20041488 Ver 9_More Info Received_20220311 (3)

Strickland, Bev
From: Deborah Shirley <[e-mail]>
Sent: Friday, March 11, 2022 2:30 PM
To: Hopper, Christopher D CIV USARMY CESAW (USA)
Cc: Cohn, Colleen M
Subject: [External] RE: SAW-2021-02303 (Central Carolina Reality Inc / Winston Road / Clayton
NC /Johnston County) - INCOMPLETE - REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Attachments: Sheet 1 of 2.pdf; Sheet 2 of 2.pdf
CAUTION: External email. Do not click links or open attachments unless you verify. Send all suspicious email as an attachment to
Report Spam.
I believe this is the last of them.
Apologies for transmitting this way.
Again, please let me know if we need to set a time aside to review together or if you have any questions.
Thanks,
DEBORAH E. SHIRLEY
Project Manager -Regulatory Specialist
Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA
North Quarter Office Park
8412 Falls of Neuse Road, Suite 104
Raleigh, NC 27615
Office [phone]
Direct [phone]
Mobile [phone]
[e-mail]
Visit us at sandec.com
This electronic communication, including all attachments, is intended only for the named addressee (s) and may contain confidential information. This electronic
communication may not have passed through our standard review/quality control process. Design data and recommendations included herein are provided as a matter of
convenience and should not be used for final design. Rely only on final, hardcopy materials bearing the consultant's original signature and seal. If you are not the named
addressee (s), any use, dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this electronic communication in error, please notify
the sender by return e-mail and delete the original communication from your system. Thank you.
Please consider the environment before printing this email.
From: Deborah Shirley
Sent: Friday, March 11, 2022 2:22 PM
To: Hopper, Christopher D CIV USARMY CESAW (USA) <[e-mail]>
Cc: Cohn, Colleen M <[e-mail]>; Camden Brunick <[e-mail]>
Subject: RE: SAW-2021-02303 (Central Carolina Reality Inc / Winston Road / Clayton NC / Johnston County) -
INCOMPLETE - REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Chris,
We have been working diligently on the project history for these parcels of land and believe that we have a good
understanding of its permitting and development history. Note that before we submitted the PCN application, we did
review the NCDWR files and thought that we had a good understanding of the permitting history. Below I have provided

a timeline and referenced Nationwide Permit verifications issued, important documents and exhibits that should assist
in your review of this Nationwide Permit request.
1995:
AID 1994-04978-Sweetwater-Commercial, Residential and Golf Course -Issued to Solaris Development Corporation
This verification authorized NWP 26 to impact 4.94 acres (3.84 ac fill & 1.1 ac excavated of headwaters and Isolated
waters), NWP 14 to impact 1.78 acres, NWP 18 to impact 0.1 acre, and NWP 12 to impact 9.33 acre (excavation and site
restoration). Per a April 19, 2000 letter from Michael Stewart of Stewart -Proctor, no authorized impacts took place and
the tract was subdivided into 2 tracts of land (see attached). Additionally, Google Earth imaging indicates that no
disturbance took place before 1999.
2002:
SAW-2002-20830-Winston Pointe Gravity Sanitary Sewer -Issued to M.A.L. Properties, LLC
This verification authorized NWP 12 to impact 0.569 acres of temporary impacts to jurisdictional waters. To our
knowledge, this utility line was constructed.
2013:
SAW-2013-01279- Winston Pointe Mixed Development- Issued to Central Carolina Reality
This verification authorized NWP 29 to impact 0.036 acres of wetland and 140 LF (280 SF) of stream associated with
three road crossings. To our knowledge, two of the three road crossings were constructed (i.e. Impact A and B) totaling
0.023 acres of wetland and 140 LF/280 SF of stream. Impact Area C was not constructed.
Other project information that we have concluded is that there was a road impact that we believe was constructed
in/around 2002, this crossing is up in the NE corner of the original Phase 1 (see attached aerial Google Earth photos and
Overall Map with notes). This presumed impact was to a wetland area per the jurisdictional determination and riparian
buffer determinations in that area. There is no permitting record for this crossing, but we believe it would have been
under the 0.10 acre NWP thresholds requiring notification in 2002. Early JD maps indicate that this is a wetland area
beyond the identified buffered stream. And finally, per the attached Approved Winston Pointe Master Plan, at Phase 3
the linear wetland feature was avoided by curving the road out to the east, see Foxtail Ct near amenity center.
In summary, we have provided a map exhibit with notes that identifies areas that have been previously
permitted/constructed, please see Winston Pointe OVERALL MAP with impacts listed.
I am going to attached as many documents as I can to this email and keep it at 10MB max and then send follow up
emails with the additional documents. My ShareFile is not currently working.
Please let me know if we need to set a time aside to review together or if you have any questions.
Thanks,
DEBORAH E. SHIRLEY
Project Manager -Regulatory Specialist
Soil & Environmental Consultants, PA
North Quarter Office Park
8412 Falls of Neuse Road, Suite 104
Raleigh, NC 27615
Office [phone]
Direct [phone]
Mobile [phone]
[e-mail]
Visit us at sandec.com
2

This electronic communication, including all attachments, is intended only for the named addressee (s) and may contain confidential information. This electronic
communication may not have passed through our standard review/quality control process. Design data and recommendations included herein are provided as a matter of
convenience and should not be used for final design. Rely only on final, hardcopy materials bearing the consultant's original signature and seal. If you are not the named
addressee (s), any use, dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this electronic communication in error, please notify
the sender by return e-mail and delete the original communication from your system. Thank you.
Please consider the environment before printing this email.
From: Hopper, Christopher D CIV USARMY CESAW (USA) <[e-mail]>
Sent: Thursday, January 20, 2022 11:29 AM
To: Camden Brunick <[e-mail]>
Cc: Cohn, Colleen M <[e-mail]>
Subject: RE: SAW-2021-02303 (Central Carolina Reality Inc / Winston Road / Clayton NC / Johnston County) -
INCOMPLETE - REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Good Morning, Camden:
Thank you for the above referenced request to utilize Nationwide Permit 29 to construct Phase 10 of the Winston Pointe
subdivision. At this time, the application is incomplete and we will require additional information to begin review. S&EC
and/or Stewart Proctor have been involved in permitting this development since the early 1990s. The development was
formerly known as 'Sweetwater' and in the early 2000's became known as Winston Pointe.
USACE Action ID SAW-1994-04978 (S&EC) authorized the use of Nationwide Permit (NWP) 26 to impact 4.94
acres, NWP 14 to impact 1.78 acres, NWP 18 to impact 0.1 acre, and NWP 12 to impact 9.33 acre.
USACE Action ID SAW-2002-20830 (S&EC) authorized the use of NWP 12 to impact .569 acre
USACE Action ID SAW-2013-01279 (Stewart Proctor) authorized the use of NWP 29 to impact 0.036 acre and 140
linear feet of stream.
I have attached several associated project maps to illustrate project connectivity/overlap.
The project status, and what (if any) impacts have occurred are unclear. Please review your files and prepare a complete
project history for our consideration as we review this recent request.
Regards,
Christopher D. Hopper
Regulatory Specialist
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Regulatory Division
3331 Heritage Trade Drive, Suite 105
Wake Forest, NC 27587
0: [phone], Ext. 35
M: [phone]
We would appreciate your feedback on how we are performing our duties. Our automated Customer Service Survey can
be accessed by copying and pasting the following link into your web browser:
https://regulatory.ops.usace.army.mil/customer-service-survey/. Thank you for taking the time to visit this site and
complete the survey.
From: RaleighNCREG <[e-mail]>
Sent: Thursday, December 23, 2021 10:47 AM
To: [e-mail]
Cc: Hopper, Christopher D CIV USARMY CESAW (USA) <[e-mail]>; Thames, Joyce A CIV
3

USARMY CESAW (USA) <[e-mail]>
Subject: SAW-2021-02303 (Central Carolina Reality Inc / Winston Road / Clayton NC / Johnston County)
Good Morning,
We have received your Pre -Construction Notification (PCN) NWP request for the above project and forwarded it to Mr.
Chris Hopper for further processing.
Thank you,
Josephine Schaffer
4

C
NOW OR FORMERLY
NOW OR FORMERLY
LEE BROTHERS RENTAL
D.B. 1322, PG. 117
PIN 1638-89-0361
LINE BEARING DISTANCE LINE °i '„ B %`:___-z'°'__... - • a„ !, y /
e Mo
BEARING DISTANCE D.B. 754 PG. 559 h E 4 .-- -_.--- -� ;-
1 N 39'45'35"E 176.52 2 N 58'08'S8"W 439.71 °4` '$k o+ 7
oa ` 1 �.�
2 S 53'19'06"E 225.14 43 S 74'58'12"W 412.59 % 6 ne
z
3 S 25'37'12"E 208.34 44 N 20'29'25"E 230.23 �31
ev-05 y' 4�`aio;-
4 S 0130'45"E 195.08 45 N 25'55'30"E 240.17� �°
5 S 21'31'37 W 79.51
46 N 39'O8'03"W 207.56-
6 S 5T08'S6"E 228.05
47 N 29'22'50'E 136.57
7 N 77*00'41 "E 330.36 48 N 04'40'21 "E 208.04 T
eo
8 N 71'49'52"E 214.67 49 N 23'24'23"E 60.00 \
9 S '18'09'37"E 60.00 _,___.
50 N 01' 17'35"E 143.22 _
" �•., ..�./ ��`�, � I ; � ` �� � ���� 1�4�11 III
10 N 71'S0'23"E 84.47 51 S 85'23'45"E 106.75 � I
12 S 49'a ' Z" r
11 S 08" , 9'3,, C 284.34
11
52 N 00 00 00 E 72.28 �,
37 00 E 44.98 ^�4 N 27'06 40 E 193.97 � - A� ry0",�
?'
r
13 N 74'29'50"E 48.98 � � ^^ � 1
�.
14 N 46'35' 1 1 "E 63.45
55 N 59'45 37"E 55.81
�. �I
15 N 38'42 29 E 254.56 57 N 49'35'30"E 139.28
„
16 N 46'22'31"W 177.20
I
17 N 05 57'31 "W 170.17
58 N 27 35 40"E 279.45
18 N 2830'3I W 99.59 59 N I0'56'02"E 164.89
19 N 10'S6'31 "W 79.49
60 N 36'52'56"W 140.31�
20 N 40' 19'29"E 65.67 61 N 18'0 1'23"W 139.99 - -_
21 N 76'02'29"E 82. 74 62 N 40'S6'01 "E 7 42.50
1
22 N 14' L1 '29"E 75.07
63 S 7435' 16"W 72.02 , ' . •
23 N 25'25'24"E 69.27
64 N 13'27'27"W 226.31 % }
24 N '58'27'29"E 246.15 65 N 55'41'16"W 237.67
25 S 40'09'31"E 125.27
66 N 10*04'33"W 260.00
31 E 53.7467 N 32' 17'35"W 161.32 �-: r` -• Ji - �--=
27 N '55'27'29 E 1 10.99 "`� .. N 89 28'05 W 2686.2.
68 N 39'20 45 E 256.77 F `-�
28 N '78' 15 29 E 107 56
29
N
60'49'30"E
169.20
N
59'09'31 W
'31 "W
65
30
N
'29'36'30"E
109.89
70
70
N
40'01
174.96
174.96
31
N
38' 13'32"E
29.25
71
N
49'15'20"W
91.64
32
S
85'06'30"W
129.37
72
73
N
N
74' 10'40"W
48'07'46"W
166.72
260.61
33
S
00'23'32"W
76.03
74
S
37'25'58"W
29.49
34
S
02'49,48"E
72.02
75
N
23'24'23"E
42.08
35
S
81'57 09 W
181.00
76
N
89'33'29"W
221.24
REFERENCES.
36
S
81'30'49 W
309.66
77
S
00'26'31"W
28.83
37
N
'82'17'46"W
403.95
78
N
6T00'46"W
285.50
1- D.B. 439 PC.140
38
N
85'40'45"W
266.85
79
S
01'00'00"E
193.00
2- D.Q. 455 PG. 623
39
N
59'34'44"W
319.72
80
S
64'55'00"W
93.00
3- D.B.. 426 PG. 612
40
N
67'14'01"W
296.41
81
N
19"07'14"W
29.85
4- D.B. 1327 PG. 823
41
N
53'37'36"W
260.95
82
S
89'59' 14"W
380.00
5- D.Q. 982 PG. 463
83
N
71'52'29"E
84.51
6- D.B. 1095 PG. 754
7- RURAL LINE PERMITS TO CAROLINA TELEPHONE & TELEGRAPH
3 r t
i l
AND CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY.
x
- �r
(ALL OF THE ABOVE RECORDED IN JOHNSTON COUNTY. REGISTRY.)
Y = 686,000
X a 2,14J,000
NOW OR FORMERLY
WILLIAM A. WESTON, JR.
D.B. 669 PG. 253
Soil & Enviro
244 West N illbrook Road ■ Raleil
'his certifies that this copy of this
Jurisdiction of Section 404 of the C
undersigned on this date. Unless
regulations, this determination of '
a period not to exceed five years i
utir¢ing the 1987 Corps of Engine
(name)l
(title)
{date)

...... .. .. ...
% ------
- - ----- - ----------
.... .......
-------- --
..... . .......
- --- - ---- --
--------------
- - --------
- - - - --- - - - ­
... ....... ..
PL ----- -- .......
----------
--------------
.... ...... .
- ----------
-------------
-- ----- ---
<
... ......
NOW 0 R FORMERLY
J. 14':
HERPFRT A AVERY
----------- DB 0552, PG. 0616
44
f
N. C. GRID COORDINATES
Y = 692,4,39.0970
X = 2,146,188.4976
(NAD 27)
7
------------
- - --------- NOTE.
Li
-28
00)
..... .....
VALLEY DRIVE NOW OR FORMERLY
SUN VALLEY
39
... ... ... .
SECTION 2
. ... .......
84 P.B. 27 PG. 377
06'
94�
95
-- --------
8
97
r 0
.. .... .....
. .......
. .........
NOW OR FORMERLY
r ARE LIMITED
C)
D,B. 1313 PG. 0928
.. ......... ....
\%
cr_
C_� "CLAYTON"
N. C. G. S.
X 2, 1
Y 6B9,524.494
13 52,060.147
'kill NOW OR FORMERLY
(NA D 2 7)
LARRY DENNING
. ... .... .......... . ...... DB 1371, PG. 0707
...............
...... .........
�z7
200
100 0 200 400 600
20
--- -------- ----
24
�52 NOW OR FORMERLY
A
2
2 . . .....
RE. LIMITED
SCALE IN FEET
121 D. B. 1313, PG. 0928
M (D
----- - 60.
L
---- ---------
-----------------_ -- -
L
2
............ 4
02
9 3 -------
ov
04 �n
. .. ..... NOW OR FORMERLY
--- ------- - 01 07pl.-
WILLIAM W SMITH
OW R R ERLY
.... ... 104
1PREE­
D. B. 10 71 PG. 607
03
-NN E
........... ....
0 3 7,,/ ,0319
.. . ........... . . . ..... .......
55 /W
102
5
45�
N
4�1
/,33
7
2
-----------
9
r
NOW OR FOR
--------- ------ MERLY
2
(19)
------------ HORACE R
Cox
D.B.- 1236, PG. 0382
(17
LAKE PATRICK IT,
------- ---------
---------- -- --
- - - - - - - - - - ............
4"
. ....... ...
T6
OW OR FORMERLY
2.
.. . ....... ----------- ---
7
Cox
WOOD
....... 0 364
- ---------
2L
4.
12
Jot
-- ----------
5)
-------------- 2
------- ...
.............
P.B. 2B PG. 201
2
9 (13)
2.81
7
349
95 . . .. . ..
480.67
4P
94"
6',3 143
�4b
. 34
T2
41,1
4
NOW OR FORM'ERLY
LIA ACRES
14 AME
8
3
SECTION' 2
I
P. B. 27 PG. 53
2
92 338
4
"7 IT
1.3 T2 7
L
f i7 To Soil & Enwonmental Consultan's, Inc,
----------
2 4 West N1 ilibrook Road IN R,,i leigh, Noti 11 Ca rolina 276(0 91 1 z
5
- -------- - --------
----------
_'I�73
AA 32.�
ly depicts the boundary of the
rate
-Mis certifies that this copy Of this pLat accul
327
323-'
e Clean Water Act as determine by tho
jurisdiction of Section 404 of th
ur published
.. ..... ........
undersigned an this date. U
nless there is a change in the law or o
---------- - -
lations, this determination of Sect
!on 404 jurisdi
3 ction may be relied upon for
. . .......
regu. .. ...........
a Period not to exceed five years from th This determin
is date.
ation was made
133
.3
utilitJng the 1987 Corps of Engineers
.3 Wetlands Delineation Manua[."
ERLY nam
t i
a
tj
PHEA`�A
NT RUN E
LEG
411
310 (date)
. .. ........
26' P.B. 29 PG. 243 EXISTING IRON PIPE
COMPUTED POINT
24
SET IRON PIPE
3
CONC. M'ON.
io
. . . ......
........... ....
OVEY LA
3
RtiiFtRFN 'LIN NE 50' RIW Y � 686,000
X = 2,148,000 up,% am soft Qvft %mm wooft qav�, qwWp wom,-,� "OEM
NTER P RANCH
RO R LiN
REEK S SHOWN," -IS-...,
"A L
369 -Y- MADE 1'�/;�.194
E
'12 (21)
AW
D TANG
_L TA CHOR
BRG
ENT CHORD
RADIUS ARC
CURVF D I-
'46'47"W
NOW OR FORMERLY
750.19 3B4.93 S 26
WMANS 25*5 7'J5" 1670.00 756-65 8
'J2'OB" 600.00 8
89.30 O'l 7E
r" A R P. 2 9,,3B 44.77 N 3,3*0
JOHNSON ----- -- --
5 0_3 9 N 4
ED
0' 17'03" E
100. 6B 100.64
3 5*55'00" 975.00
.0-3 S 0,3'2 1 '4 4" W
D. B. 620 PG. 548
4 80'08'59" 25-00 34.97 32.19 21
L
NOW OR FORMFRLY
JAMES W. STEVENS
CHARLES L. STEVENS
D. B. 732 PG. 71
NOW OR FORMERLY
. e,
0
Z ji
04 W0 NO
JI
ea:*_
AP