HomeMy WebLinkAbout640074_NOV-2019-DV-0114_20190226 +o u3d+�h;' i
ROY COOPER y 1r i i
P �
Governor s e7 � 10 w .o
MICHAEL S.REGAN 'man* r
Secretary `
LINDA,CULPEPPER NORTH CAROLI NA
Director Environmental Quality
February 26, 2019
CERTIFIED MAIL 7017 0190 0000 9562 7329
RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED
Mr. Willie Harrison
Harrison Pork Production, Inc.
4985 Harrison Blvd.
Castalia,North Carolina 27816
SUBJECT: Notice of Violation& Intent to Enforce
NOV-2019-DV-0114
Harrison Pork Production, Inc.
Permit No. AWI640074
Nash County
Dear Mr. Harrison:
On February 11, 2019, Mr. Buster Towell of the Raleigh Regional Office Division of Water
Resources received a complaint that stated that on the evening of February 7, 2019, hunters
encountered a strong odor of swine waste in a tributary to Sandy Creek in Nash County. The
complaint also stated that the water flowing in the stream was very dark and turbid. The water
body in question is located adjacent to your swine operation. On February 14, 2019 Mr. Towell
conducted an investigation of the above described complaint and discovered the following
violations of North Carolina General Statute 143-215.1(a) and your Animal Waste Individual
Permit AWI640074:
Upon entry to the property on February 14,2019,wastewater was observed flowing down gradient
in a roadside ditch. This waste stream was tracked to the spray field located near the dry stack shed
and composter. Wastewater was ponded in several places in the field and was actively running off
the field in two directions. (Photos 1, 2, and 3).
Further investigation determined that wastewater was actively flowing off spray fields on the back
side of the property from four(4)other locations where waste entered the tributary to Sandy Creek
which is classified as C-NSW waters within the Tar-Pamlico River Basin. (Photos 6&7)
A water sample was collected where runoff from the upper portion of the back spray field
intersected with runoff adjacent to the irrigation pump on the lagoon dike entered a ravine
approximately fifty(50) feet into the woods. The fecal coliform bacteria count was 17,000 colony
forming units (CFU) per 100 ml of sample. The standard for fecal coliform is 200CFU/100
milliliters (ml) of sample.
� North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality I Division of Water Resources
Raleigh Regional Office 13800 Barrett Drive I Raleigh,North Carolina 27609
NORM CAROUNNA
nnwrtmentmtnvrcnmentalMO / 919.791.4200
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Page 2 of 13
A sample was collected in the creek from approximately 200 yards down-stream from where the
wastewater was actively flowing off the spray field in one of the aforementioned locations.
The fecal coliform count was 4500 CFU/100m1 of sample.
The discharges of wastewater to waters of the State documented by DWR on February 14, 2019
constitute a violation of North Carolina General Statute(N.C.G.S.) 143-215.1(a)which states"no
person shall do any of the following things or carry out any of the following activities until or
unless that person shall have applied for and received a permit from the Commission and has
complied with all conditions set forth in that permit:
Make any outlets into waters of the State."
In addition, the discharges of wastewater documented by DWR on February 14, 2019 are also
violations of the following conditions of your Animal Waste Individual Permit AWI640074:
Permit Condition I. PERFORMANCE STANDARDS
2., which states, "The animal waste collection, treatment, storage and land application system
permitted under this permit shall be effectively maintained and operated as a non-discharge system
to prevent the discharge of pollutants to surface waters,wetlands, or ditches. Application of waste
at agronomic rates to terraces or grassed waterways is acceptable in accordance with Natural
Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) Standards."
Permit Condition I. PERFORMANCE STANDARDS
7., which states, "The spray irrigation facilities shall be effectively maintained and operated at all
times so that there is no discharge to surface waters,nor any contamination of ground waters which
will render them unsatisfactory for normal use. In the event that the facilities fail to perform
satisfactorily, including the creation of nuisance condition or failure of the irrigation area to
adequately assimilate the wastewater, the Permittee shall take immediate corrective actions
including those actions that may be required by the Division, such as the construction of additional
or replacement wastewater treatment and disposal facilities."
Permit Condition III. MONITORING AND REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
7.,which states,"The Permittee shall report by telephone to the Raleigh Regional Office,telephone
number 919-791-4200, as soon as possible, but in no case more than 24 hours following-first
knowledge of the occurrence of any of the following events:
a) Failure of any component of the animal waste collection, treatment, and storage and land
application system resulting in a discharge to surface waters
c) A spill or discharge from a vehicle or piping system transporting animal waste or sludge
which results in, or may result in. a discharge to surface waters or an event that poses a
serious threat to surface waters.
d) Any deterioration or leak in a treatment unit that poses an immediate threat to the
environment.
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-20 19-DV-0 114
2/26/2019 '
Page 3 of 13
f) Overspraying animal waste in excess of the limits set out in the waste Utilization Plan or
where runoff enters waters of the State.
The above note violations are subject to civil penalties of up to $ 25,000.00 per day. This Office
is considering recommending to the Director an enforcement action for her consideration. Please
respond to this Notice in writing within twenty (20) days of your receipt of this letter. Your
response should include the following:-
1) Copies of all land application records from January 1, 2019 thru February 14, 2019.
2) A copy of any waste analysis that corresponds to the above date.
If you wish to present any explanations for the violations noted, or if you believe that there are
factors which should be considered, please include'this information along with your response.
Your response will be reviewed, and, if an enforcement action is still deemed appropriate it will
be forwarded to the Director.
If you have any questions regarding this Notice you may contact Buster Towell or me at (919)
791-4200.
Sincerely,
fic
Rick Bolich,L.G.,Assistant Regional Supervisor
Water Quality Regional Operations Section
Raleigh Regional Office
Division of Water Resources,NCDEQ
cc: Nash County Health Department
Nash Soil&Water Conservation District
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Pa.e4of13
hx`f
.�,..�..�,,,,,
•
•
•
•
•
r• 7'r / . J • • r - f, .fit
•
tag j t ^ .? t • . f
�r iJ 1 f 1. .;T rt t � - Y X a t, r� '* 'C. ..c •- i _ -,~
*X1 • i *:. 4 Y r
tl;/_ e+..�. •
.:7J I , 1I h 4t� ti p '` 4; ,.� r
• l! ' c , `
1 ! • � !� .�' ` J I .P t. —
'.ly`
•
f` • `.��3x 1 f• r/ c. r` IF a J i+
Photo 1
• Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Pa e5of13
1
4-�+. Ly r y + 4 c.Yyz r,
dl �-ra.• r fj Y. .:r f Cr r,j 'F'.I.t E + :1 r?!.",•' ,,.° µ 4 teach� ~
-y• f { y',u 0. ,•A dt...5 C .t4i,4,, t1c444.aW•,d' �`s2,-;rJy�?;. ,.. s^ #'�"„a-i s„•, �,•xr, k.v,
' { v ?y+,,,, L e J ps Fl+'�a .4".. J'ti" r s rat rl _i ,--' i4 F
• .tr y -.} ryaya,ft4f.- J✓ Y.4't s yr^ 1 '^ �4, ; n '.'.h f,S.,Z•.„ a-w'as i..it-X>u$3t 1 'gyyyrrr, '�;°
i w t �.p'y�IAA y,yY� a. / , �r� F „3_ 'l'�+i'J uTafe..tI .Jh,�,;yj1�"1�t 0.4.1�iar� •
"%tt 1,,,iS•e.+.bf fi.: •• . ,. i P �.,F. 4 ,•�`�c > otsir' e,-r.,,... 16' + s '..•..+' ak'^ tJ J-vk -;,t.
>, d .4 4 ': , • lf• x ,k'� �N ., 4 "".sri .i i r ;$.+fs•.•."x3 c.
,� t ;.. > 3 y h. S v `gat' .�5� ,�tL,S9 ,, r. 4",-,r4' ,tr-77 y Inti.14 ''''''
t v"°E91+ Y.V..iy.ri r ,.f.,<43 .c—. � .5, f °p� `r n Pr' • 'b
_ `. - ,f-.�.� ;, h`'�+" }4 $L. s 5 tr (L� lnrl. 7 e; .G^^ 4 .1- A.a ((��C/• ', o,..
S'� dY .i,::S�$`�!4 t t r� rYr`� � S Har.d' !Xy , rG"dq 11� ...` A .1,'
i �L'. .. rvJ r`'t 1. k ° 5'p it 6. �` :.'`�77.,. v: '�'� r° 3
� q �-Z ,c- �J..,,,„!,, ��•y�'+L ��`y14" J./° rt� J.'i. 'hi. 'r��rs3� -y `u-.r<`s�ri.F. h s .�i
'-'' .13 `.t e t .ti3• i c� j,> - r+,.1,,4, .+a 4•,,..,..,.....,..4.,,,.....,.4e,,4,_..
.ystL,t ! wy y pb+rR. s 7 q *5�i-,'
y :i 9 <},3i"' K- -ra .4 I f+ v. ."e¢^ '; + Lt -r ' r a .., �s,..,�r 74 _— d{<r ?;,t�q,.. „t gbr�L-7-`•t 4't S "t' jl'ti,,, , �, +,r.L, `trot Sx - xr-} Cx h�'!rs r 6 tis.. r p 8e'kS it � x, .,,,AqF� -t' '�`� �^;. b#ear i' 4F +�e �h �+ rv+���,yl' iZ�a�` "i,� i �,,.t x� .,<q''�' z'• tF Icy'
p,'.¢ td:u,..-. ..1:14 r -,•; TI } •; i;•4' 'h *,14,i, 3?.. N 5, r. • 4 ,!�`r4 t' r`, 1.+
rr l r-1'-G-- rS v "S'�. vR, �T 1�` -! � �+ k ��a .A � +">'s Yfe A %'
t'f. a,..k'• {'}' r�` 1� �Z. ,�, a � (i9,ryry
� ' 4 � - ��F� h`1s3a '+.1.. t �"'. Z L J^F,p h h r +.. c
a�t+�'c ��" .v'�i� k- a y �T �'k �iatY•- t „x �� ! � �!t e �+�*t."}�fi��.. a �
a"�,� 1. "=7 '"'.' 'I Z" +«..c 4 ;'-' �•s v�''P{ .i'v�le .*. ?, ?i6 p '"fit 'pr a,,,p n p' ' Yi Y{.�.7
�s s� "- s j-, 1� :`'at :.. `���:: 3s: k: Srr" '::::::,r''} 71 k : i t? ,'�,ti nra'y tsa
rl ? '""4n, p,, 1- , r. 7y w ',1>'i-.' � '��� iax0,.Y + '4 �,- ^3tn ,�A t1..�t`rys�
T'O �s „ak E'1rt. �r r X y c r Au t��w,.`,r` '4 .'... ...11.., '+, b w,f lr -
l.,t.-'`,y 14.717'4 p fr> x.5. k a.443- Z,. 'a'`' . ''x$+ t w 4k.$ '4eys " 'h,f
r•'t r -' ,' ` , ,t [%. ote • '' y�"v .. :.i:Ct e,.x�,{i;5,1, ;,y k�, ,: + s '4tr ri �a••n ' �,d
e•e' +• ' •- P s-C" +•ta r t }'a[' ' . r- 7.,`- 0-ib• �•,i �t;• ,..7 ' yxJJlr v,L„ ', -'+ ;,6� '�?
r w J:J�tbti .� .'+£h s r {t '+Ptc '2,...),
`it M��7# to f%';d ark• �, ♦ s I`r'dt A' x j t 4' >
, .; t �.. us" G-�a HIS d xt t 'ct r`',�} V
jF, 1at^ ,4 nr 1. sz tit+ ,, rr (-•c 'y'¢ 't° r
r 4 J re AR' 'r ft 4 l .! �'.Ji+' •./.=s111a• .d�{t� It 1 F / R .+T+g• y lT.14P•e.
,sty e i�'QQ`,,�-i' �� -+ v n �t `.1 ?4b j`` ti`�`rL'' `cyy� i• •�'.$a!� 14 " ,• -�Y 'k'r
.5.,.. :.
{"3.� rczs.r4.'Y q r.r�a Y". 4 " v'c' �S ,,, JL a '>'. t sty
i "V+r 1."t do IM.4('-'1%1 ', r7a R o s' r t r S r !u " ^1 .,,,. .. ,,....,... ... ,.,,. .„ ,
L
J+4,inl n ,�r s 4'� trti �, r '�" -�t �'�,��+ i:,�.� t r � 1. "`„ sl i �z� NF + t ,`
F� .✓�i '. r,y"YA+i 0.,$:CVI, ti t`.f..Aa,t, �i 1�Y'�.'T t'-�1Ti'�{ 'S�`y. it* "`ti f'2' ` ' • �+,him[
✓3 S r x `�i Pr -. s. J':.d ,t r i v 7 r '"'RfF sr is.X�.P t t-'K4� ,, •1° ° �` �+ ktw t"5 s °. 'ly4 ik \ tat 'r` 3^
+ U+°;j'i . +`r;'�kr p +�� ""lrixF't ^ot. a tiT�n•i f `�F� `5..t�Ar. • \ � "', • ry.
Su a�+ `' tt" y v � 4. t ra c + ta' r `s`�; yes• n, it' �
INT�ViAr r; y"Fy.�.{$i. r+ i ui''?„: `#'�rK,- . 6,f,V t •"tee✓ 1';/ $•5X'Sx.'r i �+ i $F.` g "h;
',-y S 1 yv
,�,RR['ti 7/v✓�y �i„„'^}� ^t"1?'��1�C, �j�i./-1�`�t�R ))�'j�x�,�1r�1.yr)y %H p rF9 '.�� �1 1 �1"� . -.at
ST4'xf� '"7�;n'4Vt{;'.fie t 1!00;4:1'." t1k�'i'gx 'pll +.. �+> p t �.
(046`` 1 ' 'Y 1 yy -��`s pry — \ :+-
. /I'-V LV' 7 6°4 "fix rl l�r'a.Tft ti 1i i'l. aK i" �'tttl' '► \��1�` s '�
L C ;,' . a{ }Ic ararAtci1c y ' 1 ayl of r°t• ` u\e;1,.. aF
� J1d•,.' .f L ; b1 t, JX- lu.} df// 1 .'� t'1,1 U ,.lX f1y.�-\ , •
t.
r44�. e. ' x f� " r 'rjl cl t.*;ry \�'i,.{rt7 t _( il'�t th¥s rr "Y•- �.*
V°., � 4 i,} tl, J t e/h<. , Y fit Y '+ £ 4�Ai', i 4 frR r 3 k` i r: tgt d; a .;., :\
p ��h'.' /.n,. 2 ,>r. VYe y ^v. ,r Yy rP,�,t ?7 y�'y!t ;,I `�'�k�
S .,4 ,_yg.ra. fna PtNr1v �..M..6Cs1.stM w.41(O.IA I r�)r. D�.A' 1 .\x .11
Photo 2
Mr. Willie Harrison
NOV-20 19-DV-0 1 14
2/26/2019
P—age6of13
y [ ''U y"i'^J Rr Ir"A vt`.. r 1 .
T 'tle1 t A,'r• v I'd ! ti l+r5, } h' Fry a�' , � • F 1
a,' '+�f o- r'_.W.vti `?`'� n fi� ti *s tr 1$ a >, 4 ', + i rix ,.
", a ; c q ` it Fria viv1 ,
�+';R, 4r..' a' AS f µ 9wr• r , '4`P''� '` ,Ti ';7 't P ,r '
"` ( ys rti h� <1" vr' iy a.: A. .r ' ;i r 1 ''
4 ,1 ',- 'a.act 4 ;z`� ` ,.ii� II'r. '.a4,'* t(i i ., .• -
Y vw.
J., -,.''...�' ra.0 ,/a ,....,:. 1, t J i � ,-..,.. .�- .3771t .a; 2 . ' . n. ' .' -Sr .�
1
+-C�.: ry � r J, w''.i n ,�,y` .t.y. '�,.., Y .,,x r`"�r r n a � t � t4�c r-nr4?�:�'b. �'� -.'`o s5
r-Kn t-M..,x �- 49 r t 'i ,i' t' r y c w YSh a H",.
c �14-,. `..i, y ,l `+ e %' r h 'f ,,ti ti t.x .4
+ ,g;,,kft y` ,� ,, ., i'a+,r n 4fii� -r t}2r.sy;,"`sifi �� b: r,',' tKT f <n #6u '-e;
,x,. r.i.., A,4' ` - , e c..rt'':,.'SKf�^ , },,y '' '....,t, 1 r ry e'•^ t,,r^r a ,l.it ,,- n r",, ta r v '<,ry r:ra
's,'t' rS: Ae tvr i'p. s.:s�,.c� c , +�.h.t L e s t�..''hb 4•f. i4nv,Y `.+'r =,2:4-r l�:'4`d1'-rah s,r, -°-.:•� ,,a'''+• r p`
i`h,,"`i�Y r+ Ss�'iK i�,e �`+'P �y�$a�,� .� NdJt rrh,�. .r•.�7 t r�� � � .. ,r '�' J�•_ ��'T� • '; � Yt14'�,i
'3�d x�''�A x .r , l-a-a�F t�ld`,,rl•' '�'' � , • rY ?w sA s!m'rt, r x �`,{ x ��' 2�t L� �, �'
' 4�z-t^St" t it st h "y�„f� r r ,' . �� t `,y ,,1�4�' 7i,
1t..r'- .Z''1 r;'i S ,. A a. Pl 'S?L t - rrc ` 1 4 Aston n` '• R'
s`E I. f's"[. �:. ..12 ,, -•w i..se. Ari• ...,-* {p,.. t x.''1' `'fa a �1s{..,; lx.fr
y mahsp ;+ t v,.5°.q- . fi+ • 1 ,r ,� .-i-• t 1P'•S�r
Opr c4 P 7 c u 1 r r t tt. yy �}
fs ,r .ci-- �1 Ex as'' '{it - 4- ,*. - '�--y-�,, _,s ,g'` 1, .tam a ¢1hx4`OX+Y �"y)',~
e�'7a 4,.,.4y\r ..*; y xi ce f � k _'4 a'.Mt '''' 4# x �,C 9 S9� i w 4 14t�la.,,...,St
t rJ' elylr;i �a• �s _ley '•'Ma na, 'y y rl e.'i'
�y 1.'l� 11 JJ__�e7 t'k ,(r 4 r r ">"P }���,�r� ��^^,go �.L��r,,,,�� /� 21��.� '� r�;C,
�3�iaw YZ�A�$�T�' -?rM e'�aKh "j ..sa,,.h..y.}}p"�r I,. r ` */*t 1.'7'�N`4 r 7i{.�� 4 zt ..„ {`]
,,�.R i5 5/yN�4,P S t. .r>,,.t di. 4 1,1 y 4, ,w "�s iria R 1{•, _. - _
ti4rr�l� ¢w it 1 `'.ti V�}1 °ld\ i ,t:i t,�slrY� t 4'r 7 rd, '. w �Y{4 1 6• a.,'A'f if
i' tr: •aa:. -,�, �. _ a
v ,j?#Ok,,i f f aFi t t$ L Tu t•r a,w a fYv, . ti.�l 'r}
��t1}t�fi ,Sri hd� k � 5�,,�� t� ��5�>'^k IR tf4 '�r �".� 1 a'!'4ei. � I ' } , s1 r �y'� • I. t�L ��rL,.,
��� ;��,,�,�" t ���, �v�}} �p��}e `� �:a 4� q i t-r�' � t � ;p 5� *� r'�� ,�z.
.4, yr' .. r-�M^4 g.i t" o `c�t," �` .t,�` 1 ' � ,�' t �.r
,11. t A htr,4 t ? N rlilkn tti ,1 7.i 1r:r El,i' ,a Yt -,1.: -. • {•. i, r ,' ` Aar., ,..
/� k44�+ ;„10 '4`t ,,,a(t`��0'ra*6 )-fc eq��0� f',� - 3- ry '•he. i'. 41i r:1 ,.i< --.:.`r \'r19,14!KVNP,10-0.4.4.011,4
rSVV t�j 4k, 4 5 ¢ t23 v riy 'd to r t S r ?"" r `v '` ,:� t� r •'. , x i,..,f `.i;a' ,� "'. 'Sf l rl. X.us;
"v't�'�',t�li i " I �CPiQi`���''�''f�M� ,t ��� ' '�b � � '`� ' d y,' , �'�'1.'�`t � , ''��''�' �F;` �'� '•i.1@` , 4 ' s xS` ;i'��"', , E ' 'v 'fl 's t I C� €eR1ytt ?�,4 d�+ 1 �1 t9y �. ���+a�'�•' -ueq,,,. , i �; 1rd Y'S S '� ,''7' 1 .—da� , g,it !L p [ t t. . a,:.,
fiy`�,t Ai`.jr' ke,14 r •A it., C dlF+. .` r4Fn S,... , .r k . i 1 f,S:.a d .Ji 1k knC`. '�pya,,ji.K>� r'�„, i'r,�'` �" , ..-'. 4 ,- T
'� � k [`5x 'n�/,t '�lb�l: + t �tlt§xaj� >] A c' t 1i `iR .ai. tr�u' r � ` .``4 i' Q.'*`d}a�},5 !'`at ,, i r i "'is,;,a ie 4.i�a" ', t LV,,,,, t r f: '. •. tr r,, .a t\� :..4i�F^��fi,✓�� 4/��fi,`'� abF4411�'��� � s:�' °� / f C�; }..�' ' r o1 �H$ e , '+ * 't '"7 •�- l .,`
, 1 �f, �'(t�. / °hf{ r �1 4 Iv 1�'a,'yt�L� r,�r
t j.q"'' . .Ot t tig.3,110 s.,,. it* \'�.!,,4 ''91'+'r r' .s l 1 ;�.. .' C,,,1 0: e a��MM,h��� r 10( q+'«�3 3 ,., ._C`0
,,,rh
o�f�a ` s o a�r >„r 1' 1t .i� ' {r/ " 4 r. t,,:', ..,„,..y, ,,,, ;fir` �`tI`.eth ,. 1. t-i...,, „.,,, , ,. 'W/,,,v .; �' .xi `1t, _,r ��tv'u� AY4.<'Swi=.•i6.--'a t''YtiL. .fi.�it 'e S '1 rf a' :� 'i' t} itT +(
Photo 3
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-20 19-DV-0 1 14
2/26/2019
Page 7 of 13
i' ' ty a 0, r% l t e .' r N rr 4"?.', " +�i L.,' • *. .°ft t
.n y /fir'`, ..;t�-- , 1 - . ,:a. ,c,1/4;....„,,„:,.
�• r r,i I?."�� "1'n 7`,,, ,t . t 4R li t � a t. . ''F 'i
:4.
...
,:„., .,..
••
• , .,T. . . ..
.: ,
,,,
r y.J'� rJ'^ .•t s, 114t ibl4g {. � � t',r -,� t t J,' ,j
.44.
. K J .. _ -
. -:-Jr
'� eM, ma�nc.^�' "' {z /'*-'vi '- ""� •�-., u'c�. yyy���ty�y�� r
r, i s ti-t Y "' a r Y"� f�
r 5, x y �Ai
1q ..,.„d•ax,a a �,, �i Y ` r'v.1 ..f •a?+L T.r4;% ,' W1'9L ,. G�,�t •.,
a i.:. a1' R ,f4. >. c!v J ,, 7r., d ,. y'� < ,,., a .xj, ,.a�..'Aa.'" �.,r'z. 'ri' ' `ri*"r''-r, ,ryto-"`3'3 y�.i,
�� � aia 5 { �� 5 ,��,t S }.3 to ca -..- i �" y .P "r �:R r 4 'y4*.. .�� � 4{ x.
�''' ,,s x:, >r L � ,c-
j��rc�'`'�Y 1�l'�'j,r�, `��a a del �x'� �,k ,,, �:.n �`.1:-.
�'`� ` ��Y7'4� � ,ra7 Y ay,, s ° 1 rr.i�x � 1� T
iAj �{.PyC t >f�,, t t� w�Ii. a v y4 r ' realhv w. r y J (t�i x f�a t se rkt
v1i. title
x�,}+€�Ir"'� '�k, it.Si ., C,, , 4t'St1 +s • `gE:1 4 :i .+` (N +• ..�lie' `t � fir/
,...yyy,,,''1Z,.:AA,'�c °�'7 N � 1/•4VV4 > t ' t,P l�1 `b ',�_'.. 'q .,,,;l A R. . rr��{ .;,,-'1,,,,, r R ', 4 rr
. 'S4tx 44,,1. `S t 666...,„NN't1} / t: :,f3.4,1, ...e� ,,,Jl A t f."a.. A. y. •M1 - �`,. \ 11 7 L 5 a R,:
,� 1!u ry � r� 4 n. it r r ti r,a ri' i3
4x: i s" 1•n r y '4 rr y rTs)k. 4 Y y 1,� ,,y F 9 , +a ,',!,,,,*,,',,.,1..---.
.�?r�` e-y.a d � '`*c,:G r �,IHQ��t�.{'M'3 'Ll<r 1� bk, � 4. 's� / t'� j� � j7y'A`t�'
i . .. . r } •Y1� J ,e J t, `1, >L ,,,,
� ; d�tF,c � `^,l C�,o�+6 ""'s+tc`l�`.: V 1 S���y- �1`:Y;,� d ir 1�"OIA q "r� ,f� a'y, \'
A .y ..-C tsar 'r, Tr4 s. ' > A:y �W tbIt' P1 x . a,'4y 4 '� t d .V' '(4. "'e
ti.� j� 1� *S c \ I.} t r� l.r"'ot-I�� �r ( AY ai ti,d•. .•XS1ait s:
��ttII ti;• �, A��'3yyM /l ! a �r$��? �. t mf r � �` t� k c.<. ..ti*4,-,....\"--Ir''',5`,.../4"- 0.1-4.„.'i
'.tiLr`.i t !/,ti..�4+1r i 1.41/ .✓.,�. .a.'A7 Y tF .RT c t. -1i^tA +t i �,v'i --,. Y t� `t ao1 t 'K Y "�C'� r ,v ..a x` rrr ;r 'ji6'r J.;r R t a 7 * 4. r . t .� ¢ 1c �C'.�'� S ° :,a iIs�'1 Z,I,}Dt�Fi fl r kw A `1 +�s. \vM l �a, •��{�"4t'.<','e '' s.,
to 1K dyl r.'y3 .-ti- �` .J,41 i' " !'7�'.w'oY'� Ic .P.-' c'-�� �/+ y r -V.y', "c q°W {-'), yf *,�,F ..r- -M•
C{i'''yFQ`1✓ < J' ,�� 3`.. +. t r fr ,C."' f` t,.•-`gi .,ay ( `:N� �wr 1v� b. `q'ti;' 4R- v + °
.Si r c •'3 la ..^ t ` t `lQ r !5,. Y a ql� c 'i • A 3.�'
.fi'+x.'a t�-,,* r`r 4+x ,;eAt rx Ir...,4-1 fit' ' M l .a �1,-,"• ^F..ii :•' •: P -r''`c t'T'.�1•__
r.+ 1� Y V3. 1 (t F5r tit q 4���,1'
�rt..x t I" =S py'}t•i A'f ro'i: 4.'. ''�'e ?t • + ,,y Vg.:`.3, �` }
O"' �° gi.`3 4Wer: t,`w 6'ex``CG,"t �`V t d' ',.. 1 ?r�$ 1 v• t� ''''' � ) Tr,',y\
5 yv r ±y t '� "Ifr' l ti` ,0: .t
1. < t
>r RJ�}�"f tq.c!tit°,.� tr)�t s- �' 1y, ,I. I T 1 r� I":t J +c';
, �tN 11"`d' 1# I iltA, t'a,�S' +l 4V.l Apt 1 ��:�: � t {{ ,"O"{ J _
tAl. , .,,. `L-...y. 'rlw 4.14'-�'q Is%)tS�{'.C' 'y gF clt)i a. �at�. �\�I ,e` `4:r-l .v'7.r`, -
�i a6P r „ � 1 Prsr' # K. "' t� �\.t y.r r �' it y' ,
ae. ri:}3f s I:'aA.!o►J3�� :� ...as, . _ jl4
Photo 4
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Page 8 of 13
At... ...-,.,,:wriot r .' * •��-� v is ; °ttt L�7 1\
s{• �` Ne-Nikrt,"/' g."" ‹.:- *', t = .°i 't ,yiy'4 vas si �I i'
+` �'tit� ',.� ram, r :- 0�. fi� tr ^'�'Mr la F.f'4 ,-,-'• ,' - .ctJt
tt � � 11��
4.44?`i;fr t„ �yt ��Y` , � des,=` y ,3,'."."y< ----- • e,',$, lz.;S• "t''-'._< • �-
Y /A'
S �, L W l{ A C
�w' (4 � � �` "_` "ih��'d Sys x� � J' `-j • �P �F�'r ' �,i' ;� �'
[�L rq r� c ! i'�..� 3.A 4' tti, .e�. }t ', {+ �• I
1'
i.
a -: �cs ) y1 t 1
�'aK&Yvk,'� if}r. t' ' `-`. ,. $'I<,�a . r j,a ff kT''s :.i' n'r`� e•i_ .. \
3
•r, r� T "mad vv` y. � �, 4., a 3 r.3 1 -vs •" --�.
' ." 4 S _ ,•1..W yd+r .{ ep yip l�- �2 -".
fed.' '...z+r. i.1 e a 1S a''`-a —Ai f v 'x'•r ,g�, d+p' S °` e l
4�..cc ty.� L 3., r 3+
� �`N'y'• 3� " yu r Qu.-� S s5 �'Gam` t,i4 b '4 :.„y.�,a,F,s 5 -'6�' �,"� ri�
a` , 3• yN "� ,'S�S'i ti t „;o 3 a i 1 ;a �:,t °'t S1 '" x p.`��,,, "� ,.4
.. y i''R 5,,..L$: gt g i' .J�Y'.��F�.a'r� yp•�Pr +� rt 'c trl,y�H $ --1 z"t��1.��'" `r 4 fit* •�'„ \,...,
'r.•' S"t F'F,,,. ,: " ,4 a. h', sw y' hri" 4. —, 4wM `.+' 0' -
eS,. .r4.p< ,. `: t` rt `' %r ' 'r t• .7.rTM# 31:::�F:tS r# a "� '� - t `
,.:fir' ''y t ` Sz .,w.-W,[�. „}��r: y' 4{ -.iK +I¢ �•;? ; '° s•W. ,l" i..•eti".5 .r
�. '.'�.oih tit }��+ P+1���5� � µ� '; :�`J'.." va �•t. r:`
� �t th Alrae#4°
�'�y- � t t.��'S�^�C;�. ��f �, �q� t +.k �iaa 'Mt�,s�� C{ � ,.° } t r„di � s+,�r �"+s v��9r�6`k�r�'t..,,, �s� � u- ;'�° � ;.a 'x� {yr,,
„� ,t '! Gr •�..-0,y.vk,'3ji,52i ps ,� •`.j t•r st1"°a s '; h tF
E .Lf � �,� w. s ✓ it� i 4. f 'i �
F1::..1:oilptift,'7"- ,_ 4 .4.----'--
��.� rs Y d.+st �t '�:}�? �+ ��`" - . s'^t^' +m�a � s r t� t `�``
d ,,, 1 ,• •Ye , s sr dj tprl} iy 1 t 'ate -C£ �I
Af,
r 'ig:••,P, .a.... 1 liv.,,,,,-.$e,--:..?p.".., ---,:=1,,4.2„V4-•, , 4,1'4, w-•,.,,,,,j;is„,:...N-65f--.'s1**-,4",---),-,--;„1',t,„.e,—..
'i 1 i t 1 ,h L `q s r '��S",` ,.,,
v ,- rk y-stt �4. art, < 4ry 4 a.1
Photo 5
t
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Page9of13
ti. �. ,,�,tt ro
.A. — �r y � ^• nr� "ram ,',,`, ?
Rja a.•t 1"e`{
^v. A" S-.% � a p 4� ( ,� Y a c x. - ^1 +.TK�:Y- f L � 3t « � r fw .a,.,- iF °=. i ` ', £"� bi s ~ti ^ Pf xf G* ' v �" ' '`-.±.A.s==.4,4ri4"V '` ; T, o , r _
•••'�y^ 'FG3z ` • Z ` 'r-'a 't"r4-i+, w ,s ' '"'`" '�wpnb� y -
Jt.
�. 1G� ry.� • \-
v]Y �z 3 ,`t4 i t�`'%- ' .�' 4--av `mod ejD �014 V -'t„i• `�`•' t't _want
t • �_oc .a�yrs ,,ss�. ,� tar}: 'q-derd»a3: -rg•. ?rt^�,"Y' ...y�.. .. 'r�,,.,J .�1< K
• •
•
y j ��.. ''.,`',.-" ,. ,t .*^a-.V.0l a i' �, : �.� "' t .. t„-. " fit, -',
,� � 4 :iM.*'•''d` L .«,y .• i� y4 1`, to .. .y,
•
y . ,� — tg
^� c 'haw.` -, ,,. t' -"*— ' r % AZ - $ , < '. r-
iv'- fi r "�+'' ,.•---.'rcv 4. d' �. 11yt Y,� r',r '1' -
,.''' `, A.._- ,tzat t -S y s .w: • 5:A. 1;r .3.A^� ✓i, aid4 , # ., 1i',.. 'y ti
�� -;4 ,, ... 4 `• «,�S ,'S• ¢] .ae, 3 _5 e ��c • e:�.1 ,i�•.�. Y- r o--
1�' ,,;�r�'U�e a , as .'''r , a'";°" L •••: '7' �+ ., I _ t r ,r:v r C •
It 4 '� t sr- T��, c..3as'R' + e¢ 'o ?
]�az."+yam ff[ fc^ • 9 � .`11.-ttVa• t rfj c +
��JjFY A� 1l ! ]> � ; YYa Y-•r s s? -yam` 'r c:+r+ 'E d!�F a ,r- :]tN �., 3
w 6,4',- �, +. df'`1= `[ f,,,j� A. <t L..r,U E a'` 3r�,'.••". 7 •- a ^ '"r x}?d'''" :''�' N.
•
ti Al.4, it
• .'4 t
•
� mo t ' r . _„" a dY � str tStY c-K, S `~ A ` , fl r ,, 1.� t 46 r ` J +p}
Photo 6
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Page 10 of 13
��rt y�P 9trk Al,54• 1 t,ti - ,(4., :' t , 3:a4 n y gl Y c ,,,..4., s:,e•r - Tr r't,��y ,
i fli �. b !�i r r F : .fir !#k74, `3e t` ti. .
aI.
•
' .a.'
s "i, � xx> r. x L ly
, ,mow _ ':� .� f
ii�4t A..'' ✓.ys^.+._t d.�S'�'+°ma i SiT.Wr`.a`'e�, ,y x�y 5 1`
rd`n''y n-• �KfZ y 31 •
i
f
i K
a'k. *7ra r e ''-
d#� " . ,y`.r'' '+ .s,i;V-, , r.� ;.w c a , -' ' v 3k,-e„ h ' . w ,� kr,--xR,y '"r* 'aS .„- x2` ' w,,,N. - r 1\•P .:r • �Kt d oi 1; t+ q s9 . Yb ;�t3 v a `,
_
•
,i - 4 f„< 7y S r.r v a#,ii i•i ftr Ire.'�bafi & tr r g-�sk' . � 4 .1,`F R. . • ax ' r "�Y�4t I'�,. 0 1u S {7 b= -� La �.I, k T ' F „:y`q--,t�J E yY„ Ft;'r3 "Sy `±"^�,„ o,- "7 � c „- y , ,-Ly
3.
`�lv �S� --, u' x 1 � 14 -,lW' Ti. t-a �$ { .x . .. . y,a ,� 4fs . ,' " ! 2s4{ tl3:' i„.„"AC� :, :r,'--`," t { ta r, �',riiiirAhl f. ?` J i � ' ryJ F p .0.} t -. 1 `W4). w ,6 aINFo r ,, N .p�} 3 4 y 11I;z�� sY,, e , "S ,cjad'gC. adi$$1 4Y G r. � 7 " N �} ' hk"„ ,tiS1�.' r .s: C A 4. 'w Vb '` t+°Iet �Q, � Y y; d I t�. ^wyo,- ... ,' o IIf av t: { � e S .r `' � i\ ��x > � 4 .". r' k tl 4 e1AR }*V � r � . w �. 7 +� ju� iv y2„;*, � } y 1v." h t��' re� L�J {� ! .. rfh"*, , a?a Yr � Vtr .'��' r t ' r v � oxi � � 1, gII ry � , ,,L ✓ .4 g . lvi ..Aik.' fif: �L, 4 .Ii.";✓_ S�, °6�ivv4 _ ��TF .^.1@ � 1.:. �,tfiLi,,Mv...e + r�Y �Y v.Photo 7
Mr. Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019
Page 11 of 13
1 �
L
.1 F : [i ti \�t, I , 1 +4 (,
1ti- ._ ,+ C i y xi't� r ', (s rg `14'c, ! .'`
d 41.E r ,� I ,'i i _ `ri ''• I ��� }' ,'Ie.1`..sY ,�k`lrrttt� .
• J � i _ i_. y1.'— .< S c s r¢ ri
^� —
.. � . ' ! r ;7 y � ^. J y
µme!
.r . , j.T•4a .. JS -- j �, triV at ° , 1 4417: l -; ,, z4
4,1k
• .�yt .r Q` i O r . -•"'r` "{� +'l ) yZ3.tt -,' " :„ < � - _.Y� & w i < J 4 A . Y 2.- y_S ,r,,. •. S p. -P. D• Tik.. y(3i * - .� -r� °» t ` l + � � \` t/ u1,„� .. I
a }e-;E YtTf`a. 7 • G 4✓ .A "1 z.'., }. �:V.a `�`SFa _1yA `rY' L - .1 11
, X �,�•r ; i i t';i�'- , � -0.- t `ih - : ' i -• r.. .7" _J—'1**-0 :„ l" ��-f ' *o . . n 4
:,---t--V17-1----;--_,-A-..;:it....-;,_.:zite:4*•:•vz4,,,...v.rs..*.•,,,,..,..,.; . , uler.„ 7 ,,,i'dr., ••••,.. ,..--,--- /7-, .0..r,. .,- ...- . -.:-.7.-_- - 1: .-.....‹,c•
.:�� • � 4-,,k- R , _ hri -,mod �.. r . _ ',t"}- a' 4 .Yr .' `i.
6S raX�i : �4 '' t•$ s `r f ,attGi6i 'wad= �, [• `4 r4 nr �• "7 X 1
�xa�'t*-Y �s„�l�J `� .1 "ram a :t,w-"T-_ . Si e: �,�,� ,cam �` , �c
N �' .y.'.-ice 4y•,rr. - :,C 1.f' I '
y _ ° ✓' •
.k' - r..t •, r+iaJ1'. id.. ♦ ps" s.='"e
�• fJ r r .. `"'• £a Y r-'�11.C._ fie J t-1 .11%,1 t.' -: - '°� ---
�aa
��«o o�^ a °' i �,L,L,x'�.��52�.t"i'` '` < 1 , !cy°e+'9.4 t.,t x�+p.;;kr *tX�,
•
• #';14.11"-C.12%,0.x.'.4,'.* ' - '''.-"' rttc,.......11Z:3. ;1,1' g: '
•i• .� f .ram.r.i f C' 7 \ r
i .<
Photo 8
Mr.Willie Harrison
NOV-2019-DV-0114
2/26/2019 .
Page 12 of 13 •
•
z..;, •Y Tom- 1� ct,- >.7• tG 44 `. '• µ - ,
i� , .sir ,. ` dY •
LF) ..¢ d7%} Ra.- 7J''L
•1 .i:--t-L'+`�',tyriD .t of ' ;
•
{' ,;.•, K-7 't i yr ^ ,.,+,N .. ,,.. � j T �v .-o
Y •';',ry•- y --t-t .�L 'F. .- 7 Y"k`! ' '1✓ `- b4f - r 3 1 .'X.:�"„
AA
sty, -`~ r$_' ,� 3 E,r� r 'F -•C• r -qe, S6 4 . 4 i t•
`ma' " � ' ar r .- t€ - x ' �^ Sr s
","' .;4 q A'T,"> _l'Y fla"a � '..p -fi- , _,,,,, ?. ,,r v e�m`� •--.-, yq O
. am 4- —7.0-w,,a iIk 4• • ` I, a ..ef: • +„ Li,,,, -,
-,'Y -:rM t ` r .' •'$�.".a
•• s q.,w 'c',:wa <Yr a, pbr,., . r •Nqi 'W �!
'• � 4 . : • ..-+N s, 4. i ma's- �L 11rr r, < JfF d.' Ct : ia ", -fp � s1 .µ ,-
lm ,.: • ,ors, i,,_
';1-4-.45:,-- -11".. -•:.7. ,-.''';,:,. -i:,,'-1. %,*-..,. ..-.4i,,t.'-‘4* =' -
4.,;.,, ..4,-'.:,.:4-0.:,t4.„..#„„:".1...,..:::',.`,, ,,,,-.......„;::‘,,tiini.;:-.4.14":,,'_1;:::4:: 4.w,„"41,,,,.-• . .
PX
&r` .R'', ^r"•d n ".a}4.'f�' „".0 x '', .<.. tCt,.. �^,' ,t'J �• 1- 3•`, s..
,-,,. ,�? ,?.,. r {t'�.y� t.`yU��4 15�. '� S - ;ram
l Y 7` �-;., ,yg�j .i• •'t�'S ",`�t5�.a, 1. �^'t.°' .r .X,Y,-� �yN a.,-
/i 9.v ..fl '3 , ' '�t saw. ,, '.4. .r, ,". x ,r �a.�.
•
rri 'C
>
1 •
`°� W .t • • � ' •f,w� �. yl `_{_,,e4 � ,,rt 0,"=* yA, 4 r ` c4.7A � a, )1��., -. . z.~ ♦ rf‘ .r{ • ' '§
-i. ...1tiQPtt* rk •4-s 'f.. J . - " s . `,n.Y�'am� .
Photo 9
Mr. Willie Harrison
NOV-20 19-DV-0 1 14
2/26/2019
Page 13 of 13 -
j }� zs A
,Ir ).Yj#I x; t h5 ' N•t^' r,, .3� i '�:T1 a '4F '1. .''y >.Y N° '7A,Ni•`_
iI
lb� }n 11 r t. 'in
� �°4 rt `�I e• yr� yS>a r 1[y4� �; � :.j YYI.r.�.ti..-.r.L.�.itu .a;�}���r/Pe�'i.�1.5 -�':c.Srt'�,.�.1�;��L ! •d
;� • t 'f 4 °`i Its , - ti atk
'N' N 4 Y 9Y{.}N It Y t: -. rt �' y: (i/• 3c 4 y�
t -s : ! �.�w 7.-t.`"'t,- •.. a. )7 c` ! c -c +,�/ 1 s 1 s,�Gw ! ' t
r F1,v�r •.Y+ t °' ��j r-"'`- z - 4; r, r1L r • \ 1. 5 i ��y.^, '• S -
•
t; .:, a --- r r 1 y•'+r^-+,^k •t•ts. ,,,,:' la\j,� Ys 4 '1_
,41
`,yr,rL,+�' '-', >, ' r�.4 s ..: ' fpa +�-. F + 443 iSp p 2 .=;; .a 1. of
ti i ,.. , ,k t�' > '�Y t'*, '� i '"n ••
.•' ,I i ,. •:�'tl 7•ti" •P 4,., .1 z � ' to Ta ''
4b,,J•t+.rr.9t� � � � N t � � � Y � < ,� ;��,�� N �. � It
.t rLa�` 2"2 fi�3 ',5 0.+.'4:e,':J F s I [ir sa I l�- t s„
A.b t}ty+,�`, + .+ �j� ��♦ N k �,+ y 4 -,a j�7'r/^ ^4ro7y�..ks ,rr�v "5 7`t + ,.j. e..• .L,• �' fa ,/4.-,,,Y.,
S�df }'r"` r� I d I. ` �X }1. • �?t x t1'Vol
/�n ♦•y44«ri \ �,7 t'X, 1 - 7"�' 4,-;- �" -- y- r��.s + h ... s +
it r, •r i'1@ / n`• ..a<,,,,,,,,,,,..40 �,�f' �• y_ ,a.•• R,,,:H ¢ ,�,I,r>*�+•o-;�„ �i 11 7 \U:3y+ `h
...y �'` ` v��-a� .x��+., �.�/�'a`ifi 'fir=, I is x 6 ,cif' i��s{����. by � �, t< �...r'`u'�4'}ir�{
.,' e*: .s i f1; .' Jl�'S"';�r'�`�li n �1 dC7" ������+,,,,yyyy7 R.1♦ „r �4r �,"!� iNe tY1
.( .,tee r'2 r r t i+,. !la 4 —<� '`'. Y,�,'rt , -„
'?r�3x""7h! ✓ I
a. .:V � .1""�^ N..r j( s t e .-,TZ1.•`Mffiy4�c4,/
"'�'3Gey • ��. b+4^M4 x3- w' i+ h,•7{ aN.t. r.
'`� < '�t� 7 tit�� s.
-�• tr s a •
.r + +si �✓t: F 44, R`' �'N 1y-�, (nk'e' y,. ,S fi
'i e s'y e. *s 11 � 11.1, ft �1 + }^'� ''+d rf '1�,' T.
' '?. r ,V � 1,1 i r1;'r r ' i . '' ' t
...,
74
r},, ..!1/"J/•! SFr;f!y C�gJ-yx,." ,,' ( 11, A re ,'l Z,ail
r I ;'1 C� d+t�4•,?%a `, 04,1,
/r •� .=f?' �ii y f4 p“/.. l:„=?,,,,,v e y A�i N, _
�.`f 4.� \ r. *& lr r� v ,%,,�, - f r !rl•'S° aA�.
Y 1
1,j!'dj' ; :• +Ir*-3 3v�l +} •t urrt r v ,,P r't ,fir...' r ;'+ f' .0•1' 1( .: /• :
014
47
01,
,A.,_d
♦ 'l.,if- 1,0 h'-yy ���� S'1.t `�)'�'� \ t y+i ,, r♦",''/)'�1 5},F vy c ��l,r}♦1j ��.
�.1 wln• 1 C,x'� zg 4, ,d 4:,, „'�. 71.. • +1 t� a sxJ,.f:,..:
Photo 10