Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0006564_Temperature Study_20230703June 26, 2023 Amir Adaryani, Environmental Engineer North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality Division of Water Resources 1611 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699 RE: NC0006564 Temperature Study Response to May 26, 2023 Letter Mr. Adaryani, Baxter RECEIVED JUL 0 3 2023 NCDEQ/DWR/NPDES Baxter Healthcare Corporation (Baxter) provides the following responses to correspondence from The Division of Water Resources (DWR) dated May 26, 2023. Baxter continues to explore a wide range of temperature assessment and control options, on track with the target dates outlined in the Temperature Compliance Schedule (TCS). The following are the enumerated responses requested within the letter: 1. Official Submittal: Any requests should be officially submitted to DWR for consideration along with a revised / updated copy of the May 1, 2023 "Temperature Study Submittal ". Response: At this time with the exception of item #4 below Baxter's internal process is on track to meet the TCS compliance dates. Z Temperature Variance: As discussed during the meeting variances are difficult to secure and require EPA approval. If the goal is to seek a temperature variances, please submit an official request. Be cognizant of the fact that variance request include a significant public process. Response: It is Baxter's intent to perform an extensive evaluation of our thermal wastewater discharge and the characteristics of the North Fork Catawba River in the vicinity of the facility to determine if a Clean Water Act Section 316(a) variance from the trout stream temperature standards is appropriate. Based on the information Baxter has obtained to this point, it appears compliance with the temperature standards for non -trout Class B waters will assure the protection and propagation of a balanced, indigenous population of shellfish, fish and wildlife in the receiving water. 3. Re -assessing Water Classification(s). As discussed during the meeting, changing existing water classifications is a lengthy and difficult process. If the goal is to request a classification change, please submit an official request. Be cognizant of the fact that such request / change(s) include a significant public process. Response: It is not Baxter's intent to change the exiting water classification(s). 4. Additional Time: If you wish to request an extension of the September 1, 2023 deadline to submit the Corrective Action Plan specified in Condition A. (3) of the NDPES permit, Baxter Hearheare Corporation PO Box 1390, Marion, NC 28752 T 828 756 4151 please submit an official request with a complete explanation of the reasons why an extension of time is necessary. This additional time maybe provided via a minor permit modification (per 40 CFR Part 122.63), provided the new date(s) are not more than 120 days after the interim compliance date(s) specified in the existing permit and it does not interfere with attainment of the final compliance date (March 1, 2026). Otherwise, this request (if justified), would require a major NPDES permit modification. Response: Per item 41 above and the June 1, 2023 submittal, Baxter has requested a 120 day extension of the Corrective Action Plan submittal deadline. This is to facilitate as complete an assessment of available options as can be achieved within the time provided. In addition, the extension will afford Baxter an opportunity to obtain additional surface water temperature and environmental data regarding the receiving stream in the vicinity of the facility. No other timelines within the TCS require revision/extension currently. S. All Contributing Flows: Evaluate and include in revised / updated report (including a revised/ updated Table 2-1) each flow from the facility with any thermal contribution to influent (not only major ones) such as boiler blowdown, DW Auxiliary, sterilization, extrusion, cooling tower blowdown, overflows, etcetera. Include in this evaluation at a minimum the: flow, temperature, and destination (e.g., Cooling Recirculation or WWTP) for each flow with a thermal contribution. For the overflow from the cooling ponds that is sent to the WWTP, this evaluation should also include an explanation of the circumstances under which overflow is sent to the WWTP, the frequency of overflow, the volume/flow of overflow, the temperature of overflow, and the impact of overflow on the effluent temperature. Appendices A and B of the submitted study should be revised as necessary. Response: Attached is a revised water and temperature balance figure (Figure 1) and table (Table 1) of heat each process and the conditions resulting in wastewater discharge. The. The discharges from these sources are not overflow as defined within NPDES permitting/operation conditions because, 1. These discharges do not bypass the wastewater treatment facility and, 2. The systems equipped with high level bypasses allowing gravity discharge to the wastewater treatment facility contain treated water in a retention basin for temperature reduction and emergency water supply management. 6. Data Richness and Diurnal Monitoring: Data richness plays an essential role in compliance determination and next steps. Please provide diurnal monitoring results (hourly or more frequent) for the effluent in comparison with ambient air temperature, and heat exchange capacity. Response: Please find attached a table of the requested data currently available (Table 2). Upstream, downstream, and effluent temperatures are from the Jacobs Engineering fish community study. The wastewater treatment facility has effluent temperature data that currently can be tracked in three-hour increments. The facility is not equipped with a data logging weather station to be able to provide ambient air temperature, if required this would be sourced from the nearest publicly available weather station data. As the facility does not have ambient air temperature data a heat exchange capacity cannot be provided within the 30 day timeframe. This is expected to be part of the assessment within the Corrective Action Plan, as this information will directly inform the viability of mechanical heat exchange. options.. Z New Monitoring Data and spreadsheet Format: Provide the new monitoring data from this study (excluding eDMR) in an original spreadsheet format for further examination. Response: An excel file of this data and the table referenced in item #6 is included with the electronic submission of this response letter. 8. Fish Community Study: Provide fish community study results. Response: The finalized report prepared by Jacobs Engineering is attached (Attachment 1). 9. Details on New Operations: Provide evaluation for adopting new operation plans due to FDA requirements in comparison to current operation status in regards thermal contribution to effluent. If such evaluation is not feasible currently, please provide a timeline on when it would be available. Response: FDA compliance for pharmaceutical products is based on achieved results, and therefore no explicit regulatory rules governing new operational plans or projects can be referenced. The requirements for sterilization are a performance -based standard, i.e., Baxter must ensure that its product is sterile, with no acceptable levels of bioburden in final sterilized product. The North Cove site's terminally sterilized drug products are manufactured in accordance with the site's comprehensive control programs that, among other things, ensure that: • pre -sterilization bioburden is adequately controlled; • terminal sterilization is effective; • bacterial endotoxin testing (BET) meets established specifications prior to release • the primary packaging of the site's products is integral. The North Cove facility integrates process improvements designed to control bioburden prior to sterilization. The currently planned operational updates related to this as well as WWTP discharge are: WFI 2.0 — A replacement system of our current water distribution system for solutions mixing. This will be entering validation during summer of 2023, expected to be significantly complete before end of 2023. During validation an increase of approximately 40,000 gallons of heated water will be produced. After validation a storage tank currently used as part of the active WFI system will be used as a holding vessel for boiler re -use. This is a production side component that will be part of the engineering assessment within the Corrective Action Plan. WFI 2.0 is a key part of our new mixing system as well as providing significant control and process improvements over current WFI water distribution. North Mixing — A new solutions mixing facility utilizing bulk container raw material loading and closed system mixing, greatly reducing the potential for contamination within solutions resulting in one-off discharged batches of solutions to the WWTP. 10. Other Details Discussed DuringMeeting. Provide requested details not captured in above items but mentioned in the meeting by DWR staff orAG office. Response: To the best of Baxter staff recollection the above captures all relevant items mentioned during the meeting. Baxter Sincerely, Derek Bouchard Environmental Manager Well Water 1466 ---h North Cove Water Balance Average Production Days12022) Legend IInccmin&/R— Wets, Drains 7empemt'ares recorded WPI Production AN Temps presented in -F All Fi— presented in 1000 901/day Garcons wTra!ns i:ills 326� Prod_tt Bacawash Regeneration Biowdown Sanidxation 6 Mist Drains 29 1 26 1 53 1 153 1 1.,— Steam Production Candensate Return Bolters I I Steam NXS NVAC $aNCaations DW 'riX is r_9% 6r6ons a 4% Regereration Slowdown Steam Concensate 16 17 301 1 1 1 ) Evaporation 193 151 SMillxer Charge Water + Cot Softeners $[eririxrs Regenen[:on S—Mmer discharge to 5A Sump 16 6E Evaporation 75 _ocling rowers —•�150 Cooling Towers Regeneration 76 1 Sanitary ► 32 Sanitary To dra n 32 4 Production Waste ano Seormwater Intrusion ----0 60 Prod. Waste/ Stormwagr To drain 646 y rry H ' Co01 :g N:nwayl Fond Av3 —F:na 77 98 ,M,a Tamp 92 141 _ M:-. Tc:_.,p 65 78 T:1 Way 1E Treat— Plat Table 1- Facility Process Flow and Heat Values Source Flow (K ¢al-/ Discharge (k Tema favu- Ft rloctinntinn Carbon Filtration ----_ -------------- Deio_nizatio_n Tr_ain_—_-------- Distillation_—__ ___ Sanitiza_tion & _Misc Drains-- --- Product ---_---------- -------- 587 ------ -- 558 532 --- 153 —_ 326 — -- 29 ------- -- _ 26 5_3 --- 153 --- 0 -- ----- ---------------------- — —65 Carbon filtration before rest of WFI system. Discharge is from backwash filter cleaning —_—_— — _—�—_ 65 Deionization of filtered water, discharge is regenerative process water 212 Distillation of water prior to product use —___ —_—_—_—_—_—_--_--.___ ---------- _---- _8_5_W_ater used for dry cleaning dry filling, and other sterile water applications not in -product — — — — — — — — — — ---- ----- -- --- — 85 Water used in production — —--------- Total Discharge 261 _ ----------------------------------- — ------------- 110 Discharges through BR Sump along with Steam Production discharge, collective average of 110 F Boiler P_retreat_m_e_n_t-------_—_ Boilers _ ---------------------------- Steam _Heat _Exchangers ------ _ — 327 311 -------- _--- 101 _ _ 1_6 17 ------ — — 101 65 Regenerative cycle_ on boiler pretreatment process__ 212 Boiler producing steam for sterilizer operations — — — —_--_—_—_—_--_—_- -------------------------------------------------------------------------- NA --_ Heat exchanger system_, re_arculates 21 kgal. Of heated water back into boiler system__ Total Discharge _— --___ --- 134 110 Discharges through BR Sump along with WFI Syst_e_m_dischage, collective average of 110 F�— Transfer from Boiler to Sterilization -- 193 —_— Steam transferred from boiler system to sterilizers, is the differential between 327 kgal. In and 134 kgal. Discharge 185-212-- Product Sterilization 310 — -- Softeners —_— — —----------- ---- Sterilizers _ --_ _ _ 310 _487 _ 16 — _6_8 65 Softened well water to charge steam ovens for sterilization process - ---------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------- ---------------------y--------------------process 185 Softened char a water and 19_3 kgal./da of steam from boiler Cooling Ponds 419 — 268 _ ---____ —g _�-- ---- --- 78 Sterilizer water discharges into cooling ponds -- Cooling Pond Evaporation------ Total Discharge --- — -- _--- 151 _-- --___ -- 352 NA _ Evaporation of water in cooling ponds, assisted by mechanical spray system_ Varies---- Total discharge is via SA Sump and Cooling ponds, 89 F and 78 F average temps respectively — _-- Evaporation_ Regeneration--------------- 75 ----- --- 75 ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sanitary 60 50 5 Water for sanitary facilities use by facility staff Production Waste and SW Intrusion — 75 Discard product solutions and discard solution tnixes discharged to WW f P, system sterilization water, drain systems Temperatures not listed on Figure 1- Simplified Water Balance are approximate values based on known process conditions, i.e. groundwater source is 65 F, distillation occurs at 212 F, steam sterilization target is 185, average santiary temp 75. RECEIVED JUL 0 3 ,2023 NCDEQIDWRINPDES Table 2 - Fish Community Studv Temperature Data Date Time North Cove SchoolMidway lyitts Station Old Linville Lake James Outfaff 1/31/202311:00 8.48 8.98 22.68 1/31/202312:00 8.66 9.20 9.04 8.98 22.71 1/31/202313:00 8.89 9.42 9.36 9.23 22.81 1/31/202314:00 9.13 9.68 9.47 9.47 22.90 1/31/202315:00 9.43 9.93 9.86 9.75 22.96 1/31/202316:00 9.67 10.11 10.05 9.95 23.02 1/31/2023 17:00 9.84 10.20 10.18 10.10 23.05 1/31/2023 18:00 9.89 10.18 10.20 10.13 23.07 1/31/2023 19:00 9.88 10.14 10.18 10.14 23.03 1/31/2023 20:00 9.87 10.10 10.14 10.12 23.07 1/31/2023 21:00 9.83 10.07 10.14 10.10 23.07 1/31/2023 22:00 9.90 10.05 10.12 10.11 23.15 1/31/2023 23:00 9.78 10.02 10.10 10.10 23.15 2/1/2023 0:00 9.72 10.02 10.01 10.07 23.10 2/1/20231:00 9.68 9.98 10.07 10.07 23.11 2/1/2023 2:00 9.61 9.79 10.02 10.04 21.64 2/1/2023 3:00 9.55 9.69 9.84 10.03 23.20 2/1/2023 4:00 9.51 9.86 9.81 9.95 23.16 2/1/2023 5:00 9.45 9.62 9.90 9.92 23.11 2/1/2023 6:00 9.38 9.84 9.66 9.85 23.03 2/1/2023 7:00 9.29 9.72 9.78 9.68 23.12 2/1/2023 8:00 9.19 9.51 9.72 9.61 23.10 2/1/2023 9:00 9.18 9.53 9.51 9.54 23.01 2/1/202310:00 9.19 9.67 9.63 9.55 23.01 2/1/202311:00 9.35 9.81 9.75 9.79 23.00 2/1/202312:00 9.43 9.99 9.95 10.02 23.00 2/1/2023 13:00 9.64 10.27 10.14 10.41 22.95 2/1/2023 14:00 9.95 10.47 10.34 10.66 22.92 2/1/2023 15:00 10.10 10.50 10.52 10.66 22.86 2/1/2023 16:00 10.15 10.46 10.54 10.63 22.74 2/1/2023 17:00 10.14 10.43 10.47 10.52 22.66 2/1/2023 18:00 10.06 10.34 10.40 10.41 22.76 2/1/2023 19:00 9.95 10.36 10.30 10.28 22.02 2/1/2023 20:00 9.74 10.29 10.33 10.14 23.11 2/1/2023 21:00 9.56 10.04 10.30 10.00 22.92 2/1/2023 22:00 9.38 9.78 10.03 9.88 22.89 2/1/2023 23:00 9.20 9.59 9.78 9.77 22.77 2/2/2023 0:00 9.07 9.44 9.60 9.68 22.73 2/2/20231:00 8.95 9.32 9.43 9.59 22.70 2/2/2023 2:00 8.84 9.20 9.31 9.44 22.65 2/2/2023 3:00 8.69 9.08 9.19 9.29 22.60 2/2/2023 4:00 8.56 8.93 9.07 9.13 22.54 2/2/2023 5:00 8.47 8.80 8.90 8.96 22.52 2/2/2023 6:00 8.38 8.77 8.85 8.86 22.51 Table 2 - Fish Studv Terneerature Data Date Time North Cove Szhooi Midwpy Pitts Station Old Linville Lake iarrt 2/2/2023 7:00 8.29 8.65 8.79 8.77 22.50 2/2/2023 8:00 8.17 8.68 8.66 8.68 22.44 2/2/2023 9:00 8.15 8.66 8.67 8.55 22.40 2/2/202310:00 8.09 8.66 8.62 8.58 22.48 2/2/202311:00 8.21 9.00 8.71 8.65 22.51 2/2/202312:00 8.56 9.21 9.02 8.88 22.51 2/2/202313:00 8.82 9.28 9.21 8.99 22.48 2/2/202314:00 8.85 9.31 9.30 9.11 22.49 2/2/202315:00 8.95 9.33 9.32 9.19 22.36 2/2/202316:00 9.09 9.40 9.37 9.32 22.37 2/2/202317:00 9.12 9.36 9.35 9.27 22.31 2/2/202318:00 9.06 9.26 9.33 9.27 22.30 2/2/202319:00 8.95 9.18 9.26 9.19 22.32 2/2/2023 20:00 8.84 9.32 9.21 9.13 22.45 2/2/2023 21:00 8.79 9.14 9.31 9.06 22.43 2/2/2023 22:00 8.64 9.05 9.10 8.96 22.36 2/2/2023 23:00 8.51 8.95 9.07 8.82 22.22 2/3/2023 0:00 8.33 8.79 8.91 8.72 22.18 2/3/20231:00 8.19 8.64 8.69 8.60 22.10 2/3/2023 2:00 7.99 8.26 8.59 8.45 21.98 2/3/2023 3:00 7.73 8.07 8.22 8.29 21.92 2/3/2023 4:00 7.52 7.93 8.03 8.09 21.89 2/3/2023 5:00 7.28 7.67 7.88 7.87 21.80 2/3/2023 6:00 6.94 7.43 7.65 7.66 21.71 2/3/2023 7:00 6.62 7.09 7.35 7.40 21.58 2/3/2023 8:00 6.37 6.72 6.99 7.19 21.45 2/3/2023 9:00 6.15 6.50 6.67 7.02 21.41 2/3/202310:00 6.03 6.55 6.56 6.90 21.33 2/3/202311:00 6.03 6.74 6.66 6.99 21.35 2/3/202312:00 6.19 7.22 6.94 7.30 21.38 2/3/202313:00 6.59 7.45 7.41 7.68 21.40 2/3/202314:00 7.01 7.88 7.63 8.11 20.52 2/3/202315:00 7.42 8.09 7.97 8.44 21.38 2/3/202316:00 7.67 8.01 8.18 8.59 21.20 2/3/202317:00 7.69 7.90 8.03 8.48 21.14 2/3/202318:00 7.42 7.60 7.85 8.09 21.02 2/3/202319:00 7.07 7.05 7.51 7.72 20.87 2/3/2023 20:00 6.79 6.76 6.97 7.26 20.78 2/3/2023 21:00 6.52 6.60 6.73 6.80 20.77 2/3/2023 22:00 6.11 6.29 6.54 6.48 20.62 2/3/2023 23:00 5.74 5.96 6.21 6.11 20.61 2/4/2023 0:00 5.50 5.56 5.87 5.88 20.60 2/4/20231:00 5.22 5.33 5.55 5.56 20.41 2/4/2023 2:00 4.95 5.20 5.27 5.25 20.94 Bate Time 2/4/2023 3:00 2/4/2023 4:00 2/4/2023 5:00 2/4/2023 6:00 2/4/2023 7:00 2/4/2023 8:00 2/4/2023 9:00 2/4/2023 10:00 2/4/2023 11:00 2/4/2023 12:00 2/4/2023 13:00 2/4/2023 14:00 2/4/2023 15:00 2/4/2023 16:00 2/4/2023 17:00 2/4/2023 18:00 2/4/2023 19:00 2/4/2023 20:00 2/4/2023 21:00 2/4/2023 22:00 2/4/2023 23:00 2/5/2023 0:00 2/5/2023 1:00 2/5/2023 2:00 2/5/2023 3:00 2/5/2023 4:00 2/5/2023 5:00 2/5/2023 6:00 2/5/2023 7:00 2/5/2023 8:00 2/5/2023 9:00 2/5/2023 10:00 2/5/2023 11:00 2/5/2023 12:00 2/5/2023 13:00 2/5/2023 14:00 2/5/2023 15:00 2/5/2023 16:00 2/5/2023 17:00 2/5/2023 18:00 2/5/2023 19:00 2/5/2023 20:00 2/5/2023 21:00 2/5/2023 22:00 able 2 - Fish Communitv Studv Temperature Data Borth Cove School Midway Pitts Station Old Linville Lake lames 4.68 5.04 5.15 5.03 4.44 4.99 4.98 4.77 4.26 4.83 4.99 4.51 4.06 4.63 4.83 4.28 3.86 4.39 4.63 4.15 3.71 4.31 4.35 3.98 3.59 4.18 4.29 3.88 3.68 4.54 4.28 4.02 3.88 4.94 4.61 4.34 4.34 4.84 5.42 6.00 6.46 6.72 6.71 6.60 6.46 6.29 6.04 5.79 5.57 5.30 5.11 4.93 4.75 4.60 4.41 4.26 4.09 4.03 4.23 4.65 5.19 5.72 6.33 7.07 7.51 7.79 7.98 7.86 7.73 7.49 7.27 5.36 5.95 6.52 6.88 7.07 7.09 7.08 6.93 6.78 6.30 6.12 5.81 5.51 5.28 5.24 5.04 4.86 4.90 4.60 4.42 4.36 4.35 4.99 5.41 6.17 6.49 7.31 8.03 8.16 8.34 8.38 S.18 8.02 7.72 7.39 5.07 5.52 6.13 6.65 6.99 7.06 7.04 7.03 6.89 6.73 6.29 6.09 5.77 5.51 5.29 5.22 5.01 4.87 4.90 4.62 4.45 4.43 4.44 5.16 5.52 6.28 6.69 7.44 8.03 8.19 8.29 8.29 8.13 7.97 7.64 4.88 5.41 6.05 6.62 6.99 7.10 6.99 6.75 6.47 6.26 6.05 5.89 5.74 5.55 5.40 5.22 5.03 4.89 4.71 4.52 4.32 4.26 4.42 4.89 5.47 5.94 6.51 7.16 7.61 7.83 7.88 7.81 7.65 7.45 7.26 Outtall 20.9 i 20.88 20.81 20.82 20.74 20.69 20.70 20.69 20.73 20.75 20.88 20.90 20.90 20.86 20.86 20.84 20.76 20.78 19.77 19.78 19.85 19.94 19.95 19.83 19.83 19.72 19.78 19.71 19.77 19.76 19.97 20.08 20.47 20.44 20.28 20.44 21.34 21.44 21.64 21.57 21.51 21.61 21.65 21.51 Table 2 - Fish Communitv Studv Temperature Data Date Time North Cove School: tAldway Pitts Station Old Linville Lake lames OutfaN 2/5/2023 23:00 6.97 7.20 7.31 7.10 21.75 2/6/2023 0:00 6.81 7.02 7.19 7.08 21.73 2/6/20231:00 6.56 6.81 6.96 6.92 21.80 2/6/2023 2:00 6.29 6.72 6.72 6.84 21.73 2/6/2023 3:00 6.19 6.64 6.74 6.75 21.62 2/6/2023 4:00 6.13 6.61 6.65 6.67 21.56 2/6/2023 5:00 6.10 6.49 6.58 6.54 21.70 2/6/2023 6:00 6.03 6.41 6.51 6.40 21.58 2/6/2023 7:00 5.88 5.06 6.38 6.28 21.03 2/6/2023 8:00 5.86 6.06 6.09 6.18 21.02 2/6/2023 9:00 5.81 6.19 6.07 6.15 21.03 2/6/202310:00 5.96 6.50 6.33 6.33 21.02 2/6/202311:00 6.28 6.95 6.62 6.7S 20.51 2/6/202312:00 6.79 7.65 7.13 7.38 21.30 2/6/202313:00 7.43 8.42 7.90 8.04 21.37 2/6/202314:00 8.08 9.02 8.66 8.75 21.50 2/6/202315:00 8.72 9.52 9.23 9.38 21.56 2/6/202316:00 9.23 9.64 9.61 9.79 21.29 2/6/202317:00 9.47 9.65 9.67 9.94 21.29 2/6/202318:00 9.44 9.46 9.65 9.81 21.20 2/6/202319:00 9.22 9.22 9.47 9.53 21.24 2/6/2023 20:00 9.00 8.92 9.22 9.19 21.25 2/6/2023 21:00 8.72 8.64 8.93 9.77 21.15 2/6/2023 22:00 8.39 8.29 8.64 8.40 21.27 2/6/2023 23:00 8.00 8.16 8.28 8.08 21.68 2/7/2023 0:00 7.60 7.79 8.12 7.80 21.60 2/7/20231:00 7.23 7.45 7.72 7.48 21.55 2/7/2023 2:00 6.85 7.15 7.42 7.23 21.49 2/7/2023 3:00 6.52 6.85 7.12 6.95 21.40 2/7/2023 4:00 6.24 6.63 6.87 6.71 21.24 2/7/2023 5:00 5.91 6.32 6.62 6.50 21.19 2/7/2023 6:00 5.66 6.06 6.32 6.26 21.16 2/7/2023 7:00 5.42 5.84 6.03 6.03 21.02 2/7/2023 8:00 5.24 5.69 5.87 5.81 21.06 2/7/2023 9:00 5.17 5.79 5.72 5.71 21.16 2/7/202310:00 5.32 6.12 5.94 5.80 21.37 2/7/202311:00 5.70 6.75 6.26 6.24 21.59 2/7/202312:00 6.28 7.52 6.92 6.94 21.85 2/7/202313:00 7.03 8.28 7.73 7.68 21.97 2/7/202314:00 7.73 9.01 8.53 8.40 22.17 2/7/202315:00 8.45 9.45 9.18 9.05 22.30 2/7/202316:00 8.89 9.71 9.48 9.45 22.48 2/7/202317:00 9.30 9.82 9.71 9.65 22.46 2/7/202318:00 9.41 9.75 9.75 9.71 22.35 Table 2 - Fish Cornm pity Studv Temerature Data WI North Cove School Midway Pitts Station Old Linville LakeJames QutfaN 2/7/202319:00 9.36 9.67 9.72 9.52 22.35 2/7/2023 20:00 9.27 9.33 9.59 9.35 21.56 2/7/2023 21:00 9.07 9.06 9.21 9.04 21.55 2/7/2023 22:00 8.84 8.82 9.00 8.81 21.60 2/7/2023 23:00 8.51 8.56 8.73 8.53 21.72 2/8/2023 0:00 8.21 8.23 8.46 8.29 21.75 2/8/20231:00 7.84 8.00 8.19 8.05 21.78 2/8/2023 2:00 7.54 7.56 7.91 7.77 21.74 2/8/2023 3:00 7.27 7.40 7.55 7.55 22.07 2/8/2023 4:00 7.02 7.27 7.32 7.37 21.85 2/8/2023 5:00 6.76 6.85 7.23 7.19 18.80 2/8/2023 6:00 6.57 6.86 6.82 7.02 22.00 2/8/2023 7:00 6.41 6.73 6.81 6.84 22.06 2/8/2023 8:00 6.33 6.70 6.69 6.73 22.04 2/8/2023 9:00 6.33 6.79 6.70 6.72 22.05 2/8/202310:00 6.47 7.03 6.83 6.85 22.17 2/8/202311:00 6.70 7.46 7.07 7.06 22.18 2/8/202312:00 7.07 7.99 7.47 7.45 22.02 2/8/202313:00 7.46 8.31 8.04 7.79 22.18 2/8/202314:00 7.81 8.64 8.35 8.13 22.30 2/8/202315:00 8.21 8.92 8.71 8.41 22.35 2/8/202316:00 8.47 9.13 8.95 8.70 22.41 2/8/202317:00 8.72 9.11 9.16 8.92 22.03 2/8/202318:00 8.88 9.25 9.11 9.07 22.08 2/8/202319:00 8.97 9.35 9.21 9.17 22.20 2/8/2023 20:00 9.05 9.42 9.30 9.22 22.27 2/8/2023 21:00 9.10 9.48 9.40 9.30 22.28 2/8/2023 22:00 9.14 9.44 9.46 9.28 22.33 2/8/2023 23:00 9.12 9.47 9.46 9.24 22.39 2/9/2023 0:00 9.05 9.45 9.46 9.22 22.38 2/9/20231:00 8.98 9.65 9.44 9.24 22.99 2/9/2023 2:00 8.92 9.62 9.59 9.24 23.03 2/9/2023 3:00 8.92 9.54 9.59 9.25 23.05 2/9/2023 4:00 8.83 9.44 9.51 9.16 23.04 2/9/2023 5:00 8.71 9.38 9.41 9.10 23.08 2/9/2023 6:00 8.63 9.34 9.35 9.11 23.08 2/9/2023 7:00 8.55 9.24 9.28 9.05 23.12 2/9/2023 8:00 8.50 9.21 9.21 9.02 23.09 2/9/2023 9:00 8.52 9.37 9.16 8.99 23.11 2/9/202310:00 8.59 9.68 9.37 9.12 23.16 2/9/202311:00 8.90 9.98 9.76 9.49 23.27 2/9/202312:00 9.27 10.57 10.04 9.96 23.40 2/9/2023 13:00 9.82 10.65 10.65 10.32 22.89 2/9/2023 14:00 10.15 11.02 10.73 10.53 22.97 Table 2 - Fish Cornmunity Studv Ternoeratu,-e Data Date Time North Clue School Midway Pitts Station Old Linville Lake James Outfall 2/9/2023 15:00 10.62 11.43 11.12 10.86 23.00 2/9/2023 16:00 11.12 11.81 11.51 11.12 23.01 2/9/2023 17:00 11.38 11.90 11.83 11.40 23.07 2/9/2023 18:00 11.45 11.70 11.91 11.49 23.08 2/9/2023 19:00 11.41 11.65 11.70 11.46 23.37 2/9/2023 20:00 11.38 11.57 11.64 11.44 23.59 2/9/2023 21:00 11.28 11.46 11.55 11.43 23.61 2/9/2023 22:00 11.07 11.21 11.40 11.33 23.63 2/9/2023 23:00 10.81 11.02 11.21 11.17 23.61 2/10/2023 0:00 10.51 10.76 10.97 10.95 23.26 2/10/2023 1:00 10.24 10.51 10.71 10.77 23.57 2/10/2023 2:00 9.98 10.11 10.46 10.59 23.49 2/10/2023 3:00 9.74 10.09 10.20 10.43 21.27 2/10/2023 4:00 9.63 10.15 10.10 10.29 23.25 2/10/2023 5:00 9.47 10.24 10.11 10.11 23.25 2/10/2023 6:00 9.24 9.94 10.19 9.89 23.28 2/10/2023 7:00 9.01 9.70 9.89 9.66 23.17 2/10/2023 8:00 8.83 9.50 9.65 9.49 23.18 2/10/2023 9:00 8.69 9.55 9.53 9.36 23.14 2/10/202310:00 8.78 9.74 9.64 9.43 23.01 2/10/202311:00 9.00 9.96 9.97 9.84 23.13 2/10/2023 12:00 9.45 10.61 10.24 10.45 23.13 2/10/2023 13:00 10.08 11.27 10.87 11.17 23.18 2/10/2023 14:00 10.67 11.69 11.56 11.78 23.24 2/10/2023 15:00 10.98 11.95 11.84 12.16 23.22 2/10/2023 16:00 11.33 11.90 12.01 12.43 23.10 2/10/2023 17:00 11.50 11.80 11.89 12.41 23.08 2/10/2023 18:00 11.42 11.65 11.85 12.21 22.98 2/10/2023 19:00 11.25 11.64 11.64 11.90 22.95 2/10/2023 20:00 11.03 11.49 11.55 11.63 23.21 2/10/2023 21:00 10.80 11.28 11.46 11.32 23.26 2/10/2023 22:00 10.63 11.10 11.31 11.08 23.23 2/10/2023 23:00 10.40 10.84 11.06 10.85 23.19 2/11/2023 0:00 10.19 10.68 10.84 10.60 23.15 2/11/2023 1:00 9.99 10.35 10.68 10.43 23.07 2/11/2023 2:00 9.76 10.03 10.36 10.29 22.79 2/11/2023 3:00 9.57 9.90 10.04 10.13 22.81 2/11/2023 4:00 9.35 9.75 9.93 9.97 22.81 2/11/2023 5:00 9.17 9.60 9.75 9.81 22.83 2/11/2023 6:00 9.00 9.37 9.58 9.66 22.82 2/11/2023 7:00 8.79 9.14 9.37 9.48 22.80 2/11/2023 8:00 8.50 9.03 9.15 9.24 22.78 2/11/2023 9:00 8.37 9.04 9.04 9.13 22.75 2/11/202310:00 8.45 9.20 9.08 9.18 22.76 2/11/2023 11:00 2/11/2023 12:00 2/11/2023 13:00 2/11/2023 14:00 2/11/2023 15:00 2/11/2023 16:00 2/11/2023 17:00 2/11/2023 18:00 2/11/2023 19:00 2/11/2023 20:00 2/11/2023 21:00 2/11/2023 22:00 2/11/2023 23:00 2/12/2023 0:00 2/12/2023 1:00 2/12/2023 2:00 2/12/2023 3:00 2/12/2023 4:00 2/12/2023 5:00 2/12/2023 6:00 2/12/2023 7:00 2/12/2023 8:00 2/12/2023 9:00 2/12/2023 10:00 2/12/2023 11:00 2/12/2023 12:00 2/12/2023 13:00 2/12/2023 14:00 2/12/2023 15:00 2/12/2023 16:00 2/12/2023 17:00 2/12/2023 18:00 2/12/2023 19:00 2/12/2023 20:00 2/12/2023 21:00 2/12/2023 22:00 2/12/2023 23:00 2/13/2023 0:00 2/13/2023 1:00 2/13/2023 2:00 2/13/2023 3:00 2/13/2023 4:00 2/13/2023 5:00 2/13/2023 6:00 able 2 - Fish Comer°u.nity S- u v Ternoerature Data North Cave School Midway Pitts Stations Old Linville Lake JamesIj 8.71 9.61 9.29 9.46 22.84 8.96 9.76 9.65 9.73 22.80 9.14 10.08 9.76 9.82 22.83 9.58 10.10 10.22 10.17 22.82 9.66 10.08 10.11 10.17 22.78 9.63 10.09 10.07 10.22 22.75 9.65 9.94 10.09 10.17 22.78 9.57 10.00 9.95 10.07 22.76 9.47 9.83 10.02 9.98 23.12 9.38 9.76 9.84 9.82 23.21 9.22 9.51 9.73 9.66 23.21 8.98 9.29 9.44 9.44 21.16 8.79 9.08 9.22 9.21 22.30 8.21 8.67 8.96 8.71 22.20 7.92 8.15 8.60 8.44 22.21 7.83 7.71 7.60 7.40 7.28 7.16 7.16 7.09 7.12 7.26 7.46 7.66 7.82 8.01 8.20 8.26 8.25 8.15 8.01 7.87 7.67 7.44 7.18 6.92 6.72 7.97 7.86 7.82 7.64 7.56 7.66 7.59 7.44 7.39 7.51 7.72 8.02 8.17 8.28 8.34 8.43 8.42 8.28 8.11 7.76 7.47 7.28 7.09 6.86 6.63 8.19 7.97 7.84 7.74 7.60 7.47 7.53 7.45 7.42 7.43 7.51 7.74 7.97 8.16 8.30 8.34 8.35 8.32 8.22 8.12 7.75 7.46 7.23 7.08 6.84 6.56 6.49 6.61 6.37 6.29 6.45 6.27 6.25 6.33 6.18 6.17 6.23 8.29 8.08 7.97 7.86 7.58 7.43 7.32 7.25 7.22 7.30 7.44 7.59 7.65 7.87 8.09 8.22 8.22 8.18 8.05 7.88 7.73 7.47 7.25 7.01 6.84 6.68 6.48 6.31 6.17 22.17 22.18 22.09 22.15 22.09 22.14 22.08 21.95 21.85 21.89 21.87 22.03 22.07 22.06 21.93 21.94 21.84 21.83 21.77 18.26 22.35 22.00 21.96 22.44 22.36 22.26 22.13 22.06 22.02 Table 2 - Fish Communitv Studv Temperature Data Gate Trine NorthCove School" WdPiP tts Statior. ClId Urnrille Lake farnes Outfa# 2/13/2023 7:00 6.11 6.17 6.15 6.00 21.92 2/13/2023 8:00 6.01 6.14 6.07 5.93 21.86 2/13/2023 9:00 6.04 6.28 6.09 5.95 21.87 2/13/202310:00 6.18 6.52 6.23 6.10 21.80 2/13/202311:00 6.45 6.63 6.47 6.35 21.77 2/13/202312:00 6.69 6.86 6.65 6.65 21.67 2/13/202313:00 7.09 7.66 6.96 7.20 21.73 2/13/202314:00 7.79 8.49 7.82 7.99 21.78 2/13/202315:00 8.52 9.05 8.64 8.69 21.88 2/13/202316:00 9.04 9.37 9.17 9.12 21.72 2/13/202317:00 9.30 9.34 9.32 9.26 21.12 2/13/202318:00 9.33 9.37 9.30 9.23 21.06 2/13/202319:00 9.22 9.13 9.27 9.08 20.98 2/13/2023 20:00 8.95 8.84 9.06 8.77 20.95 2/13/2023 21:00 8.57 8.52 8.77 8.60 20.94 2/13/2023 22:00 8.23 8.18 8.45 8.35 20.92 2/13/2023 23:00 7.90 7.86 8.09 8.07 20.90 2/14/2023 0:00 7.60 7.60 7.81 7.80 20.87 2/14/20231:00 7.32 7.44 7.58 7.59 20.85 2/14/2023 2:00 7.12 7.27 7.34 7.31 20.72 2/14/2023 3:00 6.94 7.20 7.20 7.12 21.55 2/14/2023 4:00 6.79 7.12 7.12 6.90 21.57 2/14/2023 5:00 6.65 7.00 7.07 6.65 21.51 2/14/2023 6:00 6.54 6.83 6.90 6.50 21.40 2/14/2023 7:00 6.42 6.69 6.76 6.41 21.33 2/14/2023 8:00 6.29 6.49 6.60 6.28 21.31 2/14/2023 9:00 6.22 6.59 6.46 6.23 21.49 2/14/202310:00 6.36 7.01 6.63 6.44 21.47 2/14/202311:00 7.072037 6.923508 21.71039 2/14/2023 12:00 7.634399 18.1282 2/14/2023 13:00 8.542587 22.0107 2/14/2023 14:00 21.34563 RECEIVED NCDEQ/DWR/NPDES