The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About20190466 Ver 1_16-08-0034EffectsConcForm_20190410Pro ect Trackin No. /�tternal Use 16-08-0034 �.r �►`�t�',t�� ;p r� ��3ja �J:y� .. HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS FORM This form only pertains to Historic Architecture and Landscapes for this project. It is not valid for Archaeological Resources. You must consult separately with the Archaeology Group. PROJECT INFORMATION Project No: County Hyde WBS No.: 17BP.1. R.83 Document T e: Fed. Aid No: Funding: X State Federal Federal X Yes No Permit USACE Permit s: T e s: ProiecrDescrintion: Replace Bridge No. 35 on SR 1143 (Sladesville-Credle Road) over tributary to Slades Creek (off-site detour planned, no improvements). SUMMARY OF HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES REVIEW Description ofreview activities, results, and conclusions: HPOWeb reviewed on 13 September 2016 and yielded one SL, four SS, and no NR, DE, or LD properties in the Area of Potential EfFects (APE). The APE extends 500 feet from either end of the existing bridge (N-S) and 200 feet to either side of the SR 1143 (Sladesville-Credle Road) centerline (E-W) to encompass anticipated construction activities and likely impacts. Hyde County current GIS mapping, aerial photography, and tax information revealed an APE of woodland and wetland with resources dating from the 1900s to the 1990s, of which seven pre-date 1970 (viewed 13 September 2016). Among the latter are the study-listed St. John's Episcopal Church (HY0195), the recorded Gratz Credle House (HY0190), Napolean Sears Store (HY0194), Jarvis-Elixson House (HY0196), and Jarvis-Sears House (HY0197), as well as one additional house and a school building (see attached map). Constructed in 1951, Bridge No. 35 is not eligible for the National Register according to the NCDOT Historic Bridge Inventory as it is neither aesthetically nor technologically significant. The comprehensive county architectural survey (2009-2010), as well as later investigations, recorded no properties in the APE apart from those noted above. The presence of multiple, pre-1970s resources in the APE indicated the need for field assessment and full evaluations for National Register eligibility. S& ME, Inc. completed investigation of the seven identified properties for NCDOT in October 2017 (contracting process, as well as review and revision of work received contributed to expanded time frame; technical report on file at NCDOT—Historic Architecture and HPO). S& ME, Inc. confirmed the NR eligibility of St. John's Episcopal Church and established that the Sladesville School House and the previously unrecorded house no longer stand in the APE. In addition to the church, NCDOT recommended the four remaining properties as not NR eligible. In December 2017 the North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office (HPO) concurred that the church is eligible for listing in the National Register and the Gratr Credle House, Jarvis- Elixson House, and the Jarvis-Sears House are not NR eligible (see attached correspondence). HPO questioned the non-eligibility of the Napolean Sears Store. Deliberations to resolve the finding culminated in a November 2018 agreement that the store may be considered NR eligible (see attached correspondence). __ _ _ _ Hismi•ic Archrrec[nre m�d Lan�lscapes !:/•7•'li('7S ASS/iSSA�/l:�N"!:(orui jor h/inor �rn�rsportation !'�njecls ns (h�a/i�e�! in !he 1007 /'rogranu�mric Agreemeni. Page 1 of 3 The project is subject to review under both GS 121-12(a) and Section 106. Consultation with HPO and USACE is required to address the effects of the project on the two NR-eligible resources (see attached for proposed NR boundaries). The consultation is scheduled for �ewtember�'� 2018. ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS Properry Name: St. ]ohn's Epis�opal Status: DE, SL Church Survey Site No.: HY0195 PIN.� 7643-72-0425 Effects ❑ No Effect � No Adverse Effect ❑ Adverse Effect Explanation of Effects Determination: �r..o S �rY � cor•5 .}-i �-v� s K� � w. Po•�-�-}-a �ro per o�.,n.ct c��o� c.v..�— res ozrrc e.s . 8" PV c. � r` j�e �o be �.►'v�.�d � o List of Environmentnl Commitments: �ns-i-a � ( �n.�?�� Vis i �O � � ii- �� - � QYa Te�c'�' C e w�e � 1 � ,P� �r�( l� 1�tE �v►c�r d-tm� �n5�-rua�-t'�► , I � vt� i' � � 1n. c8 i o r cm l wv` s--�,piv«�1ti C�Y`Cft1Y►'� -h £. ro e�-�' �-the 2 h�s�►ry.� s��es � � � � � ��_� -1 , �- i �s; Bridge No. 35, Hyde County WBS No. 17BP.1.R.83 PA No. 16-08-0034 Page 2 � Hisraric Archirecnn•e and l.andscapes F.l•7� fsC%S AS:SI:;SSM/iN7' forni f'or Mina• Trnnspnrfation Prajec(s as (hrolified rn �he 1007 Prograinnm�ic Agreement. Page 2 of 3 ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS Properry Name: Napolean Sears Store Status: DE Survey Site No.: HY0194 PIN.� 7643-72-2538 Effects ❑ No Effect � No Adverse Effect ❑ Adverse Effect Exnlanation ofEffects Determination: R0� aC� v��re� a��9 /UGtI ,e��ye o� �o ►-v �'�� N o� S�v�'e l�ui �l j'K ,�o /a llo w��S-f&�.'��a�/'�-�[d o� � ,S�f -t-l�- 1��i-�a-�'v� i v� wa � 1�l.�o�� r,v i! 1�^e �! u c�e c'v� c�c�- s� c�d �.�v�n�" u,e,-�-I �s -� X► S�i-i� o w�l ►`�e- a� c�C- �o/e �o b-e ne/o ca-f� a,�c. dm � o�[�tfe �72 S� C(a�i ov� , Gt/�_/l h. v t c�� ke c�l y�� 5. �lar�e b v 1"1 �►hq cv� � i�s ��-�� a J � o►� �2d ��x-t� e s�'I'r J List of Environmental Commitments: _��,,, ;� sv�n r, �c-I-e.v�.-�- o� r�' -ra� �ad a s w�.ur,G� a s p dss�� e n (� /du i� c,o�.S�-v'vc��-r� � .�Yl 5�'Gl.� � iN1��" VIl`_S-,-TeM,G� n c�,��q .� boVr��G�Y — ti'V1��`ca,+L 1`1�t CO[o1r Ov� `��p, P� � � ; '� r 1 \ �� FHWA Intends to use the State Historic Preservation Of�ce's concurrence as a basi or a"de minimis" finding for the following properties, pursuant to Section 4(f�: SUPPORT DOCUMENTATION X Map(s) ❑Previous Survey Info. Photos X Correspondence Design Plans FINDING BY NCDOT AND STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE Hist ic Architecture and Landscap�s —ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS �� . NCDOT Architectural Historian Date ��a�• State Historic Preservation Office Repres�ative Date BARNES.KYLE.WILLIAM.138803539 pNiCalUS,lonUSbGovermm �tLou=IDoID ou3PKl�,ou3 USA, 7 cn=BARNES.KYLE.WILLIAM.1388035397 Date: 2019.03.12 07:5237 -04'00' Federal Agency Representative Bridge No. 35, Hyde County WBS No. 17BP.1.R.83 PA No. 16-08-0034 Page 3 Date f � Hisroric Archirectrve and Landscape.s lsFFEC%S ASSI;'SSiL1ENl:�orm jor A�/inoi� '!'rm�sporta�ion Yrojec�s ns Oualrfied in Ihe 2007 /'��ogronunalic Ag�•eemenl. Page 3 of 3 WBS No. 17BP.1.R.83 Base map: HPOWeb, nts NCDOT — Historic Architecture September 2016 Tracking No. 16-08-0034 Bridge No. 35 Replacement Hyde County I".'--��-�-.-.. 1 N � � . ----.._---_ __ j _ SR1143 -- --- ! i �' - - - _ HY0193 Siadt�sville--__ � �� --��-_.___._----HighSchoolLunchroam --..- J ; _ �_._____ _ j. ; rr_________ ; __ � _____., ;-____._ . ' � � `� � � � , ; � � � i ? � Sladesville School Housel � � No longer extant I � �_� � � � � 1 � ' I __--- � � ' I 1 - -- HYU189 StvindE '"-r____-�---_'' � I House � redle ' ;� r `� �Hl'0190 Gaatz Credle ;� _ i� M6�sE -__ ; 2 � Not N�t eligible ; � � � -- - . � , /; -- . , � � ', � �; t-----� jJ �r� / I �'_ -f I ` - _ �j'. �'� 0 ______---�I `` 'r ! � � -�. � rr %� i / I , �'` - --�---- ----_ _ / _ -�� HYDE - --Ir,,-----------------= - �-- --.. I _ t ..r ' i ��p,DE ��K � -.: - � `�' i'� ,,� � / • �. r� B d _ .,' �� __ _ _ �� .; �, � ' ' ' . � � � � �� ;� 3 ' ' ' ' ; '� . / ,, r 1� ' �� fHY0194, Napclean Sears F , � ,i� L � ; �� Stcre ' - - - -- � _.— _ — -� � NR eligibleti r ___ HYD19F St� John'a Epscopal -� -�_ 1 �h�,� ,9�� 4 ; � ' • NR �ligii�le House ,' � I 7 � Mo.longer ext�ln� ' , � - � � � - -'- - - HY0198 Jar�-EID[SDIt ' Hou '', �'� rj No�NR eligible r ' �, ,, �, �____ ► � �! � l--- _ � -,�- �I - -- - ----- _---�- � � _--- - - -- - - - - - - HY0198 Jeff 6 SaIIY HY0197 Jarvi�-Seais � Credle�Ho�s� FEouse 1 � �'� Not NR eligib�e , _-- - 6 �� _ _ _ ''1 _ __——-—_ ;——---- ;� _-- �, --- �� HY0199 Jdrdart-Credle - -- __ � � House '-----1-- '� -- -� ___--- � I I I HY0192 Fartescue-Wahah � House I L_____. � ;'�� r r �i � � I I ____--� y- � I � i I � � �5 �� i �------ ��i II ,., � ,� �----1 -.. � --- - — ____ --.- - AREA OF POTENTIAL EFFECTS (APE) ri ge lyo. . Not NR el�gible i . _.-- � � _..-�--"`-y"t,sbL��3 1� _ - __---'� _- � -"I f• Properties Evaluated Bridge No. 35 Replacement Hyde County Base map: HPOWeb, nts :� l�� `—� �`;,� , �c � �41�■ �€:;�;'N�c _/ ; �. North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources State Historic Preservation Office Ramona M. Bartos, Administrator Govemor Roy Cooper Secretary Susi H. Hamilton December 14, 2017 MEMORANDUM TO: Vanessa Patrick Human Environment Unit NC Department of Transportation FROM: Renee Gledhill-Earley �'� � Environmental Review Coordinator Of6ce oE Archives and History Deputy Secretary Kevin Cherry SUBJECT: Historic Structures Survey Report, Replace Bridge 35 on SR 1143 over Tributary To Slades Creek, PA 16-08-0034, Hyde County, ER 17-2451 Thank you for your memorandum of October 31, 2017, transmitting the above-referenced report. We apologize for our delayed response and offer the following comments. We concur that St. John's Episcopal Church (HY0195) is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C. We also concur with the not eligible determinations for: � Gratz Credle House (HY0190) • Jarvis-Elixson House (HY0196) • Jarvis-Sears House (HY0197) While somewhat deteriorated on the exterior, our staff recalls that the interior of the Napolean Sears Store (HY0194) is fairly intact. Thus, we would recommend that an effort be made to ascertain the store's interior condition, to the extent possible, and reconsider its eligibility undex Criterion C and perhaps under A for commercial and social history. The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with Section 106 codified at 36 CFR Paxt 800. Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the above comment, contact Renee Gledhill-Earley, envixonmental review cooxdinator, at 919-807-6579 or em�uonmental.review(a?ncdcr.go� . In all future communication concerning this project, please cite the above referenced tracking number. cc: Mary Pope Furr, mfuri(a�ncdot ��ov Location: 109 East Jones Stceet, Raleigh NC 27601 Mailing Address: 4G17 Mail Seroice Center, Raleigh NC 27699-q617 Telephone/Fax: (919) 807-6570/807-G599 �li'�� -=t3t%;`'� J��`' �411■ ��4 North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources State Historic Preservation Office Ramona M. Bartos, Administrator Uovemor Roy Cooper Secretazy Susi H. Hamilton November 9, 2018 MEMORANDUM TO: Vanessa Patrick Human Environment Unit NC Department of Transportation FROM: Renee Gledhill-Earley �C� ��'� x�'��'�''��. Environmental Review Coordinator OEfice of Archives and Ilisrory Deputy Secretary I{e�tin Cherry SUBJECT: Historic Structures Survey Report Update, Replace Bridge 35 on SR 1143 over Tributary to Slades Creek, PA 16-08-0034, Hyde County, ER 17-2451 Thank you for your August 22, 2018, memorandum providing additional information about the Napolean Sears Store (HY0194), which we believed might be eligible for listing in the National Register, but for which there were no interior photographs. The report of your visit to the store and visual inspection from outside, confirmed that, in general, the interior with its mercantile fittings axe intact. Given the survival of exterior and interior features, you determined and we concur that the store is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion C. The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation 1�ct and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with Section 106 codified at 36 CFR Part 800. Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the above comment, contact Renee Gledhill-Earley, environmental review coordinator, at 919-814-6579 or environmental.re��iew�ncdcr..gov. In all future communication concerning this project, please cite the above referenced tracking number. We apologize for the delay in this reply. Vi1e regret that a mishandling of the paperwork caused us to miss the regular review deadline. cc: Mary Pope Furr, NCDOT, mftiur(a7ncdot.�o Lacation: 10) East Jone. Svect, Kalcigh NC 27G01 Mailing Address: 4G17 Mail Scn•icc Center, Raleigh NC 27699-4G17 Telephone/Fax: O19) 807-fi57U/807-6599 f;i��.. --.=_,.v.. _, �_.._..� F Base map: GoogleMaps, nts Hyde County Bridge No. 35/WBS No. 17BP.1.R.83 Proposed National Register Boundary St. John's Episcopal Church (HY0195) #�454 Siadesvilie-Cr�dl� R��d, PiIV: 7643-72-0425 Napolean Sears Store (HY0194) #5441 Sladesville-Credle Road, PIN: 7643-72-2538 Base map: Current Hyde County GIS, nts Hyde County Bridge No. 35/WBS No. 17BP.1.R.83 Proposed National Register Boundary Nete: FII-�4[ Ferrcin to 6� unans �rucn a �:�: yp� H'wiie;e "�°ecr urm�ca w. • i�,miiod o.«,�a N�euorbio W�T'LAND AI�kD SiJRFACE WA3ER IMPACTS PERMII' ;�•„a F,,,, n,vz �� Pro7�rfla bok�s cOmAvcHart � � .�.siw I.' y u.ua�. s. w wui �o � :qK'ut� Di51GN `�YiRI�WCS 0O1OH wm�i.n�w.� c..c�e� u. ��m �wa.�.a .....�no� r..rs...aw. �� u.r ••••••••• fxlctinp PowuUn� � emoron.w ays-.a..c.va.mu-c..m...-.,. �'�' l uwiuc • *' °'� ��0j Propo��d Pow�r Lim ieo• � f.° a„�i y� ��ieii,�� '�' /'"{ ��G-�LI� � ;`�f r': : § �,` '; - V � \� l�� i0�'�Ih�� p aN1w1: wlC �� :+✓ w��+ PERMIT DRAWING � SHEE? 2 OF 6 oocwnwrworcwruum�w�a ST -0NMS �4L 11i�1 ALL LYYLTMId COYlIRlG pR1W10 KCyEd.E OwC .EGFV.M[nc� � WDfFJ.RLW6 y �mo�.�er�• ,�u rw-wn_ IbCWNO K rocn r // S }�.li � m� � Sie.13 �'t.ia l-+� i*� �" -� n� {I1V �u1YeO �� y � _ 1 ' w �raqnsw - � ��2� I �i T � � SITE 1 . ,�„ ,w� " .w:or�.._ I .row �I¢c-bwu �( ` ..-u.. Y •• • trpK �t'T $KEiCH SHONANG 'AVElAENL3TRUC7URE REfAilO>lSHI O £i ; SYMfiCEw�ff� WH2Tf—� 11 �EH. �R ^ ' 1 nJC:r:.. fl V y ��G� � i001.ET MIOPE�TIFS R:]RWO Ylsi �b I.MNu.O�»f�'f wm +us� .�. u'e . , . u � n�s �_.__' � �.pw v+...�u.F � � _�...- _ _— .�.�.� >, I I ,/ � �� <•.�'�-- � � �—�� o --- i . N J a5� -1 b �� ' ' ��rof ��.,.�y� ^ �.r�a ,� V'+�'�' a, / � � y.� �� rwrc. •� i�S sF�i1� �coarnov� X S2l'SBlW �I. � � W 5 l f M fsassa£ •. % r/ �u�s'WF'�c �`�'+T�'E'��" � j ' ; .J � 3 ,o�� .// 2 //pp�p n+. s f � N��y[ �\�/ . ._ r IirtCiFll ' J 1 ! CLNES.lYIP6 ! YOM6EFJM Nul�r�tl��C f, � ._ 1 \ �� . c��m , ! / tKwwiUY In r�luMY.J �!r1 fT{1MU w'�TR wJ� Iw6X y�G � 7 , 1 a A ,� � �. � „ x, ' i \\4 � �.a.sl � ( �` ` ' �\ N ?Jr'f19E �� ... �., f I I � ` . r= �_,�,:.rp' ts- . s, <eorrviu � l 1 '�'' . � , - R I � � �\,� �� .a s�.o� — � 4 ` �t "�� W�v r___-- �- �2 I � � `� g �----�� , J �5 r� SITE l ENLARGEMENT SItE 2 ENWtGEMENT � ,� �6� 2X ENURGEMENT 27( ENWtGEMENT i jc i BEGIN DIRECTIONAL p` � �4 "` � a � 80RE KFT 0 ' � x £ ei�:rs � �` a f SURFAGE WATER IMPACTS � + �--�---• � � I� /��6� S � ,�¢ ; � � � a y�� owsranNe ouowa �'�` �� ' ' ,� ! � � : �_ ��..� , � � �5 y � � ��x��:� � HANID CLEARI NG t ' FILL IN WETLANDS � �� SURFACE WATER IMPACTS � EXCAVATION IN WETLANDSJ SEE SMEEi 5 F00. ►ROFILF $:E $FIE85 Z7 TFIRU �72 FOR STR3JCfURf RA1V5 January 201�