HomeMy WebLinkAbout20171122 Ver 2_2017-1122v010423_FINAL_GUC_DRAFT 2022 MY3 Report__20230110ID#* 20171122 Version* 2
Select Reviewer:
Katie Merritt
Initial Review Completed Date 01/11/2023
Mitigation Project Submittal - 1/10/2023
Is this a Prospectus, Technical Proposal or a New Site?* O Yes O No
Type of Mitigation Project:*
Stream Wetlands Buffer Nutrient Offset
(Select all that apply)
Project Contact Information
Contact Name:* Email Address:*
Raymond Holz rholz@restorationsystems.com
Project Information
.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
ID#:* 20171122 Version:* 2
Existing ID# Existing Version
Project Type: DMS • Mitigation Bank
Project Name: GUC Buffer & Nutrient Bank Parcel
County: Pitt
Document Information
Mitigation Document Type:*
Mitigation Monitoring Report
File Upload: 2017-1122v010423 FINAL GUC DRAFT 2022 MY3
31.76MB
Report_.pdf
Please upload only one PDF of the complete file that needs to be submitted...
Signature
Print Name: * Barrett Jenkins
Signature:
GUCCreditReleaseSummary
20171122v2
AsBuiltApproved"Restoration"RBMUs:1,491,885.751
MBIReleaseAmountReleasedby
RBMUs/Taskper
Task%ReleasedbyDWRDifferenceDateApproved
PercentageMBI%DWR(RBMUs)
1.BPDPapproved,etc.20.00%298,377.1520.00%298,377.150.008/5/2020
2.PostConstruction20.00%298,377.1520.00%298,377.150.008/5/2020
3.Asbuilt+bond10.00%149,188.5810.00%149,188.580.009/4/2020
4.MonitoringY110.00%149,188.5810.00%149,188.580.004/19/2021
5.MonitoringY210.00%149,188.5810.00%149,188.580.003/24/2022
6.MonitoringY310.00%TBD
7.TransfertoStewardship5.00%TBD
8.MonitoringY45.00%TBD
9.MonitoringY510.00%TBD
ƚƷğƌwĻƌĻğƭĻķƷƚ5ğƷĻЊЉЉ͵ЉЉіЊͲЉЍЍͲЌЋЉ͵ЉЋЏАЉ͵ЉЉі 1,044,320.030.00
AsBuiltApprovedPreservation
6,824.342
RBMUs:
AmountReleasedby
MBIReleaseRBMUs/Taskper
Task%ReleasedbyDWRDifferenceDateApproved
PercentageMBI%DWR(RBMUs)
1.BPDPapproved,etc.20.00%1,364.8720.00%1,364.870.008/5/2020
2.PostConstruction20.00%1,364.8720.00%1,364.870.008/5/2020
3.Asbuilt+bond10.00%682.4310.00%682.430.009/4/2020
4.MonitoringY110.00%682.4310.00%682.430.004/19/2021
5.MonitoringY210.00%682.4310.00%682.430.003/24/2022
6.MonitoringY310.00%TBD
7.TransfertoStewardship5.00%TBD
8.MonitoringY45.00%TBD
9.MonitoringY510.00%TBD
ƚƷğƌwĻƌĻğƭĻķƷƚ5ğƷĻЊЉЉ͵ЉЉіЍͲААА͵ЉЌВАЉ͵ЉЉі 4,777.040.00
AsBuiltApprovedNOC(N.)lbs.:118,089.653
MBIReleaseAmountReleasedby
TaskLbs./TaskperMBI%Difference%ReleasedbyDWRDateApproved
PercentageDWR(lbs.)
1.BPDPapproved,etc.20.00%23,617.9320.00%23,617.930.008/5/2020
2.PostConstruction20.00%23,617.9320.00%23,617.930.008/5/2020
3.Asbuilt+bond10.00%11,808.9710.00%11,808.970.009/4/2020
MonitoringY110.00%11,808.9710.00%11,808.970.004/19/2021
4.
5.MonitoringY210.00%11,808.9710.00%11,808.970.003/24/2022
6.MonitoringY310.00%TBD
7.TransfertoStewardship5.00%TBD
8.MonitoringY45.00%TBD
9.MonitoringY510.00%TBD
ƚƷğƌwĻƌĻğƭĻķƷƚ5ğƷĻ 100.00%БЋͲЏЏЋ͵АЏ 70.00%82,662.760.00
AsBuiltApprovedNOC(P.)lbs.:7,605.887
MBIReleaseAmountReleasedby
TaskLbs./TaskperMBI%%ReleasedbyDWRDifferenceDateApproved
PercentageDWR(lbs.)
1.BPDPapproved,etc.20.00%1,521.1820.00%1,521.180.008/5/2020
2.PostConstruction20.00%1,521.1820.00%1,521.180.008/5/2020
3.Asbuilt+bond10.00%760.5910.00%760.590.009/4/2020
4.MonitoringY110.00%760.5910.00%760.590.004/19/2021
5.MonitoringY210.00%760.5910.00%760.590.003/24/2022
6.MonitoringY310.00%TBD
Stewardship5.00%TBD
7.Transferto
8.MonitoringY45.00%TBD
9.MonitoringY510.00%TBD
ƚƷğƌwĻƌĻğƭĻķƷƚ5ğƷĻ 100.00%ЎͲЌЋЍ͵ЊЋ 70.00%5,324.120.00
Annual Monitoring ReportMY3(2022)
GUC NUTRIENT OFFSET AND BUFFER MITIGATION BANK PARCEL
DWR Project #: 2017-1122v2
Tar-Pamlico River Basin
In Agreement with:
The GUC Mitigation Banking Instrument for
Riparian Buffer and Nutrient Offset Mitigation Credits Pursuant to the
Tar-Pamlico Nutrient Management Strategy
Prepared By:
Restoration Systems, LLC
1101 Haynes St. Suite 211
Raleigh, NC 27604
Phone: 919-755-9490
Fax: 919-755-9492
JANUARY 2023
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
General Notes
Planted stem die-off continues to be an issue. Low survival was observed sitewide in MY 3.
Nuisance animal activity (pig rooting /deer browse) are noticeable on site, but not problematic.
Soil conditions combined with adverse climate patterns are believed to be the greatest challenges
to vegetative success at this time. Lack of consistent moisture availability, as previously noted in
2021 Adaptive Management plan, appears to be driving mortality.
Prolonged drought during the growing season in 2022 is the most obvious reason for the decline
in survival from MY 2 to MY 3.
See Appendix C for proposed Adaptive Management Plan.
Vegetation
14,350 stems were planted in March 2022. See Appendix C for species/locations.
MY 3 (2022) data collected shows an average of 240 planted stems/acre across the Parcel.
Additionally, 35 of the 87 individual plots met the success criteria (Table 5, Appendix B).
Seventeen (17) temporary transects were conducted around the conservation easement and
resulted in an average density of the temporary transects was 202 stems per acre (Table 6
Appendix B, and shown in Figure 2A-B (Appendix A).
The vigor of trees throughout the site varied; some areas of dense herbaceous vegetation had
higher tree mortality rates.
Yearly Monitoring Summary
Random Veg.
Fixed Veg. Plots Meeting
Average Stems per acreTransects Meeting
Success (of 87 Total)
Year
Success
# %
Planted 85 98% Planted 612.6 n/a
MY 0 (2020)
w/ Natural Recruits 85 98% w/ Natural Recruits 665.2
Planted 46 53% Planted 327.5 n/a
MY 1 (2020)
w/ Natural Recruits4653%w/ Natural Recruits365.6
Planted 59 68% Planted 334.0 11 of 14
MY 2 (2021)
w/ Natural Recruits 60 69% w/ Natural Recruits 343.3 393 stems /ac
Planted 35 40% Planted 240.5 4 of 17
MY 3 (2022)
w/ Natural Recruits 35 40% w/ Natural Recruits 242.8 202 stems / ac
2021 Adaptive Management Summary
On February 1, 2021, RS implemented an adaptive management plan based on Year 1 (2020) vegetation
monitoring data (Section 6.0 and Appendix C). Random vegetation transects were surveyed across the
Parcel shortly after replanting and indicated an increase of 160 stems per acre Parcel-wide. Year 2 (2021)
vegetation monitoring data suggests the 2021 adaptive management planting had a more significant
mortality rate than expected. Climatic conditions were not favorable post-planting for establishing bare-
root saplings, especially in sandy soils. Appendix C includes a rainfall analysis for the Greenville area,
regional drought mapping, and Parcel-specific precipitation analysis from the National Drought Mitigation
Center.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Executive Summary
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
Yearly Maintenance Summaries
2021 Maintenance Summary:
In the winter of 2020/2021 RS contracted USDA Wildlife Services staff (Josh Biesecker) and
coordinated a trapping and removal effort using highly-effective remote-operated traps. By
March 2021, 12 pigs were trapped and removed .
24,650 stems were planted during the implementation of the adaptive management plan.
2022 Maintenance Summary:
In March 2022 RS planted an additional 14,350 stems across 24.5 acres observed to have
low vigor during the drought period which occurred in late 2021. See Appendix C for
location figure. These areas were monitored by random transects in MY 3. In total, RS has
planted 102,900 tree and shrub saplings at the Parcel (original planting = 63,900, 2021
adaptive management planting 24,650, 2022 maintenance planting 14,350. ) by MY 3 Report
date
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Executive Summary
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
1.0 Introduction
Restoration Systems (Sponsor) is pleased to provide the North Carolina Division of Water Resources (NC
DWR) with this Annual Monitoring Report for the GUC Bank Parcel (Parcel). As agreed upon in the GUC
Riparian Buffer and Nutrient Offset Mitigation Banking Instrument (MBI) and GUC Bank Parcel
Development Packaged (BPDP), made and entered into on February 17, 2020, by Restoration Systems, LLC
(RS), acting as Bank Sponsor (Sponsor), and the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality
(NCDEQ), Division of Water Resources (DWR). This document details the riparian area restoration
activities, monitoring efforts, and the Parcel's mitigation potential.
The Parcel is 97.14 acres and is designed to provide mitigation credits for unavoidable impacts due to
development within the Tar-Pamlico River Basin. Tar-Pamlico River Riparian Buffer mitigation credits
provided by this Parcel are available in the Tar-Pamlico River Basin, according to 15A NCAC 02B .0295
(Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rule – CMB rule) (effective date– October 24, 2014) (Appendix D).
Mitigation credits for Nutrient Offset are made available within the Tar-Pamlico River Basin USGS 8-digit
HUC 03020103. Supporting figures, tables, and photos are located in Appendix A.
NCDWR representatives Katie Merritt and Chris Pullinger conducted an onsite determination for parcel
applicability and suitability on November 11, 2017. Follow-up information was provided to Katie Merritt
on January 22, 2019, and the Division provided a Site Viability for Buffer & Nutrient Offset on March 25,
2019, and revised on May 29, 2019 (Appendix C).
A phased approach was taken to allow for the completion of the Piedmont Natural Gas pipeline 24 "Line
24" – DWR 2018-1640. The Parcel was permitted in two phases (Phase 1, 68.02 acres, and Phase 2, 29.07
acres). Completion of the pipeline within the City of Greenville's property, including 401 permit release,
occurred in March 2020, allowing RS to perform restoration activities on both phases simultaneously. As
such, both phases will be reported on and monitored congruently and as one, with one monitoring report
submitted at the end of each year and one financial assurance policy.
Restoration construction activities involved removing existing farm infrastructure, including piped
crossings, dirt roads, a utility line, and a small agricultural building. RS began preparation for the
restoration of the riparian buffer and planted the Parcel in March 2020. Riparian buffer restoration
activities included ripping/bedding the Parcel with a narrow set plow, bare-root planting, and broadcast
th
application of a permanent seed mix. During March 18–26, 2020,Axiom Environmental installed eighty-
seven (87) Carolina Vegetation Survey (CVS) monitoring plots and collected as-built data. Katie Merritt of
DWR performed a restoration verification site visit on June 17, 2020.
2.0 Parcel Location
The Parcel is located approximately 4.5 miles east of Greenville in Pitt County, NC, and within Greenville's
municipal boundaries (Figure 1, Appendix A). The Parcel is within the Tar-Pamlico River Basin 14-digit
USGS Cataloging Unit 03020103070030 of the Middle Atlantic Coastal Plain (North Carolina Division of
Water Quality \[NCDWQ\] Sub-basin Number 03-03-05) (Figure 1, Appendix A).
Parcel Location: (35.603194, -77.294509)
Directions to Parcel from Raleigh:
- Take I-440 East from Capital Boulevard,
- Follow US-264 East to US-264 West (Greenville),
- Take Old Pactolus Rd for 3.2 miles,
- The Parcel is located on the right.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 1
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
2.1 Parcel Background
The Parcel encompasses 97.14 acres of historical agricultural fields. Before Parcel development,
agricultural fields were used as biosolids irrigation fields for the City of Greenville Waster Water Facility
and row crop production of hay or sorghum. The Parcel includes three unnamed tributaries and two
surface water conveyances/ditches with direct hydrologic connection to the Tar River, in addition to a
third unnamed tributary that connects to an onsite tributary before discharging into the Tar River (Figures
3A-B, Appendix A). Before construction, Parcel surface water conveyances and unnamed tributaries were
cleared of vegetation by historical agricultural practices and maintained as cleared ditches. Small pockets
of disturbed forests were located on the Parcel at the top of Feature 2, along the margins of Feature 5,
and in the southeast corner of Feature 8 (Figures 3A-B, Appendix A). Dirt roads, a powerline, and a small
dilapidated agricultural building were removed from the Parcel's footprint.
The Parcel comprises three separate tracts just north of the Tar River. Currently, Parcel tracts are subject
to two existing 50-foot Piedmont Natural Gas Company, Inc. (PNG) Easements. PNG Line 42, DWR Permit
No. 2012-1024 v7, runs roughly east to west across the GUC-owned tracts, and PNG easement and gas
line (Line 24 – DWR 2018-1640 – 401 approval on 04-26-2019 with DWR approval and 401 release on
March 11, 2020) connects to Line 42 and runs south under the Tar River. Both PNG easements are outside
of the Parcel's footprint.
2.2 Parcel Objectives
The primary goals associated with the restoration of riparian areas within the Bank Parcel focused on
improving water quality, enhancing flood attenuation, and restoring wildlife habitat. The Project goals for
each Phase are identical, while the Restoration Plan for each differed only with regard to the removal of
existing infrastructure. These goals were achieved by creating a forested riparian buffer adjacent to
stream channels and a forested riparian area along agricultural ditches and were accomplished by the
following.
1. Removing nonpoint sources of pollution associated with agricultural production, including a)
ceasing the broadcast application of class B biosolids, fertilizer, pesticides, and other agricultural
materials into and adjacent to Parcel surface water conveyances (ditches) and streams, b)
providing a restored buffer to filter runoff from adjacent lands.
2. Reducing sedimentation within onsite and downstream receiving waters by reducing bank
erosion, vegetation maintenance, and agricultural land disturbances.
3. Promoting floodwater attenuation by increasing frictional resistance of floodwaters crossing
Parcel floodplains.
4. Improving aquatic habitat by enhancing stream bed shading and natural detritus input.
5. Providing a terrestrial wildlife corridor and refuge in an area extensively developed for agricultural
production.
6. Restoring and re-establishing natural community structure, habitat diversity, and functional
continuity.
7. Protecting the Parcel's riparian buffer functions and values in perpetuity.
3.0 Restoration Activities
A restoration plan, including the following components, was completed in March 2020.
Primary components of the Restoration Plan included the following.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 2
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
1.Removal of an existing, abandoned farm building adjacent tofeature 6B & removal of a powerline
adjacent to features 6A and 6B
2. Removal of existing compacted earth roads adjacent to features 6A, 6B, and
3. Removal of four culverts
4. Parcel-wide soil preparation & herbaceous vegetation treatment
5. Riparian area restoration (replanting) extending from the top of bank (TOB) out 200' where
applicable and
6. Parcel protection in perpetuity through a conservation easement.
Tables A & B detail the restoration and protection activities. An outline of restoration activities and
their completion dates is provided in Table 2 (Appendix A).
Table A–Summary Restoration Activities
Restoration Phase 1Phase 2
Plan Activity(Figure 3A-C, Appendix A)(Figure 4A-B, Appendix A)
1.) Removal of existing dirt roads adjacent to
Parcel Features 6A, 6B
1.) Removal of existing dirt roads adjacent to 2.) Removal of two existing culverts at the
Removal of
Parcel Features 2 & 8 confluence of Features 5 and 6A
Existing
2.) Removal of two existing culverts at the 3.) Removal of an existing, abandoned farm
Infrastructure
confluence of Features 7B and 8 building adjacent to feature 6B
4.) Removal of a powerline adjacent to
features 6A and 6B
1.) Parcel-wide soil preparation herbaceous
1.) Parcel-wide soil preparation herbaceous
vegetation treatment ahead of planting
vegetation treatment ahead of planting
2.) Establishment of a native herbaceous 2.) Establishment of a native herbaceous
Riparian community via site-specific seed mix* community via site-specific seed mix*
Restoration 3.) Establishment of a native hardwood 3.) Establishment of a native hardwood forest
forest via the planting of bare-root via the planting of bare-root saplings from
saplings from the top of bank out a the top of bank out a maximum of 200'
maximum of 200' along Parcel Features along Parcel Features
* Permanent Seed Mix: Table D
Table B – Summary Protection Activities
1.) RS was granted a Conservation Easement by the City of Greenville, North Carolina,
on March 19, 2020. The conservation easement was recorded at the Pitt County
Parcel
Register of Deeds; Book No. 3912, Page 577-600.
protection
2.) RS marked the easement at every corner with an iron, CE cap, and corner t-post.
(97.14 acres)
Additionally, easement posts were placed every 200-feet along the Parcel
boundaries
3.1 Construction Activities
Three primary construction activities occurred onsite, including 1) the removal of an abandoned farm
building adjacent to feature 6B & removal of a powerline adjacent to features 6A and 6B; 2) the removal
of existing compacted earth roads adjacent to features 6A, 6B, and 8; and 3) removal of four culverts.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 3
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
After removing the powerline, abandoned agricultural building, and compacted earth roads. Treatment
of coastal Bermuda grass was completed in 2019. RS did not feel it was necessary to apply an additional
treatment nor a pre-emergent treatment for other herbaceous species. The Parcel was prepared for bare-
root planting by ripping parallel planting beds off each of the Parcel's features. The ripping and bedding
provided additional water storage for bare-root plantings and introduced microtopography, promoting
diffuse flow and surface water storage throughout the floodplain. Soil amendments were made by the
prior farmer before the planting of 2019 row crops. RS did not apply additional soil amendments.
Four culverts were removed, two between features 5 and 6A, and two between features 7B and 8. After
the culverts were removed, the side slopes were graded to match existing slopes at approximately a five-
to-one (5:1) slope. Matting, native seed mix, and live stakes were used to stabilize the stream banks,
providing long-term stability. Where necessary, black willow live stakes were used to stabilize the banks
throughout the Parcel.
3.2 Riparian Area Restoration Activities
Restoration of the riparian area allows for the recolonization and expansion of characteristic species
across the landscape. The riparian areas were restored in accordance with 15A NCAC 02B .0295. The
planting plan for the entire riparian restoration area (Phase 1 and 2), included planting native bare root
hardwood and shrub saplings across 86.36 acres at a Parcel density of 740 stems per acre and live stakes
for stream bank stabilization where necessary and the broadcast application of 195 LB of permeant seed
mix (~2 LB per acre). Community associations utilized include 1) Brownwater Bottomland Hardwoods
(High Subtype) and 2) Mesic Mixed Hardwood Forest (Coastal Plain Subtype) (Schafale 2012). The planted
species composition is intentionally diverse and, while based on these communities, also accounted for
local observations and nursery availability.
All species were selected based on their ability for sediment stabilization, rapid growth rate, the ability to
withstand hydraulic forces associated with flood events, suitability to specific soil types, and Parcel
conditions. Trees were mixed thoroughly before planting to provide diverse and random planting across
the Parcel. Planting occurred at a density sufficient to meet the performance standards outlined in Rule
15A NCAC 02B .0295 of 260 trees per acre at the end of five years. No one tree species accounted for
greater than 50% of the established stems.
The bare root planting list is provided in Table C, followed by the permanent seed mix in Table D. MY3
(2022) vegetation data is provided in Appendix B. Vegetation data for MY3 was collected in September
and October 2022, with a final visit in November 2022 by Axiom Environmental and derived an average
planted stem density of 240 stems per acre. In addition to native hardwood trees, the Sponsor planted
several species of native shrubs, aiding in developing a robust, ecologically sound riparian buffer. Shrub
species are counted towards success criteria per the Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rule 15A NCAC 02B
.0295 (November 1, 2015).
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 4
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
Table C – Planting List
% of Total
Tree/
Common Name Scientific Name TotalPlanted
Shrub*
Trees
River birch Betula nigra Tree 5200 8.14%
Hickory (mockernut)Carya tomentosa Tree10001.56%
Chinkapin Castanea pumila Shrub Tree 200 0.31%
Sugarberry Celtis laevigata Tree 1900 2.97%
Hackberry Celtis occidentalis Tree14002.19%
Buttonbush Cephalanthus occidentalis Shrub 800 1.25%
Redbud Cercis canadensis Tree 1100 1.72%
Silky dogwood Cornus amomum Shrub 700 1.10%
Hawthorn Crataegus marshallii Shrub Tree 900 1.41%
Persimmon Diospyros virginiana Tree 1200 1.88%
Yellow poplar Liriodendron tulipifera Tree 5200 8.14%
Crabapple Malus angustifolia Tree 600 0.94%
Mulberry Morus rubra Tree 1600 2.50%
Carolina buckthorn Frangula caroliniana Shrub Tree 2000 3.13%
Black gum Nyssa sylvatica Tree 5100 7.98%
Sycamore Platanus occidentalis Tree 5200 8.14%
Chickasaw plum Prunus angustifolia Tree 500 0.78%
Wild Cherry Prunus serotina Tree 1100 1.72%
Oak (White) Quercus alba Tree 2200 3.44%
Oak (Swamp White) Quercus bicolor Tree 2100 3.29%
Oak (Laurel) Quercus laurifolia Tree 1200 1.88%
Oak (Overcup) Quercus lyrata Tree 3000 4.69%
Oak (Swamp Chestnut) Quercus michauxii Tree 3300 5.16%
Oak (Water) Quercus nigra Tree 3,000 4.69%
Oak (Cherrybark) Quercus pagoda Tree 3000 4.69%
Oak (Willow) Quercus phellos Tree 2300 3.60%
Oak (Northern Red) Quercus rubra Tree 3000 4.69%
Oak (Shumard) Quercus shumardii Tree 2100 3.29%
American Elm Ulmus americana Tree 3000 4.69%
Arrowwood Vibrunum dentatum Shrub 1000 1.56%
Total 63,900 100%
*CVS species type designation
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 5
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
Table D –Permanent Seed
Amount (in Amount (in
Common NameCommon Name
pounds) pounds)
Common Yarrow 1.95 Showy Ticktrefoil 1.95
Redtop 29.25 Purple Coneflower 11.70
Winter Bentgrass, 9.75 Virginia Wildrye, 'Madison' 9.75
Perennial Gaillardia
Creeping Bentgrass 9.75 3.90
(Blanketflower)
Clusterspike False Indigo 1.95 Narrowleaf Sunflower 2.93
Showy Aster 1.95 Oxeye Sunflower 1.95
Blue False Indigo 3.90 Wild Bergamot 0.98
Oxeye Daisy 9.75 Deertongue, Tioga 9.75
Shasta Daisy 5.85 Tall White Beardtongue 1.95
Lanceleaf Coreopsis 9.75 Clasping Coneflower 1.95
Plains Coreopsis 9.75 Blackeyed Susan 5.85
Cosmos 3.90 Purpletop 39.00
Rocket Larkspur 3.90 Blue Vervain 1.95
Total (pounds) 195.00
4.0 Mitigation Potential
DWR has determined the nitrogen and phosphorous abatement of restored riparian areas to be 2273.02
lbs per acre for nitrogen and 146.4 lbs per acre for phosphorous, as agreed to in the GUC MBI. Riparian
buffer credits were measured by the hundredth of an acre and converted into square feet. The mitigation
potential for each Project Phase is detailed below.
The Parcel generated 86.20 acres of restored riparian area within a 97.14-acre Parcel. The Parcel will
preserve 10.94 acres of riparian areas, streams, and ditches.
Table 1 (Appendix A) outlines the components and mitigation credits to be generated within the Parcel.
Tar-Pamlico riparian buffer mitigation credit generated along Features 2, 6B, 7A, 7B, & 8 (all unnamed
tributaries) can be used for either riparian buffer credits or nutrient offset credits, but not both. For this
document, RS has chosen to designate the riparian areas from top-of-bank to 100 feet as Riparian Buffer
Credit and areas from 101-200 feet as Nutrient Offset Credit. Riparian Buffer Credits can be converted
and transferred to Nutrient Offset Credits; however, Nutrient Offset Credits conversions from areas 101-
200 feet to Riparian Buffer Credits will not occur.
Nutrient offset credits (nitrogen and phosphorous) generated along the two surface water conveyances
(ditches), Features 5 and 6A, cannot be converted into riparian buffer mitigation credits. RS must request
and receive approval to transfer any mitigation credits from DWR before adding or removing credits from
the ledgers. The Sponsor will maintain three credit ledgers per Phase. One ledger will account for riparian
buffer credits, one will account for nitrogen nutrient offset credits, and one will account for phosphorous
nutrient offset credits. All mitigation credit assets shall be shown on the credit ledgers (Table 1, Appendix
A).
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 6
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
5.0 Monitoring Protocol & Success Criteria
5.1 Monitoring Protocol
Restoration monitoring procedures for vegetation at each Phase will monitor plant survival and species
diversity. Quantitative sampling will include eighty-seven (87 \[Phase 1 = 61 Plots & Phase 2 = 26)
permanent 10 x 10-meter vegetation plots as outlined in the CVS Level 1-2 Protocol for Recording
Vegetation, Version 4.2 (Lee et al. 2008) and will occur no earlier than Fall of each year (Figures 2A-B,
Appendix A). A reference photo will be taken from the origin point of each plot. All planted stems in the
plots will be marked with flagging tape and recorded. Data collected will include species, height, and
planting type (planted stem and/or volunteer). Monitoring of the restoration efforts will be performed for
five years or until success criteria are fulfilled. RS shall submit to NCDWR annual monitoring reports for
both Project Phases (1 and 2) no later than December 31 of each year. Each report will document the
success of the vegetation and any maintenance, supplemental planting, or encroachment within the
easement areas. Success criteria within the buffer and nutrient offset restoration areas will be based on
the survival of planted species at a density of 260 stems per acre after five years of monitoring.
5.2 Parcel Maintenance
A remedial action plan will be developed and implemented with the approval of NCDWR in the event the
Parcel or a specific component of the Parcel fails to achieve success criteria as outlined above. Other
vegetation maintenance and repair activities may include pruning, mulching, and fertilizing. If exotic
invasive plant species require treatment, such species will be controlled by mechanical (physical removal
with the use of a chainsaw) and/or chemical methods (aquatic approved herbicide) following North
Carolina Department of Agriculture (NCDA) rules and regulations.
If mowing is deemed necessary by the Sponsor during the monitoring period, the Sponsor must receive
approval by the DWR prior to any mowing activities within Zone 1 and Zone 2 of the Neuse buffers along
UT2 to ensure that no buffer violations have been performed. Failure to receive approval to mow within
the Tar-Pamlico buffer as defined in 15A NCAC 02B .0258 by the DWR could result in Tar-Pamlico buffer
violations and violations of the conservation easement. If necessary, the Sponsor will develop a species-
specific control plan.
5.3 Long-Term Management Plan
The conservation easement preservesall areasand prohibitsall usesof the property inconsistent with its
use as mitigation property, including any activity that would materially alter the Parcel's biological
integrity. RS will transfer or assign the conservation easement and its interests in perpetuity to a qualified
holder under NC General Statute ("GS") 121-34 et seq. and 170(h) of the Internal Revenue Code before
the submittal of the Year 4 Monitoring Report. The holder shall be a land trust or stewardship program
accredited by the Land Trust Accreditation Commission and/or has been approved by DWR. A land trust
must be certified under 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
6.0 Parcel Management Summary
MY 1 - 2020
During the June 2020 as-built walkthrough, DWR and RS determined a small area adjacent to vegetation
plot 9 was not planted during the initial Parcel planting effort in March 2020. During the as-built
walkthrough and subsequent field visits, RS took GPS points where planting did not occur. The area totaled
0.54 acres and was planted in early February 2021.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 7
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
Yr. 1 (2020) monitoring efforts determined the Parcel is meeting success sitewide. However, RS observed
extensive dieback of planted hardwood species across the entire Parcel during the Yr. 1, 2020 Monitoring
Season. RS believes poor tree stock, moderate planting conditions, and drought are the lead cause for the
low efficacy with planted stems. To ensure a successful riparian forest establishes, RS proposed replanting
twenty-four thousand six hundred and fifty (24,650) hardwood bare roots across the entire ninety-seven
(97) acre easement. Spacing and densities of the planted stems will be based on zones depending on
survivability within specific areas. A map identifying each zone is provided in Appendix C.
To offset the potential for dieback from drought, RS added Terra-Sorb to the root balls of each sapling
planted. Terra-Sorb is a non-toxic super-absorbent hydrogel material that absorbs up to 150 times its
weight in water and releases it into the roots when the soils are dry. The species below were picked from
the original planting list with minor modifications based on species success during Yr. 1. Table E outlines
the species and number of stems RS planted in February 2021. Densities were determined by Yr. 1
monitoring data and infield observations. Documentation of the January 2021 Adaptive Management Plan
is included in Appendix C.
Table E: February 2021 Planted Species and Quantities
Species Number of Stems
Betula nigra 2,800
Celtis occidentalis 1,500
Cercis canadensis 900
Diospyros virginiana 900
Fraxinus pennsylvanica 1,400
Liriodendron tulipifera 1,300
Morus rubra 700
Nyssa sylvatica 1,500
Platanus Occidentalis 2,800
Quercus alba 1,400
Quercus lyrate 350
Quercus nigra 3,350
Quercus phellos 3,250
Quercus rubra 1,000
Quercus shumardii 1,000
Ulmus americana 500
Total 24,650
MY 2- 2021
Yr. 2 (2021) monitoring efforts determined the Parcel is meeting success sitewide. However, RS observed
dieback and low vigor of planted hardwood species in several zones during the Yr. 2, 2021 Monitoring
Season, particularly in fall site visits during a late drought period. These observations led RS to conduct
supplemental planting in these zones in March 2022 with species from the original planting list. See
Appendix C for planting zone locations. See Table F below for species information.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 8
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
Table F: February 2022PlantedSpecies and Quantities
Species Number of Stems
Betula nigra 1,250
Celtis occidentalis 750
Cercis canadensis 750
Diospyros virginiana 1,250
Liriodendron tulipifera 1,250
Malus angustifolia 750
1,250
Morus rubra
1,250
Nyssa sylvatica
1,250
Platanus occidentalis
1,250
Quercus michauxii
1,250
Quercus nigra
1,250
Ulmus americana
Vibrunum dentatum 850
Total 14,350
7.0 References
Consolidated Buffer Mitigation Rule - 15A NCAC 02B .0295 (Published November 17, 2014)
Lee, M.T., R.K. Peet, SD. Roberts, and T.R. Wentworth. 2008. CVS-EEP Protocol for Recording Vegetation.
Version 4.2. North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Ecosystem
Enhancement Program. Raleigh, North Carolina.
Neuse River Nutrient Sensitive Waters Management Strategy 15A NCAC 2B .0233,
15A NCAC 02B .0240, and 15A NCAC 02B .0295
Schafale, M.P. and A.S. Weakley. 1990. Classification of the Natural Communities of North Carolina: Third
Approximation. North Carolina Natural Heritage Program, Division of Parks and Recreation, NC
Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources. Raleigh, North Carolina.
Schafale, M. P. and Weakley, 2012. A Classification of the Natural Communities of North Carolina, Fourth
Approximation.
USDA, Soil Conservation Service, 1974. Soil Survey of Pitt County, NC.
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Page 9
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
Appendix A: General Figures and Tables
Figure 1 - Parcel Location / Service Area
Figures 2, 2A-B - Current Conditions Plan View
Figures 3, 3A-B - Credit Determination
Table 1 - Project Components and Mitigation Credits
Table 2 - Project Activity and Reporting History
Table 3 - Project Contact
Table 4 - Project Baseline Information and Attributes
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Appendices
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
A6e
rutaeF
B6er
utae
F
2eru
taeF
2
³
³
Table2.ProjectActivityandReportingHistory
Activity/MilestoneBPDPProposedDateActualDate
BPDPApprovedNAJanuary23,2020
ParcelProtectionQ12020March19,2020
EasementTransfertoThirdPartyByYr.4Monitoring(2023)Onschedule
SoilpreparationQ12020March2020
RemovalofPowerline/PoleQ12020May2019
,
PlantingQ12020March122020
AsBuiltDataCollectionQ12020March18thΑ26,2020
AsBuiltReportSubmittalQ22020July2020
Year1MonitoringQ42020December2020
Year2MonitoringQ42021November2021
Year3MonitoringQ42022December2022
Yeah45MonitoringQ42023Α2024OnSchedule
Table3:ProjectContact
FirmPOC&Address
1101HaynesStreet,Suite211
FullDeliveryProvider
Raleigh,NorthCarolina27604
RestorationSystems,LLC
POC:RaymondHolz
Designer/Permitting
919.755.9490
JoshMerritt:919.755.9490
PlantingContractor
MatthewHarrell:919.755.9490
RestorationSystems,LLC
1101HaynesStreet,Suite211
SeedingContractor
Raleigh,NorthCarolina27604
NurseryStockSuppliers:ArborGen1.888.888.7158
GrantLewis;919.215.1693
BaselineDataCollection AxiomEnvironmental,Inc.218SnowAve.Raleigh,NC
27603
GrantLewis;919.215.1693
VegetationMonitoring:AxiomEnvironmental,Inc.218SnowAve.Raleigh,NC
27603
Table4:ProjectBaselineInformation&Attributes
ProjectInformation
ProjectNameGUC
CountyPitt
ProjectArea(acres)97.14
ProjectCoordinates(latitudeandlongitude)35.603194ºN,77.294509ºW(NAD83/WGS84)
ProjectWatershedSummaryInformation
PhysiographicProvinceMiddleAtlanticCoastalPlain
RiverBasinTarPamlico
USGSHydrologicUnit8digit03020103USGSHydrologicUnit14digit03020103070030
DWRSubbasin030305
ProjectDrainageArea,TotalOutfall(acres)975
ProjectDrainageAreaPercentageofImpervious
>5%
Area
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixA:GeneralFiguresandTables
MY3MonitoringReportΑDecember2022
Appendix B: Baseline Vegetation Data, CVS Output Tables
Table 5 – Total and Planted Stems by Plot and Species
Table 6 – Temporary transect data
Vegetation Plot Photos
MY3 (2022) Planted Stem Height Data
GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank Parcel Appendices
MY3 Monitoring Report – January 2023
0013
01 1
allT
0.02
111222111222
001220008
1
01
allTPnoLSP
0.02
666222
001120008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111
001020008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
2221111118242.8242.8202.3202.3202.3404.7404.7404.7526.1526.1526.1
000920008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
000820008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
222111111111111111333
20008
2022)
(MY3
0007
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data
0.02
111111111
Plot
Current
000620008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111222111
000520008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
333222
000420008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111111111222111111111111111333111222111111111111222111111111
000320008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
000220008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
including
000120008
recruits
livestakes
1
01
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
444000333444131313777777777666666555101010131313222000222444555555666555555555555444888
natural
20008
recruits
161.9161.9161.9000121.4121.4121.4161.9161.9161.9526.1526.1526.1283.3283.3283.3283.3283.3283.3283.3283.3283.3242.8242.8242.8242.excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTreeTree
or
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree222
oakTree
oakTree10%T
NameSpecies
10%T
s
Hickory
oakTree10%P
sycamoreTreeelmTree
crabappleTreearrowwoodShrub
hackberryTreebuttonbushShrubpersimmonTree222222111111red
GUC
buckthornShrub
oakTree
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree
oakTree
oakTreethan
oakTree
walnutTreecherryTree111666
Specie
birchTree
dogwoodShrub
mulberryTree
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTreerequirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTreeQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
0026
3.7323.7
01 1
allT
0.02
222
002520008
1
01
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111333111
20008
0024
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
20008
0023
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111333
002220008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111222222111222
002120008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
2022)
(MY3
002020008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data
0.02
Plot
20008
Current
0019
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
001820008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111222444111222111111
121.4121.4121.440.4740.4740.4740.4740.4740.4740.4740.4740.47283.3283.3283.380.9480.9480.94202.3202.3202.3404.7404.7404.7323.732
001720008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
001620008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
000000
001520008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
including
001420008
recruits
livestakes
1
01
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
222111999444000000333111111111777222555101010888777333000000222111111111555222444444555
natural
20008
recruits
364.2364.2364.2161.9161.9161.9excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTreeTree
or
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree
oakTree
oakTree10%T
NameSpecies
10%T
s
Hickory
oakTree10%P
sycamoreTree222elmTree
crabappleTreearrowwoodShrub
hackberryTree111buttonbushShrubpersimmonTree222red
GUC
buckthornShrub
oakTree111
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree
oakTree111
oakTree111than
oakTree111
walnutTreecherryTree
Specie
birchTree
dogwoodShrub
mulberryTree
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTreerequirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree111
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTreeQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
0039
01 1
allT
0.02
111111222111111
003820008
1
01
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
003720008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
222111222
20008
0036
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
222
003520008
1.9161.9121.4121.4121.4202.3202.3202.380.9480.9480.94404.7404.7404.7
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
222
003420008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111333111222
2022)
(MY3
003320008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data
0.02
111111222111222
Plot
20008
Current
0032
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111111111111333
003120008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111
20008
0030
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
002920008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
002820008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
222222
including
002720008
recruits
livestakes
1
01
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
666111999555777111444555555888444333555222101010333444444111444333555444333222333222888
natural
20008
recruits
364.2364.2364.2202.3202.3202.3283.3283.3283.340.4740.4740.47161.9161.9161.9202.3202.3202.3202.3202.3202.3323.7323.7323.7161.916excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTreeTreeor
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree111
oakTree
oakTree10%T
NameSpecies
10%T
s
Hickory
oakTree10%P
sycamoreTreeelmTree222
crabappleTree111arrowwoodShrub
hackberryTreebuttonbushShrubpersimmonTreered
GUC
buckthornShrub
oakTree
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree
oakTree
oakTreethan
oakTree
walnutTreecherryTree
Specie
birchTree111
dogwoodShrub
mulberryTree222
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTreerequirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree222
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTree111QuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
0052
01 1
allT
0.02
22
005120008
1
01
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111222222
005020008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111
004920008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111
20008
0048
6.6566.640.4740.4740.47404.7404.7404.7526.1526.1688000
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
004720008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111222111111555222555111111111444444
2022)
(MY3
004620008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data
0.02
222333111
Plot
Current
004520008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
20008
0044
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111333222333222
004320008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111111
004220008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
004120008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
20008
including
0040
recruits
livestakes
1
01
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
444333888555222333555999444777141414111101010131317000444333111333333444222555555111555779000
natural
20008
recruits
323.7323.7323.7202.3202.3202.380.9480.9480.94121.4121.4121.4202.3202.3202.3364.2364.2364.2161.9161.9161.9283.3283.3283.3566.656excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTreeTree
or
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree
oakTree
oakTree11110%T
NameSpecies
10%T
sC
Hickory
oakTree10%P
sycamoreTree222111333elmTree
crabappleTreearrowwoodShrub
hackberryTreebuttonbushShrubpersimmonTreered
GU
buckthornShrub
oakTree
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree111
oakTree
oakTreethan
oakTree
walnutTreecherryTree222
Specie
birchTree
dogwoodShrub
mulberryTree111
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTreerequirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTree111111333QuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
0065
01 1
allT
0.02
111
006420008
1
01
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
20008
0063
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
444444222333111
006220008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111
006120008
4.7404.7121.4121.4121.4607607607485.6485.6485.6202.3202.3202.3
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111333111
20008
0060
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
2022)
(MY3
005920008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data
0.02
222222111111444555222111
Plot
Current
005820008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111333
005720008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
005620008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111333
20008
0055
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111444555777111111222111
20008
0054
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
111333444444555111111111222
including
005320008
recruits
livestakes
1
01
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
333666555131313121212777222222111101010333151515121212555333444333555444333888111666333666777444
natural
20008
recruits
121.4121.4121.4242.8242.8242.8202.3202.3202.3526.1526.1526.1485.6485.6485.6283.3283.3283.3890.3890.3890.340.4740.4740.47404.740excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTreeTree
or
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree
oakTree
oakTree11133311110%T
NameSpecies
10%T
s
Hickory
oakTree10%P
sycamoreTreeelmTree
crabappleTreearrowwoodShrub
hackberryTree222111buttonbushShrubpersimmonTreered
GUC
buckthornShrub
oakTree111
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree
oakTree
oakTreethan
oakTree
walnutTreecherryTree
Specie
birchTree111222
dogwoodShrub
mulberryTree222
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTreerequirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree111111
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTreeQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
0078
01 1
allT
0.02
111111
007720008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
007620008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
007520008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111333111111
1
007420008
3.3323.7445.2445.2445.2404.7404.7404.740.4740.4740.47161.9161.9161.9
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111
007320008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111333333111111111111444111
20008
2022)
(MY3
0072
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data
0.02
111
Plot
Current
007120008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
333111111
007020008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
006920008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
222111222222111222444111222
006820008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
222111111
006720008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
20008
including
0066
recruits
livestakes
1
01
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
333141414777101010555333222555778111111101010111444333333555555444111222555445666555111333
natural
20008
recruits
121.4121.4121.4566.6566.6566.6283.3283.3283.3404.7404.7404.7202.3202.3202.3121.4121.4121.480.9480.9480.94202.3202.3202.3283.328excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTreeTree
or
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree111111
oakTree
oakTree10%T
NameSpecies
10%T
s
Hickory
oakTree11110%P
sycamoreTreeelmTree
crabappleTreearrowwoodShrub
hackberryTreebuttonbushShrubpersimmonTree111222red
GUC
buckthornShrub
oakTree111
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree222
oakTree
oakTreethan
oakTree
walnutTreecherryTree222
Specie
birchTree
dogwoodShrub111
mulberryTree
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTree111333requirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTree111111111QuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
(2020)
allT 87
2.15
777
131713171430
(2020)MY0
allTPnoLSP 87
2.15
Means
121113801114
Annual
(2021)MY1
allTPnoLSP 87
2.15
111111222111272727111111333666111111
464646444121212
12
(2022)MY2
87
allTPnoLSP
2.15
2221112224444447771212121010101313138881111121111111212128887771616162929294447779992121212223335558888883331111212122224445552828285240.5242.8336.3336.3345.6328.9328.9367612.6612.6665.2
MY3
3939397373737070701281281282020202525252424243331010101313131515152424241414141313141717171717171717173232323232329191911515152121213535357474742626263737374545468181822222221212121313131717171818181
91919202020191919121212101010999282828353535434345494949686868333333444444353535535353
0087
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111141414202020232323363636222999999162162162169169169358358358
20008
0086
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
008520008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
20008
0084
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111161616131318111111363636
2022)
(MY3
008320008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
Data 0.02
Plot
Current
008220008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111111111
008120008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
111333111111585860555555535353939393
008020008
01 1
allTPnoLSP
0.02
livestakes
111111222
including
007920008
recruits
livestakes
01 1
allTPnoLSP
livestakes
0.02
222555333999444777444111222000666517517522723723743707707789222555444555333111222000333262628313136292931303032
natural
20008
recruits
121.4121.4121.4364.2364.2364.2161.9161.9161.9283.3283.3283.3161.9161.9161.940.4740.4740.4780.9480.9480.94000242.8242.8242.8240.excluding
PnoLSP
including
and
natural
ACRE
Tree
Typecount(ares)count
Planted
(ACRES)
Planting
=planted
TreeTree111111or
Tree
per
=
size
All
Stem
size
all
=includes
Species
Stems
oakTree
oakTree
oakTree10%T
NameSpecies
10%T
s
Hickory
oakTree11110%P
sycamoreTreeelmTree
crabappleTreearrowwoodShrub
hackberryTreebuttonbushShrubpersimmonTreered
GUC
buckthornShrub
oakTree111
than
redbudTreeredcedarTree
hawthornShrubpineTreeelmTree
whitechestnut
than
oakTree111111333272727313131171717101010
oakTree
oakTreethan
oakTree
walnutTreecherryTree
Specie
birchTree
dogwoodShrub111
mulberryTree
less
more
less
Name:
and
by
by
by
10%PnoLS
Plot
but
by
Project
by
NameCommon
Stems
occidentaliscommon
20008.
tulipiferatuliptreeTree111requirements,requirements
styracifluasweetgumTree
marshalliiparsleydentatumsouthern
virginianacommon
virginianaeastern
pumilachinkapinShrub
Density
Total carolinianaCarolina
occidentalisAmerican
albawhitebicolorswamplaurifolialaurellyrataovercupmichauxiiswampnigrawaterpagodacherrybarkphelloswillowrubranorthern
requirementsrequirements,
Code
nigrablack
meetmeet
amomumsilkyserotinablack
rubrared
nigrariver
alatawingedamericanaAmerican
angustifoliasouthern
canadensiseastern
sylvaticablackgumTree
5.tomentosaMockernut
laevigatasugarberryTreeoccidentaliscommon
taedaloblolly for
Scientific
negundoboxelderTree
toto
Project
Table AcerBetulaCaryahickoryTreeCaryaCastaneaCeltishackberryTreeCeltisCeltisCephalanthusCercisCornusCrataegushawthornTreeCrataegusDiospyrosFrangulaJuglansJuniperusLiquidambarLiriodendronMalusMorusNys
saPinusPlatanusPrunusQuercusoakTreeQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusQuercusUlmuselmTreeUlmusUlmusUnknownShrubViburnum Color ExceedsExceedsFailsFails
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot1Plot2
Plot3Plot4
Plot5Plot6
Plot7Plot8
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot9Plot10
Plot11Plot12
Plot13Plot14
Plot15Plot16
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot17Plot18
Plot19Plot20
Plot21Plot22
Plot23Plot24
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot25Plot26
Plot27Plot28
Plot29Plot30
Plot31Plot32
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot33Plot34
Plot35Plot36
Plot37Plot38
Plot39Plot40
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY1MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot41Plot42
Plot43Plot44
Plot45Plot46
Plot47Plot48
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot49Plot50
Plot51Plot52
Plot53Plot54
Plot55Plot56
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot57Plot58
Plot59Plot60
Plot61Plot62
Plot63Plot64
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot65Plot66
Plot67Plot68
Plot69Plot70
Plot71Plot72
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot73Plot74
Plot75Plot76
Plot77Plot78
Plot79Plot80
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
GUC
MY3(2022)VegetationMonitoringPhotographs(takenSeptemberandOctober2022)
Plot81Plot82
Plot83Plot84
Plot85Plot86
Plot87
GUCNutrientOffsetandBufferMitigationBankParcelAppendixB:VegetationData,CVSOutputTable
MY3MonitoringReportΑbƚǝĻƒĬĻƩ2022
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
1Quercus michauxii3.04.930
1Quercus michauxii6.81.718
1Diospyros virginiana9.23.640
1Diospyros virginiana0.88.751
2EMPTY
3Diospyros virginiana4.03.151
3Diospyros virginiana6.52.268
3Prunus serotina8.61.161
4Quercus rubra0.11.258
4Quercus2.91.522
4Betula nigra1.07.935
4Quercus lyrata0.49.331
5Prunus serotina3.01.130
5Prunus serotina1.93.721
5Prunus serotina5.13.936
5Prunus serotina5.71.125
5Prunus serotina8.50.951
5Prunus serotina8.13.820
5Diospyros virginiana9.36.830
5Crataegus marshallii6.36.662
5Crataegus marshallii1.49.340
5Crataegus marshallii1.16.442
5Quercus nigra6.14.328
5Quercus nigra9.84.430
5Quercus0.98.140
6Quercus lyrata4.23.940
6Quercus lyrata5.11.128
6Betula nigra6.27.952
6Quercus3.19.3161
0.2
6Quercus lyrata3.56.539
6Quercus rubra0.16.520
6Quercus phellos10.04.410
7Quercus phellos7.11.161
7Quercus rubra9.92.520
7Quercus michauxii9.15.228
7Quercus phellos6.26.639
7Cercis canadensis6.99.025
7Platanus occidentalis4.56.050
7Diospyros virginiana4.10.171
8Quercus pagoda2.33.732
8Quercus pagoda7.04.452
8Quercus phellos9.69.812
8Quercus7.08.981
8Quercus4.48.4135
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)
8Quercus rubra0.65.7147
8Ulmus americana5.30.330
9Malus angustifolia1.22.037
9Quercus rubra4.90.026
9Quercus8.32.460
9Quercus lyrata7.75.070
9Quercus rubra7.67.562
9Quercus pagoda3.58.458
10Quercus rubra5.41.181
10Cornus amomum6.20.742
10Celtis occidentalis8.50.352
10Celtis occidentalis8.14.672
10Quercus8.29.131
10Ulmus americana5.94.840
11Malus angustifolia1.90.180
11Quercus alba5.43.952
11Quercus5.51.957
11Quercus rubra8.52.562
11Quercus pagoda1.19.460
12Prunus serotina4.74.840
12Platanus occidentalis5.63.7345
3.8
12Platanus occidentalis5.50.43283.1
12Ulmus americana7.80.164
12Platanus occidentalis9.15.2321
3.7
12Platanus occidentalis5.56.32822.1
12Platanus occidentalis5.78.92812.7
12Quercus rubra3.98.035
12Prunus serotina7.85.162
12Platanus occidentalis3.93.9131
13Quercus2.90.530
13Diospyros virginiana1.92.818
13Viburnum dentatum5.32.618
13Quercus phellos9.40.668
13Ulmus americana8.04.932
13Celtis laevigata5.66.860
13Diospyros virginiana8.99.970
13Ulmus americana5.89.450
13Viburnum dentatum3.37.030
13Ulmus americana1.98.942
13Celtis occidentalis7.66.152
13Quercus lyrata4.21.840
13Quercus lyrata7.40.450
14Quercus nigra3.21.328
14Celtis occidentalis4.42.840
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
14Quercus laurifolia5.71.755
14Diospyros virginiana5.20.345
14Quercus8.76.182
14Nyssa sylvatica7.26.561
14Quercus lyrata5.68.160
14Quercus3.17.78
14Diospyros virginiana8.30.658
15Platanus occidentalis6.53.099
15Quercus alba8.56.049
15Quercus5.99.049
15Platanus occidentalis8.81.0121
16EMPTY
17EMPTY
18Platanus occidentalis1.34.0130
18Platanus occidentalis5.94.4101
18Betula nigra1.87.037
19Platanus occidentalis1.00.2101
20Platanus occidentalis0.50.518
21Liriodendron tulipifera9.17.364
22Prunus serotina3.41.548
22Betula nigra9.83.062
22Liriodendron tulipifera6.29.038
22Nyssa sylvatica3.49.142
22Quercus4.09.740
22Quercus7.19.517
22Betula nigra6.86.28
23Celtis occidentalis0.73.723
23Quercus9.28.48
24Ulmus americana8.61.810
24Celtis occidentalis9.09.342
24Prunus serotina5.99.840
24Prunus serotina6.26.650
24Nyssa sylvatica3.19.443
25Quercus alba2.02.362
25Betula nigra4.91.935
25Betula nigra4.24.642
25Betula nigra2.05.720
25Quercus1.01.375
25Betula nigra6.44.335
25Quercus lyrata5.69.471
25Quercus lyrata6.26.330
25Quercus lyrata0.68.051
25Quercus7.85.532
26Betula nigra1.71.371
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
26Celtis occidentalis9.18.841
26Celtis occidentalis6.58.830
26Ulmus americana3.68.848
26Quercus phellos0.48.650
26Quercus lyrata2.75.360
26Celtis occidentalis0.91.058
26Quercus phellos6.33.444
27Platanus occidentalis6.00.6195
1.5
27Platanus occidentalis6.64.2190
1.3
27Platanus occidentalis6.77.0140
0.8
27Platanus occidentalis2.26.7160
0.4
27Platanus occidentalis3.84.0241
1.9
28Celtis occidentalis4.02.447
28Quercus michauxii8.30.090
28Celtis occidentalis3.65.6
40
28Platanus occidentalis6.78.173
28Betula nigra3.38.06
29Morus rubra1.03.2
12
29Celtis occidentalis3.72.022
29Celtis occidentalis3.51.143
29Nyssa sylvatica7.90.040
29Malus angustifolia5.60.5
63
29Morus rubra0.86.1
71
29Nyssa sylvatica0.28.9
4
29Morus rubra8.20.5
25
30Prunus serotina7.93.3
48
31Quercus bicolor3.13.690
31Quercus pagoda0.33.772
31Prunus serotina6.05.623
31Quercus rubra0.39.0100
32Crataegus marshallii5.04.1
47
32Ulmus americana7.33.7
24
32Ulmus americana0.59.8
44
32Ulmus americana4.51.5
36
32Quercus michauxii2.16.1
35
33Quercus nigra6.95.435
33Malus angustifolia6.39.4
62
33Quercus michauxii3.65.7
56
33Betula nigra2.19.4
64
33Crataegus marshallii5.04.985
34Malus angustifolia4.02.950
34Quercus nigra6.73.058
34Malus angustifolia6.76.340
34Quercus nigra9.96.830
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
34Quercus1.72.736
34Quercus0.75.541
34Quercus4.75.070
34Platanus occidentalis9.50.825
35Quercus lyrata9.25.848
35Quercus lyrata7.68.344
35Quercus5.67.311
35Platanus occidentalis9.20.257
36Cercis canadensis8.83.931
36Cercis canadensis7.86.860
36Crataegus marshallii5.06.052
37Morus rubra1.04.510
37Morus rubra3.34.520
37Quercus7.21.032
37Quercus9.41.140
37Morus rubra9.84.630
37Quercus michauxii8.37.230
38Betula nigra4.00.653
38Betula nigra7.73.110
38Quercus phellos7.26.225
38Nyssa sylvatica1.50.035
38Quercus rubra0.04.943
39Nyssa sylvatica1.50.050
39Quercus rubra0.04.950
39Platanus occidentalis4.80.8242
1.5
39Celtis laevigata3.15.481
39Morus rubra7.12.525
39Betula nigra6.90.092
39Celtis occidentalis9.60.550
39Morus rubra7.75.835
39Celtis occidentalis10.05.942
39Prunus serotina5.88.250
40Prunus serotina0.43.040
40Ulmus americana6.61.240
40Ulmus americana6.93.242
40Ulmus americana6.55.931
40Ulmus americana6.78.042
40Quercus6.99.820
40Quercus rubra3.26.610
40Prunus serotina0.47.840
41Ulmus americana5.01.8
37
41Ulmus americana4.73.8
25
41Quercus phellos9.19.269
72
41Ulmus americana3.78.6
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
41Morus rubra1.13.530
42Platanus occidentalis1.50.7350
42Platanus occidentalis9.64.6
35
43Quercus bicolor2.40.2
40
43Quercus7.34.430
43Quercus michauxii2.18.841
44Prunus serotina6.71.915
44Platanus occidentalis2.63.630
44Prunus serotina9.19.264
44Prunus serotina4.78.320
44Cornus amomum4.78.130
45Quercus0.70.661
45Cornus amomum3.94.050
45Quercus6.85.410
45Prunus serotina7.19.580
45Prunus serotina3.99.670
45Cornus amomum1.28.172
45Cornus amomum2.56.161
45Quercus michauxii0.35.980
45Quercus4.89.920
46Cornus amomum2.63.744
46Liriodendron tulipifera7.65.880
46Cornus amomum2.78.431
46Liriodendron tulipifera6.98.340
47Quercus rubra3.82.131
47Platanus occidentalis6.42.6300
1.8
47Quercus8.93.471
47Quercus phellos8.85.931
47Platanus occidentalis5.87.9
2102.3
47Platanus occidentalis6.05.7
2502.1
47Betula nigra1.15.360
48Liriodendron tulipifera2.10.536
48Quercus michauxii4.82.292
48Quercus4.65.082
48Quercus nigra7.21.780
48Quercus rubra7.44.571
48Quercus rubra9.72.362
48Quercus rubra10.05.259
48Quercus9.97.950
48Quercus rubra7.37.291
48Quercus7.69.860
48Quercus4.99.965
48Quercus4.87.345
45
48Liriodendron tulipifera1.95.5
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
48Liriodendron tulipifera2.12.710
49Nyssa sylvatica2.25.88
50Betula nigra3.03.370
50Quercus nigra5.80.735
50Quercus bicolor9.94.265
50Quercus rubra7.46.242
50Quercus9.56.560
50Quercus9.38.960
50Quercus rubra7.38.842
50Quercus rubra5.06.040
50Quercus rubra4.88.58
50Betula nigra2.75.840
51Quercus4.21.5120
51Quercus3.73.673
51Quercus6.80.565
51Quercus6.63.399
51Quercus lyrata9.21.375
51Ulmus americana8.57.333
51Ulmus americana8.410.032
51Quercus lyrata6.05.978
51Quercus5.98.668
51Quercus alba3.36.080
51Quercus phellos1.91.849
51Betula nigra5.34.485
51Liriodendron tulipifera9.04.840
52EMPTY
53Nyssa sylvatica6.32.88
53Quercus rubra9.4342
53Quercus lyrata6.35.6
35
54Morus rubra1.11.227
54Morus rubra1.23.9
30
54Celtis occidentalis6.92.5
40
54Celtis occidentalis9.71.231
54Betula nigra6.54.9
55
54Platanus occidentalis9.86.125
55Nyssa sylvatica8.70.5
8
55Platanus occidentalis9.26.0285
2.3
55Platanus occidentalis3.38.468
55Quercus6.51.7
75
55Platanus occidentalis1.76.750
56Quercus rubra2.11.320
56Quercus rubra4.51.054
56Quercus rubra2.73.840
40
56Quercus6.70.8
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
56Ulmus americana9.40.9
40
56Quercus9.23.8
70
56Platanus occidentalis9.66.2
1601.2
56Platanus occidentalis7.76.2100
56Platanus occidentalis5.66.3231
2.1
56Quercus5.08.973
56Platanus occidentalis3.46.2170
0.75
56Quercus1.06.180
56Quercus pagoda0.58.4
95
57Quercus1.62.0
112
57Ulmus americana4.40.254
57Quercus3.82.4
80
57Platanus occidentalis3.34.9240
1.25
57Platanus occidentalis0.84.2230
1
57Quercus6.02.515
57Quercus8.22.8
54
57Platanus occidentalis8.25.6210
0.5
57Platanus occidentalis5.85.5210
1.25
57Betula nigra6.68.463
57Betula nigra1.97.677
57Quercus6.40.3
60
58Celtis occidentalis4.30.650
58Platanus occidentalis4.52.8210
1.5
58Platanus occidentalis2.13.366
58Platanus occidentalis7.12.9300
1.8
58Platanus occidentalis9.32.8275
1.75
58Platanus occidentalis10.00.4210
1.25
58Nyssa sylvatica9.15.5
30
59Prunus serotina1.81.9
42
59Quercus phellos4.61.550
59Quercus1.64.974
59Quercus7.04.081
59Quercus laurifolia7.31.262
59Quercus9.81.080
59Liriodendron tulipifera8.26.410
59Quercus rubra8.19.033
59Liriodendron tulipifera2.57.470
59Nyssa sylvatica5.81.140
59Quercus phellos4.23.962
59Quercus phellos6.49.548
59Quercus5.57.440
59Quercus7.06.733
59Quercus7.06.4
41
59Quercus8.39.262
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
59Quercus nigra7.48.437
59Quercus phellos7.78.422
59Quercus nigra6.49.233
59Quercus nigra1.610.040
59Quercus nigra3.39.930
59Quercus phellos3.06.566
60Platanus occidentalis4.78.380
61Morus rubra8.35.328
61Platanus occidentalis7.37.140
61Quercus2.67.633
62Unknown8.55.745
62Quercus phellos0.31.330
62Morus rubra4.53.825
63Quercus phellos0.31.358
63Morus rubra4.53.820
63Quercus phellos7.91.15
63Quercus rubra7.13.648
63Betula nigra8.36.680
63Betula nigra6.16.891
63Liriodendron tulipifera5.29.531
63Betula nigra3.76.6111
63Liriodendron tulipifera2.18.828
63Betula nigra1.26.077
63Nyssa sylvatica2.64.531
63Nyssa sylvatica8.37.531
63Nyssa sylvatica1.17.932
63Quercus rubra3.29.9
41
63Quercus rubra5.110.0
42
64Betula nigra0.22.2
50
64Betula nigra2.61.6
92
64Quercus4.74.522
64Betula nigra5.51.7131
64Betula nigra8.53.9
72
64Malus angustifolia5.36.7
61
64Platanus occidentalis7.27.8
3203
64Quercus michauxii9.26.9
32
64Cephalanthus occidentalis2.36.1
60
64Platanus occidentalis3.31.6153
1
64Quercus7.59.950
64Quercus rubra7.38.532
65Quercus phellos2.94.548
65Quercus2.30.730
65Betula nigra8.71.293
65Crataegus marshallii10.04.458
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
65Betula nigra0.86.4108
66Quercus4.17.915
66Liriodendron tulipifera0.17.752
66Diospyros virginiana2.07.967
67Quercus0.13.672
67Quercus3.61.263
67Quercus5.53.597
67Quercus6.20.965
67Quercus phellos9.03.577
67Quercus8.90.982
67Quercus9.56.281
67Quercus7.16.172
67Quercus9.29.0134
67Quercus6.59.061
67Quercus michauxii3.49.152
67Quercus4.1683
67Quercus phellos1.55.81410.1
67Quercus0.78.9
70
68Quercus alba2.72.974
68Quercus pagoda8.93.0
60
68Cornus amomum9.05.754
68Prunus serotina8.68.845
68Prunus serotina5.39.762
68Quercus alba2.75.435
68Quercus lyrata3.00.920
69Liriodendron tulipifera1.24.4
50
69Quercus8.31.2100
69Liriodendron tulipifera8.04.440
69Diospyros virginiana7.97.658
69Quercus0.59.738
69Cercis canadensis5.50.520
69Cercis canadensis5.23.340
69Quercus alba0.70.1
50
69Diospyros virginiana8.62.4
79
69Liriodendron tulipifera7.28.542
70Quercus michauxii8.57.9
30
70Quercus0.71.1
8
70Quercus4.31.4
16
70Quercus alba6.46.1
25
70Cercis canadensis3.64.99
71Crataegus marshallii8.82.830
71Crataegus marshallii7.99.325
71Crataegus marshallii7.86.325
72Crataegus marshallii9.11.221
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
72Morus rubra2.16.65
73Betula nigra4.44.544
73Cornus amomum1.69.635
73Ulmus america4.82.615
73Quercus phellos9.70.920
73Quercus0.41.065
74Celtis occidentalis0.40.48
74Ulmus america4.92.640
74Betula nigra0.05.251
74Ulmus america5.70.323
74Ulmus america1.39.338
74Quercus phellos1.30.315
74Ulmus america1.34.728
75Betula nigra0.70.7130
75Quercus lyrata5.72.3100
75Quercus michauxii9.12.2
61
75Quercus8.94.4140
0.1
75Quercus8.310.0
120
75Cercis cadensis5.35.9
30
75Betula nigra5.08.6
2802.4
75Quercus lyrata1.85.9
80
75Betula nigra0.06.1
65
75Quercus lyrata8.61.170
75Prunus seroti5.27.7
40
76Quercus2.22.7
72
76Quercus5.02.3
106
76Ulmus america2.64.644
76Quercus9.52.555
76Quercus8.75.571
76Quercus michauxii5.84.920
76Crataegus marshallii5.89.441
76Betula nigra8.29.7110
76Betula nigra3.39.065
76Betula nigra0.18.978
77Quercus0.26.431
78Malus angustifolia0.92.640
78Quercus1.66.815
78Quercus1.47.020
78Platanus occidentalis0.28.518
79Quercus10.08.357
79Quercus pagoda8.74.250
79Quercus3.95.358
80Quercus1.02.152
80Quercus4.42.350
PlotSCIENTIFIC NAMEXYHeight (cm)DBH
80Quercus7.90.642
80Quercus rubra9.15.830
80Cornus amomum2.38.860
80Crataegus marshallii1.05.628
80Quercus4.85.420
80Quercus phellos1.41.625
80Quercus5.11.125
81Quercus rubra0.23.345
81Liriodendron tulipifera3.63.922
81Quercus lyrata8.79.058
81Platanus occidentalis6.48.869
82Platanus occidentalis0.74.83332.7
82Betula nigra2.54.698
82Platanus occidentalis3.54.63202.7
82Platanus occidentalis6.4575
82Crataegus marshallii6.18.960
82Nyssa sylvatica4.66.840
82Celtis occidentalis2.38.1
55
83Platanus occidentalis8.47.9
2202
83Quercus phellos4.67.6
90
83Quercus rubra6.99.0
89
83Quercus rubra4.97.259
84Diospyros virginia8.48.2
110
85Diospyros virginia8.08.330
85Platanus occidentalis8.37.381
86EMPTY
87Morus rubra4.10.38
87Quercus9.05.340
87Quercus6.56.560
87Quercus phellos6.99.655
87Quercus phellos6.42.912
87Quercus phellos6.99.020
111
TT
)
(269
313
14
)T
(289 21112 914
13
)T
(355
311
12
)T
(2
337214
11
)T
(69
3122312
10
)T
1 611148
(341
9
)T
(71
8
)T
25121223
(119
7
)T
(97
2111211
6
)T
(80
5
)T
(258
4
)T
(Bearing)
(14 11
21111
3
Plot
)T
03/12/2021)
Temporary 11111
(191
2
2m
x
Transects
of
)T
50m
1491111211113361122
(Date
(190
2452969413760220943741783140680202374
1
T
planting
Stems116149106108
AMP
TotalStems/Acre445243567364405243405324243445567324364567
Post
(Stems/Acre)
Total
AMP
Plots
ƷǒƌźƦźŅĻƩğ
Pre
ƒğƩƭŷğƌƌźź
ǝźƩŭźƓźğƓğ
Species
Veg
ƚĭĭźķĻƓƷğƌźƭ
ƦĻƓƓƭǤƌǝğƓźĭğ
ƌǤƩğƷğƓźŭƩğƦŷĻƌƌƚƭƩǒĬƩğƭƦƦ͵
ƭĻƩƚƷźƓğ
ƓźŭƩğƩǒĬƩğ
ğƒĻƩźĭğƓğ
ƭǤƌǝğƷźǝğ
ƚĭĭźķĻƓƷğƌźƭ
Density
.ĻƷǒƌğ/ĻƌƷźƭ/ƩğƷğĻŭǒƭ5źƚƭƦǤƩƚƭCƩğǣźƓǒƭ\[źƩźƚķĻƓķƩƚƓaƚƩǒƭbǤƭƭğtƌğƷğƓǒƭtƩǒƓǒƭvǒĻƩĭǒƭvǒĻƩĭǒƭvǒĻƩĭǒƭvǒĻƩĭǒƭvǒĻƩĭǒƭ ƌƒǒƭ
Temporary
Area
GUC
88
77
XX
P'&0$$P'&0$$
L&
##8M##8M
J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@
!"#$$%&'(
$$$M(K'&)A>*'($$$M(K'&)A>*'(
U#.U#.
$$$$
\]\]
AA
$R$$R$
$$$$
LL
!F,*-'&$M 1$
@$(@$L
L8ML8M
!F,*-'&1
$$$$
\[(\[(
B% (%
\[(8!M\[(8!M
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$C0D'&>$'@
)-7*45,)-7*45,
P(P(
B% (%
\[(8M\[(8M
!"#"$%&'("%)*&++,--,&."%&/01%,23(!3%"
0
##
P(8!M9P(8!M9
#'*E$EA--1#'*E$EA--1
3+468P+050P45730V46M03+*0J643+0K546,-750O6S5..60O48:3087;0K6MM-::-67R
J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]
$$$$
0'@ '(B
P%P%
P(8!M4P(8!M4
C+-,,-D0C*4E-7:67@($$0F547*,,0G?*78*<G#1H>I=0JK0 &L@ "5MD,*;0K687390N0C-33
(
B
XX
/%@
P(8MP(8M
99
&$&$&$&$
\\\\
E*0(>1E*0(>$M 1$
(
@@&
#8M#8M
;;
XX
$$
$$
99
O+57E09680V6408:-7P05P4676M-.0:*4?-.*:0360M575P*07834-*73:057;0:5V*P854;0*7?-467M*735,0^85,-39R
..
77
P%ZP%Z
"8779:-;*0<65;=0>4**7?-,,*0 &%
$$
$$
LB &&$ L
GA&)1$
AZAZ
<*D46P45MM-7P06V03+*0,5S6453649!-7V64M53-67!M575P*M*730:9:3*M03+530M5E*:03+-:04*D6430D6::-S,*0-:0S*-7P0V87;*;
8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$
77
\\8M\\8M
77
$R$$R$$R$$R$
)*+,-.+!/012345.3-67
H*)0H*)0
@$A@%A $ @
0
2>'(-BA+&052>'(-BA+&05
.8M.8M
%@''%
')DE0>0F1
DJDJ
LR%&R
!+!+
$RL$R
@$A@/A $ @
77
I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01
&'D @0!0 0!0&'D @0!0 0!0
C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1
(/(&
H*(I-$>'$J0EDKLE$M(K'&)A>*'($
\]#Z\]#Z
C0+0*,0F1
*A%('->*+#'*E$C0D'&>
&R%%R$
UU
>W#@>W#
<BS<BS
@R/%@R/
@$A$BA $ @
0
$RL$$R'@
JPZJPZ
#A)DE0F1 O+*0D,5730P46Q3+057;046630P46Q3+0Q*4*0D664R0J*Q0S8;:0Q*4*0;*5;R0T54*046630+54;Q66;0:**;,-7P:0-70D833*404*:36453-670D46U*.3R0J60:6-,05M*7;M*73:0+5?*0S**70M5;*R0O+*0:6-,0V*43-,-390,*?*,:0?54-*
;0Q-;*,905M67P03+*0:5MD,*:R0O+*0:6-,0DI0-:0,6Q0-70>W#&R0O+*0:6-,0D635::-8M0-:0,6Q0640M54P-75,0-70M5790:5MD,*:R0O+*0:6-,0:8,V840-:0,6Q0-705,,03+*0:5MD,*:R0J63*03+*04*.6MM*7;53-67:R0680.570.6735.30JKX
G0Y0K"04*P-675,05P4676M-:30T457;670C66,*0530(@(!&$L!&$$$0-V096807**;0V843+*405::-:357.*R0Z5P53+-0\[5M5,5E573+57=0GP4676M-:3=0@$A@%A $ @
!"#$!%&'(')*+$ *,*-*'($$$$$$$$$$$$$$$./'(01$$23435$67789:;;$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$<0=-*>01$$???@(+A%&@%',BA%&'(')*B$$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$
Q0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$XQ0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$X
!%&'(')*->N-$'))0(>-1$
888
777
XXX
P'&0$$P'&0$$P'&0$$
%'B
##8M##8M##8M
C5P*0 06V0B
J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@
!"#$$%&'(
$$$M(K'&)A>*'($$$M(K'&)A>*'($$$M(K'&)A>*'(
U#.U#.U#.
$$$$$$
\]\]\]
AAA
$R$$R$$R$
$$____
LLL
%(@% $
L8ML8ML8M
$$$$$$
\[(\[(\[(
LB'B
B/%
\[(8!M\[(8!M\[(8!M
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$C0D'&>$'@
)-7*45,)-7*45,)-7*45,
LB'B
P(P(P(
B/%
\[(8M\[(8M\[(8M
###
P(8!M9P(8!M9P(8!M9
#'*E$EA--1#'*E$EA--1#'*E$EA--1
J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]
$$$$$$
P%P%P%
P(8!M4P(8!M4P(8!M4
'B'
'B
XXX
P(8MP(8MP(8M
999
/$/$&$&$&$&$
\\\\\\
&/
&
@/
#8M#8M#8M
;;;
XXX
$$$
$$$
999
...
777
P%ZP%ZP%Z
$$$
$$$
L/ /% '$@L
AZAZAZ
8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$
777
B'@%
\\8M\\8M\\8M
777
$R$$R$$R$$R$$R$$R$
H*)0H*)0H*)0
2>'(-BA+&052>'(-BA+&052>'(-BA+&05
%L
.8M.8M.8M
B&&@/$
DJDJDJ
LRLBRLBR&
!+!+!+
$R%$R( R$
777
I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01
&'D @0!0 0!0&'D @0!0 0!0&'D @0!0 0!0
C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1
%(L/B%
\]#Z\]#Z\]#Z
&R R''R&
UUU
>W#/>W#'>W#B
<BS<BS<BS
@R /@R'/@R $
C+-,,-D0C*4E-7:67
$RBL$R$(@R'(
JPZJPZJPZ
!"#$!%&'(')*+$ *,*-*'($$$$$$$$$$$$$$$./'(01$$23435$67789:;;$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$<0=-*>01$$???@(+A%&@%',BA%&'(')*B$$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$
Q0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$XQ0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$XQ0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$X
888
777
XXX
J63*N0_
P'&0$$P'&0$$P'&0$$
BBL
##8M##8M##8M
C5P*0/06V0B
J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@
!"#$$%&'(
$$$M(K'&)A>*'($$$M(K'&)A>*'($$$M(K'&)A>*'(
U#.U#.U#.
$$$$$$
\]\]\]
AAA
$R$$R$$R$
$$$$$$
LLL
/B/'
@ $
L8ML8ML8M
$$$$__
\[(\[(\[(
@(
'%@$B
\[(8!M\[(8!M\[(8!M
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$C0D'&>$'@
)-7*45,)-7*45,)-7*45,
@(
P(P(P(
'%@$B
\[(8M\[(8M\[(8M
###
P(8!M9P(8!M9P(8!M9
#'*E$EA--1#'*E$EA--1#'*E$EA--1
J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]
$$_$$
B
P%P%P%
P(8!M4P(8!M4P(8!M4
(%
&
XXX
$
P(8MP(8MP(8M
999
&$&$&$&$B$B$
\\\\\\
&
@' @
#8M#8M#8M
;;;
XXX
$$$
$$$
999
...
777
P%ZP%ZP%Z
$$$
$$$
L$ L/ LB@ &
AZAZAZ
8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$
777
@&@(//
\\8M\\8M\\8M
777
$R$$R$$RL$R$$R$$R$
H*)0H*)0H*)0
2>'(-BA+&052>'(-BA+&052>'(-BA+&05
.8M.8M.8M
''@&$ /L
DJDJDJ
LRLBR@LRL
!+!+!+
$RL R'$RL
777
I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01
&'D @0!0 0!0&'D @0!0 0!0&'D @0!0 0!0
C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1
%%'$%/
\]#Z\]#Z\]#Z
'RL'R$/R'
UUU
>W#L>W#&>W#%
<BS<BS<BS
@R/B@R/@@R/@
C+-,,-D0C*4E-7:67
$R &$R%@$R@/
JPZJPZJPZ
!"#$!%&'(')*+$ *,*-*'($$$$$$$$$$$$$$$./'(01$$23435$67789:;;$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$<0=-*>01$$???@(+A%&@%',BA%&'(')*B$$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$
Q0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$XQ0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$XQ0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$X
88
77
XX
P'&0$$P'&0$$
L%
##8M##8M
C5P*0'06V0B
J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@J63*N0@@
!"#$$%&'(
$$$M(K'&)A>*'($$$M(K'&)A>*'(
@
U#.U#.
$$$$
\]\]
AA
$R$$R@
__$$
LL
@%
@ (
L8ML8M
$$$$
\[(\[(
''
'$B
\[(8!M\[(8!M
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$C0D'&>$'@
)-7*45,)-7*45,
''
P(P(
'$B
\[(8M\[(8M
##
P(8!M9P(8!M9
#'*E$EA--1#'*E$EA--1
J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]J834-*73:0\\,SA5.4*\]
$$$$
P%P%
P(8!M4P(8!M4
L
XX
@&$
P(8MP(8M
99
%$%$L$L$
\\\\
%
@ @
#8M#8M
;;
XX
$$
$$
99
..
77
P%ZP%Z
$$
$$
B/ (L% L
AZAZ
8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$8$*($)%BF)$Y1$$$
77
@' L
\\8M\\8M
77
$R$$R$$R$$R$
H*)0H*)0
2>'(-BA+&052>'(-BA+&05
.8M.8M
@ L/&L
DJDJ
LR'&R$
!+!+
$RL$R'
77
I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01I54;Q66;=01
&'D @0!0 0!0&'D @0!0 0!0
C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1C0+'))0(FA>*'(-1
%'(B
\]#Z\]#Z
/RB(R/
UU
>W#(>W#@$
<BS<BS
@R '@R /
C+-,,-D0C*4E-7:67
$R$'$R/
JPZJPZ
!"#$!%&'(')*+$ *,*-*'($$$$$$$$$$$$$$$./'(01$$23435$67789:;;$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$<0=-*>01$$???@(+A%&@%',BA%&'(')*B$$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$#A)DE0$M 1$H*)0$J*->'&O1$
Q0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$XQ0->$C0-LE>-$RL(*>-$8$<BS$*($%B+)$T$U$A(F$A$*($)0VB4WW$+)$T$X
$$$$$$$$$$$
C5P*0B06V0B
!"#$$%&'(
$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$
C0D'&>$'@
*2.+57P*5S,*05.-;-39S6467b0K1K06..8D-*;0S90S5:-.0.53-67:b0K1K06..8D-*;0S90.5,.-8M.53-670*2.+57P*0.5D5.-39.6DD*40-7;*2*2.+57P*5S,*0:6;-8M0D*4.*73D*4.*730+8M-.0M533*4D635::-8M0-7;*2D635:+b0K1K06..8D-*;
0S90M5P7*:-8MM-7*45,0:6-,0.,5::M57P57*:*)7!5?5-,5S-,-390-7;*20V640.46D0@)7!5?5-,5S-,-390-7;*20V640.46D0 M57P57*:*0-7;*2M-7*45,!64P57-.0:6-,0.,5::7-346P*7:6;-8M7-3453*07-346P*764P57-.0:6-,0.,5::.844*7
30:6-,0DID+6:D+648:0-7;*2D+6:D+53*:8,V840-7;*2:6,8S,*0:5,30-7;*2Q*-P+30D*40?6,8M*`-7.05?5-,5S-,-390-7;*2
`-7.0-7;*2
8$$
;
7
X
X
X
9
9
C0D'&>$!==&0,*A>*'(-!+\]\]#Z$$AZU$$$$$L8MU#.JPZ\\8M\\P%ZPMP(P(8!E4P(8!M9P(8MP8AXXC_DJ$$$$$$$$$.8M.#8M##8M$$<BS\[(8!M\[(8M
7
640
*
=0
456
!J0\\76304683-7*,90
/
=0
564
=0
4
R0HV0
00000
06&+"&>."%E-F3,:"!&G"%!,(,H"%?
>>>?.2;1%?1&#@;1%&.&+,@3<%-!?C!+
0Q-,,0S*0P-?*70-7087-3:06V0*-3+*40
$#%&/)#!&)"!0!,
54*0,-:3*;0-7087-3:06V0,SA@$$$0:^0V30R0HV09680.577630V-7;0
!"#!$% !&'()%&
>>>?.2;1%?1&#@;1%&.&+,@&A5;%!B?C!+D/-
54*0,-:3*;0:*D5453*,90V640*5.+07834-*730360S*05;;*;0\\-7087-3:06V0
48&!"9 "2&.:;%<83!%,".!-;.:=,2%&.3!%,".!-
",/$-"(,"-% !"(1&,2.(#'!&,3"
^
R
*%#", ("(#!(,
"*%#"*!'"$#%+,"%#"%)-!#"(#.!"(#!(,"
C+-,,-D0C*4E-7:67
!"#$!%&'(')*+$ *,*-*'(./'(01$$23435$67789:;;<0=-*>01$$???@(+A%&@%',BA%&'(')*B$$7.5P4RP6?A5P4676M-AD8S:R+3MR
`(F0&->A(F*(%$>/0$#'*E$C0D'&>1$0aDEA(A>*'($'K$)0A-L&0)0(>-^$A==&0,*A>*'(-$A(F$L(*>-C0+'))0(FA>*'(-#-M*00 HV03*:3-7P0V-7;:03+530:6-,0DI0-:03660,6Q0V6403+*0.46D\\:\]0-7;-.53*;=050367A5.4*0640,SA@$$$0:^
0V3R0640S*:304*:8,3:=0M-203+*0,-M*0-73603+*036D0L0360%0-7.+*:06V0:6-,0:*?*45,0M673+:0S*V64*0D,573-7PR064076!3-,,0640*:35S,-:+*;0D,573-7P:0Q+*4*03+-:0-:07630D6::-S,*=05DD,90760M64*03+570@0360@RB0367
A5.4*0\\B$0,SA@$$$0:^0V3\]053067*03-M*=0*?*70-V03+*04*D64304*.6MM*7;:0M64*R0680.5705DD,903+*04*:30-70:-M-,540-7.4*M*73:0*?*490:-20M673+:0873-,03+*0V8,,0453*0-:05DD,-*;R0HV0)>0-:04*.6MM*7;*;057;0,-M*
0-:07**;*;=08:*0;6,6M-34-.0,-M*R*43-,-`*40<*.6MM*7;53-67:,SA5.4*087,*::063+*4Q-:*0:D*.-V-*;\]R0<*.6MM*7;53-67:0V640J0\\57;0:6M*3-M*:0V640T\]054*0S5:*;06704*:*54.+AV-*,;0:38;-*:0V6403+*0.46D0S*-7P0P4
6Q7=07630670:6-,03*:304*:8,3:R0\[!H057;0C!H0?5,8*:054*0S5:*;06703*:304*:8,3:057;0:+68,;0S*0a0B$R0HV03+*9054*0763=0V6,,6Q03+*0V*43-,-`*404*.6MM*7;53-67:0P-?*7R0HV0)P0-:07**;*;057;0760,-M*0-:04*.6MM*7;
*;=0$!$! 0\\@@RBb0)P\]0-:0570*2.*,,*730:684.*c0@&B0360 B$0,S0D*405.4*05,67*0640-7050V*43-,-`*40S,*7;0Q-,,08:85,,90:53-:V90.46D07**;:=0""!H0,*?*,:05DD*54067,906704*D643:0V640P4**7+68:*0:6-,0640D46S,*
M0:5MD,*:R054M*4:057;063+*40.6MM*4.-5,0D46;8.*4:0:+68,;0D590:D*.-5,0533*73-67036076353-67:05DD*5406703+*0:6-,04*D643=04*V*4036000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000R0H
70P*7*45,=0+6M*6Q7*4:0;6076307**;0360S*0.67.*47*;05S6830M-.467834-*73:R0F54-68:0.46D0763*:05,:605;;4*::0,-M*0V*43-,-`*407**;:c0?-:-30<*.6MM*7;53-67:03+*0*25.30V*43-,-`*40P45;*04*.6MM*7;*;06703+*04*D6
43=0?-:-30000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000360V-7;0-7V64M53-6703+530M590+*,D09680.+66:*050.6MD545S,*05,3*4753*R0640M64*0-7V64M53-67=04*5;Q0->$C0-LE>-O+*0V-4:30:*?*70?5,
8*:0d:6-,0.,5::=0I)b=0eAF=0K1K=0T"b=0G.057;0DIf0;*:.4-S*03+*0:6-,057;0-3:0;*P4**06V05.-;-39R0O+*04*M5-7-7P0@L0dC!H=0\[!H=0K5b=0)Pb=0)7!H=0)7!GH@=0)7!GH =0g7!H=0g7!GH=0K8!H=0"!H=0""!H=0J5=01"C=0""!H=0
Jh5?5-,5S,*\]f0-7;-.53*0,*?*,:06V0D,57307834-*73:064063+*40V*43-,-390M*5:84*M*73R0F-:-300
Rainfall Amounts (in)
-
f Nebraska
n, J.L..' Historical
17\].
-
11
-
tetoolbox.org/) accessed on \[2021
Water Watcher' web tool. Climate Toolbox (https://clima
.S. Drought Monitor is produced through a partnership between the National Drought Mitigation Center at the University o
tional Drought Mitigation Center, Hegewisch, K.C., Abatzoglou, J.T., McEvoy, D., Chedwiggen, O., Nijssen, B., and Huntingto
NaThe ULincoln, the United States Department of Agriculture, and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
Rainfall Amounts (in)
January 4, 2023
ATTN: Katie Merritt,
North Carolina Division of Water Resources
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
Subject: DRAFT 2023 Remedial Action Plan for the GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank (DWR
Project #: 2017-0112)
Restoration Systems (RS) has observed extensive dieback of planted hardwood species across the
entire site for the GUC Nutrient Offset and Buffer Mitigation Bank during the Yr. 3, 2022 Monitoring
Season. The Yr. 3 Monitoring survey shows an average of two hundred and forty (240) stems per acre
across the site, which fails to meet the success criteria. The low efficacy is widespread across the site and
not contained to just one area of the project. RS believes soil conditions and drought are combined in
causing the low survival of planted stems.
As discussed in the 2021 AMP, soil moisture availability is a known limiting factor for tree
establishment on the soils at this site. Further review of the available literature for these soil series
indicate that reforestation efforts are prone to challenges, including drought vulnerability to varying
degrees sitewide. See USGS Soil Survey (Karnowski, Edwin H. Soil Survey, Pitt County, North Carolina. The
Service, 1974.) Prolonged drought conditions in 2022 in Pitt County contributed to significant seedling
mortality and continue to impact the site due to rainfall deficit. The climate outlook, according to the State
Climate Office, calls for a continued La Nina pattern this winter which is likely to prolong drought impacts
through a warm and dry winter pattern. (Davis, Corey. (2022, November 17). Winter Outlook for 2022-23:
La Nina Lives On. North Carolina State Climate Office Climate Blog.
https://climate.ncsu.edu/blog/2022/11/winter-outlook-for-2022-23-la-nina-lives-on/ ).
Based on the challenging soil conditions and unfavorable climate outlook, RS proposes to take a
measured approach to bringing the site up to standard. The plan includes limited planting of test areas
in January/February 2023 :
1.3,750 stems to be planted across 7.29 acres. See Figure 1 and Table 1.
2.Species will include species from original planting list as well as:
i.Aronia arbutifolia, a native shrub known for drought tolerance.
ii.Amelanchier spp., a native shrub known for drought tolerance.
iii.Pinus taeda, a native softwood which may serve as an effective nurse crop.
3.2023 Monitoring will include additional sampling in test planting areas.
RS remains committed to meeting success criteria on this site. Soil moisture challenges are
expected to diminish over time in most areas as herbaceous species build a thatch layer and additional
stems of drought resistance species and/or nurse crops further assist the successful establishment of the
target community. Drought conditions are also expected to fade at some point, at which time existing
planted stems are likely to respond with increased vigor and volunteer stems are expected in many
portions of the site. RS looks forward to meeting with DWR staff to discuss this draft plan.
1101 Haynes St., Suite 211 • Raleigh, NC 27604 • www.restorationsystems.com • Ph 919.755.9490 • Fx 919.755.9492
Figure 1: Remedial plantinglocations (yellow)
Table 1: Remedial planting species
Species #
Amelanchier spp. 350
Aronia arbutifolia 350
Betula nigra 750
Liriodendron tulipifera 150
Morus rubra 600
Nyssa sylvatica 100
Pinus taeda 400
Platanus Occidentalis 150
Quercus michauxii 400
Quercus nigra 200
Ulmus americana 300
Total 3,750
1101 Haynes St., Suite 211 • Raleigh, NC 27604 • www.restorationsystems.com • Ph 919.755.9490 • Fx 919.755.9492