Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20040561 Ver 4_Comment Response Letter to DCM 2020-7-28_20200805Strickland, Bev From: Coats, Heather Sent: Wednesday, August 5, 2020 4:50 PM To: Mairs, Robb L Cc: Howell, Jonathan Subject: FW: [External] Re: Bald Head Island/Frying Pan Shoals add info letter- Major Mod request for Permit #91-14 Attachments: Comment Response Letter to DCM 2020-7-28.pdf Hi Robb, I see this include a response to DWR. I'm not sure if Greg sent to you directly as well or not since I don't see you on this email. Heather Coats Beach &Inlet Management Project Coordinator Division of Coastal Management North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality 910 796 7302 office heather.coats(a�ncdenr.gov 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and maybe disclosed to third parties. From: Finch, Greg [mailto:gfinch@Imgroup.net] Sent: Tuesday, July 28, 2020 3:49 PM To: Coats, Heather <heather.coats@ncdenr.gov> Cc: Christian Preziosi <cpreziosi@Imgroup.net>; Jeff <jgriffin@villagebhi.org>; Chris McCall <cmccall@villagebhi.org>; Erik <eolsen@olsen-associates.com> Subject: [External] Re: Bald Head Island/Frying Pan Shoals add info letter- Major Mod request for Permit #91-14 � rnal email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as an attachment to nc. ov Hi Heather, Please end attached a PDF that includes a response to your request for additional information. Let me know if you need hard copies or there are any additional items to be addressed. Thanks, Greg Finch � Environmental Scientist - CAMA Section Manager Land Management Group � Environmental Consultants 3805 Wrightsville Avenue, Suite 15 � Wilmington, NC 28403 Direct: 910-452-0001 x 1928 I Cell: 910-470-4734 On Fri, Jun 26, 2020 at 9:27 AM Coats, Heather <heather.coats(a�ncdenr.gov> wrote: Hi Greg, Please see the attached add info letter in response to the comments we received from NCDMF. I'm also attaching NCWRC's comments we received that support DMF concerns and includes some recommended conditions, should those fisheries concerns be resolved, as well as comments/recommendations from DNCR. Please let me know if you have any questions. Best regards, Heather Heather Coats Beach &Inlet Management Project Coordinator Division of Coastal Management North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality 910 796 7302 office heather.coatsCa�ncdenr.gov 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 Email correspondence to and from this address is subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and maybe disclosed to third parties. LM � LAND MANAGEMENT GRdUP a DiAYEY� company July 28, 2020 Ms. Heather Coats NC Division of Coastal Management Wilmington Regional Office 127 Cardinal Drive Extension Wilmington, NC 28405 RE: NC CAMA Permit Application —Major Modification Request to State Permit No. 91-14 Village of Bald Head Island Frying Pan Shoals Beach Nourishment Project Response to Request for Additional Information Dear Heather: By way of this letter and on behalf of the Village of Bald Head Island (Applicant), Land Management Group (LMG) (agent) is providing the following response to your request for additional information (RAI) dated June 26, 2020 for the Major Modification application for State Permit No. 91-14. The RAI pertained to comments received from the North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries (DMF) by way of their letter dated June 2, 2020. Additional comments were received from the NC Wildlife Resources Commission (WRC), the NC Division of Water Resources (DWR), and the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO). Responses to these comments are provided below (with supporting attachments where applicable and referenced). I. NC Division of Marine Fisheries Comment and Response Comment #1: DMF requests that an Environmental Impact Statement (EISJ be prepared through the USACE. Response: The Village of Bald Head Island previously as Applicant requested and participated in a project scoping meeting (conducted on October 2, 2019) at the NCDEQ Wilmington Regional Office to present the proposed action and to discuss the appropriate process for evaluating the application for a permit decision. The lead state and federal permitting agencies determined that a request to modify the Terminal Groin Individual Permit (Department of Army Permit No. SAW-2012- 00040) and the CAMA Major Permit (91-14) was the appropriate process for a permit decision. The USACE determined that an EIS is not required for this modification request. This decision was based largely on the EIS prepared for the original terminal groin permit which evaluated the use of several candidate borrow sites including the use of a borrow site on Frying Pan Shoals. In addition, an impact assessment for fishery resources is being performed as part of the updated Essential Fish Habitat (EFH) document to be submitted under separate cover. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �2 Comment #2: Assess impacts to larval transport -Dredging in Frying Pan Shoals can potentially interfere with the passage of larvae and early juveniles from offshore spawning grounds into estuarine nursery areas. A detailed scientific field investigation, analysis, and modelling of larval transport dynamics that exist around Frying Pan Shoals currently and how that will change based on the proposed dredging activity. This information should be used to model estimated impacts of the dredging to larval ingress and egress through the inlet. Response: We respectfully disagree with your assessment for the potential of the dredging project to interrupt larvae and juvenile recruitment into the Cape Fear River estuary. Hydrodynamic modeling performed by Olsen for the project EIS (2014) predicted that there is no inlet -directed tidal flow on either peak ebb or peak flood conditions at Frying Pan Shoals. Therefore, there is no expected effect on the entrainment of larvae from the proposed borrow site by tidal action. The request for detailed scientific investigations of larval transport, analysis, and modeling would require amulti-year research project to be able to provide meaningful data that can control for inter -year variability. The need for such is doubtful considering that the presence of a borrow site at this location is unlikely to disrupt larval transport in any significant manner. If there is research or data in the literature indicating this phenomenon has occurred for other borrow sites, then we would respectfully request that this information or literature be shared with the Applicant so that it can be evaluated for its applicability to the proposed project. Given the size of the proposed borrow site relative to the large shoal feature (less than 0.5%) and the predicted physical recovery of the borrow area (as described further in response to Comment #3 below), it can be reasonably expected that the proposed action will not induce any large-scale disruption to circulation patterns. In addition, the excavated area will tie into natural bottom contours on the western edge of the shoal feature (i.e. there will not be a hole that could theoretically entrap or slow larvae). Rather, it is likely that vertical mixing and upwelling patterns would continue to be maintained with only limited, localized effects to currents/circulation. As a result, there is not expected to be an effect on the transport of larvae. Lastly, any assumed impacts to circulation (or disruption to upwelling) is unlikely to affect larval transport given that larvae have been demonstrated to exert considerable control over vertical movement within the water column (Morgan and Anastasia, 2008). Larvae and early juveniles are not passive in their movement. Migration of larvae outside the tidal influence of the estuary is influenced through wind -driven transport and directed vertical movement by larvae to maximize shoreward movement (Boehlert and Mundy, 1988). Once nearshore, then alongshore drift is the principal mechanism until larvae reach the entrainment influence of the estuary. Larvae are adapted to highly dynamic physical conditions in nearshore environments. Based upon the lack of any significant effects to circulation patterns, the uninterrupted wind -driven transport of larvae, the ability of larvae to exert control over vertical movement, and the large entrainment field of the Cape Fear River estuary; larval transport into the estuary will not be adversely affected. Comment #3: Assess sediment transport and refilling of borrow area -The proposal to dredge a hole, nearly 20 feet deep in some locations, in the shoal could negatively and potentially permanently alter the habitat on the shoal. Frying Pan Shoal is classified as a relict shoal receiving much of its sand deposits from the Holocene and Pleistocene periods (Normandeau Associates, Inc. 2014). These shoals formed over a long period of time and may not recover at rates necessary to www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �3 sustain recurring borrow activities. It is unknown how currents, wind, and storm events will respond spatially and temporally to removal of sand from the shoal. In addition, no studies have been performed to investigate the type of material that is expected to be deposited within the footprint of the excavated area. If incompatible materials fill the dredged footprint, new borrow sources will be sited on the shoal resulting in cumulative impacts to the habitat. A sediment transport model should be used to investigate the previously mentioned concerns. Response: The proposed excavation will tie into natural bottom contours along the western edge or flank of the shoal feature. As a result, there will not be a "hole" within the shoal crest. The dredge contours are designed such to induce greater rates of recharge with characteristic sand - grained sediments transported over the shoal. It is highly unlikely that there will be any fine- grained deposition post -dredging due to the ambient sediment characteristics and dynamic physical conditions of the borrow site. This is supported by observations by McNinch (2009) who commented, "Sediment dredged from the northwest flank of FPS will likely recharge episodically from sediment transported from the crest during storms, particularly extratropical nor'easters". The post -excavation substrate is expected to be self -similar to the existing condition (prior to dredging). The project as designed ensures that the depth of excavation is strategically limited such that the sediment exposed (post -dredging) has similar granular characteristics to the native seabed. In addition, the location and the design promotes rapid and continuous material transport into the excavated area. With respect to the predicted rate of sediment transport, McNinch (2009) observed the following: "The most active region of sediment recharge to FPS is likely near the cape point, particularly along the crest of the shoal where it extends seaward from the subaerial cape point and the shore parallel sand bar that merges into FPS from the updrift beach". (Note —the updrift beach or shoreline northward of the cape point is known as East Beach on BHI). Numerous individuals or organizations have performed estimates of littoral transport along the every -varying shoreline components of the State of N.C. More recently, (Van Gaalen, Tebbens and Barton, 2016) have summarized sediment transport directions from Northern Maine to Tampa Bay, FL. For the Cape Fear formation, the published rates for the two Bald Head Island shorelines that join to form the Cape Fear Point are as follows: • South Beach — 339,300 cubic meters annually toward the East. • East Beach — 341,000 cubic meters annually southward. This represents a potential net annual hypothetical rate of deposition to the Cape Fear Shoal formation of 680,300 cubic meters (i.e. 813,215 cy). Annual monitoring of South Beach indicates that net easterly transport would typically be less than that estimated above. For more information regarding sediment substrate, predicted recovery, and factors influencing borrow site selection and design, please see attached discussion prepared by Olsen Associates, Inc. (Attachment A). www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �4 Comment #4: DMF would also like to see the applicant explore alternative sand sources that may have less significant impacts to critical fisheries habitats; this would include previously permitted alternative borrow sources. Response: The Applicant understands and appreciates the need to explore and utilize the least environmentally damaging, practicable alternative (LEDPA) sand source site. A robust alternatives analysis of potential borrow sites was performed as part of the permit application. The only other viable site identified (of sufficient size, containing beach -quality sand, and being operationally feasible) was Jay Bird Shoals (1BS). Indeed, from a logistics standpoint there is preference to utilize the previously authorized and dredged JBS site. That being said, the Village utilized this site for a second time in its most recent Village -sponsored nourishment project (occurring in Winter 2018/2019), and Oak Island recently received authorization to dredge an approximate 304-acre borrow site located within JBS as part of a 1.1Mcy nourishment project to be implemented this coming winter (Winter 2020/21). As a result, the JBS sand resource will be depleted for the foreseeable future. However, the borrow site is continuing to be physically monitored on an annual basis. If the shoreline of South Beach can be maintained though federal nourishment for a period of time and sufficient physical recovery occurs within JBS prior to the next nourishment need, then the Village will seek to utilize JBS as an alternative sand source site prior to the use of FPS. Physical monitoring of the JBS borrow site will determine the volume of sand available for dredging prior to the next Village -sponsored nourishment, and this information will be provided to the agencies to determine if JBS can be utilized in lieu of FPS. The use of Bald Head Shoals seaward of the Point and western South Beach is not viable. Its proximity to this highly erosive section of shoreline adjacent to the federal navigation channel renders its use impracticable and counterproductive as it affords that portion of beach much needed protection through wave and current attenuation. Use of this shoal as a sand source site would result in the need for increased frequency of nourishment events, a condition not deemed environmentally favorable nor operationally and financially practicable. It can therefore be excluded from consideration as the LEDPA. Comment #5: Comments related to ecological effects of dredging within Frying Pan Shoals. Response: The Applicant will be submitting an updated Essential Fish Habitat (EFH) document with a more thorough impact assessment describing potential ecological effects to EFH habitat and managed species. A copy of this report will be submitted to both the NC DCM and NC DMF. A brief description of avoidance and minimization measures are provided below. In addition, attributes of the borrow site location and design that help to minimize ecological effects are outlined in Attachment A. The Applicant and project engineer have worked to reduce the limits of spatial impacts of the proposed borrow site based upon comments received subsequent to the submittal of the 2016 proposal. Of particular note with respect to avoidance and minimization efforts since the 2016 submittal is the following: the deletion of the dredge access corridor (aka "fairway"); the reduction in borrow site acreage (from 460.1 acres to 198.4 acres); and the limitation of dredging to an initial single borrow event to be monitored. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �5 The project as designed will incorporate the following protection measures identified by the South Atlantic Fisheries Management Council (SAFMC) specific for dredge and fill projects in areas designated as Habitat Areas of Particular Concern (HAPC). These include the following: 1. Impact assessment (description of potential impacts; baseline information; alternatives analysis; construction monitoring; post -construction monitoring plan); 2. Fill material should match that of recipient beach as closely as possible; 3. Dredging to be located in areas characterized by strong currents and sand movement to promote more rapid infilling rates (and thus reducing the duration of impacts to benthic habitats); and 4. Dredging should be performed in a manner intended to minimize impacts to wave energy and currents, "thus reducing the likelihood of infilling with fine-grained sediments". In addition to the SAFMC protection measures, the proposed project incorporates following design elements that helps to further reduce or avoid impacts to natural resources: 1. The site is a highly dynamic and renewable shoal feature (maintained by seaward flow of current off cape) and thus physical and biological disturbances tend to be short-lived; 2. The position of borrow site on the western flank represents a sediment sink (thus promoting rapid recovery and infilling with like material); 3. The combination of size and position of sand source site results in least impacts to shoal integrity; 4. Dredging to occur during winter months (reduced biological activity); 5. The project will allow for undredged areas in close proximity to be left undisturbed to promote more rapid recolonization of benthos (as was documented for Jay Bird Shoals and Bald Head Creek Shoals with similar post -project conditions); 6. The project will avoid hard -bottom habitat; 7. The project will avoid Primary Nursery Area (PNA) impacts; 8. The project will avoid inlet and associated shoals for large-scale sand volume needsl; 9. The project will utilize hydraulic cutter suction dredge (thereby avoiding and minimizing physical entrainment of species in close proximity to the dredge operation); and 10. The project will include post -project physical monitoring of borrow site (i.e. assessment of physical recovery). The proposed action is not anticipated to have any long-term effects on fishery species. This is due in part to the following considerations: (1) the limited spatial and temporal effects of elevated turbidity due to high sand content of dredged sediments and rapid dilution; (2) the mobility of finfish and associated avoidance behavior; (3) the physical conditions of the dredge site favoring rapid infilling and benthic recovery; (4) avoidance of peak benthic and larval fish recruitment periods during dredging and nourishment; (5) fecundity and opportunistic nature of benthic communities to accommodate anthropogenic and natural disturbance; and (6) the avoidance and minimization measures described above. Given the size of the proposed borrow area relative to the FPS feature (less than 0.5 %spatially and 0.1% volumetrically) and the annual rates of sediment input, the morphological integrity of the 1 All coastal inlets are designated HAPC for paneaid shrimp, blue crabs, and estuarine -dependent snapper -grouper species. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �6 shoal will not be affected by the proposed action. Provided the overall physical integrity of the shoals is maintained, then potential adverse effects to ecological functions are minimized. In general, it is preferable to utilize sites that are anticipated to have a high likelihood of physical recovery and biological recovery. The location of the borrow site on the western flank of FPS ensures infilling with sand (consistent with the existing substrate) and a relatively high rate of recharge. In light of the favorable physical conditions of the borrow site (suitable substrate and characteristics favorable for physical and biological recovery), avoidance of other sensitive EFH habitats, adherence to the identified SAFMC protection measures, and incorporation of additional mitigative actions, it is believed that potential adverse ecological effects are minimized. Comment #6: There are numerous questions remaining that need to be addressed before this project should go forward. Staff from BOEM are currently planning to hold a workshop this fall to discuss the state of the science of Frying Pan Shoals and how to move forward in addressing data gaps. Until then, the applicant has a viable alternative, use of Jay Bird Shoals. The NCDMF therefore objects to this permit modification request. Should the project be permitted, the NCDMF requests that the applicant be required to monitor sediment deposition rates and composition, as well as monitor benthic invertebrate composition and change to productivity. The project should be considered aone-time event until all necessary research recommended by NCDMF and the 2020 BOEM workshop is completed and reviewed. Response: The Applicant's consultant (LMG) will be attending the BOEM workshop this Fall. Contemplation of any sand source sites in federal waters (as BOEM is evaluating) would require the use of a hopper dredge and work during environmental moratoriums. As a result, potential ecological effects of such would be significantly greater. With respect to the use of Jay Bird Shoals (JBS), as referenced above, due to both the recent Village - sponsored dredging of JBS and the recent authorization issued to the Town of Oak Island (Action ID Number SAW-2018-02230) to dredge 1.1 Mcy of sand from JBS this coming year (2021), the use of JBS for additional sand nourishment needs is not possible at this time or in the near future. That being said, the Applicant will seek to preferentially utilize JBS should the sand source site demonstrate sufficient physical recovery and sufficient volumes of beach -compatible sand prior to the need for the next locally -sponsored nourishment of South Beach. Note also that this Major Modification request is for aone-time dredge event with both physical and benthic monitoring proposed to evaluate the effects of dredging on FPS prior to any requests for dredging in the future. The Applicant acknowledges the need for the monitoring of physiographic, sedimentary and benthic recovery within the proposed area of excavation. VHBI's engineer (Olsen Associates) believes that based upon the existing precepts of the Wilmington Harbor Sand Management Plan, which episodically places high quality maintenance sand on BHI, it could be necessary to construct an interim locally sponsored beach fill project on 8- to 12-year intervals (more or less). However, the use of JBS for future events could very well provide a viable alternate sand source in lieu of the FPS borrow area. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �7 II. NC Wildlife Resources Commission Comment and Response Comment #1: Request modeling of sediment transport for determining recovery/recharge. Response: Refer to response to NC DMF Comment #3 above. There have been a number of investigations studying sediment transport along the North Carolina shoreline. The published rates for the two Bald Head Island shorelines which join to form the Cape Fear Point are as follows: • South Beach — 339,300 cubic meters annually toward the East. • East Beach — 341,000 cubic meters annually southward. This represents a potential net annual hypothetical rate of deposition to the Cape Fear Shoal formation of 680,300 cubic meters (i.e. 813,215 cy). Annual monitoring of South Beach by the VBHI indicates that net easterly transport would typically be less than that estimated above. Comment #2: Concern regarding cumulative effects of multi -dredge event project. Response: The Applicant is requesting aone-time dredge event under this Major Modification request for a borrow site area that has been substantially reduced from the prior 2016 request. The Applicant and project engineer have worked to reduce the limits of spatial impacts of the proposed borrow site based upon comments received subsequent to the submittal of the 2016 proposal. Of particular note with respect to avoidance and minimization efforts since the 2016 submittal is the following: the deletion of the dredge access corridor (aka "fairway'); the reduction in borrow site acreage (from 460.1 acres to 198.4 acres); and the limitation of dredging to an initial single borrow event to be monitored. Post -dredge monitoring of physiographic, sedimentary and benthic parameters will be performed to accurately assess the recovery of the borrow site. These data will be evaluated and used for any potential consideration of future dredge events. Note that Olsen Associates believes that based upon the existing precepts of the Wilmington Harbor Sand Management Plan, which episodically places high quality maintenance sand on BHI, it could be necessary to construct an interim locally sponsored beach fill project every 8 to 12 years (more or less). However, the use of Jay Bird Shoals (JBS) for future events could very well provide a viable alternate sand source in lieu of the FPS borrow area. As a result, the potential for any long-term cumulative effects is significantly reduced or avoided. Comment #3: Adherence to applicable environmental windows. Response: The proposed modification requests to perform the work during the acceptable environmental windows and will avoid shorebird and sea turtle nesting periods (combined April 1 to November 15 moratorium). If there is any proposed deviation to the planned dredge and nourishment work window, the Applicant will coordinate with state and federal permitting and resource agencies for appropriate authorization. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �8 Comment #4: Survey and monitoring reports. Response: The Applicant has performed post -construction monitoring of the terminal groin project with reports submitted on an annual basis to the Corps of Engineers. Comment #5: Concern over repeated beach nourishment projects (higher frequency intervals). Response: Noted. Prior macro -invertebrate monitoring of the beachfront both pre- and post - nourishment (conducted along South Beach and West Beach from 2009 to 2012) revealed that macroinvertebrate taxa fluctuate seasonally. For coquina clams, no statistically significant differences were found between pre -construction and post -construction conditions. For mole crabs and ghost crab burrow hole densities, some significant differences between pre- and post - construction sampling events were identified. However, the statistical (ANOVA) analysis revealed that these fluctuations were likely due to seasonality and other factors not measured in the study rather than project -related activities (since similar differences were observed within control sites). Numerous studies have demonstrated rapid recovery of invertebrate taxa along nourished shorelines (less than one year) provided that the fill material is beach quality sand and similar in texture and composition to the recipient beach (Hackney et al. 1996, Nelson 1993, USACE 2001). Comment #6: Concern regarding beach profile slope (i.e. need to avoid backslope or trough in profile that could trap or disorient nesting sea turtles or hatchings). Response: Noted. The design avoids backsloping of beach profiles. Construction management will include monitoring of the profile to ensure that backslopes or troughs do not occur. Comment #7: Dune revegetation and stabilization should follow resource agency guidelines. Response: Noted. The Applicant will consult with appropriate agencies to implement appropriate methods for dune revegetation and stabilization. Every attempt will be made to complete the dune stabilization measures during the applicable environmental windows. Comment #8: Recommend overview of beach management activities occurring on the Island and the preparation of a single comprehensive management plan. Response: Noted. The project EIS discussed all recent and proposed dredge and beach nourishment projects (for the reasonably foreseeable future). Beach nourishment actions implemented by the Village are also a matter of permit record. A copy of the engineered beach plan outlining beach management activities for the Island is also provided for reference (Attachment B). www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �9 III. NC Division of Water Resources Comment and Response Comment: Please provide more details that addresses the concerns from the NCDMF and the NCWRC regarding practical alternatives and avoidance and minimization of impacts for this project. (15A NCAC 02H .0506(fJ and (gJ] If these issues are not resolved, the NCDWR will have to move to deny your application as required by 15A NCAC 2H .0506. If these concerns are addressed to the satisfaction of the NCDMF and the NCWRC, the NCDWR will have no objection. Response: Noted. The Applicant is providing responses and additional information to the commenting agencies (namely NC DMF and NC WRC). There have been a number of additional avoidance and minimization measures identified (to be implemented) since the prior 2017 permit modification request. Principally among these measures have been the reduction of the extent of the dredge footprint and confining this modification request to a one-time dredge event to be monitored for the assessment of physical and biological recovery (as described in more detail above). In addition, the Applicant agrees to prioritize the use of Jay Bird Shoals should adequate recovery of that sand source be demonstrated prior to the need for the next Village -sponsored nourishment. Lastly, the project is to employ the protection measures identified by the South Atlantic Fisheries Management Council (SAFMC) specific for dredge and fill projects in areas designated as Habitat Areas of Particular Concern (HAPC) as well as several other measures identified in the responses provided above. As a result, it is the position of the Applicant that the proposed project will not result in a significant impact to EFH (as has been demonstrated for other dredging projects routinely occurring within EFH and HAPC of North Carolina state waters) and therefore does not represent a degradation of state waters. IV. State Historic Preservation Office (SHPOI Comment and Response Comment: The Bald Head Island south beach renourishment project has the potential to affect culturally significant shipwrecks, if avoidance protocols are not enacted. Avoidance is essential given the potential of irreparable damage to cultural resources, as well as to the dredging equipment, as site CF1001 -the Ella is a substantial steel structure. We are aware however that work has been carried out in the area in the past, with the dredging of the channel and the installation of stone jetties (sic). We, therefore, concur with the recommendation outlined in the submitted report from 2016, which states "In the event that the buffered anomalies can be avoided, no additional investigation is recommended in conjunction with the proposed project." To that effect, we offer this "unanticipated discoveries" condition: If additional cultural resources) are identified during monitoring and/or construction, all work will be halted within the limits of the resource(sJ and the Office of State Archaeology (OSA) will be contacted. Work should move to another area and the Underwater Archaeology Branch should be contacted immediately (910-250-7320J. A staff member will be sent to assess the wreckage and determine the proper course of action. The OSA will initiate the coordination required for a determination of eligibility or recovery effort. If after consultation between the County and OSA, additional mitigation is determined necessary, the County, in consultation with OSA, will develop and implement appropriate protection/mitigation www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page � 10 measures for the resource(sJ. Inadvertent or accidental discovery of human remains will be handled in accordance with North Carolina General Statutes 65 and 70. Response: Noted. It is understood and agreed that such a condition would be included within the permit authorization for the project. On behalf of the Applicant, we appreciate the opportunity to respond to comments received for the proposed project and your assistance in processing the Major Modification request. Should you have any questions regarding the information provided, please feel free to contact me vial phone at 910-452-0001 or by email at cpreziosi@Im�roup.net. Thank you for your time and assistance. Sincerely, �I �ftr- r r � 1 Christian Preziosi Land Management Group (Permit Agent) Encl. Attachment A —Borrow Site Discussion (Olsen Associates) Attachment B —Engineered Beach Plan (Olsen Associates) cc. Jeff Griffin, Village of Bald Head Island Chris McCall, Village of Bald Head Island Erik Olsen, Olsen Associates Tara MacPherson, DCM-Wilmington Ronnie Smith, USACE Wilmington District —Regulatory Branch Sources: Boehlert, G. W. and B.C. Mundy. 1988. Roles of behavioral and physical factors in larval and juvenile fish recruitment to estuarine nursery areas. Am. Fish. Soc. Sym. 3: pp. 51-67. Hackney, C.T., M. Posey, S. Ross, and A. Norris. 1996. A review and synthesis of data on surf zone fishes and invertebrates in the South Atlantic Bight and the potential impacts from beach renourishment. For Wilmington District, US Army Corps of Engineers, Wilmington, North Carolina. McNinch, J.E., 2009, Literature Review of Cuspate Forelands —Implications of dredging Frying Pan Shoals", Report prepared for Wilmington District, USACOE. Morgan, S.G. and J.R. Anastasia. 2008. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, January 8, 2008. Vol. 105 (1): pp 222-227. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 Page �11 Nelson, W.G. 1993. Beach restoration in the Southeastern US: environmental effects and biological monitoring. Ocean and Coastal Management. 19: 157-182. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USAGE). 2001. The New York District's Biological Monitoring Program for the Atlantic Coast of New Jersey, Asbury Park to Manasquan Section Beach Erosion Control Project, Final Report. Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, MS. Van Gaalen, J.F., Tebbens, S.F., and Barton, C.C., 2016. Longshore sediment transport directions and rates from northern Maine to Tampa Bay, Florida: Literature compilation and interpretation. Journal of Coastal Research, 32(6), 1277-1301. Coconut Creek (Florida), ISSN 0749-0208. www.lmgroup.net •Phone: 910.452.0001 •Fax: 910.452.0060 3805 Wrightsville Ave., Suite 15, Wilmington, NC 28403 ATTACHMENT A. FRYING PAN �H�ALS �- �ORRQ'�V SITE DISC[JSSION >aaC>��Rouly� The Cape Fear Shoals {FPS) formation has been evaluated as a potential sand source far purposes of beach restoration beginning in the 1970's (Meisburger, 1977). That Reconnaissance level work was carried out by the Coastal Engineering Research Center (CERC} far the Wilmington District, USACOE. Both cores and sub -bottom survey comprised the ma�arity of the data acquisition performed for purposes of defining the spatial distribution of potential sand sources located within FPS. At the time, isopachs of potential sand thickness indicated at least 1.4 billion cubic yards of potential beach quality sand located within the Cape Fear Shoals formation. This estimate is assumed to be conservative. McNinch (2449) performed a Literature Review r�,f Cuspate Forelands which included a discussion of the implications of dredging Frying Pan Shoals. With respect to the latter, Dr. McNinch made the following observations which are relevant to the siting of the proposed VBHI borrow site; * "The most active region of sediment recharge to FFS is likely near the cape point, particularly along the crest of the shoal where it extends seaward from the subaerial cape point and the shore parallel sand bar that merges into FPS from the updrift beach". Note -� the updrift beach or shoreline northward of the cape point is known as East Beach on I�HI. + Sediment along the flanks of FPS likely migrate crestward during swell conditions and seaward when it reaches the crest". iaThe crest of the shoal is likely planed -off during storm canditlans, when waves are steep and breaking occurs across the shoal, and sediment is transported to the flanks". Judy, zo2o i �Isen associates, inc. • "Sediment dredged from the northwest flank of FPS will likely recharge episodically from sediment transported from the crest during storms, particularly extratrapical nor' eastern". Numerous individuals ar organizations have performed estimates of littoral transport along the every -varying shoreline components of the State of N.C. Mare recently, (Van Gaalen, Tebbens and Barton, 2016) have summarized sediment transport directions from Northern Maine to Tannpa Bay, FL, For the Cape k'ear fannatian, the published rates far the two BHI shorelines which join to farm the Cape Fear Paint (see Figure 1}are as follows: * South Beach — 339,300 cubic meters annually toward the East, • East Beach — 341,000 cubic meters annually southward. Thin represents a potential net annual hypothetical rate of deposition to the Caps Dear Shoal formation of 680,300 cubic meters {i.e. 813,215 cy). Note —annual monitoring of S. Beach indicates that net easterly transport would typically be less than that estimated alaave, In 2009, the Wilmington District, USAGE acquired some 31 Vibracores in proximity to the western side of Frying Pan Shoals as part of a sand search far the Brunswick County Share Protection Project. The Tistrict then contracted with Catlin Engineers and Scientists of Wilmington, N,C. to analyze the cores. A summary of findings was provided to the Wilmington District an 27 May 2010 (Catlin, 2010). The report included core lags, grain size classi�icatians and various summaries of the sediment characteristics encountered suitable far beach rentaration. In 2016, Olsen Associates, Inc, initiated amulti-phase Sand Search Investigation of Frying Pan Shoals (Olsen, 2U16) intended to allow for the permitting, of a barrow site within State waters. July, 2020 z �Isen associates, ir�c. The chronological Task Logic for the phased Sand Search sponsored by the VBHI can be summarized as follows: l . A coarse grid survey was performed to update general bathymetric shoal features within the 3-mile limit. Mapping utilizing federal NpS data was got reliable for purposes of coring. 2. A Phase I (coarse grid) Cultural Resource Investigations was carried out to eliminate any dense clustexs of magnetic anomalies which would indicate a high probability of a ship wreck site. It was determined that no level of geatechnical investigation would be performed in any such areas identified. 3. Based upon 1.) and 2.) above, a Vibracoring Plan was formulated so as to maximize potential depths of beach compatible sediment, with the intent of minimizing future conflicts with probable cultural resource locations. 4. Subsequent to coring, asub-bottom survey was performed to extend the data base between cores and to areas of interest where cores would not be feasibly (or safely) acquired due to shallow depths, breaking waves, or tidal surging, S. In consideration of the results of the seismic survey, Vibracore logging and laboratory analyses of sediment samples aver depth, a generalized borrow area was def ned by Olsen Associates, Inc. —all of which is dacum,ented in a comprehensive report {�lsen, 201 &). 6. Subsequently, a Fhase II Cultural Resource Investigation was performed of the selected barrow area in order to eliminate areas of avoidance recommended by the project marine archaeologist. The final Permit Application was based upon the refined borrow site limits which included buffers between, or around unverified anomalies and future dredging activities. July, 2020 � QIsBn associates, inC, l3�Rlt[�W SYTI� SELECTYUN The selection of the proposed 188.7 A. area borrow site was determined on the basis of both environn�tental and physical characteristics, Although the engineering design of the proposed barrow site is a matter of record {Qlsen, 2016}, in order to minimize environmental impacts, the following relevant selection parameters were prioritized: � Burrow Site Recovery — As recommended by McNinch (2a09), the proposed area of excavation is principally located on the crest of the existing shoal formations which is the most high energy i.e. dynamic} portion of the shoal. This will assure rapid pnst- constructian deposition of new material into the excavated area. AIthaugh it is not possible to reliably "numerically model°'the infilling process due to the complexity of the shoals ever changing bathymetry, it can be reliably estimated based upon the anticipated volume of material which episodically enters the shoal forrriation from the two (2} shorelines an BI�I which farm the Cape Foint. A conservative engineering estimate of the ability of the FPS borrow area to recover SO-90% of the neat volume removed is 1Q years, or less. • Barrow Site Substrate —For purposes of rapid benthic recovery, the post -excavation substrate should be self=similar to existing prior to dredging, This is addressed two ways: a) by ensuring #hat the depth of excavation is strategically limited such that the sediment exposed (post -dredging) has similar granular characteristics to the native seabed, and b.} by ensuring that material transport into the excavated area will be rapid and continuous. Under such constraints, benthic recovery of the "disturbed" seabed typically occurs within 1-year. • Minimization of the Area ]rrpacted —Far purposes of reducing temporal dredging impacts to pre-existing benthic resources, it is desirable to design a borrow area having the smallest effective "fast print". k`ar this site, this is accomplished principally through the utilize#ion of a cutter suction dredge, as well as the 5peci�cation of a dredged area with the thickest layer of sediment available =which far the FFS formation is synonyrnaus with the centralized portion of the shoal. Although the depth of excavation July, 2020 4 QISEn c]55oCiSt�S, inc. at that location may exceed 15 ft. below the seabed, it is reliably predicted that shoal dynamics at this location will quickly reduce the effective borrow depth due to rapid infilling and slope adjustments. Note — A secondary benefit of a cutter suction dredge is that it does not "entrain" fishery resources � in contrast to a hopper dredge which represents a quantifiable threat to fishery resources during the dredging process including etadangered species such as the Atlantic Sturgeon. * Frequency of Occurrence =The Applicant's consultant has opined that based upon the existing precepts of the Wilmington Harbor Sand Management Plan, which episodically place high quality maintenance sand on BHI, it could be necessary to construct an interim locally sponsored beach fill project every 8-12 years, mot. It is acknowledged however, that subsequent to the first use of the FPS borrow site, it could be possible that the Agency preferred borrow area located at Jay Bird Shoals may have sufficiently recovered by that time. As such, it could provide a viable alternate sand source in lieu of the F1'S borrow area. • Confirmation of Impact and l�ecvvery Predictions � The VBHI as Applicant for the development of the FFS borrow site acknowledges the need for the monitoring of physiographic, sedimentary and benthic recovery within the proposed area afexcavation. July, 2020 7 Qlsen �ss�ciates, inc. REFERENCES Catlin, Engineers and Scientists, 2Q1D, Brunswick County Beaches Renaurishment Study — Drying Fan Shoals Soil Testing and Compatibility Analysis and Geotechnical Report", report prepared for Wilmington District, USACOE, Catlin Wilmington, N.C. 284D4. McNinch, J.E., 2DD9, Literature Review of Cuspate Forelands —Implications of dredging Frying Pan Shoals", Report prepared for Wilmington District, USACQE. Meisburger, E.P., 1977. `°Sand Resources on the Inner Continental Shelf of the Cape Fear Region, N.C.," U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, CERC, Ft. Belvoir, VA, Mist. Report No. 77- l . Olsen Associates, Inc., 2Dlb. "Frying Fan Shoals —Sand Search Investigation", report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Qlsen Associates, Inc., 26] 8 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 322D4. Van Gaalen, J.F.,: Tebbens, S.F., and Barton, C.C., 2D16. Longshore sediment transport directions and rates from northern Maine to Tampa Bay, l�lorida: Literature cvtxtpilation and interpretation. Journal of Coastal Research, 32(G), 127'7-13D1. Coconut Creek (Florida), ISSN D749-D208. July, 202o c� �l�en asso�i�tes, inc. ,� ' �`% . \ . \�� ! �. � � i �� � � (� \ f.� . � � � � , � � � �� � � � �` � � �� � � .� � �, , |� ■ �■ � ■ � ,\ �f. ��: �\ ,. .�� � � \ - ,. �\� . � . . �� • .� � � `� � . . � � .;�� . � _ \* . , _ . � 'i � . / c � ,� •� z ?`�f`- SOUTH BEACH � �� j �� �� ,�� ��� = k � � � . . � � . . &� ��•| ��� �� ®_� ~ � � ���r !- � , � ,¥ ; \� /,Sze �� \��'/ /�2��� �■�-: . . � � � : :J�4�:� Jf��� ��}/\ �~�){ ■�< - ` ��� ` �� � � -- � - . . w�� g , �� }� \� / \ \ � °� ,� , � r � - . t . �� . ! � | � ! ! 2 2 ! ! ! ! ! !� , � . � ! ! ! � 2 . ��& . ���E� �� �� �I• • C� -.� r �'E ► ► � • Prepared for: Village of Bald Head Island � � . . � Prepared by: .��� �`� �. -`' Olsen Associates, Inc. ����"`- ... ._ �_. ..- 2618 Herschel Street � ,� � `�.� ' �� �*. Jacksonville, FL 32204 r:. � .� (Fax) 384-7368 ��� Olsen-associates.com C-1468 � � ��� � r '� <.-��" ,. 5.. 4 � � � �Al �_. yA : - _ . A '7!� ram`. . rr • S 'if- - �r .-` - j_.... rr� � . Y�.•� �'a Sept.2018 Olsen associates, inc. PREFACE In February 2009, Olsen Associates, Inc. issued a documentation report entitled "Village of Bald Head Island, Engineered Beach Project". The following report (dated September 2018) serves to update the earlier report in anticipation of the predicted impacts associated with Hurricane Florence to the North Carolina coastline and more specifically to Bald Head Island. It is noted that during the period 25 August to 1 September 2011, Hurricane Irene caused impact to Bald Head Island's "engineered beach" project. In accordance with FEMA Declaration No. 4019 DR NC, Project Worksheet (PW) BHGJS03 allowed for Category `G' sand placement along a portion of South Beach impacted by the event. Subsequently PW No. BHGJS0300588 was issued for the replacement of five (5) damaged sand tube groins. Sept. 2018 - i - Olsen associates, inc. DOCUMENTATION FOR THE VILLAGE OF BALD HEAD ISLAND, NC ENGINEERED BEACH PROJECT PURPOSE In 1998, the Village of Bald Head Island formally embarked on a long-term Plan for Island -wide Beach Management. Simplistically, the goal was to develop an "engineered" solution to beach erosion along South Beach and portions of West Beach, both of which are physically interrelated through a common littoral sand sharing system. At the present time the program of improvement is based upon three (3) major components: a) Large scale beach restoration through sand placement volumes sufficient to create and maintain natural beach widths and dimensions capable of protecting publicly funded upland infrastructure, habitable structures, etc. b) The reconstruction and maintenance of a complimentary sand tube groin field at the west end of South Beach intended to reduce (but not eliminate) sediment losses from the beach fill to the adjacent federal navigation project channel which serves the Port of Wilmington, NC., and c) The introduction of a 1,300 ft. terminal groin constructed in 2015 at the juncture of South Beach and the Cape Fear River. The design intent of the low profile rock structure is to create an updrift sand fillet sufficiently broad enough so as to maintain an improved shoreline orientation and berm width in an area of chronic erosion — where beach fill alone has been incapable of reliably protecting upland properties and infrastructure. Two sources of beach quality sediment were preliminarily identified for purposes of project construction and maintenance. The principal sand source was determined to be clean littoral material routinely derived from improvements to, or ongoing maintenance of, a portion of the entrance channel to the federally sponsored Wilmington Harbor Navigation Project. The second primary source of available material was borrow sites) developed from abutting shoal formations which had been deposited as a direct result of the navigation project. Utilization of Sept. 2018 - 1 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project the latter sand source was determined to be a practical means of re-establishing natural sand bypassing at the mouth of the Cape Fear River which had been eliminated by the navigation works constructed at that location in the 1800's. Currently, the Village is likewise investigating the development of a longterm borrow site within the extensive Cape Fear Shoals formation lying seaward of the eastern end of Bald Head Island. BACKGROUND Since about 1974, beach erosion experienced along portions of the Bald Head Island shoreline, NC has been principally manifest as "chronic" —with severe shoreline recession along South Beach (most particularly the western portion nearest the inlet) and the seawardmost segment of West Beach. The island's historical erosion is the apparent result of several combined factors: (1) divergent alongshore littoral transport gradients near the center of South Beach, (2) tidal currents and proximity to the Cape Fear River Entrance, (3) direct recurring impacts associated with high frequency dredging operations required by the adjacent deep draft federal navigation project, and (4) long term morphological changes in island configuration and offshore ebb tidal shoal formations due to initial navigation channel construction, long term maintenance practices and more recently, entrance channel deepening, widening and realignment in 2000. The Wilmington Harbor Entrance Channel, which extends several miles seaward of Bald Head Island, is not stabilized by jetties and until a channel reconfiguration in 2000, had been maintained at a single location and orientation by dredging since the late 1800's. In recent times, but prior to the 2000 major modifications, maintenance of the entrance channel typically required the removal and offshore disposal of between 500,000 — 1,000,000 cubic yards (cy) of beach quality material each year. Beginning in 2000, the portion of the federal navigation channel abutting Bald Head Island was deepened by four feet, widened at several locations, and reoriented (see Figure 1). It is important to understand that the seven mile long offshore ocean entrance segment of the navigation project was reoriented as part of the deepening project from its historical location to a new location directly seaward of Bald Head Island through Bald Head Shoal. The documentation of recurring impacts due to deepening, widening and reorienting the channel in the vicinity of Bald Head Island has been a major focus of a Village sponsored annual Sept. 2018 - 2 - Olsen associates, inc. l nn 4 d.�r \,1! v t .p'�. �r�n� � rsH�- • I... 1 F f � � f � 1~ �.L��rA.. 1 � r � y�� 4 +ter �� v+ .r �dJ ' - �,~�}��. � { � +" is � - 'r. �r�^ 4` ,� on �n j' i � �� _ � §H � ,d �-.� ` -�i. F i. ��r�-y!'� k0 �*�0 i� � "''r 3 '-1� f _ Oh Is � 1 � ! .� J4 -� 1 &^ P - •� �,4 �N� z}I_ > �' Nr 2��s.Y fAS ri!'� d4 � .',f �� CJ """rrr 111 e ,,�� �� -�w,, , _ �- � � _ �_ P4 �yy �� a � �" � .ter° x� `,. 1 �L�. ��� � _ .. - � � r _ q �� � �� is _. '�� � �� �� �;�.� -2 � - -30 '24 �y� .. _Z] Win` 5 . , � 7 I IV �y�. _ � f. � _ J rd ////// -21 .�, � „?� � . yam` � �. � P'.,�'i -. •� r, - a7 � ii ., � '- �-33 �� `^ -1r �: � � _i5 �� ,- �, �' �i • . r` a '•;r � �� l r �� #r l � �` l..y 39 ti ,. � ',C. w n C �4 ' t `' dfL ;d ' z� I I •. I _ « �:� ' is 4 .0 n ca '. � _+ ... �; 750 0 I500 'J000 �,�' 59000FT � ',:!i, �_ V s 3 6 2006 CONTOUR DATUM: NGVD 29 NAUTICAL CHART DATUM: MLLW 2006 SURVEY-GEODYNAMICS, INC FIGURE 1 LOCATION OF BALD HEAD ISLAND RELATIVE TO FEDERAL NAVIGATION PROJECT -3- VBHI —Engineered Beach Project beach monitoring program. The latter was initiated in 1999 prior to, as well as in response to, the ocean entrance channel's proposed reconfiguration and widening by the federal government. As of May 2018, sixteen comprehensive Annual Monitoring Reports have been published (see REFERENCE SECTION). PLAN OF ACTION In order to facilitate along -term program of engineered beach restoration, the Village of Bald Head Island adopted a shore stabilization strategy predicated upon navigation project related mitigation by State and Federal interests as the primary source of funding for sand placement. Secondary sources of funding, as necessary, have derived from Village annual revenues, the State of North Carolina and more recently the establishment of on -island special purpose Taxing Districts. The latter are directed toward beach management and enhancement activities and, in particular, beach restoration and ancillary shore stabilization structures constructed and maintained by the Village as part of a longterm Plan. For purposes of facilitating a major harbor deepening and widening program in 2000, the Wilmington District USACOE formulated a project specific action element entitled the Wilmington Harbor Sand Management Plan (WHSMP). The Plan was codified by State permit for purposes of meeting State of North Carolina Coastal Zone Consistency requirements. For the most part, the Plan was in direct response to the stated concerns and associated legal actions) by the Village of Bald Head Island (VBHI) regarding both historical channel maintenance impacts and potential new impacts of the deepening project to both the regional sediment budget and Bald Head Island. The Plan's purpose was to reverse the highly impactive "standard practice" of transporting beach quality sand removed from the channel during dredging activities to deep water offshore disposal sites. Specifically the Plan called for the future placement of all dredged beach quality sand directly onto adjacent beaches with special emphasis on Bald Head Island. The initial construction of the widening/deepening project provided over 5 Mcy of high quality sediment in 2000. Approximately 1.85 Mcy of that volume was used to initially improve the entirety of South Beach at Bald Head Island. Over a typical six -year maintenance cycle, the Wilmington Harbor Sand Management Plan proposed that approximately 1.0+ Mcy of sand predicted to be dredged biannually as maintenance would be placed on the Beaches of Bald Head Sept. 2018 - 4 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project Island in year two and four (after initial construction) and on Oak Island/Caswell Beach during year six. The 6-year cycle would then repeat. The two-year dredge and disposal cycle was planned for the life of the project but is subject to alteration based upon impact documentation and other relevant factors. Pragmatically, implementation can likewise be affected by Congressional funding of such navigation works, etc. To date, federal funding shortfalls associated with direct sand placement have been addressed by both the State of North Carolina and the Village of Bald Head Island. At this time, it is relatively clear that the Wilmington Harbor Sand Management Plan provides a partial framework for the implementation of an "engineered" beach at Bald Head Island. Since initial construction of the deepening project in 2000, six maintenance dredging operations have been conducted within three inner channel segments closest to Bald Head Island. Monitoring has conclusively shown that Bald Head Island needs sand every two to three years, not the SMP's two out of three biennial events, Even though the placement of sand is procedurally viewed as "disposal" by the USACOE, the tenets of the federal Plan allow the coastal engineering consultant to the Village of Bald Head Island to strategically define the limits of work and design templates to be filled throughout the project disposal area. By virtue of a project specific updated "design", based upon comprehensive annual beach monitoring, the Village of Bald Head Island is able to implement an engineered beach restoration project. As an adjunct to the beach restoration project, the Village maintains amulti-structure sand tube groinfield intended to limit shoreline recession in the area of most severe erosion nearest the inlet channel. The groin field was required by, and is viewed as a favorable project element by the USACOE since it correspondingly tends to reduce the amount of sand entrainment caused by the navigation channel —and particularly immediately after each beach fill placement operation at South Beach. In 2015, this groinfield was supplemented by the construction of a 1,300 ft. long rock terminal groin —intended to further increase the longevity of future beach fills constructed eastward thereof on South Beach. HISTORICAL EROSION CONTROL ACTIVITIES Beach Construction. Major beach construction activities constructed at Bald Head Island since 1991 are summarized in Table 1. The three small scale privately initiated channel disposal Sept. 2018 - 5 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project projects constructed between 1991 and 1997 were cost -shared or paid for in their entirety by the Village of Bald Head Island. Limited in scope, the three early sand placement efforts were not highly successful in providing meaningful levels of shore stabilization due to their size. As a result, the Village of Bald Head Island eventually adopted the long-range plan -of -action discussed herein, i.e., comprehensive beach restoration via an "engineered project" construction and commitment to long-term maintenance. That Plan -of -Action addressed both South Beach and West Beach. Table 1: Beach construction activities at Bald Head Island since 1991. Year Volume S onsor Location 1991 0.35 � Mcy VBHI (Sta. 24+00 to 138+00) 1996 0.65 � Mcy VBHI (Sta. 24+00 to 142+00) 1997 0.45 � Mcy VBHI (Sta. 24+00 to 128+00) 2001 1.849 � Mcy USACE* South Beach (Sta. 41+60 to 205+50) 2005 1.217 � Mcy USACE* South Beach (Sta. 46+00 to 126+00) 2006 47,800 cy VBHI West Beach (Sta. 16+00 to 34+00) 2007 1.1� Mcy USACE* South Beach (Sta. 46+00 to 174+00) 2009/10 1.850 � Mcy VBHI West Beach (Sta. 8+00 to 32+00) South Beach (Sta. 40+00 to 190+00) 2012 137,990 cy FEMA/VBHI West Beach &Western South Beach 2013 1.566 � Mcy USACE* South Beach (Sta. 44+00 to 150+00) 92,500 cy West Beach (Sta. 8+00 to 27+00) 2015 1.33 � Mcy USACE* South Beach (Sta. 41+50 to 154+00) 2016/17 50,000 cy VBHI West Beach and Row Boat Row * Disposal pursuant to the WHSMP The initial 2001, 1.849 Mcy comprehensive beach restoration project was constructed as an element of the Wilmington Harbor Deepening Project. The disposal sand was placed in the configuration of a designed berm along the entirety of the 15,500 feet of shoreline at South Beach. The limits of work and design templates were provided to the Wilmington District by Olsen Associates, Inc. on behalf of the Village. All work was performed in conformance with the requirements of the SMP. The 2005, 1.2 Mcy beach disposal project was the initial "maintenance" event (Year 2 of the SMP) of the scheduled disposal cycle and was constructed Sept. 2018 - 6 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project between November 2004 and January 2005. The 2006, non -Federal West Beach sand disposal project was independently constructed by the Village in January 2006. Sand for that work was sourced from Bald Head Creek. The 2007, 1.1 Mcy disposal project was the second declared "maintenance" event (Year 4 of the SMP) and was constructed between February and Apri12007. Approximately 1,098,000 cubic yards (pay volume) of beach quality material was placed along the South Beach shoreline in accordance with a fill design requested by the Village. In 2009/10, the terms of the WHSMP dictated that the scheduled channel maintenance sand be placed on Oak Island, in lieu of Bald Head Island. As a result, the Village constructed a 1.85 M cy beach fill along the majority of South Beach and a small section of West Beach which fronts the inlet throat. The sand source was a borrow site developed and permitted by the Village in Jay Bird Shoals. Portions of that borrow site continue to be available as a sand source today. Detailed documentation for this Village project is included in Olsen (2010). It is noted that the entire 16 sand filled tube groinfield was replaced immediately subject to beach fll completion. Subsequent to the passage of H. Irene in 2012, a FEMA funded small scale fill project was constructed along the western end of S. Beach. Five (5) sand tube groins damaged by the storm were also replaced as part of that project. The project sand source was Bald Head Creek. In 2013, the Wilmington District placed approximately 1.6 Mcy of channel maintenance material along S. Beach and 92,500 cy along the southerly section of West Beach. Similarly in 2015, the District placed approximately 1.33 Mcy on South Beach with material sourced from routine channel maintenance of the Cape Fear Entrance Channel (inner 3 sections). Erosion Control Structures (1996 to 2018) — Synopsis Erosion control structures constructed at Bald Head Island since 1996 are summarized in Table 2. A detailed discussion of the history of erosion control structures is provided in Monitoring Report No. I5 (Olsen 2017). Sept. 2018 - 7 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project Table 2: Chronology of shore stabilization structures at Bald Head Island since 1994. Year Location Descri tion 1994 Western South Beach Sand bag revetment located along 645 feet of the back- beachberm 1996 Western South Beach Sixteen (16) soft groins (geotube-type structures) were March constructed of eotextile material and sand fill Rehabilitation of 1994 constructed sand bag revetment. 2003/2004 Western South Beach Revetment lengthened by approximately 200 feet and base width increased to 40 ft and crest elevation raised to +12 ft-NGVD . Replacement of 1996 constructed sand tube groin field. 2005 Minor changes in groin location were made in an effort to (January to Western South Beach improve performance. Similarly, experimental "tapered" March) tubes were deployed in an attempt to better accommodate beach rofile recession over time. Complete rehabilitation of the sand tube groin field. 2009 Western South Beach Some adjustment of groin lengths, and the westward relocation of groin no. 16 were made in an attempt to refine the ro'ect desi 300 ft sand bag revetment was constructed on the 2011 Western South Beach downdrift (western side) of the last sand tube groin in order to rotect several endan ered residential structures. In the spring of 2013, the westernmost five (5) sand tube groins were replaced in their entirety. This work was co- 2013 Western South Beach funded by FEMA as part of a post -Irene damage mitigation effort. The project P.W. was BHGJS04 in accordance with FEMA declaration 4019 DR NC. In the spring of 2015, construction was initiated on a single 1,300 ft. long rock terminal groin designed to complement future placement of beach fill at South 2015 Western South Beach Beach. At that time, the westernmost three (3) geotube groins were removed in their entirety. A detailed description of the project is provided in Monitoring Re ort No. 15 Olsen 2017 . The two marina entrance channel structures seaward of 2015 Bald Head Marina Row -Boat -Row originally constructed by Bald Head (West Beach) Island, Ltd., were modified through the addition of rock extensions. Row Boat Row Two (2) detached breakwaters were constructed just 2017 (West Beach) north of the Marina Entrance. Construction details are rovided in Section 1.5.3 of this re ort. Note — As of Sept. 2018, all sand tube revetments are buried within a protective dune system. Sept. 2018 - 8 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project The structures which effectively contribute to the stabilization of Bald Head Island's engineered beaches — as of the date of this report —are as follows: • S. Beach — 0 1,300 ft. long terminal groin constructed in 2015; o A sand filled tube groin field (originally 16 strux; 3 removed in 2015). • W. Beach o Rubble mound rock jetties at the marina entrance channel constructed in 2015. o Two rock breakwaters constructed in 2017 seaward of Row -Boat -Row. PROJECT DESIGN South Beach. The project renourishment design for South Beach calls for the placement of approximately 1 Mcy of sand every two to three years from the local navigation project with supplementary renourishment, as required, from alternate borrow sources) developed and permitted by the Village. The project likewise provides for the continued use of structures at the western end of the South Beach fill segment, intended to increase project life. The project limits on South Beach extend approximately from Sta 045+47 to Sta 210+00, or nominally about 16,000 ft. plus fill tapers at both ends (see Figure 2). Atypical fill template for S. Beach is depicted by Figure 3. Appendix A to this document includes beach profiles which depict the conditions of the project beaches along South Beach as they existed in May 2018 —prior to the 2018 hurricane season. Normally project fills are constructed within a permit required environmental window which necessitates that completion of fill activities occur between Nov. and April of any one year —except during emergency situations where waivers may be granted. West Beach. The island's "engineered beach" systems likewise includes an approximate 2,100+ ft. long segment of shorefront along West Beach (see Figure 2). Given the steep nearshore slope of the submerged portion of this river -affected shoreline, a fill density of 30 cy/ft. is typically the maximum for this area (see Figure 3). Including tapers, the net fill episodically placed at this location is estimated at about 100,000 cy, or less. West Beach shoreline conditions are likewise comprehensively monitored annually by the Village of Bald Head Island. Sept. 2018 - 9 - Olsen associates, inc. �� o CROCK BREAKWATERS (2) ,� Q 0 m 3 0 �;�; �ROCKJETTIES(2) 2 U W _ m `� !� A, ��,: TERMINAL THE'' GROIN POINTY ' v � '�;`� TUB �,�-�: � � { (13 TR ROAN FjE�O Uxl SCALE 0 700 1400FT _April-2018 Photo September 2018 10 RAI Il I-IFAII ICI A�If� O1 -SECTION OF ENGINEERED BEACH CAPE �.� FEAR Figure 2: Locations of Engineered Beaches and Stabilizing Structures Olsen associates, inc. LIMIT OF PROJECT EASEMENT DISTANCE VARIES m LL EXISTING DUNE O (VARIES) LIMIT OF WORD � �Cti o ��y1 tr +8.0' NGVD SOUTH BEACH ATLANTIC OCEAN AVERAGE BEACH FILL DENSITY APPROX. 100cy/ft �, BEACH FILL MHW (2.5' NGVD) EXISTING BEAC //�j/�/\\�� SSUMED FILL TEMPLATE SLOPE PROFILE (TYP) '�//�%/,\,`j'/��j//�/` �j�\� DURING CONSTRUCTION NOTE: 1) FILL DENSITY TO VARY SPATIALLY DEPENDING ON CONDITION OF BEACH AT TIME OF CONSTRUCTION. 2) GROIN FILLET FILL DENSITY VARIES AND MAY EXCEED 300 CY/FT LOCAL TIDAL DATUMS MHHW +2.8 MHW +2.5 NAVD +1.1 NGVD(29) 0.0 MLW -1.8 MLLW -2.0 DUNE 8'NGVD CONDITIONS VARY �\ BEACH FI NOTE: 1) POINT FILL DENSITY MAY BE TYPICAL OF EITHER S. BEACH OR W. BEACH \ ���?� -12T0 -15FT NGVD (TYP) LOPE INTERCEPT TYPICAL SECTION OF FILL TOE AVERAGE FILL DENSITY �HW (+2.5' NGVD) APPROX. 30-50cy/ft !' (TYP) �p� LW (-1.8' NGVD) TYPICAL SECTION NTS DATUM: NGVD 29 WEST BEACH CAPE FEAR RIVER CHANNEL GORGE EXISTING PROFILE (TYP) NTS DATUM: NGVD 29 NOT FOR PURPOSES OF CONSTRUCTION DATE APPROVED REVISION - e�m� Olsen '�'� ��}= associates, inc. VILLAGE OF BALD HEAD ISLAND ��_r -"��" 2618HerschelStreet ENGINEERED BEACH PROJECT FIGURE 3 Jacksonville, FL. 32204 � _ 4;, (904) 387-6114 TYPICAL BEACH FILL SECTIONS _ • • • C-1468 VBHI —Engineered Beach Project In 2016/17, the West Beach segment of improved shorefront was extended to include some 1,400 ft. of shorefront located northward of the marina entrance —typically referred to as Row -Boat - Row (see Figure 2). Stabilizing structures maintained at that location include two (2) rock breakwaters constructed in 2016, and four (4) low profile groins last renovated in 2005. Row - Boat -Row is separated from the southerly portion of West Beach by two (2) rock jetties constructed in 2015. The latter structures protect the marina entrance channel which is an integral part of the island's water -borne transportation system which is served only by ferry and barge. Photographs of stabilizing structures discussed herein are included in Appendix B. PROJECT DOCUMENTATION In order to document shoreline changes along the South Beach and West Beach portion of the island's "engineered" beaches, the Village of Bald Head Island has routinely funded an in- depth annual beach monitoring program. Since 1999, the program has been expanded from annual surveys to include two (2) surveys (spring and fall) and two (2) aerial overflights which result in digital, rectified shoreline photography. An annual report of findings is published which addresses both the prior 12-month period as well as special events (i.e., dredge operations) and other longer term trends are included. The monitoring program specifically addresses beach fill performance and provides guidance for the design of each episodic sand placement operation. The spring hydrographic surveys are scheduled to document beach conditions immediately prior to each hurricane season in order to comply with FEMA related post -disaster eligibility requirements. The beach monitoring program presently being implemented by the Village of Bald Head Island's engineered beaches is based upon a baseline with survey stationing located on approximate 400 ft centers. As shown by Figure 4, the baseline limits extend from Row -Boat - Row, located northward of the entrance to the Bald Head marina (Sta 0+00) southward along West Beach some 4,500 ft to the "Point" (or depositional spit) abutting the existing navigation project channel and thence eastward to Cape Fear along South Beach, an additional 17,300 ft, mol. The baseline stationing is referenced to the North Carolina State Plane Coordinate System, North American Datum of 1927 (NAD27). Sept. 2018 - 12 - Olsen associates, inc. RB.3� 18+72 RB-2_ -39+)2 0 RB-3� r a. -12+pp � RB-q� Q _�__ -8a00 m RB-5�_ O �4+00 B-ol-- � 0+pp B-B2 2app 4+00 8-03_ 6M0 8+00 B.p9_ __ 10+pp u+pp W B-os� - 1q+oo ``�i __ 16+pp I'� B-pp 18+pp _____ *00 20 8-07_ 22+00 ________ 24+p0 B'08_ 26+pp 28+pp 3z+ The Point" � a, � (North of �+�, °O Terminal Groin) 3e � / ro Q�� �°�oo , "The Point" ���o (South of p$o Terminal Groin) oa+o5 s ti o� �qy� cO� L' 'r' �'�'�ti�g � eF� 4J~y 0 $ �'� �' �~ oo"p ti o 0 o R ��� � , � o F .. ., S{�� i• 4 E0-0I 7.�}� .:�: EB-� 2�Ar8p Eg-p5 26gr8B �V' [�^. 2Sgtap .-.. � I I � � � I � � � � � � � I I I I m m m m � � m m m m m m m � m m m m °' m 4 SCALE 0 700 1400FT April 2018 Photo September 2018 13 S S m S �? 8 0 CAPE FEAR Figure 4: Island -wide beach monitoring baseline. Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project Some level of beach monitoring has been performed at Bald Head Island since about 1990. Initially, surveying was limited to beach profiles from the back berm to a wading depth. In the mid-1990's offshore profiles to a depth of -30 ft or a distance of 3,000 ft were added to the program. In 2009, the program was expanded to include East Beach —pursuant to the request of property owners at that location (see Figure 4). As a result, the entire monitoring baseline length exceeds30,000 ft. Tidal Datums —The elevations and water depths along each of the survey profiles are referenced to National Geodetic Vertical Datum of 1929 (NGVD29). The relationship between NGVD29 and various tidal datums are as follows: Table 3: Tidal datums for Bald Head Island. North Carolinas. Datum Elevation (ft-NGVD 292) Mean Higher High Water (MHHW) +2.82 Mean High Water (MHW) +2.53 NAVD 1988 +1.10 Mean Tide Level (MTL) +0.35 NGVD 1929 0.00 Mean Low Water (MLW) -1.81 Mean Lower Low Water (MLLW) -1.98 ' Approximations based upon extrapolation from Southport, N.C. z NGVD 1929: National Geodetic Vertical Datum of 1929 (1929 Mean Seas Level). Horizontal coordinates are referenced to the North Carolina State Plane Coordinate System, North American Datum of 1983. PROJECT PUBLIC ASSISTANCE ELIGIBILITY Section 102(8) of the Stafford Act defines a public facility owned by a State or local government as any flood control, navigation, irrigation, reclamation, public power, sewage treatment and collection, water supply and distribution, watershed development, or airport facility; any non -Federal -aid street, road or highway; any other public building, structure, or system, including those used for educational, recreational, or cultural purposes; and any park. Additionally, Title 44 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), Section 206.201(c) includes an improved and maintained natural feature in the definition of a facility. 44 CFR 206.221(d) defines an improved property to mean a structure, facility or item of equipment that was built, constructed or manufactured. Publicly -owned engineered beaches are eligible for assistance Sept. 2018 - 14 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project because they are improved natural features, assuming they have been regularly maintained prior to the disaster. The engineered beach segments at Bald Head Island, N.C. meet the criteria of a publicly -owned non -Federal engineered beach. Concurrent with ongoing commitments by the Village to fund the project construction, the local sponsor has the capability and intent to facilitate or perform the requisite future maintenance of the beach fill project for the long-term project life of greater than 30 years. Section 206.226 Restoration of damaged facilities, further defines eligibility criteria for Beaches. For an improved beach, work to re-establish the beach as infrastructure may be eligible under the following conditions: a) The beach was constructed by the placement of sand (of proper grain size) to a designed elevation, width and slope, and b) A periodic maintenance program involving periodic renourishment of sand has been established and adhered to by the Applicant. Implicit in these regulations is the requirement of an Applicant to document the condition of the affected shoreline prior to impact by the storm which results in the declared disaster. As noted above, the comprehensive beach monitoring program implemented annually by the Village of Bald Head Island specifically seeks to fulfill that requirement. POST -STORM ACTION PLAN Immediately subsequent to a major storm event for which a formal disaster declaration may (or will in all probability) be issued, the Village will initiate the following Action -Plan elements: • A comprehensive survey of the affected beaches by a certified hydrographic survey firm, • Concurrent drone photography and eventual digital orthophotography (island -wide), • Analysis of storm induced shoreline volumetric erosion, shoreline recession, vegetation/dune impacts, etc., • Assessment and documentation of damage to infrastructure and development, Sept. 2018 - 15 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project • The formulation of an engineering report of post -storm conditions suitable for review and consideration by FEMA staff authorized to issue P.W.'s. • The submittal of all relevant documentation as to the existence of an "engineered beach" required by FEMA staff, and • As applicable, any requested letters -of -opinion, computations, or recommendations, by a State of N.C. registered coastal engineer requested by FEMA, Brunswick County or the State of NC. Sept. 2018 - 16 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project REFERENCES Olsen Associates, Inc. (2003). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 1 (Nov. 1999 —May 2003)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 66 pp plus app. (June 2003). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2004). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 2 (May 2003 —April 2004)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 51 pp plus app. (August 2004). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2005). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 3 (May 2004 —April 2005)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 38 pp plus app. (December 2005). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2006). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 4 (April 2005 —May 2006)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 40 pp plus app. (July 2006). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2007). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. S (June 2006 —May 2007)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 37 pp plus app. (December 2007). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2008). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 6 (June 2007 —May 2008)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 40 pp plus app. (August 2008). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2009). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 7 (June 2008 —May 2009)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 49 pp plus app. (August 2009). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2010). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 8 (June 2009 —May 2010)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 64 pp plus app. (August 2010). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2010). "Village of Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Renourishment Project Post -Construction Report (July 2010)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 34 pp plus app. (August 2010). Sept. 2018 - 17 - Olsen associates, inc. VBHI —Engineered Beach Project Olsen Associates, Inc. (2011). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 9 (May 2010 —May 2011)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 69 pp plus app. (August 2011). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2012). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 10 (May 2011—May 2012)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 70 pp plus app. (July 2012). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2013a). "Shoreline Stabilization Analysis", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 338 pp. (July 2013). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2013b). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 11 (May 2012 —May 2013)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 63 pp plus app. (August 2013). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2014). "Bald Head Island, N. C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 12 (May 2013 —May 2014)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 63 pp plus app. (August 2014). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2015). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 13 (May 2014 —May 201 S)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 65 pp plus app. (June 2015). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2016). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 14 (April 2015 —April 2016)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 80 pp plus app. (June 2016). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2017). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 1 S (April 2016 —May 2017)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 80 pp plus app. (June 2017). Olsen Associates, Inc. (2018). "Bald Head Island, N.C. Beach Monitoring Program Report No. 16 (May 2017 —May 2018)", Report prepared for Village of Bald Head Island. Olsen Associates, Inc. 2618 Herschel St., Jacksonville, FL 32204. 69 pp plus app. (July 2018). Sept. 2018 - 18 - Olsen associates, inc. APPENDIX A PLOTTED BEACH PROFILES WEST BEACH AND SOUTH BEACH September 2018 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z •v 00£'� m OOZ'� v T T U 0� I�' I� � N 000'� � v L 006 N 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-01: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station-018+72, Bald Head Island, N.C. oos OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v c OSti m OOti v V C f6 OS£ �_ N L 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ OS 0 July 2018 A-2 Olsen associates, inc. �I� N (V + O � � � m � DC Q H I I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I OI I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I [] [] [] N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� 009'� .-. 005'T v OOti'Z •v 00£'� m OOZ'� v U OOT'� � a✓ 000'� � (V L O 006 N 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I , I ' I 1 I L- O () _3 M �> f' '++ `' '� L) `3 4J — y S- I=- L) �� �+ h F- f- c3 � '�' O c_ U) O U 4J i C1� lJ f- C) �� F" ii (`J a3 �o _ v�'i f= O I, I 1 I I I I I I I I t I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � I I I I _i O O O_ L1 C> �� �- U'1 L" S= �+ �a {' `� O O �n oy <i r. �. d �- �i � �i N (C`J M �� �� UJ � N r, CU OQ � i i � aJ C) S) O � � S) rJ �� C`J O () Cl U c3 Q C3 Z Q C) C_ L� C� I I I I I Icc G _ ' I - ' � I c G I I I I (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-02: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station-014+72, Bald Head Island, N.C. oss 008 OSL OOL 059 009 OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti OOti �_ (V L O OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOT OS July 2018 A-3 Olsen associates, inc. �!, [] [] [] N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z7 00£'Z ooz'z ooi'z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� .-. v 009'� v OOs'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � ooi'i v 000'� N 0 00Q6 OOV OOL 009 OOs OOti 00� OOZ OOT I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I t_ I (� I O �> I M I I I I �' � C) _3 S, I.li Lj �� �� c F� f- �3 � •• O M U I I I L_ U) O ` �I I aJ � O� lJ t'i N CJ Y i+ �� "_ vl f' O _) O O �- �- � L� S� I I I I I I i' �a `� I I i) {' O � oy <i r. �. ci �> i o L<) L- O C) I I N i =J (`J M I I I I i I I � w �a r. <u a) ri i i � � aJ C) S) O � N S) rJ �� (`J O O Q U c3 Q C3 Z Q C) C_ L� C� I I I I I I I - ' I ' I � I c_ G c�c G [] [] N � � N m � I I I I (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-03: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station-012+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. 006 Os8 008 OSL OOL Os9 v 009 °LL' v c OSs m OOs v c os� 0 OOti Os£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OST OOT July 2018 A-4 Olsen associates, inc. 009'Z 005'Z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� .-. v OOL'T v v 009'Z •v 005'� m OOti'� v U 00£'� � 7 N OOZ'� � L OOT'� N �_ 000'� � 006 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ [] [] [] N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I L- I I O I I �� _3 f" M O I I I I �� f" '+i I I U 4) =� L) _3 I I S= li Lj �� �+ h F- f' ��� •'• O I I L- M U U) O I I dJ � O� lJ f_ C) �� F- �y N CJ Y i3 �� _ vl f' O _3 O O O_ �- °± `' s' 1 ' I i" �a i+ `J f- C) f' O ci �> i o L<) L- O O N =J rJ (Y7 � I I � I I i I I �� v w rJ r. <u a) � � � dJ C) S) O � N S) rJ �� rJ O O Cl U c3 () ci Z Q C) C� L� C_ �� I I I I I I I I - ' I ' I � I c_ G c�c G [] [] N � � N m � I I I I (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-04: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station-008+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. 000'� 056 006 058 008 OSL v OOL v c 059 m ;� 009 v V C f- f- C6 OSS �_ 0 OSti OOti OS£ 00� OSZ OOZ r•� U July 2018 A-5 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 009'Z 005'Z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� .-. v OOL'T v 009'Z •v oos'i m oo�'i v oo�'i ooz'i OOT'� N 000'� � 006 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-O5: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station-004+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. 000'� 056 006 058 008 OSL v OOL v c os9 m 009 v oss 0 v 005 N OSti OOti OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ �•. July 2018 A-6 Olsen associates, inc. �a f 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 009'Z OOS'Z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'T 008'� .-. v OOL'T °� v 009'� OOS'� m OOti'� v 00£'� � �_ OOZ'� � v OOT'� N 000'i � 006 008 OOL 009 OOS OOti 00£ OOZ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-06: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 000+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OSO'� 000'T 056 006 058 008 v OSL °�' v c OOL m ;� 059 v c 009 0 v OSS N OOS OSti OOti OS£ 00£ OSZ �., July 2018 A-7 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 009'Z 005'Z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'T 008'� .-. v OOL'T °� 009'� 005'� m OOti'� v 00£'� � OOZ'� � OOT'� N 000'� � 006 008 OOL 009 oos oo� 00£ OOZ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 c� � � ci m � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-07: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 004+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 000'� 056 006 058 008 OSL v OOL v c 059 m ;� 009 v c OSS 0 v 005 N OSti OOti OS£ oo£ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-8 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 005'Z 006 l� OOti'Z �? � � _3 s_ f� (` OS8 CC�� 77 OO G'(. � n O U u3 O '� QJ U O `- OOZ Z f6 _. rts „� C) u �� c F� c- � 008 7 O iZ C) rti vl C� O CL Lf) C) O Y " O �; [� U �" �n O �n C.) �� � �� �; �> � �; � �� o OSL 000 Z a °- �' �� Y +� v [1_ �i �, n_ s; o f1 L- oa C �t £� c- OOL o N I O a fV o �� ly � t!3 i O 0o .-I b (`J o (Y7 008' L v � C, cal v� Q1 s) £' �) N O � N � N dJ n O CU S] � q) O S3 N N L_ C_ ♦—� 009'� � I I ���� � / 009 v OOS'� •� I I � l � � I � i i � � OSS �' oo�'i m � m oo�'i � OOS U I. I � i� V 7 OOZ'� � I � co OSti OOZ'� � I � o vI i � 000'� , OOti N 0 I I I i � o 006 � � � OS£ 008 I OOL 00£ I 009 I I OSZ OOS I OOti I OOZ 00� OSZ OOZ I = 3 � � OOT OOZ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-08: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 008+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-9 Olsen associates, inc. .� O O O O O O O O O N r-I r-I N (h � u1 l0 i i i i i i (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'T OOL'� .-. v 009'� v 005'� OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � OOT'� � 000'� N 006 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT O O O O O O O N r-I r-I N (�") � i i i i (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-09: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 012+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 058 008 OSL OOL 059 v 009 °LL' v c OSS m 005 v c OSti 0 OOti 0 OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-10 Olsen associates, inc. O O O O O O O O O N r-I r-I N (h � u1 l0 i i i i i i (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'T OOL'� .-. v 009'� v 005'� OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � OOT'� � 000'� N 006 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT O O O O O O O N r-I r-I N (�") � i i i i (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-09: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 012+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 058 008 OSL OOL 059 v 009 °LL' v c OSS m 005 v c OSti 0 OOti 0 OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-10 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z o08 oo£'z � � OSL 77 77 OOIi'li �-� Y �-� O O O 1 0� I� Z v@i .-. v@i '" �i rti o a~', o O�L Q. v@i Q. O +% �: U p U I 000'Z ° �- � ° a N L' �� ~ � u ~ I rl o � Lf1 o � �� o �� N .�.+ ��' a° o � a° I 059 N � s: b �, +� a +� 008'Z a. o N a, c: a; � � vl p O N a; � � o Il � 009 ,a°, 0 o a �� ao 0 0 N �••� N �� CAI � V N v � O � O OOL'T v sf o N v v� a� sf �� S! N l� v L � � O ao � N 3 N �� 61 S' N �� T N T OSS +' 005'T °� I � � ��� � I v 005 v v OOti'Z •� I I j � � I I � � � 1 1 � � v c 00£'� m �� OSti m � i � OOZ'� � � � i i OOti c� ' ' / / � c� OOT'� � � � /� � � � � OS£ 000'� � � � � � %I / o 4J i i ` N O 006 ' ' �' O 00£ N � � 008 0 � � � � � / �� o OOL ' � / ' � / OSZ << 009 OOZ � ,� -� oos �— ; osi �,, oo� s � � oo£ ooi .r .... .... .... .... OOZ.... I I O 00 � I = I 3 � � 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-10: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 016+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-11 Olsen associates, inc. N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. Q1 005'T � v OOti'� 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � �_ 000'� � v 006 N 0 oos OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ ooz OOT 0 0 .� U .� c c �; M � C �I � U 3 U U 2 _ �! _ o w c� s �; �� f0 fC'� y� U +�+ f. F' C O � p� d i � {! of � U p U p. � u�i o p�. � N � ,i � O v l) o. C7 � o �- o� a o � �' M� JIV N U u u � u�'i I p d ril +'+ o / o .� a� o � � a a° N 00 NI G S � N 2� L / a N a,, `ci a o �� " o / / O p v' p u! � �: �� � � O O v �I O� ci i O l0 00 O O N � NI O �, � N � �� f`J O M O � r' 4J N �', �', c; Q � L s: £_ � O / N vYi 3 N d'� —. N rd p UJ O 3 0� Ci. O u �s U Z Q Z', Q; Z O c_ Z ? I i I i; � I I � � 1 I 1 1 1 i 1 i i 1 i r�i �� :;�� , ��r �� JI / �/ ,) . , ��� ' i� 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 ''i J � � � � � � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-ll : Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 020+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oos OSL OOL 059 009 OSS 005 LL v c OSti m OOti v U c OS£ 0 00£ 0 osZ OOZ OST 00� �S July 2018 A-12 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z • • • • • 008 I � �I 00£'Z OSL OOZ Z I � ►� OOZ'Z � OOL I 000'Z �� 059 � I � � �` 006'� 'r i ► 1 008'� 009 i i � �� OOL'� ; - •� � / , �- / OSS �i � 009'Z yi l v 005'T � � I � /; ► � 005 LL v OOti'� •v I/ ; ► v 00£'� m �i/ / OSti N m ; � // I I I , OOZ'� � ,� I I , }.� OO V ' I V I / � OOZ'Z � �_ I I co OS£ �_ 000'� � I I I I o I I 006 N � 00£ � � I I I I ► � � o 008 I I ► OSZ OOL � � s Y s i � '� � � y u O Y u u Y 009 I i I � � O a O Y � � � � OOZ I/ � � Q t° Q 0 a`+ g U � U � OOS / I � N- � O N O C Y U u H L O � c�-I O O O N d H = L � L T OS I� OOti I / I I I i � i � � t C �, � O O N O O 00£ I I � c-1 N ��������� � ON H � � m OOZ I I I I � Y � ON � � ON � N OOZ ••� ,•• za'z°az°o�z°� O >. �. � I I I OS I OOT �1 3 3 I I ' ; � � �� I I I � 1 1 � 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 � � I 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-12: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 024+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-13 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z oo�'z oo£'7z OOZ'Z ooi'z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� .-. v 009'� v OOs'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � OOT'� � 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 OOs OOti 00£ OOZ OOT I I I I , � � � , I I ; ; , I I , /" ; I I I 1 I I I � / I , ; I � I � I � � i , , I •� � , �, -- �I . , . , • }i ;� ►� I � ' �' ► I I I , , I � � � � / � �' � � I �► ' • � ,� � _ I ' � 1 '� '� � I _ � I' I I I 1 I �I I I � ,� , I � I I I I � I I I I I I � �' I I I� I I I/ I /I I I I � 0 u � i � O ''' O c I I I u u I I I I _ _ O O t yi, � aL+ to _ to fl' u " c H c G io Q 0 � g U � U � I I I I I � N- � O O C F H L I I � � N U u a+ a+ oo � o+�„ C7 � a c o N O N d ~ 3 �, � H O � = L L I I � N � >= � N I I I I O O O cO c c p d g e�-I � L e^-I C c�-I O o v o �o 00 0 0 N � N N O V N .M_. N O N � N N I� N W � Y � ON � � ON � N I I I I � > T Z Q Z Q Z O � Z I I I I I � • I I .. . ...3 3.. I � � - I i � � �� I I I I 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� I I I 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-13: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 028+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 oss 008 OSL OOL Os9 v 009 °LL' v c OSs m OOs v c Osti 0 OOti 0 Os£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-14 Olsen associates, inc. oos'z oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� .-. v 009'� v 005'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v 7 U OOZ'� � to OOT'� � v 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 I I I I �� , •, I I ,,. ' � r I I / ' I I �� � �� � � I I I ' , I I ; � „ I I I I • , , ' � � ♦ 1 I I I I I I • � / I / i 1 I I ,i • ,� I ' I I � I �� � , I ,''` I I , ' I , I �� � ,, I / I I ' �' '/ i ( � I I I I , J ;'. r '„- •, � I I�I I I ' I � I I� I � I _ I I I � I I I I I I �� , I I �' , I � 0 u � i O a+ O' c I _ �. � p �' � � N i U i ' I � � O O Y Y � r+', io io fl' u c H c. � O r+ p C. u�i C. � g U � U, O � � U1 C7 a C7' 'Y 1 /I I I I I _ � O' � O O � H H I I oo � o N� � a c o� N O N d ~ 7 �, � d, O � = L t I I � N � C � � p N C. I I cO 0 0p ccp OO d g e�i � L e^i L. I I c�-I o o v o �o 0o c O N � N N O V N N O N � N N I� N W� � N � `� L c-I � a -I � a+ � � � � O � O, I I I I O >. >. Z Q Z Q Z O� Z �. I •• I I I I � • I I 3 3 � � I I � �� I I I I 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� I I 1 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-14: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 032+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OS6 006 OS8 008 OSL �I�L v 059 °LL' v c 009 m OSS v V C f6 005 OSti 0 OOti OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ July 2018 A-15 Olsen associates, inc. 000000000 N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z ooi'z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� .-. v 009'� v OOS'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � ooi'i 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 OOS OOti oo£ ooz ooi I I I I I I I I ` I I t,_ I I �r I I I I 'r I I I I I I I I �' � I I I I I I � � �' � , I I ' ' I I I I I I I I , ,! , I I I I , ,, ' I I I I , , I I � ��_ I I I ! I , _� I� I I ,� ,� I I I� I I - I �� , I I ♦ r� � I � �♦ � I ;,, I � I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I L` �� u � Y � L: � i u° I � I I I '� I I I I I a3i O y �' l.7 +' u c « c ` � o 0 y,, U U O d � G. � I I I I U to +-' L +-' I I � L d Q a I I Y = = L �' L O .. � d c � O O ul O ti d. � � o �o 0o a o N C nl M I I I I I I I I N N I� N 00 O �: O I I I I I I ii Yam, T 'a � Z 0 � Z I I _ I I I I _ I � I � - I � c G c G I 0 0 0 0 0 0 I I I 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-15: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 034+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. OS6 006 OS8 008 OSL �I�L v 059 °LL' v c 009 m OSS v U c OOS 0 OSti O OOti OS£ 00£ OSZ ooz osi July 2018 A-16 Olsen associates, inc. 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z ooi'z 000'z 006'� 008'� OOL'� .-. v 009'� v OOs'� •v OOti'� m oo£'i v ooz'i ooi'i v 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 OOs OOti 00£ ooz ooi I I � � , , I � � , 1 , I I � � � I I I � I I I � � j, 7/' I � I � I / ; � I I I � � � � I � ,,� 1 ' I � I' 1 I � ' / I � ,/ I � �,' I � ' I I � � � �� I � � , I � /,, I � I � //,, I I I � 1 � � :_, / I I , I I �� �! , I I I I y%.' ��� � I I I/ , I , I ' , / G �q � � I � 1 � I � �� r C � C O .. O �� _ �� I I 1 � i � -- '° '= v _ � o o y .. � .. 'I I/ I I � a• o— o a �� o y o o. � a N g c� o c� / /I i o a o 0 0 ��'. a Y L I I N N U u I I O O N � F j a O d v v N a a a N I I aN'+ C O � � � I I I I I o a ,a-i � ,�-� a� N� ON I I ei N O N .-I � N m O� N � c�-1 9 � a W E "' E N E� O � O � I I I I > > — > O T j T � 10 (0 Z Q Z Q Z O � Z I I I � I ' � ' I �� �' - l =3 ;�� iil��il 0 0 0 0 0 0 � � � � 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-16: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 036+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OS6 006 OS8 oos OSL �I�L v Os9 °LL' v c 009 m oss oos 0 Osti 0 OOti Os£ 00£ OSZ OOZ osi July 2018 A-17 Olsen associates, inc. 000000000 N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� oo8'i OOL'� .-. v 009'� v 005'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� ooz'i ooi'i v 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ Ooz ooi I I , I I I I I I ' � , I I I I I I I I I I I ,� I I I I , � / ' ,� t i I I I I I I , . � // / I I � /' I I � �' I I I ' I I � . -,� � / I I , !/ I I � I I , � ,, ////"' I I I I I I I � / I I , ♦' 1 I I ' � / ' I / I I � 1 ,� / I I �� I I I I , '� I I - I • I I , I ., I I I I I I I , I I I , I I/ I I I,� I o 0 1 �� ,� ,� �'i I' _'v �'_ I _� O O aL-• Ur .. � n � m o ~ o G� s`+ � U G U I I .--I c v l7 d (7 I' 1 1 1 o o � � z~'. � I I I I I .�-I �+ O p H 'j 1 p d I - a Y Y � Y Y � C � C p � p I I �'/ r / I I � � � � � � � O O � 00 O O � NO � L N � N � I I I I Z Q Z O � Z � I I I I ' I � ' I I I I � - -��� � ;;� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � I I I I (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-17: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 038+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OS6 006 OS8 008 OSL v 059 °LL' v c 009 m OSS oos 0 OSti 0 OOti OS£ 00£ OSZ Ooz osi July 2018 A-18 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 , , (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z •v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � v 006 N 0 008 OOL 009'' 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 I I I I I I I I % ., , I I � � I I I I � `� Y ,^� I I / ; `' I I � � /' I! � ' ' i I I � , I I � I / • I I I � I ♦ I _ �� I I � � // I I I � r 1/� I I � I I I ♦ w// I' I I I � I 1 . �,• ,� I I , , I I� , , i ' �� � � ,� I I / p I , II I I I I I ,� I , I �I I % 1' I Ili Il I I � l ;► � �- ���• �� - II I +I 1 I C C � C � � � �� _ �� _, I I I I I I I m C � L U Y O � ++ N � m m �_' c ~ c i m o .. o o. � a � N � c� o t� /� � I � I/ I o a o 0 0 ��'. a Y I/ I - N N U u L •I I o .-I o � F j a o a N O N O d r y Y � L a d C I I C O O N O 1 I I I o a ,a-, � ,�-, a� N� O I I � N O N .�-I � N n0VI `y � N O N N I� N 00 a « a � a � a � � � tOV � � NO � ry � I I J � � > > — > O T j T � 10 A z° a' z° ¢ z° o" � z° � I I I I I I� �� � , I I I � � _ = 3 I � g g I I I I 1 1 I 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� , , , 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-18: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 039+60, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oos OSL OOL 059 009 C��7 v 005 °LL' v c OSti m OOti OS£ 0 00£ O OSZ OOZ OSZ �� L OS 0 July 2018 A-19 Olsen associates, inc. i �, �� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 ooz'z ooi'z 000'z 006'� 008'i OOL'� 009'� OOs'� OOti'� .-. v 00£'� v OOZ'� •v OOT'� m 000'� v 006 � �_ 008 � v OOL N O 009 OOs OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- OOZ- I � � 1 �' I I � � ' ;I, � I � , I `, I I I � � � i ,��1 I � . ,. I � � / ; � �, �, I � :'� ,I I 1 I I I I I � I � , , I / ,� I I ,', / I I I , I , � � it , I��' ( II Y ► ,I 1 r / / / I ,�, I ►� ' I / ' I ' I I ,� I / � �,� I ,� I u ,� I � I 1 I �, I I , � � ,�� I I � , 4 �, ' -' I 11 I M •I ■■ I I ,I I I '1 I I I I ' I C O I' I I O �'• O I I O � aL-+ �+ Ur �+ to n � io O ~ O n o g u o u / I I I ti c v l7 0_ l7 0 0 o c Y [V U O L I I I I O � H 1 O 1 I I = N d y+ y � a+ �' � �' � C d O O � O NO �. N C � p Yplf � „'� � N '^-I � e�-I � ON � d N � N I I I I I I I I I � — � O R y R z a z o� z� I I I I � I I 1 ' I I I = I 3 I � � g g I I I 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0� � � I 1 (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-19: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 041+50, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) Os9 009 OSs oos Osti OOti v Os8 v c 00£ m OSZ a� OOZ N 0 OST OOT Os O Os ��Z- OST- July 2018 A-20 Olsen associates, inc. 1 1' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� OOS'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v 008 N 0 OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- � I , '� � f I � � I I/ 1 I I , , 'p I I ' I � i '� \ I � - I �' , I I � r � � ' ,i � / / � ;�� - I 1 I �, , ♦, i 1 I / 1 I � / ,�I , I I / ' � 1 I I , I � � I I ' '� I � � � � � �, I � � � / I\ �I I I i / - �' I I j I , ' I I I t � I ' � I � I - �I I .r I ' I � I •I � I • I I , I , I ' ' I' 1' 0 1 � I �_� O - _ems ��` o s N� I I ... _ .. I � I o 0 6 �^ n li I 0 C W l7 a V' 0 a p p V C H ,� F� u" a N N � I I �� e a }~', 2 t� I/ I I d aN'+ i Y 6 a o V o a ' / I I I O 0� 0 �0 0'0 0 0 N O N ,,,, N O� N M a N � "'I a N� L I I e�i O W O O fV I I I I I > m> > O > j Z o i i i 1 a' z° a z° i ..I.. I I I I� 1 1 s, . g g I I u� o �n o �n o �n � � � � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 � I Figure A-20: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 043+47, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OOL 0S9 009 OSS OOS OSti v OOti v c OS£ m 00£ a� OSZ N 0 ooz OST OOT OS 0 OS- OOZ- July 2018 A-21 Olsen associates, inc. f A O O O O O O O O O N r-I r-I N (h � u1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'z 006'� oo8'i OOL'T 009'� 005'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v 008 N O OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT � I I I I ' �,F I I I I I ' � I I l� � I I I I �� Y. I f I ' , I I t �'� � I , I \� ' ,� I ,,,�j� , I • , I I ' ' I � •/ �, 1 � IF 1 � / I ., � 1 , � '' � i � I . I 11 /+ I I �j � I I �I I I � iii �I I LI 7 I , I /I I l` , �, n' • , I II I • I � II I ► I I I I I y � I ., ►I I I t � I' I ,, %� I I I, I ' I I I I I I 1 I 1 II II ' I ' I �� � N 0 0 N 3 �_ 0 4 s � I I I I I Q � � � V � V I � I = N c N � a H I� I I vt N U �+ L �+ .--I i+ 'C O � Y � per. O d N N Y o = L � L C C //I I I I I I � N ti N o ti � M y � y N 1� W 00 � N E � N � N I I I Z Q Z O � Z � I I I I � , I / I I I I � � / 3 3 I � � -� = g g I I 11 1 i11 O u1 O u1 O u'1 r-I r-I I c-i r-I (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-21: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 044+25, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OOL 059 009 OSS 005 Osti v OOti v c OS£ m 00£ a� OSZ N 0 OOZ OST OOT OS 0 OS OOZ July 2018 A-22 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� oos'i OOL'T 009'� 005'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v L 008 N 0 OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 I I ' , I I 1'� j � �- I ' I �' /. I I , I I I I �� ' I, ., I 1 / �' I ► � I �r .�, � 1 �, , I ��,' � � � � :! I I ,��' 1 I I 1 ' 1 I r 11 I I I I�- i � I I I II I' � • ' 1 ►� ' � � / I/ � III � L •/i I I � I ' I , ' ' � ►� � 4 I � � � /' I' 1 � I 1 , ' ' I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I C � I � I � " f � o � & �O .. // I I t V. � 1O a � o~'. o I I 4 m a 0 N� V p V I I 0 a 0 N V m~ � F 0 N N o .. o o � � a° o a° N O N I I I I d � L O �+ a+ L H � N � � I I I O a N�� a I I I ry rv� ry to w o o ..+ m o ,� o N ei N I I d d p L �� E E N E� ry E� I I > m > _ > ° > > ? I I I Z Q Z Q Z O� Z� I I I I I I' 1 I I I li�i��- 3 '� = g g III111� �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-22: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 045+07, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OOL 059 009 OSS 005 OSti +� v OOti v c OS£ m 00£ a� OSZ N 0 L OOZ OST OOT OS 0 OS OOZ- July 2018 A-23 Olsen associates, inc. f` 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N � � N m � u'1 l0 I I I I I I (dn9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� oos'i v OOti'T v oo�'i .v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v 008 N O OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- ' I i I� � / `r 1 ' ' � `� f� / � � ,' � I a` �� � ' I �� •I � ,- �� � > I '' ' I 1 ' I - 1 � �� ,' � � I I I ,� '' I � I I ;;�,,', I I I ' 1 , I I I 1 I , ' �1 ' I � ' 1 ' d :/ I 'I 1' I I � �' � �' I I I I 'I ' I I I I I I' ` I /I I / I I ` I I `I I � I , �I ' I / I I ,.-, __ 0 C ` C I I I' �/ I 3 N � u — n. o � .r ,� `° � �/� ' ' '" io 0 0 n� Y� u o u � I ' I ' 'c o o c � �' N V 'o .. t I I � �, � .i O c O O O i+ = d O d N L O _ � � Y d I I I ' I ' C C � � � d � � N �, N C � N M m o 0 I I I I Z Q� Z O � Z ! I I I � ' I I = 3 I � � I � ��� g g I I I I I I u� o �n o �n o �n � � � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-23 Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 046+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OOL 059 009 OSS 005 OSti v OOti v c OS£ m 00£ a� OSZ N 0 OOZ OST OOT OS OS OOZ- July 2018 A-24 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� 005'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v U 000'� � to 006 � v L 008 N OOL � 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 0� I i( I I �I � ' I � �' , 1 / i �i f� .. I y �� � % X � � I, I ., I I I I / I I I I J ' '/ / I I � I I , I I / I 1 I ' I I � , I / �• I I I II Il I I I 1' / I II I I, I I I I I I I I I I \ I I ' I I I' I � �I I �I I � I I I I � I I I I \ I I \ I I I I / I / I I � I � �� I � I ... �T I � y ��I I 10 � 3 ii I �. �. u � Y � l7 � /� / I I � � y I 0— 0 0 � O O � V V I a a �^ a I o � W l7 l7 I 0 O. p N 0 H H I L N V « « 0 u O « � " I o O 6 F� a 0 a N O N � I � I d N d Y O« "' a '�' `o a« a a a o= � � a I I I I o o� o �o ao 0 0 N O N� N O �"I N M N � � � N � d W I O W I O O I W� W N W p p I T T I i o f Z a' z° a z° z° I I II I I I I,' I��I�1 ,�� 3 3 � � II��i1� �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-24: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 046+89, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OOL 059 009 OSS 005 OSti v OOti v c OS£ m 00£ a� V (0 OSZ N 0 L OOZ 4— OST OOT OS 0 OS OOZ- July 2018 A-25 Olsen associates, inc. — I I ooz'z I O � I , � d OOT'Z OI I � _ I � � I 000'Z I I I I I 2 O I , 006'� I Q I I , � 1 008'� I � I — I I r I '` OOL'� I I I 009'� I I I I I I �� 005'� I I ', I I �,' I I '/ , OOti�.-. I I I `� I �, � v 00£'� v I I I I I �� I � v OOZ'Z �v N OOT'� m I I I I � r I ,I I I I I I 000'� i a, U 006 � I I �, � �_ I I 008 � I I I OOL N � 009 � I _.I I n ,II I' ,I I I I Z 005 � I I I i O I.i1 a N OOti I I I I I V � m 00� I I I I N I � > OOZ ao OOT � � Z `} I I I I a \ � � o O I � I � W N a � OOZ- _ _ _(v�2 I I I � I Z OOZ- O O O O O N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 I I I I I I I I I I I r II ` / I I I I I I I I I I I 1 - II 1 / rs I I I I N , I �� I I I I � -1 , � r I I I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I I � � ., I ' .' -, I I I I t I '' I I I I I I I I I I I I I ♦ I , I I �, I I N � I I�1 I I , y I I � , ,ll I \ I,, � �. R I i I � � I , I I � � , I I a u ° c � c O Y O �; � d i u° � �o o~ o ' , � � I � n I I I I i I I Y � U Y U O � � n0. � u � t � I I � I I I I I � ` a ci a° Y = L �; L I I O :, � d c p �o 0o a o N C N M I I I ,, I I I � N � � � £ � O �: O ° I 11 I I I > > > > z° O � z° � I I I I I ' ' I I I ' ' ' 3 � ' 3 � � � � I I 1 �n O u'1 O ul O u1 r-I r-I I r-I r-I (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-25: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 049+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. ooi'i O50'� 000'� 056 006 ��:� v 008 v c OSL m ;� OOL v V c 059 0 v 009 N OSS 005 OSti OOti OS� 00� �•. July 2018 A-26 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z ooi'i I C I 1 , ooz'z 0 �� ; p � _ O OSO'� I � 11 T OO I•'Z N �` QI � V � 1 o Q g', s; �. RI � .., I �, 1 `� 000'Z tn�' fl'_ � � .� p �. t+ O � � I 1 I � 000'� I I , 1 �� � � 61 C7 c. C7 N [ A `� S_ � 006'� Lf1 �� a� a d � y o �_, n. = 1 �� �> o a vl I I I � �� ;v' � a �= �: ar � 056 I I �I � 1 O T OOO' I. a.. c a.� _, v, � Ins a �� I`, � ti� � �� � O� NI � O� NI lLl IX1 I �1 O N O I �� OOL'� a' �', �' �, o N — �„ � �', �' �I � � SI n! C; � v � � 4> V � � ON > I i I 006 � 009'Z O� z' d a O z u RI cl �. C �_ I 1 ' - I '� 058 OOS'� +-� i � ; � ' � �� t � +-1 v OOti'T v I I � I � 1 1 I I - I I � 008 v v I� '• / 00£'� 'v 'v ' � � 1 I OSL � � � � ' �• OOZ'� m � m � I l' OOT'� � � � I , OOL 1t I � V I 000'� � P�_ I, T�� N � � � 059 � �_ ' � 'S� � / _ 006 0 � o v L � I / / v >✓ 008 N I � 009 N � I � O � � � / O OOL � ��j,� � � � OSS 009 � I OOS � � � i OOS 4 � � � � I OOti ',� • 1 � OSti 00� � � � � I • I I 1 I ' OOZ OOti I� � OOT � 9 � OS� 0 1 � 3 13 � • C= L CJC L OOT 00� �n � L!1 � l!1 � �n N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 Figure A-26: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 050+50, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-27 Olsen associates, inc. G 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z ooz'z ooi'z 000'z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� OOs'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � 006 � v 008 N O OOL 009` OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- I I I I I I I I 1 - '• 1 1 I I I I I I I 1 I I 1 1 I I I . I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I 1 I ,I ' 1 I 1 I �, I I , I I I .' , ' I I , I I I I I I I I I / / , 1 �. � -� I I I I I I 1I � . I I � r I I I I I , I I I I , 11 I I I I I I, , 1 I � I II ' I I 1 I I � I I, , y , I 1 ' �' r I ,� I � I , � � I � �_ �� / � I I �-� �_, : v a' -; o C: � 1 � ' I 1 � I I O L +'" c� +' 1 I I � � U U C � �. n' � U i +" S: +-' _ 1 I I I I 1 � 1 �1 I I I I � � a. ci a .. _ ' L g: L I O .. c. d' c =oa=-o r I I I I I ��.��;� � Ip W� CI O N O �i N M I I I I N N r. QI W SCI c'li SI e'I > $ �. °: %. I I fp (0 z o � z: � I I I _ I I I I I I I I 1 1 I 1 1 1 I 3 I 3 1 i l l l 1; � g 11 1 �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-27: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 051+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. ooi'i oso'i 000'i Os6 006 ��:j v 008 v c OSL m ;� OOL v U c Os9 0 v 009 N Oss OOS Osti oo� OS£ 00£ �•. July 2018 A-28 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� ooS'i v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v 008 N O OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- I I r I � i 1 � �4 , � I I, � i I I , , I I I , , I ��,' �� r I I, I I I' ' I ^ � I I, ' //I 1 1 I I i1 � 1 .I� � � I I - / I I : h + � � 1 I . I ♦I I. / I I , 'I ., I l� ��� I � I I / / `�� � S I I I� �� � I II 1 t, I 1 I I I i 1 I I I I I / I ' I I � I I I�� I I �' ' i a o � � I I �Y O �av�� 0 I I ,-. .-, O L«�« 6 m � y C 1 I I I I vqi —� a m a O�� V U '^ a I I ,� o � � y l7 l7 p a p N 0 H H L O � V � « « o 0 6 Y� a° o N O N I I I I I I a==+ L� L � N d Y 0 « a« a« a` a a o= o O� N o a ti � � I I N N� �N ti� N M O O a N L � L N •i L rl W I I I I N O O �M > > > p T j T � I I ? a' z° a z° o i i i i II�'II� I l- �`1� = 3 � i� g g IIIIII� u� o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-28: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 052+64, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v OSti °LL' v c OOti m OS� v c 00� 0 OSZ O OOZ OST �� L OS OS - July 2018 A-29 Olsen associates, inc. — oo�'z I I I ` I ' I O OOZ'Z OI I I � � I I OOT'Z I O I I - - 000'Z I Q I I , I � 006'� � — I I I I 008'� �� I OOL'� I I I I 009'� I I I , — 005'� .-. I I � v OOti'T �� I I I I v 00£'Z �v I I I I N OOZ'� m I I I I ' ' I OOT'� I I I I I T V 000' b � � to I I I I � �\ I I 006 � I I I I % , I L% , 008 N ,� I I I, '� o OOL �, I I I,/ �� O �.ii 009 I I �I 1 � �' N ('' OOS I' i 'I � ,I � I V � w J m OOti 1 I �� I I (� � > 008 ao OOZ � � Z O I I O `/`} �y � 0o V � i I i W I T y� N � a 0 � I I I I Z OOT- I I ,, I I I I ,I I I I , , , I f , I I I "� I I I I I 'J I I , , I I, I I 1• ,, , , I I � 1 �I I I , I I I 11 - I I I � ,_ I I I I , I ,� ' �► I I I , I� �I ' I � f� I �\ ' � I I I � /L I I 'I I j � ' I I I I 1 1 � 1 , - I , I` I 1 I I I I I � I ' I I I I I I I I I I I 1 ' I I I I I I I 1 I a .0 � �r ,_ � Y � c C � ��'� U J I I I 1 O Y ++ � +� u C'. F' C 1 I I I ` N O �. O N � V' U a ` ~ � ~ A I I i a c o � I I a, a a a+ 3 �; = L'. L I I d e' C'. N C O O'. O N d �'. � p �o oar a o I I I I N G `I N M � N tii n � 1 I I I � � E: �N � �' � 'o Y, m� 'ci z O � z � ' ' . �, 'r I I , I I I I I I ' ' I � ♦I � = 3 � � 1 1 I � g I O O O O O �n O u'1 O ul O u1 N r-I r-I N r-I r-I I r-I r-I (4n91V-�aa�) uo�enal3 (dn91V-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-29: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 054+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v OSti °LL' v c OOti m OS� V C f6 00� 0 0 osz OOZ OST OOZ OS 0 OS - July 2018 A-30 Olsen associates, inc. I 3 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z7 OOT'Z 000'z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� OOS'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v 008 N O OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOZ CJ 0 ` OOT- I � � � I r�i �II - 1 p � c 3 '_ � 'Y I I , ��� �° t'i '"��'. c ` o o a� a� .. � � o � o a I I � o a o 0 o m .~'. G o Y�� � y I I �� .-I O � Y a O a � N � « O « � at+ d c a o o�° o d° .�. � � � � � � I I � , JL N �"� N "� N� �"� � N M N � � � N � � � E E N E�� E N � I I �/ I f Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � I, ll / I � I �� � I � � r.l I ,r� I , ' I I , - ' '� � /I ��, . I / I � I/ - r 1 I� -, -/, , I i/ II ,♦ I ' � ;,'i' >, I 1 �` / I � 11 ,, ,, � ♦ � . /✓ � I I I � I // I I I I I 1 � � � � � I I I I I I � � I I I I I y� � � � I I I I • = I I I I I I • , , , - I 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-30: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 056+56, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v OSti °LL' v c OOti m OS� v c 00� 0 OSZ O OOZ OST OOT OS 0 OS - July 2018 A-31 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOZ'(7. OOO'Z O0Q6'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v OO5'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � L 006 N 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 I I � , I ' � �,� / 0 o L' � 2 � I /f.I � , vf0i v�0i � t'i .. � c a� a� •��• � � o v a I I I / j/ � ,, �i o n o 0 0�� H u .. t 1 o Y „ L O 1 N N ~ I „ I O O � O „' _ « � N a d � a n I /�� � c o o I o d° .�. � � � � � � lD � N M N N "� I i �"� NO N O O1 � W N I� N 00 d Y d '-I L .--I � •-I E E N E�� E N I 7 1 ` I F O �. �) Z Q Z Q 2 O � Z � I �' / I i i ; � _ �i� / / I I 1 / I 1 1 I I /� I� / I I ' 1 / � • I / I I 1 II , � � I I � � � I �1 I � 1� - /I % I , I �/ I� , I � I '' 1 ��� � I � � � I I 1 1 �� I I �� I', I I , 11 I I I I ' �' I � � � I I I I ,, ,I � 1 � � � � I I I I � � � I I I � � � I I I \ � I � = I 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-31: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 060+51, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 C��7 v 005 °LL' v c OSti m OOti v c OS£ 0 L 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OST 00� OS 0 July 2018 A-32 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'(7. OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� oos'i OOL'� .-. v 009'� v 005'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � �_ OOT'� � v 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 008 OOZ OOT I o I , p r � _ � � I �r� I I ' � 0 O L � U � d ii r � � c v�i v�i a� a� •��• � � o v a I �' o a o 0 0�� H u .. t ,� o Y „ NO N � Y � � O � I // W N W G = Y � � I ' , Y « d C L G CO � � O d N � ti � � � � N N N M I I / � � � ■ • „'� "� NO '-I � N � � � N � � 0�0 N I I �� � E E E�� E N > o�q > _ > O > I m � Z Q Z Q 2 O � Z � I �/ i � � I I � � I I � � I 1 I 1, I /, ,% I � I ', I � � / I / '•�, � � ��, / ,�, ►� I �� i I • � I �I� i I I I , / 1 II III 1 � ly I I rl � � I � ;� I , I I , I I , / .' i � , ,, � �I �i :�� �. - � �. I I I I I � I � � I ' I I I I N/� � � � I I I ,� � � � I I I � � I �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-32: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 065+50, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 078 008 OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v c OSS m 005 v c c� OSti 0 OOti 0 OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-33 Olsen associates, inc. �' 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z ooz'z 0o V'l7i 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 oos ooz oo£ ooz ooi 0 oI I � � 0 0 � I 0 � L � U � o ' I „1 v�i v�i d ii r � � c a� a� •��• � � $ � I I � / I �, 0 a o D o m~ a~ N li a+ L •+ ' 7� •-I Q � o .. s��� a o a N � o � ♦" I ' �♦ �• � d � a c o= o I i � c ° � � ti � � � � N •"� N "� N� •"� � N M I � � , I I � � I N O O1 � W N I� N 00 E E N£� o E N - > m > _ > � > I , m � Z Q Z Q 2 0 � Z � � I / ,, , I j I � � � � � ,� / I Ii � I I I 1 1 1 I � � I I I I y, / � I♦, / � /''♦ I �� � i I � r �. �I i /' ��,' i r I I �I � J_ ��i ��� � �� � I I ,' '� � • I, � , ��_ ' ✓ �%„ �I ' �♦ . .� � IX � .PI � _ I I I , I I I � I I u• ' I I I I .._ I I I I I I I I I .3.. .., .. ... .... � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-33: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 069+46, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oss 000 OSL OOL 059 v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 OS£ 0 00£ OSZ ooz osi ooi OS July 2018 A-34 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'7z OOZ'Z OOZ'7Z 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � 0 006 N �_ 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ � OOZ OOT 0 I O I „ � , N- C ` C oro �� �� I I �" 1 o � /' o � � � � � I N r � ii " r I ,� a� o��� � g � I ' oa'oo�a 0 � .. I �, �I O .-I O �O Y 0 H G = a O d « � Y I I I,' � , _ 1 N « C L � o N CO I 71( M � o N d° .�. N � "� � � � � � � � N M I / � y �"� O y �' � � N N� y � N � I� y 00 N � N I I I I , / O � O Q O �' T O T I I ,, _ I 1 Z Q Z Q Z O� Z� I C I / I � I �� � I I � I I �I I � I'I _ v � � 1 1 I a /� �� � � �. ; ,- � ' � i � � , I , 'I � ' I I , / I 1 l� ' I I '. II I r � / � I I ,'I � I /� ' I ,' � ��i� � I I - ' � �I � I I 1 I '1 �\ • I I I I I • , I i I � � � � I I I I I I , I I I ! I I I I I I , I � � � I I I � = I 3 . g .g . �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-34: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 073+39, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 C��7 v 005 °LL' v c OSti m OOti v c OS£ 0 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OST 00� OS 0 July 2018 A-35 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OO l.' li OOT'Z OOO'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v OO5'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'i 0 006 N 0 oos OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ , OOT 0 O U I � ; , ;) � O N O I I � I I � _ _ n O t r m m a+ _ O i+ O oa m d� � U � U I � O N- 0 O O � H H I ono o���a oa N O N L N O "' 2 t � r � t � ♦� a �+ a a �' C N C I / �, M N N N � � N O ~O `�.r O / „ � a N a rl 4 N .^-� a � � N � N � � O � O o ' I I I I i / Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � I I i �� � i I /1� � I ' , 1� ' '�� r I I ' I' I i A/ , I I I '� i 'I r - � I II / �; �, i � / '' � � j ,� I/ I i I• - ��. , I I I ,I I I � I �'' � i f %/I I _'- Y I I I � I � � � � � I I I I I I I I I I I I i I I I .. I ... .._ I .3.. .... .., i i �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-35: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 076+37, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v c OSti m OOti OS£ 0 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OST OOZ OS 0 July 2018 A-36 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOZ'(7. 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � �_ 000'� � v 006 N O 008 OOL 009 ooS oo� 00£ OOZ � OOT 0 O I I � 1 , 1 I � I 0 o I r ,, I ooy � d ii r O r c I f 1 v�i v�i ` O a� a� •• g u o v a� I /� o n o 0 0�� .o'^- u .. t I � Y � o .ti o o f � a o a° N O N y W t = L � L I I � ` ' N G '� d o a° O° � � � I I 1� o d° .�. � � � N �"� N "� NO lD � N M /I� v I � I I i _ y O y � y N I� y 00 E E N £�� E N Z Q Z Q 2 O � Z � I �' I � � ' I I I I I ♦ I ' I' I � � - I I � � � � I � ��� I� I� I I I 1 1 I , 1 I , ' � '' � � I I / i♦ I �� I � ,' ' r � , I I ,' , I I I . , I � /, I r I , I, �, ; � r' ,� ,, I I , I /' I 1 I I I I � r I/ , I � � ,I I ,j� rI � I ,I � I I �, I � � , I I I _ I I y� I I I I N � � � I I I / I I I I I � I = I 3 i � �r, o �n o �n o �r, � � � � � Figure A-36: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 084+16, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) os8 008 OSL OOL 059 IIIj:� v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 OS£ O 00£ OSZ ooz OSZ OOZ OS July 2018 A-37 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'Z 0o V'li 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� ... v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � 0 006 N 008 O OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 _ o I , -, I _�_ ono I I ,.' ,./ _ a��y�= '�_'�o I ,, - � s:. s 80 $� ���d� I ,. i � f � U S L a+ L � ' '/' I '1 , 1 Y 6 1 Y y � Y d�� a� �� � �• ' � o o—��o��oo I �•� I _ a N a N a�� a� vYi E N � a N� N ', I ,, _ r ' z ¢ z ¢ z O � z � , 1 / � I � � � � � �' � � I � � � � - > � � � �' � � I I 1 1 �, •+ � � � 1 � I �/ ��� I �I ' � 1 l I '� I i �, I � •I � I I � �� / �� ��_I J � �I / .� I � (I I / �' I� I I � ' I �� I I� I I � I �� � 1, r 1, � , I it i� I I � ✓ I �I I I � � I � I I I ,► � 1 � I I I I I I I I I .... .. ..I.. .�.. .... ..., = 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-37: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 088+23, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v c OSti m v c OS£ 0 0 00£ O OSZ OOZ OST OOZ OS 0 July 2018 A-38 Olsen associates, inc. i 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOZ'(7. 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � 006 N 0 oos OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ � OOT 0 0 _ ~ = I I I I ' �" I _ oro _ .� � �� � W I i I I O� � U � O L Y � d ii r � c 1 1 ' I v�i v�i r a� a� •��• � � o � � a~ I � I � ', o n o 0 o m~ � a+ L I �� ' I / 0 � .-I O 0 Y a O a N O N � � � G = « � N ♦ ► I I ., � I I � at+ V " d C L G CO � G � � � d V ON N � N � N M I I I' / , � I O O N � � � N � � 0�0 E E N E�� E N > o�q > '- > O > I I I. I I, I � , / � � , m � z° a' z° a z° o � z° � � I � � I �l� � I � I��� � � I I i� � I • I' � i� I I I 1 1 � � i / I / ; � , �I � I , / I , �I� r� I � Z !�; � � P ��� �:' �� �I� ��� ♦� t /� i � � / I I / / I � I ,� / I � I I ,� � � I � ,� ' / \1 A ��' r � � �, }% I � I Si I � I � I I S/� I / I I � � I I I I I I I I I I I I I �. I �i I I 1 � = � I I 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-38: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 092+15, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) os8 008 OSL OOL 059 IIIj:� v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 OS£ 0 oo£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ os July 2018 A-39 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOZ'(7. 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � v 006 N O 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ �' OOT 0 O I I I , - I p� I , / I I I / 0 G L � U � � N N � t'i r � c O I I ` O a� a 0 .. � O c O a~ I / / 1 � � o n 0 0 o m~ u .. t I �/ o Y „ O H a O a I .-I 0 N O N a � W = L L , I ; y N t G � . I I / V " d C L G CO � G I � I d � O � � ON N � N lD � N M I C / , I \ „'� N � � � N � � 0�0 E E N E�� E N T � _ 17 I / � � I I o � o n o �' a n O Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � I '' I I �' ' 1 I � I��� I I / I I I I � � � I I/� � � / I I 11 1 II I / , /I `/ ' I • I I ■ I i I ' I �r, / � I �, ��/{ � / I , �./ ,f /I 1 II �/jj I � I/ � I I II , � I � � /I ' I � �' � � I ' ; �� i�i � ' '` ' 1 I � �' I �' '/\ I I I i i �I Il � I � I I I II , I I q � II h I I � � I � � � � I I I , I I I I I I \ ' 1 N / r �, . I I . � �� = 3 `. � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-39: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 097+10, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) os8 008 OSL OOL 059 IIIj:� v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 OS£ O 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ 00� OS July 2018 A-40 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z 0o V'l7i 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v OOs'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � �_ 000'� � v 006 N oos 0 OOL 009 OOs OOti 00£ OOZ �' OOT v 0 p � I I I � 3 � � I I f0 f0 � ii L N H c y O 1 ` a+ O a� a� •• g u o v a� I i � o n o 0 0�� N !..) a+ L �+ I / �y � � O O ti 1 I I .-I O � Y � � N � L O L � L I / 4 I V" d C L G O .N.. O I � I O d N � ti���� N N "� � � N M I I I , �"� N� N O O1 � W N I� N 00 E E N £�� E �' I I I a� v_ d O T a N / �� I z a z a z o� z i I�' �� l I � I�� � I �l - i � 1� Ili �� I � I ,, I I � 1 1 1 I I 'I+ ►, • � , I I♦ I I, I I I /, I I /I ,I,/ r • / ,� I �� I / / I ,� � �� -I a' I 'II J� ., ' I � , ` ' � -I ' ,� I,/ �I I/� - , •- , ,�, ,�r I I 'I X ' �I / II / ' I , �I I I 1 � I � ' �� I � ,I ii � I /, I � I I �, / I � � � � � ' I I I I I +� I / = 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �r, � � � � � Figure A-40: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 102+08, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 Os8 OOV OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v c OSs m OOs v C co Osti �_ OOti 0 os£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-41 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'7Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v OOs'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� 41 OOT'� � 000'� � v L 006 N 008 � OOL 009 OOs OOti 00£ OOZ ♦/ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 0 I I 1 fi p � I I '� v�i v�i d ii r � � c ` O O I / , a� a� .. � � c � o n 0 0 o m~ a~ u .. t I I /� / � /� o Y „ o .ti o o f � a o a° N O N � � a N a O a O O .� O I I ' �/� / , / /� O d N � ti���� lD � N M N N "� I , I �"� NO N O O1 � W N I� N 00 E E N £�� E N > o�q > '- > O m > � Z Q Z Q 2 O � Z � I /' ' r I I �� i � _ ��' I I 1 ' � I I � � I I i � I� i / � l� � I � , l I I I 1 1 1 � / ' 1 I � ,I ' I I , , � I/� ;' �� � I I / I ' / � I ll I / I , '1 �t� P , ,' _ I / /� �y1J i JI � _ r - '� '`� I / I I I � � � r ,I / ' 1 I I �� I I ' [� �/ , � � I I � I /(I , �', I ' I I �/ � X� , I ..✓ I I I I 4' /, ■ � I I I 1' ,, I , I I I I I � � I � � � � I I I I I I 9 � ' /� �, � = 1 I 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �r, � � � � � Figure A-41: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 106+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 Os8 008 OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v c OSs m OOs os� �_ N L OOti 0 os£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-42 Olsen associates, inc. I I O I I OI I O I /' 1 I W � I I I ^ I v, I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .... .. r I �... I I I I I I ' I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .� 1 I � I /A / I I ' y�� 2 V Q W p. � N ,�' j�/ � I . -,' L i�a''y r I I I I I I I I I I � � � 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'7Z OOZ'(7. 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � v O 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ 00 s;,� OOT 0 I , � � oro I I I , ., �_ i' .� � .� c U , , � I I / O L � o � d ii r � � c v�i v�i ` O O a� a� .. � � o � ° a~ I I o n o 0 o m~ O a+ t I / Q « � N O N O Y O a O a a� v� s�=" •'' c� c Y Y I I � I 'yl � d � a 0 o v ° �n d i n g � N N N M I I � �� I � ."� "� NO '-I � y O y � y N I� y 00 W � W N N � N � ^' > oq > '- > O m > � I � I ,�, I I / J / Z Q Z Q 2 O � Z � I ,, I i I 1 ' � I ' � I� ��, � / l i� l� �- .I �, � i I l � � i � � I� "� I � � 1 I ' �I ' '' � � .� I I • ;i /I� '� ' '�j /I , I� ,I� ` I' � d / 1 �I I I , �I �� ��,., , / I , Y t' /, � I ' I � I,1/ � I I r� I I �I�/ I I �'� ,I ' I i , , � �„ i- i ' � i � i I 1 _s I� I I I I I I � I I I I 1 I I I I � = I 3 � � u� o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-42: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station ll 0+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 058 008 OSL OOL r�� v 009 °LL' v c OSS m OOS v c f6 OSti �_ N O OOti 0 OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OS� 00� July 2018 A-43 Olsen associates, inc. oos'z OOti'Z oo�'7z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'T OOL'� .-. v 009'� v oos'i .v oo�'i m oo�'i v ooz'i ooi'i L 000'� N 006 � 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 008 OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 o I / I fi p � I / 1. C j U � I / I /. y. O L a� a� .. � u o v o a~ I •/I � / o n 0 0 o m~ u .. t o I /I Y „ o .ti o o Y � a o a° g a x z i t / I , / / 1 Y a o a°�° I 1/ �l 0 o v �n � � � � / I j 0 a 0 o In o0 0 0 N �"� N "� N �. N / I 1 I / I , / 1 / .M.. N � � � N � � 0�0 G N O O N > O�q > > � T j > I /, // Z Q Z Q 2 0� Z� I I i I � � 1 I I I � 1 // _ l i I 1 1 ,y 1 II AA/ i I I � � I � '1 I' 1 I I II 1 1 I I ,, 1 11 i 1 ''1 1 I ' 11 1 I � 1I / / // , /y1 I , II' - / I , , I' � � ,, ;,�. �,� �'; . f `I I ' / ' I,- .A% � / /I '� _ i ,� I I , ,y I � I �� I � � I I � 1 �� I I I I �,`� I � � � I I I I � = I 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-43: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station ll4+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 058 008 OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v oss m oos os� 0 L OOti 0 OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OS� 00� July 2018 A-44 Olsen associates, inc. I I O I I OI I O � I I /' � W � I I I ^ I v, I I I I I I I 1 . . i � � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I . . . . . . 4 1 . . . I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I / , I I I I I I ;: - ♦fI ' I I ;11 � ; ,11 I� _� � I 1 ' ' 1 I I / V Q W O N ,� I I ,' � t I 1 � � �, .. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oos'z OOti'Z 007�'l, OOZ'Z ooi'z 000'Z 006'� 008'T OOL'� .-. v 009'� v 005'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v OOZ'� � �_ OOT'� � v 000'� N O 006 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00� OOZ OOT I ♦��. / o I I �' ` e a O o I ,' / / O n O O Y � � j U d O N. � C 01 (:� 6 l7 I I � 1 ' 0 O. 0 O O � H H t Q Y V � a+ O N 0 H � d O a I' I ♦ � 1 o ` O � O. " L � t I I / C d N� N�� ti� I � �� , N e-I N � N ti � N M N O W � N N 1� N 00 � N � ~ d ~ � � I I' I I 1 // N � � N � N / O > > 1 • ♦ , // Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � I 1 / I I � I 1 1 I �, 1 ,/ I I 1 1- /;11� 1 I ' 1 I � '' 11 / I I 1 1 �/ I , I 1/ / I , 1 1 I • I / , I 1 ♦ I � i 1 I I/ 1 1 /' ' 'I I I ,- I , y � J i I' 1 I �' 1 la I � _� 1 i .� 1 i ' • � � 1 /, • �' � � ly / I ' � � I � , ��/� 11� , I� I ' �� I ii ✓ I I I � ��/ I , I I I rs , I I I _` i I i , I I I I I I I I I I I I ,l � I ♦ /,' I I I I I I �♦ �/ 1 Iis I �♦.� ♦ I I I ' I I � .... _ I , I .... I ,3 ...... � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-44: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station ll 8+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 OS8 008 OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v c OSS m 005 v c OSti 0 OOti O OS£ 00£ OSZ ��Z �SZ OOZ July 2018 A-45 Olsen associates, inc. I I oI OI I � N M � I /' 1 I W � I I I ^ I v, I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .... I I I .... I I I .... .... I I I I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I .i I I ,,, �;►ii� I I ,� ; /I '/ /� ' ,� 1 .I � I I� I � / I � ,�I�y I = W . `Ow v, I I I I I . / I I � I I I I 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z 00 V'l, 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� � OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � v L 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ � OOT 0 I I �� - , / C C =� I I _ o o n 3 � O � O y � U I o 0 0 2� �~�' �° n a N I /� I� �� �� o ti v t7 a C7 O. � N V � H H V L a+ I �/ � l 0 � O .�-I O � Y � 1 O 1 I I I v � � s O 2 z O t I ./ �, / 1 6 � 6 O � N CO I 1 I� � I O O � � N 1 � � � O 1 .-I O 0 � p M N I / / , v O G W O N ti N N I� N 00 � Y L � e-I � �.'� E E N E a N £ N I I I / > e�p > '- > O T j T I / 2 Q Z Q Z O � Z � 1,/� / / I i 1 � '� � /! I I I I 1 1 � �� � 1 � I /I - / I ' / , r I / ,' I � � - I I I_ ,� ' ," � � I i' , I 1 I � I � , ` I / I I � F I I I I I i /�, /� I � � / I / i 1 �/ �/I} 1 / , I I � I �i I � � ,� I I I I � I I � � � I� � I � I I � I � I I 'I ./' I I �� I I I � I I I I I I = 3 �� g � ������������ �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-45: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 122+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 058 OOV OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v c OSS m 005 v c c� OSti 0 L OOti O OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOT July 2018 A-46 Olsen associates, inc. f 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOZ'7Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� ... v 005'T v OOti'Z "v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 I a it �� � 0 0 Y � Y •, / - - Y � � '� 1 a'-' � a n n� � � U V I I p N 0 ry U « Y , / u Y �' � .�i ' - ����o o � a� d / o N 6 M I � ' � � �/ a` � a` a " c ry c / / �N � ' / N �, N N N M p ry ,.., N 1 1 a N a a N a � E� E N E a N E N I � 1 >m-">� a z o i i /"� � �/ z° a' z° z° /' � / I � I I� I I I I, � , I I I� �- � � I � I" / II I� t /" I ' I, i' r +y / III 1 I I I I � I I ' I " I �/ /I I I� I 1 /� I► i,;l j � _ / f �/ I I i jl I I I /�. ", / , I , I I I I,� . I /I I I / I I I I � I I I � � / I � I I I I r � all ,l y � I I I I I i i I � i i . �. . I I I I I I I i i . � I = 3 � � � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � (d/�9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-46: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 126+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oss 008 OSL OOL 059 v OSS °LL' v c 005 m v c OOti 0 OS£ O 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ OS July 2018 A-47 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I M O I M M I /' � � W � I I I ^ I v, I I I I I I ' I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I /I I ' I I I I I I I I ,,; 1 / I , f � I ,l/� 1 � � l � y /I � 1 � I, �' � / I I� . . . � �, / I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I . . . I 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� 009'� .-. (` v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � �_ 000'� � v 0 006 N 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 I I ,t , I I ,,, I I • . � I I I 1 I • � I ' / I I / ,' / 1 I I � I � / I I � � I � '', I �� � � � I I ' /I � I ///AAs / I , •,�� � / I I / I� � I� •, I � I , ' 'I I .I y � 1I I � J •, I r r� ;' Il'�r �' r I I I ' r' I IJ I I ' I � �' � I I� � I I I ,1 q II I I 1 ♦ ,� � , I �1 I1 I , / ,{, I _,'f t I I I I I , I I I I� I I �I I I I I ' / ! I / I I I I r 1 I I _ 0 -_- a _ ono � _ 3 0 � / I I �, �I � 1 I I I I — rv' �� H O-«� � V « V I I I Q O i N � F 6~ ry p� F � i o f y o b " S r� t I I I I I I I N Y o ' « N « d. « d « I I I o a ti� h d� n� N V N� N�� N M O N ON n � E E N E °1 N E H • I• • • i I I I I z° ¢' z° ¢ z° o � z° i I I 'I��'� I I I i� I''_ k = 3 � � III�11� �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-47: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 130+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 OSS ('' v 005 � v c OSti m v c OS£ 0 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OJ V OOZ OS 0 July 2018 A-48 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I M � I I m QI I ^ I v, I I I I I I ' I , / �� 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 4� l► y '; � I� ' I,' / 1 I � I, I I I �1 �� ��� I I I I � I 1 I I I I I I I I I 1 I N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'Z ooi'z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'� 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� OOZ'� v U OOT'� � 000'� � L 006 N �_ 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 I I ; I I I I �„ I I �, I I I I , I •, ; , , ,1 �, / � I �I 1 � I IJ I I I I I 'I I I I I • I I � - ,, � / I I / I I I' / �I ' �I / I I y I� , / ' a; �� I � y . I i �� � I I I I I � I ♦ I / I I I r I / '� ' � �� �' � � ' � � t• •, � I�, I 1 , � I •, � � � I II � , I I I I I, r < I/ I JI ,J I I /I I I I I I I I I I I � I � I I I I = o / � r 1 I o 0 0 � = �., m .3 0 :. N U � ,, I I I O m" � �� �O a~'+ CO i I I I a N �6� N' � � � � "ss -~ � L 0 o a�� a o a I I � o � « � « i I I « ._'. N O 6 O a �+ N 6 O N O O IO I I I $ a a y, �� N f "'" rv� N l0 ND N M � ry a ry a N a ^ a� E E E E N vo I .L.. � I� I � I o > >, > oD > � > > 2 Q Z Q 2 0� 2� I I I � , I I I I i� I',_ l l i l � � L.(i O L!1 O l!1 O lf1 � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-48: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 134+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v OOS LL v c OSti m OOti v V c c� OS£ 0 L 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OSZ 0o L OS O July 2018 A-49 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v oo�'i m ooz'i v OOT'� � 000'� � 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ ooz r OOT a 0 o ,� �. � I �.' 0 0 � ��♦ � � / ��v =�� � o = = aY � � Y � � '� •ii � � o�oo��� � a'� a�� � •; , �� � � o�000 v�a� Y t Y � � � / 0 o�oo��dod i 1 a�aay� � �i 0 o a�� a��� o�o�o��om I� � / � 1 a � a � a o � a � 0 v � v^'v�� v� � T 1 1 ' � �' 'f � Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � � ', '� / I � l i I I I I � � � �� � I � � � �` � I I I I I I ' �� � �� i � � �; �� � � /� � � K �" �' l� 1 ., ' � 1 / �, . , ,, , / ' I� ��.,/ J .; ' � ' A � /� � �� �� � i � ;, if ,, , �� 1' � � � /, i � y I ,�, 'i I ' I 1 1 _ .... � ,3 ..... �� .... �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-49: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 138+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) os8 008 OSL OOL 059 C�I��'� v OSS °LL' v c oos m os� v c OOti 0 OS� 0 oo� OSZ OOZ OSZ ooi OS July 2018 A-50 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z 00£'Z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� 006 N 008 0 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ � OOZ OOT 0 �i i "' � � p / / / '� - - a .. �Y � � I y l ` a� g o N� �� � � i l �� i- _ "Y Y u u O ry '�y � l U L � s a Y = � Y� z a a Y ry Y a a o—a �—� �.� �/�i / O 6 � .�-i .ni � ' ` , / O � O O O � N M O /`� ;� � a g a� a�� a� E E � E � � E � / > m > •- > � � > � z ¢' z a z o� z� / � ±- � � l l / i l,� �' I I � � � - - � I ' � � 1 1 � i �� �, � � �/ �, .� ., � � �, , `� �i �' � �� � / / � �; r / - ,� , � � ,� i r ,, / �, � ��� /, � i� .�i �/, � / �/ r � �/ �I � .I i 1 � yy i/� �� I I I .. ... ..3 .... .., 3 i i �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-50: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 142+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 058 008 OSL OOL 059 v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c oo� 0 OS£ 0 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ OS July 2018 A-51 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I M � I /' 1 W � I I I ^ I v , I I I I I I ' I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I r� I I I I ,�I I I �► / I / � I I r I r ,, /� �•I " -, ,' � ". / / `� �' 2 Q W H N I / I r I � I � ...,, „t I I � �,.. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOT'Z 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'� � 0 006 N 0 Oos OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ � OOZ OOT 0 I r �i I I / , • _�_ o .� o , � -�- o � 3 � O « L a`+ V. a`+ a z�� C I I � / / /rr / I 6 N O. � Y � (./ � U I I r / p 0. p o 0 c N o r Y � 0 o u i o a I r g Y I I % d Y 1 0 1 1 � N � I ,, ' / G d „ay � ti �. � � � o I ' - o "' o o �O Oy0 O N N `� N N M O O � ON � � � N N a � 0 .I I ■ 1 W � N N N � N W N I• , I Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � � I�'I /I .ry- � - I �[ i; 'n�r I I I I 1 1 � I I �' 1r I I �' I / I I /� I� ` . , ,,L.I ./'/ / I I I , �Ir '' i / / = / 1 7 I� / , / // �� /�� / i ,� '� ' ,, ' . I I I = �i �I II .` I \ /� I � I ►` r rr, I I �� , I , I �r I / I I I /� r I ' I I � I I I I r p � � i � � ' � � I I I I I ' I ' I i I I I I . J . r . . . . I . . . i . . . . . . . . . � = 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-51: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 146+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oss oos OSL OOL 059 �I��:� v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 0 OS£ 0 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ �� L OS July 2018 A-52 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOT'Z 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � �_ 000'� � v 006 N O 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 I �I • , I I ' � / , I i o o � I __ _ r � O N � U � ° ° L � Y I I /j / ti N �' �.1 1+ C Y C � � O O V V I 1�/ � / o �- o 0 0 � � � U N I �� I ' , 0 ,N,'„ o .ti o o Y� a o a° N O N a � O 2 L L � � Y O i+ a 1 C � N 0 ' , I / d aN'+ C O N N � N � N M � � � N � "y � N .-I 9 � E E n E a N E N O >. I I , �� I ` / Z Q Z Q Z O � Z � I/ I I I i� � � / l i i ; � - I / I � ., I � I I � 1 1 I I, I I , I 1 I, I I I I ► , � I I / I � I ' Ir I �' ' ♦'�/ �/ I' "� /l,/ I � /I I, I . I I I' � II ` I I � I , I /� I I I I� / I II I I _� �, �� � I I I I I / �,', I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I / / I I I I • = I I • , , , I 3 � � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-52: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 150+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oss oos OSL OOL 059 IIIj:� v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 OS£ O 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ OS July 2018 A-53 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 005'Z 006 I OOti'Z �_ ► � C � � I i, i► 058 I i i� � � 00£,Z _ �� �, � �� _ � � � L o � o I ♦� / 7 OOZ'Z a o 1° n�� �- o o �� u .. c r c� .. I � n O 008 � OOT'Z o fV �O o .� o O N i� o� � :+y�Y i o a , I I �� / i .d.. ��"��-�= �' .d.. C d O ° O � f`V c0 � I , fy� OSL i 000'Z I �' � N � � N � � , _ i / 006� > Z Oq > a Z - > � a Z o� �' � Z� � OOL ,� I I I � � �� ►� 008'T I I � I I � � '�i I I � I � � � , � 1 059 I , OOL'� ,-. I I � i � I, I •, � v 009'� � I , / � � ► v 009 °LL' .. v � ,► /I , ►- v OOS'� •v . � OOti'� m , ,�� � OSS � m � � � � I � � ''►� � 00£ � � � � OOS ,� I 7 U � / , I CJ OSti .,,' � v o0i'� � o v L � /s � � L 000'� OOti N � � 0 � / � ► I I o 006 � ► 008 OS£ �, �. -, � i � ► I I I I OOL �► I 00£ �� I � I I 009 �/� , OSZ OOS � I � I I I OOti '� OOZ / I I i,. � � I 00� I � I I OSZ OOZ I = I 3 I' � � OOT OOZ �n � o � �n o �n � o �n � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-53: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 154+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-54 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 005'Z 006 � OOti'Z i � �. � ��I 058 _ o � Y � �� ��- ..�Y� ' OOZ'Z o a o o � � U � ;, s U ;, , �. 1 008 /Z N O p N L d � •� � I �i OOI� � `� � � y � O O .N_. y O ' � ,�/ / o`���= Ooo�'��""= � � OSL � 000'Z N � � 006'� � E N ZaZaZo�Z� N d E 3 N � N _ d N d E a N�� N O >. � H > I I OOL � - /� 008'T I I I � � � � � � �' � I j � � � _ � 059 OOL'� ..-. I I � i i� � �'� v � .�� - i v 009'� � � 009 °LL' � � v i v OSS N OOti'� m � � la, m � � � vl , � , o 00£ � � � �� o 005 ,� ' � "�� �� v v ooz'i os� v L � L 000'� OOti N 0 �,'� ��'� � o 006 ,; � ' � OS£ �j� 008 �,'� � � OOL 00£ �� OSZ 005 , j' OOti � � � OOZ � t.,` � 00� I ' OSZ OOZ I _ 3 .. J, � '� ....... OOT OOZ �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-54: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 158+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-55 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I � N I 1 I m `� Q I ' I ^ I v, I ' I I I I ' I I f I� , 5 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I , / I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I / I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ,✓ , '. 'I V a W m OI cn , �i 1 I I I I I I 1 , ... I I I I ...� „ � � oo�'z oss a oo£'z � � � . ,,� ,�i � -� Y C'. oos , OOZ'Z � p _ O �, � �+ �' .. � I I I H H A a. Y u y`. � C U l7� � C U I I � / OOZ'Z o �- s 0 � � � � r; Y '� OSL 1 000'l, r N t L O a+ �. L I ' f' .�_. �' .�_. C .d_.. O O g .�...�, O � I � � OOL I � 006'� ����.N�°�.��m N� � oN ti ti � � a E E o ry n y E a o N �;. p � N I � I i' � 008� > Z e'o > a Z = a > � Z o� �• i' � Z� 1 i Os9 �I r OOL'T I ail; I 1 � �_ I � I � I I I ' � � 009 009'� .-. I I � I i i � I � I � v v I 005'T � - Os5 LL I I I I ' v ' v OOti'Z •c i � c � 005 00£'� m I I i � m � I I ; '� � OOZ'� � ; OSti v �, � � , �� v OOT'� � i ' �- � �_ � OOti �_ � 000'� o I 1 o L% I , ,I 006 N � Os£ � 0 , � I ,�� I I I � o 008 , , I � I 00£ ,� /� . I OOL i I I I I 009 OSZ ,' - � I • I I I 005 �i OOZ OOti r � i i /�� I I I I I 00 � osi I I OOZ � I I OOZ � OOT.. I _ I .. � ,3,,.,... � .... 0 OS 0 0 0 0 0 �n o �n o �n o �r, N r-I r-I N r-I r-I I r-I r-I (4n91V-�aa�) uo�enal3 (dn91V-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-55: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 162+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-56 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I /� � � W � I I I ^ I v, I I I I I I ' l � � I I I � I I I I I I I I I ' I I I I I I ' I I I I .... I .. � I ,... ..I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I 1 1 I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I / I I i� I , I 1 I I I I I 1 I � I I I I I- I I' r � = V W m = , ,N, i Y I � � J ,' r � i � i � ' , , .. I O O O O O N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo�'z OOZ'7Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v oo�'i .v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � �_ 000'� � v L 006 N 008 � OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 C'. I I o _o: _ C, _ 0 o Y �� .. H H a. u C � C I � ��/I is y � U '� U I o a o 0 0 V u =, I / ., � u1 N L L C 2 Y � L I �/ / .�_. �"' .�_. C .d_.. Y C .N...� C 00 � � � � a g � � I � � �/�� � N � ,,, � ry � � � i 1 / 1 a � a� a�i o ^' �, � I 1 � z ¢' z¢ z o� z°O � ' rl 1 I � I �� I I � 1 1 I I � 1 1- I I 1 I I I � I I � I I �` 1 - � I , I , � � I I / _ I / ' l� � ' I 'I � 1/ f. � �/ I ' •� I I � •��i /%r ,� ,/I � 1 / � I 1 /f � I y I I ��I I v r� '' "� r 1 _ �/ � I I I � I I I I I I � �� 1 I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I . I• . . i . . . . . . . . . � = 3 � � �n O u'1 O i!1 O �n c-I c-I � c-I c-I Figure A-56: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 166+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oos OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v os� m OOti v c OS� 0 L 008 0 OSZ OOZ OST ��Z �S July 2018 A-57 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I O I I /' 1 W � I ' I � I I I I I I ' I I I I I I 1 I I I 1 I I I I I I I I l 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l I I I I 1 I ' I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I , I ' I I I I I I I I I I I/ I I I ,r. � ' u a M o 'w v, I I I I I 1 I I I I l I " I � 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'7Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v OOs'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m OOZ'� v OOT'� � 000'i v 006 N �_ 008 � OOL 009 OOs ooti oo£ ooz ooi 0 C' I I '�j C =' C o .� o I • C'. ,,, c 3 u� � I %,j/ a 0 o Y � .. H H a' u c � c � I I f, / 7 ` o O U U a. I ' o fl- o 0 0 � � � �..r,.. �o�� o n o o� '� a a a I ,f ,A a � N � N Y Y ✓ � Y i Y I � � , .�_. .�_. C .d_.. O O t�Vi. O o g � o � � � � � �� N O N N, N G � OI M I / /q I / � N � � 4 N e'�-I ��. H � E �N E a N � � a � a— v m� I I /� � / � o �, y Z Q z Q z 0 � Z. � I , - I I I � I � � - I I ♦- ' I � I I I I I 1 � � ill I I II , -� I I I l� I 1 � I I I l I ' I I , �l �� 1� /� 1 f �, � I �, I I 4 /I .r/�//l l �r I I ♦ I I / I I , I � I I � I ♦ I I I �; I I I I / / I I I I r I ' I ' I /, I I I I I I I I I I = I 3 I �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-57: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 170+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oos OSL OOL 059 009 OSs v OOs °LL' v c Osti m OOti os£ 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OST ooi os 0 July 2018 A-58 Olsen associates, inc. II II o II oI + I m � I I � � I I I I ' ! I I' I I I I �► i I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I f I I I I I I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I � � I I �I I I I I I I �l Y I �l I I I I I l�,r, - I , ' ' � 2 V a m � o N I ' �' I � -,I '' � I 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4f19N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z I oo£'z o . a � o �, � _ .� C. "' _ � I I ��I OOZ'Z T 7 _ H _ H � 0 a. o Y u a3`+ � � C U � Y � C U I I I � , / I / I o� � � 'L .. r, .. I ! �I o n o Y `_ a a; a l �" � 000'Z N a � a d �- � �- I � % Y � o 0 � 0 g NI, � 0 � I � I 006'� �o��.No�.��m v o a`i '^ a`i ry n a� ao � I I E N E � N o E °' N o N n o N N I I I Q 008'� z Q z — Q O z o� z� �, OOL'T I I I'� � � i 009'� .-. I l � � i i � I �� v OOs'T v � I I , I � v � I � I r� 00£'� m � � I ��� , OOZ'� � � I � I a, U � � OOT'� � � � � i, �_ � , v � �, � 006 � I I' 008 0 I I I I I . OOL ,9 �i.. � 009 '� �� . y OOs � ' '' � r I t OOti I I I oo£ / �� ,� ooz I I I ooi I = 3 ��� g � ������������ 0 �n o �n o �n o � � � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-58: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 174+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 Oss v OOs °LL' v c Osti m OOti v V C f6 Os£ 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ OST ooi os 0 July 2018 A-59 Olsen associates, inc. I I O I I OI -�MM�``++ I 1 _ I /' 1 W � I I I ^ I v, 1 I I I I I I I I I 1 I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I , I . J I I I I I 1 I � � ' I I � I l / ' 1 V W '�w H I / I 1 1 I 1 I I I � I � � 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOZ'7Z 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� OOS'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v U 000'� � N 006 � v L 008 N �_ OOL � 009 OOS OOti 00� 1 OOZ OOT 0 OOT- � �/ I ai � C =' C +' I ' o o �+ C'. a+ ;; � 3 O 2 u' I 1 a 0 o Y �� .. I H H a. u C � C I a`+ � U U '"' o '^' � C7 a: C7 I � a o n o 0 o c� � , • �o�� �..r,.. .? S O� d O O .--I � H N O N S y. �. O i = L L I I / 1 N Y Y C C I , I.�... .�... C .d_. t�Vl O O � O O In n a .. g � I ' / I N N �. N �, ON�i M O G N � � � N e^-I �, H I / It / O � N �. O 1 I w O �' � 1 � •I I Z Q Z Q Z O � Z'. � I� I I I�' I I � I I I I I � � � - I ' I �, i 1 I I I I � I I 1 I I I I I , I 1 , / I I • I I I , � 1 I I I 1 I I I � L� I I I I/ / I ✓ /�I I � I I / � I I 1 I I /I I I �' � _ I, I I 1, / ` I I I I / I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I . 1 . . I I I I . i . I . � � � = 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-59: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 178+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v c OOti m OS� v V C f6 00� 0 L ('' 0 OSZ 0 OOZ OST OOT OS 0 OS - July 2018 A-60 Olsen associates, inc. I I O I I OI I I I /' i � W � I I I ^ I v, I I I I I I I � I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I / I ,/ I I I I I I I � I I I /\ I 1 I I I I I , I I I I , ' �' I 2 V a M � .o H ' �I I � � � �� I I I 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� OOS'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v L 008 N 0 OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ ooi 0 OOT- I ,/ I o � � �� 1 o +' o 1 •'/ f+ C f+ � C N i U i I � O � y +-' � +-' H O. V C C I I , v�i a+ G � G. O +` � U G U I 1 11 I U � �+ r �+ ti Q � Y O c-1 O Q H � d p d I I ~ N N L � Y � Y ' I , .d.. .�.� C � C v C o O a � � a N O N � N G � p fpYf I ' i ' ,/ O � p � p E E N E > > _ j O >. > >. � I I \ � � b0 z° ¢' z a z o� z� I I I I I� I I � _1 I I � 1 1- I l l I � � i i �� ' I I _,, I I I I I .r I I I I I I 'I 1 I I / , I , I ` I , a ,� I I �� 1/ I I I I� � I I I �/I I /I I � I I 1 , � � � I � �� ♦ I f I I I I � I I I I � � � I I I I , I J 1 I I I .,,, 1 � I I I I I I I = I 3 i i �n o �n o �n o �n � � I � � (d/�9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-60: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 182+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v OSti °LL' v c OOti m OS� v c 00� 0 ('' L OSZ OOZ OST OOT os 0 OS - July 2018 A-61 Olsen associates, inc. I I oI oI I �� /' � � W � I I I ^ I v , I I I I I I I � , . I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ' I I I / I I I I I I I I I I I I I r I I I I � / I I I I I I I I, ' ' I V a m � O 'w v, " I J' I �' I — I I � � 1 � 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oos C I � ; oo£'z � ' � C � / OSL _ O � y � I 1 OOZ'Z s n s Y°° o � � � L I � � � � OOL 000'Z o NONa � 0 .� N o y o� � a Y�Y N o a° I � �� � I� .d.. oa���a��� "' .d.. t= �. p p ~ p ' I I I 059 006'� � oN'"No�.�m. � � � N H � � � t 1 1 E E� .-I E�� E� I , 1 �� 1 008 Z z° a' z a z o� z� 1 / 009 OOL'T I I I i� I 11 1 I j � � _ I I OSS 009'� a--� I I I � i i � � I I I +� v 005'T v I v 005 v v � � IJ v � I �' � OSti °� 00£'� m � � �� �I m � OOZ'� � � I, / ' - � OOti c� / I ' c� OOT'� � �. I � �_ � � OS£ �_ 000'� o � I/ I o 4J L , �� N L 006 N 00£ � 0 � � � I I � o 008 � � I ' OSZ OOL �� 009 -� j/ OOZ �J'� �I� ' / � I I OST OOti • / I I oo£ I I ooi / ooz ' : ;� / �' — OS OOT � = I 3 0 � '� 0 �n � o � �n o �n o �n � � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-61: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 186+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-62 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� OOS'� .-. v OOti'T v 00£'� •v OOZ'� m OOT'� v 000'� � �_ 006 � v 0 008 N 0 OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 OOT- 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 �� 4 I� o O o � r , A' � � / C N C � U � ' ' I (O � f0 �' V y C F C � 1 , � O _ io O � � � U �' U � � 1 1 '' 0 O. 0 �^ O tV O C U la ~ ~ �+ r f+ � i .ti ono � o���a oa � � r lV OO N d Y � � � N � � y C � � Y Y � p � ' � 1� I .d.. O O N O � O d N G O � � m p m i � ' r � 1 a E � a� E� a N E�� ti a ti E� i � I � 1 �� � z° ¢' z a z o� z� � / 1 � � I i I � � � I � � I ' 1, I I � � � � I I � 1I�Ij I � � i 1 � �, r r '1 �, , �, 1, �� �� �� r��,✓'� `� ' �� ,� y �� -� �� i � = 3 � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-62: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 190+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v OSti °LL' v c OOti m OS� v c 00� 0 0 OSZ 0 OOZ OST OOT OS 0 OS - July 2018 A-63 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo�'7z OOZ'Z OOZ'7Z 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v OOti'Z �v oo�'i m ooz'i v ooi'i 000'i v L 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ 00 ��' 0 C I I ' I o C 3 C 1 �, I 1 O o C d U o � s m io �' u " c F c 1 1 G � n p � � U O U O '^ c a l7 r1 l7 1 1 1 .�-I 0 O. 0 O O C H H U � �+ r +-� ti Q � Y O O ~ d p d 1 1 \ c-1 H N C N d = � � N � s O L � L �' C C 1 1 I ' 1 / 1 .d.. v � .�_. v oO O d � � � o� o�� o 0 N O N � N G �, N �, 1 1 'L 1 1 I / N O N � N N n N W '+ � O � � O � O > > - > � >' > >' 1 1 1 1 I ' b=0 z° ¢' z a z o� z� 1 I I I� I� I 1 � I � � I I � � - � I l � � i i � � � I I I ,, �� � ' ) � � I � � I , I -/ � , I /��' ' � � I/ 1,� � I �I 11'1 ' � 1 I , � ' l�l I , I/ II I I ' ��` I /I � � � �� I I 1 I / -1 I I / I I I � I I 1 ,/ I I I I I I �; / I I �`F I I I � � 1 I I I I �/ I _ .... ... � ,3 ... �� .... �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-63: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 194+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 008 OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v c os� m oo� os� 0 L 0 008 0 OSZ OOZ OST OOZ OS 0 July 2018 A-64 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z 008 I � 1 ooz'z 3 � r' �� � � OOT'Z _ _ � Y � -' 1 OOO'Z � � U U s a � � � � � L � I ; � � � OOL o� o o� � a o a° I 1/ �� � 006'� �� �� __�_ ''1 / oa������� I 1 � 059 OT OOO' I. o o� o � N c �. o m. � '� / a N� ti a N ti a� I � / E E� E�� E� I �� � OOLT z a Z a Z o� z� 009 009'� I I I � ' � � I � � I I I�� I I l i � OSS OOS'� l i � � i i � ;� � +J • � I , I v OOti'T v ' v 005 v I I � I� � OSti °� OOZ'� m � �('� � t m � !f � � OOT'� � I 1, OOti I u , 1 � OS� ; �i � 006 o o {�, ' I / 008 N 008 � . � ��/ 111� / � I I / OOL � �� � I / O OSZ �� , I 009 � � I .✓ � I I I / , I OOS / OOZ , l I � I� I I }, OOV r / I I I I (`T 0 S l� OOG ' / I I I I OOZ 1 I I I I OOZ OOT I I I I I I I ••�•• •�• •,,, OS 0 I = I 3 � � OOT- 0 0 0 0 0 0 �n o �n o �n o �r, N r-I r-I N r-I r-I I r-I r-I (4n91V-�aa�) uo�enal3 (dn91V-�aaj) uo •ena13 I I Figure A-64: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 198+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-65 Olsen associates, inc. I I o I oI I O I 1 I m N I Q I I ^ I v, I I I I I I ' I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I � � � ` I I I I I I I I I I I I I I . . . I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I �� I I I I I L^ I , I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I ' I I I I , I I I 6 I T l �� 2 a W I I I I I O , + N I I I I ��' I • � I I . � � 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z ' I �� oo£'z O _. 3 _. ' o =� o � I I 0 0 Z' Z _ _�� o. ° y ,. � F � ; ►' II OOT'Z G o � G. n o O O +` � U G U O C��� U ♦+ L ♦+ I I, p � .�-I i+ i d d , it I I OOO'Z NO d N N d � N ~ � � d �"' C C � I 11 1 p d .�-I � v r�-I � .'�-I I I T OO6' 1• N � O N � � ~ N p �� O m. � N H � H I I � " � .�i O N � � ON � ON , + I R 0�g Z z° ¢' z a z o� z� , I I OOL'T I I I i� � , � j ; l I I � � - I' 009'� .-. I I I I � I i i � I- I I � � +-� v 005'T v I I I �r v I I I ,. � I 00£'� m � � �'�� � '•� - OOZ'� � � I , .I _ OOZ'� � i ��� +J II ', 1 �_ 000'� � , �i , I L I , , O 006 1 / N � � I I I I 009 v e �� � I I I I I I 005 ; � OOti .� � I I I / oo£ � I OOZ i � I OOT I . I • . = 1 . i 3 ... , ... .... � � 0 u� o �n o �n o � � I � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-65: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 202+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oss oos OSL OOL 059 IIIj:� v OSS °LL' v c 005 m OSti v c OOti 0 0 OS£ 0 00£ OSZ OOZ osi ��Z OS July 2018 A-66 Olsen associates, inc. ooS'z OOti'Z 00£'Z OOZ'Z 0o V'li 000'Z 006'� 008'T OOL'� ,-. v 009'� v OOS'� •v OOti'� m 00£'� v ooz'i �_ OOT'� � v 000'� N 0 006 008 OOL 009 OOS OOti 00� OOZ OOT 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 I� o � I��I �;� O o �, �' a � � � � I, J n O N Y � L+ ' ��, C io O � � � U �' U n o n � � �, � d° � � II '�/ 0 �- 0 O O C s+ i+ � `° r �, � -� � = o .� o g `= a o a i ' A Y N y ICI .d.. t" � C .�_.. C O .N... O O o = � � � p N N N � if � � fOYf O G � � � .�i � N H � H i � 'yr Y � ON � � ON � ON > — > � �' � �' '■ ' ' I b0 z° ¢' z a z o� z� � � I I I I 1 I � � �; � I � � I I- � I I I I I � I 1 � � � I ; i I I� i � r� � I I �� �, � , / , I '� I ' � �' � I, -- ,, � �, � � i, ��, / / _ �� ,� � � i� � � � .�, i � �� i � ,� I � / �• t i� � � �J � , ,_ '�.' �' �� .._ .3.. ..., .... .. .... � � �n o �n o �n o �n � � � � � Figure A-66: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 206+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) 006 OS8 008 OSL OOL v 009 °LL' v c OSS m OOS OSti 0 OOti 0 OS£ 00£ OSZ OOZ OSZ OOZ July 2018 A-67 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 OOti'Z 006 I I , 00£'Z C o I I , � � � � � OS8 I I _ �� a � Y OOZ'Z .... m ,... 0 io �' o y .3 Y � O � F O I I I I T 77 001.'(. o �- o 0 0 � V � � � L ' ' 000 rl O � to c-1 O Y Q H u � d O d I I I I 0 0 0' Z lV � O N o � � _ y, • � I I ' \ V "' v c � � � O � � � � � ' ' � OSL T 006' 1• O O N ry � � n' O � N � O `I � H I I � � � �' � .--I O N N � � O N O � N I I I I \ � 008 Z z° a' z a z o� z� OOL ` I l l i�� l i i �, I I I I � � � 059 009'� I I � � i i � � � � - � v 005'T v / � /' . �� � � v 009 v � v /, � / � � v ' / � r OSS r I o � / � � ' o v I �p 1 v OOZ'Z � � � 1 �r � - � OSti I I , � / 000'� � v � • ,'r�� � o � 006 N / • �/�� OOti � �✓,r �� 008 o i• I r / I � � - • i / � OS£ OOL � � ,' I �� i "�'� r 009 00£ ri � _ I , '�� , I ' 005 • I I ' � OSZ ' OOti � � � I � I M' ' � 00£ OOZ I I OOZ I . I• . I ' . i . . . . . � OSZ OOT � = I 3 � � 0 OOZ o �n o �n o �n o N .� .� � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 Figure A-67: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 210+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-68 Olsen associates, inc. oo�'z oo�'z OOZ'Z OOT'Z 000'Z 0006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v 005'T v oo�'i .v oo�'i m ooz'i v OOT'� � 000'� � 0 006 N O 008 OOL 009 005 OOti 00£ OOZ OOT 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 1 A 1 -� 0 1 � ;; , _ _o C `° � 3 2 u° ? o s 1 � I A � e+ V. f+ v`Oi � n � y � a~'� � O io O � Y � (j (j I 1 1 1 � �+ I/J 0 O. 0 O O C ~ � ~ �^ u �+ r +-� .� In Y u O � O Q H � d O d 1 1 `/`� N O N � � 1 / I � Y Y d �'. d � d C � v � O O � � of a n 0 0� o �o ao 0 0 N O N '4 N G � N � 1 / '/ 1 1 � 1 a � a� a N ti a ti o a o 0 E '-' E N E� N � N > > _ j O >. > >. 1 1 � 1 1 , b0 z° ¢' z a z o� z� 1 � , I 1 I I I �� � I � �� ' .� ' I I � � - 1 � r I � 1 � 1/�,' � ► 1� - � 1 1 , 1♦1 1 1 1 'C ' 1 1 , 1 ,� 1 I ,1� 1 � 1, 1 �, / r • i�, /� i '�i '� �, �, ' ♦ . , i �'✓� ' 1 �1 �� � ' �� _ _I ♦ it . 1 1 �, � ♦ � i, -1 1 1 •��---- �"� � �1 1 1 1 � �i �. 1 � � 1 .... .1.. 1 1 1 1 3 .�.. 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 .... ..., C= L CJC L �n � L!1 � l!1 � �n Figure A-68: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 214+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) oos OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v oS� m oo� v c OS� 0 0 008 O OSZ OOZ OST OOT OS O July 2018 A-69 Olsen associates, inc. 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n9N-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z o � 'I �, oos'z _. 3 _ ' _ _o o C OOZ'Z `° a � I d � _ _ p O s �. � f+ I N _ io �' V y C F C I 11 , O io O O � � U U I 1 OOT'Z o n o O �^ tV O U C la �+ L +-� rl O � c-1 V1 O Q H � 1 p d I I / 000'Z NONa � N � y' :.Y�Y ' .d.. O � O O � � O O � O .�... O I / , 1 / OO6'� N � N N f`'f � � N I v � E � '-' � � `""� O E N = � E� N � � N O O N � N s � I / I r r 008'� z° ¢' z a z ;� �. o� z� I � y r'.� OOL'T I I I i� I � 009'� I I I I � � � i i � , � �, � v I � � � � 005'T v 'I r � v � �� ,T c 00� I. �v i � � I / r to � � 00£'� m � / � it I ' (• OOZ'� � � ' I - i � l.� � • V � I /I,/, ' ooi'i � , , �,• � �, ,• N I , ,�• o I � � i II , ;• 006 � I � � � I �� ,�r I 008 �(. 'i OOL / � r—� ;i �� � ' I , � I 009 r I � ' , ,v I �� � • ' 005 � - - - - - ' � rl I OOti ��� � � • I • I I � '' , I I 00£ 1� � �� � I I OOZ . _ _ �i ♦ I I � 1 � I OOT �o � � 0 u� o �n o �n o � � � � (dn9N-�aaj) uo •ena13 oos OSL OOL 059 009 OSS v 005 °LL' v c OSti � CO oss 0 008 0 OSZ •��� OOZ — OST OOZ — OS 0 Figure A-69: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 218+00, Bald Head Island, N.C. (Vertical dashed lines indicate physical limits of volume change computations) July 2018 A-70 Olsen associates, inc. ■ 0 0 0 0 0 N r-I r-I N (4n91V-�aa�) uo�ena13 oo�'z oo£'z OOZ'Z 0o V'li 000'Z 006'� 008'� OOL'T 009'� .-. v OOs'T v OOti'Z �v 00£'� m ooz'i v ooi'i 000'i v 006 N 0 008 OOL 009 OOs oo� oo£ ooz ooi 0 j I ' i� ` I o -- o — �� 0 O � — �- � � � � � ' I 11 I � I Ii 1 I O � Y � C0.1 U � � U' a l7 C I I ' � /I � O O H H N N V � L / 1 I I I I I ! , � _I I I I � N � r L d O d ` s o_,�„ y eL+ a. C d. G ;r. C o 0 � � N � N .�-I N O t�/f I I I I, I I ' I, I � I 1 1 N Ci d � N N 1� N 00 � E N � � N � N y � > _ > O > > > I Z � z Q z O � Z � I I / / I i I � � , I I I I I I I � 1 1 � I` I ��I % , �� 1 �' r I s, I /' � I, + 'I\I � �� I.I �� �'I ��� � II , ► I I I' ' ! `► � I / I r ,/ ' ,, � ,, 1 ' . '/ � /� � I I ' , �I � I I I I , r I I I .1 /� , � I / , I I / y I 1 I I � I I �' I � I I I I I I I I I I , I I I I ':� , I 1 ,/, I I � � I 1 3 � � I 3 .;� s..� � � �n o �n o �n o �n o �n N N � -I � -I ' r-I r-I Figure A-70: Measured beach profiles at baseline Station 224+80, Bald Head Island, N.C. 008 OSL OOL 0s9 009 Oss v OOs °LL' v c Osti m oo� os£ 0 00£ 0 OSZ OOZ osi ooi os 0 July 2018 A-71 Olsen associates, inc. APPENDIX B PHOTOGRAPHIC DOCUMENTATION OF EXISTING STABILIZING STRUCTURES LOCATED ON WEST BEACH AND SOUTH BEACH September 2018 Terminal Groin Location Completed Bald Head Island Terminal Groin (March 3, 2016) � l � - - � y � .,,.-s. - �- - -- - - '�� � � �.W ,_. ' _-�' '� Detached Breakwaters —Row - � � -- _- a , _.-- - _ '` Sheet Pile Groin (4. '6-oat � � _ 4_ - �. �. �j � ,��. a.. � �� � . � �., � � _ - ��- =-`� � � West _ -�.: -_ Bean - x:° - -�- -y �- _ . .��.:_ -. � - Jettie - .._s>: -.. <__ _ ,. - - � � � � �Y �= l �� _ L _ i ter_ j • � .� -_ --�_�. � � 76-,�r __e,. � - a.,r 1,�_� O 2� A �' � MIN. r r LAN❑WRR❑ END �r GEDTExTILE UNQERLAYER (SCQUR APRON} 18" TDE TUBE INTEGRAL TO � } SOUR APRON � MUST BE FILLED} o M 8 /� V �.F..� J M I D-LENGTH � O C7 NaTE: FELL PARTS NQT SFfpWN ALL TU8E5 ARE LINED AND COR TED C SEAWARD END r PROVIDE TOE TUBE g AT END, DO NOT F1LL UNLESS ❑IRECTEd. 20' BY ENGINEER NpTE.• TAPERED TfJBE WITH SPINAL SERM GROIN PLAN .Y�� + ..r � , . - k -i - K �,.Y,.. _ - ;,�E: } - , �- ��_. _ � -�-.. �s - .. _ ��_ � -�� J -��.. _ �� � w � � ��-, Typical Sand Tube Groin (13)