HomeMy WebLinkAbout20181252 Ver 1_R-5735 Architecture and ok APE for Ranger Road connector and Hiwassee Street_20180913McHenry, David G
From: Husband, Katherine L
Sent: Monday, August 27, 2018 725 AM
To: McHenry, David G
Subject: RE: [External] RE: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
H I Dave,
Sorry for the late reply, on my end, this email serves that there is no survey required for that portion of the extended
APE for Historic Architecture. And not a problem, we are juggling a lot of projects and things happen.
Thanks!
Kate
Kate Husband
Architectural Historian
Environmental Analysis Unit
North Carolina Department of Transportation
919 707 6075 office
klhusband(a�ncdot.gov
NCDOT— EAU
1598 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1598
Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the
North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties.
From: McHenry, David G
Sent: Thursday, August 23, 2018 5:42 PM
To: Jones, Damon; Husband, Katherine L
Cc: Mcdowell, Kenneth ]; Simone, Emaly
Subject: RE: [External] RE: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
Well, I guess I screwed up again. Per the attached GIS shot and the screen shot of plans below, we have another APE
exceedence on the R-5735 project in Cherokee County. We still are not beyond Hiwassee Street to the east where the
Fort Butler site is. But, the spot where the dissipator pad below is flatter terrainnear that creek. I believe most is
imported fill, but portion of where dissipator pad will go is wooded. I believe in hindsight them engineers moved it up
there to avoid the sewer line.
I don't know why this is so hard for us (me) to catch this stuff earlier — heck I didn't even notice it when I saw the other
APE exceedenace back in May. I think from now on Division 14 needs to have the APEs put in CADD drawings (sort of
like we do with HPBs — when we remember to do that!) so it will pop out when we start doing design work. Obviously I
have trouble remembering to check it during plan review.
My apology Damon.
What do you think we should do here? We have a May 2019 let and believe it or not I was getting ready to send the
permit application tomorrow because it is taking a long time to get permits over this way.
Dave
� F-5i35_State_hdICD_�hecklist_Final_1�,15,1?,pclf - �cl�-be,�,erabat F;eacler D�
File E�lit 'M`ie�r '�rl�inclo�,� Hel�
H��e Tc��,ls R-�7�� Stat� i'�,��,,, �
�=,: � � '"�w �� � 1� 1 �� � `l- -, � � �?��'�❑ T . ii3 +$' I
�� � r IH�
� ___= ti � i .� 4 ����� -__ �� _�� �'.�d.
�� 9 't, i��.�a� ��' � � � �c�r�,r�� r� ;;� �,� -�- _ __
� _ _== ` �� �� R�r a,nF � ' � �x ���r �' ;� - ,� � _
� � ��r r��+='�.� � � `'� N ��, ,�`-- -�'-� ''
�� �,Ei�TEki�LE=1�s�SY � � ',` �� _ " " 't -�
�. �, �' w , A�, ��% ,�- � � ; ���'�
_,� `� SEE �ET�sIL H ��},,y�� ; '�" �i "' ��" �"�:'�-:
� yi S_� 5�4 RIR RAF CtifR�aY [�ISSI�AT �a�_ � �`�. y�i . ^° I�;��'z
�o�'''i- - '41f+4�"L �� R�P I�r�.�F' t�'1� �.W� .���. � �'+* �� L� i
't1��; L Afi' GsL''E fS�Y' �, e � i�a�a.� i� `�
i � -,, �-' `� � � r`� �, �_, � -� , i�'t.,
4
� r 1 �' I� �� } `�r� �"� ,
} f Y � � � _ ' � � �L'_ _
[i , ��1 6
�1r � + 7 I �
� � F �: I' ,IS. "�� fi",5 4 t���� `�� ���� I��,� A�.
i+�hl� r� r,q, 4 � 9�J Cl4P -YS- /' tl r � f W'� S.
C-Il3 = �a � 11C� CI�7'' �2i i��` �4� i�
� ,�i• "�
uosr. t G �:a� �s � �a.s� �r� , I �,. ; ' � , 4�� I � =
r. '°�+ �;%� RT - F;tiv � la n� i �� ~'"�
Ef,��lv� ELEW I� �k:.73` 4{-� sU [7i1 �' ��i_ � ~� � �` �d ,r'.•� -- ~�' � ��
-EYI.�1- �T�` i�t�'S 3c� %Fi'.7C' LT. �. ,� [74. VC'V.� � I ~--�_. r�, ' Z�tia• �
`J:4�L �� 3Al.ciE irF PP � t� '"\ i� r--y rr �-n ���+ t.`�.' � � f
� s�, I �` ��'� �,� fl � �� '� + �� � �+ ��,i; 3'' ,d f � Ir ��-__ . �a
��� � �.._ev� � �-J� � � ' i; � y� �
� ��� 'ti �. r=; '���� I_�;�± y�P �- I+i �' ---�`,���'��
1, � I J � `��. c� �
1, � "j I y i' � � I� 4.7 M1 I F � I
4 I �'Y�� , ,y �. �} ^ f� M . 1 �j I�y � � � r�
�`NY } . J � � I� ! 7 � (� R
J � �, ��� ,,, � ;�, �� � �, : r" � Ir�, � � y��
� k.; � ,"�.,;.' ` '�.,��� j � �, � I �I !� � `'�i
r� rE. ,,, _. � t� i r� ,� �� ��
��� � �,� � .,�,.� � �..� r ��� " + 'I ° ��
r� � ,���� z , I � � w { � i I� �
f� �°-� � ~ �' i�,l�' ��'�� -�'��': � � � � '�� �N� �
� u� '�#r� . �� �. a�� � _ � � - � � � ����
� � ; � <:. - � �I _ � t,:
-}'�i��I��- �'�'T .`_�3� . r �����+�i .},�' -S4� �+CF h'� 1��,. � �_ L -
rr 4/ � � � �AI' Ff '�" I
� f � ;2, y�`MT .C`� 55.R7d fkT �� S T j o� i i �
II +` I '� � .{ ..� ,�',�r'. � L� d e � �•,
,1 �' �j t �,�`+' ; ��� 3 i �. ���7"'' ,rFt'""�� o-.. I
� ! �'/` ..I , �.,. . � �1�7a`� � �; ' �RE E @� �;�a
B � � �� � `+,��:�" 2. �°'��` .�` � �� , ��T.��,�.��4�c�
� I �l µ�_ _ �` .. � �l"� ,� f i'"��C1�'�R�f�hJ a "�m i .;��'-�- �,° �. � � z i� fr�'
l. � �'�i �
�
� ; . .� `?` �' (I n ' r� �i��
��` � '� �, y � �A��=;�, �� `�,�, � ���y��f�y �,�i� �' � . . � L�Y� ' (p
� ' ,/ � �C��,a+' � ��`% I'T -i �� � �. ' y+3�i LT��� � I ' I�� '��d ' . �� p � M� I
� � �I f . `� � f ' � l#V � � + t� �,,:,�'' _ �+-9� �� �� N ��'�}�1�'�-�� I , � i �`
�/� �,'�',,� ���,�;��° �� ST. ���• 4'4_i:��,�' _�,,,,�: _-:�, " " 1 � ��'!�Y ' ,a�� I�
� 6�' ,+' IL � G�� � ' �,� - � � r 'r�, L � i` i� �. w�� ha.2 �
µ � � I I 1� y. �' � I j
� �, �,� - � � � o �`�—:, .�' , b � �
� 1 �� IP � s = `' ,.' `� i� i, � ���
;,•c..
. J,
. ,+ � ( ..4 r� i� �'�_ � • r-' .�. .�Il�, � `.. . � � � A� �� � i. r� f '�� . F���Y�
,J� f`\ ; . �=,�1 r' i _�7"h� '� ' � d`"T • i 4� al� �� F� `` }.I i�
F
'll,� �l rl� �`.,'� ,{+ � "J 5 a bAF Re� r 'i�� A� �i Er� b'� �'k� �u � "" 4 ��
� ,���� t� � TCl ,��(ISTI�1�—� �, �'; � �� �i��� �� ���� ���„�I ,} ��c�c
t — f �,.� r y �,�s�� ,l� �� �� s�U L� o��fxF � k� 7. �' } �_��
� �..� F%I N .�.i�,��, ��P � � � h+� I
f m't �e �[ 27 II YV I� � s�
/` �t].� �.1— 5 I � 1�� ! . �MYr� � �� 4' .� I . 111 . , ' � A'1,' V J_ >
-_„ ,wr-. �,� � E� u � �� - {� �" ��� E.�-.� � � � � ,, ,�� �;� -=� .�
� � -'`�:��' _� 'r",- �, ,��,.'._�� ' r: �,.i `� -,f� ','+x v-
� � ` _r . �_ . � p#■�F'' ,. �� � r` " , � d` ,� ��'�F� I�� �; .1 , y x+ �S �, � - � r��� �
_ . � �3G`+ �.I �� ,�,� o ;f '�,��^� � � .h' � �_ "� �y
� 'I '� H �R17 � � �. �.. `'� a - r: +, � �'� ''#v' l 4i � � ��� +A�
' S ` ^ RL .'Y i � ' ��+ �' . 7 �. �I i�
� =s� +
� � F"i �-5�� �_ ` �°� .�.`�, r` ��,� �. ' +r# Mt r���`° � F � '•. ; t pa���i -�+' . �. .'� r `1 iv I''�4"�� y�'iti'�4tis ;r���4�
�� e�� �- .5 Y �:" �:.i3- . `.�.'��C.1 r I �� 'r-� . ��w.�P M <�`�",'� �Y. i' 'i� '����
r" -� ��' •� �'� ! c5.�:�C' -Yl�� `�' �':,f'L�F : `.- : ��i.� �" I °rf I �,^ ��CJS�i+ ��5� �'�h�� ��1 �4
I I � �� Y�`�I,�.c�� =rr�—�'� � ��•��l��r. �e .--- � — ,; ,, ' 1 ,, _ Y� � �
�� `�-� -f � � ��� ���' RT F` 1 f `=�' '' �`� I p � t 7
�-_. �I� � %� i E�; �r'� 1 �I]�! -r�fE�.Ci(7 YI + �9F5%��i-�L�,w7C� Y'1�,� , h �, Y ��' � ti � +'a �d
IY� i �� � i'i,'yr�, ---y E�(. R�`A! �, ,� �� E�i. �'4h+ �r �w4 ti� I Fra yp � 'c�b �ti�l
,. �.!.� — � � .3�L^ c,� r� � ti � � r C�
,� ��;. ��`. I �� ,� ./ ���� -- - � �' —ry ��d�S.O�J' RT '-'+ '�� Ni :�--¢ '� � � 1y�'" '�
�I i �'C�•. Ca7`. � ��a �I.°alf`) ,.- ��T �`,��Li ��1.1-f'.. .� y �y`� �r �y ,+�� �~4-
��� . , � x��. �
I 9 q'�' J IL.11—. —+ti'",^"=; ,5° ' '� t�, �
i� � � � ;�+e �r;r�;��r� � r ekFr ��'= -� �; � � s . 5� , � ���
. ; � r�� � ,- � i, D�l a�� Y ��f�G�'' i`I�y`�r �a���l_�`��r� ��-r` i_�,� 1k ti��� `�y �1 M11�'��
� F 1�
! I�} �� �- - i~` !r �i i '�/�} 4Y< I'�^ �:7 ..4'�� H�r'I� � � � r r- r�� n r-✓ x7 r �r�,s� a sti, h�- �' �'fJ ..�l ��ti�. Y-
3
From: McHenry, David G
Sent: Friday, May 4, 2018 1:54 PM
To: Jones, Damon <cdjones2@ncdot.gov>; Husband, Katherine L<klhusband@ncdot.gov>
Cc: Mcdowell, Kenneth J<kjmcdowell@ncdot.gov>; Simone, Emaly <Emaly.Simone@mbakerintl.com>
Subject: RE: [External] RE: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
10-4Thanks Damon
From: Jones, Damon
Sent: Friday, May 04, 2018 1:34 PM
To: McHenry, David G<d�mchenry@ncdot.�ov>; Husband, Katherine L<klhusband@ncdot.�ov>
Cc: Mcdowell, Kenneth J<klmcdowell@ncdot.�ov>; Simone, Emaly <Emaly.Simone@mbakerintl.com>
Subject: RE: [External] RE: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
Hey Dave,
You are right, it is all disturbed up in there. Any additional work that needs to be done in that section between Old
Ranger Road and US 64 is not going to affect any intact archaeological resources. Anything beyond Hiwassee Street or
north of Old Ranger Road would be my only concerns. The connector is fine and will not require further archaeological
review. My old PA is still valid. You can just include this email in any potential documents to show that I was made
aware of the connector and it was cleared.
Let me know if you have any additional questions.
C. Damon Jones
Archaeologist
Environmental Analysis Unit
N.C. Department of Transportation
919 707 6076 office
919 250 4224 fax
cdiones2@ncdot.�ov
1020 Birch Ridge Drive
1598 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1598
Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the
North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties.
From: McHenry, David G
Sent: Friday, May 04, 2018 12:45 PM
To: Jones, Damon; Husband, Katherine L
Cc: Mcdowell, Kenneth ]; Simone, Emaly
Subject: RE: [External] RE: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
Damon and Kate,
I think I found a gap in the APE coverage of what will be constructed on R-5735; I believe we added a connector road in
the area highlighted below in your APE map. I believe this is probably the only area where we will be disturbing that is
beyond the APE (Mac or Simone please chime in if I am missing anything else). We still are not going beyond Hiwassee
Street though.
Do you all think this is worth considering further? I believe the area in question is pretty well discturbed like most of the
rest of the area. We can do a document consultation at this point.
Thanks
Dave
� ,�R17-08-(J�f�nosurvey.pd'f - ,4ciab�e Acr�r�rat Read�r �°�
File ErJit 'sliew�, '�"�'indoaw� Help
Hc�r�e To�ls F:�i�S Cultural �a.,, A�R17-�1�-�1[127nQs,,, �
LOJ � � � �+.� � � . 1�� � � � �'J � O�J a � � +y+ -
�� �(DfiT�fl'��Eftt " � ,�� 1 � � J�,_^; � ��! .�.� �Y` �!
: f` �'� 1��� �' ,. � � '�.+ ��I,} � h �" �, y�,�� � +, •�9
�� .��v� . r�� ,y,41���' F }�..� �!�'"F �., :I�� f� � j�__4� .
rth +'o� �'� �� SR,.� '^f ��.+ � �y._ T 4 iK' '} T 1 , 4� r
�� � � .� . : � .,�rt,p� 55 S cj �� ,t�:,-�� � • �f �� *�fi ,r
� �� � �r\ y , .�`P � \t �Y .'_ � .A
�i - ,� �a �` . .. !.': . ,' • � �.. � � �Y
N��+::�� h��i�' � ",,,� tr "� � �` f- a �� •. C�''r ' � �;
'+,;Z '� � 'a � � ..� . r! ' �1 '. � „'g' ri. �W� �, x �„ . � w +'� �, ': `k £��•'t' �, a A"+c� -�,�_
� ���� � J e � j .� •:i �.. � _ a,�,� �. r . �'Y � ��' ,....`i'#� � ��"�
A �;.Y�.a��V! ����,� �'g� '" ''!` ° x� P� � �1 {� s �`_�'�"��
7�,7 .���� _:�r s {p '�ti ��� _ ii,�' ��,, �� �` �� i , �-_ - A` '��
�. � �K i r �' r �k;. �a � ��y . _� � .�.,_�3c� ... �
rp�E�y�' x.���'b k��� . y..' � � ��- 5i ^�' .�'�''-�a r h'sa.� .x
_.� 4 4�' �: �'+� s� ��. ... '�� ''� �' � j �—� ��.� . �
1 . � �� 7 444� � E� �} � .. 3 t � � ' � w� ..
i .r � C;.� �- '�;�� �i�.
��� �;;" � • �,d�,;�2: "� v� u ,ar w _ � : � ;�
� � ,� � � j �`° ., r+�` w ° - ; '�q ,iy `'q�- � R. e�` :`' � `: �' �, � '`'` ,'� k `-
� '� � i . "� � ,� ��
'�,R � M ; � µ*,r ,. �n{ � ., �:� � i! � 5 '�'
.• � � � �� �� �� jt.
f Y!� '� i v'�:i-^ r "Yr�s� �.�- ����! . -' .. _ : �°:
�'�'i-�;- 3, } K 'L � � ,st K _ - - � � �
X � �u f�i, � 5�� i`�����r � � -2�i`+ -
f'aM1b`�"6 ,i ~� r, � :w , � ±� :# � � ,r ,, ; _ � - . a ' ,,� F, fi`�] •
� a: ,� � �r ��s� �-''` s - �' x 7 E Ci''�
y � A_k _I f. 9�� '�. h ' 1 .rF _ '
t � 4 '
� r - �p $ � -' � . ,�' ,,� � -
� y... 96 . ��.-� � N �5. �� �. :.: F �-.. ,� 1. r _ \. Y� � � '�� � r ;� _
��y �,�',� � -_�_�� .;.�j}�� ,, rt � .w.�' � � ♦`�.
rt { e�':'�, � � ..+.� L'�.f � ¢:��i.'.i�i`�Y�l�"�� �'.��'� ' - er�� �•� ;.; ��i N!��
� �� �� i �� `1+' � � w �� If �� : ��' � ", � �,� � �' �t.�'� ...�
ti� .: �n _ �_ M +�.., � ��' :3�` r' � � �'�j���y �p ���
'' �,,� �^ ,�. �T :F � �• '' 't � � �� �� ,- Y 6�'���
I -��.. M � ' �� •,� l'�' � � � f i ��' . �,' �t��-.'#! �,�'.,��i,
�I �� - _ � � � f� i�✓ - r .�I h
�. F� � r�,, �, �?: w��� _�' � d�''it � ' �{ t ; � .,,�D "��'x� \ ��t� �� ���- ;'�
�'��,� a, '��Y �� �"''� _ ''' �.� ' ;� �: � ;T, �na��', � i
� � �(��� - yy�`,� � � ,}� � a ��s�y � � 4e�-� i �?
+, '.,.�.i'�ir'�� — �' � 11 � , rtit," t 14 j Yi'q ` i Yl� ,} .,� �.° .�����
E �� �', �i . 7� i �. 'F ' 'd �
. �� 1'(�'] �a. ���4 5'il} � 5 ''S' ♦ �� �ti ` �. '��,
� ."`. �v, ^ �r� 04"' '�iS L i .. 51� _ G T.}.�� YT � � �_ {d
! .� . . _ � : � , •��R :,� ..�.y; 4� �^ � - �
��'i'� � , f ��.v"` �. �. l��r
' �r. ��r•%- j�._�'f �.��..�.�:1 1s�j i �f ' �
� ��iy���yy' I � I,�. � ` I .�� � ���� �����
�. '�1• �� � �. �..' P . — . _ ��� y � . .. +M �'Y �, i � �
- rh��:�' u).��� Y �J'.. ' �'7�.1��\�
4
_y� ��`� . j ..a, I� �,4.: .
��' _ ,_�1P YF '� d .
�$ �
. � �'' '�_ .0 � " �
.�-�
' G. � 'i' � -. , � '$i'�� K - � ."a� �s I .� ��.:
�,,.... . A: 'r" sf"".'' . - ,/ . id.:r__ .3t '• Ir� �: �� ,r'
`� a`. -. � �'. � f
���HitK" Ak � E P� t r 'w � -� l
7r�i6 �� � � ' � ` � ,�,� .. �,`�' _— 4 .;- �, �� _�-�T �t � � Ihrr .e . . � �
,:,J , ,� 'k.j ,�.» _ r� . � �` ' � �:�
; �Si• � �� � z J - ' f '�i
�h �� �,/ � � 4 � � � u � � , '�X e.� i;����, _fr*,�' �` � 3� �` � 3�h r- � �
y
f'� - "� � �" ' � i���} + '_.-�. ��` 4r + I, � �� �i ;� . ��
i �
�S ,�'r 4 � � . �r� s�C' h - , c � ,,, �' � . � }'`";,� • � _ �, �' . .f,.,
_ V �~ �r s, � �+ �,s.
_ _ . 0 • �x . .- ,�nTii� ws `t�
''` �+ . I I �1 �-.:�� 4 _'�ff3' • � � a - ,
Y` �.. c� �f '�f �+k'__'y�it�' '�� •d� ��- '� J� ��t 9�' ��'� �
�., Qrt _ `� _,.i� �,� yt� .• il !?h'�.,� TMf �r g' ,4��kl� y�;; � i �"a4�A � � �: � �
'�' � ,� ,� r 1�� ,+� � � 4* s � � l��}�a} ,�.'try, 'f�` ��X � � �
�a A� ��� y, /'l•Y• t '� "f'. t _ �� �`
�e�: r� �,: ' {_���R' � �� •�'� '§� "� �� ,�x ,��,��'��Xt.
_ ,� ��_ '�` �s�� �''`L- � hy,�� � �r � ` r � � % �
R,` . i� x., r L � ,� l., 1
�� sp1. �a� �- . i „�;_..� 5^ .�� ��.
a,., {,¢'s T +i�'�= r :�{ � �: p�'P
� � � �r r.a y�. ��{7'
f� ��;ilTy�L�; ��'.*1,,�.� � � , ��,�:. ,�� .� � .
r .� ✓ i �y'� � i., �,�.'�
t�ent�ur at �0 fee� j� �. � � � �, �, "` - ~�. �@ '�
�� � ���.� .� .. _ � , .��� � '� ` f� .. ,�'� � , ,f - _u
6
From: Simone, Emaly [mailto:Emaly.Simone@mbakerintl.com
Sent: Friday, May 04, 2018 11:51 AM
To: McHenry, David G <d�mchenry@ncdot.�ov>
Cc: Mcdowell, Kenneth J <klmcdowell@ncdot.gov>
Subject: [External] RE: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
�� External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless verified. Send all suspicious email as an attachment to
ort S am.
Hi, Dave,
I think you are right. I included the attached map with the requests to Human Environment, but when I review their
determinations, they seem to have used a smaller area.
Please let me know if there is anything I can do to help.
Emaly
From: McHenry, David G [mailto:d�mchenry@ncdot.�ov]
Sent: Friday, May 04, 2018 11:28 AM
To: Simone, Emaly <Emaly.Simone@mbakerintl.com>
Cc: Mcdowell, Kenneth J <kjmcdowell@ncdot.�ov>
Subject: EXTERNAL: R-5735 Cherokee County
Emaly,
Would you please check that the APE's used for both the archaeological and architectural reviews for this project cover
the entire project? I am reviewing a new signal installation at Marks Driver where we will be putting a connector road
between Old Ranger Road and US 64, but it looks like the APE's for the cultural resource reviews for the R-5735 project
do not include the entire connector. If we need to, we can consult with the Human Environment Unit and do a MCDC
consultation/update.
Thanks
Dave McHenry
Environmental Officer
NC Department of Transportation/Division 14
828 586 2141 office
dgmchenry�a,ncdot.gov
253 Webster Road
Sylva, NC 28779
Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the
North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties.
Email correspondence to and from this sender is subject to the N.C. Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties.