NC0000175_Comments_20190207

From: Elliott Grosh
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External]Draft WW PERMITS FOR MINING IN AVERY AND MITCHELL COUNTIES
Date: Tuesday,April 30,2019 6:41:32 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
David,
The link to the draft permits sends me back to the event page. I looked at every page and do not see a real link to the
draft permits. Please send it to me.
Thank you,
Elliott L.Grosh,P.E.
362 Chestnut Hill Road
Burnsville,NC
[e-mail]
Sent from my iPad

From: Glenda Short
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Fwd: Mine hearing and dumping in river!
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:29:57 PM
• External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
to report.sr)[e-mail]
See below!
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Glenda Short<userglenda c,gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Feb 7, 2019 at 5:23 PM
Subject: Mine hearing and dumping in river!
To: david.hill c&ncdner.gov<david.hill&ncdner.gov>
Request a mine hearing occur! Mines need to adhere to struck guidelines around our precious
water! Thank You!

From: Boone Bliss Yoaa and Healing Arts
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Mine permits/public meetings
Date: Tuesday,February 12,2019 7:10:35 PM
External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
attachment to reaort.spamPnc. oovv
Hello David,
As a river recreation professional and enthusiast I spend a great deal of time in the Toe and Cane River
watersheds. I would like to request a public meeting prior to permit renewal for any mines in those watershed
areas.
Thanks for your time and professional efforts to protect our natural resources.
Elin Fisher
Boone, NC

From: il428182Ccbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Justin Landry
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 28,2019 1:11:26 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Justin Landry
26 Pleasant Ridge Dr Asheville,NC 28805-2623
[e-mail]

From: rachel good people everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Rachel Frezza
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 22,2019 11:50:54 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
HIP My family just moved to this beautiful area from Asheville,NC.We chose this area for it's beauty,rivers,and
forests.Asheville has been overdeveloped and the nature destroyed.We urge you as a family who enjoys nature to
please hold anyone who pollutes or destroys our beautiful home to rectify their mistakes and make their company
better.Thank you for holding them accountable for everyone who comes after them to enjoy the river.
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Miss Rachel Frezza
901 Griffith Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-7723
[e-mail]

From: duaa3462C�everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Lee bugger
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 14,2019 11:56:36 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Lee Dugger
15 Riverview Pkwy Asheville,NC 28805-9217
[e-mail]

From: Ibo.boggess(o)evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Laura Boggess
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 14,2019 11:54:06 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Laura Boggess
501 Bailey St Mars Hill,NC 28754-6209
[e-mail]

From: abbondurantCaeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Ann Bondurant
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 14,2019 11:49:04 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Dr.Ann Bondurant
41 Wilderness Rd Asheville,NC 28804-1124
[e-mail]

From: oaulaCabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Paula Stober
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 14,2019 11:44:36 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Paula Stober
3607 Timberoak Dr Greensboro,NC 27410-2142
[e-mail]

From: marissa.mirbach(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Marissa Mirbach
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 14,2019 11:35:45 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Marissa Mirbach
2011 Water Walk Ln Charlotte,NC 28208-4746
[e-mail]

From: AmaysnaCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Susan Joyce
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 22,2019 7:39:14 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs. Susan Joyce
643 Lower Doe Bag Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-6266
[e-mail]

From: tracvmo01(cbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Tracy Patty
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 22,2019 1:15:09 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I enjoy camping and swimming in the Tow River in Green Mountain NC.As locals and tourists enjoy the
waterways,its imperative that our Government insures our safety and the Eco sustems of the river.I urge you to
revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the
Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North Toe River and the
public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these sites should
require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,and protect
water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Tracy Patty
606 E Patterson St Hendersonville,NC 28739-6754
[e-mail]

From: sharonamae(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Sharon Meeker
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 21,2019 10:19:12 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Sharon Meeker
72 Greenwood Acres Dr Mills River,NC 28759-9736
[e-mail]

From: noraintheskywdiamondsCcaeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Nora Donovan
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 21,2019 9:30:45 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Nora Donovan
40 Old Elk Mountain Rd Asheville,NC 28804-2070
[e-mail]

From: randi(aDevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Randi Glover
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 21,2019 9:14:33 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Randi Glover
316 Riverview Dr Asheville,NC 28806-4405
[e-mail]

From: cheaface(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Chelsea Myers
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 21,2019 11:43:03 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Chelsea Myers
31 Beverly Rd W Asheville,NC 28806-4506
[e-mail]

From: timbrels.Christine(&everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Christine Rutherford
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 9:17:37 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Christine Rutherford
607 S York St Gastonia,NC 28052-4039
[e-mail]

From: hahoolulugeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Laura Spreitzer
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 7:05:30 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Laura Spreitzer
385 Old Mars Hill Hwy Weaverville,NC 28787-9662
[e-mail]

From: oattvcunninahamwoolf(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Patty Woolf
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 4:28:44 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
As a local REALTOR who understands the economic value of this regions'natural resources,I urge you to revise
your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the
Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North Toe River and the
public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these sites should
require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,and protect
water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Patty Woolf
12 Ellenwood Dr Asheville,NC 28804-2316
[e-mail]

From: 23butterflies(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Carol Swing
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 25,2019 5:16:03 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Carol Swing
223 Dula Springs Rd Weaverville,NC 28787-8396
[e-mail]

From: r mca everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Ruth McGalliard
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 4:16:16 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Ruth McGalliard
238 Territory Ln Burnsville,NC 28714-5883
r [e-mail]

From: sheana(&everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Sheana Mclaughlin
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 2:57:32 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Miss Sheana Mclaughlin
54 Mardell Cir Asheville,NC 28806-3532
[e-mail]

From: cswillis(Deveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Caitlin Sforza
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 2:03:25 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
As a native to Western North Carolina,a current resident of a neighboring county,and a land owner in Yancey
County,I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
The Toe River has been listed as one of the cleanest,if not the cleanest,river in North Carolina.As someone who
camps near the Toe,swims in it regularly as well as kayaks I beg you to consider the quality of life that will be
impacted by these mining operations.It will impact not only my family but the wildlife around the river as well.I
may not have the technical vocabulary to precisely convey exactly how detrimental these mining operations are to
our community but I do not want to hear about job creation as the opposing positive.It does not hold a candle to
how we degrade the environment for financial gain.If such operations are allowed to intoxicate the surrounding area
then it takes a toll on our access to clean water,fresh air and sustainable,nutritious food.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Caitlin Sforza
9 Ben Franklin Ln Asheville,NC 28805-9739
[e-mail]

From: sumoranCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Susan Ross
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 1:31:47 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms. Susan Ross
354 Hopson Holw Green Mountain,NC 28740-6062
[e-mail]

From: gracepcgouin(cbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Grace Gouin
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 11:55:53 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Grace Gouin
2100 Bald Mountain Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-6085
[e-mail]

From: nicaubsacesCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Nicole Walsh
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 10:51:03 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Nicole Walsh
643 Lower Doe Bag Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-6266
[e-mail]

From: zoo4sueCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Susan Bayliff
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 10:31:37 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Susan Bayliff
517 Jim Creek Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-6100
[e-mail]

From: thomasfranklinbradyCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of thomas bradv
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 9:39:10 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
mr thomas brady
390 Poverty Branch Rd Barnardsville,NC 28709-9794
[e-mail]

From: Dmac5353C�evervactioncustom.com on behalf of David McNally
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 9:11:10 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
I live on the North Toe River downstream of Spruce Pine. As a fisherman and conservationists,I have noticed a
change in the fish population over the last few years especially the species available. In addition to the mines,I
have not found out yet on what industrial facilities such as Unimin in Bakersville are dumping into the North Toe
River. All of which is very concerning and regulations should be tightened to protect our environment.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr David McNally
3745 Toe River Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-8305
[e-mail]

From: sc000eraia(a�everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Stephanie Cooper
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 7:20:08 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
We live down river,on the river,from RedhillI and urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,
The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation
to ensure that water quality in the North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are
adequately protected.The new permits for these sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure
to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Stephanie Cooper
3745 Toe River Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-8305
[e-mail]

From: cynthiabrinaleCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Cynthia Brinale
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 24,2019 6:52:13 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Pollution is bad for everyone and all creatures that depend on the river.1 urge you to revise your renewed permits
for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,
and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding
communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these sites should require the facilities with aging or
failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Cynthia Bringle
160 Lucy Morgan Ln Bakersville,NC 28705-7389
[e-mail]

From: moel90(cbevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Maggie Pelick
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 6:44:12 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Maggie Pelick
PO Box 416 Burnsville,NC 28714-0416
[e-mail]

From: blueskkvvtCcaeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Alexandria Regan
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 5:48:32 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Me.Alexandria Regan
2180 Pigeon Roost Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-8525
[e-mail]

From: Osten.mcaalliard(&everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Krvsten McGalliard
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 20,2019 3:48:53 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Our water and its ecosystems are more important.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Krysten McGalliard
238 Territory Ln Burnsville,NC 28714-5883
[e-mail]

From: sabyrd89(oeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Samantha Byrd
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Tuesday,February 19,2019 10:38:32 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Samantha Byrd
445 Sam J Byrd Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-5155
[e-mail]

From: stormvhilltop everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Coral Lisa Woods
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Tuesday,February 19,2019 10:25:39 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Coral Lisa Woods
160 Mundy Cove Rd Weaverville,NC 28787-9717
[e-mail]

From: nolipi rate 1Cabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Michael Crooks
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 4:47:36 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr Michael Crooks
275 Echo Hill Dr Green Mountain,NC 28740-6256
[e-mail]

From: philatnvCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Phillip Causill
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 2:32:49 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr Phillip Causill
1187 Byrd Branch Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-5192
[e-mail]

From: TimPen98(@everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Trey Penland
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 2:04:39 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Trey Penland
179 Maney Branch Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-5789
[e-mail]

From: heath n heaven Peveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Heather Jones
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 1:03:57 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Heather Jones
55 Indian Trail Rd Candler,NC 28715-9321
[e-mail]

From: walshlifeCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Thomas Walsh
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 1:01:59 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr Thomas Walsh
6814 Jacks Creek Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-8351
[e-mail]

From: ceceliafurmanCalevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Cecelia Furman
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 24,2019 6:24:32 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Cecelia Furman
135 Western Ln Burnsville,NC 28714-5510
[e-mail] [e-mail]

From: dugg3462C�evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Lee Duaaer
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 9:36:13 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Lee Dugger
15 Riverview Pkwy Asheville,NC 28805-9217
[e-mail]

From: kimberlvleaskelton(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Kim Skelton
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 8:23:09 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Kim Skelton
390 Parson Branch Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-8324
[e-mail]

From: spencer marthaCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Martha Spencer
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 8:12:22 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Martha Spencer
988 Henry Mountain Rd Brevard,NC 28712-6762
[e-mail]

From: abeyrd2Peveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Abbey Malk
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 7:17:17 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Water quality is necessary to life!Please do not pollute our ecosystem! I urge you to revise your renewed permits
for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,
and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding
communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these sites should require the facilities with aging or
failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Abbey Malk
105 Settlers Ridge Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-8340
[e-mail]

From: dosaatos(a)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Brenda Willis
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 5:22:30 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Brenda Willis
77 Laurel St Bakersville,NC 28705-9503
[e-mail]

From: suzannekstowe(cieveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Suzanne Stowe
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 17,2019 8:23:12 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms. Suzanne Stowe
38 Starlight Way Burnsville,NC 28714-0240
[e-mail]

From: Cheri.c1976Caleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Cheri Lee
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 17,2019 4:39:04 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Cheri Lee
129 Phillips Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-6182
[e-mail]

From: olgapaderC�everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Olaa Pader
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 17,2019 4:27:24 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Olga Pader
262 Mine Valley Trl Franklin,NC 28734-6424
[e-mail]

From: awolf815((Deveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Randall Jenkins
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 17,2019 4:20:10 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr Randall Jenkins
1657 Quillmark Rd Winston Salem,NC 27127-5843
[e-mail]

From: bradshupeCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Brad Shupe
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 17,2019 8:54:29 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Brad Shupe
153 Mills PI Asheville,NC 28804-8302
[e-mail]

From: xannOCcaevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Jamie Hopson
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 23,2019 5:04:41 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr Jamie Hopson
354 Hopson Holw Green Mountain,NC 28740-6062
[e-mail]

From: wig htm an.patricia(aevervaction custom.com on behalf of Patricia Wightman
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 3:37:08 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Patricia Wightman
79 Kyanite Dr Burnsville,NC 28714-8860
[e-mail]

From: detrinac(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Detrina Kofroth
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 11:55:07 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Detrina Kofroth
325 Advent Church Rd Taylorsville,NC 28681-4623
[e-mail]

From: maier.catherynCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Catheryn Maier
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 11:08:26 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I STRONGLY urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill
Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the
North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits
for these sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce
pollution,and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Catheryn Maier
411 Walnut St Davidson,NC 28036-8061
[e-mail]

From: melfla(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Melissa Hall
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 10:57:21 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Melissa Hall
384 APPALACHIAN Way Bakersville,NC 28705
[e-mail]

From: sciencecandance(cbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Nancy Lowe
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 10:44:24 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
We need our water to be clean.I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar
Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that
water quality in the North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.
The new permits for these sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their
operations,reduce pollution,and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Nancy Lowe
1229 Rebels Creek Rd Bakersville,NC 28705-7230
[e-mail]

From: ierinvincenzCcievervactioncustom.com on behalf of Jennifer Vincenz
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 9:31:52 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Jennifer Vincenz
111 Bell St Spruce Pine,NC 28777-3103
[e-mail]

From: ceramicsbysanaCalevervactioncustom.com on behalf of SANG ROBERSON
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 8:50:21 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms. SANG ROBERSON
112 Roberts Ln Taos,NM 87571-5977
[e-mail]

From: rblandCcaevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Rik Bland
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 16,2019 8:48:04 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
It is time to honor your oath of office and God's great creation.It well past time for the people of North Carolina to
come first.I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill
Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the
North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits
for these sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce
pollution,and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Rick Bland
83 Stone Dr Brevard,NC 28712-7677
[e-mail]

From: milnesstudio(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Robert Milnes
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 11:05:33 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Dr.Robert Milnes
1 Ridgeview Dr Asheville,NC 28804-2755
[e-mail]

From: barwickbeckyC�everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Rebecca Derby
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 9:37:43 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Rebecca Derby
131 N Main St Burnsville,NC 28714-2954
[e-mail]

From: mandy83032(c)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Amanda Laws
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 23,2019 2:41:05 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
As a citizen of Yancey County,who lives within a mile of the North Toe River,whose family has lived here,loved
lived off of this land for nearly 200 years,I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The
Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to
ensure that water quality in the North Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are
adequately protected.The new permits for these sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure
to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,and protect water quality.I have seen what can happen.It not only
affects the fish and wildlife,but the people who live here.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Mitchell and Yancey Counties deserve for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to
step up and propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Amanda Laws
5779 Double Island Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-6119
[e-mail]

From: kackvwaxk(aleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Katherine McCarty
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 6:37:01 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Katherine McCarty
72 Chestnut Hill Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8706
[e-mail]

From: bethkokol(abeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Beth Kokol
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 6:09:45 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Beth Kokol
2711 Rabbit Hop Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8622
[e-mail]

From: hilarvhovle99(u everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Hilary Moore
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 5:46:53 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Hilary Moore
1190 Upper Browns Creek Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-7301
[e-mail]

From: cdduncan58Ca1everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Desiree Duncan
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 2:53:36 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Desiree Duncan
118 Frank Biddix Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-9312
[e-mail]

From: edwcorai(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Edwina Brinale
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 12:43:12 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
This is in my back yard.
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Edwina Bringle
1783 Conley Ridge Rd Bakersville,NC 28705-7076
[e-mail]

From: merribeth66(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Meredith Bizzell
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 12:12:20 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Meredith Bizzell
185 Celo Vw Burnsville,NC 28714-4567
[e-mail]

From: cynthiabrinale(aleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Cynthia Brinale
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 11:36:50 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Cynthia Bringle
160 Lucy Morgan Ln Bakersville,NC 28705-7389
[e-mail]

From: backatthebeach(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Barb Ackerman
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 10:48:46 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Barb Ackerman
208 Melrose Ave Encinitas,CA 92024-2514
[e-mail]

From: contactahillieCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Collette Gabrielle
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 9:53:38 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Collette Gabrielle
132 Hillcrest Cir Spruce Pine,NC 28777-2955
[e-mail]

From: ienniferbstudioCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Jennifer Bueno
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 9:27:27 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Jennifer Bueno
PO Box 26 Penland,NC 28765-0026
[e-mail]

From: aatormuffin(cbeveWctioncustom.com on behalf of Emilie Pinho
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 23,2019 11:30:19 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Emilie Pinho
2562 Bald Mountain Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-6147
[e-mail]

From: khaislip everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Kristopher Haislio
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 8:57:12 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Kristopher Haislip
570 Clear Creek Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-7555
[e-mail]

From: samosonaordon(a everyactioncustom.com on behalf of David Gordon
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 8:35:44 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.David Gordon
60 Park Sq Asheville,NC 28801-3123
[e-mail]

From: fillorv(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Toni Meador
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 8:26:18 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Dr.Toni Meador
84 Distant View Dr Asheville,NC 28803-2477
[e-mail]

From: lisa.botbvl(abeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Lisa Botbyl
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 7:23:04 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs Lisa Botbyl
75 Blue Heaven Terrace Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8429
[e-mail]

From: tomtblair(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Tom Blair
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 7:12:28 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr Tom Blair
106 Vance Farm Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8582
[e-mail]

From: rebadvance(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Reba Vance
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 15,2019 5:47:57 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Reba Vance
1490 Deer Park Lake Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8481
[e-mail]

From: iimsto(aDevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Jim Stone
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 9:32:05 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
My family and friends kayak on the North Toe.Recreation there must be good for the economy,too,in addition to
mines.Water quality should be high.And,for the health of the region the river should be maintained clean.The
permits should be brought up to current best practices so the community doesn't suffer degradation of the all
important ecosystem.
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Jim Stone
647 Town Mountain Rd Apt 201 Asheville,NC 28804-3753
[e-mail]

From: donclapip caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Don Claoo
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 9:29:35 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Don Clapp
567 Greenville St Saluda,NC 28773-9780
[e-mail]

From: lefaru2Cabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Leo Farua
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 8:56:45 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Leo Faruq
106 Gashes Creek Rd Asheville,NC 28805-2504
[e-mail]

From: hstevensCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Heather Stevens
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 8:40:02 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Dr.Heather Stevens
256 S Running Creek Cv Whittier,NC 28789-8400
[e-mail]

From: bananarav(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Dana Ray
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 23,2019 8:46:04 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms Dana Ray
189 Simmons Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-7383
[e-mail]

From: maalioniclCalevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Jude Maglione
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 8:06:24 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Jude Maglione
10 Moreview Dr Asheville,NC 28803-2713
[e-mail]

From: dcwinaCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Doug Wingeier
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 6:12:46 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Rev.Dr.Doug Wingeier
266 Merrimon Ave Asheville,NC 28801-1218
[e-mail]

From: ieannecharlie79(u everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Jeanne Cummings
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 5:01:00 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
The water quality of the North Toe must be protected from mining run off! Please strengthen the permits.Thank
you.
Jeanne Cummings
Sincerely,
Mrs Jeanne Cummings
340 Vanderbilt Rd Asheville,NC 28803-2947
[e-mail]

From: ioel fafnirCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Steven
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 3:56:41 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr. Steven Sy
1625 Woodbrook St Apt 102 East Lansing,MI 48823-1751
j [e-mail]

From: fit.and.trim.petservices(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Jamie Young
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 3:18:11 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Jamie Young
101 Indian Trl Burnsville,NC 28714-3121
[e-mail]

From: char2moo2(abevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Charlene Ihrig
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:55:54 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.Let's work toward the good and work on protecting and improving our waters.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests. Everyone should have the
opportunity to share the rivers with our children and grandchildren.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Charlene Ihrig
52 Dry Branch Ln Burnsville,NC 28714-5091
[e-mail]

From: briansusansmith(aleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Susan Smith
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:28:16 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs. Susan Smith
138 W Avon Pkwy Asheville,NC 28804-1410
[e-mail]

From: amandalevesque466Ca1everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Amanda Levesque
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:28:16 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Miss Amanda Levesque
1 Battle Sq Asheville,NC 28801-2712
[e-mail]

From: aroveairl3088(cbeve[yactioncustom.com on behalf of Annette Taylor
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:22:29 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Annette Taylor
1209 Twin Creek Rd Apex,NC 27523-2818
[e-mail]

From: aroveairl3088(cbeve[yactioncustom.com on behalf of Annette Taylor
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:22:10 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Annette Taylor
1209 Twin Creek Rd Apex,NC 27523-2818
[e-mail]

From: davna.ferauson(c)evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Dayna Ferguson
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 23,2019 5:10:13 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Dayna Ferguson
131 Dellwood Ave Swannanoa,NC 28778-2603
[e-mail]

From: cbrexelCaoeveWctioncustom.com on behalf of Charles Brexel Sr.
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:03:55 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Charles Brexel Sr.
623 Harbor Creek Pkwy Canton,GA 30115-9556
[e-mail]

From: marlowrealestateCubeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Jay Marlow
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 2:01:15 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Jay Marlow
67 Frances St Asheville,NC 28806-4410
[e-mail]

From: danna.mclintock(&everyactioncustom.com on behalf of danna mclintock
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 1:43:58 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
ins.danna mclintock
920 Tumbling Fork Rd Waynesville,NC 28785-6010
[e-mail]

From: kenconserv(cieveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Ken Goldsmith
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 1:01:01 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Ken Goldsmith
722 Parkham Ln Raleigh,NC 27603-1787
[e-mail]

From: sweissman4Cabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Stephen Weissman
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 12:20:48 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr. Stephen Weissman
434 Gorman Bridge Rd Asheville,NC 28806-8812
[e-mail]

From: mistamac2(&evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Frank McConnell
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 12:17:53 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Frank McConnell
763 Cascade Lake Rd Pisgah Forest,NC 28768-8646
[e-mail]

From: kcrutchCabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Karen Crutchfield
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 12:14:40 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Karen Crutchfield
124 Mountain Dr Biltmore Lake,NC 28715-8914
[e-mail]

From: eddcort3()everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Ed Cortriaht
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 12:10:51 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Mr.Ed Cortright
4 Alpine Way Asheville,NC 28805-1536
[e-mail]

From: riddle.molly.ci(@eveUactioncustom.com on behalf of Molly Riddle
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 12:02:25 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Molly Riddle
308 Shoal Pond Cv Burnsville,NC 28714-0195
[e-mail]

From: btlawrence(cDeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Betty Lawrence
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Thursday,February 14,2019 12:01:07 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Mitchell County is near and dear to me,and like many rural counties,it is suffering economically. Its future must
lie in its beauty and pristing natural resources. It must have clean water.
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Betty Lawrence
142 Hillside St Asheville,NC 28801-1206
[e-mail]

From: rsouthecorvo(o)evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Robin Southecorvo
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please improve permits for mining facilities to clean up the North Toe River
Date: Friday,March 01,2019 6:19:18 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to revise your renewed permits for Crystal Operation,The Feldspar Corporation,Red Hill Quartz
Processing Plant,the Schoolhouse Quartz Facility,and Quartz Operation to ensure that water quality in the North
Toe River and the public health of the surrounding communities are adequately protected.The new permits for these
sites should require the facilities with aging or failing infrastructure to upgrade their operations,reduce pollution,
and protect water quality.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and even though
the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits for the
next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Specifically,pollution discharges should be lowered for TSS and Fluoride,and the limits for pH should be
tightened.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves for the NC Department of Environmental Quality to step up and
propose permits that put the environment and the public first—not corporate interests.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Ms.Robin Southecorvo
20 Friendly Holw Asheville,NC 28806-1322
[e-mail]

From: Matt Moses
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External]Public Meeting Request
Date: Thursday,February 07,2019 12:06:10 PM
• External email. Do no click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as a
to rep v
Hello David. As a property owner of river frontage downstream and paddler of the Toe River I
would like to request a public meeting prior to permit renewal for any mines in this valuable
watershed.
Thanks for your consideration and all that you and your department already do to protect our
natural resources.
Sincerely,
Matt Moses
CEO
Mountain River Guides Powered by USA Raft
2 Jones Branch Rd
Erwin, TN 37650
800-USA-Raft or 800-872-7238
www.USARaft.com
www.mountainriverguides.com
moses o,usaraft.com
Rafting on the French Broad, Nolichucky and Watauga Rivers. Caving. Fly Fishing.
Shuttle Service.Adventure Retreats. Tiny House Cabins. SUP. Onewheel.
0

From: Dale Swanson
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Public Meeting Request
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 4:16:42 PM
• External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
to re ort. v
Hello David,
As a river recreation professional and enthusiast I spend a great deal of time in the Toe and
Cane River watersheds. I would like to request a public meeting prior to permit renewal for
any mines in those watershed areas.
Thanks for your time and professional efforts to protect our natural resources.
Dale Swanson
SUP & Special Events Manager
USA Raft :: Mountain River Guides
800.872.7238
Mobile & Text 336.608.7881

From: [phone]Co)tmomai1.net
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External]
Date: Thursday,February 07,2019 4:55:21 PM
Attachments: text 1549575911692.txt
External emailail. DTk links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious emh�m ent to ail.
........................................................................................................................................................................................................
Hi I'm sending this message to request a public hearing for mine permit. The permits for the
mines near the Toe River are up for review and renewal. Please keep our environment safe
and follow safety procedures to keep the Toe River free of mine waste. Thank you
T • •Mobile:
This massage was sent to you by a T•Mobile wireless phone.

From: lauren r)iooin
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Hearing for mine permits
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:05:05 AM
6 • External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
to re ort. v
Hello,
I'm writing as a nearby resident who uses the Toe and Nolichucky river for
recreation, to request a public hearing for the mines permits. I believe this to be
important to our public and environmental health. Thanks for your help,
Lauren Pippin

From: Asia Guyer
To: Hill,_Dayi�i A
Subject: [External]Mining Permits for N Toe river
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 12:24:12 PM
NEW—
• xternal email. Do not clicklinks or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
to report,spamCcDnc,g_oy
David Hill
The North Toe River is loved by paddlers, anglers, and swimmers, provides tourism
opportunities for the local community in Spruce Pine, and is home to trout and endangered
species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive
Please consider asking the Department of Environmental Quality to hold a public hearing on
the North Toe Mines TODAY (2/8). These mines discharge effluent into the N. Toe, which is
a pristine recreation river and also home to trout and other sensitive aquatic species. It's
important that they use the best technology to clean their effluent, especially as the mining
operations in Spruce Pine expand. I am asking for a public hearing on all 6 NPDES Permits
for mining operations in Spruce Pine. Thank you! Sincerely, Asia Guyer 28787

------- -------------
Sincerely, Asia

From: Amelia Burnette
To: Hill. David A
Cc: Culpepper,Linda; Poupart.Jeff;janet mizzi(a fws.aov;davis.mollyCabepa.gov; Davidson.Landon
Subject: [External] North Toe River NPDES permits
Date: Tuesday,February 19,2019 6:27:22 PM
Attachments: 2019-02-19 NPDES Spruce Pine Minina Permit Comments.Ddf
Attachments NPDES Permit Comments Spruce Pine.pdf
External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
attachment to reaort.spam(@nc.gov J
Please see attached comments on behalf of the French Broad Riverkeeper, MountainTrue,
Defenders of Wildlife, and the Southern Environmental Law Center for NPDES permits renewals for
several mineral ore processing facilities on the North Toe River: NPDES Permits NC0000175,
NC0000353, NC0000361, NC0000400, NCO084620 and NC0085839.
Thank you,
Amelia
Amelia Burnette
Senior Attorney
Southern Environmental Law Center
48 Patton Avenue, Suite 304
Asheville, NC 28801
828-258-2023 tel
828-258-2024fax
aburnette(o)selcnc.org
Southern Environment.org

From: kbihdeCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Kristie Ihde
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Wednesday,February 13,2019 11:24:15 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs Kristie Ihde
300 School Rd E Asheville,NC 28803-9622
[e-mail]

From: whocooksforvouCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Gail Lankford
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Tuesday,February 12,2019 4:45:53 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Why would you ALLOW such major pollution for mining?Mica mining is important to the community,but no
reason they should be allowed to pollute the river!
Sincerely,
Mrs.Gail Lankford
175 Britten Cove Rd Weaverville,NC 28787-9019
[e-mail]

From: codvkelPeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Cody Kelly
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Tuesday, February 12,2019 11:01:06 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Cody Kelly
62 Johnston Blvd Asheville,NC 28806-1819
[e-mail]

From: marlowrealestateCubevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Jay Marlow
To: Hill,David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 11,2019 4:34:27 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Jay Marlow
67 Frances St Asheville,NC 28806-4410
[e-mail]

From: IaurenCclevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Lauren Reker
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 11,2019 2:02:34 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Lauren Reker
23 Calloway Dr Barnardsville,NC 28709-9748
[e-mail]

From: ecrinalerCa)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Lisa Swaim
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 10,2019 2:07:44 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I want public hearings on new permits for the six mining plants on the North Toe River.
I've lived on the North Toe since 1989,and I've seen it go from having brown water with indestructible foam
floating on top to beautiful clear wet that is safe for paddlers and swimmers,and people downstream like me.The
clearer water is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive and lets locals and
visitors fish the waters.All this provides tourism opportunities for the local community in Spruce Pine,and people
downstream like me who rent their house out for some extra income in a place where it's hard to earn a living.That
river is literally what puts food on our tables.
I have watched these mining facilities on the North Toe violate water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,
and last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
The damage didn't stop after the North Toe became the Toe River.This destruction flows right on downstream and
doesn't recognize county lines.
The Department of Environmental Quality already considers the North Toe River impaired,but the proposed new
permits for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue
unabated.This makes no sense.The local community deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the
river before the permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Lisa Swaim
1197 Lower Doe Bag Rd Green Mountain,NC 28740-6225
[e-mail]

From: hollifield7741(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Glenda Hollifield
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Sunday, February 10,2019 1:36:39 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Glenda Hollifield
48 Ellis Road Ext Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8761
[e-mail]

From: altomcho(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Aimee Tomcho
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 09,2019 7:53:42 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Aimee Tomcho
996 Byrd Branch Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-5025
[e-mail]

From: btlawrence(cbevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Betty Lawrence
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 09,2019 6:42:39 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Mitchell County is near and dear to me as the home of my parents for over forty years. Its future,in my opinion,is
dependent of retaining and improving its environment.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Betty Lawrence
142 Hillside St Asheville,NC 28801-1206
[e-mail]

From: robe rt(aeveryaction custom.com on behalf of Robert Eidus
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 09,2019 5:47:14 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Robert Eidus
300 Indigo Bunting Ln Marshall,NC 28753-6522
[e-mail]

From: hWunn(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of HK GUNN
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 09,2019 3:45:26 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
There must be a better way to deal with the effluent from the 6 mining facilities on the North Toe River-other than
NCDEQ to simply take payment to turn a blind eye on their straight piping into Our precious river-beloved&
enjoyed by many.
(Could the effluent be held in sedimentation ponds first-allowed to seep,settle&be filtered before the chemicals
reach our precious water system?)
Could NCDEQ correct the permits to reduce the amount of allowable chemicals to reflect more acceptable levels
conducive to Healthy Life?
Surely NCDEQ cannot simply re-permit at the same levels which have not been safe-nor monitored effectively;
Our Beloved River would not be IMPAIRED if NCDEQ enforced more restrictive permits.
Surely NCDEQ could do a better job MONITORING the 6(!)mining facilities on Our North Toe River&Actually
ENFORCE Tighter Permits;
SO MANY OF US ARE DEPENDING ON NCDEQ TO DO A BETTER JOB WATCHING OUT FOR OUR
HEALTH&SAFETY!
THANK YOU.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.
The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local community
in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.However,
mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and last summer,
the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.HK GUNN
PO Box 223 Little Switzerland,NC 28749-0223
[e-mail]

From: i lama rca(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Kate Lamar
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 09,2019 5:59:04 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Kate Lamar
438 Haw Branch Rd Bamardsville,NC 28709-9762
[e-mail]

From: ddduffv88Caaeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Deidre Duffv
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Saturday,February 09,2019 2:24:34 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Deidre Duffy
67 Craggy Ave Asheville,NC 28806-3148
[e-mail]

From: eeckl82(Devervactioncustom.com on behalf of Elizabeth Eckl
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 4:01:12 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Elizabeth Eckl
13 N Oak Forest Dr Asheville,NC 28803-3333
[e-mail]

From: eddcort3()evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Ed Cortriaht
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 3:06:52 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Ed Cortright
4 Alpine Way Asheville,NC 28805-1536
[e-mail]

From: dcwinaCa)evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Doug Wingeier
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 2:59:09 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Rev.Dr.Doug Wingeier
266 Merrimon Ave Asheville,NC 28801-1218
[e-mail]

From: Jim.mcalinn08(&evervactioncustom.com on behalf of James and Jeanne McGinn
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 2:51:32 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Clean water in the North Toe River is essential to all of us.Mining companies that use this resource should be held
to strict standards of conservation.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Drs.James and Jeanne McGlinn
1032 Windsor Dr Asheville,NC 28803-2159
[e-mail]

From: Iunatraveler(a evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Emer O"Shaughnessy
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 2:42:55 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Emer O'Shaughnessy
19 Alabama Ave Weaverville,NC 28787-9239
[e-mail]

From: barbaraslossCcaevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Barbara Sloss
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:53:24 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Barbara Sloss
5 Wagon Rd Asheville,NC 28805-2613
[e-mail]

From: krichdunnCaoeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of karen richardson dunn
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:48:23 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Rev.karen richardson dunn
12 Melrose Ave Asheville,NC 28804-3507
[e-mail]

From: iody(cbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Jody Whitehurst
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:39:37 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I have wonderful memories of canoeing on he North Toe River with groups of up to 20 youth-learning about
ecology,seeing wildlife,learning about communication,cooperation and other life skills while navigating crystal
clear waters though which we could see fish swimming by.We would take breaks to splash and swim in the clean
waters and to discuss the importance of protecting our watersheds.Allowing ANY kind of pollution is an abuse of a
finite and vital resource for our health.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Jody Whitehurst
47 Mildred Ave Asheville,NC 28806-3139
[e-mail]

From: whitnoid86(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Whitney Eure
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:23:57 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I am an avid kayaker and spend many days every year on the Nolichucky River,which if formed by the confluence
of the Toe and Cane Rivers.Many recreational businesses(rafting,fly fishing,etc.)depend on clean water in this
river system to maintain their livelihoods.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Dr.Whitney Eure
94 Tacoma Cir Asheville,NC 28801-1624
[e-mail]

From: bahstud(c)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Chris Burbach
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:18:03 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Chris Burbach
52 Deerwood Dr Asheville,NC 28805-1508
[e-mail]

From: dmiller0l(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Danielle Miller
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:16:55 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Danielle Miller
183 Brucemont Cir Asheville,NC 28806-3442
[e-mail]

From: mstena(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Mark Stenaer
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:13:01 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
It's a travesty that a billion dollar industry essentially owned by a foreign entity cannot improve it's dismal record of
environmental impact! Why should the local residents and rivers suffer?The Nolichucky River,which is an
outstanding resource plus a candidate for Wild&Scenic status,lies downstream and the water quality needs to be
protected.
Mark Stenger
Sincerely,
Mr.Mark Stenger
411 Laythan Ct Winder,GA 30680-2887
[e-mail]

From: sharonrothmitchell(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Sharon Mitchell
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 1:02:14 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs. Sharon Mitchell
24 Bellhaven Rd Asheville,NC 28805-1502
[e-mail]

From: ptl ion heart(a evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Paul Turner
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 11:55:57 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Paul Turner
230 Peepeye Cove Rd Leicester,NC 28748-6386
[e-mail]

From: peacemaker.ymani(oeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Ymani Simmons
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 11:55:07 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Ymani Simmons
230 Peepeye Cove Rd Leicester,NC 28748-6386
[e-mail]

From: carolio94(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Carol Diamond
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 11:50:26 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Carol Diamond
16 Krista Cir Ste A Candler,NC 28715-8610
[e-mail]

From: wilson.elisekCcaevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Elise Wilson
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 11:48:00 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Elise Wilson
160 Dorchester Ave Asheville,NC 28806-3518
[e-mail]

From: marvann era ckoffO)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Maryanne R.Rackoff
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 11:04:43 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.As an attorney and environmentalist,I believe that is what the law requires.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Maryanne R.Rackoff
45 Tree Top Dr Arden,NC 28704-3040
[e-mail]

From: sand raCabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of SANDRA BROOKS
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 10:51:31 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and last summer,
the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves better.Do not renew thee permits till changes are made in the
processes that pollute our environment.
Sincerely,
Ms. SANDRA BROOKS
24 Meeting St Asheville,NC 28803-0167
[e-mail]

From: kandpbrvan(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Ken Bryan
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 9:03:15 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
If anything,the permits should be tightened to reduce the pollution allowed in discharges.The local community in
Spruce Pine and people like me who enjoy canoeing and fishing on the N.Toe deserve a public hearing to have a
voice in the future of the river before the permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Ken Bryan
605 Oakland St Kings Mountain,NC 28086-3867
[e-mail]

From: ienherman77(5)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Jenny Herman
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 8:43:23 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Our natural resources are one of our most valuable assets in WNC,as well as in the entire state of NC.We need to
protect them for future generations.Not only are rivers affected by poor environmental policy but also surrounding
water tables and habitats.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs Jenny Herman
255 Garren Creek Rd Fairview,NC 28730-7605
[e-mail]

From: aambre114Ccbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Robert Gambrell
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 8:36:20 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Robert Gambrell
481 N Fork Rd Black Mountain,NC 28711-8762
[e-mail]

From: devinmarie(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Devin Waters-Burbach
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 8:01:45 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs Devin Waters-Burbach
52 Deerwood Dr Asheville,NC 28805-1508
[e-mail]

From: CH Nyberg(aDeveryaction custom.corn on behalf of Carl Nybera
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:58:03 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I remember the North Toe river turning green on Sunday mornings.Apparently the mining companies were
dumping pollutants when the State offices were closed.
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Carl Nyberg
9 Buckingham Ct Asheville,NC 28803-2401
[e-mail]

From: bbrookshire(&evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Becky Brookshire
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:49:08 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Becky Brookshire
3187 Anderson Branch Rd Marshall,NC 28753-6300
[e-mail]

From: aordon1820(d)evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Helen Hyatt
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:47:50 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Government is by its purpose designed to protect and serve the public and not special interests. We want a public
hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North Toe River.
The residents of Spruce Pine deserve the right to clean water for recreation for both residents and tourists to the
area. Anglers and animals that drink the water deserve to be protected.
Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and last summer,
the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.This is just not right.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
All water runs down stream,this affects all our lives and the lives of our children.This is our future,it is your one
duty to protect our water.
Sincerely,
Ms.Helen Hyatt
14 Swindale St Asheville,NC 28801-3928
[e-mail]

From: patrie.wncpsr(a)eyeryactioncustom.com on behalf of Lewis Patrie
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:22:50 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Please hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North Toe
River.This water resource is loved by many and provides tourism opportunities for the local community in Spruce
Pine.It provides succor for trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.However,mining
facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and last summer,the
North Toe closed to the public after an acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing so they are permitted a voice in the future of the river before the permits are
approved.
Sincerely,
Dr.Lewis Patrie
26 Wesley Dr Apt H Asheville,NC 28803-2095
[e-mail]

From: caleblousey(aDeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Caleb Pusev
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:22:15 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Caleb Pusey
2 E Indiana Ave Asheville,NC 28806-4415
[e-mail]

From: ski hde(caeveryactioncustom.corn on behalf of Stephan Ihde
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 7:02:13 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Stephan Ihde
300 School Rd E Asheville,NC 28803-9622
[e-mail]

From: davidiarioura(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of David Jarioura
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Friday,February 08,2019 5:29:06 AM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.David Jarjoura
1053 Sandy Mush Rd Marshall,NC 28753-6193
[e-mail]

From: sampsonaordon(a)eve)actioncustom.com on behalf of David Gordon
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 10:49:34 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.David Gordon
60 Park Sq Asheville,NC 28801-3123
[e-mail]

From: wolfmommy everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Nancy Brown
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 9:57:24 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Nancy Brown
48 Elijah Hall Rd Black Mountain,NC 28711-8805
[e-mail]

From: eva IouiseCabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Eva Humphrey
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:53:26 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Eva Humphrey
5 E Waneta St Asheville,NC 28801-1631
eva [e-mail]

From: amaavl(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Andrew Goldbera
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:53:24 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
In addition the people of our star deserve a hearing as well. My family and I love the Toe and want better and health
IEE water quality.
Thank you for your consideration and service.
Sincerely,
Me.Andrew Goldberg
279 Murdock Ave Asheville,NC 28804-3641
[e-mail]

From: marv(aDevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Mary Goodkind
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:46:41 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Clean water is a crucial resource for Western North Carolina and should not be squandered.Protecting our streams
and rivers should be one of you highest priorities.We depend on you to establish high standards and to enforce
them.
Sincerely,
Ms Mary Goodkind
23 Ridgefield PI Asheville,NC 28803-3019
[e-mail]

From: icanarvkina(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Ian Canary-King
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:39:03 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Ian Canary-King
5 Adamswood Rd Asheville,NC 28803-1805
[e-mail]

From: fairyinthecloud(atevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Tiffany Cannoncro
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:38:07 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs Tiffany Cannoncro
76 Tremont St Asheville,NC 28806-4248
[e-mail]

From: deoravejc(@everyactioncustom.com on behalf of James DeGrave
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:33:13 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.James DeGrave
35 Yorktown Cir Arden,NC 28704-9692
[e-mail]

From: tfiaura(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Theodore Figura
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 8:31:37 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Our environment is under enough assault from the reactionary Trump Administration. Please don't add to this trend
of reversing the clean water gains for which we have fought over many years. Please hold a public hearing and
consider community input rather than automatically renewing the subject permits to a known polluter.
Sincerely,
Mr.Theodore Figura
118 Logan Ave Asheville,NC 28806-4529
[e-mail]

From: flattoad(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Colleen Connolly
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:58:53 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Colleen Connolly
2574 Rabbit Hop Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8619
[e-mail]

From: flattoad(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Colleen Connolly
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:58:25 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Colleen Connolly
2574 Rabbit Hop Rd Spruce Pine,NC 28777-8619
[e-mail]

From: swarren28806Caleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Ruby Warren
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:44:07 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Rev Ruby Warren
656 Sand Hill Rd Asheville,NC 28806-1554
[e-mail]

From: susanneloar()everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Susanne J.Loar
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:29:49 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
ms Susanne J.Loar
136 Annandale Ave Asheville,NC 28801-1308
[e-mail]

From: frodaddy125(o)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of CHARLES FROELICH
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:20:21 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.CHARLES FROELICH
16 Heather Mist Dr Weaverville,NC 28787-8000
[e-mail]

From: debitrelPeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Debi Treleaven
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:14:02 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Debi Treleaven
111 Mountain Dr Biltmore Lake,NC 28715-8918
[e-mail]

From: cpiusticeCcbeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Cynthia Justice
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:11:59 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
This is just so unfair to citizens who pay your salaries!
Sincerely,
Mrs.Cynthia Justice
21 Park Rd Asheville,NC 28803-3001
[e-mail]

From: iim4cic(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Cecil Clark
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:08:01 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Cecil Clark
27 Sandon Dr Asheville,NC 28804-2422
[e-mail]

From: southworthwCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Win Southworth
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 7:04:23 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
The ethical action is to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on
the North Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for
the local community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to
thrive.Mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years;last
summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill. This is
detestable;the river must not be allowed to be at such risk again.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Win Southworth
PO Box 885 Swannanoa,NC 28778-0885
[e-mail]

From: Billiacobsnc(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of William Jacobs
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 6:39:49 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Mining is important,but must be done without sacrificing our natural heritage. I urge you to hold a public hearing
concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North Toe River.The North Toe is loved
by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local community in Spruce Pine,and is
home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.However,mining facilities on the
North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and last summer,the North Toe closed to
the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.William Jacobs
257 Montford Ave Asheville,NC 28801-1659
[e-mail]

From: eliza.j.stokesCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Eliza Stokes
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:55:30 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Eliza Stokes
1371 Baileys Branch Rd Marshall,NC 28753-9047
[e-mail]

From: lizorever(aevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Liz Prover
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:52:57 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Liz Preyer
123 Virginia Ave Asheville,NC 28806-3217
[e-mail]

From: wis4114(devervactioncustom.com on behalf of Cynthia shilkret
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:50:58 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Dear Mr.Hill-As a new WNC resident,I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act
permits for six mining facilities on the North Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,
provides tourism opportunities for the local community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species
that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality
standards repeatedly in recent years,and last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid
spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
I moved to WNC in a large part because of the natural beauty and the appreciation and protections of the natural
beauty. Please please please hold a public hearing concerning the mining facilities permits.
Thank you for your support!
Sincerely,
Ms.cynthia shilkret
28 Penley Park Dr Weaverville,NC 28787-5511
[e-mail]

From: itibbetts20l4(steveryactioncustom.com on behalf of James TIBBETTS
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:45:02 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.James TIBBETTS
1458 Turnpike Rd Marshall,NC 28753-5406
[e-mail]

From: ennaaiarcCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Anne Craig
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:30:13 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Anne Craig
132 Murdock Ave Asheville,NC 28801-1349
[e-mail]

From: susanhbeanCcleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Susan Bean
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:27:41 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms. Susan Bean
12 Lookout Dr Asheville,NC 28804-3330
[e-mail]

From: philippedeauise(cleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Philippe Deguise
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:27:14 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Philippe Deguise
103 B N Blue Ridge Rd Black Mountain,NC 28711-2707
[e-mail]

From: meandmybuds.nc(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Debra Erickson
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:24:35 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Debra Erickson
767 Roland Branch Rd Burnsville,NC 28714-5274
[e-mail]

From: sweissman4(abeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Stephen Weissman
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:16:01 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Please hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North Toe
River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr. Stephen Weissman
434 Gorman Bridge Rd Asheville,NC 28806-8812
[e-mail]

From: mrkeckb(cbevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Brian Keck
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:04:02 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Brian Keck
40 Pinedale Rd Asheville,NC 28805-1542
[e-mail]

From: rubinoianCcleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Janice Rubino
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:03:01 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved. If these permits are approved as they are again,this river will never be cleaned up and will
remain impaired. The people who live in this area deserve much better than that. Please hold a public hearing on
renewal of the permits to discuss what can be done to protect the North Toe River from the mines.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Janice Rubino
6 Shuford Rd Weaverville,NC 28787-9478
[e-mail]

From: Iahall.email(cieveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Lisa-Gave Hall
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 5:02:02 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Please help! I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on
the North Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for
the local community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to
thrive.However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,
and last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Lisa-Gaye Hall
44 Harnett St Asheville,NC 28806-2608
[e-mail]

From: rich iepetasonCabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Richard Peterson
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:54:27 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Richard Peterson
15 Girdwood St Asheville,NC 28801-3106
[e-mail]

From: fillorv(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Toni Meador
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:50:19 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Dr.Toni Meador
84 Distant View Dr Asheville,NC 28803-2477
[e-mail]

From: maalioniclCalevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Jude Maglione
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:49:06 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms.Jude Maglione
10 Moreview Dr Asheville,NC 28803-2713
[e-mail]

From: akellerll(caeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Anne Keller
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:48:34 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
As a person who values nature,clean water and the chance to spend time outdoors in Western NC,I ask that you
hold a public hearing to get input on proposed permits for mines near the North Toe River.
As an area much appreciated by birders,fishers,canoers and swimmers,the North Toe should not be allowed to be
further degraded by mining operations. I believe that local communities and folks rom across the region deserve to
be heard at a public hearing where permit details,impacts and options would be discussed.People should have a say
about what happens in their towns and outdoor areas.
I urge you to hold a public hearing before the permits are finaluzed and approved.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Dr.Anne Keller
26 Sandon Dr Asheville,NC 28804-2423
akellerI 1 @comcast.net

From: sarahsviolets(sDeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Sarah Haske
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:47:36 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms. Sarah Haske
137 Houston St Asheville,NC 28801-2121
[e-mail]

From: il428182(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Justin Landry
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:41:35 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Justin Landry
26 Pleasant Ridge Dr Asheville,NC 28805-2623
[e-mail]

From: graviernigan(a�evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Gray Jernigan
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:36:27 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Gray Jernigan
108 Belmont Ave Asheville,NC 28806-2552
[e-mail]

From: danlaliddenPeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Daniel Glidden
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:34:00 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Daniel Glidden
32 Versailles Ln Asheville,NC 28804-0014
[e-mail]

From: imchabot711(o)everyactioncustom.com on behalf of Marcia Chabot
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:31:11 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Marcia Chabot
22 Great Aspen Way Black Mountain,NC 28711-9774
jmchabot711 @gmail.com

From: tchapi(devervactioncustom.com on behalf of James Schall
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:30:12 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
Please hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North Toe
River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.James Schall
31 Elizabeth St Asheville,NC 28801-2267
[e-mail]

From: sarabensman(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Sara Bensman
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:24:31 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Sara Bensman
87 Shope Rd Asheville,NC 28805-8745
[e-mail]

From: erikbendix5l(aeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Erik Bendix
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:22:30 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Erik Bendix
232 Bull Creek Rd Asheville,NC 28805-8702
[e-mail]

From: wilkescCcaeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Chris Wilkes
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:20:08 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
The North Toe is a beautiful river and I paddled and fished it. We need to do more to protect these types of waters.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Chris Wilkes
600 Vista Lake Dr Apt 105 Candler,NC 28715-7183
[e-mail]

From: arohiereCabeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Bernard Arahiere
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:18:50 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Bernard Arghiere
853 New Haw Creek Rd Asheville,NC 28805-1120
[e-mail]

From: kevinoalmeCabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Kevin Palme
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:18:50 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Kevin Palme
183 Pearson Dr Asheville,NC 28801-1600
[e-mail]

From: davaberrongC�Deveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Dava Berrona
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:18:41 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Dava Berrong
PO Box 15643 Asheville,NC 28813-0643
[e-mail]

From: kathrvnblauPeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Kathryn Blau
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:18:36 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Kathryn Blau
25 Rough Rd Leicester,NC 28748-5165
[e-mail]

From: elainerobbins535Cabevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Elaine Robbins
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:14:58 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs Elaine Robbins
415 Blowhole Rd Marshall,NC 28753-0257
[e-mail]

From: ieanann.wheelockCaoeveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Jean Ann Wheelock
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:14:34 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mrs.Jean Ann Wheelock
22 Hibriten Dr Asheville,NC 28801-1006
[e-mail]

From: vic.reiserll(oevervactioncustom.com on behalf of Victoria Reiser
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:13:56 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Ms Victoria Reiser
387 Stoney Fork Rd Barnardsville,NC 28709-9799
vic.reiserl [e-mail]

From: evans(a)evervactioncustom.com on behalf of Evans Prater
To: Hill, David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 4:12:17 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr Evans Prater
27 Biltmore Ave Asheville,NC 28801-3603
[e-mail]

From: vfahrerCaleveryactioncustom.com on behalf of Victor Fahrer
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External] Please hold a public hearing on new permits for mining facilities on the North Toe River
Date: Monday,February 18,2019 4:31:45 PM
CAUTION:External email.Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as
an attachment to [e-mail]<mailto:rel2ort.si2am&nc.gov
nc.gov>
Dear Water Quality Permitting Section David Hill,
I urge you to hold a public hearing concerning new Clean Water Act permits for six mining facilities on the North
Toe River.The North Toe is loved by paddlers,anglers and swimmers,provides tourism opportunities for the local
community in Spruce Pine,and is home to trout and endangered species that need clear mountain rivers to thrive.
However,mining facilities on the North Toe have violated water quality standards repeatedly in recent years,and
last summer,the North Toe closed to the public after a hydrofluoric acid spill from a mine caused a fish kill.
While the Department of Environmental Quality considers the North Toe River impaired,the proposed new permits
for the next several years would allow the current pollution from the mine processing facilities to continue unabated.
The local community in Spruce Pine deserves a public hearing to have a voice in the future of the river before the
permits are approved.
Sincerely,
Mr.Victor Fahrer
333 Montford Ave Asheville,NC 28801-1609
[e-mail]

From: Christy Thrift
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External]Re: request for public hearing with the mines in Mitchell County
Date: Thursday,February 07,2019 12:15:59 PM
• External email. Do no click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
to report.sr)[e-mail]
video
pollution N Toe Penland Section.mp44
On Thu, Feb 7, 2019 at 12:10 PM Christy Thrift<thriftyadventuresggmail.com>wrote:
I would like to request a public hearing with the mines for permit renewals. I have copied a
letter I wrote and presented at a town hall meeting that outlines a lot of what I see as a river
outfitter on the N Toe River. I have also attached photos and videos of mine pollution.
Hi. My name is Christy Thrift. My husband, Scott and I own Thrifty Adventures; an adventure Guide
company established in Concord NC in 2011. (picture). We have a store front in Little Switzerland
(picture). We are members of Parkway Fire and Rescue, MSAR Team 2 (picture), members of the
Little Switzerland Business Association and also do water sampling for The French Broad River
Keeper. In 2015 we relocated from the Charlotte area to the Skyline Village Inn owned by Scott's
parents. His parents, Mike and Lynn have been business owners in this area for 14 years. (Picture)
The river(picture) is an asset to not only the community but to tourism. Spruce Pine is a small
mountain town with a world class trout stream that runs through it.The town is also a town built
around the mining industry.The mines provide a lot of money to the town and is one of the
largest employers in the area.There has to be a better way that the town and mines can work
together to preserve the river.The river is an asset to the growth of this town and should be a
focal point.
With that I would like to acknowledge the work of Starli McDowell. She has taken the river from a
river that old-timers warned against swimming in to a fairly pristine river. Hellbenders have
returned. Presence of hellbenders in a stream or river is a sign that the water is clean and
relatively clear of pollutants, and they disappear when waterways become too clogged with silt or
chemicals. Because of this they can be important indicators of waterway health. Seeing a
hellbender (aka mud puppy) is actually a good sign that the waterway is healthy. (show picture)
I would like to read you a couple statements made this season about the river.
"That smelled like chemicals...I'm gonna glow later. Hope 1 don't get cancer"one of 125 Boy Scouts.
They joined us for a week-long adventure camp. (fun pictures)
As we paddled I instructed the boys to float around a foamy white spew spotted coming out of the
middle of the North Toe River (show picture). Ofcourse one child paddled directly through it
thinking it was a rapid. I explained that I thought it might be a damaged pipe from the mines due
to recent floods.This was the first time we had seen that specific discharge.
I have since been informed by The French broad River Keeper that this is one of many permitted
discharges along the N Toe. For years we have documented the white discharges. (show pictures)
Next comment is via a fb user in response to the WLOS 13 news cast shown Thursday night 7/19-
2018
"you think that's bad And the worst part is acid leaks and sewage spills isn't anything new here we
just don't find out most of the time because it isn't at levels so high it's killing fish and smelling like
crap"

These things are noticed by tourists and concerned citizens.These issues directly affect
businesses, our health and the health of the river! This most certainly should be addressed. We
need to have better lines of communication in place when these things happen.The town
leadership now has an opportunity to take a proactive approach to the issues at hand.
I am upset and disheartened about being greeted twice, while with guests by the river. Once with
dead fish (picture) and police warning not to get in and less than 48 hrs later with signs that stated
high bacteria (picture).This was after the Health Department and DEQ advised we could return to
the river in 24 hours pending normal PH tests that did indeed came back normal Monday evening.
This means Tuesday and Wednesday we had guests and guides on the river with a reported spill
paddling through 20K plus gallons of sewage! It means that your citizens were also swimming in
sewage at swimming holes in the area for two days. Signs were only placed at Riverside Park, not
at any other popular swimming holes downstream. Both agencies that I contacted Wednesday
after our guide and guests were greeted with high bacteria signs stated, "I have no idea what
you're talking about". Clearly,they were aware of the problem! I called the NCDEQ who
immediately called people in the field to confirm there was indeed a sewage spill and we should
not have been in the water.
Our business is proactive. Less than a month ago Thrifty Adventures, Lauren Street,the Toecane
water shed coordinator and Starli Mcdowell hosted an annual river clean (show pics). I have been
doing voluntary sampling of the river for swimguide.org. A website where you can search public
swimming areas safety. After the spills I personally posted info via social media and called other
local businesses and friends who were not aware of the spills. In fact the chamber and the folks
over the BBQ and Bluegrass Festival (taking place the next day) were also unaware of the sewage
spill. I am proud of my company for doing its own due diligence to spread awareness in order to
keep guides, guests, other businesses and the community safe but we need your help.
Where do we go from here? I think step number one is transparency, honesty and respect for our
water ways. Next creating a line of communication for when things like this is crucial. We are
happy to help with creating a line of communication and helping with these processes in any way
we can.
I am hoping to help pave the path towards change and better communication for not only
business owners but also citizens especially when it is a matter of public safety.
Idea:
1: We have to have a communication system in place for these incidents.The woman at the
Mitchell Health Dept. mentioned a phone tree, I think that is a great idea.
I'd like to open the floor to discuss now.Thanks for your time.
Make it a great day!
Christy Thrift
www.thriftyadventuresnc.com
[phone]
Make it a great day!
Christy Thrift
www.thriLtyadventuresnc.com
[phone]

From: Amelia Burnette
To: Culpepper, Linda; Hill,David A
Cc: Grzyb,Julie; Davidson,Landon; hartwell(d)mountaintrue.org; Laura LaFleur
Subject: [External] Request for public hearing on NPDES permits
Date: Thursday,February 07,2019 4:17:36 PM
Attachments: 2019-02-07 Reauest for public hearina N.Toe NPDES.pdf
Elf-AIJIMORExternal email. CLu not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as an
attachment to re ort. v
Please see attached request, thanks.
Amelia
Amelia Burnette
Senior Attorney
Southern Environmental Law Center
48 Patton Avenue, Suite 304
Asheville, NC 28801
828-258-2023 tel
828-258-2024fax
aburnette(a)selcnc.ora
Southern Environment.org

From: Christy Thrift
To: Hill. David A
Subject: [External]request for public hearing with the mines in Mitchell County
Date: Thursday, February 07,2019 12:13:26 PM
- • External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify.Send all suspicious email as al
to v
I would like to request a public hearing with the mines for permit renewals. I have copied a
letter I wrote and presented at a town hall meeting that outlines a lot of what I see as a river
outfitter on the N Toe River. I have also attached photos and videos of mine pollution.
Hi. My name is Christy Thrift. My husband, Scott and I own Thrifty Adventures; an adventure Guide
company established in Concord NC in 2011. (picture). We have a store front in Little Switzerland
(picture). We are members of Parkway Fire and Rescue, MSAR Team 2 (picture), members of the
Little Switzerland Business Association and also do water sampling for The French Broad River
Keeper. In 2015 we relocated from the Charlotte area to the Skyline Village Inn owned by Scott's
parents. His parents, Mike and Lynn have been business owners in this area for 14 years. (Picture)
The river (picture) is an asset to not only the community but to tourism. Spruce Pine is a small
mountain town with a world class trout stream that runs through it. The town is also a town built
around the mining industry. The mines provide a lot of money to the town and is one of the largest
employers in the area.There has to be a better way that the town and mines can work together to
preserve the river.The river is an asset to the growth of this town and should be a focal point.
With that I would like to acknowledge the work of Starli McDowell. She has taken the river from a
river that old-timers warned against swimming in to a fairly pristine river. Hellbenders have
returned. Presence of hellbenders in a stream or river is a sign that the water is clean and relatively
clear of pollutants, and they disappear when waterways become too clogged with silt or chemicals.
Because of this they can be important indicators of waterway health. Seeing a hellbender (aka mud
puppy) is actually a good sign that the waterway is healthy. (show picture)
I would like to read you a couple statements made this season about the river.
"That smelled like chemicals...I'm gonna glow later. Hope I don't get cancer"one of 125 Boy Scouts.
They joined us for a week-long adventure camp. (fun pictures)
As we paddled I instructed the boys to float around a foamy white spew spotted coming out of the
middle of the North Toe River(show picture). Ofcourse one child paddled directly through it thinking
it was a rapid. I explained that I thought it might be a damaged pipe from the mines due to recent
floods.This was the first time we had seen that specific discharge.
I have since been informed by The French broad River Keeper that this is one of many permitted
discharges along the N Toe. For years we have documented the white discharges. (show pictures)
Next comment is via a fb user in response to the WLOS 13 news cast shown Thursday night 7/19-
2018
"you think that's bad And the worst part is acid leaks and sewage spills isn't anything new here we
just don't find out most of the time because it isn't at levels so high it's killing fish and smelling like
crap"
These things are noticed by tourists and concerned citizens. These issues directly affect businesses,
our health and the health of the river! This most certainly should be addressed. We need to have
better lines of communication in place when these things happen.The town leadership now has an
opportunity to take a proactive approach to the issues at hand.
I am upset and disheartened about being greeted twice, while with guests by the river. Once with
dead fish (picture) and police warning not to get in and less than 48 hrs later with signs that stated

high bacteria (picture).This was after the Health Department and DEQ advised we could return to
the river in 24 hours pending normal PH tests that did indeed came back normal Monday evening.
This means Tuesday and Wednesday we had guests and guides on the river with a reported spill
paddling through 20K plus gallons of sewage! It means that your citizens were also swimming in
sewage at swimming holes in the area for two days. Signs were only placed at Riverside Park, not at
any other popular swimming holes downstream. Both agencies that I contacted Wednesday after
our guide and guests were greeted with high bacteria signs stated, "I have no idea what you're
talking about". Clearly, they were aware of the problem! I called the NCDEQ who immediately called
people in the field to confirm there was indeed a sewage spill and we should not have been in the
water.
Our business is proactive. Less than a month ago Thrifty Adventures, Lauren Street, the Toecane
water shed coordinator and Starli Mcdowell hosted an annual river clean (show pics). I have been
doing voluntary sampling of the river for swimguide.org. A website where you can search public
swimming areas safety. After the spills I personally posted info via social media and called other
local businesses and friends who were not aware of the spills. In fact the chamber and the folks over
the BBQ and Bluegrass Festival (taking place the next day) were also unaware of the sewage spill. I
am proud of my company for doing its own due diligence to spread awareness in order to keep
guides, guests, other businesses and the community safe but we need your help.
Where do we go from here? I think step number one is transparency, honesty and respect for our
water ways. Next creating a line of communication for when things like this is crucial. We are happy
to help with creating a line of communication and helping with these processes in any way we can.
I am hoping to help pave the path towards change and better communication for not only business
owners but also citizens especially when it is a matter of public safety.
Idea:
1: We have to have a communication system in place for these incidents. The woman at the Mitchell
Health Dept. mentioned a phone tree, I think that is a great idea.
I'd like to open the floor to discuss now. Thanks for your time.
Make it a great day!
Christy Thrift
www.thriLtyadventuresnc.com
[phone]

From: Culpepper, Linda
To: Amelia Burnette; Poupart,Jeff
Cc: Grzyb,Julie; Davidson.Landon;hartwell(obmountaintrue.org; Laura LaFleur;Hill,David A;Greason,Jim
Subject: RE: [External]Request for public hearing on NPDES permits
Date: Sunday,February 10,2019 9:25:53 PM
Amelia—acknowledging receipt of the request and forwarding to Jeff Poupart, the Permitting
Section Chief.
Linda
Linda Culpepper
Director, NC DEQ Division of Water Resources
Email:linda.culpeepper(@ncdenr. ov
Phone:[phone]
From: Amelia Burnette<[e-mail]>
Sent:Thursday, February 7, 2019 4:17 PM
To: Culpepper, Linda <[e-mail]>; Hill, David A<[e-mail]>
Cc: Grzyb,Julie <[e-mail]>; Davidson, Landon <[e-mail]>;
[e-mail]; Laura LaFleur<[e-mail]>
Subject: [External] Request for public hearing on NPDES permits
• External Ven o not click links or open attachm u verify.Send all suspicious email as an
chment to
Please see attached request, thanks.
Amelia
Amelia Burnette
Senior Attorney
Southern Environmental Law Center
48 Patton Avenue,Suite 304
Asheville, NC 28801
828-258-2023 tel
828-258-2024 fax
aburnetteCa)selcnc.ora
Southern Environ ment.org