20140820 Ver 5_CarrawayBluff_100186_MY0_2023_20230711

ID#* 20140820 Version* 5
Select Reviewer:
Katie Merritt
Initial Review Completed Date 07/13/2023
Mitigation Project Submittal - 7/11/2023
Is this a Prospectus, Technical Proposal or a New Site?* Yes No
Type of Mitigation Project:*
Stream Wetlands Buffer Nutrient Offset
(Select all that apply)
Project Contact Information
Contact Name: * Email Address:
Emily Dunnigan [e-mail]
Project Information
ID#: * 20140820 Version:* 5
Existing ID# Existing Version
Project Type: DMS Mitigation Bank
Project Name: Carraway Bluff Buffer Mitigation Site
County: Wayne
Document Information
Mitigation Document Type:*
Mitigation As -Built Plans
File Upload: CarrawayBluff_100186_MYO_2023.pdf 4.25MB
Please upload only one PDF of the complete file that needs to be submitted...
Signature
Print Name:* Emily Dunnigan
Signature:

Baseline Monitoring Report
FINAL
CARRAWAY BLUFF MITIGATION PROJECT
NCDMS Project 9100186 (Contract #0402-07)
RFP 916-20200402
DWR Project 92014-0820 V5
Wayne County, North Carolina
Neuse River Basin
HUC 03020201
Provided by:
pres
Resource Environmental Solutions, LLC
for Environmental Banc & Exchange, LLC (EBX)
Provided for:
NC Department of Environmental Quality
Division of Mitigation Services
July 2023

fires
Memorandum
To: NCDEQ — Emily Dunnigan
Hannah Gadai, RES
From: Jamey McEachran, RES
Subject: Task 4 Draft Baseline Monitoring Report Comments — Carraway Bluff Mitigation Site (DMS
#100186) - Comment Response Memo
Date: 7/10/2023
CC: N/A
1. Soil testing was proposed to be completed in the mitigation plan, was that done? Were any soil
amendments made? Please include any action/inaction in the narrative.
Soil amendments were deemed unnecessary for the site due to the site already having soil fertile for tree growth.
This narrative is now included in section 3.1.
2. As noted in the field a deer stand was left in the easement due to nesting owls. Please include DWR's
approval to leave the deer stand in the easement within the narrative. Also, include it on the CCPV
and as -built survey.
Language regarding the deer stand is now included in section 3.2. It can also be found on the CCPV and in the as -
built survey.
3. Update the Stem Count Total and Planted by Plot Species Table with the correct survey date of
3/16/2023.
The Stem Count Total and Planted by Plot Species Table was updated with the correct survey date of March 16tn
2023.
4. There appear to be disparities between the asset table and the square feet of buffer generated in the
attribute table with the digital data. Ex: Restoration 101-200 for Carraway Creek & BH1 (1998
cleared) asset table says 34,764 sqft, and the attribute table has 34,080 sqft. Please review the
calculated square feet in the shapefile and revise the shapefile or asset table as necessary.
The disparities between the buffer shapefile and the asset table have been resolved and they now match. These
disparities were due to some issues with exporting from Civil to SHP. A small update was made to the Plat and the
new Plat is included. The new shapefile that matches the Plat is included in the digital files.
Please find enclosed the revised final As -Built submission with changes as noted above. Do not hesitate to reach out with
any question or comments. Jamey can be reached by email [e-mail] or by phone at 919-623-9889.
Thank you,
Hannah Gadai
Ecologist
Jamey McEachran
Project Manager
res.us

Table of Contents
1 Mitigation Project Summary ...................
1.1 Project Location and Description
2 Regulatory Considerations ......................
2.1 Determination of Credits ............
2.2 Asset Map........
3 Baseline ........................
3.1 Planting............
3.2 Other Activities
4 Annual Monitoring .......
4.1 Methods...........
4.2 Tables ......................................
4.3 Results and Discussion............
4.4 Maintenance and Management
References ............................................
Appendix A: Background Tables and Site Maps
Table 1: Buffer Project Areas and Assets
Table 2: Goals, Performance, and Results
Table 3: Project Attributes
Table 4: Project Timeline and Contacts
Figure 1: Site Location Map
Figure 2: As -Built Map
Figure 3: Current Conditions Plan View Map
Appendix B: Vegetation Assessment Data
Planted Species Summary
Stem Count Total and Planted by Plot Species
Vegetation Plot Mitigation Success Summary Table
Visual Vegetation Assessment Table
Appendix C: As -built Photos
General Site Photos
Vegetation Plot Photos
Maintenance Completed Photos

1 Mitigation Project Summary
L I Project Location and Description
Environmental Banc & Exchange, LLC (EBX), a wholly -owned subsidiary of Resource Environmental
Solutions (RES), is pleased to provide the Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project (Project), a full -delivery
buffer mitigation project for the Division of Mitigation Services (DMS) (DMS Project #100186). The
Carraway Bluff Project is within the Neuse River Basin within the 8-digit HUC 03020201,
03020201170060 and DWR Sub -basin Number 03-04-12. The Project easement is located in Wayne
County in Goldsboro, NC and can be accessed off of Highway 117 approximately five miles south of
downtown Goldsboro (Figure 1). The coordinates are 35.3280007,-78.010718.
This buffer project provides riparian buffer mitigation credits for unavoidable impacts due to development
within the Neuse River Basin, United States Geological Survey (USGS) 8-digit Cataloguing Unit 03020201
(Neuse 01), excluding Falls Lake Watershed (Figure 1). This Buffer Mitigation Plan is in accordance with
the Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rule 15A NCAC 02B .0295 and Nutrient Offset Credit Trading Rule
15A NCAC 02B .0703. The Carraway Bluff Project consists of a contiguous conservation easement that
totals approximately 25.39 acres and includes the Neuse River, five stream features (Carraway Creek, BH1,
BH2, BH3, and BH4) and one ditch feature (D4). Carraway Creek is a USGS-named stream that drains
directly to the Neuse River onsite. Pre-existing land use within the Project was crop production and riparian
forest. Water quality stressors previously affecting the Project included heavily manipulated/relocated and
maintained stream channels, nutrient loadings from active crop production, and lack of forested riparian
buffers.
The Carraway Bluff Project is comprised of two perennial stream channels; the Neuse River, and Carraway
Creek; four intermittent stream channels; BH1, BH2, BH3 and BH4 and one ditch feature; D4. Carraway
Creek is a named tributary of the Neuse River with a partially intact riparian buffer, while its tributaries,
BH1, BH2, BH3 and BH4 are modified natural stream channels that lack any riparian buffer. Furthermore,
the fifty -foot riparian buffers of BH1 and BH2 were determined to be subject to the Neuse buffer protection
rules ("Subject"); the fifty -foot riparian buffers of BH3 and BH4 were determined to be not subject to the
Neuse buffer protection rules ("Non -subject"). This Project was also codeveloped with a buffer mitigation
and nutrient offset bank that extends riparian buffer areas associated with this Project's streams as well as
incorporate additional stream features on the property.
The goal of the Project is to restore and preserve ecological function to the existing streams and their
associated riparian buffer areas by establishing appropriate plant communities while minimizing temporal
and land disturbing impacts. This is being accomplished through the planting, establishment, and protection
of a hardwood forest community. The result will be a riparian area that functions to mitigate nutrient and
sediment inputs from the surrounding uplands. Buffer and surrounding riparian area improvements will
filter runoff from agricultural fields, thereby reducing nutrient and sediment loads to Project channels and
provide water quality benefit to the overall watershed. The Project will provide significant functional uplift
to the watershed and will assist DMS with achieving its mitigation goals in the Neuse 01 watershed,
excluding the Falls Lake Watershed.
2 Regulatory Considerations
2.1 Determination of Credits
This Project has the potential to generate up to 641,711.542 fe riparian buffer mitigation credits within a
25.39-acre conservation easement. These will be derived from buffer restoration and buffer preservation.
The riparian buffer mitigation credits generated will service the Neuse 01 watershed, excluding the Falls
Lake Watershed. The total potential buffer mitigation credits that the Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project
Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project 1 Baseline Monitoring Report
DMS Project #100186 July 2023

will generate are detailed in Table 1, Appendix A. Where viable, buffer mitigation credits can be converted
to nutrient offset credit in accordance with the Nutrient Offset Credit Trading Rule, 15A NCAC 02B .0703.
2.2 Asset Map
See Figure 2, Appendix A.
3 Baseline
3.1 Planting
The initial planting of bare root trees occurred on March 15r'', 2023. All riparian restoration areas are planted
from top of bank back at least 50 feet from streams with bare root tree seedlings on a nine by six-foot
spacing to achieve an initial density of approximately 800 trees per acre. In addition, these areas were
seeded with an herbaceous seed mix to provide rapid herbaceous cover and promote immediate buffer
effectiveness as well as habitat for pollinators and other wildlife. The seed blend contains both temporary
and permanent seed and includes taproot species. The seed was sown utilizing broadcast seeding. Soil
amendments were not done throughout the site due to the site already having fertile soil suitable for
herbaceous and tree growth. Additionally, the site was ripped to encourage tree growth. Planting occurred
in all areas proposed for riparian buffer restoration and meets the performance standards outlined in Rule
15A NCAC 02B .0295. This includes treating invasive species and planting of at least four species of native
hardwood bare root trees. Mixed-Mesic Hardwood Forest (Coastal Plain subtype) (Schafale 2012) is the
target community type and was used for all areas within the Project. This community composition is highly
diverse and is suitable given the Project's soil and landscape characteristics and will provide water quality
and ecological benefits. The list of planted bare root tree species and their percentage of total species
composition can be found in Appendix B. Wherever possible, mature vegetation has been preserved and
incorporated into the buffer.
3.2 Other Activities
Other activities involved with the Project included bank stabilization efforts, including grading, matting,
and live staking where culverts were removed. It was determined that the most stable approach for the
crossing outside the easement at BH2 was a culvert instead of the timber mat bridge. Seeding and
livestaking occurred in the locations where the existing culverts are removed. All culvert removal activities
were discussed with the USACE and NCDWR to confirm no buffer authorization nor nationwide permit
was required for these construction activities as they were activities were exempt or deemed allowable and
additionally where well under the threshold for Notification. A deer stand was left inside Carraway Bluff
Phase II easement with approval of NCDWR due to nesting owls residing inside. Construction activities
are called out in Figure 3.
4 Annual Monitoring
4.1 Methods
Annual vegetation monitoring and visual assessments will be conducted. Monitoring plots were installed a
minimum of 100 meters squared in size and cover at least two percent of the planted mitigation area. These
plots were randomly placed throughout the planted riparian buffer mitigation area (16.25 acres) and are
representative of the riparian restoration conditions. The following data is recorded for all trees in the plots:
species, height, planting date (or volunteer), and grid location. All stems in plots are flagged with flagging
Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project 2 Baseline Monitoring Report
DMS Project #100186 July 2023

tape. Data is processed using the "Vegetation Table Shiny Tool" made available by DMS in December
2021 and is reported in accordance with the most recent DMS requirements and templates. In the field, the
four corners of each plot were permanently marked with PVC at the origin and metal conduit at the other
corners. There are 14 fixed vegetation monitoring plots (Figure 3). These plots were planted and monitored
in conjunction with plots 15-41 of the Carraway Bluff Phase II project site.
Photos are to be taken at all vegetation plot origins each monitoring year and be provided in the annual
reports. Visual inspections and photos will be taken to ensure that areas are being maintained and compliant.
The measures of vegetative success for the Project are the survival of at least four native hardwood tree
species, where no one species is greater than 50 percent of stems, at a density of at least 260 stems per acre
at the end of Year 5. Native volunteer species may be included to meet the performance standards as
determined by NC Division of Water Resources (DWR).
A visual assessment of the conservation easement is also performed each year to confirm:
• Easement boundary markers/signage are in good condition throughout the site;
• No encroachment has occurred;
• No invasive species in areas where invasive species were treated;
• Diffuse flow is being maintained in the conservation easement areas; and
• There has not been any cutting, clearing, filling, grading, or similar activities that would
negatively affect the functioning of the buffer.
Component/ Monitoring Maintenance through project close-out
Feature
Vegetation Annual Vegetation shall be maintained to ensure the health and vigor of the targeted plant
vegetation community. Routine vegetation maintenance and repair activities may include
monitoring supplemental planting, pruning, mulching, and fertilizing. Exotic invasive plant species
shall be treated by mechanical and/or chemical methods. Any vegetation requiring
herbicide application will be performed in accordance with NC Department of
Agriculture (NCDA) rules and regulations. Vegetation maintenance activities will be
documented and reported in annual monitoring reports. Vegetation maintenance will
continue through the monitoring period.
Invasive and Nuisance Visual Invasive and noxious species will be monitored and treated so that none become
Vegetation Assessment dominant or alter the desired community structure of the Project. Locations of invasive
and nuisance vegetation will be mapped.
Project Boundary Visual Project boundaries shall be identified in the field to ensure clear distinction between the
Assessment mitigation project and adjacent properties. Boundaries are marked with signs identifying
the property as a mitigation project and will include the name of the long-term steward
and a contact number. Boundaries may be identified by fence, marker, bollard, post, tree -
blazing, or other means as allowed by Project conditions and/or conservation easement.
Boundary markers disturbed, damaged, or destroyed will be repaired and/or replaced on
an as -needed basis. Easement monitoring and staking/signage maintenance will continue
in perpetuity as a stewardship activity.
4.2 Vegetation Assessment Tables
See Appendix B.
4.3 Results and Discussion
Establishment and monitoring of 14 fixed vegetation plots was completed on March 16r' and 21', 2023.
Vegetation tables are in Appendix B and associated photos are in Appendix C. MYO monitoring data
indicates that all plots are exceeding the interim performance of 260 planted stems per acre. Planted stem
densities ranged from 567 to 931 planted stems per acre with a mean of 772 planted stems per acre across
Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project 3 Baseline Monitoring Report
DMS Project #100186 July 2023

all plots. A total of 10 species were documented within the plots. Volunteer species were not noted at
baseline monitoring but are expected to establish in upcoming years. The average tree height observed was
1.3 feet.
Visual assessment of vegetation outside of the monitoring plots indicates that the herbaceous vegetation is
becoming well established throughout the project. Some invasives have been observed and treated as
necessary. Easement boundary markers and signs are clearly visible and in good condition. Additionally,
there were no signs of encroachment or undocumented concentrated flow in the easement area.
4.4 Maintenance and Management
Supplemental planting along the top of bank of BH1 and BH2 was completed on May 30r' and June 22na
To maintain diffuse flow throughout the conservation easement two engineered sediment packs were
installed on the erosional features on BH2, and Carraway Creek. Coir mat logs and additional planting will
also be implemented around the erosional features to promote diffuse flow. The engineered sediment packs
were completed on June 15r' and 23`a. Associated photos are included in Appendix C.
Project boundary will continue to be monitored for encroachment and conservation easement markings will
be replaced if damaged. Invasive and noxious species will be monitored and treated so that none become
dominant or alter the desired community structure of the Project.
5 References
NC Environmental Management Commission. 2014. Rule 15A NCAC 02B.0295 - Mitigation Program
Requirements for the Protection and Maintenance of Riparian Buffers.
NC Environmental Management Commission. 2020. Rule 15A NCAC 02B.0714 — Neuse River Basin:
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Management Strategy: Protection and Maintenance of Existing
Riparian Buffers.
NC Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Mitigation Services. 2021. Vegetation Table Shiny
Tool. https://ncdms.shinyapps.io/Veg Table Tool/.
Resource Environmental Solutions, LLC (2022). Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project. Final Mitigation
Plan.
Schafale, M.P. 2012. Classification of the Natural Communities of North Carolina, Fourth
Approximation. North Carolina Natural Heritage Program, Division of Parks and Recreation,
NCDENR, Raleigh, NC.
Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project 4 Baseline Monitoring Report
DMS Project #100186 July 2023

Appendix A
Background Tables & Site Maps

Table 1. Carraway Bluff, DMS Project #100186, Project Credits.
Neuse 03020201 - Outside Falls Lake
Project Area
N Credit Conversion Ratio (ft2/pound)
P Credit Conversion Ratio (ftz/pound)
19.16394
N/A
Credit Type
Location
Subject? (enter
NO if ephemeral
or ditch 1)
Feature Type
Mitigation Activity
Min -Max Buffer
Width (ft)
Feature Name
Total Area (ft')
Total (Creditable)
Area of Buffer
Z
Mitigation (ft)
Initial Credit
Ratio (x:1)
% Full Credit
Final Credit
Ratio (x:1)
Convertible to
Riparian
Buffer?
Riparian Buffer
Credits
Convertible to
Nutrient Offset?
Delivered
Nutrient Offset:
N (Ibs)
Delivered
Nutrient Offset:
P (Ibs)
Buffer
Rural
Yes
I / P
Restoration
0-100
Carraway Creek, Neuse
River, BH1, BH2
342
203,,
203 342
1
100%
1.00000
Yes
203,342.000
Yes
10,610.657
—
Buffer
Rural
Yes
I / P
Restoration
101-200
Carraway Creek, Neuse
River, BH1, BH2
98
98
1
33%
3.03030
Yes
32.340
Yes
5.114
—
Buffer
Rural
Yes
I / P
Restoration
0-100
Carraway Creek, BH1
(1998 Cleared)
370,511
370,511
1
100%
1.00000
Yes
370,511.000
No
—
—
Buffer
Rural
Yes
I / P
Restoration
101-200
Carraway Creek, BH1
(1998 Cleared)
34,783
34,783
1
33%
3.03030
Yes
11,478.401
No
—
—
Buffer
Rural
No
I / P
Restoration
0-100
BH3
12,497
12,497
1
100%
1.00000
Yes
12,497.000
Yes
652.110
—
Buffer
Rural
No
I / P
Restoration
0-100
BH3 (1998 Cleared)
8,551
8,551
1
100%
1.00000
Yes
8,551.000
No
—
—
Buffer
Rural
No
Ditch
Restoration
0-50
D4
29,258
29,258
1
100%
1.00000
Yes
29,258.000
Yes
1,526.722
—
Totals (ft2):
Total Buffer (ft2):
Total Nutrient Offset (ft2):
659,040
659,040
635,669.742 12,794.603 0.000
659,040
659,040
0
N/A
Total Ephemeral Area (ft) for Credit:
Total Eligible Ephemeral Area (ft):
Enter Preservation Credits Below Total Eligible for Preservation (ft):
Credit Type Location Subject? Feature Type Mitigation Activity Min -Max Buffer Feature Name
Width (ft)
Rural Yes I / P 0-100 Carraway Creek
Preservation Area Subtotals (ft):
TOTAL AREA OF BUFFER MITIGATION (TABM)
Mitigation Totals
Square Feet
Credits
Restoration:
659,040
635,669.742
Enhancement:
0
0.000
Preservation:
60,418
6,041.800
Total Riparian Buffer:
719,458
641,711.542
TOTAL NUTRIENT OFFSET MITIGATION
Mitigation Totals
Square Feet
Credits
Nutrient Offset:
Nitrogen:
0
0.000
Phosphorus:
0.000
0
0
179,865
0.0%
219,680
6.9%
Total Area (sf)
Total (Creditable)
Area for Buffer
Mitigation ftZ
60,418
60,418
60,418
60,418
Ephemeral Reaches as % TABM
Preservation as % TABM
Initial Credit Full Credit Final Credit Riparian Bui
Ratio (x:1) Ratio (x:1) Credits
10 100% 10.00000 6,041.800

Table 2: Summary: Goals, Performance and Results
Goal
Objective/Treatment
Likely Functional
Uplift
Performance Criteria
Measurement
Cumulative Monitoring
Results
Reduction in
Survival of at least four
floodplain sediment
native hardwood tree
Established and increased forested
All plots passed with 10
inputs from runoff,
species, where no one
Restore and preserve
riparian buffers to 50 feet and greater
increased bank
species is greater than
14 fixed vegetation
species found across the site
along both sides of the channel along the
and mean of 772 planted
native vegetation.
project reaches with a hardwood riparian
stability, increased
50 percent of stems, at a
plots
stems per acre across all
LWD and increased
density of at least 260
plant community;
plots.
organic material in
stems per acre at the
streams
end of MY5

Table
3. Project Attribute Table
Project Name
Carraway Bluff Mitigation Project
County
Wayne
Project Area (acres)
25.39
Planted Area (acres)
16.25
Project Coordinates (latitude and longitude decimal degrees)
35.3280007,-78.010718
Project Watershed Summary Information
Physiographic Province
Rolling Coastal Plain
River Basin
Neuse
USGS Hydrologic Unit 8-digit
3020201
DWR Sub -basin
03-04-12
Regulatory Considerations
Parameters
Applicable?
Resolved?
Supporting Docs?
Water of the United States - Section 404
No
N/A
N/A
Water of the United States - Section 401
No
N/A
N/A
Buffer Authorization - Neuse Riparian Buffer Protection Rules
Yes
Yes
N/A
Endangered Species Act
Yes
Yes
Categorical Exclusion
Historic Preservation Act
Yes
Yes
Categorical Exclusion
Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA or CAMA)
No
N/A
N/A
Essential Fisheries Habitat
No
N/A
N/A

Table 4. Project Timeline and Contacts
Activity or Deliverable
Data Collection
Complete
Task Completion or
Deliverable Submission
Project Instituted
N/A
Dec-20
Mitigation Plan Approved
N/A
Dec-22
Construction (Grading) Completed
N/A
Mar-23
Planting Completed
N/A
Mar-23
As -built Survey Completed
Mar-23
Apr-23
MY-0 Baseline Report
Mar-23
May-23
MY1+ Monitoring Reports
Remediation Items (e.g. beaver removal, supplements, repairs etc.)
Encroachment
Carraway Bluff #100186
Provider
RES / 3600 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100, Raleigh, NC 27612
Mitigation Provider POC
Jamey Mceachran [phone]
Designer
RES / 3600 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100, Raleigh, NC 27612
Primary project design POC
Frasier Mullen, PE [phone]
Construction Contractor
RES / 3600 Glenwood Ave., Suite 100, Raleigh, NC 27612
Construction contractor POC
Vic Vanover

IWae Counge9
ffs Firiynng Range
q� UC aa"0 ManufacturingAc�.
d�P
Allen Gradl
Company, Ii
Arrington
�soarc Yra
006'ro
Ley
4. e,
5
9
Galds6Ca o
C-
y Ile
Portche
:
Durham W Forest
Nashville
Rock
till
Gihsnn•pltrs 4
risyille
Ze I n
Elm Clt
Ot
Cary kn hidale
n Raleigh g
•ddlose-
��
wilsoo
o`
Garner
r`
A sa2� vet Pyr
_ "oily rings Clayton
Ken
St John AME
Fuqua - r+na3
__
_
a
L_g d
r 21 an Church
a9, v
srn•Inraid
v•Ile
Marys
I Faur
Oaks
Recorded Easement
y
Gi
M S g
L�II�n ton
oro "" 1
z
9�
53 Neuse River Basin - 03020201 [Excluding Falls Lake Watershed]
L
Carraway Bluff
onGr
Seven
14-Digit HUC (03020201170060)
gation Project
, ,1Ve
-53
wade
-- •:'-:;
I:
Figure 1 - Site Location
Dare: S/18/2423
Carraway Bluff
Drawnhy: MDE
ores
Mitigation Project
Checked by:1RM
D 500 1,000
1:12.000
Fee[
Wayne County, North Carolina
y y
�rsiori�g a r?sriienr eo7h for a rrode+n wn•rn

VICINITY MAP
NOT TO SCALE
CARRAWAY 6LUFF MITIGATION 51TE
I, ELISABETH G- TURNER, AS A DULY REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL
xx■ .x.x�%:%:�.�.
LAND SURVEYOR IN THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, CERTIFY
Y%x%.%Y%.%Y%x%%X■
THAT THIS BUFFER MAP WAS DRAWN UNDER MY SUPERVISION, IS
"■"+"■"■".'.'x'>e'
AN ACCURATE AND COMPLETE REPRESENTATION OF WHAT WAS
CONSTRUCTED IN THE FIELD, THAT THE EASEMENT BOUNDARY IS
BASED ON PLAT BOOK SEE , PG NOTES RECORDED IN WAYNE
COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS OFFICE, AND THAT THE BUFFER
AREAS SHOWN ARE CALCULATED FROM AS -BUILT CONDITIONS
EXCEPT WHERE OTHERWISE NOTED HEREON- WITNESS MY
■ ■ ■ ■
ORIGINAL SIGNATURE, REGISTRATION NUMBER, AND SEAL THIS _
■ ■ ■ • •
7th DAY OF JULY, 2023.
1►11111111►�1
• ■ • ■
• • • a a
'
0000000000000
�
op000popopoQo
SEAL _
t15ABETH G. TURNER, P.L.S. #L4440 r L-4440
9 -
GENERAL NOTE5:
1 . ALL 015TANCE5 ARE HORIZONTAL GROUND D15TANCE5 IN U.5. 5URVEY FEET
UNLf55 OTHEKW15E NOTED.
2- THE BA515 OF BEARING5 15 NCG5 STATE PLANE NA483(201 1) DATUM.
3. THE AREA SHOWN HEREON WAS COMPUTED USING THE COORDINATE
COMPUTATION METHOD.
4- THE PURPOSE OF TH15 MAP 15 TO SHOW THE A5-BUILT AREA5 FOR RIPARIAN
BUFFER CREDITS WITHIN THE CON5ERVATION EA5EMENT. TH15 PLAT 15 NOT A
BOUNDARY 5URVEY. THE LAND PARCEL5 AND THEIR BOUNDARIES AFFECTED BY
TH15 CON5ERVATION EASEMENT ARE NOT CHANGED BY TH15 MAP,
5. LINE5 NOT SURVEYED ARE SHOWN AS A DASHED UNETYPE AND WERE TAKEN
FROM INFORMATION REFERENCED ON THE FACE OF THIS PLAT.
G. 5UBJECT TO ALL EA5EMENT5, RIGHT OF WAYS, AND/OR ENCUMBRANCES THAT
MAY AFFECT THE PROPERTY(5).
7. CONSERVATION EASEMENT RECORDED IN D.B. 3777, PG. GG5 AND PLAT BOOK
P, PG. 72-F (5HFET5 1-3) IN THE WAYNE COUNTY REGI5TER OF DEED5 OFFICE.
8 STREAM TOP OF SANK LINFr_ TAKEN FROM TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY BY
Riparian Buffer Credit:
SQ FT.
Acres
Stearm & Difhes
331,974
7.621
Riparian Restoration
203,342
4.668
0'-100'
Riparian Restoration
98
0.002
101'-200'
Riparian Restoration
370,511
8.506
U-100' (1998 cleared)
Riparian Restoration
34,783
0.799
101'-200' (1998 cleared)
Riparian Restoration (131­3)
12,497
0.287
0'-100' (Non -Subject)
Riparian Restoration (131­13)
8,551
0.196
0'-100' (Non -Subject 1998 cleared)
Riparian Restoration (D4)
29258
0.672
0'-50' (Non -Subject)
Riparian Preservation
60418
1.387
0'-100'
No Credit
54,862
1.259
Total CE Area
11106, 294
25.397
N�U5E R1�R
w W W W
I W W W W W
W w w W w
W W w
w w
w w
W W
w
w w x
A5CEN51ON LAND 5URVEYING P.C. 0Or w
p
LINE LEGEND:
CE CONSERVATION EASEMENT DMS
— — RIGHT—OF—WAY
—PROPERTY LINE
-----------TOP OF BANK (BY OTHERS)
CONSERVATION
w w W EASEMENT BANK
1.
:i
rfr/
f/
ri I
f w w w
rr !
I
I
Dp r W W
-� O❑
❑ w w W w x
x
/ x
• w W w x
f 60 w w W
p w w y w sir'
�0
w w w +
I/❑S� W w w w x
f 4p
❑ W W w W x x
❑ y w Y
W W w W
w w
w Y x
EXI5TING 2Q' FORCEMAIN r�
EASEMENT
1
x
1
x fl
r
�00 X
CAKR�AFW�+AY
CREEK
sA.
iir I
r w
x �_Wr
x
x \ ��
f W
f
W W
W x
w w
w MATCHLINE
W w 100'
x I
w w
W
w x I
/
NOW OR FORMERLY
1
w w W X 11
x
f
ENVIRONMENTAL SANG 4
i
w
EXCHANGE LLC
+ X 1
1
P€N:2557-45-8424
b
P6 3775. PG 700
+ x 1
v w W W
Pa P. PG 72-D
W w.. x \4
250' 0' 250'
500'
TH15 MAP 15 NOT FOR RECORDATION, 5ALE5, OR
CONVEYANCES AND DOES NOT COMPLY WITH
G.S. 47-34
SCALE: 1 inch = 250 feet (11x17)
MAPPING REQUIRFMENT5.
m
m
y
m
I--
AS-BUILTSURVEY OF BUFFER AREAS FOR
REVISIONS. d4TEAND INITIAL
o
rn-<
f .O. BOX 145
o
II
N�
E
n
°�
m
i
2 W
CARRAWAY BLUFF MITIGATION SITE
SWANNANDA, NC 28778
r
mm
i
o{
a
R]
-[phone]
1
a
ti
NC DMS PROJ. # 100186 NEUSE RIVER BASIN
www.re5.us
w
BROGDEN TOWNSHIP WAYNE COUNTY NORTH CAROLINA
F- 1426

VICINITY MAP
NOT TO SCALE l
'Po
O� ti,E
SITE
� 19
0
WAYNE CO., NC
I, ELISABETH G. TURNER, AS A DULY REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL
LAND SURVEYOR IN THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, CERTIFY THAT
THIS BUFFER MAP WAS DRAWN UNDER MY SUPERVISION, IS AN
ACCURATE AND COMPLETE REPRESENTATION OF WHAT WAS
CONSTRUCTED IN THE FIELD, THAT THE EASEMENT BOUNDARY IS
BASED ON PLAT BOOK( SEE , PG NOTES RECORDED IN WAYNE
COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS OFFICE, AND THAT THE BUFFER AREAS
SHOWN ARE CALCULATED FROM AS -BUILT CONDITIONS EXCEPT
WHERE OTHERWISE NOTED HEREON. WITNESS MY ORIGINAL
SIGNATURE, REGISTRATION NUMBER, AND SEAL THIS 7th DAY OF
JULY, 2023.
111rr�r
CA1?o��l,�rr
0 r�5 S .
0�;9r9
ELISABETH G. TURNER, P.L.S. *L-4440 — SEAL —
- -r L-4440
LP SU
250' o' 250' 500'
SCALE: 1 inch = 250 feet (11x17)
CARRAWAY BLUFF MITIGATION SITE
N OTE5
. SEE SHEET I FOR
BUFFER AREA 5UMMARY
AND GENERAL N OTE5 .
LINE LEGEND:
CE CONSERVATION EASEMENT DMS
- - RIGHT-OF-WAY
-- —PROPERTY LINE
-----------TOP OF BANK (BY OTHERS)
y W y (CONSERVATION
w w w J EASEMENT BANK
CARRAWAY
CREEK
DEER
5TAN D
TH15 MAP 15 NOT FOR RECORDATION, 5ALE5, OR
CONVEYANCES AND DOE5 NOT COMPLY WITH G.5. 47-30
MAPPING REQUIREMENTS.
m
m
b
m
c
m
AS -BUILT SURVEY ❑F BUFFER AREAS FOR
REVISIONS, DATE AND INITIAL-
P.O. 13OX 145
fV 4
j
o
I
"
rn �
v
-
'm
W
`a�
a
CARRAWAY BLUFF MITIGATION SITE
SWANNANOA, NC z8778
_�
pres (91 9) 829-9905
iV
�g
N
NC DIMS PROJ. # 100186 NEUSE RIVER BASIN
www.re5.u5
�r
o
�•
-4
w
BROGDEN TOWNSHIP WAYNE COUNTY NORTH CAROLINA
F- 1 428

Appendix B
Vegetation Assessment Data

Planted Species Summary.
Common Name
Species
% of Total Species
-Proposed
% of Total
Species - Actual
Planted
Amount
River Birch
Betula nigra
15%
16%
2,080
Buttonbush
Cephalanthus occidentalis
5%
6%
780
Persimmon
Diospyros virginiana
5%
5%
650
American Sycamore
Platanus occidentalis
15%
15%
1,950
Overcup Oak
Quercus lyrata
10%
11%
1,430
Swamp Chestnut Oak
Quercus michauxii
10%
9%
1,170
Water Oak
Quercus nigra
10%
8%
1,040
Willow Oak
Quercus phellos
10%
8%
1,040
Northern Red Oak
Quercus rubra
10%
8%
1,040
Shumard's Oak
Quercus shumardii
10%
14%
1,820
Total:
13,000

Planted Acreage 16.25
Date of Initial Plant 2023-03-15
Dates) of Supplemental Pl-gy) NA
Dates).o NA
Date of Current Survey 2023-03-16
Plot size ACRES 0.0247
b-b.�h����oo00��0000��
®
���mm®mmmmmmmmmmm
��©©oo©0000©0000
M,ig.tim pl.
���0000©®0000©©oo
���0000©©00000000
1). Bolded species are proposed f—he current monitoring year, italicized species are not approved, and a regular font indicates [hat[he species has been approved.
2). The "Species Included in Approved Mitigation Plan" section contains only those species [hatwere included in the original approved mitigation plan. The "Port Mitigation Plan Species" section includes speces that are being proposed through a mitigation plan addendum far the current monitoring year (bolded), species that have been approved in prior
oring years through a mitigation plan addendum (regularfont), and species that are not approved (italicized).
3). nh "Mitigation Plan Performance Standard"section is derived only fromstems included inthe original mitigation plan, whereas the "Pon Mitigation Plan Performance Standard" includes data from mitigation plan approved,postmitigation plan approved, and proposed stems.

Vegetation
Performance Standards Summary Table
Veg Plot
1 F
Veg Plot
2 F
Veg Plot
3 F
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Monitoring Year 7
Monitoring Year 5
Monitoring Year 3
Monitoring Year 2
Monitoring Year 1
Monitoring Year 0
648
2
8
QJIL
810
2
Lj 8
0
769
2
10
Veg Plot
4 F
Veg Plot
5 F
Veg Plot
6 F
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Monitoring Year 7
Monitoring Year 5
Monitoring Year 3
Monitoring Year 2
Monitoring Year 1
Monitoring Year 0
729
1
8
0
729
1
8
0
972
1
7
0
Veg Plot
7 F
Veg Plot
8 F
Veg Plot
9 F
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Monitoring Year 7
Monitoring Year 5
Monitoring Year 3
Monitoring Year 2
Monitoring Year 1
Monitoring Year 0
688
1
7
0
810
1
8
0
891
1
8
0
Veg Plot 10 F
Veg Plot 11 F
Veg Plot 12 F
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Monitoring Year 7
Monitoring Year 5
Monitoring Year 3
Monitoring Year 2
Monitoring Year 1
Monitoring Year 0
769
1
6
729
1
6
0
931
1
6
0
Veg Plot 13 F
Veg Plot
14 F
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species
% Invasives
Stems/Ac.
Av. Ht. (ft)
# Species % Invasives
Monitoring Year 7
Monitoring Year 5
Monitoring Year 3
Monitoring Year 2
Monitoring Year 1
Monitoring Year 0
931
1
931
1
*Each monitoring year represents a different plot for the random vegetation plot "groups". Random plots are denoted with an R, and fixed plots with an F.

Visual Vegetation Assessment
Planted acreage 16.25
Vegetation Category
Definitions
Mapping
Threshold
Combined
Acreage
% of Planted
Acreage
Bare Areas
Very limited cover of both woody and herbaceous material.
0.10 acres
0.00
0.0%
Low Stem Density Areas
Woody stem densities clearly below target levels based on current MY stem count criteria.
0.10acres
0.00
0.0%
Total
0.00
0.0%
Areas of Poor Growth Rates
Planted areas where average height is not meeting current MY Performance Standard.
0.10 acres
0.00
0.0%
Cumulative Total
0.00
0.0%
Easement Acreage 50
Mapping
Combined
%of Easement
Vegetation Category
Definitions
Threshold
Acreage
Acreage
Invasives may occur outside of planted areas and within the easement and will therefore be calculated
against the total easement acreage- Include species with the potential to directly outcompete native,
Invasive Areas of Concern
0.10 acres
0.00
0.0%
young, woody stems in the short-term or community structure for existing communities. Species
included in summation above should be identified in report summary.
Encroachment may be point, line, or polygon. Encroachment to be mapped consists of any violation of
restrictions specified in the conservation easement. Common encroachments are mowing, cattle access,
Easement Encroachment Areas
none
#Encroachments noted
vehicular access. Encroachment has no threshold value as will need to be addressed regardless of impact
area.

Appendix C
As -built Photos

Carraway Bluff Phase I General Site Photos MYO 2023
Basal treatment on Chinese privet (3/l/2023)
Basal treatment on Bradford pear (3/l/2023)

Easement marker posts and signs installed (4/12/2023) Easement Marker Replacement (4/12/2023)

Carraway Sluff Phase I MYO Vegetation Monitoring Plot Photos
Vegetation Plot 1 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 3 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 2 (3/16/2023)
-, F-I
.: '�
Vegetation Plot 4 (3/16/2023)

Vegetation Plot 5 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 7 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 6 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 8 (3/16/2023)

Vegetation Plot 9 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 11 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 10 (3/16/2023)
Vegetation Plot 12 (3/21/2023)

=i
Vegetation Plot 13 (3/21/2023)
d
i x
Vegetation Plot 14 (3/21/2023)

Carraway Bluff Phase I MYO Maintenance Photos
Carraway Creek ESP (6/15/2023)
, W-
a.
V.
y ..[
Supplemental planting along BH2 TOB (5/30/2023)
4 jd Jp 1
A R p
BH2 ESP (6/23/2023)
Supplemental planting along BH1 TOB (6/22/2023)