Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20200065_R-4707 CP2 (Revisit) Presentation_20160516 Wrenn, Brian L From:Al-Sharawneh, Ahmad A Sent:Monday, May 16, 2016 3:54 PM To:Bailey, David E SAW (David.E.Bailey2@usace.army.mil); Wrenn, Brian L; Davila, Felix Cc:Weaver, Derrick G; Al-Sharawneh, Ahmad A Subject:R-4707 CP2 (Revisit) Presentation Attachments:R-4707_CP2_Presentation_Final.pdf Attached the presentation Ahmad Al-Sharawneh Project Development Engineer Project Development and Environmental Analysis North Carolina Department of Transportation 919 707 6010 office 919 250 4224 fax aalsharawneh@ncdot.gov 1548 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1548 Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. Email correspondence to and from this sender is subject to the N.C. Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. 1 -r_�,a,w�� i�ir�� �:k:��r���=�r�-��, . I���TH ����L�I�� � � - "� � � "�'R—_� � �'� �S ',�� � �.`�— — � z' ��' . ,,I��_r� �, �,� , __ _��: t� ;�� _ � ,+r� - �-''��,' � s34.., ik� . � T��� � ' ' ;'�� `�} �� .� �� � � - �` �` "�t.,- I °I �'��.�F ��"' � ' � -i �h - , 4 �1 � - � STI P Project R-4707 US 29 � Reedy Fo�k Pa�kway Inte�change Imp�ovements Guilfor�d County � -� � ._. �. . , , �� �� : ��:�i . � 7M�t,� . . Agenda Introductions Purpose of This Meeting ■ Project Overview ■ Project Information ■ Public Involvement ■ Merger Team Concurrences to ��t� ■ CP 2 —Alternatives Considered ■ Build Alternatives ■ Project Schedule ■ Discussion 2 STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County �� _--.�� ���_ - � �-�. �._ � . ii_ __�� �._-�.� ��-- � - �. � , .,�. _ ��� � �� ..� .. .... , f �' . � �. �,` �T'• ." F . . '�pm� � '� �' �� A YdY ,!L - S �f '� . .. � .. � :. - � .. �_ '�'«j:Z ,�� y . � �� � 1 � . ���.1. ���'s�.: '�""s,: US -29 looking North from Anita Lane Pu�pose of This Meeting STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County The purpose of this meeting is to update the merger team on the project status and introduce the revised alternative to be carried forward for detail study. = r;��� - y,� #. .. � �, — i � , ��=_. = \"t�' �'��� I � �'_: �' . Wr k- - � , �., .', �- - r�:{ Ys a` . i....� �'s _ - ' ' -- �" -� �� � SOUTH � %: � � \ . -� = J- � �- �;rXa � `�-:�- _ . `— r x�� Y z� r� .a .. . � . - ,\i:7 " - , -t h . � ., -._ .�._._ ; � _ .. ..� ,.. 6 N _��e . �•, .N � i ' � �w.� . �' ` _ :,,� � :}. cv a l+�� .:� � � ` _ � k �' `�M` � �;4 ; =�, s � � f ,� > .� � � � � ; �''� c :� ,� � � �a „x� � '�,� � � y ! , • } �.�i �,��3",�� ,� �,�: . ' - ..' ,e.b 4 �'t t q= _ �1'}� l�r - c t. ►„r.t� � ;�'4 �.� . �_ _ _ . a.,.... - . .,e�a.,:,�a 1 rr.ni�� . ��"'k. , ", ��� :S:s'S:'� 3 P�oject Info�ynation �� US 29 looking south from the Reedy Fork Parkway bridge 4 STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County • Project is located approximately 8 miles north of downtown Greensboro in Guilford County • The proposed project includes the bridge replacement and improvements to the interchange with the realignment, part on new location, and upgrade of the existing SR 4771 (Reedy Fork Parkway) and SR 2526 (SummitAvenue). • Study Area is light industrial, institutional, and residential � Existing traffic volumes are 40,000 vehicles per day on US 29 � 2035 traffic is expected to be 72,000 vehicles per day on US 29 P�oject Vicinity Map ���� # rt-a�n� US 29 ! REEQY F�RK PARKWAY INT�RCHANG�I�PROVEMENTS VICINkTY MAP �,..��n �_ US 24 AND REE�Y FOF PARKWAY [SR 4771j C'rrccnsbora = ti� � _ < r 5,,, . � ^Y a4a ; . y" � �� �<. o<^ �v � _ ,�r _.� + �7 .1 J� � � K r � „ :n .. a� y�� _ 4 F � o � '. . -. � � �anUerwn� �a •x �' - �� 2 . 5:c� � _"' � ryq Jy 5 M� STIP Project R-4707 US 29 c� Reeclv Fork Parlcway h�terrhange lnzp��ovemeizts Guilfo�d Countv t„:; �i. ,,.it�i f`�Y N-, Pu b l i c In vo l v��n �n i � -- -._ � =� �a � � �� �"d r ,_ "i �` ����r s� �} � `����' '� �� �i ;, ;- ; ���;; w .� i� �.:� � . _ . __ . _��__. � � - - -� � , �� �"`� _ — , �. �: � STI P Project R-4707 LIS 29 & Reedy Fork Parkway Inte�hange Improvements Guilford Coui�ty ► Public Involvement ► Citizens Informational Workshop held on November 13, 2006. ► Public Meeting held on April 21, 2016 • Concerns raised regarding truck access to local businesses, existing delays at study area intersections, and increased truck traffic within the study area. � Expressed the need for a traffic light at the intersection of Eckerson Road and Reedy Fork Parkway. • Existing roadway design not supporting wide turns for large trucks. • Citizens praised the inclusion of future bicycle facilities included in project design. STI P Project R-4707 Me�ge� Team Concu��ences To Date US 29 � Reedy F°rk P"'�'`��"v Iy1t�"�h"yl�e I'�'�'"°,'e"�ents Guilford County CP 1: Purpose and Need & Study Area Defined (September 21, 2006) � The Study Area extends approximately 5,000 feet north of the existing interchange along US 29 and approximately 3,000 feet south along US 29, SR 2641 (Bryan Park Road) and SR 2525 (Summit Avenue). The Study Area also extends approximately 3,000 feet south east along SR 4771 (Reedy Fork Parkway) � The project's purpose is to provide a set of objectives that will address the transportation needs identified in the study area. The purpose of the proposed project is to replace the structurally deficient bridge over US 29, improve the interchange to meet interstate standards and accommodate future traffic volumes from the Reedy Fork Ranch Mixed Use Development. 7 Me�ge� Team Concu��ences To Date . . . . � STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County � CP 2— Design Option,s fo� Detailed Study Septembe� 21, 2006 No Build Alternative Build Alternative 1: Single Point Urban Interchange (SPUI) Build Alternative 2: Partial Cloverleaf Interchange Build Alternative 3: Traditional Diamond CP 2— A l te�n a ti ves Cu��ently Conside�ed ❑ No Build STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County ❑ Build Alternative 1: Single Point Urban Interchange (SPUI) ❑ Build Alternative 1 Revised: Diverging Diamond Interchange (DDI) ❑ Build Alternative 2: Partial Cloverleaf Interchange ❑ Build Alternative 3: Traditional Diamond All BuildAlternatives include: ► Removal of the existing structurally deficient bridge over US 29; ► Improvements to the existing Summit Avenue; ► Improved traffic flow, safety, and truck movements; ► Improved bicycle and pedestrian facilities on Reedy Fork Parkway. � STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County What is a Dive�ging Diamond Inte�change? The diverging diamond interchange known as a DDI is designed to allow two directions of traffic to temporarily cross to the opposite side of the roadway to provide easier access on and off the freeway. 10 • Limits number of traffic signal phases required to move motorists through the interchange • Movements on and off of the freeway have fewer conflict points and can be free-flowing • Moves high volumes of traffic without increasing the number of lanes in an interchange What a�e the Benefits? • Safety • • • • • • STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County Fewer conflict points (18 for DDI, 24 for SPUI, 30 for Diamond) Better sight distance at turns Wrong way entry to ramps extremely difficult Less horizontal curvature reduces risks of off-road crashes Virtually no driver confusion (FHWA study) Protected pedestrian crossing can be provided at signal • Pedestrian refuge area is provided in concrete median/islands • Decreased exposure to free-flowing turning movements � • Operations • • • • • 11 � Simple left and right turns from all directions Increases left turn lane capacity without adding lanes Two phase signals with shorter cycle lengths reduces delay Better storage between the ramp terminals Better level of service and ability to handle additional traffic capacity (15%-25%) • 12 What a�e the Benefits? COStS STI P Project R-4707 LIS 29 & Reedy Fork Parkway Inte�hange Improvements Guilford County • Construction time is reduced • Requires minimal detouring during construction • Usually requires less lanes than other interchange types • Less bridge structure — construction and long term maintenance cost savings � �x� il' ' S. �-- � #�� .: .�� ,�:: �'r=_ . .. �. - . � _ - viiy"� . _�:.� y . � �` .. _ � � - �' e . �c I � , � ,��� �Az �-'�� � _ ' �� ` '-Aa � �s _ _ . -_ � _ �` .... . _ . _ �F-.. � 4'=-. `\ ' .� a =,tR s� �. " � �.-.- __ ,� � - ��u �.' r ` -� '��� � � �-�•-�"_ _ . - i � � � _ Y �A� ;`� _. - � _ • �' _ 9� =- -- . , : �, _ ., _ . - � _ ..T-- ;; c-°s__ �, - � -. �; "- - � '� - � �-_„ ��• ' -' ^'�'�1lII�� , . , 1 � ���� , a.�, `�� � .�.....�� - -�-�-- � . :��� ,.._ � z _ .,� �� I. �� I /,� / ii� 13 STIP Project R-4707 US 29 c� Reeclv Fork Parlcwav h�terrhange /nzp�-ovemeizts ��,, r�'11'�� CO1-[17tL' �X` �' ' .ec. ' N`I' ���"� :��'o—.._ � �_. ____. _ P.!,�y`�����` -� � ���.'a-:�. _ � � Q �'�� ��' �: / • � � _.� . . . _ - _.... % —. �� _ - _ '_ --. .__ _.-�_. _�+� __ .. _ _ s `�—� � 4 . < � � �' � � �N - ` o- �wi � ' l .. _, , -.- . � .,f,'•. - - _ .._e, .._.. F ���.- _' _ ' - . . . . . .�. � . .� - � _ � _ s.,_ . - :-:,- . / q . . - :—� �_. ._, . `s`�.' 4 a . j � _.. .. ' �_.�:�,._ � �, � ._" ' .. ' � yd.____ . .r � ' _ . ��, . . ' ' � .� .: , .. - ,. __ � �s`j : _ — 'y Y . . . ,� ♦ -.� . _ � __" �s .� �' . _ � .-�'��ia _.. -- ;�� ,.- ..5 � -, �' . . /� . -a , . . . _ _� � w � _ .-: J � ��,- ��^ . . .. ., ,� g: � . � ��1, . , .� ,, �,�r �h::�,. i�, :�`. , . .. �'�� ,� ,.,,� , +, � =4i � �' r � �� �!.�� � ;#* � �� �;` -'. �+ '�- `�, �� � . �.' ��' �` �:� � a ,<�' f` .� , � ��� . • . ..�� V y .3-y . . :4.. � �y y . .� - 'i���y' T -. � : .J� � . . � �r�" '�� . 4 �' a2 � �-i!' 4 �L'? �;-_ 7 ��� . u' ,'�.w.� ,� „ . . ytR T�. . y�� 'Ji, �Sr -i v i�. ,r. i ,��� ..S`'!� yr.,.�.,-�^ '� t� � .. . . 7.W S :� ,� }�T' , �'�'�` ��; � i�� �� '_,. �. y ' '. a . . . --� "� .� t ' eY a � ~� 'y jd � . ,� .. ��.� �„� �' 'v �-:��F:..�}' � ��i-� f ���a . w Y ` �� � i.��v� � �`�_�y,� �.:r-' � �x t:', � �..-,. _ ��, � � ` �`�. v� T. T t ��jF �, � .`lY( ''.� ��1� `� ` r�_ �'adN� ,�� ��' \ i � � J9K c� zY � m � ��s:'t � .t '' � �•y�,s. t � � y ��1.:�. , '� d` ' _ �� r�`,�ti, '� :: � � ,. , a�!`s� . ; � .. ' _ � i;. ,.. � • � '+'�a°r�..��'� CDM Smith recently completed this NCDOT Design Build project R-224�E - DC�1 on 1-4�5 at Mallard Creek. The DDI was chosen over the initially recommended SPUT Alternative. No�th Ca�olina DDI P�ojects Asheville Charlotte Concord Cornelius Greensboro Kernersville Leland Lumberton Mooresville Statesville Winston-Salem 14 STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Gztiilford County I-26 at NC 280 (Asheville Airport) I-485 at Mallard Creek Road I-85 at Poplar Tent Road I-85 at NC 73 I-85 at US 29-601 I-77 at Catawba Avenue I-73 at West Gate City Boulevard I-40 at Union Cross Road US 17 at NC 133 (River Road) I-95 at US-301 (Fayetteville Road) I-77 at NC 150 I-40atUS21 US 52 at Salem Creek Connector R-4707 Alte�native 1 (SPUI) vs Alte�native 1 Revised (DDI) STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County ✓ Width of the bridges over US 29 will be reduced; DDI also allows for a tangent bridge, unlike the SPUI, which requires extra bridge structure for all ramps converging to the middle of the bridge ✓ Reduction of lanes on the ramps ✓ Construction time is reduced for the interchange due to a simplified bridge, thereby reducing labor costs ✓ Ability to handle additional traffic capacity ✓ Improved bicycle and pedestrian safety ✓ Two phase signal reduces delay 15 Build Alte�native 1 � sTiP � R-a�a� ; � ,�''}� US 291 REEDY F�RK PARKWAY � INTERCHANGE IMPROVEMENT$ +' ,�� € A,LTERI�ATE 1 i , � =, 51NGLE POINT URBAN IN7ERCHANGE (SPUI) � ' F y �- " �1 � . • � . � `". x i i i�• ' ._ i`. �.:'. k�9'. 2� , . � ,, �, �, �, .- � � : . �� . � , _ - � , , . �� p , .. . � �� - , � � I" � Existingf3rid�e �-� ��I . _ , To Bc Removed ,ry � S 11 ,f f"'' �� i ` � � >�iRs ' � _ �i ♦ � .. �..�� ' 4n _`�—_ M � '�� � 1..� - . � � i�'� �.�� I Stream Impac� ' ' �`��i ♦ 47 �+ � a10 LF ' �/ ,,s' � � . — — r'� � -� Skream Impaet �� � i �4 � �yjR� t�'� ��� 147LF � ���`�. � � � ti��� �4� �� �, •\� _ � � ra� � `) � ' ti � ^�y � .e .r� �� !f rr'` � �� � j -��1�. .. � _ � .4i+ � � A/j L"? �c �-�'!. . , . � tid ` \���' .a � l f � y'y� ' t•. � ��/.}.� .�. � ... i'' ' l' ���, ��� `=7� � : � � '�'. - � d ��� � ' ��� � � � � � " . a.. � � a:� . �� ... ' .,o.., � � n��,act - � ,f . � � -Y����� �.� � S[reamlmpact �_. � � 273 LF - 19& lF � . � ... w � � � - �' i'Y' ,�a i �,�' .� �.+ � � ``�¢� s ' , _ _ . � r% � .. � _ � ;t . - Stream Impact �'� �� "�" .;. ��,_�- Wetland fmpact , ' - . - '��-�9 LF ���, �'�_ � ' 0.'37 AC ��- ' � � . � . ..r•. - � � � �. !�� ,� �` � :t �9 r� LEGENp � ., �' � �.+ F jc� .���� .b� �, ��.+�� t°� Weklanrls A9ternative ti Streams �] 12525a 540 T50 1D00 .e�o F�ei 16 � � �� � ' a h�y}�� �R�'L. 4� � } ` � F ��� � � � � �. .,� V.� �i��C�6 ,. � ., „; ar' ° - � .ti �,]�.-;�,� C FIGURE 2 STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Foyk Parl�vay L�tercharzbe Improvenze��ts Guilford County • Single Point Urban Interchange • Three signalized intersections on Reedy Fork Parkway. • Summit Avenue will be realigned. 47 0 1,077 , 0.31 Build Alte�native 1 Revised • � STPP # R-4707 US 29 I R�EDY FORFt PARKWAY IN���FCHANGE IMP�20V�IVl�NTS �,. • ALTERNATE 1 REVISED ; �NERGII'+!G DIAMONd IM1ITERCHAl�ICsE ([DDI} � i r' � ,� ` � ' �` }`• �� zg y � ��.� ,� � ; . - , , - -, �,,�;r �a f.� ; A. � , ••� .� �,,���; '� ,. , j� :. w , ° �,� ',,�4 . ;- . , ?i -s ' lo .. ` Existing B' dne A � ., , � T Bc Removcd �t � � i, � f � � �'. _ �'� � � � � . � 3� �.r ��f� ,' . � � � � � - �� ,r,�. , �" ,3; , .�� .,�; �. . ��, � I Stream Impact i�� 4�• # r. ��� 147 LF `� . !�� �� ' . ,i ��li . � �- ��� _�---� � �� � � � � � � . `�l%. f� �`� -� . �I ` . t/� '$ ��} � _ '` � � �+�. `.. �. . �� � , , _.. . d '��y ~� �+ /� � �� ✓ � �� � , � � �j � Stream �mpact Y- y 37S LF Stre�m Impact ,' r��� `.} 734 LF .t� � � .. �"t'i ,5,* r � ` `�' ��,"+ � ;� � 1CLy�� �� � Strealm�lmpa;.'. ��� '�"� �' -:1� Wetland Impacl ` � . 109 LF "� , _�.r,��`� o�anc . `��, � LEGENQ + � � M1Neklan ds AlternaQive 1 Re�ised Streams ��''" L• o izszse soo �sn i,coa �a �w..�Feei . �,al 17 0 �l � �+ ' �' 'i�k�"�, :_ � t` . � - , i: �;°��>-, x ��*�� � i - FfGURE 3 STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reecfy Fov�k Pat�I�n�crv Intercl�ar�i�e Improverrzeizts Guilforc/ CoT�ntv ;$erging Diamond Interchange � �ignalization of three intersections �n Reedy Fork Parkway ��DI has a smaller bridge compared ��o the SPUI ��ridge fits within the fiootprint 49 0 1, 303 0.58 Build Alte�native 2 18 STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reecfv Fov�k Pat�I�n�crv Intercl�ar�i�e Improverrzeizts Gi�ilf'orcl Coity7tv • Partial Cloverleaf • Loop and ramp in southeast and southwest quadrants • Ramp terminals connect with planned roadways Required R/VII (— a Stream (� Wetlands (— ac Residential Business 0 0 1,122 0.74 Build Alte�native 3 19 STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reecfy Fov�k Pat�I�n�crv Intercl�ar�i�e Improverrzeizts Guilford Couy7tv �waditional Diamond � �ne-way diagonal ramp in each interchange quadrant • I wo future loops at two quadrants � �amps are aligned with free-flow fierminals on US-29 • Signalized intersections on Reedy Fork Parkway at the ramp 55 0 0 1,140 0.62 Build Alte�native SuYnYna�y Evaluation Factor Additional Right of Way Needed- acres Residential Relocations Business Relocations Stream - linear feet Wetlands - acres Ponds Stream Crossings (#) Total Riparian Buffer (ft2) STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County R-4707 ALTERNATIVES COMPARISON Alternative 1- Alternative 1 Alternative 2- SPUI Revised - DDI Partial Clover 47 0 0 1, 077 0.31 0 5 136,255 ,• 0 0 1,303 0.58 0 5 160,828 Note: Impacts are calculated based on Functional Design and Slope Stakes plus 40' 20 53 0 0 1,122 0.74 0 5 173, 742 Alternative 3 - Diamond ��� 0 0 1,140 0.62 0 6 168,686 In te�i m Des ign � ` T �` � �' ' „' � • � ��r , • STIP # R-4707 '�,� �y. �• US 291 R�EDY FORK PARKWAY -- �, If�fTERCHANGE IMPROVEMENTS ,,�, � INTERIM DESIGN 1 ."+ ��.:�. � , � , ��� :� . t � . �\ I `'} i��� i .��• +` ' ` y _ � j, . .:,� . � a ,�.. i � �'� � ��� � C SIIIIK � �°.P _ - , T �� R•mwed / � � � " wy s � �3 � ��. ` . �i. � o � .4_.�,, ^ ��. . .. � ,�' �< , s � r„ �. � � � �' . � v r_ ,�, J� ;*� ; � • y� :��� x'��-� � M��' , :' * I Stream Impact �ti� � �..ti d ! � e�+ 315 �F R., „�`�;��'-',+�1 ' �-Ii� * • � ¢3Y �� A 4 _ �! 1}? } '1 "i� � ��R � a� _ �M�� ��� r ,�, �� ` � _ ��^� � : � � � �J, a � ;�` , . , �� !� /' y� �� . .�.• �� •� � . �`, /� �'i l 7 �,'� � � � P k L� - _ �.�'' �,i �`s� Y � `� �A� �1_. Wetland Impact ,�, --� y� f� �� - - 0.02 AC � i�-__. � � •.(� , Stream Impact � �j' ��i� ° + 'y�� �• 149 LF � M1�. �,r�; , � . �-. .,l � . � . �� 29 r g F�'� - ,� � LEGEND �` '� �� � � � �, a,r� ti, , .�'. - ` � VVetlands � �� � ' � `� � �� ,,-,�� Inlenm [�esign y , , .� � ,r �; . y � , V � � �il1�� SlfeamS ��° °�. „�r l�,; � i a ,ar' -.k�.`iz Sy.. o�ssz5o sao iso i.000 ��� ��r.�����t�i t, I s ... � �'i �Feei A ��w s��. .;,r ,,....tt.��� �...,.�n -- � FIGUREfi 21 STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Foyk Parl�vay L�tercharzbe Improvenze��ts Guilford County • Interim Design • Existing bridge is Structurally Deficient and has a high priority of replacement per the 2014 Bridge inspection report. • The Interim Design is located within the footprint of the build alternatives. • Existing ramps will be used for access to and from US 29. • The phased construction is programmed to start in 2019. Disadvantages of the SPUI STIP Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Foyk Parl�vay L�tercharzbe Improvenze��ts Guilford County wi th th e In te�i rn Des ign • More complicated phased construction decreases safety by increasing construction time and traffic interruption. • An interim SPUI bridge eliminates alternatives for other interchange types. • The interim SPUI bridge does not accommodate the interim phase design. • The existing ramps cannot be used with the interim SPUI bridge requiring temporary ramp relocations. • Less safe due to additional traffic phasing and increased time of construction 22 P�oject Schedule Environmental Assessment Public Hearing FONSI Interim Design Right of Way Acquisition Interim Design Construction Begin Right of WayAcquisition Begin Construction STI P Project R-4707 US 29 & Reedy Fork Par•lcwav Interchange Irn�rovernents Guilford County December 2016 Spring 2017 Summer 2017 FY 2018 ' FY 2019 FY 2022 FY 2024 Notes: These major milestone target dates are preliminary and subject to change. 23 24