Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAttachment C - UASAtachment C Use Atainability Study 1 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Division of Water Resources Use Attainability Study for the Proposed Reclassifications of Portions of the Yadkin River, South Yadkin River, and Associated Tributaries NORTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY DIVISION OF WATER RESOURCES WATER SCIENCES SECTION THIS REPORT HAS BEEN APPROVED FOR RELEASE _____________________________ Chris Johnson Chief, Water Sciences Section DATE:______April 2, 2024______________________________ 2 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch NC Division of Water Resources Water Sciences Section Use Attainability Study for the Proposed Reclassifications of Portions of the Yadkin River, South Yadkin River, and Associated Tributaries Class WS-V to either Class WS-IV or Class WS-IV (CA); and Class C to Class WS-IV Rowan, Davie, and Davidson Counties 8-digit HUCs: 03040101, 03040102, 03040103 Stream Index Numbers: 12-(108.5), 12-109, 12-108-(19.5), 12-108-20, 12-108-21, 12-108-21-4, 12-108-21-4-1, 12-108-21-5 The following represents the findings of the Use Attainability Study for the Proposed Reclassification of Portions of the Yadkin River, South Yadkin River, and Associated Tributaries, performed by the Intensive Survey Branch of the North Carolina Division of Water Resources. Study Plan and supporting documents can be found by contacting Intensive Survey Branch staff. Purpose and Background: At the request of the Classifications and Standards Branch (CSB) of the NC Division of Water Resources (DWR), the Intensive Survey Branch (ISB) developed and performed a Use Attainability Study (UAS) in the Yadkin River watershed near the town of Salisbury, NC. Data collected from this effort will be used to inform the proposed reclassifications in portions of the Yadkin River, South Yadkin River, Second Creek, Beaverdam Creek, Walnut Branch, Setman Branch, Fourth Creek, and the entirety of Deals Creek. To support their intention to relocate the current drinking water intake and pump station, Salisbury-Rowan Utilities (SRU) has requested the reclassification of surface waters within a new proposed critical area (CA) and protected area (PA). The proposed CA extends 0.5 mile upstream from the proposed new intake. The proposed PA extends 10 miles upstream of the proposed new intake location (Figure 1). This study examines the following reclassifications: • Portions of: o South Yadkin River (Class C to WS-IV) o Second Creek (Class C to WS-IV) o Beaverdam Creek (Class C to WS-IV) o Walnut Branch (Class C to WS-IV) o Setman Branch (Class C to WS-IV) o Fourth Creek (Class C to WS-IV) 3 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch • Entirety of: o Deals Creek (Class C to WS-IV) This study also examines the associated tributaries within the proposed PA. In addition, smaller segments of the Yadkin River, South Yadkin, and Deals Creek located within the proposed 0.5-mile CA will require classification to WS-IV (CA). Information on definitions of Class C, WS-IV, WS-IV (CA) can be found on the NC Standards and Classifications webpage (Classifications | NC DEQ). The area observed in this assessment consists of several small order tributaries in the North Carolina Piedmont, feeding the main stem of the Yadkin River in Rowan, Davie, and Davidson Counties. The surrounding land use of these water resources consists approximately of 50 percent forested, 30 percent mixed agriculture, and the remaining residential. The sampling timeframe was relatively dry, with little recorded precipitation in October and November, with more measurable rains before the final sampling event in December of 2023. Methods for Physical and Chemical Collection: Following the study plan, four new sampling sites were established to assess the suitability of these resources as potable water supplies (Table 1 and Figure 1). YADYR1 is located at the new proposed intake location in the Yadkin River within the proposed Critical Area. The three remaining sites are on the South Yadkin River (YADSY2), Second Creek (YADSC3), and Deals Creek (YADDC4). Sites were selected based on their respective bridge crossings on highway US-601, to allow ease of sampler access, as well as their upstream proximity of the proposed new intake location which addresses any inputs to the study area. All four sites were sampled for physical and chemical water quality parameters (Table 2) monthly from October through December of 2023, for a total of three sampling events for each site. All physical and chemical samples were collected following the methods described per the Intensive Survey Branch Standard Operating Procedures Manual: Physical and Chemical Monitoring Version 2.1 December 2013. Handheld, multi-parameter hydrosondes were utilized to monitor temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, and conductivity at each station during sampling events, at approximately 0.15 meters (m) below the surface. YADYR1 was sampled at depth, and therefore has physical readings at 1 m intervals to the river bottom. Secchi depth readings were also taken at YADYR1, to determine profile sampling depth. Profile sampling at the other 3 locations was impractical, therefore only surface grabs (depth of 0.15m) were utilized. 4 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Chemical parameters were selected based on relevant North Carolina (NC) Water Quality Standards (WQS) for surface waters: WS-IV and/or National Primary Drinking Water Regulations Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) as published by the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Samples were recovered using an integrated sampler for profile samples at YADYR1 while using surface grabs for the remaining sampling locations. Metals analysis included both total recoverable and dissolved metals. Acid herbicide analysis was performed by GEL Laboratories, Charleston SC. All other chemical analyses were performed by the DWR Central Laboratory in Raleigh, NC. 5 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Figure 1. UAS Monitoring Locations within the Proposed Protected Area 6 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 1. UAS Site Locations for Physical and Chemical Monitoring Station Latitude Longitude Site Description YADYR1 35.740923 -80.458362 YADKIN RIVER APPROX 125FT DOWNSTREAM OF DEALS CREEK CONFLUENCE YADSY2 35.778408 -80.506638 SOUTH YADKIN RIVER AT US601 BOAT ACCESS UPSTREAM OF US601 CROSSING YADSC3 35.762062 -80.510937 SECOND CREEK AT US601 CROSSING YADDC4 35.745565 -80.506639 DEALS CREEK UPSTEAM OF US601 CROSSING Table 2. Physical and Chemical Parameters Collected and Analyzed Metric Physical Parameters • Temperature (°C) • pH (s.u.) • Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L) • Dissolved Oxygen (% saturation) • Conductivity (µS/cm) Chemical Parameters • PCBs (µg/L) • Acid Herbicides (µg/L) • Inorganic Phenol (µg/L) • Chlorophyll a (µg/L) • Turbidity (NTU) • Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L) • Total Residue (mg/L) • Suspended Residue (mg/L) • Nitrate + Nitrite (mg/L) • Nitrate (mg/L) • Hardness (total as CaCO3) • PFAS (ng/L) • Bromide (mg/L) • Chloride (mg/L) • Fluoride (mg/L) • Sulfates (mg/L) • Cyanide (mg/L) • MBAS (Methylene-Blue Active-Sub) (mg/L) • Volatile Organics (µg/L) • Semi-Volatile Organics (µg/L) • 1,4-dioxane (µg/L) Metals (total & dissolved) (mg/L) • Antimony • Arsenic (total) • Barium (total) • Beryllium • Cadmium • Chromium (total) • Copper • Lead • Mercury (total) • Nickel (total) • Selenium • Silver • Thallium • Zinc Pesticides (µg/L) • Organochlorine • Organonitrogen • Organophosphorus Microorganisms • Fecal Coliform (cfu/100mL) 7 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Results: Physical Data All in situ physical readings collected during this study, other than the two November readings discussed below, were found to be within the limits of NC WQS for surface waters classified as C, WS-IV, and WS-IV (CA). Dissolved oxygen readings ranged from 8.8 - 11.8 milligrams per liter (mg/L) at all surface locations and showed little signs of stratification through the water column on the profile readings at YADYR1. Measurements for pH ranged from 5.9 – 7.0 standard units (s.u.) throughout the entire study. Two values at YADSC3 and YADDC4 in November showed pH values of 5.9 s.u., just slightly below the WQS of 6.0 s.u. Values observed for specific conductivity (SC) ranged between 71 and 165 µmhos/cm. YADSC3 showed the highest SC values of all readings taken. Secchi readings were only taken at YADYR1 as mentioned earlier. These values varied among the 3 sampling events with October and November having Secchi readings of 1.6 m and 1.1 m, respectively, while the number dropped significantly in December to 0.2 m. It is noted that the sand dredge was in operation during the December sampling event, causing noticeably higher cloudiness to the water. Results of surface in situ physical data , as well as at 1-meter intervals at YADYR1, are summarized in Table 3. 8 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 3. Physical Data Summary Station ID Date (m/d/y) Time (24hr) Depth (m) Temp (°C) DO (mg/L) DO (% sat) pH (s.u.) Cond (µmhos/cm) Secchi (m) YADYR1 10/26/23 10:00 0.2 14.2 9.9 96.9 6.3 101 1.6 YADYR1 10/26/23 10:00 1 14.1 9.9 96.7 6.3 101 1.6 YADYR1 10/26/23 10:00 2 14 9.9 96.5 6.5 101 1.6 YADYR1 10/26/23 10:00 3 13.9 9.9 96.4 6.6 101 1.6 YADYR1 10/26/23 10:00 4 13.8 9.8 95.5 6.6 100 1.6 YADYR1 10/26/23 10:00 4.1 13.7 9.8 95.4 6.6 101 1.6 YADSY2 10/26/23 13:15 0.2 13.4 10.1 97.7 6.4 95 NS YADSC3 10/26/23 12:00 0.4 12.8 9.8 93.5 6.1 137 NS YADDC4 10/26/23 14:25 0.3 16.2 8.8 90.5 6.6 113 NS YADYR1 11/27/23 10:20 0.2 8.2 11.2 97.3 7 93 1.1 YADYR1 11/27/23 10:20 1 8.2 11.2 96.9 6.8 97 1.1 YADYR1 11/27/23 10:20 2 8.1 11.2 96.9 6.8 98 1.1 YADYR1 11/27/23 10:20 3 8.1 11.2 96.8 6.8 99 1.1 YADYR1 11/27/23 10:20 4 8.0 11.2 96.8 6.9 100 1.1 YADYR1 11/27/23 10:20 4 8.0 11.2 96.9 6.9 100 1.1 YADSY2 11/27/23 12:30 0.2 7.7 11.8 100.8 6.0 98 NS YADSC3 11/27/23 13:30 0.3 7.7 11.5 99 5.9 165 NS YADDC4 11/27/23 14:30 0.3 10.1 10.7 97.1 5.9 121 NS YADYR1 12/13/23 9:35 0.2 6.7 11.1 90.6 6.8 71 0.2 YADYR1 12/13/23 9:35 1 6.7 11.1 90.5 6.8 71 0.2 YADYR1 12/13/23 9:35 2 6.7 11.1 90.3 6.8 72 0.2 YADYR1 12/13/23 9:35 3 6.7 11.0 90.1 6.8 72 0.2 YADYR1 12/13/23 9:35 4 6.8 11.0 90.1 6.8 72 0.2 YADYR1 12/13/23 9:35 4.3 6.8 11.0 90.1 6.8 72 0.2 YADSY2 12/13/23 11:00 0 5.9 11.5 92.1 7 81 NS YADSC3 12/13/23 12:00 0.1 5.3 11.4 90 7 117 NS YADDC4 12/13/23 13:00 0 7.5 11.0 91.9 6.9 113 NS *NS = No sample Chemical Data Nutrients and Chlorophyll a No exceedances were present in any sample analyzed for nutrients and chlorophyll a. Nitrate samples from all study locations indicated nutrient levels below the NC WQS of 10 mg/L. All samples analyzed for nitrite were below the practical quantitative limit (PQL) of 0.02 mg/L. PQL is defined here as the lowest concentration that can be reliably achieved within specified limits of precision and accuracy during routine laboratory operating conditions. Chlorophyll a samples, which are used as a measure of algal growth, indicated concentrations well below the NC WQS for surface waters classified as WS-IV of 40 µg/L. Although many samples are qualified indicating laboratory error, no value approaches the exceedance level to raise any concern. Qualified data is represented in the summary table but excluded from averages. Nutrient and chlorophyll a analytical results are summarized in Table 4. 9 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 4. Nutrient and Chlorophyll a Data Summary Station ID Date (m/d/y) NO3 nitrate (mg/L as N) NO2 nitrite (mg/L as N) NOX (mg/L as N) Chlorophyll a (µg/L) YADYR1 10/26/23 1.128 0.02 U 0.05 U 1.3 YADSY2 10/26/23 0.807 0.02 U 0.83 1.3 YADSC3 10/26/23 0.479 0.02 U 0.50 1.2 YADDC4 10/26/23 0.258 0.02 U 0.28 1.0 U YADYR1 11/27/23 1.109 0.02 U 1.1 5.6 J2 YADSY2 11/27/23 0.82 0.02 U 0.84 1.2 U, J2, P YADSC3 11/27/23 0.706 0.02 U 0.73 1.5 J2 YADDC4 11/27/23 0.407 0.02 U 0.43 2.9 J2 YADYR1 12/13/23 0.871 0.02 U 0.89 10 V1 YADSY2 12/13/23 1.004 0.02 U 1.0 4.0 V1 YADSC3 12/13/23 0.854 0.02 U 0.87 3.6 V1 YADDC4 12/13/23 0.714 0.02 U 0.73 1.4 V1 Qualifier Codes: U: Indicates that the analyte was analyzed for, but not detected above, the reported PQL. V1: The analyte was detected in both the sample and the method blank. J2: The reported value failed to meet the established quality control criteria for either precision or accuracy. P: Sample dilution occurred due to either matrix interference or target analytes being present at concentrations greater than the calibration curve. Chloride, Fluoride, Bromide, Sulfate, Phenol, and Cyanide Additional parameters tested including fluoride, bromide, phenol, and cyanide, all registered as non-detects across all sampling locations and events. Chloride results varied from 5.1-11 mg/L between all sites, well below the NC WQS of 250 mg/L. Sulfate samples collected in this study read between 3.4 and 11 mg/L, below the state standard of 250 mg/L. As mentioned earlier, all phenols sampled in this study were non-detects with one sample, YADYR1, qualified as below the PQL from the October sampling event. This analysis is qualified with a J4 meaning the data is questionable due to improper laboratory procedure. Due to the consistent low levels observed for phenol, it is reported with the appropriate qualifiers for the purpose of this report. Worth noting, the suffix _SUR determines these samples were collected as a surface grab and did not use an integrated sampler. However, all locations remain the same as listed in Table 1. Analytical results for chloride, fluoride, bromide, sulfate, phenol, and cyanide are summarized in Table 5. 10 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 5. Chloride, Fluoride, Bromide, Sulfate, Phenol, and Cyanide Data Summary Station ID Date (m/d/y) Chloride (mg/L) Fluoride (mg/L) Bromide (mg/L) Sulfate (mg/L) Phenol (mg/L) Cyanide (mg/L) YADYR1_SUR 10/26/2023 8.0 0.4U 0.4U 4.5 10U, J2 0.005U YADYR1_SUR 11/27/2023 7.2 0.4U 0.4U 4.7 10U 0.005U YADYR1_SUR 12/12/2023 5.1 0.4U 0.4U 4.3 10U 0.1U YADSY2_SUR 10/26/2023 6.4 0.4U 0.4U 3.4 10U 0.005U YADSY2_SUR 11/27/2023 6.4 0.4U 0.4U 3.9 10U 0.005U YADSY2_SUR 12/12/2023 5.5 0.4U 0.4U 5.7 10U 0.005U YADSC3_SUR 10/26/2023 7.2 0.4U 0.4U 6.0 10U 0.005U YADSC3_SUR 11/27/2023 11 0.4U 0.4U 12 10U 0.005U YADSC3_SUR 12/12/2023 7.2 0.4U 0.4U 7.6 10U 0.005U YADDC4_SUR 10/26/2023 5.9 0.4U 0.4U 8.1 10U 0.005U YADDC4_SUR 11/27/2023 6.0 0.4U 0.4U 9.2 10U 0.005U YADDC4_SUR 12/12/2023 6.1 0.4U 0.4U 11 10U 0.005U Qualifier Codes: U: Indicates that the analyte was analyzed for, but not detected above, the reported PQL. J2: The reported value failed to meet the established quality control criteria fort either precision or accuracy. Turbidity, Total Dissolved Solids, Methylene Blue Activated Substances, and Hardness All analytical results for total dissolved solids (TDS), and methylene blue activated substances (MBAS), and hardness, collected for this effort were found to be within the NC WQS for surface waters classified as WS-IV. TDS values fell between 61 and 112 mg/L. While TDS values did not exceed any standard, YADSDC3 did show elevated levels compared to other samples in this study. Turbidity results for all samples, under the state standard definition, are between 4.3 and 17 NTU. There are two readings outside of that range, that meet or exceed, the definition for turbidity in a stream. In December, YADSYR2 was measured at a value equal to the NC WQS of 50 NTU. Samplers did note that December’s sampling occurred prior to measurable precipitation. Also in December, site YADYR1 recorded an exceedance of 65 NTU for turbidity. This reading correlates with the shallow Secchi reading, discussed in an earlier section of this report. High turbidity and shallow Secchi are both recorded during a time the sand dredge was in operation. There were no other signs of exceedances for turbidity during this study when the dredge was not in operation. Analytical results for turbidity, TDS, MBAS and hardness are summarized in Table 6. MABS and Hardness were collected at the surface, and Turbidity and TDS were sampled at depth per protocol. 11 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 6. Turbidity, TDS, MBAS and Hardness Data Summary Station ID Date (m/d/y) Turbidity (NTU) TDS (mg/L) MBAS (mg/L) Hardness (mg/L) YADYR1_SUR 10/26/2023 NS NS 0.1U 25 YADYR1_SUR 11/27/2023 NS NS 0.1U 26 YADYR1_SUR 12/13/2023 NS NS 0.1U 24 YADSY2_SUR 10/26/2023 NS NS 0.1U 35 YADSY2_SUR 11/27/2023 NS NS 0.1U 29 YADSY2_SUR 12/13/2023 NS NS 0.1U 24 YADSDC3_SUR 10/26/2023 NS NS 0.1U 56 YADSDC3_SUR 11/27/2023 NS NS 0.1U 55 YADSDC3_SUR 12/13/2023 NS NS 0.1U 41 YADDC4_SUR 10/26/2023 NS NS 0.1U 35 YADDC4_SUR 11/27/2023 NS NS 0.1U 39 YADDC4_SUR 12/13/2023 NS NS 0.1U 39 YADYR1 10/26/2023 4.3 61 NS NS YADYR1 11/27/2023 6.8 55 NS NS YADYR1 12/13/2023 65 71 NS NS YADSY2 10/26/2023 17 65 NS NS YADSY2 11/27/2023 7.7 66 NS NS YADSY2 12/13/2023 50 81 NS NS YADSDC3 10/26/2023 5.2 100 NS NS YADSDC3 11/27/2023 5.8 112 NS NS YADSDC3 12/13/2023 37 102 NS NS YADDC4 10/26/2023 1.8 83 NS NS YADDC4 11/27/2023 4.3 80 NS NS YADDC4 12/13/2023 10 104 NS NS Qualifier Codes: U: Indicates that the analyte was analyzed for, but not detected above, the reported PQL. *Exceedances of North Carolina Water Quality Standards for Surface Waters in bold and shaded. NS= Not Sampled Emerging Compounds As part of DWR’s ongoing effort to expand screening of public water supply waters for emerging compounds, 1,4-dioxane and per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) was included in this UAS. While these compounds do not currently have federal water quality standards, DWR has established 1,4-dioxane in-stream target values (ITVs) of 0.35 µg/L in surface waters classified as water supplies and 80 µg/L in all other surface waters. For more information on managing emerging compounds in water, please visit the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality webpage on Emerging Compounds. Only two samples were detected above the current 1,4-dioxane PQL of 1.0 µg/L, both at station YADSY2. On 10/26/2023 1,4-dioxane results were 1.7 µg/L and on 11/27/2023 they were 12 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch 1.4 µg/L. Analytical results for all PFAS compounds detected at or above their respective PQLs are summarized in Table 7. A complete list of all PFAS compounds investigated during this UAS is presented in Table 8. Table 7. PFAS Data Summary Station ID Date (m/d/y) Analyte Result (ng/L) YADYR1 10/26/2023 PFBS 2.3 Y YADYR1 10/26/2023 PFHxA 2.1 Y YADYR1 10/26/2023 PFOS 2.6 Y YADYR1 11/27/2023 PFHBA 2.7 J1 YADYR1 11/27/2023 PFBS 2.7 YADYR1 11/27/2023 PFHxA 2.8 YADYR1 11/27/2023 PFOS 3.5 YADYR1 11/27/2023 PFPeA 2.7 YADYR1 12/13/2023 PFBA 2.5 J1 YADYR1 12/13/2023 PFBS 2.1 YADYR1 12/13/2023 PFHxA 2.1 YADYR1 12/13/2023 PFOA 2.3 YADYR1 12/13/2023 PFOS 3.5 YADYR1 12/13/2023 PFPeA 2.2 YADSY2 10/26/2023 PFBS 2.2 YADSY2 10/26/2023 PFHxA 2.4 YADSY2 10/26/2023 PFOS 2.3 YADSY2 10/26/2023 PFPeA 3.0 YADSY2 11/27/2023 PFBS 2.0 YADSY2 11/27/2023 PFHxA 2.2 YADSY2 11/27/2023 PFOS 1.9 YADSY2 11/27/2023 PFPeA 2.7 YADSY2 12/13/2023 PFBA 2.1 J1 YADSY2 12/13/2023 PFOS 2.3 YADSY2 12/13/2023 PFPeA 2.0 YADSC3 10/26/2023 PFBS 3.9 YADSC3 10/26/2023 PFOS 2.3 YADSC3 11/27/2023 PFBS 5.7 YADSC3 11/27/2023 PFOS 1.9 YADSC3 12/13/2023 PFBS 6.1 YADSC3 12/13/2023 PFOS 1.9 YADDC4 10/26/2023 PFOS 2.0 Qualifier Codes: Y: Elevated PQL due to insufficient sample size. J1: Surrogate recovery limits have been exceeded. 13 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 8. List of PFAS Compounds ABBREVIATION NAME CAS # HFPO-DA (GENX) Perfluoro-2-methyl-3-oxahexanoic acid 13252-13-6 PFOS Perfluorooctanesulfonic acid 1763-23-1 PFUNA Perfluoroundecanoic acid 2058-94-8 N-MEFOSAA 2-(N- Methylperfluorooctanesulfonamido)acetic acid 2355-31-9 PFPEA Perfluoropentanoic acid 2706-90-3 PFPES Perfluoropentanesulfonic acid 2706-91-4 6:2 FTS 6:2 Fluorotelomer sulfonic acid 27619-97-2 N-ETFOSAA 2-(N- Ethylperfluorooctanesulfonamido)acetic acid 2991-50-6 PFHXA Perfluorohexanoic acid 307-24-4 PFDOA Perfluorododecanoic acid 307-55-1 PFOA Perfluorooctanoic acid 335-67-1 PFDA Perfluorodecanoic acid 335-76-2 PFDS Perfluorodecanesulfonic acid 35-377-3 PFHXS Perfluorohexanesulfonic acid 355-46-4 PFBA Perfluorobutanoic acid 375-22-4 PFBS Perfluorobutanesulfonic acid 375-73-5 PFHPA Perfluoroheptanoic acid 375-85-9 PFHPS Perfluoroheptanesulfonic acid 375-92-8 PFNA Perfluorononanoic acid 375-95-1 PFTEDA Perfluorotetradecanoic acid 376-06-7 8:2 FTS 8:2 Fluorotelomer sulfonic acid 39108-34-4 PFNS Perfluorononanesulfonic acid 68259-12-1 PFTRDA Perfluorotridecanoic acid 72629-94-8 9CL-PF3ONS 9-chlorohexadecafluoro-3-oxanonane-1-sulfonic acid 756426-58-1 4:2 FTS 4:2 Fluorotelomer sulfonic acid 757124-72-4 11CL-PF3OUDS 11-chloroeicosafluoro-3-oxaundecane-1-sulfonic acid 763051-92-9 PFDOS Perfluorododecane sulfonic acid 79780-39-5 ADONA 4,8-Dioxa-3H-perfluorononanoicacid 919005-14-4 PFEESA/PES Perfluoro(2-ethoxyethane)sulphonic acid 113507-82-7 PMPA Perfluoro-2-methoxypropanoic acid 13140-29-9 PFECA B OR NFHDA Perfluoro-3,6-dioxaheptanoic acid 151772-58-6 R-PSDA (NAFION BYPRODUCT 4) Perfluoro-4-(2-sulfoethoxy)pentanoic acid 2416366-18-0 HYDROLYZED PSDA (NAFION BYPRODUCT 5) 2-fluoro-2-[1,1,2,3,3,3-hexafluoro-2-(1,1,2,2- tetrafluoro-2-sulfoethoxy)propoxy]-acetic acid 2416366-19-1 R-PSDCA (NAFION BYPRODUCT 6) 1,1,2,2-tetrafluoro-2-[1,2,2,3,3-pentafluoro-1- (trifluoromethyl)propoxy] ethanesulfonic acid 2416366-21-5 R-EVE 4-(2-carboxy-1,1,2,2-tetrafluoroethoxy)-2,2,3,3,4,5,5,5- octafluoro-pentanoic acid 2416366-22-6 PEPA Perfluoro-2-ethoxypropanoic acid 267239-61-2 PFESA-BP1 (NAFION BYPRODUCT 1) Perfluoro-3,6-dioxa-4-methyl-7-octenesulfonic acid 29311-67-9 14 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch ABBREVIATION NAME CAS # PFO2HXA Perfluoro (3,5-dioxahexanoic) acid 39492-88-1 PFO3OA Perfluoro (3,5,7-trioxaoctanoic) acid 39492-89-2 PFO4DA Perfluoro (3,5,7,9-tetraoxadecanoic) acid 39492-90-5 PFO5DA Perfluoro(3,5,7,9,11-pentaoxadodecanoic) acid 39492-91-6 PFMOAA Perfluoro-2-methoxyacetic acid 674-13-5 EVE ACID 2,2,3,3-tetrafluoro-3-({1,1,1,2,3,3-hexafluoro-3-[(1,2,2- trifluoroethenyl)oxy]propan-2- yl}oxy)propionic acid 69087-46-3 PFESA-BP2 (NAFION BYPRODUCT 2) 7H-Perfluoro-4-Methyl-3,6-Dioxaoctanesulfonic Acid 749836-20-2 HYDRO-EVE ACID 2,2,3,3-Tetrafluoro-3-{[1,1,1,2,3,3-hexafluoro-3- (1,2,2,2-tetrafluoroethoxy)propan-2-yl]oxy}propanoic acid 773804-62-9 NVHOS Perfluoroethoxysulfonic acid 801209-99-4 PFECA G 4-(Heptafluoroisopropoxy)hexafluorobutanoic acid 801212-59-9 Metals Chemical analyses for both total and dissolved metals from samples collected from the Yadkin River, South Yadkin River, and associated tributaries, did not result in any values above NC WQS for surface waters classified as WS-IV. Detections of barium, calcium, iron, potassium, magnesium, manganese, and sodium are considered naturally occurring and were not detected at concentrations considered problematic to this reclassification. Analytical results for total and dissolved metals are summarized in Tables 9 and 10. 15 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 9. Total Metals Data Summary Station ID Date (m/d/y) Ag (µg/L) As (µg/L) Ba (µg/L) Be (µg/L) Cd (µg/L) Cr (µg/L) Cu (µg/L) Hg* (ng/L) Mg* (mg/L) Mn (µg/L) Ni (µg/L) Pb (µg/L) Sb (µg/L) Se (µg/L) Tl (µg/L) Zn (µg/L) YADYR1_SUR 10/26/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 16 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.09 2.3 19 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_SUR 10/26/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 27 5.0 U 0.05 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.54 3.1 68 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_SUR 10/26/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 33 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.00 U 4.6 180 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_SUR 10/26/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 60 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.00 U 3.0 37 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_SUR 11/27/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 22 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.21 2.4 34 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_SUR 11/27/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 26 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.00 U 3.1 48 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_SUR 11/27/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 35 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.24 5.0 150 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_SUR 11/27/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 60 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.18 3.4 48 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_SUR 12/13/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 33 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 3.1 5.97 2.1 61 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_SUR 12/13/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 38 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.2 4.41 2.6 88 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_SUR 12/13/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 53 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.90 4.1 160 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_SUR 12/13/23 1.0 U 2.0 U 70 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.65 3.7 61 2.0 U 2.0 U 10 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U * All metals concentrations are reported in µg/L except Mg which is reported in mg/L, and Hg which is reported in ng/L Qualifier Codes: U: Indicates that the analyte was analyzed for, but not detected above, the reported PQL. 16 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Table 10. Dissolved Metals Data Summary Station ID Date (d/m/y) Ag (µg/L) Be (µg/L) Cd (µg/L) Cr (µg/L) Cu (µg/L) Mg* (mg/L) Mn (µg/L) Sb (µg/L) Pb (µg/L) Se (µg/L) Tl (µg/L) Zn (µg/L) YADYR1_DISS1 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.1 16 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_DISS2 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.3 21 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_DISS1 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.0 51 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_DISS2 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.0 50 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_DISS1 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 4.5 170 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_DISS2 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 4.5 170 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_DISS1 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.9 33 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_DISS2 10/26/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.9 33 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_DISS1 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.3 26 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_DISS2 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.2 25 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_DISS1 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.0 37 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_DISS2 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.0 39 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_DISS1 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 4.9 140 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_DISS2 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 4.8 140 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_DISS1 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.3 38 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_DISS2 11/27/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.3 36 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_DISS1 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.2 1.9 19 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADYR1_DISS2 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 1.9 12 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_DISS1 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.5 62 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSY2_DISS2 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 2.5 44 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_DISS1 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 4.0 120 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADSC3_DISS2 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 4.0 130 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_DISS1 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.5 56 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U YADDC4_DISS2 12/13/23 1.0 U 5.0 U 0.50 U 5.0 U 2.0 U 3.5 58 10 U 2.0 U 1.0 U 2.0 U 10 U *All metals concentrations are reported in µg/L except Mg, which is reported in mg/L Qualifier Codes: U: Indicates that the analyte was analyzed for, but not detected above, the reported PQL. 17 Water Sciences Section Intensive Survey Branch Pesticides, Herbicides, Volatile and Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds Chemical analyses for organochlorine, organonitrogen and organophosphorus pesticides, as well as acid herbicides, volatile and semi-volatile organic compounds did not result in any values that exceeded their respective PQLs. There is one value qualified with a lab error and has been rejected from the summary. The total number of analytes for these chemical classes is summarized in Table 11. A complete list of individual analytes is available on request. Table 11. Pesticides, Herbicides, Volatile & Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds Chemical Class YADYR1_SUR 10/26/2023 11/27/2023 12/13/2023 YADYR2_SUR 10/26/2023 11/27/2023 12/13/2023 YADYR3_SUR 10/26/2023 11/27/2023 12/13/2023 YADYR4_SUR 10/26/2023 11/27/2023 12/13/2023 Chlorinated Pesticides All 31 compounds undetected (U) All 31 compounds undetected (U) All 31 compounds undetected (U) All 31 compounds undetected (U) Phosphorus Based Pesticides All 10 compounds undetected (U) All 10 compounds undetected (U All 10 compounds undetected (U) All 10 compounds undetected (U) Nitrogen Based Pesticides All 12 compounds undetected (U) All 12 compounds undetected (U) All 12 compounds undetected (U) All 12 compounds undetected (U) Acid Herbicides * No Positive Results Detected No Positive Results Detected No Positive Results Detected No Positive Results Detected Semi Volatile Organics (BNAs) All 66 compounds undetected (U) All 66 compounds undetected (U) All 66 compounds undetected (U) All 66 compounds undetected (U) Volatile Organics (VOAs) All 60 compounds undetected (U) All 60 compounds undetected (U) All 60 compounds undetected (U) All 60 compounds undetected (U) *Analysis Preformed by GEL Laboratories Charleston, SC, 2040 Savage Road, Charleston, SC 29407 Conclusion: Based on the physical in situ values observed in the field, as well as results of laboratory analyses for all parameters detailed in the tables included herein; portions of the South Yadkin River, Second Creek, Beaverdam Creek, and Fourth Creek, in the designated study area as observed during the period of October 26, 2023 to December 13, 2023, met the WS-IV (CA) and WS-IV standards. Turbidity was the only exceedance recorded, and it was found in less than 50% of samples collected. It is not anticipated that this exceedance would prohibit effective treatment of the resulting resource or prevent it from meeting the proposed classification of WS-IV. Intensive Survey Branch always recommends implementation of a continued monitoring plan where applicable. For further questions regarding this or other studies, please contact craig.hoover@deq.nc.gov. Full datasets will be made available upon request.