Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20060413 Ver 1_Year 4 Monitoring Report_20171201STALLINGS BUFFER RESTORATION SITE -- DMS #357 Jones County NC -- Neuse River HUC# 03020204-010050 MY -4 (2017) ANNUAL MONITORING REPORT North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality Division of Mitigation Services (DEQ -DMS) -- Contract # 5765 Data Collected: October 2017 Draft Report Submitted: Nov 2017 N.C. Department of Environmental Quality Division of Mitigation Services 1652 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1652 Environmental---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Quality DMS Project Manager: Jeff Schaffer MOGENSEN MITIGATION, INC. P.O. Box 690429 Charlotte, NC 28227 (704) 576-1111 Rich(a)MogMit.com ran (919) 556-8845 Gerald(&MogMit.com MOGENSEN NIITIGATION.INC Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Page 1 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI www.Mogmit.com MMI - Charlotte (704) 576-1111 MMI -Raleigh (919) 556-8845 14 December 2017 Jeff Schaffer MOGENSEN MITIGATION INC. ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTING Eastern Supervisor/Project Manager NC Division of Mitigation Services 1652 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1652 Subject: Stallings Buffer Restoration Site #357, MMI responses to MY4 draft review comments. Dear Mr. Schaffer, Wm MOGENSEN MITIGATION, INC Thank you for your review comments on our MY4 Draft Monitoring Report for the Stallings site which you received on 27 November 2017. Below are responses to your review comments: 1a. Please ensure that MMI uses the correct coordinate system, State Plane Feet NAD 83 for all GIS shapefiles/layers. Specifically, a warning came up regarding this for the "Flat—Swamp" and "Planted BufferLine" data sources. Response: "Planted Bufferline" was an old duplicate feature which we have now deleted. "Flat Swamp" coordinates have been corrected to State Plane Feet NAD -83. 1b. Please note that while MMI did provide area breakdowns and mitigation approaches for each riparian buffer area, in future submittals, please provide the acreage and square footage in the attribute table(s) as required by contract and stated in the most recent DMS monitoring report template and digital drawing requirements. Response: Areas for the planted buffer shape files are included in the attribute tables for each polygon. The "Planted Bufferline" feature (now deleted) was a polyline rather than polygon feature, and thus did not include an area. 2. Section 1.3 page 4 — Multiple references to Figures 113-C in the second paragraph but the monitoring report does not have a Figure C. Please remove references to Figure C. Response: The MYO as -built report had a pre -restoration features map that was not included in subsequent monitoring reports. References to Figure 1C have been removed. Along with this response letter we are mailing you three paper copies and one CD containing a pdf of the revised report plus all support files and updated GIS files. Sincerely, Gerald Pottern MMI Raleigh office Environmental Field Studies ■ Wetland & Stream Delineation ■ 404-401 Permits ■ Mitigation Plans & Banking Table of Contents 1.0. Project Summary........................................................................................................................3 1.1. Project Goals & Objectives...............................................................................................................3 1.2. Project Success Criteria....................................................................................................................3 1.3. Project Setting & Pre -Restoration Conditions..................................................................................4 1.4. Project Design Approach, Components and Mitigation Assets ........................................................5 1.5. Current Conditions (2016) and Performance Summary...................................................................6 2.0. Monitoring Methods...................................................................................................................7 3.0. References....................................................................................................................................8 Figure IA. Project Vicinity Map and Directions Figure 1B. Project Components & Mitigation Assets Appendix A. Project Background Tables Table 1. Project Mitigation Components Table 2. Project Activity and Reporting History Table 3. Project Contacts Table Table 4. Project Attribute Table Appendix B. Visual Assessment Data Figure 2. Current Conditions Plan View (CCPV) Table 5. Vegetation Condition Visual Assessment Figure 3. Vegetation Monitoring Plots & Other Photos Appendix C. Vegetation Plot Monitoring Data Table 6. CVS Plot Stem Density & Success Summary Table 7. CVS Plot Stem Counts & Density by Species and Year Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Page 2 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI 1.0. Project Summary 1.1. Project Goals & Objectives The Stallings Buffer Restoration Project is located on a 146 -acre parcel of former cropland in northern Jones County NC, in the Trent River sub -basin of the Neuse River Basin, USGS Cataloging Unit (CU) #03020204-010050 (Figure IA). The NC Department of Transportation (NCDOT) purchased this property east of Wyse Fork Rd (SR -1002) in 2003 for conservation use, and also acquired a conservation easement on 3 additional acres of farmed riparian land immediately upstream on the west side of Wyse Fork Rd. Access points into the site are located on Wyse Fork Rd (Lat: 35.1682, Lon: - 77.4845) and Webb Farm Rd (Lat: 35.1722, Lon: -77.4823). The 2010 Neuse River Basin Restoration Priority Plan (RBRP) identifies agricultural impacts including stream channelization, wetland ditching, loss of forested riparian buffers, and nonpoint source runoff as causes of water quality degradation in the Trent River watershed. The Plan identifies "reestablishment of riparian buffers and corridors of substantial width to improve connectivity of protected areas" and "projects that address agricultural runoff' as priority goals for this watershed. Restoration Goals for CU #03020204 as identified in the 2010 plan include: • Promote nutrient and sediment reduction in agricultural areas by restoring and preserving wetlands, streams and riparian buffers. • Continue targeted implementation of Nutrient Offset and Riparian Buffer program projects, and focus NCDOT-sponsored restoration in areas where it will provide ecosystem functional improvement. Protect, augment and connect Natural Heritage Areas and other conservation lands. The Stallings Buffer Restoration Project was identified as an opportunity to improve water quality and augment conservation lands within the Trent River watershed. The project goals include the following: • Provide improved water quality by reducing nutrient and sediment loads to the receiving waters. • Improve terrestrial and aquatic habitat and connectivity in the Flat Swamp Watershed. These goals will be achieved through implementation of the following project objectives (Figure 113): • Restore 31.6 acres of riparian buffers by planting native tree species at a sufficient density to promote native forest succession, thus increasing riparian area root density and nutrient uptake. • Preserve 19.1 acres of riparian riverine wetlands along Flat Swamp and its tributaries. 1.2. Project Success Criteria Tree planting on 31.6 acres of riparian buffers along Streams A, B, and C was conducted in February to early March 2014. Post -construction annual monitoring will be conducted from 2014 through 2018 using 25 permanent CVS vegetation plots all five years, and 25 temporary warranty plots during the first three years. The CVS plots were established by RJG&A (now Mogensen Mitigation Inc) during March 2014. Vegetative success of the buffer restoration is evaluated based on a minimum of 320 planted Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Page 3 native hardwood trees per acre at the end of 5 years, as specified in the project mitigation plan. (Note: The 2015 Monitoring Report stated that the density criterion had been revised to 260 planted stems per acre at the end of 5 years, based on the 2014 Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rules. The original criterion of 320 trees per acre was reinstated after discussion between DMS and DWR in 2016). 1.3. Project Setting & Pre -Restoration Conditions The Stallings Buffer Restoration Project is located on a 146 -acre parcel of former cropland in the northern corner of Jones County NC, along the transition zone between the Inner Coastal Plain and Outer Coastal Plain, eight miles southeast of downtown Kinston NC. Traveling to the site from Kinston, drive east on US -70 into Jones County, turn right on Wyse Fork Rd (SR -1002) about 0.5 mile past the Lenoir/Jones County line, then travel south approximately 3.5 miles to Webb Farm Road (SR -1306). The Stallings site is located southeast of the intersection of Wyse Fork Road and Webb Farm Road (Figure IA). The northern portion of the site is accessible from Webb Farm Road, and the southern portion is accessible from Wyse Fork Road near the intersection with Moore Rd (SR -1306). Elevations on the site range from 42 to 52 feet above mean seal level (NAVD-83). The Stallings site is drained by channelized streams and ditches flowing southeastward into Flat Swamp along the eastern boundary of the site (Figure 1B). In May 2011 the NC Division of Water Resources (DWR) agent Chris Pullinger provided a letter and color -coded map indicating streams subject to Neuse River Buffer Rules (Appendix A). Intermittent or perennial channels subject to Buffer Rules are mapped in blue, and ephemeral channels or ditches not subject to Buffer Rules are mapped in red by DWR. The three streams where DMS seeks buffer credits (blue streams in DWR's map) are labeled A, B and C in Figure 1B. A fourth stream segment near the northeast corner of the site is also mapped in blue (Stream D in Figure 1B), but is not labeled on the DWR map or listed in the letter. Due to this discrepancy DMS is not seeking buffer credit along Stream D. Flat Swamp flows into Beaver Creek in the Trent River sub -basin of the Neuse River basin, USGS Cataloging Unit #03020204-010050 and DWR sub -basin 03-04-11. An adjacent protected conservation area (non -DMS) across Flat Swamp east of the Stallings site creates a combined conservation area of 307 acres. This site in turn connects with Great Dover Swamp, comprising several thousand acres of mostly undeveloped land in the Beaver Creek and Trent River watershed, between Wyse Fork Rd and US -70. The USDA Soil Survey of Jones County (Barnhill, 198 1) shows Goldsboro fine sandy loam (GoA) mapped on the higher, well -drained areas on the northern part of the site, Meggett loam (Me) on the majority of the site including the planted areas, and Stockade fine sandy loam (Sx) along the Flat Swamp floodplain. Meggett loam and Stockade fine sandy loam are designated hydric soils, although much of the area mapped as Meggett has been drained and altered by agricultural activity and is not jurisdictional wetland in its current condition. Vegetation on the former cropland areas includes a mix of grasses, herbs, shrubs, vines, and tree seedlings typical of abandoned fields. A 120 -ft -wide mowed powerline right-of-way lies east -west across the middle of the site. The floodplain of Flat Swamp along the eastern edge of the site supports about 16 acres of mature bottomland hardwood and swamp forest wetlands, and the lower reaches of Streams A and C (north and south of the powerline) have about 3 acres of disturbed (previously farmed) scrub -dominated riparian wetlands. Wetland hydrology is maintained by a combination of upland runoff and occasional overbank flooding (Stantec, 2011). Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Page 4 1.4. Project Design Approach, Components and Mitigation Assets The 146 -acre Stallings Buffer Restoration Site is former cropland purchased by NC Department of Transportation (NCDOT) in 2003, and is protected for conservation use by a deed restriction. The 3 -acre riparian buffer on the adjacent Lee property west of Wyse Fork Rd is protected by a conservation easement. In 2003 the Stallings site had sparse cover of predominantly herbaceous old -field weeds, but vegetation density and height increased over the subsequent decade (2003 to 2013) as shrubs and sapling trees became established, especially Baccharis, Morella, Rubus, and Pinus. The Mitigation Plan (Stantec Consulting Services, 2011) included 40.0 acres of Riparian Buffer Restoration (40.0 Mitigation Units), 27.2 acres of Nitrogen Nutrient Offset (27.2 Mitigation Units), 3.0 acres of Wetland Enhancement (1.5 Mitigation Units), 16.1 acres of Wetland Preservation (3.2 Mitigation Units), and 5,403 feet of Stream Enhancement (2,161 Mitigation Units), all on the 146 -acre eastern tract. The 3 -acre western tract has no mitigation credits. During the interval between development of the 2011 Mitigation Plan and project implementation in Feb -Mar 2014, natural colonization and growth of tree saplings and shrubs continued in the fallow fields and proposed wetland enhancement areas. The Riparian Buffer Restoration area was subsequently reduced from 40.0 acres to 31.6 acres, with buffers extending 200 feet laterally from the DWR-verified stream -banks, except where limited by the powerline right-of-way, roads, and areas with adequate natural woody stem density (other than pines and exotics). DMS and DWR determined that the proposed Wetland Enhancement areas along the lower reaches of Streams A and C would instead be categorized as Wetland Preservation, since supplemental tree planting was no longer needed. Stream channel reconstruction was determined to be unnecessary and was deleted from the plan based on the engineer's calculations of shear stress and stream power, and confirmation by DWR in May 2011 that the existing channels appear relatively stable. Nutrient offset buffers along the non -stream ditches were deleted, as were the proposed stream enhancement mitigation credits along Streams A, B and C. The original plan to clear and grub the riparian buffer planting areas was changed to mowing only to preserve the many native volunteer saplings. Planting areas were mowed in 2014 with a bush -hog to facilitate planting and reduce competition for the planted trees. Pinus, Liquidambar, and shrubs were mostly mowed or cut, but other native hardwood trees (Ulmus, Acer, Platanus, Fraxinus, Carpinus, Quercus and others) were left standing to the extent practicable. Some areas were too wet and soft to effectively bush -hog, and were left as is prior to planting. The contractor planted 14,200 bare -root tree seedlings of Platanus, Liriodendron, Nyssa, and Quercus within the 31.6 acre buffer restoration areas using Dibble bars during late February to early March 2014. Planted areas that were not mowed are dominated by Baccharis, Morella, Rubus, and herbaceous plants, plus scattered Pinus and Liquidambar saplings. Planted seedlings were mostly 10 to 18 inches tall, with a few seedlings 24 inches or taller, and average planting density was 449 stems/acre. The final built project as surveyed in March 2014 includes 31.6 acres of Riparian Buffer Restoration, which may be applied as either 31.6 Riparian Buffer Mitigation Credits, 31.6 Nitrogen Nutrient Offset Credits, or a combination of Riparian Buffer and Nitrogen Nutrient Offset Mitigation Credits up to a total of 31.6 (not on the same footprint) depending on mitigation need as per agreement with DWR (Table 1). The other 19.1 acres of wetland preservation, 86 acres of non -buffer upland preservation, and Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Page 5 3 -acre conservation easement west of Wyse Fork Rd do not provide any mitigation credits, but will help improve water quality and habitat along waterways that are not subject to Neuse River Buffer Rules but may be Section 404 jurisdictional waters (Tables 1 to 4 and Figures I to 1C). The monitoring contractor (MMI-RJGA) installed 25 permanent CVS vegetation monitoring plots (10 x 10 meter) marked with steel conduit at the corners (including a tall pipe at the (0,0) corner) during March 11-12, 2014. The side closest to the stream was designated as the x-axis, and a photo of each plot was taken from the 0,0 corner. For each plot the latitude and longitude coordinates of the 0,0 corner were recorded with a Trimble sub -meter GPS unit, and the x-axis angle (from 0,0 corner to 10,0 corner) was recorded with a magnetic compass. The x,y coordinates of each planted tree within the plots was recorded using meter tapes laid along the plot edges, and survey flagging was tied loosely around each tree to facilitate subsequent measurements and to distinguish them from volunteer trees. 1.5. Current Conditions (2017) and Performance Summary The Stallings site was evaluated during October 16-18, 2017, about 44 months after the original planting in Feb 2014. Native volunteer shrubs and vines, especially Morella, Baccharis, Rubus, Rhus, Vitis, Smilax, Ampelopsis, and Campsis are continuing to grow vigorously over most of the site, along with a dense herb layer dominated by Solidago, Eupatorium, Juncus, Scirpus, and grasses overtopping the planted trees. Larger volunteer Pinus, Platanus, Liquidambar, Acer, Fraxinus, Celtis, and Ulmus ranging from 4 to 8 inches dbh are common in some areas, especially along ditch banks. Areas where low planted tree density was reported in 2014 received supplemental planting in February 2015 by Carolina Silvics, the original planting contractor. Approximately 3,800 bare -root seedlings of Liriodendron, Platanus, Nyssa, Quercus, and Fraxinus were planted on 20 acres, at densities of 109 to 242 trees per acre based on the 2014 CVS plot and warranty plot data (Appendix C, Figure 5). A few of these 2015 planted trees were found in CVS plots in 2016 and 2017. A second supplemental planting (6,000 new stems, species TBD) is scheduled for the winter of 2017- 2018; Carolina Silvics staff were cutting transects for replanting with brush -cutters during the period while MMI staff were collecting this year's CVS plot data. Plots 1 through 14, 16, and 17 had transects cut through them just prior to MMI sampling in Oct 2017, while plot 15 and plots 18 through 25 had not yet been cut. Some of the monitored trees in CVS plots had been either cut or crushed under the cut shrub debris, but these losses will be offset by replanting in a few months. The new cut lines also exposed some very small planted stems that had been missed during previous sampling years. Nine of the 25 permanent CVS plots in 2017 had eight or more living planted trees, and met the 320 stems/acre success criterion (Tables 6 -7). Another 10 CVS plots had seven or fewer living planted stems and failed to meet the criterion, but exceeded 320 stems/acre based on total planted plus volunteer native hardwood trees, including Platanus, Liquidambar, Diospyros, Pinus, Prunus, Acer, Salix, Ulmus, and Fraxinus. While Pinus are typically not counted toward success, we include them here since Pine Flatwoods was presumably the native forest community on much of this site based on soils (Schafale & Weakley, 1990). The eight plots containing volunteer Pinus had 1 to 3 Pinus stems, comprising 7% to 22% of the trees counted in those plots. The remaining 6 plots failed to meet 320 stems/acre based on the total planted plus volunteer native trees; 4 of these 6 failing plots were in the recently -cut areas. The Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Page 6 average density of surviving planted stems for all 25 plots in 2017 was 6.5 trees per plot (264 trees per acre), slightly less than the 2016 average (269 trees per acre). With native volunteer trees added, the average density for all plots is 408 trees per acre. Native volunteer shrubs Morella, Baccharis, Rhus and Rubus.are also abundant in all plots, but were not counted. Much of the planted area beyond the CVS plots also exhibited low density and vigor of planted trees in 2017, due to competition from dense shrubs and/or recent cutting or crushing of small trees during the contractor's site preparation for supplemental planting this winter. Since many planted stems were recently cut (and may resprout next year), and the site will be replanted soon, it was not feasible or necessary to map low stem density areas beyond the CVS plots this year (Figure 2 and Table 5). Areas of low stem density and low vigor will be mapped and quantified in the MY5 (2018) monitoring report. Invasive exotic plants (Ligustrum, Lonicera, Rosa, Lespedeza, Pyrus, Triadica) occur as individuals or small patches at many scattered locations throughout the project site. However, invasives no longer appear to be threatening planted stem survival, since native shrubs, trees and vines have now overtopped most of the invasives. A few mature trees of Pyrus and Triadica were noted on the southeastern portion of the project, but few seedlings from these trees were observed, suggesting that they are not currently spreading. Patches of invasive Lespedeza cuneata mapped in 2015 on the eastern portion of the site are continuing to decline due to overtopping by dense native shrubs and vines. No invasive vegetation problem areas were mapped in 2017 (Figure 2.1-2.2). In 2016 we reported mowing of ditch -bank vegetation (presumably by NCDOT) extending into the conservation easement along Webb Farm Rd and Wyse Fork Rd. Subsequent mowing in 2017 appears to be confined to the road side of the ditches, as appropriate. No new encroachment or damage from vehicles or livestock was observed, other than the paths cut by Carolina Silvics for supplemental planting this coming winter. "Conservation Area" signs posted along roadsides are intact, although some are now obscured from view by shrubs and vine growth. There is no fencing around the project site. 2.0. Monitoring Methods Baseline Monitoring and Annual Monitoring and reporting methods follow the current DMS -provided templates and guidelines (Lee et al 2008; NC-EEP 2012). The 25 permanent CVS vegetation plots (10 x 10 meters) are evaluated and photographed during late Summer or Fall each year from 2014 through 2018. For planted trees, the species, height, dbh, and qualitative vigor rating of each tree is recorded (CVS Level 1 data). For volunteer trees and shrubs, the numbers of stems of each species within each height category is recorded (CVS Level 2 data). Planted and volunteer woody species are identified using Radford et al. (1968) and Weakley (2012). For the first three years (2014 through 2016) an additional 25 temporary vegetation warranty plots (100 m2 each) scattered throughout the replanted buffer areas were evaluated. Square warranty plots (10 x 10 m) were used in 2014, and strip plots (33.3 x 3 m) used in 2015 and 2016, with locations varying from year to year to maximize the cumulative sampling area covered. These plots record the total number of surviving planted tree species only; species and size data are not be recorded. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Page 7 The Stallings site does not have a perimiter fence, but the contractor checks the condition of conservation signage along the adjacent public roads, and looks for evidence of encroachment by off- road vehicles, livestock, or other potential sources of damage. Areas of invasive exotic vegetation in the planted areas are mapped in accordance with current DMS guidance. No hydrologic or geomorphic monitoring is included in the Stallings project monitoring scope. 3.0. References Barnhill, W.L. (1981). Soil Survey of Jones County, North Carolina. USDA Soil Conservation Service (Natural Resources Conservation Service), Raleigh, NC. Lee, Michael T., Peet, Robert K., Roberts, Steven D., Wentworth, Thomas R. (2008). CVS-EEP Protocol for Recording Vegetation version 4.2, October 2008. Retrieved September 2011, from: http://cvs.bio.unc.edu/methods.htm NC Ecosystem Enhancement Program. (2014). NC-EEP Monitoring Report Template and Guidance version 1.0, February 2014. http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/eep/dbb-resources NC Ecosystem Enhancement Program. (2010). Neuse River Basin Restoration Priority Plan, Draft 2010. http://www.nceep.net/services/restplans/DRAFT—RBRP—Neuse 201007.pdf Radford, A.E., H.E. Ahles, and C.R. Bell (1968). Manual of the Vascular Flora of the Carolinas. University of North Carolina Press. Chapel Hill, NC. Robert J. Goldstein & Associates, Inc. (2014). Stallings Buffer Restoration Site #357 MY -0 Baseline Monitoring Report, Final, July 2014. Prepared for NC Ecosystem Enhancement Program, Raleigh, NC. Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. (2011). Mitigation Plan: Stallings Buffer Restoration, EEP Project # 357, December 2011. Prepared for NC Ecosystem Enhancement Program, Raleigh, NC. US Army Corps of Engineers (2003) Stream Mitigation Guidelines. US Army Corps of Engineers, US Environmental Protection Agenmcy Region 4, USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service, NC Wildlife Resources Commission, and NC Dept. Environment & Natural Resources. Weakley, Alan (2012). Flora of the Carolinas, Virginia, Georgia, and Surrounding Areas. hLtp://www.herbarium.unc.edu/flora.htm. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 Jones County — Neuse HUC 03020204 Page 8 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI slmngsBuffer Restoration Site Dv&G9 Jones County - Neuse Hucm&&G � § 2 = \ \ ' § / 0 \ \U - k £ -0 k / / o A E r4 �Qj_ o $ ) § Ln e v / § � = e = 2 c m � m 3 m \ / CU ® a 1 / \ 0 § 2 § 2 Z ƒ 2 / ° k \ \ 4 ( \ / o & / § \ ± 3 § 3 C) / f R G _ \� C:— " o -0 2 \ ƒ ° co \ E / tLO Um E �0/Ln 2 ( E 2 / ƒ E / 3 z = > / § \ / C & k a 0 \ _ a \ / / _ 5 e / / 2 iz k 3 k vw4(y9)Annual vmmMm Report vmmanMitigation Inc. MMI r,. v ■ _ - - ilk �1 r - a b' '' �t�•l'il«l �� �J f Project Asset Map Stallings Buffer Restoration Jones County, North Carolina Project Assets -- As -Built March 2014 -------------------------------------------- Wetland preservation (79.1 acres) r Riparian buffer restoration (31.6 acres, for use as buffer credit or nitrogen offset credit). Project parcel boundary Project site streams Project site ditches Flat Swamp Roads Powerline easement Figure 1B. Stallings Buffer Restoration #357, As -Built Project Components and Mitigation Assets Map. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 10 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Appendix A. Project Background Tables Table 1. Project Components & Mitigation Credits Table 2. Project Activity and Reporting History Table 3. Project Contacts Table Table 4. Project Attributes Table Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 11 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 1. Project Components and Mitigation Credits Stallings Buffer Restoration, Flat Swamp, Jones County, DMS Project # 357 Mitigation Credits Stream Riparian Wetland Non -riparian Wetland Buffer Nitrogen Nutrient Offset Phosphorous Nutrient Offset Type R RE R RE R RE Totals 31.6 (31.6) a (a): Buffer restoration is applicable for Buffer Credit and/or Nutrient Offset Credit, but not both within the same footprint, up to a combined total of 31.6 units. Project Components Project Component or Reach ID Stationing or Location Existing Footage or Acreage Approach PI, P I I etc. Restoration or Restoration Equivalent Restoration Footage or Acreage Mitigation Ratio Mitigation Units Stream Enhancement Riparian Buffer Streams A,B,C 31.6 ac Rest R 31.6 ac 1:1 31.6 Wetland Enhancement Wetland Preservation Flat Swamp, streams A.0 19.1 ac Pres 0 Nitrogen Nutrient Offset (31.6) a (a): Combined total of 31.6 units of Buffer Credit and/or Nutrient Offset Credit, not applied within the same footprint. Component Summation Restoration Level Stream (linear feet) Riparian Wetland (acres) Non -riparian Buffer Wetland (acres) (square feet) Upland (acres) Riverine Non-Riverine Restoration 1,377,325 Enhancement Enhancement I Enhancement II Creation Preservation 19.1 ac High Quality Preservation BMP Elements Element Location Purpose/Function Notes BMP Elements: BIR = Bioretention Cell; SF = Sand Filter; SW = Stormwater Wetland; WDP = Wet Detention Pond; DDP = Dry Detention Pond; FS = Filter Strip; S = Grassed Swale; LS = Level Spreader; NI = Natural Infiltration Area; FB = Forested Buffer Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 12 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 2. Project Activity and Reporting History Stallings Buffer Restoration -- DMS #357 -- Jones County NC Elapsed Time Since Grading Complete: NA Elapsed Time Since Planting Complete: 45 Months Number of Reporting Years: 4 Activity or Deliverable Data Collection Complete Completion or Delivery Restoration Plan --- Dec 2011 Construction (Mowing) --- Jan -Feb 2014 Bare Root Tree Planting --- Feb 2014 MY -0: As -built Baseline Survey Mar 2014 Jul 2014 MY -1: Plant Warranty Plot Data Sep 2014 Dec 2014 MY -1: 2014 Monitoring Report Sep 2014 Apr 2015 Supplemental Tree Planting --- Feb 2015 MY -2: Plant Warranty Plot Data Sep 2015 Oct 2015 MY -2: 2015 Monitoring Report Sep 2015 Nov 2015 MY -3 Plant Warranty Plot Data Nov 2016 Nov 2016 MY -3 2016 Monitoring Report Nov 2016 Dec 2016 MY -4 2017 Monitoring Report Oct 2017 Nov 2017 MY -5 2018 Monitoring Report Final Close -Our Report Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 13 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 3. Project Contacts Table Stallings Buffer Restoration -- DMS #357 -- Jones County NC Designer Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. P.C. 801 Jones Franklin Rd, Suite 300 Raleigh, NC 27606 (919) 851-6866 Construction Contractor None Survey Contractor McKim & Creed 200 MacKenan Court Cary, NC 27511 (919) 233-8091 Planting Contractor Carolina Silvics 908 Indian Trail Rd Edenton, NC 27932 Mary -Margaret McKinney (252) 482-8491 Nursery Stock Suppliers ArborGen South Carolina Supertree Nursery 5594 Highway 38 South Blenheim, SC 29516 (843) 528-3203 Monitoring Performers Mogensen Mitigation Inc. - Raleigh Office 104 East Chestnut Avenue Wake Forest, NC 27587 Gerald Pottern, (919) 556-8845 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mogensen Mitigation Inc - Main Office P.O. 690429 Charlotte, NC 28227 Rich Mogensen, (704) 576-1111 Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 14 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 4.0. Project Baseline Information and Attributes Stallings Buf'erRestoration(EEP#357) Project Information Project C<nmty Jones Project area (acres) 146 ac NCDOT + 3 ac Private = 149 ac Project Coordinates (latitLxk and Ionaitude) 35.1718 -77.4841 Frojecti'atershed Summar} Information Physiographic Region Coastal Plana River Basil Neuse USGS HUC far Project (14 digit) 03020204-010050 NCDWQ Sub -basin for Project 03-01-11 Project Drainage Area (sq nu 0.72 Project Drainage Area % Inn1ei-6aa-s 3.80°lo CGIA Landuse Classification Fo-rest Land. Ctiitivated Land. He£beceous Cover and Sbniblaii& Reach Sumulary Information in a Wetland Suminar--Information Wetland 1 Wetland 2 Size of wetland (acres) 3.0 ac Ripariain riveiine 16.1 Ril)ai-ian iiv-erile Wetland Tyne (non-ripaaian riparian rives ine or I-Ta£rail noil-£i4ei-ile Mapped Soil Series Mezaet loans Mez2et loans & Stockade fine sand -v loam Drainage class Pooch drained Poorly drained & very poorly -railed Soli lnychic statin" Yes Yes Source of H cirobgy Owrbank fboding Overbank flooding Hydrologic Lupai-ment None Noire Native yeaetation coinnnnunity Disrnrlxdicutover Riveriue bottoinland lmr&vood Percent composition of cXotNC invasive vegetation 0% 00/6 Regulators' Considerations ReLylilatirnl Applicable? Resah-ed? SiTportina Documentation Waters of the United States - Section 404 No iv`a 11 ,11 Waters of the Uinited States - Section 401 No ilia iia Endangered Species Act No nfa 11 11 Historic Preservation Act Ices Yes Correspondence AithNC Dept. Cuhural Resotuces Coastal Zone Mainazenlent Act (CZMA).Voastat Aream Management Act (CAMA) No nia il.'a FE1'vL4 Fkolplain Con fiance No da 11. 11 Essential Fisheries Habitat No da in'a Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 15 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Appendix B. Visual Assessment Data Figure 2. Current Conditions Plan View: October 2017. 2.0. Stallings Site Key Map to CCPV Inset Maps 2.1. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site, Northern Area 2.2. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site, Southern Area Table 5. Vegetation Condition Visual Assessment Figure 3. Vegetation Monitoring Plots & Other Photos Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 16 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI `str Legend Project Easement Boundary Wetland Preservation (19.1 acres) (Not for Mitigation Credit) Planted Riparian Buffer (31.6 acres) Buffered Streams (DWR Verified) Nan -Buffered Ditches (DWR Verified) 50 225 0 450 9C Feet of W co O O N z Wz 5Q Z W OLQa a z J o: en 0 Ei _ en O v LU Z LL IL 0 UIW �m q z 0 Y z W 0 M z U M r m+r r!•,jti. LL 1n 91+ C { w �, ;tib,•; �: Figure 2.0 Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 17 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Legend Planted Buffer Wetland Preservation (No Mitg. Credit) N bA N N Buffered Streams (DWR Verified) > 320 Planted Trees/ac (Success) " o Non -Buffered Ditches (DWR Verified) <320 Planted (Fail) but > 320 Planted + Volunteer Trees/ac ' o Project Easement Boundary < 320 Planted + Volunteer Trees/ac (Fail) ° VP-25 i x VP-23 - VP-22 o A E 1t VP-24 VP-17 " VP-12tf # ";ii C4 U U VP 16 VP-19 f ► ■ . A W V• 11 VP-13 ' �1 ..Zz�,._ VP-10 1F,�.• Z 'r�; • .: v A JO r � _ -•- Fnvrrnrur�eAf[� VP-06 VP-07 t FIGURE 2.1 Feet _ NOV 2017 0 1 25 S25O Buffer Rest5(yi Site VP-05Stream C MY-4 (2017) Annual Monit ibrt MY4 of 5 Jones Count - Neuse HUC 03132;lk VP-09 Mogensen Mitigati9P4 0 125 250 Legend • VP -18 �,, ...��'� it i n ��..• VP -19 a +,' 4 4. VP -14 1:� �:. 'a• .._�aT} gip- a`.._.;. VP -06 =: r VP -08 VP -03 +: Feet 500 *. Planted Buffer Wetland Preservation (No Mitg. Credit) Buffered Streams (DWR Verified) > 320 Planted Trees/ac (Success) Non -Buffered Ditches (DWR Verified) <320 Planted (Fail) but > 320 Planted + Volunteer Trees/ac PrejaeAgE&%efftws*Bp laryms #357 < 320 Planted + Volunb2w Trees/ac (Fail) Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 1 ual Monitoring ition Inc. MMI FnVi_'=eAfti FIGURE 2.2 NOV 2017 MY4 of 5 Table 5: Vegetation Condition Assessment Table Stallings Site Buffer Restoration #357 (Flat Swamp, Jones County) Monitoring Year 4 of 5 (2017) Planted Acreage = 31.6 Mapping % of Vegetation Problem Category Definitions Threshold CCPV Number of Combined Planted (acres) Depiction Polygons Acreage Acreage Bare Areas Very limited cover of both woody and herbaceous material 0.1 N/A 0 0 0% Low Stem Density Areas Woody stem densities clearly below target levels based on 0.1 *** Not Mapped; See Note Below 0% MY3, 4, or 5 stem count criteria. Total7-0—F 0% Areas of Poor Growth Rates or Vigor ' Areas with woody stems of a size class that are obviously small F0.25 ***Not Mapped; See Note Below 0% given the monitoring year. Cumulative Total 0 0 60% Easement Acreage = 50.7 Mapping % of Vegetation Problem Category Definitions Threshold CCPV Number of Combined Easement (SF) Depiction Polygons Acreage Acreage Invasive Areas of Concern Areas of points (if too small to render as polygons at map scale). 1000 N/A 0 0 0% Easement Encroachment Areas Areas of points (if too small to render as polygons at map scale). none N/A 0 0 0% Problem areas are based on field observations in October 2017, 44 months after initial tree planting. Competition from tall Grasses, Solidago, Eupatorium, Rubus, Baccharis, Morella, and other dense native plants may be limiting planted tree survival and growth. Easement (Mitigation Assets) acreage = 31.6 acres planted + 19.1 acres preserved riparian buffers = 50.7 acres. Total conservation parcel acreage = 146 acres. *** Many small planted trees were recently cut or crushed in Oct 2017 during cutting of transects for replanting this winter. Consequently, the majority of the planted area currently has low planted stem density and/or low vigor. Since the site will be replanted soon, it was not feasible or necessary to map and measure low density areas beyond the CVS plots this year. Areas of low stem density and low vigor will be mapped and quantified in the MY5 (2018) monitoring report. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 20 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County- Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI • 1fff� \� F � i �rey n r�a� wr�1-;a��7'�,��'�c-',� A� h 34 `^� '"�97FRrta his �' ` y •y �y �a� sr '� CVS VegPlot-1: MY -1 Sep 23-25, 2014 CVS VegPlot- 1: MY -4 Oct 16- 18,2017 �� Y-r�� 1„g ^�j.T' �{ah �•��L' � ��;�J� it; •�~~ ' '. V Y- � � f k � S •4- l •i:�i`'-Ldrlr'+i.>j psr-.. P„r .�;1 }dr r • .-,,'"�{st � `j' �y.� ''iJ 1•-'@.. t`••���'i�1.,- � `�''. .s.x �Y?aar: ! � _ -- S.` • ti n '��ytiLjf vL!- .��.. � •7 �. S/S �- - _�,�.. �tla L��'S ' • � ��:� �R_"lam"�_e � { �i'o f �" ':..` fir':. �!� t.. '- ..^'s'C"' •-; rr >�' f. Lc � z• n v� 1 07 � . bis• 14p $ � ��:� 1' zz I�, ,F � ..►^..'. , � � _ � ._ � � 1. �� z . � �,.: . - - �,r / •times.. ` ! ti` � � � Figure 3.3 Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 23 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Figure 3.4 Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 24 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Figure 3.5 Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 25 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI - fik, AFt CVS . ' - .. �� ... � � �t9 •'''mss �_ ����iF � � �,, p.d _ _ ,y •' • 1 Mar 11-12, 2014 CVS VegPlot-11:Oct.2017 x L`�Im AV ._• - 5q.�`. R. _ '"' _y moo'! '..;.ra;+3i' .Y�rvsry�. .l ,C,:.,�-�< �;,�•.¢'''�-.� 14, �p y d 14 '� ,�L -~ire--. �� �' t t�J� i•. f -' h - , y� fe �- J . • " +R � �.� �� � y-� � � � � 'a'`'rt �:- �k.: 7r. -. .�. �.. ..... ...-r..-.- _. _•9.,d':/�. `_ J 3G��..ai]��'Q`Yr_r�7f 11� �.� � !\_^.�/_ Figure 3.7 Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 27 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Figure 3.8 Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 28 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Figure 3.9 Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 29 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI J7 - i t ✓ ° yrs i . • � i " .� � !./l _ A... - i CVS •' • ' 1 1 •' • ' Oct.2017 WC "At 41 Av .. � .+.sem. �Lk %n .iii+: % �` i� �4 k .-' •/ . �'' `'�'T}��� � j I y�Y y, _ ��,'+�r-� - �• .. �,.,.;�'�• �•ys,.' '• � ' s� ;�. _.. -7 R;! � \:. fey } •c � ��°� .z y �' ji �� - +� �`S n t ,�� � t.�,�*s,�•,•„�•""�--t�� �t _ � ��` � --.• 4' T-� max,- °°� • � . moi; fi� •+� c �:��,. � FRI - t Y r - f•;N s _ '�- F-_n'� ; �: •4"�`"� r � !` r s''�-'^'a;r� ."%y'J� S�� .;7•�+� - , ,r�' '� Tc,�•p��"i°'y fcrt{ ^a,�.r n• ' A-k, -- - i"�,.}-• - _-^./'.. �^�."�:`�:-:raw'>- .:� �.�� ��'�y ."� - 1` Y w: may.:.:- T'"+-' ��i.'J.�.:'i'x`�S �i'r�.�::�'Y.;ird�'�.�.-;::..':.:.:'p`1�.ti7•�>.-'�•^fiw -J:. `-;'�: •. .. ~."_=+ A'. T�Nl 7 -7, ,tm V�a _ 5�� `gam r ~ Figure 3.13 Vegetation Monitoring Plots & Other Photos - Stallings Buffer Restoration #357 - MY4 (2017) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 33 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI �M TT�.I'r+� �Fr 4���• r�[ I lgib'� `��. _ �CN, �Q�y�f ��� g3 6i 49, 1 � `t � �;>� 00� ] '9�' �T�''{m,�y+c• [� � .s� A 3- .4 wetlandBaccharis thicket west of Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 33 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Appendix C. Vegetation Plot Monitoring Data Table 6. CVS Plot Stem Density & Success Summary Table 7. CVS Plot Stem Counts & Density by Species and Year (Scanned 2017 raw data sheets are in support files on CD) Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 34 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 6. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities & Success Stallings Buffer Site #357 Flat Swamp, Jones Co. Stream/Wetland, Riparian Buffer, & Total Stem Densities (stems per acre, MY4: Oct 2017) Plot ID Stream/ Wetland Stems Volunteer Stems2 Success Total Stems Criteria Met? 0001 243 283 526 NO 0002 121 81 202 NO 0003 324 121 445 YES 0004 283 81 364 NO 0005 121 81 202 NO 0006 81 81 162 NO 0007 122 202 324 NO 0008 202 162 364 NO 0009 162 121 283 NO 0010 445 0 445 YES 0011 122 202 324 NO 0012 445 243 688 YES 0013 324 40 364 YES 0014 284 40 324 NO 0015 243 162 405 NO 0016 283 81 364 NO 0017 365 40 405 YES 0018 162 40 202 NO 0019 243 202 445 NO 0020 162 283 445 NO 0021 404 324 728 YES 0022 405 283 688 YES 0023 566 162 728 YES 0024 122 40 162 NO 0025 364 243 607 YES Project Avg 264 144 408 NO Woody Stem Classification I Stream/Wetland Stems = Native planted trees and shrubs. Does NOT include live stakes or vines. 2Volunteers = Native volunteer trees and shrubs. Does NOT include vines or planted stems. 3Total = Planted + volunteer native woody stems, including live stakes. Excludes exotics & vines. Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 35 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 7A. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities: MY -4: Oct 2017. Stallings Buffer Site #357. Scientific Name Common Name Species Type 357-01-0001 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0002 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0003 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0004 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0005 PnoLS P -all T Acer negundo Boxelder maple Tree Acer rubrum Red maple Tree Alnus serrulata Hazel alder Shrub Crataegus spp. Hawthorn Shrub Diospyros virginiana Persimmon Tree Fraxinus pennsylvanica Green ash Tree 1 1 Ilex opaca American holly Tree Ilex vomitoria Yaupon holly Shrub Juniperus virginiana Eastern redeedar Tree Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum Tree 1 5 1 1 1 1 Liriodendron tulipifera Tuliptree Tree 1 1 1 Nyssa sylvatica Blackgum Tree I I I Pinus taeda Loblolly pine Tree Platanus occidentalis American sycamore Tree 5 5 6 3 3 4 2 3 3 31 2 2 2 Prunus angustifolia Chickasaw plum Shrub I Prunus serotina Black cherry Tree Quercus nigra Water oak Tree 1 1 1 2 2 2 Quercus phellos Willow oak Tree 5 5 5 Quercus rubra Northern red oak Tree 2 2 2 2 2 2 Rhus copallinum Winged sumac Shrub Ulmus americana American elm Tree Stem count size (ares) size (ACRES)0.0247 Species count Stems per ACRE 61 61 1 21 21 243 243 13 4 526 3 3 1 0.0247 1 1 121 121 5 8 2 3 202 324 8 1 0.0247 3 324 11 5 445 7 3 83 7 1 0.0247 3 2831 9 5 364 3 3 5 1 0.0247 2 2 4 In 1211 202 Color Codes for Planted Tree Density Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements by 10% Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements, but by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements, by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements by more than 10% Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 36 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County- Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 7B. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities: MY -4: Oct 2017. Stallings Buffer Site #357. Scientific Name Common Name Species Type 357-01-0006 357-01-0007 357-01-0008 357-01-0009 357-01-0010 PnoLS P -all T PnoLS P -all T PnoLS P -all T PnoLS P -all T PnoLS P -all T Acer negundo Boxelder maple Tree Acer rubrum Red maple Tree 1 Alnus serrulata Hazel alder Shrub Crataegus spp. Hawthorn Shrub Diospyros virginiana Persimmon Tree Fraxinus pennsylvanica Green ash Tree I 1 1 2 2 2 Ilex opaca American holly Tree Ilex vomitoria Yaupon holly Shrub Juniperus virginiana Eastern redcedar Tree Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum Tree 1 3 3 1 Liriodendron tulipifera Tuliptree Tree I 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 1 yssa sylvatica Blackgum Tree I 1 l Pinus taeda Loblolly pine Tree 1 2 1 l Platanus occidentalis American sycamore Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 l 2 2 2 Prunus angustifolia Chickasaw plum Shrub Prunus serotina Black cherry Tree Quercus nigra Water oak Tree 1 1 1 Quercus phellos Willow oak Tree I 1 1 4 4 4 Quercus rubra Northern red oak Tree I 1 1 3 3 3 2 2 2 Rhus copallinum Winged sumac Shrub Ulmus americana American elm Tree Stem count size (ares) size (ACRES) Species count Stems per ACRE 2 2 4 3 3 8 5 5 9 4 4 7 11 11 11 1 1 1 1 1 0.0247 0.0247 0.0247 0.0247 0.0247 21 2 4 2 2 4 5 5 7 2 2 5 5 5 5 81 81 162 1 121 324 202 364 162 162 283 445 445 445 Color Codes for Planted Tree Density Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements by 10% Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements, but by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements, by less than 10% L M Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements by more than 10% Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 37 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County- Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 7C. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities: MY -4: Oct 2017. Stallings Buffer Site #357. Scientific Name Common Name Species Type 357-01-0011 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0012 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0013 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0014 PnoLS P -all T PnoLS 357-01-0015 P -all T Acer negundo Boxelder maple Tree 1 Acer rubmin Red maple Tree Ahms serrulata Hazel alder Shrub Crataegus spp. Hawthorn Shrub Diospyros virgimana Persimmon Tree Fraxinus pennsylvanica Green ash Tree 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 2 Ilex opaca American holly Tree Ilex vomitoria Yaupon holly Shrub Juniperus virginiana Eastern redeedar Tree Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum Tree 4 3 1 I 1 1 1 Liriodendron tulipifera Tuliptree Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Nyssa sylvatica Blackgum Tree Pinus taeda Loblolly pine Tree 3 Platanus occidentalis American sycamore Tree 2 2 2 5 5 5 3 3 3 1 1 1 Prunus angustifolia Chickasaw plum Shrub Prunus serotina Black cherry Tree Quercus nigra Water oak Tree I 1 I I Quercus phellos Willow oak Tree 2 2 2 2 2 2 4 4 4 Quercus rubra Northern red oak Tree 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 Rhus copallinum Winged sumac Shrub Ulmus americana American elm Tree Stem count size (ares) size (ACRES) Species count Stems per ACRE 3 2 121 3 1 0.0247 2 121 8 4 324 11 4 445 11 1 0.0247 4 445 17 6 688 8 4 324 8 1 0.0247 4 324 9 5 364 71 6 283 7 1 0.0247 6 283 8 7 324 6 6 1 0.0247 3 3 243 10 6 405 Color Codes for Planted Tree Density Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements by 10% Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements, but by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements, by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements by more than 10% Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 38 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County- Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 7D. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities: MY -4: Oct 2017. Stallings Buffer Site #357. Scientific Name Common Name Species Type 357-01-0016 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0017 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0018 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0019 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0020 PnoLS P -all T Acer negundo Boxelder maple Tree Acer rubrum Red maple Tree Alnus serrulata Hazel alder Shrub Crataegus spp. Hawthorn Shrub Diospyros virgimana Persimmon Tree 5 Fraxinus pennsylvanica Green ash Tree 1 1 I Ilex opaca American holly Tree Ilex vomitoria Yaupon holly Shrub Juniperus virginiana Eastern redeedar Tree Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum Tree I I I Liriodendron tulipifera Tuliptree Tree 1 1 1 Nyssa sylvatica Blackgum Tree 1 I I I I I 1 1 I Pinus taeda Loblolly pine Tree 1 Platanus occidentalis American sycamore Tree 4 4 4 2 2 2 1 1 1 5 2 Prunus angustifolia Chickasaw plum Shrub Prunus serotina Black cherry Tree I Quercus nigra Water oak Tree 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 Quercus phellos Willow oak Tree 1 1 1 4 4 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 Quercus rubra Northern red oak Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 Rhus copallinum Winged sumac Shrub Ulmus americana American elm Tree Stem count size (ares) size (ACRES) Species count Stems per ACRE 7 41 283 7 1 0.0247 41 283 9 6 364 9 44 364 91 1 0.0247 364 10 5 405 41 41 1 0.0247 4 4 162 5 6 5 5 202 243 6 1 0.0247 5 243 11 4 4 1 0.0247 6 2 2 445 1 162 11 4 445 Color Codes for Planted Tree Density Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements by 10% Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements, but by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements, by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements by more than 10% Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 39 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County- Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 7E. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities: MY -4: Oct 2017. Stallings Buffer Site #357. Scientific Name Common Name Species Type 357-01-0021 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0022 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0023 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0024 PnoLS P -all T 357-01-0025 PnoLS P -all T Acer negundo Boxelder maple Tree Acer rubrum Red maple Tree 2 1 Alnus serrulata Hazel alder Shrub Crataegus spp. Hawthorn Shrub I Diospyros virgimana Persimmon Tree Fraxinus pennsylvanica Green ash Tree 2 2 1 1 1 1 Ilex opaca American holly Tree Ilex vomitoria Yaupon holly Shrub Juniperus virginiana Eastern redeedar Tree Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum Tree 2 Liriodendron tulipifera Tuliptree Tree Nyssa sylvatica Blackgum Tree 2 2 2 2 2 2 4 4 4 Pinus taeda Loblolly pine Tree 3 1 Platanus occidentalis American sycamore Tree 2 21 3 71 7 7 1 1 21 3 3 4 Prunus angustifolia Chickasaw plum Shrub Prunus serotina Black cherry Tree 1 1 2 4 Quercus nigra Water oak Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 Quercus phellos Willow oak Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 Quercus rubra Northern red oak Tree 4 4 4 10 10 10 1 1 1 Rhus copallinum Winged sumac Shrub Ulmus americana American elm Tree Stem count size (ares) size (ACRES) Species count Stems per ACRE 10 4 405 10 1 0.0247 4 405 18 8 728 10 3 405 10 1 0.0247 3 405 17 7 688 14 3 567 14 1 0.0247 3 567 18 3 3 0.0247 II 6 3 3 728 121 121 4 91 3 4 162 364 9 1 0.0247 4 3641 15 6 607 Color Codes for Planted Tree Density Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements by 10% Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements, but by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements, by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements by more than 10% Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 40 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County- Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI Table 7F. CVS Vegetation Plot Stem Densities: MY -4: Oct 2017 - Annual Mean Densities. Stallings Buffer Site #357. Scientific Name Common Name Species MY5 (2018) Type PnoLS P -all T MY4 (2017) PnoLS P -all T MY3 (2016) Pnol-S P -all T MY2 (2015) Pnol-S P -all T MY1 (2014) PnoLS IP -all T Acer negundo Boxelder maple Tree 1 2 Acer rubrum Red maple Tree 4 6 1 Alnus serrulata Hazel alder Shrub 1 Crataegusspp. Hawthorn Shrub 1 Diospyros virginiana Persimmon Tree 51 1 4 Fraxinus pennsylvanica Green ash Tree 8 8 17 10 10 14 8 Ilex opaca American holly Tree 2 1 llex vomitoria Yaupon holly Shrub 1 Jumperus virginiana Eastern redcedar Tree 1 Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum Tree 31 39 23 24 Liriodendron tulipifera Tuliptree Tree 101 10 101 11 11 12 191 19 19 25 25 25 Nyssa sylvatica Blackgum Tree 13 13 13 16 16 16 17 17 17 25 25 25 Pinus taeda Loblolly pine Tree 13 9 5 6 Platanus occidentalis American sycamore Tree 50 50 64 49 49 62 59 59 65 73 73 89 Prunus angustifolia Chickasaw plum Shrub 1 1 Prunus serotina Black cherry Tree 9 ill 14 Quercus nigra Water oak Tree 11 11 12 7 7 8 4 4 4 4 41 4 Quercus phellos Willow oak Tree 31 31 31 27 27 27 261 26 27]51 23 23 Quercus rubra Northern red oak Tree 40 40 40 46 46 46 41 41 41 51 52 Rhus copallinum Winged sumac Shrub 10 Ulmus americana American elm Tree 1 Unknown Shrub/Tree 4 4 4 1 1 Stem count size (ares) size (ACRES) Species count Stems per ACRE I 1 163 7 1 2641 1631 25 0.618 7 2641 252 151 4081 166 7 2691 1661 25 0.618 7 2691 271 19 439 170 7 275 170 25 0.618 7 2751 214 Ill 3461 202 7 3271 202 25 0.618 7 3271 266 12 431 Color Codes for Planted Tree Density Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements by 10% Exceeds 320 trees/acre requirements, but by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements, by less than 10% Fails to meet 320 trees/acre requirements by more than 10% Stallings Buffer Restoration Site DMS #357 41 MY -4 (2017) Annual Monitoring Report Jones County - Neuse HUC 03020204 Mogensen Mitigation Inc. MMI