The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About20190177 Ver 1_B4828 13-08-0047RevisedSignedEffectsForm_20190209�'G°�R��`�� .. .�,� � , ,},,;, : � � 1 �._ su�:,.,��r Projeet Tracki��g No. (I�iLernal Use� 13-08-0047 iZevis�d la� ll- I� HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS FORM Tnis form only pertains to Historic Architecture aiid Lar�dscapes ;or tr�is prcject. It is not valid for Archaeological Resources. You must consult separately with the Archaeology Group. PRn.TF("T iNFnRMATinN Project No: B-4828 County: Vance WBS No.: 38598.1.2 Docuinent Type: Fe�l. Aid No: BRZ-1526(4) � Funtling: State X Federal Fe�leral X Yes ❑ No Permit NWP Permit(s : Type(s): ProiectDescription: Repla�e Bridge No. 56 on SR 1526 (Weldon Mill Road) over Sandy Creek (off-site detour, no improvements) SUMMARY OF HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES REVIEW Descri�tion of review activities, results, and conclusions: HPOWeb reviewed on 17 September 2013 and yielded one SL (Weldon's Mill (VN0035), one DE (Bridge No, 56), and no NR, LD, or SS properties in the Area of Potential Effects (APE). The APE extends 700 feet from either end of the existing bridge (N-S) and 150 to either side of the SR 1526 (Weldon Mill Road) centerline to encompass all proposed construction activities. Vance County current GIS mapping, aerial photography, and tax information indicated a partly wooded APE and residential properties dating mostly the 1970s-2000s (viewed 17 September 2013). The APE intersects a large parcel on which stands the study-listed, nineteenth-century Weldon's Mill (VN0035), located to the west of SR 1526 (Weldon's Mill Road) on the south bank of Sandy Creek. Constructed in 1949, Bridge No. 56 is an 81-foot-long, two- span, steel, girder and floorbeam structure recommended as eligible for the National Register of Historic Places (NR) by the NCDOT Historic Bridge Survey. The presence of the nineteenth-century mill, as well as the absence of a comprehensive architectura I survey for the county indicated the need for a field investigation and evaluation. NCDOT engaged Dovetail Cultural Resource Group to prepare a NR eligibility evaluation of the Weldon's Mill property, and the resultant report (April 2014) confirmed its eligibility and recommended defining boundaries. The North Carolina State Historic Preservation Office (HPO) concurred with the eligibility finding, but suggested revised (reduced) boundaries, subsequently accepted by NCDOT (see attached correspondence and map). In 2016, as the project design advanced, NCDOT and HPO revisited the eligibility recommendation for Bridge No. 56 and agreed that it is neither technologically nor aesthetically significant and only one of many examples of a common standard design (as also stated in the Historic Bridge Survey records). Following consultation with planning and design engineers, NCDOT - Historic Architecture scheduled discussion of project effects on the Weldon's Mili property for April 4, 2017. Property Name: Sacrvey Site No.: ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS Weldon's Mill Status: DE VN0035 PIN.� 1054302003 Effects �No Effect � No Adverse Effect ❑ Adverse Effect ta.-ti1� �� His�oric �irchiiecnu�c n�u( Lcrndscnpes f7�7�7:Y'7S,4SSESShILNl'Jorni Jo�� A4ina� Trnn.��pnrtnliun Prnjects a.c Oimli/ied fn lhe 2007 Progro�mm�6c Agreei�+un. Page 1 of 2 L�i Explanation oiEffects Deterrr�ination: �11 �� o s�a,. �a-y�S-i-Y� c-�'"��- o�+ �v ��' �'� s w i{ 1 o c ccl�r w �-�-in. ih `�-�•,¢- �erx i s� �,� Ro �«M-� o v-�-s i d e, Ce�.s-� o-�� -��n�e. �n,i�-�-��'' i�. b aund a�- .'�x i5�-I�►�-�, �v � ld-i v��s a�vt� s-E-Yucivre s� acce sS �o�� l t/�e- �fo�7b�� d o �j�l,�, er � avv. �l. e.. -F��'e.s cu � Y I Y`eV►�a� v�. �vld i S�✓bea• �e }� mra r P ed� ��a� b Y � d � I� a�� bQen �relo co�.-I-ed -Fo �-I�-� s��i �l� o� s�2 ��a6 C�l�n M�`i� Ru� . List of Environmental Commitments: � ,81^/a� �. Y7�t / �i Yt O� �/`f � " �rd v�ol Ore oY, �si d� �i`// .�u.�s ,bo�--1-� e.�� %iNeerih al o�eS �� Go�-C,�N S• /� � C/ �J �yrr✓�Yi`d� ��'' Gt�l aS fi i-r Gi.1 i l�t me �t f'oT I�eW ,d r�}c� �`t a.5 ,6��J� eS�a b��,�ti e d�'v ��.cc�� f�'� o� �j �a�►-� v!, rr�we v� reme �r fs �J/c� i h cv rsi'o,� � n��l�-e- h i`s �r� c r! e r�L-- �G�r� �'a e vnavoi'�la,bl� curr��l c��e� v�/��! � I �c v o T-� s�� r^i"� /,�rch i"f'e � re_ H,vS� b� i K�d rm e�1 �c� d � f-ib� a.l e�G�s co�szl!-�afr`d� �i �t ffPO a��FHt�vf} vn�er� . tlDec.2o1$— /�1oe c. A v os'¢��en ��i' ��e�l �o � s`�l@ u/e!�l�n�iJ FHWA Intends to use the Stat H storic Preservation Office's concurrence as a basis for a"de minimis" finding for the following properties, pursuant to Section 4(f�: SUPPORT DOCUMENTATION ve �Z. i l � � � / �� L��'1�� X Map(s) ❑Previous Survey Info. Photos X Correspondence Design Plans Technical report and photographs on file NCDOT - Historic Architecture FINDING BY NCDOT AND STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE Architecture and Landscapes -ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS ,--_ � � n NCDOT Architectural Historian State Historic Preservation Office Federal Agency Representative ve �.,../T7"'_ Date "�'T'% Date /� Date B-4828, Vance County, Tracking No. 13-08-0047 Hi.sroric Archireclure nnd /.midscnpes IsFFIC%S ASSIiSSiL1/:NT form jor Minor Transpor�n�ion Projecis ns Ounlified in !he 2007 Nrogrm�u�ralic Agreemenr. Page 2 of 2 �� r�-k�►,� No , G3- d8' - oo �{ �- .. , J . � �� .,. } � ' � � J nf h 89�; .�� `' t y � . � � ; Y d� i � � � � �€ rs � {�� r i` � � Legend f� �� , r �,�,�1,�`�• .��r .� ;; � +� � «�, ,� � � . � , .�� _,� �- �, .� + �, � �` .� ��:�t ,� � � B-4828 Study Area a . �` � � �� '- ��F: � '� � Proposed ROW ,`..� ;�:� �<� . �°;�`.�r:.�' � � - `�:. �` Y�: � �` • r , Previous Study Area ` e� ` a � I� '� � t ;``� `�!�� y �� `' y ti � � y L � J .Y. ,� � : � � � � Y,r� ��W : '� � ..� `"��+�.� — � �`� e:� rA T�. 'f+! ' u�w' � .F" S 1 r,`, f � t��, � y . �., t� � �, �'� , � 1 E � � � �, � , j �f� � Y` �1 �i� �:' �a ° + �'� �x � +'y�*{� �t �: �. ��'��s,, �♦" �; � T � � �.YJ� .�... �� s� ��'.. 4,. ��5�'1"� .e� '�/�� ..�. . . �i`�� x �� ' � � � i ( : ? <�� y. 1 . � yi }�, . ., . . y DR�� ; fi ��t " •.� 1�../l' � 'd�l d; � p �^ � t- '� �� -�� ,� � � �s �� k» � �� 3 . � �} - j/��'1 �'^� u�' r . t�`A'_ : � a . `' , 't j � tiY �.y � ;� �� '1 { ,`. > > i 3 ,. y 4�. (� � � f � �t a 4�'� - ; �' xe fi � '�.,j 8�y��1'j :e `�'��Y � �� :. . 1 � ��y ��fy �� . � , .. .. � �y�,rQ � �y{ _ +y��p �� -�� - .1.��95a,r : ,. /. '<n��3't�:..ri�.b��f' "'� i�1i� ... .��, f 4.i�� ,f+A��.� . �J6 y'�=� 7.i- a.4�. � 1"'�t`� �r i� . . R'�. .r+� � ,� � . a � � � �. ;: � ,��y �� t � � „ �. � �. ��t.- p .. F:�� J � � � �� .1 . �. ,• �f�: �r� ��, W �$`, . •�4` '�?f� yc-.&- '� L��Yy�� ,�. �r �.�1 .. . rJ ��. A .#�. Nt ��lM� � .`?I _.•iS} a� ��'f �.€ � .�:.' ; � +��- �� , j�*'��': r . ' �i�= ��, }"e.. ' �s. � :# ' " � � f � ' " � , �E , � `��`� �'�. �� ,�'� � • � �' � �P�� y r t. _ ��r ;'_�' � , f `� �"' � ` i� ,� , �� ,. �. � � . ; d'�: 3 � �� ;'�i'y ��• i._ �'d �i.... Y4 R,Y�'�.�� .�� x��'.�a:�:: � _i ta7,.4 .t�f�� P f. �r - � .w �r, � . S't �j �'.1 �{'� "� f• ��'� � � nY t� 4� 33}�r�� 'fR � t '� - x i.,�� .1. �� ' � �� ^ . I �� _ �-�.. k '� � � ( � .�� `� �; ` � .. � h� � �. t f'. � t . �� :�� 1�' ,��. �� '� 7? � . F + ,��Q�Sr �fli'R�>4 r � ,.i ' ��;'4s ;.? `� ,. .;� � �%' �pr� � �� a °� ;,*� �y'�"�� s ,y`.�� di"'�►� �v �� w:, I , � "� � � ` ,.' t.,, t ��`',�{ �,r „r �+� . a� '4 ��{� `. ,R., � , o t �1 � . �, � a � t' S�� , � ;� i� � � � �' � �� pw , -��' � �sw� � � �i � �`�� ,• � ��, � i _ ty.� Y ,,,r� � � �+� � �':: y �` �:+ '�'. '7,Y_ .'k �,"�-,'''� U •fX'f}a° � �'i�' 4 �+i�'. ��<,� . rh � ,_� ��-�.. . �,� . .� `� �'_� � a�..� �.�,��rF�'�'°�_>..��"�Y,� •i,��,�r :i �� i- - a; ..��,-�;a. ,� 7e t�- .. 4�. ��' i t , .�;� Vl?��y � %�, � � �� s Y �� '� A � � � � . . ' � � ' , � j ,�� >� ",S, .,, sg � � � �;1 � ��` �.� � ��. � � ��,� ,� �. 1� � � '��. ,�'��.� f �� y s �. `. � �3 .. - �� .. � b� r►� .�j � • � 2 � �$;� �.� _ � a ! �� 4 ,. �, X_a �y s . . � N� �"'�' �� . s+ (,��j �!" i # k^ � , . . � r .� � � � �:�� ,� 'M � '�+ir � '� .�, #,J� .� � . ` � � z'� � tE��a�S � � �� - # " � �� . ��.�� .�..� f�� "� �� . a .�` q� •,.��"'� . �� ,; , � � ,,��' r r t'� , � . � ` . . .-. � . ' �` � . r N "` .. � " E �� 'e.� �.s ��s_ i r+ �� i- � € r 7�'i'as{ �. � ,�F .. { ,t . � �� .• � � ••t�� t�t� � �§ ,- _ �`t ��# ��st � ��i�" ? M� .�� ,�1� .. a. .1`��.,* � ` s + , It�� ' ri,; � , -� ��,g 'a � ,�;. `u. �: �� • '� �:;�; �Il � i�` :�� :: ��' � y�". ', �; s , � � ; l�� j �r .�� X �_ ��" , � � f � y+ r , �: . . ' , � ��T1 '-•��;�� i � �� M 4 � •� � � .1 \ . � ff�' - ♦ # ' �.'� y�'r R � �t', t £� �.. � � #� `�y �`, �t ,� � ...+, *,�� r,. �,f "i,�� t k '� , � � � n �.'� hh�-_ �'�` � { � � ... �{ ,1 � f,� �,"" �� "_� �w . ' .� ' .� �� .�� (: ,'j. .,, + ♦ � Y � {:� �;Fs,�� °��' �ro- 1 _ f Y � i� �` j+ M � 4 � _71.'} � i � � f . � .c. � � q �. Map Created: November 2018 Oata Sources: NCDOT GIS Unit, NC OneMap, ESRI, STEWART �� r�m_ � � '-:� � � �� .�� ST E WA R T 0 250 500 eet �� ra ��NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ° DIVISION OF HIGHWAYS �_�� DIVISION 5 BRIDGE NO 56 REPLACEMENT WELDONS MILL R CHURCH RD. (SR 1526) VANCE COUNTY TIP PROJECT B-4828 STUDY AREA , FIGURE 2 �;,�Na . �3�0$--ooy�- Revised Proposed National Register Boundary Base map: Vance County GIS, 2013 Aerial, nts NCDOT — Historic Architecture September 2014 B-4828, Tracking No. 13-08-0047 Weldon's Mill (VN0035) Vance County :� ��i, i� � ''', 'I ,It ..��;;a . IGu��``\`\\ :; �� ,, ..•'- j;. North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources State Historic Preservation Office Ramona n4. Bartos, Ad�nitiistrator Governor Pat McCrory Secretary Susan Kluttz l��ay 23, 2014 IviEMORANDUM TO: Vanessa Patrick Human Environment Unit NC Department of Txansportation FROM: Ramona M. Bartos �•��"�`� Officc of tlrchives and History Deputy Secretary Ket•in Cherry SUBJECT: Historic Structures Survey Report for the Replacement of Bridge 56 on SR 1526 over Sandy Creek, B-4828, Vance County, ER 14-0938 Thank you for your May 6, 2014, memorandum transmitting the above-refexenced report. We have reviewed the document an offer the following comments. Despite the poor condition of the mill and the lack of information on the interior, we concur that Weldon's Mill (VN0035) is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C as a rare surviving example of a late nineteenth-/early twentieth-centuiy grist mill in Vance County and even the larger northern piedmont region of the state. The description of the property covers several subsidiary resources, but it is not until the last paragraph (p. 20) that their contributing/noncontributing status is addressed. We do not believe that the miller's cottage or store contribute to the property due to extensive alterations. Since a pexiod of significance is not proposed, we assume it would extend to the mid-1960s. Consequendy, it is unclear why the mid-twentieth-century shed (dated to third quarter of the twentieth century) and shed are deemed noncontributing. There is no justification given for including the entire parcel of 35.9 acres. Two mill ponds are mentioned. The larger pond, closer to the mill, has been largely silted in over the last few decades. Given that there is no discussion of either pond (and, in particulat, no explanation of the role of the smaller pond at the southwest edge of the property), there appears little reason to include the entire parcel. Also, there is a small "leg" diat extends south to SR 1541, Faulkner Road, which might have been an access, but based on aerials, now appears irrelevant. We would recommend a boundary that cuts off that "leg" and ends at the west end of the eastern pond or, for even smaller boundaries, draw the western edge in a north-south line crossing the east end of peninsula that now fills most of the eastern pond, or (smallest) draw a square to include only the mill, dam, and some of the pond (first 75 yards, approximately). ��e will look forward to your response to our comments and a map that clearly outlines the boundaries that you wish to consider eligible. Location: 1D9 East Jones Strect, Raleigh NC 27G01 Mailing Address: 4Gt7 Mail Sen•ice Center, Raleigh NC 27G'J9-4Gi 7 Telephone/Fax: (919) 807-(,57U/807-(599 The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with Section 106 codified at 36 CFR Part 800. Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the above comment, contact Renee Gledhill-Eatley, environmental review coordinator, at 919-807-6579 or r.enee.gledhill- earlev�a.iicdcr.gov. In all future communication concerning this project, please cite the above referenced tracking number. cc: Mary Pope Furr, NCDOT M �� 4� �d w � ti � � � �n � �� PAT MCCRORY GOVERNOR To: From: Date: STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTN�NT OF TRANSPORTATTON Renee Gledhill-Earley Vanessa E. Patrick September 9, 2014 ANTHONY J. TATA SECRETARY Subject: 8-4828, Vance County. Bridge No. 56 Replacement, SR 1526 (Weldon's Mill Road) over Sandy Creek. Tracking No. 13-08-0047. ER 14-0938. Thank you for your memorandum of May 6, 2014 conveying agreement with the proposed eligibility of Weldon's Mill (VN0035) for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. We have considered your recommendations for reducing and reconfiguring the National Register boundary originally suggested and wish to employ that illustrated in the accompanying graphic for discussion of project effects on Weldon's Mill. The northern, southern, and eastern boundaries conform to the current parcel lines. The western boundary, as in the second option described in your memo, crosses the "peninsula" extending into the eastern mill pond. The eastern boundary also conforms to the existing right-of-way line on the western side of SR 1526 (Weldon's Mill Road); no critical architectural or landscape features are located within the right-of-way. Should questions arise, please contact me at 919-707-6082 or vepatrick(a�ncdot.qov. V. E. P. Attachment SeN��u �� 9��.�t� MAILING ADDRESS: NC DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PROJECT DEVELOPMENT $� ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS UNIT 1598 MAIL SERVICE CENTER Rn�EicH NC 27699-1548 TE LE PHONE: 919-707-6000 FAX: 919-212-5785 WEBSITE:NCDOT.GOV LOCATION: CENTURY CENTER, BUILDING B 1020 BIRCH RIDGE DRIVE RALEIGH NC 27610 • �i i` . y � °�: ,l� � �.�'�va . .��, � "��P' : ;, �Gu.��..:' ,>; / North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources State Historic Preservation Office Ramona n4. Bartos, Administrator Go��emor Pat McCrory Secretacy Susan Kluttz September 22, 2014 MEMORANDUM TO: Vanessa Patrick Human Environment Unit NC Department of Transportation FROM: Renee Gledhill-Earley '�� Environmental Review Coordinator Office of Archit�es and Hisrory Deputy Secre[ary Ke�tin Cherry SUBJECT: Replace Bridge 56 on SR 1526 over Sandy Creek, B-4828, Vance Counry, ER 14-0938 Thank you for your September 9, 2014, memorandum providing revised boundaries for Weldon's Mill (VN0035), a property that we mutually agreed is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C. We will add the determination of eligibiliry to our recoxds, map the property in our GIS for future reference, and look forward to discussing the effects that the above referenced undertaking may have on the eligible property. The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with Section 106 codified at 36 CFR Part 800. Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the above comment, contact Renee Gledhill-Earley, environmental review coordinator, at 919-807-6579 or renee.gledhill- earle�rt,ticdcr.�ov. In all future communication concexning this project, please cite the above referenced tracking number. cc: Mary Pope Furr, NCDOT Location: lU9 East Jones Strect, Raleigh NC 27G01 Mailing Address: 4G17 niail Sen�ice Centcr, Raleigh NC 27G99-4617 Telephone/Fau: (919) 807-6570/SU7-G599