Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout19960975 Ver 1_Complete File_20020401O?0? W A r?RQG co r o -c Michael F. Easley, Governor William G. Ross Jr., Secretary North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Gregory J. Thorpe, Ph.D. Acting Director Division of Water Quality April 1, 2002 Tracy Rush Jay Carter and Associates, Inc. P. O. Box 891 Southern Pines, NC 28388 Dear Ms. Rush; Re: DWQ review of 2000 and 2001 Annual Wetland monitoring reports Columbus County Airport Columbus County DWQ # 96-0975 DWQ staff have reviewed the above mentioned reports dated January 31, 2002 (received January 29, 202). These reports are sufficient to meet the mitigation requirements of the 401 Water Quality Certification with the following additions. Please address these points in a subsequent submittal so we can approve these reports: 1. The flashboard risers must eventually be replaced with permanent water control measures. Please present a schedule to accomplish this. 2. An engineer must certify the stability of the new dam especially given its past problems. Please provide this written certification. 3. A map of sampling locations must be provided with }'our response and all subsequent reporting, and 4. Please address the goal of mitigation (in terms of wetland type and functions) in your response and all subsequent reporting. I can be reached at 919-733-9646 if you have any questions. cc: File Copy Central Files DWQ Wilmington Regional Office ITC Wetlands Restoration Program ?A Nr_DENq N. C. Division of Water Quality, 401 Wetlands Certification Unit, 1,350 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1650 (Mailing Address) 2321 Crabtree Blvd., Raleigh, NC 27604-2260 (Location) (919) 733-1786 (phone), 919-733-6893 (fax), (http://h2o.enr.state.nc.us/ncwetlands Sincerely, Re'(?'u7Q rw' uAr- ?afl t a wQ Zoa ? u«-? Coluwbcs R6-oR7S rk air a4 a?? ?u ?? 2, aD2 2-a.0 -Z) cv -Row; pit-- 'jk? '4 ?Qpsln bEor?Q ria-errs /1?9?- R.UeM$ _ __ va? li'? 'OA DR. J.H. CARTER III & ASSOCIATES, INC. 2 9 2002 Environmental Consultants 06 P.O. Box 891 • Southern Pines, N.C. 28388 (9 0) 95-104 • F x (910) 695-3317 'Letter of Transmittal C16; To John Dorney, Supervisor Wetlands/401 Certification Unit 2321 Crabtree Boulevard, Suite 250 Raleigh, NC 27604-2260 WE ARE SENDING YOU Date: 28 Jan. 2002 Job # 9212 Attn: John Dorne Re: DW Project # 960975 Attached X Reports Copy of letter Plans Prints Photos Maps Data COPIES DATE # P s DESCRIPTION 2 1-31-02 39 2000 Annual Report, Columbus County Airport Wetland Mitigation Plan Implementation, Columbus County, NC DWQ Project # 960975 2 1-31-02 39 2001 Annual Report, Columbus County Airport Wetland Mitigation Plan Implementation, Columbus County, NC DWQ Project # 960975 THESE ARE TRANSMITTED For approval X_ For your use _ As requested For review and comment REMARKS: Approved as noted Approved as submitted Returned for corrections For your information COPY TO: John Whitehurst - Columbus County SIGNED: Andy Lamm - Hobbs, Upchurch & Associates, Inc. If enclosures are not noted, please contact us immediately Endangered Species Surveys • Environmental Assessments • Land Management 9 Wetlands Mapping and Permitting ? r A - ' 2 9 2002 17 2000 ANNUAL REPORT COLUMBUS COUNTY AIRPORT WETLAND MITIGATION PLAN IMPLEMENTATION COLUMBUS COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina Water Quality Certification 2671 (DWQ Project #960975) Prepared By: Ms. Tracy Rush and Dr. J.H. Carter III Dr. J.H. Carter III & Associates, Inc. Environmental Consultants P.O. Box 891 Southern Pines, North Carolina 28388 Submitted 31 January 2002 N.C. Division of Water Quality Wetlands/401 Certification Unit 2321 Crabtree Boulevard, Suite 250 Raleigh, NC 27604-2260 "f . , I , 2000 ANNUAL REPORT COLUMBUS COUNTY AIRPORT WETLANDS MITIGATION PLAN IMPLEMENTATION COLUMBUS COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA INTRODUCTION Columbus County Airport proposes to restore wetland hydrology on at least 4.76 acres, and potentially as much as to 8.6 acres, in order to mitigate for the loss of 4.76 acres of jurisdictional wetlands during construction of a runway extension. In addition, wetlands hydrology will be enhanced on 2.34 acres of jurisdictional wetland. This report, prepared in accordance with North Carolina Water Quality Certification 2671 (DWQ Project 4960975), outlines wetlands mitigation and monitoring activities at the Columbus County Airport during 2000. Mitigation and monitoring activities at the airport in 2000 consisted of water control, groundwater monitoring and monitoring of vegetation plots. PROJECT SITE The Columbus County Airport is located 1.14 miles southwest of Brunswick off State Road 1181 (Figure 1). The airport property contains 246.9 acres and consists of a single runway 5500 feet long, a small terminal building, hangers and support buildings. Most of the unpaved airport grounds are vegetated with manicured grasses and low brushy thickets. Vegetation is kept to less than 6 feet in height in order to comply with Federal Aviation Administration clear zone regulations. The wetlands filled during.construction of a runway extension consisted of herbaceous and shrub wetlands dominated by species such as sweet gum (Liquidambar styraciflua), red maple (Ater rubrum), swamp blackgum (Nyssa biflora), inkberry (Ilex glabra), waxmyrtle (Myrica cerifera), titi (Cyrilla racemiflora), sweetbay (Magnolia virginiana), cinnamon fern (Osmunda cinnamomea), netted chain-fern (Woodwardia areolata), beakrushes (Rhynchospora spp.) and soft rush (Juncus effusus). All of the filled wetlands had been ditched in the past and had varying degrees of hydrologic modification. The restoration area is located in the southwest portion of the airport property adjacent to the runway (Figure 2). The restoration area is vegetated with saplings, shrubs and herbaceous Figure 1. Location of Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. vegetation including sweet gum, swamp blackgum, red maple, loblolly pine (Pinus taeda), waxmyrtle, inkberry, blueberries (Vacinium spp.), sweet pepperbush (Clethra alnifloia), broom- sedge (Andropogon virginicus) and bracken fern (Pteridium aquilinum). Ditching in the past has adversely impacted the hydrology of the restoration site and adjacent areas. A significant area appears to have been impounded in the past (organic cross-bedding in sandy sediments). Soils on the proposed mitigation site are Rains and Grifton fine sandy loams. Both series are hydric soils. A narrow band of jurisdictional wetland (2.34 acres) occurs within the restoration site (Figure 2). Some of the wetland is dominated by herbaceous species, especially beakrushes, panic grasses (Dicanthelium spp.), meadow beauties (Rhexia spp.), southern waxy sedge (Carex glaucescens), honeycomb-head (Balduina uniflora), Coastal Plain thorough-wort (Eupatorium recurvans), yellow pitcher-plant (Sarracenia flava) and woolly sunbonnets (Chaptalia tomenstosa). Another portion is dominated by low shrubs such as black willow (Salix nigra), Virginia willow (Itea virginica), red maple and tag alder (Alnus serrulata), with a ground cover of netted chain-fern, Virginia chain-fern (Woodwardia virginica), royal fern (Osmunda regalis), camphor-weed (Pluchea sp.), false-nettle (Boehmeria cylindrica), climbing hempweed (Mikania scandens) and joe-pye-weed (Eupatorium fistulosum). The reference wetland area, located on the north side of the runway consists of low shrubs and herbs. Dominant herb and grass species include plume grass (Erianthus giganteus), hairy seedbox (Ludwigia pilosa), hairy panic grass (Panicum scoparium), Virginia chain-fern, slender spikegrass (Chasmanthium laxum) and bushy bluestem (Andropogon glomeratus). Dominant shrub species include inkberry and possum-haw viburnum (Viburnum nudum). 2000 MITIGATION ACTIVITIES Two 10-inch boards were installed in the water control structure on 13 September 2000 to hold water within the mitigation area. Water was not passing through the structure at this time. On 28 November 2000, the water level had risen to the top of the second board and some water was running in between the boards (Figure 3). Two additional boards were installed at this time (Figure 3). t(` /'' ti ION •'/' 1, al(a?i. 1 . 1 } '} ? N l.. /! Q o f i ? J 0W C ? r•1 ' r? ' ? ? 3 0 W bD ,j t ..... /il U ri. Q N Go 0 0 0 U t8 rn _O O 0 bA Cd O 9.1 0 N «3 ? O O t"n U 0 Q O U o ? o ? C N W w 1 (. , > Figure 3. Water control structure with 2 boards installed (top) and the addition of 2 more boards (bottom) at Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. A . , I 2000 MONITORING ACTIVITIES Monitoring Wells The 9 monitoring wells were installed on 15 September 1999. Three wells are located in the reference wetland, 5 wells are located in the mitigation area and 1 well was installed in an adjacent upland (Figure 2). The electronic monitoring wells are programmed to record water levels every 12 hours and are downloaded every 3-4 months. Water elevations and rainfall amounts for the period 1 January 2000 through 31 December 2000 are displayed graphically in Appendices A-C. The goal is to create wetland hydrology within the mitigation area (82, 83, and 84 foot wells). Criteria for wetland hydrology are met when the areas are inundated or saturated to within 12 inches of the surface for at least 12.5% of the growing season (30 consecutive days in most years). The growing season for Columbus County runs from mid-March to mid-November (240 days). In addition, groundwater in the mitigation area must be within +/- 2 inches of the reference wetland provided that the hydrograph for both areas have a similar shape. The 78 and 79 foot wells in the reference area met the wetland hydrology criteria (Appendices A.1 and A.2). The 78 foot well had standing water throughout most of the year. The 79 foot well had standing water periodically throughout the year and had water within 12 inches of the surface most of the year. The 80 foot well in the reference area did not meet wetland hydrology criteria during the year (Appendix A.3). The water level rose to within one foot of the surface, but did not remain there for more than a day or two. The 82 foot well is located in the narrow band of jurisdictional wetland in the mitigation area. This well site had standing water until the beginning of May (Appendix B.1). The water level then dropped several feet over the next month (probably due to spring vegetation growth) and then fluctuated the rest of the year. In the mitigation area, the 83 foot (west) and 84 foot (west) well sites had standing water until the beginning of May also and met the wetland hydrology criteria (Appendices B.2 and B.4 respectively). The 83 foot (east) well had water within 1 foot of the surface until 4 April 2000 when the well battery failed and data was not recorded until a new battery was installed on 12 June 2000 (Appendix B.3). t ' A ' The 84 foot (east) well had water levels within 1 foot of the surface for a period of 8 or 9 days on several occasions (Appendix B.5), but did not meet the wetland hydrology criteria of 30 consecutive days. The 85 foot upland monitoring well did not meet wetland hydrology criteria during the year. The water level at this location was within 1 foot of the surface only several days during the growing season (Appendix C.1). Average rainfall for Columbus County is approximately 49 inches (USDA 1990). Rainfall amounts recorded in Whiteville (State Climate Office of North Carolina) totaled 52.22 inches for the year. Rainfall amounts for the year 2000 in southeastern North Carolina can be considered normal. Vegetation Monitoring Plots Vegetation monitoring plots were inventoried on 13 and 14 September 2000. Two plots are located in the reference wetland, 5 plots (one at each monitoring well) are located in the restoration area and 1 plot is located in an adjacent upland area (Figure 2). The vegetation plots measure 10 meters by 10 meters and are centered on each monitoring well with the exception of the reference area. There are 2 wells within one of the vegetation plots in the reference area because of the sharp change in elevation in this area. The vegetation in each plot was characterized by species, prevalence and percent cover (see Appendix D-F for complete species lists). Plot R-1 in the reference area was dominated by possum-haw viburnum, woolly panic grass (Panicum scabriusculum), plume grass, hairy seedbox and Virginia chain-fern (Table 1).. Plot R-2 was dominated by slender spikegrass, broomsedge (Andropogon glomeratus) and inkberry (Table 1) with trace amounts of a variety of herbs, grasses and low shrubs (Appendix D). All of the dominant species located within the reference area are wetland indicator species. Plot #1 in the mitigation area, located at an elevation of 82 feet, was dominated by black willow. Other dominant tall shrub species included red maple, tag alder, swamp blackgum, elderberry (Sambucus canadensis) and possum-haw viburnum. Groundcover was dominated by joe-pye-weed, marsh dewflower (Murdannia keisak), swamp smartweed (Polygonum hydropiperioides), netted chain-fern and Virginia chain-fern (Table 2). All of the dominant species located in Plot #1 are wetland indicator species. Ar I . Table 1. Dominant vegetation* in the Reference Monitoring Plots, Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. 78 feet 79.5 feet Scientific Name Common Name Wetland Indicator Plot R-1 % Cover Plot R-2 % Cover Andropo on glomeratus bushy bluestem FACW+ -- 10-25% Chasmanthium laxum slender spikegrass FACW- -- 25-50% Erianthus iganteus plume grass FACW 10-25% -- Ilex glabra inkberry FACW -- 5-10% Ludwigia pilosa hairy seedbox OBL 10-25% -- Panicum scabriusculum woolly panic grass OBL 25-50% -- Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum FACW+ 50-75% -- Woodwardia virginica Virginia chain-fern OBL 5-10% -- * See Appendix D for a complete species list. z U O U 1 pO U O U v? 0 0 cql O C4 a? •3F ° O Q ? -? o HU Sw `o °' ? o ` o ` o ` 0 0 `n 0 `^ o y o n n C-4 o -, n N o tn O O -4 N O r-4 N O -4 O 1-4 , to 0 'WO k n 0 0 ? ? 0 0 0 0 ke) ,. _, ,--4 ,-, N V? ,_ N N l pMp o N O v1 Vl v7 O N tr) O O -4 O W) y 64 0 0 k OO a o N O kr) O 4.0 0 0 0 0 ' 00 `n O 0 , r- 0 W) O `n 0 Q > o c c 0 0 0 ? 0 0 k ?I k ?n ° 4.0 2 U `n N V N O - , , i C?' O r, i N N N N 00 . 0 0 O A kA O i O O O 0 I.J 3 a a U a a a ? ? ? a a ^, ? ? U U U U U U ? U U Gg Gg Q GQ W ? Ag U U U P?I G?.1 w Q w w w w w w w w 0 0 w 0 0 0 Q w 0 0 ?? w w w w b > c,; 0 a) N) t? ° ° U 3 . o w ° ' ? • 0 CS O ? •? O ? ?' O' ? O U U CS U Cl CS O Z2 Ci 81 v .r Q t3 CS •? z _ . ,bq C? ti •, p U by N p b Q .V O O p 'V Zi O N k K O ti .K ?, V a O O U N 0 U 4-O, W A a? Water level data was downloaded from the 9 monitoring wells every 3-4 months throughout the year and boards were installed in the water control structure. Four of the six (66%) monitoring wells within the mitigation area have hydrographs similar to the reference area and meet the wetland hydrology criteria. The 8 vegetation monitoring plots were inventoried and species cover and presence data was collected at each. The reference area and mitigation area are both dominated by hydrophytic species. REFERENCES United States Department of Agriculture. 1990. Soil survey of Columbus County, North Carolina. 138 pp. APPENDIX A: REFERENCE AREA GROUNDWATER MONITORING WELL GRAPHS AND RAINFALL DATA 0 ai (;aa;) NOIlHA3l3 LQ o o LQ o o aro r- r ti co r r n ? pp-330-9Z 00-390-9 L 00-3a0-90 - 00-AON-9Z _?- 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-130-LZ 00-PO-L L pp-130-LO o0-daS-LZ --- ------------ oo-des-L L -- -= 00-daS-LO +" ' - - 00-6nV-8Z - - -= 0o-6nV-9 L pp-6nV-8o 00-Inr-6Z 00-Inr-6 L 00-Inr-60 - - :_ .- 00-unr-6Z 0o-unr-6L 00-unr-60 pp-AeW-0£ pp-AeW-OZ 0U-AeW-06 00 JdV-o£ 00JdV-OZ _ 00-jdV-O L pp-jeW-6£ -- -- - 00-JeW-LZ 00JBW-LO Oo-ga=I-OZ _ 00-gaA-0 L pp-uer-L£ oo-uer-LZ - ; ._- - oo-uer-L L oo-uer-Lo ?t LO M LO N LO O ct ci N O (Say3ui) -1-ltl=INIVH 0 ca a>i w N cu c 0 C7 Ii c' o; ca !. > a? w 0 U 7 w c T c 0 U .n E 0 0 U 0 0 0 N O c 0 ca a>i N c m co t -- ca 2 ca U c a? a a? c s 3 c O E ca w c Ca 'p c c o L ca U c ? 0 0 = Z ca > m ?- a? ? L O 0U ? N 3 c E 0 ? 2-0 cU o a2- 'Ca .O x c m Q C1 d (4901) NOIJLVA3-13 ?n o cn o cn o uq o o LQ ai M co co r,- r- co cfl cri LO er Lf? lqt to 0 LO N cA to d CM N i- O (sayaul) -IIV-ANIVM OO-3aa-9Z 00-aaa-9 L 00-Oa(I-90 00-AON-9Z 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-130-LZ 00-PO-L L 00-PO-LO 00-daS-LZ 00-daS-L L oo-daS-Lo 00-6nV-8Z 0o-&V-8 L o0-6n`d-80 00-Inr-6Z 00-Inr-6 L 00-Inr-60 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-6 L 00-unr-60 00-AeW-oE 00-AeW-oz 00-AeW-0 L 00-JCIH-OE 00-Jd`d-oZ 00 Jd`d-O L 00-JLIN- LE 00JLIN-LZ oOJeW-L L 00 JeW-LO 00-ga=I-OZ 0o-ga=I-O L oo-Uer-LE oo-Uer-Lz o0-Uer-L L oo-uer-Lo 0 c 0 c 4) w m a 3 .0 c O 0 01 a! w'. a? U! c6 co J J Z C C m O U n E 0 0 C 0 0 N L O \H c 0 a? m c a? rn ti cc O cc 0) U c a? N t c 0 c 7 O E ca 4- c a c3 C C CU - ca O N o U c •? 0 0 ca z a> c L ? a> O cU 3 ? c ? E o Co 0 U C 0 ?Q c? Q N d X c a? CL Q (190)) NOLLVA3-13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 00 ti co ti r- ? F- v 'cr LO M LO N L r LO C) M CV r p (SOtPui) -1- V=INIVH 00-39(1-9Z 00-090-9 L 00-090-90 00-AON-9Z 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-LOO-LZ 00-PO-L L 00-430-LO 00-daS-LZ 00-dOS-L L 00-daS-LO 00-6n`d-8Z 00-6ny-9 L 00-6n`d-90 00-Inr-6Z 00-Inr-6 L 00-Inr-60 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-6 L 00-unr-60 0o-AeW-o£ Do-I,eW-OZ 00-AeW-O L 00JdV-0£ 00-jdV-OZ 00Jdy-0 L )OJeMM )0-Meld-LZ DOJeW-L L )OJeW-LO )O-ga=I-OZ )O-qa=l-0 L )0-uer-L£ )o-uer-LZ )o-uer-L L )o-uer-LO c 0 a? w CD cu 3 c O C? c 0 cc to > a? w N 0 U J J U- z c 0 U 0 0 .Q E 0 U 0 0 0 N L O c 0 ca ca a>i N c a? a? 0 co ca O Lm U C a? SD (D c L 3 c 0 E ca c ca C C ca 0 M Cc cU c -? 0 o Z m? a? 0 L ? a) 0 c ? 0 E o 2 ?U 0 Q 0 V Q M Q X -v c a? Q. Q Q APPENDIX B: MITIGATION AREA GROUNDWATER MONITORING WELL GRAPHS AND RAINFALL DATA .f f qi , LO o Un o co 00 00 co (;aa;) NOIlbA3l3 n o 'n o o co 0 o LO o LO o ci 0) CO co r-- ti t- 00-39(1-9z 00-09(3-9 L T 00-099-90 -- - - - 00-AON-9Z "--?_ -- -- = 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-PO-LZ 00-130-L L 00-PO-LO 00-daS-LZ - -- - - -- = 00-d9S-L L - - 00-d9S-LO 00-6md-9z 00-6ny-9 L 00-6ny-90 00-I n r-6Z 00-Inr-60 --- 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-60 00-AeW-oz - -- 00-AeW-O L 00-jdy-0£ 00-jd`d-OZ T 00 jd`d-o L 00 JUM M - 00-JeW-LZ - - 00-JUIN-L L - - 00 JBW-LO 00-ga=I-OZ o0-ga:j-O L - oo-uer-L£ oo-uer-Lz o0-uer-LL oo-uer- Lo LO M LO N LO LO o M N r O (sayaul) TIVANlb2! c 0 ca N W. m a 3 C 0 C9 I c 0 co N w U 0 co J J tai. z_ c 0 U 0 E 0 0 U 0 0 0 N L- O c `0 " cc a? m a? N co c? c? c O ca rn c 0 3 c O 0 E m m c ca C f6 O ca L m cU a? c ? 0 o z a 0 c L o Q? cu U c n o E 7 0 ?0 U 0 s? 0-0 ?a c? a m X 'v C a? CL CL Q 0 (4801) NOLLVAT13 0 0 0 0 0 0 co co 00 00 r- r- 00-n90-9Z 00-Oaa-9 L 00-094-90 - 00-AON-9Z -- _ ?= 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-100-LZ 00-100-LL 00-130-LO 00-daS-LZ 0o-daS-L L 00-dOS-LO - - 00-find-8z - - 00-6md-8 L 00-6md-80 00-Inr-6Z . 00-Inr-6 L 00-Inr-60 00-unr-6Z --?` _ -_ 00-unr-6 L 00-unr-60 _J 00-ABIN-O£ 00-Ae W-OZ 00-AeW-O L o0-jdy-0£ 00 Jd`d-OZ 00Jdy-0 L 00-JeW-L£ - 00-jeW-Lz 00-JBW-L L - - - 00JLW-LO 0o-ga=I-OZ ---- 0o-qa=I-0 L -- oo-uer-L£ ----- 00-Uer- LZ - oo-uer-L L - - oo-uer-Lo d LO M LO N Lc) cA O M N r O (say0ul) "I-lV-ANIVH c 0 cc a>i w a? 3 c 0 0 c 0 a a? w U 0 U I J J U- _Z 2 0 U 0 0 0 N 0 c 0 N N c N 3 i 4- m pq ca 2 co C 0 cc 0 rn E 4) L C 0 3 C C 0 0 E m c6 ?a E- o ca ?- U C .? O O 0z Co -0 C c o c a U a>i N a D cu 0 .a U c .? 0 0 0 0. Q - a C_ ?o U U N C6 X `v C N Q. CL a ., 0. O v Co (4001) NOLLVA3-13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 00 00 Cl 1- ti ti to Nt ? M LO N L LO It M N r O (Sa43ui) -IId=INIVH 00-3aa-9Z 00-39(1-9L 00-390-90 00-AON-9Z 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-130-LZ 00-PO-LL 00-PO-LO 00-dOS-LZ 00-dOS-L L oO-daS-Lo 00-6nV-8Z 00-6n`d-9 L 00-6n`d-90 00-Inr-6Z 00-Inr-6 L _ 00-Inr-60 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-6 L 00-unr-60 00-AeW-O£ OO-few-oz 00-AeW-O L 00JdV-OE 00-jd`d-OZ 00JdV-0 L 00JBIN-L£ 00JeW-LZ 00Jew-L L 00JBW-LO 00-ga=I-OZ 0o-ga=I-0 L - oo-uer-LE 00-Uer-LZ oo-uer-L L oo-Uer-Lo O c 0 cu ca (D w a? c 3 c 0 0 I c o. 0 a? w 4) 0 t: U. J U- z c 0 0 U .c E 0 U 0 O O N L 0 c 0 ca m a? c ca N a N M co ca 0) N c 0 cu ca c 0 c 0 0 E cc c E ca C ? ca o CU Co cu U c ? 0 o cz ai a? c L ? a) 0 cc U U) c ? 0 E 0 0 -- 0 o_ 0 c? Q- tLn , V ¢ M co X 'a C N Q Q. :• a. (4981) NOIJLVA3-13 ?n o Ln o Ln o 00 co co co N o o co c OD ern o Lq o 0 0 co 00 co ao 00-39a-9Z 00-090-9L 00-1398-90 - -- -- 00-AON-9Z 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-100-LZ 00-PO-L L 00-PO-LO 00-daS-LZ - - 00-daS-L L 00-d9S-LO 00-6ny-8Z - _ = 00-6md-8 L 00-6md-90 00-Inr-6Z 0o-Inr-6 L _ 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-6 L 00-unr-60 --- - - 00-AeIN-0£ ,,,-- - - _ 00-AeIN-OZ 00-jd`d-0£ 00-jdv-OZ - - 00Jdy-0 L -- 00-JOIN-L£ - --- 00JeW-LZ - - 00-JeW-LL oOJeW-LO 00-4aA-OZ - - o0-gaA-0 L -- 00-uer-L£ 00-uer-LZ oo-uer-L L - oo-uer-Lo d M LO N ul LO o d M CV •- o (sayOui) TMANIVIA c 0 ca w a? 3 c 0 0 c 0 ca m w 7 I' w c c 0 E 0 0 U 0 0 N 0 c ca0 m a? m c V5 3 m m co ca 2 ca c 0 m rn E a? 3 c 0 E ca ? 0 0 Co L U v? c .? ca 0 ca z r- 0 :r0 cc a>i co m ? E 7 ca o ?U c .C 0 0 o n L 0 0 o C7 U 00 X ?v a? CL CL Q .' v At 0 LO on (;aa}) NOIldA3-13 O o o q o 0 0 co 00 co 00 co ? ? cl) ch N N N L O ?t ch N •- O (sayaui) TIV:JNIVM 00-Oad-9z 00-Oaa-9 L 00-394-90 00-AON-9Z 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-PO-LZ 00-PO-L L 00-PO-LO 00-dOS-LZ 00-daS-L L 0o-daS-LO 00-6ny-8Z 0o-6ny-8 L 00-6nb-80 00-Inr-6Z 00-Inr-6 L 00-Inr-60 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-6 L 00-unr-60 00-Aen-0£ 00-Alamoz 00-AeW-O L 00 Jd`d-0£ OO Jdv-Oz o0 Jdv-o L 00-JeW-L£ 00 JeW-LZ 00JBW-L L 00JeW-LO 00-gaA-OZ 00-ga_A-0 L oo-Uer-L£ oo-Uer-Lz oo-Uer- LL 00-Uer-LO c 0 03 a>i w L m a 3 v c 0 0 O c 0 0s cc m w m U c1 c T C 0 U m E 0 0 U 0 0 0 N L c 0 cu ca m N c N ca m m m w 00 ca m a C 0 cc ns rn E m c .3 m 0 E ca 03 C a ca c ? ca 0 co c U t c ? 0 o cZ a>i .? 0 c L m o aU ? m .o ? c ? E 0 0 0 ?U 0 ?0 0s a. L C7 Q m x °v c m CL CL Q .1, • d I APPENDIX C: UPLAND AREA GROUNDWATER MONITORING WELL GRAPHS AND RAINFALL DATA •1 1 e O co co (;aa;) NOIIVA3l3 o q o q O O o oooo c to ccoo coo coo co I- to LO M LO N to LO O M N O (say:)ul) -1-Id=INIVM 00-094-9Z OO-000-9 L 00-Oaa-90 00-AON-9Z 00-AON-9 L 00-AON-90 00-PO-LU 00-PO-L L 00-PO-LO 0o-daS-LZ 00-daS-L L 00-daS-LO 00-6ny-8Z 00-6n`d-9 L 00-6ny-80 00-Inr-6Z 00-Inr-6 L 00-Inr-60 00-unr-6Z 00-unr-6L 00-unr-60 o0-Aen-oE 00-fieW-OZ oo-,KeW-o L 00-Jd`d-OE 00-Jdd-OZ 00-jd`d-0 L 00-JBIN-LE 00-JBYY-LU 00JeW-L L OOJeW-LO 00-4a=I-OZ 0o-4aj-0 L oo-Uer-L£ oo-Uer-LZ 00-Uer-L L oo-Uer-Lo c 0 ca w L 4 3 c: O c 0 ca a>i w'. a? ca 0 U c c 0 U 0 E 0 U 0 0 0 N `o 0 co N a? c N OD co 2 ca a ca CL 0 a? t c c 0 0 E ca ca c ca ca o ca `- U O L O 0 ?Z a>i a L 0 0 0 aU .a E 0 0 m o w- U 0 Q 0 L V Q U X C a? CL CL Q 'o , APPENDIX D: VEGETATION PLOTS R-1 and R-2 WETLAND REFERENCE AREA COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: Reference-1 ELEVATION: 78 feet 9/13/00 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple x FAC Aroma arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Carex laucescens southern waxy sedge x OBL C erus stri osus straw-colored flatsed e x FACW Eleocharis tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass 10-25% FACW Eu atorium fistulosum 'oe- a-weed x FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Galium obtusum blunt-leaf bedstraw x FACW- Itea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Ludwi is landulosa c linddc-fruit seedbox x OBL Ludwi is ilosa hairy seedbox 10-25% OBL L co us vir inicus Virginia bu leweed x OBL Mania scandens - climbing hem weed x FACW+ Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC Panicum scabriusculum wool) panic grass 25-50% OBL Pas alum dilatatum dallis rass x FAC+ Pluchea foetida camphor-weed x OBL Pol onum sa ittatum tearthumb x OBL Rh nchos ora corniculata short-bristle beakrush x OBL Rh nchos ora macrostach a tall beakrush x OBL Salix ni ra black willow x OBL Scir us c erinus wool grass x OBL Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Solida o fistulosa pine barren goldenrod x FAC+ Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum 50-75% FACW+ Woodwardia vir inica Vir inia chain-fern 5-10% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% v i , COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: Reference-2 ELEVATION: 79-80 feet 9/13100 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple X FAC Amelanchier obovalis serviceber X FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem 10-25% FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber X FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane X FACW Aster dumosus bush aster X FAC Calama rostis cinnoides Nuttall's small-reed grass X OBL Carex laucescens southern wax sedge X OBL Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass 25-50% FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush X FACW C rills racemiflora titi X FACW E/eocharis tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush X FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass X FACW Eu atorium album white thorough-wort X --- Eu atorium frstulosum 'oe- a-weed X FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort X FACW Eu atorium recurvans coastal-plain thorough-wort X FACW- Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort X FAC Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod X FAC Gelsmium sem ervirens yellow jessamine X FAC Helianthus an ustifolius swam sunflower X FAC+ Ilex coriacea sweet allber X FACW Ilex labra inkber 5-10% FACW Li uidambar st raciflua sweet um X FAC+ L co us vir inicus Virginia bu leweed X OBL - L onia fi ustrina maleber X FACW L onia lucida fetterbush X FACW M rica hetero h Ila evergreen bayberry X FACW N ssa biflora swam black um X OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern X FACW+ Osmunda re alis royal fern X OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass X FAC Panicum scabriusculum wool) panic grass X OBL Panicum verrucosum warty panic grass X FACW Pol ala lutea oran e milkwort X FACW+ Pteridium a uilinum bracken fern X FACU Quercus ni ra water oak X FAC Rhexia mariana Maryland meadow-beauty X FACW+ Rhus co allina winged sumac X NI Rh nchos ora ce halantha clustered beakrush X OBL Rubus s blackber X --- Table Continued on next page *See next page ,*A 1 rf, Continued from previous page: PLOT NUMBER: Reference-2 ELEVATION: 79-80 feet 9/13/00 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Scleria s p. nutrush x --- Scutellaria inte rifolia hyssop skullcap x FAC Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Solida o fistulosa pine barren goldenrod x FAC+ Solida o ru osa wrinkled goldenrod x FAC Solida o stricta willow-leaf goldenrod x OBL Sphagnum s p. sphagnum moss x --- S m locos tinctoria horse-sugar x FAC Toxicodendron radicans poison iv x FAC Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum x FACW+ Violas . violet x --- Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern x OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% APPENDIX E: VEGETATION PLOTS #1, #2, #3, #5 and #6 WETLAND MITIGATION AREA COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 1 ELEVATION: 82 feet 9/13100 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 10-25% FAC Alnus serrulata to alder 10-25% FACW+ Aster dumosus bush aster x FAC Boehmeria c lindrica false nettle x FACW+ Cinna arundinacea wood-reed x FAM C rills racemiflora titi x FACW Erianthus i anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium com ositifolium do fennel x FAC- Eu atorium fistulosum ioe- a-weed 5-10% FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Galium obtusum blunt leaf bedstraw x FACW- Itea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Li ustrum sinense Chinese rivet x FAC Lonicera japonica - Japanese hone suckle x FAC- Ludwi is landulosa c lindic-fruit seedbox x OBL Ludwi is ilosa hairy seedbox x OBL L co us vir inicus - Virginia bu leweed x OBL Mikania scandens climbing hem weed x FACW+ Murdannia keisak marsh dewtlower 10-25% OBL M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um 5-10% OBL Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Pluchea foetida camphor-weed x OBL Pol onum h dro i eroides swam smartweed 5-10% OBL Pol onum sa ittatum tearthumb x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Salix ni ra black willow 50-75% OBL Sambucus canadensis elderberry 5-10% FACW- Toxicodendron radicans poison iv x FAC - Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum 10-25% FACW+ Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern 10-25% OBL Woodwardia vir inica Vir inia chain-fern 10-25% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 2 ELEVATION: 83 feet 9/13/00 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 5-10% FAC Amelanchier obovalis serviceber x FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem x FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane x FACW Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass x FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush x FACW C rilla racemiflora titi 10-25% FACW Eleocharis tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium leucole is white-bract thorough-wort x FACW+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Ga lussacia frondosa dan leber x FAC Gelsmium sem ervirens yellow jessamine x FAC H ericum h ericoides St. Andrew's cross x --- H ericum stans St. Peter's wort x FACW- Ilex coriacea sweet allber 10-25% FACW Ilex labra inkber 50-75% FACW Itea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Liriodendron tuli ifera tulip poplar x FAC Ludwi is ilosa hairy seed ox x OBL L onia lucida fetterbush 10-25% FACW M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Rhexia mariana Maryland meadow-beau x FACW+ Rhus co allina win ed sumac x NI Rh nchos ora racilenta slender beakrush x OBL Rh nchos ora inex ansa nodding beakrush x FACW Rh nchos ora microce hala ca itate beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Sphagnum s p. sphagnum moss x --- Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC - Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry 5-10% FACW Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum x FACW+ Otis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern x OBL Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern x OBL X r. caroliniana Carolina yellow-eyed grass x FACW+ *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL= Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% s.. ? I ", W COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 3 ELEVATION: 84 feet 9/13/00 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Amelanchier obovalis serviceber x FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem x FACW+ Aroma arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Aster dumosus bush aster x FAC Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass x FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush x FACW C rilla racemiflora titi 25-50% FACW Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Eu atodum rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Gelsemium sem ervirens yellow jessamine x FAC Ilex coriacea sweet allber x FACW Ilex labra inkber 50-75% FACW Leucothoe racemosa leucothoe x FACW Li uidambar s raciflua sweet um x FAC+ Liriodendron tuli ifera tulip poplar x FAC L co odium alo ecuroides fox-tail clubmoss x OBL L onia lucida fetterbush 10-25% FACW M rica cerifera bayberry x FAC+ M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC - Panicum s panic grass x --- Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Pinus taeda loblolly pine x FAC Pol ala lutea orange milkwort x FACW+ Pteridium a uilinum bracken fern x FACU Rhexia mariana Maryland meadow-beau x FACW+ Rhexia etiolata ciliate meadow-beau x FACW+ Rh nchos ora inex ansa nodding beakrush x FACW Rubus s p. blackber x --- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Solida o fistulosa pine barren goldenrod x FAC+ Solida o ru osa wrinkled goldenrod x FAC Sphagnum s p. Sphagnum moss x --- Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% ,*t •1 , J 1k COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 5 ELEVATION: 83 feet 9/14/00 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 25-50% FAC Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber 10-25% FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane x FACW Boehmeria c lindrica false-nettle x FACW+ Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush 5-10% FACW C rills racemiflora titi x FACW Eleocharis tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium com ositifolium do fennel x FAC- Eu atorium fistulosum 'oe- a weed x FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Galium obtusum blunt leaf bedstraw x FACW- Ilex labra inkber x FACW Juncus canadensis Canada rush x OBL Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Liriodendron tuli ifera - tulip poplar x FAC Ludwi is alternifolia bush seedbox x OBL Ludwi is ilosa hairy seedbox x OBL L onia lucida fefterbush x FACW Mania scandens climbing hem weed 5-10% FACW+ M rica cerifera bayberry x FAC+ M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um 5-10% OBL Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC Panicum scabdusculum wool) panic grass x OBL Panicum verrucosum warty panic grass x FACW Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Pluchea odorata camphor-weed x FACW Pol onum h dro i eroides swam smartweed x OBL Pol onum sa ittatum tearthumb 5-10% OBL Rh nchos ors racilenta slender beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry 10-25% --- Salix ni ra black willow 25-50% OBL Sambucus canadensis elderberry 5-10% FACW- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ S ha num s p. sphagnum moss x --- Toxicodendron radicans poison iv x FAC T ha latifolia cat-tails x OBL Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum 10-25% FACW+ Woodwardia areolata Netted chain-fern 10-25% OBL Woodwardia virginica Virginia chain-fern 50-75% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 6 ELEVATION: 84 feet 9/14100 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 10-25% FAC Alnus serrulata to alder 10-25% FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber 5-10% FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane x FACW Baccharis halimifolia eastern false-willow x FAC Berchemia scandens su le'ack x FACW Boehmeria c lindrica false-nettle x FACW+ Carex s no fruits sedge x --- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush 10-25% FACW C villa racemiflora titi 25-50% FACW Eleocharis tuberosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus l anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium com ositifolium do fennel x FAC- Eu atorium fistulosum 'oe- a-weed x FAC+ Eu atorium erfoliatum common boneset x FACW+ Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Fra aria vir inica Virginia strawberry x FAC- Galium obtusum blunt leaf bedstraw x FACW- Gelsmium sem ervirens yellow jessamine x FAC Ilex codacea sweet allber x FACW Ilex labra inkber x FACW Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Li uidambars raciflua sweet um x FAC+ Liriodendron tuli ifera tulip poplar 10-25% FAC - Ludwi is alternifolia bush seedbox x OBL L onia lucida fetterbush x FACW Mania scandens climbing hem weed x FACW+ Murdannia keisak marsh dewflower x OBL M rica cerifera bayberry x FAC+ Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass 10-25% FAC Panicum sco arium hairy panic grass x FACW Panicum verrucosum warty panic grass x FACW Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Pol ovum h dro iperoides swam smartweed x OBL Pol onum sa ittatum tearthumb x OBL Rh nchos ora ce halanta clustered beakrush x OBL Rh nchos ora racilenta slender beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Scir us c erinus wool grass x OBL Smilax laurifolia l aued-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Smilax rotundifolia reenbrier x FAC Sphagnum s - sphagnum moss x --- Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Woodwardia areolata Netted chain-fern x OBL Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern 5-10% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% APPENDIX F: UPLAND VEGETATION PLOT #4 Plots #2 and #5 are located at an elevation of 83 feet. Plot #2 consisted of a dense shrub layer dominated by inkberry with lesser amounts of red maple, sweet gallberry (Ilex coriacea), titi, fetterbush (Lyonia lucida) and highbush blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum) (Table 2). Plot #5 was dominated by 8-10 foot tall red maple and black willow trees with patches of shrubs including red chokeberry (Aronia arbutifolia), sweet pepperbush, blackberry (Rubus sp.), elderberry and possum-haw viburnum. Groundcover was dominated by climbing hempweed, tearthumb (Polygonum sagittatum), netted chain-fern and Virginia chain-fern (Table 2). All of the dominant species located in Plots #2 and #5 are wetland indicator species. Plots #3 and #6 are located at an elevation of 84 feet. Plot #3 was dominated by inkberry and titi with scattered fetterbush (Table 2). The herbaceous layer was generally sparse (Appendix E). Plot #6 had an 8-10 foot tall overstory of tag alder, tulip poplar and red maple. Dominant shrub species included red chokeberry, sweet pepperbush and titi (Table 2). The herbaceous layer was generally sparse under the trees and shrubs and included cypress witchgrass (Panicum dichotomum) and Virginia chain-fern. All of the dominant species located in Plots #3 and #6 are wetland indicator species. Plot #4, the uplands plot, is located at an elevation of 85 feet. Dominant tree species within the plot included blackgum and southern red oak (Quercus falcata) with scattered sweetgum and water oak (Quercus nigra) (Table 3). The dense shrub layer consisted of sweet pepperbush, sweet gallberry, leucothoe (Leucothoe racemosa) and fetterbush. Bracken fern was the dominant groundcover and yellow jessamine (Gelsemium sempervirens) was the dominant vine species. Soil samples were taken near the center of each vegetation monitoring plot (Table 4). Both reference area soil samples had saturated hydric soil. In the mitigation area, Plots #1, #5 and #6 all had saturated hydric soils. Plots #2 and #3 had dry crumbly dark soil. The upland vegetation Plot (#4) had sandy dry soil. SUMMARY The mitigation project will be considered successful when wetlands hydrology has been enhanced or restored on sufficient areas to mitigate for the lost water quality values. The hydrology success criteria will be when the groundwater within the mitigation area is within one inch of the reference wetland provided that the hydrograph for both areas have a similar shape. Table 3. Dominant vegetation* in the Upland Monitoring Plot, Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. 85 feet Scientific Name Common Name Wetland Indicator Plot #4 % Cover Clethra alnifolia sweet pe erbush FACW 10-25% Gelsemium sem ervirens yellow jessamine FAC 5-10% Ilex coriacea sweet gallberry FACW 5-10% Leucothoe racemosa leucothoe FACW 5-10% Liquidambar styraci ua sweetgum FAC+ 5-10% Lyonia lucida fetterbush FACW 10-25% Nyssa sylvatica black gum FAC 10-25% Pteridium aqualinum bracken fern FACU 5-10% Quercus alcata southern red oak FACU- 10-25% Quercus nigra water oak FAC 5-10% * See Appendix F for a complete species list. Table 4. Soil sample information for 2000, Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. PLOT DEPTH VALUE/CHROMA COMMENTS Reference Plot #1 0-6" l OYR 3/3 1" of standing water 6-12" 1OYR 6/1 mucky silt Reference Plot #2 0-10" 7.5YR 2/0 sandy silt, saturated at 8" 10-12" 1OYR 3/2 oxidized root channels Plot #1 0-8" 1OYR 3/2 saturated, greasy, organic muck Plot #2 0-12" 7.5YR 2/0 black, dry, crumbly Plot#3 0-6" 1OYR 2/1 dry crumbly, sandy silt w/ 7.5YR 4/6 mottles 6-10" 2.5 YR 5/4 silty sand Plot #5 0-12" 10YR 3/2 water in hole at 3-4" and rising Plot #6 0-6" 1OYR 2/1 black saturated silty loam 6-12" 1OYR 4/1 gray saturated sand Plot #4 (upland) 0-8" 1 OYR 2/1 silty sand, dry, crumbly 4r - LAA COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 4 ELEVATION: 85 feet 9/13/00 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple x FAC melanchier obovalis serviceber x FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem x FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass x FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush 10-25% FACW C rilla racemiflora titi x FACW Dios ros vir na persimmon x FAC Ele hanto us nudatus smooth elephant-foot x FAC Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Gelsemium sem ervirens yellow jessamine 5-10% FAC Ilex coriacea sweet allber 5-10% FACW Ilex labra inkber x FACW Leucothoe racemosa leucothoe 5-10% FACW Li uidambars raciflua sweet um 5-10% FAC+ L onia lucida etterbush 10-25% FACW Moss moss x --- M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa s Ivatica black um 10-25% FAC Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Pinus taeda loblolly pine x FAC Pteridium a uilinum bracken fern 5-10% FACU Quercus falcata southern red oak 10-25% FACU- Quercus ni ra water oak 5-10% FAC Rhus co allina win ed sumac x NI Sassafras albidum sassafras x FACU Smilax lauca catbrier x FAC S m locos tinctoria horse-sugar x FAC Toxicodendron radicans - poison iv x FAC Vaccinium staminlum deerber x FACU Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape X FAC *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X = present but less than 5% a , „ d 2 9 2002 2001 ANNUAL REPORT COLUMBUS COUNTY AIRPORT WETLAND MITIGATION PLAN IMPLEMENTATION COLUMBUS COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina Water Quality Certification 2671 (DWQ Project #960975) Prepared By: Ms. Tracy Rush and Dr. J.H. Carter III Dr. J.H. Carter III & Associates, Inc. Environmental Consultants P.O. Box 891 Southern Pines, North Carolina 28388 Submitted 31 January 2002 N.C. Division of Water Quality Wetlands/401 Certification Unit 2321 Crabtree Boulevard, Suite 250 Raleigh, NC 27604-2260 <t •In 2001 ANNUAL REPORT COLUMBUS COUNTY AIRPORT WETLAND MITIGATION PLAN IMPLEMENTATION COLUMBUS COUNTY, NORTH CAROLINA INTRODUCTION Columbus County Airport proposes to restore wetland hydrology on at least 4.76 acres, and potentially as much as to 8.6 acres, in order to mitigate for the loss of 4.76 acres of jurisdictional wetlands during construction of a runway extension. In addition, wetlands hydrology will be enhanced on 2.34 acres of jurisdictional wetland. This report, prepared in accordance with North Carolina Water Quality Certification 2671 (DWQ Project #960975), outlines wetlands mitigation and monitoring activities at the Columbus County Airport during 2001. Mitigation and monitoring activities at the airport in 2001 consisted of water control, groundwater monitoring and monitoring of vegetation plots. PROJECT SITE The Columbus County Airport is located 1.14 miles southwest of Brunswick off State Road 1181 (Figure 1). The airport property contains 246.9 acres and consists of a single runway 5500 feet long, a small terminal building, hangers and support buildings. Most of the unpaved airport grounds are vegetated with manicured grasses and low brushy thickets. Vegetation is kept to less than 6 feet in height in order to comply with Federal Aviation Administration clear zone regulations. The wetlands filled during construction of a runway extension consisted of herbaceous and shrub wetlands dominated by species such as sweet gum (Liquidambar styraciflua), red maple (Acer rubrum), swamp blackgum (Nyssa biflora), inkberry (Ilex glabra), waxmyrtle (Myrica cerifera), titi (Cyrilla racemiflora), sweetbay (Magnolia virginiana), cinnamon fern (Osmunda cinnamomea), netted chain-fern (Woodwardia areolata), beakrushes (Rhynchospora spp.) and soft rush (Juncus effusus). All of the filled wetlands had been ditched in the past and had varying degrees of hydrologic modification. The restoration area is located in the southwest portion of the airport property adjacent to the runway (Figure 2). The restoration area is vegetated with saplings, shrubs and herbaceous Figure 1. Location of Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. ?i ?i rl ?a • _. rig ` Al 1 , ,t 1 I ' a Q 0 a .v , 1, 1t •? ` .. 5 ? H O r ti,-? Z WW F :, ` ( p ? a i ?? ? C l s a 3 I ! ? }' vl N K % o0 t O O U O U _0 O O «i a 0 3 •O O ? O O wU O O 0 °z UO r."' ? o U o :3 4 t 0 U N V-4 L-0 ,e vegetation including sweet gum, blackgum, red maple, loblolly pine (Pinus taeda), waxmyrtle, inkberry, blueberries (Vacinium spp.), sweet pepperbush (Clethra alnifloia), broom-sedge (Andropogon virginicus) and bracken fern (Pteridium aquilinum). Ditching in the past has adversely impacted the hydrology of the restoration site and adjacent areas. A significant area appears to have been impounded in the past (organic cross-bedding in sandy sediments). Soils on the proposed mitigation site are Rains and Griffon fine sandy loams. Both series are hydric soils. A narrow band of jurisdictional wetland (2.34 acres) occurs within the restoration site (Figure 2). Some of the wetland is dominated by herbaceous species, especially beakrushes, panic grasses (Dicanthelium spp.), meadow beauties (Rhexia spp.), southern waxy sedge (Carex glaucescens), honeycomb-head (Balduina uniflora), Coastal Plain thorough-wort (Eupatorium recurvans), yellow pitcher-plant (Sarracenia flava) and woolly sunbonnets (Chaptalia tomenstosa). Another portion is dominated by low shrubs such as black willow (Salix nigra), Virginia willow (Itea virginica), red maple and tag alder (Alnus serrulata), with a ground cover of netted chain-fern, Virginia chain-fern (Woodwardia virginica), royal fern (Osmunda regalis), camphor-weed (Pluchea sp.), false-nettle (Boehmeria cylindrica), climbing hempweed (Mikania scandens) and joe-pye-weed (Eupatorium fistulosum). The reference wetland area, located on the north side of the runway consists of low shrubs and herbs. Dominant herb and grass species include plume grass (Erianthus giganteus), hairy seedbox (Ludwigia pilosa), hairy panic grass (Panicum scoparium), Virginia chain-fern, slender spikegrass (Chasmanthium laxum) and bushy bluestem (Andropogon glomeratus). Dominant shrub species include inkberry and possum-haw viburnum (Viburnum nudum). 2001 MITIGATION ACTIVITIES A dam breach next to the water control structure occurred sometime between late November and early April (Figure 3). The breach was repaired in April and 2 boards were installed in the water control structure in late May (Figure 3). The water level remained low (below the 2 boards) throughout the summer and fall with no water passing through the water control structure. Figure 3. Dam breach adjacent to water control structure (top) and the repaired dam (bottom) at Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. ,r 2001 MONITORING ACTIVITIES Monitoring Wells The 9 monitoring wells were installed on 15 September 1999. Three wells are located in the reference wetland, 5 wells are located in the mitigation area and 1 well was installed in an adjacent upland (Figure 2). The electronic monitoring wells are programmed to record water levels every 12 hours and are downloaded every 3-4 months. Water elevations for the period 1 January 2001 through 31 December 2001 are displayed graphically in Appendices A-C. The goal is to create wetland hydrology within the mitigation area (82, 83, and 84 foot wells). Criteria for wetland hydrology are met when the areas are inundated or saturated to within 12 inches of the surface for at least 12.5% of the growing season (30 consecutive days in most years). The growing season for Columbus County runs from mid- March to mid-November (240 days). In addition, groundwater in the mitigation area must be within +/- 2 inches of the reference wetland provided that the hydrograph for both areas have a similar shape. The 78 and 79 foot wells in the reference area met the wetland hydrology criteria. The 78 foot well had standing water throughout most of the year (appendix A.1). The 79 foot well had standing water periodically throughout the year and had water within 12 inches of the surface most of the year (Appendix A.2). The 80 foot well in the reference area did not meet wetland hydrology criteria during the year. The water level rose to within 1 foot of the surface, but did not remain there for more than a day or two (Appendix A.3). The 82 foot well is located in the narrow band of jurisdictional wetland in the mitigation area. This well site had standing water until the beginning of May. The water level then dropped several feet over the next month (probably due to spring vegetation growth) and then fluctuated until mid-September when rainfall amounts decreased significantly (Appendix B.1). In the mitigation area, the 83 foot (west) and 84 foot (west) well sites had standing water until the beginning of May also and so met the wetland hydrology criteria (Appendix B.2 and B.4 respectively). The 84 foot (west) well failed sometime after 6 September, but it can be assumed that the water level dropped abruptly in mid-Septemebr due to low rainfall amounts . The 83 foot (east) well failed sometime between January and April 2001 the failure was not discovered until the data was analyzed after the April visit. A new well was installed on 22 May 2001. The ,i .0 water level rose to within 1 foot of the surface numerous times during the growing season, but did not remain there for 30 consecutive days (Appendix B.3). The 84 foot (left) well had water levels within 1 foot of the surface for a period of 2 or 3 days on several occasions (Appendix B.5), but did not meet the wetland hydrology criteria of 30 consecutive days. The 85 foot upland monitoring well did not meet wetland hydrology criteria during the year. The water level at this location was within 1 foot of the surface only several days during the growing season (Appendix C.1). Average rainfall for Columbus County is approximately 49 inches (USDA 1990). Rainfall amounts recorded in Whiteville (State Climate Office of North Carolina) totaled 34.11 inches for the year, well below normal. Vegetation Monitoring Plots Vegetation monitoring plots were inventoried on 6 September 2001. Two plots are located in the reference wetland, 5 plots (one at each monitoring well) are located in the restoration area and 1 plot is located in an adjacent upland area. The vegetation plots measure 10 meters by 10 meters and are centered on each monitoring well with the exception of the reference area. There are 2 wells within one of the vegetation plots in the reference area because of the sharp change in elevation in this area. The vegetation in each plot was characterized by species, prevalence and percent cover (see Appendices D-F for complete lists). Plot R-1 in the reference area was dominated by possum-haw viburnum, woolly panic grass (Panicum scabriusculum), hairy seedbox, plume grass and Virginia chain-fern (Table 1). Plot R-2 was dominated by slender spikegrass, bushy bluestem (Andropogon glomeratus), inkberry and slender fragrant goldenrod (Euthamia minor) (Table 1), with trace amounts of a variety of herbs, grasses and low shrubs (Appendix D). All of the dominant species located within the reference area are wetland indicator species. Plot #1 in the mitigation area, located at an elevation of 82 feet, was dominated by black willow and red maple. Other dominant tall shrub species include tag alder, possum-haw viburnum and elderberry (Sambucus canadensis). Groundcover was dominated by netted chain- fern and Virginia chain-fern (Table 2). Percent cover of red maple increased and marsh Table 1. Dominant vegetation* in the Reference Monitoring Plots, Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. 78 feet 79.5 feet Scientific Name Common Name Wetland Indicator Plot R-1 % Cover Plot R-2 % Cover Andropogon glomeratus bushy bluestem FACW+ -- 10-25% Chasmanthium laxum slender spikegrass FACW- -- 25-50% Erianthus giganteus plume grass FACW 10-25% -- Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod FAC -- 5-10% Ilex glabra inkberry FACW -- 5-10% Ludwigia pilosa hairy seedbox OBL 10-25% -- Panicum scabriusculum woolly panic grass OBL 25-50% -- Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum FACW+ 50-75% -- Woodwardia virginica Virginia chain-fern OBL 10-25% -- * See Appendix D for a complete species list. z 0 O U 0 O y O U 0 a bb 0 0 0 jE 0 C? bQ N 9 o U A N U H s. c, 0 o O W) 14 o O kn o o , 00 1=4 0 ztt >. o O o o "' O o `n o 'r' N N kn ' N l? M 00 .r W A N .-? V 1 N ' `? O .-+ ' `? O kn 0 M \ 0 0 0 v? , r , N , , , , d OO ?Sy o N O O eq r,, o N N , , , , , , `n N `n N `n r-- , , kn cV M 00 U O O O O O ?-- ' 0 y `? ? O 0 0 0 `n \° \° 0 0 ID V O ? ' ?' N O O N N N 00 a u A O O kn ' ?n ' •n O ry O -4 0 U U U U U U .,? U ? aa ? ? v aa ? O ? w 0 0 w C z O ' .cl Q. ~ ' cd U PW" N O b A ' O ? cn N N ra ? U C,3 o cd U N + U ++ 3. ^? t b W 0 N bU U 3. s, '? v) ... U U ' ti cd cn p bo o H ? ° rz ?^ ° ?, 0 0 0 0 r? ? ? ?C U U ? ti '?1 N 8, N C4 a? U N aU+ F'+ 0 U W W a Q a> a> GO ,r dewflower (Murdannia keisak) decreased in 2001. All of the dominant species located in Plot #1 are hydrophytic species. Plots #2 and #5 are located at an elevation of 83 feet. Plot #2 consisted of a dense shrub layer dominated by inkberry with lesser amounts of red maple, sweet gallberry (Ilex coriacea), titi, fetterbush (Lyonia lucida) and highbush blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum) (Table 2). Red maple became more prevalent in 2001. Plot #5 was dominated by 10-15 foot tall red maple and black willow trees with patches of shrubs including red chokeberry (Aronia arbutifolia), sweet pepperbush, elderberry, blackberry (Rubus sp.) and possum-haw viburnum. Groundcover was dominated by netted chain-fern and Virginia chain-fern (Table 2). Percent cover of netted chain fern and red chokeberry decreased in 2001. All of the dominant species located in Plots #2 and #5 are hydrophytic species. Plots #3 and #6 are located at an elevation of 84 feet. Plot #3 was dominated by inkberry and titi with scattered fetterbush (Table 2). The herbaceous layer was generally sparse (Appendix E). Plot #6 had a 10-15 foot tall overstory of tag alder, tulip poplar and red maple. Dominant shrub species included sweet pepperbush, titi and blackberry (Table 2). The herbaceous layer was generally sparse under the trees and shrubs and was dominated by cypress witchgrass (Panicum dichotomum). Red maple increased in prevalence in 2001. All of the dominant species located in Plots #3 and #6 are hydrophytic species. Plot #4, the uplands plot, is located at an elevation of 85 feet. Dominant tree species within the plot included blackgum and southern red oak (Quercus falcata) (Table 3). The dense shrub layer consisted of sweet pepperbush, fetterbush and water oak (Quercus nigra) saplings. Bracken fern was the dominant groundcover and yellow jessamine (Gelsemium sempervirens) was the dominant vine species. Soil samples were taken near the center of each vegetation monitoring plot (Table 4). Both reference area soil samples had saturated hydric soil. In the mitigation area, Plots #1, #2, #5 and #6 all had saturated hydric soils. Plot #3 was not saturated, but had oxidized root channels in the upper 12 inches. The upland vegetation plot (#4) had sandy dry soil. SUMMARY The mitigation project will be considered successful when wetlands hydrology has been enhanced or restored on sufficient areas to mitigate for the lost water quality values. The < 14 "1 Table 3. Dominant vegetation* in the Upland Monitoring Plot, Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. 85 feet Scientific Name Common Name Wetland Indicator Plot #4 % Cover Clethra alni olia sweet pepperbush FACW 5-10% Gelsemium sempervirens yellow jessamine FAC 5-10% Lyonia lucida fetterbush FACW 5-10% Nyssa sylvatica blackgum FAC 25-50% Pteridium aqualinum bracken fern FACU 5-10% Quercus alcata southern red oak FAC+ 10-25% Quercus ni ra water oak FAC 5-10% * See Appendix F for a complete species list. IV . 11 Table 4. Soil sample information for 2001, Columbus County Airport, Columbus County, North Carolina. PLOT DEPTH VALUE/CHROMA COMMENTS Reference Plot #1 0-8" l OYR 3/2 1" of standing water, gleyed, oxidized root channels 8-12" 1OYR 5/2 mucky silt Reference Plot #2 0-6" l OYR 2/1 sandy silt, saturated 6-12" 10YR 5/3 oxidized root channels, organic streaking Plot #1 0-12" 1OYR 3/2 saturated, greasy, organic muck, gleyed Plot #2 0-8" 1OYR 2/1 8-12" 10YR 3/2 saturated, gleyed, organic streaking, sandy muck Plot#3 0-6" 1OYR 2/1 organic 6-8" 10YR 4/3 8-12" 1OYR 5/6 oxidized root channels, sandy Plot #5 0-8" 10YR 3/2 saturated to surface 8-12" 10YR 4/1 sandy Plot #6 0-6" 1OYR 2/1 saturated to surface, organic 6-12" 10YR 511 silty sand Plot #4 (upland) 0-8" 7.5YRYR 2/0 silty sand, dry, crumbly (salt&pepper) .* , j hydrology success criteria will be when the groundwater within the mitigation area is within one inch of the reference wetland provided that the hydrograph for both areas have a similar shape. Water level data was downloaded from the 9 monitoring wells every 3-4 months throughout the year. Two wells failed and were replaced during the year. The dam was breached sometime in the winter 2001, but was repaired in April and 2 boards were installed in the water control structure in May. Three of the six (50%) monitoring wells within the mitigation area have hydrographs similar to the reference area and meet the wetland hydrology criteria. This is less than in 2000 and the decrease can be partially attributed to the lower than normal rainfall amounts during 2000. The 8 vegetation monitoring plots were inventoried and species cover and presence data were collected at each. There have been several changes in the vegetative composition in all monitoring plots. There has been a general increase in shrub and tree species coverage and a general decrease in herbaceous species coverage. The reference area and mitigation area are both dominated by hydrophytic species. REFERENCES United States Department of Agriculture. 1990. Soil survey of Columbus County, North Carolina. 138 pp. ,tt 'J APPENDIX A: REFERENCE AREA GROUNDWATER MONITORING WELL GRAPHS AND RAINFALL DATA (4881) NOIIVA3-13 O O U? O U O U O U O O O ao 00 ti I,- to (0 LO LO 1* d ? r- ? ti r- r- P- ti r-- r- r- r- Lo-Oea-LZ LO-09G-L L --- -- - LO-390-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO LO-100-SZ LO-po-8 L LO-100-80 Lo-des-oz LO-des-8 L LO-des-8o Lo-6ny-6Z --- - __?_ _-- _ - -- - - - L0-6ny-6 L -- - -- -- - LO-6ny-60 ---- LO-Inr-O£ LO-Inr-OZ -- LO-Inr-o L -- - - - Lo-unr-06 -- - -- Lo-unr-OZ Lo-unr-o L Lo-AeW-LZ Lo-AeW-LO - - LO jdd-LZ LO-jd`d-L L - - Lo -JeMzz __ ..__ Lo-?eW-ZL Lo-J lw-ZO - - - LO-4a=I-OZ - - ---- - LO-ga=I-0 L Lo-uer-L£ -=== LO-uer-LZ 60-uer-LL L0-uer-Lo N LO ?- N O N r-: O (s9y0ul) " lV=IN1b21 c 0 cc c? a>i w 0 co C 0 0 c 0 c3 a? w U O ?II C T C O U rn n E 2 0 U 0 O N O c 0 ca N (D c a? co a 2 c6 a) U C a? m N _c L_ 3 O E ca ca C ca a3 C O OL 0U co as 0 O = z as ?U a O c E 0 0 0 0 mU o QCL cc L ?a a X_ C a? Q Q Q M " .k 0 0 w (;aa;) NOIIVA3-13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 r- r- ti ti ti ti U? N an cn o CV r O (SayOul) -1-ld=INI" LO-Oaa-LZ LO-39a-L L LO-39o-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO LO-IOo-sZ LO-po-s L LO-IOo-so LO-daS-sZ Lo-daS-8 L LO-daS-s0 LO-6ny-6Z LO-6ny-6 L LO-6ny-60 LO-Inr-0£ LO-Inr-OZ LO-Inf-O L LO-unf-0£ LO-unf-OZ L0-unf-o L LO-AeW-L£ LO-AeW-LZ LO-AeW-L L LO-AeUV-LO LO AV-LZ LO-AV- L L Lo-AV-Lo LO-JeW-ZZ LO-MIMU LO-JeW-Zo LO-4a_A-OZ LO-gazj-0 L LO-uef-L£ LO-uef-LZ Lo-Uem L LO-Uemo C 0 c ca a>i w L Q? a 3 .O c 0 0 c 0 cu 0 ID w 0 0 co O a Z a c 0 U 0 E 0 0 U 0 0 N L O c 0 ca 4) c m N rn ti ca U C m a? a m c 0 E cc O C cc c CU O C6 L cc U a c 0 o az > a? a? 0 o 0 0 c?a U .0 E 0 c ?0 0 CL 0 co Q C7 ¢ N Q x_ C m Q. Q 0 00 (4001) NOIldA3l3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 to N T to O tV T O (say:)ul) lld:INIVM W-300-LZ LO-Oad-L L W-390-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO LO-po-8Z LO-PO-8 L LO-1OO-80 Lo-daS-8Z Lo-des-8 L LO-des-80 LO-6ny-6Z LO-6ny-6 L LO-6n`d-60 LO-Inf-O£ LO-Inf -0Z LO-Inf -0 L LO-unf-0£ LO-unf -0Z LO-unf -0 L LO-AeW-L£ LO-Aon-LZ LO-AeW-L L LO-Aelw w LO-jdV-LZ LOJdy-L L LO-AV-Lo LOJeW-ZZ LOJBIWZL LOJeW-ZO LO-ga=I-OZ LO-gaj-0 L Lo-Uer-L£ Lo-Uer-LZ LO-uem L Lo-Uemo c. 0 as 0 W` L as C OI o 0 c 0'. ca a> w' a? U 7 75 C ca C C 0 U 0 0 .Q E 0 0 U T 0 0 N L O c 0 as a? m c m m 0 ao ca 2 c6 U C 5D 0 a L c L CD 0 E co as C L C6 "p c O O L ca CU cU ? r c ? 0 0 :r Z ca (D ?- (D L O 0U .r CU En -a c E o - rn o U 4- 0 ?0 ca. cL ?a V) a X C m Q. Q a . R 1 11 APPENDIX B: MITIGATION AREA GROUNDWATER MONITORING WELL GRAPHS AND RAINFALL DATA LQ M co (4091) NOIIVA3-13 o cn o cn o LQ o U? o cn ooo o 0 0 0 co o 00 co 000 r- r r- LO-Oaa-LZ LO-090-L L LO-090-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO L0-3O0-8Z LO-300-8 L LO-PO-80 LO-dos-8Z Lo-des-8 L LO-des-80 LO-6nd-6Z LO-6n`d-6 L LO-ond-60 LO-Inr-OE LO-Inf -0Z LO-Inf -0 L LO-unf -0E LO-unf-OZ LO-unf-o L LO-AeW-LE LO-AeW-LZ LO-AeW- L L LO-Any- w LO AV-LZ LO-jdV-L L LO-AV-Lo LOJeW-ZZ LOJeW-ZL LOJeW-ZO LO-gaA-OZ Lo-geA-0 L Lo-Uer-L£ LO-Uef-LZ Lo-Uem L Lo-Uemo U? N L r LO O N r- O (SO43ul) TIVANIVM c 0 ca a>i W a? 3 v c 0 O C 0. co as m w a? U O 1 to co .r' C O U E 0 U 0 0 N L 0 c 0 0 a? a? c m N co 0 O cu C cu0 ca 0 E N L C C 0 E ca ca C ca -p C C O L CU Co ca u C 'C 0 0 :_. Z ca a? a a? ? L 0 0U 3 U) c E 0 ? o - o U o CL 'ca L- V C6 X C m CL Q Q . *" , d 0 co (4001) NOIIVA313 0 0 0 o q o 0 co co co 00 r- co ti U? N ?A T L O CV r o (sa40ul) -11y:INIVM [0-aaa-LZ LO-oaa-L L W-09(3-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO W-3O0-8Z W-100-9L LO-100-80 LO-daS-8Z LO-des-8 L LO-daS-80 L0-6nb-6Z LO-6ny-6 L LO-6ny-60 LO-Inf -o£ LO-Inf-OZ LO-Inr-o L LO-unf -0£ LO-unf -0Z LO-unr-0L LO-Aevy-L£ LO-,Kevy- LZ LO-Aevy-L L LO-Aevy-LO Lo-AV- LZ LOJdy- L L LO-AV-Lo LOJevy-ZZ LO Jevy-Z L LOJevy-Zo LO-4a=I-OZ LO-Qaj-O L LO-Uef-L£ LO-Uef-LZ LO-Uem- Lo-Uemo _ cc0 cc (1) w L a? co 3 0 0 0 _ O ca cc a>i w m U cc co c ca E 0 0 U T 0 0 N L O c 0 cc m a) a? ..- N (D a? M O 0 cc cc E a? L 3 U) c O E cc cc o cc ?U cc o cc Z ? T o 00 ?U > cn m ? a? ?C L E cc O 3U _ -C 0 0 o fl. rnQ w o >, n? cu o 00 N m X .a C CL CL a • f 4? 1 O Ict co 400;) NOULVAT13 O O O O O R O V) 00 co 00 r- co ti LQ N L r to O (1j r O (Sayaui) -1-lH:INIVM LO-390-LZ LO-09G-L L LO-090-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO Lo-3O0-oz LO-13O-8 L LO-130-90 Lo-des-oz LO-daS-B L Lo-daS-80 LO-6nV-6Z LO-6ny-6 L LO-6nV-60 LO-inr-0£ LO-inr-oz LO-Inr-O L LO-unr-0£ LO-unr-Oz LO-unr-0 L LO-Aew L£ LO-AaW-LZ LO-AaW-L L LO-AaW-LO LO-jdV-LZ LO-AV-L L LOJdv-LO LOJeW-ZZ LOJaW-Z L LOJaW-z0 Lo{la=I-OZ LO-4a_A-0 L Lo-uer-L£ Lo-uar-LZ Lo-uar-LL Lo-uor-Lo c 0 ca ca a>i w L ca 3 v c 0 O C 0 :r co m w N 0 U 0 s co 1 .c E 3 0 U 0 0 N L 0 w c 0 ca m a? m c ca a? m a? co ca d a r_ 0 ca rn E a> L C 0 E CU ca - c w o L •? ca LU c ? ca o co z c v c ? 0 0 U ca > m? L E CD 0 0 ?U c ? 0 0 o sc-L a? Q o .a CL tu 0 O U ri 00 X_ C a? Q Q I e. 1 A Lq d' O (4891) NOIIVA3-13 o o cn o Un o coo co 00 co co co co co W-090-LZ LO-390-LL W-390-LO LO-AON-LZ L O-AON-L L LO-AON-LO LO-PO-8Z LO-PO-8 L = LO-PO-90 - - Lo-daS-8z Lo-daS-8 L Lo-daS-80 LO-6nd-6Z LO-6ny-6L - - - L0-6md-60 -- LO-Inr-o£ LO-Inr-Oz - LO-Inr-o L - - - LO-unr-OE - LO-unr-Oz LO-unr-OL -. -_ .. _ - - -- LO-/?eW-L£ LO-AeW-LZ -? - - - - - LO-AeW-L L LO-?eW- LO LO jdy-LZ LO-AV-L L LOjdV-Lo LO-JeW-ZZ ?.-_ - - LO-JeW-z L -- LO- UIN-ZO LO-4a=I-OZ Lo-4a=l-0 L Lo-uer-m Lo-uer-Lz Lo-uer-L L Lo-uer-Lo to N Lr) O N •- O (Sayaul) TIVANIVU a: _ 0 cc ca ai w U co i N 3i of co I' o! N 7 .a E 0 U 0 0 N 0 c 0 a 0 a? 3 m co ca 2 co _ 0 a 0 E a s r 3 cn 0 E Co ca -o ca LU c ? ca o Ca z cc a = 0 0 0 aU > cn N Z. E 0 a o 3U :3 o o Q -Q >, CUo C? U m X_ C a? CL CL Q I I ?o O LO co (1001) NOLLVA3l3 0 0 0 o q O O 00 co 00 co co I- P- Lp-Oao-LZ - LO-Oaa-LL - -- LO-39(3-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO LO-300-oz LO-100-8 L LO-130-90 --- _?_ LO-daS-8Z LO-daS-8 L LO-deS-80 _ LO-End-6Z -- --?.,-`-?- - - ----- - - - LO-6nd-6L - -- -- -- LO-6nd-60 LO-Inr-0£ LO-Inf -0Z ,ate = LO-Inf -0 L - -- =- LO-unr-0£ Lo-unf-Oz --- LO-unf -0L LO- eW-L£ Lp-?eW-L L Lp-?(eW-LO - -- --- Lo-jdd-LZ LOJdd-L L LO-add-Lo - - LOJeW-ZZ LOJBIWU LOJeW-Zo LO-ga=I-OZ Lo-gaA-OL - L0-uef-L£ Lo-uemz -- Lo-uem L Lo-Uemo LO (V LO r LO O fV 1? O (say0ui) lld=INIVM c ca0 ca ai w a`) a 3 c 0 0 0 c a) ED N U i? I? E 0 0 U 0 0 N 0 c 0 a a? a? c ca 0 m co ca 2 ca c 0 cu () .r c t 3 0 E CU ca _ C c o cu LU c ? ca o ca z cc a c ? O 0 ?U > m a) Z .0 a E Z. c0 ?U .0 o o CL -- Q >, c To U L6 m x_ C a? CL CL Q IV 4 1, APPENDIX C: UPLAND AREA GROUNDWATER MONITORING WELL GRAPHS AND RAINFALL DATA I K t '. 0 co 00 (4981) NOIldA3l3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a`oo 0 0 0 000 Go co 00 ti UO N LO r- tO Cl CV O (say0ul) lld?Nl?d21 LO-090-LZ W-09(]-LL LO-oad-LO LO-AON-LZ LO-AON-L L LO-AON-LO LO-PO-9z LO-130-9 L LO-}00-80 LO-das-8Z LO-des-8 L LO-des-80 LO-6ny-6Z LO-6ny-6 L LO-6ny-60 LO-Inr-O£ LO-Inr-OZ LO-Inr-O L LO-unr-0£ LO-unr-OZ LO-unr-o L LO-ABIN-L£ LO-AeW-LZ LO-AeW-L L LO-AeW-LO LO-AV- LZ LO-AV-L L LO-Jd`d-LO LO-JeW-ZZ LO-JeW-Z L LO JelN-ZO LO-ga=I-OZ LO-ga=j-0 L LO-Uer-L£ LO-Uer-LZ Lo-Uer-LL Lo-Uer-Lo c cc0 cc N w L co 3 .0 c 0 0 (9 c :r0 ca a) w N 0 Ca - i 4 C c 7 0 U N 3 n E 0 0 U 0 0 N 0 c 0 a a? a? c (D °' LO 00 cc 2 ca c ca Q 0 a? c 0 E ca ca C cts Ca 'p c Co O ca to ca vs O Z cu a>i O 0U ca c E 0 0 2-6 0) U o t O CL CL = Co ?a U X .a c N tl CL . 7i , .4 APPENDIX D: VEGETATION PLOTS R-1 and R-2 WETLAND REFERENCE AREA COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: Reference-1 ELEVATION: 78 feet 9/6/01 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple x FAC Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Carex laucescens southern waxy sedge x OBL C erus stri osus straw-colored flatsed e x FACW Eleocharis tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus i anteus lume rass 10-25% FACW Eu atorium tistulosum 'oe- a-weed x FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Galium obtusum blunt-leaf bedstraw x FACW- Itea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Ludwi is landulosa c lindric-fruit seedbox x OBL Ludwi is ilosa hairy seedbox 10-25% OBL L co us vir inicus Virginia bu leweed x OBL - Mania scandens climbing hem weed x FACW+ - Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC Panicum scabriusculum wool/ panic grass 25-50% OBL Pluchea foetida camphor-weed x OBL Pol ovum h dro i erioides swam smartweed x OBL Rh nchos ora comiculata short-bristle beakrush x OBL Rh nchos ora macrostach a tall beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Salix ni ra black willow x OBL Scir us c erinus wool grass x OBL Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Solida o frstulosa pine barren goldenrod x FAC+ Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum 50-75% FACW+ Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern 10-25% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover f IN COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: Reference-2 ELEVATION: 79-80 feet 916101 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple X FAC Amelanchier obovalis serviceber X FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem 10-25% FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber X FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane X FACW Aster dumosus bush aster X FAC Calama rostis cinnoides Nuttall's small-reed grass X OBL Carex laucescens southern waxy sedge x OBL Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass 25-50% FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush X FACW C rilla racemiflora titi X FACW Eleochads tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush X FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass X FACW Eu atorium album white thorough-wort X --- Eu atorium flstulosum 'oe- a-weed X FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort X FACW Eu atorium recurvans coastal-plain thorough-wort X FACW- Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod 5-10% FAC Gelsmium sem ervirens yellow jessamine X FAC - Helianthus an ustifolius swam sunflower X FAC+ Hexast lis arifolia wild ginger X FAC- Ilex coriacea sweet allber x FACW Ilex labra inkber 5-10% FACW Li uidambars raciflua sweet um X FAC+ L co us vir inicus Virginia bu leweed X OBL L onia li ustrina maleber X FACW L onia lucida fetterbush X FACW M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry X FACW N ssa biflora swam black um X OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern X FACW+ Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass X FAC Panicum scabriusculum - woolly panic grass X OBL Panicum verrucosum warty panic grass X FACW Pinus s pine X --- Pol ala lutea orange milkwort X FACW+ Pteridium a uilinum bracken fern x FACU Quercus ni ra water oak X FAC Rhexia mariana Maryland meadow-beau X FACW+ Rhus co allina winged sumac X NI - Rh nchos ora ce halantha clustered beakrush X OBL Rubus s blackber x --- Table Continued on next page *See next page A 1 ? • f Continued from previous page: PLOT NUMBER: Reference-2 ELEVATION: 79-80 feet 9/6/01 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Scleria s p. nutrush x --- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Solida o fistulosa pine barren goldenrod x FAC+ - Solida o ru osa wrinkled goldenrod x FAC Solida o stricta willow-leaf goldenrod x OBL Sphagnum s p. s ha num moss x --- S m locos tinctoria horse-sugar x FAC Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum x FACW+ Violas . violet x --- Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC X ris s yellow-eyed-grass X --- Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern x OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FAC W = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover APPENDIX E: VEGETATION PLOTS #1, #2, #3, #5 and #6 WETLAND MITIGATION AREA a 46 1 r , COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 1 ELEVATION: 82 feet 9/6/01 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 25-50% FAC Alnus serrulata to alder 10-25% FACW+ Boehmeria c lindrica false nettle x FACW+ Cinna arundinacea wood-reed x FAM C erus virens green flatsed e x FACW C rills racemiflora titi x FACW Erianthus i anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium fistulosum 'oe- a-weed x FAC+ Galium obtusum blunt leaf bedstraw x FACW- ltea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Li ustrum sinense Chinese rivet x FAC Lonicera japonica Japanese honeysuckle x FAC- Ludwi is landulosa c lindic-fruit seedbox x OBL Ludwi is ilosa hairy seedbox x OBL L co us vir inicus Virginia bu leweed x OBL Mania scandens - climbing hem weed x FACW+ Murdannia keisak marsh dewflower x OBL M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Parthenocissus uin uefolia Virginia creeper x FAC Pluchea foetida camphor-weed x OBL Pol onum h dro i eroides swam smartweed x OBL Pol onum sa lttatum tearthumb x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x -- Salix ni ra black willow 50-75% OBL Sambucus canadensis elderberry 5-10% FACW- Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC Viburnum nudum possum-haw viburnum 5-10% FACW+ Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern 10-25% OBL Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern 10-25% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover .6 '' .` COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 2 ELEVATION: 83 feet 9/6101 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 10-25%% FAC Amelanchier obovalis serviceber x FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem x FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane x FACW Carex laucescens southern wax sedge x OBL Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass x FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush x FACW C rilla racemiflora titi 10-25% FACW Eleocharis tuberculosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium leucole is white-bract thorough-wort x FACW+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Ga lussacia frondosa dan leber x FAC Gelsmium sem ervirens yellow jessamine x FAC Ilex coriacea sweet allber 10-25% FACW Ilex labra inkber 50-75% FACW Itea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Liriodendron tull ifera tulip poplar x FAC L onia Iucida fetterbush 10-25% FACW M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Rhexia mariana Maryland meadow-beau x FACW+ Rhus co allina winged sumac x NI Rh nchos ora racilenta slender beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Sphagnum s p. s ha num moss x --- Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC _ Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry 5-10% FACW Viburnum nudum ossum-haw viburnum x FACW+ Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern x OBL Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern x OBL X ris caroliniana Carolina Yellow-eyed grass x FACW+ *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 3 ELEVATION: 84 feet 9/6/01 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple x FAC Amelanchier obovalis serviceber x FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem x FACW+ Aristida vir ata wand-like three-awn grass x FACW- Aronia arbutifolia red chokeberry x FACW Arundinaria tecta switch cane x FACW Aster dumosus bush aster x FAC Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass x FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush x FACW C rills racemiflora titi 25-50% FACW Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Eu atodum rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Gelsemium sem ervirens yellow jessamine x FAC H ericum s p. St. John's-wort x --- Ilex coriacea sweet allber X FACW Ilex labra inkber 50-75% FACW Li uidambar st raciflua sweet um . X FAC+ Liriodendron tuli ifera tulip poplar x FAC L co odium alo ecuroides fox-tail clubmoss x OBL L onia lucida fetterbush 10-25% FACW M rica cerifera bayberry x FAC+ M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC Panicum s panic grass x --- Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Pinus taeda loblolly pine x FAC Pol ala lutea Oran e milkwort x FACW+ Pteridium a uilinum bracken fern x FACU Rhexia mariana Maryland meadow-beau x FACW+ Rhexia etiolata ciliate meadow-beau x FACW+ Rh nchos ora inex ansa noddin beakrush x FACW Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Solids o fistulosa pine barren goldenrod x FAC+ S ha num s p. s ha num moss x --- S m locos tinctoria horse sugar x FAC Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL= Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 5 ELEVATION: 83 feet 9/6101 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red ma le 25-50% FAC Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber 5-10% FACW Boehmeria c lindrica false-nettle x FACW+ Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush 5-10% FACW C rilla racemiflora titi x FACW Erechtites hieracilfolia fireweed x FAC- Eu atodum fistulosum ioe- a weed x FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Euthamia minor slender fragrant goldenrod x FAC Galium obtusum blunt leaf bedstraw x FACW- H ericum h ericoides St. John's-wort x --- Itea vir inica Virginia willow x FACW+ Juncus canadensis Canada rush x OBL Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Li ustrum sinense Chinese rivet x FAC Liriodendron tuli ifera - tulip poplar x FAC Ludwi is alternifolia bush seedbox x OBL Ludwi 'a ilosa hairy seedbox x OBL L co us vir inicus Virginia bu leweed x OBL - L onia lucida fefterbush x FACW Mikania scandens climbing hem weed x FACW+ M rica cerifera bayberry x FAC+ M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass x FAC Panicum verrucosum warty panic rass x FACW Persea borbonla red bay x FACW Pol ovum h dro i eroides swam smartweed x OBL Pol onum sa ittatum tearthumb x OBL Rh nchos ora racilenta slender beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry 10-25% --- Salix ni ra black willow 25-50% OBL Sambucus canadensis elderberry 5-10% FACW- Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Sphagnum s p. s ha num moss x --- Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Viburnum nudum ossum-haw viburnum 10-25% FACW+ Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern 10-25% OBL Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern 50-75% OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL = Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 6 ELEVATION: 84 feet 9/6/01 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator Acer rubrum red maple 25-50% FAC Alnus serrulata to alder 10-25% FACW+ Aronia arbutifolia red chokeber x FACW Bacchads halimifolia eastern false-willow x FAC Berchemia scandens su le'ack x FACW Carex s no fruits sedge x --- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush 5-10% FACW C rilla racemiflora titi 25-50% FACW Eleocharis tuberosa long-tubercle sikerush x FACW+ Erianthus i anteus plume grass x FACW Eu atorium com ositifolium do fennel x FAC- Eu atorium fistulosum 'oe- a-weed x FAC+ Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Galium obtusum blunt leaf bedstraw x FACW- Gelsmium sem ervirens yellow jessamine x FAC Ilex coriacea sweet allber x FACW Ilex /abra inkber x FACW Juncus effusus soft rush x FACW+ Li uidambars raciflua sweet um x FAC+ Lirlodendron tuli ifera tulip poplar 10-25% FAC Ludwi is alternifolia bush seedbox x OBL L onia lucida fefterbush x FACW Mania scandens climbing hem weed x FACW+ Murdannia keisak marsh dewflower x OBL M rica cerifera bayberry x FAC+ N ssa biflora swam black um x OBL Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Osmunda re alis royal fern x OBL Panicum dichotomum cypress witch grass 10-25% FAC Panicum sco arium hairy panic grass x FACW Panicum verrucosum warty panic grass x FACW Parthenocissus uin uefolia Virginia creeper x FAC Persea borbonla red bay x FACW Pol onum h dro i eroides swam smartweed x OBL Pol gonum sa ittatum tearthumb x OBL Pterldium a uilinum bracken fern x FACU Rh nchos ora ce halanta clustered beakrush x OBL Rh nchos ora racilenta slender beakrush x OBL Rubus s p. blackberry x --- Scir us c erinus wool grass x OBL Smilax laurifolia laurel-leaf reenbrier x FACW+ Smilax rotundifolia reenbrier x FAC Sphagnum s p. sphagnum moss x --- Toxicodendron radicans poison i x FAC - Vaccinium co mbosum hi hbush blueberry x FACW Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern x OBL Woodwardia vir inica Virginia chain-fern x OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL=Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover APPENDIX F: UPLAND VEGETATION PLOT #4 COLUMBUS CO. AIRPORT PLOT NUMBER: 4 ELEVATION: 85 feet 9/6/01 Wetland* SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME % COVER Indicator cer rubrum red maple x FAC melanchier obovalis serviceber x FACW Andro 0 on lomeratus bush bluestem x FACW+ ronia arbutifolia red chokeberry x FACW Chasmanthium laxum slender s ike rass x FACW- Clethra alnifolia sweet a erbush 5-10% FACW C rilla racemiflora titi x FACW Dios ros vir iniana persimmon x FAC Ele hanto us nudatus smooth elephant-foot x FAC Eu atorium ilosum hairy thorough-wort x FACW Eu atorium rotundifolium round-leaf thorough-wort x FAC Gelsemium sem ervirens yellow jessamine 5-10% FAC H pericum s p. St. John's-wort x -- 11ex coriacea sweet allber x FACW Ilex labra inkber x FACW Leucothoe racemosa leucothoe x FACW Li uidambar s raciflua sweet um x FAC+ L onia li ustrina maleber x FACW L onia lucida etterbush 5-10% FACW Moss moss x --- M rica hetero h lla evergreen bayberry x FACW N ssa s lvatica black um 25-50% FAC Osmunda cinnamomea cinnamon fern x FACW+ Panicum dichotomum - cypress witch grass x FAC Persea borbonia red bay x FACW Pinus taeda loblolly pine x FAC Pteridium a uilinum bracken fern 5-10% FACU Quercus falcata southern red oak 10-25% FACU- Quercus nigra water oak 5-10% FAC Rhexia mariana Ma land meadow-beau x FACW+ Rhus co allina winged sumac x NI Sassafras albidum sassafras x FACU S m locos tinctoria horse-sugar x FAC Toxicodendron radicans - poison i x FAC Vaccinium staminium deerber x FACU Vaccinium tenellum ale-leaf blueberry x FACU- Vitis rotundifolia muscadine grape x FAC Woodwardia areolata netted chain-fern x OBL *Wetland Indicator Key: OBL= Obligate Wetland Species FACW = Facultative Wetland Species FAC = Facultative Species FACU = Facultative Upland Species Upland = Upland Species + and - values represent species near the wetter end of the spectrum (+) and species near the drier end of the spectrum X + present but less than 5% cover