20231150 Ver 1_More Info Received_20230929

Wetlands and Environmental Planning Group
Leonard S. Rindner, PLLC.
September 29, 2023
Ms. Samantha Wooten
401 & Buffer Coordinator
Division of Water Resources
NC Department of Environmental Quality
Re: DWR #20231150 Pre -Construction Notification for NWP #29
Ms. Wooten,
for Additional Information
Thank you for providing comments on our PCN submittal for the Rogers Pond project. In cooperation with
the project engineers, we have worked to provide itemized responses to your letter comments below.
Please let us know if you have any questions or need any further information to process this PCN request.
Thank you in advance for your timely consideration of these materials.
Response to Comment '1':
The construction drawings have been updated to reflect all permanent and temporary impacts on the
overview sheet as well as the insets. In addition, the Cross Section Drawings have been enlarged and
provided on individual sheets for clarity.
Response to Comment'2':
With further efforts to lower elevations the impacts associated with the stream crossing of Intermittent
Stream 'E' have been reduced by an additional 18LF. The attached exhibit sheets and impact tables have
been updated to reflect this additional minimization effort.
Thank you for your consideration of these materials and please contact me if you have any questions,
[phone] or email at [e-mail].
Sincerely,
��A�1�
Daniel Kuefler, PWS
Environmental Scientist
Charlotte Office:
10612-D Providence Rd.
PMB 550
Charlotte, NC 28277
[phone]
[e-mail]
www.wetlands-epg.com
1
Len Rindner, PWS
Principal
Asheville Office:
1070 Tunnel Rd., Bldg. I
Suite 10, PMB 283
Asheville, NC 28805

C. Proposed Impacts Inventory
1. Impacts Summary
1 a. Which sections were completed below for your project (check all that apply):
❑X Wetlands ❑X Streams —tributaries ❑ Buffers ❑ Open Waters ❑ Pond Construction
2. Wetland Impacts
If there are wetland impacts proposed on the site, then complete this question for each wetland area impacted.
2a.
2b.
2c.
2d.
2e.
2f.
Wetland impact
Type of impact
Type of wetland
Forested
Type of jurisdiction
Area of
number
Corps (404,10) or
impact
Permanent (P) or
DWQ (401, other)
(acres)
Temporary T
W1 P
Fill
Headwater Wetland
Yes
Corps
0.083
W2
Choose one
Choose one
Yes/No
W3
Choose one
Choose one
Yes/No
W4
Choose one
Choose one
Yes/No
W5
Choose one
Choose one
Yes/No
W6
Choose one
Choose one
Yes/No
2g. Total Wetland Impacts:
0.083
2h. Comments:
Wetland F
3. Stream Impacts
If there are perennial or intermittent stream impacts (including temporary impacts) proposed on the site, then complete this
question for all stream sites impacted.
3a.
3b.
3c.
3d.
3e.
3f.
3g.
Stream impact
Type of impact
Stream name
Perennial (PER) or
Type of
Average
Impact
number
intermittent (INT)?
jurisdiction
stream
length
Permanent (P) or
width
(linear
Temporary (T)
(feet)
feet)
S1 P
Culvert
Stream C
PER
Corps
3
132
S2 P
Fill
Stream C
PER
Corps
3
26
S3 P
Culvert
Stream E
INT
Corps
3
102
S4 P
Fill
Stream E
INT
Corps
3
16
S5 T
Construction Access
Stream C
PER
Corps
3
40
S6 T
Construction Access
Stream E
INT
Corps
3
40
3h. Total stream and tributary impacts
374
3i. Comments:
S2 & S4 are for stabilizing riprap that will be placed at pre-existing stream bed elevations as a no -loss impact
S1- 0.0101 AC; S2-0.0125 AC; S3-0.0078 AC; S4- 0.0048 AC
Total loss to WOTUS: 0.0179 ac
Page 4 of 10
PCN Form — Version 1.4 January 2009

W
D:
H V
�a
Z rn
W O
O
O
�. J
W '
O /
H 1
Z M /1
LLI a
W W
CA
OC
yWQ/
Y J
H v C C C
N a Z Z Z J
a
~M V �u 5u UA
W (n W a W a W a Z=J
L
�0 30 3� 3"
xO xo xO�2 � u
WJ g
C� J W O W O W O d V a
� Le
Z GGo h Ln
M
JQ O
Z O
Z IL
uj
J
uj 1-1
I( 0. UD
J
J�
S1
1�
W o
J O
a
$
N
w0
v�
wLn
= N
LL II
Z t
U
o\
C \
a
��
G
O
r-I
`Q
oc
\
H Q
\
Z 'oLU
2 CD
I. J
� N
LL.
G
o\
0
x
W O
/�
z III
z
\ co
W� c a
O \ \ 000 .1
c z"'t
a
m Q 000 W
\N G Z N a o00 z Z
go z a
3o gq o
LLI www
C 3 0
W 0
L
oC x
H
W
Z 000
i
U M'I
N rl
Z ow
\ N O
a'd N d
L M
O E
U E
C
O
._
n
Z M
Q .C—
U
111.c:
on
QU
w

N . V en *'I
W _O Z_ Z (� c Z N O
m a W O z
Z e d 0�= N II
CLGaa� a 0oC
E0W
U LUU_ 0. =pVQmaLIL- • C a
oacga� O
41
LUa Z a I 7 �u� N— Q —A
'C
Z vNxw m z 0OCFA V ��
LU Q W Q m O c.i Li X p� H p
Q CO 00 C Q H W LU
W Ln
LUCD N Q 0. h W d 0 Re~ V N LL II
LY C t0 W LU m C C d = Z V
�y J W LD LU \
Z N J d J O Q LL N J~
!- O OC z O W d J
N
LA a�i d Z W L~/f CMi d ZC-3 N \\
W
Wco
I
m
a �\
z , \
t; O
H
m LZ ad \
0 \\ W C W N
G C7 p O
gMa
L 000-1W y~j 0 d
` 3 c;
�� r 0
00
III
\\ J) 00
W \\
LLUJ
W \ \ H \
X I
O LU ww
C \ \ O W 011 / •
z \ \ V W „ I O,
p L000
III m
zQ I I 1000
y I I _
X LU N
LU LU rlj
000 \ ` OD
N
U
III Z
/ O LU
H U
W X —
Z O o
O H v
LU Can O
Z �_ >
z V� o
c v
W ._ U
Q W a
0
i \ U
m

\ uj � N O H O ow OLU w
cc N W -e p C m W Z N O
Ln W CC �j �p 0 •
Q O O= —� J L Z J T
m H dJQ ^0 w0 w ppM
LL�Q9= /!//mV•a�ac� �_ po•f C o+
J y W W V 3 M
\IL
N H LLI O �'O W N `bw 0
oC_FoXad O�cJo 0 o U
\ / d �m W W O O 9 I •
/ • _ �+
W I-- a
w • 0 {%1
' O O J 00•i
0 0 0 o
00
X. SS,V o L
w w
a z c
O
O w w
' w
o � I
M 1 ` 0 w 00
I
o 0
0z x` \
LL d W \ w \
H
LL C H/ f Q a Q OCD 0
w
N. W ' O Z
ca — 0 0 0 A
Wix
J
M
W i„ 0w Ow O Sf •
\ \ LU W
wo �
axiW
0 0 o a
\ c
�\ z
1 ' Ow ow oc N
Z
I� m LL CO
I \� 0 w0 \ N O N
I ` N
o �o O 0 \ w V
0
woo
swoo
0 w w N
0 0
Z�
I I I I Uc
w p
w i
�' O 0 N
2 ala ®, \ W.c u
00 M w
L
z C aw a
LL U
w N O S o
M

V
C
O
a
L
O
ce
rl
W
O
L
a
w
E
w
L
C
W

C
O
a�
-
0
Lu
LL
1,
1
:.
zo
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■\1■■■■�■■■■■■■■
•
■■■■■■■■■■■■■\\■■'J■■l�■■■■■■■■■■
-
LLI
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■�==�=="'=7■■■■■■■■
CD
_
CD
W
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■�I�■■,�■■■■■■
CD
CA
•
a
.
_
LLI CC
•
LUc
x
LU
co
_LU
a�
co
cL
a�
L
C
W
's
W
41
V
fQ
E
cLu.c
.,
�a
LU
a

.a
C
O
a
a� -
0
oC -
LU
LA-
0 z
ui
CD
"'
■■■■■■■■\�\■■■■■■■■1 ■■■■■■■■■■
LU
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■���_■�■■■■■■■■uio
a
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■.J■■■■■■■_
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■CD
C
CD CD
w
O
L
C
W
i
's
W
V
fQ
a,,
a
cLu.c
.,
�a
LU
a

J
U ^ $
0
H w l0
U o �
Z u
� v �
R � � o
V \
LL.o \�C LLI z�
(; I CD N Q\ LL
N c 0
Q co J
�oG 1 /// �aZa0
_ d W
H O L6 l d D: O W W
H ' O
M / 1
=SS
1000,
L~N O @J
H oc
Xx \ W oC O
O O
LL MCD 9L
U M'I
N rl
Z N O
� n
a'd N d
L M
O E
U E
C 0.
O °1
._
n
Z�
c
w.c:
aU w

.a
C
O
a
a� -
LL
o°� -
LU
cc
qA LA
-
■■■■■■�■■■■■i��■■r�■■■■■■■■■■ CD
UJ
■■■■■■■ii■■��i�� i■■■■■■■■■■■
LL
■■■■■■■■■L■I/lam%JGI■►\■■■■■■■■■■ CD _
.
a
■■■■■■■■■■■■Ili_■■■■■■■■■ -
-
- -_ - -
•
cn co
LLI
L.
CL Lu
LU
W
co
's
W
V
fQ
E
a
cLu.c
.,
�a
LU
a

O
N rl
Z
ow
N O
•
i, pp O
a'd N d
L M
O E
uU
o
U 0)
Q
V
=
O
'C
H
w Q
V
o
LU 11
Z u
v
�
�
O
O
Z
N
o
P-
O
C
ci W J
LLJ
0
oa
azc
"
W
°�
W C7
M S W
W
O
t/f
.w
to
W
Ln
Ln
LU
V
o
>
o
J
V
V
a
c
'
Cl
W
co
CD
to
Ln
coo
Ln
O
a
io
W0
LL
M
> m
LU
r�r
r
v
N
n
(7
V
O
n
N
N
W
N
Z
N
O
L
U
0
-
Z on
C
ai
U L
(3)
Q
W .c
c
Q W
0
a
_�
0
co

z ow
N 0
0
• r
z
o rn
I w w
P.
z
z
42 0. Z
LU
F-
z
D LLI
0—
U)
F- F-
LLI a_ z
cl LU
z 12
D
0 ow
<
CL m
wz
D 0 z
CL
z
0
U)
w
w
LJ w
u
E2
<
LLI -0 -n
of 0 Z< N <
0 ZCL
LL, z E-L u
U) ul V) F3
0 71
LL,
z E iE WT pg an L.L,V a QL
E :Z) lz' ,, - oz L-L, 77, Z. Z, Lz,
-,, z 0.
LLJ a. u C, < 0 1) F,� 0 u < HN - H 3: - - N .0
Z LU LL z
Fz
.0 -Z, 0 LL 0,74,01 W, 0 u<
Z, LL, - IL
u 0! LL, z - i
'T. " = = � L 0,
< :1 aka
M LOL, F- z • m
CL t H<.O 't
pL 7.,
'z z CL
ZO x CL 8'. U- G� 2 U)
uz - 2 D, 02 c,, L.0 loll 4
w Z' Vl mm 0, .7, "
=
Lu 2 m , OR LU 6, >?� P, 'o -Z L-L,
m Z
T
zo M4
Hu
;U, Vi �L
j § P F- u E;5 UZ L,
WM 2 z a M. Im W. L
0 W " r LL <
z uj I � W) - §0
l2w2p�gm llr�- W�Wffl
z
IL "I LU o zl�pWFOWZ,0,92,P� p (9
6'5 z u z 0
LL 0 CL �: 0 �-
LU
0 Z X,OT=W LL,
Ll
u 3' P UZI 0 IZ ��2 2 Ln go
a! 0� Im, � 0 zz u
0, 0 0 0
IE-M I., z u u 0 wow I�w
w n . cr
Q<F-W� Zzw Ru mn-� u z
w u 2 � M
V) m 02
ou vuw) WF oz . F I'll' 2.5 WS -KFFHFZ 'Z H F< Fw z 0.
CY
4 i 'd t� un LU 16
Z
Lu.c: w
u
0
C, P
0
u

•
U
Z
M�
N 1-I
•
\
o 1L
N O
•
0 wl
N
L
M
O
E
U
�
•
•
=
O
._
F _
¢
U � G5
WW
ZZ yy
"is�
g o fig � %5 a
—� aaN
W
,III=11
OF
��
¢ mZ❑ W C b ~i
m� Nm �? U OQ <
Z
LL (
—�
I
VI �
•
O�UN—
�
�o �J ZN6 Z ¢g �y Z�
�ZWU
�W�<
i I
W
••
pew 3aN ¢d�zw o t8I
mew;
d� oNLL cg
r �zmo O ZS�
1�4 Zw4 IZULLry Fy-~ -Fa
O W oFU ¢� U® 6 U4� 4411
W
f7
¢i zd
�'
n
U��i UZC�V 3 I¢F JG�Z wcoi
;
toiwro Z`.f0 �q�Zai �� �p4 JJp
Om� tj6N � U3�< rcC QISa
N
N
I.OU
U6o mP ?WVQiI l I UV1? 6 w
-
�
N
n M e � Ic
•
z
a)
O
L
U
0
Z t1A
cn
C
ai
g L
Q
W .c
c
Q W
0
a
1
_ �
���
0
U
2