HomeMy WebLinkAboutDEQ-CFW_00082291MMM
Supporting information includes analytical method description, 8tohles, and 5 figures.
MeiSun 1,c',8|ba» Mark Strvnarl, Az�drevvLind�rmn�,N�i�hac|Dichardoon�Ben
KearnS4 Admn Pickett5, Chris and DcddFLU.
/Department ofCivil and Environmental Engineering
University ofNorth Carolina aLCharlotte
North Carolina 28223,USA
2Department of Civil, Construction, and Environmental Engineering
North Carolina State University
Raleigh, North Carolina 27695, USA
»Nbhona| Exposure Research Laboratory
U.S. Protection Agency
Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27711, USA
4Cape Fear Public Utility Authority
Wilmington, North Carolina 28403, USA
oTovvnofPiMeboro
Pittsboro, North Carolina 27312, USA
o Fayetteville Public Works Commission
North Carolina 283O1,USA
*Corresponding Author Email: msun8(0uncc.edu; Phone: 704-687-1723
Page I of 12
OEQ-CFVV_00082291
Analytical standards: PFASs studied inthis research are listed bnTable S1. For legacy PFASs,
native and isotopically labeled standards were purchased from Wellington Laboratories
(Guelph, Ontario, Canada). Native PPPrOPzAwas purchased from Thermo Fisher Scientific
(Waltham, M/\). Noanalytical standards were available for other PB8CAs.
PFAS quantification: PPAS concentrations in samples frorn DWTPs and adsorption tests were
determined hyliquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (L{-Mg/w&S)using alarge-
volume 0.9mDcirect'ection method. An AgilentllOOSeries LC pump and PESciesAPI
3OOOLC-MS/M5system equipped vvidha4.6rnms5OnnnHPLC cokomun/|{inchcsCl@5pn
lOO` Phenomenex Inc.) was used for PFAS analysis. The eluent gradient is shown in Table S4
in SI. All samples, calibration standards, and quality control samples were spiked with
isotopically labeled internal standards, filtered through 0.45-p.m glass microfiber syringe filters,
and analyzed in duplicate. The MS transitions for PFAS analytes and internal standards are
shown in Table S5 in SI. The quantitation limit (QL) was 25 ng/L for PFOS and
perfhzorodecomoic acid,i and 1OnvfL.for other legacy PB/\Ss and PPPr(}Pz/\. The ()Lvvao
defined as the first point of the standard curve, for which the regression equation yielded a
calculated value within ±3O% error. For P98CAsvvithouL analytical standards, chromatographic
peak areas are reported.
PP/\S concentrations along the treatment train of[XyVTPCwere analyzed using aWaters
/\ronitvuhra performance Unnk1 chromaLog7onh interfaced with aWaters C)uattroPremier XB
triple quadrupole mass spectrometer (Waters, Milford, LMA, USA) after solid phase extraction.
Method details are described elsewhere.' The ()Lfor all PF/\Sy with analytical standards was
O.2nF/L,and peak areas were recorded for pFBC/\awithout standards.
Page 2 of 12
Table SI. Perfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) detected in the Cape Fear River (CFR) watershed
Perfluorocarboxylic acids (PFCAs)
................................................................................................................................................................................................. ........................................... .............................................. ..................................................
...........................................................
..........................................................
Perfluorobutanoic acid (PFBA)
214.0
C4HF702
375-22-4
3
4
Perfluoropentanoic acid (PFPeA)
264.0
C5HF902
2706-90-3
4
5
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA)
-------------------------------------------
314.1
---------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------
C6HF1102
-----------------------------------------------------------
307-24-4
---------------------------------------------------------
5
6
Perfluoroheptanoic acid (PFHpA)
364.1
C7HF1302
375-85-9
6
7
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA)
-------------------------------------------
414.1
----------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------
C8HF1502
-----------------------------------------------------------
335-67-1
---------------------------------------------------------
7
8
Perfluorononanoic acid (PFNA)
464.1
C9HF1702
375-95-1
8
9
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Perfluorodecanoic acid (PFDA)
--------------------------------------------
514.1
---------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------
C1oHF1902
-----------------------------------------------------------
335-76-2
---------------------------------------------------------
9
10
..........................................................
Perfluorosulfonic
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------
..............................................................................................................................................................
acids (PFSAs)
---------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------
..........................................................
---------------------------------------------------------
Perfluorobutane sulfonic acid (PFBS)
300.1
C4HF9SO3
375-73-5
4
5
Perfluorohexane sulfonic acid (PFHxS)
400.1
.............. ..................................................
C6HF13SO3
...........................................................
355-46-4
.........................................................
6
7
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS)
-------------------------------------------
500.1
---------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------
C8HF17SO3 :
-----------------------------------------------------------
1763-23-1
---------------------------------------------------------
8
9
................................................................................................................................................................................................. ...........................................
Perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids with
................................................ .............................................................................................................. ..........................................................
one ether group (mono -ether PFECAs) .........................................................
Perfluoro-2-methoxyacetic acid (PFMOAA)
180.0
C3HF503
674-13-5
2
4
Perfluoro-3-i-nethoxypropanoic acid (PFMOPrA)
230.0
C4HF703
377-73-1
3
5
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Perfluoro-4-methoxybutanoic acid (PFMOBA)
-------------------------------------------
280.0
----------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------
C5HF903
-----------------------------------------------------------
863090-89-5
---------------------------------------------------------
4
6
Perfluoro-2-propoxypropanoic acid (PFPrOPrA)
330.1
C6HF1103
13252-13-6
:
5
7
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------ : ---------------------------------------------------------
Perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids with multiple ether group (multi -ether PFECAs)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------
Perfluoro(3,5-dioxahexanoic) acid (PF02HxA)
246.0
C4HF704
39492-88-1
3
6
.................................................................................................................................................................................................
Perfluoro(3,5,7-trioxaoctanoic) acid (PF030A)
...........................................
312.0
............................................... ..................................................
C5HF905
......................................................
39492-89-2
4
8
Per fluoro(3,5,7,9-tetraoxadecanoic) acid (PF04DA)
.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
378.1
C6HF1106
............................................... ..................................................
39492-90-5
...........................................................
5
.........................................................
10
Page 3 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082293
Table S2. Operational conditions of DWTP C on sampling day (August 18,2014)
Raw water ozone dose
3.1 mg/L
Raw water total organic carbon concentration
6.0 mg,,,L
Aluminum sulfate coagulant dose
43 mg/L
Coagulation pH
5.70
Settled water ozone dose
1.3 mg,,,L
Settled water total organic carbon concentration
1.90 mg,,"L
Empty bed contact time in
biological activated carbon filters
9.4 minutes for granular activated
carbon layer
2.3 minutes for sand layer
Meditun pressure UV dose
25MJ/CM2
Free chlorine dose
1.26 mg/L asC12
Free chlorine contact time
17.2 hours
Table S3. Water quality characteristics of surface water used in adsorption tests
Table S4. LC gradient method for PFAS analysis
Mobile phase A: 2 mM ammonium acetate in ultrapure water with 5% methanol
Mobile phase B: 2 mM ammonium acetate in acetonitrile with 5% ultrapure water
Page 4 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082294
Tab|cS5. MStransitions for PFAS Analysis
Page 5 of 12
Page 5 of 12
Tab|eS6. Maximum,
minimum, mean and median concentrations
(np/i)ofPPASoa1th,cc
drinking
water intakes.
°Concentrations less than quantitation limits
were considered as
zero to
calculate means
and PFASs.
�Other PFECAs were present inwater samples from community Cbut could not be quantifiedand were therefore not included in
Page 6 of 12
F
0
Cluff
xe OH
PFMOAA
F F F 0
F F F OH
F
PFMODA
F
F 0
F F
0
0-----/, +� "b
/H,
, F
F
PFO2HxA
F / F F \ \ 0 / /r- F F
0
F F F F F
PF04DA 0
F
f
0-
F
OH
F
PFmOprA
PFPrOPrA
rI*UiUA
Figure SI. Molecular structures of PFECAs evaluated in this study
Page 7 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082297
N
Rhvr
mnui.Wy A
N
DIAUP
Deep Mver
Flow direction . .....
..........
Community B DWTP
North Carolina Cape Fear Ili �,er
WA
...........
so
I : ............. Wi 7
................. ... NY
. ............ ........ ...... ........
ta
fu ON . .....
rTk
co KS Mo
.......... VA
......... .............
TU
Az nN OR . ...... .........
AR
AL 0,k
. . . ........ .
TX . . ......... . . ...............
-� for PA C u.',, `., 3
100 km
comn-lunity C
DVV-TP
Figure S2. Sampling sites in the Cape Fear River watershed, North Carolina. The scale is for the
Cape Fear River watershed map.
Page 8 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082298
1200
1000
0)
c
u
c
0 600
cu
c
c(Da 400
c
0
N#
0
Q�Q�pQ�PQ�g Q��e Q��yQ���PQ�pPQ��Pp�®PQ�g pE,
Q�
ma
150
0
®PP��PP�®P� ��P�p p�P�k4�p�
Page 9 of 12
DEQ-CFW 00082299
im
C
0
CU
2000
a)
0
a
Q�Q�OQ(PQ�Qj Q�QO Q��-�,���'QF'`4�®Q`Q�,�Q`Q�,oQ`��Qj ��,�-{.�Q�Q54�®Px��®�
Figure S3. PFAS concentration distributions in the CFR watershed at three drinking water
intakes. Concentrations less than quantitation limits were considered as zero. Upper and lower
edges of a box represent the 75t', and 25thpercentile, respectively; the middle line represents the
median; upper and lower bars represent the 901hand 10thpercentile, respectively; and dots
represent outliers (>90thor <10ffi percentile).
Page 10 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082300
2,5E+07
2,0E+07
S 1, 5 E+07
LOE+07
5,OE+06
2500
2000
1500 19
1000
Vl.
500
. ........... . ............
.............
0
611`15/13 711" -; 0 113 %1`13/13 1 OIQ 21/ 13 12/ 12/13
'00
4,E�07
M e a n #1 om,
400
PFASs
300 �P
is
2,E�07
2,0c
LE4-07
100
'0 0 -----------------------------------------------
..... 0
6/1,5,'13 760."13
911"13/13 Q/ 2 8 3 12VIV13
07
Community C
5,&�-07
al Mean flow
4,E 7
PM ks-
-g, I07
21-�-07
1,E+07
O,E,00 ......................................... ...
6 1/13 7/11/13 7/31/13 8/301,113 91'1"/29/13
6000
5000
4000
C
3000
V�
2000
1000
0
Fig -Lire S4. Total PFAS concentrations in the source water and stream flow at the three studied
DWTPs. Stream flow data were acquired from US Geological Survey stream gage records
Page 11 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082301
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a
80%
60%
.......................
.........
40%
20nX
0%
-20% -----------------
-----------------------------------------------------
--- ----------------
- -- --------------------------------
0
20 40
60 so
10G.
120 140
firne (min)
-4!-PFBA
--?A,-PFPeA
-.--.-,,,PFHXA
-*-PFHpA
-XI PFOA
PF NA
--(>-PFDA
PRS
-*-PFOS
C
60%
40%
20-
-20% -----------------
----------------- -----------------
----------------------------------------------------------
-----------------
0
20 40
60 so
100
120 140
firne (min)
-4-PFSA
-�-PFPeA
-.-.-,,-PFHXA
-*-PFHpA
-\- PFOA
PF N.'A
-<)-PFDA
--O-PFBS
--.:,.-PFHS
-*-PFOS
loc.%
or e
4M,,
2055
-20% A .................
................. T ----------------
T ---------------- T ----------------
T -----------------
----------------- 1 :
0
20 40
60 80
1 or,
120 140
time (min)
--,t,-PFBA
--*-PFPeA
PFHY.A
--X-PFP.[)A
PFOA
PFNA
-<)-PFDA
-*-PFBS
Mix"
--.A-PFOS
—111
SaX.
6M.
4(YX
E
2, OIX
0%
-20%
0
80%
6 W/c.
4 WX
101 2 u
0%
-20%
0
1-11.
801%
6M.
E
0%
-20%
0
20 40 60 80 100 120 140
tittle (min)
-,�!-PFMOPrA -8-PFMOSA PFPrOPrA
--,'�-PF02HxA -0-PF030A PF04DA
20 40 60 so loc) 120 140
time (min)
-*-PFtVI0PrA -0-PFMOBA PFPrOPrA
,>-PF02HxA -G-PFO.30A PF04DA
20 40 60 80 1.00 120 140
time (min)
-4-PFNIOPrA -0-PFMOBA PFPrOPrA
�—PF02HxA -0-PF030A PF04DIA
Figure S5. PFAS adsorption at powdered activated carbon doses of (a, b) 30 mg,/L, (c, d) 60 mg,/L
and (e, f) 100 mg/L. Figures show average PFAS removal percentages of duplicate tests.
Reference
1. Nakayama, S.; Strynar, M. J.; Helfant, L.; Egeghy, P.; Ye, X.; Lindstrom, A. B.,
Perfluorinated compounds in the Cape Fear drainage basin in North Carolina. Environ. Sci.
Tcchnol. 2007,41, (15), 5271-5276.
Page 12 of 12
DEQ-CFW-00082302