20080731 Ver 1_More Info Received_20080612

08-0"131
CLEARWATER ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS, INC.
June 11, 2008
Mr. Alan D. Johnson
Division of Water Quality
Mooresville Field Office 3`#i y?
610 East Center Ave, Ste 301 Q ,+
Mooresville, North Carolina 28115
jl'N
Reference: Request for Information
DWQ Project #08-0731 WEE ANDISANIO?sro 4 var??' iL??C'ia
Broad River Highlands
Cleveland County, North Carolina
Dear Mr. Johnson,
A Request for Information letter from the DWQ was received by Mr. Todd Black,
Owner/Developer on June 3, 2008 outlining six (a-f) minor items in need of response. This
letter was based on a site visit with Alan Johnson from the DWQ and Anna Salzberg from
ClearWater Environmental Consultants, Inc. (CEC) at the Broad River Highlands project in
Cleveland County (Figures 1-2). This letter addresses all items, which are included in detail
below. Please see revised Figures 4.1-4.4 (1 : 200 scale) and Detail Sheets A-C (1 : 50 scale)
for plan representation of all changes made according to the Request for Information letters
and site visit. These plans have been sent to both the DWQ Raleigh office and Mooresville
office.
a) Impact #1: The proposed road that runs adjacent to this stream is shown
improperly on the site diagram. This should be corrected and a copy provided to
DWQ. The road is shown impacting the stream channel.
The road was shown incorrectly on this original site plan, and has been corrected to
represent accurately on the plan what is proposed for the project site. See revised
Figures 4.1-4.4 (1 : 200 scale) and Details A-C (1 : 50 scale).
718 Oakland Street
Hendersonville, Norfh Carolina 28791
Phone: [phone] Fax: [phone]
www.cwenv.com
Mr. Alan Johnson
June 11, 2008
Page 2 of 3
b) Impact #2: The crossing shall be located below the confluence of the two channels.
This temporary crossing #2 was removed from the impact plans and will not be
utilized in the field. The crossing will be restored and the banks will be graded to
match upstream and downstream topography. The banks will be replanted
following the N.C. Guidelines for Riparian Buffer Restoration (see Figure 3).
c) Impact #4: The rip rap in the stream immediately up and down stream of the
culvert needs to be imbedded in to the channel to allow for better stream flow and
aquatic passage.
As recommended, heavy machinery will be utilized to imbed the rip rap into the
stream channel, thereby holding the stream grade flowing through the culverts and
allowing for aquatic life passage.
d) Impact #5: There is no need for the utilization of the temporary crossing.
This temporary crossing #5 was removed from the impact plans and will not be
utilized in the field. The crossing will be restored and the banks will be graded to
match upstream and downstream topography. The banks will be replanted
following the N.C. Guidelines for Riparian Buffer Restoration (see Figure 3).
e) Impact #6: The proposed temporary crossing should be upstream of the
jurisdictional limit. Strongly recommended that silt fence and check dam be
utilitzed to prevent the potential of sediment entering the stream below the crossing.
This temporary crossing #6 was removed from the impact plans and will not impact
jurisdictional stream or wetland areas. The crossing will be restored and the banks
will be graded to match upstream and downstream topography. The banks will be
replanted following the N.C. Guidelines for Riparian Buffer Restoration (see Figure
3).
fi Impact #7: There is no need of the utilization of this site for a temporary crossing.
This temporary crossing #7 was removed from the impact plans and will not be
utilized in the field. The crossing will be restored and the banks will be graded to
match upstream and downstream topography. The banks will be replanted
following the N.C. Guidelines for Riparian Buffer Restoration (see Figure 3).
Mr. Alan Johnson
June 11, 2008
Page 3 of 3
Please continue to process this Broad River Highlands Nationwide permit, and do not hesitate
to contact me at [phone] if you have any questions or comments.
Since ely,
A a Salzber
Project Biologist
?s?
R. Rid 4e,WAS.
Principal
cc: Cyndi Karoly, DWQ
Todd Black, Fall Creek Land Co.
David Odom, Odom & Associates Engineering
CLEARWATER-,-- - ?
Broad River Highlands D L? ?7 L1 ?A ??
Environmental Consultants, In I ) iftile Vicinity
Cleveland County 718 Oakland Street
North Carolina Hendersonville, NC 28791 jli_; Figure 1
828-698-9800
vJFIU?^iuz' r?i+: 1U::vi4ti :tl?93 uetr+
81°44'00" W 81`43'00" W WGS84 81042'00" W
Stt PL a-ar[ s y , {
u k+Sh nom/ `
.=
L?? 1 (\? ?f?? ?`a'S•'?'
!
y
.[
_
.gyp ?1143?'`- \ ?'• -
r
S e
¢ 3
? yr ?i R
U

/ ] c

O V
LJ( V Xi ! x. '
h
O

V y II ,rr t- ??

'I tt r t? r t? 0
0
m

/-

q
{
1 I __
Y l s. t
- - Approximate Site
Boundary
,
p t. ;r'? A o
o
Uy
I ??? Rr,?;-

14, o
Lf1
m
++ 4
c'
' 1?'q ?? y6 I E ecb { Carn ?g

81044'00" W 81°43'00" W WGS84 81042'00"
-'
ss
IvIN Trd o _s 1 mite -
a 1030 FEEI u 5w II}3o METERS
Map created with TOPO!?++ 02003 National Geographic (v k w.nationalgeographic.coudtopo)

CLEARWATER
Broad River Highlands F,nvironmental Consultants, Inc. USGS TOPO
Cleveland County 718 Oakland Street
Figure 2
North Carolina
Hendersonville, NC 28791
828-698-9800
oS- 0-131
0
Z
TYPICAL LIVE STAKE
cross section view
ama-". ww"e m
Ark
11
RIPARIAN TREES 8. SHRUBS
• • • • • • • • • • • • •
LIVE STAKES
• • • • • • • • • • • • •
PROFILE VIEW
VID
JIB a
l k nu
A'-1
1H
,fir tt>il vvU ;??JY?N4I41? BNVa
NOTES
L LIVE STAKES SHOULD BE PLANTED
EVERY 2' IN STAGGERED ROWS
2. LIVE STAKES SHOULD BE DRIVEN
WITH AT LEAST `/5 OF TOTAL LENGTH
BELOW GROUND
3. SPLIT STAKES SHOULD NOT BE
USED
4. LEAF BUDS SHOULD POINT UPWARD
5. STAKES SHOULD BE INSTALLED
PERPENDICULAR TO STREAM BANK
6. RIPARIAN PLANTINGS SHOULD BE I
TO 3-GALLON PLANTS PLACED ON
10'X10' CENTERS STAGGERED ROWS
1. SPECIES COMPOSITION FOR
PLANTINGS SHOULD COME FROM NCEEP
RIPARIAN BUFFER GUIDELINES
Skw fl, by of bwk
STREAM BED
>
-IDlodrxnkr,wggne0mn-
•
>
• LIVE STAKES
>
>
> • • RIPARIAN TREES a SHRUBS
>
>
plan view
TYPICAL MATTING STAKE
ILL
NOTES.
I. BANKS SHOULD BE SEEDED WITH
NATIVE GRASS MIXTURES PRIOR TO
INSTALLING MATTING
2. MATTING SHOULD BE INSTALLED
ACCORDING TO MANUFACTURER'S
RECOMMENDATIONS
3. STAKES SHOULD PLACED EVERY
IN STAGGERED ROWS
COIR MA
MATTING STAR
MATTING PLACED IN
6' TRENCHES,
STAKED, BACKFILLED,
AND COMPACTED

MATTING PLACED IN
6' TRENCHES. 2
COIR MATTING I?
STAKED, BACKFILLED,
AND COMPACTED r

l EAM•BED:: .. .
CROSS SECTION VIEW
PLAN VIEW
I-
W
w
Z Z
O ;
? z
Q 'o
N L>
U) J z
0 _ a
M J
YJ W
ZQ
Q ? U
J
= J
? Q
O
F
N?wy
LL LL
/ z
LL ?
U
Q
of
W Q
O
CL
L
Lu
w
LL
F
Z o o
z
u z rz
z 3 w a
_ a o u
o ?
P
n O
N O
NcO to
U 9, O
Z D P
1.- 01 o6
rn J
0 J ^ `D
2
a Z N ^
Y cl) v N?
a W W
O o z ..
w s a
nSD_tL
L ?
In
?V
In
C
0
0
L U
C
QU E
C
o
C
W
IMPACT AREA #2
STREAM CULVERT
PERMANENT ROAD
70 LF
STREAM
WETLAND
imrAu i AKCA it4
AFTER-THE-FACT STREAM CULVERT
PERMANENT ROAD
24 LF EXISTING
56 LF NEW
0
Z
W
W
Z
Q
2 w
V >
w
= W
7
?0
W?
?> U
W
0
O
w
OCL
Q
O
m
u
z
z
z
0
U
0
W
LLI
J
U
w
w
0
0
o
z
o
2 z
?w
a.
- maw
o?
a
?o
mo
N aD
P c.>
U O
Z . Q`
01 N J 'o a,
p J n o
Z cQ
a Z N ^
J 0 N
K .
a W W v
U o z ..
z o x
o w = a
n=d ti
'v1 Vj
N
C
O
C
? U
C
Q? E
1 0
C
W
? N
M -?
r M
r m
D D
Z 3
V
t;

r
[E
ii
1
11

3
r'
{ f
f
M
3

>
Z
rn

D
n
? )JI

I

i I

n -1 C
< M
I 1
i
3
I'

f
/.. Q
t J
. _?.. ?'
-.. L.

i !
l?
f
\ S
M1
1 S I
t
i

<
. r {
i I
,
+
r
? f

t r
v tl
s
I
l j
u 1 E

I

{
y i t

Cl
carW
atcr 718 OAKLAND ST
HENDERSONVILLE NC 28791 I INCH 200 FEET BROAD RIVER HIGHLANDS SHEET NO.
4
1
PHONE: [phone] DRAWN BY, CSG DETAIL SHEET .
Environ mental Consultants, Inc. FAX: [phone] DATE' 04.14.08
NC
CLEVELAND COUNTY
CEC PROJECT NO.: 540 ,
STREAM
WETLAND
PROJECT SUMMARY
Z N
°
w
w {
x V
U
Z
Y
F
Z
O
O
,,^^ U
Z
VI O
Q a
W
Z
J
Q U
J
O_ w
LLI
2z
W =-i
>a
w
D
Q
O
w
m
LL
O
O
N
Z
m W
U U
Z 3 ? u
d r U
d Q W
ol
r-- C>
CO O
N coO
U P O
Z OOP
w a,
J 10
^
O J
OD
Z>
Q Z N ^
J O N
Q v ?
O p W v
Z ..
so z X
W = Q
n = IL LL
L °c
N
C
3
N
c
O
U
c
Q? E
c
O
W
N
IM
A
r rn
D
Z 3
0

? ?.gym
w .w

ClearWater 718 OAKLAND ST
HENDERSONVILLE NC 28791 I INCH = 200 FEET BROAD RIVER HIGHLANDS SHEET NO.

P
(828) 698
9800
DETAIL
SHEET 4.3
HONE:
- DRAWN BY. CSC
Environmental Consultants, Inc. FAX: [phone] DATE: 04.14.08
CLEVELAND COUNTY
NC
CEC PROJECT NO.. 540 ,

.
.-? w
.
1
s
Y .'

4
E
d ' s
r
y

"

s
t
k

I ? d
IMPACT AREA #3
?

AFTER-THE-FACT
STREAM CULVERT t
r t
PERMANENT ROAD
/
24 LF EXISTING
51 LF NEW

f
a1

r %

IMPACT AREA #4
`
Y

AFTER-
THE-FACT STREAM CULVERT 1.
PERMANENT ROAD
. 24 LF EXISTING
56 LF NEW >
STREAM
WETLAND
o ,}
z V
w '
w y
V
U
Z
Y
F
Z
7
O
U
'^
Z
V/ z
Q a
J
w
w
Z '
Q U
J
S?F-
W
_ rr2nn
VI
W Q
F-
W
0
O
w
in
N
I3r Iwla
P
n O
OD O
N N p
P
Zco O•
J ol
p J^`D
Z
Q Z N
J O ^
N
a'v?
W W ?
o Z
00 X
Z O
W = Q
=ww
L
ro?
0
? U
c
E
o
w