20221792 Ver 1_CAMA Application_20221220

DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
FIELD INVESTIGATION REPORT
APPLICANT'S NAME: Brian and Susan Shugart
2. LOCATION OF PROJECT SITE: 2206 East Yacht Drive, adjacent to the AIWW, in Oak Island, Brunswick
County.
Lat: 33.9249451N Long:-78.1369531W
3. INVESTIGATION TYPE: CAMA
INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURE: Dates of Site Visit — 9/8/22 & 11/8/22
Was Applicant Present — No
5. PROCESSING PROCEDURE: Application Received — 8/23/22 Complete - 11/28/22 Office - Wilmington
6. SITE DESCRIPTION:
(A) Local Land Use Plan — Brunswick County
Land Classification from LUP —Residential
(B) AEC(s) Involved: PTA, EW
(C) Water Dependent: Yes
(D) Intended Use: Private
(E) Wastewater Treatment: Existing — N/A
Planned — N/A
(F) Type of Structures: Existing — Single Family Residence with existing bulkhead, fixed access pier and
fixed covered platform
Planned — construct new floating dock, four new fixed finger piers and two boat
lifts (3 slips)
(G) Estimated Annual Rate of Erosion: N/A
Source - NIA
HABITAT DESCRIPTION:
[AREA]
DREDGED FILLED OTHER
(A) Vegetated Wetlands (Coastal
Wetlands)
(B) Non -Vegetated Wetlands
808 SF
(Open water)
additional
incorporated
(C) Other (High ground)
(D) Total Area Disturbed: 808 SF (.018 acres)
(E) Primary Nursery Area: Yes
(F) Water Classification: SA Open: No
8. PROJECT SUMMARY: The applicant proposes to expand an existing private private pier, with the addition of
four fixed finger piers, a piling -less dual hinge I-beam gangway and floating dock, including the construction of
two boat lifts, increasing the slip count from zero existing slips to a total of three slips.
127 Cardinal Drive Ext., Wilmington, NC 28405
Phone: [phone] FAX:[phone] Internet: www,nccoastalmanagement.not
An Equal Opportunity 1 Affirmative Action Employer - 60% Recycled 110% Post Consumer Paper

Shugart Docking Facility
Page Two
9. PROJECT DESCRIPTION:
The project site is located at 2206 East Yacht Drive adjacent to the A1WW, near Oak Island, Brunswick County.
The site is approximately 0.49 acres and is vegetated primarily with lawn grass and ornamental plants. There is
an existing single family structure on the site and an existing bulkhead (authorized via CAMA General Permit
72294D in 2018) located landward of coastal wetlands. The project site has approximately 120 ft. of shoreline
frontage along the AIWW. Along the eastern half of the property there is a section of Coastal Wetlands, which
consists of Smooth Cordgrass (Spartina alterniflora), beginning east of the pier and measuring approximately 40
ft. to the property line shared with the town, and extending approximately 30' waterward from the bulkhead.
There is currently a fixed pier (80' x 6') which originates in the center of the parcel and extends waterward
(northerly) from the bulkhead. The fixed access pier terminates on a T-head, fixed covered platform (18.5' x 19').
The current pier was authorized via CAMA General Permit 77634D, issued in February 2021. The original
general permit application for the property (2020) included a proposed boat lift and floating dock, but shallow
water depths found on site (less than two feet at nonnal low water) were deemed not sufficient to obtain a general
permit consent form from the Division of Marine Fisheries, and the floating dock and boat lift were removed from
the permitted drawing. A second general permit application for this property was received by DCM in May 2022
included a proposal for 2 boat lifts and a proposed floating dock (different configuration from prior general permit
application) but could not be processed as a general permit due to shallow water concerns from DMF and three
proposed slips. At that time DCM informed the agent that any proposal that involved formalized slips would
necessitate a CAMA Major Permit application.
The Brunswick County Land Use Plan classifies the adjacent waters as Conservation. The waters of the Al W W
are classified SA by the Division of Water Resources. This area is IS designated as a Primary Nursery Area
(PNA) by the N.C. Division of Marine Fisheries and they are CLOSED to the harvest of shellfish.
PROPOSED PROJECT:
The applicant proposes to expand an existing private pier, with the addition of four fixed finger piers, a piling -less
dual hinge I-beam gangway and floating dock, including the construction of two boat lifts, increasing the slip
count from zero existing slips to a total of three slips. According to the application materials, the property owners
are proposing to extend a piling -less gangway to the north from the waterward end of the existing fixed covered
platform. The piling -less gangway and its support arms would extend 13' waterward, providing access to a
floating dock (8' x 22') that would be oriented parallel with the shoreline, serving as slip 3. The purpose of the
piling -less I beam gangway is to provide access to a floating dock that is past the USACE setback line (without
driving pilings) and to have the proposed floating dock located in deeper water to potentially lessen resource
impacts to shallow bottom habitat. The USACE Navigation Section has provided prior approval for this
encroachment in an email dated 10/13/22 (a copy of this email is included in the application materials). The
proposed floating dock would be located in water depths ranging from -0.5' to -1.2' @ NLW (verified on site by
DCM staff). The proposed boat lifts (2 @ 14.5' x 16') would be located to the east and west of the existing
covered gazebo, and each boat lift would be accessed by two finger piers (one 7' x 4' and one 14' x 4') extending
waterward from the northwestern and northeastern corners of the existing covered gazebo.
According to the work plan drawings, the applicant's proposal is located within their riparian corridor, and within
'/4 of the width of the waterbody, which measures approximately 406' across. The proposed floating dock would
extend approximately 12' past the USACE federal channel setback, without utilizing any pilings driven past the
setback.

10. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS
The proposed docking facility, would result in the additional incorporation of 808 sq. ft. of Estuarine Waters and
Public Trust Area. The existing facility currently incorporates 831.5 SF of Estuarine Waters and Public Trust
Area. The proposed expansion extends approximately 12' past the USACE setback (without pilings) and a total of
70 ft. into the waterbody (from the edge of marsh) which measures approximately 406 ft. across. This distance
conforms to the pierhead line and width. This area is designated as PNA, and the proposed floating dock would
be located in water depths ranging from -0.75 to -1.2 at NLW. The piling -less design would prevent the
installation of physical stops on the floating dock. The proposed boatlifts would be located in water raging from -
0.2' to -0.5' at NLW. Minor increases in turbidity should be expected during construction.
The total area of platform was calculated as follows:
Shoreline length = 120 ft. x 8 ft. = 960 SF allowable
Existing Fixed Access Pier = 80 ft. x 6 ft. = 480 SF (not counted for shading, access credit)
Existing Fixed Covered Platform = 18.5 ft. x 19 ft. = 351.5 SF,
Proposed Floating Dock � 8 ft. x 22 ft. = 176 SF
Proposed Fixed Finger Pier = 2 @ 7 ft. x 4 ft. = 56 SF
Proposed Fixed Finger Piers= 2 @ 14ft. x 4 ft.= 112 SF
Proposed Boatlifts = 2 @ 14.5 ft. x 16 ft. = 464 SF, (not counted for shading)
Total Counted sq. ft. = 695.5 SF
Submitted by: Patrick Amico Date: 12/20/22 Office: Wilmington

SF-G,
Southern environmental Gr-oup, Inc.
55 15 SoutL Collcgc Road, Suite E
Wilmington, NC 21+E z
2206 East Yacht Drive
Oak Island, Brunswick County, NC
CAMA Major Project Narrative
Prepared for:
Mr. Brian Shugart
1880 Woodstock Road
Clemmons, NC 27012
Prepared by:
Dana Lutheran
Southern Environmental Group, Inc.
5315 South College Road, Suite E
Wilmington, NC 28412
RECEIVED
Date: NOV 18 2022
10 October 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN �)F Cli
1) Project Information:
a) Applicant Contact Information:
b)
Brunswick Co. Parcel ID #:
c)
Project Location:
d)
Project Size:
e)
Waterbody:
f)
Width of Waterbody:
g)
DWR Water Classification:
h)
Primary Nursery (PNA):
2) Project History:
Phone: [phone]
Email: briandshugar(@Yahoo.com
235GA030 (see Attachment 1)
2206 East Yacht Drive (see Attachment 2)
fl- 0.49 AC (see Attachment 1)
Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway (ICWW)
Approximately 445 linear feet (see Attachment 3)
SA;HQW (see Attachment 4)
This area is classified as PNA (see Attachment 5)
The Applicant purchased the property in 2020 and was told, by the realtor, that he could have a dock. It wasn't until
the Applicant went to obtain a permit, from the Division of Coastal Management (DCM), that he became aware of
the inability to secure a permit for boat lifts and/or floating structures, at this location. In order to be able to take
advantage of his riparian rights, the Applicant secured a CAMA General Permit and installed a 80' x 6' fixed pier
and 18.5' x 19' fixed and covered, observation platform (see Attachment 6). As part of that permit process, the
Applicant enlisted Stroud Engineering, to survey the mean low water depths, at the site. The work was undertaken
on 8 March 2021, using NAVD 1988 MLW Datum, where 0.00' MLW equals 2.57' NAVD 1988 (see Attachment
7). The structure was built as per the approved plan.
3) Proposed Project:
The Applicant is seeking approval to install eight (8) pilings, 14.5' x 16', for two (2) 12 ton boat lifts; one (1) 22' x
8' floating platform (i.e., taxi dock); two (2) 4' x 4' finger piers and two (2) 7' x 4' platforms, which will all be
accessible by the existing dock and gazebo. A pileless gangway will be used, in place of pilings, to secure the floating
platform to the existing covered, fixed platform. The floating platform will be used for loading and unloading only
and will not serve for overnight docking. To ensure the proposed structures will not negatively affect the substrate,
the platform will include permanent stops, to keep the structure from resting on the bottom, during low tide.
Additionally, the lifts will be installed so they can only be used in water depths greater than 18". This can be achieved
by limiting the length of the cables. Please see Attachment 8, for details of the proposed work.
Equipment, such as a barge and pump will be used to install the pilings. If necessary, the barge will be moored, when
not in use, in an area where it will not rest on the bottom. Typical building materials will be used to construct the
floating platform and finger piers.
4) Purpose and Need:
The purpose of this project is to provide access to Public Trust Waters, through the installation of two boat lifts and
a floating platform, at Mr. Shugart's waterfront property, in Oak Island, North Carolina.
5) Existing conditions:
The project site is located on a relatively narrow (i.e., —433') Atlantic 1CWW, where boat traffic is very heavy,
especially from March through October. The area is not a protected, No Wake Zone, and wave action has caused the
accumulation of sediment to take place, waterward of the existing bulkhead. Coastal wetland species (i.e., Smooth
Cordgrass (Sparlina alternaflora)) can be found under and east of the existing pier but not within the proposed work
area (see Attachment 9), Substrate within the area of the proposed work is comprised of a layer of compacted muck,
overlain by a relatively thin sand layer, with sparse shell matter (see Attachment 9). According to the Division of
Marine Fisheries' (DMF) Submerged Aquatic Vegetation (SAV) Overlay .kmz file, SAV has not been mapped and
based on numerous on -site evaluations, do not typically grow, within the area of the proposed worMO
10). According to the Mean Low Water Depth Survey, water depths in the location of the proposed work range from
-0.2' to -1.2' MLW (see Attachment 8). NOV 18 ?n??
F)CM WlI- Vage1*of 22

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Mai or Permit PN
There are two docks, with floating platforms and boat lifts, on the west and east sides of the project site. The western
structure is approximately 120' long and approximately 37 linear feet away from proposed slip #1, while the eastern
structure is approximately 110' long and, at its closest point, approximately 89 linear feet away from proposed slip
#2 (see Photos I & 2 below). The western dock is within the 15' setback.
Photo 1 Distance between adjacent western and project
docks
Photo 2 Distance between adjacent eastern and project
docks
Since the project site abuts the Atlantic ICWW, the development is restricted by the US Army Corps of Engineers'
(USAGE) Navigational Channel Setback line (see Attachment 11). SEGi submitted a copy of the proposed plan to
Mr. Justin Arnette, with the USACE Navigation Unit, who said the agency has no comment on the proposed project,
as long as there are no pilings, waterward of the USACE's Navigational Channel Setback line (see Attachment 12).
It should be noted, an evaluation of aerial photos revealed the majority of the docks, built along this section of the
ICWW, contain boat lifts and floating docks and do not have 2' of water at normal low water. In fact, a good number
of them have little or no water during that time. Many of those docks, including the two adjacent docking structures,
also extend beyond the USACE's Navigational Channel Setback. Please see Attachment 13
6) Threatened and Endangered Species:
To ensure protection of the West Indian manatee (Trachechus manatus), the work will be undertaken between
November I and May 31. If this is not possible, the Applicant will adhere to the US Fish and Wildlife's guidance
entitled "GUIDELINES FOR AVOIDING IMPACTS TO THE WEST INDIAN MANATEE, Precautionary
Measures for Construction Activities in North Carolina Waters" (see Attachment 14).
7) Shellfish
The area is closed to shellfishing (see Attachment 15). During SEGi's field evaluation, which occurred on 8/10/22,
no shellfish were observed within the proposed work area (see Attachment 9).
S) Adjacent Riparian Property Owner Notifications:
In accordance with 15A NCAC 07J .0204(b)(5), the adjacent riparian property owners (APO), as identified in the
permit application, have been notified via certified return mail. The notification included the application and site
plan, for the proposed development, as this project requires a CAMA Major Development Permit Application.
According to the Brunswick County GIS, the following are the adjacent riparian property owners:
Map Number Parcel ID Owner Mailing Address
1 SE 22"d Street Town of Oak Island 4601 East Oak Island Drive, Oak Island, NC 28465
2 235GA029 Mitchell Rowell PO Box 237, Indian Trail, NC 28079
RECEIVED
�,iu iILnry i,dvc uccu ttuiuteu. rtease see nitacnment io, ror copies or me cernnea man reeetprs,
NOV 18 2029
Page 3 of 22
DCM WILMINGTON, NC:

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN i
9) DWR Pre -Filing Request Requirement:
SEGi submitted a Pre -Filing Request Form to the DWR on 8/10/22 (see Attachment 17). Additionally, on or about
7 July 2022, SEGi spoke with Ms. Holley Snider, with the Wilmington Region Office DWR, who recommended the
Applicant submit the CAMA Major Permit Application, for official review.
The project proponent hereby certifies that all information contained herein is true, accurate, and complete to the
best of my knowledge and belief.
The project proponent hereby requests that the certifying authority review and take action, on this CWA 401
certification request, within the applicable reasonable period of time.
Summary:
In summary, the Mr. Brian Shugart is seeking authorization, in the form of a CAMA Major Permit, to perform new
work, within Public Trust Waters, at his property, that abuts the Atlantic ICWW, at 2206 East Yacht Drive, in Oak
Island, Brunswick County, North Carolina.
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
Page 4 of 22

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN i
Attachments
Description
Page
I
Brunswick County GIS Aerial, Deed and Parcel Information
6
2
Vicinity Map
7
3
Width of Waterbody Exhibit
8
4
Division of Water Resources Water Classification Map
9
5
Division of Marine Fisheries Primary Nursery Area Map
10
6
CAMA General Permit 77634
11
7
Stroud Engineering Mean Low Water Survey
12
8
2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Site Plan
13
9
August 10, 2022 Site Photos
14
l0
Division of Marine Fisheries Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Map
15
11
US Army Corps of Engineers Navigational Setback Aerial
16
12
USACE Navigation Unit Email
17
13
Aerial Photos of Oak island Section of ICWW
18
14
"GUIDELINES FOR AVOIDING IMPACTS TO THE WEST INDIAN MANATEE,
Precautionary Measures for Construction Activities in North Carolina Waters"
19
15
Division of Marine Fisheries Shellfish Closure Map
20
16
Adjacent Riparian Property Owner Certified Mail Receipts
21
17
Division of Water Resources Pre -Filing Request
22
RECEIvsia
NOV 18 209
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
Page 5 of 22

BOU NP-1
APPLICATION for
Mayor Development Permit
past revised 12127106)
North Carolina DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
9. Primary Applicant/ Landowner Information
Business Name
Project Name (if applicable)
Na
2206 East Yacht Drive
Applicant 1: First Name
MI
Last Name
Brian
Shugart
Applicant 2: First Name
MI
Last Name
If additional applicants, please attach an additional page(s) with names listed.
Mailing Address
PO Box
City
State
1880 Woodstock Road
J-
Clemmons
NC
ZIP
Country
Phone No.
FAX No.
27012-9780
us
336 - 529 - 7285 ext.
Street Address (if different from above)
City
State
ZIP
Same
_
Email
[e-mail]
2. Agent/Contractor Information
Business Name
Southern Environmental Group, Inc. - (Segi)
Agent/ Contractor 1: First Name
MI
Last Name
Dana
A
Lutheran
Agentl Contractor 2: First Name
MI
Last Name
Mailing Address
PO Box
City
State
5315 South College Road, Suite E
Wilmington
NC
ZIP
Phone No. 1
Phone No. 2
28412
910 - 228 -
1841 ext.
ext.
FAX No.
Contractor #
NA
Street Address (if different from above)
City
State
ZIP
Same
Email
[e-mail]
RECEIVED
<Form continues on backs
NOV 16 2022
252-808-2808 .. 1-888-414Cq,d ST www.necoastaimanagem4jGLMWILMIN�,j-0,N !N

Form DCM MP-1 (Page 2 of 4)
APPLICATION for
Major Development Permit
3. Project Location
County (can be multiple)
Street Address
State Rd. #
Brunswick
2206 East Yacht Dr.
NA
Subdivision Name
City
State
Zip
NA
Oak Island
NC
28465 -
Phone No.
Lot No.(s) (if many, attach additional page with list)
NIA- - ext.
NA, I ,
a. In which NC river basin is the project located?
b. Name of body of water nearest to proposed project
Cape Fear(030300050802)
AICWW
c. Is the water body identified in (b) above, natural or manmade?
d. Name the closest major water body to the proposed project site.
❑Natural ®Manmade ❑Unknown
AICWW
e. Is proposed work within city limits or planning jurisdiction?
f. If applicable, list the planning jurisdiction or city limit the proposed
®Yes []No
work falls within.
Oak island
4. Site Description
a. Total length of shoreline on the tract (ft.)
b. Size of entire tract (sq.ft.)
—107 LF
0.49 +/-
c. Size of individual lot(s)
d. Approximate elevation of tract above NHW (normal high water) or
NA, I
NWL (normal water level)
(if many lot sizes, please attach additional page with a list)
8' ®NHW or ❑NWL
e. Vegetation on tract
The project site is a maintained single family dwelling, with typical ornamental trees, shrubs and grasses. Beyond the
existing bulkhead, Spartina alternaflora can be found on the east side of the existing dock (see attached Project Narrative,
for Existing Conditions photos).
f. Man-made features and uses now on tract
Currently there is a single family dwelling, with associated driveway, a bulkhead, along the northern side of the property, 80'
x 6' fixed pier, and 18.5' x 19' fixed observation platform, extends waterward of the bulkhead (see attached 2022 GE
Aerial).
g. Identify and describe the existing land uses adiacent to the proposed project site.
Residential is dominant land use adjacent to the project site. However, NE 22nd Street, which is a dead end road, is directly
to the east of the project site (see attached Project Narrative for Adjacent Riparian Property Owner Map).
h. How does local government zone the tract?
i. Is the proposed project consistent with the applicable zoning?
Single family
(Attach zoning compliance certificate, if applicable)
®Yes ❑No ❑NA
j. Is the proposed activity part of an urban waterfront redevelopment proposal? ❑Yes ®No
k. Has a professional archaeological assessment been done for the tract? If yes, attach a copy. ❑Yes ®No ❑NA
If yes, by whom?
I. Is the proposed project located in a National Registered Historic District or does it involve a ❑Yes ®No ❑NA
National Register listed or eligible property?
<Form continues on next pages RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
252-808-2808 .. 1-888-4RCOAST .. www.nccoastalmanagem Mr lllMINGTORI, NC

Form DCM MP-1 (Page 3 of 4)
APPLICATION for
Major Development Permit
m. (i) Are there wetlands on the site? ❑Yes ®No
(ii) Are there coastal wetlands on the site? ®Yes []No
(iii) If yes to either (i) or (ii) above, has a delineation been conducted? ❑Yes ®No
(Attach documentation, if available)
n. Describe existing wastewater treatment facilities.
The project does not reqire wastewater treatment.
o. Describe existing drinking water supply source.
The project does not require drinking water
p. Describe existing storm water management or treatment systems.
The upland development was authorized through the Town of Oak Island. The project does not propose any new built upon
area.
S. Activities and Impacts
a. Will the project be for commercial, public, or private use? ❑Commercial ❑Public/Government
®Private/Community
b. Give a brief description of purpose, use, and daily operations of the project when complete.
The purpose of this project is to install two boat lifts and one docking platform, in order to access and utilize Public Trust
Waters, from a single family property, with dedicated riparian rights. The property owner will utilize the facility at his leisure.
C. Describe the proposed construction methodology, types of construction equipment to be used during construction, the number of each type
of equipment and where it is to be stored.
The pilings will be installed by either jetting or hammering. Installation of the proposed floating structure will entail
assembling the structure on dry land, floating it into position, and connecting it to the existing, 18.5' x 19', fixed platform, with
the pileless gangway. A small boat and barge will used to install the pilings, which should not take more than one day. The
remaining work will take place shortly thereafter. Traditional building materials will be used in the construction.
d. List all development activities you propose.
The proposed work entails the installation of pilings to support the two (2) proposed 7' x 4' uncovered, fixed platforms and
two (2)14' x 4' finger piers, as well as the installation of the six (6) pilings, to be placed 14.5', outside to outside and from
bow to stern, and 16', on center and from port to starboard and on each side of the 14' x 4' finger piers (total of twelve (12)
pilings), for two (2) 12 ton boat lifts, and a 22' x 8' floating platform.
e. Are the proposed activities maintenance of an existing project, new work, or both? New
f. What is the approximate total disturbed land area resulting from the proposed project? NA ❑Sq.Ft or []Acres
g. Will the proposed project encroach on any public easement, public accessway or other area ❑Yes ®No ❑NA
that the public has established use of?
h. Describe location and type of existing and proposed discharges to waters of the state.
NA
i. Will wastewater or stormwater be discharged into a wetland? ❑Yes ®No ❑NA
If yes, will this discharged water be of the same salinity as the receiving water? []Yes ONO ®NA
j. Is there any mitigation proposed? []Yes ®No ❑NA RECEIVE®
If yes, attach a mitigation proposal.
Form continues on back> NOV 19 2022
252-808-2808 .. 1-888-4RCOAST .. www.nccoastalmanagement.net ` NC

Form DCM MP-1 (Page 4 of4)
APPLICATION for
Major Development Permit
6. Additional Information
In addition to this completed application form, (MP-1) the following items below, If applicable, must be submitted In orderfor the application
package to be complete. !tams (a) — (0 are ahvays applicable to any major development application Please consult the application
instruction booklet on how to property prepare the required items below.
a. A project narrative.
b. An accurate, dated work plat (including plan view and cross-sectiona[ drawings) drawn to scale. Please give the present status of the
proposed project. Is any portion already complete? If previously authorized work, clearly indicate on maps, plats, drawings to distinguish
between work completed and proposed.
c. A site or location map that is sufficiently detailed to guide agency personnel unfamiliar with the area to the site.
d A copy of the deed (with state application only) or other instrument under which the applicant claims title to the affected properties.
e. The appropriate application fee. Check or money order made payable to DENR.
f. A list of the names and complete addresses of the adjacent waterfront (riparian) landowners and signed return receipts as proof that such
owners have received a copy of the application and plats by certified mail. Such landowners must be advised that they have 30 days in
which to submit comments on the proposed project to the Miision of Coastal Management.
Name Rowell, Mitchell & Beverly Phone No.
Address PO Box 237, Ind[an Trail, NC 28079-0237
Name Town of Oak Island - Mr. Steve Edwards Phone No.
Address 4601 East Oak Island Drive, Oak Island NC, 28465
Name Phone No.
Address
g. A list of previous state or federal permits issued for work on the project tract. Include permit numbers, permittee, and Issuing dates.
CAMA GP 77634 (see attached)
h. Signed consultant or agent authorization form, if applicable.
i. Wetland delineation, if necessary.
j. A signed AEC hazard notice for projects in oceanfront and inlet areas. (Must be signed by property owner)
k. A statement of compliance with the N.C. Environmental Policy Act (N.C.G.S. I I3A 1-10), if necessary_ If the project involves expenditure
of public funds or use of public lands, attach a statement documenting compliance with the North Carolina Environmental Policy Act.
1 7. Certification and Permission to Enter on Land I
understand that any permit issued in response to this application will allow only the development described in the application.
The project will be subject to the conditions and restrictions contained in the permit.
I certify that I am authorized to grant, and do in fact grant permission to representatives of state and federal review agencies to
enter on the aforementioned lands in connection with evaluating information related to this permit application and follow-up
monitoring of the project.
I further certify that the information provided in this application is truthful to the best of my knowledge.
Date—10/10/2022^ Print Name _Dana Lutheran on behalf of Brian Shugart ("Applicant')_
Signature
Please indicate application attachments pertaining to your proposed project.
❑DCM MP-2 Excavation and Fill Information ❑DCM MP-5 Bridges and Culverts
❑DCM MP-3 Upland Development
®DCM MPA Structures Information
UCEIVE[)
NOV 18 2Q21.
7$'e�-`J; t)a't-3g if{ .. '�-$78-4s•P�C. f3 l�t5� .. kli 1PJ l�J.E3C C.4�5� :l�eYanfaC�F•Ei7 r�rE$_nut
; )r,M WILMINGTON, NC;

Form DCM MP.4
STRUCTURES
(Construction within Public Trust Areas)
Attach this form to Joint Application for CAMA Major Permit, Form DCM MP-1. Be sure to complete all other sections of the Joint
Application that relate to this proposed project. Please include all supplemental information.
1. DOCKING FACILITY/MARINA CHARACTERISTICS
a. (i) Is the docking facility/marina:
❑Commercial ❑Public/Government NPrivate/Community
❑ This section not applicable
b. (i) Will the facility be open to the general public?
❑Yes NNo
c. (i) Dock(s) and/or pier(s)
d. (i) Are Finger Piers included? NYes ❑No
(it) Number 1 (Component 11
If yes:
(tii) Length 80,
(ii) Number 2 (Components 4 & 5)
(iv) Width 6'
(iii) Length 14'
(v) Floating ❑Yes NNo
(iv) Width 4'
(v) Floating ❑Yes NNo
e. (i) Are Platforms included? NYes ❑No
f. (i) Are Boatlifts included? NYes ❑No
If yes:
If yes:
(ii) Number 2 - Components 3A & B and 6
(fi) Number 2 (Components 9 & 10)
(iii) Length Components 3A & B - T / Component 6 - 22'
(iii) Length 14.6 from outside to outside
(iv) width Components 3A & B - 4' / Component 6 - 8'
(iv) Width 16' on center
(v) Floating NYes NNo
Note: Roofed areas are calculated from dripline dimensions.
g. (1) Number of slips proposed
h. Check all the types of services to be provided.
3
❑ Full service, including travel lift and/or rail, repair or
(ii) Number of slips existing
maintenance service
0
❑ Dockage, fuel, and marine supplies
N Dockage ('vet slips") only, number of slips: 1
N Dry storage; number of boats: 2
❑ Boat ramp(s); number of boat ramps:
❑ Other, please describe:
I. Check the proposed type of siting:
j. Describe the typical boats to be served (e.g., open runabout,
❑ Land cut and access channel
charter boats, sail boats, mixed types).
[]Open water; dredging for basin and/or channel
runabout, 'at ski
❑Open water; no dredging required
®Other; please describe:
Open water, where dredging prohibited due to PNA
designation
k. Typical boat length: 35
RECEIVE®
NOV 18 ?0??
DCM WILMINGTON, SIC
252-808-2808 :: 1-888-4RCOAST :: www.nccoastalmanagement.net revised: 12/27/06

Form DCM MP-4 (Structures, Page 2 of 4)
m. (i) Will the facility have tie pilings? (i) Will the facility be open to the general public?
❑Yes NNo ❑Yes NNo
(ii) If yes number of tie pilings?
0
2.
DOCKING FACILITY/MARINA OPERATIONS
N This section not applicable
a.
b.
Check each of the following sanitary facilities that will be included in the proposed project.
❑ Office Toilets
❑ Toilets for patrons; Number: ; Location:
❑ Showers
❑ Boatholding tank pumpout; Give type and location:
Describe treatment type and disposal location for all sanitary wastewater.
C.
Describe the disposal of solid waste, fish offal and trash.
d.
How will overboard discharge of sewage from boats be controlled?
e.
(i) Give the location and number of "No Sewage Discharge' signs proposed.
(ii) Give the location and number of "pumpout Available" signs proposed.
f.
Describe the special design, if applicable, for containing industrial type pollutants, such as paint, sandblasting waste and petroleum products.
g.
Where will residue from vessel maintenance be disposed of?
h.
i.
Give the number of channel markers and "No Wake' signs proposed.
Give the location of fuel -handling facilities, and describe the safety measures planned to protect area water quality.
j.
What will be the manna policy on overnight and live -aboard dockage?
k.
Describe design measures that promote boat basin flushing?
RECEIVED
Nov 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
252-808-2808
:: 1-888-4RCOAST :: wrww.nccoastalmanaaament.net
revised: 12127/06

Form DCM MP-4 (Structures, Page 3 of 4)
If this project is an expansion of an existing marina, what types of services are currently provided?
m. Is the marina/docking facility proposed within a primary or secondary nursery area?
❑Yes ❑No
Is the marina/docking facility proposed within or adjacent to any shellfish harvesting area?
❑Yes ❑No
o. Is the marina/docking facility proposed within or adjacent to coastal wetlands/marsh (CW), submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV), shell bottom
(SB), or other wetlands (WL)? If any boxes are checked, provide the number of square feet affected.
❑CW ❑SAV ❑SB
❑WL ❑None
p. Is the proposed marina/docking facility located within or within close proximity to any shellfish leases? ❑Yes [:]No
If yes, give the name and address of the leaseholder(s), and give the proximity to the lease.
3, BOATHOUSE (including covered lifts) ®This section not applicable
a. (i) Is the boathouse structure(s):
❑Commercial ❑PubliclGovernment ❑Private/Community
(ii) Number
(iii) Length
(iv) Width
Note: Roofed areas are calculated from dripline dimensions.
4. GROIN (e.g., wood, sheetpile, etc. if a rock groin, use MP-2, Excavation and Fill.) ®This section not applicable
a. (i) Number
(ii) Length
(ili) Width
5. BREAKWATER (e.g., wood, sheetpile, etc.) ®This section not applicable
a. Length b. Average distance from NHW, NWL, or wetlands
c. Maximum distance beyond NHW, NWL or wetlands
6. MOORING PILINGS and BUOYS ®This section not applicable
a. Is the structure(s): b. Number
❑Commercial ❑PubliclGovernmenl ❑PrivatelCommunity
c. Distance to be placed beyond shoreline d. Description of buoy (color, inscription, size, anchor, etc.)
Note: This should be measured from marsh edge, if present.
RECEIVED
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
252-808-2808 :: 1-888-4RCQAST :: www.nccoastaimanagement.net revised: 12/27/06

Fo rra DQW-9 Pj`jid-fir (Structuess, urge 4 v-V A-)
e. Arc of the swing
7. GENERAL
a. Proximity of structure(s) to adjacent riparian property lines
Approximately 32.5' from the western riparian property line
and 25' from the eastern riparian property line.
Note: For buoy or mooring piling, use am of swing including length
of vessel.
e. Width of water body
Approximately 455 LF
e. p) Will navigational aids be required as a result of the project?
©Yes ONo ❑NA
(ii) If yes, explain what type and how they will be implemented.
b. Proximity of structure(s) to adjacent docking facilities.
Approximately 54' from the western adjacent structure and
80' from the eastern adjacent structure.
d. Water depth at waterward end of structure at NLW or NWL
-1.2' NLW
&. OTHER ❑This section not applicable
a. Give complete description: T
The floating platform will have permanent stops incorporated into the design and the boat lift rabies will be limited to keep the
lifts from being used when water depths are less than 1F and to keep the platform and bunks from resting on the bottom, at
any time.
10 October 2022
Date
22GS East Yacht Drive
Project Name
Brian Shugart
Applicant Name
Dana Lutheran for Brian Shugart
Applicant Signature CF1V
N O v 1E
F)CM MUM.'
252-508.2308 :. 1-883-1Kis'OAST revised: 2IRVas

dlutheran@se Lus
From: [e-mail]
Sent: Thursday, August 11, 2022 10:40 AM
To: '401 [e-mail]'
Subject: 2206 East Yacht Drive 401 Pre -Filing Request
Project Name:
2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit
Applicant Name:
Brian Shugart
Address:
Same as project, Oak Island, Brunswick Co.
Consultant:
SEGi — Dana Lutheran (910.228.1841)
Project Description:
Install two boat lifts and a floating platform
50uthern environmental GOUP, Inc.
5515 South College Koad,5uite F
Wilmington, NC 28412
['iron e. 910.45 2.271 1
Mo6ile:910.228.1 841 (preferrecD
www.5egi.us
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
Page I of I
i DCM WIL.MINGTON, NC

ROY COOPER
Governor
ELIZABETH S. BISER
Secretary
BRAXTON DAVIS
Director
NORTH CAROLINA
Environmental Quality
December 20, 2022
Southern Environmental Group INC
C10 Dana Lutheran
5315 South College Road, Suite E,
Wilmington NC 28412
Dear Ms. Lutheran:
The Division of Coastal Management hereby acknowledges receipt of your application, acting as agent for Brian and
Susan Shugart for State approval for development of the subject property located at the at 2206 East Yacht Drive, in
Oak Island, Brunswick County. It was received as complete on November 28th, 2022 and appears to be adequate for
processing at this time. The projected deadline for making a decision is February 11, 2023. An additional 75-day
review period is provided by law when such time is necessary to complete the review. If you have not been notified
of a final action by the initial deadline stated above, you should consider the review period extended. Under those
circumstances, this letter will serve as your notice of an extended review. However, an additional letter will be
provided on or about the 75th day.
If this agency does not render a permit decision within 70 days from November 28th 2022, you may request a
meeting with the Director of the Division of Coastal Management and permit staff to discuss the status of your
project. Such a meeting will be held within five working days from the receipt of your written request and shall
include the property owner, developer, and project designer/consultant.
NCGS 113A-119(b) requires that Notice of an application be posted at the location of the proposed development.
Enclosed you will find a "Notice of Permit Filing" postcard which must be posted at the property of your proposed
development, You should post this notice at a conspicuous point along your property where it can be observed from
a public road. Some examples would be: Nailing the notice card to a telephone pole or tree along the road right-of-
way fronting your property; or at a point along the road right-of-way where a private road would lead one into your
property. Failure to post this notice could result in an incomplete application.
An onsite inspection will be made, and if additional information is required, you will be contacted by the appropriate
State or Federal agency. Please contact me if you have any questions and notify me in writing if you wish to receive
a copy of my field report and/or comments from reviewing agencies.
Sincerely,
Patrick Amico
Field Representative
cc: Cameron Luck, DCM
Kim Harding, DMF
Courtney Milliron, LPO
Greg Curry, USACE Holley Snider, DWR
Brian and Susan Shugart, Applicants
D \E\\ QUA
Ogwdor�l q 6rvba�nW QUM
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality I Division of Coastal Management
Wilmington Office 1 07 Cardinal Drive Extension I Wilmington, North Carolina 28405
910,796,7215

ROY COOPER
Governor
NORTH C UNA
Enwronine,;ral Quality
December 20, 2022
Gan [e-mail]
2 Pages
Star News
Legal Advertisement Section
Re: Major Public Notice for:
• Karen and Mike Hobbs
• Brian and Susan Shugart
Hello: Please publish the attached Notice in the Friday, December 23, 2022 issue.
ELIZABETH S. BISER
Secrelary
BRAXTON DAVIS
Director, Division ofCoaslal Management
The State Office of Budget & Management requires an original Affidavit of Publication prior to payment for
newspaper advertising.
* ** "Please send both original affidavit and invoice for payment to:
NC Division of Coastal Management, c/o Tanya Pietila, 127 Cardinal Drive Extension, Wilmington, NC 28405.
Contact number: 910-796-7226. (Customer No. 489895)
Thank you for your assistance.
4 incerely,
nya K. ' tila
Perinitting Support & Customer Assistance
cc: MHC Files
Cameron Luck — MHC
USACE
State of North Carolina I Environmental Quality I Coastal Management
127 Cardinal Drive Ext., Wilmington, NC 28405 919 796 7215

NOTICE OF FILING OF
APPLICATION FOR LAMA MAJOR
DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
The Department of Environmental Quality hereby gives public notice as required by NCGS 113A-
119(b) that the following applications were submitted for a development permit in Areas of Environmental
Concern as designated under the CAMA: On December 16, 2022 Karen and Mike Hobbs proposed to construct
an additional docking facility w/ the construction of a new access pier & two (2) new boat lifts for a total of
three (3) proposed slips at 131 Fayetteville St., adj. to theAIWW in Holden Beach Brunswick County, And on
December 20, 2022 Brian and Susan Shugart proposed to expand an existing private pier w/ the addition of
four (4) fixed finger piers, a piling -less dual hinge gangway & floating dock, and two (2) boat lifts increasing
the slip count from zero (0) to three (3) total slips at 2206 E. Yacht Dr., adj. to the AIWW in Oak Island,
Brunswick County. Copies of these applications can be examined or copied at the office of Patrick Amico N.C.
Dept. of Environmental Quality, Division of Coastal Management, 127 Cardinal Drive Ext., Wilmington, NC
28405, [phone] during normal business hours.
Comments mailed to Braxton C. Davis, Director, Division of Coastal Management, 400 Commerce
Avenue, Morehead City, NC 28557-3421, prior to January 13, 2022 will be considered in making the permit
decision. Later comments will be accepted and considered up to the time of permit decision. Project
modification may occur based on review and comment by the public and state and federal agencies. Notice of
the permit decision in these matters will be provided upon written request.

Attachment 2
N.C. DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
AGENT AUTHORIZATION FORM
Date 8/12/2022
Name of Property Owner Applying for Permit:
Mailing Address:
1180 Woodstock Rd.
Clemmons, NC 27012
I certify that I have authorized (agent) . 5outhem EaviroDmental Group, Inc. to act on my
behalf, for the purpose of applying for and obtaining all LAMA Permits necessary to
install or construct (activity) two boat lifts, a finger pier and floating platform ,
at (my property located at) 2206 fast Yacht Dave, Oak Island, North Carolina
This certification is valid thru (date) unf;l the nrWaot ,s complete
Property Owner
Date
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

Ln
Ln
m
ru Fee
r� 14. DO 0684
rur 03
M 6 $6.06 H-
C3
$
P.,Uo-- 10YI312022
$8.93
C3
ru
C3 9�64f----
t,
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN i
Attachment 2
Vicinity Map
NOV 13 2022
Page 7 of 22
0CM WILMINGTON, NC

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN C3F Cli
Attachment 3
Width of Waterbody Exhibit
RECEIVU)
NOV 18 20
DCM WILMINGTON, NC;
Page 8 of 22

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN i
Attachment 4
DWR Water Classification Map
Intracoastal Waterway
924
.' ...,_,...,_,�• �""'+,......, x5 �; s s (��,' .yc '' 3 b p t i a , _ Invacoaswl 1Na:e-�roay
�Y y F.orn a line cross;,
ICWW so th of SR 1112
to Cape Fear R;,er Basi_,
R'-"v Ps' LBR
; 1. :. 03030M
1 µ•: 403.511
S Acrea
r dex a 55-25
ean, SA:HQ1N
Lcn^.to ...
i
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
Page 9 of 22

2206 East Yacht Drive LAMA Major Permit PN _ 5L_SL
Attachment 5
NC DMF Primary Nursery Area Map
-- - -- r---------
---------I-
I----- --------
RECEIVED
NOV 18 202.2
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
Page 10 of 22

z
v
1
v
Z
N
W
>?
moo^
by
Q�
uz
I.q CHANNEL WROTH
------y----�-- ---
...
F
l
aP
---1----1
--```j -
W
••a_
-
r
S(�O 15
wwrn
z
Gn�
I
1
'
'
I
J
z in
SETBACK US ICWW
I
i
� �
o a a
I
l
�,
Ic,
I
I
'
I L
�_
a
w aa�o�
o
li
'
1
YI
2YK0Vf Qo
w0 -OZ
N
OK1
�1
u'
IZ
¢N�aa'o
��
O
d
1
NI
?A
Ia
IQ
all-W�o~w0
�I
is
Q
Z
Z
W
3oz
Zw>oaQOQQ OM_
W
>zI
1
1
`
QZtn2••V1N
izam
I
I>
iD
\� dl
•--ii
�I ,\•
I
1 I
vl2wzU
-owl- 1 7 a
li
IN
-
�I
'
I
i I
��aQ IW u
LLxJ Ix Q
v>a-�U
O
Y
10
IZ
IQ
ti
ti ry
'
I O o z
<O�OZ IOw
Q
O
IJ
IJ
NS ZN�cw.)N
>w3 w-
NI
z
to
w�00YxrQ
S83°19'19"E $L> >. EX.
�866
BULKHEAD
�a�v2aV,
w�wz��aa
1n
N
J0
4CNIJ 6.86 $ F
w
w
oouw ¢
Qo
v
U1
Ln
--g EragoU
1-
via
�O
to M
O
NQ
to
W
M
OD
3
M
M
wo
c
'n
O
M
6
O
Z
•'L
VI
a¢�
=>
R/W US ICwW
a
I
zoW
w
R/W US
ICWW
�
W
z�a
J
O
p
Ln
W
;
WSW
LL11
Z
U
I1
_
o
In
V
3
WWQi
Q
O
c
M
U�
O
JW
O
'n
N
M
Q,
M1
(7
J c�
is
O
V
O
M
OCc
Q
O
e
o
Kll
N
J"
J�
W
w
I•I
w
w
VO
M
Z
Z
.
CO
O
O
M
O
.-.
00
O
O
V Q
w OD
z
W LLJ
LLIm�Q
N p
Q
60.16'
a
ZCDo
27"W
"'
waCL CL
w3Z
N83°53
W
_
ui
Z CD to
cr Ih
— — —
30N
om
E. YACHT DRIVE
-
.-----
-----------
r Y
T_ n
- - -
- - -
>oo
--------
�,0-
mmm
ZQ J
N�0
OZ�
�w
0
>
w O
J
w

Length of Shoreline: 145'
Existing Platform Area: 351.5 SF
Proposed Platform Area: 168 SF
Total Platform Area: 519.5 SF
Number of slips existing: 0
Number of slips proposed: 3
Wooden, permanent "stops" are to
be placed at 18" above the substrate,
on the lifts and floating platform.
The substrate is packed, mucky sand, with
little or no shellfish and no SAV
Note: This map has been modified to depict
the existing and proposed structures,
both the Applicant's and neighbors.
These are approximate locations and
AICWW
g components tih
•�
measurements and were not surveyed.
R�fm` fiogepe Horm6 '
wi pi
gang wo see
' com nt 3A
pone
Proposetl Tx 4'
stops
lip CHANNEL WIDTH
Mc plattortn
------
/anen
-----�--cti-------
-5'
'
-----•'�—' — —�--
3--
Component a 3
— — — — _
\
i
Proposetl ]' x 4' 1
finger platform 1
1
r
SETBAC i ICWW
1-3zs O 4
1 i l
• I
5 Oz o 1
• I � I
a
Approx mate location of a
2 [oat lift tloc Yacht Dr cility I
et 22o4EYacht Dr.
1
I //?
� 1
�_f • C 1 I
=
'
I0
I
1 /
I Componentl0
Proposetl boat I
ICJ
p
1 Compon t 9
I t lim4 5 nbwootleh
j lift 4.5'x16)wtlp
L R\\\—\ Pe Psanent wootler�
0 'Gal
I �
oI
Ietope n n
I�
[J
Components 485
2 - Proposetl 14 x 4'
COmPon t2
Existing 185' 19' (flt
fi-d --etl_;
U
X
finger piers
Qf platter r� u
Go
OI
d
0
I a
IQ
U Z QI
1/II
ComgyoerRt -Id
�1
Z
1
x 6' Pier
\y
I
ShRltetl9ea0'
1
\,/ II
I
I \.✓
I
II
Approx Coestel
�IV� ' / 1
I
1rry
1 Wetland Line
I
"/ y✓
1t
I
t
R/W US ICWW
CAMA Major Permit Dock Plan
for
Mr. Brian Shugart
2206 East Yacht Drive, Oak Island
6 October 2022
Sheet 1 of 1(v2) z
- -Pier Head Line
Approximate location of
20'x 13'""' platform,
-- 13'x 13'floating platrorm
and boat lift, at 2302 E
Yacht Dr.
ti �l
583"79'79"E Sz e: EX. BULKHEAD
N 46. 86" g! 'S�berss w W
n
— — — a
w
-139,
unQ
U;
;4,w00
`n
Ln
a
M
O
c
`r' o
I
4
R/W US ICWW
a_
w
I
rsl
LI_I
LI-
�/ Town of
Q
3
I-- Oak Island
Vi
N rn
N
Q
�
0o
MI
1
Ni
LL.1I
CO
ZI
I
60.16r
\
a
I
I
N83e53r27//W
I
DRIVE
I
------
E. YACHT
_--------.-----•-
0
O
O
�
IIh
q
a s
¢��
W
—VW
J
N_arn
2
XCX
WO.W lit
U
O
¢
IM1
U
Z
(]
!n
�Lr)
V T
^
0 O
Lill O
W
c)wL
4 0
m^a
L .I <
LJ
X0-a_
W � Z
Irm-
WPM
Cr `_ V
In
Y
omcN
V)
LL1 O
>60
�^
Za3
X m00
N�
oz�
0
LLB
a o
LEI
> O
C
LLI 0
J
W

a
roastal el lands est�i
1,V"wrn closest dock. v+ilh Flis
and substrate iii the area nI'd
work
Eastern closest dock"
sIlbOtte in the area of ll�
area ol'thc proposed cork Dock n itlf lilts and Iloaler actUsy IC .ii 11.'frum
NI.. =
project siteAftir
r
7.7
f r2;4'
l
Dock ith lilts and floater across IONAN From
hrojcct site

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN ,C�17 CI],
Attachment 10
Google Earth with SAV Overlay
RECEIVE[
NOV I B 2422
$)t„ M WILMINGT'ON, NC
Page 15 of 22

2206 East Yacht Drive CA_MA Maior Permit PN ,9r Cii
Attachment 11
USAGE Navigation Channel Setback Aerial
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NO
Page 16 of 22

From: Annette. Justin R CIV USARMY CESAW (1-154
To: drutheranrafseai.us
Lc:"Arnim. Patrick P'
Subject: RE: [URL Verdict: unknownJ[Non-DOD Source] RE: [External] 2206 East Yacht Drive, Oak Island CAMA Permit Site Plan
Date: Thursday, October 13, 2D22 6:25:24 AM
Dana,
That meets what we discussed. That is an interesting change in design, I like it. Thanks.
Justin
Justin Arnette
Team Lead Cartographer
Landuse Coordinator
Wilmington District
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
910-251-4196
iustin.r.arnette@usace army -mil
From: [e-mail] <[e-mail]>
Sent: Wednesday, October 12, 2022 1:18 PM
To: Arnette, Justin R CIV USARMY CESAW (USA) <[e-mail]>
Cc: 'Amico, Patrick J' <[e-mail]>
Subject: RE: [URL Verdict: Unknownj[Non-DoD Source] RE: [External] 2206 East Yacht Drive, Oak Island CAMA Permit Site Plan
Hello, Justin.
Attached is the revised plan, with the floater moved back 5'. Please feel free to call with any questions or
concerns.
Dana
rjouthem E-nvimnmental Goup, Inc.
5315 south College Road, Suite E
Wilmington, NC 26412
rkane: 910.45 2.2] 1 1
M.6ile:91 o.zza,i s+i (preferrecD
From: Arnette, Justin R CIV USARMY CESAW (USA) <[e-mail]>
Sent: Friday, September 30, 2022 9:57 AM
To: dlutheranOsegi.us
Cc: 'Amico,Patrick Y<Patrick.AmicoaC, nrdenr.eov>
Subject: RE: [URL Verdict: Unknown][Non-DoD Source] RE: [External] 2206 East Yacht Drive, Oak Island CAMA Permit Site Plan
Dana,
Just to be clear, there is no pierhead line in the corps eyes. The setback line is the only line that my office looks at or takes
into account. I know other agencies may look at and take a pierhead line into account but we do not as the setback is the line
that restricts construction.
Thanks.
Justin
RECEIVED
NOV 13 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

FA
ti ,ljf�yj?
& . Ail

United States Department of the Interior
FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE
Raleigh Field Office
�a'g Post Office Box 33726
H s. Raleigh, North Carolina 27636-3726
GUIDELINES FOR AVOIDING IMPACTS TO THE WEST INDIAN MANATEE
Precautionary Measures for Construction Activities in North Carolina Waters
The West Indian manatee (Trichechus manatus), also known as the Florida manatee, is
a Federally -listed endangered aquatic mammal protected under the Endangered Species
Act of 1973, as amended (16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.) and the Marine Mammal Protection Act
of 1972, as amended (16 U.S.0 1461 etseq.). The manatee is also listed as endangered
under the North Carolina Endangered Species Act of 1987 (Article 25 of Chapter 113 of
the General Statutes). The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) is the lead Federal
agency responsible for the protection and recovery of the West Indian manatee under the
provisions of the Endangered Species Act.
Adult manatees average 10 feet long and weigh about 2,200 pounds, although some
individuals have been recorded at lengths greater than 13 feet and weighing as much as
3,500 pounds. Manatees are commonly found in fresh, brackish, or marine water habitats,
including shallow coastal bays, lagoons, estuaries, and inland rivers of varying salinity
extremes. Manatees spend much of their time underwater or partly submerged, making
them difficult to detect even in shallow water. While the manatee's principal stronghold in
the United States is Florida, the species is considered a seasonal inhabitant of North
Carolina with most occurrences reported from June through October.
To protect manatees in North Carolina, the Service's Raleigh Field Office has prepared
precautionary measures for general construction activities in waters used by the species.
Implementation of these measure will allow in -water projects which do not require blasting
to proceed without adverse impacts to manatees. In addition, inclusion of these guidelines
as conservation measures in a Biological Assessment or Biological Evaluation, or as part
of the determination of impacts on the manatee in an environmental document prepared
pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act, will expedite the Service's review of the
document for the fulfillment of requirements under Section 7 of the Endangered Species
Act. These measures include:
1. The project manager and/or contractor will inform all personnel associated with the
project that manatees may be present in the project area, and the need to avoid any harm
to these endangered mammals. The project manager will ensure that all construction
personnel know the general appearance of the species and their habit of moving about
completely or partially submerged in shallow water. All construction personnel will be
informed that they are responsible for observing water -related activities for the presence
of manatees. RECEIVED
2, The project manager and/or the contractor will advise all construction personnel 1 8 2022
Page 1 of 3
DCM WILMINGTON, NC

there are civil and criminal penalties for harming, harassing, or killing manatees which are
protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act and the Endangered Species Act.
3. If a manatee is seen within 100 yards of the active construction and/or dredging
operation or vessel movement, all appropriate precautions will be implemented to ensure
protection of the manatee. These precautions will include the immediate shutdown of
moving equipment if a manatee comes within 50 feet of the operational area of the
equipment. Activities will not resume until the manatee has departed the project area on
its own volition (i.e., it may not be herded or harassed from the area).
4. Any collision with and/or injury to a manatee will be reported immediately. The report
must be made to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (ph. 919.856.4520 ext. 16), the
National Marine Fisheries Service (ph. 252.728.8762), and the North Carolina Wildlife
Resources Commission (ph. 252.448.1546).
5. A sign will be posted in all vessels associated with the project where it is clearly visible
to the vessel operator. The sign should state:
CAUTION: The endangered manatee may occur in these waters during the warmer
months, primarily from June through October. Idle speed is required if operating
this vessel in shallow water during these months. All equipment must be shutdown
if a manatee comes within 50 feet of the vessel or operating equipment. A collision
with and/or injury to the manatee must be reported immediately to the U.S. Fish and
Wildlife Service (919-856-4520 ext. 16), the National Marine Fisheries Service
(252.728.8762), and the North Carolina Wildlife Resources Commission
(252.448.1546).
6. The contractor will maintain a log detailing sightings, collisions, and/or injuries to
manatees during project activities. Upon completion of the action, the project manager will
prepare a report which summarizes all information on manatees encountered and submit
the report to the Service's Raleigh Field Office.
7. All vessels associated with the construction project will operate at "no wake/idle" speeds
at all times while in water where the draft of the vessel provides less than a four foot
clearance from the bottom. All vessels will follow routes of deep water whenever possible.
8. If siltation barriers must be placed in shallow water, these barriers will be: (a) made of
material in which manatees cannot become entangled; (b) secured in a manner that they
cannot break free and entangle manatees; and, (c) regularly monitored to ensure that
manatees have not become entangled. Barriers will be placed in a manner to allow
manatees entry to or exit from essential habitat.
Prepared by (rev. 06/2003):
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Raleigh Field Office
Post Office Box 33726
Raleigh, North Carolina 27636-3726
919/856-4520
Page 2 of 3
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
t)CM WILMINGTON. NC

Figure 1. The whole body of the West Indian manatee may be visible in clear water; but
in the dark and muddy waters of coastal North Carolina, one normally sees only a small
part of the head when the manatee raises its nose to breathe.
flra
Illustration used with the permission of the North Carolina State Museum of Natural Sciences.
Source: Clark, M. K. 1987. Endangered, Threatened, and Rare Fauna of North Carolina: Part I.
Are -evaluation of the mammals. Occasional Papers of the North Carolina biological SuptmOQV �I
3. North Carolina State Museum of Natural Sciences. Raleigh, NC. pp. 52.
Page 3 of NOV 10 202Z
DCM WILMINGTON, NCB

Y -01, 1, Ternl,c)i IV CIA)suity hdAr Vem!r whm I, eq,j (A,.,P:lt M
-4K, -A�,I ;
P—= &WIfig.
C�W I
I 099a
Glow A— N.".
h.. ,,; .,, '' I .. .. I , ,, :!. t F- I TA 1* in--, -- —
To access official prodamartions, -- I tl,LJW��W
, 7
To access maps of permanent closed P
osure areas and written permanent
descriptions, dick on the gtt)vohg area
label in the map and then click on the
'Attachments' link that appears in the
pop up window.
AP..

JCAMA / DR DGE & FILL N 9 776311 # A B C
ENE PERMIT Previous permit
New ❑ odifi tion ElComplete Reissue ❑Partial Reissue Date previous permit issued
As authorized by the tate North Carolina, Department of Environmental Quality
and the Coastal the
rces ommission in an area of environmental concern pursuant to 15A NCAC u Rules attached.
Applicant Name Project Location: County .
Street Address/ State Road/ Lot # s
Address_ . �-. i1�1.�-11���1���t Lc.�} ()--
City� -- OKE-State �`� ZIP�1 l'_--V - -
Phone # JMail __ Subdivision ._ —.— _--. -
Authorized Agent- — City .-ow Ak�4---
-- — _ ZIP-1
CJ CWW*TA LJ ES ElPT5 Phone # (_- _) T River Basin
Affected CJ OEA ❑ HHP CJ tH U UBA iJ NIA
AEC(s): Adj. Wtr. Body — mat a unkn)
_
n Pws: � _
w\
OItW: yes / nOrN o PNA yes no Closest Maj. Wtr. Body
61
Type of Project/ Activity VrVI t
k.,/ (Scale:'t % 0 )
Pier (dock) length -
Fixed Platform(s)
Floating Platform(s)
Finger pier(s)
Groin length
Bulkhead/ Riprap length _
avg distance offish
�.�
max distance off re . i-
Basin. channel �j
cubic yards — I
Boat ramp
Boathouse) Bo lift
Beach Bulldo ing_. !
i
,
Other --
i
Shoreline length
SAM not sure yes l9
Moratorium: nja yes � ; •
Photos: yes no
WaiverAttached: yes
A building permit may 6e required by:
1 Ll See note on back regarding River Basin rules.
( Note Local Planning )%, Isdictlon) kta, �j
Notes/ Special Conditions
Ag
t or Applicant Printed Name
S' nature Please read compliance statement on back of permit **
- 5
Application Fee(s) Check #
A'I�'=:�,� NOV 13 2022
.''JoKfiNlersPri e a —
%/f��i i C WILMINGTO N(
Si re
i(ok
Issuing Date Expiration Date

2206 East Yacht Drive CAMA Major Permit PN 5F Cli
Attachment I
Brunswick County GIS
Aerial, Deed and Parcel Information
RE-CEIUED
NOV 18 2022
?ACM WILMINGTON, NG
Page 6 of 22

llifll�lll�lllllllilll�f�lflflllll�ll $3�4�� ��-04D0
Brunsulek County, NC Register or deeds page 1 of 1
-3tum Rd Type
otal Rev. lnl-
k S Ck If •I_a_�.; __Cash $
eturtti Cash
rortions of document are illegible due to condition
of original.
Wcumeot contains seals verified by original
rs�•r meat the'r,}r v t he-1-1-jtpd or copied.
—lul�TrulAt I•'I of C" I-V-r'lrptrj
STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA INS" RUit[FNT OF
COMBINATION
COUNn OF BRUNSWICK prepared by: I -OWN OF OAK ISLAND
Tf is Instrument of Ctiombiirarion is madt: this the I I lit day of February, 2020 by the owner Brian & Susan
Shugart whose mailing address is 1880 Woodstock Rd. Clem mons, NC 27013,
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the maker of this Instrument of Combination presently owns tax parcel 235GA030 and tax
parcel 235GA030 in the Town of Oak Island, NC (formerly known as Lung, Beach, NC) by virtue ordeeds recorded
in Book 4083 at Page 721 and Book 403 at Page 721 in the Brunswick County Regis" respectively; attd
Wit the owner wishes to consolidate tax parcel 235CA030 and tax parcel 235CA030 into a single
lot and tax parcel for compliance with Oak island Zoning regulations, all taxation, and assessment purposes only;
and
WHEREAS, this is a limited special purpose instrument for the purpose specified above and is not a
conveyance and is a re-plat(ing oi'the property and does not change or modify in any mannor the ownership interest
in the above mentioned property; and
WHEREAS, upon execution and recording of this Instrument of Combination tax parcel 235GA030 and
lax parcel 235GA030, Oak island, NC are hereby combined into a single lot and parcel for compliance wilh i }ak
Island 'Zoning regulations, all taxation, and assessment purposes only. Description is as (allows:
BEING all tax parcel 2351GA030 and tax parcel 235GA030 of Oak Island, NC f formerly known as Long
Beach, LNC) as described in recorded deeds in Book 119 at Page 41 and Book 119 at Page 41 of the Brunswick
County Registry, said lots having the metes, bounds and location as described herein.
Il\' V4'I"f11E55 WI{ERI,OF, the rn et his hand and seal t - day and year fits] above
written.
(SEAL)
- — — (SEAL)
STATE OF NORTH CAjZ(I,INA*'***** COUNTY OF 13HUNSWICK
i, (%�rr� Yam. _�r�, a Notary Public of said County and State, do Itereby certify that
A_.____personally appeared before me this Jay and acknowledged
the execution of the foregoing instrument. Witness my hand and official seal or stamp, this _ day of
STAMP OR SEAL: Notary Public ►�LQ��y���
MyCommissianhxpites,_I7•"_/l,-." __—.
NOTARY
=z
pUaLIG
%y9
RECEIVED
�ltltllMti��
NOV 19 2022
Page 1 of 1
:ACM WILMINGTON, NO

7126122, 2:52 PM
BRUNSWICK COUMV
Appralsal Card
711R1en» l.e•en eu
HUGART BRIAN ETUX SHUGART StISAN Relum/Appeal Parval: 235GA030
Notes:
2206 E. YACHT OR OAK ISLAND 28465 OAK ISLAND PLAT: UNIQ ID
00119/00041 101812
0073888 ID NO:206613148730
BRUNSWICK COUNTY (100), DOSHER HOSP TAX (100), OAK ISLAND (100), OAK CARD NO. 1
ISLAND FIRE (540) of 1
Reval Year: 2039 Tax
ear: 2022 L-1R 8-151 S-10 TRANQUIL HARBOUR PL 119/41 2.0000 LT SRC=
praised by 81 on 07/06/2020 306D OAK ISLAND - EAST TW-03 Cl- FR- EX- AT- LAST ACTION
14 08 20210624
CONSTRUCTION DETAIL
MARKET VALUE
DEPRECIATION
CORRELATION OF VALUE
Foundation - 3
ER.
IQUALIRATE
BASE
Standa D.DDDoo
Plers>Bft W Con 10.0
U5
MOD Area
RCN
EYB
AYB
REDENCE TO MARKET
ub Floor System - 4
01
01 13,781
175
154.00
58227
02
02
%GOOD 100.
DEPR. BUILDING VALUE - CARD 582,27
PI d/Ptl bd 8.0
TYPE: SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL SFR CONSTRUCTION
EPR- OB/XF VALUE - CARD 64,58
ARKET LAND VALUE - CARD 560,00
Exterior Walls - 19
Hardy Plank 32.00
STYLE: 2 - 1.5 Stories
OTAL MARKET VALUE - CARD 1,206,85
Roofing Structure - 03
Gable 7.0
Roofing Cover- 13
APPRAISED VALUE - CARD 1,206,85
Metal anding Sea 8.0(TOTAL
Interiorr Wall Wall Construction-- 5
D all/Sheetrock 21,0
17• {!'
a Tay
TOTAL APPRAISED VALUE -PARCEL 1,206,85
nterfor Floor Over - I
remit The 12.0
1! S f S 1{ 1 ; t
TOTAL PRESENT USE VALUE - PARCEL
to
nterlor Floor Cover - 12
Hardwood p.0
M,
tl• {' t P �'TOTAL
TOTAL VALUE DEFERRED - PARCEL
TAXABLE VALUE - PARCEL 1,206,85
Heating Fuel - 04
Electrlc 1.D
N' fllf N'
HeatingTlPe
PERMIT
Heat PumpOn 4.0
{'
W �•
CODE DATE NOTE NUMBER AMOUNT
r Conditioning Type - 03
ntrdl 4.0
{ 11' { 11' T . ]" 1
if
eedrooms/Sathrooms/Half-
Bathrooms
1' {-
OUT: WTRSHD:
/3/1 17.00
u.
{• u s rY 7
SALES
DATA
_
i
FF.
INDICATE
BAS� FUS - 3 LL - 0
U' �•
fT'
RECORD
DATE
DEED
TYPE
U
/
SALES
PRICE
Bathrooms
BAS - 1 FUS - 2 LL - 0
000 AGE
M R
alf-eathrooms
4314 455
4083 721
2 020
7�OIBJ
CO
GW'�
U
Q
V
V
59500U'30061382
BAS - 1 FUS - 0 LL - O
N'
0968 884
12009
2 994
WD
WD
U
U
Ie
V
8250
BAS-OFUS-OLL-0 01
q
1 ua If
OTAL POINT VALUE 124.00
BUILDING ADJUSTMENTS
Market Deol n
12
.35
1.350
uellty
4 ABOVE
1.100iii,
VERAG
{•
�. �!' l Ir 1'
ze
I
Size
0.950(I'
AL ADJUSTMENT FACTOR 1.41
AL QUALITY INDEX 17
�•
HEATED AREA 3,343
NOTES
Click on Image to enlarge
SUBAREA
OD
DESCRIPTION
OUN
LTF
H
N
UNIT
PRICE
ORIG %
COND
BLDGE
AYB
EYB
ANN DEP
RATE
V
%
COND
OB/XF DEPR.
YALU
GS
TYPE
AREA
% RPL
CS 30
2
2
8
LEVATOR
(PASSENGER)
NCRETE PAVING
IER/DOCK(RESID)
ECK COVERED
ULK HEAD
0.000
0.000
0,000
0.000
0.000
J3
1
83
4
-
i3
18,000.0
3.5
35.0
200.0
_
_
_
202
202
202
2021201
201
202
2021
2021
201
S
S
S
S
S
10
10
10
1
10
1800
291
1400
32
264a
8A5
203
10
313
FOP
86
03
3986
FUS
130
09
1811
LLU
154
02
4774
FIREPLACE 1 -None 12
SUBAREA
TAL
OB XF VALUE 64,57
TOTALS
5,75
582,27
BUILDING DIMENSIONS aAS=S17W4S11E3S9E12N4E6S1E14N1ESS1E17N7E4N15W4N12W56Area:2036;FOP=S23W10N12W56N12E17SSE49Area:863;FUS=Si8E4S1E13S10E14NI
10E7N2E6S2E7N1E3NISW4N5W9S5W7N5W1455W7N5W9S5W4Area:1307•LLU=W6S4W12N8W3N12E5N18E17512E42516W4S5W17NiW7S1Wi5S1Area:1548•T TotalArea:5754
LAND INFORMATION
HER
r
]USTNENTS AND
IROADUNIT
LAND
TOTAL
HIGHEST AND
USE
LOCAL
FROM
DEPTH
LND
CONTES
LAND
UNT
TOTAL
ADJUSTED
LAND
OVERRIDELAND
BEST USE
CODE
ZONING
TAGS
gEPTH
SIZE
MOD
FACTF
ACLC TO OT
TYPE
PRICE
UNITS
TYP
ADJST
UNIT PRICE
VALUE
VALUE
NOTES
FR WATERW
0104
R6
1 120
1 1B5
1 1.0000
1 0
1.0000
PS 280,000.0
2.000
LT
1.000
280,000.01
56000
TOTAL MARKET
LAND
DATA
560,00
[TOTAL PRESENT USE DATA
Page 1 of 1
https:fltax.brunsoo.notAtsnotlAppralse[Card.aspx?parcel=235GA030&TaxYear-2022
RECEIVED
NOV 18 2022
DCM WILMINGTON, NC
1/1

ROY COOPER
Governor
ELIZABETH S. BISER
Secretary
BRAXTON DAVIS
Director
December 20, 2022
MEMORANDUM:
�nEQ
NORTH CAROLINA
Environmental Quality
FROM: Cameron Luck, Assistant Major Permits Coordinator
NCDEQ - Division of Coastal Management
400 Commerce Avenue, Morehead City, NC 28557
Fax: [phone] (Courier 11-12-09)
cameron.lucka-NCDENR.gov
SUBJECT: CAMA
Applicant: Brian and Susan Shugart
Project Location: 2206 E. Yacht Drive, adj. to the AIWW, Oak Island, Brunswick County
Proposed Project: The applicant proposes to expand an existing private pier, with the addition of
four fixed finger piers, a piling -less dual hinge I-beam gangway and floating dock,
including the construction of two boat lifts, increasing the slip count from zero to a
total of three (3) slips.
Please indicate below your agency's position or viewpoint on the proposed project and
return this form to Cameron Luck at the address above by January 13, 2022. If you have any
questions regarding the proposed project, contact Patrick Amico at [phone] when appropriate, in-
depth comments with supporting data is requested.
REPLY: This agency has no objection to the project as proposed.
**Additional comments may be attached**
This agency has no comment on the proposed project.
PRINT NAME
AGENCY
SIGNATURE
This agency approves of the project only if the recommended changes
are incorporated. See attached.
This agency objects to the project for reasons described in the attached
comments.
DATE
E Q North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality I Division of Coastal Management
Wilmington Office 1 127 Cardinal Drive Extension I Wilmington, North Carolina 28405
NORTH CAROLINA -
.e ..e t of en.troome W mail /� 910.796.7215

Major Permit Fee Schedule
Project Name: County: Check No & Amoun
PA� �qgqoo 3�f \,LD
Development Type
Fee
DCM %
DWQ %
(14300160143510009316256253)
(2430016024351000952341)
I. Private, non-commercial development
that does not involve the filling or
$250
100% ($250)
0% ($0)
excavation of any wetlands or
open water areas:
Il. Public or commercial development that
does not involve the filling or excavation
$400
100% ($400)
0% ($0)
of any wetlands or open water areas:
Ili. For development that involves the
filling and/or excavation of up to 1 acre
of wetlands and/or open water areas,
determine if A,B, C, or D below applies:
lil(A). Private, non-commercial
development, if General Water Quality
$250
100% ($250)
0% ($0)
Certification No. 4175 can be applied:
III(B). Public or commercial development,
if General Water Quality Certification
$400
100% ($400)
0% ($0)
No. 4175 can be applied:
III(C). If General Water Quality
Certification No. 4175 could be applied,
but DCM staff determined that additional
$400
60% ($240)
40% ($160)
review and written DWQ concurrence is
needed because of concerns related to
water quality or aquatic life:
III(D). If General Water Quali
$400
60% ($240)
40% ($160)
Certification No. 4175 cannot be applie
IV. Development that involves the filling
and/or excavation of more than one acre
$475
60% ($285)
40% ($190)
of wetlands and/or open water areas: