HomeMy WebLinkAboutNCC000001_Draft Permit_20081114 W 7.4Michael F.Easley,Governor
•rp State of North Carolina
(i William G. Ross,Jr.,Secretary
CO Department of Environment and Natural Resources
y Coleen H.Sullins,Director
O Y Division of Water Quality
November 14,2008
Mr. Haywood Phthisic III,President
The Neuse River Compliance Association
PO Box 1562
Apex,North Carolina 27602-3562
Subject: Draft NPDES Permit No.NCC000001
Neuse River Compliance Association
Dear Mr. Phthisic:
The Division of Water Quality has reviewed the Neuse River Compliance Association's application
for renewal of its NPDES permit and has considered the group's requests for modification of the
roster and allocations list in Appendix A of the permit.The Division has made a tentative
determination to re-issue the permit,with changes,and we are enclosing a draft permit and fact
sheet for your review and comment.
The draft permit includes the following changes:
• The body of the permit is identical to the current permit except that reporting dates and the
address for the Wetlands Restoration Program have been updated.
• Appendix A includes several proposed changes:
• Progress Energy Carolinas,Inc., owner of the Lee Steam Electric Plant,is now listed as a
co-permittee member of the Association.Appendix A shows an allocation of zero. If
Progress's request to lease allocation is approved and the Association provides
documentation of the completed lease before the end of this comment period,the
Division will include the transfer in the final permit. The leased allocation will then be
deducted from the former Burlington Industries allocation.Because the leased allocation
comes from within the Association,the transaction will not affect the group's total TN
allocation.
• The table adds nine new allocations,to credit NRCA members for regionalization of
other facilities and elimination of those dischargers: five at New Bern,three at
Goldsboro,and one at Raleigh's Neuse River plant.
• The table also reflects Kinston's connection of its Peachtree system to its Northside plant
and the elimination of the Peachtree discharge point.
With these adjustments,the Association's Estuary TN Allocation increases by 17,380 lb/yr,from
1,137,171 to 1,154,5511b/yr,for calendar year 2009. The combined estuary allocation for all affected
point source discharges in the Neuse River basin remains at 1,640,000 lb/yr.
Division of Water Quality,Point Source Branch Telephone(919)733-7015 _one Carolina
1617 Mail Service Center,Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1617 FAX(919)733-0719 N,A hCarol t
512 N.Salisbury Street,Raleigh,North Carolina 27604 On the Internet at http://h2o.ennstate.nc.us/ d►'u i,
An Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer
Mr.Haywood Phthisic III,President
Draft NPDES Permit No.NCC000001
November 14,2008
As agreed in the 2007 settlement discussions between DWQ and the NRCA,the reserve allocations
held by SGWASA and the Town of Clayton are shown in Appendix A as part of the Association's
total allocation but are not listed with the two members'active allocations.The intent of this
approach is two-fold: (1)the NRCA's total allocation is the sum of its member's individual
allocations,consistent with the Neuse rule,and(2) the allocation given for each member is
consistent with its individual NPDES permit.
The permit does not reflect the sales of allocation from UNIFI-Kinston to Johnston County and
Clayton,nor the sale from Benson to Johnston County. Although these members have already
executed contracts for the transactions,the closure of UNIFI's operations and uncertainty about
future operations at the site have delayed action on that permit renewal. The Division,in turn,has
delayed actions on the other individual permits so that we could act on the permits as a group and
ensure that all of the revised nitrogen limits become effective simultaneously.We are now moving
forward with the UNIFI(now DuPont)renewal and expect to send the draft permits out for public
review in early 2009.
At this time,the Division is submitting a notice to the newspapers of general circulation in the
counties of the Neuse River basin,inviting public comment on the draft permit. The notice is
scheduled to be published on or about November 15th.Following a 30-day comment period,we
will review all pertinent comments received and take appropriate action on the permit renewal.
Please provide any comments you have regarding the draft permit to this office no later than
December 15th.
If you have any questions concerning this draft permit,please call me at(919)807-6402 or reach me
by e-mail at mike.templeton@ncmail.net.
Sincerely,
1
Michael E.Templeto ,P.E.
Point Source Branch
Enclosures: NPDES Permit NCC000001 and Fact Sheet
cc(w/enclosures): Cindy Finan,Executive Director,NRCA
Glenn Dunn,Poyner&Spruill,PO Box 10096,Raleigh,NC 27605-0096
Alissa Bierma,Upper Neuse Riverkeeper,112 Blount St.,Raleigh,NC 27601
Larry Baldwin,Lower Neuse Riverkeeper,1307 Country Club Road,New Bern,NC 28562
Marshall Hyatt,EPA Region 4
Raleigh and Washington Regional Offices,DWQ/SWPS
Basinwide Planning Unit
NPDES Unit Files
Central Files
2
Permit No.NCC000001
DRAFT
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
DIVISION OF WATER QUALITY
PERMIT
TO DISCHARGE WASTEWATER UNDER THE
NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM
In compliance with the provisions of North Carolina General Statute 143-215.1,other lawful standards
and regulations promulgated and adopted by the North Carolina Environmental Management
Commission,and the Federal Water Pollution Control Act,as amended,
The Neuse River Compliance Association
and Its Co-Permittee Members
are hereby authorized to discharge Total Nitrogen from the Co-Permittee Member treatment facilities
listed herein to receiving waters in the Neuse River Basin in accordance with effluent limitations,
monitoring requirements,and other conditions set forth in this Permit.
This Permit shall become effective January 1,2009
This Permit and the authorization to discharge shall expire at midnight on December 31,2013
Signed this day
DRAFT
Coleen H.Sullins,Director
Division of Water Quality
By Authority of the Environmental Management
Commission
Certificate of Coverage
DRAFT Page ii of ii
Permit No.NCC000001
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CERTIFICATE OF COVERAGE i
PART I - SPECIAL CONDITIONS 1
SECTION A-WASTEWATER CONTROLS
A.(1.)DEFINITIONS 1
A.(2.)CO-PERMITTEES AND TN ALLOCATIONS 2
A.(3.)EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS 2
A.(4.)MONITORING REQUIREMENTS 3
A.(5.)REPORTING REQUIREMENTS 3
A.(6.)COMPLIANCE 4
PART II - STANDARD CONDITIONS 1
SECTION A-DEFINITIONS 1
SECTION B-GENERAL CONDITIONS 4
SECTION C-OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE OF POLLUTION CONTROLS 7
SECTION D-MONITORING AND RECORDS 9
SECTION E-REPORTING REQUIREMENTS 11
PART III - OTHER CONDITIONS 1
APPENDIX A - CO-PERMITTEES,TRANSPORT FACTORS,AND TN ALLOCATIONS 1
APPENDIX B - POINT SOURCE FACILITIES ASSIGNED TOTAL NITROGEN ALLOCATIONS 1
Part I
DRAFT Page 1 of 4
Permit No.NCC000001
PART I
SPECIAL CONDITIONS
A.(1.) DEFINITIONS
(a.) Allocation(or"TN Allocation"): The mass quantity(as of TN)that a discharger or group of
dischargers(such as the Association)is allowed to release into surface waters of the Neuse River
Basin.TN Allocations may be expressed as Estuary TN Allocation or as the equivalent Discharge
TN Allocation.
(b.) Association: The Neuse River Compliance Association,a not-for-profit corporation comprised of
NPDES-permitted dischargers in the Neuse River Basin;established voluntarily under T15A
NCAC 2B .0234 to meet the aggregate Estuary TN Allocation of its members.
(c.) Co-Permittee Members: Those NPDES dischargers that for a given calendar year are members of
the Association and are listed in Appendix A of this Permit.
(d.) Discharge TN Allocation: TN Allocation specified at the point of discharge(or"end-of-pipe"). A
Co-Permittee Member's Discharge TN Allocation is equivalent to its Estuary TN Allocation
divided by the applicable Transport Factor.
(e.) Discharge TN Load: Actual TN Load measured at a Co-Permittee Member's point of discharge
(or"end-of-pipe").
(f.) Estuary: The Neuse River estuary,which extends from approximately Streets Ferry to the
Pamlico Sound.
(g.) Estuary TN Allocation: TN Allocation specified at the estuary.
(h.) Estuary TN Load: TN Load determined at the estuary. A Co-Permittee Member's Estuary TN
Load is equivalent to its Discharge TN Load multiplied by the applicable Transport Factor.
(i.) Load(or"TN Load"): The actual mass quantity(as of TN)that a discharger or group of
dischargers releases into surface waters of the Neuse River Basin.TN Loads may be expressed as
Discharge TN Load or as the equivalent Estuary TN Load.
(j.) Regionalization: The consolidation of wastewater collection and/or treatment systems that
results in the elimination of one or more NPDES-permitted discharges.
(k.) Total Maximum Daily Load(of TMDL): The allowable load of a pollutant that can be discharged
to a water body without causing loss of that water's designated uses.Also,the Phase II of the Total
Maximum Daily Load for Total Nitrogen to the Neuse River Estuary,North Carolina,approved by the
U.S.Environmental Protection Agency on March 19,2002,and subsequent revisions approved by
the EPA.
(1.) Total Nitrogen(TN): The sum of the organic,nitrate,nitrite,and ammonia species of nitrogen in
a water or wastewater.
(m.) Transport Factor: Fraction of the TN in a discharge that is predicted to reach the estuary,as
determined by the Division.
Part I
DRAFT Page 2 of 4
Permit No.NCC000001
A.(2.) CO-PERMITTEES AND TN ALLOCATIONS
(a.) Co-Permittees to this Permit shall be the Neuse River Compliance Association(the"Association")
and each of its Co-Permittee Members.The Co-Permittee Members,the Transport Factors
assigned to each,the Members'individual TN allocations,and the Association Estuary TN
Allocation shall be as listed in Appendix A,which is hereby incorporated into this Permit in its
entirety.
(b.) Upon timely and proper notification by the Association as described elsewhere in this Permit,the
Division shall revise Appendix A to incorporate changes in Association membership,allowable
changes in TN Allocations,or reapportionment by the Association.
(i.) Changes in membership.
(A) Enrollment. In the event that a discharger joins the Association,the Division shall
add the discharger and its TN Allocation to Appendix A as a Co-Permittee Member
and adjust the Association's TN Estuary Allocation accordingly.
(B) Termination. In the event that a Co-Permittee Member's membership is terminated,
the Division shall delete the departing Member and its TN Allocation from Appendix
A and adjust the Association's TN Estuary Allocation accordingly.
(ii.) For the purposes of this Permit,allowable changes in TN Allocations include those resulting
from purchase of allocation from the Wetlands Restoration Fund;purchase,sale,trade,or
lease of allocation among the Association,its members,and non-member dischargers;
regionalization;and other transactions approved by the Division.
(iii.) The Association may reapportion its TN Allocation among its Co-Permittee Members;
however,the Division shall only incorporate the corresponding changes into Appendix A
when specifically requested in writing by the Association.
(c.) Changes in Association membership and changes in individual or Association TN Allocations
shall become effective only at the beginning of the following calendar year(January 1).
A.(3.) EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS
(a.) Beginning on the effective date of this Permit and lasting no later than the expiration date,the Co-
Permittees are authorized to discharge Total Nitrogen(TN)from the treatment facilities listed in
Appendix A subject to the following effluent limitations.
(i.) Association TN Limitation. In any calendar year,the Association's Estuary TN Load shall
not exceed its Estuary TN Allocation as specified in Appendix A:
Association TN Limitation: For any calendar year,
Association Estuary TN Load < Association Estuary TN Allocation
where
Association Estuary TN Load(or Allocation) = Sum of Estuary TN Loads(or Allocations)
for All Co-Permittee Members
(ii.) Co-Permittee Member TN Allocations. In any calendar year,a Co-Permittee Member shall
be in compliance with its Estuary TN Allocation in Appendix A if:
(A) the Association Estuary TN Load complies with the Association Estuary TN
Allocation in Appendix A,or
Part I
DRAFT Page 3 of 4
Permit No.NCC000001
(B) in the event that the Association Estuary TN Load exceeds its Estuary TN Allocation,
the Co-Permittee Member's Estuary TN Load does not exceed that Member's Estuary
TN Allocation in Appendix A.
(b.) Other Individual Limitations. In the event that a Co-Permittee Member's membership in the
Association is terminated,the departing Member shall no longer be eligible for coverage under
this Permit and shall become subject to the TN limitation set forth in its individual NPDES
permit.
(i.) Termination of membership shall become effective only at the beginning of a calendar year
(January 1). Re-imposition of a discharger's individual TN limitation shall become effective
only at the beginning of a calendar year(January 1).
(ii.) The Association shall notify the Division if it determines that any Member will depart at the
end of a calendar year and shall provide an accounting of all allowable changes in the
Member's TN Allocation since the most recent issuance of the departing Member's
individual NPDES permit.
(iii.) Upon receipt of the notification and accounting described above,the Division shall modify
the TN limitation in the departing Member's individual NPDES permit,effective January 1
of the succeeding year,to reflect all allowable changes in the Member's TN Allocation and
shall also modify Appendix A of this permit accordingly.
A.(4.) MONITORING REQUIREMENTS
(a.) Each Co-Permittee Member shall continue to monitor its discharge(s)and report the results to the
Division as specified in its individual NPDES permit.
(b.) The Association shall assemble the results of its Co-Permittee Members and report the combined
results to the Division as specified in Condition A.(5.),below.
A.(5.) REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
(a.) The Association shall serve as the primary point of contact between the Division and the Co-
Permittee Members on matters related to this Permit,unless otherwise noted.The Association's
responsibilities in this regard include:
(i.) preparation and submittal of any reports required by this permit or of related information
requested by the Division;
(ii.) submittal of any request for modification or renewal of this permit;and
(iii.) distribution to the Co-Permittee Members of correspondence from the Division,including
but not limited to that pertaining to permit issuance,modification,and renewal;
compliance;and reporting.
(b.) Mid-Year Report. No later than August 31 of each year,the Association shall submit a mid-year
report to the Division.The report shall include,at a minimum,the following information:
(i.) for the period beginning July 1 of the preceding year and ending June 30 of the current year,
a Discharge Monitoring Report,for informational purposes only,of each Co-Permittee
Member's Discharge and Estuary TN Loads and the Association's Estuary TN Load.
(ii.) notification of any changes in Association membership or TN Allocations to become
effective in the following calendar year.
(c.) Year-End Report. No later than February 28 of each year,the Association shall submit a year-end
report to the Division.The report shall include,at a minimum,the following information for the
previous calendar year:
Part I
DRAFT Page 4 of 4
Permit No.NCC000001
(i.) for the period from January 1 through December 31 of the preceding year,a Discharge
Monitoring Report of each Co-Permittee Member's Discharge and Estuary TN Loads and
the Association's Estuary TN Load;
(ii.) a summary of changes in Association membership,including regionalization of discharges;
(iii.) a detailed summary of all purchases,sales,trades,leases,and other transactions affecting
the TN Allocations of the Association or its Co-Permittee Members;
(iv.) a description of the Association's TN control strategy for the preceding year and changes
for the coming year;
(v.) a detailed summary of measures taken to control TN discharges;
(vi.) an assessment of progress made;and
(vii.) a description of efforts planned for the upcoming calendar year(s).
(d.) Five-Year Report. No later than July 1,2013,in conjunction with application for renewal of this
Permit,the Association shall provide a detailed summary of all membership changes and
allowable changes in TN Allocations of the Association or its Co-Permittee Members occurring
during the term of this Permit.
A.(6.) COMPLIANCE
(a.) In the event that the Association exceeds its Estuary TN Allocation in a given calendar year,the
Association shall make offset payments for the excess TN for that year at a rate of$11 per pound
(15A NCAC 2B.0240)or such other rate as may be adopted by the Commission. Payment shall be
made no later than May 1 of the year following the exceedance and shall be submitted to:
NCDENR/Ecosystem Enhancement Program
Attn: Wetlands Restoration/ In-Lieu Fee Program
1652 Mail Service Center
Raleigh,NC 27699-1652
and three copies shall be submitted to:
NCDWQ/Point Source Branch
Attn: Neuse River Basin Offset Payments
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh,NC 27699-1617
(b.) For any calendar year in which the Association exceeds its Estuary TN Allocation,the Association
shall be in violation of this Permit,and the Division may take appropriate enforcement action
against the Association for such exceedance.
(c.) For any calendar year in which the Association exceeds its Estuary TN Allocation,any Co-
Permittee Member that exceeds its Estuary TN Allocation shall also be in violation of this Permit;
and the Division may take appropriate enforcement action against the Member.
(d.) Submittal of offset payments shall not limit the Division's authority to enforce the terms and
conditions of this Permit,nor shall it relieve the Association or its Co-Permittee Members of their
responsibility to comply with any other applicable federal,state,or local law,rule,standard,
ordinance,order,judgment,or decree. In determining the amount of any penalty to be assessed
against the Association or its Co-Permittee Members,the Division shall credit the Association or
its Members for any offset payments submitted by each;provided that the Association includes
with the offset payment submittal an accounting of each Member's contribution.
(e.) No Co-permittee Member shall be liable for any other Co-permittee Member's non-compliance
with this permit.
-ENDOFPARTI-
Appendix A
DRAFT Page 1 of 3
Permit No. NCC000001
APPENDIX A
CO-PERMITTEES,TRANSPORT FACTORS,AND TN ALLOCATIONS - NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
Discharge TN Allocations Estuary TN Allocations/Limits
Permittee Permit Facility 095 TF
Holdings Totaly Holdings Totally 11NnQBdsal
1 Apex,Town of 1.1 NC0064050 Middle Creek WWTP r+-',-w� 3.6 50% 40,547 40,547 20,274 20,274
2 Benson,Town of 2.1 NC0020389 Benson WWTP 3 50% 33,790 33,790 16,895 16,895
3 Cary,Town of 3.1 NC0048879 North WWTP- "- l-, 12 50% 135,158 143,246 67,579 71,623
3.1.1 Connection formerly Morrisville WWTP,NC0050041 0.2 / 4,044 2,022
3.1.2 Connection formerly Morrisville WWTP,NC0050938 0.2 :% 4,044 2,022
3.2 NC0065102 South WWTP" --":.(--1
- . f*F• 16 50% 180,211 180,211 90,105 90,105
4 Clayton,Town of 4.1 NC0025453 Little Creek WWTP 1.9 50% 21,400 21,400 10,700 10,700
5 Contentnea Metropolitan 5.1 NC0032077 Contentnea Sewerage District WWTP 2.85 70% 32,100 32,100 22,470 22,470
Sewerage District
6 Farmville,Town of 6.1 NC0029572 Farmville WWTP 3.5 50% 39,421 42,211 19,711 21,106
7.1 1 Connection formerly Walstonburg WWTP,NC0020362 0.138 5eg 2,790 1,395
7 Goldsboro,City of 7.1 NC0023949 Goldsboro WWTP -`Fl-F 16.8 70% 189,221 200,181 132,455 139,876
7.1.1 Connection formerly Genoa Industrial Park WWTP,NC0030392 0.4 78% 8,088 5,662
7.1.2 Connection formerly Town of Eureka WWTP,NC0028062 0.04 50% 809 404
7.1.3 Connection formerly Walnut Creek WWTP,NC0039233 0.08 )9% 1,618 1,132
7.1.4 Connection formerly Norwayne Jr.HS WWTP,NC0034801 0.012 158% 243 121
7.1.5 Connection formerly C.B.Aycock HS WWTP,NC0034819 0.01 X0% 202 101
8 Heater Utilities,Inc., 8.1 NC0064564 Neuse Colony WWTP 0.75 50% 8,447 8,447 4,224 4,224
Owned By Aqua NC
9 Johnston County 9.1 NC0030716 Central Johnston County WWTP 4.99 50% 56,203 67,467 28,102 33,734
9.1.1 Connection formerly White Oak Plantation WWTP,NC0060330 0.5 ,60=/ 5,632 2,816
9.1.2 Agreement formerly Buffalo Creek WWTP,NC0064556 0.5 58/ 5,632 2,816
Effective:January 1,2009.
Appendix A
DRAFT Page 2 of 3
Permit No.NCC000001
APPENDIX A(continued)
CO-PERMITTEES,TRANSPORT FACTORS,AND TN ALLOCATIONS - NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
Discharge TN Allocations Estuary TN Allocations/Limits
Permittee Permit Facility Q95 TF Facility Facility Individual
Holdings Total Holdings Total WQBLs I')
10 Kenly,Town of 10.1 NC0064891 Kenly Regional WWTP 0.63 50% 7,096 7,096 3,548 3,548
11 Kinston,City of 11.1 NC0024236 i Northside-WWTP- «k\ftR-F 4.5 70% 50,684 126,711 35,479 88,697
11.1.1 Connection formerly Peachtree WWTP,NC0020541 6.75 ADS. 76,026 53,218
12 La Grange,Town of 12.1 N00021644 La Grange WWTP 0.75 70% i 8,447 8,447 5,913 5,913
13 New Bern,City of 13.1 NC0025348 New Bern WWTP 4.7 100% 52,937 64,210 52,937 64,210
13.1.1 Connection formerly Zachary Taylor WWTP,NC0066613 0.5 ,i09% 5,632 5,632
13.1.2 Connection formerly Neuse Woods Apts.WWTP,NC0042430 0.012 100% 243 243
13.1.3 Connection formerly W.Craven MS WWTP,NC0029904 0.017 100% 344 344
13.1.4 Connection formerly Neuse River W&S WWTP,NC0070084 0.1 100% 2,022 2,022
13.1.5 Connection formerly Craven County W&S WWTP,NC0056545 0.15 100% 3,033 3,033
14 Progress Energy Carolina Carolinaiii 14.1 N00003417 Lee Steam Electric Plant x 70% 0 0 0 0
14.1.1 Lease from NRCA,former Burlington Industries allocation \j„il P)
15 Raleigh,City of 15.1 NC0029033 Neuse River WWTP 60 50% 675,790 682,483 337,895 341,242
15.1.1 Connection formerly Plantation Inn WWTP,NC0027570 0.025 50% 506 253
15.1.2 Connection formerly Falls Village WWTP,NC0046230 0.006 50% 121 61
15.1.3 Connection formerly Neuse Crossings WWTP,NC0064408 0.3 50% 6,066 3,033
15.2 NC0030759 Smith Creek WWTP 6 50% 67,579 70,814 33,790 35,408
15.2.1 Connection formerly Jones Dairy Farm WWTP,NC0064149 0.08 50% 3,235 1,618
15.3 NC0079316 Little Creek WWTP 1.85 50% 20,837 22,455 10,418 11,227
15.3.1 Connection formerly Middlesex WWTP,NC0022363 0.08 50% 1,618 809
16 South Granville Water& 16.1 NC0026824 SGWASA WWTP(formerly JohJU st d .R) 3.5 10% 58,599 58,599 5,860 5,860
Sewer Authority i
Effective:January 1,2009. 1
Appendix A
DRAFT Page 3 of 3
Permit No. NCC000001
APPENDIX A(continued)
CO-PERMITTEES,TRANSPORT FACTORS,AND TN ALLOCATIONS - NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
Discharge TN Allocations Estuary TN Allocations/Limits
Permittee Permit Facility 095 IF Facility Facility Individual
Holdings Total Holdings Total WQBLs"
17 Unifi-Kinston,LLC 17.1 NC0003760 Unifi-Kinston WWTP 3.6 70% 35,193 35,193 24,635 24,635
18 US MCAS Cherry Point 18.1 N00003816 Cherry Point WWTP 3.5 100% 39,421 39,421 39,421 39,421
19 Wilson,City of 19.1 N00023906 Wilson WWTP 14 50% 157,684 157,684 78,842 78,842
.+ ' y 20 NRCA and 20.1 N/A [Group allocation held in common] N/A 24,440
Co-Permittee Members 20.1.1 Deeded formerly Burlington Industries,NC0001376 24,449.2,
20.1.2 Leased leased to Progress Energy,NC0003417,from Burl.Ind.allocation 0 E
20.2 N/A [Other individual allocation available to group] N/A 6,113
20.2.1 Purchase by formerly Bay River MSD,NC0057011,NC0066109 3668
Town of Clayton
20.2.2 Purchase by formerly Bay River MSD,NC0057011,NC0066109 2,445c4
SGWASA
Association Estuary TN Limit 1,154,551 lb/yr
Footnotes:
(I) WQBLs: water quality-based estuary limits,such as those pursuant to Neuse rule,T15A NCAC 02B.0234(6)(c),(7)(g),and (8)(h).See Special
Condition A.(3.)regarding applicability of individual WQBLs in lieu of group limit.A member's estuary limit may be less than its estuary allocation,
such as when the facility holds part of the allocation in reserve or is subject to more stringent limits in order to protect local water quality.
(3)**7 Allocation purchased and held in reserve for future use by the co-permittee member.
(-6 i' 6k.r .c Li._5k-R•— P L..4 ;s 01/4.....4a- 1, i int l oiLc1 k 5,44111/r
w �`��� �1 '44,
Note for Reviewers�Progress Energy has requested a lease of
afr krU.,PrXA O0! (Qq ..;,,,jb zw. Vv. o� ' . .�E4..%ri . �t'-`- t1,oG',k t approximately 9,000 Ib/yr from the Association that, if approved, is to be
a ''
(T' � deducted from the former Burlington Industries allocation. At the time of
w—NCSii,,, t� °PP ri Sk'r'c'�{r., ""' Public Notice,the lease awaits approval of the NRCA membership at its
ba� �I-6.b ti- I _ � December meeting.The approved amount will be noted in the final permit
�[ ;� � � 1 and deducted from item#20.1.1. Regardless of the amount leased,the
values of item#20.1 and the Association Estuary TN Limit will not change
from those shown in this draft permit.
Effective:January 1,2009.
Appendix B
DRAFT Page 1 of 3
Permit No.NCC000001
APPENDIX B
POINT SOURCE FACILITIES ASSIGNED TOTAL NITROGEN ALLOCATIONS
NEUSE RIVER BASIN
The following is a list of all treatment facilities that,as holders of individual NPDES permits in 1995,are
assigned a Total Nitrogen(TN)allocation pursuant to state rule T15A NCAC 2B.0234,Neuse River Basin
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Management Strategy-Wastewater Discharge Requirements,adopted December
1997 and revised October 2002.
The rule establishes an aggregate Estuary TN Allocation of 1.64 million pounds TN per year for these
facilities and prescribes how the allocation is to be divided among the individual facilities.The
allocations,individual and aggregate,become effective with calendar year 2003.
The Total Maximum Daily Load for Total Nitrogen to the Neuse River Estuary,North Carolina,approved by
the USEPA Region 4 in July 1999,also concludes that this aggregate allocation is the maximum
allowable contribution from point source dischargers to the Neuse River estuary.
NPDES Permittee Facility Subbasin Transport
No. Factor
1. NC0037869 Arbor Hills MHP-1 Arbor Hills Mobile Home Park 30401 10%
2. NC0066109 Bay River MSD(no longer a surface discharge) Bayboro WWTP 30410 100%
3. NC0057011 Bay River MSD(no longer a surface discharge) Oriental WWTP 30410 100%
4. NC0058785 Bible Baptist Church Bible Baptist Church WWTP 30401 10%
5. NC0027570 Bobby L.Murray Plantation Inn WWTP 30402 50%
6. - Burlington Industries(now closed) Wake Plant WWTP(formerly NC0001376) 30402 50%
7. NC0051322 Carolina Water Service,Inc.of NC Ashley Hill WWTP 30402 50%
8. NC0056618 Carolina Water Service,Inc.of NC Carolina Pines WWTP 30410 100%
9. NC0062219 Carolina Water Service,Inc.of NC Kings Grant Subdivision WWTP 30402 50%
10. NC0033111 Carolina Water Service,Inc.of NC NE Craven WWTP 30410 100%
11. NC0064378 Carolina Water Service,Inc.of NC Willowbrook WWTP 30402 50%
12. NC0023841 City of Durham North Durham WRF 30401 10%
13. NC0023949 City of Goldsboro Goldsboro WWTP 30405 70%
14. NC0021253 City of Havelock Havelock WWTP 30410 100%
15. NC0024236 City of Kinston Northside WWTP 30405 70%
16. NC0020541 City of Kinston Peachtree WWTP 30405 70%
17. NC0025348 City of New Bern New Bern WWTP 30410 100%
18. NC0029033 City of Raleigh Neuse River WWTP 30402 50%
19. NC0023906 City of Wilson Wilson WWTP 30407 50%
20. NC0032077 Contentnea Metropolitan Sewerage Dist. Contentnea Sewerage District WWTP 30407 70%
21. NC0029904 Craven County Schools West Craven Middle School WWTP 30408 100%
22. NC0070084 Craven County Water&Sewer Stately Pines WWTP 30410 100%
23. N00056545 Craven County Water&Sewer Trent River WWTP 30410 100%
24. NC0065706 Crosby Utilities Crosby Utilities/Cottonwood 30402 50%
25. N00046230 Crosby Water and Sewer,Inc. Falls Village WWTP 30402 50%
26. NC0022853 Durham Products Eno Sewage Facility 30401 10%
27. NC0003760 E.I.Dupont de Nemours&Company,Inc. Kinston Plant 30405 70%
28. NC0066150 FMRK,Inc. Brighton Forest WWTP 30403 50%
29. NC0024520 G&S Associates Days Inn-Durham 30401 10%
30. NC0043389 Gorman Baptist Church Gorman BC WWTP 30401 10%
31. N00040606 Heater Utilities,Inc. Barclay Downs WWTP 30402 50%
32. NC0060577 Heater Utilities,Inc. Beachwood WWTP 30402 50%
Appendix B
DRAFT Page 2 of 3
Permit No.NCC000001
NPDES Permittee Facility Subbasin Transport
Permit No. Factor
33. NC0062740 Heater Utilities,Inc. Briarwood Farms WWTP 30403 50%
34. NC0062715 Heater Utilities,Inc. Crooked Creek WWTP 30403 50%
35. NC0056391 Heater Utilities,Inc. Cross Creek Mobile Estates WWTP 30402 50%
36. NC0049662 Heater Utilities,Inc. Hawthorne Subdivision WWTP 30401 10%
37. N00058505 Heater Utilities,Inc. Mallard Crossing WWTP 30402 50%
38. N00064564 Heater Utilities,Inc. Neuse Colony WWTP 30402 50%
39. NC0063614 Heater Utilities,Inc. Wildwood Green WWTP 30401 10%
40. NC0060771 Indian Creek Overlook Indian Creek Overlook 30402 50%
41. NC0063746 Ira D Lee&Associates Deerchase WWTP 30402 50%
42. NC0073318 Ira D Lee&Associates Whippoorwill Valley WWTP 30402 50%
43. NC0030716 Johnston County Central Johnston County WWTP 30402 50%
44. N00060330 Johnston County White Oak Plantation WWTP 30402 50%
45. NC0038938 Johnston County Board of Education Corinth-Holder Elementary&Middle School 30406 50%
46. NC0064149 Jones Dairy Farm Utilities Jones Dairy Farm WWTP 30402 50%
47. NC0040266 Knightdale MHP Limited Partnership Knightdale MHP Limited Partnership 30402 50%
48. NC0059099 Lake Ridge Aero Park Lake Ridge Aero Park 30401 10%
49. NC0032573 Lenoir County Public Schools Moss Hill Elementary School WWTP 30405 70%
50. NC0032565 Lenoir County Public Schools North Lenoir High School WWTP 30407 50%
51. NC0032557 Lenoir County Public Schools South Lenoir High School WWTP 30407 50%
52. NC0061492 Maury Sanitary Land District Maury Sanitary Land District WWTP 30407 50%
53. NC0049034 Mount Auburn Training Center Mount Auburn Training Center 30402 50%
54. NC0043001 Mt.Sylvan United Methodist Church Mt.Sylvan UMC WWTP 30401 10%
55. NC0037915 Nash/Rocky Mount Schools Southern Nash High School 30407 50%
56. NC0035181 NC Center For Mature Adults NC Center For Mature Adults 30403 50%
57. NC0026824 NC DHHS Butner WWTP 30401 10%
58. NC0042340 Neuse Woods Apartments Neuse Woods Apartments 30410 100%
59. NC0064246 Pace Mobile Home Park Pace Mobile Home Park 30402 50%
60. NC0036471 Person County Schools Helena Elementary School WWTP 30401 10%
61. NC0001881 Phillips Plating Company Phillips Plating Company 30410 100%
62. N00060526 Pope Industrial Park II Ltd Pope Industrial Park II Ltd 30402 50%
63. NC0051071 Redwood Partners LLC Redwood Academy WWTP 30401 10%
64. NC0049042 Riley Hill Baptist Church Inc Riley Hill Baptist Church Inc 30406 50%
65. N00064556 River Dell Utilities,Inc. Buffalo Creek WWTP 30406 50%
66. NC0056278 River Mill Homeowners Association,Inc. River Mill WWTP 30402 50%
67. NC0038784 Riverview Mobile Home Park Riverview Mobile Home Park 30402 50%
68. NC0030724 Southside MHP Southside MHP WWTP 30403 50%
69. NC0056731 The Chesson Group Grande Oak Subdivision WWTP 30401 10%
70. N00064050 Town of Apex Middle Creek WWTP 30403 50%
71. NC0020389 Town of Benson Benson WWTP 30404 50%
72. NC0074837 Town of Bridgeton Bridgeton WWTP 30410 100%
73. NC0048879 Town of Cary North WWTP 30402 50%
74. NC0065102 Town of Cary South WWTP 30403 50%
75. NC0025453 Town of Clayton Little Creek WWTP 30402 50%
76. NC0048062 Town of Eureka Eureka Town-WWTP 30407 50%
77. NC0029572 Town of Farmville Farmville WWTP 30407 50%
78. NC0066516 Town of Fuquay-Varina Terrible Creek WWTP 30403 50%
79. NC0026433 Town of Hillsborough Hillsborough WWTP 30401 10%
80. NC0025712 Town of Hookerton Hookerton WWTP 30407 50%
81. NC0064891 Town of Kenly Kenly Regional WWTP 30406 50%
82. NC0021644 Town of La Grange La Grange WWTP 30405 70%
Appendix B
DRAFT Page 2 of 3
Permit No.NCC000001
NPDES Permittee Facility Subbasin Transport
Permit No. Factor
83. N00022363 Town of Middlesex Middlesex WWTP 30407 50%
84. N00050938 Town of Morrisville Morrisville WTP 30402 50%
85. NC0050041 Town of Morrisville Morrisville WWTP 30402 50%
86. NC0026662 Town of Princeton Princeton WWTP 30406 50%
87. N00030406 Town of River Bend River Bend WWTP 30411 100%
88. NC0020842 Town of Snow Hill Snow Hill WWTP 30407 50%
89. NC0057606 Town of Stantonsburg Stantonsburg WWTP 30407 50%
90. NC0021342 Town of Trenton Trenton WWTP 30411 100%
91. NC0031828 Town of Vanceboro Vanceboro WWTP 30409 100%
92. NC0030759 Town of Wake Forest Wake Forest WWTP 30402 50%
93. NC0020362 Town of Walstonburg Walstonburg WWTP 30407 50%
94. NC0079316 Town of Zebulon Little Creek WWTP 30407 50%
95. NC0065714 Tradewinds Homeowners Association,Inc. Tradewinds WWTP 30402 50%
96. NC0056499 Uniprop,Inc. Mill Run Mobile Home Park 30402 50%
97. NC0039292 Uniprop,Inc. Riverwalk Mobile Home Park 30402 50%
98. NC0003816 US MCAS Cherry Point Cherry Point WWTP 30410 100%
99. NC0061638 Utilities Inc Amherst WWTP 30403 50%
100. NC0039233 Village of Walnut Creek Walnut Creek WWTP 30405 70%
101. NC0025631 Wake Technical Institute Wake Tech WWTP 30403 50%
102. NC0030392 Wayne County Genoa Industrial Park WWTP 30405 70%
103. NC0034819 Wayne County Board of Education Charles B.Aycock High School 30407 50%
104. NC0034801 Wayne County Board of Education Norwayne Junior High School 30407 50%
105. NC0003191 Weyerhaeuser Company New Bem Mill 30408 100%
106. N00064408 Whitewood Prop Inc Neuse Crossing WWTP 30402 50%
107. NC0031640 Willow Springs Country Club Willow Springs CC WWTP 30407 50%
108. NC0081752 Willowhaven Country Club Willowhaven CC WWTP 30401 10%
109. NC0066613 Zachary Taylor Hwy 55 Site WWTP 30410 100%
- PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT -
41617rvv`, r
Fact Sheet - NPDES Permit
NCDENR Neuse River Compliance Association
NcwrH CAROLINA DEIARTM[NT OF
ENVIRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES NPDES No. NCC000001
PROPOSED ACTION
The Neuse River Compliance Association and its co-permittee members have applied for renewal of the
NPDES permit governing the group's discharge of Total Nitrogen to the Neuse River and its tributaries.
The group made application on June 28,2007,and modified its application on July 25,2007,and
October 6,2008.
The Division finds the Association's application to be acceptable and has made a tentative
determination to re-issue the permit,with changes.
The Division will publish a notice of this determination in the principle newspaper for each county in
the river basin on or about November 15,2008,and will accept comments on the draft permit for 30
days following publication.After the close of the public comment period,the Division will consider all
significant comments and make its final decision regarding this permit action.
INTRODUCTION
The Neuse River Basin is classified as Nutrient Sensitive Waters(NSW),due to long-term nutrient
impacts on the river's estuary from point,nonpoint,and natural sources of pollution. In December 1997,
the Environmental Management Commission adopted the Neuse River Basin Nutrient Sensitive Waters
(NSW)Management Strategy,a rules package designed to address these nutrient impacts and restore
water quality in the basin.The Strategy required that Total Nitrogen(TN)loads to the estuary(1995
baseline)be reduced by 30 percent by the year 2003.
The basin has also been listed on the state's 303(d)list of impaired waters because of the nutrient
impacts.The Division developed Total Nitrogen TMDLs for the basin,based upon the NSW
Management Strategy,and the USEPA approved the TMDLs in 1999(Phase I)and 2002(Phase II).The
2000 303(d)list again includes the basin,now noting that the TMDLs have been approved and are being
implemented.
One portion of the NSW Management Strategy,the Wastewater Discharge Requirements rule(T15A
NCAC 213 .0234),establishes specific nutrient control requirements for the point source dischargers in
the basin.
• The rule sets forth a system of Total Nitrogen allocations to achieve the stated 30 percent
reduction in point source loads to the estuary.Toward this end,it:
• sets a wasteload allocation of 1.64 million pounds TN per year(at the estuary)for all point
source dischargers in the basin.
• further divides this allocation among the existing dischargers.
• requires that large facilities(those with permitted flows equal to or greater than 500,000
gallons per day)meet their individual TN allocations,effective in 2003.
• prescribes what allocations are required for new and expanding dischargers as well as how
they will be handled when permitted facilities consolidate(regionalize)their wastewater
discharges.
• provides that interested dischargers can form a group compliance association and work
together to meet their combined TN allocation. Under this option,the individual
dischargers are subject to TN limits in a group compliance NPDES permit in lieu of the TN
limits in their individual NPDES permits.
FACT SHEET Neuse River Compliance Association
DRAFT NPDES PERMIT NPDES No. NCC000001
• The rule also prescribes Total Phosphorus limits for the most significant dischargers in the
basin.
The subject permit is a group compliance permit as described above.It first became effective January 1,
2003,and is the only such permit to be developed under the Strategy's Wastewater Discharge rule.
PERMIT OVERVIEW
Co-Permittees
The Neuse River Compliance Association("NRCA,"or the"Association")is a not-for-profit corporation
established in North Carolina in 2002.The purpose of the Association is to function as a"group
compliance association"as provided in the Wastewater Discharge rule.
The Association's members include both public and private entities,all of which discharge treated
wastewater in the Neuse River basin under existing individual NPDES permits.
The Association and each of its members are co-permittees under the group permit.In general,the
Association serves as the contact between the Division and its co-permittee members in matters
pertaining to this permit.
Scope of the Permit
The group compliance permit governs the combined discharge of Total Nitrogen from the co-permittees
to the estuary.Requirements in this permit supplement those in the co-permittee members'individual
NPDES permits but do not replace the requirements in the individual permits except where specifically
stated.
Each member's individual NPDES permit remains in effect and continues to govern the other
parameters of concern for that discharge.
PROPOSED EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS AND MONITORING REQUIREMENTS
The Division developed effluent limitations,monitoring requirements,and special conditions for the
original group permit based on the Neuse River Basin Nutrient Management Strategy,the approved
TN TMDLs,and extensive deliberations with the USEPA Region 4 and with the affected dischargers.In
subsequent years,the Division has modified Appendix A to reflect changes in membership and
transfers of allocation to and among the members.
The body of the proposed permit is unchanged from the original permit except for an updated address
in Condition A.(6.).The draft Appendix A has again been revised to reflect changes in membership and
transfers of allocation.
Effluent Limitations
Group and Individual TN Limitations
Appendix A of the permit contains the definitive list of(1)Co-Permittee Members in the Association,(2)
discharge and equivalent estuary TN allocations for each member,and(3)the transport factor for each.
These values are taken from allocation method in the Wastewater Discharge rule.
The appendix also includes the sum total of the member's estuary allocations,which represents the
Association Estuary TN Allocation.All TN allocations are expressed in terms of pounds of TN per year
and apply to a calendar year period.
The permit establishes TN limits for the Association and,under certain conditions,for the individual
co-permittee members.Any group or individual TN limit in this permit is equal to the corresponding
estuary TN allocation in Appendix A.
-2- 11/14/2008
FACT SHEET Neuse River Compliance Association
DRAFT NPDES PERMIT NPDES No.NCC000001
The Association is subject to a TN limit,equal to its Estuary TN Allocation,throughout the term of this
permit.
Individual members of the Association will be subject to individual TN limits only in those years in
which the Association exceeds its limit.In that case,each co-permittee member is subject to its
individual TN limit from Appendix A.If the Association as a whole complies with its limit,the member
dischargers are not subject to individual limits for that calendar year.
Changes in Membership or TN Allocations
The TN allocations of the co-permittee members can change as the result of purchases,sales,trades,
leases,and other transactions.These changes,in turn,affect the Association's TN allocation.Changes in
membership also affect the Association's allocation due to the addition or subtraction of the discharger's
allocation from the group total.
Whenever changes in the allocations or the membership occur,Appendix A of the permit must be
modified in order to formally incorporate those changes and adjust the enforceable limits in the permit.
The TN allocations and limits are expressed as calendar year values;therefore,any adjustments can
become effective only at the beginning of the calendar year(January 1)following the transaction or
membership change.The Association will notify the Division each year of proposed changes in
Appendix A(see Reporting Requirements,below).
Co-Permittee Members
The Association is currently comprised of the following co-permittee members and facilities:
Co-Permittee Member Facility
1. Town of Apex Middle Creek WWTP
2. Town of Benson Benson WWTP
3. Town of Cary North WWTP
South WWTP
4. Town of Clayton Little Creek WWTP
5. Contentnea MSD Contentnea MSD WWTP
6. Town of Farmville Farmville WWTP
7. City of Goldsboro Goldsboro WWTP
8. Heater Utilities(Aqua NC) Neuse Colony WWTP
9. Johnston County Central Johnston County WWTP
10. Town of Kenly Kenly Regional WWTP
11. City of Kinston Northside WWTP
12. Town of La Grange La Grange WWTP
13. City of New Bern New Bern WWTP
14. Progress Energy Lee Steam Electric Plant
15. City of Raleigh Neuse River WWTP
Town of Wake Forest Wake Forest WWTP
Town of Zebulon Little Creek WWTP
16. SGWASA SGWASA WWTP(formerly John Umstead WWTP)
17. UNIFI/DuPont-Kinston UNIFI/DuPont WWTP
18. USMCAS Cherry Point Cherry Point WWTP
19. City of Wilson Wilson WWTP
The TN allocation for each member is included in Appendix A of the permit.These allocations include
the original allocation assigned to the facility in the Wastewater Discharge rule plus any allocation
acquired through regionalization or other transactions.
-3- 11/14/2008
FACT SHEET Neuse River Compliance Association
DRAFT NPDES PERMIT NPDES No. NCC000001
The Association also holds the TN allocation originally assigned to Burlington Industries(formerly
NC0001376),which the industry deeded to the Association.
As this permit is released for public review,Progress Energy is negotiating a lease of nitrogen allocation
from the Association.The Division proposes to include any such lease under this permit if the
Association documents that the lease is completed prior to the end of the public comment period.The
transfer would then be reflected in Appendix A. Because the leased allocation comes from within the
Association,the transaction will not affect the group's total TN allocation.
Monitoring Requirements
All members of the Association are required under the individual NPDES permits to monitor TN on a
regular basis and report the results in their Discharge Monitoring Reports(DMRs).The group
compliance permit does not duplicate these monitoring requirements or require additional TN
monitoring.
Instream monitoring is not required under this permit.However,it is required of the co-permittee
members through their individual NPDES permits and,for most,is conducted by the Lower Neuse
Basin Association,a coalition of dischargers that,by agreement with the Division,conducts instream
monitoring for its members.
Reporting Requirements
Each member will continue to report its TN monitoring results on its individual DMRs.The Association
is not required to duplicate these detailed reports.
The Association will submit year-end,mid-year,and 5-year reports on its activities to the Division.The
year-end report(due February 28 of each year)will include an accounting of the Association's and its
members'TN discharges for the previous calendar year for compliance purposes. It will also include a
list of transactions during that period affecting TN allocations,an assessment of progress made,and
planned activities for the coming year.The mid-year report(due August 31 of each year)will include an
updated accounting of TN discharges for informational purposes. It will also identify any changes in
TN allocations or in membership for the following year and will serve as a request to modify Appendix
A to incorporate those changes.The 5-year report is intended to ensure that the Division and the
Association agree on the group and individual allocations at the end of the permit term.
Compliance
The Association is required by rule to make offset payments to the Wetlands Restoration Fund for any
calendar year in which it exceeds its TN limit. In addition,the Division may take appropriate
enforcement action against the Association or its co-permittee members or both in the event that they
exceed applicable TN limits in the permit.
The Association has not exceeded its TN limit in the first six years of its existence.The group's
combined nitrogen reduction has been exemplary,reaching nearly 70% reduction from 1995 baseline
levels as compared to the mandated 30% reduction for point source discharges in the basin.
Expiration Date
The original permit expired December 31,2007.The Division received timely application for renewal
and,with the Association's consent,administratively extended the permit and delayed renewal for one
year. As a result,renewals of this group permit will now follow-rather than precede-those of the
members'individual NPDES permits,whose nitrogen limits it is meant to reflect.
-4- 11/14/2008
Arr4 Permit Review Sheet
NCDENR Neuse River Compliance
Association
ENVIRONMENT ANO nbau ._RESOUeGE3
NPDES No. NCC000001
PERMIT REVIEW
Please review the attached draft permit package and provide comments and/or concurrence at least
one week before the close of the public comment period (below).
If you have any questions on this fact sheet,the draft permit,or other attachments,please contact
Mike Templeton at(919)733-5083,extension 541.
PROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR PERMIT ISSUANCE
Draft Permit to Public Notice: November 15,2008
End of Comment Period: December 15,2008
Permit Scheduled for Issuance: December 30,2008
NPDES Recommendation by:
Signature Date
This space is used by the regional office personnel to identify specific
concerns in reference to issuance of the subject permit.Attach
REGIONAL OFFICE COMMENTS additional sheets as needed.
Regional Recommendation by:
Signature Date
REVIEWED AND ACCEPTED BY:
Regional Supervisor:
Signature Date
NPDES Unit Supervisor:
Signature Date
THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
POST OFFICE BOX 1 562 .
APEX, NORTH CAROLINA 27602-3562 ) •
�1►
October 6,2008 OCT 3 2008 �
Ms. Colleen Sullins,P.E.,Director ——_.__. •
Division of Water Quality
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh,North Carolina 27699-1617
Re: Modification to Neuse River Compliance Association NPDES Permit No.
NCC000001
Dear Ms. Sullins:
The Neuse River Compliance Association(NRCA)holds NPDES Permit Number NC000001
from the Division of Water Quality. This permit has not been modified since January,2006 and
is currently awaiting renewal. To date,we have not received a draft of the permit.
This letter is to officially notify you that the NRCA has accepted Progress Energy, Lee Steam
Plant(NPDES Number NC0003417) into membership in the NRCA. This membership was
approved at our meeting in September,2008. Progress Energy is not a newcomer to our
organizations. They have been a member of the Lower Neuse Basin Association,our sister
organization, since it was created in the 1990's. We have been anticipating this request, since
Progress Energy first came to our board with this concept in 2007. Due to ongoing negotiations
between DWQ and Progress Energy,we have been in constant contact with Mike Templeton of
your staff,regarding our ability to assist Progress Energy. Both Mike and Progress Energy felt it
necessary to resolve certain issues before their membership was considered by our board.
In light of this situation, we would request the Division include this Progress Energy facility in
our renewed permit,when it is issued.
Thank you for your consideration and attention to this matter. If you have any questions or need
any further information regarding this request, please feel free to contact me at 919.989.5044,or
Cindy Finan, Executive Director at 919/387-3478 or Glenn Dunn, our legal counsel at 919/783-
2842.
Sin ly, DE e _ C ,/ EIt));
ayywood M. Phthisic, III T OCT414,J/1f
9 O
Chairman
DIVISION OF WAIER QUAUIY
Cc: Shannon Langley, Progress Energy DIRECTOR'S OFFICE
Glenn Dunn, Poyner and Spruill
•
THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
POST OFFICE BOX 1 562
APEX, NORTH CAROLINA 27502
June 28, 2007
North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
Attention: NPDES Unit,Mike Templeton
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
Dear Mr. Templeton:
The Neuse River Compliance Association(NRCA) was formally organized as a not-for-profit
organization in 2001. Shortly after it was formed, it applied for and received,NPDES permit
number NCC000001. This permit was issued in compliance with the Neuse River Nutrient
Management Strategy, which authorized the group compliance approach,allowing the group to
comply with an aggregate limit for Total Nitrogen into the Neuse River Estuary.
We are happy to report that the NRCA has been in existence for five years and has cumulatively
removed 8,579,433 pounds of Total Nitrogen from the estuary compared to the discharge that was
occurring in 1995. The group was given a mandate to reduce their Total Nitrogen discharge by
30%, and in 2006,this group of dischargers had removed 70% of that original loading to the
estuary.
The NRCA has served as a national model for"compliance associations"and the success that can
be achieved when point sources work together. Through this innovative and altruistic approach,
our members have collectively spent in excess of$50 million dollars and many of them are now
treating well below the limits established as 'Best Available Technology." Though the efforts of
our members we have upgraded treatment plants, encouraged optimization of treatment
processes,encouraged reuse projects,and we are currently discharging at just under 50%of our
permitted limit for Total Nitrogen.
The Neuse River Compliance Association and its Co-Permittee Members hereby apply to renew
their permit,NCC000001 for another five year period. The enclosed attachments list the
members of the NRCA and provide the required Five Year Report, which include information on
the group's allocations,activities and performance.
If you have any questions or need any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me at
919/989-5044 or our Executive Director,Cindy Finan at 919/387-3478.
Sinc y,
rod thisic, 111 Chairman RECE
JUN 2 9 2007 J
DENR-WATER QUALITY
POINT SOURCE BRANCH
Enclosures: EPA Form 1 (Attachment 1)
EPA Form 3510-2A NPDES Permit Application(Attachment 2)
Neuse River Compliance Association Membership Roster and
Co-Permittee Application and Information(Attachment 3)
Five Year Report(Attachment 4)
Allocation Summary
Compliance/Enforcement Summary
Performance Graph(2003-2006)
2007 Blue Ribbon Water Quality Trading Award Nomination
Please print or type in the unshaded areas only
(fill-in areas are spaced for elite type, i.e., 12 characters/inch). For Approved. OMB No. 2040-0086. Approval expires 5-31-92
FORM U.S.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY I. EPA I.D. NUMBER
1 &EPA GENERAL INFORMATION S TA C
Consolidated Permits Program F D
GENERAL (Read the "General Instructions"before starting.) 1 I 2 13 14 15
LABEL ITEMS
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
If a preprinted label has been provided,
I. EPA I.D. NUMBER NCC000001
affix it in the designated space. Review the
Neuse River Compliance Association informationcrec, crosscathroughlly;
and entert the
III. FACILITY NAME incorrect, nthrow
PO Box 1562 correct data in the appropriate fill-in area
below.Also,if any of the preprinted data is
V. FACILITY Apex, NC 27502-3562 absent (ce she area information the left of the lou
appear) peass e proa ithehpror should
MAILING LIST in area(s) below. If the label is complete
and correct you need not complete Items
I, Ill, V, and VI(except Vl-B which must be
complVI. FACILITY if no letel haed s beens)rovedplReferltothe
LOCATION instructions for detailed item descriptions
and for the legal authorization under which
II. POLLUTANT CHARACTERISTICS this data is collected.
IN TR I N Compete A through J to determine whether you need to submit any permit application forms to the EPA. I you answer"yes"to any
questions,you must submit this form and the supplemental from listed in the parenthesis following the question. Mark"X"in the box in the third column if
the supplemental form is attached. If you answer"no"to each question,you need not submit any of these forms. You may answer"no"if your activity is
excluded from permit requirements;see Section C of the instructions.See also,Section D of the instructions for definitions of bold-faced terms.
SPECIFIC QUESTIONS MARK"X" MARK"X"
YES NO FORM SPECIFIC QUESTIONS FORM
A. Is this facility a publicly owned treatment works ATTACHED YES NO ATTACHED
which results in a discharge to waters of the x ❑ B. Does or will this facility (either existing or
U.S.?(FORM 2A) X ❑proposed) include a concentrated animal X Elfeeding operation or aquatic animal
production facility which results in a discharge
16 17 18 to waters of the U.S.?(FORM 2B) 19 20 _
C. Is this facility which currently results in D. Is this proposal facility21
discharges to waters of the U.S. other than ❑ x ❑ in A or B above)which willllresult in discharge ❑ x ❑
those described in A or B above?(FORM 2C) 22 23 24 to waters of the U.S.?(FORM 2D
E. Does or will this facility treat, store, or dispose of 25 26 27
hazardous wastes?(FORM 3) F you or will you inject at this facility industrial or
1:1 X ❑ municipal effluent below the lowermost stratum
❑ X ❑
containing, within one quarter mile of the well
bore, underground sources of drinking water?
G Do you or will 28 29 30 (FORM 4) 31 32
you inject at this facility any H. Do you or will you inject at this facility fluids for 33
produced water other fluids which are brought to
the surface in connection with conventional oil or special processes such as mining of minerals,raby in the
natural gas production, inject fluids used for ❑ X ❑ sFitu combustionch ustion,of fossilon fuel,or ofa ❑ X ❑
enhanced recovery of oil or natural gas, or inject geothermaleor recovery of
fluids for storage of liquid hydrocarbons? energy?(FORM 4)
(FORM 4) 34 35 36
I. Is this facility a proposed stationary source J. Is this facilitya37 38 39
which is one of the 28 industrial categories listed proposed stationary source
in the instructions and which will potentially emit ❑ X which isNOT one of the 28 industrial potentially
100 tons peryear of anyair regulated ❑ emlistit
in the instructions and which will ppollutant ❑ X ❑
pollutant i emit 250 tons per year of any air pollutant
under the Clean Air Act and may affect or be regulated under the Clean Air Act and may affect
located in an attainment area? FORM 5 40 41 42 or be located in an attainment are? FORM 5 43 44
III. NAME OF FACILITY45
1 SKIP Neuse River Compliance Association
15 16-29 30
IV. FACILITY CONTACT 69
A. NAME&TITLE (last, first, &title) B. PHONE (area code&no.)
2 Haywood M. Phthisic, Ill, Chairman 919 989 5044
_15 16
V. FACILITY MAILING ADDRESS 45 46 48 49 51 52 55
A. STREET ORP P.O. BOX
C I PO Box 1562
3
15 16
B.CITY OR TOWN 45
C
C. STATE D.ZIP CODE
4 Apex NC 27502
15 16
40 41 42 47 51 FACILITY LOCATION
A.STREET, ROUTE NO. OR OTHER SPECIFIC IDENTIFIER
C I N/A
15 16
B. COUNTY NAME 45
N/A
46
70
C. CITY OR TOWN D.STATE E.ZIP CODE F.COUNTY CODE
6
C N/A N/A N/A N/A
15 16
40 41 42 47 51 52 54
EPA FORM 3510-I (8-90)
CON'T'INUED ON REVERSE
CONTINUED FROM THE FRONT
VII. SIC CODES 4-di.it, in order of•riorit
A. FIRST B. SECOND
c N/A ' (specify) 7 N/A (specify)
7
15 16 17 N/A 15 16 19 - N/A
C.THIRD D. FOURTH
c N/A (specify) 7 N/A (specify)
s ,s 17 N/A s ,s 79 N/A
VIII. OPERATOR INFORMATION
A. NAME B. Is the name listed in Item
c Neuse River Compliance Association VIII-A also the owner?
8
18 19 ss ❑ YES ❑NO
C.STATUS OF OPERATOR(Enter the appropriate letter into the answer box;if"Other,"specify.) D.PHONE area code&no.)
F=FEDERAL M=PUBLIC(other than federal or state) 0 (specify) C 919 387 3478
S=STATE 0=OTHER(specify) Non-Profit Org. A
P=PRIVATE 56 15 16 18 19 21 22 25
E.STREET OR PO BOX
PO Box 1562
26 55
F.CITY OR TOWN G.STATE H.ZIP CODE IX. INDIAN LAND 111 .111111C Apex NC 27502 Is the facility located on Indian lands?
B ❑ YES X NO
15 16 40 42 42 47 51
X. EXISTING ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITS
A. NPDES(Discharges to Surface Water) D. PSD(Air Emissions from Proposed Sources)
C T I See Attached List ° T N/A
9 N 9 P
15 16 17 18 30 15 1 16 I 17 1 18 30
B. UIC(Underground Injection of Fluids E.OTHER(specify) (Specify)
9 U I N/A 9 i
T I ° N/A N/A
15 16 17 18 30 15 16 1 17 18 30
C. RCRA(Hazardous Wastes) E.OTHER(specify) (Specify)
EN9 R ' N/A 9 T 8 N/A N/A
15 16 17 18 30 15 16 17 18 30
XI. MAP
Attach to this application a topographic map of the area extending to at least one mile beyond property boundaries. The map must
show the outline of the facility, the location of each of its existing and proposed intake and discharge structures, each of its
hazardous waste treatment, storage, or disposal facilities, and each well where it injects fluids underground. Include all springs,
rivers and other surface water bodies in the ma. area. See instructions for •recise re.uirements.
XII. NATURE OF BUSINESS •rovide a brief descri.tion
A Not for Profit Association of NPDES Permit holders permitted to discharge wastewater treatment plant effluent
to surface waters of the Neuse River Basin in North Carolina. The Association and its member/Co-Permittees
control the discharge of total nitrogen from member facilities so that the aggregate total nitrogen loading a the
Neuse River Estuary is less than the sum of the individual member allocations which were established to meet a
Total Maximum Daily Load(TMDL) for total nitrogen. The Association's Permit is effective for members of the
Neuse River Compliance Association in lieu of individual total nitrogen permit limits as provided for in each
Member/Co-Permittee individual NPDES permit.
XIII. CERTIFICATIONseeinstructiorllMMIMIMIIIMIIMI
s)
I certify under penalty of law that!have personally examined and am familiar with the information submitted in this application and
all attachments and that, based on my inquiry of those persons immediately responsible for obtaining the information contained in
the application, I believe that the information is true, accurate nd complete. I am aware that there are significant penalties for
submitting false information, including the possibilit of fine an imprisonment.
A. t�IAME&OFFICIAL TITTLE(t pe or prim B. SI N UR/t J� C. DATE SIGNED
4ywoevin, /Sec.
COMMENTS FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
c
C
15 16
55
EPA FORM 3510-I (8911)
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
FORM
2A NPDES FORM 2A APPLICATION OVERVIEW
NPDES
APPLICATION OVERVIEW
Form 2A has been developed in a modular format and consists of a "Basic Application Information" packet
and a "Supplemental Application Information" packet. The Basic Application Information packet is divided
into two parts. All applicants must complete Parts A and C. Applicants with a design flow greater than or
equal to 0.1 mgd must also complete Part B. Some applicants must also complete the Supplemental
Application Information packet. The following items explain which parts of Form 2A you must complete.
BASIC APPLICATION INFORMATION:
A. Basic Application Information for all Applicants. All applicants must complete questions A.1 through A.8. A treatment works
that discharges effluent to surface waters of the United States must also answer questions A.9 through A.12.
B. Additional Application Information for Applicants with a Design Flow 2 0.1 mgd. All treatment works that have design flows
greater than or equal to 0.1 million gallons per day must complete questions B.1 through B.6.
C. Certification. All applicants must complete Part C(Certification).
SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION INFORMATION:
D. Expanded Effluent Testing Data. A treatment works that discharges effluent to surface waters of the United States and meets
one or more of the following criteria must complete Part D(Expanded Effluent Testing Data):
1. Has a design flow rate greater than or equal to 1 mgd,
2. Is required to have a pretreatment program(or has one in place),or
3. Is otherwise required by the permitting authority to provide the information. •
E. Toxicity Testing Data. A treatment works that meets one or more of the following criteria must complete Part E(Toxicity Testing
Data):
1. Has a design flow rate greater than or equal to 1 mgd,
2. Is required to have a pretreatment program(or has one in place),or
3. Is otherwise required by the permitting authority to submit results of toxicity testing.
F. Industrial User Discharges and RCRA/CERCLA Wastes. A treatment works that accepts process wastewater from any
significant industrial users(SIUs)or receives RCRA or CERCLA wastes must complete Part F(Industrial User Discharges
and RCRA/CERCLA Wastes). SIUs are defined as:
1. All industrial users subject to Categorical Pretreatment Standards under 40 Code of Federal Regulations(CFR)403.6 and
40 CFR Chapter I, Subchapter N(see instructions);and
2. Any other industrial user that:
a. Discharges an average of 25,000 gallons per day or more of process wastewater to the treatment works(with certain
exclusions);or
b. Contributes a process wastestream that makes up 5 percent or more of the average dry weather hydraulic or organic
capacity of the treatment plant;or
c. Is designated as an SIU by the control authority.
G. Combined Sewer Systems. A treatment works that has a combined sewer system must complete Part G(Combined Sewer
Systems).
ALL APPLICANTS MUST COMPLETE PART C (CERTIFICATION)
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
.BASIC APPLICATION INFORMATION
PART A.BASIC APPLICATION INFORMATION FOR ALL APPLICANTS:
All treatment works must complete questions A.1 through A.8 of this Basic Application information Packet.
A.1. Facility Information.
Facility Name
Mailing Address See Attachment 3 for listina of Members of the Neuse River Compliance Assoc.and Co-Permittee Applicants for
renewal of this permit. Attachment 4 includes the 5 Year Report required by the existina permit.
Contact Person
Title
Telephone Number J )
Facility Address
(not P.O.Box)
A.2. Applicant information. If the applicant Is different from the above,provide the following
Applicant Name Neuse River Compliance Association
Mailing Address PO Box 1562
Apex, NC 27502
Contact Person Cindy Finan
Title Executive Director
Telephone Number f9191387-3478
Is the applicant the owner or operator(or both)of the treatment works?
❑ owner 0 operator
Indicate whether correspondence regarding this permit should be directed to the facility or the applicant.
❑ facility X applicant
A.3. Existing Environmental Permits. Provide the permit number of any existing environmental permits that have been issued to the treatment works
(include state-issued permits).
NPDES NCC000001 (See Attachment 31 PSD
UIC Other
RCRA Other
A.4. Collection System information. Provide information on municipalities and areas served by the facility. Provide the name and population of each
entity and,if known,provide information on the type of collection system(combined vs.separate)and its ownership(municipal,private,etc.).
Name Population Served Type of Collection System Ownership
See Individual Permits
Total population served
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
A.5. Indian Country.
a. Is the treatment works located in Indian Country?
❑ Yes X No
b. Does the treatment works discharge to a receiving water that is either in Indian Country or that is upstream from(and eventually flows
through)Indian Country?
❑ Yes X No
A.6. Flow. Indicate the design flow rate of the treatment plant(i.e.,the wastewater flow rate that the plant was built to handle). Also provide the
average daily flow rate and maximum daily flow rate for each of the last three years. Each year's data must be based on a 12-month time period
with the 12"'month of"this year"occurring no more than three months prior to this application submittal.
a. Design flow rate See Individual Co-Permittee Permits mgd
Two Years Ago Last Year This Year
b. Annual average daily flow rate
c. Maximum daily flow rate
A.7. Collection System. Indicate the type(s)of collection system(s)used by the treatment plant. Check all that apply. Also estimate the percent
contribution(by miles)of each.
X Separate sanitary sewer %
0 Combined storm and sanitary sewer %
A.8. Discharges and Other Disposal Methods.
a. Does the treatment works discharge effluent to waters of the U.S.? 0 Yes 0 No See Individual Co-Permittee Permits
If yes,list how many of each of the following types of discharge points the treatment works uses:
i. Discharges of treated effluent
ii. Discharges of untreated or partially treated efluent
iii. Combined sewer overflow points
iv. Constructed emergency overflows(prior to the headworks)
v. Other
b. Does the treatment works discharge effluent to basins,ponds,or other surface impoundments
that do not have outlets for discharge to waters of the U.S.? 0 Yes 0 No
If yes,provide the following for each surface impoundment:
Location:
Annual average daily volume discharge to surface impoundment(s) mgd
Is discharge 0 continuous or 0 intermittent?
c. Does the treatment works land-apply treated wastewater? 0 Yes 0 No
If yes,provide the following for each land application site:
Location:
Number of acres:
Annual average daily volume applied to site: mgd
Is land application 0 continuous or 0 intermittent?
d. Does the treatment works discharge or transport treated or untreated wastewater to another
treatment works? 0 Yes 0 No
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACIUTY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
If yes.describe the mean(s)by which the wastewater from the treatment works is discharged or transported to the other treatment works
(e.g.,tank truck,pipe).
If transport is by a party,other than the applicant,provide:
Transporter Name
Mailing Address
Contact Person
Title
Telephone Number ( )
For each treatment works that receives this discharae,provide the following:
Name
Mailing Address
Contact Person
Title
Telephone Number f )
If known,provide the NPDES permit number of the treatment works that receives this discharge
Provide the average daily flow rate from the treatment works into the receiving facility.
mgd
e. Does the treatment works discharge or dispose of its wastewater in a manner not included
in A.8.through A.8.d above(e.g.,underground percolation,well injection):
❑ Yes 0 No
If yes,provide the following for each disposal method:
Description of method(including location and size of sites)if applicable):
Annual daily volume disposed by this method:
Is disposal through this method 0 continuous or 0 intermittent?
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACIUTY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
WASTEWATER DISCHARGES:
If you answered"Yes"to Question A.8.4,complete Questions A.9 throuah A.1$once for each outfall(Including bypass points)through
which effluent is discharged. Do not include information on combined sewer overflows In this section. If you answered"No"to Question
A.B.a,go to Part B,"Additional Application Information for Applicants with a Design Flow Greater than or Equal to 0.1 mgd."
A.9. Description of Outfall. See Individual Co-Permittee Permits
a. Outfall number
b. Location
(City or town,If applicable) (Zip Code)
(County) (State)
(Latitude) (Longitude)
c. Distance from shore(if applicable) ft.
d. Depth below surface(if applicable) ft.
e. Average daily flow rate mgd
f. Does this outfall have either an intermittent or a periodic discharge? 0 Yes 0 No (go to A.9.g.)
If yes,provide the following information:
Number f times per year discharge occurs:
Average duration of each discharge:
Average flow per discharge: mgd
Months in which discharge occurs:
g. Is outfall equipped with a diffuser? 0 Yes 0 No
A.10. Description of Receiving Waters. See Individual Co-Permittee Permits
a. Name of receiving water
b. Name of watershed(if known)
United States Soil Conservation Service 14-digit watershed code(if known):
c. Name of State Management/River Basin(if known):
United States Geological Survey 8-digit hydrologic cataloging unit code(if known):
d. Critical low flow of receiving stream(if applicable)
acute cfs chronic cfs
e. Total hardness of receiving stream at critical low flow(if applicable): mg/I of CaCO3
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
A.11. Description of Treatment See Individual Co-Permittee Permits
a. What level of treatment are provided? Check all that apply.
0 Primary 0 Secondary
❑ Advanced ❑ Other. Describe:
b Indicate the following removal rates(as applicable):
Design BOD5 removal or Design CBOD5 removal
Design SS removal
Design P removal
Design N removal
Other
c. What type of disinfection is used for the effluent from this outfall? If disinfection varies by season,please describe:
If disinfection is by chlorination is dechlorination used for this outfall? 0 Yes 0 No
Does the treatment plant have post aeration? 0 Yes 0 No
A.12. Effluent Testing Information. All Applicants that discharge to waters of the US must provide effluent testing data for the following
parameters. Provide the Indicated effluent testing required by the permitting authority for each outfall through which effluent Is
discharged. Do not include information on combined sewer overflows in this section. All information reported must be based on data
collected through analysis conducted using 40 CFR Part 136 methods. In addition,this data must comply with QA/QC requirements of
40 CFR Part 136 and other appropriate QA/QC requirements for standard methods for analytes not addressed by 40 CFR Part 136. At a
minimum,effluent testing data must be based on at least three samples and must be no more than four and one-half years apart.
Outfall number:
PARAMETER MAXIMUM DAILY VALUE AVERAGE DAILY VALUE
Value Units Value Units Number of Samples
pH(Minimum) s.u. g
pH(Maximum) s.u. r r .. �,:.
Flow Rate
Temperature(Winter)
Temperature(Summer)
•For pH please report a minimum and a maximum daily value
MAXIMUM DAILY AVERAGE DAILY DISCHARGE
DISCHARGE ANALYTICAL
MLJMDL
METHOD
Conc. Units Conc. Units Number of
Samples
CONVENTIONAL AND NON CONVENTIONAL COMPOUNDS
BIOCHEMICAL OXYGEN BOD5
DEMAND(Report one) CBOD5
FECAL COLIFORM
•
TOTAL SUSPENDED SOLIDS(TSS)
END OF PART A.
REFER TO THE APPLICATION OVERVIEW(PAGE 1) TO DETERMINE WHICH OTHER PARTS
OF FORM 2A YOU MUST COMPLETE
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
BASIC APPLICATION INFORMATION
PART B. ADDITIONAL APPLICATION INFORMATION FOR APPLICANTS WITH A DESIGN FLOW GREATER THAN OR
EQUAL TO 0.1 MGD(100,000 gallons per day).
All applicants with a design flow rate 2 0.1 mgd must answer questions B.1 through B.6. All others go to Part C(Certification).
B.1. Inflow and Infiltration. See Individual Co-Permittee Permits. Estimate the average number of gallons per day that flow into the treatment
works from inflow and/or infiltration.
gpd
Briefly explain any steps underway or planned to minimize inflow and infiltration.
B.2. Topographic Map. See Individual Co-Permittee Permits. Attach to this application a topographic map of the area extending at least one mile
beyond facility property boundaries. This map must show the outline of the facility and the following information. (You may submit more than one
map if one map does not show the entire area.)
a. The area surrounding the treatment plant,including all unit processes.
b. The major pipes or other structures through which wastewater enters the treatment works and the pipes or other structures through which
treated wastewater is discharged from the treatment plant. Include outfalls from bypass piping,if applicable.
c. Each well where wastewater from the treatment plant is injected underground.
d. Wells,springs,other surface water bodies,and drinking water wells that are: 1)within Y mile of the property boundaries of the treatment
works,and 2)listed in public record or otherwise known to the applicant.
e. Any areas where the sewage sludge produced by the treatment works is stored,treated,or disposed.
f. If the treatment works receives waste that is classified as hazardous under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act(RCRA)by truck,rail,
or special pipe,show on the map where the hazardous waste enters the treatment works and where it is treated,stored,and/or disposed.
B.3. Process Flow Diagram or Schematic. See individual Co-Permittee Permits. Provide a diagram showing the processes of the treatment plant,
including all bypass piping and all backup power sources or redunancy in the system. Also provide a water balance showing all treatment units,
including disinfection(e.g.,chlorination and dechlorination). The water balance must show daily average flow rates at influent and discharge points
and approximate daily flow rates between treatment units. Include a brief narrative description of the diagram.
B.4. Operation/Maintenance Performed by Contractor(s).
Are any operational or maintenance aspects(related to wastewater treatment and effluent quality)of the treatment works the responsibility of a
contractor? 0 Yes 0 No
If yes,list the name,address,telephone number,and status of each contractor and describe the contractor's responsibilities(attach additional
pages if necessary).
Name:
Mailing Address:
Telephone Number:
Responsibilities of Contractor:
B.5. Scheduled improvements and Schedules of Implementation. See Individual Co-Pemiittee Permits. Provide information on any uncompleted
implementation schedule or uncompleted plans for improvements that will affect the wastewater treatment,effluent quality,or design capacity of the
treatment works. If the treatment works has several different implementation schedules or is planning several improvements,submit separate
responses to question B.5 for each. (If none,go to question B.6.)
a. List the outfall number(assigned in question A.9)for each outfall that is covered by this implementation schedule.
b. Indicate whether the planned improvements or implementation schedule are required by local,State,or Federal agencies.
❑ Yes ❑ No
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
c. If the answer to B.S.b is"Yes,"briefly describe,including new maximum daily inflow rate(if applicable).
d. Provide dates imposed by any compliance schedule or any actual dates of completion for the implementation steps listed below,as
applicable. For improvements planned independently of local,State,or Federal agencies,indicate planned or actual completion dates,as
applicable. Indicate dates as accurately as possible.
Schedule Actual Completion
Implementation Stage MM/DD/YYYY MM/DD/YYYY
-Begin Construction / / / /
-End Construction / / / /
-Begin Discharge
-Attain Operational Level
e. Have appropriate permits/clearances concerning other Federal/State requirements been obtained?
0 Yes 0 No
Describe briefly:
8.6. EFFLUENT TESTING DATA(GREATER THAN 0.1 MGD ONLY). See individual Co-Permittee Permits.
Applicants that discharge to waters of the US must provide effluent testing data for the following parameters. Provide the Indicated
effluent testing required by the permitting authority for each outfall through which effluent is discharged. Do not include Information
on combine sewer overflows In this section. All Information reported must be based on data collected through analysis conducted
using 40 CFR Part 136 methods. In addition,this data must comply with QA/QC requirements of 40 CFR Part 136 and other appropriate
QA/QC requirements for standard methods for analytes not addressed by 40 CFR Part 136. At a minimum effluent testing data must be
based on at least three pollutant scans and must be no more than four and on-half years old.
Outfall Number:
MAXIMUM DAILY AVERAGE DAILY DISCHARGE
DISCHARGE ANALYTICAL
POLLUTANT METHOD ML/MDL
Conc. Units Conc. Units Number of
Samples
CONVENTIONAL AND NON CONVENTIONAL COMPOUNDS
AMMONIA(as N)
CHLORINE(TOTAL
RESIDUAL,TRC)
DISSOLVED OXYGEN
TOTAL KJELDAHL
NITROGEN(TKN)
NITRATE PLUS NITRITE
NITROGEN
OIL and GREASE
PHOSPHORUS(Total)
TOTAL DISSOLVED SOLIDS
(TDS)
OTHER
END OF PART B.
REFER TO THE APPLICATION OVERVIEW(PAGE 1)TO DETERMINE WHICH OTHER PARTS
OF FORM 2A YOU MUST COMPLETE
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
FACILITY NAME AND PERMIT NUMBER: PERMIT ACTION REQUESTED: RIVER BASIN:
Neuse River Compliance Assoc., NCC000001 Renewal Neuse
BASIC APPLICATION INFORMATION
PART C. CERTIFICATION
All applicants must complete the Certification Section. Refer to instructions to determine who is an officer for the purposes of this
certification. All applicants must complete all applicable sections of Form 2A,as explained In the Application Overview. Indicate below which
parts of Form 2A you have completed and are submitting. By signing this certification statement,applicants confirm that they have reviewed
Form 2A and have completed all sections that apply to the facility for which this application Is submitted.
Indicate which parts of Form 2A you have completed and are submitting:
Basic Application Information packet Supplemental Application Information packet:
❑ Part 0(Expanded Effluent Testing Data)
❑ Part E(Toxicity Testing: Biomonitoring Data)
❑ Part F(Industrial User Discharges and RCRA/CERCLA Wastes)
❑ Part G(Combined Sewer Systems)
ALL APPLICANTS MUST COMPLETE THE FOLLOWING CERTIFICATION.
I certify under penalty of law that this document and all attachments were prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance with a system
designed to assure that qualified personnel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted. Based on my inquiry of the person or persons who
manage the system or those persons directly responsible for gathering the information,the information is,to the best of my knowledge and belief,true,
accurate,and complete. I am aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false information,including the possibility of fine and imprisonment
for knowing violations.
Name and official title Hay o M.P thisic,I hairman
Signature
Telephone number (919)989-5044
Date signed June 28,2007
Upon request of the permitting authority,you must submit any other Information necessary to assure wastewater treatment practices at the treatment
works or identify appropriate permitting requirements.
•
SEND COMPLETED FORMS TO:
NCDENR/ DWQ
Attn: NPDES Unit
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, North Carolina 27699-1617
NPDES FORM 2A Additional Information
ATTACHMENT 3:
Co-Permittee Members of the Neuse River Compliance Association
Permit
FACILITY NPDES Permit Flow'
(MGD)
Town of Apex NC0064050 3.60
Town of Benson NC0020389 3.00
Butner/SGWSA NC0026824 3.50
Cary North NC0048879 12.00
Cary South NC0065102 16.00
County of Johnston. NC0030716 4.99
Town of Clayton NC0025453 2.50
Contentnea MSD NC0032077 2.85
Town of Farmville NC0029572 3.50
City of Goldsboro 01 & 02 NC0023949 16.80
Town of Kenly NC0064891 0.63
City of Kinston (Regional) NC0024236 11.85
Town of LaGrange NC0021644 0.75
Neuse Colony NC0064564 0.75
City of New Bern NC0025348 6.50
City of Raleigh NC0029033 60.00
City of Raleigh-Smith Cr. NC0030759 6.00
City of Wilson NC0023906 14.00
Town of Zebulon/Raleigh Little Cr. NC0079316 1.85
Unifi-Kinston, LLC NC0003760 3.60
MCAS Cherry Point NC0003816 3.50
Individual Co-permittee Application and Information Sheets Follow
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL OF
NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE WITH THE
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: TOWN OF APEX
Contact: John Cratch Phone Number: (919) 249-3360
Facility Address: 300 Pristine Waters Drive Apex, NC 27502
Mailing address: PO Box 250 Apex, NC 27502
Email Address: john.cratch@apexnc.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name: Town of Apex Water Reclamation Facility
NPDES Permit No.:NC0064050
Receiving Waters: Unnamed tributary of Middle Creek
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°42'30" Longitude: 78°50'03"
Permitted Flow: 3.6 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse Nutrient
Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy) in pounds per year: 40,547 lbs/yr
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired,regionalization,etc.)
in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately): N/A
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 40,547 lbs/yr
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES permit)in
pounds at the discharge location: N/A
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a percent:
50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year: 20,274
lbs/yr
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and com: : e.
61/41/ sem , ' U� / q 0
Name and Title Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Town of Benson
Contact: Keith R. Langdon Phone Number: 919-894-3553
Address: P. O. Box 69, Benson, North Carolina 27504
Email Address: Elan don!ir;to«notbenson. corn
Facility Operator(if different than owner): same
Facility Name: Town of Benson WWTP
NPDES Permit No.: NC0020389
Receiving Waters: Hannah Creek
Outfall No.:001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35° 23' 21" Longitude: 78° 30' 29"
Permitted Flow: 1.9 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 33,790 Pounds per Year
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
N/A
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 33790 Pounds per Year
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: N/A
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
16,895 Pounds per Year
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
ac)rate and complete.
e4Age ��Yt7s^1 /
• Date y QGY J
ame and
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER:
Contact: LINDSAY L. MIZE Phone Number: (919) 575-4068
Address:211 WEST C STREET, BUTNER,NC 27509
Email Address: lmize@sgwasa.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner): JARVIS KOONCE - ORC
Facility Name: SOUTH GRANVILLE WATER AND SEWER AUTHORITY WWTP
NPDES Permit No.: NC0026824
Receiving Waters: KNAP OF REEDS CREEK
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 36°07'39" Longitude: 78°46'20"
Permitted Flow: 5.5 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location (as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 58,599
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
DHHS PURCHASED FROM BAY RIVER MSD—61,130 POUNDS
FACILTIY NAME CHANGE FROM DHHS TO SGWASA
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 58,599
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: 24,450
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 10%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
5,859.9
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate an s omplete.
411.116..d.464.11 /i JUNE 18,2007
essay L. Mize, Executive Director Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Town of Cary
Contact: Robert P. Bonne Phone Number: 919-469-4303
Address: PO Box 8005, Cary NC 27512
Email Address: rob.bonne@townofcary.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner): n/a
Facility Name: North Cary Water Reclamation Facility
NPDES Permit No.: NC 0048879
Receiving Waters: Crabtree Creek(Neuse)
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°, 50', 09" Longitude: 78°, 46', 32"
Permitted Flow: 12 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location (as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy) in pounds per year: 135,160
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
Morrisville 17,810
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted) at the Discharge Location: 143,246 as per Final Rule
October 2002 (Cary Disputed Amount 152,970)
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit) in pounds at the discharge location: 0
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
71,623
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
acc and mp e.
. June 19,2007
Robert P. Bonne, Utilities Director Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Town of Cary
Contact: Robert P. Bonne Phone Number: 919-469-4303
Address: PO Box 8005, Cary NC 27512
Email Address: rob.bonne@townofcary.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner): n/a
Facility Name: South Cary Water Reclamation Facility
NPDES Permit No.: NC 0065102
Receiving Waters: Middle Creek (Neuse)
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°, 38', 48" Longitude: 78°, 45', 28"
Permitted Flow: 16 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy) in pounds per year: 180,210
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately): 0
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 180,210
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: 0
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve) at the Estuary in pounds per year:
90,105
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accura and co ete. /,
June 19, 2007
Robert P. Bonne, Utilities Director Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Johnston County
Contact: Haywood M. Phthisic, III Phone Number: 919.209.8333
Address: P.O. Box 2263 Smithfield, N.C. 27577
Email Address: haywood.phthisic@johnstonnc.com
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name: Central Johnston County Regional Wastewater Facilities
NPDES Permit No.: NC 0030716
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35' 22' 32" Longitude: 78' 32' 18"
Permitted Flow: 7.0 mgd
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location (as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 56,203 lbs
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.) in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
NC 0060330, 5,632 lbs NC 0064556, 5,632 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted) at the Discharge Location: 67,467 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: -NA-
Total
NA-1otal Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
33,734 lbs.
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
ertify that t 1 e above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accrate an s • L ete.
Ric J. est• , County Manager Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Town of Clayton
Contact : James Warren Phone Number: 919-553-1536
Address: PO Box 879, Clayton NC 27528
Email Address:jowarren@townofclaytonnc.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner): n/a
Facility Name:
NPDES Permit No.: NC 0025453
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates:
Latitude:35 39 50 Longitude:78 25 26
Permitted Flow: 2.5 mgd
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 21,400
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
SGWSA 7,336#
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted)at the Discharge Location:21,400
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: 7,336#
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
14,368# 10 .O0 L0"0
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
l
(' 4 Tr-) 5-(V) ? SA, 7
( Name and Title Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Contentnea Metropolitan Sewerage District
Contact: Charles M. Smithwick, Jr. Phone Number: 252/524-5584
Address: P. O. Box 477 Grifton, NC 28530
Email Address: crosdl@vol.com
Facility Operator(if different than owner): Renee Pridgen
Facility Name: Contentnea Metropolitan Sewerage District
NPDES Permit No.: NC0032077
Receiving Waters: Contentnea Creek
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35 21' 20"N Longitude: 77 24' 58" W
Permitted Flow: 2.85 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year:32,100 pounds/yr
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
None
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 32,100 pounds/yr
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: None
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 70%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
22,470 pounds/yr
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
Name and Title Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: T r tic- C 0(IN- t
Contact: Rt cl,o,c d I . �tc K s Phone Number:(as-1)1s 3 - pin
Address: P.b. [box 8b; 3611 I\ . Ma,.. S+•
Email Address: rucks o co,fp.v,11e -cc • Ctn"
Facility Operator(if different than owner): IId cfl M aecJ�N►cc•} S '
c(VtCc1
Facility Name:
NPDES Permit No.: c-003.9 S 1t
Receiving Waters: I\ .tSt
Outfall No.: P's - Di-01 lJ o cbt‘ OOI
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 3S 3s' it' N Longitude: 110 31 30, w
Permitted Flow: 3 ,s MGO
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location (as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 3q 41,1 ILO v
i
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds perppyear at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately): a 190 Ill.)yid
N.4...CTow. Or�� y.101skerino3 /
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 41. 111 IL.r y for
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: p
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: sb 7.
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year: 3,Ir los.i ,�,f.lyc�
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurat and co plete.
Al btil
Name Tit at
NE USE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: City of Goldsboro Water Reclamation Facility
Contact: Karen Brashear, Public Utilities Director
Phone Number: 919-735-3329
Address: P.O. Drawer A, Goldsboro, NC 27533
Email Address: kbrashear@ci.goldsboro.nc.us
Facility Operator(if different than owner): Robert P. Sherman/WRF Superintendent
Facility Name: City of Goldsboro Water Reclamation Facility
NPDES Permit No.: NC0023949
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.: 001 and 002
Location Coordinates:
Pipe 001 Latitude: 35 degrees 20'44" Longitude: 77 degrees 59'59"
Pipe 002 Latitude: 35 degrees 20'14" Longitude: 77 degrees 59'53"
Permitted Flow: 14.2mgd
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 198,118 lbs per year I$ 221
1
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
The City of Goldsboro treats wastewater from Wayne County,Walnut Creek,and
Fremont. 809 lbs per year
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 197,309 lbs per year
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: 0 lbs per year
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 70%
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
138,521 lbs per year
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
5J 0411ir‘ 63/0.4‘1.4.".._
Name and Title P,....t01,1-1, . I.t-fr l;f-,�E D;rc6 - a 1 -D 7
S 1oR Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
("O-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Town of Kenly
Contact: Scott Shelton,Town Manager Phone Number: 252-284-2116
Address: P.O. Box 519
Kenly, NC 27542
Email Address: scott.shelton@townofkenly.com
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name: Kenly Regional WWTP
NPDES Permit No.: NC0064891
Receiving Waters: Little River in the Neuse Basin
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°34' 58" Longitude: 78°09' 31"
Permitted Flow: 0.63 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Met. Strategy)in pounds per year:
7,112 lbs. 40 0i c Cry'
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
O lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocationrmitted)at the Discharge Location:
7,112 lbs -q-CA(�
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location:
0 lbs
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent:
50 %
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
3,556 lbs 354V Ci#
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
.5.
/70(A) /ki6 - 19 - o
Name and Title Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PEILMITEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL OF
NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE WITH
THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: C344-4) ,r �`n.Sk"W>
Contact:OfxvCk. C Phone Number: 2-52-1 9 34z) — 32-4 S
Address: Bc Cc 3 Z_44.4-try‘ ` s -2'3 D
Email Address:o„,ck. ` . �� .�,� . Yl C ,
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name:
NPDES Permit No.: 1,4 C 0024 Z 3(,
Receiving Waters: N15e_ yQ_r-
Outfall No.: 001 , M
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°11- Nur Longitude: 47 c 30 G.(1
Permitted Flow: 11
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year(Pc.ac�4yit-e._. -- 4(,%OZ.
N-la t sid - So)V&4
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
�czO�4 r -L- GSo se d t'. 2004 - SA cru.. r
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: -.-fig; , - �Oc
ala O�
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location:
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 0 c!1
o
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
1 O 5%... .Z
Name and Title Date
A
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE /MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Town of La Grange, North Carolina
Contact: John P. Craft, Town Manager Phone Number: (252) 566-3186
Address: PO Box 368/203 South Center Street
Email Address: jperaft@lagrangenc.com
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name: Town of La Grange
NPDES Permit No.: NC0021644
Receiving Waters: Unnamed Tributary of Mosley Creek
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°18'45" Longitude: 77°46'32"
Permitted Flow: 0.750 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: -0-
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
-0-
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 8,447
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: -0-
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 70%
tike
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:-0- (511:9
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.) /
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
ac and complete.
�"/, aa.m/fildvittfix DateI /9 —
Zoo ,
Na and Title / /
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER:
Contact: Mike Harwood Phone Number: 919.467.8712 x 706
Address: 202 MacKenan Ct., Cary, NC 27511
Email Address: MSHarwood@aquaamerica.com
Facility Operator(if different than owner): EnviroLink, Inc., PO Box 670, Bailey NC 278
Facility Name:
NPDES Permit No.: NC0064564
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35.6455556° Longitude: -78.4055556°
Permitted Flow: 0.75 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location (as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy) in pounds per year: 8,447 pounds
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations (through purchase, plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: none
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 8,447 pounds
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve (not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: none
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve) at the Estuary in pounds per year:
4,224 pounds
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
Mike Harwood, Regional Manager—Compliance and Engineering
‘/g7M'
Name and Title Dat
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER:
Contact: Walter B. Hartman, Jr., City Manager Phone Number: 252-639-2701
Address: PO Box 1129 New Bern, NC 28561-1129
Email Address: citymgnnewbern-nc.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner): Judy Majstoravich, Plants Manager
Facility Name: City of New Bern Wastewater Treatment Plant
NPDES Permit No.: NC0025348
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35 08' 20" Longitude: 77 03' 37"
Permitted Flow: 6.5 mgd
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location (as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 52,937
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase, plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition_separately):
Trent River WWTP removed from Trent River discharge
Stately Pines WWTP removed from Neuse River discharge
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted)at the Discharge Location:
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location:
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 100%
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
58,569
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
curs d complete.
46 /9 2ao �
Na e a d Title 4:4-0
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: City of Raleigh
Contact: H. Dale Crisp Phone Number: (919) 857-4540
Address: PO Box 590, Raleigh, NC 27602
Email Address: Dale.Crisp@ci.raleigh.nc.us
Facility Operator(if different than owner): N/A
Facility Name: Neuse River WWTP
NPDES Permit No.: NC0029033
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.:00I
• Location Coordinates: Latitude: 350 42' 59" Longitude: 780 28' 54"
Permitted Flow: 60 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt.Strategy)in pounds per year: 675,790 lbs.
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.) in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
Plantation Inn WWTP(formerly NC0027570)—506 lbs.
Falls Village WWTP (formerly NC0046230)—121 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 676,417 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: 0
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
338,209 lbs.
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate an► co U4AesDiect)r-
'', '1 4[c
t!o d
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: City of Raleigh
Contact: H. Dale Crisp Phone Number: (919) 857-4540
Address: PO Box 590, Raleigh,NC 27602
Email Address: Dale,Crisp@ci.raleigh.nc.us
Facility Operator(if different than owner): NA --
Facility Name: Smith Creek WWTP
NPDES Permit No,:NC0030759
Receiving Waters:Neuse River
Outfall No.:001
0 0
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35 54' 29" Longitude: 78 32' 18"
Permitted Flow:6.0 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy) in pounds per year: 67,579 lbs.
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
Jones Dairy Farm WWTP(formerly NC0064149)—3,235 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 70,814 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit) in pounds at the discharge location: 0 .
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
•
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted.and not in reserve) at the Estuary in pounds per year:
35,408 lbs.
•
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is,to the best of my knowledge and belief,true,
accurate and o =tete.
a
�i Rib tCicc e5Dh- h1A
Name and e Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: City of Wilson
Contact: Russell Brice Phone Number: (252) 399-2491
Address: P. O. Box 10, Wilson, NC 27894
Email Address: rbrice@wilsonnc.org
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name: Hominy Creek Wastewater Management Facility
NPDES Permit No.: NC0023906
Receiving Waters: Contentnea Creek
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 34° 40' 37" Longitude: 77° 54' 51"
Permitted Flow: 14 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year: 157,684
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
None
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted) at the Discharge Location: 157,684
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: None
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
78,842
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate .nd complete.
Name and Title I ate
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: City of Raleigh
•
Contact: H. Dale Crisp Phone Number: (919) 8574540
Address: PO Box 590, Raleigh, NC 27602
Email Address: Dale.Crisp@ci.raleigh.nc.us
Facility Operator(if different than owner): N/A __
Facility Name: Little Creek WWTP
NPDES Permit No.: NC0079316
Receiving Waters: Little Creek
Outfall No.:001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 35°48' 57" Longitude: 78° 16'20"
Permitted Flow: 1.85 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt.Strategy)In pounds per year:20,837 lbs.
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired,regionalization,
etc.)In pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
Middlesex WWTP(formerly NC0022363)—1,618 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 22,455 lbs.
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location: 0
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 50%
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted and not in reserve) at the Estuary in pounds per year:
11,227 lbs.
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief,true,
accurate and c
g PU (? ALC
r
Name and l itle 4 Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL
OF NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE
WITH THE NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER:
Contact: Vanish E. Green Phone Number:252-522-6223
Address:4693 Hwy 258 South Kinston NC 28502
Email Address:GreenVE@unifi.corn
Facility Operator(if different than owner): James Proctor
Facility Name:
NPDES Permit No.:N00003 760
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.:001
Location Coordinates: Latitude:35 19 29 Longitude:77 27 56
Permitted Flow:3.6 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse
Nutrient Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy)in pounds per year:35,193
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations (through purchase,plants acquired, regionalization,
etc.)in pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 35,193
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES
permit)in pounds at the discharge location:
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a
percent: 70%
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted and not in reserve)at the Estuary in pounds per year:
24,635
Certification (Must be signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurat nd complete.
4„,,j .2 I 0.7
Name and Title Date
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
CO-PERMITTEE/MEMBER INFORMATION AND APPLICATION FOR RENEWAL OF
NPDES PERMIT FOR TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE AS CO-PERMITTEE WITH THE
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
FACILITY OWNER: Commanding Officer—MCAS Cherry Point
Contact: Glenn Hartzog Phone Number: (252)466-4789
Address: Environmental Affairs Dept./PSC Box 8006/Cherry Point , NC 28533-0006
Email Address: glenn.hartzog@usmc.mil
Facility Operator(if different than owner):
Facility Name:
NPDES Permit No.: NC0003816
Receiving Waters: Neuse River
Outfall No.: 001
Location Coordinates: Latitude: 34°57' 11" Longitude: 76°53' 13"
Permitted Flow: 3.5 MGD
Original Total Nitrogen Allocation at the Discharge Location(as assigned in the Neuse Nutrient
Sensitive Waters Mgmt. Strategy) in pounds per year: 39,421
Other Acquired Total Nitrogen Allocations(through purchase,plants acquired,regionalization,etc.)in
pounds per year at the discharge location: (please list each acquisition separately):
Total Nitrogen Allocation(Permitted)at the Discharge Location: 39,421
Total Nitrogen Allocation Held in Reserve(not permitted through the individual NPDES permit)in
pounds at the discharge location:
Total Nitrogen Transport Factor to the Estuary as assigned by DWQ expressed as a percent: 100
Total Nitrogen Allocation (Permitted and not in reserve) at the Estuary in pounds per year: 39,421
Certification (Must he signed by the individual who would be authorized to sign a permit renewal.)
I certify that the above information is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true,
accurate and complete.
/
1_ )
Nam• kind Titl•
,t 1 Date
1
Attachment 4
Five Year Report
Neuse River Compliance Association
NPDES Permit No. NCC000001
NRCA Allocation Summary
-- ----- -_ -- Permit Original Discharge Original Additional
FACILITY NPOES Permit Flaw' Acquired Total Discharge Total Estuary Reserve Pending
-----------. Allocation Transport Estuary Allocations Allocation - -
- Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation
(MOD) (lbs/Yr.) Factor Allocation Acquired Year/Number , -- ---_ ___---
2007 2007
Original NNam(Original Na - Acquisitions
Town d Apex NC0064050 3.60 40,547 50% 20,274
Town d Benson - NC0020389 3.00 33,790 50% 16,895 33 790 20,274
SGWASA(Town d Butner)- - NC0026824 3.50 58,599 10% 5,860 6113 2005,NC0057011,NC0066109 33,790 16,895 ---
Cary
North NC0048879 12.00 135,158 50% 67,579 2022NC0050041 58,599 ,620 2445
___ _ --- 143,246 71,623----- - - - --
Cary South _ - - NC0065102 16.00 180,211 50% 90,105 2022 NC0050938 - _---
Cou dJohreton 180,211 90,103_"--- -------- -
^t NC0030716 4.99 56,203 50% 28,102 2816 NC0060330 - -
67,467 33,734 - --
Town dClayton -- NC0025453 2816 NC0064556 -- --_ --
2.50 21,400 50% 10,700 3668 2006,NCo057011,NC0066109 21,400_
Contentnea MSD --NC0032077 2.65 32,100 70% 22,470 22,70 3868`- -
Town of Fannvdle - - NCp029572 3.50 39,421! 50% 19,711 1395,NO0020362 _ 32,100 22,470' - -
C d Goldsboro 01 8 02 NC0023949 16.80 189,221 70% 132,455 5662 NC0030392 - 97,311__ 21,1067 809-NC0026062
-
�---------- - --- _. 197.3 1388.11 - --
Tam of Kenly NC0064891 0.63 7,096 50% 3,546 _1132 tJC0039233
City d Kinston(Peachtree) NC0020541 6.75 76,026' 70% 53,21 7,096 3• - -
City of Kinston-Regional Water Reclamati NC0024236 11.85 50,684 70% 35,47 53,218 2006 NC0020541(Peachtree) 126,710 - - -
Town d8,4475,9
LaGrange - NC0021644� 0.75 8,447 70% 5,913 85,913 - -
13 --
City of New Bern NC0025348 6.50 52,937_ 100% 52,93? 5,632 2007,NC0066613 58.568
City d Raleigh NC0029033 60.00 675,790 50% 337,8 �•�� _5055Stately Pines,Trent Riv
95t 253rNC0027570 -
61 NC0046230 6066-Neuse Crossing
Raleigh-Little Creek WWTP(Zebslon) NC0079316 1.85 20,837 1 50% 10,41; 809 NC0022363 622,415_ 311.209
Raleigh-Smith Creek W TP(Wake Fore NC0030759 6.00 67 579 50% 33 •h 1618 2006,NC0064149 70,45Y 1 70,81 355,.408
407 - -
City of Wilson NC0023908 14.00 157,684 50% 78,84. - --
157,684 78,842 -'-
Added Nambers(2802-2007)
Neuse Colony (2005) 45 h 3.60 8,447 50% 4,224►
Urrfi-Kinston LL ) NC0003760�NC0064 35,195 70% 24,637 _ 8,447 4,22g
MCAS Cherry Point(2005) NC0003816 t 3.50 39,421_ 100% 39,421 - •121 24,635 -- -
AssodationAllocation 48,879 50% 24,440r-
48,87439,421 39,421 -
NRCA TOTALS
I 184.92 2,035,672` 1,118,913 88,1 24,017
---___- 0`'1 2,077,012 1,144,p17 6113-- - --
-- _Total NRCA Estuar Allocation+Reserve 1,150,130_
-- ---
Five Year Report-Progress Report
Compliance
The NRCA has been in full compliance with the permit since it was issued in 2003.
Current members of the compliance association discharged the following flows and
pounds of total nitrogen to the Neuse Estuary in the years shown:
Year Average Monthly Total Estimated
Flow (MGD) pounds TN to
Estuary
1995 83.808 1,784,130
1996 85.675 1,741,492_
1997 81.444 1,653,262
1998 93.442 1,387,717
1999 94.659 1,123,169
2000 92.582 1,056,202
2001 86.818 907,381
2002 89.926 797,991
2003 107.463 711,398
2004 101.203 558,553
2005 101.757 566,627
2006 102.970 542,205
The Association is extremely proud of the efforts of its members in their ability to
remove more nitrogen from the Neuse every year and the removal rates that they have
been able to achieve. It should be noted that one new member was added to the group in
2004 (Neuse Colony) and two additional members were added in 2005 (MCAS Cherry
Point and Unifi-Kinston, LLC.) We have seen that the commitment, experience and
knowledge of our members has helped the group to minimize nitrogen loading,which we
hope will further improve water quality in the Neuse River estuary in the future.
Enforcement Summary
The Association has an internal enforcement policy that requires the individual members
to report to the group and to pay an assessment if they violate their individual nitrogen
allocation. The group notifies any member who is out of compliance with their
individual allocation for a given year, and requires the payment of an assessment and
submission of a compliance schedule to insure that the noncompliance is being
addressed. The enforcement policy gave the members one year of leniency(2003) before
assessments were made.
Starting with 2004's data the group notified two members that they had exceeded their
allocation for that year. The Town of Kenly and Contentnea MSD(CMSD) were
assessed and paid penalties under the group's enforcement strategy. In 2005, these two
dischargers paid to lease nitrogen from other members in order to establish their
compliance, rather than to face continued enforcement. The group requires regular
updates on these member's status and their plans to bring their plants into compliance.
The three towns that make up CMSD are working to control infiltration and inflow. This
is a slow and expensive task for small towns. They have made major improvements to
the collection system, however I&I is still a major priority. The board has been presented
with a plan which includes an upgrade and expansion of this facility. A decision should
be made in the next 6 months. During 2006, the facility experimented with"Kenaf'to
assist in TN reduction. The regional office of DWQ was aware of this test and other
facilities have used this product with some degree of success. The facility ran the study
for 6 months using this product and determined that it was detrimental to the treatment
process and did not accomplish any nitrogen removal. They discontinued the study in
August of 2006.
The Town of Kenly was asked by the Association to secure the services of a consulting
engineering firm to assist them in planning for improvements to their facility. The
Association had sent several operators from large facilities to the Town of Kenly in
efforts to assist the operator to optimize their treatment process. It appeared that the
inability to control the process 24 hours per day, due to a lack of automation and an
"around the clock"staff, was limiting their success in meeting the nitrogen allocation.
The NRCA formally asked the Town of Kenly for an engineering report in late 2006.
The Town presented their engineering report to the Association at their May meeting.
The Town is pursuing funding to carry out the necessary improvements to their
wastewater process. The Association will continue to monitor their progress in this
effort.
The Marine Corps Air Station at Cherry Point joined the Association in 2005. The base
had problems meeting their nitrogen allocation in the past and wished to lease nitrogen
from the Association to allow them to be compliant while they upgraded their plant. The
Base has begun construction of the upgrades to their facility and has brought the plant
into compliance with the nitrogen allocation, without the use of the leased nitrogen. They
accomplished this through staffing changes and by educating their staff in nitrogen
removal optimization techniques.
NRCA Four Year Performance
--♦—Monthly Discharge - - - Monthly Limit —Best Fit Linear Trend Line
100,000 ------ -- ---- - - -
90,000 — -- - - �_ - - - - - - - -
•
80,000 —
0 70,000
Z —
0
60,000 — -
a
50,000 —. _ _ ► ■�`.�
40,000 mow•
ilk
30,0000 0 o M (4M , , . , , , . MM , ,
E44� $ 4 4 4 4 4 44 44441pp '44' 44 $ 4q 4EEEy
15.
_ Q42 LL � Ql - Qo 82iLLi
14
Month
2007 Blue Ribbon Water Quality Trading
Awards
Nomination:
Neuse River Compliance Association
North Carolina
Contact Information:
Neuse River Compliance Association
PO Box 1562
Apex, NC 27502-3562
919/387-3478
Cindy Finan, Executive Director
Email: cfinan(a nc.rr.com
Program created by:
The Lower Neuse Basin Association
and the
NC Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources-
Division of Water Quality
Background
The Neuse River is approximately 150 miles long with its basin encompassing 6,192
square miles. The basin covers all or part of 19 counties and has a population of 1.3
million people. (See Figure 1.) The Neuse River Estuary is a shallow estuary that feeds
directly into the Albemarle-Pamlico Sound system which is the United States' second
largest estuarine complex and a key fisheries nursery for the mid-Atlantic coastal region.'
The estuary has experienced major eutrophication issues since the early 1970's. The
increased nutrient loading to the estuary has caused major algae blooms and fish kills.
The publication of the book"And the Waters Turned to Blood"by Rodney Barker in
1997 brought considerable attention to the plight of the Neuse River Estuary. When
initial research indicated that phosphorus was the problem, the State of North Carolina
initiated a phosphorus detergent ban in 1987. Problems in the estuary continued and
further research pointed the finger at nitrogen as the limiting factor.
The management strategy for the Neuse River Estuary included a Total Maximum Daily
Load (TMDL)that was adopted in 1999. Studies showed that a reduction of 30%was
necessary in the Total Nitrogen loading, with a deadline of 2003. The point source
dischargers in the basin were given an allocation of 1,640,000 pounds of Total Nitrogen
in order to meet this reduction. There was no allocation reserved for new or expanding
facilities. Allocations were given based on the permitted flows that existed in the permits
in 1995. This caused a great inequity in the distribution of the Total Nitrogen allocations,
Paerl,Hans W.,Lexia M. Valdes,Alan R.Joyner and Michael F.Piehler;University of North Carolina at
Chapel Hill,Institute of Marine Science. Martin E. Lebo,Weyerhauser Corp. "Environmental Science and
Technology",2004,38,3068-3073
Page 2 of 16
where some dischargers had permits for much more flow than they would ever need and
others were caught at or near capacity, with little or no room for growth.
Figure 1.
Falls Lake MA
Wilson
Durham
Neuse River
Cary
Pamlico Sound
Raleigh
1141111P
Smithfield
Goldsboro 1.
111111411144, _
Kinston
New Bern
Havelock
A river basin group called the Lower Neuse Basin Association existed at the time that the
TMDL was developed. This group was primarily a basin coalition that conducted
comprehensive basin-wide monitoring of the river and it's tributaries in order to comply
with their individual NPDES permits. Due to the inequities caused by the distribution of
the allocations, the "Neuse Rules"that were developed by the State, allowed for the
formation of compliance groups by the major point source dischargers. The concept of
the compliance group was to allow a group of dischargers to meet a collective limit, thus
allowing them to pursue reduction strategies where the most benefit could be enjoyed at
the lowest cost. In 1996, the General Assembly of the State of North Carolina
appropriated 2 million dollars for the Lower Neuse Basin Association, to provide grants
Page 3 of 16
to dischargers in the basin to help them pursue nitrogen reduction strategies at their
plants, or to remove wastewater discharges from the river.
From the members of the Lower Neuse Basin Association came an altruistic group of
dischargers who became the Neuse River Compliance Association (NRCA). The NRCA
is a non-profit, 501 c (3) organization. They worked with the State and were given the
first permit issued to a compliance association in the United States in December, 2002.
The members of the NRCA and their respective allocations are listed in the excerpt of the
Annual Report for 2005 which is included in AppendixA. For clarification purposes, the
members of the Lower Neuse Basin Association and the Neuse River Compliance
Association are essentially the same,but the State required that a new non-profit be set up
to receive the permit. The NPDES permit,NCC000001, applies only to Total Nitrogen
and gives the group a collective limit for the number of pounds of TN that can be
discharged by the members in a year. Each member has an allocation for TN that is
expressed in two ways; 1)pounds of Total Nitrogen at the point of discharge and 2)
pounds of Total Nitrogen at the estuary(which is the discharge pounds multiplied by the
transport factor.) Under the group permit, if the group complies with the collective TN
limit, then all of the members are deemed by the State to be compliant with their TN
limit. If the NRCA were to violate its TN limit for the year, the group would be subject
to enforcement from the State and the bylaws of the Association would reflect that
violation back to,the member(s)who were in noncompliance with their individual
allocation. Under the NRCA Bylaws, the fine paid by the group would ultimately be
charged back to the offending members.
Page 4 of 16
Accomplishments of the NRCA
To date the members of the Neuse River Compliance Association have spent in excess of
50 million dollars on nutrient reduction at their plants. The deadline of a 30% reduction
by 2003 was met and exceeded by more than three years. The Total Nitrogen loading
from the group in 2000 showed a reduction of 46% over the 1995 levels. By the end of
2001, the group had reduced their nitrogen loading by 53%. As of 2005, the reduction
reported by the group was up to 68%! It should be noted that in 2005 the group took on
two new members, Unifi-Kinston, LLC and the Marine Corps Air Station at Cherry
Point. The collective discharge data for the NRCA is shown in Table 2. A comparison
of the discharge from the original group of members and with the addition of the two new
members in 2005 is reflected in the table.
Table 2: NRCA Total Nitrogen Discharge by Year
Year Total Flow Total Estimated
(MGD) pounds TN to
Estuary
1995 83.808 1,784,130
1996 85.675 1,741,492
1997 81.444 1,653,262
1998 93.442 1,387,717
1999 94.659 1,123,169
2000 92.582 1,056,202
2001 86.818 907,381
2002 89.926 797,991
2003 107.463 711,398_
2004 101.203 558,553
2005 101.757 566,627
2005* 98.837* 522,171*
*Loading in pounds from the original members, if you exclude values for new 2005
members: MCAS Cherry Point and Unifi-Kinston, LLC.
Total permitted allocation w/o new members: 1,073,115
Estuary Discharge w/o new members: 522,171 pounds
%of permitted discharge 48.66%
Page 5of16
Total permitted allocation w/ new members: 1,137,171
Estuary Discharge w/new members: 566,627
%of permitted discharge: 49.83%
Mandated Reduction by 2003: 30%
Reduction Demonstrated by NRCA over 1995 Loading: 68%
Reduction Demonstrated by Original NRCA Members: 70%
NRCA Trading Dynamics
The Neuse Rules allow dischargers that need more allocation to acquire it from others
who have excess allocation. The rules for the Neuse Basin do not allow for point sources
to trade with non-point sources at this time. No discussion of point source/non-point
source trading is contained in this nomination package. Trading among point sources
encourages economic efficiency in meeting the overall nitrogen limit in the Neuse, based
on the assumption that dischargers will make trades to benefit both parties while still
meeting the required reduction. The NRCA has no authority over trades at this time,
other than the fact that the bylaws prohibit the selling of nitrogen to a non-member
(nitrogen allocation cannot leave the group). However, members are free to buy nitrogen
from non-members (nitrogen may be brought in from non-members.) One of the keys to
achieving benefits from trading is that there is a"transport factor" for nitrogen assigned
to each discharger. The State established Nutrient Management Zones with associated
transport factors to the various sub-basins of the Neuse. (See Figure 2.) The concept of
the transport factor is not unique to the NC strategy, but works on the premise that
nitrogen gradually diminishes as it travels down the Neuse to the estuary. A discharger
located further upstream may discharge more nitrogen without having an adverse effect
on the estuary. For example, one pound of nitrogen discharged directly into the estuary is
assumed to have the same effect as two pounds discharged in the Raleigh area. It would
Page 6 of 16
follow that rather than spending a certain amount to reduce its nitrogen in the Raleigh are,
that same amount would be better spent to reduce a discharge directly into the Neuse
estuary and would achieve twice the benefit. In exchange, a discharger in the Raleigh
area who provides funds to reduce a discharge at the estuary would receive the nitrogen
allocation that the discharger in the estuary was no longer discharging.
Figure 2: Nutrient management zones for the Neuse River basin.
�:•i�ii^"t•�t
Vicinity Map
rcA
NEU2
„NEW NEU7
14.
EU4 �I r'� A1119
Petard 714 beltowed
1aFaWyMa�ebrY� �: •�1�: �:
t lax
17,1; 70%
100%
N a.RNw
rB
I sm e
NrA
NEU2 &db.nNuMr 20 0 440 Miu �EN1R
;r
The State of North Carolina has encouraged the NRCA to conduct trading only in the
permanent sale of nitrogen that can be reflected in the individual permits of the
dischargers. Due to the fact that nitrogen allocation is a scarce commodity in North
Carolina and the management strategy did not reserve any allocation for growth in the
basin, dischargers are simply not going to sell nitrogen permanently. There have been
Page 7 of 16
only two official sales/trades, involving allocation that was purchased from a system that
went to land application of the wastewater. The sales have been controversial, have been
highlighted by considerable media attention and the State has not allowed the acquired
nitrogen to be added to the NRCA permit as of this date. As a complicating factor, the
environmental groups that advocate for the Neuse River do not understand the concept of
trading and want any and all reductions to be experienced by the river. They put constant
pressure on the State to limit trading, even though it is provided for in the rules, and fight
to have every pound of nitrogen that is removed from the river to be removed forever.
These groups fail to recognize the significant achievements of the NRCA and the
extraordinary reductions that have been achieved by these point sources. The 30%
reduction that was identified was mandated for non-point sources as well,but there is
little or no pressure on the non-point sources to accomplish the required reductions and
there is little data to document what reductions have taken place from non-point sources.
Due to the limitations that have been discussed previously, the NRCA has had to been
extremely innovative in managing nitrogen within the group. The NRCA has specific
bylaws and enforcement policies that prevent members from gaining the protection of the
group permit if they are not making necessary improvements to their plant and
operations. The enforcement policy requires members who exceed their individual
allocation to pay an assessment to the group that doubles each year. The monetary basis
for the assessment is the amount that the discharger would pay the State of NC to
purchase nitrogen from the Ecosystem Enhancement Project. The first year, the member
would pay 25% of this amount, 50%the second year, up to the full amount. If the
Page 8 of 16
member is reluctant to make necessary improvements to the plant or fails to pay the
assessment, the group can vote to remove them from membership, which would subject
them to enforcement from the State of NC for violation of their allocation. In this way
the group uses peer pressure to encourage continuous improvement among the
membership. In the same way, the group provides technical assistance to members who
could benefit from improved operational strategies. Due to the diversity of the
membership in terms of size and resources, the larger members who have more resources,
assist the smaller members who may be lacking in knowledge or funds. The best aspect
of the enforcement policy as an incentive for compliance, is that any assessments
collected from the members are held in escrow and are returned (in the amount of 80%)
to the member once compliance is achieved. The group does retain 20% of these funds
as an administrative cost. This seems far more palatable to the dischargers than paying
fines to the State without hope of getting any of it back!
A good example of the effectiveness of the group compliance approach is the situation
that was experienced with a new member to the NRCA in 2005. The Marine Corps Air
Station at Cherry Point had been exceeding its nitrogen allocation for some time before
joining the NRCA. The base joined the NRCA in order to lease nitrogen for a three to
five year period to allow them to comply with their permit while the plant was upgraded.
The terms of their membership and their agreement to lease nitrogen, showed a major
commitment on the part of Cherry Point to make the improvements needed to meet their
allocation. The lease agreement called for the cost of the lease to increase each year,
providing an incentive for them to make improvements in a timely manner. With these
Page 9 of 16
incentives in place, the Marine base began a comprehensive training program for its
operators and made some substantial operational improvements to optimize their
treatment process. In the end, Cherry Point never did violate their individual allocation
and did not need the allocation they had leased. They continued to pay their lease
payments, in good faith and have pursued the necessary improvements to their plant.
One important feature of this lease agreement, was that the membership determined that
the funds paid by Cherry Point would be earmarked for projects that would directly
benefit the Neuse River and nutrient management. The group voted to use the funds to
partially fund a reuse project for another member that will essentially divert that
member's entire wastewater discharge to a nursery operation during the summer months,
thus removing this loading from the river when the stress is the greatest. If Cherry Point
were not a member of the NRCA, it is doubtful that any regulatory agency could have
compelled it to pay a penalty assessment, and even if a penalty was paid, the funds would
not have been used to benefit the Neuse.
Two smaller members of the NRCA are still pursuing funding for necessary capital
improvements to their plants in order to meet their nitrogen allocations. In the mean
time, the group monitors their progress, requires them to make regular reports to the
group and provides short term leases opportunities for them to avoid the enforcement
assessments that the group's enforcement policy requires. In some respects, the members
would rather negotiate a short-term lease for needed nitrogen, rather than to fall subject to
"enforcement"by the group. Even though lease costs cannot be recouped by the member
Page 10 of 16
(as they can from the enforcement policies), it is often cheaper and better to be
considered "in compliance."
Accounting Procedures and Evaluation of the Program
The NRCA is required to report to the State of NC, Division of Water Quality every six
months. The group is required to submit two reports to the State each year that include
the total loadings from each member, to determine compliance with the permit, along
with other aspects of the group's activities. The Midyear Report is due on Aug. 31 of
each year, which includes the last 12 months of Total Nitrogen data for each member,
reported as Total Monthly Flow,Monthly Average Total Nitrogen and the loading
expressed as pounds for each month and totaled for the period. This report is not used for
compliance purposes,but is used to give the State a running 12 month snapshot of the
group's loading. The Annual Report is required to be submitted by February 28th of each
year and includes all data(as described above) for the calendar year along with a survey
of member's activities. This report includes information regarding regionalization, a
summary of all purchases, sales, trades, leases or other transactions affecting the
allocations of the members, enforcement updates, changes in membership, control
strategies for the coming year, a summary of measures taken to control TN for the last
year(for each member),and an assessment of progress made and a description of other
efforts or projects for the coming year(s). The fact that all of the activities of the
association are governed and reported under an NPDES permit make this program fairly
unique. This type of reporting and its subsequent review by the State provides
transparency for all activities of the NRCA and any leases or trades that might take place.
The State discourages temporary leases and encourages permanent trades that then can be
Page 11 of 16
reflected in the individual NPDES permits. The State uses the NRCA permit as a means
of tracking and accounting for all Total Nitrogen Allocations of the members. The
NRCA reports are submitted under the conditions of the NPDES permit and are therefore,
public information and subject to public scrutiny as well. A copy of the data portion of
the 2005 Annual Report is included in Appendix A. The narrative portion of the report is
too lengthy to be included here. The Executive Committee and Executive Director of the
NRCA are in contact with the staff of the Division of Water Quality on a continuing basis
and meetings are held periodically to discuss issues that affect the permit and the group.
The uniqueness of this program necessitates constant communication and the utmost
cooperation between the NRCA and the State. We are essentially making this up as we
go along, so communication and cooperation are essential to the success of the program
and to the development of future strategies to enhance membership in the NRCA and the
benefit to the Neuse River.
Collaboration and stakeholder involvement have always been a part of the NRCA. By its
very nature, it includes representatives from 20 members (large municipalities, small
towns, a private utility, industry and a military base.) The diversity of the membership
and the various representatives and elected officials who serve as the delegates, deliver a
variety of opinions and viewpoints. Due to the state-issued permit, there are
opportunities for public input, notice and hearing involving most association activities.
The association has kept the conservation groups informed of their efforts and has
supplied them with copies of the annual reports. The group is actively involved with two
different universities in the North Carolina University System to participate in research
Page 12 of 16
and the sharing of data on the Neuse Estuary and to draw on the expertise of academia.
These research efforts are explained in a subsequent section of the nomination.
Actual or Anticipated Environmental Improvement
To reiterate the actual environmental improvement that has been experienced by the
Neuse River, thanks to the NRCA: in 1995 the point sources who make up the current
membership of the NRCA discharged 1,784,130 pounds to the Neuse River Estuary. The
permit that was in force in 2003 and 2004, permitted the group to discharge 1,073,115
pounds of Total Nitrogen. The group reported a discharge of just 722,374 pounds or 67%
of the permitted load. In 2004, the members decreased this amount by 163,821 pounds,
discharging 558,553 pounds of nitrogen(52%of the permitted limit.) In 2005 the group
discharged 566,627 pounds of TN, or 50%of its permitted limit(which increased to
1, 137,171 due to the addition of two new members and their allocations.) The total
impact on the Neuse was the reduction of the Total Nitrogen load by 68%or a total of
1,217,503 pounds in 2005 over what was discharged in 1995. If you look at the
cumulative reduction since 1996, the NRCA has kept 7,337,508 pounds of TN out of the
Neuse River from what was being discharged during the baseline year of 1995. One can
only imagine the benefits to the river and estuary from a reduction of this magnitude.
Actual or Expected Economic Benefits
The economic benefits that have been realized by the Neuse River and its estuary and the
State of North Carolina thanks to the efforts of the NRCA are difficult to quantify. A
great deal of money has been spent by the municipalities and industries that hold
membership in the NRCA. It is estimated that over fifty million dollars has been spent
Page 13 of 16
I
on upgrades to wastewater facilities and to construct new facilities to remove nitrogen
from the receiving waters. The conditions in the Neuse River and the estuary have
greatly improved, and the NRCA is now participating in research being conducted by the
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Institute of Marine Science to further
document the recovery of the estuarine system. The NRCA is supporting this research, in
the amount of$65,000 per year, to assist in this effort. In addition to the economic
benefits that have undoubtedly been experienced by the aesthetic improvements and
public perception of the river and the coast, the other major economic benefit is the
growth that the NRCA has now provided for in the eastern part of North Carolina. The
development of the TMDL for the Neuse, mandated a 30%reduction in nitrogen loading
from point sources. As mentioned previously, there were no provisions for growth in
terms of new or expanding wastewater facilities. The 68%reduction that has been
realized by the NRCA has bought the State of North Carolina some room to grow, in a
part of North Carolina that is trying to grow very rapidly.
The improvements made by NRCA members and the fact that many of our members are
treating well below what is accepted as Best Available Technology, have provided an
excess allocation that stands to allow some growth in the basin that otherwise would have
been impossible. The NRCA is currently participating in negotiations with the State that
might allow the members of the NRCA to leverage some additional flows for their
facilities, based on their ability to treat below BAT levels and based on the unused
portion of the allocation that they group holds. The group shares information and
promotes reuse projects that will also remove flow and nitrogen from the wastewater
Page 14 of 16
discharges, that could allow for more growth for the towns and cities of eastern North
Carolina. The NRCA is anxious to pursue point source, non-point source trading as a
way of providing additional reductions from agriculture and non-point sources that could
help their town provide more growth, while protecting the river and the estuary. The
group is currently supporting research by North Carolina State University into alternative
methods of providing nutrient offsets, that might allow municipalities to expand buffers
within the basin,purchase conservation easements and construct stormwater retrofit
projects that would benefit the river and the estuary. The group hopes that by conducting
this research and showing the benefit and cost of other alternatives, that the
Environmental Management Commission of NC could be persuaded to add some
additional measures to provide for this type of non-point source,point source trading.
Conclusion
This group has had to been innovative, cooperative and altruistic in their struggle to
reduce nitrogen loadings to protect the Neuse, while meeting the pressures of growth and
economic development. The have proven their ability to meet the challenge of a
mandated reduction in nitrogen loading, by working together and sharing information and
resources and accomplishing what no one though was possible. They take their
obligation to the Neuse very seriously and conduct additional research and monitoring to
look for new ways to improve the estuary and to optimize nitrogen removal at their
plants. Their efforts have gone unnoticed and unappreciated by the citizens of North
Carolina, thanks to conservation groups that fail to acknowledge the effort and
commitment they have demonstrated. The NRCA has not simply used nutrient trading in
Page 15 of 16
its most traditional sense, but has looked for innovative ways to bring new tools to the
trading tool box. To be a member of the NRCA is a much bigger commitment than just
agreeing to buy some nitrogen when you need it. This group constantly strives to bring
all its members up to a standard of excellence that provides the best treatment and the
cleanest reclaimed water to protect the Neuse River and its estuary.
Appendix A- Excerpt from the NRCA Annual Report for 2005
See Appendix A-File Attached
Page 16 of 16
TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT 1 ,
- - - -- L - -� i- , PAGE 1 OF 4,
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
YEAR-END REPORT FOR 2006 - 1-
2006-JAN THROUGH DEC February 25, 2007
NPDES PERMIT NO: NCC000001 i -- ----- --
END OF PIPE ESTUARY
Permit 2006 Member TN Member TN Temporary Original Adjusted TN I 2006 TN __
FACILITY NPDES Permit - Flow' Avg Flow Allocation Discharge Transport Lease Estuary Allocation 200.6! Discharge
(MGD) (MGD) (Ibs/Yr.) (Lbs/Yr.) Factor Agreement Allocation (Ibs/Yr.) r (Lbs/Yr.) -
Town of Apex NC0064050 3.60 2.343 40,547 31,076 50%
Town of Benson NC0020389 3.00 1.192 33,790 13,178 50% 20'274 20,274. 15,538.0
Butner/SGWSA NC0026824 3.50 2.100 58,599 42,924 10% 16'895_ 16,895! 6,589.0
Cary North _- NC0048879 12.00 6.989_ 143,246 77,357 50% 5,860 15,6231 .8,678.5
Cary South NC0065102 16.00 4.824 180,211 33,247 50% 71,623 71,6231 38,678.5___
County of Johnston. _NC0030716 90,105 90,105 _ 16,623.5
4.99 4.233 67,467 24,560 50% -3000 33,734 30,7341 12,280.0
Town of Clayton NC0025453 2.50 1.469 21,400 17,680 50%
Contentrtea MSD NC003207710,700 10,700 _ 8,840.0
2.85 1.994 32,100 32,330 70% 5000 22,470 27,470' 22,631.0
Town of Farmville _ NC0029572 3.50 2.076 42,211_ 21,184 50% - r
City of Goldsboro 01 8 02 NC0023949 16.80 7.742 198,118 83,348 70% -_ 31,526 38,121 18,343.6
138,521 138,521 58,343.6
Town of Kenly NC0064891 0.952 -
0.63 0.404 7,096 8,480 50% _ 3000 3,548 6,548 4,240.0
'City of Kinston (Peachtree) NC0020541 6.75 2.114 76,026 33,055 70%
City of Kinston (North) NC0024236 4.50 3.161 50,684 50,044 70% 53,218 53,2181 23,138.5
Town of LaGrange NC0021644 0.75 0.535 8,447 5,839 70% 35,479 35,479135,030.8
Neuse Colony N000645645,913 5,913 4,087.3
0.75 0.109 8,447 5,386 50%
'City of New Bern _ NC0025348 6.50 3.349 52,937 37,033 100% 4,224 2,934 7,033.0
City of Raleigh _ NC0029033 60.00 44.798 676,417 313,508 50% 52,937 38,209} 37,033.04
City of Raleigh-smith Cr. NC0030759 6.00 1.026 67,579 9,386 50% 333,790 338,2091 _154,794.0,
City of Wilson NC0023906 14.00 8.495 157,684 100,857 50% 33,790 33,7901 4,693.0
1--- 78,842 78,842t 50,428.5
Town of Zebulon/Raleigh Little Cr NC0079316 1.85 0.591 22,455_ 6,238 50%
Unifl-Kinston_LLC NC000376011,227 11,2271 3,119.0
360. 0.420 35,193 12,140 70% -5000 24,635 19,6351 -
8,498.0
MCAS CherryPoint NC0003816 3.50 2.059 39,421 18,082 100% 10000 39,421 _ 49,421i 18,0.82.0
Association Allocatiod
NRCA TOTALS 48,879 0 50% -10000 24,4401 14,4401 0.0
177.571 102.970 .Net 0 1,137,171 1,137,1711 542,205
THIS MONITORING REPORT HAS BEEN COMPILED FROM CO-PERMITTEE MEMBERS MONTHLY DISCHARGE MONITORING
REPORTS_ I CERTIFY THAT IT IS ACCURATE AND COMPLETE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE.! ]
--
HAYWO_OD M_PHTHISIC, CHAIRMAN,NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
DATE
1. Flow from Nutrient Management Strategy with subsequent changes. 2. Goldsboro Pipe 02 is from Constructed Wetlands
•
3. Formerly Burlington Industries
y-- --
I
-Temporary-lease agreements between Unifi-Kinston LLC and Contentnea MSD,Kenly and Johnston Co.and MCAS Cherry Point and NRCA are reflected in the estuary allocations a_bo_v_e_.
-
_ TN discharge is calculated from DMR monthly flow and TN concentration. The product is rounded to whole number. 1
THIS REPORT PREPARED BY CINDY FINAN,NRCA EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT
----------- PAGE 2 OF 4
-L-- I 1 I I
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION - - -
YEAR-END REPORT FOR 2006 February 25, 2007
2006-JAN THROUGH DEC I
IDATA FROM CO-PERMITTEE MEMBERS -
-- Jan-06
Feb-06 Mar-06
FACILITY Flow TN Conc. TN Disch Flow TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow TN Conc. TN Disch.
(mg) (mg/I) (Ibs) (mg) (mg/I) I (Ibs) (mg) (mg/I) (lbs) (mg) (mg/I) --fibs)Town of Apex 72.975
4.95 3,013 63.494 4.96 2,627 65.076 4.830 2,621 64.045 5.1401 2,745
Town of Benson 37.775 4.051,276 29.333 3.54 866 29.956 6.29 1,571 31.043 7.78 2,014
Butnerr/SGWSA 63.289 3.86 2,037 57.792 5.43 2,617 54.932 7.16 3,280 54.270 8.20 3,711
Cary North 205.220 4.25 7,274 184.800 4.46 6,874 194.370 4.28 6,938 195.300 _ 3.22 5,245
Cary South 165.726 3.09 4,271 146.944 2.47 3,027 151.342 2.12 2,676 147.240 2.61 3,205
County of Johnston. 117.804 2.60 2,554 109.623 1.58 1,445 153.585 1.62 2,075 132.745_ 2.38 _2,635
Town of Clayton 41.954 8.95 3,132 36.836 3.97 1,220 44.995 3.95 1,482 45.451 2.83_ 1,073
Contentnea MSD 78.870 3.99' 2,625 59.610 3.18 1,581 50.300 4.53 1,900 45.910 6.67 2,554
Town of Farmville 71.658 1.63 974 58.057 1.93 934 56.620 2.35 1,110 49.120 2.76 _1,131'
City of Goldsboro Pipe 01 222.600 4.10 7,612 162.320 5.02 6,796 189.810 5.36 8,485 178.170 3.30 4,904
City of Goldsboro Pipe 02 30.400 2.29 581 41.630 3.46 1,201 2.830 2.32 55 10.570 1.57 138
Town of Kenly 14.800 13.10 1,617 10.800 9.4 847 11.700 4.4 429 10.700 8.70 776
City of Kinston(Peachtree) 122.014 7.00 7,123 97.635 6.97 5,676 106.710 5.37 4,779 99.596 4.72 3,921
City of Kinston(North) 60.967 7.43 3,778 51.084 6.86 2,923 35.950 12.56 3,766 26.337 21.02 4,617
Town of LaGrange 11.720 3.03 296 10.228 3.14 268 11.311 3.86 364 8.928 2.52 188
Neuse Colony 2.920 31.68 771 2,382 28.38 564
City of New Bern2.790 14.73 343 2.862 7.64 182
138.620 2.48 2,867 113.489 3.33 3,152 123.418 4.38 4,508 124.089 3.90 4,036
City of Raleigh 1388.137 4.04 46,771 1253.720 3.49 36,492 1386.498 1.94 22,433 1305.886 1.880 20,475
City of Raleigh-Smith Cr. 30.471 2.03 516 27.048 2.49 562 29.615 2.56 632 28.197 _3.08 724
City of Wilson 314.790 3.10 8,139 253.660 2.76 5,839 243.620 2.97 6,034 205.140 3.08 5,269
Town of Zebulon/Raleigh, Little 18.573 5.12 793 14.800 2.69 332 14.982 3.05 381 15.426 4.45 573
Unifi-Kinston,LLC 13.456 11.09 1,245 11.261 15.98 1,501 12.245 10.77 1,100 10.78810.71 964
MCAS Cherry Point 66.824 4.04 2,252 59.492 3.46 1,717 66.265 2.21 1,221 58.570 2.96 1,446
Association Allocation 0 _ -
TOTALS_, 0 0 0
_ _1 3291.563 111,517 2856.038 89,061 3038.920 78,183 2850.383 72,526
AVERAGE CONCENTRATION 4.06 3.74 }
3.08 3.05
TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT
PAGE 3 OF 4
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION
YEAR-END REPORT FOR 2006 I -- ----
1
2006--JAN THROUGH DEC - _ February 25, 2007
DATA FROM CO-PERMITTEE MEMBERS j ----
May-06
--May-06 Jun-06 Jul-06 Aug-06
FACILITY Flow TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow _ TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow TN Conc. TN_Disch.
(mg) (mg/I) (Ibs) (mg) (mg/1) (Ibs) (mg) (mg/I) (Ibs) (mg) (mg/I) (Ibs)
Town of Apex 70.948 5.140 3,041 81.592 4.220 2,872 67.609 3.08 1,737 65.514 2.94 1,606
Town of Benson 40.098 1.98 662 37.713 3.91 1,230 37.130 1.63 505 34.466 2.18 627
Butner/SGWSA 57.337 8.3 3,974 69.667 6.68 3,881 66.511 6.15 3,411 60.391_ 7.94 3,999
Cary North 192.820 4.20 6,754 251.100 3.65 7,644 216.380 2.87 5,179 205.840 3.40 5,837
Cary South 148.893 2.50 3,104 142.200 1.86 2,206 127.813 2.16 2,302 121.799 2.08 2,113
County of Johnston. 112.454 2.41 2,260 135.489 2.36 2,667 111.850 1.70 1,586 102.561 2.26 1,933
Town of Clayton 44.259 3.77 1,392 46.94- 1.9i 771 42.714 2.78 990 42.086_ 1.81 _635
Contentnea MSD 59.380 4.23 2,095 62.280 8.70 4,519 55.570 8.72 4,041 47.650 9.54 3,791
Town of Farmville 65.195 6.81 3,703 74.103 1.04 643 61.860 2.92 1,506 47.570 5.35 2,123
City of Goldsboro Pipe 01 224.170 3.36 6,282 246.030 3.14 6,443 254.320 2.37 5,027 210.380 2.75 4,825
City of Goldsboro Pipe 020 0.000 0.00 0 12.390 1.70 176 35.480 0.69 204 28.340 1.17 277
Town of Kenly 11.500 8.50 815 11.800 4.57 450 9.800 5.30 433 9.500 2.70 214
City of Kinston (Peachtree) 103.273 3.9900 3,437 92.840 2.880 2,230 93.248 5.59 4,347 56.383 3.28 1,542
City of Kinston (North) 24.366 16.53 3,359 40.412 8.96 3,020 51.618 2.06
Town of LaGrange 887 44.353 5.39 1,994
9 11.082 4.41 408 10.448 3.60 314 16.938 3.76 531 20.201 4.57 770
Neuse Colony 3.289 20.91 574 3.331 12.52 348 3.443 12.43 357 3.413 10.01 285
City of New Bern 123.004 3.350 3,437 113.062 3.240 3,055 139.441 3.35 3,896 34.736 3.58 1,037
City of Raleigh 1342.059 1.46 16,341 1478.998 2.21 27,260 1350.163 1.54 17,341 1353.532 1.94 21,900
City of Raleigh-Smith Cr. 28.566 3.01 717 32.981 3.19 877 30.824 3.57 918 29.252 3.89 949
City of Wilson 227.870 3.43 6,518 235.050 4.05 7,939 232.520 4.08 7,912 182.430 5.58 8,490
Town of Zebulon/Raleigh-Little` 17.781 4.21 624 21.369 3.11 554 14.943 3.94 491 15.637 4.26 556
Unifi-Kinston, LLC 11.680 11.68 1,138 14.291 14.29 1,703 12.960 11.08 1,198 13.060 9.29 1,012
MCAS Cherry Point 59.101 3.00 1,479 67.006 2.39 1,336 61.778 2.78 1,432 60.427 2.69 1,356
Association Allocatiorj 0 - _
TOTALS 0 0 0
_ 2979.125 72,114 3,281.101 82,138 3,094.913 66,231 2,789.521 67,871'
AVERAGE CONCENTRATION 2.90 3.00
----- 2.57 2.92
I
i
•
TOTAL NITROGEN DISCHARGE MONITORING REPORT
-__T
I I I PAGE 4 OF 4
NEUSE RIVER COMPLIANCE ASSOCIATION -- - _ - --
YEAR-END_ REPORT FOR 2006
2006-JAN THROUGH DEC February 25, 2007
_
DATA FROM CO-PERMITTEE MEMBERS
FACILITY - - Sep-06 Oct-06 Nov-06 _ Dec-06
Flow TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow I TN Concj TN Disch. Flow TN Conc. TN Disch. Flow ITN Conc. TN Disch.
(mg) (mg/I) (lbs) (mg) l (mg/I) (lbs) (mg) (mg/I) (lbs) (mg) (mg/I) (lbs)-
Town of Apex - 65.108 4.65 2,525 69.401 4.15 2,402 90.079 3.85 2,892 79.282 4.53 2,995_
Town of Benson 33.386 3.52 980 31.426 4.70 1,232 47.822 3.17 1,264 44.896 2.54_ 951
Butner/SGWSA 65.935 5.58 3,068 65.828 7.70 4,227 84.227 7.40 5,198 66.485 6.35 3,521
Cary North _ 217.200 3.21 5,815 215.760 3.52 6,334 235.800 3.53 6,942 236.220 3.31 6,521
Cary South 122.250 1.99 2,029 147.126 2.10 2,577 181.650 1.93 2,924 157.635 2.14 2,813
County of Johnston. 115.602 2.49 2,401 111.611 1.12 1,043 179.337 1.30 1,944 162.315 1.49 2,017
Town of Clayton 44.542 4.81 1,787 42.605 3.43 1,219 55.739 3.09 1,436 48.100 6.34 2,543
Contentnea MSD _ 70.070 5.92 3,460 49.500 4.58 1,891 81.180 2.88 1,950 67.630_ 3.41 1,923
Town of Farmville 75.980 3.28 2,078 51.730 3.20 1,381 79.490 4.85 3,215 66.530 4.30 2,386
City of Goldsboro Pipe 01 293.390 2.67 6,533 192.560 2.51 4,031 335.330 2.73 7,635 316.620 4.06 10,721
City of Goldsboro Pipe 02 41.020 0.00 0 48.640 0.28 114 51.570 0.82
Town of Kenly 13.100 2.80 306 11.600 7.50797 15.72_0 2.56 955
720
City of Kinston(Peachtree) 0.000 0.00 16.200 5.90 7970 10.000 0.10 1,070
0 0.000 0.00 0 0.000 0.00 0 0.000 0.00 0
City of Kinston (North) 207.203 4.25 7,344 154.595 4.68 6,034 232.840 3.38 6,564 224.170 3.08 5,758
Town of LaGrange 27.775 3.36 778 16.337 3.90 531 23.250 3.38 655 27.063 3.26 736_
Neuse Colony 3.591 15.60 467 3.642 18.17 552 4.062 9.84 333 4.234 17.27__ 610
City of New Bem 51.098 3.38 1,440 0.000 3.74
Cit of Raleigh 0 100.831 4.84 4,070 160.699 4.13 5,535
Y g 1326.619 2.42 26,775 1345.279 2.81 31,527 1437.713 2.41 28,897 1382.556 1.50 17,296
City of Raleigh-Smith Cr. 30.273 2.31 583 31.702 3.01 796 39.725 3.66 1,213 35.682 3.02 899
City of Wilson 297.100 4.03 9,986 223.460 4.87 9,076 346.570 4.33 12,515 336.660 4.68 13,140
Town of Zebulon/Raleigh-Little 17.246 2.92 420 15.430 2.42 311 27.100 3.50 791 22.432 2.20 412
Unifi-Kinston, LLC 13.040 5.74 624 10.943 4.99
_ CherryPoint 455 11.599 5.66 548 17.937 4.36 652
62.430 3.40 1,770 62.037 2.58 1,335 64.730 2.54 1,371 62.821 2.61 1,367
MCASatin PcaGorT _
TOT_ALS__ 0 0 i 0
_ 1 3,193.958 81,169 2,901.212 77,794 3726.844
AVERAGE CONCENTRATION 3.05 93,507 3580.487 84,821
3.22 3.01 `-
2.84