20190044 Ver 2_Thoroughfare Swamp Mitigation Bank Parcel- MY3 Report_20220920

ID#* 20190044 Version* 2
Select Reviewer:
Katie Merritt
Initial Review Completed Date 09/20/2022
Mitigation Project Submittal - 9/20/2022
Is this a Prospectus, Technical Proposal or a New Site?* O Yes O No
Type of Mitigation Project:*
Stream Wetlands Buffer Nutrient Offset
(Select all that apply)
Project Contact Information
Contact Name:* Email Address-*
Jason Lorch [e-mail]
Project Information
......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
ID#:* 20190044 Version:* 2
Existing ID# Existing Version
Project Type: DMS Mitigation Bank
Project Name: Thoroughfare Swamp Mitigation Site
County: Wayne
Document Information
Mitigation Document Type:*
Mitigation Monitoring Report
File Upload: Thoroughfare Swamp Mitigation Bank Parcel- MY3
16.8MB
Report.pdf
Please upload only one PDF of the complete file that needs to be submitted...
Signature
Print Name: * Jason Lorch
Signature:

ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
DWRID#20190044v2
WildlandsHoldingsIII,\[\[/͸ƭThoroughfareSwampMitigationBank
MonitoringYear3Report
September2022
PREPAREDBY:
WildlandsEngineering,Inc.
312WestMillbrookRoad,Suite225
Raleigh,NC27609
Phone:[phone]

MONITORINGYEAR3REPORT
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
WildlandsHoldingsIII,LLC
TABLEOFCONTENTS
1INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................2
1.1ProjectDescription.................................................................................................................2
1.2BankSponsor..........................................................................................................................2
1.3ProjectHistory........................................................................................................................2
1.4ProjectLocation......................................................................................................................3
1.5ProjectDesign.........................................................................................................................3
2VEGETATIONMONITORING.....................................................................................................4
2.1SuccessCriteria.......................................................................................................................4
2.2DescriptionofSpeciesandMonitoringProtocol...................................................................4
2.3ResultsofVegetationMonitoring..........................................................................................4
2.4ParcelAdaptiveManagement................................................................................................5
2.5Conclusions.............................................................................................................................5
3REFERENCES............................................................................................................................5
LISTOFTABLES
Table1ProjectReportingHistory
Table2TreeSpeciesSelectedforBufferRestoration
Table3Character/ExistingTreeSpecies
Table4MonitoringPlotSummaryΑPlanting(AsBuilt)
Table5MonitoringPlotSummaryΑYear3
APPENDICES
AppendixA:Figures
Figure1ProjectLocationMap
Figure2ServiceAreaMap
Figure3CreditGenerationMap
Figure4MonitoringComponentsMap
AppendixB:BankCreditLedger
AppendixC:VegetationAssessmentData
Table6VegetationPlotSuccessSummary
Table7StemCountTotalandPlantedSpeciesbyVegetationPlot
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults
AppendixE:OverviewPhotographs
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel Page1
MonitoringYear3Report

1.0Introduction
1.1ProjectDescription
TheThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel(Parcel)ispartofWildlandsHoldingsIII,LLC,(Sponsor)
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBank(Bank).TheprojectencompassestheheadwatersofThoroughfare
SwampwhichflowsintoFallingCreekandeventuallytheNeuseRiverapproximately20miles
downstreamfromtheParcel.TheParcellocationisdepictedinFigure1.ThepurposeoftheParcelisto
provideriparianbufferandnutrientoffsetmitigationcreditstocompensateforbufferimpactsaccording
totheConsolidatedBufferMitigationRule15ANCAC02B.0295(effectiveNovember1,2015)and
developmentrequiringnutrientoffsetpaymentsaccordingto15ANCAC02B.0703withintheNeuse
RiverBasinHydrologicUnitCode(HUC)03020201excludingtheFallsLakeWatershed.TheBankmay
alsoprovidenutrientoffsetcreditsforstormwaterrequirementswithnewandexistingdevelopment
requiringnutrientoffsetswithinthe03020201HUCoutsidetheFallsLakeWatershed.TheBankservice
areaisdepictedinFigure2.
Priortoconstruction,theParcelwasanagriculturalfieldusedforcropproduction,primarilycornand
soybeans.TheParcelwasrestoredtoprovideecologicalandwaterqualityenhancementstotheNeuse
RiverBasinbycreatingafunctionalripariancorridor.Approximately23.553acreshavebeenprotected
withapermanentconservationeasementalongThoroughfareSwamp(A2),oneunnamedtributary(B),
andoneephemeralchannel(A1).ProjectfeaturesontheParcelhadlittletonoexistingriparianbuffer
exceptforthreeseparate,individualrowsofmaturetrees.Aconservationeasementwasrecordedon
theParcelinJanuary2020.
1.2BankSponsor
TheThoroughfareSwampMitigationParcelisapartoftheBank.TheMitigationBankingInstrument
(MBI)fortheBankwassignedinNovember2019.
WildlandsHoldingsIII,LLC
1430SouthMintStreet,Suite104
Charlotte,NC28203
Phone:[phone]
Attn:ShawnWilkerson
Email:[e-mail]
1.3ProjectHistory
ProjecthistoryisprovidedinTable1.
Table1.ProjectReportingHistory
ActivityCompletionDate
WildlandsHoldingsIII,LLCMBINovember2019
BankParcelDevelopmentPackageApprovedNovember2019
ConservationEasementJanuary2020
BareRootPlantingFebruary2020
AsBuilt&BaselineMonitoringDocumentApril2020
Year1MonitoringCompletedOctober2020
Year2MonitoringCompletedSeptember2021
Year3MonitoringCompletedSeptember2022
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel Page2
MonitoringYear3Report

1.4ProjectLocation
TheParcelislocatedinsouthwestWayneCountyneartheborderofSampsonCountyandinvolved
bufferrestorationonThoroughfareSwamp(A2),oneunnamedtributary(B)andoneephemeralchannel
(A1)inaccordancewiththeConsolidatedBufferMitigationRules(15ANCAC02B.0295).Theprojectis
locatedwithin
HUC03020201170030andNorthCarolinaDivisionofWaterResources(NCDWR)
Subbasin030412andwasrestoredforriparianbuffermitigationcreditandnutrientoffsetcreditinthe
NeuseRiverBasinHUC03020201(excludingFallsLake).
FromRaleightakeI40E.Continuefor42.7miles,thentakeexit341tomergeontoNC50S/NC55E
towardsNewtonGrove.FollowNC50Sfor1.3miles,atthetrafficcircletakethethirdexitontoNC50
S/NC55E/Mt.Olive,andcontinuethisroutefor6.7miles.TurnleftontoDobbersvilleRoad,theproject
islocated0.4milesdowntheroadontheleft(35°ЊЍ͸В͵АЉ͸͸N,78°ЊЎ͸Ѝ͵ЍЍ͸͸W).
1.5ProjectDesign
Approximately23.553acresareprotectedinaconservationeasement.TheParcelwillgenerate13.046
acresofNeuseriparianbuffercredits.Additionally,theParcelwillgenerate7.725acresofnutrient
offsetcredits,whichcreates17,559.07poundsofnitrogencredits.Parcelcreditgenerationisshownin
Figure3.TherevegetationplanfortheParcelincludedplantingofbareroottreesandcontrolling
invasivespeciesgrowth.BareroottreesselectedfortheParcelwerenativebottomlandhardwood
speciestypicalforCoastalPlaincommunitiesasdefinedbySchafale(2012).Adjacentforestedareas
werealsousedasareferencefortheParcel.TreespeciesselectedforplantingontheParcelaswellas
sizespecifications,plantingdensity,andplantcompositionaredetailedinTable2.
Table2.TreeSpeciesSelectedforBufferRestoration
SizePlantingDensity
ScientificNameCommonNamePlantingComposition
(feet)(Stems/Acre)
Liriodendrontulipifera TulipPoplar23 30 5%
Quercusphellos WillowOak23 92 15%
Platanusoccidentalis Sycamore23 152 25%
Betulanigra RiverBirch23 152 25%
Quercusmichauxii SwampChestnutOak23 121 20%
Fraxinuspennsylvanica GreenAsh23 30 5%
NyssaSylvatica BlackGum23 30 5%
Totals607100%
NaturalrecruitmentofdesirableCharacterTreespeciesshallbecountedtowardsthesurvivaland
successrateoftherestoredsite.ͻ/ŷğƩğĭƷĻƩƩĻĻƭͼaredefinedasplantedorvolunteerspecies
identifiedfromasurveyoflocalvegetationonlessdegradedsectionsofthespecifiedstreamandfrom
referenceliteraturethatdetailsnativespecies.AlistofCharacterTreespecies(otherthantheplanted
species)isincludedinTable3.
Table3.Character/ExistingTreeSpecies
ScientificNameCommonNameWetlandIndicatorStatus
Acerrubrum RedMapleFAC
Liquidambarstyraciflua SweetgumFAC+
Liriodendrontulipifera TulipPoplarFACU
Quercusfalcata SouthernRedOakFACU
Juniperusvirginiana EasternRedCedarFAC
Notes:*Source:Schafale&Weakley(1990)
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel Page3
MonitoringYear3Report

2.0VegetationMonitoring
2.1SuccessCriteria
BuffervegetativesuccesscriteriaarebaseduponthedensityandgrowthofspeciesasdefinedinTables
2&3.VegetativesuccesscriteriaarebaseduponguidelinessetforthintheConsolidatedBuffer
MitigationRule15ANCAC02B.0295(effectiveNovember1,2015)andisdefinedasasuccessrate
equivalentto260livestemsperacreattheendofthe5yearmonitoringperiod.
Ifvegetativesuccesscriteriaarenotachievedbasedonacreagedensitycalculationsfromcombined
monitoringplotsovertheentirerestorationarea,orifaninspectionofabufferrestorationsiteindicates
thatportionsoftheParceldonothavesufficientstemdensitiesorareotherwisedeficient,
supplementalplantingshallbeperformedwithtreespeciesapprovedbyNCDWR.Supplemental
plantingshallbeperformedasneededuntilvegetativesuccesscriteriaaremet.Noquantitative
measurementsofherbaceousassemblageswillberequiredtomeetthevegetativesuccesscriteria.
2.2DescriptionofSpeciesandMonitoringProtocol
ThequantityofmonitoringplotswasdeterminedinaccordancewiththeCarolinaVegetativeSampling
(CVS)Protocols(LevelsII)suchthatatleast2percentoftheParcelisencompassedinmonitoringplots.
Atotalof17plots(10metersby10meters)wereestablishedwithinthecreditgenerationarea.PVC
pipewasusedtomarkthefourcornersoftheplots.MonitoringplotlocationsareshowninFigure4.
GPSpointsweretakenateachofthecorners.Areferencephotowastakenfromthesouthwestcorner
ofeachplot(AppendixD).Allplantedstemswithintheplotsweremarkedwithflaggingtapeand
recorded.Totalnumbersoftreespeciesplantedwithinthemonitoringplotsaswellasplantingdensity
andplantcompositionaredetailedinTable4.DetailedresultsoftheMonitoringYear3stemcountare
summarizedinAppendixC.
Table4.MonitoringPlotSummaryΑPlanting(AsBuilt)
TotalStemsCalculatedPlantingDensity
ScientificNamePlantingComposition
Flagged(Stems/Acre)
Liriodendrontulipifera12 30 5%
Quercusphellos36 85 14%
Platanusoccidentalis64 152 25%
Betulanigra65 158 26%
Quercusmichauxii52 121 20%
Fraxinuspennsylvanica10 24 4%
NyssaSylvatica16 37 6%
Totals 255607100%
2.3ResultsofVegetationMonitoring
The17vegetationplotsweresampledinSeptember2022attheendofthethirdgrowingseason.A
referencephotowastakenfromthesouthwestcornerofeachplot,whichcanbefoundinAppendixD
alongwiththestemcountrawdata.Totalnumbersoftreespeciesidentifiedwithinthemonitoringplots
aswellasdensityandcompositionaresummarizedinTable5.Vegetationresulttableswithplanted
stemdensity,andstemcountbyplotandspeciesaresummarizedinAppendixC.
The2022vegetationmonitoringresultedinanaverageplantedstemdensityof578stemsperacre,with
individualplotdensitiesrangingfrom445to607stemsperacre.Bothindividualandaverageplot
densitieswellexceedthefinalrequirementof260stemsperacre.Inventoryofvegetationplot5shows
thatthereare44loblollypine(Pinustaeda)stemswithintheplot.Manyofthesestemsareshorterin
height,withthemajorityfallingbetween50137centimeters.Plantedstemswithintheplotaretypically
taller,withanaverageheightof191centimeters.Thissuggeststhattheloblollypinestemsarenot
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel Page4
MonitoringYear3Report

outcompetingplantedstems.Additionally,eachofthe15originallyplantedstemsarealive.Theplotwill
continuetobeassessedtoensuretheloblollypinestemsdonotbegintonegativelyimpactplanted
stems,atwhichpointaselectiveremovalwilltakeplace.
Table5.MonitoringPlotSummaryΑYear3
TotalStemsCalculatedLiveStemDensity
ScientificNameLiveStemComposition
Flagged(Stems/Acre)
Liriodendrontulipifera8 19 3%
Quercusphellos33 78 14%
Platanusoccidentalis63 150 26%
Betulanigra65 155 27%
Quercusmichauxii50 119 21%
Fraxinuspennsylvanica11 26 4%
Nyssasylvatica13 31 5%
Totals 243578100%
2.4ParcelAdaptiveManagement
Adaptivemeasureswillbedeveloped,orappropriateremedialactionswillbeimplementedintheevent
theParcel,oraspecificcomponentoftheParcel,failstoachievethesuccesscriteriaoutlinedinthe
BPDP.Parcelmaintenancewillbeperformedtocorrectanyidentifiedproblemsthathaveahigh
likelihoodofaffectingprojectsuccess.Suchitemsincludebutarenotlimitedto;excesstreemortality
causedbyfire,flooding,drought,orinsects.Anyactionsimplementedwillbedesignedtoachievethe
successcriteriaandwillincludeaworkscheduleandupdatedmonitoringcriteria.
2.5Conclusions
OverallvegetationisdoingwellacrosstheParcel.All17vegetationplotsexceedthesuccesscriteriumof
260stemsperacre,withanaveragestemdensityof578stemsperacreandindividualplotsranging
from445to607stemsperacre.Additionally,herbaceousvegetationhasbecomewellestablished
acrosstheParcel.
3.0References
GuidelinesforRiparianBufferRestoration.NCDepartmentofEnvironmentandNaturalResources,
EcosystemEnhancementProgram.October2004.
Lee,MichaelT.,Peet,RobertK.,StevenD.,Wentworth,ThomasR.2006.CVSEEPProtocolforRecording
VegetationVersion4.0.Retrievedfrom
http://www.nceep.net/business/monitoring/veg/datasheets.htm.
Peet,R.K.,T.R.WentworthandP.S.White.1998.Aflexible,multipurposemethodforrecording
vegetationcompositionandstructure.Castanea63:262274.http://cvs.bio.unc.edu/methods.htm
Schafale,M.P.2012.GuidetotheNaturalCommunitiesofNorthCarolina,FourthApproximation.
Schafale,M.P.andWeakley,A.S.1990.AClassificationoftheNaturalCommunitiesofNorthCarolina,
ThirdApproximation.
WildlandsHoldingsIII,LLC(2019).ThoroughfareSwampNutrientandBufferBankingInstrument.
NCDWR,RaleighNC.http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/wq/nutrientbufferbanks
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel Page5
MonitoringYear3Report

APPENDIX A. Figures

APPENDIX B. Bank Credit Ledger

Gov't Requiring
NCDWRCity of RaleighCity of RaleighCity of RaleighJohnston CountyNCDWRTown of CaryCity of RaleighCity of GoldsboroCity of RaleighCity of RaleighCity of RaleighJohnston CountyNCDWRJohnston
CountyTown of CaryCity of RaleighTown of CaryCity of RaleighTown of CaryCity of RaleighCity of RaleighNCDWRCity of RaleighCity of RaleighCity of DurhamCity of DurhamTown of GarnerNCDWRCity
of RaleighTown of Smithfield
-

Acres

1.93
1.75 1.56 1.52 1.42 2.96 1.70 1.59 1.44 0.90
0.24 0.16 - 0.77 0.74 0.70 0.61 0.43 0.22
0.17 0.15 - 0.77 0.32 0.27 0.11 0.10 0.00
0.77 0.61 -
-
Nitrogen
Nutrient Credit Balance
Pounds of

4,389.43
3,982.58 3,545.78 3,460.08 3,219.58 6,731.12 3,870.70 3,608.14 3,272.35 2,055.35 555.35 355.75 0.00 1,756.52 1,688.72
1,587.72 1,391.72 988.72 500.32 376.32 332.87 0.00 1,755.91 717.29 624.63 247.09 228.21 0.00
1,755.91 1,392.81 -
5.79

Acres

0.18 0.19 0.04 0.11 1.26 0.12 0.15 0.54 0.66 0.09 0.16 0.03
0.04 0.09 0.18 0.21 0.05 0.02 0.15 0.46 0.04 0.17 0.01 0.10
0.16 0.61
From Bank

Nitrogen13,169.31
Credits Debited/Sold
Pounds of

406.85 436.80 85.70 240.50 2,860.42 262.56 335.79 1,217.00 1,500.00 199.60 355.75
67.80 101.00 196.00 403.00 488.40 124.00 43.45 332.87 1,038.62 92.66 377.54
18.88 228.21 363.10 1,392.81
5.79
Acres

1.93
1.54 0.77 0.77 0.77
Bank
13,169.31

Nitrogen
Pounds of
Credits Released/Available to

4,389.43
3,511.54 1,756.52 1,755.91 1,755.91
Project Name
(Outside of the Falls Basin)
Nitrogen Credit Ledger
DWR Project #: 2019-0044v2
Date Last Updated: 09-12-2022
Thoroughfare Swamp Bank Parcel
Neuse River Basin (HUC 03020201)
Arlington Heights THs (SPR-0103-2019, N-14-18)Cathedral Parrish Hall (Trans #594259)Andover Apartments Clubhouse Area Improvements (SPR-0011-2020)Circle K 42 Garner (JC# 19-142-P)Fenton
Phase 1 (20-DP-1205) PARTIALCarroll Middle School Modular Unit Renovations (N-0165-05, SPR-0010-2020)JBA Properties, LLC (Allen Grading Co., Inc. office site)Renaissance Park Apartments
(Trans #SPR-0065-2020)Wildcat Branch Subdivision (Trans #SPR-0253-2019) PARTIALVictory Church (Trans #SPR-0090-2020) PARTIALTractor Supply (20-013-P)Carthusiast (JC# 20-047-P)Homestead
Vet Clinic (19-DP-0175)Wykoff Subdivision (Trans #SPR-0182-2019)Genesis UMC Building AdditionFuller Elementary School (N-0004-20, SPR-0157-2020)Chase Bank - High House and Magness (20-DP-4896)Towne
Bank Drive Remote Drive Thru (N-0059-06, BLDNR-022015-2020)Animal Hospital & Office/Flex Buildings (N-0100-17, Trans. # 488762) PARTIALOak Forest PointeRaleigh Piedmont AptsThe Corners
at Brier Creek Townhomes - North D1900337The Corners at Brier Creek Townhomes - North D1900337 (assigned to Durham)Timber Drive TownhomesCamden Village District Apartments (N-0006-22)
(SPR-0008-2022) PARTIALProject XD / Amazon Fulfillment Center PARTIAL
Thoroughfare Swamp Neuse Buffer & Nutrient Offset Mitigation Banking Instrument
Purchaser or % Credit Release
Task 1: Conservation Easement Recorded & Financial AssuranceTask 7: Item B(1) of Section IX in the MBI completed and approved by NCDWRShenandoah Homes LLCThe Catholic Diocese of RaleighGontram
Architecture, Inc.Circle K Stores, Inc.Task 2: Mitigation Site Earthwork, Planting & Installation of Monitoring Devices Completed 20%USEF HCG Fenton Venture LLCWake County Public SchoolsAllen
Grading Company, Inc. Craig Davis PropertiesKB Home RaleighVictory Church InternationalPrimax Properties, LLCTask 3: Monitoring Financial Assurance posted and Approval of AsBuilt Report
10%Dr. Henry J. VanpalaIerne Enterprises, LLCM/I Homes of Raleigh, LLCGenesis United Methodist ChurchWake County Public School SystemBDG Architects LLPTowne BankJones Darton, LLCTask
4: Monitoring Report #1 Approved by the DWR & Financial Assurance Renewed 10%Oak Forest Pointe, LPRaleigh Piedmont Partners, LLCLennar CorporationLennar CorporationTimber Drive Associates,
LPTask 5: Monitoring Report #2 (10%)CUSA NC Holdings LPSamet Corporation
Sale/
Totals
4/3/20205/7/20206/5/20207/2/20209/1/20209/3/20209/4/20209/9/20202/3/20213/1/2022
1/20/20202/27/20203/23/20203/27/20204/23/20205/27/20207/20/20207/22/20208/19/20208/25/20208/26/20208/28/20209/16/20201/15/20212/11/20212/12/20212/12/20212/16/20212/15/20222/25/2022
12/10/2019
Release Date

Gov't Requiring
NCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWR
NCDWR

---

1.30
Acres

3.25
1.47 1.47 4.07 - 1.32 0.28 -
--
-

56,826.60

Square Feet

Buffer Credit Balance
141,780.50
64,155.50 63,870.50 177,294.90 - 57,341.40 56,826.60 12,391.92 -

1.321.30
9.78
Acres

1.78 0.01 4.07 1.02 0.28
From Bank
285.00
77,625.0057,341.4056,826.6044,434.6812,391.92

177,294.90
Credits Debited/Sold 426,199.50
Square Feet

1.301.30
9.78

Acres

3.25
2.60 1.32
Bank
Credits
57,341.4056,826.6056,826.60

113,424.40
141,780.50 426,199.50
Square Feet

Released/Available to
Project Name
Ridgemoor (DWR #19-1377)Gregory and Deborah Covington Property Garage (DWR #19-0941)IFB NO. 16-020320 PARTIALIFB NO. 16-020320 PARTIALIFB NO. 16-020320 PARTIALPNG Line 142 Pipeline (DWR
# 20210364) PARTIALOlde Town Master Plan Community (DWR # 20060447 v3) PARTIAL
(Outside of the Falls Basin)
DWR Project #: 2019-0044v2
Date Last Updated: 09-12-2022
Buffer Restoration Credit Ledger
Thoroughfare Swamp Bank Parcel
Neuse River Basin (HUC 03020201)
Thoroughfare Swamp Neuse Buffer & Nutrient Offset Mitigation Banking Instrument
Purchaser or % Credit Release
Task 1: Conservation Easement Recorded & Financial AssuranceTask 7:Item B(1) of Section IX in the MBI completed and approved by NCDWRLennar Corporation, LLC - Raleigh DivisionsMr. Gregory
CovingtonTask 2: Mitigation Site Earthwork, Planting & Installation of Monitoring Devices Completed 20%NC DEQTask 3: Monitoring Financial Assurance posted and Approval of AsBuilt Report
10%NC DEQTask 4: Monitoring Report #1 Approved by the DWR & Financial Assurance Renewed 10%NC DEQTask 5: Monitoring Report #2 (10%)Piedmont Natural Gas Company, Inc.Toll Brothers
Sale/
4/3/20203/8/2021
2/13/20202/17/2020
5/28/20208/19/20208/25/20201/15/20212/15/20227/19/20227/21/2022
12/10/2019
Release Date
Totals

Gov't Requiring
NCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWRNCDWR
-

0.00

Acres

0.00
0.01 - 0.00 - 0.00 -

75.50
Buffer Credit Balance
Square Feet

161.74
291.13 - 124.12 - 75.50 - 75.50
0.01

Acres
0.01 0.00 0.00

75.50
291.13124.12
490.75

From Bank
Square Feet

Credits Debited/Sold
0.000.000.00
0.01

Acres

0.00
0.00
Bank
Credits

75.5075.50
129.39124.12
161.74 566.25

Released/Available to
Square Feet

Project Name
IFB NO. 16-020320 PARTIALIFB NO. 16-020320 PARTIALIFB NO. 16-020320 PARTIAL
(Outside of the Falls Basin)
DWR Project #: 2019-0044v2
Date Last Updated: 09-12-2022
Buffer Preservation Credit Ledger
Thoroughfare Swamp Bank Parcel
Neuse River Basin (HUC 03020201)
Purchaser or % Credit Release
Thoroughfare Swamp Neuse Buffer & Nutrient Offset Mitigation Banking Instrument (MBI)
Task 1: Conservation Easement Recorded & Financial AssuranceTask 7: Item B(1) of Section IX in the MBI completed and approved by NCDWRTask 2: Mitigation Site Earthwork, Planting & Installation
of Monitoring Devices Completed 20%NC DEQTask 3: Monitoring Financial Assurance posted and Approval of AsBuilt Report 10%NC DEQTask 4: Monitoring Report #1 Approved by the DWR & Financial
Assurance Renewed 10%NC DEQTask 5: Monitoring Report #2 (10%)
Sale/
4/3/20203/8/2021
5/28/20208/19/20208/25/20201/15/20212/15/2022
12/10/2019
Release Date
Totals

APPENDIX C. Vegetation Assessment Data

APPENDIX D. Vegetation Monitoring PlotPhotos and Data Results

VegPlot1Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
1 Betulanigra 0.40.6245
2 Platanusoccidentalis 2.40.5125
3 Quercusphellos 4.50.569
4 Betulanigra 9.90.5305
5 Betulanigra 9.30.5360
6 Platanusoccidentalis 9.45.1115
7 Betulanigra 7.25.170
8 Platanusoccidentalis 4.85.0280
9 Quercusmichauxii 2.75.1121
10 Quercusphellos 0.45.163
11 Betulanigra 0.59.7430
12 Platanusoccidentalis 2.49.6179
13 Nyssasylvatica 4.79.760
14 Betulanigra 7.29.8305
15 Quercusmichauxii 9.79.6194
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot2Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
16 Quercusphellos 0.80.6111
17 Betulanigra 2.40.5221
18 Quercusmichauxii 4.50.5138
19 Platanusoccidentalis 9.90.5269
20 Betulanigra 9.30.5205
21 Nyssasylvatica 9.45.130
22 Quercusmichauxii 7.25.1134
23 Betulanigra 4.85.0129
24 Platanusoccidentalis 2.75.1179
25 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 0.45.167
26 Betulanigra 0.59.7240
27 Platanusoccidentalis 2.49.6205
28 Betulanigra 4.79.754
29 Betulanigra 7.29.8280
30 Platanusoccidentalis 9.79.6196
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot3Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
31 Betulanigra 0.80.2231
32 Nyssasylvatica 0.42.861
33 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 0.55.381
34 Quercusphellos 0.57.3265
35 Nyssasylvatica 0.99.4105
36 Betulanigra 5.99.6260
37 Platanusoccidentalis 5.87.3273
38 Platanusoccidentalis 5.45.2280
39 Quercusmichauxii 5.12.9126
40 Quercusphellos 5.10.5210
41 Quercusmichauxii 9.50.5207
42 Platanusoccidentalis 9.42.7195
43 Betulanigra 9.64.8182
44 Quercusmichauxii 9.87.0190
45 Fraxinuspennsylvannica 9.99.7172
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot4Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
47 Liriodendrontulipifera 0.50.333
48 Quercusphellos 2.90.4155
49 Quercusphellos 5.00.4Dead
50 Platanusoccidentalis 7.20.5203
51 Nyssasylvatica 9.50.657
52 Betulanigra 9.54.895
53 Quercusphellos 7.34.7102
54 Platanusoccidentalis 4.84.7227
55 Betulanigra 2.74.6258
56 Betulanigra 0.24.5218
57 Betulanigra 0.29.482
58 Platanusoccidentalis 3.19.6115
59 Quercusmichauxii 4.89.697
60 Betulanigra 7.19.6207
61 Platanusoccidentalis 9.49.8152
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot5Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
62 Betulanigra 0.60.2235
63 Quercusmichauxii 3.00.3129
64 Platanusoccidentalis 5.60.5210
65 Betulanigra 7.10.6169
66 Nyssasylvatica 1.10.956
67 Platanusoccidentalis 9.55.1264
68 Betulanigra 7.34.9341
69 Liriodendrontulipifera 5.14.836
70 Platanusoccidentalis 2.94.9320
71 Quercusmichauxii 0.45.0127
72 Quercusmichauxii 0.69.6147
73 Betulanigra 3.09.6170
74 Platanusoccidentalis 4.89.6350
75 Quercusphellos 7.39.787
76 Betulanigra 9.59.6219
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot6Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
77 Liriodendrontulipifera 0.60.8121
78 Betulanigra 1.02.7360
79 Platanusoccidentalis 1.05.0290
80 Betulanigra 1.07.4253
81 Quercusphellos 1.19.5147
82 Betulanigra 5.49.3305
83 Liriodendrontulipifera 3.96.945
84 Platanusoccidentalis 5.54.7177
85 Quercusmichauxii 5.62.5284
86 Platanusoccidentalis 5.60.2123
87 Betulanigra 9.90.2310
88 Platanusoccidentalis 9.92.3167
89 Quercusmichauxii 9.94.661
90 Platanusoccidentalis 9.86.8270
91 Nyssasylvatica 9.79.1150
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot7Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
93 Platanusoccidentalis 0.20.688
94 Nyssasylvatica 0.22.8Dead
95 Quercusphellos 0.35.0267
96 Betulanigra 0.37.6149
97 Quercusmichauxii 0.59.8Dead
98 Platanusoccidentalis 4.99.6193
99 Quercusmichauxii 5.07.2187
100 Platanusoccidentalis 5.04.8207
101 Betulanigra 4.92.7236
102 Liriodendrontulipifera 4.90.5Dead
103 Quercusmichauxii 9.40.5111
104 Quercusphellos 9.42.4Dead
105 Betulanigra 9.54.5243
106 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 9.67.0162
107 Nyssasylvatica 9.59.424
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot8Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
108 Quercusmichauxii 0.50.2149
109 Betulanigra 0.62.3400
110 Liriodendrontulipifera 0.64.7Missing
111 Quercusmichauxii 0.57.1162
112 Betulanigra 0.59.4280
113 Platanusoccidentalis 5.29.4365
114 Betulanigra 5.27.1190
115 Quercusmichauxii 5.24.871
116 Platanusoccidentalis 5.22.7300
117 Betulanigra 5.00.594
118 Quercusmichauxii 9.70.7143
119 Quercusmichauxii 9.72.873
120 Betulanigra 9.84.9152
121 Platanusoccidentalis 9.67.2410
122 Nyssasylvatica 9.69.6Dead
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot9Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
124 Quercusphellos 0.40.5197
125 Platanusoccidentalis 0.62.9113
126 Platanusoccidentalis 0.74.9305
127 Quercusmichauxii 0.87.3184
12 Quercusmichauxii 1.09.584
129 Betulanigra 5.69.3345
130 Quercusphellos 5.57.3196
131 Quercusmichauxii 5.54.8Dead
132 Betulanigra 5.32.751
133 Platanusoccidentalis 5.30.4265
134 Quercusmichauxii 9.50.3142
135 Quercusmichauxii 9.62.9155
136 Betulanigra 9.74.8280
137 Quercusphellos 9.87.0102
138 Nyssasylvatica 9.99.421
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot10Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
139 Betulanigra 0.20.890
140 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 2.40.891
141 Betulanigra 4.90.5310
142 Quercusmichauxii 7.00.48
143 Platanusoccidentalis 9.50.3203
144 Betulanigra 9.94.4173
145 Liriodendrontulipifera 7.34.861
146 Platanusoccidentalis 5.24.9159
147 Quercusphellos 3.05.1168
148 Quercusphellos 0.65.370
149 Nyssasylvatica 0.99.838
150 Betulanigra 3.39.558
151 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 5.59.3132
152 Platanusoccidentalis 7.79.1149
153 Quercusphellos 9.98.9134
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot11Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
154 Betulanigra 0.80.4360
155 Quercusmichauxii 0.62.6205
156 Quercusphellos 0.55.2114
157 Platanusoccidentalis 0.37.5280
158 Quercusphellos 0.39.9157
159 Nyssasylvatica 5.19.558
160 Liriodendrontulipifera 5.27.3Missing
161 Platanusoccidentalis 5.35.2171
163 Quercusmichauxii 5.32.9215
164 Platanusoccidentalis 5.20.7360
165 Quercusphellos 9.60.8161
166 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 9.83.088
167 Betulanigra 9.85.4187
168 Quercusmichauxii 9.77.7114
169 Platanusoccidentalis 9.69.8200
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot12Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
171 Betulanigra 0.30.8280
172 Platanusoccidentalis 2.80.8330
173 Betulanigra 5.30.7270
174 Platanusoccidentalis 7.60.7195
175 Quercusphellos 9.40.5260
176 Platanusoccidentalis 9.75.1300
177 Betulanigra 7.35.1280
178 Quercusmichauxii 5.05.281
179 Platanusoccidentalis 2.85.397
180 Quercusphellos 0.45.3260
181 Platanusoccidentalis 0.59.7170
182 Betulanigra 2.89.7250
183 Quercusmichauxii 4.99.7143
184 Platanusoccidentalis 7.29.6350
185 Quercusmichauxii 9.59.562
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot13Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
186 Quercusphellos 0.20.6230
187 Betulanigra 2.50.599
188 Betulanigra 5.00.3250
189 Quercusmichauxii 7.30.2190
190 Platanusoccidentalis 9.70.2128
191 Platanusoccidentalis 9.84.9170
192 Betulanigra 7.45.1375
193 Quercusmichauxii 5.25.137
194 Quercusmichauxii 3.05.0210
195 Platanusoccidentalis 0.84.9290
196 Betulanigra 0.69.4300
197 Quercusmichauxii 3.09.3220
198 Platanusoccidentalis 5.09.3160
199 Platanusoccidentalis 7.29.2360
200 Quercusmichauxii 9.79.7117
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot14Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
201 Quercusphellos 0.30.6213
202 Platanusoccidentalis 0.32.8330
203 Liriodendrontulipifera 0.35.2190
204 Betulanigra 0.47.5370
205 Platanusoccidentalis 0.39.7460
206 Quercusphellos 4.89.6295
207 Betulanigra 4.87.3550
208 Quercusphellos 4.85.2135
209 Quercusmichauxii 4.83.099
210 Betulanigra 4.80.8375
211 Platanusoccidentalis 9.50.4285
212 Quercusmichauxii 9.52.5220
213 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 9.44.88110
214 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 9.47.271
215 Quercusphellos 9.49.9164
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot15Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
216 Quercusmichauxii 0.20.5125
217 Platanusoccidentalis 2.70.6146
218 Quercusmichauxii 5.20.688
219 Nyssasylvatica 7.50.5Dead
220 Betulanigra 9.70.5250
221 Betulanigra 9.55.1122
222 Liriodendrontulipifera 7.35.159
223 Quercusmichauxii 5.05.121
224 Quercusmichauxii 2.55.178
225 Platanusoccidentalis 0.15.1215
226 Quercusmichauxii 0.19.638
227 Betulanigra 2.09.7260
228 Quercusmichauxii 4.79.858
229 Quercusphellos 7.09.7148
230 Nyssasylvatica 9.69.892
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot16Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
231 Quercusmichauxii 0.30.9157
232 Quercusphellos 2.80.8258
233 Liriodendrontulipifera 5.20.7130
234 Betulanigra 7.20.6290
235 Platanusoccidentalis 9.20.5280
236 Betulanigra 9.35.1450
237 Platanusoccidentalis 7.25.2375
238 Nyssasylvatica 5.15.358
239 Quercusphellos 2.85.5Missing
240 Platanusoccidentalis 0.55.6330
241 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 0.49.9258
242 Platanusoccidentalis 2.99.8500
243 Quercusmichauxii 5.39.6276
244 Betulanigra 7.39.5305
245 Quercusphellos 9.49.4205
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

VegPlot17Year3
TreeIDSpeciesX(m)Y(m)Height(cm)
246 Quercusphellos 0.50.887
247 Betulanigra 2.80.7550
248 Platanusoccidentalis 4.90.6280
249 Quercusmichauxii 7.50.5148
250 Betulanigra 9.50.4320
251 Quercusmichauxii 9.64.8270
252 Fraxinuspennsylvanica 7.64.9104
253 Quercusmichauxii 5.15.0240
254 Betulanigra 2.95.1550
255 Platanusoccidentalis 0.55.1331
256 Quercusphellos 0.79.8235
257 Quercusphellos 3.19.7123
258 Liriodendrontulipifera 5.29.6Missing
260 Platanusoccidentalis 7.89.5275
261 Quercusphellos 9.99.777
ThoroughfareSwampMitigationBankParcel
AppendixD:VegetationMonitoringPlotPhotosandDataResults

APPENDIX E. Overview Photographs