20201937 Ver 2_DWR AsBuilt Review - Dead Tree Phase A_20230130

From: Merritt, Katie
To: Baker. Caroline D
Subject: FW: DWR AsBuilt Review - Dead Tree Phase A
Date: Monday, January 30, 2023 3:38:06 PM
Attachments: 20191639 Ver 2 Mitigation As -Built Plans 20211015.odf
20200047 Ver 2 AsBuilt Survey Signed 20210930.odf
Please file email thread and attachments as 1 pdf and title file same as subject of email. For
2020-1937v2
From: Merritt, Katie
Sent: Monday, January 30, 2023 3:37 PM
To: Barrett Jenkins<[e-mail]>
Subject: FW: DWR AsBuilt Review - Dead Tree Phase A
Barrett,
I forgot to mention that I included a couple of survey examples in the email below so that you
can see what I am referring to with regards to my comments.
Thanks,
Katie
From: Merritt, Katie
Sent: Monday, January 30, 2023 3:36 PM
To: Barrett Jenkins <bienkinsna restorationsystems.com>
Subject: DWR AsBuilt Review - Dead Tree Phase A
Hey Barrett,
I have finalized my review of the Dead Tree Phase A As -Built Report submitted to DWR by
Restoration Systems, LLC on September 19, 2022. As a result of the review, DWR has the
following comments that need to be addressed:
1. The report is lacking in the following:
a. Signed & Sealed survey - the survey provided is inadequate. The survey
should not include the Project Credit Table in place of accurate
measurements taken by the surveyor. The measurements taken by the
surveyor are used to compare with the Credit Table in the Report, which are
two separate documents DWR uses to compare for accuracy and
consistency. As described the approved UMBI for this site, the Survey for
this site needs to include a legend that depicts the measured ft2 (and
acres) of each mitigation type and its corresponding widths. For this
specific site, since it is only a Nutrient Offset site, there is no need to
separate out Ephemerals, Streams and Ditches or separate out the specific
widths (100, 200) where the 1:1 ratio is applied. However, the surveyor
needs to show the measured ft2 and acreage of the following, as it is
currently shown in the corresponding Project Credit Table: Restoration

areas, Diffused flow deduction areas, No Credit Areas (includes the areas
denoted as "Preservation" and where it is less than 50' width.). Modify the
survey to remove the Project Credit Table and have the surveyor replace the
Credit Table with their own legend depicting the measurements of the areas
as described above.
b. The baseline monitoring data shows performance standards that appear to
be based on 320 stems/acre rather than 260 stems/acre. Just bringing
this to your attention
c. Section 5.3 does not indicate that IRS has established a conservation
easement. Usually at this stage, the AsBuilt report identified that the
conservation easement was secured. It also identifies anything else that is
relevant to the easement, such as any assignment to a long term steward.
Explain.
d. Section 5.4 does not indicate specific bonding at this stage. Usually, at this
state, a bond is being secured or has been secured for monitoring. Explain.
e. The planting plan identifies two shrubs. Are these species "shrubs" or mid -
story trees? The BPDP only approved Trees for planting and trees to be
used towards the performance criteria. Explain
Please provide a detailed and formal response to all items above, including all necessary
documentation, and submit to DWR via the electronic submittal form. Thank you for your
patience and understanding.
Thank you,
Katie
Katie Merritt
Nutrient Offset & Buffer Banking Coordinator
401 & Buffer Permitting Unit
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
Work Cell: 919-500-0683
Website: https:://deq.nc.gov/about/divisions/water-resources/water-quality-permitting/401-
buffer-permitting/nutrient-offset-buffer-mitigation-pro ram
512 N. Salisbury Street, Raleigh, NC 27620
1617 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699-1617

VICINITY MAP
NOT TO SCALE
/
SITE
WAYNE CO., NC
LONG POND BRANCH MITIGATION SITE
I, ELISABETH G. TURNER, AS A DULY REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL LAND
SURVEYOR IN THE STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, CERTIFY THAT THIS BUFFER
MAP WAS DRAWN UNDER MY SUPERVISION, IS AN ACCURATE AND
COMPLETE REPRESENTATION OF WHAT WAS CONSTRUCTED IN THE FIELD,
THAT THE EASEMENT BOUNDARY IS BASED ON PLAT BOOK SEE , PG _
NOTES RECORDED IN WAYNE COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS OFFICE, AND
THAT THE BUFFER AREAS SHOWN ARE CALCULATED FROM AS -BUILT
CONDITIONS EXCEPT WHERE OTHERWISE NOTED HEREON. WITNESS MY
ORIGINAL SIGNATURE, REGISTRATION NUMBER, AND SEAL THIS 14th DAY
OF OCTOBER, 2021. "o"1111,"///
Riparian Buffer Credit:
SO, FT.
Acres
Streams & Ditches
77,429
1.77
Buffer Restoration
231,100
5.3
0'-109(Min. 30')
Buffer Preservation
115,028
2.63
0'-100' (Min. 30')
Nutrient Offset Ditches
887,245
20.37
0'-200' (Min. 50')
Nutrient Offset Stream
248,926
5.71
101'-200' (Min. 50')
No Credit
14,044
0.32
Total CEArea
1,573,772
36.10
SEAL
ELISABETH G. TURNER, P.L.S. #L4440 - -r L-4440 ck:: -
vti/MATCHLINEI
L� uu
,'/////�r�lll
p BHIRIITBE5T
DB 631 PG 465
PIN: 2534-12-8367 I
J11p9
®
® PROPIERN IS
INE
\ ym ®1(DB zae9, i 106)
B
N/F ,u-,-,,�Y1�r��
I �GEORGE L GRAN
/
E wife
DEBPI� H. GRP}JTHAM
/
DB 2365, PG 789
PIN: 2534-12-5350 \
BILLY
OB
PIN:
W/BANNER . ./✓
15171 PG 372
2534-12-6362 `
�\
Q
al.
GV20L BEM. PC
2 1
DB 2534, PG 521 \
PIN: 2534-12-5211 \
NSF
GEORGE L. GRANTHAM
\
\
and wife,
DEBRA H. GRANTHAM - OZV
LINE LEGEND:
\ \
e
DB 2639, PG 303 co
PIN: 2534-21-0806 l
CE CONSERVATION EASEMENT
N/P/�\\ o'D
— — — —RIGHT—OF—WAY
\ GEORCE L. GWw and GinfejaRA H.
`
— —PROPERTY LINE
-----------------TREELINE
DB 2399, PG 106
PIN: 2534-11-6881
\ `
WILUAI KY ODOM
O
k wife, WILMA M. ODD
\
DB 1282, PG 49
PIN: 2534-42-0409
\
GENERAL NOTES-
1 . ALL DISTANCES ARE HORIZONTAL GROUND DISTANCES IN
CL LONG POND
BRANCH IS PROPERTY
U.S. SURVEY FEET UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED.
2. THE BASIS OF BEARINGS IS NCGS STATE PLANE
_ rEPc 4 0B 22e2, 9 a
\ I_ DB 2399, PG 106)
NAD83(2011) DATUM.
_
3. THEAREASHOWN HEREON WAS COMPUTED USING THE
`91•CyyO
COORDINATE COMPUTATION METHOD. \
4. THE PURPOSE OF THIS PLAT IS TO SHOW THE AS -BUILT
AREAS FOR RIPARIAN BUFFER CREDITS WITHIN THE
.-
CONSERVATION EASEMENT THIS PLAT IS NOT A \ N/F
-
BOUNDARY SURVEY. THE LAND PARCELS AND THEIR W1LMA BMT BRITT, It al.
DB 1041 PG 218 \ '1 00
BYTHIS CONSERVATION P
BOUNDARIES AFFECTEDIN: 2534=1i-5233 N/F
EASEMENT ARE NOT CHANGED BY THIS PLAT. \
GEORGE L. GRANTHAM
5. LINES NOT SURVEYED ARE SHOWNASADASHED
LINETYPE AND WERE TAKEN FROM INFORMATION
and wife,
DEBRA H. GRANTHAM
\
REFERENCED ON THE FACE OF THIS PLAT \
06
DB 2399 PG 106 _
TRACE ONE �_
6. SUBJECT TO ALL EASEMENTS, RIGHT OF WAYS, AND/OR
CL LONG POND
2534-20-2843 BRANCH IS PROPERTY
ENCUMBRANCES THAT MAY AFFECT THE PROPERTY(S). \
7. CONSERVATION EASEMENT MAP RECORDED IN PLAT
\PIN:
-- (DB 2399. PG 106)
BOOK P, PG. 32-J S 33-A IN THE WAYNE COUNTY REGISTER
\ /
OF DEEDS OFFICE. EASEMENT LINES PROVIDED BY
\
\
WILDLANDS ENGINEERING.
OF
B. STREAM TOP OF BANK LINES TAKEN FROM TOPOGRAPHIC
SURVEY BY LAND SURVEYING.
\
_
CHARLE&IA�fe HAPMAN
_ SUSAN E. CF{MMAN
2534-30 5392
\ _ / PIN:
�48
300' 0' 300' 600' THIS MAP IS NOT FOR RECORDATION, SALES, OR
CONVEYANCES AND DOES NOT COMPLY WITH G.S. 47-30
SCALE: 1 Inch = 300 feet (11x17)
MAPPING REQUIREMENTS.
--
I
o
m
T�
Ag
o
N'
%
o
�m
<
p
m
o
<
w
AS -BUILT SURVEY OF BUFFER AREAS FOR
EVI810N6, DATEAND INITIAL:
WILDLANDS ENGINEERING, INC.
LONG POND BRANCH MITIGATION BANK PARCEL
P.O. BOX 148
RNER SWANNANOA, NC 28778
P-0702 [phone]
N
T
i
i
�
D
o
NEUSE RIVER BASIN
! LAND SURVEYINGi TurnerLandSurveying.com
1
N
GRANTHAM TOWNSHIP WAYNE COUNTY NORTH CAROLINA
Certified DBE/WOE

4ue9 uoge6g!W jegng
ueued,y pue iasgO ryau)nN
at
woodnaBu6,saDZM'
dno>J
Aanans line-sv
LL
a
m
L60E'Z9S'ZSZ `v p Z�
lSSBZ ON'a6ue�O e�
K
O
ON 'lSunoO a6uejp
peog uoysag'S bCL
w
x
. ♦
'd!Usumol JanRl alU!l
i
�
•
NOIlV?MSMI ?133uf1S
;
w
i
iins C13HSINVG
eg
a
3
{uap0
4oa[o.b
m
O
a
O
da
U
m
z
a
�
F
m
F
r
o
W
y
N
y
�
O
O
w
Itzw
z�
¢
F
r
LLw
r
ww
z
rc
r
DN
0�
aw at
r
Or
Ow
O,
rw
J
F
DZ
DJ
J
z
ZZ
y
Z¢J¢
Za
r
u
F
ww
at at
wW
�a
Fm
r
F
�w
�I
�W
�xa
�O
0
i
Wa
w
za
zw
o
3 t «
.o
� T N
� L N y m L
N O _
O
u oo` a a
o rn . m
0
d o zE
a r o 0
/ E `o m o
/ a o
0o
ao
/
E
z o r o a
-� m m
oUM
u EwO1 Z.0
�{\GPP /
Z`o
S /
uv16Ea mmo
o
0 y 1.
-2 E
c
w o U v
0
/
/
H N t -
/
/
/
o
m
E
Z
,6
o
m
2 m o m
m a
J
u
ear
y'm mm
>.2
da m
U 9 to
d J O
a
a a
E N t
p
T Q N T
C
.+f6'z W66 Z
OlO
«tia
m
F m t
� E
o
a
v` E
g
3 c
d
Q J
�
m w-O3
h
Z 0
E ? %
`mm
= Q o
" o
O
1��/,,//
9 t
n
�II11a`
\\\�P •.... d�U
It o
o E.c
a
i v. P b0' • 0
9 Z y N N
O L)
= V:�
C/) %: J_
< ' � J Q: Z;
a n
oaE
- Y,
w � •0�
an ..............
a o v
; o
�moom
coC�
L, J \\
�y
P M
> a
EQNEM
�z¢
Z Wco
GU
O
Q
= N h
W
3Wad
0
N W
Z
Z �
Q
z
O
WOZ)E9OVN
QC) ON
N
u
HI210N
at at
r r r r
N
0
K wat at�
OW+i
or w
aQw
—
w U U U U
Z
r 0!
m r LL N LL N
W J w J a
y c Wc ¢
z C
w rcw ^w^
Y
sz
a
GW�
o
m
QP\�
¢
z arc r0' a� r� w
w 2
rc
w�
� r
w
Q
0 ¢ y Z N ¢ K Z W ¢
�o
N
xti
>
W
a > o aQ LLQ aN
o: �z oz g� °a o
wz�
N
Z
oN
2
W
$w U
Z w mw
Zd
�Va
I�
. mx
<
U °a oa °w ow °z
rQ)�wa
!y
z
U
(j
ur
`. o
z