Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20052116 Ver 4_Exhibit D, other federal, state, local approvals_20181213Exhibit D - Other Federal, State, Local Approvals Planning Board Report To: Mayor Dawn Morgan and the Board of Aldermen Cc: Curtis Swisher, Town Manager Agenda Item Number: K -570.A2 Planning Board Date: 12/14/15 A. Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner, for properties located at 1680 Pine Tree Drive; in the 1600- 1900 blocks of Teague Lane; and the 1400 block of Kendallwood Drive adjacent to Interstate 40, being all of PIN #(s) 6874-65-5960, 6874-74-6262, 6874-86-7026, 6874-72-7049, 6874- 69-3553, and 6874-82-3360 containing 810.16 acres more or less. Petitioner requests a Two - Phase Special Use District rezoning from RS -20 (Residential Single -Family, 20,000 square foot minimum lot size) and MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District) to MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District). Requested Use(s): Multiple Uses Apply. Zoning Docket K -570.A2 Jeff Hatling presented the following staff report to the Planning Board and a power point presentation was provided. Staff Recommendations and Planning Board Actions Members Present: Jim Waddell - Chairman, Tom McDaniel, Ed Green, Janice Carroll, Margaret Burks, James Fradenburg, Steve Hutchins and Karen Caudle Members Absent: Phyllis Mendel — Vice -Chairman and Bronda Smith -Martin Staff Recommendation: Rezoning: Approval Site Plan: Approval Plannine Board Recommendation: Motion made by Margaret Burks to recommend to the Board of Aldermen approval of the Rezoning, Site Plan, and Conditions as presented in the Staff Report. Seconded by James Fradenburg. Vote: (7:1) Motion carried. For: Jim Waddell - Chairman, Tom McDaniel, Ed Green, Janice Carroll, Margaret Burks, James Fradenburg, and Steve Hutchins Against: Karen Caudle Community Development Director/Date: Te-ff YgVj4jx 12121115 Mr. Jeff Hatling, Community Development Director highlighted the history of the Caleb's Creek project. This is an amendment to the original plan that was approved in 2001. The primary change in this request is the removal of the golf course and replacement with seven miles of public greenways and three hundred acres of open spaces. A golf course in this development would no longer be economically viable. Mr. Hatling mentioned road improvements including improvements to Teague Lane and connectivity between Bunker Hill Road and Glenn High School. Commercial truck traffic will be restricted to access from the Union Cross Road and I-40 area. The primary land use is single-family residential. There is a slight modification to move one greenway section to take it away from existing homes and also provide a linear loop system for the greenway. Caleb's Creek Elementary will be accessible from the greenway. There are 44 different parcels in this project. Each parcel has a set of approved uses. This project will be built in phases over a ten to twenty-year period. The original golf course area along I-40 will now be commercial office space. The Temple School Road Extension area has an environmentally sensitive area with no adjacent residential property, making this area ideal for higher density residential development. This project is designated as a traditional neighborhood development. The primary new street is the Glenn Hi Road — Bunker Hill Road connector. This is the east -west corridor parallel to the I-40 corridor. This will also serve the Welden development. Staff is preparing cost estimates for this connector. Staff will recommend that the Board of Aldermen submit this to the Winston-Salem Metropolitan Planning Organization for funding at the time of the next call for projects. The traffic generation estimates are similar to the original estimates from 2001 for this development. The developer held a neighborhood meeting in December. At that time, a roundabout was shown on Teague Lane at the Dutch Treat subdivision. A roundabout will not fit there, so this will remain a normal type of intersection. Teague Lane will be improved by the developer from the Dutch Treat subdivision southward. North of Dutch Treat, any road improvements will be made by the Town of Kernersville. Within the conditions, there is a road development fee that is projected to generate $2,000,000 and a park development fee that is projected to generate $755,000. 2 PLANNING STAFF REPORT ON REQUEST FOR REZONING Zoning Docket: K -570.A2 Planning Board: 12-14-15 PETITIONER: Greer -Louis, Inc., Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner OWNERS: Boyd Brown, Manuela Brown, and BOMA NC, Inc. PROPOSED AMENDMENT: From: Residential Single Family Minimum Lot Size 20,000 sq. ft. (RS20) & Mixed Use — Special Use District (MU -S) Two Phase To: Mixed Use — Special Use District (MU -S) Two Phase Acres: 810.16+/ - LOCATION OF PROPERTY AND SURROUNDING ZONING DISTRICTS: Properties located at 1680 Pine Tree Drive; in the 1600-1900 blocks of Teague Lane; and the 1400 block of Kendallwood Drive adjacent to Interstate 40, being all of PIN #(s) 6874-65-5960, 6874-74- 6262, 6874-86-7026, 6874-72-7049, 6874-69-3553, and 6874-82-3360. 3 The surrounding zoning is Residential Single Family minimum lot size 20,000 square feet (RS -20), Residential Single Family minimum lot size 30,000 square feet (RS -30) and Agriculture (AG). The RS -20 parcel proposed for rezoning is a small triangle piece of their property on the north side of I- 40. The developer is considering placing a subdivision sign at that location. PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION: The property is physically divided north to south by several streams. The land primarily slopes gently towards the streams with some steep areas near the streams and ponds. The former land use was Pine Tree Golf Course. The remaining property is a mixture of woodlands and grasslands. GECGCK' 4 J FINDINGS Rezoning Process: Mixed Use — Special Use District The proposed zoning district is Mixed Use — Special Use District (MU -S). The Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) states that the purpose of the Mixed Use — Special Use District (MU -S): "...is intended to accommodate a mix of residential, commercial, and light industrial uses in a cohesive development which is compatible with the natural terrain and surrounding uses. This district encourages innovation by offering flexibility in design and layout requirements to achieve a greater choice of living and working environments". The MU -S district is only permitted through the Special Use District, Two Phase rezoning process. The submittal documents for this First Phase include: 1. Site Plan -The submitted site plan describes forty-four (44) separate land use parcels. Each parcel is listed with a general land use and approximate acreage, density and the estimated number of housing units. It also shows the approximate location of streets; future street connections to potential adjacent developments; pedestrian paths or walkways; greenways; existing topography; stream buffers; wetlands; and open space. The site plan includes three tables: permitted use table; phasing table; and density table. 2. Adjacent Property Owners Map -_The submitted Adjacent Property Owners Map shows adjacent property lines; property ownership as listed in the Forsyth County Tax Office. The adjacent property owner map also includes the information on developer, agent for the developer, and design firms. 3. Street Layout Map — The map provides the primary street layout and the cross-section design of the streets. It also includes the conceptual way -finding. 4. Vision Book — The vision book describes: the central location of Calebs Creek; convenient access to schools, medical services, retail, and transportation network; the "walkable", "bikeable", "fishable", "floatable", and "explorable" natural setting; layout and land uses; landscape design; and amenities. Zoning History: The original 2001 approved Calebs Creek master plan was approved also as a Mixed Use - Special Use District (MU -S) zoning district. It consisted of 935.41 acres. Since the approval four (4) phases of development have been approved for construction: 1. Calebs Creek Elementary School — Property was donated and the school has been built. 2. Brunswick — Single family residential neighborhood located off Watkins Ford. Site approved for 78 housing units, with 22 currently completed. 3. Deer Run — Single family residential neighborhood located off Glenn View Drive. Site currently approved for 37 housing units with 9 construction permits issued. 4. Haddington — Single family residential neighborhood located off Teague Lane. A developer is currently working towards starting home construction January 2016. Approved for 104 housing units. 5. Calebs Creek Retirement Center — Located off Teague Lane. Construction has not yet started. Case and location Decision and Date PB Rec. Staff Rec. K-570 Approval 817101 Approval Approval Rich Taylor, Agent for Calebs Creek K-570 Tract ID Haddington N/A Approval 3/14/05 Approval Doug Stimmel, Agent for Calebs Creek - Debbie Joyce, Manager K-570 Tract IN Brunswick N/A Approval 4/11/05 Approval Doug Stimmel, Agent for Calebs Creek - Debbie Joyce, Manager K-570 Tract IF Deer Run N/A Approval 5/9/05 Approval Doug Stimmel, Agent for Calebs Creek - Debbie Joyce, Manager Approval K-570 Tract 4 NA Approval 11/14/05 Doug Stimmel, Agent for Calebs Creek - Debbie Joyce, Manager. This site was the central area of Calebs Creek that was proposed by the second developer of Calebs Creek. A revised FDP will be submitted by the current developer. K -570.A1 Retirement Center Approval 12/6/11 Approval Approval Seamon WhiteSide+Associates for BOMA NC LLC The primary change being requested is the removal of the golf course, replaced with walking and biking trails. The original submitted Calebs Creek development in 2001 that was reviewed by staff and Planning Board did not include a golf course, but included a walkable and biking community that is similar to what is currently being proposed. The golf course condition was added during the Board of Aldermen review process. At that time it was felt a golf course was economically viable. Fourteen (14) years later the golf course industry has drastically changed. Staff worked with the current developer on studying different golf course design options, but the financial numbers did not work. Exhibit A of this Staff Report is "Calebs Creek Golf Course Assessment Report" that was prepared to assess the economic viability of a golf course at Calebs Creek. In the report numerous findings show new golf course demand is on the decline, and the Triad Region has a large supply of golf courses. The combination of lack of demand and large supply limits the financial viability of a new golf course in the Triad. Some of the facts stated in the assessment include: 1. Published data confirms that interest in the game and the number of golfers in the United States probably peaked around 2007 at slightly more than 30 million. 2. Studies today say closer to 25 million play golf, a decline of 16-17%. 3. A new course today (18 holes, 7,000+ yards, practical clubhouse, maintenance building, two on -course restrooms, practice range, practice green, parking lot, etc.) is very expensive, likely between $6,000,000 - $12,000,000 not including the cost of land. 4. A 2012 study by the Golf Course Superintendents Association of America (GCSAA) shows that approximately 70% of courses in the Transition Zone and Southeast United States spend more than $350,000/year on maintenance and 58% of that is for labor. Ina highly competitive golf market like the Triad, 1 would estimate a "good" shape for Calebs Creek will require a maintenance budget of $650,000+ or. $36,000/hole/year. Better condition, $750,000+ or $42,000/hole. Tournament shape? Well, that might require close to $1,000,000 or $55,000/hole. 5. An interesting quote was found on golf.com: "The Triad is home to more accessible, affordable daily fee courses than most other loosely defined urban areas in the US. In fact, the only way to spend more than $50 on a round of golf here is to rack up a big bar bill." 6. For budgeting purposes, 1 believe a course should target $2 million in gross revenues. Weather data and my experience says to expect only about 200 peak revenue days each year. This means a course would have to generate approximately $7,500 per peak day. 100 rounds at $75.00 per round or 200 rounds at $37.50 per round. Either measure to calculate revenue will be difficult to achieve in the Triad. The other 165 days will generate revenues of only about a third of the revenue of a peak day of $1,500 - $2,500 per day. 7. According to VisitNC.com there are 27 golf courses within 20 miles of Kernersville and 52 golf courses within 35 miles. 8. The rule of thumb is that for every $1,000,000 of construction costs, a course should charge $10 in golf fees (GF & Cart). So a $10,000,000 course would charge $100.00 to play. This rate is out of reach of most daily fee golfers, more than most are willing to pay and is far higher than the most expensive courses in the Triad are currently charging. Adjusted to reflect today's higher costs of everything, that $10 per million figure should probably be closer to $12 or $13. 9. Any course costing more than $2,000,000 -$3,000,000 million would instantly price itself out of the golf market. Continued on the Following Page Existing Approved Site Plan Land Uses: The table to the right shows the projected land uses from the current 2001 plan and the proposed 2015 plan taken from the 2001 and 2015 traffic studies. The build out of Calebs Creek will be over a 10 to 20 year period. The projected land uses will change. A good example is the proposed land "Uses" does not currently include a church as projected in 2001, however there is good chance that a church will want to locate along I-40 in an area currently projected for retail. Proposed Site Plan R 11 8 To the right and on the following page are the proposed permitted uses that would be considered during Final Development Plan reviews, broken down by the 44 different parcels.A,ts.nd Crafts Studio CALEBS CREEK - PERMITTED USES WORKSHEET MU -1 -------------- MU -2 MU -3 MU -4 MU -5 MU -6 CO -1 CO -2 CO -3 CO -4 CO -5 CO{ CO -7 AM Single Family (attached) C,ng,g,t, Care Facility We Car, Community Conwnienc, Store Food or Drug Store Hardware Store N—cri, I -awn and Garden Supply Store, Retail Wholesale Trade B BUSINESS & PERSONAL SERVICES Motor Vehicle, Repair & V.int—mce Motor Vehicle, Body or Paint Shop RECREATIONAL USES 1:c 1:1onler0caj"d— ,Theater, In nor INSTITUTIONAL & PUBLIC USES Adult Day Care Home Adult Day Care Center Care Institution ,�11,d Child Day Can., Urge Home Child Day Care, Small Home Church or Religious Institution, Community Church or Religious Institution, Neighborhood College or University Government Offices Hospital or Health Center Nursing Car, Institution Police or Fire Station School, Priast. School, Vocational or Professional IMANUFACTURING& MINING Manufacturing A Broadcast Studio Park 8, Shuttle Lot Terminal, Bus orTaxi ©©©©©©©©©©©©©© CALEBS CREEK - PERMITTED USES WORKSHEET ------------------.9 ling c F:mily (detached) ©©©©©©©© RL -20 RL -21 RL -22 RL -23 RL -24 ©©©©©©©© Single Family (attached) ------------------------ ------------------------ congregate Care Facility nil ------------------------ Life Care Community TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES ���i Park & Shuttle Lot Terminal, Bus or Taxi 0000©aaa OWN ©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©©© WORKSHEETCALEEIS CREEK - PERMITTED USES RM -1 RM -2 RM -3 RMM---� ling c F:mily (detached) ©©©©©©©© ©©©©©©©© nil Park & Shuttle Lot Terminal, Bus or Taxi 0000©aaa 10 The proposed master plan has 6 distinct 3. Natural Areas - Over 300 acres of features: uses 1. "Village Center": Mixed Use (MU) Parcels, Amenity Center (AC), and Public Greenway - The "Village center" provides the focal point for the development and surrounding area to gather for social, cultural, recreation and commerce activities while providing an access point for the public greenway. 2. Public Greenways and Private trails - The developer will be constructing a public greenway that will anchor the walkable and bikeable design of Calebs Creek. Private trails will link the Calebs Creek neighborhoods to the public greenway. 11 cale6's ereA master zoning pian natural areas will be preserved as open space. Those natural areas will provide a nature preserve for plants and wildlife. It will also allow the streams to meander and flood in their natural environment. 4. "Commercial Center": Commercial/Office (CO) —The "commercial center" is adjacent to I- 40 and will have direct access to the I-40 / Union Cross interchange. This central location within the Triad makes it a prime location. The land uses of the park, range from office, light manufacturing to multifamily residential. 5. Single Family Residential Sections: Residential Low Density (RL); iee �ra,deatwl - Aedi�m denai�j .:x<d wa< i�l, da. a. N[ a 11tq u.,m. open.p.cer6uHelg�eemvay �=n..�y "gnu wael�ad wl b.Ffar i•:i -1 1. "Village Center": Mixed Use (MU) Parcels, Amenity Center (AC), and Public Greenway - The "Village center" provides the focal point for the development and surrounding area to gather for social, cultural, recreation and commerce activities while providing an access point for the public greenway. 2. Public Greenways and Private trails - The developer will be constructing a public greenway that will anchor the walkable and bikeable design of Calebs Creek. Private trails will link the Calebs Creek neighborhoods to the public greenway. 11 cale6's ereA master zoning pian natural areas will be preserved as open space. Those natural areas will provide a nature preserve for plants and wildlife. It will also allow the streams to meander and flood in their natural environment. 4. "Commercial Center": Commercial/Office (CO) —The "commercial center" is adjacent to I- 40 and will have direct access to the I-40 / Union Cross interchange. This central location within the Triad makes it a prime location. The land uses of the park, range from office, light manufacturing to multifamily residential. 5. Single Family Residential Sections: Residential Low Density (RL); Residential Medium Density (RM) - The single family residential sections make up the largest land use portion of the development. The single family residential parcels will offer a range of attached and detached style homes. 6. Multifamily Sections: Residential High Density (RH) - The multifamily 12 developments will be placed throughout the entire development. The multifamily units will offer a range of housing opportunities ranging from retirement community style housing and luxury apartment complexes to provide rental housing for the growing corporate, manufacturing, medical, and logistic office workers. ITi i i ■.- - n te rf _ o - ■ ■ - illoge Center- Trailheads, mixed residential homes, Resident's Club, and local shops converge to create a buzz of activity. Let your exploration begin with a bike ride around the lakes that culminofes with refreshments at a local watering hole. Or take a stroll down free -lined streets to pick up items for tonight's dinner, Enjoy your afternoon meeting friends for tennis and coffee. Home to great natural features that deserve to be conserved and explored, Caleb's Creek is a planned community designed to celebrate and protect the rolling hills, wide valleys, creeks, wetlands, lakes, wooded areas and vast fields. With over 11 miles of trails planned within the community, each neighborhood is provided dired access to all nature ha: to offer. 66 4' S walkable bikeable , fishabl.e\. �,.. , 1 exp to r:� Resident's Club - Getting Organized Nestled within the Village Center is the place where everything gets organized. Classes, proggrams and community happenings all happen at the Resident's Club. Situated to catch your eye upon arrival and enjoy expansive views of the Big Lake from the back = zkc, the main building serves as a welcome center cjpd. home to everything active that doesn't happen on the #roil. 5w � PT • - - : i z .. 0P "v. Morn F.r#rorxe �;+ Teugue - - •r4.^ PAW• tiiks_ sz3 a'dstn3 to zs Dj srVT Kernersville Development Plan: The Kernersville Development Plan is the "comprehensive plan" for the Town of Kernersville. It was originally adopted in 1985. It contains the community's Goals, Land Use Plan, Thoroughfare and Street Plan, and Parks and Recreation Plan. KERNERSVILLE DEVELOPMENT PLAN GOALS Enhance Kernersville's "small town atmosphere ". What is Kernersville's "small town atmosphere"? ❑ vibrant downtown ❑ historic architecture ❑ sense of place ❑ commercial clusters vs. commercial strips ❑ community activities Establish Kernersville as a "unique high quality community within the Triad". What is a "unique high quality community within the Triad"? ❑ preserved historic architecture ❑ commercial & industrial areas that incorporate historic architectural facade designs and materials during development ❑ residential areas that are predominantly single-family residential ❑ system of sidewalks, greenways and parks ❑ diverse economic base ❑ strong industrial, office and commercial tax base Improve the "natural environment". What is the "natural environment"? ❑ landscaping ❑ watershed protection ❑ air quality ❑ wildlife habitat Land Use Plan The Land Use Plan has designated Calebs Creek areas as "Traditional Neighborhood Developments" (Mixed Use), which is defined as: Traditional Neighborhood Developments (Mixed Use) — Intended to accommodate residential and commercial buildings, public spaces and amenities and institutional uses are mixed in a compact, pedestrian -oriented arrangement designed to lessen the need for a total reliance on the automobile and to generate a sense of community. Using these TND principles, three major components must be considered: residential development, neighborhood -serving commercial development, and the layout of the street system. The intended residential densities for TND areas should be a net average of at least five dwellings/acre for the total TND tract. 15 KERNERSVILLE LAND USE PLAN = ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTED _ TRADITIONAL NHBRHD DEV _ ACTIVITY CENTER PRIVATE RECREATION - HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL - BUSINESS SUPPORT PRIVATE OPEN SPACE MIXED RESIDENTIAL - COMMERCIAL - PARK MFG HOUSING _ COMMERCIAL. NEIGHBORHOOD RURAL RESIDENTIAL MIXED USE INDUSTRIAL LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL OFFICE SCHOOL MED DENSITY RESIDENTIAL BUSINESS CENTER The Land Use Plan ' Calebs Creek Area section states: The Calebs Creek development and surrounding area, including the area east to Union Cross Road is designated as a "Traditional Neighborhood Development" (TND). These areas are intended to accommodate residential and small scale commercial buildings, public spaces and amenities, and institutional uses that are mixed in a compact, pedestrian - oriented arrangement to create a village type sense of place. To achieve that unique sense of place, three major TND components must be included: 1) residential development, 2) neighborhood -serving commercial development, and 3) street grid layout with pedestrian and bicycle facilities. 16 Thoroughfare and Street Plan The Thoroughfare and Street Plan includes proposed streets that are needed to address the traffic demands of an urbanizing area. The primary new street required to serve the developing area south of I-40 is the Glen High Road/Bunker Hill Road Connector. This proposed street provides a crucial east -west connector between Union Cross Road and NC 66. The street will become a major part of the street network of Calebs Creek and Welden. Staff is currently preparing cost estimates for constructing Glen High Road Extension from Union Cross to Calebs Creek. Staff will be recommending to the Board of Aldermen that the Town submit that project in the next call for projects from the Winston-Salem Urban Area Metropolitan Planning Organization. 17 The Thoroughfare and Street Plan describes the "southern road network": Southern Road Network Issue: With the anticipated relatively rapid growth in the area, south of I-40, the Town will need to pursue road improvements and additions to the existing road network. Funding will remain a major challenge to facilitate those improvements. The Town has a planned thoroughfare network that is projected to meet traffic demands. Without the implementation of that thoroughfare plan the road network south of I-40 will far exceed the capacity to carry future traffic demands: Recommendations: ■ The Town shall continue to work with the Forsyth County Commission, Winston- Salem Urban Area Metropolitan Planning Organization, and developers in implementing the thoroughfare plan south of I-40. ■ With the major roads and interchanges seemingly adequately planned for the future, the County and Town will need to work towards reserving the rights -of -ways for these improvements and ensure connectivity between the thoroughfares. Issue: Planned future road and road widening projects have the potential of negative and/or positive impacts on the surrounding area in such residential, commercial and industrial areas of NC 66, Union Cross Road, Whicker Road and Extension (Kernersville Boulevard), Shields Road (Kernersville Boulevard), Old Salem Road, Glenwood Drive, Teague Lane, Glen High/Bunker Hill Extension, and Temple School Road Extension. Many times, the current property owners along the corridors are concerned about the unknowns of when a road project will take place and future phases of the project. Recommendations: ■ As property is developed along the corridors that will experience road widening or new projects, the Town shall pursue the required right-of-ways and easements for the ultimate potential road width to assist in minimizing the future impacts of the road improvements. ■ The Town shall develop the data that can be provided to adjacent property owners with projections of when road improvement projects will be required and what type of road improvements would potentially take place iffunding was available. ■ The Town shall develop enhancement standards that can be used to assist in minimizing the future adverse impacts of the road improvements, such as landscaping, lighting fixtures, sidewalks, bike lanes, etc. that offer the opportunity to enhance the area. ■ It is recommended that the NCDOT Complete Street "2 -lane Avenue" street type be the road design for thoroughfares through residential neighborhoods. See Appendix B — "NCDOT Preliminary Complete Streets Planning & Design Guidelines Framework" for further information on "complete streets ". 18 Traffic The developer was required to prepare a new traffic study. That traffic study is available for review at the Community Development Department. Following is a table showing the projected land uses used in the original 2001 traffic study and the 2015 revised traffic study: Current Current Daily Propose Propose Daily Density/Units Trips Density/Units Trips . .. 976 5,719 331 2,243 1,564 14,967 1,139 12,525 `.. 794 5,059 . `. . 314 957 • 156,000 1,718 275,200 4,533 384,800 1,908 581,200 349 • 96,200 1,098 56,900 21314 98,500 4,366 145,000 61061 .. 459 12 pumps 6,511 • • •• •• 20,000 458 20,000 676 75,0001 683 MINE 1 35,835 1 36,769 The above land uses are only projections to get a snap shot of potential daily traffic trips per day. As discussed in the Land Use Plan section the actual land uses will be different than the projected. Example in the current traffic study uses a high number of 1,139 units for the "single family home" compared to 331 units for the "residential condo/townhouse". It is likely that the "residential condo/townhouse" numbers will be higher because of the strong demand from empty nesters and young professional. The "single family home" land use generates a higher traffic count than the "residential condo/townhouse", which allows the traffic study to reflect the worse case scenario. The traffic study identifies street improvements that need to take place. The remaining road improvements will be paid for through a road development fee, paid at the time of obtaining a building permit which was established during the original rezoning case. The road improvement projects will be completed in phases as development occurs. The developer's street improvements to existing streets include: ❑ Teague Lane from the turn lane improvements at intersection of the future Temple School Road extension north to Haddington or Havenstraat. ❑ Ogden School Road from the intersection of Teague Lane east to the end of the eastern boundary of Calebs Creek. All interior streets within Calebs Creek is the responsibility of the developer. 19 The street design follows the NCDOT Complete Street Guidelines that have been adopted by the Town. A condition is proposed to prohibit truck traffic on the "Urban/Suburban Avenues" (turquoise color). Those avenues run through residential areas and have the potential to be a truck cut -through street. The "Urban/Suburban Boulevard" (blue color) will serve as the primary east -west connector. The street width will increase in areas that require on -street parking. Example the street width shown below for a "Local/Subdivision Street: Residental" has a face of curb (FOC) to FOC of 24', which would accommodate no on -street parking, for a through steet in a neighborhood that has alleys. Most residental developments would require a minimum of a FOC to FOC of 26' or 28' to allow parking on one side. � '''�';= ,.r:,m� '2� a .. • tri I I RESID4ET1/1 o�rsno rr �rc rc�o, nivti� rs tx i°Qwce `n16� . s,ars w�ru.�. A road development fee was developed during the original rezoning with a formula using the known variables of trips per day by land uses, internal caption of the trips and the known cost of transportation improvements. The following table shows the original fees and projected revenue for the proposed land uses. a. Single Family (detached) b. Multifamily (attached) c. Non -Residential. Parcels 5 & 6A -6F d. Convenience Store (w/pumps) e. Church f. Recreation Outdoor Field Complex g. Non -Residential 3A, 313 & 4 TOTAL $500/per unit X 1,341 =$ 670,500 $338/per unit X 992 =$ 335,296 $664/ per 1,000 sq ft X 40,000 = $ 26,560 $4,616/ per pump X 6 = $ 27,696 $247/per 1,000 sq ft X 150,000 = $ 37,050 $978/per acre X 25 = $ 24,450 $2,323/per 1,000 sq ft X 120,000 = $ 278,760 $1,400,321 The above fees are paid at the time of building permit issuance. The fees increased 10% on July 1, 2004 and 10% every 3 years thereafter. If a land use not listed above is used within this development, a trip/unit number would be assigned using the Trip Generation Manual published by the Institute of Transportation Engineers and cost per unit based on the above schedule would apply. 20 The fees have gone up 10% four times. Below illustrate those changes. a. Single Family (detached) b. Multifamily (attached) c. Non -Residential. Parcels 5 & 6A -6F d. Convenience Store (w/pumps) e. Church f. Recreation Outdoor Field Complex g. Non -Residential 3A, 3B & 4 TOTAL $733/per unit X 1,341 =$ 982,953 $495/per unit X 992 = $ 491,040 $1,069/ per 1,000 sq ft X 40,000 = $ 42,760 $6,759/ per pump X 6 = $ 40,554 $362/per 1,000 sq ft X 150,000 = $ 54,300 $1,432/per acre X 25 = $ 35,800 $3,401/per 1,000 sq ft X 120,000 = $ 408,120 $2,055,527 Parks and Recreation Plan During the last update of the Parks and Recreation Plan the community survey found that the top three recreational facilities citizens would like to see is: 1. Walking Trails 2. Greenways 3. Bike Routes The Plan calls for eight (8) miles of greenways completed by 2022. To assist in achieving that goal Calebs Creek will be providing approximately 7 miles of public greenway trails. The Town's Greenway Plan calls for the Calebs Creek greenway to connect to the NC 66/Old Salem Road Metro Activity Center and Welden via the proposed greenway line that will run parallel with the Williams gas line. The Plan also calls for a neighborhood park in the general area of Watkins Ford Road and Teague Road. The Plan states: Proposed Neighborhood Park Facilities A site-specific master plan should be prepared for each new park site and local neighborhood residents should be made part of the development process. Where feasible, the parks should be linked to other recreation sites by pedestrian routes and greenways/trails....... Neighborhood parks typically house smaller or less active facilities such as open play areas, sport courts, playgrounds, and picnic facilities. Neighborhood parks should be approximately 5-15 acres in size, with 10 acres generally considered optimal to provide a balance between active and passive uses. To assist in achieving that neighborhood park goal Calebs Creek has a recreation fee of $293 per housing units with increases of 10% every three years. With a projected 2,578 housing units, the recreation fee will generate over $755,354 in revenue to assist in establishing and developing the neighborhood park. Schools: To assist in addressing school capacity needs, Calebs Creek's original developer dedicated the property for Calebs Creek Elementary School. The Winston-Salem/Forsyth County School Board is currently studying projected enrollment and determining new school construction to address growth. The Community Development staff is working closely with school board staff to assure they have the growth data to continue to meet the needs of growth. 21 Water & Sewer: The original developer of Calebs Creek, City County Utilities Commission, and Town of Kernersville worked out a sewer agreement to provide sewer for Calebs Creek and the southern area of Kernersville that includes the Kernersville Medical Parkway area (Hospital & VA), and NC 66/Old Salem Road Metro Activity Center. A sewer utility access fee was developed for Calebs Creek by projecting the Town's cost of providing sewer to the development and creating a fee structure that distributes the cost to the different land uses. The current sewer utility access fee with a 10% increase every three years is: ■ $1,464 per housing unit/living unit; ■ .44 cents per square foot for non-residential structures; and ■ $989 per acre for Recreation Services, Outdoor. The individual subdivision and developments are responsible for their sewer systems. The City County Utilities Commission and Town of Kernersville were only responsible for a new pump station and trunk lines. Wetlands and FEMA: The streams have associated Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood zones. There are scattered wetlands along the streams and isolated wetlands. The developer completed a environmental review of the streams and wetlands to receive a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers "Notification of Jurisdictional Determination." A copy of that report is available at the Community Development Department. Currently the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has identified the 100 year flood zone through a detailed study that shows the floodway and flood fringe. There is no known flooding of residential or non-residential structures on the proposed development site or immediately downstream from the proposed development. The developer is proposing to significantly exceed the federal and local level flood regulations. The majority of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood zone (flood fringe and floodway) is located in the open space areas. Watershed: The proposed development is located in the Abbotts Creek watershed, which is classified as a Type III. Accordingly, the Town of Kernersville Watershed Protection Ordinance is applicable. The initial watershed review process will take place during Final Development Plan submittal (Phase II), and a watershed permit will have to be obtained prior to the issuance of each building permit, which requires a second review of the development plan. In subsequent development review processes, the developer is responsible to determine and to indicate on his development plans limits of proposed impervious surface for each site specific case. All provisions and limitations found in the Watershed Protection Ordinance will then be applied through the issuance of either a low density watershed permit or a high density watershed permit. Calebs Creek has a "Stormwater Master Plan" that tracks the pervious and impervious coverage. Prior to submittal of a request for a building permit or zoning permit on the proposed site, the developer obtains approval from the Town for amending the Stormwater Master Plan with new impervious coverage. 22 Low Impact Development (LID) is an approach to stormwater management that can benefit both the economy and the environment by reducing infrastructure costs (reducing hard infrastructure costs such as pipes and rip raps), increasing lot yields (by eliminating the need for big retention - based stormwater control measures like big wet ponds) and enhancing water quality protection (resulting in more vegetated areas interspersed with pavement and buildings). LID practices goal is to maintain and restore the hydrologic regime by creating a landscape that mimics the natural hydrologic functions of infiltration, runoff, and evapotranspiration. Structural BMPs refer to physical structures designed to remove pollutants from stormwater runoff, reduce downstream erosion, provide flood control, and promote groundwater recharge. The developer will be required to use Low Impact Development (LID) development practices. Several types of structural Best Management Practices (BMPs) vary greatly in their design and they each have advantages and disadvantages relative to each other, some BMPs can be considered as LID practices and other as basic stormwater treatment devices. The Town of Kernersville use the policies, criteria, and information, including technical specifications and standards, in the most current revision of the North Carolina Stormwater Best Management Practice Manual as the basis for the design, implementation and performance and maintenance of structural stormwater Best Management Practices (BMPs) or Stormwater Control Measures (SCMs). The North Carolina Stormwater Best Management Practice Manual includes among others the following LID practices or Stormwater Control Measures (SCMs) that developers can use to treat stormwater runoff in their projects to meet the Town of Kernersville Watershed/Stormwater rules: • Bioretention is the use of plants and soils for removal of pollutants from stormwater runoff via absorption, filtration, sedimentation, volatilization, ion exchange, and biological decomposition. In addition, bioretention provides landscaping and habitat enhancement benefits. • Stormwater Wetlands are constructed systems that mimic the functions of natural wetlands and use physical, chemical, and biological processes to treat stormwater pollution. 23 • Disconnected Impervious Surfaces (DIS) is the practice of directing stormwater runoff from built -upon areas to properly sized, sloped and vegetated pervious surfaces. Both roofs and paved areas can be disconnected with slightly differing designs. DIS is low cost and has been proven to reduce the volume and flows associated with stormwater runoff. • Permeable Pavement is an alternative to conventional paving materials (concrete and asphalt) that allows stormwater to infiltrate through void spaces for temporary storage. • Infiltration Devices are trenches or basins that fill with stormwater runoff and allow the water to infiltrate, i.e., exit the device by infiltrating into the soil. Recommended watershed conditions are: 1 2 3 The Developer shall verify whether or not stream buffers are applicable to the site before approval of Final Development Plan. The developer shall have a certified consultant evaluate the site to determine the extent, if any, of regulated stream buffers that may be applicable to this site (Stream identification). A report shall be submitted identifying the presence, or absence, of regulated streams and any required buffers. Developer shall provide a detailed grading plan showing provisions for adequate drainage of surface water between and around building foundations. Finish grading in the vicinity of the building foundation shall result in a minimum slope away from the building of six (6) inches in ten (10) feet and be in compliances with the most current requirements of the North Carolina Building Code. Shallow, grassed drainage swales provided to transport surface water drainage shall have a minimum slope of two (2) percent. An engineered stormwater management plan will be submitted to the Town Watershed Administrator for review and approval prior to a Final Plat. When final development plans are submitted, Developer shall include provisions for the treatment of stormwater runoff, including the use of low impact development techniques. At least 30% of the runoff shall be treated using LID practices and the rest will be treated using basic stormwater treatment devices or BMPs. LID treatment options may include, but are not limited to Bioretention Areas, wetlands, Disconnected Impervious Surface (DIS) practices, Permeable Pavement and Infiltration Devices. All stormwater management requirements and regulations that 24 are applicable and adopted by the Town and/or NCDENR and/or other regulatory agencies with jurisdiction over the site at the time final development plans are submitted, shall be adhered to. Detailed calculations will be required for all Stormwater Control Measures (SCMs) or Best Management Practices Stormwater Structures (BMPs). Any required permanent stormwater management devices will be installed prior to issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy permits. 4. A "Special Intensive Development Allocation" SIDA would be required to go over fifty (50) percent impervious surface coverage for the commercial property. 5. Calebs Creek developer agreed to reserve 12.82 Acres of an undeveloped portion of its property adjacent to Calebs Creek Elementary School project to remain it as Low Density project or provide treatment to the run-off from the impervious area portion of the school property according with the "Storm water Management Agreement" between Winston- Salem Forsyth County Board of Education and the Hommel Brown Group, LLC on May/28/2009. 6. The developer shall provide a Watershed / Stormwater Conceptual Master Plan and Impervious Calculations Chart to tract the pervious rights of the project. Restrictions on new impervious surface apply to this site as shown on the Stormwater Master Plan. When final development plans are submitted, developer shall include an update of the Stormwater Master plan and shall obtain approval from the Town. The Stormwater Master Plan shall comply with provisions of Chapter C of the Unified Development Ordinance and shall include the "Watershed/Stormwater Conceptual Master Plan" and the "Impervious Calculations Chart". Dam Safety: Existing, and any modified or proposed dam involved in this development project must meet the requirements of the North Carolina Dam Safety Act. A zoning condition requires the property owner's covenants and restrictions include language that all dam maintenance and up -grades, and all associated costs, shall be the responsibility of the property owners. Revenue & Expenditures: The Town of Kernersville annexed this property January 18, 2001. The development of this property has increased the Town's revenue and expenditures. The goal in most annexations is to have the new revenue meet the new expenditure needs and contribute revenue to community wide expenditures such as street improvements, parks and recreation, and emergency services protection. 25 RPVPnna The estimated tax base for the Calebs Creek development is as follows: ESTIMATED TAX BASE FOR CALEBS CREEK 1,470 Housing Units ($250,000 per units) _ $367,500,000 1,108 Retirement & High End Apartments ($140,000 per unit) _ $155,120,000 252,200 sq.ft. Office ($120 sq.ft.) _ $ 30,264,000 384,800 sq.ft. Warehousing ($80 sq.ft.) _ $ 46,496,000 243,500 sq.ft. Retail ($100 sq. ft.) _ $ 24,350,000 20,000 sq. ft. Club House, Swim & Tennis ($150 sq.ft.) _ $ 3,000,000 *TOTAL $626,730,000 *Total does not include equipment, personal property and vehicle tax revenues. To compare the proposed development tax base revenue impact on the Town of Kernersville, two general comparisons can be made. One comparison is the tax base per acre and the other is the tax base per person. Town of Kernersville 1/01/2015 Calebs Creek Estimates *Tax Base $2,326,165,097 $626,730,000 Acres 11,356 810 Tax Base Per Acre $ 204,840 $ 773,741 Population 24,177 5,440 Tax Base Per Person $ 96,214 $ 115,217 *Source Forsyth and Guilford County Tax Offices TR2 2014 Reports As the tax base revenue analysis above concludes, the Calebs Creek development exceeds the Town of Kernersville's current tax base per acre and per person. Expenditure Expenditures to service the Calebs Creek development will cost less on average than serving the existing areas of Town. This is due to the following facts: ❑ Very little funding will need to be expended on roads, since the roads will all be new and built to town standards. ❑ Solid waste service to the residential units will be more efficient due to the compact development and proper layout of all pick-up areas. Apartments and commercial development pay for their own solid waste disposal. ❑ Police and fire protection will be more efficient due to the compact development. The Fire Rescue Department currently has a temporary station on Teague Lane and owns land for a new station at the intersection of Teague Lane and Hedgecock Road. ❑ Park and transportation development fees are being imposed to assist in the construction of future roads and park facilities. The developer will also be constructing the public greenway. 26 As the development ages it will need similar funding for roads, parks and other public facility improvements as in the existing areas. However, since all public improvements being installed will be to Town standards, the average cost will remain below the cost of repairing public facilities, which were not built to current Town standards. Design: The village center area (MU 1- 6) will be required to meet the Central Kernersville Overlay District. The commercial/office areas will be required to meet the Highway Corridor Overlay District. The residential areas will be required to meet the following standards: Developer shall comply with the submitted illustrated residential traditional stylistic designs. At the time of Final Development Plan submittal the architectural design of the residential units shall be submitted. The traditional stylistic architectural features shall include a combination of the following: Roofs: • Hip and/or Gable(s) Roof, with a Pitch between 4:12 and 12:12. Windows: • Window trim that incorporates the use of decorative shutters, heads, aprons and/or cornices. Entrances: Well defined stylistic front entrances, with paneled doors Garage doors -- • Garage doors shall be paneled and framed with decorative trim. • The front of the garage for front -loading garages shall not extend more than 3 ' from the front wall or if adjacent to the porch shall not extend 3' from the porch front. _ Porches • The porch must beat least 36 square feet in area and have minimum depth of 5'. t Design Features on all Sides • The design standards shall apply to all sides of the structure. Trim: • Distinctive trims shall be incorporated. am No two elevations with identical windows and door design are to be used on the same block. (A block is defined as the area between intersecting streets). Alternative design standards may be submitted at the time of Final Development Plan provided that the applicant presents, at the time of submittal, proposed findings of facts that the proposed design would implement the design purposes of creating a unique high quality community more adequately than a design which would meet the strict requirements of the residential design standards. 27 The development will include a way -finding design that follows the conceptual design shown below: conceptual way -finding ..,. Impacts on Surrounding Area There are currently 71 adjacent property owners to this site of 810 acres. The adjacent property border measures approximately 9 miles. Approximately 50 homes (excluding the current Calebs Creek houses) are within 200' of the 9 mile perimeter. The majority of these homes are located in the Teague Lane area. The proposed development plan has placed residential use alongside the majority of adjacent residential areas. The density of housing units and type of landscape buffers of the proposed residential areas will be major factors in influencing the impacts the proposed development will have on the adjacent property owners. The major impact will be changing a rural area to an urban area. The majority of surrounding property owners live in the area because of its rural setting. The change to an urban setting will bring traffic, neighbors, sounds and lighting they currently do not experience. The urban setting will also bring greater choices of living and working environments to both existing and future residents. This rural to urban transition has been taking place in southeast Forsyth County during the past 30 years. A study of Forsyth and Kernersville approval from 1990 to 2000 of major subdivisions and rezoning approval for southeast Forsyth County (the area south of 1-40; west of the Guilford County line; north of the Davidson County line; and east of the City Winston-Salem city limits, including the Union Cross Business Park) shows the following: Southeast Forsvth Countv 1990 to 2000 Land Use Changes -New Residential Developments 531 lots 393 acres -Rezoned to a Higher Non- Single Family Residential Use --- 705 acres Total --- 1,098 acres The residential developments are scattered throughout the southeast corner of Forsyth County. The industrial, commercial and institutional included the 398 acre Union Cross Business Park (approximately 3 miles from the Calebs Creek development); the recently constructed 1,000,000 square foot Ralph Lauren logistic center at the northeast quadrant of US 311/NC 66; business park area that includes Caterpillar and Herbal Life; Old Salem Road/NC 66 Metro Activity Center including the anchors of Bishop McGuiness High School, Moses Cone Medical Office, Piedmont Triad Regional Council Office; Kernersville Medical Parkway currently consisting of the VA Health Clinic and Kernersville Medical Center; Welden; and Calebs Creek Elementary and Southeast Middle schools. 28 Community Out -Reach: The developer held an open house November 4th at Calebs Creek Elementary School to provide surrounding residents back ground on the proposed modifications to the Calebs Creek plan. Over 60 citizen came to the open house. Phasing: The Unified Development Ordinance requires a conceptual phasing plan for Mixed Use — Special Use Zoning Districts. The phasing plan for Calebs Creek follows the logical extension of the streets and utilities. Specific phasing zoning conditions are proposed. Caleb's Creek Conceptual Phasing 11/17/2015 29 STAFF ANALYSIS: Land Uses: Calebs Creek consists of the land of the former Pine Tree Golf Course that has been pursuing development for over 30 years. The petitioner for the proposed Calebs Creek development has made the largest investment of any other proposal to make the redevelopment of this property a reality. The proposed mixed use development will provide a: 1. village center to serve the surrounding residential area; 2. public greenway to serve the Kernersville area; 3. a mix of residential uses to provide a variety of housing opportunities; and 4. business park area to provide employment opportunities. This large scale development has caused public concern of "tract housing", meaning all structures are the same color and design. Zoning conditions are written setting a minimum design standard for residential and non-residential structures. Kernersville Development Plan: Goals The goals of enhancing Kernersville's "small town atmosphere"; establishing Kernersville as a "unique high quality community within the Triad"; and "improving the natural environment" are being implemented with this development proposal. The "small town atmosphere" goal will be implemented by: ❑ providing a village center with historic architecture; and ❑ design standards that incorporate historical design features. The "unique high quality community within the Triad" goal will be implemented by: ❑ commercial areas required to comply with the Highway Corridor Overlay District; ❑ residential areas required to comply with the detail design standards; ❑ residential areas being predominantly single family residential with the largest percent of land area being used for single family; ❑ a network of sidewalks, greenways and trails; and ❑ a diverse economic and tax base is being created through the proposed mixed use development. The "natural environment" goal will be implemented by: ❑ protecting the environmental sensitive areas of wetlands, stream buffers and natural habitat; ❑ establishing a compact mixed use development that will lessen the role of automobiles, thus protecting air quality; and ❑ the entire development being required to incorporate streetyard trees. T.and [1w Plan The proposed Calebs Creek rezoning would implement the Land Use Plan by creating this area as a "Traditional Neighborhood Development". 30 Thoroughfare and Street Plan The Thoroughfare and Street Plan recognized the lack of "connectivity" of our street system as one of our major traffic issues. This proposed development is situated between four of Kernersville major thoroughfares: I-40, US 311, NC 66, and Union Cross Road. The development is within 3 miles of 5 major interchanges: 1-40/Union Cross Road; I-40/NC 66; US 311/Union Cross Road; US 31l/High Point Road; US 31I NC 66. Also, the interior street system and future connections to adjacent properties create a grid system where topography allows. These road network elements create "connectivity" and will allow for the distribution of traffic rather than concentrating traffic. The distribution of traffic will also take place, because traffic will be disbursed in all directions: northeast to Greensboro; southeast to High Point; south to Davidson County; west to Winston-Salem; and north to Kernersville. The proposed road development fee would be used for the construction of roads to serve the occupants, residents, or invitees of the subdivisions or developments and these funds could also be used for roads which serve more than one subdivision or development within the area. All funds received by the Town of Kernersville pursuant to this condition would be used only for development of roads, including design, land acquisition and construction. Parks and Recreation Plan The Calebs Creek development will greatly assisting in implementing the Parks and Recreation Plan by providing a public greenway and financially contributing to a future neighborhood park. Impact on Surrounding Area: Staff is recommending that during the Final Development Plan review a bufferyard requirement be established. The recommendations are: ❑ A minimum of a 30' Type II bufferyard, with 10 supplemental shrubs per 100' shall be installed if lots within the proposed development are less in acreage then the adjacent lots out- side of the Calebs Creek development with a home within 300' of the development. ❑ The Planning Board may require a 6' berm in locations that are not retaining a sustainable amount of existing trees and/or topography requiring additional elevation to properly buffer the proposed adjacent use. ❑ During the Final Development Plan reviews, the petitioner shall submit outdoor lighting plans. Individual fixtures and lighting systems shall be designed, constructed and installed to control glare and light trespass, minimize obtrusive light while maintaining safety, security and productivity, and curtail the degradation of the night time visual environment by reducing light pollution. 31 Exhibit A Calebs Creek Golf Course Assessment Report September 14, 2015 Calebs Creek Golf Course Assessment Report Kernersville, North Carolina August 20, 2015 Revised — September 14, 2015 DAVID T. ALLEN PGA CLASS A PROFESSIONAL * GOLF COURSE DEVELOPER * CONSULTANT 25941 NESTING COURT #102 BONITA SPRINGS, FLORIDA 34134 August 20, 2015 via E -Mail Mr. Kurt Sandness, Director of Strategic Land Development Seamon, Whiteside & Associates, Inc. 501 Wando Park Boulevard, Suite 201 Mount Pleasant, South Carolina 29464 Caleb's Creek — Golf Course Assessment Report Kernersville, North Carolina Dear Kurt: Thank you for asking my thoughts on the feasibility of constructing and operating a profitable golf course in Kernersville, North Carolina. The following are my thoughts and opinions on golf course ownership; specifically, the opportunity for a semi -private championship golf course facility at Caleb's Creek. 50 `Real Estate' Golf Courses The late 1980's through 2005 was a boom time for golf course development. Many wonderful courses were built in the United States during those years, but many ordinary and unnecessary courses were constructed as well. What many do not realize is that only a small percentage actually became successful as operating businesses. It was during this time period that beyond the hiring of a `name' architect, little thought was given to the quality of the golf experience and the ability of the facility to be economically viable in its market. The developer's `formula' projected to was to build the course to the level of the price of the homes for sale around it; then, use the course as a sales tool to attract homebuyers. The course would increase the value of the homesites by more than it cost to build and operate the facility. The `Build It and They Will Come' mentality was in full flight. we know the actual number is closer to 20-25%. Once the developers sold out their lots; they would either operate the course, transfer ownership to the members or sell it to a third party. Either way, the course was projected to make ends meet by serving the demand of the homeowners. For a while they often would, but things usually worked out differently in the longer term. Back then, the thinking was that 30-40% of buyers of golf course homes were expected to be golfers. Now we know the actual number is closer to 20-25%. While courses did help sell tens of thousands of homes..... unless the golf course was unique and ideally located near a thriving population center, once subsidies from the developer ( lot enhancement fees) stopped and the original home buyers aged out or moved elsewhere, the course usually began to struggle financially. Now here in 2015, after the financial collapse in 2008 and the spike in golf interest attributable to Tiger Woods; the reality is that in many areas too many `real estate' courses compete to attract the same golfers. As a result, most courses tend to struggle and many barely stay open. New Courses Create New Golfers? The popular thinking 25 years ago, I believe because it sounded good and helped generate interest and enthusiasm with lenders/ investors to build new courses, was that a new golf course created new golfers. Today, we know that is not true. The hope 51 was every course brings some new players into the game, but only a small percentage of beginners ever persevere and become a `golfer'. The old adage is true; 'The older you are the more difficult it is to learn to play golf'. Why? Because, golf is difficult. It has been called an intensely personal pursuit. Golf requires thought, takes a lot of time, is expensive and is notoriously frustrating as perfection is essentially impossible. It's also more athletic than it appears to the average person. An individual can play all their life and never really be good. Many are drawn to the game by family, friends, TV broadcasts, etc. and they try to play. And today's young adults, the millennials, are an instant gratification generation with short attention spans. Many expect to be good at anything they try quickly. Golf is different, very much at odds with those traits. So while many give the game a try, the majority eventually find alternative forms of recreation more attractive. Published data confirms that interest in the game and the number of golfers in the United States probably peaked around 2007 at slightly more than 30 million.... roughly 8-10% of the population. Today, as you travel by courses you see less activity and fewer golfers. Studies today say closer to 25 million play golf, a decline of 16-17%. Perhaps the greatest concern for our sport.....less and less young people playing while the average age of a golfer is..... increasing. The National Golf Course Owners Association offers these definitions of golfers: Occasional - plays less than 8 rounds per year Core - plays 8-24 rounds per year Avid - plays 25 or more rounds per year These are the golfers that sustain the business of golf. These are the golfers every golf course and club must attract. No matter what we may hear, new golf courses do not create new golfers in meaningful numbers. Over the years it has become evident that every course cannibalizes golfers from all the other courses in their market area. Costs to Build vs. Costs to Buy Anyone considering building a course today should know that a long term growth in value and a profitable exit strategy do not exist in golf. A new course today ( 18 52 holes, 7,000+ yards, practical clubhouse, maintenance building, two on -course restrooms, practice range, practice green, parking lot, etc. ) is very expensive; likely between $6,000,000 - $12,000,000 not including the cost of land. It is not unusual for it to be more if the site is difficult ( rock outcroppings, steep terrain, etc. ) and the facility has been deemed to be `special' to compete in its market. Now compare costs of building with the sales / purchase price of an existing course in decent condition. Typically half or less in some areas. Perhaps MUCH less as was the case with Pine Knolls. What Makes a Golf Course Successful and Special? Generally, a golf course is seen as `successful' when its popularity and revenues make it financially self-sustaining in the first two years. If a course can do this, it has a strong probability of operating profitably far into the future. In all but a few unique situations, whenever a course is not a quick profit generator, the owner's eagerness to write those subsidy checks vanishes quickly and the quality of the project goes down hiII.....fast. It is important to acknowledge this because the value of the property surrounding a golf course struggling to survive can be dramatically impacted, such as adjoining residential neighborhoods. A course's ability to command high fees and generate sustainable revenues comes down to its design, proximity to an economically strong population center, playability, aesthetics, condition, management and amenities. My definitions: Design - how well the entrance, clubhouse, and the individual golf holes flow and fit into the site's natural elements. Playability - how effectively the course challenges skilled players while presenting an enjoyable experience to all levels. Aesthetics - all about the overall experience, everything you touch and come into contact with, and the visual interest of the experience. Condition - quality of the playing surfaces. 53 Management - vital to success of a golf course. Requires an uncommon and rare mix of business, people and industry skill. If a course lacks any of the above, it will inevitably suffer long term and struggle to generate the revenue necessary to sustain its operation. A Golf Course is just a Turf Farm? Most people don't see golf courses as a carefully designed and complicated turf farm with a retail operation, but that's what they are in the business sense. Caleb's Creek lies in North Carolina's Piedmont region, a well-known "transition zone" for grass. The two most common types used in golf are Bent & Fescue ( cool season grasses) and Bermuda ( warm season grass) . Both are grown successfully in Kernersville, but in any given year or season, both can struggle from the effects of the weather. Bent & Fescue do best in cooler, wetter conditions of late fall, winter and early spring while Bermuda thrives when soil dries out and temperatures climb with the arrival of sunny, warm weather in late spring. But too much of either, proves damaging to the turf. Maintaining quality playing surfaces is the top priority for a golf course. Turf problems can have a devastating impact on the business. These days discerning golfers have high expectations as they want conditions close to what they see on the PGA Tour. After all, they are paying for the experience and they want to see similarly groomed courses. Winter weather in North Carolina this year left course operators with a real problem from `Winter Kill'. The weather kept the clay soil too wet and too cold for too long resulting in acres of dead bermuda grass in the fairways and around the greens. The remedy was to reseed, resprig and perhaps sod the affected areas followed by intensive watering and fertilizing in order to establish new root growth and restore the playing surfaces as fast as possible. This work is expensive and is made more expensive because growing bermuda grass must be done in the warmest time of the year; summer, that also coincides with the busiest time of year for playing golf. The net result is that the sub -standard playing conditions impact the business of golf. The cost of reseeding combined with lost revenues could be a devastating blow to thinly capitalized golf courses. 54 Maintenance Budgets Each site presents a developer and architect with a unique set of circumstances. Climate, foliage, uplands, wetlands, sun angles, soil quality, environmental restrictions, drainage problems, water availability and quality, rock outcroppings, highway access, etc. as part of its layout. The master plan and golf course design must consider all these factors and more in order to maximize the site's land value for the developer and create the quality golf course needed to maximize revenues and minimize reoccurring maintenance costs. Something that is not easy to do and only a few do well. Presenting attractive playing conditions at a golf course with practice range, putting green and clubhouse grounds through a variety of weather conditions and activity levels requires skilled attention 365 days a year. This budget should be the largest line item for the course. A 2012 study by the Golf Course Superintendents Association of America (GCSAA) shows that approximately 70% of courses in the Transition Zone and Southeast United States spend more than $350,000/year on maintenance and 58% of that is for labor. In a highly competitive golf market like the Triad, I would estimate a "good" shape for Caleb's Creek will require a maintenance budget of $650,000+ or $36,000/hole/year. Better condition, $750,000+ or $42,000/hole. Tournament shape? Well, that might require close to $1,000,000 or $55,000/hole. Again, the site, golf course design, standards and weather all impact this number which can vary from year to year as was evident this past winter season. Capital Expenses Components of newly built golf courses do not last forever. A significant capital expense reserve should be established to reconstruct greens, tees, cart paths, water features, irrigation systems, clubhouse, etc. as part of any budget. Modern golf course greens as well as other modern improvements have depreciable components with acceptable life spans such as underground drainage pipes and irrigation. It is land preparation costs such as these that are depreciable components that will be periodically be retired, abandoned or replaced as part of a typical golf operation. Similarly, land preparation costs for general grading and shaping, constructing or reconstructing tees, recontouring fairways to construct or reconstruct bunkers are not subject to depreciation. 55 Project Description As I understand the requirements, the course contemplated for Caleb's Creek would be an 18 -hole championship semi -private golf course. It will take approximately 200+ acres of land and would be immersed within a master planned community. Caleb's Creek's location lies between the Greensboro -High Point MSA with nearly 750,000 people and the Winston-Salem MSA with 655,000 people which means that collectively 1,400,000 million people have are in vicinity of the property. If the National Golf Foundation's statistics are correct, approximately 8%-10% of the US population is a golfer. That would mean the area may have as many as 140,000 golfers. Although this may sound encouraging, other pertinent data needs to be considered when evaluating the feasibility of a golf course. The Market(s) North Carolina is among the country's `richest' golf states. There are many golf destinations steeped in tradition from the mountains to the coast. Most notable is Pinehurst, located in the Sandhills Region which is indeed the "St. Andrews of American Golf". North Carolina also annually hosts two PGA Tour events, the Wells Fargo Championship in Charlotte and The Wyndham in Greensboro. In addition, in recent years Pinehurst County Club hosted the United States Open and Quail Hollow will host the PGA Championship in 2017. Golf markets evolve over time; typically following the combination of population growth, athletically minded people and suitable weather to support golf. Minnesota and other northern states may have the most demand for golf per capita, but few golf courses are built in those locations because of the severe seasonality of the business. San Diego was one of the top three North American golf markets in the 1990s, but things have changed in recent years. Once an ideal golf market, the area became overbuilt and now many once flourishing courses struggle to meet operating expenses. Some are even shutting down; in reality many more probably should .... and there are other areas like San Diego, Myrtle Beach is another example. The Triad is clearly home to many golfers, but for decades it has been a buyer's market for tee times. Green fees for public golf courses typically range from $30 to 56 $50. The cost of private club memberships can vary widely all across the region. With discounted tee times widely available and promoted on golf web sites, it's practically impossible to determine a course's actual yield from golf fees without having access to their financial records. An interesting quote was found on golf.com "The Triad is home to more accessible, affordable daily fee courses than most other loosely defined urban areas in the US. In fact the only way to spend more than $50 on a round of golf here is to rack up a big bar bill." According to VisitNC.com there are 27 golf courses within 20 miles of Kernersville and 52 golf courses within 35 miles. Refer to Exhibit A and Exhibit B for a list of courses. A Golf Course Investment Golf course ( s ) are not appropriate investments for those investors expecting quick returns. There is potential, even a likelihood, for significant operating losses, minimal operating profits and there is almost never a positive exit strategy. Risks, expenses and other variables... primarily weather are not factors with other investments and can have a major impact on a golf course's revenues. There are no walls and no roof in golf. Skilled management is vital to the success of a golf course. Operating a semi -private golf course profitably requires an uncommon and rare mix of business and people skills, along with a great deal of industry specific knowledge and experience. While golf management companies are eager to operate a course; the farther removed a course owner (s) is from the daily details of their golf course, the more the golf course can be expected to under -perform financially and ultimately struggle as it comes to profitability. Obstacles to Success 1. Mother Nature: Pests, Environmental Issues.....a long list. Any period of drought, severe cold, high winds and torrential rain damages or ruins the turf, washes out the bunkers and sometimes knocks down trees. A course's playing surfaces are constantly exposed and at the mercy of mother nature. 57 2. Staff: Good service staff is difficult to find, time consuming to train and challenging to motivate. Turnover is constant. Other than the superintendent, the golf professional and the kitchen manager, golf staff are among the lowest paid employees in the workforce. Maintenance staffs are particularly difficult to retain. Their pay is low, the work arduous and workdays start early.....6:00am or earlier. 3. Competition: One course takes golfers away from another. Most golf studies indicate stagnant player participation growth in the United States since 1990, yet 3,000+ golf courses have been built since that year. That means fewer golfers to support each golf course. 4. Obsolescence: Modern equipment in the hands of today's athletes has rendered many older courses essentially obsolete to elite players. 300 yard drives are now common; Par fours once long at 420 yards are now 490 yards! Balls fly straighter, higher, stop faster. Greens must be designed with contours to challenge the skilled players. Courses need to be 7,200+ yards to be relevant. This means as many as 20+ acres of rarely used turf must be maintained even though nearly 100% of most golfers do not play a golf course from the championship tees. S. Weather: Probably should top any list of obstacles. Golf faces a double whammy..... It is an extremely cyclical business and it is weather dependent. The key to budgeting is knowing how many "Playable" and "Peak" weather days you can expect. 6. Playable Days / Peak Days: In the Triad and across the south, golf season begins with Daylight Savings Time in Mid -March, then really gets going the first week of April which happens to coincide with the Masters. So Mid -March through Early November is the busiest period (8 months) . Thanksgiving through Mid -March is the slowest (4 months) . Rain Days, Snow Days, Cold Days all must be accounted for in a budget. bestplaces.net says Kernersville receives 42 inches of rain per year and 9 inches of snow. US averages are 37 inches of rain and 25 inches of snow. The number of days with measurable precipitation is 115, but the actual days impacted by weather is likely at least 15-20 more. Why? It might be sunny the day after a big rain or snow event, but the turf will surely be wet and not suitable for playing golf. National Weather Service records say there are 220 sunny days per year in Kernersville with precipitation most likely to occur Mid -Summer 58 (53% of days) . For budgeting purposes, I would conservatively estimate only 200 actual peak weather and revenue days per year. While more may be warm and sunny for a bit, a forecast of rain and storms will keep golfers away. Daily fee players are a pay as they go crowd and they won't spend money to play golf nor will they play to get wet. They also don't spend money to play golf and freeze. 7. New Golfers: Baby boomers are not retiring as young as expected. Working full time doesn't allow as much time for golf. As previously mentioned, studies now suggest that the attention span of the millennial generation is not long enough to learn and play golf! 8. College Sports, NASCAR: I know firsthand how college football in the south impacts a golf courses business. Saturday afternoons in September and October throughout the south can actually become slow times because of college football games. If UNC, Wake Forest, NC State and Duke all play home games on the same day, few will be golfing. And with marquee games on TV all day ... the football games will have tens of thousands of golfers in the stands. 9. Vandalism: Is rarely discussed, but it's always a course owners concern. Prestonwood Country Club in Cary, North Carolina is an example. Prestonwood has dealt with a number of damaged greens and fairways that required extensive work. Insurance may cover some of the repairs, but almost never covers the impact to the business. Summary The rule of thumb is that for every $1,000,000 of construction costs, a course should charge $10 in golf fees (GF & Cart). So a $10,000,000 course would charge $100.00 to play. This rate is out of reach of most daily fee golfers, more than most are willing to pay and is far higher than the most expensive courses in the Triad are currently charging. Adjusted to reflect today's higher costs of everything, that $10 per million figure probably should probably be closer to $12 or $13. The practice of constant promotion, frequent player discount cards, tiered pricing, internet specials, etc. combined with the Triad's buyer's golf market has created an intensely competitive business environment. I find nothing to support the thinking that a new 59 course added to the Triad could yield the revenue needed to support it in today's marketplace. The Golf 20/20 Commission of 2007 cited a PGA survey of the average revenues of a daily fee golf courses in North Carolina. (I trust the PGA survey's more than most. ) The PGA survey lists annual revenues for a daily fee golf course to be approximately $1,200,000; not enough to justify the costs of building and operating a high end golf facility in 2007 much less now or when Caleb's Creek would open its course for play several years from now. Sadly, I would expect today's revenues numbers to be no higher than 2007 which was essentially the peak. For budgeting purposes, I believe a course should target $2 million in gross revenues. Weather data and my experience, says to expect only about 200 peak revenue days each year. This means a course would have to generate approximately $7,500 per peak day..... 100 rounds at $75.00 per round or 200 rounds at $37.50 per round. Either measure to calculate revenue will be difficult to achieve in the Triad. The other 165 days will generate revenues of only about a third of the revenue of a peak day of $1,500 - $2,500 per day. A semi -private golf facility with a membership base and corresponding monthly dues line is planned at Caleb's Creek. The cash from member's dues is very helpful in the slow months, but golfers will do the math. If they play a lot and expect joining will save them money each month, they will join so long as the joining fee is not out of reach. If they don't expect to play as much, they will pay as they go. Offering membership also raises expectations from the members. The club must create and sustain a real value proposition for its members. The Triad is already overbuilt with golf courses and it is not a golf destination market. Public access daily fee and semi -private courses there do not command the fees I believe are necessary to be financially viable ( See Exhibit B) . The region's weather and turf difficulties add to the challenge and most notably the risks. Caleb's Creek lacks affiliation with a hotel/resort which gives it little opportunity to capture business from traveling golfers. In my view the considerable investment required to build and operate a semi -private 18 hole golf facility at Caleb's Creek would never generate a return and therefore should 60 not be built if financial viability is a consideration. Any course costing more than $2,000,000 -$3,000,000 million would instantly price itself out of the golf market. If a championship course at Caleb's Creek is to be built, the developer, future home owners through their annual HOA fees and perhaps the Town of Kernersville should expect to forever subsidize its operation. A well designed golf course would be a wonderful and valued addition to the site and to the town, but I do not believe a course can be built at a price that would allow it to operate without requiring significant subsidies. Sincerely, David T. Allen 61 Exhibit B The following are the public and private golf courses I found within 20 miles of Caleb's Creek. The fees listed are from my internet and telephone survey. Most courses use `tiered pricing' and offer other specials, so their fees vary by time of day, weekdays versus weekends, season and holidays. I believe the fees listed are a close approximation for what an adult golfer would expect to pay for a round of golf including cart this past summer. 1. Pine Knolls Golf Course $24 - $29 18 holes 6,258 yards par 71 (Public) 1100 Quail Hollow Rd Kernersville, NC 27284-8269 (336) 993-5478 2. River Landing Golf Course $10 - $29 9 holes 2,884 yards par 72 (Public) 2025 Sandy Ridge Rd Colfax, NC 27235-9745 ( 336 ) 668-1171 3. Maple Leaf Golf Course $14 - $32 18 holes 6,024 yards par 71 ( Public) 4070 Hastings Rd Kernersville, NC 27284-9513 ( 336 ) 769-9122 4. Pleasant Ridge Golf Course $15 - $29 18 holes 6,432 yards par 72 ( Public) 1518 Pleasant Ridge Rd Greensboro, NC 27409-9766 ( 336 ) 668-7107 5. Olde Homeplace Golf Club $15 - $32 18 holes 6,345 yards par 71 (Public) 4295 Wallburg Rd 63 64 Winston Salem, NC 27107-9267 ( 33 6 ) 769-1076 6. Winston Lake Golf Course, Winston Lake Park $21 - $28 18 holes 6,213 yards par 71 ( Municipal) 3535 Winston Lake Rd Winston Salem, NC 27105-4847 (336) 727-2703 7. Reynolds Park Golf Course $22 - $29 18 holes 6,320 yards par 71 ( Municipal) 2391 Reynolds Park Rd Winston Salem, NC 27107-1538 (336) 650-76 8. Meadowlands Golf Course $29 - $48 18 holes 6,706 yards par 72 (Public) 542 Meadowlands Dr Winston Salem, NC 27107-6024 ( 336 ) 769-1011 9. Oak Hollow Golf Course $32 - $39 18 holes 6,483 yards par 72 (Municipal) 3400 N Centennial St High Point, NC 27265-2287 (336) 883-3260 10. Dawn Acres Golf Course ? no answer 18 holes 6,365 yards par 71 (Public) 7712 Nc Highway 68 N Stokesdale, NC 27357-9325 (336) 643-5397 11. Cardinal Golf and Country Club N/A 18 holes 7,002 yards par 70 ( Private Non -Equity) 5700 Cardinal Way Greensboro, NC 27410-9307 (336) 668-2749 64 12. High Point Country Club N/A 27 holes ( Private Equity) 916 Abbotts Creek Church Rd High Point, NC 27265-7502 ( 33 6 ) 869-2416 13. Old Town Club N/A 18 holes 6,661 yards par 71 (Private Non -Equity) 2875 Old Town Club Rd Winston Salem, NC 27106-5299 ( 336 ) 72 2 -1584 14. Jamestown Park Golf Course $30 - $35 18 holes 6,665 yards par 72 (Municipal) 7041 E Fork Rd Jamestown, NC 27282-9574 ( 336 ) 454-4912 15. Pine Brook Country Club N/A 18 holes 6,404 yards par 72 ( Private Equity) 5475 Germanton Rd Winston Salem, NC 27105-1600 (336) 767-0034 16. Wilshire Golf Club $22 - $31 18 holes 6,164 yards par 71 (Public) 1570 Bridgton Rd Winston Salem, NC 27127-7312 ( 336 ) 788-7016 17. Bur -Mil Park Golf Course $7 - $8 9 holes 875 yards par 27 (Municipal) 5834 Bur -mil Club Road Greensboro, NC 27410 (336) 373-3800 18. Forsyth Country Club N/A 65 18 holes 6,700 yards par 71 ( Private Equity) 3101 Country Club Rd Winston Salem, NC 27104-3098 (336) 768-7559 19. Sedgefield Country Club N/A 18 holes 7,130 yards par 71 ( Private Equity) 3201 Forsyth Dr Greensboro, NC 27407-7299 (336) 299-5324 20. Starmount Forest Country Club N/A 18 holes 6,612 yards par 71 ( Private Non -Equity) 1 Sam Snead Dr Greensboro, NC 27410-6087 (336) 299-0427 21. Blair Park Municipal Golf Course $22 - $30 18 holes 6,449 yards par 72 (Municipal) 1901 S Main St High Point, NC 27260-4464 (336) 883-3497 22. Grandover Resort $49 - $69 36 holes, 6,800 yards, 7,100 yards both par 72 (Public) 1000 Club Rd, Greensboro, NC 27407-8286 (800) 472-6301 23. Greensboro National Golf Club $30 - $42 18 holes 7,072 yards par 72 (Public) 330 Niblick Dr Summerfield, NC 27358-9767 ( 336) 342-1113 24.Iron Play Golf Course $16 18 holes par 54 (Public) 66 6261 Lake Brandt Rd Summerfield, NC 27358-9224 ( 336) 644-7991 25. The Long Creek Club $15 - $24 18 holes 6,465 yards par 72 (Public) 5801 Bethania Tobaccoville Road Bethania, NC 27010 (336) 924-5226 26. Winding Creek Golf Course $24 - $28 18 holes 6,503 yards par 72 (Municipal) 72 Winding Creek Rd Thomasville, NC 27360-2551 (336) 475-5580 27. River View Golf Course $12 - $15 9 holes 2,585 yards par 35 (Public) 1185 Joe Ayers Rd Pine Hall, NC 27042-8175 (336) 548-6908 28. Greensboro Country Club, N/A 36 holes, 6,130 yards par 71 7,376 par 72 (Private Non -Equity) 410 Sunset Dr Greensboro, NC 27408-6400 (336) 272-4364 29. Fairfield Golf Club ? no answer 9 holes 2,955 yards par 35 (Public) 6901 Appletree Rd High Point, NC 27263-9402 ( 33 6 ) 431-2913 30. Colonial Country Club N/A 18 holes 6,605 yards par 71 (Private Equity) 7047 Colonial Club Dr 67 Thomasville, NC 27360-5900 (336) 472-7501 31. Stonewall Golf Course $18 - $25 18 holes 5,222 yards par 70 (Public) 3200 S Friendship Rd Germanton, NC 27019-9131 ( 33 6 ) 591-4653 32. Hemlock Golf Course $18 - $24 18 holes 5,603 yards par 70 (Public) 1872 Power Dam Rd Walnut Cove, NC 27052-7922 ( 336 ) 591-7934 33. Tanglewood Golf Course $4.50 - $49 54 holes Championship course 7,101 yards Par 70 Reynolds Course 6,567 yards Par 72 Par 3 Course (Public) 4201 Manor House Cir Clemmons, NC 27012 ( 336) 703-6421 34. Bermuda Run Golf Course N/A 36 holes West course 6,625 yards Par 70 East course 7,082 yards Par 72 ( Private ) 324 Bermuda Run Dr Bermuda Run, NC 27006 ( 336 ) -998-8155 35. Gillespie Golf Course $20 - $22 18 holes 6,445 yards Par 72 (Public) 306 E Florida St Greensboro, NC 27406 (336) 373-5850 36. Monroeton Golf Course $26 18 holes 5,685 yards ( Public) 68 213 State Rd. 2431 Reidsville, NC 37320 ( 336 ) 342 -1043 69 Planning Board Questions Mr. Hutchins asked who would be responsible for street maintenance in the development. Mr. Hatling stated that the streets would be public and would be maintained by the Town. Mr. Hutchins also asked about dam maintenance and greenway maintenance. Mr. Hatling stated there is a master restrictive covenant that covers this by requiring the home owners to provide dam maintenance. The greenway would be part of the Town's park system. Mr. Waddell asked about truck traffic in the development. Mr. Hatling stated that the streets would be Town streets and can be posted for no truck traffic. In Favor Darrell Davis, 1804 Beech Leaf Court, Kernersville NC Mr. Davis stated that he spent 10 years on the Planning Board. He is very impressed with this project as it has been proposed. He is also pleased that this is on the agenda. He regrets that it will not have a golf course but understands why. He also thinks the greenway will be better for the community. Beth Tucker, 7255 Watkins Ford Road, Kernersville NC Ms. Tucker mentioned that she owns property near Teague Lane. She said that the neighbors there want to keep the integrity of the community and keep it clean. She asked if the development will have a homeowner's association (HOA). She also wants assurance the Town will keep neighbors informed regarding this development. Mr. Waddell stated this is a two-phase rezoning and any final plans will include public notice and also confirmed that there will be a homeowner's association. Debbie Joyce, 2102 N. Elm Street, Greensboro NC Ms. Joyce stated that there will be a HOA for every neighborhood in this development. Joyce Crider, 1670 Pine Tree Lane, Kernersville NC Ms. Crider stated that she is not against this plan. She said that when she moved to North Carolina, her family specifically wanted to live in a golf course community, and she is disappointed in this change. Mr. Waddell clarified that the golf course was part of the original plan. This hearing is for the purpose of removing that requirement. The golf course had always been part of the plan. Mr. Hatling said that the developer was first told by golf course experts that a golf course would not work for this project within the last six months. She also asked if there would be homes directly behind her property. Mr. Hatling said that is possible and would be determined by the final development plan and there are buffering standards that would apply. Mr. Waddell reassured her on this. Opposed Patty Nichols, 408 Drayton Park Drive, Kernersville NC Ms. Nichols said that she is not necessarily opposed but has questions about the project. 70 She asked about the density and price range for the homes in this development. She also asked if Ms. Crider's driveway would remain where it is now. Mr. Hatling said that would depend on Ms. Crider's deed and legal documents. He also stated that the detached single-family homes would be in the $250,000 range. Mr. Waddell stated that the final development plan would address her concerns and would be presented in an open session of the Planning Bernard Taylor, 1560 Teague Lane, Kernersville NC He expressed a concern about additional traffic on Teague Lane. He said that traffic is already bad during school hours. Mr. Waddell said that the project will be built in phases and that road improvements will hopefully be made before the project is completely built. Natalie Williams, 102 Havenstraat Street, Kernersville NC She asked about the roundabout that was part of the original proposal but has now been changed to a standard intersection. She wanted to know if there would be a stoplight, a 4 - way stop, or some other method of traffic control. Mr. Hatling stated that a stoplight would be unlikely. He said that a center turn lane on Teague Lane is possible with the existing right-of-way. Scott Dampier, 104 Havenstraat Street, Kernersville NC He asked how four homes per acre could be considered low density. He stated that he was told numerous times that the golf course would remain. As a PGA golf member, he is disappointed that this will not happen. He mentioned several golf programs. He asked if local businesses have been approached regarding a semi -private golf course. He also asked about the widening of Teague Lane. He said that traffic is very bad at 2:00 in the afternoon due to the school. Board Discussion None Board Recommendation Motion made by Steve Hutchins to recommend the Rezoning and Site Plan as presented by staff. Seconded by Margaret Burks. Vote: (7:1) Motion carried. Karen Caudle was opposed. 71 Town Ordinance Zoning Petition of Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner Zoning Docket K -570.A2 ORDINANCE 0 -2016 - AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE KERNERSVILLE ZONING ORDINANCE AND THE OFFICIAL ZONING MAP OF THE TOWN OF KERNERSVILLE, NC BE IT ORDAINED by the Board of Aldermen of the Town of Kernersville as follows: SECTION 1. The Kernersville Zoning Map be amended by changing from RS -20 (Residential Single Family, 20,000 square foot minimum lot size) and MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District) to MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District) for requested uses: Multiple Uses Apply. Approved for property located at 1680 Pine Tree Drive, the 1600-1900 blocks of Teague Lane, and the 1400 block of Kendallwood Drive adjacent to Interstate 40, being all of PIN #(s) 6874-65-5960, 6874- 74-6262, 6874-86-7026, 6874-72-7049, 6874-69-3553, and 6874-82-3360 containing 810.16 acres more or less as recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds, Forsyth County, North Carolina and being further described as follows: BEING KNOWN AND DESIGNATED as 1680 Pine Tree Drive, the 1600-1900 blocks of Teague Lane, and the 1400 block of Kendallwood Drive adjacent to Interstate 40, being all of PIN # 6874-65-5960, 6874-74-6262, 6874-86-7026, 6874-72-7049, 6874-69-3553, and 6874-82-3360 containing 810.16 acres more or less as recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds, Forsyth County, North Carolina. SECTION 2. This ordinance is adopted after approval of and upon condition of compliance with the site plan entitled Caleb's Creek Master Zoning Plan, identified as "Attachment A of the Special Use District Permit" issued by the Board of Aldermen the 12th day of January, 2016 to Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner. SECTION 3. The Board of Aldermen hereby directs the issuance of a Special Use District Permit pursuant to Chapter 19 of the Town code for the Town of Kernersville. Said Special Use District Permit attached hereto and incorporated herein. SECTION 4. This Ordinance shall be effective from and after its adoption. Adopted this the 12th day of January, 2016. Mayor ATTEST: Town Clerk SPECIAL USE DISTRICT PERMIT Issued by Board of Aldermen of the Town of Kemersville The Board of Aldermen of the Town of Kemersville has issued a Special Use District Permit for the site in this zoning petition of the Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner. The site shall be developed in accordance with the plan approved by the Board and bearing the inscription: "Attachment A, Special Use Permit" for Caleb's Creek approved by the Board of Aldermen the 12th day of January 2016 and signed, provided the property is developed in accordance with requirements of the zoning district to Mixed Use - Special Use District (MU -S) Chapter 19 of the Town Code, the Erosion Control Ordinance, and other applicable laws permitted with the uses of. Multiple Uses Apply. Land Uses The development of parcels within the property shall be governed by the following: a. Master Zoning Plan. b. Zoning Chart and Permitted Uses Worksheet shown on the Master Zoning Plan. c. Greenway & Trail System Map as depicted on the Master Zoning Plan, with the exception Town of Kernersville dedicated greenway shall be extended between RL - 21 and RL -24, and not be extended to RL -22. d. Street Layout Map. e. Vision Book. 2. Variations in land use such as acreage, density, units and/or square footage that does not exceed above five percent (5%) of the values listed on the Zoning Chart shall be permissible as long as such variation is consistent with the land uses referenced on the Master Zoning Plan. Variations may decrease. 3. The minimum acreage for greenways, parks and conservation areas within the project shall be 312 Acres which includes acreage previously dedicated and/or developed by third parties. 4. The developer shall include as part of the submittal of a Final Development Plan for single family neighborhoods; elevations, floor plans, and exhibits outlining the architectural style and materials for the residential housing, along with the wayfinding signage and structures for the area. Design Standards 5. Developer shall comply with the submitted illustrated residential traditional stylistic designs. At the time of Final Development Plan submittal the architectural design of the residential units shall be submitted. The traditional stylistic architectural features shall include a combination of the following: 2 31 7 Roofs: • Hip and/or Gable(s) Roof, with a Pitch between 4:12 and 12:12. Windows: • Window trim that incorporates the use of decorative shutters, heads, aprons and/or cornices. Entrances: • Well defined stylistic front entrances, with paneled doors Garage doors • Garage doors shall be paneled and framed with decorative trim. • The front of the garage for front -loading garages shall not extend more than 3' from the front wall or if adjacent to the porch shall not extend 3' from the porch front. Porches ,� • The porch must be at least 36 square feet in area and have minimum depth of 5'. Design Features on all Sides • The design standards shall apply to all sides of the structure. Trim: • Distinctive trims shall be incorporated. ONOW No two elevations with identical windows and door design are to be used on the same block. (A block is defined as the area between intersecting streets). Alternative design standards may be submitted at the time of Final Development Plan provided that the applicant presents, at the time of submittal, proposed findings of facts that the proposed design would implement the design purposes of creating a unique high quality community more adequately than a design which would meet the strict requirements of the residential design standards. Within all residential areas streetyard trees shall be placed either within 20' of the right- of-way or easement, or within the right-of-way of a Public Works Services approved utility corridor plan. The minimum planting intervals shall be one tree per lot or 50' on center whichever is less. The Planning Board shall consider establishing appropriate front residential setbacks for homes located on thoroughfares and collector streets. Considerations shall be given to amount and type of traffic, topography and building design such as the use of front porches. The Master Zoning Plan designates the type of land use within the property as identified by the following zoning districts: a. RL = Residential — Low Density b. RM = Residential — Medium Density c. RH = Residential — High Density d. MU = Mixed Use e. CO = Commercial / Office f. AM = Amenity Center 9. The Zoning Chart designates acreage, density and number of units and/or square footage for each of the internal tracts within the property. 10. The Permitted Uses Worksheet designates the type of use allowed within the zoning districts shown on the Master Zoning Plan. 11. The Greenway & Trail System Map designates the conceptualized locations for types of public and private trail networks within the development area. 12. The Street Layout Map designates the type of street sections and conceptualized locations of such roadways within the development area. The street and right-of-way widths, on -street parking, bike lane, planting strip and sidewalk shall vary based on the adjacent land uses and determination during the Final Development Plan for conformance to a complete street design. 13. The Vision Book conceptualizes the development program for the project. 14. The Town of Kernersville Unified Development Ordinance ("UDO"), its applicable Zoning Overlay Districts and General Site Plan Requirements, except as designated herein, shall apply to the entire development of the property along with the following: a. Central Kernersville Overlay District shall apply to the non-residential land uses within the Mixed Use (MU) Parcels. b. Highway Corridor Overlay District shall apply to the non-residential land uses within the Commercial / Office (CO) Parcels. 15. Roadways within the development area shall be in accordance with the Street Layout Map. The street and right-of-way widths, on -street parking, bike lane, planting strip and sidewalk shall vary based on the adjacent land uses and determination during the Final Development Plan for conformance to a complete street design. 16. During Final Development Plan submittal the applicant shall submit the wayfinding signage and structures for the area to conforms to the rezoning submittal "conceptual way -finding" Golf Course, Parks and Greenways 17. A recreational land fee of $200 per housing/living unit shall be paid at the time of the each building permit issued within the development to serve this development or developments with the immediate area. All funds received by the Town of Kernersville pursuant to this condition shall be used only for the acquisition or development of recreation, park or open space sites. The fees shall increase 10% on July 1, 2004 and 10% every 3 -years thereafter. 18. Greenways, parks and conservation areas within the development area shall be dedicated to either the Property Owners Association or Town of Kernersville at the time a plat is recorded for an adjoining development parcel. The dedication of such area shall define the entity responsible for maintaining the applicable greenway, park and/or conservation area. The following locations currently are identified to be dedicated to the Town of Kernersville following construction of the adjoining development parcel: Ll a. Greenway and park located along Teague Lane comprising of approximately 9.80 acres and 4,930 linear feet of trail. b. Greenway and [ark located between RL -3 and RL -4 comprising approximately 7.05 acres and 2,250 linear feet of trail and along the eastern boundary of MU -1. c. Greenway located between MU -5 and RL -23, around the existing lakes and connecting the existing lakes to the elementary school comprising 9,240 Linear feet of trail. d. Greenway and park between RL -21 and RL -20 & RL -24. e. The minimum dedicated public greenway easement shall be thirty (30) feet. During Final Development Plan additional park land dedication shall be provided that follows the topography and delineation between the greenway and adjacent land uses. £ A minimum areas of four hundred twenty five (425) feet by seventy (70) feet shall be provided along the public street between MU -5 and AM. g. Conservation areas along Abbotts Creek. 19. The construction of buildings, structures, playgrounds, trails, bridges, etc. within the greenways, parks and conservation areas shall be the responsibility of the developer. The construction schedule for these facilities / improvements will be coordinated and based upon the construction of a development parcel(s) adjacent to the applicable greenway, park or conservation area; the completion of the facilities / improvements listed below shall occur in conjunction with the development of the final phase of the applicable internal zoning district(s) as follows: a. Greenway located east of Teague Lane and north of Ogden School Road; RH-2. b. Greenway located east of Teague Lane and south of Ogden School Road; RL -4 c. Greenway located west of Teague Lane and north of Ogden School Road; RL -23. d. Greenway located west of Teague Lane and south of Ogden School Road; MU -4. e. Greenway. Thirty (30) Space Public Parking Lot & Parks located around the Existing Lakes; RL -20, RL -21 and RL -22 or within three (3) years of completing the club house, whichever comes first. f. Greenway connecting existing lakes to elementary school; RM -5 or RM -4 whichever comes first. g. Greenway located between RL -3 and RL -4 and eastern boundary MU -1; RL -3. h. Conservation area along Abbotts Creek; RM -1. 20. The developer shall retain the rights to the pervious area available within a greenway, park and/or conservation area adjacent to a development parcel that is not required for use of any impervious facilities located within the greenway, park and/or conservation area. 21. The 30' public access easement and walkway to the conservation area located east of the Haddington Subdivision to be coordinated by the Town of Kernersville with the homebuilding team that develops this parcel to assist in implementation of the Greenway & Trail System outlined in the Vision Book. Amenity Center 22. The developer shall be responsible for the construction of the building(s) and facilities within the Amenity Center Zoning Tract. The construction of these improvements shall k, commence no later than thirty (30) days following issuance of the four hundredth single family certificate of occupancy within the development area. Transportation: 23. NCDOT Approval: The Town of Kernersville will submit all encroachment and driveway permits to the NCDOT for approval and will be responsible for any NCDOT requirements, except those required for Teague Lane. The Developer shall complete the application forms. 24. Road Development Fee: In lieu of certain road improvements at various intersections, all land uses within this development, except the conservation areas, park and golf course, shall be subject to the following fees: Single Family (detached) $500/per unit Multifamily (attached) $338/per unit Non -Residential 3A, 3B & 4 $2,323/per 1,000 sq ft Non -Residential. Parcels 5 & 6A -6F $664/ per 1,000 sq ft Convenience Store (w/pumps) $4,616per pump Church $247/per 1,000 sq ft Recreation Outdoor Field Complex $978/per acre The above fees shall be paid at the time of building permit approval. The funds shall be used for the construction of roads to serve the occupants, residents, or invitees of the subdivisions or developments and these funds may be used for roads which serve more than one subdivision or development within the area.. All funds received by the Town of Kemersville pursuant to this condition shall be used only for development of roads, including design, land acquisition and construction. The fees shall increase 10% on July 1, 2004 and 10% every 3 -years thereafter. If a land use not listed above is used within this development, a trip/unit number shall be assigned using the Trip Generation Manual published by the Institute of Transportation Engineers and cost per unit based on the above schedule shall apply. 25. Right -of -Way and Easements: Any infrastructure improvements, except for off-site improvements which are not adjacent to the development, placed upon this Developer\Development that requires additional right-of-way and/or easements from other property owners, the Developer shall make a good faith effort to acquire the needed right-of-way and/or easements. If the Developer is unable to acquire the needed property, the Developer must submit documentation to the Town that a good faith effort was made to acquire the property. If the Town elects to acquire the property to facilitate the public infrastructure improvement, the Developer shall reimburse the Town for all expenses, including but not limited to; right-of-way and easement cost, surveying, engineering, legal, appraisal, and administration fees. 26. Negative Access Easements: A negative access easement shall be platted along Teague Lane and Ogden School Road excluding those accesses, which are approved as part of this development. 27. Building Permits: Selective building permits may be issued by the Town prior to the sewer system being placed in service, however, no certificate of occupancy will be issued until the sewer system for that area of service has been inspected by the CCUC and 5 officially placed in service. Building permits shall not be issued until all applicable road development fees have been paid in full. 28. Teague Lane: The developer shall be responsible for the improvements of Teague Lane in accordance with the Street Layout Map. The street and right-of-way widths, on -street parking, bike lane, planting strip and sidewalk shall vary based on the adjacent land uses and determination during the Final Development Plan for conformance to a complete street design. In the section north of the Haddington entrance, and area south of entrance to RH-I the street design width may need to be narrowed to fit within the current right- of-way areas not controlled by Calebs Creek. All improvements shall be constructed to NCDOT Standard Specifications. The construction schedule for the improvements of this roadway shall be coordinated with the development of the final phase of the applicable internal zoning district(s) within the property subject to right-of-way acquisition as follows: • The intersection of SR 4312 extension may be at the intersection of Haddington or Havenstraat, which shall be determined by the available right-of-way. The said intersection to Ogden School Road; RL -23 or RH-2. • Ogden School Road to Hedgecock Road; RL -7 or RL -6 or RHI whichever comes first. • Hedgecock Road to Temple School Road extension; RH-1. 29. Ogden School Road: The developer shall be responsible for the improvements and extension of Ogden School Road in accordance with the Street Layout Map. The street and right-of-way widths, on -street parking, bike lane, planting strip and sidewalk shall vary based on the adjacent land uses and determination during the Final Development Plan for conformance to a complete street design. All improvements shall be constructed to NCDOT Standard Specifications. The construction schedule for the improvements and extension of this roadway shall be coordinated with the development of the final phase of the applicable internal zoning district(s) within the property as follows: • Ogden School Road (East) to Project Boundary; MU -1 or MU -3, whichever comes last. • Ogden School Road (West) to Pine Tree Branch; AM. • Ogden School Road (West) from Pine Tree Branch to Project Boundary; RL - 13. If the Town of Kernersville or NCDOT pursue the construction of the Glen High Road extension to Calebs Creek, the developer shall construct Ogden School Road to the said extension with the same design, construction and completion schedule. 30. East-West Connector to SR -4312: This street provides for a roadway connection from the eastern terminus of SR -4312 to Teague Lane. The developer shall be responsible for the construction of this roadway in accordance with the Street Layout Map or modified to intersect Teague Lane at Haddington. The street and right-of-way widths, on -street parking, bike lane, planting strip and sidewalk shall vary based on the adjacent land uses and determination during the Final Development Plan for conformance to a complete street design. All improvements shall be constructed to NCDOT Standard Specifications. The construction schedule for this roadway shall be coordinated with the development of the final phase of the applicable internal zoning district(s) within the property as follows: • East-West Connector to Stream Crossing; RL -19. 7 • East West Connector from Stream Crossing to CO Zoning Districts; RL -17, RM -3 or RM -4, whichever comes first. • East West Connector from SR -4312 through CO Zoning Districts; CO -4 or CO - 5. 31. No truck traffic shall be allowed on the "Urban/Suburban Avenues", the east west connector from CO parcels to Teague Lane and the Loradale Drive extension. 32. Crosswalks shall be provided on all boulevard and avenue intersections with connecting streets and greenways. 33. Traffic calming devises and techniques shall be incorporated in all areas where potential traffic speeds may exceed the residential speed limit of 25 mph. 34. Regarding the public greenway surface the developer may request modification from asphalt surface standards when crossing the Williams Gas Line if facts are presented that makes asphalt financially impracticable. Stormwater Management 35. The Developer shall verify whether or not stream buffers are applicable to the site before approval of Final Development Plan. The developer shall have a certified consultant evaluate the site to determine the extent, if any, of regulated stream buffers that may be applicable to this site (Stream identification). A report shall be submitted identifying the presence, or absence, of regulated streams and any required buffers. 36. Developer shall provide a detailed grading plan showing provisions for adequate drainage of surface water between and around building foundations. Finish grading in the vicinity of the building foundation shall result in a minimum slope away from the building of six (6) inches in ten (10) feet and be in compliances with the most current requirements of the North Carolina Building Code. Shallow, grassed drainage swales provided to transport surface water drainage shall have a minimum slope of two (2) percent. 37. An engineered stormwater management plan will be submitted to the Town Watershed Administrator for review and approval prior to a Final Plat. When final development plans are submitted, Developer shall include provisions for the treatment of stormwater runoff, including the use of low impact development techniques. At least 30% of the runoff shall be treated using LID practices and the rest will be treated using basic stormwater treatment devices or BMPs. LID treatment options may include, but are not limited to Bioretention Areas, wetlands, Disconnected Impervious Surface (DIS) practices, Permeable Pavement and Infiltration Devices. All stormwater management requirements and regulations that are applicable and adopted by the Town and/or NCDENR and/or other regulatory agencies with jurisdiction over the site at the time final development plans are submitted, shall be adhered to. Detailed calculations will be required for all Stormwater Control Measures (SCMs) or Best Management Practices Stormwater Structures (BMPs). Any required permanent stormwater management devices will be installed prior to issuance of any Certificate of Occupancy permits. 38. A "Special Intensive Development Allocation" SIDA would be required to go over fifty (50) percent impervious surface coverage for the commercial property. 39. Calebs Creek developer agreed to reserve 12.82 acres of an undeveloped portion of its property adjacent to Calebs Creek Elementary School project to remain as Low Density 8 project or provide treatment to the run-off from the impervious area portion of the school property in accordance with the "Storm Water Management Agreement" between Winston-Salem Forsyth County Board of Education and the Hommel Brown Group, LLC on May/28/2009. 40. The developer shall provide a Watershed/Stormwater Conceptual Master Plan and Impervious Calculations Chart to tract the pervious rights of the project. Restrictions on new impervious surfaces apply to this site as shown on the Stormwater Master Plan. When final development plans are submitted, developer shall include an update of the Stormwater Master plan and shall obtain approval from the Town. The Stormwater Master Plan shall comply with provisions of Chapter C of the Unified Development Ordinance and shall include the "Watershed/Stormwater Conceptual Master Plan" and the "Impervious Calculations Chart". Dams 41. All dams within the developed area shall be approved by NCDEHNR-Dam Safety Section pursuant to the "Dam Safety Law of 1967" and as may be later amended, prior to issuance of any Certificates of Occupancy within the Development. -All responsibility for the maintenance and upkeep of the dam or appurtenances as may be required to preserve its integrity as a water impoundment structure, or as directed by NCDEHNR, together with all liability connected with any dam, shall be and remain with Developer or until subsequently transferred to, and accepted by, the aforementioned Property Owners Association. The Property Owners Association's Covenants and Restrictions shall include language that all dams within this development are the common property of the Property Owners Association and that responsibility for all maintenance, upkeep, up -grades, and repairs shall be timely addressed by the Property Owners Association and at its expense. 42. Calebs Creek property owner's covenants and restrictions shall include language that all dams are the property of the Calebs Creek property owner's association and the maintenance, up -grades and associated costs, shall be the responsibility of the property owner's association. 43. All necessary approvals from the Town, CCUC, NCDEHNR, EPA, NCDOT, and Corp of Engineers shall be the sole responsibility of the developer of the applicable zoning district. Flood Zone 44. If construction of a primary structure is proposed in a FEMA flood zone, a Letter of Map Revision (LOMR) shall be submitted for FEMA review and approval, copy of said approval shall be provided to the Town of Kernersville Community Development Department. Buffers 45. The following shall be required for bufferyards: ❑ A minimum of a 30' Type II bufferyard, with 10 supplemental shrubs per 100' shall be installed if lots within the proposed development are less in acreage than the adjacent lots out -side of the Calebs Creek development with a home within 300' of the 6 development. ❑ The Planning Board may require a 6' berm in locations that is not retaining sustainable amount of existing trees and/or topography requiring additional elevation to properly buffer the proposed adjacent use. ❑ If a church use is proposed on RL -21, which is adjacent to Tax Lot 008A Block 5631, the developer of said parcel shall preserve the natural area between that lot and the existing drainage ditch. ❑ As part of the submittal of the Final Development Plan (excluding those associated with the development of single family residential neighborhoods), the developer shall submit an outdoor lighting plan for review and approval by the Town. Individual fixtures and lighting systems shall be designed, constructed and installed to control glare and light trespass, minimize obtrusive light while maintaining safety, security and productivity, and curtail the degradation of the night time visual environment by reducing light pollution. Sidewalks 46. The sidewalks shall comply with the standards set forth on the Street Layout Map, and NCDOT Complete Street Guidelines. Sewer 47. A sewer utility access fee shall be payable to the Town of Kernersville for each parcel developed and shall be paid at the time of issuance of each building permit as follows: a. $1,000 per housing unit/living unit; b. .30 cents per square foot for non-residential structures; and C. $675 per acre for Recreation Services, Outdoor outside of Parcel 7. The fees shall increase 10% on July 1, 2004 and 10% every 3 -years thereafter. Land Uses 48. See following Permitted Use Tables Uses That Would Be Considered During the Final Development Plan Reviews. Jeff A. Hatling, Community Development Director 10 11 RL -1 RL -2 RL -3 RL -4 RL -5 RL -6 RL -7 RL -8 RL -9 RL -10 RL 11 RL -12 RL -13 RL -14 RL -15 RL -16 RL -17 RL 18 RL -19 RL -20 RL -2I LRL-22 RL -23 RL -24 RM -1 RM -2 RM -3 RM -4 RM -5 ®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®® ----------------------------- Li a Care Communitv ----------------------------- RETAIL AND WHOLESALE TRADE ----------------------------- ABC Store fliquorl ----------------------------- Arts and Crafts Studio ----------------------------- Convenience Store ----------------------------- Food or DruR Sto ----------------------------- Furniture and Home Furnishino Sto ----------------------------- General Merchandise Store ----------------------------- Hardware Store ----------------------------- Numew. Lawn and Garden SuvpIv Store, Retail ----------------------------- Restaurant (w/o drive- thru servicel, ----------------------------- Restaurant (with drive, thru sendicel Retail Store, Specialtv or Misc. ----------------------------- Shoccini, Center ----------------------------- Wholesale Trade A ----------------------------- ----------------------------- BUSINESS & PERSONAL SERVICES Bankine and Financial Services ----------------------------- Bad and B—kfast ----------------------------- ----------------------------- ----------------------------- Funeral Home ----------------------------- Hotel or Motel ----------------------------- Medical or Dental Laboratory ----------------------------- Medical and Suraical Offices ----------------------------- Motor Vehicle, Repair & Maintenance ----------------------------- Motor Vehicle, Bodlv or Paint Shop ----------------------------- Non -Store Retailer ----------------------------- Offices Miscellaneous ----------------------------- Professional Office ----------------------------- Services. Business ----------------------------- ----------------------------- Servi— Personal ----------------------------- Testinj, & Research Lab ----------------------------- Veterinary Services ----------------------------- Warehousin ----------------------------- RECREATIONAL USES ----------------------------- Recreation Services, Indoo ----------------------------- Recreation Services, Outdoo ----------------------------- Recreation Facilitv, Public ----------------------------- Swimmini, Pool, Private ----------------------------- Theater, Indoor ----------------------------- INSTITUTIONAL& PUBLIC USES �������������������������i�i� Adult Dav Care Home Adult Dav Care Cente Child Ore Institution Child Dav Care Center Child Dav Care, Large Home Child Dav Care, Small Home Church or Religious Institution Communitv ®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®® Church or Reliaious Institution NeiRhborhood ®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®® Government Offices Hoscital or Health Center Museum or Art Gallery Neighborhood Organization Numina Care Institution School, Privet MANUFACTURING & MINING Manufacturine TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES Access Easement, Private Off -Site Broadcast Studio Park & Shuttle Lot Terminal, Bus or Taxi ®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®®® 11 CALEBS CREEK - PERMITTED USES 2015 Rezoning Submittal (11.11.2015) RESIDENTIAL USES Single Family (detached) X X X X X X X X X Single Family (attached) X X X X X X X X X Multifamily X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Congregate Care Facility X X X X X X X X X X X Life Care Community X X X X X X X X X X X RETAIL AND WHOLESALE TRADE ABC Store (liquor) % X X X X X X X X X X Arts and Crafts Studio X X X X X X X X X X X Convenience Store X X X X X X X X X X X Foodor Drug Store X X X X X X X X X X X Furniture and Home Furnishings Store X X X X X X X X X X X General Merchandise Store % % X X X X X X X X X Hardware Store X X X X X X X X X X X Nursery. Lawn and Garden Supply Store. Retail X X X X X X X X X X X Restaurant (w/o drive- thru service) X X X X X X X X X X X X Restaurant (with drive- thru service) X X X X X X X X X X X Retail Store, Specialty or Misc. % % X X X X X X X % X Shopping Center X X X X X X X X X X X Wholesale Trade A X X X X X X Wholesale Trade B X X X X X X BUSINESS & PERSONAL SERVICES Banking and Financial Services % % % X X X X X X X X X Bed and Breakfast X X X X X X X X X X X X Building Contractors, General X X X X X X X X X X X X Car Wash X X X X X X X X X X X X Funeral Home X X X X X X X X X X X X Hotel or Motel X X X X X X X X X X X X Medical or Dental Laboratory X X X X X X X X X X X X Medical and Surgical Offces X X X X X X X X X X X X Motor Vehicle, Repair & Mal ntenance X X X X X X X X X X X X Motor Vehicle. Body or Paint Shop X X X X X X X X X X X X Non -Store Retailer % % % X X X X X X X X X X Offices, Miscellaneous X X X X X X X X X X X X Professional Office X X X X X X X X X X X X X Services, Business A X X X X X X X X X X X X Services. Business B X X X X X X X X X X X X Services. Personal % % % X X X X X X X X X X Testing & Research Lab % % % X X X X X X X X X Veterinary Services X X X X X X X X X X X X Warehousing X X X X RECREATIONAL USES Recreation Services, Indoor X X X X X X X X X X XX X Recreation Services. Outdoor % % % X X X X X X X X X X Recreation Facility, Public X X X X X X X X X X X X X Swimming Pool. Private X X X X X X X X X X X X X Theater, Indoor X X X X X X X X X X X X INSTITUTIONAL & PUBLIC USES Adult Day Care Home X X X X X X X X X X X X X Adult Day Care Center X X X X X X X X X X X X X Child Care Institution X X X X X X X X X X X X Child Day Care Center X X X X X X X X X X X X Child Day Care, Large Home X X X X X X X X X X X X Child Day Care, Small Home % % % X X X X X X X X X Church or Religious Institution, Community X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Church or Religious Institution, Neighborhood X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Club or Lodge X X X X X X X X X X X X X College or University X I X I X X I X I X I X X I X I X X X Government Offices % % X X X X X X X X X X Hospital or Health Center X X X X X X X X X X X X X Ubrarv, Public X X X X X X X X X X X X Museum or Art Gallery X X X X X X X X X X X X Neighborhood Organization X X X X X X X X X X X X X Nursing Care Institution % % % % X X X X X X X X X Police or Fire Station X X X X X X X X X X X X Post Office X X X X X X X X X X X X School, Private X X X X X X X X X X X X School. Public X X X X X X X X X X X X School. Vocational or Professional % % % X X X X X X X X X MANUFACTURING & MINING Manufacturing X X X X Manufacturing B X X X X TRANSPORTATION & UTILITIES Access Easement, Private Off -Site X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Broadcast Studio % % % % % % X X X X X X X X X Park & Shuttle Lot X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Terminal. Bus or Taxi X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Utilities X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X TOWN OF KERNERSVILLE Dawn H. Morgan, Mayor Curtis L. Swisher, Town Manager P.O. Box 728 134 East Mountain Street Kernersville, NC 27285-0728 Telephone (336) 996-3121 Fax(336)996-4822 Date: December 21, 2015 To: Kemersville Board of Aldermen RE: Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner, for properties located at 1680 Pine Tree Drive; in the 1600-1900 blocks of Teague Lane; and the 1400 block of Kendallwood Drive adjacent to Interstate 40, being all of PIN #(s) 6874-65-5960., 6874-74-6262, 6874-86-7026, 6874-72-7049, 6874-69- 3553, and 6874-82-3360 containing 810.16 acres more or less. Petitioner requests a Two -Phase Special Use District rezoning from RS -20 (Residential Single -Family, 20,000 square foot minimum lot size) and MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District) to MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District). Requested Use(s): Multiple Uses Apply. Zoning Docket K -570.A2 This is to certify that I, Keith Hooker, have had mailed at my direction, on the 21st day of December, 2015, from the offices of the Town of Kemersville, 134 East Mountain Street, P.O. Box 728, Kernersville, North Carolina 27285 by first class United States Postal Service, notices of the above petitioned zoning request and the time and place of the public hearing regarding the same to the persons at the address listed on the attached sheet. This further certifies that the above persons are all of the adjacent property owners to that property subject to the Rezoning Petition above set forth according to the Tax Office of Forsyth County and that the addresses are those listed in said office for the purpose of tax listing. This certification is made in accordance with the provisions of N.C.G.S. 160A-384, this 21st day of December, 2015. a. rk Keith Hooker Town Clerk ALDERMEN Kenny Crews - Irving Neal - Joe L. Pinnix Jr. - Tracey H. Shiftlene - Chris Thompson NORTH CAROLINA'S PIEDMONT TRIAD TOWN OF KERNERS VILLE P.O. Box 728 Kernersville, NC 27285-0728 Date: December 21, 2015 Dawn H. Morgan, Mayor Curtis L. Swisher, Town Manager 134 East Mountain Street Telephone (336) 996-3121 Fax (336) 996-4822 To: Kernersville Board of Aldermen RE: Zoning Docket K -570.A2 Winston-Salem/Forsyth County John E. Van Horn Jane Burton Steelman Heirs Board of Education 1544 Teague Lane 2964 Friendship Ledford Road PO Box 2513 Kernersville, NC 27284 Winston-Salem, NC 27107 Winston-Salem, NC 27102 PIN #6874-88-7871 PIN #6874-88-9514 PIN #6874-89-3211 PIN #6875-70-9172 Robert E. Williams Bernard H. Taylor Gabrielle N. Willis -Floyd 1550 Teague Lane 1560 Teague Lane 1580 Teague Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-88-8490 PIN #6874-88-8284 PIN #6874-88-8150 Kevin M. Williams Timothy M. Allen Billy Lawrence Chamelin 1590 Teague Lane 1240 Somerset Crossing Lane 1604 Teague Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-87-8926 PIN #6874-87-7786 PIN #6874-87-7650 Fred J. Bowen Richard T. Hedgecock Deer Run at Caleb's Creek HOA 1606 Teague Lane 1358 Rock Barn Road PO Box 9336 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Greensboro, NC 27429 PIN #6874-87-7357 PIN #6874-87-7108 PIN #6874-46-1197 Norman G. Parrish John J. Choate Mark Williams 1620 Teague Lane 101 Havenstraat St. 102 Havenstraat St. Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-87-6042 PIN #6874-97-1899 PIN #6874-97-1637 William Blackwell Scott Lawrence Pope Leo 0. Whicker 601 Woodland Drive 1349 South Park Drive Unit C 841 Silver Dapple Lane Greensboro, NC 27408 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-97-7086 PIN #6874-95-8436 PIN #6874-82-9959 Bill D. Katsis James S. Blackburn, Jr. Brunswick at Caleb's Creek H/0 7493 Watkins Ford Road 7471 Watkins Ford Road 2311 W. Cone Blvd. Apt. 150 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Greensboro, NC 27408 PIN #6873-99-1140 PIN #6873-88-1032 PIN #6873-76-7561 Shirley Mae Lauten Trustee Emi Chamberlain Survivor Trust Bobbie L. Chamelin 7405 Watkins Ford Road 3751 Hampstead Road 1740 Teague Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Glendale, CA 91206 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6873-66-9059 PIN #6874-73-2267 PIN #6874-73-2150 ALDERMEN Kenny Crews - Irving Neal - Joe L. Pinnix Jr. - Tracey H. Shifflette - Chris Thompson NORTH CAROLINA'S -� PIEDMONT TRIAD Michael Ray Chamelin Cecil Pearman, Jr. Joseph W. Willard Revocable Trust 110 Dascomb Court 1750 Teague Lane 1754 Teague Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-72-1975 PIN #6874-72-1705 PIN #6874-72-0563 Winnie Pauline Williams Heirs John W. Lane Ralph Edwards Hedgecock, Jr. 1760 Teague Lane 5983 Hedgecock Road 5979 Hedgecock Road Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-72-0431 PIN #6874-61-1868 PIN #6874-51-8869 Gary F. George Jeffery Stephen Jones Archie U. McNamara 5975 Hedgecock Road 2305 Pine Meadow Drive 5937 Hedgecock Road Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-51-6980 PIN #6874-51-5940 PIN #6874-51-4819 Ralph E. Hedgecock Berrier Construction Co. Inc. Roy Anthony Lane 5961 Hedgecock Road 170 Winterberry Place Trail 5901 Loradale Drive Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-51-2819 PIN #6874-41-8966 PIN #6874-42-5247 PIN #6874-33-9837 Joan Lane Norris Frankie Ray Lane Beverly Lynn Smith Parnell 5935 Loradale Drive 5911 Loradale Drive 4340 Glenn Hi Road Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Winston-Salem, NC 27107 PIN #6874-43-8210 PIN #6874-44-5025 PIN #6874-34-4105 PIN #6874-43-1819 Ophelia B. Jackson Kenneth R. Binkley Kay McEntire 1182 Glennview Drive 1190 Glennview Drive I250 Glennview Drive Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-35-4502 PIN #6874-46-0324 PIN #6874-46-8468 Ophelia B. Jackson Edith S. Blackburn Family Trust Joann S. Soucek 1186 Glennview Drive 1137 Glennview Drive 1136 Glennview Drive Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-46-0537 PIN #6874-47-I077 PIN #6874-27-7448 Ralph T. Kiger William M. Crider Henry M. Davis 1V 1010 Sedge Garden Road 1670 Pine Tree Lane 1676 Pine Tree Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-27-9628 PIN #6874-76-9669 PIN #6874-75-2732 Henry Dalton Everhart, Jr. Candace C. Warner Timothy A. Miller 1431 Kendallwood Drive 1421 Kendallwood Drive 1411 Kendallwood Drive Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-69-1313 PIN #6874-69-1428 PIN #6874-69-I623 Craig W. Schwarz Robert W. Cherry Elizabeth Ann Tucker 1490 Somerset Crossing Lane I495 Somerset Crossing Lane 7255 Watkins Ford Road Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-69-3771 PIN #6874-69-5700 PIN #6873-65-5338 Velma L. Matthews Billy Lawrence Chamelin Charles Eugene Chamelin 3441 Smithtown Road 1604 Teague Lane 1944 Teague Lane East Bend, NC 27018 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6873-67-2110 PIN #6873-57-5501 PIN #6873-67-2648 Jerald Chamelin Coy Smith Chamelin David P. Matthews 1930 Teague Lane 1920 Teague Lane 19I0 Teague Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6873-67-5901 PIN #6873-68-4510 PIN #6873-59-5824 PIN #6873-58-6110 Curtis W. Campbell Marie P. Scott Tony M. Scott 5839 Kenville Green Circle 1856 Teague Lane 1856 Teague Lane Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6873-69-1500 PIN #6874-60-1080 PIN #6874-60-5055 Kyle Steven Scott Janet Weaver Hedgecock 1850 Teague Lane 5946 Hedgecock Road Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-60-5241 PIN #6874-60-3524 Lou Ann Reid Steven Hayes 1900 Teague Lane 1574 Running Deer Drive Kernersville, NC 27284 Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6873-69-4155 PIN #6874-46-2516 BOMA NC, LLC True Homes, LLC 7206 SW 146`h St Cir 2649 Breckonridge Centre Drive Palmetto Bay, FL 33158 Unit 104 PIN #6874-46-0095 Monroe, NC 28110 PIN #6874-45-2936 PIN #6874-46-3472 PIN #6874-46-2070 PIN #6874-46-3586 PIN #6874-46-3005 PIN #6874-46-2510 PIN #6874-46-3I4I PIN #6874-46-2414 PIN #6874-46-3296 PIN #6874-46-3236 PIN #6874-46-3365 PIN #6874-46-3478 PIN #6874-46-2309 PIN #6874-46-2302 PIN #6874-46-2206 PIN #6874-46-1290 PIN #6874-46-1174 PIN #6874-46-8120 Keith Hooker Town Clerk Joyce Ella Hedgecock 5978 Hedgecock Road Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-61-2340 Alohalani B. Pickett 1606 Running Deer Drive Kernersville, NC 27284 PIN #6874-46-1049 Boyd J. & Manuela H. Brown 1500 San Remo Avenue Apt/Unit 125 Coral Gables, FL 33146 PIN #6874-82-3360 Dawn Morgan, ayor TOWN OF KERNERSVILLE Curtis L Sw shell Town Meader P.O. Box 728 134 East Mountain Street Kernersville, NC 27285-0728 Telephone (336) 996-3121 Fax (336) 996AB22 NOTICE OF PENDING REZONING ACTION A petition to amend the Zoning Map of Kemersville has been filed by Debbie Joyce, Agent for Owner, for properties located at 1680 Pine Tree Drive; in the 1600-1900 blocks of Teague Lane; and the 1400 block of Kendallwood Drive adjacent to Interstate 40, being all of PIN #(s) 6874-65-5960, 6874-74-6262, 6874-86-7026, 6874-72-7049, 6874-69- 3553, and 6874-82-3360 containing 810.16 acres more or less. Petitioner requests a Two -Phase Special Use District rezoning from RS -20 (Residential Single -Family, 20,000 square foot minimum lot size) and MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District) to MU -S (Mixed Use — Special Use District). Requested Use(s): Multiple Uses Apply, Zoning Docket K -570.A2 The Kemersville Board of Aldermen will hold a public hearing regarding this petition on Tuesday, January 12, 2016 at 7:00 p.m. in the Kemersville Municipal Council Chamber at Town Hall, 134 East Mountain Street, behind the Library and Chamber of Commerce. This notice is being sent to you because your property is either included in this request or it abuts to or is located directly across a street or road from the property proposed for a zoning classification amendment. This notice is provided in pursuant to N.C. General Statute 160A-384. The purpose of the public hearing is to gather citizen comments. For those citizens that cannot attend, written comments are encouraged. The Board of Aldermen's policy is to limit the time of public comments with the total time allocation for both those in favor and those in opposition being twenty (20) minutes per side. If you have any questions concerning this petition, please contact. the Kemersville Community Development Department by mail at P.O. Box 728, Kemersville, NC 27285; at (336) 992-0605; by email at cd@toknc.com; or visit Staff at Town Hall. Keith Hooker Town Clerk ALDERMEN Kenny Crews - Irving Neal - Joe L. Pinnix Jr. - Tracey H. Shiftlour — Chris Thompson NORTH CAROLINAS PIEDMONT TRIAD