 j <0.5 2.1 j 0.31 j <20 30 4.7 j 24 19000 5.8 1.6 j 230 <0.2 7.9 j 14 j 0.54 <5 <5 <1 0.71 j 23 2.1 <0.5 59 26 BC-24F (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 560 <2 <2 6.7 j <0.4 46 j <0.5 <5 <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 310 <1 <5 12 j <0.2 <40 <40 16 MO <5 <5 <1 6 8.5 j 13 M <0.5 4.1 j <20 BC-24F (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/22/2019 2000 <2 <2 25 <0.4 21 j <0.5 <5 <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 1000 <1 <5 38 <0.2 <40 <40 2.7 0.79 j <5 <1 4.2 j 4.8 j 3.9 <0.5 4.5 j 2.7 j BC-24H (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/22/2019 6100 <2 2.9 71 0.18 j 28 j <0.5 0.74 j <1 <20 3.4 j <5 <10 3300 3.3 <5 45 <0.2 <40 <40 2.6 2.5 j <5 <1 5.4 11 1.7 <0.5 13 4.9 j BC-24J (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/15/2019 43000 <2 37 160 0.45 37 j <0.5 5.1 0.29 j <20 42 7.1 26 39000 15 2.4 j 340 <0.2 130 20 j 0.19 2.8 j <5 <1 1.8 j 70 2.2 0.24 j 61 40 BC-24J (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/15/2019 9800 0.61 j <2 47 0.35 j <50 <0.5 <5 0.26 j <20 7.3 j 2.6 j 5 j 10000 10 <5 190 <0.2 <40 <40 7.8 0.76 j <5 <1 <5 12 1.9 <0.5 74 12 j BC-243 (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/15/2019 33000 <2 22 120 0.4 42 j <0.5 4.1 j <1 <20 31 8.3 21 32000 13 1.4 j 290 <0.2 170 15 j 0.075 2.4 j <5 <1 1.5 j 54 2.1 0.23 j 54 36 BC-26G (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 3500 <2 <2 24 j 0.21 j 23 j <0.5 1 j 0.26 j <20 1.9 j <5 3.1 j 2500 1.3 <5 25 <0.2 <40 <40 7.4 <5 <5 <1 4.1 j 14 11 <0.5 4.3 j 4.7 j BC-26G (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 32000 <2 <2 230 1.7 54 <0.5 2.3 j 0.28 j <20 26 8.8 49 24000 6.5 2.1 j 640 <0.2 <40 18 j 2.7 3.9 j <5 <1 4.5 j 34 3.7 0.23 j 31 45 BC-26G (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/14/2019 1900 <2 <2 20 j <0.4 32 j <0.5 <5 0.2 j <20 <10 <5 2.1 j 1600 0.49 j <5 25 <0.2 <40 <40 2.4 <5 <5 <1 1.6 j 7.4 j 4.1 <0.5 2.6 j 3.8 j BC-26I (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 3500 0.75 j 3.9 19 j 0.22 j 100 <0.5 1.5 j <1 <20 2.7 j <5 3.8 j 1800 0.47 j <5 29 <0.2 33 j <40 7.2 0.88 j <5 <1 3.1 j 1 25 8 <0.5 6.5 3.6 j BC-26I (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 <400 <2 <2 3.3 j <0.4 27 j <0.5 <5 0.31 j <20 <10 <5 <10 <100 <1 <5 58 <0.2 <40 <40 0.16 <5 <5 <1 <5 5.8 j 4.9 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-26K (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 410 <2 <2 5.7 j <0.4 40 j <0.5 <5 0.44 j <20 <10 <5 <10 300 <1 <5 4 j <0.2 <40 <40 1.8 <5 <5 <1 5.4 <10 2 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-26K (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 110 j <2 <2 4.5 j <0.4 24 j <0.5 1.3 j 0.26 j <20 <10 <5 <10 150 <1 <5 23 <0.2 6.1 j <40 0.027 <5 <5 <1 1.1 j 21 1.6 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-28I (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 <400 <2 <2 14 j <0.4 21 j <0.5 1.3 j 0.2 j <20 <10 1.3 j <10 <100 <1 <5 59 <0.2 <40 <40 0.067 0.72 j <5 <1 <5 31 7.1 <0.5 <5 4.4 j BC-28I (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 3600 <2 5.1 34 0.34 j 45 j <0.5 <5 0.26 j <20 2.9 j <5 2.5 j 2300 1.3 <5 29 <0.2 5.1 j <40 2.2 <5 <5 <1 3.1 j 5.9 j 2 <0.5 4 j 6.6 j BC-28I (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/14/2019 2200 <2 6.9 28 0.23 j 21 j <0.5 <5 0.23 j <20 1.4 j 1.5 j 3 j 2300 2.6 <5 91 <0.2 <40 <40 1 <5 <5 <1 1.3 j 9.4 j 1.9 <0.5 70 4.7 j BC-28K (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 840 1 j 1.6 j 14 j <0.4 62 <0.5 1 j 0.27 j <20 <10 <5 2.4 j 1100 0.5 j <5 14 j <0.2 8.9 j <40 3.6 <5 <5 <1 3.6 j 19 8.9 <0.5 3.7 j <20 BC-28K (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 2300 <2 7.4 25 <0.4 42 j <0.5 3.2 j <1 <20 1.8 j <5 3.3 j 1800 0.62 j <5 77 <0.2 5.5 j <40 4.9 1.4 j 2.5 j <1 2.4 j 65 10 <0.5 6.1 3.9 j BC-28M (0) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 0 - 0.5 05/14/2019 1800 <2 <2 24 j <0.4 37 j <0.5 <5 0.28 j <20 1.8 j <5 2.3 j 1200 0.43 j <5 13 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.32 <5 <5 <1 1.8 j 8.1 j 3.6 <0.5 2.5 j 3.6 j BC-28M (2) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 2 - 2.5 05/14/2019 270 j <2 <2 4.8 j <0.4 56 <0.5 1.9 j <1 <20 <10 <5 <10 300 <1 <5 12 j <0.2 <40 <40 0.058 1.1 j <5 <1 <5 25 4.5 <0.5 <5 <20 BC-28M (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 05/14/2019 19000 <2 82 37 0.47 51 <0.5 2.9 j <1 <20 18 4.4 j 11 14000 3.8 <5 150 <0.2 27 j 7.4 j 2.2 1.9 j <5 <1 2.9 j 62 5.1 <0.5 33 19 j BC-28M (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 05/14/2019 <400 0.77 j 4.4 5.2 j <0.4 41 j <0.5 2 j <1 <20 <10 <5 2.2 j <100 <1 <5 30 <0.2 31 j <40 7.7 1.4 j <5 <1 1.2 j 35 8.7 <0.5 <5 <20 NC-OC (7) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 7 - 7.5 06/20/2019 45000 <2 1.6 j 100 0.64 110 <0.5 3.2 j 0.34 j <20 44 9.6 49 33000 16 1.2 j 220 <0.2 <40 24 j 0.15 2.3 j <5 <1 3 j 24 3.1 0.17 j 83 41 NC-OC (12) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 12 - 12.5 06/20/2019 79000 <2 3.2 250 0.98 42 j <0.5 1.8 j 0.41 j <20 88 24 58 54000 23 2.5 j 430 <0.2 <40 56 0.19 2.2 j 2.2 j <1 5 21 0.62 j 0.31 j 120 190 NC-OC (17) Ash Basin Soil SPLP 17 - 17.5 06/20/2019 69000 <2 3.1 240 0.9 53 <0.5 1.3 j 0.26 j <20 98 26 39 58000 27 2.3 j 570 <0.2 <40 51 0.15 2.2 j <5 <1 2.1 j 14 1.6 0.36 j 130 1 87 Prepared by: BER Checked by: ENK Page 3 of 3 TABLE 3 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - NOTES DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC ABBREVIATION NOTES BGS - below ground surface BOD - Biologic Oxygen Demand CB - Compliance Boundary COD - Chemical Oxygen Demand Deg C - Degrees Celsius DMAs - dimethylarsinic acid DUP - Duplicate Eh - Redox Potential ft - Feet GPM - gallons per minute IMAC - Interim Maximum Allowable Concentrations. From the 15A NCAC 02L Standard, Appendix 1, April, 1, 2013. MDC - Minimum Detectable Concentration McSe - Methylseleninic acid mg/kg - milligrams per kilogram mg/L - milligrams per liter mg-N/L - Milligram nitrogen per liter MMAs - monomethylarsonic acid mV - millivolts NA - Not available or Not Applicable ND - Not detected NE - Not established NM - Not measured NTUs - Nephelometric Turbidity Units pCi/L - picocuries per liter PSRG - Primary Soil Remediation Goals RL - Reporting Limit SeCN - selnocynante SeMe (IV) - Selenomethionine SPLP - Synthetic Precipitation Leaching Procedure S.U. - Standard Units TCLP - Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure ug/L - micrograms per liter ug/mL - microgram per milliliter umhos/cm - micromhos per centimenter Well Locations referenced to NAD83 and elevations referenced to NAVD88 LABORATORY FLAGS < - concentration not detected at or above the adjusted reporting limit. ^ Federal MCL. * - Interim Maximum Allowable Concentrations (IMACs) of the 15A NCAC 02L Standard, Appendix 1, April 1, 2013. 1g - Result confirmed by second analysis performed out of hold. 2g - The concentration in the Blank QC is less than the reporting limit but greater than 1/2 the reporting limit. B - Target analyte detected in method blank at or above the reporting limit. Target analyte concentration in sample is less than 1OX the concentration in the method blank. Analyte concentration in sample could be due to blank contamination. B1 - Target analyte detected in method blank at or above the reporting limit. Target analyte concentration in sample was greater than 1OX the concentration in the method blank. Analyte concentration in sample is not affected by blank contamination. B2 - Target analyte was detected in blank(s) at a concentration greater than 1/2 the reporting limit but less than the reporting limit. Analyte concentration in sample is valid and may be used for compliance purposes. B3 - Target analyte was detected in Continuing Calibration Blank(s) at a concentration greater than 1/2 the reporting limit but less than the reporting limit. Analyte concentration in sample is valid and may be used for compliance purposes. 134 - Target analyte was detected in Continuing Calibration Blank(s) at or above the reporting limit. Page 1 of 2 TABLE 3 CLOSURE SOIL SAMPLE ANALYTICAL RESULTS - NOTES DAN RIVER STEAM STATION DUKE ENERGY CAROLINAS, LLC, EDEN, NC LABORATORY FLAGS (CONTINUED) B5 - Target analyte was present in blank(s) above the method detection limit but less than the reporting limit. Data is valid for compliance purposes. B6 - Target analyte was detected in Continuing Calibration Blank(s) at a concentration greater than the reporting limit. BC - The same analyte was detected in an associated blank at a concentration above 1/2 the reporting limit but below the laboratory reporting limit. CO - Result confirmed by second analysis. CH - The continuing calibration for this compound is outside of Pace Analytical acceptance limits. The results may be biased high. CL - The continuing calibration for this compound is outside of Pace Analytical acceptance limits. The results may be biased low. CR - The dissolved metal result was greater than the total metal result for this element. Results were confirmed by reanalysis. CU - The continuing calibration for this compound is outside of Pace Analytical acceptance limits. Analyte presence below reporting limits in associated samples. Results unaffected by high bias. D3 - Sample was diluted due to the presence of high levels of non -target analytes or other matrix interference. D4 - Sample was diluted due to the presence of high levels of target analytes. D6 - The precision between the sample and sample duplicate exceeded laboratory control limits. E - Analyte concentration exceeded the calibration range. The reported result is estimated. H - Sample analyzed past the recommended holding time. H1 - Analysis conducted outside the EPA method holding time. H2 - Extraction of preparation conducted outside EPA method holding time. H3 - Sample was received or analysis requested beyond the recognized method holding time. H6 - Analysis initiated outside of the 15 minute EPA required holding time. HS - Results are from sample aliquot taken from VOA vial with headspace (air bubble greater than 6 mm diameter). j - Estimated concentration above the adjusted method detection limit and below the adjusted reporting limit. j- - Estimated concentration, biased low. j+ - Estimated concentration, biased high. Ll - Analyte recovery in the laboratory control sample (LCS) was above quality control (QC) limits. Results may be biased high. L2 - Analyte recovery in the laboratory control sample (LCS) was below QC limits. Results for this analyte in associated samples may be biased low. L3 - Analyte recovery in the laboratory control sample (LCS) exceeded quality control (QC) limits. Analyte presence below reporting limits in associated samples. Results unaffected by high bias. M - Matrix spike / matrix spike dup failure. M1 - Matrix spike recovery was high: the associated Laboratory Control Spike (LCS) was acceptable. M2 - Matrix spike recovery was Low: the associated Laboratory Control Spike (LCS) was acceptable. M4 - The spike recovery value was unusable since the analyte concentration in the sample was disproportionate to the spike level. M6 - Matrix spike and Matrix spike duplicate recovery not evaluated against control limits due to sample dilution. N2 - The lab does not hold accreditation for this parameter. P2 - Re -extraction or re -analysis could not be performed due to insufficient sample amount. P4 - Sample field preservation does not meet EPA or method recommendations for this analysis. P8 - Analyte was detected in the method blank. All associated samples had concentrations of at least ten times greater than the blank or were below the reporting limit. RO - The data are unusable. The sample results are rejected due to serious deficiencies in meeting QC criteria. The analyte may or may not be present in the sample. Rl - Relative Percent Difference (RPD) value was outside control limits. S - Associated calibration check did not meet specified criteria. S1 - Data review findings indicate result may be unreliable. Use with caution. U - Analyte was analyzed for, but not detected above the MDC. Page 2 of 2