Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20181249 Ver 1_Attachment 12 - 2016-02-22 E-mail from Gary Jordan to Kiersten Bass_20181217Re: Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Recommendation for the Preferred Alternative" From: Jordan, Gary <garyJordan@fws.gov> To: Kiersten Bass <kbass@hntb.com> Cc: emidkiff@ncdot.gov <emidkiff@ncdot.gov>, Donnie.Brew@dot.gov <Donnie.Brew@dot.gov>, Hanson, Robert P (rhanson@ncdot.gov) <rhanson@ncdot.gov>, Jennifer Harris <jhharris@hntb.com>, Midkiff, Eric </o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=ebed7dee8bef40d2b165cf3a34adc30c- emidkiff>, Hanson, Robert P</o=ExchangeLabs/ou=Exchange Administrative Group (FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=d2a73b1 e66bf44baba9d 1 d23f4a369e1- rphanson> Sent: February 22, 2016 4:01:47 PM EST Received: February 22, 2016 4:02:08 PM EST Kiersten, Striking the last sentence would probably be the best. Thanks for addressing that. I understand the intended meaning of the original statement, but I just did not want anyone to be confused by it. We have no Issue of Concern in the selection of the preferred, but there is a Issue of Concern for the overall project. Although the coordination on the dwarf wedgemussel issue is going very well, it is still within the realm of possibility that the USFWS could issue a Jeopary Biological Opinion. Gary JordanFish and Wildlife Biologist Liaison to NCDOT US Fish and Wildlife Service P.O. Box 33726 Raleigh, NC 27636-3726 Phone: 919-856-4520 x.32 Email: garyJordan@fws.gov <mailto:garyJordan@fws.gov> On Mon, Feb 22, 2016 at 3:50 PM, Kiersten Bass <kbass@hntb.com <mailto:kbass@hntb.com» wrote: Gary — I would like to clarify that an Issue of Concern, in accordance with the project's 6002 Coordination Plan, is any issue that could delay the project or could prevent an agency from granting a permit or other approval that is needed for the project. Through agency review of the draft Preferred Alternative Report, NCDOT is asking if the agencies have an Issue of Concern regarding the selection of DSA 2 as the Preferred Alternative. In your email below, you note that the USFWS does not oppose DSA 2 being selected as the Preferred Alternative. We acknowledge that additional coordination regarding DWM is required. Barring any issues of concern, NCDOT will move forward with developing preliminary designs for the Preferred Alternative and prepare the Final EIS. I propose we revise the meeting summary to strike the last sentence. Please let me know if this revision satisfies your comment. Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Thank you, Kiersten R. Bass Planning Services Manager ¢HNTB North Carolina, P.C. From: Jordan, Gary [mailto:garyJordan@fws.gov <mailto:garyJordan@fws.gov>] Sent: Monday, February 22, 2016 2:23 PM To: Kiersten Bass Cc: 'eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil <mailto:eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil>' (eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil <mailto:eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil>); Ridings, Rob; Van Der Wiele, Cynthia; Wilson, Travis W.; Gledhill-earley, Renee; 'Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us <mailto:Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us>' (Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us <mailto:Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us>); Houser, Anthony A; Teague, Jeff L; Huang, Herman (hfhuang@ncdot.gov <mailto:hfhuang@ncdot.gov>); Hopkins, Joey; Lauffer, Matthew S; Elam, William H; Joyner, Drew; Robbins, Jamille A; Marshall, Harrison; Furr, Mary Pope; Mellor, Colin; knmedlin@ncdot.gov <mailto:knmedlin@ncdot.gov>; Hauser, James W; Staley, Mark K; Stanley, Mike; Ishak, Doumit Y; Childrey, Tom; Paugh, Leilani Y; Pilipchuk, John L; Chapman, Amy; dwjernigan@ncdot.gov <mailto:dwjernigan@ncdot.gov>; awshapiro@ncdot.gov <mailto:awshapiro@ncdot.gov>; cjlee@ncdot.gov <mailto:cjlee@ncdot.gov>; keith.hanson@noaa.gov <mailto:keith.hanson@noaa.gov>; Desai, Rupal P(rpdesai@ncdot.gov <mailto:rpdesai@ncdot.gov>); Pleasant, Kyle A (kpleasant@ncdot.gov <mailto:kpleasant@ncdot.gov>); ken.riley@noaa.gov <mailto:ken.riley@noaa.gov>; Donnie.Brew@dot.gov <mailto:Donnie.Brew@dot.gov>; emidkiff@ncdot.gov <mailto:emidkiff@ncdot.gov>; Jennifer Harris; rbruce@hwlochner.com <mailto:rbruce@hwlochner.com>; kmaseman@hwlochner.com <mailto:kmaseman@hwlochner.com>; fred.skaer@gmail.com <mailto:fred.skaer@gmail.com>; John Studt Qfstudt@gmail.com <mailto:jfstudt@gmail.com>); rhancock@ncdot.gov <mailto:rhancock@ncdot.gov>; Hanson, Robert P (rhanson@ncdot.gov <mailto:rhanson@ncdot.gov>) Subject: Re: Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Recommendation for the Preferred Alternative" Kiersten, As the draft summary states I was not able to attend the meeting. However, I do have one comment. The draft summary states "If this coordination continues satisfactorily to USFWS, the agency does not foresee any Issues of Concern with regard to the selection of DSA 2 as the Preferred Alternative." This statement, as written, could be misunderstood by some people. The USFWS does have an issue of concern, as we previously stated multiple times, with the overall project. The likely adverse effects on the dwarF wedgemussel are a serious concern. Since this concern covers all the alternatives to one degree or another, the USFWS has not taken a position for or against any particular alternative. In other words, we are not opposing the selection of DSA 2 as the Preferred Alternative, but our serious concerns remain. Perhaps you could reword the statement to clarify or even just delete it. Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Gary Jordan Fish and Wildlife Biologist Liaison to NCDOT US Fish and Wildlife Service P.O. Box 33726 Raleigh, NC 27636-3726 Phone: 919-856-4520 x.32 Email: garyJordan@fws.gov <mailto:garyJordan@fws.gov> On Mon, Feb 22, 2016 at 1:49 PM, Kiersten Bass <kbass@hntb.com <mailto:kbass@hntb.com» wrote: All — thank you for attending the interagency meeting (February 17, 2016) regarding the draft Preferred Alternative Report for Complete 540 project. Attached for your review is a draft summary of the subject meeting. Please review and provide your comments on the draft summary by Monday, February 29th. A revised final summary will be distributed soon afterward. If I have missed anyone or you feel others should be included in this review, please let me know so that I can share the draft and final versions with them. If you have any questions regarding the project or this summary, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you, Kiersten R. Bass Planning Services Manager ¢HNTB North Carolina, P.C. 343 E. Six Forks Road, Suite 200 Raleigh, NC 27609 Direct 919.424.0457 Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Mobile 919.610.1366 -----Original Appointment----- From: tahart@ncdot.gov <mailto:tahart@ncdot.gov> [mailto:tahart@ncdot.gov <mailto:tahart@ncdot.gov>] On Behalf Of DOT PDEA INTERAGENCY MEETING CALENDAR Sent: Tuesday, February 02, 2016 4:09 PM To: DOT PDEA INTERAGENCY MEETING CALENDAR; Medlin, Kenneth N; Midkiff, Eric; donnie.brew@fhwa.dot.gov <mailto:donnie.brew@fhwa.dot.gov>; 'eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil <mailto:eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil>' (eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil <mailto:eric.c.alsmeyer@usace.army.mil>); Ridings, Rob; Van Der Wiele, Cynthia ; 'garyJordan@fws.gov <mailto:garyJordan@finrs.gov>' (garyJordan@fws.gov <mailto:garyJordan@fws.gov>); Wilson, Travis W.; Gledhill-earley, Renee; 'Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us <mailto:Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us>' (Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us <mailto:Chris.Lukasina@campo-nc.us>); Houser, Anthony A; Teague, Jeff L; Little, Timothy M; Hopkins, Joey; Lauffer, Matthew S; Elam, William H; Lovinggood, Ray D; Joyner, Drew; Robbins, Jamille A; Marshall, Harrison; Furr, Mary Pope; Mellor, Colin; Rivenbark, Chris; Riffey, Deanna; Hauser, James W; Staley, Mark K; Stanley, Mike; Strickland, Neal O; Ishak, Doumit Y; Roy Bruce; Kristin Maseman; 'jshlotter@hwlochner.com <mailto:jshlotter@hwlochner.com>'; Kiersten Bass; Jennifer Harris; jstudt@dawsonassociates.com <mailto:jstudt@dawsonassociates.com>; fskaer@dawsonassociates.com <mailto:fskaer@dawsonassociates.com>; Hall, Dolores; Argabright, Van; Barbour, Deborah M; Bourne, John S; Childrey, Tom; Cook, Alena R; Dagnino, Carla S; Dunlop, James H; Fuller, Gregory A; Griffin, Randy W; Hancock, Richard W; Harris, David B; Harris, Philip S; Ishak, Joseph; Johnson, Benjetta L; Kite, Steve; Kuse, Jessica D; Lee, Donald G; Chambers, Marla J; Marshall, Travis K; Memory, John R; Morgan, Stephen R; Murphy, Brian G; Paugh, Leilani Y; Pilipchuk, John L; Rochelle, Rodger D; Thomas, Earlene W; Tortorella, James; Twisdale, John W; Chapman, Amy; Clarence Coleman; Fritz Rohde; George Hoops; Henry Wicker Jr.; Karen Compton; Pace Wilber; Tom Steffens; Walter, Tracy A; Nelson, Eric B Subject: Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Recommendation for the Preferred Alternative" When: Wednesday, February 17, 2016 1:00 PM-3:00 PM (UTC-05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada). Where: Structure Design Conference Room This meeting is being held in the Structure Design Conference Room CCA. Meeting time is subject to change until 2 weeks before meeting day. Entire agenda can be found at our new web location: https://connect. ncdot.gov/resources/Environmental/Pages/Merger-Process-Guide.aspx <https://connect.ncdot.gov/resou rces/Environmental/Pages/Merger-Process-Gu ide.aspx> Meeting packages will be posted 2 weeks prior to the designated meeting date at the following website: https://xfer.services.ncdot.gov/pdea/MergerMeetings/ <https://xfer.services.ncdot.gov/pdea/MergerMeetings/> Please contact meeting requestor listed below if packets are not available within the designated 2 week period. Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Join online meeting <https://meet.lync.com/ncconnect-ncdot/tahart/WGG3P8CC> https://meet.lync.com/ncconnect-ncdot/tahart/WGG3P8CC <https://meet.lync.com/ncconnect- ncdot/tahart/WGG3P8CC> First online meeting? <http://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?Linkld=389737> [!OC([1033])!] Call In Number 919-250-7882 EASTERN REGION AGENCY MEETING — February 17 Time: 1 pm to 3 pm Requestor: Eric Midkiff STI P#: R-2721, R-2828, R-2829 Project: Complete 540, Triangle Expressway Southeast Extension Division: 4 and 5 County: Wake and Johnston Purpose: Recommend a Preferred Alternative [Section 6002 Coordination, Not in Merger] PROJECT TEAM LEADS: FHWA — Donnie Brew NCDWR — Rob Ridings USACE — Eric Alsmeyer NCDOT — Eric Midkiff Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the TEAM MEMBERS: USEPA — Cynthia Van Der Wiele, Ph.D. SHPO — Renee Gledhill-Earley USFWS — Gary Jordan OSA — Dolores Hall NCWRC — Travis Wilson CAMPO — Chris Lukasina SUPPORT STAFF: Roadway — Tony Houser Structures — Rick Nelson Roadway — Jeffrey Teague TIP — Mike Stanley Division 4 — Tim Little ROW — Neal Strickland Division 5 — Joey Hopkins PDEA — Eric Midkiff Hydraulics — Matt Lauffer Cong. Man. — Doumit Ishak Hydraulics — Bill Elam Hydraulics — Ray Lovinggood Consultant — Roy Bruce (rbruce@hwlochner.com <mailto:rbruce@hwlochner.com>) HES — Drew Joyner Consultant — Kristin Maseman (kmaseman@hwlochner.com <mailto:kmaseman@hwlochner.com>) HES — Jamille Robbins Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Consultant — Jeff Schlotter (jschlotter@hwlochner.com <mailto:jschlotter@hwlochner.com>) HES — Harrison Marshall Consultant — Kiersten Bass (kbass@hntb.com <mailto:kbass@hntb.com>) HES — Mary Pope Furr Consultant — Jennifer Harris Qhharris@hntb.com <mailto:jhharris@hntb.com>) NES — Colin Mellor Consultant — Fred Skaer Qstudt@dawsonassociates.com <mailto:jstudt@dawsonassociates.com>) NES — Chris Rivenbark Consultant — John Studt (fskaer@dawsonassociates.com <mailto:fskaer@dawsonassociates.com>) NES — Deanna Riffey NES — Jim Hauser NES — Neil Medlin Roadside — Mark Staley FACI LITATORS: PDEA — Eric Midkiff Consultant — Roy Bruce, Lochner Email correspondence to and from this sender is subject to the N.C. Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. This message was secured by the HNTB Email Security system. Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the This e-mail and any files transmitted with it are confidential and are intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. If you are NOT the intended recipient and receive this communication, please delete this message and any attachments. This message was secured by the HNTB Email Security system. This e-mail and any files transmitted with it are confidential and are intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. If you are NOT the intended recipient and receive this communication, please delete this message and any attachments. Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Attachment 1. image001.png Type: image/png Size: 16 KB (17,086 bytes) Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the Attachment #1 image001.png Image �-1Nhile U5F1NS stafFwas ur�able tra attend the meetirx�, the a�er�cy pranrided verbal cnmmer�ts t� Eric hali�kiff in advar�ce �f the meeting. N�a�T presented those comments, which reiterated the a�ency'� continued �ttention to potential effects on the �nrartwedc�emussel, but �Isc� n�ted the or�oin� coor�ination between N�DOT and U�FW� in the multiphase dwarf wed�emussel �����I�}�����r. I##hicrnnrr�ina4inn r�nn#in�iac eafiefar#nrilirfnl IC�ll41C fhaarvanr3rr�noc nnf �i .,.ti.l i Feb 22, 2016 4 02 08 PM ESTRe Complete 540 (R-2721, R-2828, R-2829) -"Interagency Meeting to Review the