Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSAM WILSON DAIRY FARM_ENFORCEMENT_20171231MAY 13 'ge e:oe FROM USDA-SCS ADMIN ,w • SOIL.&WAI ER PAGE.003 CONS FRVAIION Orange Soil and Water Conservation District 306 Revere Road a P.O. Box 8181 Hillsborough, NC 27275 • Phone. (919) M-8181 • Ex(. 2750 Fax: (919)732.7559 May S, 1998 Mr. Sam Wilson PO Box 871 Mebane, NC 27302 Dear Mr. Wilson: Enclosed you will find a copy of the Animal Waste Storage Pond and Lagoon Closure Report form. on March 26, 1998, you contacted a certified operator and began hauling waste from your lagoon to start the process of closure. our office monitored your progress throughout the process and feel confident that all measures were taken to ensure proper application rates and clean -out procedures were followed. I visited the farm on April 30, 1998 and observed that the lagoon had been cleaned of all sludge and bulldozers had graded the area to natural conditions. Also, you were on the site preparing to seed all of the disturbed (denuded) areas with fescue. At this time, you have completed all of the required procedures for closing the lagoon as stated in the last section of the attached -Report Form." As required by the Waste Management Plan, the fields that did not have permanent vegetation (grasses) will be planted in corn. Please notify our office when you have completed planting your crop so we can process your request for cost -share funds. Thank you for your cooperation on this matter. Please call if you have any questions or concerns. Sincerely, Gail M. Hughes Soil Conservationist GI,M:iw ** TOTAL PAGE.003 ** 13 MAY '98 16:52 F6 TRANSWORLD/rSAFAR CIS • PAGE .001 Qt� TEL NOS: 229579 / 229537 / 333129 FAX NOS: 216487 / 333488 emaa address: tma ortd@fon"-aet.com TO: MS THERESIA BONNER FROM: FARIDA Dear Ms Bonner, FAX: 000 1 336771 463 DATE: 13 MAY 1998 Further to yr teleconversation, I would hereby like to confirm four pax balloon safari ex Sarova Mara for the momiug of 13 June 1998. The price is US$ 385 per person. You can pay the monies when u arrive nairobi - all you need to do is to call us on arrival then we can send someone to collect the monies, or you can advise us in which hotel you will be staying. payment can be made by credit cards or cash. I understand you have been trying to send a fax, but canno get thru, however if you do have e-mail, pls send us an e-mail. Best regards/farida ** TOTAL PAGE.001 ** f'MAY 13 'ge e:oe FROM USDA-SCS ADMIN PAGE.002 Animal Waste Storage Pond and Lagoon Closure Report Form (Please type or print all infortnativn chat Does not require a >ignature) General Information: Natne of Farm: Facility No: — owner(s) Name: o I+ / ISO A yiailing Phone No: 5746` Operation Description (remaining animalsonly): ❑ Please check this box if there will be no animals on this farm after lagoon closure. If there will still be animals on the site after lagoon closure. please provide the following informatiun on the animals that wiill remain. Operation Description: Type of Swine No. of Animals Type of Poukt No. of Animals Type of Cattle No. of Animals D Wean to Feeder D Laver X Dairy - a — 7 Feeder to Finish 0 Pullets Site r' So- eJS (teoe( 7 Farrow to Wean 7 Farrow to Feeder rJ Farrow to Finish Other TypeofLirestock: MunberofAnimals: Will the farm maintain a number of animals Greater than the 2I1.0217 threshold? Yes c7 No F2, Will other lagoons be in operation at this farm after this one closes? Yes ❑ No III-' How many lagoons are left in use on this farm?: 0 (xame)zm J4' hNaar) of the Water Quality Section's staff in the Division of Water hml irI /r ]>ns 1- � M Regional Office (see map on back) was contacted on ;JZ 5199 (date) for notification of the pending closure of this pond or lagoon. This notification was at least 24 hours prior to the start of closure which began on (date). I verify that the above information is correct and complete. I have followed a closure plan which meets all MRCS specifications and criteria. I realize that I will be subject to enforcement action per Article 21 of the North Carolina General Statutes if I fail to properly close out the lagoon. Name of Land Owner (Please Print :_• :SQyn W i I15on Signature: ��+/� l� Date: - The facility has followed a closure plan which meets all requirements set forth in the MRCS Technical Guide Standard 993. The following items were completed by the owner and verified by me: all waste liquids and sludges have been removed and land applied at agronomic rate, all input pipes have been removed, all slopes have been stabilized as necessary, and vegetation established on all disturbed areas. Name of Technical Specialist (Please Print): 6AI i. "Uo rjt<S Affiliation: OmnV Soil . vJaTex Comet aV T%tA D s «r A No.:7�2.8181 x2.75d Return wit ,in 15 days to owing comp etlon of amma water storage ponU or lagoon c osure to: N. C. Division Of Water Quality- Water Quality Section Compliance Group P.O. Box 29-;35 Raleigh. INC 27626-093-4 PLC - I Max, 3. 1996 � - i •�.a-,,�,.,�, i'-:> • • r .. SOIL &WATER CONSERVATION Orange Soil and Water Conservation District 306 Revere Road • P.O. Box 8181 Hillsborough, NC 27278 • Phone: (919) 732-8181 • Ext. 2750 May 29, 1996 Mr. Sam Wilson 4048 Mebane Oaks Court Mebane, NC 27302 Dear Mr. Wilson: N.C. Dept. of EI-INR MAY 3 '1 19SB rY4 Winston -Saner Regional Office The Orange Soil and Water Conservation District Board met on May 21, 1996. The Board discussed your request for cost -share assistance to close your lagoon. As we have not had any previous requests of this nature, the District wanted more information on how to proceed on the actual closing of a lagoon. At the present time, the District does not have funds available to share in the cost of closing the lagoon. (We are at the end of our fiscal year - June 30, 1996). More funds should be available in late August or early September. I encourage you to come by the office and sign an application requesting cost -share assistance. The District staff and Board will then be able to request additional funding for the new fiscal year. Meanwhile, the staff will be gathering information on how to proceed with the closure of a lagoon. Please keep in mind, until the lagoon can be pumped out and properly closed, you are responsible for maintaining the maximum liquid levels in the lagoon. It is our understanding that if the lagoon overflows, the Division of Enviromental Management (DEM) can find you in violation of water quality standards. Mr. Sam Wilson -2- 5/29/96 If you have any questions, you can reach me by calling the District office - 732-8181, Ext. 2753. Sincerely, .L. / 4/' Gail M. Hughes Soil Conservationist GMH:jw cc: Mr. Steve Mauney, NCDEHNR State of North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources Winston-Salem Regional Office James B. Hunt, Jr., Governor Jonathan B. Howes, Secretary Leesha Fuller, Regional Manager Mr. Sam Wilson 4048 Mebane Oaks Court Mebane, NC 27302 E)E H NR DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL November 30, 1995 SUBJECT: NOTICE OF VIOLATION Animal Waste Operation Inspection Wilson Del Farm Alamance County Dear Mr. Wilson: An inspection of the animal waste handling facilities at your dairy operation was conducted by Jim Johnston, Beth Mortan and Daphne Cartner of this Office on October 30, 1995. Specifically, the inspection was conducted to determine the status of. your compliance with Title 15 A, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0200 regulations, which govern wastewater disposal systems which do not discharge to surface waters of the State. Animal waste management systems which comply with the .0200 regulations are "deemed permitted" by the Division, and thus, are not required to apply for individual permits for operation. The primary factor in assessing compliance with the regulations is whether or not a discharge of pollutants occurs from the facilities (in your case a lagoon) during any rain event less severe than a 25 year storm. A 25 year storm is a storm of such severity, that it can statistically be expected to recur once every 25 years. A 25 year storm in Alamance County would amount to any rainfall 6 inches or greater within a 24 hour period. You should be aware, however, that because the weather data used to compile what is a 25 year storm covers many years, it is possible to experience 25 year storms on two consecutive days. Likewise, you could receive 5 inches of rain one day, and 5 inches the next, and neither would constitute a 25 year storm, so you would -need at least 10 inches of freeboard to prevent a discharge. At the time of the inspection, it was noted that your lagoon was full and spilling over the emergency spillway. The general recommendation for lagoon operators is to maintain at least 18 inches of freeboard in a lagoon (1 foot plus the 6 inches from the 25 year storm). Thus, you should attempt to pump your lagoon 585 Wauphtown Street, Winston-Salem. North Carolina 27107-2241 Telephone 910-771-4600 FAX 910-771-4631 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer 50% recycled/ 10% post -consumer paper QQ 614 --"- immediately since the liquid level is spilling over the low point of your structure. In the future, steps should be taken to prevent waste from building up to a point that it spills over. Should you require technical assistance on how to handle the wastewater generated from your operation, contact your local Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) office at (910) 226- 0477. Please be aware it is a violation of North Carolina General Statutes and Rules to discharge wastewater to the surface waters of the State without a permit and/or to fail to follow a certified waste management plan. The Division of Environmental Management has the authority to levy a civil penalty of not more than $10,000 per day per violation. Please respond to this Notice of Violation, in writing , no later than January 9, 1996, as to what steps have been taken to correct the above deficiency. Send the letter to this address: Mr. Steve Mauney NCDEHNR 585 Waughtown St. Winston-Salem, NC 27107 If you have any comments or questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Mr. Jim'Johnston or Mr. Mauney at (910) 771-4600. Sincerely, Larry D. Coble Regional Supervisor ccJerry Dorsett Alamance County NRCS Alamance County Health Dept. Alamance County, Division of Soil & Water Conservation Central Files WSRO DEAR OCT 24 '95 03:11PM DEAR HEALTH, 6• WA ` F ix ---m EHIVF P.1 OF AVIRONMEENT, AND NATURAL RESOURCES RALEIGH REGIONAL OFFICE 3800 Barrett Drive, Suite 101 Raleigh, North Carolina 27609 (919)571-4700 / FAK.- (919)571-4718 FACSIMILE You will be receiving _ o __ pages (including this cover sheet). If you do not receigeall pages, please call sender at 619/571-4700. COMPANY. FAX NUMBER: MESSAGE: C � a. Sqw, w��sah Owner, •' ,,;�_' '- •24 6EM WATER QJAL t TY SECTION TU OC 24 95 �',�� 11PM� RRO P.,21gi� Sim Regnlres imtnnediate �ttendnn- DIVISiON OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAG$M$Nl' Facility' No. — � ANIMAL REMLOT OPERA17ONS SITE VISITATION RECORD DATE:" 1995 Time: _ * pO Farm Name/Owner Maj2ingAddress.- Counry: luregtator On Site Representative: Phone: Physical -gdd rss/I motion: Phone -- Type of Operation: Swine Poultry � Cattle Design Capacity 3(oS NnmberofArtim-74 DEhi Certification Number: A.CE als on Site: Latitude: • ��. DEM C cau0n Number: ACNEW. 5 Longitude: —�' Elevation: �F�t Circle Yes or No Does the Animal Waste Lagoon have sufficient. tree board (aPPntx'mately 1 F of 1 Foot +?S y' ear 24 hotti storm event Foot + 7 inches) Yes or o A a1 Freeboard: ,_fit Was any seepage observeditm the lagoon(s)? No - Inches Is. adequate lawd available for i �Y erosion observed? yes �vo Y: es or No is cover crop adequate? Crop(s) being utilized_ 4 �'�r Na Does the facility =et SCS min=Lum Si tback criteria? 200 Feet from Dwellings? xe— No Y, 100 Fee: from wells? es s No ' c animal waste Stockpiled within 100 Feet of USGS Blue Line Stream? Yes " o al mal waste land anplied or spray aria ted within 25 beet of a USGS Ma 1 s �' animal wa3ie discharged P qA Line'- Yes ged into waters of the state by man-made ditch, flushing eimilar man-made devices? yes o "H res Inc is�•iliry maintain • 1I yes. Flease Explain. system. or other adequate waste mauagement records (vglu s of matttzre, yin sPrUY irdgared on specific acreage with cover tap ), Yes t[`19l" ` d appLcd Additional P'or Cor==ts: d Id cc: ,Facility Assessment Unit Use Attachments ifNeeded. .9". TOWL P.02 • November 6. 1992 li_ 6 ": 1 ul TO: David Harding THROUGH: Steve Mauney FROM: Ron Linville SUBJECT: Concentrated Animal Feedlot Follow-up Inspection Sam Wilson Dairy Farm-Alamance County A site visit on October 22. 1992 Indicated that this facility appeared to be in compliance with BMPs and that no discharges were evident at the farm. Mr. Wilson indicated that all pumping of animal waste is continually manned. The lagoon had approximately 15" of freeboard. Mr. Wilson was aware that it was time to pump the lagoon before any spillage occurred. The lagoon was protected from heavy rainfall inflow by berming along the edges. Generally, this operation appeared to be very clean for a dairy operation. If we can be of further assistance, please call us at 896-7007. MSM/rl cc: WSRO Central File 0 • 0 RECEIvEb DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL �Re Tt. NRC� RALEIGH REGIONAL OFFICE AUG 2 7 4$91 WATER QUALITY Date: Winston-Sa'em Rsc to: t3 iice °,�2 311 To: Please Comment and Respond By: Immediate Action Please Discuss With Me Please Advise 1� Please Sign For Your Information Please Prepare Draft For Note and File REMARKS Signature �7) r FROM .W NRCD AU6 2 7 IN W!Won �Sglem Ugionai.Uffin DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT RALEIGH REGIONAL OFFICE August 22, 1986 MEMORANDUM TO: R.W. Van Tilburg FROM: Wally Sanford i Jim Greer l / SUBJECT: Fish Kill of Mid -July at Sam Wilson's Farm Alamance/Orange County In response to questions raised as to the origin of fatal stress on these fish, Mr. Greer and I agree that upstream of Mr. Wilson's feed lot fish were not in distress, water appeared clear, and dissolved oxygen was repeatedly measured at adequate levels. Downstream there was 100% fish kill, floating solids, and measured anaerobic conditions. Jessica Howells took samples that should document our observations. Therefore, in our opinion, the necessary and sufficient condition for the subject fish kill was clearly the runoff of lagoon waste from Mr. Wil- son's farm and not low flow or dissolved oxygen. We recommend assessment of DEM and Wildlife expenses, but no civil penalty. WS:JG:/jf COBLE .NORTH CAROLINA • • DISTRICT OFFICES: P.O. Box 299 �- 324 WEST MARKET STREET NUN HOUSE OFFICE BUILDING GREENESORO, NC 27402-0299 4INGTON, DC 20515-3308 (202)225-3066 (�ongreso of the Eniteb *tate� (919) 333-6005 610 FFRNDALE BOULEVARD COMMITTEES: 30oua of Repmentatibeo HIGH POINT, NC 272604742 (919) 886-6106 JUDICIARY SMALL BUSINESS WO{ W9{a bingtoll, MC 20515-3306 124 WEST ELM STREET GRAHAM, NC 27253-0814 (919) 229-0159 P.O. Box 1813 116A WEST SECOND STREET LEXINGTON, NC 27293-1813 r �R August 7, 1986 R41`CF4I ♦�� �LAUG i1 (704)249-7011, Ext. 385 1 1988 Mr. Paul Wilms Director WA. of Enoironn,*n,a1 %jL Environmental Management Division Rakish. Ql (> P. 0. Box 27687 Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 Dear Mr. Wilms: This is written on behalf of Mr. Sam Wilson, Route 6, Box 43, Mebane, North Carolina, a dairy farmer. It is my understanding that a large number of fish died in the Haw Creek in mid —July, and that State authorities investigating the kill, notified Mr. Wilson that manure —laden water he used from his lagoon to water his parched corn field was the probable cause for the kill. Our concern centers around whether the NRCD has the capability of determining if the fish died from the spill into the creek or if they died as a result of the drought. If Mr. Wilson is held completely responsible for the kill, he will be charged for the investigation and the replacement value of the fish. The figure totals approximately $950, according to Information obtained from the Fish Division. As with all farmers, Mr. Wilson is struggling. I trust it will be possible to determine the cause of the kill, and to ensure that if Mr. Wilson is held liable for the investigation and the replacement value, that his liability will only be assessed on the basis of the number of fish which actually died as a result of anything he may have caused. Your attention to this matter will be greatly appreciated. Please advise me about the disposition of this matter. Sincerely, �� f l/ & WARD COBLE Member of Congress HC/ j m 1°86 WATER (JCLITY SECTION ..REPRESENTING THE COUNTIES OF ALAMANCE. DAVIDSON, AND GUILFORD VAN 'P1 i �racr�cr� lr r LSO N 11+(L*j o CZr'Pa I-T. wj • RECEIVED AUG 419, F;GG4 f.=Cl A.a! OFFIC7. l J r 12.2 Index to Inland Fishing Waters, No.Haw-1-1 9 BIOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION OF FISH -KILL (Waters Involved) Haw Creek County(ies) Alamance & Oran Date(s): From 7/18 To 7/19/86 A. OBSERVATIONS REPORTED: I received notification of a fish kill in Haw Creek off Mebane Oaks Road(SR-1007) near the 1�lamance and Orange County line from Doug Flake, Area Sergeant for the Wildlife Resources Commission's District 5 area at 2115 hours on 17 July, 1986. Mr. Flake indicated that a variety of fish species were observed dead by Mr. "_'ommv Hicks who lives next to the creek. At.2130 hours, I called Mr. R.W. Van Tilburg whose with the Raleigh Regional Office of Environmental 1`lanagement and informed him of the kill. Mr. Tilburg informed me that Mr. Wally Sanford with the Water Quality Section of Environmental `'anagement would inspect the kill site during the night and. contact me the next morning. I arrived at Haw Creek on 18 July, 1986 at 0830 hours and met with Mr. Flake and Mr. Hicks. I then inspected the creek for 4 mile stretch above SR-1007 and a mile stretch below. The creek was very turbid(black) and appeared to be contaminated with livestock sewage(a poignant odor was prevalent). Dead fish were mainly confined to a stretch of the creek approximately 290-300 yards above and below the SR-1007 road crossing. I then contacted Wally Sanford by phone to rerort my findings and to learn if a fish pick-up would he required. After consultation with the Winston-Salem Regional Office, Mr. Sanford. informed me that it nTould be advisable to conduct a pick-up. I then contacted Shari Lunardini, Assistant Fishery Biologist in District 5 and requested. that she bring the necessary equipment needed for the fish kill assessment. A total fish plck-up was conducted by 4 Commission personnel over a 2 hour period. Fish were then classified as to species, inched classed and weighed. The dead fish were then transported .by Commission personnel to the Alamance County landfill. The majority of dead fish collected were bream and catfish species. Because fish were still in distress downstream of SR-1007, I inspected Fp,aT Creek on 19 July, 1986 to see if an additional pick-up mould be necessary. I observed approximately 40 more dead fish along a i mile stretch below the previous dav's sample area. I included these fish in the data repo-ted based upon tY known number and webight percentages from the Initial pick-up. I also observed increased stream floe in the creek which was helping the water quality. Apparently, Environmental Xar.agement had requested that frPsh- wat,er be. romped into the tributary to increase dis^olvPd oxvaen levels. An interview +:•as nrnv19e:1 the. Rurlin-. nn limes News rer ^P.quast to explain the Commission's rPsronsi.Y;ilities and activities. B. 'EVALUATION OF DEAD FISH: • REPLACEMENT COSTS: A GAME FISH SPECIES:�6.�mo+-/G 6hss LENGTH NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH or VALUE/L9. TOTAL VALUE Z;... _. s: -- B_ 9' _- 10• 11:...- 7-_ — yks . SO - U o 12' 13' — • CCN/�P�c-^'✓_gyp \I SPECIES: L[ NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH or VALUE/LB. TOTAL VALUE 1y-7 0.Y/ 6,0,27 �sY vim_ 7 ,7i 13 0-5y - zs6,° lz 0._ S .Oc 5.vo o 31 2.a� (cZ:cc. Sue- TOT,AL SPECIES: LENGTH, NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH or VALUE/LB. TOTAL VALUE 6_ _ ... B. SPECIES: NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH Q VALUE/LB. TOTAL VALUE SUB- TOTAL—' s .....:. .. ... __ _.. .. ....__ — .. .:.._ 6 TOTAL C. FISH TRANSPORTATION COSTS: GAME FISHES: Frm To Niles one -ray 0 50.30/Mile S EVALUATION OF DEAD FISH: COSTS: REPLACEMENT COSTS: ONGAHE FISH SPECIES:.Tcf�/»<.d ,ENGTH NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH a VALUE/LB. 1' -- 2• — 9' 0 (� 6' =i T B.. _._ice 0 .3 a 9' — • SPECIES: •Z-�m— TOTAL VALUE NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH or VALUE/LB. TOTAL VALUE 10 — — 1i• 9 L i7./L- 12' �-- — 13' in• —1— 0, 32 c 15' — 16' — $us - TOTAL ////'' Z-`/j SPECIES: �lNriU . - LENGTH NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH or VALUE/LB. TOTAL VALUE 1• — 2' -- 3' — n' — 5• — T• — B" — 9' — 10• -- — 11' — 12' -- — 13' — iu• — 15' — SUB- TOTAL - y,S-�•YU TOTAL /I C. FISH TRANSPORTATION COSTS: c. 3 :; L" "l G SPECIES: *1 f1< /;/'.. NUMBER WEIGHT VALUE/FISH or VALUE/LB. TOTAL VALUE /77 14ONGAME FISHES: From To Miles ona- ay 0 50.30/Mile . S �7 • 1 D. , COST OF FISH -KILL INVESTIGATION: • FIELD INVESTIGATORS: PROTECTION PERSONNEL MILEAGE BOAT RENTAL NAME HOURS SALARIES S.WMI. SUBSISTENCE 53.00/11R. SUBTOTAL, PROTECTION f f f FIELD INVESTIGATO INLAND FISHERIES PE�}R��SjjONN^EL MISCELLANEOUS s f f _ Z .C,• /fV.00 SUBTOTAL. INLAND FISHERIES A //,,JJ f I3 ', $ 21 %� f L^' CC s '-' f/�� REPORT AND EVALUATION PREPARATION: NAME, HOURS SALARIES f ". 4 `S SUBTOTAL f L 1' GRAND TOTAL E:, COST SUMMARY;, B. FISH REPLACEMENT C. FISH TRANSPORTATION I D. FISH INVESTIGATION SALARIES MILEAGE SUBSISTENCE BOAT RENTAL MISCELLANEOUS TOTALS GRAND TOTAL PROTECTION INLAND FISHERIES a 4.9 TOTAL' / a �q4. YD SUB -TOTAL: • S !; 14 • b $ s 9�.6b 46 O a d l I %e0 /6. �f�[ S I�2, 2 S 1 V �L79. 23 13 N _ r \� I ` 1 J IY zip l SJ L ( n • v 1 (\ rl Qt , ,ahoy �ac����,a� �a�>-S� �a�u��• �rr�� �o� �'<+>�:c,—�r� a�uoN� LZ \ T I ,I C�Vl �r /I�Z 4� COMPLANT REP09T DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WINSTON-SALEM REGIONAL OFFICE DATE:-nT, Z19_?L- TIME: NAME OF CALLER:_ �ofn] 41 Lks F� ADDRESS: Street TELEPHONE NUMBER: POINT OF POLLUTION:_ DIRECTIONS: SOURCE OF POLLUTION: NATURE OF CALL: r /s Uh REPORT REFERRED TO: P.O. Box Zip w6 , , - S43 - Flll IMMEDIATE ACTION'TAKEN: CPA �S��ds� r t V -- D V - SICKED A !� • • IVF�r4.CRECIE . Dept. NRCD Orange Soil and Water Conservation District 110 East King Street - Hillsborough, North Carolina 27278 - Phone 7: December 1, 1986 ., Mr. Larry noble N.C. Department Natural Communirty Development 8025 th Point Blvd. win s,'on-Salem, N. C. Dear Mr. Coble: Resources and 27106 DEC 3 1930 361, Ext. 41)lvWOn of ;Environmental Mani errent Dept. NR p ;�� DEP •�: DlvtsiQr .,i Emlro'Mental Manager-,Cnt WItIBe� Clem Reg, Office I am forwarding my comments and recommendations regarding Sam Wilson's dairy farm in Mebane, N. C. Mr. Wilson and I visited on November 24, 1986 on the farm and agree to several possible solutions that should help eliminate his problems with the handling of waste from his livestock. Mr. Wilson has purchased the auxiliary engine that Dr. James Barker recommended in his November 4 letter to Mr. Wilson. This engine would be added to the irrigation traveller so it can propel itself through the field. Mr. Wilson also plans to use the manure solids separator as recommended. The existing diversions around the lagoon will be cleaned out to allow proper drainage, therefore, diverting some of the excess rainfall run-off from entering the lagoon. The use of the separator and the de- crease in excess rainfall into the lagoon will lessen the total liquid that must be irrigated. During my visit with Mr. Wilson, we discussed the possibility of terracing the field that is being irrigated. I feel as large as the field is and with its rolling landscape, it would not be feasible to terrace on the contour and still be farmable. My recommendations, and Mr. Wilson agrees, is to use field striperopping with two or three natural draws being seeded as grassed waterways. The striperopping pattern would lay across the general contour of the field with 108 feet wide strips. These strips will have an alternating pattern of grass and cultivated crop throughout the field. The grass strips will be maintained for hayland, therefore, these strips could be irrigated more frequently than the crop strip, plus the grass will act as a filter should run-off begin in a crop strip. Mr. Wilson has excavated three "catch basins" at the toe of each pre- dominate natural drain. I feel these basins are an excellent way to collect any accidental run-off of waste before it reaches the stream. Mr. Wilson and I also discussed the need for some "fine tuning" of these basins such as sizing, seeding vegetation around the edges, fencing cows out, etc. The pasture that these basins are in will be reseeded and the number of cattle on the pasture will be decreased so a good stand of grass can be maintained. CONSERVATION - DEVELOPMENT SELF-GOVERNMENT Mr. Larry Coble -2- December 1, 1986 I feel this combination of striperopping, grassed waterways in the natural depressions, and the catch basins will be the most effective ways to prevent any future problems. Mr. Wilson, having installed the basins on his own, is eager to cooperate and willing to do all of the recommended plans on the field. Due to the time of year, we are limited in how much progress can be made. We must wait until spring for suitable weather conditions and seeding time for the striperopping system but I feel the catch basins will be suitable during this short period of time. If you have any questions concerning my recommendations, please feel free to call. Sincerely, Gail M. Hughes Orange Conservation District Technician GMH:jw cc: Sam Wilson 44�dessica M. Howells William Mainous Dr. James Barker v4-Cl J Orange Soil and Water Conservation District 110 East King Street - Hillsborough, North Carolina 27278 - Phone 732-9361, Ext. 451 LE7nmimn RqDecember 1, 1986iM,tnRQement Mr. Larry Coble N.C. Department Natural Resources and Community Development 8025 North Point Blvd. Winston-Salem, N. C. 27106 Dear Mr. Coble: I am forwarding my comments and recommendations regarding Sam Wilson's dairy farm in Mebane, N. C. Mr. Wilson and I visited on November 24, 1986 on the farm and agree to several possible solutions that should help eliminate his problems with the handling of waste from his livestock. Mr. Wilson has purchased the auxiliary engine that Dr. James Barker recommended in his November 4 letter to Mr. Wilson. This engine would be added to the irrigation traveller so it can propel itself through the field. Mr. Wilson also plans to use the manure solids separator as recommended. The existing diversions around the lagoon will be cleaned out to allow proper drainage, therefore, diverting some of the excess rainfall run-off from entering the lagoon. The use of the separator and the de- crease in excess rainfall into the lagoon will lessen the total liquid that must be irrigated. During my visit with Mr. Wilson, we discussed the possibility of terracing the field that is being irrigated. I feel as large as the field is and with its rolling landscape, it would not be feasible to terrace on the contour and still be farmable. My recommendations, and Mr. Wilson agrees, is to use field striperopping with two or three natural draws being seeded as grassed waterways. The striperopping pattern would lay across the general contour of the field with 108 feet wide strips. These strips will have an alternating pattern of grass and cultivated crop throughout the field. The grass strips will be maintained for hayland, therefore, these strips could be irrigated more frequently than the crop strip, plus the grass will act as a filter should run-off begin in a crop strip. Mr. Wilson has excavated three "catch basins" at the;toe of each pre- dominate natural drain. I feel these basins are an excellent way to collect any accidental run-off of waste before it reaches the stream. Mr. Wilson and I also discussed the need for some "fine tuning" of these basins such as sizing, seeding vegetation around the edges, fencing cows out, etc. The pasture that these basins are in will be.reseeded and the number of cattle on the pasture will be decreased so a good stand of grass can be maintained. CONSERVATION - DEVELOPMENT - SELF-GOVERNMENT 14A • Mr. Larry Coble -2- December 1, 1986 I feel this combination of striperopping, grassed waterways in the natural depressions, and the catch basins will be the most effective ways to prevent any future problems. Mr. Wilson, having installed the basins on his own, is eager to cooperate and willing to do all of the recommended plans on the field. Due to the time of year, we are limited in how much progress can be made. We must wait until spring for suitable weather conditions and seeding time for the striperopping system but I feel the catch basins will be suitable during this short period of time. If you have -any questions concerning my recommendations, please feel free to call. Sincerely, `� ,�Z /'6 � Gail M. Hughes Orange Conservation District Technician GMH:jw cc: Sam Wilson Jessica M. Howells William Mainous Dr. James Barker AGRICULTURAL. j .EXTENSION North'Carolina•State�Uniuersity , SERVICE ' School of Agriculture: and Life -Sciences .=. Department of Biological and November 4, •1986 Agricultural Engineering Box 7625; Raleigh,.NC 27695-7625 Telephone'(919) 737-2675 N. Dept NRCO s. NOV101 ; f Mr,:; Sam Wilson -DivlsionOt. Wilson Dairy Farm'`: EnvitonMentel Marmeatro Route 6-Box 43' _Winston,Selem Reg.OfNod "Mebane, North:Caro-lina" 27317 Dear Sam: I,am,forwaTding.* comments, and recommendations regarding'waete"management at,. your' dairy farm.As..,a• follow up to,.our'yisit on October 29,, 1986., Regarding lagoon:management, I have two _auggeetions I would try:to put. the' . manure so ids -separator back into operation to reduce .the amount of manure solid e'entering ''the lagoon. This}would reduce ,the frequency,of.solids clean ' out.from-the lagoon 'and`reduce._th'e amount of -solids pumped`;through the ` irrigation'system. Secondly;. h would.;pump -the .,lagoon end;Jowei .it as, much as ` possible' -during the dryer periods when'f,ield conditions would .allow a higher infiltration rate,in order to 'provide, more ;storage during ahe:rainy .peiioda.'' %:Otherwise, after evaluating, the alternatives', I believes'the 'system that you have: is a manageable as any, both from a cost..and labor. standpoint. Ttie'first thirivl'would do -regarding irrigation.would'be to Add the auxiliary'-, engine to. th_ a traveller. :so it .would propel' itself throughthe :field'. This, . . 'wouldaliow a. more uniforiiapplication•rate, reducing *the likelihood of:rdnoff during irrig4t•ign. 'Also the faster the traveller;forward 'speed, the•lower th'e it application rate would be'. Lighter applications;would:-be„necessary forGwetter soil'" -conditions. -'-If a• field appi'icition' ie an.'axbeolute must •'to. prevent' lagoon : s over 164.'when soil moisture conditions are: near'satdretion, then I would` prot+elily only irrigate onto -the. upper�haltf,of the field s[ fiery `light'ratee As discussed during our, visit, SCS advice' should,,be sough,i'on whether ,or. not contoured terracing of'the field••being.icrigatedywould b'a-feaeible. We have r found', at -,other Land; app,: i:catton. ,si•tes' that';coneour terraces with minimal elope `-to a'=grassed: waterway outlet.significantly'reducea;the'amount"of reinfahl runoff from the lower edge.of the field.-.These-terracea provide temporary storage'.of 'a significant amount of.-runoffotherwise:would `leave that field.. They also provide filtering;: in conjunction.with the grassed outlet,, of the sediment and menace solids in.ihe.runoff.':Construction.of these'terraces would'' '• be'e�lig'ible'.-for coat-sha'ring-under the North Carolius',AgricuItural Cost -Share Program. Coope,athie Extension; Work in Agricuitum and Home Economics A&T and N;C!State btniveriitles,MdCotintiesand U S.'Department o%Agriculture t,oU`tit,i' ' ,. ,.tt+.nao - Pk+l•'F cu gh9.cc!{C�'.:. n n f;ous"s FrsoGourMa •.(¢'L`Svy v;C, : • i,nt, � s' S�,e S nn ,�:ca'aCc; �11' .' :r 4 t dc:.a. '.�`t8,,q-.•,',n>., t]k. b jT':�'ift. fj.M. C:i2C ri.tl 1. Ft•a /Yrt{f:.. 1. [T ii:)L'.b .'.t �4'o'tl4i t'(.f r: l}L ::j �{ 7 yJl'•1 .. .:'.j rlJCul ?-:.n �':,r:L Jp*P{j° Y �.'' ::gllJ! .'1.' -.r 7L Ci7G j'. j61 .., ',Ihl-•' �.(.(Jf�i:�Cj dD.U:,r .S��G.,+Tj' �,L�Ilil! Sf••G.f t'.' :U:G:fiG� .. :it `'T.i�.flf. �.6:°�tr ..aL 1. .'s -(i•.}f:c Q1' T . {'. Ct [it •Fn.r; RCq ,3.' '. SC.�', 9F u'., r . -. ',91R (.t ,t }^h,r �T4l, 341 "<T 1-11C ,Cju 1..,./ J+J CUvF A:.'.t .. f. . 1. b'f'I a.'Y . L S i. ail.• '(•ferr�'�, :1, f I'.�, a4, r?'1.t Jj �''}!t' :1:, UT Ifi T ..11:;31t1 :at i�" d, � a . '' r y .!j (�1 llj.l�tt 5:'i 4, �.re r '11 :'.•.� • �' ,l� t 4 ..Y v^r:. trr n,., i !'•^ -r !• ,•y 9, r�.jf ,,rf1r! '.. t., . •. �, r,�n. yyf-1 lld .'. tG Jr£ p'nri ,t, P,JL rt'+I C ( - 9t IC, (, .i lL L. jF N- .UC• G-;, rqn•. ':✓t J- t30: r '• so. bf,:bT:F y�AS •,,, L'Jd rfirnr.,otJ J,IT :Sgrf; ra: t{r.'-1 .-J .rrA g •`u(t �•ir�. : Y5. 1.Ul _1.a:..liGTrr1•' .�'r'lj)"rriL 1. ;ldj'i.1 r}P: rLf.F -�1: U,.+r a.^• .:r:GIT'. :'iVii .. r(`.i ,,Utf ni'l: r'. 'f, ^l. i,r ,:S L.-j .1l +7 .: t A l+'� ZT"L.Ir V•''� t• ... •,l fA ji'z;- 4T.rYl <: i iU:>{/J rr .i,.jC . t3:'!t.2I li T.•.T. 9(,r, rr f !' :i4 I1'P.-' T•. it! .vb.T �.�1.'iL a liji4\ Cif iJ r. `•G l`i 'i. tiC '.L' i3tt44°f JifjtirJ rfl t :'f (! 44 t'.1. 9Lrr YAT:1Tf,,•r,T,A 1, v„ l X(ij•G,"� •. t1 r1'+. Yii2 �'�'I F"1•.i.1 iNir ri...l'i f'. :JU^(:-fnj.G!!'it. ip'. i:.!15 LC (.r {):f pr ," iT':j, .., 'Ty'l �. •.{fij•i`i('tJ-' r ^ . .}Lf_: aC, t;r.: •3.. 1. •a :!' ''C[frrtlTh `,, A- J't•).. tj 7.', i,(, ,.r ..-+r 'ii, tj. fi.1:sL, Tf' °. .r 1 'i? Ui. - ;n. Fl" _.i' rP: t^l: .rj.'!Y tt -. A.4�("La•r(^ ..:+lj,.' � +�'"f•itt[^ qr %:J') - - .. . '• ' � for 71�(1 �ii :' . ..,J.. YiL-.''p�(715 c.: �'.J 4' =:' l•if+°h. 1(Jf0 ... :r. 'j,IN ](AV431': ..\r { S. ' ♦{�S�, ItI �' r,l)i 17?fJ �..�L ')A1l� (.11(l, :?r`. 1 J ,f)(T '�. .. nU L�. �j.1 +. T!'r. TfJi ('V' "1 i.•.3.J tr)1r. h:$TL - r. i1�:_' _ C..C.4.} ilr JUt.0 rile. 1'tt•. r r..rr. -n'.:.lo r tJ • l t `'• '1"=F . .t„', If?'.4� .. ' �a,,rj¢`?L rto:5 i^`.T.o�•uf..'i11t� .. j'�::.r•..E,..:..� � .. - . ' `>!i'= t,r r'K7u D�. .: rs."^�. _ li:und tJu'E;trr3+r !1. • 3 r:;.j • S f5@G�,r�r FSos M('f+�' fSyr^•rip' lAf.'<KnvdJC .. -y'(iLiCl,jtr7"7f EK. tajlj'oFi,1.151,� - '. .-.- �•r,-4 dJp' .t.:;n '({ .I1 �� .•.�ai,J 1r.T��'�J\'I ..� iiC �IQ�• Q�1�{�h:tM S''y1 •' \.s .. '•�fC.fi�.{�!S'l.J,I tS.i J r �r LlA i.. '� `. tTr�`'�+�� h::l1W4lJlC+A Lf� .I. JT�. �ti�i,il.1 77 J .. , t - 1 .. a •- ems: �}y.;a+ ;• „ur:• +.- ' - - ..S:G..)a: 1+itl iL� �W'.• n SL,y.��+..E{,.�-I'3yr !f r r.r'r %�' C .�i t4 �.71 .i ({':;;E•'i' .t r( �Sr. .... ?Y. i�. '.. .F r3. (t-Y L�. '7? t ,f ',;., k•+,:..�at.::FCG*.?,ori..-:-„ ,C.: �^ r.:.Y�. - 3•". �r �.,;;�:e.':e:'_ r;, '.T. k.:*"+{•. i?, f j.Q ,?j r+. .;�"Jy .J(L.'fl Q'L/ LY,i r. �1}i.. y.Ci.. t.1 �''GG �1'i/'s.. 'a. '% ' ••'� e � '' ,' �•!' ., .. �. fit. .�. ..�. .'•' � . AGRICULTURAL. EXTENSION North Carolina State Uniuerslty SERVICESchool'of Agriculture and Life Sciences•. • ' Department of Biological and ! NOvea44r '4, 1986 +' ' Agricultural Engineering Box 7625;'Raleigh, NC 27695-7625 ;, <. Telephone {919) 737-2675. REGt1VE0 *:,i 1 HC:OtlptNRCU , .Mr: Sam Wilson ,.., , Divieibt9f3f Wilson' Dairq•Farm IGflt �' haute_.6, Box. 43. ' Mobane North':C aralina '37911 - Dear Sam:.. _ Z am forwarding.my.commsnte.end recomicenditioni 'regarding waste'•managemerie et r7 your dbIry. fsrm'ae a follow-up to.our..visit-ion October. 29;,1986.. ,"hegarding lagoon management, I'have tvo suggeatione ,I•would'try to put the ' manure solids;eeparator back in'to."opikiatipri.to,reduce the'amtiunt of manure ' solids entering -.the lagoon. .this would reduce -the .frequency of solids clean out from the tagoon.aad;reduce the amount of. solids pumped through,t.he., frr.igaiion 'iyatemi" Secondly; I would'pump"the lagoon•and.Lover it as much as poeeible during the 'dryer periods when.fietd conditions would allow a - higher infiltration'iata',in oidor to, provide,-more,:storage during the rainy.,period' `Otherwise'; after evaluating tie,alieinstivis, I believe,thi-eyatem that you have is. as manageable aa.any, both from a^cost and •labbr•:eteddpoint.• The first thing-I`would do regarding'irrigation would Se,'tb idd':the auxiliary angine;.to ,the, -traveller, so it, would,.propel .itself .through- ctie '£ eld..'`Thi''a would' allow 'a more-uniform''applicetion rate ,reducing the likelihood'of'runoff• ''during irrigation., Also the faster .the travella5-forward-speed,,'the rower. the epplicstion•rate: would be.'.' Lighter:appllc.aii'and. would•. be. necessary 'for: wetter .soil conditions.:: If'a 'field'appit`cation,Is'an absolute must to prevent lagoon .,overflow when soil, moisture, Conditions are near pbturation. then l would; probably only" rri"gate. onto,' Sha u+per'half -of the';tield `aC very '.light':'rates. =i a r As discussed during -our visit, SCS'sdvice_should;be,soughi on whither ornot contoured cerraciog.of the ficld.being irrigated vould'be feasible. Fie have foutid''st-tither land•appl'ication-sites that contour terraces.with minimal'slope ' .,:to a grassed waterway: outlet•significantlq"roducee the amount of rain fal°1{ , runoff from'.06 lower edge. of 'the.field-.'�Theie terraces provide temporary r." storage of -a significant amount, of runoff that otherwise.would leave•the field. They Also provida`filtering,'in Con juneti'om'with"the grassed outlet,, of the!' .sediment and manure solids :in, the runoff... Construction of these.terracea would be eligible for co®t-ehsri'ng under the'.korth•Caro1ina�Agriculturel.Cost-Share Program.. Coop'eratwe Extenswn Work in Agr[cultum and Xome`EconomaeafA@Tand N.0 State Universttee8,100 Countresand USD art tofAgru^ulture.' . C3oh<csr{, i L;r.[aucK,v ;}, o•,s n •.)6+;�i<1tn�� ux+S'clo),�i$,,couovs.,.,,'VS�.'„rs4i 4i l,' ? ',�. ,Z:cisr r.zV, {¢<•..Sl)0.(*c rtul.cv,'Lcu:, :. :' q"C�S�.' fist [;}! .. ...;;:,:.:r • r ' � li..,. r.. !L• !' �l7'. ,'•1 -e .-t ', :fir J .1 i , P 1 �}tibl.i• .. Lr.r l4 �r ofti r , ' ryP,ctta!yr),:y, H:''t,+:rdr.iv+3 1 - �.. � .-. e. ^� ,,-__-r..-•.-.�,..i,.-- ._ .�.,_....__— � , � •fir{Oi.O. mt>.;.: En t, _true( T'.t`��r:✓ . { A• Siff Nr: Uft Wilson •f..., :Page 2 ' November 4R 1986 k ,r <'t believe tbaE,tliese refinewants'i'loug with diagent attention to the management'of your. existing syatep-vould-,go a long'.,\ways 'toward 4limfrgtiag tMe "r pofenii I for ,dirsct, at.ream discharge•of xbstea•`fcpm your Wiy,ojlgratloa. Should-you;have, quesiions,about if I Cd b'e2of. + J .. 3 \ � furt'her'issiataace,` please contact me: Sincarelyc�.�i.x - J 1/ I >' laiaab C.;6azker, Rxtansion Specialist t ;•,, ' giotogicT and Agricultural Bnjligearing ... c JCBfbb cc: W Iism 9 mainoua' + Arry 'Coble01 iltlesiC4 Howe lie Y, t I• r. l s , y ♦ r 1 . r /. � >:. - . �• . '.y r. o �. _ _ � � ' - •. .. �� _ _ - � I 1 r .. � , Y �wr .. .. .- .. . u ,. � . t;,7 � r+ �. � .a �' >' , r..i r �� �y; � �, }. ��.t ji:7.. °'.. ry ,-: �1. :, rite. ., ��� Cjtit,�-i :rlt - , _.. + � .. - T vie. _{ � r � . - s� . ,�., 4 9 W.C. Dept. NRM NOV 10 1986 Division of Environmental Management Winston-Salem Reg. Office State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Govemor DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary October 7, 1986 CERTIFIED MAIL ETURN2I RECEIPT REQUESTED Mr. Sam Wilson Wilson Dairy Farm Route 6, Box 43 Mebane, North Carolina 27317 Subject: Notice of Designation Wilson Dairy Farm Alamance County, North Carolina Dear Mr. Wilson: This letter is to notify you that the Wilson Dairy Farm in Alamance County has been designated by the Director, Division of Environmental Management, a concentrated animal feeding operation and should submit applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit in accordance with Title 15, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0123 and adopted Federal Regula- tions 40 CFR 124.82 (a)(2)(ii). Attached for your information is a copy of the Director's designation. An evaluation of your Dairy Operation conducted August 11, 1986, and September 8, 1986, by members of the staff of the Water Quality Section, indicated that your Dairy Operation is a concentrated animal feeding operation. This designation was made based on the following considerations: 1. The location of the feedlot relative to the surface waters of the State; 2. The direct discharge of animal waste to the State's surface waters; and 3. Indication of dissolved oxygen and fecal coliform violations in an unnamed tributary to Haw Creek, thereby requiring the submission of applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit. P.O. Box 27687, Raleigh. North Carolina 27611-7687 Telephone 919-733.4984 An Egwl Oppommiry / AHimutive Action Employer Mr. Sam Wilson Page Two October 7, 1986 If you can permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State, by such minor changes as can be effected within sixty (60) days from receipt of this notice to submit permit applications (such as, but not limited to, diversion of outside drainage from pen areas, modifications to lagoons, closing off drainage ditches), a permit application will not be required. If, however, modifications necessary to permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State cannot, or are not completed within sixty (60) days of receipt of this notice, a permit application must be submitted. For your information, the following items are enclosed: One copy of the Federal Register - Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations 40 CFR 124. 2. Three copies of NPDES Discharge Permit Application - Short Form B. If you cannot permanently eliminate the discharge within sixty (60) days, the permit applications will be processed. Said permit will contain a time schedule leading to the completion of construction of an animal waste management system which will assure that discharges to the surface waters do not occur. We know from past experience that excellent advice with regards to managing animal waste may be obtained from the North Carolina State University's Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering at (919) 737-2675. If you need any technical assistance in this matter, I strongly suggest that you contact the Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering. Permit applications should be submitted, in duplicate, to the Director, Division of Environmental Management, Post Office Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611. Assistance, if desired, can be obtained by contacting Mr. Larry Coble, Regional Supervisor, North Carolina Depart- ment of Environmental Management, Water Quality Section, 8025 North Point Boulevard, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27106, telephone (919) 761-2351. The applications should be accompanied by construction plans for the non -discharging animal waste management system. ri Mr. Sam Wilson Page Three October 7, 1986 Should you have any questions regarding this matter, do not hesitate to contact us. _ yp Water`@"uality Section Chief Enclosures cc: Mr. Thomas Hilliard N.C. State University, Dept. of Biological and Agricultural Engineering N.C. State University, Agricultural Extension Service Water Enforcement Branch, EPA WSRO ✓ G ' 0 SENDER:, COMPlate ik#M,1, Y, 3 and 4. Put Your addrew in the "RETURN -TO" the I reverse side. Failure to do this will prevent t rd frofn,r. ' a being raurnatl t0 You. TM i�turn raealDt Ise will orovlG" ' + You tM rytr,e of [M parson ONIvarW to and tM 0ag of + dallvarv. For add tlonel Yew • of ow rep eary ge�an , available. Comult pm mestw for fees and check'boafes) 7— for ser ,ice(s) rpuated. 1. ❑ Show to whom, date and address of delivery. 2. ❑ Restricted Delivery. 0. rSam Wilson [Route ilsoFarm 6, Box 43 Mebane, NC 27317 a, Type o1 Service: Article Numijer ❑ Reg,stered ❑ Insured Certified ❑ COD Express Mail O O f Always obtain signature of addresseeegr agent and DATE DELIVERED. 5. ip •tune - Adtlraeee x .� 6. S& nature - Agent , x ]. Oate of Deliverr/v- 8. Addr 's Address (ONLY t request K is Department of Natu Div 512 North Sal James G. Martin, Governor S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Mr. Sam Wilson Wilson Dairy Farm Route 6, Box 43 Mebane, North Carolina Dear Mr. Wilson: 27317 rubject: Wilson Dairy Farm Randolph County, North c,e _ Carolina This letter is to notify you that the Wilson Dairy Farm i Qlamance County has been designated by the Director, Division of Environm Management, a concentrated animal feeding operation and should submit applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit in accordance with Title 15, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0123 and adopted Federal Regulations 40 CFR 124.82 (a)(2)(ii). Attached for your information is a copy of the Director's designation. An evaluation of your Dairy Operation conducted August 11, 1986, and September 8, 1986, by members of the staff of the Water Quality Section, indicated that your Dairy Operation is a concentrated animal feeding operation. This designation was made based on the following considerations: 1. The location of the feedlot relative to the surface waters of the State; 2. The direct discharge of animal waste to the State's surface waters; and 3. Indication of dissolved oxygen and fecal coliform violations in an unnamed tributary to Haw Creek, thereby requiring the submission of applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit. Pallwliow Prrvmtion Pays P.O. Brno 27697, Rakish North Carolina 27611.7697 Tekplw 919-733-7015 M Equal Oppornmkv A((irmuive A.ii. F....,4 Mr. Sam Wilson Page Two September 18, 1986 If you can permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State, by such minor changes as can be effected within sixty (60) days from receipt of this notice to submit permit applications (such as, but not limited to, diversion of outside drainage from pen areas, modifications to lagoons, closing off drainage ditches), a permit applica- tion will not be required. If, however, modifications necessary to permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State cannot, or are not completed within sixty (60) days of receipt of this notice, a permit application must be submitted. For your information, the following items are enclosed: One copy of the Federal Register - Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations 40 CFR 124. 2. Three copies of NPDES Discharge Permit Application - Short Form B. If you cannot permanently eliminate the discharge within sixty (60) days, the permit applications will be processed. Said permit will contain a time schedule leading to the completion of construction of an animal waste management system which will assure that discharges to the surface waters do not occur. We know from past experience that excellent advice with regards to managing animal waste may be obtained from the North Carolina State University's Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering at (919) 737-2675. If you need any technical assistance in this matter, I strongly suggest that you contact the Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering. Permit applications should be submitted, in duplicate, to the Director, Division of Environmental Management, Post Office Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611. Assistance, if desired, can be obtained by contacting Mr. Larry Coble, Regional Supervisor, North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development, Division of Environmental Management, Water Quality Section, 8025 North Point Boulevard, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27106, telephone (919) 761-2351. The applications should be accompanied by construction plans for the non -discharging animal waste management system. r • Mr. Sam Wilson Page Three September 18, 1986 Should you have any questions regarding this matter, do not hesitate to contact us. Si cer�ly, George erett Water Quality Section Chief Enclosures cc: Mr. Thomas Hilliard _ N.C. State University, Dept. of Biological and Agricultural Engineering N.C. State University, Agricultural Extension Service Water Enforcement Branch, EPA WSRO State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor September 181986 R. Paul Wilms p, S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary Director CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Mr. Sam Wilson Wilson Dairy Farm Route 6, Box 43 Mebane, North Carolina 27317 Subject: Wilson Dairy Farm Randolph County, North Carolina Dear Mr. Wilson: This letter is to notify you that the Wilson Dairy Farm in Alamance County has been designated by the Director, Division of Environmental Management, a concentrated animal feeding operation and should submit applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit in accordance with Titlt 15, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0123 and adopted Federal Regulations 40 CFR 124.82 (a)(2)(ii). Attached for your information is a copy of the Director's designation. An evaluation of your Dairy Operation conducted August 11, 1986, and September 8, 1986, by members of the staff of the Water Quality Section, indicated that your Dairy Operation is a concentrated animal feeding operation. This designation was made based on the following considerations: 1. The location of the feedlot relative to the surface waters of the State; 2. The direct discharge of animal waste to the State's surface waters; and Indication of dissolved oxygen and fecal coliform violations in an unnamed tributary to Haw Creek, thereby requiring the submission of applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit. Poltulm Prevention Pars P.O. Box 27667, Rakiiih, North Carolina 27611-7697 Tekphone 919-733-7015 An Equal opportunity Affirmative Action Emp6m Mr. Sam Wilson Page Two September 18, 1986 If you can permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State, by such minor changes as can be effected within sixty (60) days from receipt of this notice to submit permit applications (such as, but not limited to, diversion of outside drainage from pen areas, modifications to lagoons, closing off drainage ditches), a permit applica- tion will not be required. If, however, modifications necessary to permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State cannot, or are not completed within sixty (60) days of receipt of this notice, a permit application must be submitted. For your information, the following items are enclosed: One copy of the Federal Register - Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations 40 CFR 124. Three copies of NPDES Discharge Permit Application - Short Form B. If you cannot permanently eliminate the discharge within sixty (60) days, the permit applications will be processed. Said permit will contain a time schedule leading to the completion of construction of an animal waste management system which will assure that discharges to the surface waters do not occur. We know from past experience that excellent advice with regards to managing animal waste may be obtained from the North Carolina State University's Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering at (919) 737-2675. If you need any technical assistance in this matter, I strongly suggest that you contact the Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering. Permit applications should be submitted, in duplicate, to the Director, Division of Environmental Management, Post Office Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611. Assistance, if desired, can be obtained by contacting Mr. Larry Coble, Regional Supervisor, North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development, Division of Environmental Management, Water Quality Section, 8025 North Point Boulevard, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27106, telephone (919) 761-2351. The applications should be accompanied by construction plans for the non -discharging animal waste management system. Mr. Sam Wilson Page Three September 18, 1986 Should you have any questions regarding this matter, do not hesitate to contact us. Si cer6ly, George erett Water Quality Section Chief Enclosures cc: Mr. Thomas --Hilliard N.C. State University, Dept. of Biological and Agricultural Engineering N.C. State University, Agricultural Extension Service Water Enforcement Branch, EPA WSRO NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Winston-Salem Regional Office September 12, 1986 MEMORANDUM TO: L. Page Benton, Jr. Deputy Director THROUGH: George Everett Water Quality Section Chief FROM: Larry D. Coble Regional Supervisor PREPARED BY: Jessica Moss Howell s Environmental Technician V SUBJECT: Concentrated Animal Feedlot Designation Sam Wilson Dairy Farm Alamance County, North Carolina Attached is a Report of Investigation conducted on August 11, 1986 and September 8, 1986 by the staff of the Winston-Salem Regional Office concerning Sam Wilson's Dairy Farm. Also attached are a suggested memoran- dum of designation as a feedlot for the Director's signature, letter of designation with a copy of the appropriate Federal Register, three copies of Short Form B Application for NPDES Permit, one copy of supplementary instructions for the Section Chief's signature and a copy of a Report of Investigation conducted on January 14, 1986. It is our recommendation, as indicated by the report, that the owner of the subject operation be required either to cease any discharge of wastewaters to the surface waters of the State or to submit applications for a permit to discharge wastewater to the surface waters until an animal waste management system can be constructed which will assure that discharges to surface waters do not occur. It should be noted that Mr. Wilson has both the means and the knowledge to properly conduct his dairy operation so as to prevent any discharge by using land application techniques. Because he has demonstrated that he cannot consistently operate without a direct discharge, it is felt by WSRO that Mr. Wilson's dairy operation in Alamance County should be designated a concentrated animal feedlot operation. L. Page Benton, Jr. Page Two September 12, 1986 If you have any questions or require additional information or documentation, please advise. LDC/JMH/cm Attachments cc: Central Files WSRO NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Winston-Salem Regional Office Report of: Concentrated Animal Feedlot Designation Place Visited: Sam Wilson's Dairy Date: August.11, 1986 & September 8, 1986 Rt. 6, Box 43 River Basin: Cape Fear Mebane, N.C. Time Spent: 8 Hours By Whom: Jessica Moss Howell S environmental Technician V Person(s) Contacted: Mr. Sam Wilson, Owner Directions to Site: From Winston-Salem proceed East on I-40 to I-85 North past Mebane.to Mebane Oaks Rd. (SR1007). Turn right (South) on Mebane Oaks Road.and travel 0.85 miles to SR2128; turn left and travel 0.25 miles and Sam Wilson's dairy farm will be on the left. Receiving Stream: U.T. to Haw Creek Classification: IdS-III River Basin: Cape Fear, 03-06-02 Drainage Area: NA Longitude: 79°.15'53" Latitude: 36°03'51" Elevation: 575' Number of Animals Fed: Approximately Size of Animal Feeding Area: Mr. Wilson has 450 240 acres, 100 acres is in pastureland and Type: Holsteins about 2 acres contains the feeding and milking areas. Total Animal Units: 450 Amount of Waste Reaching Navigable Water: Mr. Wilson estimated that 3000 gallons of manure reached the surface waters during the spill that occurred on July 14, 1986. In an investigation conducted March 19, 1986 concerning scum in the stream, Mr. Wilson said that he had lost 10,000 gals. of waste to the stream during Location of the Animal Feeding Operation Relative to Navigable Water: the week before the Feeding operation is approximately 900 feet from the affected stream. investigation. ,f Page Two The Means of Conveyance of Animal Wastes and Process Waste Waters into Navigable Waters: Animal wastes gain access to the stream by way of Mr. Wilson's waste management system. The WSRO has documented spills occurring at Mr. Wilson's farm due to a hole in an irrigation line, the overloading of waste on application fields and the subsequent runoff of waste, and the overflow of Mr. Wilson's waste lagoon. Pollutants are Discharged into Navigable Waters through a Man -Made Ditch, Flushing System or other Similar Man -Made Device: Yes -'By way of the spray irrigation system No Pollutants are Discharged Directly into Navigable Waters which Originate Outside of and Passes Over, Across, Through or Otherwise Come into Direct Contact with the Animals Confined in the Operation: Yes No Sam Wilson Concentrated Animal Alamance Report: Dairy Farm Feedlot Designation County. On July 17, 1986 the Raleigh Regional Office received a report of a fish kill on Haw Creek on SR1007 in Alamance County. Mr. Wally Sanford investigated and found that the fish kill had resulted from the discharge of a large amount of animal waste to an unnamed tributary to Haw Creek from Mr. Samuel A. Wilson's dairy farm. Mr. Sanford discussed regulations and clean-up techniques with Mr. Wilson; Mr. Wilson indicated that he would pump out the solids and remove the dead fish. The following day, July 18, 1986, Messrs. Greer and Daniel with the Raleigh Regional Office supervised the clean-up. I also went to the site as Mr. Wilson's farm is in Alamance County (which is the responsibility of the Winston-Salem Regional Office). I took dissolved oxygen (D.O.) readings. The D.O. downstream from Mr. Wilson's dairy at SR1007 was 0.6 mg/l; the D.O. at Mr. Wilson's dairy farm at SR2128 (where there was a large amount of solids) was 0.6 mg/l; the D.O. upstream from Mr. Wilson's dairy at SR2187 (Wilson Road) was 6.8 mg/l. Photographs were also taken at these locations. North Carolina Division of Inland Fisheries Staff conducting a count of fish killed estimated the number of dead fish at 800 to 900. Mr. Wilson and his son, Danny Wilson, were pumping solids out of the creek. Mr. Wilson estimated that 21,000 gallons of liquid were pumped from the creek that day. Mr. Wilson also indicated that only 2000 to 3000 gallons of manure was discharged to the creek. He said that they had been spray irrigating their corn fields approximately three days before the fish kill and, when the hose was pulled too tightly, a junction between two hoses began to leak. This ran off the field and to the stream. When he saw the stream turning black he told Danny to turn off the pump; however, he did not pump the manure from the stream nor did he notify our Office. Mr. Wilson installed two waste lagoons in July, 1977, as a result of complaints concerning animal waste from his dairy being discharged to the stream. The Orange County Soil Conservation Service designed the lagoons and the North Carolina Agricultural Extension Service assisted in funding the installation. Only one lagoon is currently used as an animal waste lagoon; the other lagoon is being used as a fresh water pond. On May 15, 1983 a complaint investigation by staff of the Winston- Salem Regional Office again found animal waste from Mr. Wilson's dairy farm being discharged to surface waters. During the investigation it was found that the lagoon was overflowing at a low point on the far side of the lagoon. Mr. Wilson was told to build up the earth wall of the E 40 Page Two lagoon to better contain waste and to inspect the lagoon on a regular basis. I also conducted a complaint investigation concerning Haw Creek on March 19, 1986. I took D.O. readings (13.2 mg/1) and BOD, COD, residue, ammonia, and metals samples. At the time of the investigation Mr. Wilson's animal waste maintenance system appeared well maintained and I saw no sign of a discharge. Mr. Wilson admitted that there had been an accidental spill at this spray irrigation site when one location was overloaded. However, he indicated that approximately 10,000 gallons of manure were lost and, because of the high D.O. in the stream, I thought that this quantity was unlikely. Sample results did indicate numerous water quality violations. The fecal coliform level was 3100/100 ml; total dissolved solids were 1200 mg/l; manganese was 8300 ug/l; copper was 130 ug/l; and zinc was 270 ug/l. Water quality limitations for WS-III waters (Haw Creek is Class WS-III) are 1000/100 ml for fecal coliform, 500 mg/l total dissolved solids, 200 ug/l manganese, and action levels of 15 ug/l and 50 ug/l for copper and zinc respectively. Mr. Wilson said that he would be more cautious in the future. Due to the number of times that waste from Mr. Wilson's farm has gained access to the surface waters of the State, I conducted investigations on August 11, 1986 and September 8, 1986 to determine if the Wilson dairy farm met the criteria needed to be designated as a concentrated animal feedlot. It was determined that Mr. Wilson has approximately 450 Holstein cattle that he feeds and milks in a covered area with a concrete floor. The cows stay in this area overnight, are driven to fields during the day, and are gathered up again in the evenings. As such they are contained in the feeding and milking area for more than 45 days during the year. Waste from this area is scraped and hosed down the sloping floor of the feeding area to a ditch which carries the waste to the lagoon. Mr. Wilson said that the feeding and milking area is cleaned every other day. He estimated that this area was approximately two acres in size. The feeding area itself consisted of two lanes 300 feet by 14 feet in size, as well as a third feeding area that was approximately 50,000 square feet. Mr. Wilson said that his lagoon holds approximately 1,000,000 gallons and the waste is land applied about three days out of every week. The application area is Mr. Wilson's feed corn crop and border areas. After the July 17, 1986 fish kill, Mr. Wilson dug three pits at the low points in the pasture below the application area to catch runoff. One pit was full of rainwater during the investigation. The pits would hold approximately 1000 gallons each. When spray irrigating Mr. Wilson said that they check the sprayer every hour and move it to a different location if necessary. P Page Three During the August 11, 1986 investigation D.O. and pH readings were again taken as were fecal coliform samples. The D.O. was 3.2 mg/l, the pH was 6.7 S.U., and fecal coliform was 240/100 ml downstream from the dairy at SR1007. At the dairy at SR2128, the D.O. was 3.4 mg/l, the PH was 6.9 S.U., and fecal coliform was 43,000/100 ml. Upstream from the dairy at SR2187 the D.O. was 7.4 mg/l, the pH was 7.0 S.U., and fecal coliform was 40/100 ml. Water quality standards for D.O. and fecal coliform are 4.0 mg/l (minimum instantaneous value) and 1000/100ml, respectively. Due to the documented water quality violations in Haw Creek and in an unnamed tributary to Haw Creek and to unpermitted discharges of waste- water to the unnamed tributary it is recommended that Sam Wilson's dairy be designated a Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation. It is also recom- mended that sufficient actions be taken to prevent further discharges to waters of the State. IS6uth bbo ire • ��l��� ••; � �� III � � �•��r � � 9995 on mil .V l/ 63J\ ) Zy3j ��r ' � ,I 6M t, II ;LoM-Ai'Y6 FtAi.I�-JJ `a,,f,criAT� JOCII..00.- IA .+J& 3lo°b31.51'/ �oNCgJr}t.�dE 79° ISMS �/ s�— AA` 64 JtWA poiAL LL,46�)- MAP /SANE �1,�4d'�'AN4�E. ngg A State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Govennor R. Paul Wilms S. Thomas Secretary September 18, 1986 Director CERTIFIED MAIL NO. P 039 815 904 RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Mr. Sam Wilson Wilson Dairy Farm Route 6, Box 43 Mebane, North Carolina 27317 Subject: W' Raridolph CountNorth Carolina Dear Mr. Wilson: This letter is to notify you that the Wilson Dairy Farm in Alamance County has been designated by the Director, Division of Environmental Management, a concentrated animal feeding operation and should submit applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit in accordance with Title 15, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0123 and adopted Federal Regulations 40 CFR 124.82 (a)(2)(ii). Attached for your information is a copy of the Director's designation. An evaluation of your Dairy Operation conducted August 11, 1986, and September 8, 1986, by members of the staff of the Water Quality Section, indicated that your Dairy Operation is a concentrated animal feeding operation. This designation was made based on the following considerations: The location of the feedlot relative to the surface waters of the State; The direct discharge of animal waste to the State's surface waters; and Indication of dissolved oxygen and fecal coliform violations in an unnamed tributary to Haw Creek, thereby requiring the submission of applications for an NPDES Discharge Permit. Pollution Prevention Pays P.O. Bon 27697, Rakigh, North Caroline 27611-7687 Tekphone 919-733.7015 Ala__._— A— C J Mr. Sam Wilson Page Two September 18, 1986 If you can permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State, by such minor changes as can be effected within sixty (60) days from receipt of this notice to submit permit applications (such as, but not limited to, diversion of outside drainage from pen areas, modifications to lagoons, closing off drainage ditches), a permit applica- tion will not be required. If, however, modifications necessary to permanently eliminate the discharge of wastewater to the surface waters of the State cannot, or are not completed within sixty (60) days of receipt of this notice, a permit application must be submitted. For your information, the following items are enclosed: 1. One copy of the Federal Register - Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations 40 CFR 124. Three copies of NPDES Discharge Permit Application - Short Form B. If you cannot permanently eliminate the discharge within sixty (60) days, the permit applications will be processed. Said permit will contain a time schedule leading to the completion of construction of an animal waste management system which will assure that discharges to the surface waters do not occur. We know from past experience that excellent advice with regards to managing animal waste may be obtained from the North Carolina State University's Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering at (919) 737-2675. If you need any technical assistance in this matter, I strongly suggest that you contact the Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering. Permit applications should be submitted, in duplicate, to the Director, Division of Environmental Management, Post Office Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611. Assistance, if desired, can be obtained by contacting Mr. Larry Coble, Regional Supervisor, North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development, Division of Environmental Management, Water Quality Section, 8025 North Point Boulevard, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27106, telephone (919) 761-2351. The applications should be accompanied by construction plans for the non -discharging animal waste management system. Mr. Sam Wilson Page Three September 18, 1986 Should you have any questions regarding this matter, do not hesitate to contact us. Sincerely, George Everett Water Quality Section Chief Enclosures cc: Mr. Thomas Hilliard N.C. State University, Dept. of Biological and Agricultural Engineering N.C. State University, Agricultural Extension Service Water Enforcement Branch, EPA WSRO P NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT September 18, 1986 MEMORANDUM TO: George Everett, Chief Water Quality Section FROM: R. Paul Wilms, Director Division of Environmental Management SUBJECT: Designation of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation Sam Wilson's Dairy Farm Alamance County, North Carolina On August 11, 1986, and September 8, 1986, Jessica Howells, Environ- mental Technician V in the Winston-Salem Regional Office, conducted an inspection of Sam Wilson's Dairy Farm for the purpose of making a determi- nation as to whether or not the dairy should be designated a concentrated animal feeding operation. During the course of the inspection, the following determinations were made: 1. Animals are confined for more than 45 days in a 12-month period; 2. Forage is not sustained in the areas of confinement; 3. Approximately 450 mature dairy cattle are maintained in the area of confinement north of SR2128 in Alamance County; 4. Due to inadequate animal waste management techniques animal waste is allowed to enter the State's surface waters by the malfunction of land application equipment, the overloading of waste and resultant runoff from an application area, or the discharge of animal waste from Mr. Wilson's lagoon. This has occurred numerous times in the past and has been documented by the Winston-Salem Regional Office on four different occasions since 1977. 5. Samples taken of the U.T. to.Haw Creek on July 18, 1986 revealed a dissolved oxygen (D.O.) level upstream from Wilson's dairy (SR1140) of 6.8 mg/l. At Wilson's dairy (SR2128) the D.O. was 0.6 mg/1. Downstream from Wilson's dairy on SR1007 the D.O. was 0.6 mg/l. There were 800 to 900 fish that died as a result of this D.O. depletion, according to the N.C. Division of Fisheries. Samples n George Everett Page Two September 18, 1986 were also taken on August 11, 1986. SR1140 the G.O. was 7.4 mg/1 and the At Wilson's dairy.at SR2146 the D.O. fecal coliform level was 43,000/100 at SR1007 the D.O. was 3.2 mg/l and Upstream from Wilson's dairy at fecal coliform level was 40/100 ml. of the U.T. was 3.4 mg/1 and the ml. Downstream from Wilson's dairy the fecal coliform level was 240/100 ml. In consideration of the determinations made during the August 11, 1986, and September 8, 1986, inspections, and in compliance with the requirements of Title 15, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0123, and 40 Code of Federal Regulations, Section 124.82, I am hereby designating the Sam Wilson Dairy Farm as a concentrated animal feeding operation. Notice should be given to Mr. Wilson to make application for an NPDES Discharge Permit in accordance with the requirements set forth in Title 15, North Carolina Administrative Code 2H .0123. RPW/JMH/cm cc: WSRO Central Files 1-3 juawdolanaa AliunwwcC),g saoinoseH joinION 10 JuaualaodaQ ouiIoaCO ulN uaarsns :31V0 "L- • 0 y Mlllicovsky et°. Drive RECEIVED Route 6, Box 57-a N.C. D1,pt. p.; Mebane, N.C. 27302 Phone 563-4691 JUI_ July 18th . 1986 Environmcn,al P+ia;:< , nent Winston-Salern Reg, Office i Mr. Paul Wilms State of N.C. Dep. of Nat.Res. and Com. Develp. 8025 North Point Boulevard. Suite 100 Winston-Salem_--NC_--27106_3295---------------- Dear Mx. Wils Investigation Haw Creek Alamance County . Mrs. Jessica Howels. July 18th. 1986 This letter is about the latest violations in_.the_.water quality of our creek which runs in to the Haw River. We want for you to understand that this grossy violations of the enviroment dobe by Mr.Sam Wilson is not new. In your records is my first complaint, nine years ago, which your office investigated. Year after year because nobody is doing nothing to really stop the manure to be dumped -NOT ACCIDENTALLY - in the creek, he just will tell the next inspector or neighbord in line " I AM SORRY" This was and accident and I will tie more carefull in the future. Because he is our neighbord, so many people in tgis area do not want to take actions against him. I talked twice with Mr. Wilson and he gave me the same empty words that we are hearing today. When my lawyer told him that he was ready to go to court to make him to,clean the creek, he came with some of the money to do the cleaning. At that time we took 150 truck loads of manure out of the cree. Some kind of accident ..I Our neigbords are angry. People can not do any fishing and we have to live with the decomposed odors from the manure. Why do we have to live, year after year, with this unpleasent situation.? Your Agency must fine this man and gave him the FINAL NOTICE. NO MORE MANURE IN THE CREEK. PERIOD . Mr. Wilms. Twelve years ago my wife and myself bought this peace of land. We develop our subdivision which is called Fork Creek.When we bought it was beatiful/ The creek water was qualified by the Alamance County Healt dept. almost drinkable. We have done a lot of improvements along the creek and clean the stream twice for trash and foreign mate- rials. We want our creek back as it was before.We hope that this time you have more than enough evidences to impose a stiff penalty on Mr. Wilson so he will learn that he can not play with people health and the enviroment.We expect,from your Agency,periodically checks on this matter because every year, in the summer when the water is low, we notice the WRE runing down the stream. Please let us #now about the outcome of this investigation. Sincerely yours., E ela B. /f J es Mil covs �0 1 2 3 4 �f D 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 A B C N.C.. PT. OF NATURAL RESOURCES & CO NITY 1 — couNTr. r"T/ys�A /LtA nl(� DEVELOPMENT LAB NUMBER Deaoe� /JN �J �� RIVER BASIN: t kpit 1—fdT' DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT oATE RECIEVEo REPORT TO: ARO, F.110. MRO'. RRO, WaRO WiRO WSRO TS /y �`..—.� U WATER QUALITY FIELD -LAB FORM IOM1! Re Recd by '"� I From Bus -Courier —Other Other Shipped by: COLLECIOR(S): �� B�us�C Courier/, �O`the aAMBIENI SAMPLE TYPE.,lr Q1 ER EMERGENCY ❑SPU7 BOD RANGE �%1+I�f) SEED: )�U STATION LOCATION_ f AOW FV1LI S+I/'\ REMARKS: i -4 i DATA ENTRY BYCK: COMPLIANCE DATE REPORTED: StaKon Number Date Beginiyy/mm/ Time Begin Date En Time To Depl OM DB DBM Valuelype-- - Composite Sae A H L T S B C G GN%% / BODs 110 / •ie. s.� /n. �!-ro'L /I IC Ioride 940 m /I NH3as N610 m /I Ni- Nirkel 1067 COD High340 - /I Arsenic Tota 0 u /I TKN os N 625 m /I Pb- Lead 1051 u / COD Low 335 m 7 ChI a: T6 32217 .01 NO NO3 as N 630 m /1 Sb- Antimony 1097 u /1 Colilorm=MF Feca131 16 -�yC� /IOOmI Chi a:Cor. 32209 _d /I PO4 as P 70507 os /I Se- Seleni m 114 u /1 ° Colilorm: MF total 4 /IOOml Pheo h tin a 32213 u /l P'. Ta1ae as P 665 m /I Zn- Zinc 109 u /1 Colilorm: Tube Feco131615 /100ml Color: True 80 Pt -Co P: Dissolved as Is666 m /I Colilorm:Tube Total 31505 1100ml1 Chromium=Hen. 1032 H A -Silver 1077 u /I Pesticides Scocific.11y ` Residue Total 500 m /I C snide 720 - I AI -Aluminum 1105 u /I - SOS mg/1 Fluoride91 mg/I mVolatile Be - Bet Ilium :012 /I Scan Organochlorine Fixed 510 r m /I Formaldehyde 71880 m~/I Co- Calcium 916 m /I Scan Or anophos horns Residue :$ ended 530 /1 Grease and Oils 556 rngh Cd- Cadmium 1027 u / Volatile 535 m /1 HardnessTota1900 m /l Co - Cobalt 1037 u /1 Organics S ecilicall F'xed 40 m /I MBAS 38260 m /l Chromium: tal 1034 u /I H 403 units Phenols 32730 u /I Cu-Co er 1042 u /I Scan Base / Neutral Extractables Acidity to PH 4 5 436 mg/1 Sulfate 945 nn /i Fe- Iron 1045 ug/11 Scan Acid Ealractables Auden to PH 8 3 435 m /l Sulfide 745 m /1 H-Mercur 900 u /I 2 Alkali nii ro PH 8 3 415 m /I Specific Cord. 95 uMhosAm Li - Lithium 1132 u /I $ ecial Analysis Specifically 2 - Alkalirtitr to PH4541U m /I Biomass: Dry Wt. 573 g/M I M -Ma nesiom 927 mg/1 _ 2 IOC 68 /1 nr Biomass=Peri Ash Free 572 9/M Mn-Manganese 1055 ug/I Scan Acid Herbicides 2 lurbidit NTU Chi a: Pere Fluro 82547 mg/M No -Sodium 929 mg/II Scan Par eables Sampling Poem Water Tempiraturej%C D.O. pH ConduUance Alkalinity Acidity PT o12S`C PH 8.3 pH 4.5 pN 4.5 pM 8.3 63 2 10 300 400 94 82244 431 87243 82242 Secrhi(Meters) Air Temperatu+e(°C) D.O.%Saturation Salinity%, Algae; Floating Mats Precipitalion(In/Day) Cloud Cover. Wind Direction(Deg.) Win Force Severity Beaufort 78 20 301 480 1325 45 32 36 37 1 Hr Sippfle.Ible Dead Fs Turbidity Severity Odor.Atmosp ere Stream Flow Detergent Suds Oil -Grease Floating Debris Sludge Severity Marterlml/UHd Severity Severity Scverity Severity Severity Severity 50096 1340 1350 1330 1351 1305 1300 1345 1315 Y DMI/Revised 785 E •ga�i�a�UayUoal cNs 00 �Ua$eu� W o 5 n S 6� g8 "dafl'0-N 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 A B C OF NATURAL RESOURCES & CONNNNITY N.CPT. COUNTY p /Lt/V C DEVELOPMENT LAB NUMBER 00008: Y/ RIVER BASIN: _ 1 FA'f' DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT DATE RECIEVED REPORT TO: ARO, FRO. MRO. RRO. WORD WiRO WSRO T$ WATER QUALITY FIELD -LAB FORM (DM1) ® Recd 1, � _ Frc Other Shipped by: Bus ourier,Olh r SAMPLE TYPE DATA ENTRY COLLIE IOR(S): 'S �rl� G i N ❑AMBIENT ❑EMERGENCY`, ❑SPL]IIT COMPLIANCE T� DATE REPORTED/7 BOD RANGE 5Q—�CMSEEDP Al(1 -j}' STATION LOCATION: 61:9AAL- A I 1A )I IShA1 - rS I A I I Station Number Date Begin yy/mm/ Lime Begin Dale End time End Dept DM DB DBM Volue type Composite Sam pe A H L T 5 8 1 C G GN%% 800LC ii(­,e,_e &t'_4 m /I Chloride940 m /I X NHi as N 610 / m /I Ni - Nickel 1067 COD High340 !! mil/I Arsenic Total 10 u /I TKN as N 625 m /I Pb- Lead 1051 u / OD -Low 335 raq/t Chl a: Fri 32217 .911 NO -NO as N 630 m /I 56- Antimon 1097 u /1 COIIImm:MF Fem131 16 4�5od V /100m1 Chl a: Corr, 32209 a /I P as P 70507 mg/1 Se -Selenium lid u /1 I � Codform: MF TOI.1 31504 /100-1 Pheo h tin a 32213 a /I P: Total as P 665 m /I Zn- Zinc 1092 u /I Coliform.iu6e Fera131615 /100ml Color: True 80 PI -Co P: Dissolved as P666 m /I Colibrm Tube Total 31505 /IOOmII Chromium:Hea. 1032 r tt,�e/I A -Silver 1077 u /I Pesticides Specifically s Residue Total m /I Cyanide 720 m /1 At - Aluminum 1105 u /1 Volatile 505 m /I Fluoride9 1 m /I Be- Ser Ilium`a12 /I Scan Or9anochlorine Fixed 510 m /I Formaldehyde 71880 m /I Ca- Calcium 916 m /1 Scan Or onophos horns Residues ended 530 m /I Grease and Oils 556 /1 Cd- Cadmium 1027 a / V0101de 535 m /I Hordness:Tola1900 m /1 Co- Cobalt 1037 a /I Organics Specifically Fixed 540 m /I MBAS 38260 m /1 lChromitinsjoral 1034 u /1 H401 anics Phenals 32730 a /1 Cu-Co er 1042 /I Scan Base / Neutral Erstwoables Acidity to PH4.5 436 m /I Sulfate 945 nn/I Fe -Iron 1045 a /I Scan Acid Exlractobles Aridity ro pH 8 3 435 m /I Sulfide 745 m /I H -Mean. 1900 a /I 2 AIka16rity to PH 8.3 415 ra/1 S eciflc Cond.95 uMhos/cm Li - Lithium 1132 u /1 Special Analysis Specifically 2 _ Alkalinity ro pH45410 m /I Biomass:Dr Wt. 573 9/M M -Ma nesium 927 m9/1 2 TOC 68 m /I Biomass: Peri Ash Free 572 9/M Mrs -Mon9anese 1055 ug/I Scan Acid Herbicides 2 lmbidil 76 NTU Chl a: Pert Flwo 82547 mg/M Na- Sodium 929 mg/I Scan Pur Babes Sampling Point Water Temperolare('C) D.O. pH Conductance Alkalinity Acidity PT s o12S`C PH 8.3 pH 4.5 PH 4.5 pH 8.3 63 10 300 400 94 82244 431 82243 82242 Secchi fMelers) Air Temperalare('C) O.O.%Sahlrarion Scrhnily%a Algae;Floaring Mats Precipltation(In/Day) Cloud Cover. % Wind Daection(Deg.) Win Force Severity Beaulorr 78 20 301 480 1325 45 32 36 37 1 Hr. Settleable Dead Fs Turbidity -Severity Odor:Almosp ere Stream Flow Detergent Suds Oil -Grease Floating Debris Sludge Severity Maner(ml/IIHrI Severity Sevarily Severity Severity Severity Severity 50086 1340 1350 1330 135) 1305 1300 1345 IMS DMI/Revised 7.85 / N.c 4>epF/�O Sep NRCQ. WjL`rO°�PiL,- o� 1986 j7S1%,� ta/ 41 of e �a mReg ��eqt, • 1 2 3 4 wi 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 A B C REPORT TO. ARO, FPO, MRO, Other Shipped by: WORO Wi BOD RANGE: �j--,.,[Q SEED gA All) tv NAPT. OF NATURAL RESOURCES & COMWITY DEVELOPMENT LAB NUMBER 00008: w7 DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY FIELD -LAB FORM (OM1) SAMPLE TYPE OAMBIENT ❑EMERGENCY ❑SPLIT ODATE RECIEVED� Time Gj Real bv- �_ From. Bvs Courier -Other DATA ENTRY BY:/-i7,.. CK: PT PLIANCE DATE REPORTED:�C/ REMARKS: v Station Number Dote Beginlyy/rem/ Ilme Begin D.teE.d Time End DM DB DBM Value Type Composite Sample Type IDepth A H L T S B C GN%% � O eOD 310/ l0 m /I Chloride 940 m /I NH3as N 610 m /I Ni -Nickel 1067 COD High 340 m /I Arsenic Tola 10 u /1 TKN as N 625 m /I Pb- Lead 1051 u / COD: Law 335 mg/Img/I Chl a: Tri 32217 u /1 NO -NO3s N 636 m /I Sb- Antimony 1097 u /1 CPIlform:MF Feaa131 16 4- /100ml Chi a: Carr 32209 u /I PO4 an P 70507 m /I S, Selenium 114 v /1 Colilarm: MF Total 31504 /IOOm1 Ph o h tin a 32213 u /1 P: Totot as P 665 m /I Zn- Zinc 109 v /I Coliform.Tube Feco131615 /100ml Color: True 80 Pt -Co P: Dissolved as P666 mg/ I Coliform: Tube Total 31505 /100ml Chromium:HexA032 '9'og%I A -Silver 1077 u /1 Pesticides Specifically Residue -total 500 m /I C snide 720 .c m- /I Al -Aluminum 1105 u /I Volatile 505 m /I Fluorlde9 1 mg/I Be- 8er Ilfum!012 /I Scan Organochlorine Fired 510 mg/1 Formaldeh de 71880 m /I Ca- Calcium 916 m /I Scan Or anophos horvs + esidueS ended 30 . J/y3 m /I Grease and Oils 556 m /I Cd-Cadmium1027 a / Volatile 535 m /I Hardness:Total 900 m /l C, Cobalt 1037 u /1 Organics Specifically Fred 540 m /I MBAS 38260 m /I Chromium:Total 1034 u /1 M403 units Phenols 32730 u /1 Cu-Co er 1042 a /1 Scan Base / Neutral Extractable,, Acidity to PH 4 5 436 m /I Sulfate 945 m /I Fe- Iron 1045 u /I Scan'Acid E.traclable,, Aridity to PH 8 3 435 mg/l Sulfide 745 m /I M-Mercu. 1900 u /f 2 Alk al aril to PH 8 3 415 m /I S ecific Cand. 95 uMhos/cm Li - Lithium 1132 u /I Analysis $ e<il ice 2 —Special Alkalinity to PH 5410 m /1 Biomass:Dr Wt. 573 9/M M -Mo nesium 92] mg/1 2 TOC B m /I Biomass: Pert Ash Free 572 9/M Mn-Mangane se 1055 ug/I Scan Acid Herbicides 2 ImbidB 76 NTU Chl o: Pert Fluro 82547 mg/M I Nu -Sodium 929 mg/I Scan Pur eobles Sampling Point Water Temparolure(°C) DO. PH Conductance Alkol,..Iy Acidity PT s at25`C PH 8A PH 4.5 PH 4.5 PH 8.3 63 2 10 300 400 94 82244 431 87243 82742 Secchi(Meters) A it Temperature (C) D.O,%Sotwotton Salinity%. Algae: Floating Mils Precipitation(in/Day) Cloud Cover: Wind Direction(Deg.) Win Force Severity Beaufort 78 20 301 480 1325 45 32 36 37 I H. Senlea a Dead Fit Turbidity Severity Odor:Atmosp ere Stream Flow Detergent S., Oil -Grease Flooring Debris Sludge Severity Moner(ml/111`10 Severity Severity Swerily Severity Severity Severity 50086 1340 1350 1330 1351 1305 1300 1345 1315 DM1/Revised �. 7.85 • � ,Ot, Hey,,, _ . � '•� nst 7I 4/ Of Qal�e�RegaO j of 0 • COBLE RN CAROLINA MON HOUSE OFFICE BUILDING MOTOR, DC 20516J306 /2021225 3086 COMMITTEES: JUDICIARY SMALL BUSINESS • I QCongrea of the Vniteb Mateo Jbouoe of Repreoentatibeo Ula bington, MC 20515-3306 August 7, 1986 Mr. Paul Wilms Director Environmental Management Division P. 0. Box 27687 Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 Dear Mr. Wilms: RECENED AUG 1 1 1988 San of En/eonita"tAi AA, 43hI12h. 86 " 1575_ DISTRICT OFFICES: P.O. Box 288 324 WEST MARKET STREET GREENSBORO, NC 27402-0288 (919) 333-5005 610 FERNDALE BOULEVARD HIGH POINT, NC 27200-4742 1910) BB6-6106 P.O. Box 814 124 WEST ELM STREET GRANAM, NC 27253-0814 (818) 228-0188 P.O. Box 1813 11 SA WEST SECOND STREET LAXINGTON, NC 27283-1813 (704) 248-7011, EXT. 306 This is written on behalf of Mr. Sam Wilson, Route 6, Box 43, Mebane, North Carolina, a dairy farmer. It is my understanding that a large number of fish died in the Haw Creek in mid -July, and that State authorities investigating the kill, notified Mr. Wilson that manure -laden water he used from his lagoon to water his parched corn field was the probable cause for the kill. Our concern centers around whether the NRCD has the capability of determining if the fish died from the spill into the creek or if they died as a result of the drought. If Mr. Wilson is held completely responsible for the kill, he will be charged for the investigation and the replacement value of the fish. The figure totals approximately $950, according to information obtained from the Fish Division. As with all farmers, Mr. Wilson is struggling. I trust it will be possible to determine the cause of the kill, and to ensure that if Mr. Wilson is held liable for the investigation and the replacement value, that his liability will only be assessed on the basis of the number of fish which actually died as a result of anything he may have caused. Your attention to this matter will be greatly appreciated. Please advise me about the disposition of this matter. Sincerely, 1 WARD COBLE Member of Congress WATER "LITY SECTION ,.. ,.., ..REPRESENTING THE COUNTIES OF, AIAMANCE, DAVIDSON. AND GUILFORD RECEIVED — N-C-Degt, NRCD, AUG 2r 1986 Division ut Min ""t �L e M 5� State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North'Carolina 27611 - James G. Martin, Governor R. Paul Wilms S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary Director August 5, 1986 Mr. James Millicovsky Millicovsky Drive . Route 61 Box 57-B Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Dear Mr. Millicovsky: This is in response to your letter of July 18, 1986, concerning a discharge of wastewater from a Dairy Farm operated by Mr. Sam Wilson and located in your neighborhood. Our Raleigh Regional Office is completing an investigation into the latest incident of wastewater discharge. In addition, the Winston-Salem Regional Office is developing the necessary administrative actions to assure that Mr. Wilson installs adequate wastewater handling facilities -to serve his dairy. As these modifications to the waste handling facilities are put in place you. should see some improvement in the operating methods of Mr. Wilson and a significant reduction in the impact of his dairy farm operation on Fork Creek. In order for you to keep abreast of our activities with Mr. Wilson, I would recommend that you contact Mr. Larry Coble from time to time at 919/761-2351 in Winston-Salem. Thank you for your lett cc: arry Coble R.W. Van Tilburg :ter. RECEIVED N.C. Dept. NRCD AUG 1 1986 Division of Environmental Management Pollution Prevention Pays Winston-Salem Reg. Office po. Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7697 Telephone 919-733- 015I I' An Equal Opportunity Affi mauve Action Emplam - � If•11' r/, . Millicovsky Drive Route 6;:Box 57-B Mebane, N.C. 27302 Phone 563-4891 ---July .,1986,' "-�&f 'Nat State ofN.C.':Dep.16s and Com.7.1Develp.' .' 8025 North Point B6iilevard.'�,,Suite,100-*-�-.. t Winston Salem.' NC 271o6-2295 ------- - -------------- M i �7_Dear Mr.Willi Investigation -Hjiw,'CreekT�, . ...... Al amance-County Mrs.JessicaHom % ,v -� , `oP our creek which runs in to .the Haw R�.ver. RECEIVED N.C. Dept. NRCD JUL 221986 D1'v1 s;cn' Of' Environ-menta Manageri-,ef.- n Winston-Salem Reg. Office enviroment dobe 'by Mr. Sam Wilson is not'new.-Iln'yourreco first complaint,'nine years ago ..which your .off lcd.inv `after year because nobody is doing nothing to really to be dumped --NOT ACCIDENTALLY in the creek;',he 1 tell the next inspector -or neighbord•in line -AM SORRY �k I more carefull ,in Future -' d �accident and, I.. will: he "t .16 'dto ur neighbord,-lso many p o, not want , t �'Mr wwii son'..". -did ihe - gave.1m gaiiist,.hid.,.V� .talked -twice.4— 'that wel�&e' hearing to Wheh�my 2aw mpty words d yertg�o rt'i;to:make':him -,to clean -kthe76i�" e was, ready 'to')go..to c0u) -,-At 'thgi� �ti66'_w 't' �U 'the ��c eaning - 0 '1 .", ith s'md:of.the money � o,.. 0 -"Some:kind,of ;truck loads of manure 6itt"6f'_the lcree. ;a6cid can � ., - ' - "' `f i sh ineah r.ne'* People:can: -an, - u igbord not do, Yj, s .-are, angry i'�, to alive ;with ",the-'--decompos6d',�odors rom, -the manure.;�y&yjdo live; year- after z�rear his A ipleasent'.,sltil6Lt3.on.r?--.- d 'theFINAL-NOT -fine' r --,Your Aaency must -this,man,an m _gave.hi ht � '14-i t was "ty "ealt dept..��. ng -the -=6 ek -and ls.�W 'want,our- ,-have more,-,ythab` I son -`i&'he .'will ".1 i i n"v- 3. - i &m 6rii . W 6 ;e reek 4ater,.*a tikable '`We'he `stream twice .;as. as - --it was be ;% IMPORTANT ,l WHILE YOU WERE OUT M_ of Phone 1 q AREA CODE NUMBER EXTENSION TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL CALLED TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN WANTS TO SEE YOU URGENT RETURNED YOUR CALL Signed N. C. Dept. of Natural Resources and Community Development qqq NORTH C LINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURC AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Date To: From: Remarks: ❑ Note and file ❑ Note and return to me ❑ Note and sea me about thi. ❑ For your approval Ej Per om mmr rwlon Par your mgveat 19— Note, initial and forward ❑ Your ...a,., please ❑ For your Information Prepare reply for my I,n.t.,. Prepare information for me to reply ❑ Pleue .rower, with copy, to an. � aSTNro • TED AUG 'r 1� State of North Carolina • jvU`°AOr`IC Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street' Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 . James G. Martin, Governor R. Paul Wilms S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary Director August 5, 1986 Mr. James Millicovsky Millicovsky Drive Route 6, Box 57-B Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Dear Mr. Millicovsky: This is in response to your letter of July 18, 1986, concerning a discharge of wastewater from a Dairy Farm operated by Mr. Sam Wilson and located in your neighborhood. Our Raleigh Regional Office is completing an investigation into the latest incident of wastewater discharge. In addition, the Winston-Salem Regional Office is developing the necessary administrative actions to assure that Mr. Wilson installs adequate wastewater handling facilities to serve his dairy. As these modifications to the waste- handling facilities are put in place you. should see some improvement in the operating methods of Mr. Wilson and a significant reduction in the impact of his dairy farm operation on Fork Creek. In order for you to keep abreast- of-- our activities with Mr. Wilson, I would recommend that you ;contact. Mr.. Larry.... .. Coble from time to time at 919/761-2351 in Winston-Salem. Thank you for your letter and your concern in this tter. Si r V R. aul Wilms cc: Larry Coble JR�W. Van Tilburg Pollution Prevention Pays P.O. Box 27687, Raleigh, North Camlina 27611.7687 Telephom 919-733.7015 ...'- .: An Equai Opportunity Affi mative Action Employer rq�T a GTO-J, T 2U0 Ue, GX4�' *70; aTqe3j=jp,: :p omjmdap 91). V Pup[, qj', :.VQ guTUE a TR, um OTO", 0 4.R4wTxli ! aXam6!�.,,4an6q;, Slow d sure .btj_:op ease "qTjt!p'u bTdoed.- IM080paoq Tau r: auk _T T*!'I', Pulg' q.UOP.T0D!R,,P OCTT J�n� c OUT . T� M , Pakq2TOtiTjo,.'lao�oedsuT !.xeu eqk._-TT admnp. eq o!� sanu XMINMIDOVII lost-i p 2UTop Da*q-'aieAllaG4.31��'zm .RuTlq!pU -ST.. Apoqou as�1�.v i ,S_-MOA. qupk":�ypTdt�oo' , !said,. _i',uosTTm- meS.,*jrM�,.Aq: eqop, !.usmoap 0� nod ao;:`fUsm, UT BVsuns =1V *I., f MET Z�L 04:'-'.3IG8JD_-an0 t , I 8 a fIl";. a --------------- go ,A;� lcj?,41.00AWi 00T.-: 9�TnSx-pa dTGA iLa LIS-UO;SUIM luaLuageue w lelyawuojjhuj OU01SI lASQ.- sass zz j np- GuNd . ..... V-V9(j -3-N 'eusqGIN 9 xog '9 %nokj:'4 03AI30 8 3 GAIJC] ANSAODIIJIVY ON .I,MeTus, uo�Uu I RECEIVED N.C. Dept, NRCD �'UL 7') 1966 Civisicn j Environmental Management .Winston-Salem Reg. Office July 27, 1986 Mr. Paul Wilms N.C. State Dept. of Nat. Res. & Com. Developement 8025 North Point Boulevard Suite 100 Winston Salem, N.C. 27106 3295 Dear Mr. Wilms: Enclosed is a letter sent to you re- cently by our neighbors, Estela B. and James Millicovsky. We also have property along the Haw Creek and we agree with the Millicovsky's that something should be done to prevent these so-called accidents that seem to occur on a regular basis. Complaints against Mr. Wilson have been filed before by us as well as the Millicovsky's. We truly hope that this latest incident of July 18, 1986 will be the last, and that the proper action from your Department will pre- vent any further cause for our complaints. Thank you for your interest and attention to our problem. ,inter Donald & ClaraPerry f_ cp DONAJJD �"V. CLAYU FEIRRY ROUTS 6, BOA 64-A ;r-B.�?dli, N.C. 27302 PiA j N . �,i Off. �•a..�-y_ July kith. 1986 ivir. Paul Alme State of ;+.i:. Dap. of Nat.Res. and Com. Develp. 8025 North Point Boulevard. Suite 100 Anston Salem. r+C. 2Z106_22Q�_____________ ---------------- - ----- ---- Dear idr. mils Investigation Haw Creek Alamance Jounty . uir3. Jessic=t Howels. July 18th. 1986 Phis letter is about the latest violations In the water quality of our creek which runs in to the Haw River.. de want for you to understand that this gro.-sy violations of the enviroment dobe by vx.Sam Wilson is not new. In your records is my first complaint, nine years agog which your office investigated. Year after year because nobody is doing noticing to really atop the manure to be dumped -UOT ACCIDENTALLY - in the creek, he just will tell the next inspector or neighbord in line " I AV.' SORRY" Thi3 Nas and accident and I will be more oarefull in the future. Because he is our neighbord, so many people in this aret: do not w*int to take actions against him. I talked twice with Mir. Wilsor and he -eve me the Same empty words that we are hearing today. .Phan my lawyer told him that Y:e was ready to go to court to make him to,clean the creek, he came with some of the money to do the cleaning. At that time we took ,50 truck loads of manure out of the arse. Some kind of accident ...,I Cur neigbords are angry. People can not do any fishing and we have to live with the decomposed odors from the manure. why do we have to lives year after year, with this unpleasant situation.? Your Agency must tine this man and gave him the FINAL NOTICE. NO MORE ftANURE IN THE CREEK. PRRIUD . xr. Wilma. Twelve years ago my wife and myself bought this peace of land. We develop our subdivision which is coaled Fork Creek,4hon we bought it wac bestiful/ The creek water was qualified by the Alanance County Healt dept. almoat drinkable. Wa have done a lot of improvements along the creek and clean the stream twice for trash and foreign mate- rials. We wart our creek back as it was before.We hope that this time you have more than enough evidences to impose a stiff penalty on Yx. ;411son so he will learn that he can not play with people health and the enviroment.Ws expeet,from your Agency,periodically checks on this matter because every year, in the summor when the -ranter is low, we notice the _ ivUaE runing down the stream. :•lease let us Snow about the outcome of this investigation. .sincerely yours.. iistelr. > . James .:..1licovsky Sw RECEIVED N.C. Dept, NRCD JUL ^i im Oivisicn :,f Environmental Management Winston-Salem Reg, office July 27, 1986 Mr. Paul Wilms N.C. State Dept. of Nat. Res. & Com. Developement 8025 North Point Boulevard Suite 100 Winston Salem, N.C. 27106 3295 Dear Mr. Wilms: Enclosed is a letter sent to you re- cently by our neighbors, Estela B. and James Millicovsky. We also have property along the Haw Creek and we agree with the Millicovsky's that something should be done to prevent these so-called accidents that seem to occur on a regular basis. Complaints against Mr. Wilson have been filed before by us as well as the Nlillicovsky's. We truly hope that this latest incident of July 18, 1986 will be the last, and that the proper action from your Department will pre- vent any further cause for our complaints. Thank you for your interest and attention to our problem. DOi�TALD ;: CLARYi PERRY ROUT 60 BOX 64-A MEB�TgE, N.C. 27302 si cer Donald & Clara Perry LL �r�nd n f L RECEIVED _ N.C. Dept, NRCD JUL !•j 1586 Division cf Environmental Manager mnt i Winston-Salem Reg. OfticQ July 27, 1986 Mr. Paul Wilms N.C. State Dept. of Nat. Res. & Com. Developement 8025 North Point Boulevard Suite 100 Winston Salem, N.C. 27106 3295 Dear Mr. Wilms: Enclosed is a letter sent to you re- cently by our neighbors, Estela B. and James Millicovsky. We also have property along the Haw Creek and we agree with the Millicovsky's that something should be done to prevent these so-called accidents that seem to occur on a regular basis. Complaints against Mr. Wilson have been filed before by us as well as the Millicovsky's. We truly hope that this latest incident of July 18, 1986 will be the last, and that the proper action from your Department will pre- vent any further cause for our complaints. Thank you for your interest and attention to our problem. cp Sincerely, �<k Donald & Clara Perry T/ 4 I 1 July 18th. 1986 Mr. Paul Wilms State of N.C. Dep. of Nat.Res. and Com. Develp. 8025 North Point Boulevard. Suite 100 Winston Salem. -NC. 27106:2M ------------------ ----------------------- Dear rTx. Wile Investigation Haw Creek Alamance County . Mrs. JessicaFlowelrs. July 18th. 1986 This letter is about the latest violations in the water quality of our creek which runs in to the Haw River.. We want for you to understand that this groosy violations of the enviroment dobe by Mr.Sam Wilson is not new. In yciir records is my first complaint, nine years ago, which your office investigated. Year after year because nobody is doing nothing to really stop the manure to be dumped -NOT ACCIDENTALLY - in the creek, he just will tell the next inspector or neighbord in line " I Arr1 SORRY" This was and accident and I will be morn carefull in the future. Because he is our neighbord, so many people in tgis area do not want to take actions against him. I talked twice with far. Wilson_ and he gave me the same empty words that we are hearing today. When my lawyer told him that he was ready to go to court to make him to,clean the creek, he came with some of the money -to do the cleaning. At that Limo we took 150 truck loads of manure out of the cree. Some kind of accident ....1 Cur neigbords are angry. People can not do any fishing and we have to live with the decomposed odors from the manure. 6Vhy do we havo to live, year after year, with this unpleasant situation.? Your Agency must tine this man and gave him the FINAL NOTICE. NO MORE MANURE IN THE CREEK. PERIOD . 1W. Wilms. Twelve years ago my wife and myself bought this peaca of land. We develop our subdivision which is celled Fork Creek.When we bought it war, beatiful/ The creek water was qualified by the Alamance County Healt dept. almost drinkable. We have done a lot of improvements along the creek and clean the stream twice for trash and foreign mate- rials. We want our creek back as it was before.We hope that this time you have more than enough -evidences to impose a stiff penalty on Mr. Wilson so he will learn that he can not play with people health and the enviroment.We expeot,from your Agency,periodically checks on this matter because every year, in the summer when the water is low, we notice the -pruning down the stream. Please let us #now about the outcome of this investigatbn. Sincerely yours., Estela B. James olillicovuky NKDATA ALERT --EMERGENCY ACTION > INQ FILE > ALERT-&86 PSWD > FORMAT NRT,68 ENTERED THIS DAT , RECORD IS NO 00038 EMEFFgENCY: LAGOON DISCHARGE/FISH KILL LOCATION: HAW CREEK AT SR 1007 DATE 07/18/86 > �ALERTE NEXT RCD > 00039 F DATA TIME NOTIFIED: 2202 EDT PERSON NOTIFIED: DATE OF,INCIDENT: 07/17/86 DATE INVESTIGATED: INVESTIGATED BY NAME/DIV/OTHER AGENCY: SANFORD/DEM/RRO DESCRIPTION OF EMERGENCY: OVERSPRAY FROM LAGOON COUNTY: ORANGE VAN TILBURG/SANFORD 07/17/86 ype,mty i,�uii.,�gzrz h�:3•�Z�k 6 r,� 1�-- G3 (_ Ti6 t a s3 -'(7 CAUSE ( IF KNOWN) : ERROR (tea -Li` 3 -4q 302 `5 CORRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN/PLANNED: CEASED DISCHARGE; DAM, PUMP, FLUSH ON 7/18 wsRo a61 1351 (jG6J« STATE CONTAC WALLY SANFORD LOCATION: RRO MtCKj 5( pgGcz PHONE: 2314 4B 0-001 NKDATA ALERT - RESPONSE DATE 07/18/86 ACTION > INQ FILE > ALERT-RSP86 PSWD > FORMAT > NRALERTR NEXT RCD > 00030 NRT68 ENTERED THIS DATA, RECORD IS NO 00029 FRD DATA EMERGENCY: FISH KILL LOCATION: HAW CREEK AT SR 1007/ORANGE COUNTY PREPED BY: WALLY SANFORD DATE OF INCIDENT: 07/17/86 EMR REC: 038 RESPONSE DATE: 07/17/86 NARRATIVE OF INCIDENT: TOMMY HICKS (563-1636 - REQUESTS ANONYMITY) REPORTED TO ROGER JONES, WILDLIFE OFFICER (228-1257/733-3633) THAT FISH WERE DEAD IN THE CREEK IN HIS YARD. MR. JONES CALLED MR. VAN TILBURG WHO DISPATCHED ME AT 2202 ON 7/17/86. MR. HICKS AND I LOCATED THE POLLUTION SOURCE ON THE FARM OF MR. S.A. WILSON (UPSTREAM). I DISCUSSED REGULATIONS AND CLEANUP TECHNIQUES WITH MR. WILSON AND HE PREFERRED TO DAM, PUMP, FLUSH, AND REMOVE THE FISH USING HIS LABOR AND OUR TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE RATHER THAN A CONTRACTOR. GREER AND DANIEL OF THIS OFFICE PROCEEDED TO THE SITE ON 7/18/86 AT 0930 TO ASSIST THE CLEANUP WHICH WAS ALREADY UNDERWAY. MR. JONES ESTIMATED 300-400 DEAD BREAM, CATFISH, AND OTHER SPECIES. ABOUT ONE-HALF MILE OF STREAM WAS ESSENTIALLY SEPTIC WITH NEAR COMPLETE KILL. COSTS SO FAR ARE FIVE HOURS, 117 MILES, AND ONE PAIR OF WORK PANTS. THE CLEANUP WILL BE DOCUMENTED BY GREER OR DANIEL, SO MORE INFORMATION AND EXPENSES WILL FOLLOW. 4B 0-001 IMMSG PRINT: YES NETWORK COMMUNICATIONS TIME 10:40 07/18/86 TO: FROM: JULIE FREDERICKS/RRO NRT68 SCREEN HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY TRANSMITTED ALERT -EMERGENCY FOR FISH KILL, ORANGE COUNTY, CAN BE VIEWED ON REC. NO. 038. RESPONSE FOR SAME IS ON REC. NO. 029. PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT. THANKS. � � ��,�dJw�i J �� �W 11 as �1) ° ar4l .�! V1� n y,1 (q b ��/ wd �h 9 Q9�av� -vot4 y `-1 ��vHvv�d (DVS b1Jtl�R uZ r x 0 0 N TA ALERT - RESPONSE DATE 87/18/86 ACTION > INQ FILE > ALERT-R%P86 P%WD > FORMAT > NRALERTR NEXT RCD > 88031 NRT65 ENTERED THIS DATA, RECORD IN NO 88830 FRD DATA EMERGENCY: FISH KILL LOCATION: ORANGE CO'/ALAMANCE CO. (HAW CREEK AT %R 1807) PREPED BY: WALLY %ANFORD DATE OF INCIDENT: 8707/86 EMR REC: 838 RESPONSE DATE: 87/17/86 NARRATIVE OF INCIDENT: THIS IS TO UPDATE THE TRANSMISSION OF THIS MORNING, ROGER JONE% CALLED ME BACK TO INDICATE THAT THE NEIGHBORS DOWNSTREAM OF MR. WIL%ON WERE %O IRATE THAT THEY INTEND TO CONTACT THE GOVERNOR AND MEDIA. IT TURNS OUT THAT THIS SPILL IS A REGULAR OCCURRENCE, BUT HAS BEEN HANDLED BY THE W%RO. I CONTACTED JE%%ICA HOWE AND %TEVE MAUNEY FOR FURTHER INFORMATION WHICH MIGHT INFLUENCE ANY POSSIBLE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CIVIL PENALTIES. AND M%. HOWE IS TO DELIVER APPROPRIATE DOCUMENTS TO DANIEL AND GREER AT THE SPILL SITE, I ALSO REQUESTED A FISH PICKUP FROM MR. JONE% AN POTENTIAL EVIDENCE' ADDITIONAL COSTS BY WRITER OF 2 HOURS. IMM%G PRINT: YES NETWORK COMMUNICATIONS TIME 11:24 87/18/86 TO: FROM: JULIE FREDERICK%/RRO NRC*NRT65 SCREEN HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY TRANSMITTED ALERT -RESPONSE UPDATE FOR REC. NO. 029 IN ON REC. NO. 830. PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE RECETPT. THAWS! nTT[ TUA3aaf /,am j_ •idea R3TMN 4au3 toamTl /Norcrc/nm 'iit=-T9L/6T4 30 "Tlia 200 ioo39o0 oo"Td 'soSio mp of oof�Ro =00 Am anSooge aat lT So t99fiooaD Am " a" PTao" •Aa9000009 oT 3T lT 9opo9 ogwpdasdb " TTTA Poo ogiI saTaomwol qi ioro 9me"do ARM MP Pus Somme op So7Twa Lvwp TTTa oQ OR no PToo o� "on" dV1ab '�>qi We 9T � iaoo Woa K PTA+ oRi 99TR»9a am nw oQ &TM PWT an to lio a9a aaa9w up 3m P"W" ETA .an .was& peopmu"11-TT" o oq of P64164d9 31 'emn mp 3v •oTToyY 'Wi N Pawns" osaa some" ToTiao,nd iO Hama as '9oTiosode laTTP9oR oioaa pa9 aoiod9 9oas9T 969oom 'SA to WF3oahaT o p ftpW O&WOSM •Paaa 00 UT 990130MA 4TToa► xwm SO In osSaeo VIP ATq"ud AMA oa oM •9"3olTiooa9T op "OS" W " T LT93oafsoSdd9 PoSSasso 9Tgy •Roaaa oR3 03 000aoo pompS AT3u&p3m 9 W138109 asa9w oQ7 H ooe'['M 000'OT-hosw�r'ssaaw;ssl-sgW-9rp91TSsT L92do "q to mnXv2Mo ap 1aT=p '3"p p9393o on •qTo ftTTdmo oq3 aril a00230da gaol 4UM ogi ~ op 'aooTTA WS '2K Q3TA oiodo SlTWAM 'Wt '"'RURta '"me" PoPaodoaa Pas Taioi @(am) P MMG 9osd0 VVIsTW�000aal39a M 9T (001t) oNIft POATOWN la TwT Ion op eald"p) (00 pUMMU MUM Toopo m "I osaTS& On ATOW"wo w TT" n =env o TMOI Sol M ioToT► ISTTsa► So»a op"" gap 9M 'q9T 'iT �PSoII ao 'MUM wTat.ago9 oRi RSTi a9tTwr T9oTa9RP 9 +r& L IMINOW LR Poaaol:od 9aTss9Tioo�9f 9, ISIMp poWWt . Mtftn aoai Wm to ddw 9 9f PMoTo4 A&MM 1li10IV '7fA;1 APi ' iaTR�O �7.1if m/ .sALmi osM Soon IKOIC o9TTaaoa Rise/ •oasgR �k osoTO • W! 9161491 T"Or 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 a l� 11� 19 14 15 17 18 19 20 A B C 44�L4n N. EPT. OF NATURAL RESOURCES & CLUNITY couNlr. S DE OPMENT RIVER BASIN: . - DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT O REPORT TO: A o, . o MR Rp . w.RO WiR wsgo. s WATER QUALITY FIELD -LAB FORM 1OM1l Other Shipped by: Bu�41 I er rj�/ISAMPLE TYPE COILECTORM �i OAMBIENT )1/ (EMERGENCY ❑SPLII ❑COMPLIANCE BOO RANGE 7, SEED f�� CHLORINATED: Nit 1 1i Station N.nter Dore Begm1 yy/mm/ Time Begin Dote En lime En 0epr DM OB 08M Va .e Type A H L Composite T 5 B SamPle Type C(!�>NXX BODS 31037 m /I Chloride9/ mg/1 NH I s N 610 0�3m /I XJNi - Nide11067 ate,/0 O u / COD Ni h 340 O O m / Arsenic Tol u /1 TXN asN 675 • m / P - Lead 1051 . / COD to. 335 mg/Img/I Chl is. T6 32217 u /1 NO -NO3as N 630 a /I $ - Anrim n 1097 u /I CoGlorm:MF Fecal I I /I ml —Chi .:C.,r 209 . /1 / P os P 70507 m /I - Seleni m u 1 Colifor .MF olol 4 /IOOml Ph o h tin a 32213 .01 P Total as P 665 m /I Z.- Zinc 109 u /I Colilorm.Ivbe Fem131615 /1 Oml Color: Ir.e 80 P1-Co P'Dissolved as P666 m /I C Iifor;n.Tvbe Twat 3150S /100m1t Chromium:Ho.1032 . /1 A -Silver 1077 . /I Pesti i s Specifically R•ald.e Total Q A m /l Cyanide 770 m /I AT - Al.minvm D05 u /.1 V larile 505 mg/ I Flu ide9 1 m /I - Beryllium 1012 /1 Scon Or anochlorine Fired 510 m /I Formaldeh ] 680 m /I —Be Co- Calcium 916 m /I Scan Or anophos horus Residue: nded 530 -0 m /I Grease and Oil, 556 m /1 Cd- Cadmium 1027 u / Volatile 535 m /I Hardne s:Total9 /I Co- Cobalt 1037 . / Organics Specifically Feted 40 > mg/1 MBAS 38260 m /I Chromium: wl 1034 u / -_ N! units Acidic r H4 5 436 m /I Phenols 2730, u /1 Cu-C. ei 1042 /1 Scan Base / Neutral Eatract.bles S.I1a1e945 m /I F, Iran 1045 . /1 Scan Acid Evlr.Uables Audit r H 8 3 4 mg/1 S.Ilide 745 m /I H-Mertur 0 /1 Alkolinit 10 3 415 m /I Specific Cord. 95 .Mhos/cm li - lithium 1132 u /I Special Analysis S ecificall A6alinit to PH4 SIIO m /I 2 Biomass: Dr W1. 577 g/M M -Ma nesi.m9 ] m /I _ TOC 680m /I 2 Biomass: Peri Ash Free 572 9/M Mn-Mang onstse 1055 ayll Scan Acid Herbicides tmbidB 76 NTUI 2 Chi o: Peri Fluro 82547 mg/M No- Sodi.m 929 m /I $can Pur eabks Sampling Point PT 63 7 W.rer T•mpe.alv,•1YI 10 D,0 300 PH 0 Con .cmno .125`C 94 AlLolinity PH 8.3 PH 4.5 82244 431 Audit y PH 4.5 PH 8.3 87243 82242 Sech ci(Mebrsl /8 6 Air mPem r.lel•CI 70 D.O S Sor.ro0on 301 .IinilyL 480 Algae: Flooring Mats Severity 1325 Precipim 45 Clod Cover, CloCover:; 32 Wind Direarion(Deg ) 36 Win Forte Beo.lon 37 I Mr SerHra • Monerlml/IINri 50086 Dead Fish Severity 1340 Turbidily Sewrity 1350 Od.r.Atmosp ere Seventy 1330 Stream Flow Severn r 1351 Detergent 5. s Sever Br 1305 Oil -Grease Sevaritr 1300 Flowing Flooring Debris 1345 Sl.dpe Sevony 1315 DMI/Revised IU/B[ DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT September 20, 1977 Mr. Lee W. Settle, PA Attorney at Law 105 South Fourth Street Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Subject: Requested Slides Mr. Millicovsky's Complaint Investigation Alamance County Dear Mr. Settle: Enclosed is a copy of the slides taken during our investigation of Mr. Millicovsky's complaint. The reproduction fee was $7.82. Please make the check payable to the Department of '_natural Resources and Community Development, and return to me. Should you have any questions concerning this matter, please contact me. Sincerely, Russell D. Radford Regional Engineer RDR/cs Water Quality Operations Branch Enclosure April 16. 1983 Mrs. Clara Perry' Route 6. Box 64A Mebana, North Carolina 27302 Dear Mrs. Perry- SDDJECTt COWLAIRT IHVESTICATIOH. HAW cunt ALAyANCE COMM. A Enclosed Is a copy of data from samplas,colloctsd during an Investigation performed by Jessica Hovellst, a Chemical Analyst with the Winston-Salem Regional Office, an March 191, 1963. This data reveals water 4uslity violations for fecal coliform as wall as extremely high values for Biochemical Oxygen Demand (ROD) (despite tha high leval of Dlesolved Oxygen (D.O.) in the water), Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), total and 'suspended residue, aluminum, mangansee, and mine. Mrs. Howells spoke with Mr._ Sam Wilson".'who ague the dairy farm upstream from the sampling site. He stated that, during the,operstion of hie spry Irrigation system for'manure. approximately 10,000 gallons of tha,manure solution accidently gained access to the creek. This occurred approximately 1 vVsk before the Investigation. This was very'probably the source of the water quality violations In the creak. However, during the inspection Of Mr. Wiisoa'm lagoon system and .waste handling operation, no runoff or potential problems were observed by Mrs. Howells. At the time, it appeared to be a well -maintained system. Mr. Wilson stated that the msnurw ran off of Lis land while he was not watching the spray system. Re said that he would be more cautious In the future.. We will closely monitor the stroaa and the dairy operation over the forthcoming sentbo and will take appropriate action If it Is necessary. Should you have any questions or If you obeerve any other changes in ths'stresmg place* contact our office at 919/761-2331: Sincerellyyt M�l/JMH/am M. stem uemoey act E i IDt Regional Engineer At""" County Health Dept. WSSO : Central lllss L*6"m-T LTTOG T'1SKc '` �?ysraWoca �onxrra ;j3$TrP Ty6br• cc:F• P iH bterouir FrbTucrez Id' IICSWcsS parTuea gTucetnyx�' rP6.sczon�r� hrese+A GOUCUCC, nnz obTTGO IFC 8Ta\5PT• i32T• gyorryq 1w, PaAq MN drrasCTous ox U xon oP Ptns sua,o[pet cpsnitga Trr '&oDrrJrccwMf• LonC!%ra auq ATTT Cor•6 ubbtobz fTCG VC9TOU TE Tr TO a-;GG8sesi,' MB nTTi GToP,anya rroaTcoz CFO 9Cz6819 suq r;)s gvTO, ubourrTco un6z r•j nonTq Pu au.zu csnCTora T-7 CPr; WM(lxq•. o& PTa Tsuq nPTTQ PQ Mus uOC ftuMOVIV rim 9"V). sere H3 saTq Cpgr 're to Ps a AGTT-w'3TurQTceq OXOC6m' I z- firreoa sCaC ., erg. rpe msnnzc zsu Ott baroarrTs'7 br-OPTctn Drvrc opactAGq A iMe• LOAcTT.:• VC CpC CT+t6° Is; vb'-«Drtaq cT, T:z' MTTnou,e raPooa ol4revi ur;q r_uors plcrugY:nd OLatur;on' uo znuO;. 01. ^erez ctnnTTO. AVOTRCTOua To rpt# ctcojc• goneeuz' c;nxyal cTry TusbccrTL . T nr sr pGjOze r}ra TunooCTKuriou' SPTO e•ua AO.tia �'ZIP*PTp gpG oontee cr Gee aoynrTon 7ccTg4u9T3 BuTuOl ccccaO Co C14' cze-r• ,jrTe occnzze,} vbbzox;croreTA TLtTBrCTon Ol e,; Tut wunn-W ebbzoxTincCQyh T7-ulo i,rryronrt ag rt;6 Dyvn!,zw ttow CPq asmbTTu£ eTCU• T>n arurnq rpsr' ''g4tTne, CPw' ObOLVCToa o6 PTO rbza), bits' l:oc..y Te z:w;ra :a{CP rjr • �s�j @1Troou', .:,ro or..ua C e gsTrl Coto nuaCznvr; irasp7luo'ec' Owl s.Tnr.• augOL)' cpc TcaT V],Aur:n T)G"IlUUq (COLD) tGr"7y Y.Dci 3RFS�r4.rgf;r{ &03Tgn6' ':7•jf .iS Dll1'l° ,rznaq (P7Dti (C ;a1);r;c .C:ro ;DT3P Tcn.;;T 01 :1Y 'areev a Ally 0*01 Tu P'G oz Tocccj COTTEor" to cn: fy ua CxCvn!0A 171Z.Y nf?yRuu tot 1310e1Ia41cuT 17xe; eo HeKTonsT (JUTco' o;.r R"cP TV TuJZ • MITs gore r:sassTa nvrot Jn•,T'TCX :,TnyuI:ToLM hcxTorrrGq pa 1639Tc1 HOIRCIT'r" v Cp_ iorc:rr VJ?TRar n;Cir Spr t•1TuQCOrr-ZuT;T` c.ncSoeey Ta x CobA A qur•a M) eawbTG:t cOjroct�aq r;R;.Yu6 it TuavaeTROCTou `li rWLi "UJf ui_D. `Ti9 cfninci,� eo;irxvx.,u zrm.,duevnim' j%OVZ j=jta sczzlr: rj Oso' 'oxrp �aa arTrru S1303 KontT t,' Lox C��'C JbtTT T�? To u pw 3 4 5 6 7 a 9 la 11 17 13 14 L 11 IE 19 2C A 9 / N4SEPT. OF NATURAL RESOURCES & COl UNITY COUNTY: t/9,A.t2DEVELOPMENT RIVER BASIN° ,. DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT 'O RE PORT TO: A O, P7mR6, RRO, Wo RO Wilt ,= -SRO. S WATER QUALITY FIELD -LAB FORM (OM1) L� Other Shipped 6y: Bu , ourie I er �/� SAMPLE TYPE COLLECTORISI- i-R / / aAMBIENT A/ (EMERGENCY _ ❑SPLIT ❑COMPLIANCE - BOD RANGE: SEED' CHLORINATED: A C A)Q Station Number Dote Begin yy/mm/ Time Begin Date End Time End Dept DM D8 OBM Va ue TYP. Composite Somple Type A H L T S B C(/E N%% SOD 10 m /I m Chloride940 /I NH as N 610 m /I Ni - N� Dickel 1067 i0 u / r COD High 340 1100 m /I Arsenic Total 1002 /I TKN os N 625 i m / Pb- Lead 1051!4/aou / COD:Low 335 m9/1 Chl o: T6 32217 u /1 NO 'NO as N 630 ♦ m /I 5b- Antimony 1097 u /1 Colilorm: MF Fecol 31616 'O /100-1 Chl a: Corr 32209 u /1 / PO4 as P 70507 m /I Se- Selenium u l Colilorm:MF Total 04 /IOOmI Pheo lstin a 32213 u /I P= Total as P 665 m /I Zn- Zinc 109 zo /I Colilo.m:Tube Fam131615 /IOOmI Colon true 80 Pt-Ccr Is Dissolved as P666 m /1 C Iilorm:Tube Total 31505 /IOOml Chromium:He..1032 u /1 A -Silver 1077 u /I Pesticides Specifically Residue Total a m /I Cyanide 720 .on /I At - Aluminum 1105 409 dwo 4 Volatile 505 m /I Flu ,ide951 mg/I, Be- Ber Ilium1012 /I Scan Or anochlorine /� Feed 10 00 m /I Formaldehyde 71880 m /I Ca- Calcium 916 m /1 Soon Or arw hos horus i . Residue:S ended 530 m /I Grease and Oils 556 m /1 Cd- Cadmium 1027 2Q 0 u / Volatile 535 m /I 1-fordness:Tota190 m /I Co- Cobalt 1037 - u /I Organics Specifically / Fixed 540 3V1 m /I M8AS 38260 m /I Chromium: otpl 1034 `• u /1 H 403 units Phenols 32730 -u /1 C.-C.er 1042 in /I I Scan Base / Neutrol Extractables At to PH 4.5 436 m /I Sulf Ple 945 mg/1 Fe- Iron 1045 u /1 Scan Acid Extraclables Acidity to PH 8 7 435 n+ /I Sulfide 745 m /I I H -Mercer 900 u /1 Alkalinity to PH 8.3 415 mg/1 Specific Cord. 95 uMhos/cm - Li - Lithium 1132 u /I Special Analysis Specifically 2 Alkalinity to PH• 5610 mg/1 Biomass: Dr Wt. $77 9/M M - nasium 92]Q. m /I a 2 ^ IOC e m /1 Biomass: Pere Ash Free 572 9/M Mn-Manganese 1055 as.! /I Scan Acid Herbicides 2 Turbidity 76 NTU Chi a: Peri Flmo 82547 mg/M Na-Sodium 929 m /I Scan Pur ea6les Sampling Point Water Temperature('C) DO, pH Conductance Alkalinity Acidity a125'C pH 8.3 PH 4.5 pH 4.5 PH 8.3 Pi 9 5- ��jjIf 63 2 10 /• 300 . 0 94 82244 431 82243 82242 Seachi(Meters) Air Temperature(•C) U_Saturation Salinity%. Algae: Floating Mats Preciptlotion(In/Day) Cloud Cover.% Wind Direction(Deg.) Win Force Severity Beaufort 78 20. 301 480" 1325 45 32 36 37 I H.. Sau lea a Dead fishTurbidity Severity Odor:Atmosp are Stream Flow Clete grin, sra Su Oe -Grease Floating Debris Sludge Severity Matto (ml/IIHr) Severity Severity Severity Severity Severity Severity 1+0086 1340 1350 1330 1351 1305 1300 )345 1315 OMI/Revised 10/82 r I I j 1 1 •i L' I� �I�I �� � li II► i - -- _.� -c, \` _ --- ` � -- - - . _ -- - - 1' � � '�. • • � _. DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT' . September'20, 1977 Mr. Lee W. Settle, PA. Attorney at Law 105 South Fourth Street Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Subject: ,Requested Slides Mr. Millicovsky's Complaint Investigation Alamance County Dear Mr. Settle:'. , Enclosed is a copy of the slides taken during our:investigation of,'' Mr. Millicovsky's complaint. The reproduction fee was $7.82. Please make thecheck payable to the Department of Natural Resources and Community Development, and return to me. Shouldfyou have any questions concerning this matter, please contact me. Sincerely, Russell D.' Radford Regional -Engineer Water Quality Operations Branch RDR/cs Enclosure o.. .-1 o , 014;41 r' .. �. 1'O(l. -A - -gal:, .-1-• '� .' a a � I Mr. Set Wilson uste. 6, . ins- 6l lhbam . North Carolina2'M2 ,. . Doer Mr. Wilson: Subject: lion -concentrated Designation The Wilson Farm Also mae County This correspondence is in reform=* to a complaint concerning the Wilson Farm in Alamance County which was received at the Borth Piedmont Piald Office on April 12, 1977. The complaint concerned animl waste in a street. Your facility was inspected by a member of my staff on April 12, 1977. Your dairy operation has been designated as a non -concentrated aaimsl feeding operation by the Director. Division of Environmental Management. An such, a permit is not required. The daalgnation of non -co neontrated animal feeding operation pertains to the strum which boarders your property to the vast. The stream is an un- named tributary to Haw Creek and parallels the Orange-Alaaance County line. Our investigation show that holding lagoons have been installed to catch any pollutant runoff from the ear's lounging area. The facilities seam to have boon aimed to insure a non-disabarging system should the lagoons be operated and maintained properly. In order to achieve and maintain a eon -discharging system, it is re- commended that the water level in year lagoon be lowered through controlled irrigation each year before the ommet of inclement weather. Such action will allow you to maintain at least two (2) fat of frooburd in the lagoon. Mr. Sao Wilson • • September 9. 1977 Pap 2 Should Tau have my 4uotioss pr if this office ass be of aq assiatmas in the future, plamsi contact Mr. Russell D. Radford. BsSional NnSinser of the forth Piedmont Field Offices S002 Silas Crook Parkway Nsteoolas. Winston -Sales. North Carolina 271069 or by telephone at (919) 761-2311. Sincerely, L. P. Benton. Chie! Water Quality Section eel Mr. Howard Dalton ilesroae County Health Dept. ✓1U rF D Mr. Robert A. Carter Mr. M. W. Puette Mr. Durwood Laughinghouse Mr. Paul Trains NC Agricultural Extension Services bc: Honorable James A. Graham NORTB CAROLINA DEPARTMRNT OF NATURAL RRSOURCRS i CCMM MTY MB,LOPUM Division of Environmental Management September 79 1977 MEMORANDUM TO: Mr. L. P. Benton, Jr., Chief Water Quality Section FROM: W. E. [night, Director Division of Environmental Management SUBJECT: Non-concentratod Designation The Wilson Farm Alamanco County The Wilson Farm has been investigated by way of a complaint. The attached documents have been prepared according to current policy. The facility is designated a non -concentrated animal feeding operation as: 1) A maximum of two hundred seventy-five (275) animal units are involved. 2) A pollutant discharge does not occur to the State's surface water through a man-made ditch, flushing system, or similar man-made device. 3) A pollutant discharge does not occur to the State's ---Sur-facn"rateis which originate outside of* and pass over, across, through, or otherwise come into direct contact with animals confined in the operation as a result of any other than a 25-year, 24-hour rainfall event. Attacheea cc: . Robert A. Carter Mr. M. W. Puette Mr. Durwood Laughinghouse Mr. Paul Traiaa, EPA NC Agricultural Ext. Services bc: Honorable James A. Graham 3 E 0 � -A& NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Water Quality Operations Branch North Piedmont Field Office September 1, 1977 MEXORANDUM TO: File THRU: Russell D. Radford RD 4AP FROM: Richard W. Caspar Al - SUBJECT: Wilson Farm Alamance County An inspection of the Wilson Farm lagoon was performed by the writer on`July 25, 1977. Two lagoons have been installed. The first lagoon had the approximate dimensions of 75' x 50' with a depth of 6 feet. The first lagoon was installed as a solids separator. The second lagoon had a surface area of approximately one acre with an average depth of 10- to 12- feet. There were no flow -through pipes installed in the dam structure (non -discharging purposes). However, a spillway has been installed for emergency precautions should the water reach such heights. Contour landscaping has been performed to eliminate non - contaminated rain runoff from the lagoon's drainage area. mm Attachment cc: Mr. Robert A. Carter Mr. M. W. Puette Mr. Durwood Laughinghouse Mr. Paul Trains. NC Agricultural Extension Services bc: Honorable James A. Graham NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL AND ECONOMIC RESOURCES OFFICE OF WATER AND AIR RESOURCES Water Quality Division P. O. Box 27687 Raleigh. North Carolina 27611 REPORT OF __Complaint Investigation of Animal Waste in a Stream r ------------------------------------------------------- Place visited Mr. Sam Wilson's Farm, Alamance/Orange Counties April 12 & 27 77 ---------------------------------------------------------- Date -------------- 18---- May 19, 1977 Address Rt._ 6� Box_43�_Mebane� N_ C___27302 _ River Basin Cap! -Fear --june 9L13-6 17. 1977 By Whom Richard WCaspar� Engineer_ _____ - - _------ -Time Spent _52 hours Persons Contacted _Messrs._ James Millicovsky t Individual lodging the complaint; Sam Wilson, -------------------------------------------------- Co-owner of the Wilson Farm; Howard Delton, Alamance County Extension Agent Reason for Visit __Investigate a complaint of animal waste entering flowing waters. --------------------------------------------------------------------- Copies to: Mr. Robert A. Carter Mr. James Millicovsky Mr. Sam Wilson North Piedmont Field Office Central Files REPORT Mr. M. W. Puette Mr. Durwood Laughinghouse Mr. Paul Traina NC Agricultural Extension Services In response to a complaint from a downstream property owner, an investigation was conducted to determine the source of animal waste floating in a stream in Alamance County. Subsequent investigations were necessary to prove a water quality violation in that the Wilson Farm could not be classified as a concentrated animal feed lot operation. The following information pertains to the investigations: Part I. INSPECTION OF ANIMAL FEED LOT OPERATION 1. Directions to Site: Direction to site where solids are in the stream - I-85 to Mebane Oaks Exit. South on SR 1007 approximately 1.5 miles to stream. The site is 600 feet upstream of the SR 1007 bridge over the stream. Direction to Wilson Brothers Farm - I-85 to Mebane Oaks Exit. South on SR 1007 to SR 2128, east (left) on SR 2128 for 1200 feet. The farm is located on the left. vQ V19 Revised 4/26/72 2. Receiving Waters: At the floating solids site - Mr. Millicovsky's Reservoir Name: Raw Creek Classification: Class "A -II" Drainage Area: Greater than five square miles (field estimate) Average Discharge: 2.8 CFS (field estimate) 7Q10: unknown Wilson Brothers Farm - At SR 2128 Bridge Name: Tributary to Haw Creek Classification: Class "A -II" Drainage Area: Approximately 2.4 square miles Average Discharge: 2.2 CFS 7Q10: 0.0 CFS 3. Discharge Coordinates: Wilson Brothers Farm - Longitude: 79 15' 56" Latitude: 36 03' 46" Elevation: 578 feet 4. Topography: Reference is made to the: Alamance County - Soil Survey Series 1956, No. 9 United States Dept. of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service - In cooperation with the North Carolina Agricultural Experiment Station The majority of the land is classified D.6B - Davidson clay loam, greatly sloping phase (2 - to 6 - percent slope) — This soil occurs on smooth upland flats, normally between stream breaks. The surface soil is dark reddish -brown, friable clay loam that has a moderate, fine, granular structure. The subsoil is dark -red, firm clay with a medium to fine, subangular blocky structure. Throughout the profile are black or brown concretions about 0.1 inch in diameter. In some areas the lower subsoil is somewhat firmer than in other areas and resembles the lower subsoil of the Mecklenburg soils. The horizons are barely discernible because of their uniform texture and color. The depth of the soil over bed- rock ranges from 4 to 20 feet. Included with this soil are small, nearly level areas, which total about 190 acres, and small, eroded gently sloping areas. These inclusions are small and are similar to this soil. They are not shown separately on the soil map. F This soil is moderately permeable and high in available water -holding capacity. It contains a medium to high amount of organic matter and has a medium to high capacity for storing plant food. Use and management. -- Most of this soil is used for small grain, pasture, hay, corn, soybeans, and vegetables. It is well suited to these crops, but early vegetables grow slowly because this soil warms late in spring. It is the best soil in the county for clover or alfalfa. Because it is not susceptible to serve erosion, this soil does not need exacting management. Crops should be grown in rotations that have some close -growing crops. The soil needs to be cultivated on the contour and limed and fertilized according to the results of soil tests. 5. Farm Site: A. The majority of the Wilson Farm utilized as a "feeding area" is located 500 feet from the nearest flowing water. There is no vegetation in the feed lot area whenever the animals are confined. B. The area between the feeding area and the stream is heavy woods and ground cover. The exception to the ground cover lies in the extreme bottomland. Heavy rains have flushed animal waste to the bottomland covering several hundred square feet. Slight vegetation exists in this low -land area. C. The milking parlor, lounging area, and feeding area are located atop a gently sloping hill. Ample area exists for the installation of holding -and hauling -facilities for the animal waste. D. Mr. Wilson is presently milking 186 cows daily. During the site evaluation, several cows and calves were noticed on the concreted slat adjacent to the milking operation. --The total number of - mature dairy cattle would not exceed 200 at the Wilson Brothers Farm. E. According to Mr. Sam Wilson, he has been engaged in gathering in- formation on various types of solutions to the discharge. The Orange County Soil Conservation Service has been requested by Mr. Wilson, to aid in the design of a holding lagoon. Mr. Wilson stated the holding lagoon could be installed within a 60-to-90 day period if conditions are favorable. F. The Wilson'Brothers Farm has 45 acres located in Alamance County. Adjacent to this is 200 acres in Orange County. The milking operation and Mr. Sam Wilson's residence is located in Alamance County while the majority of the pasture and farmland is located in Orange County. Mr. Wilson has stated that, his agricultural assistance, for the most part, is out of Orange County. G. During the first week in June, 1977, Mr. Wilson had a contractor perform considerable land clearing. The work was done in the area between the milking parlor complex and the receiving stream. 6. Climatology: The nearest location of collected data was the Burlington Filter Plant, not more than 10 miles away. The following data are the yearly averages from 1951 through 1960: Total Precipitation January 3.58" July " 4.42" February 4.21" August 5.01" March 4.15" September 3.61" April 4.14" October 3.35" May 3.30" November 2.85" June 3.04" December 3.31" Annual precipitation amounted to 44.97". Based upon data collected from 1946 through 1955, the Mean Annual Lake Evaporation in the Alamance County Area ranges from 40 - to 42 inches. Rainfall intensity for the Wilson Brothers Farm area, Alamance County follows. The data is from the Guide for Sediment Control Construction Sites in North Carolina U. S. Department of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service Raleigh, North Carolina March, 1973 Pages B-12 through B-17.__ Recurrence Interval Rainfall 2 year - 1 day @ 3.5 inches 5 year - 1 day @ 4.5 inches 10 year - 1 day @ 5.3 inches 25 year - 1 day @ 6.1 inches 50 year - 1 day @ 6.8 inches 100 year - 1 day @ 7.7 inches Part II DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED TREATMENT FACILITIES Although definite plans and specifications are non-existent, Mr. Wilson stated on April 27, 1977, his interest in installing a solids storage area, a pre -settling basin, and a large liquid holding pond. The solids holding area would be of adequate size for a minimum of 7 days storage. The pre -settling basin would be constructed of concrete to allow farm machinery to enter and remove the solids. A plug would be installed to the lower base to allow for drainage, should the need arrive. The liquid holding facility would have a capacity around 300,000 gallons. In checking with the "Dam Safety Act of 1967", the proposed liquid holding lagoon might be of such magnitude that a Permit from the Division of Earth Resources, would be required. A letter to this extent along with a copy of the " Dam Safety Act of 1967", and Title 15 NCAC Chapter 2, Subchapter 2H, Section .0700 - Dam Safety Approvals-, were forwarded to Mr. Wilson on May 4, 1977. In a phone conversation with Mr. Wilson on May 5, 1977, the writer learned the Orange County Soil Conservation Service would be designing the holding lagoon for Mr. Wilson. Mr. Wilson also stated he did not think the proposed lagoon would fall in the specifications requiring a Permit. However, proper procedures would be followed. The following few pages are the results gathered from the stream study preformed on May 19, June 9, 13, and 17, 1977. As a preliminary indicator and while in the area on routine sampling inspection, Mr. Wilbur Christmas collected water samples at the Wilson Farm on May 19, 1977. The results were as follows: Location _ _D._.0. Fecal-Coliform Upstream 7.2 510 Downstream 5.2 1100 SR2128 In that the Wilson Farm could not be designated a "concentrated animal feeding operation" with respect to the stream in question, a study to determine whether or not a water quality violation existed'due to the discharge was necessary. The preliminary grab samples of May 19, 1977 indicated the possibility of a water quality violation. The results of the additional studies follow. m �j Part III Evaluation: There are two streams which flow into the reservoir which Mr. Millicovsky has constructed. The first parallels the Alamance- Orange County line in Alamance County. The second stream originates in Orange County and flows approximately 2000 feet in Alamance County before entering the reservoir. The stream which parallels the county line in Alamance County is the stream in which the Wilson Dairy Farm has been discharging. The discharge has occurred mainly during high intensity - or long duration - rains. The milking parlor and the concreted lounging area drains to the north and then eastward across a 500 feet land mass, and then into the stream. During heavy rains, animal waste particles are flushed into the stream. The rapidly flowing waters wash the solids downstream to the headwaters of Mr. Millicovsky's Reservoir. Due to the lower velocity of the flowing waters in the reservoir, the solids have a chance to settle out As the intensity of the water flow through the reservoirs decreases, reduced oxygen transfer along with accumulation of solids increases the degradation of the water quality. The reduced water quality is in the form of lower dissolved oxygen concentrations and higher floating solids. Fecal coliform counts are also high at times. The drainage basin for the stream under study was surveyed on June 9, 1977. There are no farming operations discharging to the stream. Above the Wilson Dairy Farm are several housing developments, a golf course, and wooded land. Downstream of the "old" discharge point from the Wilson Dairy Farm and below SR 2128 bridge is a tract of land which was used to pasture two black angus.--The stream -distance from the "old" discharge point to SR 2128 bridge is approximately 800 feet with no point source of discharge. From the SR 2128 bridge to the headwaters of the reservoir is approximately 1000 feet with no point source of discharge. It can stated beyond any questionable doubt that the animal waste entering the stream that parallels the Alamance-Orange County line in Alamance County came from the dairy operation complex on the Wilson Farm. On or around the first of June, 1977, Mr. Wilson had a considerable amount of land cleared. The cleared land existed between the milking parlor complex and the receiving stream. In doing so, one of the results was the water course from the milking parlor to the stream was eliminated. However, a defined route will be re-established once heavy rainfall reoccurs in the area. According to the USGS Map (C 21 SE), the name of the stream network is known as Haw Creek. Cross referencing several streams in that area with the States -Stream Classification Index (Title 15 NCAC, Chapter 2, Subchapter 2B, Section .0311, April 1, 1977), the Haw Creek has a classification of Class A -II. Title 15 NCAC, Chapter 2, Subchapter 2B, Section .0211 (c) (3) out- lines the water quality characteristics pertinent to Class A -II waters. Sub -section (A) and (G) of the stated guideline is hereby quoted: " (A) floating solids; settleable solids; sludge deposits: only such amounts attributable to sewage, industrial wastes or other wastes as will not, after reasonable opportunity for dilution and mixture of same with the receiving waters, make the waters unsafe or unsuitable as a source of water supply for drinking, culinary, or food -processing purposes, injurious to fish and wildlife, or impair the waters for any other best usage established for this class. (G) dissolved oxygen: not less than 6.0 mg/l for trout waters; for non -trout waters, not less than a daily average of 5.0 mg/l with a minimum instantaneous value of not less than 4.0 mg/l; swamp waters may have lower values if caused by natural conditions. As it has been shown in this report and through the slides taken, severe water quality conditions exist at times in the reservoir. However, the water quality violations do not start at the upper headwaters of the reservoir. The dissolved oxygen concentrations start to drop immediately below the 'old" discharge point. The full impact of the discharge is felt in the reservoir. It -seems to the writer -that the only way to protect the water quality in the stream under consideration is to eliminate any discharge coming from the Wilson Dairy Operation Complex. From the site visit, the discharge can be eliminated in one of two ways. First: Provide a complete shelter for the lounging area with all the rainfall diverted away from the contact of any animal waste. Secondly: Install a holding lagoon which would provide adequate storage for the rainfall runoff. Each system would require special attention and considerations. The final decision as to what system to utilize, or another consideration not mentioned, would rest upon the responsible parties for the Wilson Dairy Farm. In a phone conversation with Mrs. Wilson on July 15, 1977, the writer learned that a farm pond has been installed between the milking parlor complex and the stream which has been under study. According to Mrs. Wilson, the contractor completed the project and pulled off the job site the first part of the week. (The week of July 10, 1977) An inspection of the site and retaining pond has been set for July 25, at 3 p.m. L • • W MJON r71Km XuN61.1177 AWIMAI Gou1NTy 1 IV* Boiro� F6c s� ' bRow'nt 1 1 of No '3017v a po e. c4owTll E 1 oto uiJ[M�lE %v14foN ` fiuNT ianvo a 7•0 `j4 RM `I Fiee�Le &TToM Doe 5 4 1 poi_ B i � F'tx,o-L_ l3oTiwa cu .y00L 4'� t 1 Coo pEPnt aF t11'foM Saaos o- IA�� �1 �pcAr�Rf OoQ•��� 1 Nam'✓ 'Ni- Nc Sac,01 avER PLOW fbmT Doe-3� Y0111•: Ne o"ft AWAF41 tw 7ue umtbM /Mt w i •&o PIX00" t[+surogle FffPA4 I►na MILLKuvrWVj impe we. � Miul�,dvrKjl's E.Z ,` 1\I`�� /���y: � _..v n� j/ jo^�•; `� �fl � ��`/�\ � 1 '�1 �l -,.�� i y�l I6w 1 �✓ �r� yi I� r� v �v% J j r / r 95 tS oliL 'wo ii�N�7 \��•\ �N " j J �) ;� Jh�\, I' \ i f " \1 v l f J�^\ \ �\ F �� Iv �I �53. I i � ��'l °� ' .• �I �1 it i ," �A ('. _ E I n9h tEo o°1Ll rJU ^yr1Y7-Jl� n 9, j � fI� bL'oiOnll9/�%�-j i\ � � 1 \�•) \1 `1 'I � �.����;\\ � �/r " �� ` %� 1 /JA� �r �1.A, 11 IV V '. ol—J /N�'bd A--l %i""i 46T8,60 Lh10, 1 1 'V '�� r;p r �� v J}• .fy-41WI, 1 1 3 � \ ;• ' '1 it I I oss � n lfisc ° N q _ • � Ofg M OIOQLe •' yJ/ II iN jadeyVWV V log N , V a 0 [ +i ° �` 396 q 1r 9 [ ♦ 7 � 5 ,4 ooze ipng I. d I ,. IS 1 (¢{'((/1,' S a° �`� •, ' [ MON [ .Y[1 ............'. . 1 O YI 4, 1 L •• /41Nnoo 3'JNvwtr1d ►Na►dd j3axLgV No$11r►'1 • d9"tJ if9NM'1 R ' � 3'NH9�►UI W VOJLL S IX14wv DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT September 8, 1977 Mr. Lee W. Settle, F.A. Attorney at Law. 105 South Fourth Street Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Subject:, Request for Photographs • Mr. Millicovsky's Complaint ' Investigation 'Alamance County Dear Mr. Settle: This letter is in reference to'your request concerning the duplication ofphotographs of Mr. Millicovsky's•complaint•in- vestigation conducted by our office.; Our office has placed an order for a duplicate copy of such photographs on August 31, 1977. According to the photo shop, reproduction will take 12 days. The photos and the invoice should be forwarded -to you from this office on or around September 15, 197% -Should you have any questions concerning this reporduction, please contact me. -Our address and phone number are.in the letterhead: Sincerely yours., 40 Pell. Radford Regional Engineer RDR/mm Ile r 'tit • _u Lli �.. �. rat —... ..v .... •J1. vI:11. DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Mr. Lee W. Settle, P.A. Attorney at Law 105 South Fourth Street Mebane, North Carolina 27302 September 8, 1977 Subject: Request for Photographs Mr. Millicovsky's Complaint Investigation Alsmance County Dear Mr. Settle: This letter is in reference to your request concerning the duplication of photographs of Mr. Millicovsky's complaint in- vestigation conducted by our office. Our office has placed an order for a duplicate copy of such photographs on August 31, 1977. According to the photo shop, repeoduction will take 12 days. The photos and the invoice should be forwarded to you from this office on or around September 15, 1977. Should you have any questions concerning this reporduction, please contact me. Our address and phone number are in the letterhead. _ Sincerely yours, LRadford Regional Engineer RDR/mm -1 - " , I I'll"'Ir TFl- 71" DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Water Quality Operations Branch July-20. 1977 Mr. James Millieovsky Route 6, Box 57—B .• Mebane,_ North Carolina 27302.,' Subjects Complaint Investigation Report Alamance County -Dear Mr. Millicovskq:.' Our investigation into the Wilson Dairy Farm discharge has been completed.- A copy of the investigation report has been enclosed for your information. A site visit has been set for July 25,. 1977 at 3:00 p.m. to observe the holding facilities installed at the Wilson Farm.- Thank you for'•bringing this water quality problem to'our attention. Should our services be,ne'eded in the . future, please.coniact us. Sincerely, Russell D. Radford Regional Engineer . RDR/dk Enclosure r rrn•� �a � T,' uxgvr vtnlcar'`= "*Jv;T.._ .d:_;' "� .h ,:%,i.-• ot= o,.. •a' ::'. i.A,. i�Ti�•rT, -C.. ynr:C d. a, •i �'..'r. .. p. $.a. ;r, ', f b'.0 .:G.r .. f _ ' .. (r li�:1((f •Ira.: rl..r :'iJ L SJ:i U? DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Water Quality Operations Branch July 20, 1977 Mr. Sam Wilson Route 6, Box 43 Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Subject: Complaint Investigation Report Alamance County Dear Mr. Wilson: Our investigation into a complaint concerning a eater quality violation in a stream entering the property of Mr. Millicovsky has been completed. A Copy of the investigation report has been enclosed for your information. In that you could not be reached at the time, your wife has extended per- mission for Mr. Caspar and myself to visit your dairy location and look at the holding facilities which you have recently installed on July 25, 1977, at 3:00 p.m. Should this date and time prove inconvenient for you, please contact me. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Sincerely, O� Russell D. Redford.' Regional Engineer RDR/dk Enclosure DIVISION OF BNVIROWNTAL MANAaMim Water Quality Operations Branch July 20, 1977 Mr. James Millicovsky Route 6, Box 57-B Mebane, North Carolina 27302 SubJact: Complaint Investigation Report Alsmance County Dear Mr. Millicovskyt Our investigation into the Wilson Dairy Farm discharge has been completed. A copy of the investigation report has been enclosed for your information. A site visit has been set for July 25, 1971 at 3:00 p.m. to observe the holding facilities installed at the Wilson Farm. Thank you for bringing this water quality problem to our attention. Should our services be needed in the future, please contact us. RDR/dk Enclosure c Sincerely, �)o 7" - -- -Russell D.-Radford - Regional Engineer DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT Water Quality Operations Branch July 20, i977. Mr•. Sam Wilson Route 6, Box 43 Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Subject: Complaint Investigation Report Alamance'County` Dear Mr.. Wilson: Our investigation into a complaint concerning a water quality violation in-s stream entering the property of Mr. Millicovsky has been completed'. A Copy of the investigation report has been enclosed for your.information. - J In that you could not -be reached at the time, your wife has extended'per- mission.for Mr.'Caspar and myself to visit your dairy location and look at the holding facilities which you have recently installed,on July 25, 1977, " at 3:00 p.m. Should this date and time prove inconvenient for•you,•pleass,, contact me. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Sincerely, Russell D. Radford , Regional Engineer- RDR/dk Enclosure +G'r. i1 a ! UL NORTH CAANA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL AND AOMIC RESOURCES Division of Environmental Mangement Water Quality Section M E M O R A N D U M TO: File THRU: Russell D. Radford Regional Engineer FROM: Richard W. Caspar Engineer P "' SUBJECT: Wilson Farm, Alamance County North Piedmont Field Office June 20, 1977 Another inspection was conducted on that portion of tributary paralleling the Alamance-Orange County line in Alamance County where the Wilson Farm dis- charges. This insotction was done on June 17, 1977 under the instruction of Russell Radford. I had a considerable amount of trouble with the D.O. meter. Therefore, all D.O.'s were performed using the Winkler Method. Readings were as follows: 100 ft. upstream of "old" discharge point @ 8*6 P.P.M. 100 ft. downstream of "old" discharge point @ 7*2 P.P.M. SR # 2128 Bridge @ 5.4 P.P.M. Headwaters of Millicovsky's Reservoir @ 02 P.P.M. The segment of stream of Millicovsky's Reservoir was completely covered with solids for a length greater than 100 feet. However, there has been no discharge from the Wilson Farm in over 3 weeks. From all appearances, the solids on the bottom are starting to break down rapidly. Solids are being brought to the surface through gas production. There has been no significant rainfall in the area for over 3 weeks. lim Ix Offim iRgp k to 'June 159'1977 WAM&,QU, M IM&;; t Mr, James Niilicovsky Route;, k wAk "anei,.I".Cerol na. 27302, y it -1 SUBJECT: Ombudsman-: Case -N;o T -,j Complaint of Pdllufi6n� teiultlfio' from farm ; il(: !01' 1 Willion Brothers M Alamance-Orange County ,Dear ,Mr. MOAGOVAY9 .. ... .. ,Your recent 'call to the Go*ernors Ombudsman has'been referredtb!;66"through the Depaftont of, Natural, and.Economi.q. Resources' Ombudsman Offiqe forj*spo,n,se. Prior to ?respanding!.to,;Y0,Uf,.,;.,obt4i'ne'd from,thei ntFfeld Office 6 11. P -No North I 1 comp.1 . ete' report " of -activities., A,;opy of tfie.,4ctiiiitii$')-4�p 6rt Is"incorporated '.he th for your In- el The activities reportr&eilstliat, a substantial amount of hasbeen-spent 1n,determining specifically there"xtein't df;�pol,juiion being caused:by the Wilson Dairy Farm, operation and in determining a.,metho4'for resolving the :problem: Mr. Russell"Rad- ford's letter to you dated June 39-1977, provided you with a'haii6 outline of the General Statutes-under.which this agency,may proceed in.this matter. i From a legal standpoint, the Wilson Brothers Farm cannot be constituted as a "concentrated animal feeding lot" under either North Carolina or Federal regulations since there are less than 300 animal units located on the farm and therp,js,,,no,,direct discharge through a manmade conveyance to the surface waters' On the other Hand; as pd ift6d out-i h- Mr. Radford's notes to file concerning Wilson Farms Alamance County, enclosed herewith, it has been definitely established that water quality standards are being violated as a result of present and past discharges from the Wilson Brothers Fam.,operation. There is, therefore* a basis for requiring corrective action at this location. As you pointed out in your letter to Mr. Radford dated May 20 1977, Mr. Sam Wilson was advised on the initial visit that adequate pollution control measures would have to be taken to insure that water quality standards not be violated. On that occasion and according to .".Mr. Radford on occasions since that time, Mr. Wilson has exhibited a very cooperative attitude and.-haklIndicated that he is proceeding to take such actions as are necessary to prevent fur - ther discharges to the surface waters. Mr. Wilson does states however# that a sufficient period of time to allow construction is needed. !Mr. Millicovsky / 'Page Two June 15, 1977 In Mr. Radford's letter to you, dated June 3, 1977. he advised that additional stream monitoring work would be conducted and a formal report concerning this matter would be prepared. It is doubtful that this report will be available before the middle or latter part of July since the field works laboratory work, and report preparation will require at least forty-five (45) days. In the meantime, staff mem- bers of the North .Piedmont Field Office will continue to work closely with Mr. Wilson to assure that reasonable progress is made toward eliminating'the problem. In reviewing Mr. Radford's notes to file concerning'Wilson Farm''you will see that substantial sludge deposits apparently, as a result of animal waste discharges. have settled in the bottom of the creek and in the upper portion of your reservoir. Even with no additional wastewater being discharged to the reservoirs a reasonable amount of time will be required for these materials to stabilize and for your.reser- voir to return to norr•;al. While I cannot give you an exact date by which the problem will be completely resolved. I.have been advised that I1r. Nilson has moved the livestock to another area of his farming operation and that this may result in some immediate improvement. Please be'assured that vie have not taken your complaint concerning this matter lightly. As previously stated, a considerable amount of time has been spent in measuring the extent of the problem and in trying to effect a sollution to the.pro- blem. We will continue to pursue this clatter until a satisfactory result is accom- plished. My personal apologies to you for failure of our staff members to keep you adequately informed with respect to the status oi' the investigation. By copy of this letter, I am directing that Mr. Radford provide you with frequent informal reports of the status and to provide you with basic data as it becomes availahle. If you need further explanation concerning this natter, do not hesitate to con- tact me. Yours very truly, L. P. Benton, Chief ;cater quality Section Attachments cc: Paul Sabo Russell Radford V� IvyA­d- . NORTH CARO LINA DRFAnMT OF NATQRAL AND R MMIXC USO01CRS Division of Muvireamental Management Yates Quality sestina NEMOZAAD$M TOR Mr. L. P. Benton. Jr., Read Water Quality Section PEONS Russell D. Radford Regional Engineer North Piedmont Field Office Jose 1*. 1977 8MMCT1 Status Report on the Millicovsky Complaint Alamsnce County The North Piedmont Field Office (la'PO) became aware of Mr. Milliaovsky's problem between 8 and 10 a.m. the morning of April 12. 1977. Mr. MillicovsiW called Mr. Russell Radford, Regional Engineer. NPPO, and stated large amounts of animal waste solids were entering his newly constructed reservoir by way of the Wilson Dairy Farm. While on his way to Raleigh for an afternoon conference, Mr. Dick Caspar of the NPFO, stopped by Mr. Millicovsky's residence to make a preliminary site Investigation. Mr. J. Wilson was also contacted and the dairy operation rapidly reviewed. Two phone calls were placed to the Millicovoky residence to inform him of the programs being made by the NPFO. The first on April 20, 1977 and the second around April 25, 1977. Both times Mr. Millicovsky was not at home. A message was left on the latter date. On April 27, 1977, the Wilson farm was revisited by Mr. Caspar and the Alamence County Agricultural Extension Agent, Mr. Howard Dolton. During this visit, the operation was observed in greater detail. Mr. Sam Wilson, co-owner of the farm, stated his plans and intensions on eliminating the descharge. A latter was received at the NPPO on May 3. 1977 from Mr. Millicovsky re- questing the status on his problem with regards to our office. A reply was for- warded on May 9. 1977. In short the reply letter to Mr. Millicovsky stated that our investigation was completed and that he (Mr. Millicovsky) should be receiving a copy of our findings within tan (10) days. However, it was discovered that the Federal Register's discription of a "concentrated animal feeding operation" was misiaterpmsted by the investigating engineer. This fact was brought to light by the regiooal engineer after the report was prepared for shipment to Raleigh. Memo to Mr. L. P. on, Jr. June 14, 1977 Be Page 2 • Sample.results on fecal coliform taken on May 19, 1977, were learned by the staff of the NPFO on May 26. 1977, the sas day Mr. Millicovsky called Mr. Radford. The results showed a definate water quality violation. Therefore, an intensive survey of the stream was scheduled for the week of June 7, 1977. Due to an emergency episode, the survey was not initiated until June 9, 1977. The stream survey included the followings Fecal Coliform Dissolved Oxygen Pictures Visual Observations Fecal coliform samples were also taken on June 13, 1977, on the stream@ polluting the Millicovsky Reservoir. _._._.._:_A..Einai-report will be prepared and forwarded as soon as all the data can be collected and analysed concerning the water quality of the stream entering Mr. Millicovsky's reservoir. The primary time factor in the report will be dependent upon the sample analysis results being returned from the laboratory. Ce ee: *[r. Robert A. Carter DIVISION OF ENVIRpidlEp°1'Ai. MANAgEMENT June 3; ,'1 77 Mr. James Millitovsky' Route G,,Box 57B' Mebane, North Carolina 27302 Subject,: Complaint Investigation, Wilson Farm' Alamance County Dear Mr. Millicovsky: This letter is to inform you of the, status of our investigation on the Wilson Farm's discharge inm ,Alaance County. In order to re^ulate a discharge from a faniin. onaratioa, in connection ,rith livestock, the operation v:ust first be desi,7nated as s concentrated animal feedinj. operation." Outside t'.',l? nu:ab-r of livestock needed for such a designation at ne Wilson Farm, one of the two following conditio-ns must nrmiail. a) Pollutants arc disc'iarged into navigable ',:ar.;rs ro.r;h a iian--..a.le ditch, flur,'.u.i; system or other similar man -.,jade levice, or (i) "poll.iit�nts .ai.acliared directly into navi.:•shla waters which originate outsida of and passes over, across, through or otherwise come into direct contact with the animals confined in the operation. The definition of "mnn-made" as defined in 41 C717 (Code of Federal Register) 124, Section 124.32 (a)(4) means "constructed by man and used for the purpose of transporting wastes." The discharge from the Wilson Farm is not made to the stream by way of a man-made ditch, flushing system or other similar man-made devices. Condition "b" is non -applicable due to the fact the nearbv stream does not come into direct contact with the animals confined in the operation. Therefore, according to State- and Federal -regulations concerning animal feeding operations and concentrated animal feeding operation, the Wilson Farm cannot be brought under permitting requirements. However, the receiving stream's water quality standards must be maintained. June 3, 1977 • • Pad %1 � q 3.1 I f �'Ns i if ng rtisam hae�a bless•II classification.;:M anch various aonditions':mget.be mainCained;in`the eta a. _hym ,Oas°Of eha;rconditiobe as fecal coliform. 9 NCAC (North`,Carolin& Administrative `Code) 28, saction :0211 (c) (3)(1) states ;that "Pecal:coliform for a Class II.:etream'ds not.to eieznedra'log mean of 1000/100'`ml basad;on-at least five conescutive eamplas'eiasdnad during:. any'•thirty 30)_,day psriod�:nor exceed:2001100 MI. in any Moro. thau:'262-of;.the . samples si�a ed during such,period." 71 On May'19,'1977, pater ''samples were collected -upstream and dovnstrea'm of the Wilson:Farm's discharge point. This was,done as a preliminary indicator to tdstelMeivtb if=toatei�"quality standards were being violated with respect to fecal 16011116'rm >4MW iesults of, the'collectdd samples was learned on May 26, 1977. Afvioiatlodzbf'fechi`toli'ftirm had occurred in .the stream.. With.the results of the preliminary study in.miae; amoro intensive study onathe receiving stream's waterquality has teen.sabedided begiatling on June 6, 1977..• Other'factors which will be looked into during the intensive survey will be floating solids, settleable solids, and sludge deposits, pH and dissolved I have?intentiong oP keepin ,you informed as to the final results of the study li't=needs 6' be ointed out that the study, sampling analysis, data collating and report preparation,will require time. An estimated 'time 'table%of events is -"es' follaios Intensive survey ,30 days ~ Sampling analysis a.n-1 data collating ' .10 davc Report nrenarati.on (' 5 days The time table has also incorporated normal functions wPIich are carried out at this office. Should you have anv questions concerning our intentions with respect to the discharge at the Wilson Farm, ,please contact me. Ply office is locafed at 11003 Silas Creek'1'srkway Extension, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27106. The telephone number Ys (919) Sincerely, j. sell: D.--,Radford a. ..8egional�Enginesr Water RDWee Quality Operations Branch DIVISION OF;$NVIRONMENTAL.MANAQMVNT May 9, 1977 y Mr. James Millicovsky Route 6, Box 57Ba:e. Mebane, North Carolina-::,27302 Subjeat .,„<Complaint Investigation Dear "Mr.:-'NYllicovskyt Thaak.'you-for your Utter. 'of.=May 2, 1977 %%h:response to�your.latter, -our investigation�of -The:WilsaasBrothars Farm;.,.. has been"completed. 'The,;final report'.is being -.typed: A copy. -of'the".'report .will .. . be forwarded to you after going to Raleigh, -'This report should be in your posses- sion within ten (10) days. -Mr': Gaspar has tried'to contact you -twice, by phone, since the investigation was initiated.. The first time your carnet -cleaning man answered. The second time, a message was left with your maid. It was necessary for Mr.-Ca"spar. to re -visit Mr. Wilson's farm on April 27, 1977. At that -time, Mr. Sam ailson and the�Alamance. County Extension Agent were present.- An, indepth, prof r4w,was; j,Q"RaZby_"s. _Wi7 $pn. a. tc.,cwhat _•:__ :::, mr. Wilson was'proposi.n� in eliminating the dischar^.e. Once again, thank you for your concern-. Should you have any questions or if I can'be of further assistance, please contact me. Sincerely, 6,0 :Russell D. Radford Regional Engineer. 'Water Quality Operations Branch RDR/cs Dl02.3h,.Carolina ➢eit, �'Qf latara7,.and Economic Resources. lcri :Piedmont.PIald Qtf. . 8003'811as Creek Parkway.Ekt. wiaeton Sales. NC. 27106_• Heiitlemem_ ' Att.'Mr. Ralu q •- E Z �e is A aZj1fJ4.�� MCEIVEly North Pl.d-MI ,. o.ohmal Ofto MAY g 1977 About 4 weeks ago I talk with Xr. Radt Yollation problem in xW creek.. Same day,l qas bapp co to lospeot..the.creek - running on the back' he es bush, _la .% ppresesCe, great amouwW of'sau stream heavq deposits :of the same organic>aateria and waaure all -,over both: sides. of the. creel tjr where° the manuie is.00*iug from. I..told h ' FARIS.- t, we went Mith 1M. Caspar to the P l� am to talk ;with Mr. •Joe Tilsou, in my'presen 16z..� pact tBe Dair :'facilities. Than Ur.. Caspar .aplaa 'Chat they wi15`,'Lave.,to build a System to hi a },b several, more things.: to corsecty lack of con.aweii lacing health d NAtee ounuTY GN. Ji Caep,�_ t i abant the s<p house -and. floating on. the `a�.ong ; tiia . banks De t ;I -•.know ter ins - en pollution requirements. faailities;r vio- Mr. Caspar told Mr. wtlson thatAhe will receive.and about a week a letter explaining what he had found .and what thsreceive Wilson boo have to do. At the same r.- time, fir. Caspar toldae that I ,rill receive will a copy of this letter.- O far I Uavett receive etter. Week before I Call the ➢apt. ofSNat. and Boon.Re ours- amdSIltalk with Mr. Radford. e told Ahat you. Were-very_..bmsY=amd=you_..._p to comple to the inform ve®�8' fo'r ffir�- Cam - , ry soon, and Send the letter. - well Gentlemen, The wilsones Fare continuos pouring manu- re in the. Creek. This situacion is going on for more than.a year, but heavily in the last 5 or four month. I donit:know of any action from your Dept. or .eqy other State Dept,. Nobody has contact me to tell me what are you. going to do. I have talk with several neighbors about this problem and -we are waiting for your answer, before to take further actions on this veredible this oreek goeaL=to_the case of Pollution -'More than the water of Haw River, is killingi:fish and vegetation along bani�s.`T m afraid that thshot weather will, arrive soon and there will bs''bo.way �0,zlive.with the odor of the descomposed organic me- terisls. pleaseC"act as soon as possible. - Awaiting for your answer to this letter and -the copy of the inform from,:•1ir. Caspar .over the organic Sediments and' pollution OIL this creek, sincerely yours.., James Miltl��ovai 'may G.Lti, Sto3-v9 J