HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0024406_Bromide Reduction Evaluation Semi-Annual Report_20240603DUKE
ENERGY,
May 28, 2024
Sergei Chernikov, PhD
NC Department of Environmental Quality
Division of Water Resources
Complex NPDES Permitting Unit
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617
Subject: Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC
Belews Creek Steam Station Permit No. NC0024406
Bromide Reduction Evaluation Semi-annual Report
Dear Dr. Chernikov,
Belews Creek Steam Station
Duke Energy Carolinas
3195 Pine Hall Road
Belews Creek, NC 27009
As required by Condition A. (20.) of the subject NPDES permit, attached are three copies of the
semi-annual status report summarizing Duke Energy's efforts to reduce bromide discharge and
potential subsequent Total Trihalomethane (TTHM) formation in downstream municipal water
treatment systems.
Should you have questions regarding this report, please contact Melonie Martin at 336-669-2994
or Melonie.Martin@duke-energy.com.
Respectfully,
Michael F. Lanning
General Manager III, Regulated Stations
RRECDG Belews Creek Steam Station
Attachment
Cc (via email): Lon Snider, NCDEQ WSRO
Melonie Martin, Duke Energy
Brenda Johnson, Duke Energy
Belews Creek Steam Station
Bromide Reduction Evaluation NPDES Permit No. NC0024406
Semi -Annual Progress Report
May 2024
Pursuant to Condition A. (20) Bromide Reduction Evaluation of the NPDES Permit
Number NC0024406. Duke Energy submits this semi-annual progress report. This report
is required to summarize on -going investigations focused on minimizing bromide
discharge at Outfall 003, 006, and 111 as well as efforts aimed at reducing the formation
of total trihalomethanes (TTHM) at downstream water treatment plants. Outfall 003 and
Outfall 111 are no longer in operation. Outfall 003 was replaced by Outfall 006 to the Dan
River. Outfall 111 was a toe drain that was rerouted to comingle with other low volume
wastewater, ultimately discharging via Outfall 006 to the Dan River.
• Duke Energy has worked cooperatively with the North Carolina Division of Water
Resources (DWR), the Town of Madison and City of Eden to address the
bromide/TTHM issues since being advised of the municipality's issues with TTHM
formation.
• Bromide itself is not a health concern in surface waters. There is no water quality
standard for bromide and no NPDES permit limit.
• Duke Energy has provided direct technical expertise and financial assistance to
Madison and Eden to help address their respective TTHM issues.
Town of Madison
• No updated information new to report.
City of Eden
• No updated information new to report.
Belews Creek Steam Station
• Duke Energy has partnered with UNC-C and Electric Power Research Institute
(EPRI) to perform a lysimeter pilot at Mayo Power Plant that is reviewing halide
sequestration and encapsulation strategy from a long-term perspective.
• Belews Creek's conversion to natural gas for Unit 1 was completed in 4th quarter
of 2019. Conversion of Unit 2 was complete in the 4th quarter of 2020. This
modification to the operation of the station is a result of other factors but is
expected to have an added benefit of decreasing the mass of bromide discharges.
Belews Creek Steam Station
Bromide Reduction Evaluation NPDES Permit No. NC0024406
Semi -Annual Progress Report
May 2024
Pursuant to Condition A. (20) Bromide Reduction Evaluation of the NPDES Permii
Number NC0024406. Duke Energy submits this semi-annual progress report. This report
is required to summarize on -going investigations focused on minimizing bromide
discharge at Outfall 003, 006, and 111 as well as efforts aimed at reducing the formation
of total trihalomethanes (TTHM) at downstream water treatment plants. Outfall 003 and
Outfall 111 are no longer in operation. Outfall 003 was replaced by Outfall 006 to the Dan
River. Outfall 111 was a toe drain that was rerouted to comingle with other low volume
wastewater, ultimately discharging via Outfall 006 to the Dan River.
• Duke Energy has worked cooperatively with the North Carolina Division of Water
Resources (DWR), the Town of Madison and City of Eden to address the
bromide/TTHM issues since being advised of the municipality's issues with TTHM
formation.
• Bromide itself is not a health concern in surface waters. There is no water quality
standard for bromide and no NPDES permit limit.
• Duke Energy has provided direct technical expertise and financial assistance to
Madison and Eden to help address their respective TTHM issues.
Town of Madison
• No updated information new to report.
City of Eden
• No updated information new to report.
Belews Creek Steam Station
• Duke Energy has partnered with UNC-C and Electric Power Research Institute
(EPRI) to perform a lysimeter pilot at Mayo Power Plant that is reviewing halide
sequestration and encapsulation strategy from a long-term perspective.
• Belews Creek's conversion to natural gas for Unit 1 was completed in 4th quarter
of 2019. Conversion of Unit 2 was complete in the 4th quarter of 2020. This
modification to the operation of the station is a result of other factors but is
expected to have an added benefit of decreasing the mass of bromide discharges.
Belews Creek Steam Station
Bromide Reduction Evaluation NPDES Permit No. NC0024406
Semi -Annual Progress Report
May 2024
Pursuant to Condition A. (20) Bromide Reduction Evaluation of the NPDES Permit
Number NC0024406. Duke Energy submits this semi-annual progress report. This report
is required to summarize on -going investigations focused on minimizing bromide
discharge at Outfall 003, 006, and 111 as well as efforts aimed at reducing the formation
of total trihalomethanes (TTHM) at downstream water treatment plants. Outfall 003 and
Outfall 111 are no longer in operation. Outfall 003 was replaced by Outfall 006 to the Dan
River. Outfall 111 was a toe drain that was rerouted to comingle with other low volume
wastewater, ultimately discharging via Outfall 006 to the Dan River.
• Duke Energy has worked cooperatively with the North Carolina Division of Water
Resources (DWR), the Town of Madison and City of Eden to address the
bromide/TTHM issues since being advised of the municipality's issues with TTHM
formation.
• Bromide itself is not a health concern in surface waters. There is no water quality
standard for bromide and no NPDES permit limit.
• Duke Energy has provided direct technical expertise and financial assistance to
Madison and Eden to help address their respective TTHM issues.
Town of Madison
• No updated information new to report.
City of Eden
• No updated information new to report.
Belews Creek Steam Station
• Duke Energy has partnered with UNC-C and Electric Power Research Institute
(EPRI) to perform a lysimeter pilot at Mayo Power Plant that is reviewing halide
sequestration and encapsulation strategy from a long-term perspective.
• Belews Creek's conversion to natural gas for Unit 1 was completed in 4th quarter
of 2019. Conversion of Unit 2 was complete in the 4th quarter of 2020. This
modification to the operation of the station is a result of other factors but is
expected to have an added benefit of decreasing the mass of bromide discharges.