WQ0014868_Setback Waivers_20180312

Barber, Jim
From: Barber, Jim
Sent: Monday, March 12, 2018 3:21 PM
To: Doby,.Troy
Subject: RE: WQ0014868 = Smithfield Fresh Meats Corp. RLAP
Attachments: WQ0014868 Smithfield Farmland attB 15 Sept 2008.pdf
Troy;
In researching the FRO files, I didn't find executed setback waivers for the two fields in question; SF09-01 or SF09-02 as
footnoted in the Attachment B for permit WQ0014868. I do know from past site visits that EMA does direct injection
when land applying on these two fields because of setback issues to homes along Barker Ten Mile Rd and NC Hwy 20
and property line configurations. If the 400' buffer was instituted to the residences verses the 200' buffer with injection;
both fields would be marginal for land application, hence EMA utilizing the injection method.l
I would propose changing the language in both footnotes to address the need for executed setback waivers if injection is
not utilized or provide updated buffer maps with the necessary 400' buffer to address the language of " regardless -Of
whether a surface application method".
I don't recall the reason for the language in the Attachment Bin the 22July 2014 permit. I'm providing a copy of the
Attachment B issued 15 Sept. 2008 that was done by the Fayetteville Regional Office that addresses the 200' buffer for
injection. Hopefully a copy of this modification is in the central(file.
If you have any questions, please give me a call or email. I'll be in the office Tuesday, out Weds and in Thursday and
Friday of this week.
Jim Barber
Environmental Engineer
NCDEQ-DWR-WQRO
Fayetteville Regional Office
910-433-3340 voice
910-486-0707 fax
iim.barberAncdenr.gov
E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and
may be disclosed to third parties.
`-j Go Green! Print this email only when necessary. Thank you for helping NCDENR be environmentally responsible.
From: Doby, Troy
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2018 2:03 PM
To: Barber, Jim <[e-mail]>
Subject: WQ0014868 - Smithfield Fresh Meats Corp. RLAP
Jim,
1

There were footnotes on setback waivers in the2014 permit, but I can't find any signed setback agreements in the
file. Do you have copies of these? My inclination is to remove them if I don't have copies of them.
Also, on five properties, the ownership has changed since 2014. I am putting a note that before residuals can be placed
on these fields, there has to be a new Land Owner Agreement in place. As you point out, this is up for renewal soon and
this will not force them to spend time putting new LOAs in place, but notify them they will have to do it if they want to
keep the land in the permit in the future or replace it.
Thanks for checking on setback agreements.
Troy Doby, PhD, PE
Non -Discharge Permitting Unit
Water Quality. Permitting Section
512 N. Salisbury Street
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1617
919-807-6336
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/wq/aps/lau
2

Barber, Jim
From:
Sent:
To:.
Subject:
Troy;
I will research the FRO files for permit applications past to see if the setback waivers exist and will email you later today
with what I find:
Barber, Jim
:Thursday, March 08, 2018 9:30 AM
Doby, Troy
RE: WQ0014868 = Smithfield Fresh Meats Corp. RLAP
Jim Barber
Environmental Engineer
NCDEQ-DWR=WQRO
Fayetteville Regional Office
910.433-3340 voice.
910-486-0707 fax
iim.barber(ncdenr.gov
E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and
maybe disclosed to third parties.
` j Go Green! Print this email only when necessary. Thank you for helping NCDENR be environmentally responsible.
From: Doby, Troy
Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2018'2:03 PM
To: Barber, Jim <[e-mail]>
-Subject: WQ0014868 - Smithfield Fresh Meats Corp. RLAP
Jim,
There were footnotes on setback waivers in the2014 permit, but I can't find any signed setback agreements in the.
file. Doyou have copies of these? My inclination .is toremove them if I.don't have copies of them.
Also, on five properties, the ownership has changed since 2014. I am putting a note that before residualscan be placed
on these fields, there has to be a new Land Owner Agreement in place. As you point out, this is.up for renewal soon and
this will not force them to spend time putting new LOAs in place, but notify them they will have to do it if they want to
keep the land in the permit in the future or replace it.
Thanks for checking on setback. agreements.
Troy Doby, PhD, PE
Non -Discharge Permitting Unit
Water Quality Permitting Section
512 N. Salisbury Street
1617 Mail Service Center
Raleigh,, NC 27699-1617
1

ATTACHMENT B - Approved Land Application Sites
Smithfield Farmland Corporation — Tar Heel Division
Certification Date: July 22, 2014
Permit Number: WQ0014868 Version: 3.0
Field
Owner
Lessee
County
Latitude
Longitude
Net Acreage
Dominant Soil Series
Footnotes e
SF03-01
Dunham, Steve \
Bladen
34° 44' 06"
78° 43' 07"
21.60
Lakeland sand, I-7% slopes
i
SF03-02
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 44' 15"
78° 43' 12"
13.30
Centenary sand
3
SF03-03
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 44' 18"
.78° 43' 20"
21.30
Centenary sand
SF03-04
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 44' 12"
78° 43' 26"
19.00
Wasda muck
SF03-05
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 44' 08"
78° 43' 21"
8.00
Lakeland sand, 1-7% slopes
SF03-06
Dunham, Sieve
Bladen
34° 44' 02"
78° 43' 33"
32.00
Lakeland sand, 1-7% slopes
SF03-07
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 43' 28"
78° 44' 21"
37.20
Wickham fine sandy loam, 1-6% slopes
3
SF07-01
Burney, J W
Dunham, -Steve
Bladen ,
34° 43' 1I"
78° 44' 26"
21.8
Altavista fine sandy loam, 0-3% slopes
3
SF07-03
Burney, J W
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 43' 15"
78° 44' 10"
12.3
Altavista fine sandy loam, 0-3%slopes
3
SF07-06
Burney,.1 W
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 43' 29" ,
- 78° 43' 53"
19.3
Wickham fine sandy loam, 1-6%slopes
SF07-08
Burney, J W
Dunham, Steve
Bladen
34° 43' 37"
78° 43' 44"
12.1
Altavista fine sandy loam, 0-3% slopes
SF07-09
Burney, J F
Dunham, Richard
Bladen
34° 43' 44"
78° 43' 44"
21.3
Wickham fine sandy loam, 1-6% slopes
SF07-14
Burney, J F
Dunham, Richard
. Bladen
34° 43' 55"
78° 43' 27"
7.5
Lakeland sand, l 7% slopes
3
SF07-15
Burney, J F
Dunham, Richard
Bladen
34° 43' 51"
78° 43' 41"
3.0
Lakeland sand, 1-7% slopes
3
SF10-01
Butler, Murdock M
Bladen
34° 46' 32"
78° 49' 19"
53.00
Norfolk loamy fine sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF 10-02
Butler, Murdock„M.
Bladen
_34° 47' 30"
78° 49' 48"
45.0
Autryville loamy sand, 0-3% slopes
SF10-03
Butler, Murdock M
Bladen
34° 47 23"
78° 49' 54"
31.00
Norfolk Ioamy fine sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF12-01
King, Hinton McCall
Bladen
34° 48' 19"
78° 51' 46" •
49.00
Norfolk loamy fine sand, 0 to 2% slopes
Total acreage for Bladen Count},
427.7
SF06-01
Tyson, Vance -
Cumberland
34° 55' 43"
78° 50' 24"
5.5
Autryville loamy sand, 0-3% slopes
SF06-02
Tyson, Vance
Cumberland
34° 55' 48"
78° 50' 14"
31.1
Autryville loamy' sand, 0-3%slopes
SF06-03
Tyson, Vance
Cumberland
34° 55' 29"
78° 50' 14"
64.5
Deloss loam
3
SF06-04 '
Tyson, Vance:U
Cumberland
34° 55' 43"
78° 50' 24"
35.0
Deloss loam
3
SF06-05
Tyson, Vance.0
Cumberland
34°55' 48"
78° 50' 14"
34.00
Deloss loam
3
SF06-06
Tyson, Vance U
Cumberland
34° 55' 29"
78° 50' 14"
79.00
Deloss loam
3
SF06-07
Tyson, Vance U
Cumberland
34° 55' 50"
78° 49' 41"
77.00:
Deloss loam
3

ATTACHMENT B - Approved Land Application Sites
Smithfield Farmland Corporation — Tar Heel Division
Certification Date: July 22, 2014
Permit Number: WQ0014868 Version: 3.0
Field
Owner
Lessee
County
Latitude
Longitude
Net Acreage
Dominant Soil Series
Footnotes
Total acreage for Cumberland County
326.10
SF08-01
King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
34° 44' 50"
78° 53' 29"
7.5
Goldsboro loamy sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF08-02
King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
34° 44' 44"
78° 53' 21"
17.00
Goldsboro loamy sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF08-03
King, Hinton McCa11
Robeson
34° 45' 01"
78° 53' 12"
89.50
Marlboro sandy Ioam, 0 to 2% slopes
SF08-04
King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
'34° 43' 18"
78° 55' 15"
64.50
Norfolk loamy sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF08-05
King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
34° 43' 22"
78° 56' 02"
46.00
Goldsboro loamy sand, 0 to 2%slopes
-.
SF08-06
'King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
34° 43' 50"
78° 56' 00"
21.50
Norfolk loamy sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF08-07
King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
34° 43' 21"
78° 56' 47"
37.00
Goldsboro loamy sand, 0 to 2% slopes
SF08-09
King, Hinton McCall
Robeson
34°.46' 35"
78° 58' 06"
45.00
Coxville loam
3
SF09-01
Musselwhite, Douglas
Robeson
34° 47' 40"
78° 55' 56"
36.00
Wagram loamy sand, 0 to 6% slopes
1
SF09-02
Musselwhite, Douglas
Robeson
34° 47' 49"
78° 56' 06"
27.50
Goldsboro loamy sand, 0 to 2% slopes
2
SF09-03 -
Musselwhite, Douglas
Robeson
34° 47' 21"
78° 55' 53"
9.50
Wagram loamy sand, 0 to 6% slopes
SF09-04
Musselwhite, Douglas
-
Robeson
34° 47' 12"
78° 55' 59"
25.00
Wagram loamy sand, 0 to 6% slopes
Total acreage for Robeson County
426.00
Total Land Application Area
1179.8
A reduced setback from a residence under separate ownership has been approved for this land application site. Residuals may be land applied within 200 feet of the residences along Barker Ten
Mile Road regardless of whether a•surface or a subsurface application method.
2. A reduced setback from a residence under separate ownership has been approved for this land application site. Residuals may be land applied within 200 feet of the residences along Highway
20, regardless of whether a surface or. a subsurface application method
3. Residual land application events on these fields shall be prohibited from December through March inclusive. No residuals shall be land applied to these fields when the vertical
separation between the depth of the residuals land application and the water table is less than three feet.
1.