Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20051690 Ver 1_Erosion Evaluation 4_20070803Z,05 1 EcoScience Corporation 1101 Haynes Street, Suite 101 Raleigh, North Carolina 919-828-3433 EcoScience MEMORANDU TO: George Howard, AUG 3 ZOO/ Restoration Systems, LLC (RS) DENR - WATER QUALM' ' WETI "AND STORkMATER BRANCH FROM: Michael Gloden DATE: January 31, 2007 RE: Erosion Evaluation No. 4 (12-28-2006) 06-277.04 The purpose of this memorandum it to provide you with the results of the most recent erosion evaluation of the former impoundment of the Carbonton Dam, performed in accordance with your Section 401 permit obligations. The former impoundment included 126,673 linear feet of affected stream reaches that extended through portions of Lee, Chatham, and Moore Counties, North Carolina. This evaluation was performed to document any evidence of erosion within the former impoundment ' including but not limited to bank failure, loss of stream bank trees, severe head-cuts, and the loss or gain of large depositional features. History The North Carolina Division of Water Quality (NCDWQ) Section 401 permit condition #9 associated with the Carbonton Dam - Deep River Restoration Site requires that a "survey [of] the present lake ' bed and its flooded tributaries [shall occur] at least every two weeks (bi-weekly) or within three days of a rain more than or equal to one inch at Moncure, NC." In order to satisfy permit condition #9, Restoration Systems, LLC authorized EcoScience Corporation (ESC) to conduct weather related ' erosion evaluations within the former Carbonton Impoundment (ESC Proposal P06-003 January 13, 2006). ' As described in greater detail within the summary memorandum for erosion transit 1, ESC has observed that the greater than or equal to one-inch rain events appear to result in a river stage increase to at least 1500 cubic feet per second (cfs). Thus, ESC proposes to use the correlation between large, regional rain events that cause more than a 1500 cfs reading at the Ramseur gaging ' station as the "initiation threshold" for a field evaluation. ESC estimates that this initiation threshold occurs after a river stage rise equal to ten percent of bankfull. Methods A rainfall event ranging from 1 to 3 inches occurred in the upstream watershed between December 22 and December-26, 2006 (Figure 1). A peak in river stage of over 3,210 cubic feet per second (cfs) was recorded at the USGS Ramseur river gage on December 25, 2006 as a result of this storm (Figure 2). The "initiation threshold" from this storm occurred on December 25 and the "evaluation threshold" on December 27. An erosion evaluation was conducted within the formerly impounded reaches of the Deep River on December 28, 2006. The activities on December 28 included Erosion Evaluation No. 4 1 06-277.04 observation points along the main stem of the Deep River and at accessible points along tributaries that comprise the former site impoundment. Activities on January 4, 2007 included a survey assessment of the substrate bar located between NC Highway 42 (NC42) and the former dam footprint within the Deep River. ESC expects to continue using these methods for future evaluations of greater than 1500 cfs river stage events. River Transit Erosion Evaluation A two-person team performed a twelve-mile canoe transit of the Deep River. The point of ingress was the Glendon Carthage Road bridge and the point of egress was the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission boat ramp (Figure 3). The team stopped at the mouth of all credited tributaries as described in the Mitigation Plan as well as at points along the river where notable conditions occurred. At each observation point, GPS data was collected for the location, photography was taken, and notes were recorded to describe the condition. Observation points previously evaluated during the last erosion evaluation (November 27, 2006) that showed no signs of change are not documented by this current evaluation. Additionally, observation points occurring at confluences to the deep river that appeared stable are not described in this report. Observation points are mapped on Figure 3. River Observation Point 1 River Observation Point 1 is located on the Deep River at the Norfolk-Southern rail bridge. No x change was observed relative to the assessment recorded on November 27, 2006 (Photo 1). Bank ' failure and sloughing continues on both banks directly below the bridge. River Observation Point 2 1 River Observation Point 2 is located on the Deep River approximately 1.0 mile downstream of the \ / Norfolk-Southern rail bridge. At this loc?atirm the Ii-ft hk of thA non Rim is_xperiencinq J?gnant inns of bank material ri??P +n ????r?? ;??k of vP Pt do . A narrow buffer between the ' river and adjacent agriculture, combined with poor herbaceous vegetation, has allowed for erosion to occur along this 150-200 foot stretch of bank (Photo 2). River Observation Point 3 River Observation Point 3 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with the upstream end of an oxbow near McClendon's Creek. Most of the vegetation appeared to be intact, and stream banks show no new signs of erosion (Photo 3). River Observation Point 4 River Observation Point 4 is located on the Deep River at the bridge crossing of Carbonton Road. On November 27, 2006 this location had a massive logjam on the upstream side of the bridge with woody debris spanning the entire width of the channel. This logjam has been flushed out between the two left-most bridge supports (Photo 4). Just below the bridge, the right bank of the Deep River ' has experienced erosion possibly as a result of the redirection of water from the upstream logjam (Photo 5). River Observation Point 5 X River Observation Point 5 is located on the right bank of the Deep River at the confluence with an unnamed tributary. At this location well established herbaceous vegetation had previously ,b0A1* UIT maintained stream bank stability. As a result of seasonal vegetation loss, the rise in storm surge 9,,tt *s eroded bank material and down cut the tributary (Photo 6). Erosion Evaluation No. 4 2 06-277.04 1 River Observation Point 6 River Observation Point 6 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with Big Governors Creek. A few areas at waters edge showed continued scouring but the majority of the bank material ??-appeared stable and still intact. Both banks of Big Governors Creek lack vegetative cover. An A10 accumulation of woody debris remains at the confluence (Photo 7). p River Observation Point 7 River Observation Point 7 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with an unnamed tributary ' X on the Knight Cattle Corporation property. At this _Location significant erosion has allowed a piece of the bank to break off and slide into the center of the channel f Photo 8). A head-cut has continued to migrate up the tributary and bank material continues to erode (Photo 9). ' River Observation Point 8 River Observation Point 8 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with an unnamed tributary near Monitoring Station 27. A head-cut continues to transport sediment from the tributary and has ' eroded further upstream. Significant sloughing and freshly exposed roots are present on the left bank (Photo 10). River Observation Point 9 River Observation Point 9 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with an unnamed tributary. A large head-cut at the confluence continues to migrate upstream, and bank material continues to [O>erode. A significant area of new sloughing was observed on the right bank of the tributary (Photo River Observation Point 10 River Observation Point 10 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with an unnamed tributary near Monitoring Station 2. Down cutting of the tributary was observed and large amounts of sediment has built up at the confluence with the Deep River (Photo 12). River Observation Point 11 River Observation Point 11 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with an unnamed tributary near Monitoring Station 23. A large head-cut has continued moving sediment out of the tributary while the banks remain steep and unvegetated. A large piece of the bank with a tree growing on it has broken off the bank and slid into the tributary (Photo 13). I \X River Observation Point 12 River Observation Point 12 is located on the Deep River at the confluence with Line Creek. Line Creek continues to experience severe bank erosion. Banks on Line Creek are deeply incised and sediment accumulation at the confluence has increased. The Norfolk-Southern railroad crosses Line Creek at this location and the banks have eroded further back towards the bridge. Woody debris remains scattered throughout the channel (Photo 14-15). River Observation Point 13 ?.?jqt River Observation Point 13 is located on the Deep River at the bridge crossing of NC 42, just upstream of the former Carbonton dam. At this location the massive logjam seen on November 27, 5(,0vJ?, 2006 has broken apart between the right-most two bridge supports. An accumulation of debris remains between the center-most spans. Below the bridge and above the old dam site scouring as observed near top of bank, but exposed bedrock maintains bank stability (Photo 16). 41 fo)-? ciusiun avaiuation ivo. 4 3 06-277.04 River Observation Point 14 River Observation Point 14 is a new point located approximately 1 mile downstream of the Glendon Carthage Road bridge over the Deep River. Limited erosion and bank sloughing was observed on the right bank (Photo 17). River Observation Point 15 River Observation Point 15 is a new point located approximately 1.5 miles downstream of the )C Glendon Carthage Road Bridge on the Deep River. Bank sloughing and freshly exposed roots were observed in several places (Photo 18). River Observation Point 16 River Observation Point 16 is a new point located on the Deep River at the mouth of Lick Creek. Heavy erosion and incision of the banks was observed on both sides of the creek (Photo 19) ' River Observation Point 17 River Observation Point 17 is a new point located approximately 2500 ft downstream of the X Carbonton Road bridge. Large scale erosion has occurred on the right bank in the form of a massive separation of bank material into the Deep River. The approximately 45 by 20 foot piece of ' the bank remains intact and has numerous live trees on it, including a 14 inch diameter sweetgum tree (Photo 20). ' River Observation Point 18 River Observation Point 18 is located at the confluence of an unnamed tributary on the left bank of the Deep River. This location occurs approximately 2500 ft below the confluence with Big Governor's Creek, and was documented for erosion on the June 26, 2006 evaluation. The headcut ' at this location appears unchanged, but an increase in bank erosion was observed, particularly on the right bank (Photo 21). i River Observation Point 19 River Observation Point 19 is a new point located at the confluence with an unnamed tributary on the right bank of the Deep River. Significant sloughing has occurred on the right bank and a small headcut is present (Photo 22). Land Transit Erosion Evaluation ¦ A two-person team reviewed as many credited tributaries during daylight hours as possible at public road crossings. Either a 500-foot reach or 20 bankfull widths of each credited tributary were ' evaluated at each stop, whichever was greater. Some long-term monitoring stations were visited that were not on credited reaches to compare conditions to previous visits in order to further describe the extent of the flooding event. At each observation point, photographs were taken and ' notes were recorded to describe notable conditions. All Land Observation Points were assessed for erosion during the previous evaluation on November 27, 2006. Land Observation Point 5 was not assessed for erosion during this evaluation because the landowners were not able to be reached for property access. Observation points are mapped on Figure 3. Land Observation Point 1 ' Land Observation Point 1 is located at the crossing of Carbonton Road over Line Creek, a credited tributary to the Deep River. At this location drift lines and sediment deposition were observed on both banks as evidence of overbanking (Photo 23). Upstream of Carbonton Road, Line Creek is restricted by three culverts and the deposition on streamside vegetation was significant. The large Erosion Evaluation No. 4 4 06-277.04 entrenchment ratio of Line Creek supports a well developed floodplain and relieves stormflow stress on stream banks (Photo 24). Both reaches above and below Carbonton Road have very low flow and the banks appear stable. Limited erosion and scouring of bank material was observed (Photo 25). Land Observation Point 2 Land Observation Point 2 is located at Monitoring Station 45 near the crossing of Cool Springs Road over McClendon's Creek. This section of McClendon's Creek is a non-credited reach but was visited for a comparison to stream conditions further downstream. On the day of observations, ?c McClendon' Creek still had a high river stage and flow velocity. River stage had fallen below ankfull but was still elevated such that a full erosion evaluation of the banks was not possible ?Nlr" " hoto 26). Stormflow had exceeded bankfull, and a moderate layer of fine sediment was observed ?A on streamside vegetation. Both banks showed signs of scouring as trees were undercut and bare ?b roots were exposed (Photo 27). No trees were undercut to the point of falling, but a few were leaning significantly. Land Observation Point 3 Land Observation Point 3 is located at Monitoring Station 47 near the bridge crossing of Glendon- Carthage Road over McClendon's Creek, a credited tributary to the Deep River. As expected, signs o more significant stormflow were apparent at Land Observation Point 3 in comparison to Land servation Point 2 located further upstream on McClendon's Creek. Evaluating banks for erosion was again made difficult by high river stage and flow velocity (Photo 28). Stormflow had exceeded IG bankfull though no significant bank failures were noted. Undercut banks as well as several areas of exposed, unvegetated bank areas subject to potential erosion were observed (Photo 29). A moderate layer of fine sediment was observed on streamside and floodplain vegetation. Land Observation Point 4 Land Observation Point 4 was taken at Monitoring Station 40 near the bridge crossing of Steel p6 BAS Bridge Road over Little Governor's Creek, a credited tributary to the Deep River. This section of Lille Governor's Creek received significant stormflow with overbank flooding apparent in multiple ?Oqut Many stretches of streambank along this reach of Deep Governor's Creek are vegetated, n several areas, portions of the banks have experienced significant scouring and erosion (Photo P 30-31). Just downstream from the Steel Bridge Road bridge, a large riffle complex continues to erode along the left streambank, where stream flow becomes restricted by the bridge (Photo 32-33). Summary The rain event which triggered this erosion evaluation caused the USGS gauge at Ramseur to register a peak discharge on December 25, 2006 of 3210 cubic feet per second (cfs). Despite the high rainfall totals and peak discharge associated with this storm, the Deep River and its tributaries were observed to experience erosion consistent with previous evaluations. Head-cuts identified at tributaries to the Deep River continue to slowly migrate. Scouring and erosion of tributary banks continues to be problematic in areas where herbaceous vegetation has never established, or has ' seasonally diminished. The banks of the Deep River are generally stable, with a few areas experiencing storm flow scour and erosion. SUBSTRATE ISLAND SURVEY In addition to the erosion evaluation, multiple cross-sections of the substrate island between the NC 42 bridge and the former dam footprint of the Carbonton Dam were completed on January 4, 2007. trosion tvaiuation No. 4 5 06-277.04 Three (3) permanent cross-sections previously established over the substrate island, and one (1) permanent cross-section previously established just upstream of the former dam, were completed. Figure 4 maps the location of the substrate island cross-sections at the site of the former Carbonton Dam. Figure 4A compares the cross-sectional survey from January 4, 2007 to the dimensions from the previous survey on 11-29-06, and the first survey on 06-27-06. No significant change in the substrate island was observed from the monitoring cross-sections. Cross-sections 1, 2 and 3 show only minor signs of sediment transport from within the channel, with the most noticeable change along the right bank. Since the first survey, the right bank has gradually experienced erosion as noted from the 01-04-07 survey lines (black) departure from the 06-27-06 survey line (red). Cross- section 4 shows an initial degradation of channel bed form after the first survey, with stability in recent surveys. Overall, the cross-section surveys show that increased flow conditions following dam removal have had almost no impact on the substrate island, and minor effect on surrounding banks. Erosion Evaluation No. 4 6 06-277.04 DEEP RIVER EROSION EVALUATION FIGURES Erosion Evaluation No. 4 1 06-277.04 Z U z u 0 ODO a ?, _? w ?N? c Lu 0) co 6 U) C14 C14 > - O N o Z O Q E °'C m p NNW 0 in ? z o I. V? On, ? F O L .D L r'a L C C? O LL O i. m F U m W J O m c U R N p 0 p o u O a, z p' Q L cc o w +- LLI m N a` w U LL ° Q Q w U Z ~ 10- 3 m Q Un -Cl U o o w z C7 ? 2 O 'it or k z § Y .} e 4 - ? oy 3,?? F •cw, ?.. F ? 5 7 - d t . f (? to H sr •? a U a LLJ C M ------------ v ;, s r d W a O r a v c z z 0 ?o y O w o j R a (1) O c Q) Cl > N O z U L E C C r n n n 0 r = m m.2 of s v M M N N N p C, :., z U) in U m C 0 0 0 0 0 CL 0 0 o r U) r U 0 0 0 ,n o in o rn o Z) Z 2. •a N V M M N N c (Y m 2 m „r most Q Z U - I w CSI U- U LL O ''' O 90 L) U U U " C o ? N U I , / Z O (o ?'' a t a '., O 3 s O o a p U nil W ?0 - 1 0 O O ''I W il ? z z I 90 W 9 Ncn? C` z °o N 00 Q ? z 0 N U ! 0 W c m c? co I I. U 90 Q O ? O 0 W W F- O Q Z'75 U 0 o 90%' v oo W N e! p U CL F- c o ,= 9 % z w > O I w c 90 i I O ^ . HO a ? ._? O O O O C) O O O O 0 O O O O O ?? J E z O LO 0 L M M N 0 D O LO N r r LO ' (s;0) OBJegosld xew U Z v Sr' c L 0 O o U•O a O ai c: C G 2 N > co C ?+ L ++ ++ J o O = M aN+ 4i C-4 CO o W (Z 0 CA ? . a ? o o ? o (9 ? z C7 `. ) °up d d La N? = i°o LJ NON ° _ L` ? m z a` o c d Q U d H o O w ,?•, ° U) CD .y s .• 1 0 cu (3) 00 > } ¢ p N r' 41 (D It r1l, f 40 04 C r co C U) ? i ,'aa (n co O 70 ' S. -? 4 { ! n W C7 R U O o Qy r ^ U wG >ZZ o a _ ?o°?g°Z a x 8 ?' I O WQO VIA ny0gp S W U § a vCC t 5t d W L.j S N W W N N Z O rn O U Z O 1 U N N N O & U W K V & O O O r W W W O Z N W U N 0 H Z CL Q Z V U ~a U La J O & a . W W & & ~ 0. in O ? I >Z >Z Q W W N !Nk OQ W UW i Q ...... O 4 O W N b W 2 F YU ! JvZ3 / 7&OO imUn \ A- ?I 5. NnI N14 f ,n 6 o Z K & H / O 2 Zf pN . J 1 \ 1 \ ZQ .- Rx0& W & m / N X \ V rH OD N \ Cr XNW - N V_ z n o W N O 3 N U O ?Z w L D a z z W O V1 O Q? •C? U j >Z Z X00 at ~ n_' a a w •U _ O - IZ W y(/fj (/? ?O Z CL z c?. x m Z fA c? o wmp wQI _(A0 U O n¢y J10 _ y 2IM U ?C L) JL_ I O uJ (n U F- U > N w (n OJ x T x O x 12-Z n n n N ° n o O n °n m° '^ n n n n i9 R n t0 O CO 0 n °n m n m° c o m .y Oj Jr- Q Q H = O 0) N O> > N I NW I J tiff khIHI ti M 1+1'1 -'I f l-1 O O ?W J III! IIII, 1111 IIII IIII Id II IIII II O Q O O O U I I 1 O O V V H Hill IIIT IITII II IIIT I I FIT II IT, Ti IT III I I IIT I I I.I. O O O O N IT ITI i+1 L Ii 1 liilif ITII + -1 I 1 1 °o $ S °p N I'd ITII IITI III I I4 I 1 Fill HI rILII?H 'it- HI! r!I rr MI FULL ' ll li 11 I:I_I 1a-111 1. LW m m F ii I 171111 :III IIII , I II I If b °S b b Hill IIII IIII IIII II II ITT ITII LL? ``N LLM LL? i 1" r r r z W X X/ X X I I ' I III. N ' I ° H O $ $ $ $ Hill 1111 1111 11.1 11 I I I I I.I it 11-1 Vr[, ? 11 m O m It 1+1 I + ,? I !?1 O O p p n n Hill IIII?I I. IITI I I I I I I III II III I II III II I I:.II ITII It IT I( 1111 ;T II II 111111 did F" +Lff V V p p p o p N N R p N O y1 Q ry O H c`1 lNV O N g t°`? t?V InV p O N¢ l°V t?V tnV rv O N N /1 lV N 1411YA313 NOI1YA313 N N011VA313 N N m O N011VA313 ILL LLI ILLI 1111 l.l I. . w I I I I 011 IIII IIII ITII IIII 1111 IIII 1111 I 1 (I II IIIhI I 1 I I I `I I I l - ILLLL IIII III 111111 ii II LLII?II 111111F '. 1 r.1.1 IIII IIII 1111 IH 1111 F+I I IH 111 1111 41h 1111 IMI 1111111 1 +IH It ILL 11l II.!I ' 111 41 111 iI LL Ill IIII IIII III III 111 I'I I I, 1111 1111 III 1 1, IIII IIIT IIII IM 1+1 11*I L ?. . L k 1+1 ? I`+111t 1 _1.:1,11. IIIT IIII Hill II II II!I IIII L,I TI I I I I I,I'I,I ' I -1 I I IH HI IHI tit I I I I?I ILL LLI IW II I 4 .I 11.1- IIIT IIII IITI Fm I TII IIIII I I II 11 11 4 II I I ' I'I II ILL LLI ILLI -•I I. I I .4 4 I I I.'I_I IIII IIII 1111 1111 IIII II II 111 i 1 1 IJ 11 11 ?. ?41T' I?,II?II II IIII IM HI HI I 1 1 I HI FI4 M' 'rh Hl Iu 1111 w 1111 Iw IIII PUT I'9 _LII "' M1' '4 I ? uw I I1?. I' l l IIII IH IIIT F+ I IIII IFFI I.I 111 i a ?I I'llll %I?I ILL LLI IW F 41 1.. I I I IIII ITII IIII I IIII II T '. 1 I IH HI IHI IH M1. u 41 1 IIII IIIT IIII ITn ITII IIIT uTl InT . IIII 4 1 If 1 4 II ? 1 1 rIH HI 11H 1H Hli I 11 ILL LLI ILLI ILL 1111.4 1 4 1 1 11 IITI IIII Hit IIII IITI IIIT IIII III 1 1 1 II1+4 I I I I -I I I ILL LLI IWI11 L. 144 L 4 ? J. 1_I _ IIII II II IITI Fit[ IIII?I?I Illlil'I 1 1 I 5 1 I II 'I I:I IH? MI IHI'+?I IM -1 I II 'ILI. 1111 LL I IIII IW II_ IIII IIII 1 I I II 1 _I I. I_I. 1 1 1 1 ,111 I I+ I II r1 II I I'?I 1-1-71 I I I 17 I I1 I 1 511 ILL LI IIIT I II 1111_ 1111 IIII 11 ( I I I I I I -1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 11, Il I'. I H I+- 11 ?. 11 IIIT IIII I I I I' '. ? I I I I I I I IIII Illnill ? IH HI 1-1+L I' I+'HI ILL W ' 11 1 I I I I I- L.11 ' IIII II TI I I I I I I I I 11-i I- I I I I I I I I III . 11 I ?I IIL WI '.IJ.LL L II ilu' 1111 1111 I I 1 1 1111 ITI I 1 I 1 1 1111 I hll 11t 1-1 Ii l I- 11 -1-111 ILL 1111 LI 11 1 I.I L IIII I I I I II J-1.1.1 I I', ITII III I I L'+ I I ILI W 1. I. I I 1.1:1 IITI IIIT II I III I I I I I II I I I I I I I II I'.I I I- IH LL HI: 111 I I} I- i:l I.I. I 1 I -1 L. I.. -I'r 1'I? _1-L;ll_ IITI ITII I I III 1 I.I I i 1 1 I-1 I I I I I.I I'I': IH Hlr i 1 1.1.1.1, ILL LLI I I.I: _ I.L.I_I! ? ITII II IT IIIT IIIT I I I1 illllll? 5 1+} I II I I I I III IIIIIII 11 11 I I11I'. I I 1 ?11 LLI ' IITI IIIT III FIT I 111. Ii11'II'. I I I I I', I I .I IIII 'Illlll IH rlr ri ;11'1- I..,1 .1M HI ILL IIII LLI I_ 1111 IIII ?LI. IIII'( 1 I ,1 I ? I I? 1 '._I',1 WL ,111 HII nn IH 1n1 HI IIII IH IH fI1 Il n'1 HIfTIHI i?iT T Inl IH HI I ILL 1 1 LLll. ll LIO ' LL LI 11 LI LL tilt 11 IIII IIIT II 111:1 III': I- I I I I. I I I I II11I :Ii II t 11'I' t 11 1 r 1 -1rt HI f+ k I 1}I I !I '1 LLI 111 I Ik'r+'. FtIM IH ll1L II I I III III II II IT, I I II H I+ LO II I +t -tff H +1 Hill rl '+1'.1 +I IL LLI ITI 111111 II I` Hl l :ULL 4 1. 101 0 V I W L m 'w L I I I I', did III I ,I 1111 1 1 1 I L I 1 1 I [III IIII IT I II I I I I I 'I'I'I-I 1 I 11.,1 I' JLl LI' :w1 1 II LL I 1111' IIII I II I II II?II I III LI I i` I 'I' 111' 111111111 IIII '. -= -1 } I I I F+ l f )11, .. . 1 ILL LLII III IH 1111 IIII HI 1 41 IIII :I H? III . HI III II III IHI H I Will, Will, 11 I 11 LL 'ILL W I W 11 IT ITT III III IIII It I ITIIIII 71 l it 'Til ITI I III IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII ITII L?l ?1,1 MI Li.II . IF+I II++I F+ I - 111 IIII f}I WL IIIT IIII II'I'I'I IT I I I I II I I I II 'I I IIII I ill TI IT II I ? ??1.` I-I I I I+ HII ILL IT L ' 11 ' I I I I I III! I I 'll II LL II . , I Illjl?l T I I I I I . I IIII I TI I I III I LL WLEI .1 ' J L : ' I LI I'l l IT 1 [LI IIII hill I I I I 1 1 111 IIII I H N F,H i Iri 11 F BFI F+ MI 1nL IIII T I D IE II'I?L V I I I I l ?r. I n l nl 1, I IIII w II II IF+ MI FfI-F + I+Ih II I IF+ Hlf I !I1 IT W1.1 1. I I I LI l1. IIII I IIIL I 4 I. I IIIT I I IIII. IT'I?I I II.I IIIT III III I 111 I II ? I'?I IT IITI ITI I IIII n11 I II1 111 I ul III ITI I I I,In I I IITIn II II I'd I I lrl + l H HI u H Ti I IL III WLI11 IIIIIIII Iu- III] W ITII Il w ?l III I LLI I III, H II „III H } IT I }I 1 I I' ` VI I ' I I II ly I III I I I I ++ . ri LI I 1 }• I_I.. i II I..I.I ' I If 1111 Illilll I I i I I 1.1 I I I . Il T I IIII ITn I I I I 1tl I I. I I 1-.I.I? I I I I ;I I I I I, l l II I . I.I I 111 I I I LLI did I I I I'I I MH1M I I H ' I I 1'1 rT I I 11 I' II MI1 nl I II LLLIW I I II I .1 I I I L l1 1 L -u 1. III I I I'I IIII II I I I I I L I I'1 41 IHI Ill +I IIII I-I? r ? +II 'Wl ITII I II IIII?II I IITI I I I I I I II I'.I I 11 I IIII II I III IITI II r+ HFI+ I I IH II'I +1 F+ I I iL.l I II I I I IJ I I?IL ' W I ICI I I -1 I I II I I ll IITI did _ a. l,1 I I ? I.. I I I I1 ' LLI 111 I 'r1-1 I I ? I } I I . rlil' Ira I L III ,L. LI L I'I'I I LI I. I I I I II I I Iyl ? L_ I I I I l i :1! : I I I III IH II 'T II I H:NIM 1 h1 rIM III H-? II'Illl:li If+I ?111+ I TII Hi1 111 111 LI,1 I 1 L'. LW?U L W 111. 111 IIIT I I 'I I'I ( I I I I I.1 I I 11 I I'll 1- did _L:. 11 .III I I I -.1 i1J I 1 ' I ITII iH l I I ++I III I h+ HII L.I_ I I :l I_I I I I I I I I I I.? I i 1,1 I. I_ t I 111. IIIT II?I I +trl!-I H. I I 1 I ICI I-I I I I I?I IT, IT +t w III ITIII ILL IIIT III l?l I III I I I I n ++ 111 (IIL ' ' i 1111 II IT I,( I III??I I I I I I I I I?I ;I ,II .I I 'II IITh IIII ITII IN 'M11-1 1 -I.-} hrl l- MI III IIII .L? ly,l I ,1111,1 I 11. , , I? I I I.. L'.I . I 'I?I?If If l ll Ilil IH C H 1:1 h II I I HI III IItIllll II+I H#H IIII HI II L I IWI ILII 1 1 I IW1Il I LLII I I.I I I II I '. I I 1 1 1 1.11 II I IIIT IIII IIII IITI IIII I 1 1 ilt I I I +Ih!H.IHI + ILL Ill ILLI ILL LLI IT I Iy O .. I I l.'.: ILLW IIII,IIL'.LI.. 1. t Hit I IriITI N I NIII IT 1 IT IIII 11 H+ I ' I I I I III I-,[ I I# iiht h? II IIIIdll I III : ! I I I +'. 1+ ICI I I H I I+ ki I di L I FIT 'I I II I .11 I'.Itl lT I IIII I II II I 1110 II I I.I'? 1 . i-1 ' M h+1. MI M'. I M 1+1 I F+I 41 N MI IIII '.11 1 1 111.1 1111 LLI I W?.I.I U 1 , 1 IIII II11 IIII IIII IIII IIIIIIIII l Ili I II ' 'I II IIII II II H I I HI 1111 I I1 11I h4 I I I 1 h}I11' I ICI ' ' IIII IIIT III III Hit I ITI lid II IT Hit I II II I I I II I I + 111 IN. t W kl {I I III! I ht I ll I I I L IA : L. u. IIII I I T ?III Hill III IIIIIII I ITT rl II I I . I:I IF- r+F III +IM HI If`I I F+ rl 'LL 111 :1 ILI 1 ' IIL LLI II I I II I I..I ' 11 1,1 I r I II I I r+''+++ I I +-1- 1 II LL I ILLI. ILL I II LLI 1 r II'_I -L I; I i' 1 L„I I I IIIP II II' III I IIIT 1 11 1711 1 n 1 Illi L I 1-'I 11 I+ H I- } I+I I IHI # H li I : I LL In1 LI 1c1 ?I n, 'I r. L 11L 'n IIII L 'rl 1 1 LI. 1 1 IH I I+ L 'I'. + 1. 1111 II I I ' I I I-I- 1 1 'l lL LI,1 ll I II 1 I.I. 1 T 1. I.I I I, I I I' 1 1 I'. I (II II1I I II I IIT I I I II IT IIIT W I I I. I I I I I 1 - 1 '1 r+ iL I+I f !?n+l ll +11+ 1+1 1 n 1? 11,. ry' 11 . I I I I Hill I I I I I 1 I '. I l H r r1, I I_'_ II' L L l l l III. LLI I LL ILL 1111 I . ' +-1' I I I 1 II I I I I IT +H ?Il {+ l I p lll LL . IIII ' 1 1 L I J 1 r ' I 1 ' lil I I LLI L LL LLI I 1 l T' I•I it !T In. IIII ,l l11 1 1 ,IIIIT 111 IIII. + r#i +IH HI iF II+I HI ! ? IIIT L'. L ILL +I l1'. I!1! .11E IIII WC 1111 'ILI I. 1 ,11 IIII I LLI 11 1'1 I+ I I +.I nII +IHI II I`F I H MI 1 ,1111'L II 1, 1I?I r 1 1 1 1 1+I ILL 1 UI ILL ' Ln1. W III I I_ ILII ' II1 IT 1111 1111 III 1 7 IIII I 11 HII rll ,III I I ,I l I I 19 I I IH HI 1 IH, 'IH MI Irl' h' Irl- IIIT Illi IITI III IIIT IIII ITII IIII IIIT wl ,IIII 'I. IIIIT I I I I I Ih' I I , I!#1 tl lk HII II 1? rl' 1 I. 11 11: ILL wI I L 1?I'. I I I 1 1111 -: 'I Hill I-il 11 ,II I 11', IIII ITII 1. I. I I I I .1.1. 1!1 II I u11 111 11 11 - 1 IIIIII Hill IIII :r n I I I I I II MI +: F+ F+I ILL IIIT I J I II I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I_ L L I I I II W IITI ITII IF+ II I hr l} I I II I I I -I+ I . I II I I?I I ? I I I IC IIII I+Ii ILL LI I, I 1 ,II I I I I1 L L'Jl ' IIII 117 II I I I I ? I1 I I I I I I I I II I II I I TI' IH M I 111, T I 1 1-1 }I'n- Ili 1. I}I 111 II 1.;11+ ' Irl' II IIII IT II II It ICI'. lll'. III II'I III III IITI IIII IIII'illll III IIII i I+ #I TI I hl Frl r 41 H M I ILL I Ii l I I I. 11 LIlI LL. LLI Illi II I I I ' I.I IIII II 1`1111 Till I L1 I I I+f{ 111+ 1 iF I II ? +li .I'.I h 1: ' H 1111 L? L I!I I I IIII II I II 11 I I 1 1 I I 1 1 I .I i`l 111 III III; II I III III i IH Hl h? l I I '. I?I .III l+ HI I u I!II lu1 IIII 1 I 11. 1,1- 'III I : 1 I L1 D u IIII'11111 al ' IIII ITII IH II I Hr I I I # r:l , It I rl II I II HI+II+ I I I T MI , LI I I'I' Ill I? I I 11. I I I ILII IT II 1171;.0 1 1 11 . I.:'. ` II IIII IIII n Illlll l I III '' IT I I III' 14 t1 M I I' I H I T II II III I T II III it I I I I I 111I I L 11 111 I 1 1 L L I L I II 17 I H HI I M HI + W 'A 11 Im Ml T IY11 ILL I!II W L11 11 IIIIII II 11 Hid W I L I I I ' I L I IT LLI I 'T:IT' Id I II if I I I I??I' I' !k '+'IHI 4' IM HI Irl4 ?l-? H-I! I Li II II .L'I„111 IIIIIIIII LILL IIII LLII II II ;I I I I. II I I I' 1 11 II.I III IH I I I HI IF+I I I IH I I. HI F I I I I I ?II I + I` ?:.I- 1 V I LL W II IW ILL WI I I l UI I I'.t 1 Ilr I IIII IIII III ITII I 11 I`I I 1 1 III I H ii MI IMI Hit IIII I M 111 HI 1111 IHI I H 111 1 111 tl Id Ilr III T Ifll II IIIT IIII IIII IIII IIII II I I IH k:. t+I hl I t MI Ih+I }r F+I ILL ' I IIII II II II I 11' ? I I I I I I I I I - I? ITI IIII ' ' ' 1111 I I I I I TIl1 I I 11 II 11 I I I I - 1 n 111 r 1 ? -1 - 5 I 1 I I'1IIIn,. IITI Inl l I'I I.I +!1- 111 1111'. I}I I}I'rFl IL' :l rl I+IF I I II I 1- II 'r! ILL IIIT 11 LI,H 1 1 II11 1111 111 II II LLI I l IL 111_ 11 I I III I'Ijlljl IIII l ITII I I I I I :II I I I+ +: I-IHI Ik h+I+ r 4 Ir I I Illi IIII IIIII IIII IIII 11 I I I,.I I l r IT11+ 11TI Lt Ti r0 I 1 n r, i IH hhi IHI IIH I+Ir h 4 r Hh 11 ITII LLI IITI ILLI IITI w 711 ILI 1. 11 1 11 1 L L.. ' III II 11 II11 1 did 1 IIII 1 I I I ITII :III ? ILL IT LLI ILLI T ILL I Illl 41. 4 y' ll l„ ' h ill II IITI II I I II IIIT 1 II I . !III Iu III w 011 ILLI 1111 Iu IIII w IIII 1 4 I uIll IIIIT 1'. 'I!I I I IH I II HI III IIh+l III IH Ilr FFI 11 I IIII 411 IIII ?h! 11 11 WI 1111 11W 1 / 11 I I, 111 II I 1 L11 LLI I 1nT 1 ITn 1 'llll InT I ITI . I II II f IIIT II I ITII I H HI I I+I hl 1+ +!I'- 4I F- ,411 II IIT IITI ITI ITII I TV I I II I I I I, I I I I I I IIII il!I IH HI IHI IM HI:. I I` 1+1 ILL LLl I , ILLI 111 Ill 1_ 1 1 1' 111E IIIT IIIT IITI IIII III T( I II I I I I,II II I I I, I III'. IITI IIII 11 LLI ILL .LI I:I I I I. L IIII IIII IIIT II 1 1-1 I I I I I IM HI IHI IH rl hl- -1'I IF IT IITI IF 111 IIIT ILLI ITII Iu. IIII LLI II I L.I LiL I III I -LL I I ITII IH IIII HIhIrI III iH IIII +I'r1 II I 1 : I I I I II-141 1-1 t.l ILL lll ly I l ll ILL 1 I LI I I- I.I IITI III II'I Illi III l 111 .1 1 II II I I I I I I I '. 1-ill I I I II IH Il llL l+hl LI a tl li .I'.I I : - L?I tl-- .L1.1 ,.I. + .I.I IIII IIll ll II I I 'I I I I 1 1 IH I+II I+ I II II I :1.1 I LL 1111 LLI IIII 111 III I I I I r 111D I I I I I I I I I II?Ili IIII ILL IIIT LI.I IL Illlj IIL l I I I' I I: IL Ilrll l._ 1 LLI I11 1TiT l "il I I IIII I 11 11 uilllli IITI IT11 IH F+I I? H4 TV HI. IF!1411+ Fh1f Iu IIII w4 IIII 1' 1 I II u III w lid Iw?1u IIII 1111 w 1111 II I IH I I I HI I ITII IH IIIT HI IIII IIIT IHI IH IIIT MI ILL LLI 1 11 W1 1IllW1 ' LLI IIIT IIII I III IIII IIII IIII IIII IIII II ,I1111 Illl IITI If IH IHI IH I+I IIII ?FIk x W MI L HIV DEEP RIVER EROSION EVALUATION PHOTOS Erosion Evaluation No. 4 06-277.04 .o O N L r O O s _..?? 70 i F , I# 4 i•':ti ? f I l'1 k, ti 7 ? i I ? ' r ? `?7 fQ ? ji +?i 4 W 0 L W ^L' Q W ^, O O I O O? Z N O o? ECo L Y O C: -0 CU N C Q a) c DU C O O O- N U U U) J ? lq? h N O (L 0 ea AL, W N 0 R N O O t (L K' 70 - - _ ?. M '+ t ^ ?y £ ? A X f ?. r R 7 4 ?, . r e c ter fy N N N 0) L L N QL) 4- _r__ 4- Y U O 'L r CD O Z Lf- O U E Q) N O c 4-- 0 C -0.2 N cn -_ O Q? m O ? L ,C Q c Q Mm W c C +r0 O .? d r L ? U U N J N 0 j. M O O AL, W O w M O O ._ IL ,. i j ? a _ iT ? ?, ` ? ?' pc ? f ; ?7i Y , ? ,. may, r j i mfr i` '? rt L e . 14 ' c , ? `? • :'? ' ? „ .. ,gip ?? . . k 1 r- f v r.X / ' S "- ?cc 1 ' lr? 41. 4r ' M1 ??`? 11 N Q (D a) am 1"Sl W rrY O Q? N E O U ? O x X O (D Cc O _ O cn a) E c CU Q) a) F= 4- -0 Q O :3 (n a) -0 c _ cu ?O o W ,? c -cu c a) U O O O Q L U U ? N J 0 2?•a 3 ? y { {?: va 4k :,qty,, V .O a C O L 0 L et 0 O L a L (D L.L a- W O 0) CD U) O L U m E O ca C ? O C ? -Q (a C U U c 0 o fl. o L ? U U ? N J 0 qe r C_ O a C ca L U) m O L R U) O ++ O t a i a ??R 1t lr 1 :V. (D L CD N, L I..L Q O CU ? L O N C cn 0 N N cu E ? Y M M 0-0 O 0) 0 O L O U C O Q O ? U U O N J i tab' ja J a a I ?? ? ? ? T+ ? use ?-7: - ;. LO O a _ O m L N .C O L co O O t a •L W ^` c ? c m E ? Y CU M C ? L o _o O o ? U N C ? o ? N o aL+ U CO E 0 c n 0 N U U N N J Cl M p r C O N .y •A N O 7 ? W CD .O a 0 L N O O t a M ` . "All .: $ b,yyy,R o-. Yrf _ °b? WIV f # Y gg?? d ?Y]?? ? d ^W W L U cn -L O C ,O V rn Fn c O -0 cn C O M L L L > O Q E O O = ^o W Y U ? C N ? N C O U c? C O C ?O .Q- L (U U U cn a) J o 1 y • f? ? Y=.4 t??n? F?, ? ?J a M 0 O O 0 N is N O 7 W > W O a _ O L O L R ao O 4a O t CL L>T C 4- C U -0 cu M c (D c c O W CU N? 0) ^A 0) W Q O ? Y ,?- ca 0-0 U N L L O (6 U? c c Q0 o ? U U (D J r) ti r C_ O a O L .Q O R Ci O 4-1 O t a +i ?. ,'iP' t't:;1 ?.,: •n T R1"', ?,x,}ry .w .t AT 33.?s'a '15 c2 t . v `. .'a wow Iv- ?A11pIR MgR?f e ?' ? t „?i?i'4S l k i ? p.w 4,v'Y/i f N Y j?? CE Y CU C U 0 N C 0 (u a) a) > Q ? a) 0) N C ? U 0 ? 0-0 C a) a) ? C C C 00 UU C 0 c 0.9 M U U N J D t , i sq? 1 M 000 N .y A N O 7 W > til 00 ^O I.L G O A/ W N O I.L 0 r 0 O t a Y ri ? x+51-, ;,?:.. '?? ?r?•t'Ey? ? d?' y 4'?\. ;?t? ?? tYk 5? ? if A r? ?.. Y 1 ? AW11 .4Y? 1 i :V . /-pNl r '44 A y A s f ALi; I '7 r v -l? N O VJ 0 C C O C o O cO G ? Y co a) m O (n) a) M a) M C N C ? O a X c? a) V/ C: O m O a) -a /i:E m a a) a) O 0 C a) O U a) a) U 21? C O O .a M U U fn a) J 0 y .O a c 0 m N L 1 0 O t a L O L Q? N O F L O L >? Q Q o? o U ? C O N ? -INC O U m c .o c Q o ._ ? U U ? O J ? N Taints C O /? 4- \V VJ r O a O ?a L N O L Ldp N r O 4a O t IL 1 F O) C O C _ O a) C a) E c 2?-, c L O ? C a) E O7 C O C ? C CU ca C C N a) L E ?> a) N cn Q. O () E a) o ° a) E 0-0 c a) a) : C C C O O L) C) c O C Q O ? U U ch a) J ? r' r O a c O m > L O N O ci T- 0 4a O t a i j 1 , f yyry S IT ? A ,y T ? t k" f i i 1 A C'7 N C O U) C L O O C 2>1 CU ?- ? .P) o M c O M 'U) O L L (L) m i >> -a i c CL CU C) U O ? U -0 c a) O ? ? C C C O O U U c O C Q O. (U U U N J ? N T- 0 a c O a m N O L R O r O t EL ?L W Y ? O O O O L ` U 5 a) ? c ? J (a L CU a) L m a) E Y c a) -0 a) O 0 a) c .o cn o ° a) a) 0-0 c a) a) :3 :3 c C C O O UU c 0 c ?- o .Q- (U U U ? m Jo r 1 " C ?O ' a c 0 L N .C > i wi O L i ° a ch ?L Y 0 a) 0 O O L O U 3 a? -0 c ? L ^Ll W E Q a) ? O O 0 a) c .o cn o 0 -0 c a) a) :3 :3 C C C O O U U c 0 o Q o M U 0 (n a) J 0 r i .= ? as F of E ? g r Y.y r . M T- 0 CL c O ca m .a O L N? I.L CO O 0 L a -4- Q (D a) Q? W 0 N cn 0 L U N Y CD C: U N N U 0 Z c 0 0 C/) 0 a> 0 E m m a c :3 O ` ^ ! v C c +? O Q- C U U cn N J c 'o a C O c6 L O L N>_ N ti r O O t a 1 1 T N L N N O N Q ? N N N t: D N O U ? o o 0 _0 c c •- N c 0.0 0 0 a? o a? E ca c a? L O (n U c O c N L O ^' L ?>> N u Q Y N C cu m c O ? Q O .- L M U U O N -o N TI, c 0 IL c O L O L N CO T- 0 O s a N L ^Ll m ry L L N v J ? I O .? O O Z •? 0 0 a? o ? m E m c a? L c o C U O N L N L m ? Y Q? m 0 O ? Q 0 M U U cn 0 0 J ? W T" a. Q .O a C O AL, W N O L m ? R rn T- 0 4+ O .r- > (^D' N W a^'L W ( W W ? W C O O .F Y O N L N N U Y ? ,U N J L O : Y CO G C in c O C Q O L ? U U N J 0 L cr- f.+ C_ O a c O L N L N>_ I.L. G N O 4.0 O t a i Q r) .C C O ?L L ??0/ >_ LL ?/ 0- -0 N C N 00 L U O c o c E? m ? L O cn U) C O N U ? N C) o L N ? - N a) N L .? X ? O Y Q C Q m Qm C O C Q O .- L N U U U) N J 0 co T- 0 a c 0 R m N 0 R r N 0 4w 0 t n IF 1.- iA 41 S v i+? b.a, ,:, ? ? `,• ?? . 'Vi'a 4. A A V L- a) LL a) W O ^W W L U VJ L O C W O Ma) W LF- O E a) L O a) Y L2 cu o o? v, a) a) ? c E O X ? O .0 0-0 Q O Qw E O o Q O. CU U 0 (n a) J 0 r C O a 0 a) N d O ' N N O ' O t a m N ? +r L N O O cn p a) L ++ m ? U Q c a) cn a) o? a) o U C M a) O E U C/) E O o Q O M U U U) O a) J 0 0 Of T- r C O IL c O ca d N .C O c ca J M N O O s CL r y C O c O L U Y O c s L cn > O O L U ? O O ? U N N _0 > O CU N E c c? o ? o C? : o N ? L U E a? J Cn C O o O Q- .L C U U U m J D . O ' IL c O L N .Q c m ' J N O 4.0 ' O t a 0 ry c O c O E. m U 0 c ch U) 0 L U N CY) L 0 E -a m O o c o 3 .? o ? ? Y N ? N ? U ? 0 0 j o c O o Q O Z- U U U J N 0 3 ` f y k M O C O N O N O 7 ?w w r c .0 a 0 N N 0 c m J N O 4+ O CL A R R: w r _y{ . yy .? t? ja r„ Sd 1 1 7 t} fl xSS? h' J C V", 'eA Q X , F .b 5' ' f aw i W 4 P LVI \V O O C ^O^ l.i U O C U) N O U N O (D U) O N W O ? ^Y^ Y ^W L U ? _c CU J () O c O Q ? 'L ? U U N 0 m O ry m C L CL VJ N C o a c O ca N O a C J co N O 4a O L a O O U CD 0) Y M a? rn a? E L Um C 0-0 a? > U > U LU c O o Q O L (U U U O O J ? N C 'o a c O a d N O a m J ti N O 4.+ O L a ca Y O C N C (p L N '' ^L v L J 0-0 N UO L O U Y (n ? C O O L U ? N O 0 L- 0-0 c U) O U 0- X c O C Q O N U U U N J r) M C ?O a O c? d iL N J N O 4-0 O t a ti i I v z, i ? i w IN, yj i i .lief I .TJ^?' 'M1 a { I yL cwt ? v y it fL? M O s cu U IL O C CD ? N co c c ?4-0 a cn L E U c? N cn O ? -0 W CU ? G W C _O C ?--' O .?- O U U U N J ? Sr ' } "tf K' I ?+y, l hn?? M CL f 1.1? f? ?l 1 !4 y 1` y ` k. I cu O co U c O c N CU Y a ? U ? _N C o O Q X (1) C 5U C%) L E O C +O Q- CU U U U) ai Jo v CIJ N O 3 w w � � Y�, r3a•'' (� 0. � rr CD 0 O 0 4 • a: V 0 a c it a? m J T M O O L a 1'. ?t. `. M ?+'iN• r.t .7? r if o Ir Y 1 " I 1 » 4 41 st «,? 11 1 ? ?O LL .L W t? V J L U ? L L O N T ^' V? V>! 0 _ ^V' ^` W W^' J ? C .O O .Q- ;? L ? U U ? N J ? I* O a A? W V C J N M O 4-T O t a ? T ? ? F N ?p. 7 t?...?`*, ` T yy T...y ! ..q". - 't y ? d `W.. ??y??. ?. ` rt d ?'?? A R k A 6* I ' 46r T 07 cu O O N ML .L W O E c L U O L X O T a) CL 0 O O U N N J ? O C Q O CU U U O N 0 o lq* O IL c O d N .Q C J M M O O L a m O Of N m N L L O O V/ E m m a) ? c U o (n _0 O C O . N cn > O O L CD N Y N C _ m J m C O C Q O M U U fA O N J 0