The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About20160007 Ver 1_CORRECTED WQC Neuse Buffer Authorization application_20160218Carpenter,Kristi From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments: Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: CORRECTED INFORMATION!!! Montague, Heather W Thursday, February 18, 2016 3:29 PM Carpenter,Kristi; Ridings, Rob; Alsmeyer, Eric C SAW; Mccurry, Britt A; Dunigan, Jason T; Harper, Aaron A FW: CORRECTED WQC/Neuse Buffer Authorization application - SR 1400 (Ballentine Dairy Road) Wake SR 1400 (Ballentine Dairy Road) Wake County wqc-buffer authorization coverpage.pdf; SR 1400 Ballentine Dairy Road Wake pictures.pdf; FUQUAY-VARINA SR1400 Wake topojpg; SR 1400 Ballentine Diary Road - Wake soilsjpg; SR 1400 Ballentine Dairy Road Wake - Site ljpg; SR 1400 Ballentine Dairy Road Wake PCN.PDF; SR 1400 Ballentine Dairy Road Wake DWM biological conclusion.pdf; SR1400 Ballentine Dairy Road Wake - Historic Architecture and Landscapes....pdf; SR1400 Ballentine Dairy Road Wake - Archaeological Assessment.pdf Follow up Completed This application has been processed and the WQC issued and distributed (NCDWR Project No. 2016007 issued 02/08/16). However, I am now noticing that the Historic Architecture and Landscapes Assessment and the Archaeological Assessment (the final two attachments from my 12/29/15 4:48pm email) did not attach correctly. Somehow although with the correct file names they both became repeats of the DWM biological conclusion email. Therefore, your set of this material may include three biological conclusion emails with NO historic assessment information. In order to make your copy of this application complete, please omit any repeat biological conclusion emails and incorporate the two historic assessment documents NOW attached to this email. I apologize for any confusion this error has caused. Heather W. Montague Environmental Specialist Division 5 North Carolina Department of Transportation 252 492 0111 office 919 691 1596 mobile hwmontaque(a�ncdot.qov 2612 North Duke Street Durham, NC 27704 d� , � � �M � � Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. From: Montague, Heather W Sent: Tuesday, December 29, 2015 4:48 PM To: Carpenter,Kristi Cc: Ridings, Rob; 'Alsmeyer, Eric C SAW'; Mccurry, Britt A; Dunigan, Jason T; Harper, Aaron A Subject: WQC/Neuse Buffer Authorization application - SR 1400 (Ballentine Dairy Road) Wake W BS 5C.092026 By copy of this email I am notifying the USACE of the intent to use a non-reporting NWP 14. NCDOT staff, this email is to for your information only so that you know this project is in the application phase. Once the permits are received I'll distribute copies. Heather W. Montague Environmental Specialist Division 5 North Carolina Department of Transportation 252 492 0111 office 919 691 1596 mobile hwmontaque(cancdot.qov 2612 North Duke Street Durham, NC 27704 ,4 � � �Y* � Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. Email correspondence to and from this sender is subject to the N.C. Public Records Law and may be disclosed to third parties. Project No: WBS No.: f�i�►fl� Projed Tracking Na. (In(erna( Uee) 13-07-0005 HISTORIC ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPES ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS FORM This form only pertains to Historic Architecture and Landscapes for this project. It is not valid for Archaeological Resources. You must consult separately with the Archaeology Group. PROJECT INFORMATION Counry: Wdke 5C.092026 Document � Federnl I X Yes I I No Funding: Permit X State I I Federal NWP 14 ProiecrDescriation: Drain, base, and pave SR 1400 (Ballentine Dairy Road) from SR 1301 (Sunset Lake Road) for 0.511 miles west (to Station 26 + 22.87, see attached design). Work will be confined to the existing 40-foot maintenance limits; no trees will be cut within the existing 60-foot ROW; no fencing will be affected; ditches will not be relocated, but maintained where necessary to ensure proper dreinage; existing pipe at permit site (Station 50 + 50) will be replaced in kind and in place. SUMMARY OF HISTOIi1C A1V ll t�v1�w DESCRlPT/ONOFREVlEWACT/V/T/ES. RESULTS, AND CONCLUSIONS: HPOW2b reVIEW2d Ofl 8 AUgUSt 2013 and yielded one NR (Jones-]ohnson-Ballentine Farms Rurai Historic District (WA0723)), and no SL, LD, or DE properties in the Area of Potential Effects (APE). The Division has adjusted the projed to avoid the nearby SS, the Paul Stephenson House (WA0562) (to the west of the project area), as well as incorporated other avoidance and minimization efforts detailed above. Wake County current GIS mapping, aerial photography, and tax information indicate an APE of some woodland, cultivated fields, and several residential and agricultural properties dating to the early, mid, and late twentieth century (8 August 2013). The county architecturel surveys (1988-91 and 2005-6) and related publication recorded no properties in the APE other than the ]ones-]ohnson-Ballentine Farms Rural Historic Distrid (WA 723), which includes the Ballentine Dairy Farm (WA 571) (Keily �ally, 71reHistoncArchi[ectureofWakelounty, North Carolina (Raleigh: Wake County Govemment, 1994, pp. 152, s�a-3�5)). Google Maps "Stf22Y VIEW�� confirmed the presence of the previously recorded resources and the hvo additionai early-twentieth-century resources in APE (8 August 2013). The APE extends 100 feet from either end of the proposed 0.511-mile project length and 100 feet to either side of the existing SR 1400 (Ballentine Dairy Road) centerline to encompass aIl proposed construction activities as currently defined. As the project is state funded, only GS 121-12(a) applies, however the Federal permit area is also subject to Section 106 review. The presence of the NR-listed historic district, as well as the unrecorded resources, indicated the need for a field investigation. An NCDOT architectural historian met with Division 5 representatives on site on 4 September 2013 and confirmed the proximity of the NR district to the project area and discussed possible design adjustments. The two previously unrecorded properties contain circa-1920 resources (#1305 and #1500 Ballentine Dairy Road), but both are unexceptional examples of their types and also located outside the permit area. Resolution of ROW issues and minimization of design impacts reached completion in November 2015, and on 1 December 2015 representatives of NCDOT, HPO, and USACE considered project effects and established the finding detailed below. Nisbric Areblleclvre nud Lnnrhe'npes EFI9i(%S.45SG,1'SM6'NT(orm JimiNinor 7}nnspnr'm(inn Prq/e�Ls ns Oun/iJ'rra(m Ihe 2011]Yrogmnnnabe Agreemem. Page 1 of 3 ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS PropertyName: )ones-Johnson- Starus: NR Ballentine Farms Rural Historic District Survey Sire No.: WA0723 PIN: Multiple Ejjecrs ❑ No Effect X No Adverse Effect ❑ Adverse Effect Eznlanarion ofEffecrs Dererminarion: Proposed construction activities will not occur within the NR boundary or otherwise impact any contributing feature. List ofEnvironmental Commitments: FHWA Intends to use the State Historic Preservation Office's concurrence as a basis for a"de minimis" finding for the following properties, pursuant to Section 4(�: - Hie'lonc Ar'dellrtteoe nnd /anAscnpt.e /ih}/i( TS A557iSSAfliN7'/orm jar Flino� )'mnsponurim� /'ru�rcis nx Q�xJ�lied in Ihe 2007Yrogmrmm�lic Agrcen�enl. Page 2 of 3 SUPPORT DOCUMENTATION X Map(s) ❑Previous Survey Info. ❑Photos ❑Correspondence X Design Plans FINDING BY NCDOT AND STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE Historic Architecture and Landscapes —ASSESSMENT OF EFFECTS NCDOT Architectural Historian Date � , , �1 1,/ 12-�-15� State Historic Preservation Office Representative Date „� �- %�i�'�+-� �.2- / ' �-D I S Federal Agency Representative Date Ni.aunr An'himanrc nnAlnnd�cope.v /i7�}%ifTSAStilLl'UffN%'jmni frr d/a�nr Tmnspnnariai I'miecrs as Qm/�edirt Ne7MD Prognrrnxnnic Agnernem. Page 3 of 3 �''°" vniceno or = h� �y m fum � °P � �O� M NBroeM%�" Xeneln0lonn N W,� 4 A f.� kM� S c cme�a.,tq � reuia«xo� sm��4�a� n. ? Ballentine Dairy Road (SR 1400) Improvements a �o� Wake County WBS No. SC.092026 Base maps: HPOWeb, nts NCDOT — Historic Architecture August2013 Tracking No. 13-07-0005 ,.. _ _. _o _ 13-07-0005 NO NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES o��a ELIGIBLE OR LISTED ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES ��b �: � �-� � R��i� PRESENT OR AFFECTED FORM ,�'F o Q;�, o: This form only pertains to ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESOURCES for this project. It is not E ti�,�" �e � �..... ''*:� valid for Historic Architecture and Landscapes. You must consult separately with the ...� � Historic Architecture and Landscapes Group. PROJECT INFORMATION Projec[ No. WBS No: F.A. No: Sr 1400 SC.092026 N/A Federal Permit Required? County: Documenl: Wake MCDC Funding.• � State ❑ Federal � Yes ❑ No Permit Type: NWP 3/ NWP 14 Project Description: Clear right of way (as needed), improve roadway grade, drainage, base, erosion control, and pave binder and surface. The project limits will not affect the Paul Stevenson House (WA0562). Right of way will be established at 60 feet by widening roadway to 22 feet, shoulders to 6 feet, and 13 ft. ditch widths for a total of 60 ft. ROW. SUMMARY OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL FINDINGS The Nort/r Carolina DepRrtment of Transportation (NCDOT) Archaeo%gy Croup reviewed the subject project and determined: � There are no National Register listed ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES within the projecYs area of potential effects. � No subsurface archaeological investigations are required for this project. ❑ Subsurface investigations did not reveal the presence of any archaeological resources. ❑ Subsurface investigations did not reveal the presence oF any archaeological resources considered eligible for the National Register. ❑ All identified archaeological sites located within the APE have been considered and all compliance for archaeological resources with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and GS 121-12(a) has been completed for this project. � There are no Nationat Register Eligible or Listed ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITES present or affected by this project. (Attach any notes or documents as needec� "NO NAT/ONAL R(iG15TF.'R F.WGlRI.EOR /lST6D ARCNAF,O/.OGICAL S/TES PRESENTOR Al%GEC71iD form farMinor 7rarrsporlolion Projecrs as Quolified in Ihe 2007 Psogramma�ic Agreemem. 1 of 5 Brief description of review activities, results of review, and conclusions: A review of the Office of State Archaeology map files on July 15, 2013 found no recorded sites within the projecYs vicinity. A drive over survey of the project found the ROW staked along the entire route (Figure i ). The earthen dam located near the eastern terminus of the proposed project was inspected because of the possibility of a mill near the roadway (Figure 2& 3). No such evidence was found, no structure or foundation remains and there was no evidence of a millrace below the dam. The dam showed no evidence of a mill operation as well. A pedestrian survey of the agricultural fields at the western end of the project yielded no cultural evidence. The permit area for replacement of the banel crossline is present in Figure 4. The impounded pond is not present on the 1914 Soil Map of Wake County thus dating the dam construction to sometime after 1914 (Figure 5). No further work is warranted. SUPPORT DOCUMENTATION See attached: � Map(s) ❑ Previous Survey Info Other: Signed: � Photos ❑Correspondence "NO NA710NAL R/iGlSTF.'R lil./GIRLF.OR /JS7ED ANCHAli01,0(i/CA/. S/7L5 PRF.S/iNTOR AFFGCTF.'D joroi/orMirror Trnnsponation Projecrs aa Q�mlifieAin Ihe 2007 ProRrmnmmic Agreement. 2of5 � i �e�� uu� mx i v.. Figure 1. Ballentine Road, SR 1400, behveen arrows. Figure 2. SR 1400, note large impounded pond north of the east end of the proposed project. "NO NAT/ONA/, RF,GIS7'F'R GL/G/BLGOR LfSTF.D ARCNAEOlAG1CA7. SI7ES PRIiSGN7'OR AFF'F,'CTb'D farm jor Minor T�ompanoiion Projecls as Qualified in tlie 1007 Progmmmalic Agreemenl. 3of5 . M Y 1 !s./Z ' `1 �/i f `° $ �.1.$#� 'f �. �t i � l� i��g' }"�i a� ( S� �' � 3 3 S�y#�� # S "�� 7' /..r t A 14{ tR i« � 's�� ' r'` ", ��`��'§�'��^�`�, - v...� z �i a ) x � x 'A? S �S �c 1 i . ' z ��wq�.cs �II �e . C`� 5 i '��r G h{� {�. '�` n 2 . S t� � �a�GA � � � . (�{ � �. t � k � v"62 a Y _f . �F�<� , %� t� . _ Y 4i . . ` ; f" .� . ' i' 'l' - P3 . . �i s��;�' � � .. .`s Aq� � . . t�i', � . � �� `� ) I4 � � , r �,< �-.. ' � 'z n�� j ,r,. e��,,•" ; p bp . ta�> � y � �� _ hn '. . . H'�' �� ~� �X � t �y � � � � ��- � �r� f �f' i k j�y ' .. �, � t '"'.. i 's1�}, L � � �� F 4 � 3 ! � , . .� � � � ' � . � fxY.h�3�r`��' h�i' � `� . d �$A t4 Y`� � , �: w-ra s'n �� y . . *° �'• �u st,�= 'yn � " £h `v"` ?: �.yt 1 � .. � ,t ��8,� .,. . � ' ..,k �� " �� `�.r, �.ae-+"3�1'� �.x�o s_e. y. .Y �. Figure 5. Wake County Soil map of 1914. Area of pond is encircied. "NO NAT/ONAL RG(i1S77iR /iIJGIR/.li OR USTliD ARCHAtiOLOC;/CdL SlTGS PRN.'SIiN7'OR AFFEC7'L•'U jorra forMinor lmrrspona�im� Projecls as Qiml feJln rhe 2007 Progrnnuno�ic Agreemem. SofS wu , If� � � � 8 � i �y � • 8 °" � ��0 � "�� ; ��€ � �� ! ' � . �~` /� � k! `�� : �',�� ' . � � � � !�. . $ . �P% � �� . �. • ry� ` � �' �f � .,Y.' N� . ' . - ti " ..� �}. . Ml�� , l , �� ...��'d . ,.�� ` v ,. � �, � � ` • . q � �� ^�' °�w"�". ;�`9� , (� cw�m°^r'�z �- ��. �-ii y � � s� rt< ,�.��6°n � ` �6�` ,�i �' � � �.�.�� , _ � �� , � �� ° � � �- �� ai�„� p �a,„„;,,, � �� . � �t � .; � �i� � �, �� - �o,,.,� �p ' � P . y� r . f -. � .E ... ._.py� � 4+vWi � � QQ '�� ' �,�-�� a+nwxe ,.� . � ,. ,�-� � � oy�� _.. �yet' . . � � , r�� q� _ -. . . : � �t � . � � �� . .,��' yp �� e�+ . � ' ^E � .� Po'ensV?�. . IW y �. � ��; �$ o . n �� , o ;, �,� 4 .,,�q� a ,, . D v� . t� d,' �rW^ � €4E,. .. g3 . � ;y° , .a . . . . . i�:, .. � ."' . a �... � . .. , ' a . � t9!/ � �4 � $ . .:.. 5 � �i� '� � � , . 14 ' .O � B.� �r�a � , � - ' y`� � � ' • .' � pg 8 �,. k :. � � 3 � �' ��, � � ' . � � � � w4 � . . _ � , b � �euwnd` ' � � ! .� . �v f4..� � }(V� � ,V� � � /x #�P •5 bKIW3 WWeJ "M.Y .: � �� .� 1 s � , �S' 7 . � p '�. �. Wv�e,,.��s M ;�;� w' � aa°" . ' q ' p u . � I gb � .y � �y � o �6 g p � ' . t ' �� F � � . Y . .x p. ��d'� � �` � EWMrtuM-#uhlH ��- • � � . . �,�� .. � �,,. , ,h��ie.ta� . . ��s �s � O O �yF ��e �... ... M ., 'N�rv �4 � ! . � ..`� � � i i >:�, ` �i . -a r �-n-' �: � „ �'"��_ �� ba Rci--��. j ' � �'�'°�„� ,,�� t<t�f�]1,�'sun�C � � , r � � r.' s � '�. ,@ l7 � t�-4 � , '�St t � � �} S Y "; T Y. 5 C � �. v W Y t .�. ✓X' . � "r �35� �, y � t �w��a E � . . . W , s �, � , � `�'—, . ��..��. �. . � + ,� � �'' . � . t� �'.� ��. .::�' , . .. . aes � � �� z��: � �.. {� � „s� i .; 1.�'� � �,;. �` t4 l�� 4 ..: {F �. . J �' '�LL �t .� Qt � �l * a�iF � ;�y < � � �5 � � �� . � f � .. 3� s �� , � � x � �Sr�' 'r��."� i .. �.� �: , 5 � '. .�' "t$x � (�h fi+ �'�� .: .�.."Y... � �h< r �55'k�rv �j�n' u21 3 � S�' � � � T sr�i i5 R 5 ?=i �� • � �l g kyw_ F 2 �.�AFP G�I.M1TY. VOkIF (:�ROLNp T � /��'��i � �V,�\c ( �..�a�`� � , � � ,� v � � .�9�' �J �� ' .� � U ��\ \ �'^•\�. � I�- ��,� �� \�J� � � � �,�� 'U k �� __� � � ��:' �� a�\V � Con J � l (� � � �� 1„��,'J i I�~�� ~ I� > J�" # � '�� a, � �:��J� � �� i; SR 1400 Ballentine Dairy Road