Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20190159 Ver 1_StrawberryHill_100094_MY2_Buffer_2023_20240116 (MY2) MONITORING REPORT – Riparian Buffer Mitigation STRAWBERRY HILL MITIGATION PROJECT Johnston County, North Carolina Neuse River Basin HUC 03020201 NCDMS Project #100094 (Contract #7745) USACE Action ID: SAW-2019-00124 DWR Project #2019-0159 Provided by: Resource Environmental Solutions, LLC for Environmental Banc & Exchange – Neuse I, LLC (EBX-Neuse I) Provided for: NC Department of Environmental Quality Division of Mitigation Services 1652 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699-1652 January 2023 December 4, 2023 Via email: mdeangelo@res.us Matt Deangelo RES Subject: DMS Comments on the MY2 Report Strawberry Hill, Project ID #100094, DMS Contract 7745 Matt, DMS received the MY2 draft report on 11/10/2023 and visited the site on 11/30/22. DMS offers the following comments for the report: Stream Report 1. Section 1.5.1 – References applying a “liquid organic soil amendment” to bare areas on site. Please give more details about the soil amendment. 2. Section 1.5.2 – Incorrect statement that “One stage recorder and one flow gauge are documenting conditions on reaches JH1-A and JH1-B, respectively.” This sentence implies that crest gauge data is being collected on JH1-A and flow data on JH1-B. 3. Please review cross sections. Some cross section BHRs are not reproducible with the numbers in the report. For example, XS-3 calculates to a 0.95 BHR based on report numbers (using formula LTOB Max Depth / [BKFL Elev. Based on MY0 XSA – Thalweg Elevation]) but is reported as 1.00. Reviewing the submitted Excel data (again using XS-3 as an example) to remove possibility of rounding errors produces similar results. We can reproduce all MY1 BHRs with the method described above. 4. A few minor encroachments (scalloping) were identified during the 11/30 site visit. Please add these areas to the CCPV and indicate how future encroachments will be prevented in these areas. Buffer Report 1. Section 1.5 – Provide detail on “liquid organic soil amendment” proposed for application to bare areas. 2. A few minor encroachments (scalloping) were identified during the 11/30 site visit. Please add these areas to the CCPV and indicate how future encroachments will be prevented in these areas. Please incorporate the revisions and provide a response to comments letter, one (1) hardcopy, and one (1) pdf copy along with any updated digital files that may be needed based on the comments above. If you have any questions, or wish to discuss these comments further, please contact me at any time. I can be reached at (919) 218-0226, or via email at jeremiah.dow@ncdenr.gov Sincerely, Jeremiah Dow Eastern Regional Supervisor NCDEQ Division of Mitigation Services cc: Jamey McEachran, RES 3600 Glenwood Avenue, Suite 100 Raleigh, NC 27612 Corporate Headquarters 6575 W Loop S #300 Bellaire, TX 77401 Main: 713.520.5400 res.us January 12, 2024 Jeremiah Dow NC DEQ Division of Mitigation Services 217 West Jones Street Raleigh, NC 27604 RE: DMS Comments on the MY2 Report Strawberry Hill, Project ID #100094, DMS Contract 7745 Listed below are comments provided by DMS on December 4, 2023 regarding the Strawberry Hill Stream and Riparian Buffer Mitigation Project Year 2 Monitoring Reports and RES’ responses. Buffer Report Comments: 1. Section 1.5 – Provide detail on “liquid organic soil amendment” proposed for application to bare areas. This has been revised to clarify that the amendment is a liquid humic acid fertilizer. 2. A few minor encroachments (scalloping) were identified during the 11/30 site visit. Please add these areas to the CCPV and indicate how future encroachments will be prevented in these areas. The CCPV has been revised to include these areas and discussion has been added to Section 1.5. The encroachments are very small and narrow and do not appear to result in any tree mortality. The areas are mapped as lines as the areal coverage is minimal. Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project i Year 2 Monitoring Report - Buffer Project #100094 January 2024 Table of Contents 1 Project Summary ...................................................................................................................................................... 1  1.1 Project Location and Description ....................................................................................................... 1  1.2 Monitoring Protocol and Project Success Criteria ....................................................................... 2  1.3 Project Components ................................................................................................................................ 3  1.4 Riparian Mitigation Approach ............................................................................................................. 3  1.5 Monitoring Performance (MY2) .......................................................................................................... 4  2 References .................................................................................................................................................................. 5  Appendix A: Background Tables and Site Maps Figure 1: Site Location Map Figure 2: Current Conditions Plan View Map Table 1: Buffer Project Areas and Assets Table 2: Summary: Goals, Performance and Results Table 3: Project Attributes Table 4: Project Timeline and Contacts Appendix B: Vegetation Assessment Data Table 5: Plant Species Summary Table 6: Vegetation Plot Mitigation Success Summary Table Table 7: Stem Count Total and Planted by Plot Species Appendix C: Photos Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos General Site Photos Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project 1 Year 2 Monitoring Report - Buffer Project #100094 January 2024 1 PROJECT SUMMARY 1.1 Project Location and Description The Strawberry Hill Project is within the Neuse River Basin within the 8-digit HUC 03020201, 14- digit HUC 03020201140010 and DWR Sub-basin Number 03-04-02. The Strawberry Hill Project is located in Johnston County in Smithfield, NC at the crossroads of Yelverton Grove Road and Brogden Road (Figure 1). To access the Project from Raleigh, take I-40 East to US-70 East. Then take US-70 BUS West until taking a right onto South 3rd Street in downtown Smithfield. Then take a left onto Brogden Road. Follow Brogden Road for 2.9 miles and the downstream extent of reach JH1-B will be on your left. The coordinates are 35.469579 °N and -78.323896 °W. Environmental Banc & Exchange – Neuse I, LLC (EBX-Neuse I), a wholly-owned subsidiary of Resource Environmental Solutions (RES), is pleased to provide this Year 1 Monitoring Report as a component of the Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project (Project), a full-delivery stream and buffer mitigation project for the Division of Mitigation Services (DMS) (DMS #100094). This buffer component of the Project is designed to provide riparian buffer mitigation credits for unavoidable impacts due to development within the Neuse River Basin, United States Geological Survey (USGS) 8-digit Cataloguing Unit 03020201 (Neuse 01) (Figure 1). This Buffer Project provides mitigation in accordance with the Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rule 15A NCAC 02B .0295 and Nutrient Offset Credit Trading Rule 15A NCAC 02B .0703. The Strawberry Hill Project also entails a stream mitigation component, generating stream mitigation credits through stream restoration. Conditions pertaining to the stream mitigation component of this Project will be provided in a separate baseline monitoring report. The conservation easement of the Strawberry Hill Project totals 22.12 acres and includes two unnamed tributaries and three ditches that drain into Polecat Branch and eventually the Neuse River. Previous land use within the Project was primarily crop production and disturbed riparian forest. The Project area was used extensively for agricultural and forestry purposes for over 80 years. Land use adjacent to and surrounding the Project is either crop production or forest regeneration. Water quality stressors affecting the Project include pollution from crop production and lack of forested riparian buffer. Previous buffer conditions demonstrated significant degradation with the loss of stabilizing vegetation because of continued crop production and recent clear cut of adjacent riparian forest. The goal of the buffer component of the Project is to restore and preserve ecological function to the existing streams and their associated riparian buffer areas by establishing appropriate plant communities while minimizing temporal and land disturbing impacts. Buffer and surrounding riparian area improvements will filter runoff from agricultural fields, thereby reducing nutrient and sediment loads to Project channels and provide water quality benefit to the overall watershed. Project attributes are summarized in Table 1. Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project 2 Year 2 Monitoring Report - Buffer Project #100094 January 2024 1.2 Monitoring Protocol and Project Success Criteria Annual vegetation monitoring and visual assessments are being conducted. Riparian vegetation monitoring is based on the “Carolina Vegetation Survey-Ecosystem Enhancement Program Protocol for Recording Vegetation: Level 2 Plot Sampling Only Version 4.2”. Monitoring plots were installed a minimum of 100 meters squared in size and cover at least two percent of the planted mitigation area. These plots were randomly placed throughout the planted riparian buffer mitigation area (15.13 acres) and are representative of the riparian restoration conditions. The following data is recorded for all trees in the plots: species, height, planting date (or volunteer), and grid location. All stems in plots are flagged with flagging tape. Data is processed using the CVS data entry tool. In the field, the four corners of each plot were permanently marked with PVC at the origin and metal conduit at the other corners. Photos of each plot are to be taken from the origin each monitoring year. There are 13 fixed vegetation monitoring plots (Figure 2). Photos are being taken at all vegetation plot origins each monitoring year and be provided in the annual reports. Visual inspections and photos are taken to ensure that areas are being maintained and compliant. The measures of vegetative success for the Project are the survival of at least four native hardwood tree species, where no one species is greater than 50 percent of stems, at a density of at least 260 stems per acre at the end of Year 5. Native volunteer species may be included to meet the performance standards as determined by NC Division of Water Resources (DWR). A visual assessment of the conservation easement is also performed each year to confirm:  Easement boundary markers/signage are in good condition throughout the site;  No encroachment has occurred;  No invasive species in areas were invasive species were treated,  Diffuse flow is being maintained in the conservation easement areas; and  There has not been any cutting, clearing, filling, grading, or similar activities that would negatively affect the functioning of the buffer. Component/ Feature Monitoring Maintenance through project close-out Vegetation Annual vegetation monitoring Vegetation shall be maintained to ensure the health and vigor of the targeted plant community. Routine vegetation maintenance and repair activities may include supplemental planting, pruning, mulching, and fertilizing. Exotic invasive plant species shall be treated by mechanical and/or chemical methods. Any vegetation requiring herbicide application will be performed in accordance with NC Department of Agriculture (NCDA) rules and regulations. Vegetation maintenance activities will be documented and reported in annual monitoring reports. Vegetation maintenance will continue through the monitoring period. Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project 3 Year 2 Monitoring Report - Buffer Project #100094 January 2024 Component/ Feature Monitoring Maintenance through project close-out Invasive and Nuisance Vegetation Visual Assessment Invasive and noxious species will be monitored and treated so that none become dominant or alter the desired community structure of the Project. Locations of invasive and nuisance vegetation will be mapped. Project Boundary Visual Assessment Project boundaries shall be identified in the field to ensure clear distinction between the mitigation project and adjacent properties. Boundaries are marked with signs identifying the property as a mitigation project and will include the name of the long-term steward and a contact number. Boundaries may be identified by fence, marker, bollard, post, tree-blazing, or other means as allowed by Project conditions and/or conservation easement. Boundary markers disturbed, damaged, or destroyed will be repaired and/or replaced on an as-needed basis. Easement monitoring and staking/ signage maintenance will continue in perpetuity as a stewardship activity. Road Crossing Visual Assessment Road crossings within the Project may be maintained only as allowed by conservation easement or existing easement, deed restrictions, rights of way, or corridor agreements. Crossings in easement breaks are the responsibility of the landowner to maintain. 1.3 Project Components This Project generates 642,070.977 riparian buffer restoration credits on pre-existing non-forested land, and 8,091.309 buffer preservation credits. The total area of riparian preservation is less than 25 percent of the total area of riparian buffer mitigation in accordance with 15A NCAC 02B .0295 (o)(5). The total riparian buffer mitigation credits that the Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project generate are summarized below, but the detailed Project credit breakdown, including buffer credits that are convertible to nutrient offset credit, utilizing the DWR “Project Credit Table Template (Updated February 2022),” is provided in Table 1; Appendix A. Mitigation Totals Area Square Feet Credits Restoration 652,991 642,070.977 Preservation 81,431 8,091.309 Total Riparian Buffer 734,422 650,162.286 1.4 Riparian Mitigation Approach The buffer mitigation is in accordance with the Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rule 15A NCAC 02B .0295 and Nutrient Offset Credit Trading Rule 15A NCAC 02B .0703. In addition to traditional riparian restoration, the Project also incorporates the alternative buffer mitigation options: Preservation of Buffers on Subject Streams, as outlined in 15A NCAC 02B .0295 (o) (5), and Restoration and Enhancement of Ditches, as outlined in 15A NCAC 02B .0295 (o) (8). Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project 4 Year 2 Monitoring Report - Buffer Project #100094 January 2024 Riparian restoration along the Project streams and ditches is accomplished through the planting, establishment, and protection of a hardwood forest community. Restoration activities included planting a composition of native bare-root tree species along streams and ditches based on reference data. The result will be a riparian area that functions to mitigate nutrient and sediment inputs from the surrounding uplands. Preservation occurs in some areas along Reach JH1-A and JH1-B. Some of these preservation areas were associated with stream restoration under the stream mitigation component of the Project; therefore, some of the areas were cleared during construction of the new stream corridor. However, these impacted areas were planted under the same criteria as restoration areas. 1.5 Monitoring Performance (MY2) Year 2 monitoring of 13 fixed vegetation plots was completed on October 3rd, 2023. Vegetation tables are in Appendix B and associated photos are in Appendix C. MY2 monitoring data indicates that all plots are exceeding the success criteria of 260 planted stems per acre. Planted stem densities ranged from 324 to 688 planted stems per acre with a mean of 529 planted stems per acre across all plots. A total of 12 planted species were documented within the plots. Seven volunteer species were identified across the plots, and it is expected that more volunteers will establish in upcoming years. The average planted stem height in the vegetation plots was 2.7 feet. Visual assessment of vegetation outside of the monitoring plots indicates that the herbaceous vegetation is establishing in much of the riparian area. However, areas where Priority II stream restoration activities involved extensive grading are struggling to establish dense vegetative cover though still have adequate tree density at this time. The total area of bare areas amounts to 3.77 acres and are depicted in Figure 2. In November 2023, RES applied an organic soil amendment in the form of humic acid to these areas to promote soil health and vegetative growth while minimizing damage to planted trees. RES also noted that loblolly pine (Pinus taeda) is establishing in some areas, totaling about 3.9 acres (Figure 2). The pines are still short, but RES plans to treat these promptly to minimize their competition with desirable trees. For the most part, easement boundary markers and signs are clearly visible and in good condition although there are several along the farm fields that have been damaged from large farm equipment, so RES is planning to re-establish and add markers where applicable. The previously reported (in MY1) encroachment associated with ditches JH2 and JH3 along Stevens Sausage Road were resolved as of March 2023. RES installed additional t-post markers along with horse tape to provide a physical barrier to prevent future encroachment and replanted the driving path footprint with containerized trees to ensure adequate tree density and vigor. Specifically, 65 three-gallon containerized trees were planted including American sycamore (Platanus occidentalis), river birch (Betula nigra), willow oak (Quercus phellos), and swamp chestnut oak (Quercus michauxii). RES also relocated a roadside ditch crossing that enables farm equipment to access the fields away from the easement. The construction is complete, and the landowner and farmer are complying and actively utilizing the new driveway. Locations of activities are depicted in Appendix A, Figure 2 and photos Appendix C. Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project 5 Year 2 Monitoring Report - Buffer Project #100094 January 2024 During MY2, inspection of the easement determined two minor encroachments have occurred. One area is located at the boundary edge near the top of JH1-B where the adjacent landowner is mowing his lawn around several of his fruit trees at the boundary, but no planted trees are harmed, and the areal coverage is minimal. For this issue, RES plans to discuss alternative, allowable methods with the landowner to protect his fruit trees while complying with the easement restrictions. Another area occurs at the lower end of JH1-B along the adjacent crop field. Farm equipment has slighty “scalloped” into the easement boundary. However, it is narrow enough that trees do not appear to be affected. For this issue, RES plans to add more easement markers along the boundary at shorter intervals to provide a more visible line. Additionally, RES did document several markers (t-posts and signs) throughout the Project area had been damaged by farm equipment along some of the crop field edges. RES will repair or replace these markers. Additionally, there is no undocumented concentrated flow in the easement area. 2 REFERENCES Lee Michael T., Peet Robert K., Roberts Steven D., and Wentworth Thomas R., 2008. CVS-EEP Protocol for Recording Vegetation Level. Version 4.2 NC Environmental Management Commission. 2014. Rule 15A NCAC 02B.0295 - Mitigation Program Requirements for the Protection and Maintenance of Riparian Buffers. NC Environmental Management Commission. 2020. Rule 15A NCAC 02B.0714 – Neuse River Basin: Nutrient Sensitive Waters Management Strategy: Protection and Maintenance of Existing Riparian Buffers. Resource Environmental Solutions, LLC (2020). Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project – Final Mitigation Plan – Appendix A – Final Buffer Mitigation Plan. Schafale, M.P. 2012. Classification of the Natural Communities of North Carolina, Fourth Approximation. North Carolina Natural Heritage Program, Division of Parks and Recreation, NCDENR, Raleigh, NC. Appendix A Project Background Tables and Site Maps 0 1,000500 Feet Figure 1 - Site Location Strawberry HillMitigation Project Johnston County, North Carolina Legend Proposed Easement Neuse River Basin - 03020201 (Excluding Falls Lake Watershed) ©Date: 3/24/2022 Drawn by: MDD Checked by: JRM Document Path: R:\Resgis\entgis\Projects\101038_Strawberry_Hill\MXD\6_Monitoring\Figure 1 - SIte Location_Buffer.mxd 1 inch = 1,000 feet Strawberry HillMitigation Project Projec t Coordintates:35.469579, -78.323896 JH1-B JH1-A JH4 JH3 JH2 JH5 12 3 4 5 6 7 13 11 12 10 9 8 Esri, HERE, Garmin, (c) OpenStreetMap contributors © Figure 2 - CCPV MY2 Strawberr y HillMitigation Project Johnston County,North Carolina Date: 1/11/2024 Drawn by: MDD Document Path: R:\Resgis\Projects\NC\101038_Strawberry_Hill\MXD\6_MonitoringMaintenance\MY2\DWR\Figure 2 - CCPV DWR - Strawberry Hill.mxd Restoring a resilient earth for a modern world 1 in = 300 feet 0 300150 Feet Legend Recorded Easement (22.12 ac)Supplemental Planting Vegetation Plot >320 stems/acre Riparian Buffer MitigationApproach Riparian Restoration, 0-100' Riparian Restoration, 101-200' Riparian Restoration (Ditch),0-50' Riparian Preser vation, 0-100' Riparian Preser vation, 101-200' Non-diffuse Flow DeductionArea Area Not Viable for Credit Sur veyed Top of BankEncroachment Line Checked by: JRM Area 20-29 ft. cSupplemental Plantingin Feb. 2023 Agricultural Access DrivewayInstalled in Mar. 2023 cLoblolly PinesPresent Bare Area Bare Area Bare Area Minor scalloping from farmer.Minimal area. Trees not impacted. Mowing aroundtrees. Minimal area Table 1. Strawberry Hill, DMS# 100094, Project Credits Project Area N Credit Conversion Ratio (ft2/pound) P Credit Conversion Ratio (ft2/pound) Credit Type Location Subject? (enter NO if ephemeral or ditch 1) Feature Type Mitigation Activity Min­Max Buffer Width (ft)Feature Name Total Area (ft2) Total (Creditable) Area of Buffer Mitigation (ft2) Initial Credit Ratio (x:1)% Full Credit Final Credit Ratio (x:1) Convertible to Riparian Buffer? Riparian Buffer Credits Convertible to Nutrient Offset? Delivered Nutrient Offset: N (lbs) Delivered Nutrient Offset: P (lbs) Buffer Rural Yes I / P Restoration 0­100 Cropland (JH1, JH5)370,703 370,703 1 100% 1.00000 Yes 370,703.000 Yes 19,343.778 — Buffer Rural Yes I / P Restoration 0­100 Timberland (JH1)122,409 122,409 1 100% 1.00000 Yes 122,409.000 No —— Buffer Rural Yes I / P Restoration 101­200 Cropland (JH1, JH5)9,149 9,149 1 33% 3.03030 Yes 3,019.173 Yes 477.407 — Buffer Rural Yes I / P Restoration 101­200 Timberland (JH1)6,810 6,810 1 33% 3.03030 Yes 2,247.302 No —— Buffer Rural No Ditch Restoration 0­50 JH2, JH3, JH4 136,211 136,211 1 100% 1.00000 Yes 136,211.000 Yes 7,107.672 — Buffer Rural No Ditch Restoration 0­50 Segment Less than 50' (JH2)6,799 6,799 1 100% 1.00000 Yes 6,799.000 No —— Buffer Rural No Ditch Restoration 0­100 Non­diffused Flow Deductions (JH1, JH2, JH4) 16,303 0 1 100%No —No —— Buffer Rural Yes I / P Restoration 20­29 Segment Less than 30' (JH1)910 910 1 75% 1.33333 Yes 682.502 No —— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— ——— Totals (ft2):669,294 652,991 642,070.977 26,928.857 0.000 Total Buffer (ft2):669,294 652,991 Total Nutrient Offset (ft2):0N/A Total Ephemeral Area (ft2) for Credit:00 Total Eligible Ephemeral Area (ft2):187,681 0.0%Ephemeral Reaches as % TABM Enter Preservation Credits Below Total Eligible for Preservation (ft2):223,098 9.1%Preservation as % TABM Credit Type Location Subject? Feature Type Mitigation Activity Min­Max Buffer Width (ft)Feature Name Total Area (sf) Total (Creditable) Area for Buffer Mitigation (ft2) Initial Credit Ratio (x:1)% Full Credit Final Credit Ratio (x:1) Riparian Buffer Credits Buffer Rural Yes I / P 0­100 JH1, JH5 80,658 80,658 10 100% 10.00000 8,065.800 Buffer Rural Yes I / P 101­200 JH1, JH5 773 773 10 33% 30.30303 25.509 Buffer — Buffer — Buffer — Preservation Area Subtotals (ft2):81,431 81,431 Square Feet Credits 652,991 642,070.977 00.000 81,431 8,091.309 734,422 650,162.286 Square Feet Credits Nitrogen:0.000 Phosphorus:0.000 Neuse 03020201 ­ Outside Falls Lake 19.16394 N/A Restoration: Enhancement: Mitigation Totals 0 TOTAL AREA OF BUFFER MITIGATION (TABM) TOTAL NUTRIENT OFFSET MITIGATION Mitigation Totals Nutrient Offset: Preservation: Total Riparian Buffer: 1. The Randleman Lake buffer rules allow some ditches to be classified as subject according to 15A NCAC 02B .0250 (5)(a). last updated 08/03/2020 ivisionŽĨDŝƚŝŐĂƚŝŽŶ^ĞƌǀŝĐĞƐ;D^ͿǁŝůůŚĂǀĞƚŚĞĨůĞdžŝďŝůŝƚLJƚŽĐŽŶǀĞƌƚZŝƉĂƌŝĂŶƵĨĨĞƌDŝƚŝŐĂƚŝŽŶƌĞĚŝƚƐƚŽEƵƚƌŝĞŶƚKĨĨƐĞƚƌĞĚŝƚƐ, where viable, in accordance with this table. Credit conversions must be calculated using the guidance provided in the Clarified Procedures for Calculating Buffer Mitigation Credits and Nutrient Offset Credits letter issued by the DWR in November 2019. Objective/Treatment Likely Functional Uplift Performance Criteria Measurement Cumulative Monitoring  Results Established and increased forested riparian  buffers to 50 feet and greater along both sides of  the channel along the project reaches with a  hardwood riparian plant community; Reduction in floodplain  sediment inputs from  runoff, increased bank  stability, increased LWD  and organic material in  streams, increased Survival of at least  four native hardwood  tree species, where no  one species is greater  than 50 percent of  stems, at a density of  at least 260 stems per  acre at the end of Year  5.  13 fixed vegetation plots 13/13 passed ‐ MY1 13/13 passed ‐ MY2 Table 2: Summary: Goals, Performance and Results  Goal Restore and preserve native floodplain and  streambank vegetation. USGS Hydrologic Unit 8-digit 03020201 USGS Hydrologic Unit 14-digit 03020201140010 DWR Sub-basin 03-04-02 Project Coordinates (latitude and longitude)35.469579, -78.323896 Planted Acreage (Acres of Woody Stems Planted)19.73 Project Watershed Summary Information Physiographic Province 65m - Rolling Coastal Plain Project Area (acres) 22.12 River Basin Neuse Table 3. Project Attributes Project Name Strawberry Hill Mitigation Project County Johnston Project Drainage Area (Acres and Square Miles)383 ac (0.60 mi2) Project Drainage Area Percentage of Impervious Area 2% CGIA Land Use Classification Bottomland Forest, Cultivated, Evergreen Shrubland, Southern Yellow Pine, Unconsolidated Sediment Table 4. Project Timeline and Contacts Data Collection Task Completion or Activity or Deliverable Complete Deliverable Submission Project Instituted NA Dec‐20 Mitigation Plan Approved NA Nov‐20 Construction (Grading) Completed NA 20‐Jan‐22 Planting Completed NA 07‐Mar‐22 As‐built Survey Completed NA May‐22 MY‐0 Baseline Report Mar‐22 May‐22 Encroachment  MY1 Monitoring Report Nov‐22 Jan‐23 Encroachment Adressed Farmer access driveway relocated. Easement boundary  markers and horse tape installed. Mar‐23 Supplemental Planting Replanted 65 container trees on driving path  encroachment area. Feb‐23 MY2 Monitoring Report XS ‐ June‐23 VP ‐ Oct‐23 Nov‐23 Remediation Items (e.g. beaver removal, supplements, repairs etc.)    Provider RES / 3600 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100, Raleigh, NC  27612 Mitigation Provider POC Jamey Mceachran (919) 623‐9889 Designer RES / 3600 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100, Raleigh, NC  27612 Primary project design POC Ben Carroll, PE (336) 514‐0927 Construction Contractor RES / 3600 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100, Raleigh, NC  27612 Construction contractor POC Jacy Kirkpatrick Areas noted in Nov‐22. Hunting driving path continued use and farm equipment cutting  corners. Only applies to buffer mitigation‐only section of Project. RES is actively resolving. Strawberry Hill  #100094 Appendix B Vegetation Assessment Data   Appendix B. Vegetation Assessment Data   Table 5. Strawberry Hill Riparian Buffer Planted Species Summary Common Name Species % Zone 1 % Zone 2 Total Planted Amount River birch Betula nigra 10 10 1,600 Buttonbush Cephalanthus occidentalis 5 5 800 Yellow poplar Liriodendron tulipifera 10 10 1,600 Wax Myrtle Morella cerifera 5 10 1,000 Swamp tupelo Nyssa biflora 5 5 800 American sycamore Platanus occidentalis 10 10 1,600 Laurel oak Quercus laurifolia 5 10 1,000 Overcup oak Quercus lyrata 10 10 1,600 Swamp chestnut oak Quercus michauxii 10 10 1,600 Water oak Quercus nigra 10 10 1,600 Willow oak Quercus phellos 10 10 1,600 Bald cypress Taxodium distichum 10 0 1,000 TOTAL 15,800 Table 6. Strawberry Hill Riparian Buffer Vegetation Plot Mitigation Success Summary Plot # Planted  Stems/Acre  Volunteer  Stems/Acre  Total  Stems/Acre  Success  Criteria  Met?  Average  Planted  Stem  Height  1 647 0 647 Yes 2.0  2 607 324 931 Yes 3.4  3 486 162 647 Yes 1.6  4 688 243 931 Yes 1.4  5 567 688 1255 Yes 3.2  6 567 607 1174 Yes 3.0  7 526 0 526 Yes 2.2  8 445 0 445 Yes 2.4  9 647 0 647 Yes 3.6  10 526 0 526 Yes 1.6  11 324 243 567 Yes 3.7  12 486 162 647 Yes 3.7  13 364 121 486 Yes 3.4  Project Avg 529 196 725 Yes 2.7    Appendix B. Vegetation Assessment Data   Table 7. Strawberry Hill Riparian Buffer Stem Count Total and Planted by Plot Species PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T Acer rubrum red maple Tree 3 Baccharis baccharis Shrub 115 Betula nigra river birch Tree 222222222222333222 111 Cephalanthus occidentali common buttonbushShrub 1 1 1 333111 Clethra alnifolia coastal  sweetpepper Shrub 1 Liquidambar styraciflua sweetgum Tree 2 6 11 Liriodendron tulipiferatuliptree Tree 111111 222 222111333 Magnolia virginiana sweetbay Tree 1 Morella cerifera wax  myrtle shrub 222 111222444 Nyssa biflora swamp tupelo Tree 111 Pinus pine Tree 4 Platanus occidentalis American sycamoreTree 222 333 222111 222 Quercus laurifolia laurel oak Tree 222 333222 111 111111 Quercus lyrata overcup oak Tree 333222 222444 222 222 Quercus michauxii swamp chestnut oakTree 222222111 666 222111 Quercus nigra water oak Tree 222 111222222222444888 Quercus phellos willow oak Tree 111111333444111111111222 222 Sambucus elderberry Shrub 6 Taxodium distichum bald cypress Tree 333666 333 111333 16 16 16 15 15 23 12 12 16 17 17 23 14 14 31 14 14 29 13 13 13 11 11 11 16 16 16 13 13 13 8887795568896611667666555666888 647 647 647 607 607 931 486 486 647 688 688 931 567 567 1255 567 567 1174 526 526 526 445 445 445 647 647 647 526 526 526 038‐01‐0011 101038‐01‐0012 101038‐01‐0013 PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T PnoLS P‐all T Acer rubrum red maple Tree 3 Baccharis baccharis Shrub 6 4 3 29 Betula nigra river birch Tree 3 3 3 17 17 17 17 17 17 18 18 18 Cephalanthus occidentali common buttonbushShrub 2 2 2 7 7 7 8 8 8 9 9 9 Clethra alnifolia coastal  sweetpepper Shrub 1 Liquidambar styraciflua sweetgum Tree 19 Liriodendron tulipifera tuliptree Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 14 14 14 17 17 17 33 33 33 Magnolia virginiana sweetbay Tree 1 Morella cerifera wax  myrtle shrub 2 2 2 11 11 11 11 11 11 23 23 23 Nyssa biflora swamp tupelo Tree 222333555151515 Pinus pine Tree 4 Platanus occidentalis American sycamoreTree 1 1 1 111111111111181818 Quercus laurifolia laurel oak Tree 2 2 2 1 1 1 131313131313242424 Quercus lyrata overcup oak Tree 1 1 1 2 2 2 181818171717161616 Quercus michauxii swamp chestnut oak Tree 1 1 1 15 15 15 14 14 14 12 12 12 Quercus nigra water oak Tree 1 1 1 1 1 1 232323303030202020 Quercus phellos willow oak Tree 1 1 1 3 3 3 2 2 2 22 22 22 23 23 23 34 34 34 Sambucus elderberry Shrub 63 Taxodium distichum bald cypress Tree 161616151515202020 8 8 14 12 12 16 9 9 12 170 170 233 181 181 184 242 242 242 6 6 7 7 7 8 5 5 6121219121213121212 324 324 567 486 486 647 364 364 486 529 529 725 563 563 573 753 753 753 Species count Stems per ACRE Current Plot Data (MY2 2023) Annual MeansCurrent Plot Data (MY2 2023) 11113 0.32 0.320.02 0.02 0.32size (ACRES)0.02 1 0.02 1313size (ares) Stem count MY0 (2022) Scientific Name Common Name Species Type MY2 (2023) MY1 (2022) 1 0.02 1 0.02 1 0.020.02 1 0.02 1 0.02 101038‐01‐0009 101038‐01‐0010 Scientific Name Common Name Species Type 101038‐01‐0001 101038‐01‐0002 101038‐01‐0003 101038‐01‐0004 101038‐01‐0005 101038‐01‐0006 Strawberry Hill Strawberry Hill Stem count 101038‐01‐0007 101038‐01‐0008 size (ares) size (ACRES) Species count Stems per ACRE 1 0.02 1 0.02 1 0.02 1 Appendix C Photos Strawberry Hill Riparian Buffer Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos (MY2) Vegetation Plot 1 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 2 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 3 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 4 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 5 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 6 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 7 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 8 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 9 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 10 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 11 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 12 (10/03/2023) Vegetation Plot 13 (10/03/2023) Strawberry Hill General Site Buffer Photos (MY2) Boundary Condition along JH1-A (10/3/2023) Pines along JH1-A (10/3/2023) Sunflowers along JH1-A (10/3/2023) General Condition along JH1-A (10/3/2023)   Bare area along JH1-B (10/3/2023) Boundary condition along JH1-B (10/3/2023) JH1-B looking upstream (5/19/2023) General Condition along JH1-B (10/3/2023)   Newly installed agricultural driveway near JH2 (5/19/2023) Supplemental plantings on old path along JH2 (5/19/2023) Markers and horse tape blocking path near JH2 (3/6/2023) Markers and horse tape blocking path near JH3 (10/3/2023)   Boundary condition along JH3 (10/3/2023) Diffuse flow live stakes in JH5 swale (5/19/2023)