HomeMy WebLinkAbout20071505 Ver 4_Public Notice_20151014I I
I ''' I PUBLIC NOTICE
US Army Corps
Of Engineers
Wilmington District
Issue Date: October 14, 2015
Comment Deadline: November 13, 2015
Corps Action ID Number: SAW- 2013 -01159
The Wilmington District, Corps of Engineers (Corps) received an application from
Mr. Marcus Jones, Director of Engineering for Henderson County seeking Department of the
Army authorization for 1,792 linear feet (If) of stream impacts (1,6001f of existing, unauthorized
stream impacts and 1921f of new stream impacts) and 0.01 acres of new impacts to jurisdictional
wetlands, associated with the completion of subdivision road infrastructure and permitting of
existing, unauthorized stream impacts in the 302 -acre bonded phases at the residential
development known as Seven Falls in Etowah, Henderson County, North Carolina.
Specific plans and location information are described below and shown on the attached plans.
This Public Notice and all attached plans are also available on the Wilmington District Web Site
at http: / /www.saw.usace.armv.mil/ Missions /Ref4ulatorvPennitPropram.asi)x
Applicant: Mr. Marcus Jones, Director of Engineering
Henderson County
1 Historic Courthouse Square
Hendersonville, North Carolina 28792
AGENT: Mr. Clement Riddle
C1earWater Environmental Consultants, Inc. (CEC)
32 Clayton Road
Asheville, North Carolina 28801
Authority
The Corps evaluates this application and decides whether to issue, conditionally issue, or deny
the proposed work pursuant to applicable procedures of the following Statutory Authorities:
® Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. 13 44)
❑ Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403)
❑ Section 103 of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act of 1972 (33
U.S.C. 1413)
Location
From U.S. Highway 64 in Etowah, turn south onto Etowah Park Road. Travel approximately 0.2
mile and turn left onto Etowah School Road. Travel approximately 1.5 miles and turn right onto
Pleasant Grove Road. Travel approximately 0.8 miles, the project site is south of Pleasant Grove
Road.
In general, the site is bordered to the north by the Pleasant Grove Road, to the south by unnamed
tributaries to Little Willow Creek and Folly Creek, to the east by Judd Wilson Mountain and
Folly Road, and to the west by Pleasant Grove Church Road.
Project Area (acres): 302
Nearest Town: Etowah
Nearest Waterway: UTs Folly Creek, Folly Creek, UTs Little Willow Creek, and
Little Willow Creek
River Basin: Upper French Broad (06010105)
Latitude and Longitude: 35.28378 N, - 82.58937 W
Existing Site Conditions
The proposed Seven Falls Bonded Phases project is a 302 -acre area site included in bonded
phases that were originally a part of the 1,400 -acre Seven Falls Golf and River Club residential
development. The area of the bonded phases includes residential lots platted and recorded with
Henderson County. Property outside of the designated bonded phases is not included in the
proposed project. Approximately 1,667 linear feet of existing stream impacts where measured in
the bonded phases. Existing stream impacts were associated with partial development of the
Seven Falls Golf and River Club. The original permit authorization for the Seven Falls Golf and
River Club was revoked by the Corps in April of 2010; therefore, existing impacts to
jurisdictional streams and wetlands at the property are unauthorized.
In 2007, the Corps, NC Division of Water Resources (DWR), and Henderson County received
applications on behalf of Mountain Development Company, LLC (later renamed Seven Falls,
LLC) for the Seven Falls Golf and River Club development. This development included 40
different parcels of land totaling approximately 1,400 acres. The applicant originally proposed a
total of 900 residential units which included 700 single - family lots, 164 town homes, and 36
condominiums. Amenities included a golf course, a river club, and hiking trails.
In July of 2007, Henderson County and the developer entered into a performance guarantee
agreement which provides financial security to complete proposed infrastructure improvements
and allow the developer to record and sell lots before all the required infrastructure is complete.
The improvement guarantee included roads, water, and sewer infrastructure, but did not include
the golf course, club house and other amenities. The purpose of an improvement guarantee is to
ensure that the bonded infrastructure is completed in case of default by the developer.
Approximately 125 residential lots were sold between July of 2007 and December of 2008.
2
The DWR issued a Water Quality Certification for the project in January of 2008, and the Corps
issued a Department of the Army Permit in August of 2008. The Corps permit was revoked in
April of 2010 due to on -going non - compliance. The Corps cited impacts to over 2,500 linear feet
of stream and failure to provide the permit required compensatory mitigation.
In June of 2010, Henderson County declared that the Seven Falls Golf and River Club
development was in default of the performance guarantee and the developer failed to complete
the required infrastructure improvements. Since June of 2010, Henderson County has actively
pursued all legal avenues available in order to obtain the bond money designated to complete the
infrastructure improvements within the Seven Falls bonded phases boundary.
In October of 2012, Henderson County reached a settlement with Lexon Insurance Company
regarding the bond provided by Lexon for development work within the bonded phases of the
Seven Falls Golf and River Club property. Henderson County received 6 million dollars in bond
funds. At that time, Henderson County did not believe that the bond money would cover the cost
of all bonded improvements.
The Henderson County Board of Commissioners, at its meeting in January of 2013, directed the
County Attorney to send a letter on behalf of the Board to all entities with a property interest in
the Seven Falls Golf and River Club development. The purpose of the letter was to invite all
stakeholders to a meeting with the purpose of attempting to set up a method of negotiating an
agreement on how to allocate bond funds. In March 2013, after failure to reach an agreement, a
law suit was filed by Henderson County against all interested parties in the Seven Falls Golf and
River Club development which asked the Court for guidance as how the bond funds should be
spent. Included in this suit was a motion for "Partial Summary Judgment for Emergency Relief."
This motion requested the Court release monies from bond funds for remediation, site
stabilization, fixing or adding to current soil erosion measures, and seeding. This motion was
granted by the Court in May of 2013 and stabilization activities were completed in the summer
of 2013.
In February of 2015, the Superior Court Judge ordered a continuance in the Seven Falls matter to
allow Henderson County to obtain permits from the Corps and DWR. A hearing was held in May
of 2015 and the Court approved monies from bond funds could be spent on activities associated
with acquiring permits for improvements to road infrastructure (all permits, not just 401 and 404)
and obtaining bids for construction. Bid requests would be made only after all permits are
secured. Bids would be presented to the Court and the Court would order allocation of bond
funds for construction of the roads. Construction activities cannot proceed until a Court motion is
granted which dictates the allocation of funds.
The Seven Falls bonded phases area is almost entirely forested with exception of an extensive
abandoned road network in various stages of completion. There are also remnants of old
agricultural fields on site. The site is mountainous with elevations ranging from 2,080 above
mean sea level (MSL) near Pleasant Grove Road to 2,520 feet above MSL at the southern
boundary.
Six natural community types were identified within the bonded phases boundary: riparian forest,
red oak- hickory forest, old fields, wetlands, streams, and open water. The following is a
summary of each of the six habitat types identified on site.
Riparian forest community type is located in sheltered areas at low to moderate elevations. They
are primarily narrow, rocky gorges, steep ravines, and low gentle ridges within coves. Soils are
generally rocky and acidic. On site, this community type is scattered throughout the central and
southern portions of the property. They are located adjacent to stream channels and within the
stream channels' associated valleys. In general, these areas have a dense forest canopy with a
limited number of mesophytic trees. Dominant tree species observed include white pine (Pinus
strobus), Canadian hemlock (Tsuga canadensis), yellow birch (Betula lutea), black gum (Nyssa
sylvatica), red oak (Quercus rubra), and white oak (Quercus alba). The shrub layer is well
developed and often forms dense thickets. Shrub species observed include great rosebay
rhododendron (Rhododendron maximum), mountain laurel (Kalmia latifolia), dog hobble
(Leucothoe axillaris), American holly (Ilex opaca), and red maple (Acer rubrum). Less common
shrub species observed include blueberry (Vaccinium pallidum), deerberry (Vaccinium
stamineum), and sassafras (Sassafras albidum). The herbaceous layer is generally not well
developed in these communities but some common species observed on site include Christmas
fern (Polystichum acrostichoids), galax (Galax aphylla), and Indian cucumber root (Medeola
virginiana).
The red oak- hickory forest type is located on dry slopes and ridge tops. On site, this community
type is scattered throughout the central and southern portions of the property. Dominant tree
species include Virginia pine (Pinus virginiana), white oak, southern red oak (Quercus falcata),
sweet pignut hickory (Cayra glabra var. odorata), mockernut hickory (Carya tomentosa), and
shagbark hickory (Carya ovata). Other trees observed were sourwood (Oxydendron arboreum),
black gum, and yellow poplar (Liriodendron tulipifera). Conifers such as red cedar (Juniperus
virginiana), white pine, Virginia pine, and Canadian hemlock were observed but rare in this
habitat. Species observed in the midstory include sassafras, flowering dogwood (Cornus florida),
and American holly. Shrubs observed in this habitat include mountain laurel, great rosebay
rhododendron, huckleberry (Gaylusaccia baccata), American hazelnut (Corylus americana),
maple leaf viburnum (Viburnum acerifolium), blueberry, and deerberry. Vines such as common
greenbriar (Smilax rotundifolia) and saw tooth greenbriar (Smilax bona -nox) were observed, as
well. The herbaceous layer is sparse and patchy. Common species observed in this layer include
false Soloman's seal (Maianthemum racemosa), false yellow foxglove (Aureolaria flava),
goldenrod (Solidago spp.), whorled coreopsis ( Coreopsis major), spotted wintergreen
(Chimaphila maculatum), woodland sedge (Carex rosea), and panic grasses (Panicum spp.).
An anthropogenic community (old field) is a direct result of prior dairy farming activities and
ongoing agricultural practices. On site, this community is located north of the old trout farm and
on the property adjacent to Pleasant Grove Church Road. These areas are devoid of a canopy and
lack substantial woody vegetation. Plant species identified in this area include pokeberry
(Phytolacca americana), blackberry (Rubus spp.), lanceleaf plaintain (Plantago lanceolata),
Queen Anne's lace (Daucus carota), dock (Rumex crispus), evening primrose (Oenothera
biennis), horsenettle (Solanum americanum), buttercup (Ranunculus spp.), thin leaf mountain
mint (Pycnanthemum tenuifolium), mountain mint (Pycnanthemum spp.), and butterfly weed
rd
(Asclepias tuberosa). Composites observed in the herbaceous layer include alternate leaf wing
stem (Verbesina alternifolia), crownbeard (Verbesina occidentalis), ironweed (Vernonia
noveboracensis), whorled coreopsis, beggars ticks (Bidens cernua), fleabane (Erigeron
philadelphicus), sunflower (Helianthus spp.), Indian plaintain (Cacalia muhlenbergii), round leaf
eupatorium ( Eupatorium rotundifolium), goldenrod, and aster (Aster spp.). Grasses observed
include corn (Zea mays), foxtail millet (Setaria italica), barnyard grass (Echinochloa crusgalii),
fescue (Festuca spp.), panic grass, and velvet grass (Holcus lanatus).
There is 0.79 acre of wetlands on site. These areas exhibit the presence of hydric soil, hydrophytic
vegetation, and evidence of wetland hydrology and connectivity. The wetlands on this site are
composed of stream head seeps and wetlands resulting from the neglect and failure of sediment
and erosion control measures. Dominant trees observed were red maple and black willow (Salix
nigra). Shrub species observed included Chinese privet (Ligustrum sinense), elderberry
(Sambucus canadensis), silky willow (Salix sericea), tag alder (Alnus serrulata), swamp haw
(Viburnum nudum), pepper bush (Clethera acuminata), dog hobble, and yellow root
(Xanthorhiza simplicissima). Dominant species in the herbaceous layer include microstegium
( Microstegium vimineum), downy lobelia (Lobelia pubera), jewelweed (Impatiens capensis),
stinging nettle (Urtica dioica), ironweed, and green coneflower (Rudbeckia lacinata). Grasses
and sedges were common and included soft rush (Juncus effusus), marginal rush (Juncus
marginatus), American bur reed (Sparganium americanum), shallow sedge (Carex lurida),
fringed sedge (Carex crinita), fox tail sedge (Carex vulpinoidea), yellow flatsedge (Cyperus
flavescens), straw -color flatsedge (Cyperus strigosus), soft stem bulrush (Scirpus validus), and
woolgrass bulrush (Scirpus cyperinus). Ferns observed include cinnamon fern (Osmunda
cinnamomea), royal fern (Osmunda regalis), and netted chain fern (Woodwardia areolata).
Freshwater habitats include the streambeds and banks of Little Willow Creek and Folly Creek,
and their unnamed tributaries. There are approximately 3.5 miles of stream channels within the
bonded phases boundary. In general, these tributaries flow south to north and eventually into the
French Broad River. Streams within the central and southern portion of the property are bordered
by mature riparian forest. Stream channels north of the old trout farms and flowing through the
old fields lack any significant riparian buffer. Despite a large influx of sediment during
construction of roads in 2008, stream channels are recovering and are in good to fair condition.
Three small on -line impoundments exist in succession adjacent to Folly Creek. This system
impounds approximately 0.31 acre (collectively) of an unnamed tributary to Folly Creek.
The Seven Falls bonded phases project site is located within the Blue Ridge Mountain
physiographic region of North Carolina and more specifically the Broad Basin and Southern
Crystalline Ridges and Mountains Ecoregions. Two soil associations are present on site; they are
the Codorus - Toxaway - Rosman association and the Evard - Edneyville -Ashe association. The
Corodus - Toxaway - Rosman association is classified as nearly level, well drained to very poorly
drained soils that have a loamy and sandy subsoil and underlying layer. This association is found
on floodplains. The Evard - Edneyville -Ashe association is classified as sloping to very steep, well
drained, and somewhat excessively drained soils that have a loamy subsoil. This soil association
is found on mountain ridgetops and side slopes. Soil series present on site include: Ashe,
Bradson, Brevard, Edneyville, Evard, Hayesville, Tate, Toxaway, and Tusquitee.
61
Wildlife species inhabiting the site include those typically found in the forest types of the region
previously described. Although site - specific studies and inventories documenting species
utilization of the Seven Falls bond phases project area have not been conducted, general
observations of fish and wildlife use were recorded during the stream and wetland delineation,
and on -site meetings.
A file review of records maintained by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and North
Carolina Natural Heritage Program (NHP) was conducted. The FWS lists 8 species as occurring
in Henderson County that are subject to consultation under Section 7 of the Endangered Species
Act. The NHP database identifies 11 element occurrences (EO) within a 2 -mile radius of the
project site; 7 EOs, comprised of 3 species, hold a Federal status and are subject to Section 7
consultation. The Federally listed species identified by the FWS and NHP are listed below.
Common Name
bog turtle
Carolina northern flying squirrel
northern long -eared bat (NLEB)
Appalachian elktoe **
bunched arrowhead
Scientific Name Status
Glyptemys muhlenbergii T(S /A)
Glaucomys sabrinus coloratus E
Myotis septentrionalis
Alasmidonta raveneliana
Sagittaria. fasciculata
mountain sweet pitcher plant ** Sarracenia rubra ssp. jonesii
small whorled pogonia Isotria medeoloides
T
E
E
E
T
swamp pink ** Helonias bullata T
white Irisette Sisyrinchium dichotomum E
— Species with a Federal status subject to Section 7 consultation and within 2 miles of the project site.
Habitat assessments for Seven Falls Golf and River Club, including the bonded phases area, were
conducted in April and May of 2007. Potential fauna were identified to the taxonomic unit level
necessary to determine if the observed specimen was a protected species. A "Threatened and
Endangered Species Assessment" was included in the original Seven Falls Golf and River Club
permit application. Changes to site conditions since the time of the original assessment include
clearing of land and installation of roads, and clearing/under- brushing riparian areas. Because
site conditions have remained relatively unchanged, with exception of those changes listed
above, the Corps' opinion is the previous threatened and endangered species report is still valid.
The Corps, CEC, nor FWS have not observed listed species during 2007, 2008, or during multiple
site visits in 2014 and 2015.
Summer habitat for NLEB is present on site. Most tree clearing associated with road infrastructure
has already occurred. Minor tree clearing will be needed in the vicinity of the proposed access road
near Gore Lake. This tree clearing will occur outside of the May 15- August 15 moratorium. In the
event that additional tree clearing is needed during the May 15- August 15 moratorium, the
applicant would consult with the FWS prior to tree cutting activities.
A survey for Appalachian elktoe in the French Broad River was conducted in April of 2008. No
live or dead native mussels were found in the survey area. The French Broad River adjacent to
the Seven Falls Golf and River Club was reported to have been significantly affected by
on
sedimentation from upstream sources, and a heavy bed load of coarse, shifting sand was found in
all depositional areas and in many erosional habitats. Riparian areas adjacent to the French Broad
River were selectively cleared during construction activities associated with development of the
Seven Falls Golf and River Club, and river conditions have likely not improved since the original
survey. Because site conditions have remained relatively unchanged, with exception of those
changes listed above, the Corps' opinion is the previous Appalachian elktoe survey is still valid.
Additionally, the proposed bonded phases project no longer abuts the French Broad River and
the nearest developable lot in the bonded phases is greater than 1,400 feet from the river.
The FWS will be notified via Public Notice about the project and will be given the opportunity to
comment on the project and its potential effects on Federally listed species and their habitat.
In November of 2007, the Corps notified the NC State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) and
Tribal Historic Preservation Office (THPO) via Public Notice of the site development at the
proposed Seven Falls Golf and River Club. In December of 2007, the THPO commented on the
project indicating that cultural resources important to the Cherokee people may be threatened
due to proposed ground disturbance at the site. In January of 2008, the SHPO recommended a
comprehensive survey of the Seven Falls Golf and River Club project site (which includes the
Seven Falls bonded phases). In February of 2007, an intensive archaeological survey at the
proposed Seven Falls Golf and River Club project site was conducted. During the survey, 34
sites and 16 isolated finds were located within the Seven Falls Golf and River Club project
boundary. Six sites were recommended eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic
Places; all other sites were recommended ineligible. Of the 6 eligible sites, 1 site (31HN220) is
located within the Seven Falls bonded phases project boundary.
In May of 2008, the Corps determined that proposed activities at the Seven Falls Golf and River
Club may adversely affect the 6 eligible historic and cultural sites. The Corps developed a
Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) to mitigate potential adverse effects to the sites. The MOA
was signed by interested parties in July and August of 2008. The MOA included data recovery
excavations at all 6 eligible sites, including 31 HN220; however, data recovery was never
completed. Site 31HN220 was partially impacted by road construction (vegetation clearing and
grading) associated with development of the Seven Falls Golf and River Club. Currently, site
31 HN220 is contained within the road right -of -way and a platted residential lot. At present,
development is not proposed at this lot. However, road construction would be completed in
accordance with the performance bond. The MOA was nullified when the Corps' 404 permit was
revoked. Henderson County has not been granted development rights for individual lots. As
such, Henderson County cannot pursue data recovery for 31 HN220 at this time.
The SHPO will be notified via Public Notice about the project and will be given the opportunity to
comment on the project and its potential effects on archaeological and cultural resources.
A delineation of jurisdictional waters of the U.S. within the Seven Falls Golf and River Club
property was conducted from November of 2006 to January of 2007 by CEC. The jurisdictional
determination was field verified by the Corps in March and April 2007. However, a "Notice of
Jurisdictional Determination" was never issued due to the Rapanos v. United States court case
[547 US 715 (2006)] that was pending at the time.
7
The area within the Seven Falls bonded phases boundary was re- delineated in June of 2015. A
"Request for Jurisdictional Determination" was submitted to the Corps on July 30, 2015 and a
subsequent site field verification was conducted by the Corps on August 11, 2015. Jurisdictional
streams on site include Little Willow Creek and unnamed tributaries (UTs) of Little Willow
Creek, and Folly Creek and UTs of Folly Creek. All of the streams within the bonded phases
boundary are tributaries to the French Broad River. The French Broad River north of the site is a
navigable -in -fact water. Little Willow Creek and Folly Creek are classified by the NC Division
of Water Resources (DWR) as class "C" waters.
There are wetlands located within the bonded phases boundary. The majority of these wetlands
have been identified as wetland seeps and are contiguous with their associated stream channel.
Additional wetlands resulting from the neglect and failure of sediment and erosion measures
have also been included in the updated delineation. The site also contains three open -water ponds
associated with an abandoned trout farm.
A "Notification of Jurisdictional Determination" for the Seven Falls bonded phases area was
issued on August 24, 2015 under Action ID SAW- 2013 - 01159. A summary of jurisdictional
waters of the U.S. located within the bonded phases project boundary is shown below:
Feature
Stream
Wetlands
Open Water
Applicant's Stated Purpose
On -site Totals
Amount Unit
18,335 linear feet
0.79 acres
0.31 acres
The basic project purpose of the proposed project is to provide road access to residential lots.
More specifically, the overall project purpose of the proposed project is to complete road
infrastructure that would provide access to 206 residential lots within the bonded phases of the
abandon Seven Falls Golf and River Club development. Lot owners currently have no access to
their property. Road infrastructure would facilitate the development of a viable, residential
community in Henderson County, North Carolina.
Project Description
The proposed Seven Falls Bonded Phases project includes new impacts to jurisdictional streams
and wetlands for the completion of residential subdivision road infrastructure and permitting of
existing unauthorized stream impacts. The 302 -acre area represents property included in bonded
phases that were originally a part of the 1,400 -acre Seven Falls Golf and River Club residential
development. The area of the bonded phases includes residential lots platted and recorded with
Henderson County. Property outside of the designated bonded phases is not included in the
project. Approximately 1,667 linear feet of existing stream impacts were measured in the bonded
phases. Existing stream impacts were associated with partial development of the Seven Falls
Golf and River Club. The original permit authorization for the Seven Falls Golf and River Club
N.
was revoked by the Corps in April of 2010; therefore, existing impacts to jurisdictional streams
and wetlands at the property are unauthorized.
The proposed road network in the bonded phases area is mostly consistent with the original plan
for the Seven Falls Golf and River Club. Several road sections would not be completed as
originally planned and access from Pleasant Grove Church Road has been added. As proposed,
the project includes 11 existing stream crossings, installation of 1 new stream crossing, and
lengthening of 2 existing stream crossings in order to provide sufficient road widths. Permanent
road impacts are identified in the table below.
Stream Impacts
Wetland Impacts
Impact # Acres
8* 0.01
Totals 0.01
*New impacts.
Avoidance and Minimization
The applicant provided the following information in support of efforts to avoid and/or minimize
impacts to the aquatic environment:
W
Linear
Impact #
Feet
Notes
1 *
104
No existing culvert, new impact
2
93
3
113
4
43
5
62
6
245
7
106
9*
115
57 LF of unauthorized impacts, increase to 115 LF
10
147
11
101
12
168
13
375
14*
30
67 LF existing (pre -Seven Falls) impacts, increase to 97
LF
15
90
Totals
1,792
*New impacts.
Wetland Impacts
Impact # Acres
8* 0.01
Totals 0.01
*New impacts.
Avoidance and Minimization
The applicant provided the following information in support of efforts to avoid and/or minimize
impacts to the aquatic environment:
W
The Seven Falls Golf and River Club residential development was started in 2007 and more than
125 lots were sold at the onset of development. In June of 2010, Henderson County declared that
the Seven Falls Golf and River Club development was in default of the performance guarantee
and the developer failed to complete the required infrastructure improvements. Approximately
70 lot owners (in good tax standing with the County) cannot build on their property due to lack
of infrastructure and lack of access to the residential lots they purchased. Additionally,
approximately 50 foreclosed lots are unlikely to be sold without infrastructure in place.
Because the bond money is site specific and because platted and recorded lots have already been
sold, alternative site locations and alternative site plans are not feasible. Henderson County
received $6 million in bond funds. At this time, Henderson County does not believe that the bond
money will cover the cost of all bonded improvements. Henderson County is striving to
construct roads in an economical manner which provides access to the most lots, and leaves
money remaining for additional infrastructure (water and sewer).
Several road sections from the original development plan will not be completed, and access from
Pleasant Grove Church Road has been added. In doing so, eight stream crossings have been
avoided. Three crossings have been added to provide access from Pleasant Grove Church Road;
however, two crossings will be bridge replacements (no steam impact) and one crossing is in the
location of an existing crossing.
The original development plan road layout was designed to avoid impacts to streams and
wetlands to the maximum extent practicable. Because the site is covered in long linear stream
segments, it would be impossible to avoid all of the streams while continuing to maintain a
rational project design and the flexibility needed to construct a large scale master planned
residential community. The property contains an extensive road network in varying stages of
completion. Henderson County would utilize the existing roads to complete road infrastructure at
the site. And, as mentioned above, several road sections from the original plan would not be
completed.
Avoidance and minimization has taken place on site through elimination of several road sections
and general adherence to the original road layout. The table below summarizes the total
avoidance and minimization that has taken place within the Seven Falls bonded phases project
site.
Total On-
Proposed
Total
Feature Site
Impacts
Avoided Percentage
Streams 18,335 LF
1,792 LF
16,543 LF 90%
Wetlands 0.79 AC
0.01 AC
0.78 AC 99%
Compensatory Mitigation
The applicant offered the following compensatory mitigation plan to offset unavoidable
functional loss to the aquatic environment:
10
Upon completion and implementation of practical avoidance and minimization efforts, a total of
1,792 linear feet of stream impacts and 0.01 acres of wetland impacts associated with the
development within the Seven Falls bonded phases project area are unavoidable. Unavoidable
stream impacts will be mitigated for at a proposed compensatory mitigation ratio of 1:1.
The applicant is proposing to mitigate stream impacts at a 1:1 ratio through North Carolina
Department of Mitigation Services (DMS). By letter dated September 29, 2015, DMS has
indicated they are willing to accept payment for impacts up to 1,792 linear feet associated with
development of the Seven Falls bonded phases.
Mitigation as a whole consists of avoidance, minimization, and compensation. Through
avoidance and minimization, 90% of streams and 99% of wetlands will remain unimpacted at the
site. Several crossings on site have been completely eliminated, greatly reducing impacts when
compared to the originally proposed development. The applicant, Henderson County, is
proposing a 1:1 mitigation ratio for unavoidable impacts in an effort to "stretch" limited funding
and provide the most benefit to public, including property owners with the Seven Falls bonded
phases project area and residents of Henderson County.
Lot owners within the Seven Falls bonded phases project area have no access to the property
they own and no utilities to make lots viable. Therefore, the property as a whole has remained
abandoned since approximately 2008. Henderson County received $6 million in bond funds.
Because of minimal funds, Henderson County must prioritize work, and use funds cautiously and
efficiently. As an example, Henderson County will contract the completion of roads to provide
access; however, the roads will not be paved. This will provide additional funds for the next
phases of the project which includes installation of utilities. The funds saved by completing
compensatory mitigation at a 1:1 ratio would be enough to connect the Seven Falls development
to the existing municipal water supply. Paying for compensatory mitigation at a 2:1 ratio may
jeopardize utility construction that can be funded using bond money. Minimizing project cost in
completion of the proposed residential subdivision road infrastructure may provide additional
funds for future phases which may include installation of water and sewer utilities. In the event
utilities could not be constructed, remaining bond funds could be placed into an escrow account
to be used at a later date when a third party could defray the remaining costs of development.
Lack of utilities would cause existing lots to remain undevelopable. Proposing mitigation at a 2:1
ratio is not in the best interest of the lot owners with the Seven Falls bonded phases area or
residence of Henderson County because it compounds funding constraints that already make the
project difficult to complete.
Abandoned and vacant properties, such as those at Seven Falls, are a public nuisance. They are
associated with tax delinquency and denying local governments of desperately needed tax
revenues. Instead, abandoned and vacant properties consume tax dollars and decrease
neighboring property values. A smaller number of county residents must bear a greater portion of
the county tax burden. Henderson County is protecting the public interest by enforcing bond
requirements which includes development of infrastructure. By supporting Henderson County's
efforts to make the most efficient use of bond funds, including supporting a 1:1 compensatory
mitigation ratio, the tax burden of Henderson County residents would be lessened by
transforming abandoned land into a viable residential development.
11
Essential Fish Habitat
Pursuant to the Magnuson- Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act, this Public
Notice initiates the Essential Fish Habitat (EFH) consultation requirements. The Corps' initial
determination is that the proposed project would not effect EFH or associated fisheries managed
by the South Atlantic or Mid Atlantic Fishery Management Councils or the National Marine
Fisheries Service.
Cultural Resources
Pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, Appendix C of 33
CFR Part 325, and the 2005 Revised Interim Guidance for Implementing Appendix C, the
District Engineer consulted district files and records and the latest published version of the
National Register of Historic Places and initially determines that:
❑ Should historic properties, or properties eligible for inclusion in the National Register, be
present within the Corps' permit area; the proposed activity requiring the DA permit (the
undertaking) is a type of activity that will have no potential to cause an effect to an
historic properties.
❑ No historic properties, nor properties eligible for inclusion in the National Register, are
present within the Corps' permit area; therefore, there will be no historic properties
affected. The Corps subsequently requests concurrence from the SHPO (or THPO).
❑ Properties ineligible for inclusion in the National Register are present within the Corps'
permit area; there will be no historic properties affected by the proposed work. The Corps
subsequently requests concurrence from the SHPO (or THPO).
❑ Historic properties, or properties eligible for inclusion in the National Register, are
present within the Corps' permit area; however, the undertaking will have no adverse
effect on these historic properties. The Corps subsequently requests concurrence from the
SHPO (or THPO).
® Historic properties, or properties eligible for inclusion in the National Register, are
present within the Corps' permit area; moreover, the undertaking may have an adverse
effect on these historic properties. The Corps subsequently initiates consultation with the
SHPO (or THPO).
❑ The proposed work takes place in an area known to have the potential for the presence of
prehistoric and historic cultural resources; however, the area has not been formally
surveyed for the presence of cultural resources. No sites eligible for inclusion in the
National Register of Historic Places are known to be present in the vicinity of the
proposed work. Additional work may be necessary to identify and assess any historic or
prehistoric resources that may be present.
12
Site 31HN220 was partially impacted (vegetation clearing and grading) by road construction
associated with development of the Seven Falls Golf and River Club. This site is contained
within the road right -of -way and a platted residential lot within the bonded phases area. At
present, development is not proposed at this lot. However, under the proposed action road
construction would be complete in accordance with the performance bond. The previous MOA
was nullified when the Corps' 404 permit was revoked. Henderson County has not been granted
development rights for individual lots. As such, Henderson County cannot pursue data recovery
for 31 HN220 at this time. Further clearing and grading activities proposed in the bonded phases at
Site 31HN220, may affect the integrity of this historic or culturally significant site.
The District Engineer's final eligibility and effect determination will be based upon coordination
with the SHPO and/or THPO, as appropriate and required, and with full consideration given to
the proposed undertaking's potential direct and indirect effects on historic properties within the
Corps- indentified permit area.
Endangered Species
Pursuant to the Endangered Species Act of 1973, the Corps reviewed the project area, examined
all information provided by the applicant and consulted the latest North Carolina Natural
Heritage Database. Based on available information:
❑ The Corps determines that the proposed project would not affect federally listed
endangered or threatened species or their formally designated critical habitat.
® The Corps determines that the proposed project may affect, not likely to adversely affect
federally listed endangered or threatened species or their formally designated critical
habitat. The Corps initiates consultation under Section 7 of the ESA and will not make a
permit decision until the consultation process is complete.
❑ The Corps is not aware of the presence of species listed as threatened or endangered or
their critical habitat formally designated pursuant to the Endangered Species Act of 1973
(ESA) within the project area. The Corps will make a final determination on the effects of
the proposed project upon additional review of the project and completion of any
necessary biological assessment and/or consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service and/or National Marine Fisheries Service.
The following federally listed threatened species may occur at the project site.
Common Name Scientific Name
Northern Long -Eared Bat (NLEB) Myotis septentrionalis
Summer habitat for NLEB is present on site. Most tree clearing associated with road infrastructure
has already occurred. Minor tree clearing will be needed in the vicinity of the proposed access road
near Gore Lake. The applicant proposes to avoid clearing trees at this location trees during the
moratorium for the NLEB (May 15- August 15). In the event that additional tree clearing is needed
during the May 15- August 15 moratorium, the applicant would consult with the FWS prior to tree
13
cutting activities. The Corps concludes a federally protected species may be present within the
Seven Falls bonded phases boundary. As noted above, summer habitat for NLEB is present on site
and development at the site may affect, not likely to adversely affect NLEB.
The Corps initiates informal consultation with FWS under Section 7 of the ESA and will not
make a permit decision until the consultation process is complete.
Other Required Authorizations
The Corps forwards this notice and all applicable application materials to the appropriate State
agencies for review.
North Carolina Division of Water Resources ( NCDWR): The Corps will generally not make a
final permit decision until the NCDWR issues, denies, or waives the state Certification as
required by Section 401 of the Clean Water Act (PL 92 -500). The receipt of the application and
this public notice, combined with the appropriate application fee, at the NCDWR Central Office
in Raleigh constitutes initial receipt of an application for a 401 Certification. A waiver will be
deemed to occur if the NCDWR fails to act on this request for certification within sixty days of
receipt of a complete application. Additional information regarding the 401 Certification may be
reviewed at the NCDWR Central Office, 401 and Buffer Permitting Unit, 512 North Salisbury
Street, Raleigh, North Carolina 27604 -2260. All persons desiring to make comments regarding
the application for a 401 Certification should do so, in writing, by November 13, 2015 to:
NCDWR Central Office
Attention: Ms. Karen Higgins, 401 and Buffer Permitting Unit
(LISPS mailing address): 1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699 -1617
Or,
(physical address): 512 North Salisbury Street, Raleigh, North Carolina 27604
North Carolina Division of Coastal Management (NCDCM):
Based upon all available information, the Corps determines that this application for a Department
of Army (DA) permit does not involve an activity which would affect the coastal zone, which is
defined by the Coastal Zone Management (CZM) Act (16 U.S.C. § 1453).
Evaluation
The decision whether to issue a permit will be based on an evaluation of the probable impacts
including cumulative impacts of the proposed activity on the public interest. That decision will
reflect the national concern for both protection and utilization of important resources. The benefit
which reasonably may be expected to accrue from the proposal must be balanced against its
reasonably foreseeable detriments. All factors which may be relevant to the proposal will be
considered including the cumulative effects thereof, among those are conservation, economics,
aesthetics, general environmental concerns, wetlands, historic properties, fish and wildlife
14
values, flood hazards, flood plain values (in accordance with Executive Order 11988), land use,
navigation, shoreline erosion and accretion, recreation, water supply and conservation, water
quality, energy needs, safety, food and fiber production, mineral needs, considerations of
property ownership, and, in general, the needs and welfare of the people. For activities involving
the discharge of dredged or fill materials in waters of the United States, the evaluation of the
impact of the activity on the public interest will include application of the Environmental
Protection Agency's 404(b)(1) guidelines.
Commenting Information
The Corps of Engineers is soliciting comments from the public; Federal, State and local agencies
and officials, including any consolidated State Viewpoint or written position of the Governor;
Indian Tribes and other interested parties in order to consider and evaluate the impacts of this
proposed activity. Any comments received will be considered by the Corps of Engineers to
determine whether to issue, modify, condition or deny a permit for this proposal. To make this
decision, comments are used to assess impacts on endangered species, historic properties, water
quality, general environmental effects, and the other public interest factors listed above.
Comments are used in the preparation of an Environmental Assessment (EA) and/or an
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA). Comments are also used to determine the need for a public hearing and to determine the
overall public interest of the proposed activity.
Any person may request, in writing, within the comment period specified in this notice, that a
public hearing be held to consider the application. Requests for public hearings shall state, with
particularity, the reasons for holding a public hearing. Requests for a public hearing shall be
granted, unless the District Engineer determines that the issues raised are insubstantial or there is
otherwise no valid interest to be served by a hearing.
The Corps of Engineers, Wilmington District will receive written comments pertinent to the
proposed work, as outlined above, until 5pm, November 13, 2015. Comments should be
submitted to Mr. David Brown, Asheville Regulatory Field Office, 151 Patton Avenue, Room
208, Asheville, North Carolina 28801, at (828) 271 -7980, ext. 232.
15
Seven Falls Bonded Phases ( +/- 302 AC)
Etowah
'3y 6
t
vs�s
s,
ye
Mill $
River
e
Q`G
N
f
�9
Horse
Shoe
3�PA Gs",
1
40�
pry
u r..
ldnunh: r..i Y G
� o
i
$
G�. a
N
I } �
- 0
Laurel
" Rd Park u e g 6
Hendert onvi l le
Hendersonville
.ri }4X �hloN
eply D �i
�G
JJ �_
".a
Bonded Phases Boundary
Flat
Rock
li.
Legend
0 0.5 1 2
Bonded Phases Boundary Miles
Drawn by: RLN 07.21.15; CEC Project# 696
Henderson County, CLearWater _ Site Vicinity
North Carolina Figure 2
32 Clayton Street
Asheville, North Carolina 28801
l
rr+ \
Etowah
'3y 6
t
vs�s
s,
ye
Mill $
River
e
Q`G
N
f
�9
Horse
Shoe
3�PA Gs",
1
40�
pry
u r..
ldnunh: r..i Y G
� o
i
$
G�. a
N
I } �
- 0
Laurel
" Rd Park u e g 6
Hendert onvi l le
Hendersonville
.ri }4X �hloN
eply D �i
�G
JJ �_
".a
Bonded Phases Boundary
Flat
Rock
li.
Legend
0 0.5 1 2
Bonded Phases Boundary Miles
Drawn by: RLN 07.21.15; CEC Project# 696
Henderson County, CLearWater _ Site Vicinity
North Carolina Figure 2
32 Clayton Street
Asheville, North Carolina 28801
Seven Falls Bonded Phases ( +/- 302 AC)
• - Q -�. N 0-5 /
J Oil
• a
� L
Little Willow Creek
99
i -
I j,- .
Bonded Phases Boundary (,
�r
Legend
Bonded Phases Boundary
Drawn by.L.22.1�6: CEC�r j�A63fi1\
Henderson County,
North Carolina
CLearWater
32 Clayton Street
Asheville, North Carolina 28801
p
VA
I�
I
0 500 1,000 2,000
USGS Topographic Map
Horse Shoe Quad
Figure 3
I
Seven Falls Bonded Phases ( +/-
'F ui S
I'
Broad Creek � -
4
a
o,
3
P
4
Legend
Seven Falls - Bonded Phases Boundary
Seven Falls Golf and River Club - Original Boundary
Drawn by: RLN 07.21.15; Project# 696 .1 ;�,,,�
Henderson County,
North Carolina
302 AC)
d�
M SG _
0
'D �6
m e
�o
0
KirS f
° "es Rd
F
r �_ L'' -�.t' max' _@•' �R�
CLearWaLer
32 Clayton Street
Asheville, North Carolina 28801
• 0 500 1,000 2,000
Feet
Boundary Comparison
Figure 1
Z
Seven Falls Bonded Phases ( +/- 302 AC)
�f
'm
N
G%
O
L
CD
r—
Impact #16
67 LF - measured
(increase to 97 LF)
Existing Bridge L
to be Replaced
r
O
Existing Bridge
to be Replaced
I
0
\ I Stream Impacts
I mpact # Measured For Permit
1 0 0
2 0 0
3 93 93
4 156 156 J\
5 62 62
6 0 104 I,
7 0 0
8 245 245
9 57 115
10 147 147 I�
11 101 101
--------- - - - -_1 12 0 0
' - - I 13 168 168
I 14 375 375
` - ^ - -�.' '- ---- ------ - - -��� I 15 106 106
Pleasant Grove Road 1 16* 67 30
Totals 1577 1702
*Crossing #16 has an existrg 0
`- 67 foot culvert that would be
increased to 97 feet, for a total
new impact of 30 feet.
� � I
� I I
i
I
I �
I
f
I
i
I
I
Impact #2
I 0 LF
Impact #4
� I ^
Two Crossings
J 156 LF \
i� Impact #3////
93 LF o
I
Impact #6 \ \
0 LF - measured /
�\ I (increase to 104 LF) V �paFct #5
i
i
_ lo, i
i
i
i
i
i
i
� I
1
1
Impact #10
147 LF
Impact #13
168 LF
f
Impact #9
57 LF - measured
(increase to 115 LF)
Bridge j
(not installed)
Impact #12
0 LF
Impact #11
101 LF
Impact #14
375 LF
/0 250 500 1,000 17500
Feet C
Henderson County,
North Carolina
/ I
Impact #15
106 LF
1
pact #17
)1 AC \
O
Bridge
(not installed) /
(not installed)
stalled) /
0
Lear r
224 South Grove Street, Suite F
Hendersonville, North Carolina 28792
Impact #7 I �-
0 LF Impact #8
245 LF / / z-
Legend
Stream - - - - USGS Streams
Culvert State Roads
Linear Wetland Roads Not to Complete
Wetland Bonded Parcels
Open Water Bonded Phases Boundary
Cultural Resources
Drawn by: RLN 07.20.15; CEC Project #696\
Seven Falls - Bonded Phases Plan
Existing /Proposed Stream Impacts
IN
1
1
1
I
I
Z
Seven Falls Bonded Phases ( +/- 302 AC)
�f
'm
N
G%
O
L
CD
r—
Impact #16
67 LF - measured
(increase to 97 LF)
Existing Bridge L
to be Replaced
r
O
Existing Bridge
to be Replaced
I
0
\ I Stream Impacts
I mpact # Measured For Permit
1 0 0
2 0 0
3 93 93
4 156 156 J\
5 62 62
6 0 104 I,
7 0 0
8 245 245
9 57 115
10 147 147 I�
11 101 101
--------- - - - -_1 12 0 0
' - - I 13 168 168
I 14 375 375
` - ^ - -�.' '- ---- ------ - - -��� I 15 106 106
Pleasant Grove Road 1 16* 67 30
Totals 1577 1702
*Crossing #16 has an existrg 0
`- 67 foot culvert that would be
increased to 97 feet, for a total
new impact of 30 feet.
� � I
� I I
i
I
I �
I
f
I
i
I
I
Impact #2
I 0 LF
Impact #4
� I ^
Two Crossings
J 156 LF \
i� Impact #3////
93 LF o
I
Impact #6 \ \
0 LF - measured /
�\ I (increase to 104 LF) V �paFct #5
i
i
_ lo, i
i
i
i
i
i
i
� I
1
1
Impact #10
147 LF
Impact #13
168 LF
f
Impact #9
57 LF - measured
(increase to 115 LF)
Bridge j
(not installed)
Impact #12
0 LF
Impact #11
101 LF
Impact #14
375 LF
/0 250 500 1,000 17500
Feet C
Henderson County,
North Carolina
/ I
Impact #15
106 LF
1
pact #17
)1 AC \
O
Bridge
(not installed) /
(not installed)
stalled) /
0
Lear r
224 South Grove Street, Suite F
Hendersonville, North Carolina 28792
Impact #7 I �-
0 LF Impact #8
245 LF / / z-
Legend
Stream - - - - USGS Streams
Culvert State Roads
Linear Wetland Roads Not to Complete
Wetland Bonded Parcels
Open Water Bonded Phases Boundary
Cultural Resources
Drawn by: RLN 07.20.15; CEC Project #696\
Seven Falls - Bonded Phases Plan
Existing /Proposed Stream Impacts
N
Seven Falls Bonded ( +/- 302 AC)
Ci
i
0 250 500 1,000
Feet
Drawn b�� 125.15; Projec�
Henderson County,
North Carolina
i
11 rr ,' j
Lear ter
C a
W
32 Clayton Street
Asheville, North Carolina 28801
Legend
Owned by Seven Falls LLC
Owned by Other LLCs
Owned by Individuals
Owned by Bank
Owned by McElrath Carolina Investments LLC
Delinquent Taxes
Parcels
Parcel Ownership
Henderson County Parcel Data
Figure 6