Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0047597_Renewal (Application)_20151030 (2) C Effluent Toxicity Report Form - Chronic Pass/Fail and Acute LC50 Date: 04/27/12 Facility: CITY OF DURHAM-SDWRF NPDES#: NCO047597 Pipe#: 001 County: DURHAM La�A�atoPerm Test: TRITEST, INC. { Comments: Xi gn Zre of Operator in Responsible Charge X � ✓i' '�_... Signature of Laboratory Supervisor * PASSED: 2.26% Reduction Work Order: 1204-01297 Environmental Sciences Branch MAIL ORIGINAL TO: Div. of Water Quality N.C. DENR 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Chronic Pass/Fail Reproduction Toxicity Test Chronic Test Results Calculated t = 0.395 Tabular t = 2.508 CONTROL ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 % Reduction = 2.26 % Mortality Avg.Reprod. # Young Produced 22 29 26 22 20 18 28 24 29 29 32 31 0.00 25.83 Control Control Adult (L)ive (D)ead L L L L L L L L L L L L 0.00 25.25 Treatment 2 Treatment 2 Effluent %: 90% TREATMENT 2 ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Control CV V 17.611% PASS FAIL # Young Produced 20 24 24 28 24 27 29 26 24 25 26 26 % control orgs X producing 3rd brood Check One Adult (L) ive (D)ead L L L L L L L L L L L L 91.7% lst sample 1st sample 2nd sample Complete This For Either Test pH Test Start Date: 04/18,/12 Control 8.25 7.95 7.80 7.88 7.47 7.78 Collection (Start) Date Sample 1: 04/16/12 Sample 2: 04/18/12 Treatment 2 8.32 8.09 7.77 8.12 8.03 7.93 Sample Type/Duration - 2nd 1st P/F s s s Grab Comp. Duration D t e t e t e I S S a n a n a n Sample 1 X 24 hrs L A A r d r d r d U M M t t t Sample 2 X 24 hrs T P P 1st sample 1st sample 2nd sample D.O. Hardness(mg/1) 47 .......... .......... Control 8.14 8.14 8.32 7.84 8.41 7.42 Spec. Cond. (µmhos) 220 526 608 Treatment 2 8.09 7.92 8.15 7.85 8.29 7.13 Chlorine(mg/1) ,,,,,,,, <0.1 <0.1 LC50/Acute Toxicity Test Sample temp. at receipt(OC) 2.5 4.0 (Mortality expressed as %, combining replicates) Note: Please % % % % % % Concentration Complete This Section Also - % - - % % - °s Mortality start/end start/end LC50 = % Method of Determination Control 95% Confidence Limits Moving Average Probit _ -- % Spearman Karber _ Other High Conc. IE pH D.O. Organism Tested: Ceriodaphnia dubia Duration(hrs) : Copied ,from DWQ form AT-1 (3/87) rev. 11/95 (DUBIA ver. 4 .41) ( • Effluent Toxicity Statistical Results - Chronic Pass/Fail Date: 04/27/12 Facility: CITY.OF DURHAM-SDWRF NPDES#: N00047597 Pipe#: 001 County:DURHAM Laboratory Performing Test: TRITEST, INC. Reduction: 2.26% CONTROL 90% Effluent # Replicates 12 12 Female Live 12 12 Adult Male 0 0 Adult Dead 0 0 Adult Mortality 0.00% 0.0016 # Neonates 310 303 Mean # Neonates 25.833 25.250 Standard Deviation 4.549 2.340 Coefficient of Variation 17.6111 Fisher's Exact Test CI A = 12 B = 12 a = 12 b \ 12 a/A = 1.00 b/B = 1.00 Success is: survival Critical b value = 8 12 > 8 The test concludes that the proportion of survival is not significantly different for the control and the effluent groups. Test Passes! SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA ORDERED OBSERVATIONS i Group Neonates Centered i Group Neonates Centered 1 C 18 -7.8333 13 E 26 0.7500 ,! 2 C 20 -5.8333 14 E 26 0.7500 3 E 20 -5.2500 15 E, 26 0.7500 4 C 22 -3.8333 16 E 27 1.750.0 5 C 22 -3.8333 17 C 28 2.1667 6 C 24 -1.8333 18 E 28 2.7500 7 E 24 -1.2500 19 C 29 3.1667 8 E 24 -1.2500 20 C 29 3.1667 9 E 24 -1.2500 21 C 29 3 .1667 10 E 24 -1.2500 22 E 29 3.7500 11 E 25 -0.2500 23 C 31 5.1667 12 C 26 0.1667 24 C 32 6.1667 t • SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA (cont. ) COEFFICIENTS AND DIFFERENCES i x(n-i-1) x(i) a(i) x(n-i-1) - x(i) 1 6.1667 -7.8333 0.4493 14.0000 2 5.1667 -5.8333 0.3098 11.0000 3 3.7500 -5.2500 0.2554 9.0000 4 3.1667 -3.8333 0.2145 7.0000 5 3.1667 -3.8333 0.1807 7.0000 6 3.1667 -1.8333 0.1512 5.0000 7 2.7500 -1.2500 0.1245 4.0000 8 2.1667 -1.2500 0.0997 3.4167 9 1.7500 -1.2500 0.0764 3.0000 10 0.7500 -1.2500 0.0539 2.0000 11 0.7500 -0.2500 0.0321 1.0000 12 0.7500 0.1667 0.0107 0.5833 1 W = X 279.9928 287.9167 Calculated W = 0.972 Critical W = 0.884 0.972 >_ 0.884 C� The reproduction data is normally distributed evaluated at a 990 confidence interval. Test Passes! F test for Homogeneity of Variance Control variance 20.6970 F = _ = 3.78 Effluent variance 5.4773 Numerator degrees of freedom: 11 Denominator degrees of freedom: 11 Critical F = 5.32 3.78 s 5.32 =► The Test PASSES, the variances of the two groups are significantly the same, homogeneous. • EQUAL VARIANCE t TEST 25.8 - 25.3 = o.395 t = 1.477 Degrees of freedom = 22 Critical t = 2.508 0.395 < 2.508 Test passed. There is not a significant difference in reproduction between the Control and the effluent evaluated at a 99% confidence interval* a Chronic Test PASSES CI Ceriodaphnia dubia Chronic Pass/Ficity Test • Client: Cr 5�vj�(LF NPDES#: NC Culture Trans er(Date/Time): Wei �r� /R Organism Born(Date/Time): 41 z / tib- Days Fed By Time Age of Organism: '-7 f�f5 Time Fed(Culture): 1� cw� '� Da 0 d. a Dilution Wate Batch: u } y� — Organism source:LZ Lc 4 }�y Temp Dilution Water: I-S.� Da 1 �. Start Date: W 1 Time:- - Temp stock solution 2__ Day 2 1"Transfer Date: 1,.fIL Time: Analyst: Pte- Randomized: � Incubator: �}- 2"d Transfer Date; �- Analyst: � Day 3 �S X325 Time: =Sam Analyst: �U Day4 Ending Date: z•- Z Time: Z, ,,, (�r0 ................................. _ _ _ _ _ Analyst:— Reviewed by: P� Day 5 � Control . . . . ._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._._.-•-•-•-•-•-•-•-•-•-._. Da 2 I 2 3 4 _ _ _ _ - - - - - : Day c. 101''n" 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Collection(Start)Da�Iv # Young Produced 6 Adult: Live Dead1=`SarnPle: 20'Sample: Sample Type/Duration Day 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 i Grab Composite Duration #Young Produced 12 V Sample y G��a SIIZ (o to . v , 2- 1, (a 1 a : Adult: Live, Dead . � ! 2 Sample Day 7 1 - 2 3 4 5 6 7 # Young Produced 8 9 10 11 12 ! Control 1° Sample 2" Sample Hardness Adult: Live, Dead `3 `( m Conductivity 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 S/cm ' L!Total Produced .z� .Z9 Chlorine Zc( Zq 32 �3 m Effluent % Sample Temp L °C Da 2 1 2 3 4 a'S v 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 #Young Produced ; pH 100% Adult: Live, Dead L ; Da 5 Pg Start End Start End Start End 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 # Young Produced Control �5 ' �g ►z Adult: Live, DeadTreatment cr t_ S-I)- Z•CIA -�-,1-4 Da 7 D.O. Start End StartEnd—] Start End 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 # Young Produced C� 1a ,I Control kc) o Adult: Live, DeadTreatment -9 Temp. Start End Start End Start End 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 ' #Total Produced -L Z 2 ' ` v 2 Z� 2(rJ control X5. 1 aS,o. as -•-•-•---•-•- - - - - - - - -•- - - - - - - - -•-._._._._._._._._._._:_.tI Treatment 1,ixi v ,r Tritest, Inc. ( � Bioassay Chain of Custody Form Facility Name: C %'±!, OR F Address: &60 F-Aq P.-Wcl kV P.O. Box: Phone#:_(I_ z) �ln 0 ` 4 324 ,"/-7 Contact: d w Pn C/'70/v County: 3>tWfe n'/117 NPDES permit#: 60y 7 5-1-7 pipe 601 % Effluent Dilution(IWC): Test Method: Plant Flow: Sample Collector: Print Signature Sample Type: Composite Date Started 14-16•-)L Time: 01:00 M r PM Date Ended . jz Time: ;o o M r PM Samples per Hr: #Hrs: Grab _ Date: Time: AM or PM C� Sample Volume: , aT .L Chilled during Collection Ye or No Method of Transportation to the Lab Chain of Custody Release Relinquished By Date Time- Received By Date ITime 13 'o a q-r7- oca Comments: For Tritest, Inc. Use Only Tritest Work Order Number. • Receiving Temperature: Residual Chlorine: Received By. #of Bottles Received: TriTest,Inc.Address:6701 Conference Dr.,Raleigh,NC 27607 Phone:(919)834-4984 Tritest, Inc. (• Bioassay Chain of Custody Form Facility Name: ��►j L��= �l/R h�g��-, S' t� l- Address: C6 C.5-, rgjL,R n.;w P_O. Box: A / C4ffiPe L k},l Phone#: _( r I O Lf 3 1►'C ,Z`�S�j`) Contact: Ap 7)6_e S d N County: SUR hAn-, NPDES permit#: Q 75-__0/ pipe: Q 6 % Effluent Dilution(IWC): Test Method: Plant Flow: J • Sample Collector: Print C19W LcS v cel Signature Sample Type: i-amposite Date Started + -)2--Time: :oo.(9br PM Date Ended L4 -)q. j mime: ;o O or PM Sample per Hr: #Hrs: Grab Date: Time: AM or PM Sample Volume: l Q•T- L Chilled during Collection?• (S)r No Method of Transportation to the Lab: Chain of Custody Release R i quished By Date Time- Received By Date Time -*1:.pS lfoS -1 -I 1 -l-4- -L 1_r Comments: l For Tritest, Inc. Use Only Tritest Work Order Number: 1 d0 y-D«� Receiving Temperature: Residual Chlorine: Received By. #of Bottles Received: Tri-rest,Inc.Address:6701 Conference Dr.,Raleigh,NC 27607 Phone:(919)834-4984 Effluent Toxicity Report Form - Chronic Pass/Fail and Acute LC50 Date: 04/26/12 Facility: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES#: NC0047597 Pipe#: 001 County: DURHAM rator Perform i Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. Comments: dilution water batch 1 Signature of Operator in Response e 2hZe and 2 used. X Signature of La oratory Supervisor Work Order: Environmental Sciences Branch MAIL ORIGINAL TO: Div. of Water Quality N.C. DENR 1621 Mail Service Center North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 Chronic Pass/Fail Reproduction Toxicity Test Chronic Test Results Calculated t = 9.271 Tabular t = 2.508 CONTROL ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 % Reduction = 47.96 % Mortality Avg.Reprod. # Young Produced 16 20 19 20 20 18 16 21 14 23 19 15 0.00 18.42 Control Control Adult (L) ive (D)ead L L L L L L L L L L L L 0.00 9.58 Effluent %: 909. Treatment 2 Treatment 2 TREATMENT 2 ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Control CV 14.544% PASS FAIL Edult Produced 11 10 '10 11 9 12 ll 8 5 11 8 9 % control orgs X producing 3rd L) ive (D)ead L L L L L L L L 1 L brood L L L 100% Check One 1st sample 1st sample 2nd sample Complete This For Either Test pH Test Start Date: 04/18/12 Control 8.13 8.03 8.07 8.14 8.22 7.96 Collection (Start) Date Sample 1: 04/16/12 Sample 2: 04/18/12 Treatment 2 7.72 7.93 7.77 8.05 7.88 8.03 Sample Type/Duration 2nd 1st P/F s s s Grab Comp. Duration D t e t e t e I S S a n a n a n Sample 1 X 24 hrs L A A r d r d r d U M M t t t Sample 2 X 24 hrs T P P 1st sample, 1st sample 2nd sample D.O. Hardness(mg/1) 42 .......... .......... Control 7.72 7.46 7.67 7.41 7.70 7.25 Spec. Cond. (pmhos) 175 498 564 Treatment 2 7.96 7.30 7.88 7.64 7.96 7.43 Chlorine(mg/1) ,,,,,,,, <0.1 <0.1 LC50 Acute Toxicity Test Sample temp. at receipt(OC) ,,,,,,,, 1.2 0.6 (Mortality expressed as %, combining replicates) ffSoec' tion Alsote: Please Concentration mplete This % % % Mortality start/end start/end LC50 = % Method of Determination Control 7-1 95% Con i ence Limits Moving Average Probit -- % Spearman Karber _ Other - High Conc. pH D.O. Organism Tested: Ceriodaphnia dubia Duration(hrs) : Copied from DWQ form AT-1 (3/87) rev. 11/95 (DUBIA ver. 4.41) Meritec 60 Mini Chronic Pa /F ill Tedaphnia dubia Incubator#:* ' Dlient: r tn1. Pipe#: Count � r' �1 Y U VA Date Start. L4 -1 V-1 Z Date End: —t-1-2S i VPDES#: NC_-0004 7 Date/Time of Culture Transfer: IT1 5L /iQ :dqAjA Time Start: lU —c,�AK\ Time End: f ;J Dilution Water: Lake RoWs"" Date/Time Neonates born: M 1st Renewal Date: `� -ZD -1 L Time: M fest Organism Source: TrayVRandomized:UY Age of Neonates at Test Start: � hours 2nd Renewal Date: �(-23 -/z Time: = �5 747jn Stirred/Aerated for D.O.: Y /NCulture Tray Temp: L Y.9 °C Analyst(s): mer, MR, ST Reviewed by: /VV— Control y: — Control Organism Reproduction _Collection (Start) Dates: RgK#2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Sample 1 �� l�'#Young Produced 0 0 0 0 O O O O p Adults Live/ Dead Sample Information Da #5 1 2 4 5 6 7, A. At 10 11 1 100% pH G/C? Duration #Young Produced b 3 117 3 ,Sy 3 - � � 72//- Sample 1 �. (p hours Adults Live/Dead L— lr 1 1 - L L Sample 2 7, Z hours D !y#7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Transferred by: Fed by Batch # Sample Sample #Young Produced ' z- ' 2 Day 0 WYL- ln� Adults Live/Dead Cr L L ptE,"s�" , ,�.a•Rr: � � L� � Transfer Day 0 2 �j ,f��,�:a�, i "�°�II�'� Day 1 '.i i ;� X11.9, �- Hardness �L � iltN' 'i, Day 2 Z lr ii Total Produced r0 � � � - (mg/l-) •�`��`' �*t' _ � 1 Spec.Cond. ^� /_ )�(��y_ ,I Day 3 o (urnhos/cm) 11 M -i�1 s (J4 Day 4 Percent of Control producing third brood /° Chlorine ytIN « Ftp, Day 5.�`r'� Test Sample Organism Reproduction (ms/�) Ti �' "'"�p',g {� ( 0.I C� Receipt Sample y..♦� }"y iii roti tPJ;j fu�1" Day 6 c,l Effluent%: _70-1 Temp.(°C) !; i1;ri 2;19 "" i l ;.A' A Terminated by: PAy#2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ' 10 11 12 pH 1st Sample 2nd Sample 2nd Sample #Young Produced O O O 0 C) 0 U 0 r-> 0 O Control i 3 $.o3 '910? 'V q Z -7.q Adults Live/ Dead Sample Da #5 1 2 4 5 �L6 7 8 9 1 11 12 initial final 5-tial final initial final #Young Produced 3 3 T 3 FLWD.O. 1st Sample 2nd Sample 2nd Sample Adults Live/ Dead i_ L (^ (� y. L L_ L 7 4� 70 7.7-1 Control 77 7.(07 7� � �� Pi!y#7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 #Young Produced 10 ! r / �j Sample 7.ao " 7-�gl 7 -3 -9b �.q Adults Live/Dead {� [� radial final initial final initial final Temp. 1st Sample 2nd Sample 2nd Sample Total Produced 1 9 1J Control t4'� ZVO Zq,? 2q.t/ zqj� Comments:l�r W.NSrn lvcc-l' r711 �� S zr ) r�.;�'i .� Sam le z�l,y zd,[o �a,0 2V•`/ p.1, - `/ 1 f v v/ ' C rO,) {vv „ '3� 0it I initial final initial final initial final MERITECH, INC. Mentech Sample ID#; f n Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody rt��.� 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 • Email: txmrtech(a-D_bellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client:__ C, )nn!:�j til- Pu A h.,A9 SD W/r E PO#: Contact Person: 12 Dock 0,N NPDES#: NC Q 0 y 7 5 7 Address: F: r/"t :,(Vg J-C,) J lf'y/n/ Phone: 9/e_i -5-2"r , q3n City: c li tJ rk-L- Pipe#: n 1 i County: 'r,>(,//C h,3n.., State, Zip: :;4.7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sam pie Site: PLntj'T- G'rj_Z---4,&-&7— Sample -& '— Sample Type: ❑Grab (Composite #of containers: Sampling Time: Start Date: - ��. /l. Start Time: !0 0 AM PM End Date: —7, f—) End Time: 0 O (2Sg�>PM — CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL (no air space), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH E*' Collector's Name: Print: G/7, f4 (.E.� G'OC/re/L Signature: �� TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: Vt5hronic(7 days) Test Organism: Ceriodaphnia dubia (water flea) �� ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales prome/as (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations (if multiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: Date: 4=-/7-/z Time* PM Received by: Date: �4-/7./2�- Time: '/ '` IV PM /� Relinquished by: �M�Cjrf2l d _r-ra1'teA Date: Time: AM C9 Received by: Date: q-1 7-�/Z Time- / 113 S AM M Relinquished by: ����—�� Date: �/7—/ 2- Time: /SSS AM �M Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX �Meritech Pick-up ** Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) 0elinquished by: �kv)c .n_�) Received by: W-o{,J r tri u- Date: 4-/:7- )2 Time: AM PM Sample Temperatures(°C): f •Z / 1,2- / / Sample Condition: -L-� WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy MERITECH, INC. Mentech Sample ID# Bioassay Sample Chain of Custodv _ 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 ~ Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 • Email: txmrtech cDbellsouth.net Web Site. www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: /TY al-- _ PO#: Contact Person: /300 Po0SoIV NPDES#: NC 0 0 SLZS'97 Address: o'0_' F6oXR11VG7-PN /?cam Phone: 9/Y--reo -L/3g� City: PCL %//LL Pipe#: a 0/ County: VuRHd M. State: /1/0 Zip: 27 /7' SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: /C'L 19/I/7� L��L�cE rvT Sample Type: ❑Grab Composite #of containers: Sampling Time: Start Date: 2 Start Time: 9.'O o W PM End Date: End Time: 9:p Q PM CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN 49 AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE *'*SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL (no airspace), CHILLEDAN/D,COV RED/WNITH Collector's Name: Print: C/��1,CLc �'nC(�'C/t Signature: L Wi t.i TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: [+Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: ZCeriodaphnia dubia (water flea) �� ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) fwc: % Test Concentrations (if multiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: � C�j�r Date: Time: 9;/s' A PM Received by: COLO ito o M. Date: `f-/9•i_ Time: do PM 1 Relinquished by: [ Date: f-{ [�-1 7, Time: -2�! zD AM Received by, �Z_fL— Date: l �/-/ Z Time: Z AM Relinquished by: Date: bf-/17-/ Time, +j�3 S AM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX ❑ Meritech Pick-up ** Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** W-HI Ick SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) •3elinquished by: lay�U- ) Received by: � `�� Date: - - /Z. Time. 7 AM Sample Temperatures(°C): Q• G / D fo / / Sample Condition: WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA (cont.) I • COEFFICIENTS AND DIFFERENCES i x(n-i-1) x(i) a(i) x(n-i-1) - x(i) 1 4.5833 -4.5833 0.4493 9.1666 2 2.5833 -4.4167 0.3098 7.0000 3 2.4167 -3 .4167 0.2554 5.8334 4 1.5833 -2.4167 0.2145 4.0000 5 1.5833 -2.4167 0.1807 4.0000 6 1.5833 -1.5833 0.1512 3 .1666 7 1.4167 -1.5833 0.1245 3 .0000 8 1.4167 -0.5833 0.0997 2 .0000 9 1.4167 -0.5833 0.0764 2.0000 10 1.4167 -0.4167 0.0539 1.8334 11 0.5833 0.4167 0.0321 0.1666 12 0.5833 0.4167 0.0107 0.1666 1 W = X 113.8114 119.8333 Calculated W = 0.950 Critical W = 0.884 0.950 a 0.884 The reproduction data is normally distributed evaluated at a 99% confidence interval. Test Passes! F test for Homogeneity of Variance Control variance 7.1742 F = _ = 1.93 Effluent variance 3 .7197 Numerator degrees of freedom: 11 Denominator degrees of freedom: 11 Critical F = 5.32 1.93 s 5.32 =► The Test PASSES, the variances of the two groups are significantly the same, homogeneous. / SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA (cont. ) 1 COEFFICIENTS AND DIFFERENCES i x(n-i-1) x(i) a(i) x(n-i-1) - x(i) 1 4.5833 -4.5833 0.4493 9.1666 2 2.5833 -4.4167 0.3098 7.0000 3 2.4167 -3.4167 0.2554 5.8334 4 1.5833 -2.4167 0.2145 4.0000 5 1.5833 -2.4167 0.1807 4.0000 6 1.5833 -1.5833 0.1512 3.1666 7 1.4167 -1.5833 0.1245 3 .0000 8 1.4167 -0.5833 0.0997 2.0000 9 1.4167 -0.5833 0.0764 2.0000 10 1.4167 -0.4167 0.0539 1.8334 11 0.5833 0.4167 0.0321 0.1666 12 0.5833 0.4167 0.0107 0.1666 _ 1 - W = X 113.8114 119.8333 Calculated W = 0.950 Critical W = 0.884 0.950 z: ,0.884 The reproduction data is normally distributed evaluated at a 99% confidence interval. Test Passes! F test for Homogeneity of Variance Control variance 7.1742 F _ = 1.93 Effluent variance 3.7197 Numerator degrees of freedom: 11 Denominator degrees of freedom: 11 Critical F = 5.32 1.93 s 5.32 =► The Test PASSES, the variances of the two groups are significantly the same, homogeneous. EQUAL VARIANCE t TEST 18.4 - 9.6 t 9.271 0.953 Degrees of freedom = 22 Critical t = 2.508 ' - 9.271 > 2.508 • Test fails. There is a significant difference in reproduction between the Control and the effluent evaluated at a 990 confidence interval. =Chronic Test FAILS The mean # of young produced by each -group is dissimilar 4 DURHAM Administration / CITY OF DURHAM 919-560-4381 V DEPARTMENT OF WATER MANAGEMENT Customer Billing Services • 101 CITY HALL PLAZA• DURHAM, NC 27701 919-560-4412 919-560-4381 • FAX 919-560-4479 Laboratory Services www.durhamnc.gov 919-560-4386 h 8 6 9 Plant Maintenance 1 919-560-4388 CITY OF MEDICINE ,. Regulatory Compliance 919-560-4381 Wastewater Treatment North-919-560-434 March 28, 2012 South-919-560-4336 Water Supply&Treatment Williams-919-560-4349 Brown-919-560-4362 Water&Sewer Maintenance Environmental Sciences Branch 919-560-4344 Division of Environmental Management North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources 1621 Mail Service Center v Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1621 SUBJECT: March Toxicity Testing - 2012 South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 Please find enclosed the toxicity results for the-South-Durham-Water-------------- Reclamation he-South-DurhamWater----------- -Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 conducted in March 2012. As a result of the January failure,we are running the multiple dilution analyses in February and March. The first test was completed on February 8, 2012 and was marked invalid by Meritech due to quality control problems in the lab. The second analysis was completed on February 29, 2012 and indicated a 58.1%chronic value. This result showed a chronic value-of-82.16%. These analyses were completed by Meritech, Inc., 642 Tamco Road, Reidsville,North Carolina. We have scheduled three additional analyses in the month of March with Meritech and Tritest laboratories. We are continuing to pursue possible sources of to by contacting industries and septage haulers as well as analyzing additional metals samples on the effluent. If you have any questions,please call me at 919-560-4386. S' rely, 0'1� Robert Dodson • Superintendent enclosures Good Things Are Happening In Durham Effluent Aquatic Toxicity Report Form / Phase II Chronic Ceriodaphnia Facility: South Durham NPDES:# 'NCOO 47597 Pipe#: 001 County: Durham " ' /0tory Performin est: Meritech, Inc. Comments: : d- Signature of O.R.0 Signature of Laboratory Supervisor Sample Information Sample 1 Sample 2 Control Test Start Date End Date StartTime End Time ' 3/5/12 3/7/12 - � Information3/7/12 3/14/12 10:39 AM 10:52 AM Collection Start Date � " ;. Start Renew 1 Renew 2 Start Renew 1 Renew 2 Grab _ 100 % 100 % 100 % Control 'Control Control Treatment Composite k 7.73 7.76 7.70 8.27 8.18 8.21 (Duration) 24.0 -24.0 pH Initial x ' 46 Hardness(mg/I) 44 pH Final 8.20 8.23 8.18 8.08 8.08 799 D O.Initial 8.46 8.06 8.21 7.63 7.68 7.63 Spec.Cord.(pmhos/cm) . 457 , 525 193 167 D.O.Final 7,19 7.24 7.35 7.38 7.14 7.37 Chlorine(mg/1) <0.1 <0.1 emp.Initial 25.1 24.9 24.7 25.1 25.0 25.3 �d }a- 24.5 24.6 24.8 24.5 24.6 24.8Sam le temp.at receipt 1.0 oC 1.Q oC Organism# Chronic Test Results 1 2 --3 - 4..- 5 .6 .. 7 8 9 10. 11.... 12 Mean- Final Control Mortality% 0 Control #Young 16 -1617 16 18 18 1:8 23 22 16 Fla.0 %Control 3rd brood 90 Adult L L L- I-L - L L' L L L L Control Repro CV 14.1 :� 48 Hour Mortality Control IWC • 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Mean O Of 10 0, Of 10 Effluent% #Young - 21 22 201 "21 16 21 19 23 22 20.5 Significant? ,Y N Adult L L L L L I L I L I L I L L Final Mortality Significant @ 22.5 (L)ive(D)ead or . No Conc 1 2 3` 4 5 ' 6 7 8 '9 10 '-Mean Reproduction Analysis: Effluent%, #Young 15 16 18 20 21 .22 21 20 17 1918.9 Repro.LOEC= 90 4- %; ;,NOEC= 75 % Adult L L L L L L L L L L R� Method: Dunnett's Test 4rj (L)ive(D)ead 5.0 Normal Distrib? YES Method Kolmogorov 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean Statistic: 0.5714 Critical 1.035 . Effluent% #Young Equal Variances? YES Method: Bartlett 16 13 10 11 19 15 15 1 14 19 17 14.9 Statistic. 13.2481- Critical. 15.09 Adult 75 (L)ive(D)ead L Lx Red' L L L L L L L L • 17.2 Non-Parametric Analysis(if applicable): - Method: 1 2 3 4 5 6 - 7 8 .9 10 Mean Effluent% Rank Sum Critical Sum -Effluent% #Young 3 9 9- 1- 9 6 11 2 21 12 4 8.6 (L)ive(D)ead L L D L L- - L L L L L.. %R°a 9Q 52.2 - t 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean Overall Analysis: Effluent% #Young 7 9 1 4 13 17 12 6 1 13 9 12 10.2 Result=PASS/FAIL or Adult %Red Test LOEC= 90 %; NOEC= 75 % 101J (L)ive(D)ead L L, D L L L L' L L L 433 82.16 % ' Chronic-Value= ATT; Environmental Sciences Branch ` Should use highest test concentration or highest MAIL Div..of Water Quality concentration with D.O.>5 0 mg/I N.C.DENR t Reduction from Control Reproduction Mean TO; 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh,NC 27699-1621 DWQ form AT-3 (8/91)Rev.11%95 C _ ENVIRONMENTAL LABORATORIES A Division of Water Techno/ogy and Conrro/s, Multi-dilutional Ceriodaphnia dubia Chronic Definitive Test Data Sheet Test Effluent Information: Dilution Water: Lake Reidsville Client: ��fyti -. �Uvl '' Hardness Conductivity NPDES#: two -Op L? SR? Batch# Transfer Day (mg/L CaCO3) (umhos/cm) 3- n� 0 (/� 113 2 Y / 1st Sample 2nd Sample Collection Start Date 3�S(/Z-- 3�72- Sample D.O.Adjustment: Sample Type/Duration C! -Z q C L q Stirred Aerated None Conductivity (umhos/cm) - . :7L L - Residual Chlorine (mg .Temperature(°C) I (}, Neonates: -M 10.0% pH %� Tray.#:'.. ..,..., - - Transfer Date/Time: 3-�-1Z Incubator#: Born"Date/Time` 3-lv-�Z / `E� -3TS� — Temp. of Stock:, ` °C Age st Start of;Test; zz 8 : __ t hours -Randomization: Yes .. . No - Test Start, Renewal,°and End Dates/Times: Test Trarisferred;by: ° Test Fed By:._ Start Date: 3 i Z -- Time: 103 Start: Start: _ ►�� ` Day 1: l 1 st Renewal Date: 3 /i L . Time: �1 y �- �l Day2: Da 2: ^- R r 2nd Renewal Date:; _.3- Day 3: iz-�4- Time: %S ,t �) Day'5: ���� . Day 4:, 1, . Day 5. End_Date: e: /,-) A4ry Terminated: Day 6: S5V Chemical and Physical Determinations: `,Test Start. . ..1 st'Renewal' -2nd Renewal - - Start...: -End jStart ,.End. r� Start End pH ,Control., - g 2-, 101 High Cohc. ?'�� .Z� :Control . 7.03 7,3 g 7 7.r D. ,. 3 HighCoiic. �. �� r* ��� �� �.7 . :� Temp. :Control 2S. Z�,S Z Z.7-�0 3 � �:5 High Conc. ZS" 2 .� L>< 7 'i , l P/ l% `[ : � 0 Ivlernecn, mc. Ceriodaphnia dubia Chronic Multidilutional Reproduction Client: 1.Jy v`�ti,nti- S��C 1"� Start Date: �'7�/Z Start Time: D� `Os" NPDES#: NC E*j�t4�S�t 7 End Date: ;3/11///Z__ End Time:' S -Analyst(s): - S Revie'wed'by:' � Replicates Day# 1 2 3 4 = 5 6 7 8 9 10 %3rd Brood 2 control 5 l �. -� ?> Sf, C.V. Mean: `I ,. 7 • `d EReproduction � - Total < 7 2 7L7 .57% 5 7Y dv Total `�-f -1 I n % RED. 177 2 Total.. p % RED. E FE] -Sc 2 Q O O Total = y % RED. J 2 0 p O O. O ,v TotalJ I R % RED. .. 2 0 O. Total / ro .} % RED. I • t-fi..i r�,r�L• • ��:. '� �t c} �2+r d.�� y� 8 r S•c:, --)�"�:�- ;�/IrC� ��� , '�� .�o� - MERITECH, INC. MentechSample ID# Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 . Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 Email: txmrtech'Obellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: l sJ h ��%ll'mg 51� vit;,t- PO#: Contact Person: /fie,ct S e.,til NPDES#:;NC - or,1-p7 Address: X,,VV Teti/ Phone: ! City. C A 00 g, L' h z // Pipe#. G, ', County: 0 U P_A,r3r,n State: `) Zijf7�71!7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: I / _f L� I i r tJ Sample Type: ❑Grab Z Composite #of containers: Sampling Tine: Start Date: }�- ! L Start Time: PM. End Date: -S ( (.'j < End Time:- .,��M PM:-.+ CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BETAKEN ; 'AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no air space), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print: Kl��,r-.,� .�; y/ S 7r, , Signature:, ,TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION I Test Required:]_ Chronic(7 days) Test Organism '❑ Cerioda`phnia dubia (water flea) t L_i c-'- 'i2 4-4Pi,i0ilrS} - Y , ❑•"r�`i.:Gp ai }7+w�a:as (fathead npinno`."r'} = 4 'M)sidopsis Bahia (shrimp) � C: I t% _ Test'Concerifrations''ifmtlti le'dilutions-)': ( P- Comments: `�" (?(r'-i' 1`'U. SX!PP Relinquished by: - .� ,;Date" _ ! Timer ' '`� ' \AM PM Received by: ;- (; , h = Date:' (. Time: +�}LM�� PM Relinquished by: �• Date: �. Jt Time: (L AM P _ Received b �`' - �= - Date:' ? Ti z Y• - f m -r� ,AM M) Relinquished by Date: 3 Ci. /Z., Time: AM Received by: Date: Time: AM pM. Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date; Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment:;❑ UPS ❑ ,' Fed EX 'P� Meritech Pick=up ** Samples shipped on-Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday`delivery :- . :,. SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use-Only) Relinquished by., K'_Z. 6 Received by: �.,t,v r,q nu_ Date: f Z Time: �(^ 1� AM CPU) Sample Temperatures(°C): j,0 ! f,ei / / Sample Condition': WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy MERITECH, IN-C. Meritech Sample ID# Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 Phone: 1-336-3424748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 • Email: txmrtech(a)bellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com 'CLIENT INFORMATION Client: PO#. Contact Person: A 1; NPDES#: NC C-)C)L117_5 Address: Phone: I City: tip X it Pipe#: County: Ou/ /1/9"n State: /LJCI Zip: SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: P 1,4r,07- f--(rFL 7- Sample Type: D Grab Composite #of containers: Sampling Time: Start Date: Start Time- AM PM End Date: .3 � End Time: PM — CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no air space), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH IC P E Collector's Name: Print: CJI)XV_T % Signature: TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: Ej Ceriodaphnia dubia (water flea) ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) L_j r--1 Pittiept, nz— *aIes proatas (flatheadiminnow) E] Mysidopsisbahia (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: /)-I Li IT-Z Ph- J) L ta f--, i;e tJ SHIPPING INFORM ATION Date: Time: (LM Relinquished by: PM Received by: Cf =Ih­ll ("Lrlo rni Date: 2_ Time: Relinquished by Date: T 9--., Time: A Received by: Date: 3ZEL Time* 133,(f) AM Relinquished by: Date: _3/ $ A-2_ Time: /5-10 AM (�M� Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(OC): Method of Shipment: 0 UPS El Fed EX Meritech Pick-up Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) Relinquished by: R6i D,/l6 Received by: Date: 12- Time: /5/0 AM* PM Sample Temperatures('C)- I.0 Sample Condition: WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy Title: south durham File : southdurham Transform: NO TRANS FORMATIPI,7 ,Kolmogorov Test"";for Normality - --------------------------------------------------------------------------- D = 0. 0728 -(P-'value > 0 . 100) D* = 0. 5714 Critical D* = 1 . 035 (alpha = 0 . 01 , N '= 60) 0 . 895 (alpha = 0. 05 , N = 60) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Data PASS normality test (alpha = 0. 01) . Continue analysis.- - ., s Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION • Bartlett ' s Test for Homogeneity of Variance , ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Calculated B1 statistic = 13 .2489 (p-value = 0 . 0212) Data PASS B1 homogeneity test at 0 . 01 level . Continue analysis. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Critical B = 15 . 0863 (alpha = 0 . 01, df = 5) = 11. 0705 (alpha = 0 . 05, df = 5) ; " i Title: south 'durham File : southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATIP" Summary Statistics on Data TABLE 1 of 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- GRP IDENTIFICATION N MIN MAX MEAN --- ---------------- ---- ---------- ---------- ---------- 1 control 10 16 . 0000 23 . 0000 18 . 0000 2 22 .5 10 16 . 0000 23 . 0000 20 .5000 3 45 10 15 .0000 22 . 0000 18 .9000 4 75 10 10 . 0000 19 .0000 14 . 9000 5 90 10 2 . 0000 21. 0000 8 . 6000 6 100 10 4 . 0000 17. 0000 10 .2000 --------=------------------------------------------------------------------- Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION Summary Statistics on Data TABLE 2 of 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- GRP IDENTIFICATION VARIANCESD SEM C.V. --- ---------------- -------------- ---------- ---------- ------ ---- 1 control 6 .4444 2 .5386 0 . 8028 14 .1033 2 122 .5 3 . 8333 1 .9579 0 . 6191 9. 5507 3 45 5 .4333 2 .3310 0 . 7371 12 .3331 4 75 9 .2111 3 . 0350 0 . 9597 20.3690 5 i 90 30.4889 -__5 .5217 1. 7461 64 .2055 6 100 15 .2889 3 . 9101 1.2365 38.3343 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 20 0 20 �ritical Fisher' s value (10,10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 10. Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level . Fisher' s Exact Test NUMBER OF ---------------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10 0 10 90 9 1 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- x TOTAL 19 1 20 Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 9 . ('- Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level . Fisher' s Exact Test NUMBER OF -------------=-------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10 0 10 100 9 1 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 19 1 20 Critical Fisher ' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 9 . Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level . A Summary of Fisher' s Exact Tests ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- NUMBER NUMBER SIG GROUP IDENTIFICATION EXPOSED DEAD 0 . 05 ----- ------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----- CONTROL 10 0 1 22 . 5 10 0 2 45 10 0 3 75 10 0 4 90 10 1 5 100 10 1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -. ---• DURHAM ' o Administration CITY OF DURHAM 919-560-4381 j DEPARTMENT OF WATER MANAGEMENT Customer Billing Services • ' 101 CITY HALL PLAZA• DURHAM, NC 27701 919-560-4412 919-560-4381 • FAX 919-560-4479 Laboratory Services www.durhamnc.gov 919-560-4386 yY 8 6 9 Plant Maintenance l 919-560-4388 CrrY Of MEDICINE • Regulatory Compliance 919-560-4381 Wastewater Treatment North-919-5 60-43 84 March 19, 2012 South-919-560-4336 Water Supply&Treatment Williams-919-560-4349 Brown-919-560-4362 Water&Sewer Maintenance Environmental Sciences Branch 919-560-4344 Division of Environmental Management North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1621 SUBJECT: February Toxicity Testing-2012 South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 Please find enclosed the toxicity results for the South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 conducted in February 2012. As a result of • the January failure, we are running the multiple dilution analyses in February and March. The first test was completed on February 8, 2012 and was marked invalid by Meritech due to quality control problems in the lab. The second analysis was completed on February 29, 2012 and indicated a 58.1% chronic value. These analyses were completed by Meritech, Inc., 642 Tamco Road, Reidsville,North Carolina. We have scheduled four analyses in the month of March with Meritech and Tritest laboratories. We are continuing to pursue_po'ssible_sources_of toxicity by contacting industries and septage haulers as well as analyzing additional metals samples on the effluent. If you have any questions,please call me at 919-560-4386. S' ely, o • Robert Dodson Superintendent enclosures Good Things Are Happening In Durham Effluent Aquatic Toxicity Report Form / Phase II Chronic Ceriodaphnia .A Facility: South Durham NPDES: # NC00 47597 Pipe#: 001 County: Durham Laboratory Performing Test: Meritech, Inc. Comments: lution water batch#936,937 and X 938 used. L4 �_ �'L-'1 ! X Signature of O.R.0 Signature of Laboratory Supervisor Sample Information Sample 1 Sample 2 Control Test Start Date End Date Start Time End Time - Information 2/29/12 3/7/12 10:09am 8:31am Collection Start Date 2/27/12 2/29/12 �_ r=- Start Renew 1 Renew 2 Start Renew 1 Renew 2 Grab ; 100 % 100 % 100 % Control Co Treatment ntrol Control Composite -� (Duration) 24.9 24.0 t �` pH Initial 7.52 7.58 7.58 8.21 8.13 8.16 i H Final 8.19 8.14 8.17 8.02 8.21 7.99 Hardness(mg/1) _ E42 42 p DO Initial 8.10 8.26 8.55 7.56 7.47 7.41 Spec Cond.(pmhos/cm) 533 540 166 167 D 0.Final 7.18 7.00 7.57 7.35 7.40 7.52 , s-a M <,0. <0.1 .._ ,._ �.��.� Temp.Initial 25.5 25.0 24.8 25.5 25.7 255 Sample temp.at receipt 0.6 OC 0.9 0 ;.MAI ;,. Temp Final 24.4 24.3 25.0 24.4 24.3 25.0 Organism# Chronic Test Results 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Mean Final Control Mortality% 0 Control #Young 18 23 16 17 19 22 17 21 22 17 19.2 %Control 3rd brood 100 (L)ive(D)ead L L L L L L L L L LControl Repro CV 13.4 • �, 48 Hour Mortality Control IWC 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Mean 0 Of 10 0 Of 10 Effluent% #Young 18 17 19 SI 18 18 16 15 16 17 16 17.0 Significant? Y N 22,5 (L)i a(D)ead L L L L L L L L L L %Retl Final Mortality Significant @ 11.5 % or No Conc 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean Reproduction Analysis- Effluent% #Young 20 15 15 13 17 15 19 r16.0 Repro L16 15 15OEC= 45 %; NOEL= 22.5 Adult L L D L L L L L L L %Red Method Dunnett'sTest 45 (L)ive(D)ead 16.7 Normal Distrib? YES Method Kolmogorov 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean Statistic, 0.9153 Critical, 1.035 ° Equal Variances? YES Method: Bartlett Effluent/° #Young 20 8 16 14 15 17 7 16 16 14 14.3 Statistic: 14.51*3T Critical Adult %Red 75 (L)ive(D)ead L L L L D L L L L L 25 d Non-Parametric Analysis(If applicable): Method: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean Effluent% Rank Sum Critical Sum Effluent% #Young 13 10 12 11 21 10 11 12 14 1212.6 90 (L)ive(D)ead L L L D L D L L L D 34.4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Mean Overall Analysis: Effluent% #Young 13 21 19 15 14 12 14 23 10 1 12115.3 Result=PASS/FAIL or 100 (L)Ive(D)ead L L D L L L L L D D FRe3d Test LOEC= 75 %; NOEC= 45 % Chronic Value= 58.1 % ATT; Environmental Sciences Branch Should use highest test concentration or highest MAIL Div.of Water Quality concentration with D.0 >5.0 mg/I N.C.DENR t Reduction from Control Reproduction Mean TO: 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh,NC 27699-1621 DWQ form AT-3 (8/91)Rev. 11/95 EN\/IROTIMENTAL t.Aja<3RATORJES l A Division of VVa re/Techr,o/o9y and Congo/s, /nc_ Multi-dilutional Ceriodaphnia dubia Chronic Definitive Test Data Sheet Test Effluent Information: Dilution Water: Lake Reidsville Client: 1�v Yl� Sn U Hardness Conductivity p Batch# Transfer Da (mg/L CaCO3) (umnoslcm) NPDES#: �� CO 0-7�-I � 3 O 2 3�S 5 lla 1 st Sample 2nd Sample Collection Start Date 2'z? Z z 1 zq i z Sample D.O.Adjustment: Sample Type/Durationmi.9 G �rrZ��'� Stirred Aerated None Conductivity (umhos/cm) 33 v Residual Chlorine (mg/1) ��. <0• a Neonates: Temperature(°C) ©•to �• (�/ 100% pH ,�j� �O Tray#: - -- Transfer Date/Time: Incubator#: _ Born Date/Time: �' A e") Temp. of Stock: °C Age at Start of Test: hours Randomization: Yes No Test Start, Renewal, and End Dates/Times: l�9 Test Transferred by: Test Fed By: 2 Start Date: 24 %Z X Time: Q- Start:_�_ Start: _ Day 1: 1st Renewal Date: J� Z/iZ Time: �� �o�P9 Day 2: Day 2: _ _ Day 3: 2nd Renewal Date: 3 JZ Time: gwo2,gm Day 5: Day 4: � C Day 5: End Date: 3 J� Time: 0 ���1� Terminated: Day 6: Chemical and Physical Determinations: Test Start 1st Renewal 2nd Renewal Start End Start End Start End Control �,Z ,(�Z ��. ��j g•ZJ� F pH �.5Z g• /. 5 i High Conc. T � Control s(� .�j �> X 7 0' - • r�� D.O. High Conc. $.�� ��l O J t Zl� too d�5 ?.�7 7 Control . `�3 Temp. High Conc. 2�. Z [ , 2 FJ_ C) 2 1.3 25,E ivlernecn, Inc. Ceriodaphnia dubia Chronic Multidilu/tional Reproduction Client: t'�nr�►rn - J Start Date: Z- Start Time: NPDES#: NC L4 7 5, -1? 7 End Date: Z/-7 A Z End Time: 3 ,-n Analyst(s):�M2/Me�; s-r— Reviewed by: ItL Replicates Day# 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 %3rd �Brood control 5 -3 Lf P7 IKP Li C.V. Mean \7 d' v e,� Reproduction Total a3 /(o / v /7LZ I 2 Q 0 Q Q O 0 G � 22.5% 5 3 9 3 7 , Total % RED. , 2 0 O © Q 5 S' 3 7 p S— Total % RED. 2 Q O G D 0 o p ��ve• +s 5 7 ------ Total j % RED. r� 2 0 Q d V % 5 ['p l 36. 3 a 7 dAD 5 o -P 0 - -D I � ry Total 3 /© j 1 / a % RED. 5 U --- © Li 7 r 3 Total j % RED. , Go1G ¢c`�tC De,,d bolaef, Law Peer OeV'I 1Dn a.,3`7-la. C��.}.01 )A A on 3-7-1x. MERITECH INC. MeritechSample ID#. ops Q Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC.27320 (• -` Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 Email: txmrtechC@bellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs_com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: I T b 7XI a s'-,c> W PO#: Contact Person- �Q d_< 01V ,� f NPDES#: NC Q 6(4 7 ,j i� ���z Address: �t d ARR ilYG-raT! ,�D��f Phone: City: G'Lrj,R IOEL Hip/l Pipe#: �Q/ County: h fiili State: 1y 6- Zip: ,`Z'7-1-"/7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: Ao1VTF- rF1_at✓h/r Sample Type: El Grab Ems` omposite #of containers: vZ Sampling Time: Start Date: ;L� 171 / Z Start Time: Ca2 6 PM End Date: End End Time:—6L&AMPM —� CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no airspace), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print:_RF C L/1i -� 4c jri/r',�.�7/i.rl Signature: CEYi - TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: 2rChronic(7 days) Test Organism: L?"Ceriodaphnia dubia (water flea) �• -0-Acute{24-48 hours) - ❑ Pimephales promelas- (fathead-minnow-)--- - --- ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: AUC-17G(,6 ALU7z ,t.5 — SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: A(V4 64�n+ -L, Date: %Z Time: 5�A PM Received by: OvA-1, Date: a 2 Time. ��EM PM Relinquished by: Date: . :,� �,���%?i Time: 2 �� AM M' Received by: G Date: Z Time: Z :O C) AM PM Relinquished by: Date: �''2 S- 1-2- Time: /S3 S AM P Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed,EX f Meritech Pick-up ** Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** �• �y�K SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) Relinquished by: ` ►"`^���-�'�^ I(,E Gv� 4 i Received by. Date: JTime: l AM PM- Sample Temperatures(.61 o .\. I G, 1 1 Sample Condition: !Ica WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy MERITECH,'INC. MeritechSample ID#• Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 i. Phone: 1-336-342748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 Email: txmrtech(@bellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Tent: GiT Y 4f Q4ZAk41,4 SD��F• PO#: Contact Person: NPDES#: NC (20 ,Z75 ?7 Address ��DS` F,�I,O/?//�/G7'O,(J r°OfID Phone: 9/9��'d0 -`/3�d City: 0,41,4 PeL• hl/L L- Pipe#: QO/ County: OLLR/9/9,4 t• State:__�Vc — Zip: 2 7s'/7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: pL ./EFFLUENT Sample Type: El Grab E?Composite #of containers: Sampling Time: StartDate: Start Time: 9;Q O PM End Date: 3 -/� End Time: O d <2V PM — CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no air space), CHILLED AND COVE ORED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print: �'//fl�C t GGC(CE/Z Signature: L-c TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION % Test Required: echronic(7 days) Test Organism: L'J Cefiodaphnia dubia (water flea) ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) EWC; 9 0 % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: 1Y1 ai-7'PLS QlLLGT/ONf SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: cza �, Date: Time: ;O 46�u-) PM Received by: C(94PA o ,A Date: Time: ?,'o.$ Q_RP PM Relinquished by: 1 Qi niff dnio Date: �3•/• ��- Time: AM M Received by: �G- Date: 3-J ^ I Z Time: AM Relinquished by: Date:Date: 3-1 -12 Time: 5-2-0 AM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ uPS ❑ Fed.EX Rr Meritech Pick-up **Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery'* SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) Relinquished by: Received by: Date: ��^ Time: AM OM Sample Temperatur ):( 0 .0(/ 0-,5 / / Sample Condition: 0 C GI WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy Title : south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION Kolmogorov Test for Normality ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- D = 0 . 1167 (p-value = 0 . 0411) D* = 0 . 9153 Critical D* = 1 . 035 (alpha = 0 . 01 , N = 60) = 0 . 895 (alpha = 0 . 05 , N 60) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Data PASS normality test (alpha = 0 . 01) . Continue analysis. Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION �0Bartlett ' s Test for Homogeneity of Variance ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Calculated B1 statistic = 14 . 5197 (p-value = 0 . 0126) Data PASS B1 homogeneity test at 0 . 01 level . Continue analysis. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Critical B = 15 . 0863 (alpha = 0 . 01, df = 5) = 11. 0705 (alpha = 0 . 05, df = 5) �i Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION • Summary Statistics on Data TABLE 1 of 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- GRP IDENTIFICATION N MIN MAX MEAN --- ---------------- ---- ---------- ---------- ---------- 1 control 10 16 . 0000 23 . 0000 19 .2000 2 22 . 5 10 15 . 0000 19 . 0000 17 . 0000 3 45 10 13 . 0000 20 . 0000 16 . 0000 4 75 10 7 . 0000 20 . 0000 14 .3000 5 90 10 10 . 0000 21 . 0000 12 . 6000 6 100 10 10 . 0000 23 . 0000 15 .3000 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION Summary Statistics on Data TABLE 2 of 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- GRP IDENTIFICATION VARIANCE SD SEM C.V. --- ---------------- -------------- ---------- ---------- ---------- 1 control 6 . 6222 2 . 5734 0 . 8138 13 .4030 2 22 . 5 1 . 5556 1.2472 0 .3944 7.3366 3 45 4 .4444 2 . 1082 0 . 6667 13 .1762 4 75 15 . 7889 3 . 9735 1 .2565 27 .7869 5 90 10 .2667 3 .2042 1 . 0132 25 .4299 6 100 18 .2333 4 .2701 1.3503 27. 9088 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION ANOVA Table ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- SOURCE DF SS MS F ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Between 5 257 . 5333 51 . 5067 5.4302 Within (Error) 54 512 .2000 9 .4852 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Total 59 769 . 7333 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- (p-value = 0. 0004) Critical F = 3 .3769 (alpha = 0 . 01, df = 5, 54) = 2 .3861 (alpha = 0 . 05, df = 5, 54) Since F > Critical F REJECT Ho: All equal (alpha = 0 . 05) Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION Dunnett ' s Test - TABLE 1 OF 2 Ho:Control<Treatment ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TRANSFORMED MEAN CALCULATED IN SIG GROUP IDENTIFICATION MEAN . ORIGINAL UNITS T STAT 0 . 05 ----- -------------------- ----------- ------------------ ------ --- 1 control 19 .2000 19 .2000 2 22 . 5 17 . 0000 17 . 0000 1. 5973 3 45 16 . 0000 16 . 0000 2 .3233 4 75 14 .3000 14 . 3000 3 . 5576 5 90 12 . 6000 12 . 6000 4 . 7919 6 100 15 .3000 15 . 3000 2 .8316 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dunnett critical value = 2 .3100 (1 Tailed, alpha = 0 . 05, df [used] = 5, 40) (Actual df = 5, 54) Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION Dunnett ' s Test TABLE 2 OF 2 Ho:Control<Treatment ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- NUM OF MIN SIG DIFF 1 o OF DIFFERENCE GROUP IDENTIFICATION REPS (IN ORIG. UNITS) CONTROL FROM CONTROL ��- ----- -------------------- ------- -----------=---- ------- ------------ 1 control 10 2 22 . 5 10 3 . 1816 16 .6 2 .2000 3 45 10 3 .1816 16 .6 3 .2000 4 75 10 3 . 1816 16 . 6 4 .9000 5 90 10 3 . 1816 16 .6 6.6000 6 100 10 3 . 1816 16 .6 3 .9000 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Fisher' s Exact Test NUMBER OF=====__________ ---------------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10 0 10 22 . 5 10 0 10 ---------------------------------------------- ----------------------------- TOTAL 20 0 20 Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 10 . Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level . Fisher' s Exact Test NUMBER OF ---------------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10 0 10 45 9 1 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 19 1 20 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 9 . Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0. 05 level . Fisher' s Exact Test ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- NUMBER OF ---------------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10 0 10 75 9 1 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 19 1 20 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- ( ------------------------------- writical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 9 . Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level. Fisher' s Exact Test ---------- NUMBER OF ---------------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10, 0 10 90 7 3 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 17 3 20 Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 7 . Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level . Fisher' s Exact Test NUMBER OF ---------------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 10 0 10 100 7 3 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 17 3 20 Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 10) (alpha=0 . 05) is 6 . 0 . b value is 7 . Since b is greater than 6 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0 . 05 level. Summary of Fisher' s Exact Tests ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- NUMBER NUMBER SIG GROUP IDENTIFICATION EXPOSED DEAD 0 .05 ----- ------------------------- ----------- ----------- ----- (..-- CONTROL 10 0 • 1 22 .5 10 0 2 45 10 1 3 75 10 1 4 90 10 3 5 100 10 3 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- . a Effluent Aquatic Toxicity;Report Form /-Phase II Chronic Ceriodaphnia Facility: South Durham NPDES: # NC00 47597 Pipe#: 001 County: Durham Lab ry Zeoring st: Meritech,,lnc. . - Comments: ""INVALID TEST** Average control,reproduction.<.15.0 x x 16-15-1 Signature of O.R.0 Signature of Laboratory Supervisor Sample Information Sample 1 Sample 2 Control Test Start Date End Date Start Time End Time •- "'�- ��s Information Collection Start Date . 2/6/12 2/8/12 , r. 2/8/12; 2/15/12 10:00 AM 8:13 AM xW, --. - Start Renew 1 Renew 2 Start Renew 1 Renew Grab Treatment 100 % 100 % 100 % Control Control Control Composite ' (Duration) 24.1 24.1 - pH Inial -7.72 it7.72 7.58 8.13 8.08 8.08 0. �''" _ r `' 44 42 pH Final 8.17.- 7.99 -8.00 8.19 7.98 7.95 Hardness(mg/1) _ �, - µ^.r x D.O.Initial 8.10 8.03 -8.47 7.74 7.68 7.64 Spec.Cond.(pmhos/cm) 537 528 171 167 7.40 . '7.49 - 7.48 7.41 '7.55 7.45 ` D.O.Final Chlorine(mg/I) <0.1 <0.1 emp Initial 24.6 25.0 24.3 •24.3 24.4- '24.4' aa'' t- ,� ' Sample temp.at receipt 1.0 0 C 1.0 0 c 24A_ Temp Finaf 24.3 25.1 24.4• 24.3 ', •25.1 Organism# Chronic Test Results 1 2 3 4 5 61 7 8 9 10 11 12'.YMeanFinal Control Mortality% 10 Control #Young 17 15 16 ..17 14 16 15 11 11 8 14.0 : ;%Control 3rd brood 80 Adult,.- a a Control Repro CV 21.6 L'� L L -L , L�� -L� L L L D �.� _ - 48 Hour Mortality Control, IWC 1 - • 2 -3 ' 4'' '15 -'6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Mean 0 Of 10 0 Of 10 s Effluent%' #Young;; 16 11 11 14 15 19 9 13 16 16 14.0 Significant? Y N Adult L L L' L' L %Red1 -L L 22;5' (L)ive(D)ead L L L Final Mortality Significant @ 00, or <Zo Conc 1 2 3 4 5 6' 7 8 9 10 Mean - -- - Reproduction Analv'sis: Effluent% #Young 18 5 13 ,12 6 17 9 7 10 16 11.3 Repro.LOEC= .Invalid %; NOEL= Invalid Adult L D D L L D; L D L L %Red Method &n'nett'sTest 4j (L)ive(D)ead 19.3 Normal Dlstnb? YES Method Kolmogorov r' Statistic: 0.7235 Critical:' 1.035 ~- 1 2 3 4 . 5 6 7 --8 9 10 Mean "Effluent% #YoungEqual Variances? YES Method: Bartlett 16 8 .1 8 13 7 8'1 14 6 11 7, 9.8 Statistic: 3.61 iL-'t, Critical: 15.09.- Adult %Red " :.75 (L)roe(D)ead L D D I L I DJTT-D I L I L I D 30.o Non-Parametric Analysis(if applicable): Method: 1, - 2 .3 4 5 ... .6 -. 7 . 8 - 9 10 Mean Effluent% Rank Sum• Critical Sum Effluent% #Young 10 12 9. 17 4 5 4 15 7 9O (Ljive(D)ead L L L L -_D- L D D, L %Red 36.4 1 2. 3 - 4 5 6 . •7 8 9 ' 10 Mean Overall Analysis:- Effluent% .IM 10 14 8 12 1 ,191- 10' 12 8•, 11 10111'.41 Result=PASS/FAIL or + ;Test LOEC= Invalid %; NOEC= Invalid % 1 OO L' L" L L L 'L L L . D L _ 18 6 Chronic Value ' Invalid % r' ATT:' Environmerital Sciences Branch Should use highest test concentration or highest MAILDiv.of Water Quality concentration with D.O.>5.0 mg/l_ N.C.DENR t Reduction from Control Reproduction Mean TO: .1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh,NC,.27699-1621,. DWQ form AT-3 (8/91)Rev. 11/95 Meritech, Inc. Ceriodephnia dubia Chronic Multidilutio1nal Reproduction Client: ). ')%VICi.Vy - ,-X- ? k Start Date: �'� 11 Z Start Time: I 00 NPDES#: NC p()�! �� 7 End Date: � 1 r71/t- End Time: j 3A!r _ n t Analyst(s): -Reviewed by: C��1���� �r-u�nG!�V`'it �'✓�l� _ J - • Replicates Day#• 1 2 3 4 5" 6" 7 8 9"" 10 %3rd Brood 2 J0 ��i v Mea r C.+ 0. of cP o t o. ., c n r 5 (� J 3 e i 3 S :° '� y Yl_D �.•v• n _ 7 ,�' �� Reproduction TotalJL . 2 d' D O 0 0 0 V v cl iA 7 j. Total ' f ' ? % RED. 2 U - U 0 4 JJ d 5 i J q 751 `-t 7 TotalL&:NV. )' t!T, 91 % RED. ' Al 2 0 ` �) % 5 L t—' 'j 1 313 60 p Total L �' -IT) 4/1> % RED. ' �,11 2 V % 5 7 Total . % RED. J 2 O © rJ V r� % 5 - y 7 � `�V 1 s � y � VzOdyr I;z 73 ��. Total t J - / " ' % RED. I I r , -Z0 1 A �i0YY1J+ lip) M ERITECH, INC. Mentech Sample ID#. 02-c,9 c. Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody ., 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 Email: txmrtech(o-)bellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: i- fVC(I?�/ =J-�- _:> 4.//i /= PO#: Contact Person: �) r>045y ; NPDES#: NC Address: 4'C• iK_ Phone: City: 0/7 k f ,/ Piippee#: County. L(I?�j r►:r.� State: Al L- Zip: 2 r j/ 7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: A.6/7- ' cc•�� Sample Type: ❑Grab alcomposite #of containers: (-- Sampling Time: Start Date: ,�- / Start Time: �:�7?J AM PM End Date: •t") Z End Time: AM PM CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL (no air space), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print: ��1, },/�,�a l,� C Ht!Alt�ZI ,,' Signature: ✓(-Z�uc� jl�,. . TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: eCeriodaphnia dubia (water flea) ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations (if multiple dilutions): Comments: SI-IIPPIN.G INFORr.j.TION) Relinquished by: i4,,j !/`1A .� Date: 9 Time: 0 PM Received by: L_ f� Date: �^ / 2- Time: ' c U� A PM Relinquished b / Date: .-G Time: try PM Received by: /G-- Date: -2 - C/ - / 2- Time: �/rf Y AM PM Relinquished by:`�'��—/�- Date: c y•- )Z Time: Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX 14 Meritech Pick-up '* Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory-Use Only) Relinquished by: INk t,:'l"'S Received by: 1 t O e)1 .�;�L� Date: t1- 11, Time, I JCC> AM %PM Sample Temperatures(°C): i a / 1- C) / / Sample Condition: �(C, WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy Title: south durham File: southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION Bartlett ' s Test for Homogeneity of Variance --------------------------------------'-------------------------------------- Calculated B1 statistic = 3 . 6117 (p-value = 0 . 6066) Data PASS B1 homogeneity test at 0 . 01 level . Continue analysis. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Critical B = 15 . 0863 (alpha = 0 . 01, 'df = '5) = 11. 0705 (alpha = 0 . 05, df = 5) Title: south durham File : southdurham Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION r, ANOVA Table SOURCE DF SS MS F ------------------------------------------------------_----------------------- Between 5 221. 7333 44 . 3467 3 . 1887 Within (Error) 54 751 . 0000 13 . 9074 -----'=---------------------------------------------------------------------- Total 59 972.. 7333 ----------------------_-----------------7----- -----.--------------------------- (p-value = 0 . 0136) .Critical F = 3 . 3769 (alpha = 0 . 01, df = 5, 54) = 2 .3861 (alpha = 0 . 05, df = 5, 54) Since F > Critical F REJECT Ho: All equal (alpha = 0 . 05) Fisher' s Exact Test NUMBER OF ------------------------------- IDENTIFICATION DEAD ALIVE TOTAL ANIMALS -------------------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 1- 9 10 22 . 5 0 10 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 1 19 20 Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 1) (alpha=0 . 05) is negative. b value is 0 . no significant difference .Fisher' s Exact .Test.,. ------------------------------------------------- ;: NUMBER• OF ------_-- - --.---------,------------ ----- i IDENTIFICATION ALIVE- DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS ----------=--------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 9 1 10 .45 6 4 10 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TOTAL 15 5 20 Critical Fisher' s value (10, 10, 9) (alpha=0 . 05) is- 4 . 0 . b value is 6 . Sincel:b is greater than 4 . 0 there is no significant difference between CONTROL and TREATMENT at the 0. 05 level-. a Fisher'_s -_Exact Test _ NUMBER OF , IDENTIFICATION ALIVE DEAD TOTAL ANIMALS -------------- ----- ----- --------------- CONTROL 9 1 10 75 5 5 -10 ----------- ----------- ----- CONTROL 10 1 1 22 . 5 10 0 �l 2 45 10 4 3 75 10 5 4 90 10 4 5 100 10 1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- i DURHAM Administration s CITY OF DURHAM 919-560-4381 �• DEPARTMENT OF WATER MANAGEMENT Customer Billing Services 101 CITY HALL PLAZA• DURHAM, NC 27701 919-560-4412 ' 919-560-4381 • FAX 919-560-4479 Laboratory Services www.durhamnc.gov 919-560-4386 1 8 6 9 Plant Maintenance 919-560-4388 CnY OF MEDICINE Regulatory Compliance 919-560-4381 Wastewater Treatment January 31 2012 North-919-560-4384 South-919-560-4336 Water Supply&Treatment Williams-919-560-4349 Brown-919-560-4362 Water&Sewer Maintenance Environmental Sciences Branch 919-560-4344 Division of Environmental Management North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1621 SUBJECT: First Quarter Toxicity Testing- 2012 South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 Please find enclosed the first quarter toxicity results for the South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NC0047597. The analysis was completed by Meritech, Inc., 642 Tamco Road, Reidsville,North Carolina. The results indicated a failure for the first time in over 15 years. As per the permit, I have scheduled additional testing for the month of February and March. In addition, City staff is investigating possible sources of toxicity. If you have any questions,please call me at 919-560-4386. Sincerely, '�z S� Robert Dodson Superintendent enclosures •'i Good Things Are Happening In Durham Effluent Toxicity Report Form - Chronic Pass/Fail and Acute LC50 Date: 01/19/12 -,cility: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES#: NCO047597 Pipe#: 001 County: DURHAM orator Perform' g Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. Comments: Id gnatu e of ti5erator in Response e C e X Signature of Laboratory Supervisor Work Order: Environmental Sciences Branch MAIL ORIGINAL TO: Div. of Water Quality N.C. DENR 1621 Mail'Service Center Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Chronic Pass/Fail Reproduction Toxicity Test Chronic Test Results- Calculated t = Tabular t = CONTROL ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 % Reduction = 33.78 % Mortality Avg.Reprod. # Young Produced 24 16 18 20 20 22 8 22 23 21 10 21 8.33 18.75 Control Control Adult (L)ive (D)ead L L L L L L D L L L L L 50.00 12.42 Treatment 2 Treatment 2 Effluent %: 90% TREATMENT 2 ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 121 Control CV -26-920% ----PASS-FAIL--- -- - # Young Produced 10 11 16 15 4 16 11 12 19 10 14 11 % control orgs X 1adult . producing 3rdbrood Check(L)ive (D)ead D D L L D L L D L D L D 81.31 1st sample 1st sample 2nd sample Complete This For Either Test pH Test Start.Date: 01/11/12 Control 8.14 7.99 8.06 7.97 8.05 7.97 Collection (Start) Date Sample 1: 01/09/12 Sample 2: 01/11/12 Treatment 2 7.87 8.08 7.70 7.96 7.61 7.92 Sample Type/Duration 2nd 1st P/F s s s Grab Comp. Duration D t e t e t e I S S a n a n a n Sample 1 X 24 hrs L A A r d r d r d U M M t t t Sample 2 X 24 hrs T P P 1st sample 1st sample 2nd sample D.O. Hardness(mg/1) 44 Control 7.60 7.27 7.48 7.45 7.51 7.40 Spec. Cond. (pinhos) 171 529 541 Treatment 2 7.88 7.33 7.86 7.57 8.00 7.61 Chlorine(mg/1) ,,,,,,,, <0.1 <0.1 LC50/Acute Toxicity Test Sample temp. at receipt(OC) 1.1.0 1.0 (Mortality expressed as %, combining replicates) Note: Please Concentration Complete This Section Also Mortality start/end start/end LC50 = % Method of Determination Control 95% Con ince Limits ' Moving Average _ Probit -- % Spearman Karber _ Other - High Conc. pH D.O. Organism Tested: Ceriodaphnia dubia Duration(hrs) : Copied from DWQ form AT-1 (3/87) rev. 11/95 (DUBIA ver. 4.41) --��II Mini Chronic Pass/Fall Test: Cerioa'aphnia dvbia Incubator# LC) Client: vr�arn - dy �v` Pipe#: WL County: 0,�r-�kpXry& Date Start: IIff L Date End: NPDES#: NC no L7 s 97 Date/Time of C ulture Transfer. �� 6- �I. Time Start: (�./SRM' Time End: /� N IO'.�5�/t/�— Dilution Water. Lake Reidsville ) Date/Time Neonates loom: - O-12- LSA PA-3 �pM1st Renewal Date: 1 Z Time: 16 Test Organism Source: Tray-i ` Age of nates at Test Start vim. 3 hours 2nd Renewal Date: 1 1- Time. A� Stirred/Aerated for D.O.:YRandomized. Y/N Culture Tray Temp: C Analyst(s): Reviewed by: N Control Organism Reproduction Collection(Start_)—Dates.- Da ates:Da #2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 r #Young Produced p O O p 0 p p p O O O Sample 1: i(� I L Sample 2: '/�/ L Adults Live/Dead L- L— (,. L- L L L l_ L. L_ L Sample Information Da #b 1 2 31 41 56 6 7 8 P. 1 11 1 100%pIH G;/C? Duration # Young Produced (o y 3 3 Sample 1 7.7(o C Z Ll hours Adults Live/Dead L (^ L L hL IL L Sam le 2 ,N 3 C- Z hours Dav 97 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 TramftTr.edby Fed by #Youn Produced a (o ( Batch# �Z4� I sar s�p� l�Y'L r�- Day 0 Hudrww Day 2 'IVA- Total Produced j ,o spec.Can; 1� �Q LI + Day 3 )�t4J`� -�, (umlros►cm 1 1 Day 4 � Percent of Control producing third broad: r�,� Mo - h )e 0D,t Day fi Test Sample omanism Reproduction 91.3 tDay 6 Rxdpt Sampl• Effluent%: T-.P-Nt �, �. Terminated by: Da #21 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 D 11 12 H 1st Sampre 2nd Sample 2fK1 Sample #Yo -- Control �un Produced O p O p CU ( O O I 7•q1 [:Adults - 7,9 7.70 7,9f� 7,(0J N Da F#5 1 2 4 5 1 1 1 Sample LO N frnbat n ,Ni ,� N #Youn Produced 3 3 D.O. 1st sample 2nd Sample 2nd Sample Adults Live/Dead L L_ L jr l� iL L L co , Control .4r71�,zj .0 74 �� .S` Da #7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 CD #Youn Produced © 7 p O � � p Sample Lf-r'7.33 7. ,57 13-007.6) Adults Live/Dead y, L L L D L L p n N Temp. 1st sampre 2nd Sample 2nd Sampre N Total Produced 0 Control 2 S7 L4' ZS' X1,3 co ents: l� Sample 252 y�• S1' Z� .� so irl n I indW fina[— mihal 01/30/2012 03 16 3363421522 #2114 P 003/005 MERITECH, tN M®rlteen Sample IQ#: 011095 B/n Sam 642 Tamco Rd, ReidsvillePhone- 1-336-342-4748 F2-1522 Email: txmrtech(c�bellsouth.net Web moritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORM Client f�'' AF �l/��1I►Oyi - S�/, F PO#: Contact Person: A6A NPDES#- NC Q0 67 97 Address: to/0 I �dn! SDA Phone: City: CAkrC-1- 11,1/ Pipe#: County:__7)9Ahd4i State: IV zip: a27� 7 SAMPLE IN90RMATIN Sample Site: PL wr 7gr_L�1�'"•'vr Sample Type: ❑Grab 'Composite of containers: �Sampling Time. Start Date: �- 9 Z Start TimPM End Date: - 'Z End Time: A© PM —► CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(ho air ace), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print: .9e6-T.W, D lc&k w Signature: .ywtir T TOXICITY TEST INFORM TION Test Required: �ronle(7 days) Test Organism: [�Ce odaphnla dubfa (water flea) • ❑ Acute(24-{a hours) ❑ Pf ephales pfomelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mj sidopsis bahla (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if IT iltiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFITRelinquished by: � Date: /2- Timer PM Received by: C L ^ Date: Z.-. Time: ,! M PM Relinquished by: pate: Time: 1 1 S AM Received by: _/.�_ Date: / "/ 2 Time. AM Relinquished by: Date: f-l — I Z Time: 6 AM 'MD Received by; Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: pate: Time: AM PM Received by: Data: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature CC). Method of Shipment ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX Meritech Pick-up Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be early labeled for Saturday delivery"* •RelinSAMPLE RECEIVING Labarat Use Onl quished by: 1u��.,e/>S Received by: Ol_d,.t,,y tLn L L pate: 1- Time: N5D AM PM Sample Temperatures(°C): r.o / 1.D 1 ! Sample Condition: CQ. WRITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW Client copy 01/30/2012 09. 17 3363421522 92114 P. 0^04/005 MERITECH, IN Merltech Sample IP 0: O� 1� L [ , Bloassay Sample Chain of stodv 642 Tamco Rd,Reidsville NC 27320 - Phone: 1-33&-342-4748 Fax: 1 36-342-1522 • ~ Email: txmirtophlabellsouth.nat Web Site: www.maritech-labs-conj CLIENT INFORMATI N Client: e r- DY94 400 - Sa Ld RF Po#: Contact Person: 0/V NPDES#: NC 00 Y7 j9 7 Address: GG QFAR A j Phone: f 9 1 - 1V3 J4 City: hA P E Pipe#: d 0 County: V W,00! State: Al G Zip: a�7 SAMPLE INFORMATI, N Sample site: LAN I— Z-J=j% J1gnrd Sample Type: ❑Grab D-,l.omposite #of containers: Sampling Time: Start Date.,__ M Start Time: 01, ® PM End Date: a - End Time: 41: CHRONIC TESTS SHOULD BE TAKEN AFTER 10:00 AM IF AT ALL POSSIBLE "*SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no air. ace), CHILLED AN COVERED WITH ICE'** Collector's Name: Print �„CirN A'� Gt>7� � Signature: r,� � —� TOXICITY TEST INFORM TIO Test Required: Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: a odaphnia dubia (water Flea) [3-Acute(24-48 hours) E] pi ephales promelas• (fathead minnow) ❑ M ldopsis bah/a (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if rr Itiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFORMAT N Relinquished by: /( r Date: - �• L- Time: 9:/O w- PM Received by: Ifo /� Date: — y Time: ' O PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: a-r o AM 4M Received by: Date: Time: U AM Relinquished by: —� Date. �� Time: /SSD AM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by:, Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C). Method of Shipment ❑ UPS ❑ Fed FX �. Meritech Pick-up "*Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery=" SAMPLERECEIVING Laborat Use Only) (Itelinquished by: KjI t e1_5 Received by: 91 G_W(Q n t_A.. Date: 1- 12.- '2— Time: 1550 AM PM Sample Temperatures(°C): 1. 0 / / Sample Condition: WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW1 Client copy 01/30/2012 03: 17 3363421522 #2114 P. 005/005 Effluent Toxicity Statistical Results - Chronic Pass/Fail Date: 01/19/12 t• Facility: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES# NC0047597 Pipe#: 001 County:DURHAM Laboratory Performing Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. Reduction: 33.781 CONTRO 90% Effluent # Replicates 12 12 Female Live 11 6 Adult Male 0 0 Adult Dead 1 6 Adult Mortality 8.33$ 50.00W # Neonates 225 149 Mean # Neonates 18.75 12.417 Standard Deviation 5.048 3 .895 Coefficient of Variation 26.920 Fisher's Exact Test C,, A = 12 B = 12 a Ll bm 6 a/A - 0.92 b/B = .50 Success is: survival Critical b value - 6 6 s 6 The test concludes that the proportion survival is signif- icantly different for the control and t1a effluent groups. Test Failedl Chronic Test FAILS The survival proportions of the two grcFps are dissimilar DURHAM CITY OF DURHAM r• € DEPARTMENT OF WATER MANAGEMENT 101 CITY HALL PLAZA• DURHAM, NC 27701 919-560-4381 9 FAX 919-560-4479 www.durhamnc.gov lir� 1 8 6 9 ---- --- --- --- ---- -- ------ CITY OF MEDICINE October 31, 2011 Administration 919-560-4381 -ustomer Billing Services 919-560-4412 Laboratory Services ` 919-560-4386 Environmental Sciences Branch Plant Maintenance Division of Environmental Management 919-560-4388 Regulatory Compliance North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources 919-560-4381 1621 Mail Service Center Wastewater Treatment Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1621 North-919-560-4384 South-919-560-4336 later Supply&Treatment Williams--919-560- 4349 SUBJECT: Fourth Quarter Toxicity Testing- 2011 Brown-919-560-4362 South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 Water&Sewer Maintenance 919-560-4344 please find enclosed the fourth quarter toxicity results for the South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NC0047597. The analysis was completed by • Meritech, Inc., 642 Tamco Road, Reidsville,North Carolina. If you have any questions,please call me at 919-560-4386. Sincerely, Robert Dodson Superintendent enclosures Good Things Are Happening In Durham C Effluent Toxicity Report Form - Chronic Pass/Fail and Acute LC50 Date: 10/20/11 vacility: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES#: NC6047597- Pipe#: 001�C6unty: .DURHAM aboratory erf min Test: MERITECH.LABS, INC. , s Comments: dilution water batch X Signatu of Operator ,in Respon-s-i-Ble C arg 907, 908, and' 909 used. X , Signature of La oratory Supervisor * PASSED: 11.07% .Reduction Work Order: Environmental 'Sciences Branch MAIL ORIGINAL TO: Div. of Water 'Quality ' N.C. DENR 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Chronic Pass/Fail Reproduction Toxicity Test Chronic Test Results Calculated t =. 2.101, Tabular,t­2.508 CONTROL ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 it 12 Reduction'= 11.07 % Mortality `, %Avg.Reprod. !#.Young Produced 25 20 23 14 21 23 26 23 20 24 23 20 0.00 21.83 • Control Control Adult '(L)ive (D)ead` L•: L L L L L L L L L L L 8.331 _19.42 19.42 'Treatment 2 =Treatment 2 Effluent %: ,90% TREATMENT 2--ORGANISMS_ 1- •2, „ 3 4 _5 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Control _CV _ 14:462% ^ PASS • '•FAIL #;Young Produced 21 15 -16 19 19 20 22 20 23 18 18 22 •% control, orgs • E�heck producing; 3rd 'brood SOne -Adul't (L)ive (D)ead L' L L - L"': L L L D L L L L 91.7% ; - 1st-sample ,;lst sample 2nd sample ; Complete This 'For Either? .Test, pH Test Start:Dater 10/12/1.1 Control. 8.02 b.08�1 Collection (Star _ t) Date Sample 1: 10/10/11 Sample 2: 10/12/11 Treatment 2 7.24 7.84 7:65 7.83 7.68 7.79 Sample Type/Duration 2nd 1st P/F s s 's Grab Comp. Duration • D t e t 'e t e I S S a n a n a n Sample 1 X 24 hrs L A A r d r d r d U . M M t. t " : t' Sairiple 2 X 24 hrs T P P 1st'sample.', 1st sample ` 2nd sample_. D.O. Hardnesss(mg/1) 48 ..... ........ Control' 7.68 7.,48 7.67 7.607.43 Spec. Cond. (pmhos) 186 533•,' 565 Treatment 2 8.16 7..44 7.85 7.64 8.0. 5 7.43 'Chlorine_(mg/.1) .......... ,<O.l <0.1 LC50/Acute Toxicity Test Sample temp. at receipt(°C) ,..,.... 0.3 .0.7 (Mortality expressed'as .%, combining,'-replicates) -Note: Please Concentration Complete This Section Also % % Mortality- start/end -start/end LC:5 = % Method of :Determination Control 95% 'Con i ence Limits . •Moving Average Probit Spearman Karber Other — High pH D.O. Organism'Tested: Ceriodaphnia dubia Duration(hrs) : Copied from DWQ form AT-1 (3/87) rev. 11/95 (DUBIA ver. 4.41) Meritech,Inc. Mini Chronic Pass/Fai Ceriodaphnia dubia Incubatc, Client:. : �oy1 Yl Pipe#: w County: A.') �� ;Date Start: _10� [ �� � t� Date End: J v 3. %'r'` Time End:. . NPDES,#: NC �,og76q 7. Date/Time of Culture Transfer..°(D; l l'1�'' � ''_q4 A.,+ Time Start: �-14S '� , /= Dilution'.Water: Lake,Reidsville: '_' Date/Time Neonates 1�!f -tfl �l 3l)IPS►'.• 1st Renewal Date: b�] Time: Test Organism Source: Tray•# ''` = Age,of tyeonates.at Test;Startrrl; Ste' hours 2nd Renewal Date: '(D�l ��) Time: ' ;� e9 4A Stirred/.Aerated for'D.O.: Y'� IV Random iied:UY/ N Culture Tray,Temp:, 2S; °C Analyst(s): (Z g'j Reviewed by; Control Organism Reproduction - - - Collection (Start) Dates. ?ay_#2 1 2 3 4 5` 6 7 8 >,9',. �10, 11�, 12' . , �111 #Youn Produced �:- b d 6 Off. t© ' ,0.' ::C� `�:'" _:'0;• - ,Sample 1; f� _ IQ ,[) Sample'2: .L Adults Live/`bead L-:. ,t- L_ �— — L Sample Information ii Da #5 1' 2 3 4 5 8 9";'`':10 11 12 100% H -G]C? Duration #Youn 'Produced 7E Sam le 1 7 3 Zy hours Adults Live/Dead L L L L go,: Z hours ' Da #7' 1 .2 3 4 56:. •,7 + 8 ' 9' :1 •_1. 12° Transferred by: Fed by: Sample Sample _ #Youn Produced�� O _ '' �r" Batch# �`� �'p$ 1, 2 Day 0 �- Adults Live/Dead Transfer Day OWN,� � _Day 1 Hardness - -r Day 2 hi'�-, ' (mgf�) �' 8 Total Produced Day 3 - Spec.Cond. �A 1$7 (umhosicr i)' j vim'' _ 33�� Day 4 Percent of Control producing third.brood:.� /oChlorine (rri9it j: Day 5 u2_ Test Sample Organism•Reproduction Day,_6 7Et4'f— `Receipt Sample g , Temp.(°c`) i+ �'� (�.� Terminated by: Effluent%: Q }_ y; H 1st Sample'. •. 1st Sample 2nd-Sample Da #2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 -8 94 .10' 11' 12 _ 010 O . ' �,o� 'l.`I#YoungProduced 0, O 0 : -0 C0 } . 7. ,• [Adults Lve Dead 97�� 7g7;�Q 7.Sam le Da #5 1' 2 ` 3 4 5 6' 7 8 ;? :9 10- 1'1 12 initial final mica fina irnUal final #Young PrOduced oZ ,3`': �' 1 D.O. 1st Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sample Adults Live/Dead L L „:; L_ L' ba #7 12 3 4 6” ' 7 8 -' `9.:. 10, 1 1 - -Control 7th 7G7 `�,(vU 7,7y 7,q; #Youn Produced 07.17/7 Sample "�'��� �'� �� �'� 6,0 5' 3 _ ,milia - final - initial final - ,- initial final 1 Adults Live/Dead I L = Temp. - i 1st Sample Tst Sample 2nd Sample Total Produced f� ADZ o� Control ���� 2�,� 2� Comments: Sample Z+l,(� �{,(q. Z(��I� L -,q,'l tnlilal -.final Initial final Initial final i MERITECH, INC. Meritech Sample ID#: 'I] I I Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd,Reidsville NC 27320 • �` Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 Email: txmrtech(a)bellsouth.net Web Site- www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: 1 QF efl*h )R , PO#: Contact Person: QA) NPDES#: NCOOg}`7 -7 Address: / Phone: "S () City: A,f}f � T f Pipe#: � County: �j�,p � State: / � Zip: ! `7 ,,) SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: ALA V77,�, Errl.[1&117 Sample Type: ❑Grab Ll�'Co`mposite #of containers: _ Sampling Time: Start Date: !�- �/�- StartTime: r> A PM End Date: l�M ^�I End Time: 6 0, AM PM ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no airspace), CHILLED A D COVERED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print: y�!}1„� [' �/j4jZl Signature: TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: Chronic(7 days) * Test Organism: Ceriodaphnia dubia (water flea) ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: Date: - �� / Time: �:-�. At PM . Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by &JA4 Date: 10- 13-11 Time: AM PM Received byDate: �y,s j��'/� Time: AM P Relinquished by: e Date: f� r�3 /' Time: Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX ❑ Meritech Pick-up **Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** It SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) Relinquished by: C 30n�5 Received by: NLLa)_,t_)rC.Q. Date: PC 3' I Time: 2: IDS AM PM Sample Temperatures(°C): Q. / 0- Ip Sam le Condition: -------- ------------ - - - - ---- - - ---------------- -' - — --------WHITE-='Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy Effluent Toxicity Statistical Results - Chronic Pass/Fail `-Date: 10/20/11 Facility: SOUTH DURHAM, WRF - NPDES#: NC0047597 Pipe#:' 001 -C8unty:DURHAM= Laboratory Performing Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. Reduction: 11.07% CONTROL 90% Effluent # Replicates 12 12 Female Live 12 Adult Male_ 0 0 Adult Dead 0 1 Adult Mortality 0.009. - - 8.33% # Neonates 262 233 Mean' # Neonates 21.833 19.417 Standard Deviation 3.157 2.429 Coefficient of Variation 14.462% Fisher!_s`_,Exact,Test A = 12 . B12. a 12 b = 11 � .� ,,a/A =_1.00 /B = 0.92 b ., ,Success is: survival Critical .b value.=,,8 11 > 8 The test concludes thatthe proportion-'of survival -is not significantly different=for the control and 'the ,effluent.,groups�. Test Passes! SHAPIRO-WILK!S ,TEST'FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION -OF­DATAA' ORDERED-OBSERVATIONS i Group Neonates Centered i Group Neonates Centered 1 C 14 -7.8333 13 E 20 0.5833 2 E 15 -4.4167 14 - C 23 1.1667 '3 E 16 -3.4167 15 C 23 1.1667 4 C 20 -1.8333 16, -C 23 1.1667 5 C 1 20 -1.8333 17 C ' 23 �" 1.1667 6 C 20 _ -1.8333' 18._ E 21 1.5833 .E,. 18=. '=1:4167-_ ' .19 C .: 24_„ _ _ 2.,.1667, 8 E 18 -1.4167- 20 -E,,. 22 2_;5833 9 C 21 -0.'8333 -21` E 22 `2'.5833 10 E 19 -0.4167 22 C 25' `3..'1*667, 11 E 19 -0.4167 23 E 23 - 31:5833 12 E 20 0.5833 , 24 C 26- 4:1667,_ r ` SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA (cont.) -COEFFICIENTS AND DIFFERENCES - - - - - i x(n--i-1-) -- 1 4.1667 -7.8333 0.4493 12.0000 2 3.5833 -4.4167 0.3098 8.0000 3 3.1667 -3 .4167 0.2554 6.5834 4 2.5833 -1.8333 0.2145 --4.4166 5 2.5833 -1.8333 0.1807 4.4166 6 2.1667 -1.8333 0._1512 4.0000 7 1.5833 -1.4167 0.1245 3.0000 8 1.1667 -1.4167 0.0997 2.5834 9 1.1667 -0.8333 0.0764 2.0000 10 1.1667 -0.4167 0.0539 1.5834 11 1.1667 -0.4167 0.0321 1.5834 12 0.5833 0.5833 0.0107 0.0000 1 ' W X 164.3954 174.5833 Calculated W = 0.942 Critical W = 0.884 0.942 a 0.884 The reproduction data is normally distributed r evaluated at a 99t confidence interval. `• Test Passes! F test for Homogeneity of variance Control -variance 9.9697 F = _ = 1.69 Effluent variance 5.9015 Numerator degrees of freedom: 11 Denominator degrees of freedom: 11 Critical F = -5.32 1.69 s 5.32 =► The Test PASSES, the variances of the two groups are significantly the same, homogeneous. J l a EQUAL -VARIANCE't TEST 21.8 - 19.4 t = = 2.101 " 1.150 Degrees of freedom 22 Critical t = 2.508 2.101 < 2.508 Test passed. There is not ,a'significant difference in reproduction , between the Control,and the effluent evaluated at a 999. confidence interval. Chronic Test PASSES �,J DUMAM %# CITY OF DURHAM DEPARTMENT OF WATER MANAGEMENT • 101 CITY HALL PLAZA• DURHAM, NC 27701 919-560-4381 • FAX 919-560-4479 www.durhamnt.gov 1869 CfTY OF MEDICINE Administration July 19, 2011 919-560-4381 :ustomer Billing Services 919-560-4412 Laboratory Services 919-560-4386 Environmental Sciences Branch Plant Maintenance Division of Environmental Management 919-560-4388 Regulatory Compliance North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources 919-560-4381, 1621 Mail Service Center Wastewater Treatment Raleigh,North Carolina 2769.9-1621 North-919-560-4384 South-919-560-4336 later Supply&Treatment Williams-919-560- 4349 SUBJECT: Third Quarter Toxicity Testing -2011 Brown-919-560-4362 South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 . Water&Sewer Maintenance 919 560-4344 Please'find enclosed the,third quarter toxicity results for the South Durham Water'Reclamation Facility,NC0047597. The analysis was completed by. Meritech, Inc., 642 Tamco Road, Reidsville,North Carolina. If you have any • questions,please call me at 919-560-4386. Sincerely, Robert-Dodson Superintendent enclosures Good Things Are Happening In Durham Effluent Toxicity Report Form - Chronic Pass/Fail and Acute LC50 Date: 07/14/11 Facility: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES#: NC0047597 Pipe#: 001 County: DURHAM 4 abo tory erf mi Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. - ifJ Comment's: dilution waters 888 & X UC. Si ature o Operator in Re onsi arge 889 also used: hard-48,,46 X cond-180,177 Signature--o Laboratory Supervisor * PASSED: -7.83% Reduction Work Order: Environmental Sciences Branch MAIL ORIGINAL TO: Div. of Water Quality N.C. DENR 1621 Mail Service Center Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Chronic Pass/Fail Reproduction Toxicity Test Chronic Test Results Calculated t = 71_ .893 Tabular t = 2.508 CONTROL ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 °% 'Reduction = -7:83 Mortality Avg.Reprod. # Young Produced 16 19 17 19 20 19 20 19 15 17 19 17 0.00 18:08• ' Control Control Adult (L)ive (D) ead L L L L L L L L L L �L_ L 0.00 19.50 Effluent %: 90--,-,,-' Treatment 2 Treatment 2 TREATMENT 2 ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Control CV 8.9660 PASS ,FAIL #-,YoEng Produced 21 19 21 20, 21 19 20 16 2.3 20 17 17 %_control orgs X producing"3rd brood'. ,' Check One ;Adult L)ive (D)ead L L L L L L, L L L L L L 100,% 1st sample lst sample 2nd sample Complete This For Either Test PH Test Start Date: 07/06/11 Control 8.21 8.09 8.15 8.11 8.20 8.00 Collection (Start).--Date Sample 1: 07/04/11 Sample 2: 07/06/11 Treatment 2 7.61 8 .10 7.70 8.02 7.59 7.98 Sample Type/Duration 2nd 1st P/F s s s Grab Comp. Duration D t e t e t e I S S a n a n a . n Sample 1 X 24.•1 hrs L A A r d r d r ' d U M M t t t Sample 2 X;, ;~24 hrs T P P 1st sample 1st sample- 2nd sample D.O. Hardness(mg/1) 48 Control 7.68 7.33 7.77 7.42 7.54 7.27 Spec. Cond.'(umhos) 179 524 503 Treatment 2 7.73 7.43 7.94 7.50 8.00 7.20 Chlorine(mg/1) ,,,,,,,, <0.1 <0.1 LC50/Acute Toxicity Test Sample temp. at receipt( C) ,,,,,,,, 0.8 0.7 (Mortality expressed as combining replicates) Note: Please % % % % % % Concentration Complete This Section Also % % % % % Mortality. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 start/end start/end iE % Method of Determination Control i ence Limits Moving Average Probit _ -- Spearman Karber _ Other High Con- pH D.0. '! Organism Tested: Ceriodaphnia dubia Duration(hrs) : Copied from DWQ form AT-1 (3/87) rev. 11/95 (DUBIA ver. 4.41) Meritech,Inc. if Mini Chronic Pass/Fail Test: Ceriodaphnia dubia Incubator#: Client: �� � �//tom h Pipe#: ZY) County: ' ,-A,,a,w l Date Start: ��f1 f Date End: '7,J;1•--1 NPDES#: NC ' LI-75-' 7 Date/Time of Culture Transfer: ?-✓ Time Start: q6 4?N1 Time End: Dilution Water: Lake Reidsville Date/Time Neonates born: 7-�' .M 1st Renewal Date: -Sf_ !/ Time: UQ45b . ,a^ Test Organism Source: Tray 4�'Randomized:UY Age of eS-onates at Test Start:,at), Shours 2nd Renewal Date: 7 -� !) -Jf Time: ��� A,-,)Stirred/Aerated for D.O.,: Y / N Culture Tray Temp: °C Analyst(s): (--V- l�,�" Reviewed by: Control Organism Reproduction Collection (Start) Dates: Dji!y#2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 #Youn Produced © O O © p 01 p O © 0 ' Sample 1: 7' Sample 2: -�, Adults Live/Dead �-- t- L-1 L I L Sample Information Day#5 1 2 1 4 5 6 7 8 9 1Q_ 11 12 100% p H G/C? Duration #Young Produced •Y "41 `� Sam le 1 L hours Adults Live/Dead I Ll L- L-- . t_ L L-_ L. Sam le 2 3 Z`/ hours Dgy#7 1 2 `3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Transferred by Fed by Batch # Sample Sample #Youn Produced N �b �' ° ' 2 Day 0 �� � tf Adults Live/Dead L L (� Transfer Day 0 2 5 IIp�' ' %, Da 1 tf 1. .t✓ P.a '+'ti y > Hardnessf �� / sw Day 2 Wl- Total Produced � [)l'' l ) -7 (mg/L) �,��� _:rc�'_ l i Day 3 Spec.Cond. (umhos/cm � � y Percent of Control producing third brood: % i ,.,,.y .. S`� Da 4 � P 9 chlorine t re• r_ � e Day 5 � ( g Test Sample Organism Reproduction ) 'Gt Day 6, lip— ReceiptSamp le 's �, N,I' r ^ f i Fx ; ti, Effluent%: G� Temp.(°c) Dtr Terminated by: DLay#2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 pH 1st Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sample #Young Produced o O 6 O 0 b D Q D e) 01o , Control 9.�� �.p`l g J�'�• �� � . 0�- Adults Live/Dead L L- �- Sam le !�] x'10 7,7D I Da #5 1 2 3 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 12 initial final initial final .� �mtial final #Young Produced 3 _ 173& 01 D.O. 1st Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sample Adults Live/Dead L_ C_ L L t_ Control '1(,,J 7,33 7,?7� y-2 Da #7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 1 #Young Produced 77-3Sam le 7� `/J 7q/ 15 'w 7 Adults Live/Dead initial final initial final initial final L �•- � j,, Z-- j^ �:, I--• L- L L • Temp. 1st Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sample Total Produced 1L21 I loflb 116 K61 I Control (1, nts: Sample initial final initial final hal final MERiTECH, INC. MeritechSample ID# Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd,Reidsville NC 27320 Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: i-33'6-342-1522 • Email: txmrtech(abellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: i�✓i '? n / �l s/_'.h F,r.; l /%i-�;f ! PO#: Contact Person: �'y (; /� �,,, 1 Y NPDES#: NC Address: (! _� Ffy�'i?, =c ry Ii;:: r',i-I Phone: City: Pipe#: County: 17rali ,�,,, State: f Zip: /7 C' r SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: � ;1,,i f Y f F;l�;c- % Sample Type: ❑Grab ® Composite- #of containers: Sampling Time: Start Date: !7-"71 -if Start Time: i`4M-PM ' End Date: -/ r End Time: ! �M� PM ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no airspace), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH ICE*** . Collector's Name: Print. '- �`j" (?•�"!'� r `'"s t,/'� "' Signature: •f_ TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: Chronic(7 days) ,Test Organism: Z Ceriodaphnia dubia (water flea) _ 1 ❑ Acute(24-A8 hours) . ❑ Pimephales promelas_(fatF"ad minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia-(shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions):.` Comments: �y SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: + ��. 1 �;� �� : Date: Time: .QM PM Received by: �l')/,( ('4/�yr`j Date: •` .� Time: 7! '� AMS PM , Relinquished by.1( �,( f Date:. , Time: !�j AM Received;by.Z, r, ti Date: %.",lS✓�� Time: �'�=�{'-�,AM °P Relinquished by: ,/�.� r Date: %���j^1�.. . Time: `�'. "AM, P Received by: Date: Time: -AM' PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM ' Sample Temperature Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX ❑ . Meritech Pick-up "*Samples shipped on'Triday must be FzciEx and m`ust'be-_clearly labeled for Saturday delivery*4 SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use OnIV) •� ,' Relinquished by. l f Received by. - Date: �t r Time: AM PM Sample Temperatuec1c Sample Condition: ._-cC'.Gf WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy MERITECH, INC. Meritech Sample ID#: •max Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody -� 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 . Email: txmrtech(ftellsouth.net , Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: C/J`,,' O/-_ IOW1714M - SDWRF PO#: Contact Person: :5oZ5 d op.Sol+/ NPDES#: NC 004 7 r'9 7 Address: 6605" ,cf;rR,P/A/�TaN f'OAD Phone: `f/9-rC0-(13 g 6 City: C///,)R&Z Z//L L Pipe#: o a/ County: IIMA4 State: I/C Zip: .2 7" SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: 1`�;Z_AIV 7" 5fF1IV&,1/7` Sample Type: 11Grab (J Composite #of containers: ,,_ Sampling Time: Start Date: - E // Start Time: 9:O a PM End Date: 7-7-// End Time: `7, o o PM ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no airspace), CHILLED AND C VEREDD WITH ICES*** Collector's Name: Print. Signature:_--1% TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION Test Required: ❑ Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: El Ceriodaphnia dubia (water flea) ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑-Mysidopsis bahia !shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: L-rrcl' Date: 7- 7-// Time-, _211a -AD PM . Received by: CIO Lp o 0A1t Date: ;7-7-11 Time: 91,10 ,AM PM Relinquished by. Date: ;7-7-/� Time. %�S' AM 4g) Received by. �-r/ Date: - ��/l Time- AM PM Relinquished by: Date: �� % %% Time: AM M Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C): Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX ❑ Meritech Pick-up ** Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** C, SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) Relinquished by: Received by:, 0-k-L)re_ncl�_ Date: [I-'7- ( Time: 2:44-5 AM P Sample Temperatures(°C): �:., / D1 / / Sample Condition: WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy Effluent Toxicity Statistical Results - Chronic Pass/Fail Date: 07/14/11 Facility: SOUTH,DURHAM WRF NPDES#: NC0047597 Pipe#: 001 County:DURHAM Laboratory Performing Test: •-MERITECH LABS, INC. Reduction: -7.839. CONTROL 90o Effluent # Replicates 12 12 Female Live 12 12 Adult Male 0 0 Adult Dead 0- 0 Adult Mortality 0.00%. O:OOa # Neonates 217 234 Mean # Neonates 18.083, 19.500 Standard Deviation 1.621" 2.023 Coefficient of Variation 8.9660 Fisher's Exact Test A = '12 B = !12 a'= 12 b 12 j • _ :a/A 1.00 b/B = 1.00 Success is: survival Critical -b'value' -8 The test•concludes that- the proportion of survival is,-,,not , significantly different for the control and the efflunt groups. Test Passes! " --SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST ,FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF -,DATA ORDERED OBSERVATIONS i Group Neonates Centered i Group Neonates Centered 1 E 16 -3 .5000 13 , E 20 0.5000 2 C 15 -3 .0833 '14 C 19 0.9167 3 E 17 -2.5000 15 C 19 0.9167 4 E 17 -2.5000 16 C 19 ' 0.9167 5 C, 16 -2.0833 17 , C 19 0.9167 6 ;C; 17 -1:0833 18 C = 19 0.-9167 7 C 17 -1.0833 19 E 21 1.5000 1 ` 8 C 17 - .0'833 20 'E' ._ 21 1.5000 9 E 19 -0.5000 21 E 21 1.5000 10 E 19 -0.5000 22 C .. 20 1.9167 11 E 20 0,5000 23 C 20 1.9167 12 E 20 0.5000 24 E 23 3 ;5000 SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA (cont.) COEFFICIENTS AND DIFFERENCES i x(n-i-1) x(i) a(i) x(n-i-1) - x(i) 1 3.5000 -3.5000 0.4493 7.0000 2 1.9167 -3.0833 0.3098 5.0000 3 1.9167 -2.5000 0.2554 4.4167 4 1.5000 -2.5000 0.2145 4.0000 5 1.5000 -2.0833 0.1807 3.5833 6 1.5000 -1.0833 0.1512 2.5833 7 0.9167 -1.0833 0.1245 2.0000 8 0.9167 -1.0833 0.09,97 2.0000 9 0.9167 -0.5000 0.0764 1.4167 10 0.9167 -0.5000 0.0539 1.4167 11 0.9167 0.5000 0.0321 0.4167 12 0.5000 0.5000 0.0107 0.0000 1 W = X 69.9664 73.9167 Calculated W = 0.947 Critical W = 0.884 0.947 z 0.884 The reproduction data is normally distributed evaluated at a 99% confidence interval. C• Test Passes! F test for Homogeneity of Variance Effluent variance 4.0909 F = _ = 1.56 Control variance 2.6288 Numerator degrees of freedom: it Denominator degrees of freedom: 11 Critical F = 5.32 1.56 s 5.32 =► The Test PASSES, the variances of the two groups are significantly the same, homogeneous. EQUAL VARIANCE t TEST ' 18.1 - 19.5 t = _ -1.893 0.748 Degrees of freedom = 22 Critical t = 2.508 -1.893 < 2.508 Test passed. There is not a significant difference in reproduction between the Control and the effluent evaluated at a 99% confidence interval. Chronic Test PASSES DURHAM ( CITY OF DURHAM : DEPARTMENT OF WATER MANAGEMENT • 5a 101 CITY HALL PLAZA• DURHAM, NC 27701 919-560-4381 • FAX 919-560-4479 311 www.durhamnc.gov 1869 QTY OF MEDICINE May 5, 2011 Administration 919-560-4381 :ustomer Billing Services 919-560-4412 Laboratory Services 919-560-4386 Environmental Sciences Branch Plant Maintenance Division of Environmental Management ' 919-560-4388 Regulatory compliance North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources 919-560-4381 1621 Mail Service Center Wastewater Treatment Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1621 North-919-560-4384 South-919-560-4336 `ater Supply&Treatment Williams-919-560- 4349 Brown-919-560-4362 SUBJECT: Second Quarter Toxicity Testing- 2011 Water&Sewer Maintenance South Durham Water Reclamation Facility,NCO047597 919-560-4344 Please find enclosed the second quarter toxicity results for the South Durham • Water Reclamation Facility,NC0047597. The analysis was completed by Meritech, Inc., 642 Tamco Road, Reidsville,North Carolina. If you have any questions,please call me at 919-560-4386. Sincerely, Robert Dodson Superintendent enclosures Good Things Are Happening In Durham Effluent Toxicity Report Form - Chronic Pass/Fail and Acute LC50 Date: 04/28/11 �' ilatory orm ity: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES#: N00047597 Pipe#: 001 County: DURHAM erfin Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. _ Comments X -• S"iSWature of Operator in Response e arge X '��/ Signature of Laboratory Supervisor * PASSED: 5.65% Reduction Work Order: Environmental Sciences Branch MAIL ORIGINAL TO: Div, of Water Quality N.C. DENR 1621 Mail Service Center North Carolina Ceriodaphnia Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1621 Chronic Pass/Fail Reproduction Toxicity Test Chronic Test -Results---- ---- Calculated t = 1.700 Tabular t = 2.508 CONTROL ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 % Reduction = 5.65 # Young Produced 19 23 23 26 23 23 25 24 26 J2325 23 Mortality Avg.Reprod. 0.00 23.58 Adult (L)eve (D)ead L L L L L L L L L L L Control Control 0.00 22.25 Treatment 2 Treatment 2 Effluent %: 90% TREATMENT 2 ORGANISMS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Control CV 7.976% PASS FAIL # Young Produced 18 22 23 21 22 21 23 22 25 21 25 24 % control orgs pCheck Wult producing 3rd brood EOne (L)ive (D)ead L L L L L L L L L L L L 100% lst sample 1st sample 2nd sample Complete This For Either Test PH Test Start Date: 04/20/11 Control 8.20 8.09 8.25 8.10 8.19 8.11 Collection (Start) Date Sample 1: 04/18/11 Sample 2: 04/20/11 Treatment 2 8.00 8.13 7.86 8.04 7.97 8.11 Sample Type/Duration 2nd s s s Grab Comp. Duration D 1st P/F t e t e t e I S S a n a n a n Sample 1 X 24 hrs L A A r d r d r d U M M t t t Sample 2 X 24 hrs T P P 1st sample 1st sample 2nd sample D.O. Hardness(mg/1) 42 Control 7.41 7.18 7.60 7.24 7.53 7.26 Spec. Cond. (pmhos) 175 511 540 Treatment 2 7.54 7.40 8.03 7.19 7.64 7.30 Chlorine(mg/1) <o.1 <0.1 LC50/Acute Toxicity Test Sample temp, at receipt(OC) 0.6 0.5 (Mortality expressed as %, combining replicates) Note: Please % % ° ° % % % % % Concentration Complete This Section Also ° Mortality start/end start/end 50 = % Method of Determination Control % Confidence Limits Moving Average Probit l % -- % Spearman Karber _ Other - High Conc. pH D.O. Organism Tested: Ceriodaphnia dubia Duration(hrs) : Z�] Copied from DWQ form AT-1 (3/87) rev. 11/95 (DUBIA ver. 4.41) M Inc. / ., Mini Chronic Pass/ Ceriodaphnia dubiaIncubato :_ Client: .V I',%f'l_ W'lor" :..:��,�t.t �'f @ Pipe#: t".,?� County: g„}t i tc.V't'/, •PA Date Start: �-�'ZU- t I Date End: ! NPDES#: NC 3 a tr' j:' Date/Time of Culture Transfer: L - 3 Time Start: �'� �t�:��� fir') Time End: �� 1 Dilution Water: Lake Reidsville Date/Time Neonates born: ` - - - ' 1st Renewal Date: -LZ-! Time: ire-, .n Test Organism Source: Tray# Age ofeonates at Test Start: 1 hours 2nd Renewal Date: +-f; -ZS'-1 Time: Stirred/Aerated for D.O.: Y�andomized:UY/N Culture Tray Temp:_Z5-/ °C Analyst(s): Reviewed by: Control Organism Reproduction Collection (Start) Dates: Da #2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 EAdults n Produced G C) I C) c �.� �� Sample 1: -\4S 1 Sample 2: ` -Li.; 1 Live/Dead L L C Lr L ( � ( L Sample Information Da #5 1 2 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 - 100% pH G/C? Duration #Young Produced `� `� �� L Sam le 1 �,�f 7 "Z hours Adults Live/Dead Z. t� L_ L_ L_ �- L-- L Sam le 2 �, 73 C.. Z hours Pay#7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Batch# Sample Sample Transferred by: Fed by, #Young Produced Day 0 �- ►7lQ Adults Live/ Dead �, L-- l L L Transfer Day 2 rJ rt ' k�r`` � '� Day 1 Hardness ,,223 (mglL) �Z � F��u"??� '���',�� Day 2 Total Produced � J • f�`�1`-• ` 9 o�. j � �•4� dlt;xc< Da 3 Spec.Cond. Y (.mhos/cm) Day4 Percent of Control producing third brood: % ax,,tf t;,: . .°;., ••, Chlorine ) Test Sample Organism Reproduction (m9�L) ` e1.�0`; Day 5 1 )2'(i✓L_ ,t+rev F •.,r.nrs fir.:� _es / Day 6 YtXC~� Receipt Sample .e;� ry ¢�•�y} p�>•�'•�{ Temp.�°c�Effluent %: Terminated b Y:,. Day#2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 pH 1st Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sdmple #Young Produced G U U c) G C.) C-) Ca C� Control `0'` L) Z. �•� `h.l Adults Live/Dead l_.- It L. I L- I I Da #5 1 2 4 5 6 7 9 1 1 1 Sample `�� t3 7�� `],q� • �� nidal hna initial final initial final #YoungProduced -5/_ _1 _ .3 r D.O. 1st Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sample Adults Live/ Dead l.1 L_ L L, (� I L Control 74) 7l�( 7,(q0 7.Z 6 pi!y#7 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 #Young Produced 11161 M-177 Samp,le 7,517.00 $)) 7,64 7'v Adults Live/Dead L L L Linitial final initial final initial final Temp. list Sample 1st Sample 2nd Sample Total Produced 93 02 Control 25'2 2q• 2a, �,mments: Sam le initial final initial final initial final MERITECH, INC. Meritech Sample ID# Bioassay Sample Chain of Custody 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 • Phone 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 x Email: txmrtech(cDbellsouth.net Web Site: www.meritech-labs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: PO#: Contact Person: /3 oa 12OioS0/✓ NPDES#: NC O oy: 7' -g7 Address: E,'E�S -9oF'lNG7�!✓ F0,4D Phone: City: 4:�//pPC4 /-1/,-L Pipe#: p / County: Q;�A�/,��n State: Zip: 27S'/7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: LClE V7 Sample Type: ❑•Grab Ercomposite #of containers: Sampling Time: Start Date: `�-l6-/� Start Time: �;0 Ott PM End Date: -/`7--// End Time: ;D 0 (AM) PM ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no airspace), CHILLED AND PO RED WITH•4CE*** Collector's Name: Print: y-�/cLS L.00Ki R_ Signature: _ TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION SiTest Required: [Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: OlCeriodaphnia dubia (water flea). ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pimephales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis Bahia (shrimp) IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by: Date: Time: 0 (40 PM . Received by: G'o1D x o aAA Date: // Time: 7,•10 op PM Relinquished by: h 1 Mao Date: ��(-(( Time: _L' I Received by: Date: -4-- 9-A Time: �� AM/!jffM T�^� Relinquished by: Q: Date: 1�—�Lj-b Time: l 'Z- AM tQ Received by. Date: Time' AM PM Relinquished by: Date: Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C). Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX ❑ Meritech Pick-up ** Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery** SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) Relinquished by: Received by: `��� �, ( 16-)u- Date: - (- Time: : - AM P l Sample Temperatures(°C): AQ- / Sample Condition: � - WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy MERITECti INC. � Mentech Sample ID#. Bioassay Sample Chain of Cusfodv 642 Tamco Rd, Reidsville NC 27320 . Phone: 1-336-342-4748 Fax: 1-336-342-1522 Email: txmrtech(cDbellsouth.net Web Site, www.meritech-!abs.com CLIENT INFORMATION Client: i`�y i= �ii/�1J+ ► - 6Lt rl PO#• Contact Person* NPDES# NC (jQ q:7_5�'C-j`7 Address: L 0� -/�l�h�//(!s jLs1"tI 1�Q Phone: !M l (11 0_ 43FZ City: CA(j AGL ja,j , Pipe#: (� County State' /J �-- Zip: Z 7�/1.7 SAMPLE INFORMATION Sample Site: ?L Aj1/l Sample Type: ❑Grab ni'C omposite #of containers: ,Z Sampling Time: Start Date- q -Z� - Start Time: 9"cb PM End Date- 0 End Time. CO AM PM S ***SAMPLE CONTAINERS ARE TO BE COMPLETELY FULL(no airspace), CHILLED AND COVERED WITH ICE*** Collector's Name: Print: A 6 C—M Nftz_7> eimnlftaw Signature: TOXICITY TEST INFORMATION CTest Required: Chronic(7 days) Test Organism: �iodaphnia dubia (water flea) • ❑ Acute(24-48 hours) ❑ Pime phales promelas (fathead minnow) ❑ Mysidopsis bahia (shrimp) i IWC: % Test Concentrations(if multiple dilutions): Comments: � SHIPPING INFORMATION Relinquished by:_o/jl_q,nrot� CG Ir�-tii Date, - j Time: AM PM . Received by. Date: �. - Time. AM PM Relinquished by: �� Date: f{--� I i Time:t� AM PM Received by: �G� �- Date: Time: AM Relinquished by:_'/ �-�- Date: y- �J- Ej ( Time: 1 2.V AM PM ' Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Relinquished by: Date- Time: AM PM Received by: Date: Time: AM PM Sample Temperature(°C)• Method of Shipment: ❑ UPS ❑ Fed EX ❑ Mentech Pick-up r ** Samples shipped on Friday must be FedEx and must be clearly labeled for Saturday delivery*" SAMPLE RECEIVING (Laboratory Use Only) !e . Relinquished by: �� t�s�5 Received by ,Ll Date: q-4- ( Z Time: 1152-6 AM PM Sample Temperatures(°C): rr;. /G- Sample Condition: �t WHITE=Laboratory copy YELLOW=Client copy Effluent Toxicity Statistical Results - Chronic Pass/Fail Date: 04/28/11 C • Facility: SOUTH DURHAM WRF NPDES#: NC0047597 Pipe#: 001 County:DURHAM Laboratory Performing Test: MERITECH LABS, INC. s Reduction: 5.65. CONTROL 90. Effluent # Replicates 12 12 Female Live 12 12 Adult Male 0 0 Adult Dead 0 0 Adult Mortality 0.00. 0.00% # Neonates 283 267 Mean # Neonates 23 .583 22.250 Standard Deviation 1.881 1.960 Coefficient of Variation 7.976. Fisher's Exact Test A 12 B = 12 a = 12 b = 12 a/A = 1.00 b/B = 1.00 Success is: survival Critical b value = 8 12 > 8 The test concludes that the proportion of survival is not significantly different for the control and the effluent groups. Test Passes! SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA ORDERED OBSERVATIONS i Group Neonates Centered i Group Neonates Centered 1 C 19 -4.5833 13 E 22 -0.2500 2 E 18 -4.2500 14 E 22 -0.2500 3 E 21 -1.2500 15 C 24 0.4167 4 E 21 -1.2500 16 E 23 0.7500 5 E 21 -1.2500 17 E 23 0.7500 6 C 23 -0.5833 18 C 25 1.4167 7 C 23 -0.5833 19 C 25 1.4167 8 C 23 -0.5833 20 E 24 1.7500 9 C 23 -0.5833 21 C 26 2.4167 10 C 23 -0.5833 22 C 26 2.4167 11 C 23 -0.5833 23 E 25 2.7500 12 E 22 -0.2500 24 E 25 2.7500 SHAPIRO-WILK'S TEST FOR NORMAL DISTRIBUTION OF DATA (cont. ) r • COEFFICIENTS AND DIFFERENCES i x(n-i-1) x(i) a(i) x(n-i-1) - x(i) 1 2.7500 -4.5833 0.4493 7.3333 2 2.7500 -4.2500 0.3098 7.0000 3 2.4167 -1.2500 0.2554 3 .6667 4 2.4167 -1.2500 0.2145 3 .6667 5 1.7500 -1.2500 0.1807 3 .0000 6 1.4167 -0.5833 0.1512 2.0000 7 1.4167 -0.5833 0.1245 2.0000 8 0.7500 -0.5833 0.0997 1.3333 9 0.7500 -0.5833 0.0764 1.3333 10 0.4167 -0.5833 0.0539 1.0000 11 -0.2500 -0.5833 0.0321 0.3333 12 -0.2500 -0.2500 0.0107 0.0000 1 W = X 73.6049 81.1667 Calculated W = 0.907 Critical W = 0.884 0.907 >- 0.884 The reproduction data is normally distributed /- evaluated at a 99% confidence interval. l ' • Test Passes! F test for Homogeneity of variance Effluent variance 3.8409 F = _ = 1.09 Control variance 3 .5379 Numerator degrees of freedom: 11 ' Denominator degrees of freedom: 11 Critical F = 5.32 1.09 s 5.32 =► The Test PASSES, the variances of the two groups are significantly the same, homogeneous. { EQUAL VARIANCE t TEST 23 .6 - 22.3 t = = 1.700 0.784 Degrees of freedom = 22 Critical t = 2.508 1.700 < 2.508 Test passed. There is not a significant difference in reproduction between the Control and the effluent evaluated at a 99% confidence interval. Chronic Test PASSES l • 1 I