20171365 Ver 1_Historic/Prehistoric Information_20171026

Project Tracking No. (Internal Use�
12-05-0008
HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES
ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS FORM
This form only pertains to Historic Architecture and Landscapes for this project. It
is not valid for Archaeological Resources. You must consult separately with the
Archaeology Group.
PROJECT INFORMATION
Project No: U-4405 Counry: Cumberland
WBS No.: 39049.1.1 Document
Ty e:
Fed. Aid No: STPDA-0401(230) Funding: ❑ State X Federal
Federal ❑ Yes X No Permit
Permit s : Type(s :
ProiectDescrintion: Improvements to US 401/US 401 Business (Raeford Road) from SR
1409 (71� School Road) to US 401 Business (Robeson Street) in Fayetteville.
SUMMARY OF HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES REVIEW
Description of review activities, results, and conclusions: HPOWeb reviewed on 22 May 2012 and
yielded one NR, one SL, no DE, LD, or SS properties in the project area: the Wooten Log House (CD
0606-SL) near the eastern end of the project area and the Seventy-First Consolidated School (CD 0519)
at the western end. Cumberland County current mapping, aerial photography, and tax information
indicates multiple pre-1965 properties, dating predominantly to the 1940s-1960s, in the Area of Potential
Effects (APE) (viewed May-June 2012). Constructed in 1976, Bridge No. 6 on SR 1007 (Wilkes Road)
over US 401 Business (Raeford Road) is neither included in the NCDOT Historic Bridge Survey, nor
representative of any distinctive engineering or aesthetic type. The Cumberland Counry comprehensive
architectural survey (1970s) and Fayetteville surveys (1980; 2001-2 update; 2008-9 "modern'� recorded
and addressed the individual properties identified above, as well as several notable modernist buildings
along Raeford Road. The presence of a National Register-listed property, as well as pre-1965 properties
throughout the entire project area indicated need for a field investigation. The APE extends 500 feet to
either end of the proposed 5.5-mile project length (E-W), 200 feet to either side of the US 401/US 401
Business (Raeford Road) centerline (N-S), and 200 feet beyond Y-line work to encompass all construction
activities as currently defined.
NCDOT architectural historians established and surveyed the APE in November 2012. They confirmed
that the Wooten Log House is located well beyond likely project impact, and the proposed widening in
the vicinity of the Seventy-First Consolidated School will occur within the existing right-of-way and not
affect any contributing elements of the property. They identified three resources requiring additional
investigation and evaluation: the A& W(now Lindy's) Drive-In (CD 1040), Owen's Florist and Owen's
House (CD 1330), and the Lafayette Lanes Bowling Alley (CD 1042). The ]uly 2013 architectural
evaluation report, prepared by Coastal Carolina Research for NCDOT, recommended all three resources
as eligible for the National Register (technical report on file at NCDOT); in September 2013 NCDOT and
HPO agreed that the drive-in and the bowling alley are eligible, while the florist store and house are not
(see attached). A]uly 2014 consultation with HPO and FHWA revealed that the project as defined at that
time imposed an adverse effect and a 4f situation for both of the properties in question. NCDOT refined
the design and in November 2015 obtained concurrence with HPO and FHWA on "no adverse effect" and
��de minimis" findings for both properties as detailed below.
Hrsloric Archirecture nnd I,andscapes E% FECTS ASSCSSMENTjorm for Mrnor Trnnsportn(ion Projec(s as Oun(ified in rhe 2007 Progranmiaric Agreemen�.
Page 1 of 3

ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS
Property Name: Lindy's (former A& W) Status: DE
Drive-In
Survey Site No.: CD1040 PIN.� 0427-11-1195
Effects
❑ No Effect � No Adverse Effect ❑ Adverse Effect
Ex lanation o E ects Determination: � � p/� .�'y�,,�,
/°}%i Y� k��.� 5 i �/ -�'_� "
, �►�' 2�j'� —i' / q�.y�i'v�,ul divt. d n�o-�'�L. S/' �wa�.f
> P'� ��i1tir r na�� si �. �-, �off %b il ► �w/ �e/ �+ .
` a l a e % Sjd -- Wil( Nof CGi �,����s ��/�
cal� riV►'h (,�-��'� �r f f � `�
� �
List of Environmental Commitrnents: .._,_
ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS
Properry Name: Lafayette Lanes Bowling Status: DE
Alle
Survey Site No.: CD1042 PIN� 0417-90-0844 and
0417-90-1889
Effects
❑ No Effect �Cj No Adverse Effect ❑ Adverse Effect
Explanation ofEffects Determination: ��� ���,.� f'� j�� �i e-,,,,
�,� � �,tiv s►.le..w�.fk �v�� �o�v t���-a-Y, � �o v�,��- .
� . � w� � ��� � � ��- �s�-.��
s�i �� � � / �y
��i�H�e�r�c�-. �� y'e�o'+'�t� �i'k�l� � l%,oR.c� o���
/
List ofEnvironrnental Commitrrients: --
FHWA Intends to use the State Historic Preservation Office's concurrenc as a basis for "de
minimis" finding for the following properties, pursuant to Section 4(f�: ( J�'_ �/. � `j .
��► � y <�rn�,-�-�w� Dr��-� �cv�oyo� �,��.�
4a� ��� l.a�.es ,8ow /� hq f}/l� y�c,p�oyz-
✓ �
Hisroric Archnec�ure and /.anclscapes EF�FECTS ASSLSSM�;N7'jorm for Mina� Transporration Projec�s as Oualified in the �007 Programmntic Agreen�enr.
Page 2 of 3

SUPPORT DOCUMENTATION
�f Map(s) ❑Previous Survey Info. ❑Photos �Correspondence ❑Design Plans
FINDING BY NCDOT AND STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE
Historic Architecture and Landscapes —ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS
NCDOT Architectural Historian Date
.
�
State Historic Preservation Office Re�
� `V�,
Federal Agency Representative
11�1�-IS
Date
11 �171)�
Date
Historic Architec(ure and l.ondscnpes E1�FECTS ASSF.SSMENT jorm for Minor 7ransportnrion Projects as Ounlifred in (he 2007 Progranrnmtic Agreemen(.
Page 3 of 3

North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources
State Historic Preservation Of�ce
Ramona M. Baztos, Ad�niiustrator
Governor Pat McCrory
Sectetary Susan Kluttz
September 17, 2013
MEMORANDUM
TO: Vanessa Patrick
Human Environment Unit
NC Departrnent of Transportation
FROM: Ramona M. Bartos ��'�` µ��`�"�"�
�?��
Of6ce of ALchives and I-listory
Deputy Secretary Kevin Cherry
SUBJECT: Historic Architectural Evaluation, Improvements to US 401 /US 401 Business (Raeford Road),
U-4405, WBS #39049.1.1, Cumberland Counry, ER 13-1G44
T'hank you fox your letter of August 5, 2013, transmitting the above survey report.
For the purpose of compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, we concur that
Lindy's (CD 1040, the former A& W Drive-In) is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places
under Criterion C for its architectuxe and that the proposed National Register boundaries appear appropriate.
A typo on page 14 of the report lists the period of significance as 1951 to 1967; the period should begin with
the drive-in's construction in 1963.We also concur that the Lafayette Lanes (CD 1042) is eligible for listing in
the National Register under Criterion A for Yecxeation and C for architecture, and that the proposed boundaries
appear appropriate.
At this time we cannot concur with the recommendation regarding the Owen's Florist and Owen's House
(CD 1330). We believe that the shop's architectural significance is best evaluated in terms of mid-twentieth
century commercial architectuxal, not just limited to florists or nurseries. The two Chicago-style windows are
very late examples of the type and the modernism of the glass storefxont additions, while dating to the potential
period of significance, does not appear to be fully integrated into the overall design of the building. Overall, we
do not believe that this pxoperty is architecturally significant enough to meet Criterion C.
The above comments are made pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and the
Advisory Council on Historic Preservation's Regulations for Compliance with Section 106 codified at 36 CFR
Part 800.
Thank you for your cooperation and consideration. If you have questions concerning the above comment,
contact Renee Gledhill-Earley, environmental review coordinator, at 919-807-6579 or renee.gledhill-
earle�a�,ncdcr.gov. In all future communication concerning this project, please cite the above referenced
tracking number.
cc: Mary Pope Furr, NCDOT, mfurr(a�ncdot.gov
Jeroen van den Hurk, Coastal Carolina Research, jvandenhurk(�a,ccxtarboro.com
Bruce Daws, Fayetteville Historic Resources Cominission, bda�vsCa�ci.fay.nc.us
Location: 109 East Jones Street, Raleigh NC 27601 Mailing Addrese: 4G17 Mail Service Centey Raleigh NC 2769911617 Telephone/Fax: [phone]-6599