Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
NC0000396_Renewal Application_20100611
Progress Energy NPDES permit renewal request Asheville Steam Electric Plant Permit Number: NC0000396 Buncombe County June 11, 2010 &*,, Pro ress 9 Energy Hand Delivered File Point: 12520 -13-01 Tom Belnick, Supervisor Complex NPDES Permitting Unit North Carolina Division of Water Quality 1617 Mail Service Center Raleigh, NC 27699 -1617 June 11, 2010 Subject: Carolina Power & Light Company dba Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant NPDES Permit No. NC0000396 Buncombe County Renewal Application Dear Mr. Belnick: The current NPDES permit for the Asheville Steam Electric Plant expires on December 31, 2010. Progress Energy hereby requests that the NPDES permit for the facility be reissued. Enclosed are EPA Application Form 1 — General Information, EPA Application Form 2C — Wastewater Discharge Information and EPA Application Form 2F — Stormwater Discharges Associated with Industrial Activity, all in triplicate. As we have previously discussed with DWQ staff, in order to facilitate enhancements to the existing dam of our 1964 ash pond, Progress Energy proposes to relocate outfall 001 to a point approximately 3000 feet downstream of its current location. This relocation will be necessary to allow for additional stabilization work to be undertaken on the existing 1964 ash pond dam. The proposed relocation is to a point where access under Interstate 26 already exists. Coordinates for the proposed discharge point are North 35.47367 and West - 82.504. Enclosed with this renewal application is information pertaining to the 7Q10 and IQ 10 flows provided to us by staff of the USGS for this location. With reissuance of the NPDES permit, Progress Energy requests the following language regarding usage of biocides and the completion of the Biocide Form 101 be added to the permit: The permittee shall not use any biocides except those approved in conjunction with the permit application. The permittee shall notify the Director in writing not later than ninety (90) days prior to instituting use of any additional biocide used in cooling systems which may be toxic to aquatic life other than those previously reported to the Division of Water Quality. Such notification shall include completion of Biocide/Chemical Treatment Worksheet —Form 101. Division of Water Quality approval is not necessary for the introduction of new biocides into outfalls that are tested for whole effluent toxicity. Completion of the Biocide Worksheet is thus, not necessary for those outfalls with toxicity testing requirement. In addition, Progress Energy also requests the following reductions in monitoring requirements based on analysis of sampling results during the term of the current permit: Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Plant 200 CPU Drive 1 Arden, NC 28704 Outfall 005 Remove sampling requirements for Beryllium, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Lead, Manganese, Nickel, Silver, Thallium, Zinc and Fluoride Outfall 001 Remove monitoring requirements for Beryllium, Cadmium, Chromium, Coopper,,Lead, Manganese, Silver, Thallium, Zinc, Fluoride, Total Nitrogen and To a1 pho_� Reduce required monitoring for Mercury to twice per month -ou Condition A.(7) of the,current NPDES permit for the Asheville Steam Electric Plant requires that Progress Energy request a continuation of its 316(a) variance beyond the term of the present,permit Enclosed is an EPA guidance letter dated August 11, 1988 outlining the general procedure to be followed in requesting the continuance of a316(a) variance The following, is Progress Energy's response to the pertinentYfactors contained in the EPA general procedure for the reissuance of the 316(a) variance. 1 The permittee must request the variance be continued Response Progress Energy hereby requests continuation of the 316(a) variance reflected in its present NPDES permitfor the Asheville Steam Electric Plant 2. Plant operating conditions and load factors are unchanged and are expected to remain so for the term of the reissued permit Response The plant operating conditions and load factors are unchanged and are expected to remain so for the term of the reissued permit 3 There are no changes to the permittee's knowledge to the plant discharges or other discharges in the plant area which could interact with thermal discharges Response During periods of drought, as makeup water is pumped from the French Broad River to Lake Julian to sustain, operating cooling water levels, Progress Energy staff suspect there may be some influence m Lake Julian from our upstream discharge point in the French Broad River This permit application includes a proposal to relocate the discharge point from the facility's ash pond (outfall 001) to facilitate enhancements to the facility's 1964 ash pond dam. This outfall relocation should also eliminate any potential influence in Lake Julian from our discharge in the French Broad River 4. There are no changes to the permittee's knowledge to the biotic community of the receiving water body which could impact the previous 316(a) determinations Response- As demonstrated by Progress Energy's environmental monitoring, since issuance of the current NPDES permit there have been no changes to the biotic community of Lake Julian which would impact the previous 316(a) determinations If you have•any questions regarding the enclosed information, please contact Shannon Langley at (919) 54'6 -2439 I cent, under penalty of law, that this document and all attachments were prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance with a system designed to assure that qual f ed personnel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted Based on my inquiry of the person or persons who manage the system, or those persons directly responsible for gathering the information, the information submitted is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete I am aware that there pare significant penalties for submitting false information, including the, possibility of fines and imprisonment for knowing violations Sincerely, - M, ��� Garry A Whisnant Asheville P1ant,Manager Enclosures CC. Laurie Moorhead (Asheville Plant) Crystal Diedrich (Asheville Plant) Shannon Langley (PEB 4) * August 11, 1988 R17: 4M-FP UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGION IV 343 COURTLANO XTR99T 7 ATLANTA, GCOROIX 30349 Mr. Clyde Baldwin 'Division of'Water KY* Natural Resources Prvtectlon Cabinet port Boone Plaza i8 'Aeilly Road Frankfort, KY 40601 & Environmental RE: 346 GL a for Permit Reissuance Dear t�lr. n: ,o, Questions have arisen as to what pures and activities are necessary in reissuing a permit for a facility which has thermal limitations based on a previous variance granted under Section 316(x) of the Clean meter Act. The following, is provided as 'a, follow�up to information provided at the February 1988, EPA/State meeting in Aestin, Florida. J A thermal variance granted under 5316(a) terminates on, expiration of the NPDES permit of which it is a, part (Attachment A). Procedures for a reissuance are virtually unchanged from an initial determination. The amount of data necessary to support the variance at the time of reissuance will probably be minimal. Bkxmver, if conditions have changed materially, a significant quantity of informa- tion may be needed. NEE: Tb the extent that permittees are unaware of these, regUirements, they should be notified, of they expeditiously so that they can be prepared. The general procedure is as follows: I. The permittee must request that the variance be continued, preferably at the time of permit application. At that time, he should provide a basis for that continuance. The basis couldbe as simple ash (•a) plant operating conditions -and load factors are unchanged and are expected to remain so for the term of the reissued permit, (,b) there are no changes (to his knowledge) to plant discharges or other discharges in the plant site area which could interact with the thermal discharges, and (c) there are no. changes (-to his knowledge) to -the biotic community of the receiving water body which would impact the previous 316 determinations. 2. If the permitting authority agrees with the, basis, appropriate permit oondi- t -ions would be developed; otherwise, additional data would be requested as needed. Request for additional data must be made within 60 days of receipt of the application ,(Answier to Question 7, Attachment A) . Additional studies can be made a permit requirement if needed '(Answer to Question 7.1. Page 2 August 11, 1988 0 3. The Fact Sheet/Utionale should contain a summ' ary of 316 variance activities from the - previous permits (dates, deteLminations, limitations, etc.) and indication of the proposed basis for continuing the 316 variance. an language is included in, Attachment B. Sale 4. The Public notice ;requirements are contained in S124.75(a), is also ,included in Attachment B. ale language Should you have have questions or need assistance, -404/347 -3012. feel free to contact me at Sincerely yours, j U� charles ,s. Kaplan, P.E. National Expert Steam Electric/Water Enclosures 1„ - , cc: Mr. R. Bruce Scott Identical letters sent to all states in Region IV PI—P nrint nr tvnA in the ii—hnirlpri areas nniv Form Approved OMB No 2040-0086 FORM' US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY IJEPA I D NUMBER GENERAL,INFORMkTION EPA S TIA C Consolidated f5ermiis Program F GENERAL (Read the "General Init-rucurins before starting) 2 LABEL,ITEMS q. % GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS i if if a preprinted label has been providea, affix it in the a, �R space R iview the information carefully if any ofoii rough it and enter the correct data in'the is incorrect, cross through F. appropriate fill-in,area below Also, if any of the,preptinted data is absent (the area to the left of the label space lists the PI FA "A information that should appear), please proAde it in the proper PLEAbE2PI1A fill-in area(s) below If th6,label is Complete and correct, you need not co m pletedierns I'll(, V, and'VI (ex'Oept.1/1-81 which UWE, must be completed regardless) Complete all items if no label 'U1W has been provaed Refer to the instructions for detailed item N UMbLKE TYNAME (III `FACIU, _�g 'Or�, U" descriptions and for the legal authorizations underwhich this Y,ILOCA data is collected, 11 POLLUTANT CHARACTERISTICS INSTRUCTIONS Complete A through J'to determine whether you needto submit any permit application forms to the EPA If you answer "yes" to any questions, you must submit,this form,and the supplemental form listed in the parenthesis foil-owing the question Mark W in the box in the third column If the supplemental form is attached If you answer "go" to each question, you need,not submit any',,of these forms You may, answer 'no"'if your activity is excluded from permit requirements, see Section C of the instructions See also, Section D ofthe instructions for definitions of bold-faced terms Mark *X* Mark'X SPECIFIC QUESTIONS YES NO FORM ATTACHED SPECIFIC QUESTIONS YES NO FORM ATTACHED A Is this facility a publicly owneid,treatment works which results in a discharge,to wateis•of the U S 9 (FORM 2A) X B Does or will this facility (either existing or proposed), include 'a concentrated animal feeding operation or X aquatic animal production facility which results in P Is 17 Is — 19 20 21 discharge to waters of the U S.? (FORM 213) - C Is this a facility which currently results in `discharges to X X D Is this a proposed facility (other than those.descnbed in,A *result X waters of the U S other than,thos&descnbed in A or B or B,above) which ittill in a,discharge to.watersW above. (FORM iC) X2 23 24 the U S 9 (FORM 2D) _25 t 2e 21 E Does or will this (facility treat, store, or of F Do you or will you inject at this facility lirdustrial or - -dispose hazardous wastes?'(FORM 3) X municipal effluent below the lowermost stratum X containing, within one quarter mile of the well bore, 28 N 30 underground sources of drinking water? (FORM 4) 131 M 33 G rpo you or will you,qect,at,this facility any produced water H Do, you or will you inject at,this facility fluids for special or other fluids- which are 'brought' to the surface in- processes,such as mining of sulfur byithelFrasch process, connection with conventional oil or natural gas•production, X solution mining of minerals, in situ combustion of fossil inject fluids used for enhanced recovery of,oil or natural fuel, or recovery of geothermal energy? (FORM 4) gas, or inject fluids for storage of liquid hydrocarbons? (FORM 4) —34 35• 37 n 39 1 Is this facility a proposed stationary source which is one J Is this facility a proposed stationary source which is of the 28,industrial categories listed'in the instructions and X, NOT one of the 28 industrW Categories fisted in the X Which will potentially emit 100 tons per year of any air instructions and which will potentially erri tons per :pollutant regulated'6nder the Clean Air Act and may affect, year of any air pollutant regulated under the Clean Air Act 10' 41 42 43 or be located in an,attainment area? (FORM!5) and may affect or be located in an attainment area'? (FORM 5) III NAME'OF FACILITY TI SKIP' I Asheville -Steam Electric Plant IV FACILITY'CONTAC A, NAMEA TITLE (last,firsi: &title) B PHONE (area code& no) W 'I 2 Jc Whisnant, Garry A. Pl ant lManager 8�8 6 7L5 A -1 16 41 46 48 1,49 51 1 52 V FACILTY'MAILIN6,ADDRESS A STREET OR P 0 BOX 10" c I live I I I I I I I I I I I I I 61 2 0 CP&L,Dr J3 AeR 16 B CITY OWTOWN C STATE D ZIP COD c Arden C 2J7J4 4 40, 41 42 47 51 VI FACILITY LOCATION A STREET, ROUTE NO OR,OTHER SPECIFlb IDENTIFIER 3 QU c I I I I I I I I J 6 A& -rive SO CE! ,SO 2 01 " M p, 5 R`- , 45 B COUNTY NAME Buncombe . . . A P. 'V� 70 C -CITY OR TOWN D STATE E ZIP CODE F COUNTY CODE (i(known) V-� Lfl,Ardiln' 1401 J2' 7134 17 51 53 S4 EPA Form 3510-1 (8-90) CONTINUE ON REVERSE CONTINUED FROM THE FRONT VII SIC CODES (4-digit, to orderof non A FIRST B SECOND e '4911 (spec) Electric Power Services 7 (speck) 7 15 116 19 15 116 18 C THIRD D FOURTH e (specify) 7 (sPeC�) 7 5 18 1g 15 18 18 VIII `OPERATOR INFORMATION A NAME B Is the name fisted to Item t VIII -A also the owner? s Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a. Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc 0YESONO 15, 16 - - - 55 BB C STATUS OF OPERATOR (Enter the appropriate letter into the answer box j "Other, "specify) D PHONE (area code & no) F = FEDERAL M= PUBLIC (other than federal ar state) P (specify) ` A 8 2�8 687 5 2 01 S= STATE P = pP,RIVATE 0 = `OTHER (spec) _ 56, 15 16 18 jig z1 11 M E `STREET OR P O BOX - � "` �� r" `s� �:' ,_. , � � �•�y,st`' "�t� t a fit; v4'"vs i� �x. �r.•, ^3.,: -.. 's�'��.}, >•.tl": �u� "�SE ^`"d'. ks, y k "` k x '� . Y^Y' Cpl , x _ AID' C & Drive ' iMd 66 AiX Sf F CITY OR TOWN IG STATE I H ZIP CODE IX INDIAN LAND - Is the facility located on,lndian lands? JB A rden NC 28704 ❑ YES © NO 5z 1s 1B a +1 iz a s1 X EXISTING ENVIRONMENTAL PERMITS D PSD (Air Em+ss+ons romPra osedSources <`Syu�3tt,;f C T I.. "'E_f "4'$'Fr`"'}`i3° r` ]; "'{s•° eehlieS ;:u -1 u .' = s P A NPDES D+schar es toSuraceWate "r C s T N I NC0 0 0 0 3 9 6 , a, s B 'UIC Under round Fn ectron o Fluids -E OTHER` s ect C I i I I t T (SpeClity) WNCRAPCA Air Permit =' - a - 30 15 •18 1J 1B - 30 C' RCRA' Hazardous Waltes — E OTHER :sec+ ' C T I - s ec+ State non discharge permit for ash (P JJ) 9 R - g WQ0000020 reuse 15 1 10 17 18 _ _ ,30 15 1 16 1 17 118 _ 30 XI MAP , Attach to this application a topographic map of the area extending to attleast one'mde beyond property boundaries The'map must show�the outhne,of the facility, the location of each of its existing and proposed intake and discharge structures, each of its haiardoud waste treatment, storage, or disposal facilities, and each well where,it -injects fluids underground' Include all springs, rivers, and -other surface water bodies in-We map area See mstructions'for precise requirements- - - XII NATURE,OF BUSINESS provide a bnefdescn tion) Electric utility - This facility is an ,electric generating facility consisting of two ecoal sfired units with a total net capacity of 376 Megawatts and two Internal Combustion turbines with a total net capacity of 324 Megawatts XIII CERTIFICATION (see instructions) I certify under penalty of la'w that 1 have personally,examined and am famthar with the information submitted inithis application and all attachments and that, based on my inquiry of those persons immediately responsible for obtatntng,the information contained to the application, I believe that the information ts'true, accurate, and complete I ;am aware that there are significant penalties for submtthng,falde tnformahon, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment A NAME' &OFFICIAL TITLE (type or print) B SIGNATURE C',DATE,SIGNED Garry A. Whisnant Manager - Asheville Steam Plant o / � ( 04 COMMENTS FOR OFFICIAL OSE ONLY ; ���;s5ag{ BEY C. iAFi � xj e ' id t ✓ 55 R''1 °c -43"1x�G46'4 F�ME, �.k3R'i'x'u]i"t EPA Form 3510 -1 (8.90) EPA I D NUMBER (copyfrom Item 1 ofform 1) Form Approved OMB No 2040 -0086 Please print or tune in the unshaded areas oniv N Approval expires 3 -31 -98 FORM 2C NPDES U S, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY mod" EPA EXISTING MANUFACTURING " COMMERCIAL, MINING AND S LVICUL'TURE OPERATIONS Consolidated Permits Program I OUTFALL LOCATION For each outfali, list the latitude and longitude of,ds location to the nearest 15,seconds and the name of the receiving water A OUTFALL NUMBER (list) B LATITUDE C LONGITUDE D RECEIVINGWATER'(name) 1'DEG 2,MIN 3 SEC, 1 DEG 2 MIN 3,SEC 001 35 28 03 82 32 56 'French Broad River 002 35 28 10 82 32 20 Lake Julian II FLOWS, SOURCES OF POLLUTION, AND TREATMENT TECHNOLOGIES A Attach a line drawing showing the water flow through the facility Indicate sources of intake water, operations contributing wastewater to the effluent, and treatment units labeled to correspond to +the more detailed descriptions in Item B Construct a water balance on the line drawing,by showing average flows between intakes, operations, treatment units, and outfalls If a water balance cannot be determined (e g ;for certam'mmmg,activities); provide a pictorial description of themature and amount of any sources of water and any collection or treatment measures B For each outfall, provide a description of (1) All operations contnbuting wastewater to the effluent, incl6ding process wastewater, sanitary wastewater, cooling water, and storm water °runoff, (2) The average flow contributed by each operation, and (3) The treatment received by the wastewater Continue on additional sheets ff necessary 1 OUT- 2 'OPERATION(S) CONTRIBUTING FLOW 3 'TREATMENT FALL NO (list) a OPERATION (list) b AVERAGE FLOW (include units) a DESCRIPTION b LIST CODES FROM TABLE 2C -1 _ 001 'Ash sluiceu water - 'See attachmenC 2 for flows Sedimentation„ Neutralization - - 1 =U - 2 -K Coal Pile runoff See at wchmenc 2 for fhowe Sedimentation, Neutralization - 1 -U 2 -K _ FGD wastewater See attachment '2'for flows Flocculation, coagulation, wetland treatment 1 -G " - Low volume wastewater See attachment 2 for flows Sedimentation, Neutralization 1 -U 2 -K - -- WaPei treatment wastes - Boler blowdown - Plant drains - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - -, _ 'Ash hopper seal water Air,preheater cleaning wastes _ Chemical metal cleaning wastes Evaporation of neutralization and precipitation 1 -F 2 -K Plant stormwater ,See,attachment 2 for flows Sedimentation, Neutralization 1 -U 2 -K, - Comustion urk- 2-wastewateis - - b - T - See - attachment 2 for flows Sedimentation, Neutralization 1 -U - 2 -K 002 Once through cooling water See attachment 2 for flows 'Evaporation 1 -F' Circulating water Co heat exchangers See attachment 2 for flows Evaporation 1 -F OFFICIAL USE ONLY (ejfuentguidebnevsub- categorrer) EPA, Form, 3510 -2C (8 -90) PAGE 1iof4 CONTINUE ON REVERSE Cn NTINIJFn FROM THE FRONT C Except for storm runoff, leaks„ or spills,, are any ofthe discharges described in Items III' A or B intermittent or season a19 © YES (complete the following table) ❑ NO (go to Section 111) 3 FREQUENCY 4' FLOW 'a DAYS'PER B TOTALVOLUME 2 OPERATION(s) WEEK b MONTHS a FLOWRATE,(mmg.) (specitywnhumus)' 1 LONG TERM 2 MAXIMUM 1 LONGTERM 2 MAXIMUM 1 OUTFALL CONTRIBUTING FLOW (specify PER YEAR C DURATION NUMBER (hst) (hsi) avemge) (specifyavemge) AVERAGE DAILY AVERAGE DAILY fin day') 001 Water treatment, wastes /Filter Rarely 0,003 0.006 backwash - 2 /year 0 003 pear 0 005 Combustion Turbines unit Chemical metal cleaning waste 0 -90 „000 gallons produced every 5 -8 years Plans are to evap instead of discharge ,Air preheater cleaning 2 /yr /unit 0 01 0 01 Revers Osmosis reject stream (if installed for process water makeup) as needed` 0 015' 0075 ill ,PRODUCTION A Does an- effluent guideline limitation promulgated by EPA under Section 304 of the Clean Water Act apply to your facility? W] YES `(complete fhem'111 -8) ❑ NO'(go to Section IV) B Are the limitations In the applicable, effluent guideline expressed inderms of production (orothermeasure of operation)? ❑ YES (complete Item 111-0 W1 NO (go to Section 1V) C If you answered "yes” to Item III -B, list the quantity which, represents an,actual measurement of your level of production, expressed In the terms and units used In the applicable effluent guideline, and 'indicate, the affected outfalls _1- AVERAGE DAILY PRODUCTION 2,AFFECTED OUTFALLS (listoutfoll numberv) a QUANTITY PER DAY b UNITS OF MEASURE c OPERATION, PRODUCT, MATERIAL, ETC rspecify) IV IMPROVEMENTS A Are you now required by any Federal, State or local authonty to meet any implementation" schedule for the construction, upgrading or operations of wastewater treatment equipment or practices or any other environmental programs which may affect the discharges described In this application? This includes, but is not limited to, permit,00ndnions, administrative or enforcement orders, enforcement compliance schedule letters, stipulations, court;orders, and grant orloan conditions ❑ YES (complete thefollowing table) ® NO (go,to7iem'1V -B) 1 IDENTIFICATION OF CONDITION, 2 AFFECTED OUTFALLS 3 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT 4 FINAL COMPLIANCE DATE AGREEMENT, ETC a NO b SOURCE OF DISCHARGE a ,REQUIRED 6 PROJECTED B OPTIONAL You may attach additional sheets describing any additional water pollution control programs (or other environmental projects which may affect your discharges) you now have underway or which you plan Indicate whether each program Is now underway or planned, and indicate your actual or planned schedules for construction ® MARK "X" IF DESCRIPTION OF ADDITIONAL, CONTROL PROGRAMS IS+ATTACHED EPA Form 3510 -2C (8 -90) PAGE12 of 4 CONTINUE ON PAGE 3 - CONTINLIED'EROM PdGE,2 EPA I D NUMBER (copyjrom Item ! oJForm /) EPA Form 3510 -2C (8 -90) PAGE 3 of 4 CONTINUE ON REVERSE V INTAKE AND EFFLUENT CHARACTERISTICS A, B, 8 C See instructions before, proceeding — Complete one set of tables for each outfall — Annotate the outfall number in the space provided NOTE Tables VyA, V- B,,and V -Care Included on separate sheets numbered V -1 through V -9 D Use the space below to Ilst,any of the pollutants listed In'Table�2c -3 of the Iinstructions, whlch� you know'or have'reasom,to believe Is,dlscliarged or may be discharged from any outfall For every pollutant you list, briefly describe the reasons you believe It to be present and report'any analytical data In your possession 1 POLLUTANT 2 SOURCE 1 POLLUTANT 2 SOURCE Asbestos Used in insulation, trace amodnts may be washed down drains in plant areas during maintenance activities Strontium Trace elements occasionally, Uranium present in coal Vanadium Zirconium VI POTENTIAL DISCHARGES NOf COVERED_BY'ANALYSIS Is any 'pollutant, listed, in Item V -C a substance or a component of a substance which you currently use or manufacture as an Intermediate or final product or byproduct? YES'(hrr all such pollutamts'helow ) ❑ NO (go to item V! -B) The following substances may be present in coal Antimony Arsenic 'Beryllium Cadmium Chromium Copper Lead `Mercury Nickel Selenium ;Silver Thallium Zinc See attachement 4 for Potential Discharges Not covered by Analysis EPA Form 3510 -2C (8 -90) PAGE 3 of 4 CONTINUE ON REVERSE rr1NTINl 11zn FRr1M THr FRONT VII BIOLOGICAL TOXICITY TESTING'DATA Do you have any knowledge or reason to believe that any biological test for acute or chronic toxicity has been made on any of your discharges or on a receiving water In relation to your discharge within the last 3 years W`YES,(ident fy lhe,tevt(y) and describe their purposes below) ❑ NO (go to Section VIM Outfal'1 001 From 2006 through 2009, 12 chronic toxicity tests were performed on the ash pond discharge as required by the current NPDES permit. All of the -tests were recorded as "pass" and exhibited no toxicity at required testing concentrations VIII CONTRACT ANALYSIS;INFORMATION Were any of the analyses reported In Item V performed'by a contract laboratory or consulting firm? ® YES,(hrt the name, address, and telephone number of, and pollutants analyzed by - ❑ NO'(go to Section /X) each suchdaboratory orfirm below) C TELEPHONE D POLL'UTANTS,ANALYZED A NAME B ADDRESS (area code & no (list) Pace Analytical Labs 2225 Riverside Drive (828) 254 -7176 Metals, TOC, BOD, Asheville, NC ',28804 Nutrients, TSS, COD, Flouride, Oil and Grease, cyanide, phenols, volatiles Environmental Testing Solutions PO Box 7565 (82&)1 S50 -9364 Aquatic Toxicity Asheville, NC 28802 Applied Speciation and 18804 Northcreek Parkway (425) 483 -3300 Selenium_ Speciation Consulting, Bothell, WA 98011 IX CERTIFICATION 1 certify under penalty of, law that,this document and all attachments were, prepared `under my direction or supervision in, accordance with a systemi4esigned,to 'assure that qualified personnel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted' Based, on my inquiry of the person or persons who manage the system or those persons directly responsible for gathenng the information, the mformahomsubmitted is, to'the best of my knowledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete ham,6vare that there are significant penalties for submitting false information, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment for knowmgmolations A ,NAME & OFFICIAL TITLE (type or print) B rPHONE NO (area code & no) Garry A Whlsnant, Plant Manager (828) 687 -5201 C SIGNATURE ,D DATE SIGNED �& 0 /o ( O EPA Form 3510 -2C (8 -90) PAGE 4 of 4 W U) w LW w Ir z O W 0 z z Z O U O U N 0 V) o M W Q a w Ord S N O U) OJ do $ O� Z v �,� z Q aQ EE aQ c b w to U O Z N = j O Y c U ¢L u U Q LL F' Q C z W � N v 3 N C C W Y> W N v of .9 E QQ LLi BOO $ z zQ J O O T� ' � >I ~ p J a m,E O �� W K m> Q _F- w 7 p J U W W w W m .0>, ., z O J > J J > C m O N rt U > p> Q b a b v b b V rn m L A g v v v y vz t E= y �, a z ' o E - F O w a) Z Z Z U U - a w 4 Zz Up Q Q Z I y ��v v U- O� \ E tp ^ ZO +~ bl CJl E i71 E Ol E' bl E H m `p m a F- m gE `b ~ Ur 0 U- a m LL O w �t o 0 m c = LL �� m o � n OOS , V . v Z Q Z Q r1 Ln rn Ln T m v Q I i C N N W N v c Q a d m �� '(N a' m �i > m w W co N 4 < Q,` RC' U N ,7 N N 2 W - la O J \ z \ z \ z O N \ zi m d C =) Z M O O O t _ Q N O ._ W O Q �° M j .r m b -Z, U z a � � O �� Q N � O 01 H O? 8 -o Z O U O M w`� ¢ S 5t Z O F N m O m c 'Z p W \ z �, \ 2 \ Z' N m ° z z O �, a>, d Z W J m a o O a E v J O `o -> z U Z> J > J > a) n0 w Q� N £ `o d W `O. N 0 ° w z o a J =:: E w o9 "� b Q Q �i �i �i Qi �i O� N 0 Q O Q E N w > z z z z z � ' U v`Z Qr \ O i�-N z N lO m C N m O i i_ U z O Z U J m N N H VT N > V NOON 'O a U m cc Q c E N 'ot n. > �Z \ z \ 2 \ 2 \ Z \ Z m T �; w } E w w J w w $E c ¢ H O z J J Z _ 3— Z al 7 >• Y �+ Q z O a a c 7 O yE o m w n w 00 m Ln O°'n g O c J Q O' Da) G m m' O ¢ x O Q U) O U Q } N ri r- V O w N 11 r'1 N rn N Q w w o U) °— ¢ v rr-I - Q ° N° Q` �' z rI O c m p H w U d m m O z _��` W p p O V� l0 m IO.•N U Z F C UQ N Q� ^R' O O Ln VI lli w 00 7xi a w 0 4) Z) W 2' ��_(( -Z O N n O m = Q i 'W V (•1 d' l0 W > W > W > kO >, m X m % Q U Y Z O J J J z duo N Y m'¢ W v w m c O O N > W IWO LL c I hi Odle W z 0 O rn U 0 v c M IL O E, Q u y �Nm �� w } I E ro �`� En �� R m H Os m o w 5 z a of W fn Y Q Q O O_ d = C E C I O m� N v o E a) a` m �zz ° J Z N �n U m� U C-z f �, ° m r 10 oC'i ov E o aEi m'� �QQ b oN °v' ° 0. Q aw ? r Q m E 0 U E 0 �'O fv ,1-- O Q LL r r ~ c Q d U`- m° a U H ail U LL U-O <O Z h,' z J C g > a mo a,o v vt� a 3 o r y _ o m� a� L° a ow W U) w LW w Ir z O W 0 z z Z O U O U N 0 V) o M W Q a w O W 7 Z z Z O U m W f- M W Q a z O W D Z F- Z O U O O U N O N' M LL Q w w LL N OW N O)'; ZQ c Dz Q b M _ o W < W J v ~ H Z -U, W Z O CQ7 D K W �'Q `. Z W U Z O U � ro b ro b Q z z W C) 0 ri C E E A LL ti Ow U ZJ rMj V Q V Q W D M Q Q D C, N N ri V V Q O Z O ~ ~ CK O H Z ` Z Ln O U ZO V V V U W J N N -i z z U. } Q N W 'O M b Z 0 vW z ,z Z a o W o0 U N N V > V J_ Q Z O r O �w W O U V V m Z O U LU Z X aWUJ Y J mQ Q Ni pF N�W�� `�/ /`�/,`�/, /� /� /� XX XX / / \ XX / \ X XXXXX X /� \ XX \ \ X / \, ma / \ , " ` I \ / \ \ / \ / \ / \ / \ I \ I \ / \ , l 1 _ O N M 0 E Z Jz J Z U °i O 0 - m E 7 E UA C.: v m - y D m ° N Q Q O U90 Fz Q Z O o ' N o m UO d� 3 M v d � 'M n :C � v vo YE � - o .F -C ovC °�rC F-,d C o >cm M W Q a z O W D Z F- Z O U O O U N O N' M LL Q w w D O O o O O v C ti ,O tY w m 0O O 0) Z M o0 a c) w zr U m O LL O w Q a 2 O w LL 0 W D Z F- z O U N S L �' ' Ri O � z¢ L¢ O N 0 C; N N O y� y y'q O, O C `O C V) N O CO d« y �. GI O W ¢ O C N d N g 7 N _,r N N iC N Q W Z 0 - c m o E;w yEo z0 F- w O N> N l0 O u1 U Z O O F W E -L A N E O O L N J w W> ^F "Z `p o � r 1-06 ui z is 3 cr y ,� m Y O O d p U y N 70 E 3 > ro ro ro rd ro ro ro ro m ro` ro m ro ro ro wyo, a °^ Up ¢ b ro b ro ro b' b ro b b ro b ro O N �cda�Em (n ~ r-i rl 'ri rl rl rl rl rl rl rl rl rl rl wZ N 7 E�smo$m Z p m c N z O rl r r-4 rrrr -1 rl ri \ rl \ rl T 5 y F \ \ \ \ \ \ bl \ O) \ \ 01 \ \ Q) \ \ r > E E a E E E �E � E E E E E E E E E E c� 0 io F m - —aE LL U) O'LU - U'� +a�i io'Q 3`0 ri ,-� a r <r <r m � �r H" w v r 01 J N O Z,Q U) U) Q', Ln M O M O 0 Ln ri r- O r� l!) .--I 01 (V A+' FC O N L N U� p O Q N af z O O 2�, O O O O ,M z z s N a E .-1 O O O r-1 O C Y N N O -E L_ N y C JmyJ -� z O O N O d O ' N ,a F- `-' LU Q K M ri O rl O M O tf1 O d' N N r-I rl w W r-1 o p V U> O Q p O O Z 7 •-• \ O O O O O O 00 O \ \ a d Q LU z ° ' O O O °, O O O O O z z --g ao c Z p v jY E'�rrn O. N = - - O O 'O O $ z J co a 4 a. 4 � � FC < < � a RC $o'w«dOa >> z z % z z z z o z z z z z z 2 C N 7 O r J>- LL N O O° O w O d Z o y C j V C d Cl) O O p °, w �' FC FC RC FC FC FC FC FC FC FCC FC FC FC FC p73 O'N, O \ \ \ \ �z O \ \ \ \ \ z \ rz \ z .. z z z z z z z z z z N' "O E N cO Gl N C 7 U O Z O ,O m coo S z a LLJ O 01 M M W r N rl L7) M W M E- to 01 y a > N c 3�m m°' c E? J < N o o rl M r O t!1 M ri N to r N L O- N U v > v O M O v O v O O O v O n] O v O V O O v O v F- 3 3 w$ o J o M o �m E "a p w 0, o f o' 'o $« z r rJ H ri w m � � u) O w H m U �O y X aw ,d-, O `�_ � ^F- N co t0 O O O O W O N H O O l0 t!) ao rl 01 1, O O rl O O\' ri O O W CO y UQ v U W rl O O O O O O O O' O O O O O U J A L X 3¢ag�,oN Z V V O O V O O O V V O V V (n w V o 0 LU N —c o C O T d o" N N O. O= V w En > d .. n. W Q m C (O N m c O L E X J O a�— m O 3 O� m a wrm L. �w 2 \X/ \X/ \X, `X/ \X/ \X/ \X/ `X/ \X/ \X, \X, `X/ \X/ \X /, `X/ �oo�..oao -Y U W ,W, LL / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ /` / \ / \ / \/\ S T C- d Y l J 52 C_..6 Cy 2,0 J O c maX�[[=Qc N and ¢ F O y 1`LO.m C UrW F- C, O,XXXXXXX Z XXXXXXXX a. co d c L c m l0 L E .O 3� U mr0 F W Z ar ' ♦ I \ I \ I \ I \ / \ ♦ \ / \ I \ I \ I \ I \ / \ � ` / N N c oo m Z W O F ' O F- m O F- O, O 4 tD CL m c c d° c 'CN �v a y O zI r c o rN Ov CL m o Z) 0 b c E dd^ . r - EN ? d o 0 c� 0 ,o J¢ o F O N � d L a � rn rn o n N U : d Z a a U w � a M�v 2 0 O N O' v O M O LL i A 2 -T 2 m m r F- F- w N w w W, Z O W D z z Z O U O m o� U N O ,Lf) Cl) LL ra LL W F- 0 LL W S r 0 lr LL C] W Z Z 0 U w C7 Q a z O W z_ r Z O U 0 m U N O N Cl) LL Q a w LL h oN O� z¢ az Q c 0 m o o W f W N W Q r z U' W O 0� w ma -Z U Z O U) ro �a ro b ro b ro � ro 2s' ro ro ro, ro ro ro ro b ro b ro ;b ro, ro� rd b ro ro ro b ro b b b ro ro, ro� (o b r r-I r1 r-i r-I ri r-I r-I ri r-I r-I r-I .� r1 r-I rl r-I r-I .-1 r-I Z Z Z .f U 0 r-I r-I r-1 r-I H r-I r-I 1-1 r-I r-I H zr 0 \ 0� \ 0� \ Oi \ Vi \ 0� \ 0� \ 0� \ b� \ 0� I- Di \ fi \ to \ ✓T \ \ \ \ \ \ 0 r m LL N Ow U) Q} ri r� r-I r•I r-I r-I r-I r-I '.� ,� '-I .--I r-i r-I ri r-I r-1 .--I .-I zQ �z Q U) 0Q < \ Z \ z \ z \ Z \ z \ z \ z \ y \ z z z -'� z Z+, z F-� Z Z z z O N Q Lu Z \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ J OQ �Z w Iz Z Z Z Z Z z Z Z Z Z z Z z Z Z Z Z Z J > U U O U z W J FC FC FC FC` F1 FC a Q Q a 9 K4 K 4 4 Zi z z z z Z Z z z z Z+, z Z z z z z Z z LL LL Q y N - W O Z - In Cl) p !QOM 4 �i �i �i �i �i �. �i !�i v �i Q� �i �i !�i �i �i \ r \i r \i F \i \s r \i \s r \i r \i y\ y\ r \i \i r \i \ r \i \ r \i \ Q p v ii (U f 4 a U w w n t` OD OD W 00 00 w AD O O W 00 O co co co '� O Q to L(1 r-I iJ r-I r-I r-I ri M M r-I r-I 1) r-I ri > N M M O 0 % O O O O O O O O 0 OZ O O O O O O O O_ } J V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V Q O Z U pl Ol O O O O r O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ^F -�- Z O ri O i-•1 Lf ui L(1 L(1 Ln O ip L(1 Ln Ln LO Ln Lf L(1 Ln - O LIl U V V V �� V, V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V O E+ E+ _ I-U uj OH " \J�, `J�/ `J�/ \J�, \J�/ \X/ X `J�/ \J�, `J�/ \X, \X/ \J�, \J�/ `J�, X `J�, \X/ wm ma Z z / \ I \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ iC O 'a. uj nww co O mU ,a J N L7 w I- u u u u u u u u u u u u u H(Y o > r LU Q F" � Q r Q c 41 S a € m N d)i .N '� t00 £yy � E ° d b� 5 C b O'er O fb °� O wry O N m M � r` �, O d' J Zx0 O' J¢ Z LL' LL N p C O y C W C N p S N ,,,� U� W O E N C C 0 {{ O 1n a 2 n O O= _^ m O O O fh O w t eo U 'S. o L M y �_ 2 L U_ E �p cry r� C cr_S f V `� cr3 O C 41 c�� O�„ N W O d'�o CS C n �. q L I' L C '6,0 L C N N O (n d Qom' V7 N QI� CS Qn m y ab COD m> O m N LL N u (�l U N N d L W U l E OG t 0 U r d U C tb N S r U fb cp ET O r` N O I O 0'r d C N ' C - C N r m 0, — T r` W a( _ E E C U U <O >,� O Y i N JI btb �r� W O nP E O N roa- 4 Q CD �d > ° d- l >r >N E O� > O�l �v'C {0 > ; d l0 > �'d >� m d > O > O °r d >O m� > Q NIm O >L (7 ,N� m a E v>C fmC o ar NU w C7 Q a z O W z_ r Z O U 0 m U N O N Cl) LL Q a w LL O O z m o � o W v Y � Q W F= z_ U' W O C7 o _a J W z QW U pz U a U) z z w z� O Ur m IFO,Z, >, �, >, � b ro ro b b b b rd ro \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ A A A A; A A A A A A ro ro ro ro rt 0 fo M M ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro �iI r-i I H I H I r-L I II I 'i I H I H I IHI 'I I HI HIHIHI -i I -1 IHIr, Ir-II z z z z z z z z z z z \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ z z z z z zr z Zr z z z ,z z z z z z z z z z z z zlzlzlzlzizlzIz I zlzl NINI I NitOINIOINIOINI�I O O O O N O N O .,i O O V V V V V V V V V V V O O O a O O O tO O O Ln IO O O Lf lfIO n N O 1-1 r V V V V 'V V V V V V V U�M N X X XX X XXXXXXX z z z z z z z z, z z a� z' ❑ w F- OLLJ x F:4 X4 .4 4 4 4 �' 4 F:4 Z =1 a� —z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z w W U U z J O w ii 'j(5:: 'Lua X Z J a X 4 4 4 FC 4 9 4 4 4 4 z z z z z z z z z z LL _ y QXXXXXXXXXXX O I LL W Ox� z � Q , L1'� O O � 1v 'o 0 O ' L H D O N 24 ~ F � N Fr b C _ a� dO o C Z z LL d N HO N ' E N t> C z z z z z z z z z z U wz z Ma 2 LL9 - N H :fo p C H y E O U 1 NN Z l 'd 0 w O cn Ln m co m ao eo m p ao m N .-I r-I r-I ri r-1 rl rl r-I rl e-1 `{N N N N N o') Ci tC h C cn a a U Q D jO U Ot a v O O O O O O O O O } J V V V V V V V V V V Z O O < �w O O O O O O O O O O V a ui V Ln V to V Ln V Ln V to V Ln V Ln V Ln V Ln V 2 z cu 0 v O � z z z z z z z z z z z \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ z z z z z zr z Zr z z z ,z z z z z z z z z z z z zlzlzlzlzizlzIz I zlzl NINI I NitOINIOINIOINI�I O O O O N O N O .,i O O V V V V V V V V V V V O O O a O O O tO O O Ln IO O O Lf lfIO n N O 1-1 r V V V V 'V V V V V V V W V) LU w w z O w n z z Z O U LA w U a a 0 m ,00 U LLN O a a w U�M N X X XX X XXXXXXX X XXX J m a O Z ❑ Y Q Wm >� °mow LL O Z. O w W U (L r5 l J ii 'j(5:: 'Lua X XXX X XXXXX i� � j I QXXXXXXXXXXX O I � Q , L1'� O O � 1v 00 b O ' L H D O N N F � N Fr b C _ a� dO o C Z z LL d N HO N ' E N t> C C vy Cq W ^ � n N U Ld Ma 2 LL9 - N H :fo p C H y E O 1 NN Z l 'd 0 a Ur O > b W > d r6 LN > L S > q N an m 5 a UO N U N CH `{N N N N N o') Ci tC h C cn a a U Q D U Ot a v a W V) LU w w z O w n z z Z O U LA w U a a 0 m ,00 U LLN O a a w W S F O w LL 0 W Z) Z z Z O U i w t, a z O W D z_ z 2 O U a, ao U d N r� LL a W LL (1) OW N O�] zQ �z ¢ C- 0 N o o W f Y UJ F ~ LU Z Ur W Z O LI) O 4a JA F ,uj �Z U Z O U _ - En ro ro m ro m ro\ ro ro m ro rd ro rt' ro m ro l ro m ro FCC rt ro ro ro ro ro ro ro ro rt ro ro ro a ¢ \ \ \ z \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ z \ \ \ \ \ \\ z z A' A A A A A A - z z D LLJ p 1 r-4 r-i 1--1 i -4 RC ZE, O11 \ \ \ �1; \ z \ X1,1 \ \ i�Jl, \ bbl'1 \ \ \ �:j \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ z \ z m LL N W O} Z Q v a, FC a Ca u FC FC rl I A FC rJ FC a a FC A Q \ \ \ z ¢r \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z 04 Z Z Z Z z Z b Qv v z z z F F wbz O a a a a Z� FZ \ U U J " \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ zz-, \ \ z \ z \ z' \ z \ z \ z \ z z \ z' ' z v U O Vr O dr O Vr O d� O U W Z J Q �. �i �i }4 !� �i �i �. Qi Qi � Qi Qi �i Qi � � S-1 S4 < \ z \ z \ z (V a \ z \ z \ z \ z \, z \ z \ z v a \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z v a v a J LL } Q a 0, N W �° 4! 'b ro ro ro � RC H F - < g1 g 4 4 N � � FC g RC < FC 4 O1 � W w z z z �/ z z z z z z z �, z z rc., z z z z �V �1 Z O �+ }4 N N a U LU O (Nn N N N N N N N N dr N N' (N N N N N N 4J 4-1 J ¢ f O O O O 7 O O O O O z O O z O zi } J N V V V V V V V V V V V - V, V V V V V Q Z O - D F Q O O O O 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O Y .Z� -Z Ln Ln �Ln 1 Ln Ln Lh L(1 Ln 0 O 1 Ln 2 Ln Uf lfl m m 'n Ln i l V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V rL Z N OU (nu :i u m a m Q 0 iC o � ww O U Y w > w awv) -1 ¢ W < ww N O W Z z w .,P: ' W O ¢ W , ~� m I F, Z Q d N b �� 'Q C d _ b •• Z LU` Q N W �' N ^ N -c °�g�c N = c O '.�. �. ', d d 'z m L o N (OD aci ;o��o b w b ;, c c o '�S rh L °_• p J Z Z b ¢ R LL a C W a_ C W _ $N B_ d_ N y Cy d Nr.�.. c d c _ m N L� N v C w N t �' N r N� ^ NE N 0 0 !n NL• `ri M.�.• m W o d c L y U {p I� o d(^ L_iLL^ d, w L N c d L_ 5 p (nom d ¢`. (n yy UN ¢t`') y U� ¢� CC,, Qd C� L1� m00 C U� d l`1� m rD C d C m +C O) (h �� C Gl,.0 m C c� d NO m m j0) mw y'- m O"ma'Op d Cis 4S. v% C m NL� �5.� CO UO 0 N d Lr N r N U U m W, m N 'm N m W L m C�� Url Im r mr7 N m Ci OIL C0 2 0 � co O: C� m W O mi m'i'.... ,a Ov L co �jLL L m m¢ N N �N N N.� C7 N (o 7 v Q m LL n c moa, M�LL .ter.. W a C G� L i w t, a z O W D z_ z 2 O U a, ao U d N r� LL a W W ,C7 a w LL 0 W _z z Z O U w w W z O w z_ z Z O U 0 00 U N O V1 E O LL Q a W OW OJ Z Q az Q c 0 o rn o w a f z U' W U O v7 O L J m LIJ, vrL ' w U Z O U ro ro ro ro ro ro, ro ro ro ro' ro ro ro ro ro ro' ro ro ro z \ \ \ \ \ \ \ z \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ A H a A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A H Z, zz W UD { f a + + f z ~ O \ z bl Ol tyl M bl Ql CD \ of bl m Ol bl bl tTl Cn bl Ol C71 Ol L) F m _ LL N OW O J rl rl i r I ri r rl j H r-I ri r-I r-I r-I r-I H r ' r-I H rl Z Q 13a U) A �' �' Q FCC 4 < 4 9 rt a ¢ a z' v z v z v z v' z �, z v z a a v z v z y, z v z v, z v z v z 'z z v z y z v z Q C N v b Z W � I- a a C9 W [u rC FC rC FC FC FC 9 [*. () 4 FC Q 4 RC a 4 9 4 9 rC' F• z J OJ; p �U u \ z \ \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z O z O Z O d O U Z W J Q i4 F:4 �i �i �i �1 �i � �i �i �i �i 0:4 4 4 F�4 w �> Q W a \, z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z N a \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z, \ z \ z \ z \ z \ z LL LL >- 0 r N w b M ') f`O `p o ' b 5 ` - FC, FC FC FC FC FC FC FC 4 RC, FC KC < FC' FC FC 4 w z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z z U g p N 44 >~ a U 111 Ji co Co N N N N N N N N N N N d' N N d' N N N N Q. y0 z O O O O O O O 0 z O O O O O O O O O O O O } J ry V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V Q z _O N Qs O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O Y =z = f Ll lfl Ln lfl l!1 Ln Ul f f Ln L! Ln U) lfl Lll ol In Ln ifl Ln a w V V V V V V V V V V V v V V v V V V V z U N 0 v N U Ti,Q / \ / \ ./ \ I � / \ / \ I \ / \ / \ I \ I \ / ` I \ / \ I \ I \ I \ / \ I \ / \ / O Y ce > `w aww w JJQ K ma D W - N 0 W z w to d' W m 'I _ Q 'm � Oifa Of f0 �, yrq a N� z ^ N Q N a 0 r Q� C b^ d C N, N O O N � �� JZDO LL ^1D " O'.".. Lp U_ 00 ;. OW� v C �� C�� ��� � a:�.N �Nv (CO N -6 fi t� U V 'LO n AtnOv O O �L N O b ._.iL O C .. �1^ -i z U �� �c .L.. .d_. d� E�� ,Q,yy1 G� _� �� d� ZW _� Nc� 00 > O >�` K" y� KN w� KI� oa�Y d d 1A ar. pr. m_M M Z a ZS� d (n ry C6 a- ,OW NC NCO NyLL '� m LL n =y= =Cr o 20 CTM—C.), -6Zdz �n rn z-us E n Za U` �m C N d Im C M N m L 7 L m i 07 h L M Y (O L m 7 r m 7� to M ;E O) L m 9 C O T N �'me0 5v m N W 'M C1 C M C1y r0]t a�i A aa O^ QI't� {r1 N 2'C M1 M� f0 Z� m N T r' M,C& O, N !1],� OJ 0) m�C6 10 O� C2 V N , O �O v M,4, N N, !t0 a N fl v N O. N N S Ned M LO M M a th a, M M GI M .i M C M�... a N R,Zi... w w W z O w z_ z Z O U 0 00 U N O V1 E O LL Q a W F- z O Of LL W 2 F- O Of LL W _Z F- z 0 0 0 CP c0 U N O N M li wW LL U) OW } o Z Q az Q c c - O o W W J N N Q � N W Q z U' W 0 O N 0 v� QW U z Q b b b H zz z Z) W zfp r-I r-I r-i r-I O� 01 M 0) m U- 0 w co O J rl r-I r-I r-I ZQ o z Q .-. N Q FCC F:4 F z z C N Q v � W 1 z O Ur W QS `v z z 0j z' z U z O W jN z z z z LL N W Z o M M `n _O �w z z z z � O U W N d N N N jO O O O } J N v v v v a 0 o b w x S ° o o ° Vo b X� �z 5 ° uS in in L) z v v v v " ° U U z a ww >WO, Lu 0 \X/ X X X Mm m < X Y O V J O r ww >w awN ma w o N Z �3 U F O z Ul .IP5 w o U <1 U w a ,z O Z O c Q w u, ~ C $ U � �I O J,Z 7 `o J Q Z LL b W S. Z� FO c d C `4 .c P W LL c cV C 2 = 2 M 2 O'm ('7 00 �.� W c O W1 00 C d a'` ( f01 Z L O OD LL O N N p GQ d a m m 00 QI m T- 0] Lice} V �.� a �i! 'Q N � 4 V �n O�I� N LJ N ,W clN W d M W O N T W L 2 U _a M Co (b Q to Vm M N d m N U O L3 CSi. �O 1� 1�1 7 N d `N N a dP a a �- c''�M W 0_,1C O_ "d N OSN a. .0�� NaC �0_i. fOC NV gym{ Vv O�v�LLv M..��V•�N.Mi ��'4r�aaoC Opp C 0 CP c0 U N O N M li wW § ® ) 0 LL 3 \ ƒ \ \ \ k z j ƒ \ LLI D \ u % } / k E b'§ z =I \ ( u } g«� § X09 Z/ e§ \ 0 S � ( _ 5 ;i,z z \/ ca - // 7} �I EQ k /\ ! )ƒ 9 _§ —§ 4 \ 2\ / %> m §k� - § m.Z) § ) » ( 'n ) < . j 0 t / q ( � \ l m� 0 14 0 \ ( ^ % t § , 0 ® / §§ s y c» f ` ) ��� )§ \ 2 _ 2u / �§) ) / 2 3 2 §g)) / { \� § § §/ / 6 } / )`(\ ! 0 7 Ek E��� E0) 0- /) \ §§2} o e e � EG �u=e6«ca=;= 5® o ; , ; / & § 04 _,_�_ m ) > m &a »& % } / k E i O v 4 .V. w m D z a 0 O W O N 'E r O d m E O a 7 O cm J C Z N 0'a xW O Q W y Q' c, S� z Z 7 ,Q W y S Ei Z W a Q w Z O vO Z y}O W mZ U) a Z 'w' W J c W' (L o (0 CLL O N) LL LL W ° vl 0 Q) O J 5 N O J Z d Z c' a Z �Q y EE Z �Q M y O C Z +� w O 5 O J u Y b 4 m , N C �r < F C w N N C C w Y W N V - D ry 4 ? o LL Q 'S E Q Qw O �v F-> O = z - �J mQ 0 O Ow (7 Z O a8 v� W ~� w pQ J' r c� R E (7 �w w ma _ vw OJ w w w m °, Zzo O J J J c V U U O Q >4 >1 Q b Ci rd b m b N N «N F c c �� CD N p ° r-I r-i H r-I -4 i a'y Z S z Z z Z;. U U �Q =n c d or c w'Z U° \ Q Q $U C °Z` ' Q bl bl ill Ol Ol O O ' FQ- U c U� E E E m LL N O ? O m O c 49'a LL LL V m g d o 0,N w O V) r-I d' n. } Q O ID y O J r-I rl �-I r-1 r-1 N 111 � l N W m O m v z Z 0 Z Q li N �. `5 N Q D r o;a J y U) # m FC FC FCC FC v m w w Q rC' z z z z z Q N O ¢'� > O > L �`CD o Z O m m «`� w N Q M 1, Ln c E m. O --. F N ..0. _ O Z iU Lfl Ln 'CN l0 O' O p Z O v Z W d' N `.o R, W r Q - N' N M« c L Z O d U' v Z U 4 X U w p z z z z z z m,LO `o F- y O m,R w M a a E U U W W W y v n 0. «m. p¢ > < N J J J 7C7 LL N N O W 2 y « M p a W 0 'O J 7 y E «' O M b LL Q FC (1`i RC FC A`i �N N O, EO NL W z z ,z z z pp -U - __ ^Qk c N O C N X Q „w l� LL m ¢,. p -o m w rn c U W Q 7 Off', N L M O M p z O 0O O O OL N O N 0 _ W l0 C O J 4 > v Z \ \ \ \ \ 2 > t >' J Q � �E w z z z z z w w w �r .� o E c Q m `w Z J J J Z 3- N v l0 >, .D OU r c w rt d Q p z c0 N 111 V) N 00 O) Ln -W N TYN `n c N NI g O O p N co ri OD rO d' } ._. v .� V N vw H m d J V W N O i.0 0-0,0 rl EE m O z ___ o Di O m LL 2 O w LL 0 W D z_ z Z O U m W N F- �z (n O O1 c a� O L v N Cbi � `� N E W fh CO` A° a0 c W m W P7 Q 5O M y o. ^ v a d' m m �Oo �O'o r� d cd n d d d o,_m cd U �' N N a m R LL' h�W' (n v]'N N W a �` O` M M �Ve� W N U d N I� 'Q' O fN "d 7 � a �0 ,� m Wo �'� 0 RH � .+e `y°. E��� c orC aC cC �C w ..H ,�H >t-xF w Q a z O W 7 z z Z O U O U N O N fh `o LL Q w W LL N oN 01% ZQ c Q oz 0 o U V) W _ U V Y J J N _ H H H % Z - Z U U, W O Z - N Z Z F F¢ - - K W Q=z w U Z O U � r ro ro Q b b (n a a z tz v L L) Z H O� LL N OW N O>- `Z Q vZ Q w D U U) z Ur N N z z Qr Z Z of 0 0 H QHQ z ` F z z z O U U J O O w J J 2 n aC J > > z z z z LL LL Q Q E Et W a a M O O Z O. r Q v v U Z % % Z. z Z OI w N N k kD � V i � N v v V } N J Q z O ~QQ Z L Ln N N U V V W W m O Z U X ° °WC2 Y m J m -X X c X NiW K I XXX X XX X I \ / XX X / \ I X - I \� / X X XXXX X / \ / / \ I I \ / X X X X XX X I \ / X N N LU m I \ • • ` / / \ / ma �• l Q 4! U U N N � l0 N N _ _« O O ' '6 « «0 E E E E � y i Z t t O Y ~ J J � ~ N �L_ y i � J J I J�Z Z t0! V V t Y A A N N ~ �N, C C d E E �' ~ N N It- w Q a z O W 7 z z Z O U O U N O N fh `o LL Q w W E O y 'c i O W m Z rn 0 O JJ N U q O NO' O' U O LL O W Q a O w LL 0 W z p z O U �nvSC>;ayo� LL CO O,w U CS E cc L w O'er 1-B O T c ZYQ D¢ U N L N y j C C7 — Q� d m 6. c 0 J Q O o `OF o W Q § c d c a ami U O N C m N N N c Y w O c m d J m j m o 42 N O y V �0 O 0� < C L n O �aEo11 D J W ^r -Z iC?3J��° 3 "y ¢ U 38�10YH Y O J N '6 �E'JrEm ro J oi. e'y �o �� y Q b N �C m e (' a o , E 'a F- L A - wz E' p vOi °' S,? ca o o g u> Z' °.yy «d-�o UO o j N y E 0 OU i.J'o E m~ LL N w O J c L U m o > M,co cru . c a 3,= U) .c o a o w O O J z r1 S- N U 'D Z Q dO — C L '.0 N N O N V N `- 'E oNi`ia?i Cry, 2 \�i 0, N 3 J FL" 5 > N iZI O C E C N O Z - Y 2 °: C � w w b_ v o J 9 0 d U W .�- 0 >00 ° ° y m zJ OQ r vw \ z c Uy X 0- p i0 N U O 2 a� E c rn c m J,o O v$� cy c N z- W Q FC \ ym� dold c j N? O > > N z n N = a o o,N �} W p,0 Z O , y N m O m o m �> IN L N O CAN r d C �`1 K FC O N w -Z L\ z 0Emc,y o[�v N'�,,O z O - m m s .o ,c Z - W O m in .�. m m rn d > m;c J m ¢ dcmcEiELm O N � V [; UUO v H J 0 O . Q O Z (n E J J m° g O 1 W � 'd u �.3 a .� O Q O W N YO d` N N —Z W m U z V U 8¢— a doN o w m OU - w _ m'w F- Z - ,V c c i.. [o m O d �NnEo�COL � �,m J N C m y o o p L X w¢ m 'n J O - o nwN � � c E c n�ppmH3oJ Y = J O o 0 >` U l`0 LL / \ I \ / \ I \ / \ / \ I \ / \ I \ / \ I \ / \ I \ / \ , / c m d c O c Y d W w an d J ¢ o O,w mxy8Jo ( a N r O0 Ea 5st M% y V m d z,� m 7 0 c £, o m« E m N w d r ¢ m c c W 0 U 5 N V Z Q p dN � dU dL m E > '~ 7O O O O JZ ¢� E CN N 2 � O E C Wy nN 14 m N a ~ 47 F O a � p ' C NT C)[] 0 Q V W � g ' o 1 2 2m4 v o 'o d m C nC` ao ,a C � r XN NUD w W > W z O W z Z H z O U 0 m U N O m' E LL a w r z O w LL w x r O LL O W Z F- z O U s m m U N 0 h M 0 LL Q w 6-,1 Ow I CO O� ZQ c z U o o w h f w J N W Q r z U` w z� O r N tw 0'Q --Z U Z O U N V) Q H� Z Z) z z c W UO z� O� U� m LL N Ow ° J Z Q v z Q N N Q Q C N z O W F- v W r Z J OJ vZ > U u OZ U M Q 7 > J LL LL } Q +d O v W M o M Q O 7 -Z X�v a U a O U w N M J } J N Q O Z O 2 ^ y vz a W z O ILU fl .0 `X/ \X, \X, X \X, / \ \X, `X, / \ x \X, / \ \X/ / \ \X, / \ x \X, / \ `X, / \ \X/ / \ `X, / ` \X/ / \� X \X/ / \ \x/ O / \ / \ / \ / \ / Q j' _- Wm d Y >Z Q a�w O ma U J N 'g z o W W rcr > I F- Q m:i;� z ° U w b r or �L Q by J Q Z c ,� En o � � 1 ❑ W ,^ N O � o YW �c . 1 C M L o�1 _tN ' q L>o U E m 00 O�> N oN p d o Cpl aL v S C W N �S£ N C N d Q 0 Q 1 q co Q ? R' CNc U O N U O �oC aG Lu v E U > O > > > O N 6 > 1U 0 ? �•-• > O > ON O 1 Q)s O Or, O ` O L U M N'ES ,' CD a v N U s m m U N 0 h M 0 LL Q w w N LU w w z O 111 D z_ z Z O U s co U N O LO m o LL a W oW - O� ZQ ,z nQ c b o zz o W N i ♦- Hs> z z_ w zo C7 N O °Q v�LU w U Z O U U) Q H W z Z 7 v UO O� OF �o Oy O� Z Q vz Q - - U) a Q � N z wti F v O F D z J z O —Z z * U U z O U _ W W Q rn to a LL } ^ N LL W p a z O - t7 Cl) p 0 LUU O U W N Cn J } J_ N Q p z O Q =z w z O o u wQ LLJ `J�/ \J�/ `J�/ \J�/ \J�, \J�/ \J�/ \J�/ X \J�, \J�, \J(, \J�' \J�/ \X/ \J�, \X, \J�/ \J�, \J�, \J�/ I/ ` / \ / \ / \ / \ / ` / \ ,/ \ ,/ \ / \ / \ / \ / \� / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / m Z z Y >z w d Q LLJ U) nww a ma UO w 2 N Jr O l zw g 0 °u~io O U ww ~M > I O Q I O Z LL, CC O C N r c m ° n n o A ° ' Z J Q Z O N O N -C -2 O - v Lc d LL = O7 O O 2; Z L � bcFp m LL F O cO N P oc v O CL p C ` 0 d 0Cb QN L Q Q Q a5 L NU Ni O N ' C n o eb U a w N LU w w z O 111 D z_ z Z O U s co U N O LO m o LL a W 0 j ( § D \ Q \ } § 0 of 0 j $ \ \ \ 5 LL z< �< LLI \ E_ \ LU - �o� D 6§ } \ .\ E§ / \ /S §§ LL z< _z )2 } - /f « _ �| LLJ § L 0 �§ -j u § \ k - - a - j< ° - �'� E$ ) G ( \ < t ® _ § D © w \ q } �( 4-1 ° { Q \ 2 / . S _ a ® °§{ § ƒ - ( § / § k /§ 7 _ zw\ mow) ] 2 22 F- @ @ \� _. / #ƒ ) ®C5Eyes04) %a) [� ®® {. §> r \))2 z =« < <t U- , « .� 2. - ®� -� 99 } °. @ |F ;s = ®a ~� -§_ "22���5. 0 /[ /a£ -elR, "��= a s \ «3kE6 . - 72- ƒ4 =,tee, }@�5so® 4- _ ). § §� a;e } +�§ ;2$� _ / \i / \�ca 4>>m�4ai¥42uao2a§§w| \� J /\ \k \\ N, CO /, m�\ {� \ \coƒ m mm§§ =±ma %=rte _ 0 - !�in=e«ek%, =�9��LL°a ;E R »z:4— Ef£= «£e[\ »2»752#3 El ;t \ } § 0 of 0 j $ \ \ \ 5 > W Q Q O Q LL O W Z z Z O U W LU W W Q' Z O W .Z z Z O U m m U N OF C O LL Q Q W LL (1) O W z J e m - o lY W Q "" r z U' W o Z H _O J QQ W —Z QW U Z O N N N F- D Z.z v LU VO Z F O� Ur m LL W OW - O J ZQ V Z Q U) a Q ti N t'3 Z O r~ b W Q Z I '_'r O Q w J > U U O U W U) z w j N a � J LL LL y y N W o Z Q 7 � Q �v ---Z W L) O U W J N � i J N Q 0 0 b k Ul U N H X� H v Z W = O z O b Q a Q z N Q+ m 8 N 04 w w Z > U :D d W m m a 'p - ?< ow r U Y w >w Q Q y W(q W < wix m a r D, W N z_ K N N r w m Q' ~ Oz ^ b�tb 11 O N N r N N b poI W n N C 1 V O N N O N mi�� [b N L N N rg' T_ N aS �'� O t{,ao N o O N —r6� 0 5 O n E b O N "E' J Z J QZ O LL 'D{ O` C O d M ?_.O D `-' D`, ?_ C �� 0r m ... x m x C A A x C r X� c+Q a SLn t O.� ,t GR Q� Z't Z�^ O a (n VJ P d c (`') V N A O E..O. m� D i -� m 0 .� d N C cD� y N C Or A N c y LL ll n N vc S y ° w 2 dm� 2 O. I� d = c cY,d M y N. m Z Z W Z m n a Z O Q U` y ,m'� a L N L w L m J w J �w�L Oy J. N' m m m N' m J a, NfU r (O M m N W N O�� E m O N'a N Q N Q .r.. IN Q N� N E N`Q M L d rM .N..' M rov M �! 07 b'C W LU W W Q' Z O W .Z z Z O U m m U N OF C O LL Q Q W z O a LL W S F O LL w W 7 Z F Z O U W Q a z O W D Z F= Z O U �1 W O a 0 m av U N 0 N M LL Q a W LL OW !n o �} ZQ oZ Q c 0 r o ,o W N N LU W Q F Z_ U' W C7 O v� p LIJ QW v� U pZ U N Q w Z Z 7 c U`O O~ U ^� m' LL O'y O, Z Q Z Q Q Q y N Z O a D W ti F v H CD'W Z O J "U ; U O U W co Q J LL } ^ Q N LL W p �i Z O r M M p O X�v �Z a U a O U W N Z U > q } J N _ _ 0 o ro w k w k, 2 g F Z S 0 N U H 0 N U ro li v z a° z �° q L) o v a v' 124 a' o v z N a OF Z Z u 5 m O m'a a Y a > W swan J Q w K '�' w N ma Z) o p Z 2 Z, y p u7 Q� W W W , a F x I Z I Z Z W Q co '(�C'p C C Q C C J Z.� C J Z? Q 'LL E b �S` _ Z �p C _ L id p(, �.O �(C N d'� of LL UI C N C d V (Oi = VYI� _�{� PV,^ �_ O U = O� i F- `O (h W 0 - 01 O p 00 C .-. N'� N C i� 'W O W O C O c �D C U Ul M O O (n ` Z L d a a 0 N A rot v O �fh m L16 m m C1� m d> i- m pp cp� L �, Ufa a CN a 71n V Din N b N` CL W.O. W O W'd W T°' y1N 1 SEq d. V i..) CO ED co m� m Od Lv a av CL att����� a a a'h a� N a a<`1 vn a �n °� at4b f0 (J M Opp a v au a O v u „°, N M v� n m n co`C mC 2 ,7� ern- �a �C W Q a z O W D Z F= Z O U �1 W O a 0 m av U N 0 N M LL Q a W \ } \ ƒ \ \ / co zz \ ) w b.) z _ƒ \ ( u } < LU z q ƒA ` 2% 5 ¢\ EG \ 0 \ r /E 6§ ue - -` W / z< =< \\ � &\ § _§ \ ƒ F- 0 -) ; ° § . u / Lu U// \ _ g E( # R ) § § >1 § R ! \ H zz AD % �L ° 2 E § w U £, < , a �(§ §\ s (§ \ } / )( [ z SF-\ CL I z - £ § §k R) ) ^ ~� ^ ~ ^ ~^ ^ 7 ee�3; ;/ a% a; �b ob , )`2\ $$7 E/ 6/ )Q 22 22 E2 Ek )) 7 ` � /( }k $A ƒ {( \ { 5§ OD S \ ) w EPA ID Number (copy from Item 1 of Form 1) Form Approved OMB No ,2040 -0086 P!anaa rint ,-, t. n,,,fho,—had.el. —1v NC0000396 I Approval expires 5-31-92 FORM 2F NPDES U S Environmental�Protection Agency �1 Washington, DC,20460 For Application for Permit to Discharge Storm Water Discharges, Associated with Industrial Activity Paperwork Reduction Act Notice Public reporting burden for this application is estimated to,average 28 6 hours per application „including time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information Send comments regarding the burden estimate, any other aspect of this collection of information, or suggestions for improving this form, including suggestions which may increase or reduce this burden to Chief, Information Policy Branch, PM -223, U S Environmental Protection,Agency, 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20460, or Director, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, Office of Management and Budget, Washington, DC 20503 I. Outfall Location For each outfall, list the latitude and longitude of ds location to'the,nearest '15 seconds and the name, of the, receiving water A Outfall Number (list) B Latitude C Longitude D Receiving Water (name) SW -1 35 28 01 82' 32 13 Lake Jul -fan 'SW -2 35' 27 51 82 32 05 Lake Julian SW -3 35, 27 55 182 32 06 Lake Julian SW -4 35, 28 39 82 32 46 Lake Julian SW -5 35 28 29 82 32 51 Unnamed tributary to Powell Creek ISW -6 35 28 23 X82 32 45 Lake Julian II. Improvements A Are you,now required by any Federal, State, orlocal authority to'meet any implementation schedule for the construction, upgrading or operation of wastewater treatment4gwpment,or practices or any,other environmental programs which may'affect the, discharges described in this application? This includes, butts not limited to, permit conditions, administrative or enforcement orders, enforcementcompliance schedule letters, stipulations, court orders, and granb or, loan conditions 1 Identification of Conditions, Agreements,,Etc 2 :Affected Ouffalls 3 Brief Descriptiowof Project 4 Final, Compliance Date number source of discharge a req b prof N/A I f B You may attach additional sheets describing any additional water pollution (or other environmental projects which may affect your discharges) you now have under way,or which you, plan Indicate whether each program is now underway or planned, and indicate your`actual or planned schedules for construction III Site Drainage Map Attach,a,site map showing topography (or indicating0e oubine'of,drainage areas served by the outfalls(s) covered in the application if a,topographic map is unavailable) depicting the facility including each of,ds intake ,and,di`scharge structures, the'drainage area of each storm water outfall, paved areas and buddings, with in, the drainage area of each i storm water outfall, each'knovinpast or present %areas used for outdoor, storage of disposal of sign ificant'matenals, each existing (siructurat control' measure ,to reduce, pollutants in,storm water runoff, materials loading and access "areas, areas where pesticides, herbicides, sod condrtioners?and'fertilizers ., are applied, each of its hazardous waste treatment, storage or disposal units (including each area not required to, haveia RCRA permit which isrused for accumulating hazardous waste under 40 CFR 262 34), each well where Fluids from,the.facility are infected underground, springs, and other surface water bodies which recerved,storm water discharges from the facility EPA Form'3510 -2F (.1 -92) Page 1 of 3 Continue on Page 2 Continued from the Front IV. Narrative Description of Pollutant,Sources A For each outfall provide an estimate of the area (include units) of imperious surfaces (including paved areas and building roofs) drained to the outfall and an estimate of the,total surface area drainetl by the outfall Outfall Area of Impervious Surface Total Area Drained Outfall Area of Impervious Surface Total Area Drained Numtier (provide units) (provide units) Number (provide uni (provide units) SW -1 0 34 acres 3 69 ares SW -4 0 o9 acres 5 5 acres SW -2 0 13 acres 0 38 acres SW -5 0 09,acres 4 0 acres SW -3 0,84 acres 9 X06 acres SWr_6 0 18 acres 7, 6 acres B Provide a; narrative description of significant materials that are currently or In the past three +years have been treated, stored or disposed in a manner to, allow exposure to storm water, method of treatment, storage, or disposal, past and" present, materials management practices employed'to minimize contact'by °these materials with storm water runoff,, materials loading and access areas, and,the location, manner, and'frequency'm which pesticides, he�biades, sod,conddloners,,and'fertihzers are applied See attachment 6 For each outfall, provide, the location and a description of existing, structural and nonstructural control measures to reduce pollutants in storm water runoff, and a description of 'the treatment;thelstorm'water receives, Including the schedule,and� type of maintenance for +control and treatment measures and the ultimate disposal ofany solid or fluid wastes other than,by discharge Outfall LIsTCodes from Number _ _ Treatment Table 2F -1 See attachment 7 - V. Nonsto=ater Discharges A I certify under penalty of law hat the outfall(s) covered by this apphcatlon have,been tested or evaluated for the presence of nonstormwater discharges, and that all , nonstormwater�jdischarged from these oudall(s),are Identified In either an accompanying,Form 2C or From,2E appllcation,for the outfall Name °and Official Title (type or print) Signature Date Signed Laurie Moorhead, Env Specialist B Provide a description of the method used, the date of any testing, and the onsite drainage points that were directly observed during a test On an annual basis, the Asheville Plant Environmental Specialist conducts a visual inspection of all stormwater outfalls during an extended period of dry weather This visual inspection serves to ensure that there are no unpermitted discharges from the permitted stormwater outfalls Certification statements are signed, dated and kept onsite behind Tab 5 Annual Certification Page of the SWPPP Dates for previous certifications include April 16, 2010, April 23, 2009 VI. Significant Leaks orSpills Provide existing Information regarding the history of significant leaks or sp(lis of toxic or hazardous pollutants at -the facility,In the lastrthree years, including; the approximate date and location'of the spill or Leak, and the,type,and amount ofmatenal released There have been no leaks of spills of toxic or hazardous pollutants on the old or new access roads in the past three years EPA Form'3510 -2F (1 -92) Page 2 of 3 Continue on Page 3 EPA ID Number (copy from Item 1 of Form 1) Continued from Paaer2 Nc00003§6 V EPA Form 3510 -2F (1 =92) Page 3 of 3 VII. Discharge Information A, B. C,.& D See instructions before proceeding Complete one set of-,tables for each outfall Annotate th&outfall number in the space provided' Table VII -A, VII -B, VII -C are included on separate sheets numbers VII -1 and VII -2 E Potential discharges not covered by analysis — is any toxic pollutant listed in table 2F -2, 2F -3, or 2F-4, a substance or a component,of a substance which you currently use or manufacture as an intermediate or final product or byproduct? ❑✓ Yes (list all such pollutants below) ❑ No (go to Section 1X The following elements could be present in coal and /or" oil Antimony Arsenio Beryllium Cadmiun Chromium Lead Mercury Nickel Selenium Silver Thallium Zinc VIII Biological Toxicity Testing Data Do you have any' knowledge or reason to believe that any biological,test for acute or chronic toxicity has been made on any of your discharges or on a receiving water in relation to your discharge within the lastiTyears? ❑Yes, (list all ^such pollutants�below) ❑✓ No (go to SectiondX) IX Contract Analysis Information Were any of the analyses reported in Item VII performed by a contract laboratory or consulting firm ?' © Yes (list the °name, address, and telephone number, of, and pollutants ❑ (go to Section X) analyzed by, each such laboratory or firm below) A Name B Address C Area Code & Phone No D Pollutants Analyzed Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225 Riverside Drive (828)254 -7176 All Asheville, NC 28804 X. Certification I certify underpenalty of law that this document and all attachments were prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance with a system designed to assure that qualified personnel properly gather and evaluate thetmformation submitted Based on my inquiry of the person or persons who manage the,system or those persons duectly'responsible for gathering the information, the information submitted is, to the best of, my knowledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete I am aware that there are significant.penalhes for submdtmg,false information, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment for,knowmg,violahons ,A Name•& Official Title (Type Or Print) B Area Code,andiPhonefNo Garry A Whlsnant, Plant Manager (8281) 687 -5201 C Signature D Date,Signed 61101(,D V EPA Form 3510 -2F (1 =92) Page 3 of 3 EPA ID Number (copy from Item 1 of Form 1) Form Approved OMB No 2040 -0086 00000396 I Approval expires 5 -31 -92 VII. Discharge information (Continued from page 3 of Form 2F) Part A — You must provide the results of at least one analysis for every^pollutant inithis table Complete one table for each outfall See instructions' for additional details Pollutant and CAS`Number (if available) Maximum Values (include 'units) Average Values (include units) Number of Storm Events Sampled Sources of Pollutants Grab Sample Taken During First 20 Minutes Flow - Weighted Composite Grab Sample Taken During First 20 Minutes Flow- Weighted Composite Oland Grease <5 0 mg /l N/A J 1 Below detection level Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD5) 4 6 mg /l 2 0 mg /l ri Decaying vegetation Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) 432 mg /l 64 0 mg /l 1 Decaying vegetation Total Suspended Solids (TSS)_ 426 mg /l .92 7 mg /1 .1 Erosion, Settled dust and debris Total Nitrogen 4 9 mg /l 2 1 mg /l 1 Fertilizer Total Phosphorus 0,79 mg /,l '0 18 mg /l 1 Fertilizer pH Minimum 6 7 Maximum 5 7 Minimum Maximum 11 Part B — List each pollutant that is limited in an effluent guideline which the facility is subject to or any pollutant listed in the facility's NPDES permit for its process wastewater °(d the facility is operating under an existing NPDES permit) Complete one table fog each outfall See the instructions for additional details and requirements Pollutant and CAS Number (d available) Maximum Values (include units) _ Average Values (include units) Number of Storm Events Sampled Sources of Pollutants Grab Sample Taken During First 20 Minutes Flow- Weighted Composite Grab Sample Taken During First 20 Minutes Flow- Weighted Composite Total Copper 68, 5 ug /l 11 8 ug /Q 1 Total Iron 38300 ug /l 7230 ug /1 1 ~ Total Arsenic 46 4 ug /l 13 6 ug /l 1 Total Selenium <10 ug /l <10 ug /1- 1 Total Silver <5 0 ug /l <5 0 ug /l 1 Total Thallium ,<10 ug /l <10 ug /l 1 TKN 4, 5 mg /l 1 9 mg /l 1 Nitrate- Nitrite 0 40 mg /l 0 15 mg /l - 1 Total Mercury 0 33 ug /l <0 2 ug /l 1 Total Beryllium 3 4 ug /l <0 1 ug /l 1 Total Cadmium <1 0 ug /1 <1 0 ug /l 1 Total Chlorides i69 4 mg /l 31 3 mg /1' 1 Total Chromium 43 4 ug /l 718 ug /l 1 Total Flouride <0 1,0 mg /l <0 10 m4/1 1 Total Lead 45 8 ug /l 7 3 ug /l 1 Tot Managanese 1010 ug /l 125 ug /l 1 Total Nickel ,32 2 ug /l 5 2 ug /l 1_ Total Zinc 325 ug /l 54 1 ug /l 1 TRCt 250 ug /1• 1 • Possibly analytical inteference from naturally occurring manganese and /or turbidity in the sample Result from TRC,grab sample at end sampled outfall_,SW -3 only due to; representative outfall sta tus of SW sampling,event waa 20 -ug /1 No known source - EPA Form 3510 -2F (1-92) Page VII -1 Continue on Reverse Rnnfinuart frnm the Frnnt Part C = List each pollutant shown in Table 2F -2, 2F -3, and 2F -4 that you know or have reason`to believe is present See the instructions for additional details and' requirements Complete one table for each odtfall Pollutant and CAS Number (ifavadable) Maximum Values (include units) Average Values (include units) Number of Storm Events Sampled Sourcesof,Pollutants Grab Sample Taken During First 20 Minutes Flow- Weighted Composite Grab Sample Taken During First 20 Minutes Flow-Weighted Composite P_a_rt,D — Provide data'for, the Fstorm,event(s) which resultedon the maximum values for the flow weighted composite - sample 1 Date,of Storm Event 2 Duration of Storm. Event (in minutes) 3 Total rainfall during storm event (in inches) ,4- Number of.hours between beginning ofistorm measured and end of previous measurable rain event 5 Maximum flow rate during rain event (gallons/mmute,or specify units) 6 Total flow from rain event (gallons or specify units) 31/11/2010 210 minutes 0 39 on 3/11/2010 (during sampling) Precipitation over the next four days totaled 1 81 inches 168 hours 20 6 GPM 9,548 gallons from outfall SW -3 during sampling event 7 Provide a descnptiomof, the, method'of flow, measurement or estimate A container with a known volume and a stopwatch was used to measure flow from,SW,outfall pipe `EPA Form 3510 -2F (1 -92) Page VII -2 Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 1 Form 1— Item XI - Map � Fretly Mtrt• w \�: °ice-... � •.. o- k �' , j31®e Mtu ; t t Dscktl/ -o /ti •_ l 1i ti>. I •rc.• ••r.... ��`�' C)lik F ort sI P Pk ._ � t � �� /��� �•�. f �,�t ; • +• tom. , r� /. ,� �►,� � gland %;I �� ' _ .` u�� (\of � �/ •�. •" � `' � •I � Shoal! � .- �, , � /... - Ir - ' Son 1 s } : ( Asheville Plant ' .. ,�� Kam_ , -z' Ifb `.S• �,` rye pM +RY41 J 'r, �.,� \ // �!i�'r1 is t, - • . - _ v �• 5 w 0 8001,200 2,400 3,000 4,800 Fmt s Attachment 1 — Form 1 — Item XI — Map Carolina Power & Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant Buncombe County Page 1 of 2 June 2010 VW f,� �,,r,�J t,1 ;ti •- �.� 1, _ �� - gland •p .• +; 1`✓��, �. -�"� : �1 ��J �, �} Park �'}• �� r +' 4 � v N so aa -+ � -rt t ..� �•�.-. `� _ 1 >, .�0 • ' ;. �1 / �� set • -,; ' j `x 40 , ' Proposed relocation t of Outfall 001 —,.r '�``,` �� `: ••} /` �uni t o •aftheri ni an n + (, Outfall002 Outfall 001 i I 11 1 (� �� • �� \ r : • fit• - 1�, — • • \. a/IFf • ` . M 660 330 0 880 1,920 1,880 Fast s Attachment 1 — Form 1 — Item XI — Map Carolina Power & Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant Buncombe County Page 2 of 2 June 2010 Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 2 Form 2C Item II —A I- m- drawing for Flows, Sources of Pollution and Treatment Technologies 0 (D � 3 Q a 0. a) (D m CEv c = p O —> o 'CL m w 0_ O O U Y c U- '0 -- ►------------------------------------- l d [O0 llepno ;o - - - - -- -- _------------- - - - - -- > uoge�ola� pasoToid y }inn nnol; a�n ;n� 0 0 0 i >_ O 'cn a o CO a) — l 0 c o U i Q - (� C ,11 U C c OC N (B i N N N CID ` L 2 (0, LL O CL 7 m cn N cn J C>> E w > N co w m L U N E U LL co l N N > °' x CL - N Z, `O (T 3 m m c �- c - c w C N O N ! O U) N >. (0 a) m N U) C cn 'D _ N 4 CU Y (0 c cn O O Cl) O Q_ C Y � J O O —.2 L C c U J O CO 0) t U C Q a) _ (D d E c a) O /i' dm E c CD U > c w (W - - - - - i U o 0- :3 CIO UU 7 �U C C C a) U G :? U En CCU Q�� CL a O EL 3a? E o_ 00 X (D cli 0 CY) aO N N } tLA C: _ a) c � (n Q E Q Im > 3 U 0 (D � 3 Q a 0. a) (D m CEv c = p O —> o 'CL m w 0_ O O U Y n O m ,0 L > U � c LL :, c CIO J � w L C)- a�U c U- d >_ O 'cn a c o ,11 'O- N UrO N ` L (D U a cn J (n > N (A, w U N E c U06 LL co N N > °' x CL - `O (T 3 �- c - c w U) N >. cn 'D CU Y (0 C cn C c U 7 N a) _ (D d E c a) O /i' a) E a) U o 0- :3 CIO y V� CAI 7 G :? U O EL 3a? U X O a) — cu O UH Cn CIO > 3 v cm �' E m Cv �° a) c cn o in cn a) D- a��i' Cv i:� o .r CID V) N CIO rli (D U CU -) C U) n O m ,0 L > U � c LL :, c CIO J � w L C)- a�U Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, 'Inc. Asheville .Steam Electric Plant — NPDES Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 2 Form 2C - Item II -A Flow, Sources of Pollution, and Treatment Technologies Stream Name Average Flow Comments A Ash Pond Discharge 3 52 MGD Outfall 001 B Intake to Once- through Cooling & Circulating Water to Heat Exchangers 255 1 MGD C Plant Potable and Sanitary Uses 0.002 MGD From POTW D Makeup to Lake from River 2 68 MGD 2009 Average E Low Volume Wastes • Ash Hopper Seals • Sandbed Filter Backwash • Boiler Blowdown • Truck Wash • Water purification process waste streams 0 05 MGD 2600'Gal /event 0 006 MGD Variable variable Rare Usage Startup - Estimated F Circulating Water from Heat Exchangers 19 3 MGD ,Estimated G Ash Sluice Water 3 03 MGD Estimated H Dam Seepage 0 09 MGD Calculated I City Water Supply to Boiler Makeup 0 MGD Rare Usage J Coal Pile Runoff 0 01 MGD Based on Average Annual Rainfall-of 47" and 50 % Runoff K Storm Water 0 07 MGD Estimated L Chemical Metal Cleaning Wastes 0 - 90,000 Gallons (0 gallons anticipated) Normal Practice is Evaporation M Water From Combustion Turbine Facility Operation (Blade wash activities) 0 - 0 02 MGD Intermittent N From Lake to Intake 256 59 MGD Estimated O Intake to Service Water 0 05 MGD Estimated Q Fire,Protection Water 0 010,MGD Estimated R Air'Preheater Cleaning 10,000 gallon-s'/event Estimated S Discharge to Lake Julian 255 1 MGD T' Emergency Fire Protection Water 0 Used for firefighting Outfall 002 - Calculated U Diesel Fire Pump to Lake,Julian 0 -128 MG /week Estimate - pump testing V Flue Gas Desulfunzation Blowdown 0 086 MGD Calculated X Intake to FGD system 01 08 MGD Y Chloride Dilution Water 0 35 MGD z Constructed Wetland Discharge 0 376 MGD Outfall 005 AA Makeup water supply 22 Million gallons/ year Calculated Attachment 2 - form 2C - Item IIAFlows, Sources of Pollution, and Treatment Technologies Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a /Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc Asheville Steam Electric Plant Buncombe County June 2010 Page 2of 2 Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit, Number NC0000396 Attachment 3 Form 2C — Item II -13 Description of Flows, Sources of Pollution and Treatment Technologies Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 3 Form 2C - Item II -B Flow; Sources of Pollution, and Treatment Technologies The Asheville Steam Electric Plant is located in Arden, North Carolina south of Asheville, North Carolina The Asheville Steam Electric Plant is a coal - fired, steam cycle electric generating plant with two generating units Two Internal Combustion (IC) Turbines are also located on the plant site The plant has a 320 -acre cooling lake (Lake Julian) on the east side of the French Broad River in Buncombe County, North Carolina Chemical constituents contained in'the discharges from this plant will', in part be representative of °the naturally occurring chemical,quality of the intake, water and will also_ have, chemical constituents of such quality and quantity associated with similar discharges for fossil generating facilities of this size, type and in this geographical location Either all or part of the elements listed on the, Periodic Table, either singularly or in any combination, may from time to time be contained in the discharge J Outfall 001-- bischarge from Ash Pond to French Broad River The-Plant's ash ,pond (hereinafter;_referred to as -the 1982 ash pond), is- located east,of•the French Broad River; south of the, plant and discharges into the French Broad River The ash pond receives.ash sluice water, various low volume wastes, coal pile runoff, limestone pile runoff, gypsum pile runoff, air pre- heater cleaning water, fire protection system drainage, chemical metal cleaning wastes (potentially), storm water and other waters from the Combustion Turbine Facility on the Plant's site Wastewater from the plant's truck wash and, weigh stations also are directed to the plant's 1982-Ash Pond ,Accumulated water within the boundaries of the old ash pond (hereinafter referred to as the 1964 ash pond) may also from time to time be transferred to the 1982 pond The plantwill. also be considering installation of a reverse osmosis system to treat water for plant process uses ,Reject water from this plant process system will be sent,to the ash pond The pond provides treatment by sedimentation and neutralization to the above - referenced individual waste streams Water leaves the 1982 ash pond via a standpipe with skimmer and flows by pipe and lined ditch to a secondary basin, where it is discharged by overflow to a ditch that coveys it to the French Broad River Toe `'1 ^-� Carolina Power &- Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 drains from both the 1982 pond and the 1964 pond drain to the French Broad River Detailed descriptions of the individual Waste streams are below Ash Sluice Water Fly ash and bottom ash from both units are hydraulically conveyed by an ash sluice pipeline to the ash pond As needed, alum is added to the ash sluice influent to aid settling A Selective Catalytic Reduction system (SCR) is operated on both Unit 1 and Unit 2 for NOx emissions control Urea is injected to reduce NOx emissions A byproduct of this process is an "ammonia slip" which will be carried to the 1982 ash pond via ash sluice water As necessary, a system to mitigate SO3 emissions may also infect additional ammonia into't'he combustion, process This mitigation system has not been needed to date but, may become necessary as fuel sources change. Various boiler sediments and ash accumulations collected during maintenance activities may also be transported to the 1982 ash pond The ash pond discharge flows into the secondary settling pond where it combines with the FGD treated wastewater prior'to discharging to the French Broad River. Progress Energy plans to relocate this secondary settling pond and discharge point during the term of this permit to facilitate modifications designed to enhance the 1964 ash pond dam's safety factor Coal Pile Runoff Storm water runoff from the coal pile is collected in drainage ditches that surround the coal pile The drainage ditches are routed to the 1982 ash pond for1reatment During maintenance activities, sludges removed from catch basins, sumps,, etc may be, transported -to either the 1982 ash pond or°the 1964 ash pond for disposal_ Limestone and Gypsum Piles Runoff Storm water runoff from the limestone and gypsum piles is collected in drainage ditches which are routed to the 1982 ash pond for treatment During maintenance activities, sludges removed from catch basins, sumps, etc. may be transported to the 1964 ash pond and /or the 1982 ash pond for disposal Storm Water Storm water runoff from the plant area, parking lots, combustion turbine area, oil storage and handling facility and the plant's substations is routed to the ash ponds for treatment During 2 Carolina Power,& Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 maintenance activities, sludges removed from catch basins, sumps, etc may be transported to the 1964 ash pond and /or the 1.982 ash pond for disposal Low Volume Wastes Boiler water make up is withdrawn from Lake Julian and purified'utilhzing vendor supplied equipment Boiler water is treated with ammonia, hydrazine, and sodium hydroxide Boiler blowdown and drainage is sent to the ash pond and may contain small quantities of the chemicals. A new Reverse Osmosis system or alum coagulation /filtration service will be used in conjunction with the vendor supplied equipment -to provide water for various plant processes The reject stream from the Reverse osmosis unit will be sent to the 1982 ash pond Some molybdate waste'from the closed cooling water system is created through valve leakage and t maintenance activities -and is discharged to the 1982 ash pond A furnace ash hopper seal is maintained by using plant service water A standard operation water level is ,maintained' in' a seal trough for the ash hopper seal Overflow from this trough is discharged to the. 1982 ash - pond. A sodium hydroxide solution is fed into this flow stream as necessary for ash pond pH adjustment Sulfuric acid is fed to the ash sluice water as necessary for 1982 ash pond pH adjustment Coal dust suppression is achieved by spraying a propnetary chemical on coal at different stages ,of coal use Small amounts of excess dust suppression chemical have the potential to, be discharged to the, 1,982 ash pond via plant drains or coal pile runoff Small amounts of urea waste from bulk urea unloading operations are discharged to,the 19,82 ash pond All plant area floor drains are routed to the 1982 ash pond and include equipment drainage and wash down along with rainfall runoff During maintenance activities sludges removed from catch basins, sumps, etc may be transported to the 1982 ash pond and /or the 1964 ash pond for disposal In many cases,, added chemicals are consumed or chemically altered during the plant processes Only trace amounts might'be recoverable in water entering the 1982 ash pond Detectable levels of these chemicals would not be expected to occur in ash pond discharges Flue Gas Desulfunzation Blowdown (Low Volume Waste) The Flue Gas Desulfunzation (FGD) system directs flue gas into an absorber where a limestone (calcium carbonate) slurry is sprayed Sulfur dioxide in the flue gas reacts with the limestone to produce calcium sulfate (gypsum) This system reclaims any unreacted limestone slurry to be 3 Carolina Power & Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NG0000396 reused in the absorber A small blowdown stream is used to maintain the chloride concentration in the reaction tank The blowdown stream is passed through a clarifier to remove solids and the chloride concentration in the waste,stream is diluted using water from Lake Julian Chemicals are used to adjust pH and to aid solids removal in the clarifier A constructed wetland is used to remove metals, mercury and selenium specifically, and the, treated wastewater is discharged into the secondary settling pond Air Preheater Cleaning (Low Volume Waste) The air preheater will be water`washed once per year or more frequently as needed The wastewater from this activity will be discharged to the 1982 ash pond Chemical Metal Cleaning Wastes The boilers are chemically cleaned every five -to -eight years using Tetraammonia ethylene diamine tetraaccetic acid (EDTA)'solution This cleaning solution and its rinses are stored on site for disposal by evaporation in an operating unit's furnace Typical cleanings would result in awaste of approximately 80,000 gallons Should evaporation not be used, the wastewater can be treated by neutralization and precipitation prior to being conveyed to the 1964 ash pond, or to the 1982 ash pond, or other means- of disposal `Cleaning of other heat exchanger surfaces may produce 5,000- 10,000 gallons of wastewater every three -to -five years. Other Wastes Operation of the combustion turbine (CT) generation facility may produce turbine blade wash water, inlet filter cooling water, various' condensate waters, and water,from equipment ,and tank drains' These wastewaters will be collected in the storm water collection system of the CT site and routed to the 1982 ash pond During maintenance activities, sludges removed from catch basins, sumps, etc may be transported to the 1964 ash pond and /or the 1982 ash pond for disposal Plant Potable and Sanitary'System The supply of water for plant potable and sanitary use is obtained from the Asheville /Buncombe Water Authority system and waste from this system is discharged to the Metropolitan Sewage District System 4 Carolina Power & Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Herbicide and Pesticide Usage in the Treatment System,Ponds Herbicides may be used as needed to control nuisance aquatic vegetation These herbicides are applied by'licensed applicators, or persons under the, immediate supervision of a, licensed applicator, in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions Pesticides may be used as needed to perform biological assessments These Pesticides are applied by licensed applicators, or persons under the immediate supervision of a licensed applicator, in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions 230 KV Substation Storm Water Storm water runoff from the substation located adjacent to the plant is conveyed to the 1964 ash pond This water may be transferred to the 1982 ash pond as needed to maintain appropriate water levels in the 1,964 ash pond Outfall 002 - Discharge to,Lake Julian Once - Through Cooling Water This flow provides condenser cooling water for the generating units 1 and 2 Maximum condenser flows for units 1 and 2• are 150 MGD and 156 MGD, respectively Once - through cooling water{is used to supply non - contact cooling water for the component closed cooling water system The component closed cooling water system flows combine with unit 1 and 2 condenser flows prior to discharge to Lake Julian Maximum component closed cooling water system flows for unit 1 and 2 are 9 1 MGD and 10 2 MGD, respectively Discharge flow to Lake Julian is calculated at the intake to units 1 and 2 condensers and to the circulating water to'the heat exchanger, The discharge, of water from the heat exchangers is routed to an ash sump The majority of thiswater,is further routed to the discharge of units 1 and 2 condensers Less than one percent of the flow to the ash sump is used to supply ash sluice water, preheater cleaning water, and fire protection water Control of biological fouling on heat- exchanger,surfaces is accomplished by addition of sodium hypochlorite as required, which is usually less that 2 hours per day per unit, with a net total residual chlorine,of less,than 0 2 ppm discharged during that period Cooling is accomplished by evaporation from the surface of Lake Julian and mixing and convection with lake waters Make up for Lake Julian is from the French Broad River, natural runoff and creek flows Water 5 Carolina Power & Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 is pumped from the French, Broad River during dry periods to supplement the flow Although discharge from Lake Julian to the river is extremely rare, any occurrence would be during periods of heavy rainfall. Herbicide and Pesticide Usage in the'T'reatment System Ponds Herbicides may be used as needed to control nuisance aquatic vegetation These herbicides are applied by licensed applicators, or persons under the immediate supervision of a licensed applicator, in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions Pesticides may be used as needed to perform ,biological assessments- These Pesticides are applied by licensed applicators, ,or persons under the'immediate supervision of a licensed applicator, in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions N Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 4 Form 2C — Item'VI Potential Discharges Not Covered by Analysis Carolina Power & Light Company d %b /a Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 4 Form 2C -'Item VI - Potential Discharges Not Covered By Analysis Chemical Estimated Quantity Frequency Purpose Used er ear Hydrazine (35 %) 1840 lb /yr Continuous Oxygen scavenger in _ boiler Ammonium hydroxide. 2730 1-b./yr. Continuous pH control of boiler water _ Sodium hydroxide 141,139 lb /yr Continuous pH control of ash pond 25 Sodium hydroxide 30 gallons As required pH control of boiler 50% _ _ water Sodium hypochlorite 91,072 lb /yr As required Control of biological (1a5 %) fouling on, heat exchangers Sodium molybdate 100 pounds As required Corrosion control in closed cooling water system Tetraammonia EDTA 35,000 pounds Every 5 to 8 years Boiler cleaning (38,% Urea (50 %) 7365 tons /yr Continuous during NOx control high ozone months Sulfuric acid (93 %) Variable As needed pH control of ash pond BetzDearborn Dustreat 11,400 pounds - As,required Coal dust suppression - DC9136 estimated proprietary chemical Fyrewash (detergent) 200 gallons As needed Combustion turbine blade washing Detergents /cleaning Variable As needed Housekeeping agents _ Limestone ,(Calcium 21,944 tons /yr Continuous Flue Gas carbonate Desulfurization Polymer (high weight, 3255 lb /yr Continuous Solids removal — FGD anionic, emulsion-type) wastewater Coagulant (Ferric .3060 lb /yr Continuous Solids removal — FGD chloride — 41 % ) wastewater Sodium Hydroxide 17600 lb./yr. Continuous pH ,adjustment — FGD 25% wastewater Hydrochlonc.Acid 400 gallons - Continuous pH adjustment- FGD 30% estimated wastewater Magnesium Hydroxide Variable Continuous Applied to coal for slag control Aluminum Sulfate 25 %- variable _ As required Water treatment 50% , ,Alum processes, TSS control Carolina Power & Light Company Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number, NC0000396 Sumachlor 50 As needed Coagulant for water treatment filter 'MIT7602 (Organic As needed R �O Anti - scalant Polymer) _ _ 50% Caustic Variable for R O pH As needed for pH R O pH adjustment adjustment adjustment and 1'000 gallons for Periodic Typically 4 /yr R O cleaning per for R O cleaning R O cleaning event Hydroclonc Acid 1000 gallons /event Periodic Typically 4 /yr R O membrane cleaning Citric adid 1000 gallons /event Periodic-Typically 4 /yr R O membrane cleaning Trilon B (EDTA) 1000 gallons /event Periodic Typically 4 /yr R -O cleaning ROClean P911 1000 gallons /event Periodic Typically 4 /yr R O cleaning Bisulfite (sodium As needed R O layup bisulfate 600 gallo ns /event Alkyl alcohol Variable As needed Freeze conditioning agent Propylene Glycol Variable As needed Freeze conditioning agent Calcium Chloride Variable As needed Freeze conditioning agent Diethylene glycol Variable As needed Freeze conditioning ,agent Glycerin variable As needed Freeze conditioning agent Fertilizer Variable As needed- Wetland treatment cell - lant mana ement Pelletized Lime Variable As needed Wetland treatment cell plant management Rev April 2010 Mar, 16. 2010 1: 48PM ,USGS science 1(ar a c�iang /n� wror►d No, 2668 N. 1 ❑ Not applicable '% S keW-� VIi4 Fax to. &0) Date: /�'�o -r44 Il ;2"0 /0 Subject: / Comments: AA .. s A Oukk note firom: J. Curtis Weever, P.E. Hydrologist (Civil Rng) joweaver@usgs.gov http: / /nc.water.usge.gov/ U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey 391 8u nset ° Ridge ° Road Raleigh, NC 27607 (919) 571 -4043 (919) 5714041 FAX Mar. 16. 2010 1: 48PM No. 2668 N. 2 Request No: l/ Site No: Stromflow Conditions: LOGIN n GINSIATED 'A REQUEST ?OR WATER°SMLY STATIS=CS Station No. -Type Station 20 Data Index , Station Name , YM4,4;•+ 13f60 Location A4 IVC /y6 wtA - o-r Sk,,lw.,J - - -- Lat. 3S °.Z` ", Long 2 ® 3V 2 V", Basis. Xre-v e l�ro l� %vim S ky 1-*4 Qaad No. E, Coaaty Ne JePso,^ a 91 State _ District V? HQC G2 G d I d C p• . N�CD d y- U," U., D =aivage Aran . Average Discharge. &atimated, using, . �? cfsm. w+ i."7 4!_G� cis. (�) Ki namom Di.schaxp., " Min. day ? Q -year rscu:rreaca interval of sir;. cfs• Dirt. -& day s -year recamnce' intarval- q5I �f sm. t3lets. " VR z Min. 'I dap � -yank recu =Ce interva].� �. y��fS � (A� l� �i a.�? dsy "�• °year' recurrence' interval, �fsm. '�3 legs. (A) ,PceMd /7rCM-j liver av Ale-leAc` ai T s�� a� Sfr River at D.A. sq mi.. Type_..- Creek near Rive K mi• Type Creek• sear loiter Transmitted by comp. to S"90-- Computed by - C W date, �.' 10 • D y ...,». Checked Jr- W dazte� 4, 1�1C D � Q Ravi.emed by .� date Z- 2r✓� -G�i . Remarb�s a ; . • ., , 0.3 OA � 0-7: �7-7 (. V -04) (a) Estimate is basal oat records ected at or (near the site. (b) Estimate is based entirely an runoff observed at nearby streams. (a) Estimata based an pmeadnres ,Sivea j*' OPen-FL14 Repoi't 90 -399 '1'LovF7ow Charaeteri atics of Streams in 'North Carolina's' (d) Estimte based on procedureo given ira Open -File Report. 90 -399 and in =Mjuetion vith records collected at or sea the site. n r 'A Ma r, 1,6. 2,010 1: 49,PM No. 2668 N, 3 United States Department of the Interior . ID U.S., GEOLOGICALSURVEY 391GSunset Ridge Road Raleigh, North Carolina 27607 February 23, 2004 Ms. Susan A. Wilson, Environmgntal Engineer N.C. Division of Water Quality, NFDES Unit 1617 Mail Service Center Raleigh, North Carolina 27699 -1617 Dear Ms. Wilson: In response to your request for low -flow data, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) does not have site - specific, low -flow discharge data for French Broad River at NC'280 near Skyland, NC (station id 03447840, drainage area 660 m12): The low -flow characteristics that are pro- vided on the attached sheet have been computed by correlating the runoff characteristics of a nearby continuous - record gaging station upstream of the request site., Please note that the.flow, estimates do not- specifically account.for the presence of any diversions. or regulation, present or future, which may occur upstream of the request site. Because afsimilar request for the 1Q10 low -flow discharge was received about.the3 same time from Progress Energy, this, low» flow statistic is included on the attached sheet. Low -flow characteristics were analyzed using streamflow records from a continuous - record gaging station on the'French Broad River near Fletcher, operated since July 2001 and located upstream at Secondary'Road 1419 (station id 03447840, drainage area 640 m12). Because of the short period of record at the Pletcher gage, low -flow analyses at this gage were completed by correlation analyses using two' other gaging stations having Wong periods, oftecord (station id's 03443000 and 03451500). 'Shen, using the difference in drainage areas between the request site,and,the K, etcher gage, low -flow characteristics at the- request location were deter- mined using the low -flow yields' (expressed,as flow per square mile drainage, area) at the Pletcher gage. The estimated 7Q10 discharge is 306 W/s and is lower than the estimate pro- vided to `you in an e-mail dated January 14, 2004. Analyses of `low -flow characteristics at all three gaging stations indicates 'a decreasing, trend in low -flow yields between the gages -at Blantyre and Asheville. Between these two locations, thexiver is affected by some diversions occurring4n tributaries along with regulation by small upstream reservoirs and a power plant located about 8 miles upstream of,Blantym The anal- yses indicate that most of the decrease in low -flow yields occurs between the Blantyre and Fletcher gages. The table shown on the accompanying page summarizes the low-flow characteristics at the gaging stations used in the analyses. As previously discussed in January, the French,Broad River downstream from3lantyft is affected by some'regulation and diversions. The low -flow discharge values are baked on stream,flow records available through September 2003, and the associated low-flow yields for each value is listed to provide insight in the changing low -flow yields between the gages, (919) 571 -M - FAX (919) 571-4041 Ma r, 16. 2010 1; 4'9 PM No. 2 6U N. 4 Ms. Susan A. Wilson Page 2 February 10, 2004 These data are preliinivary and' subject to revision pending approval for publication by the Director of the U.S. Geological Survey, and are made available, through our cooperative ,pro- gram' of water�resources investigations with `the forth Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources. if you have any questions regarding this information, please, contact, us at (919) 571 -4000. Sincerely, . Curtis Weaver Hydrologist Enclosure r: Lovwflaw charactsrlstics � (Bela) swon name m � ®° r a ki, , 03443400 Fnrach Broad River at Bla Vts (Secondary Road 1503, Henderson County) Z96 3.3 197 (0.666) 375 (1:267) 232 (0.851) 316 (1.068) 43447687` French Broad River aear Fletcher (Secondary Road,1419, Buncombe Coanty) 640 2:7 ' 297 (0.463) 613 (0.957) 397 (0.620) 515 (0 .'804) M4415001'rewh Broad River at AsiwyU1e (Secondary'Road 1348, Buncombe County) 945 12 425 (0.450) 833 (0.882) 563 (0.5M 720 (0.762) These data are preliinivary and' subject to revision pending approval for publication by the Director of the U.S. Geological Survey, and are made available, through our cooperative ,pro- gram' of water�resources investigations with `the forth Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources. if you have any questions regarding this information, please, contact, us at (919) 571 -4000. Sincerely, . Curtis Weaver Hydrologist Enclosure Mar, 16. 2010 1:49NM No. 2666 N. 5 REQUEST'NO -,,- 91623 SITE °NO :,_ �01 DATE:. 02/10/2004_ SOURCE: DPNR fDWO) ACTION: Now STATION NUMBER: 09447,84_ STATION TYPE: Un agId (20) STATION NAME: _ Frepch Broad giverat NC 280 near Wland. NC LOCA'T'ION: At NC' ,Lon ,-Sh 'd e " 2 miles w - _ 'S- lan LATITUDE: 35028'53" LONGrME: 810 QUANDRANGLE:NAME AND °NUMBER: Sialand ELM COUNTY CODE: „ Henderson _10891 STATE CODE: NC r371—DISTRICT CODE: _ _ NC 33711 wmROLOGIC UNIT CODE: 06010105 _ ENR BASIN CODE: - -03-02 DRAINAGE AREA: 66L®12 Flow statistics as follows: AVERAGE FLOW: Estimated using 2.70, ft3/S/mi2 1,780 fe/$ We note f A ANNUAL 7Q10:M[Egl l%IUM FLOW: 0,4634 ft3 /s/mi" 306 /$ see note r A� ANNUAL 30Q2 MINIMUM FLOW: 0.9570 fp/shnIa 631 ft% seemote U WINTER 7Q10 MITTIMUM FLOW: 0,6198 W /slmZ 409 WIS see note f ANNUAL 7Q2 MINIMUM FLOW: 0.8041 fe/shop 531 fe /$ see note U ,OT HER FLOWN,(specifY): �10I0_ 0,4258 ft3 /.s/mi2 282 �!s see note � NOTES: [A] Estimate is based on records collected at or near the' request site. [B] Estimate is based entirely on runoff characterWcs observed at nearby;streams. r [C] Estimate,based on procedures given in USGS Water Supply Paper ?403 "Low -flow Characteristles of Streams in North Carollbi'o (Giese and Mason, 1993). [1D] Estimate based on procedux" given in USGS Water Supply Paper 2403 and in conjunction with streamflow records collected at or near the request site. ,[E] See remarks. These data are,considered provisional and subject to revision,pending approval by the Director, USGS. REMARKS: • Low -flow estimates based on low -flow characteristios upstream gaging station 03447687 (French Broad River near Fletcher),during 7uly'2001 through September 2003, 1Q10 flow requested by Progress Energy- ,,,Requested by Ms. Susan Wilson, N.C. Division of Water Quality ll Ms. Louise,England, Progress Energy ENTERED BY:_ TCW FEE CAGED: $ 150 — Ma r. 16. 2010 1: OPM No, 2668 P. 6 United 'States Department of the Interior U.S; GEOLoGICAL SURVEY 396 Sunset Ridge.Roid Raleigh, North Carolina 27607 February 23, 2004 Ms, Louise,England, Senior Environmental Specialist Progress Energy - IMC 3932 New Hill - Hoileman`Road New Hill, North Carolina 27562 Dear Ms. England: In,response to your,request for low -flow data, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) does not have site - specific, low -flow diicharge'data,for French Broad River at NC 280 near Slcylaud,,NC (station id 03447840, drainage area 660 mi ), The low -flow characteristics,that M- Provided,on the attached sheet,have been computed by correlating the runoff characteristics of a nearby continuous- record gaging�station,upstream'of the request'sits.. Please note that the flow estimates do not specifically account for thepresence of any diversions or regulation, present or future, which may occur upstream of the request site. Because your request was received about the same time,as a similar request -from the N.C. Division of Water Quality (DWQ), the low- flow'statistics esti- mated for the DWQ are included on the attached sheet. Low -flow characteristics were analyzed using streamflow records from a continuous- record gaging station on the French Broad River near Fletcher,, operated since July 2001 and located upstra= at Secondary Road 1419 (station id 03447840,,drainage area 640 M12)• Because °of the short period of record at the Fletcher gage,,low- flow,anal'yses at,this gage were completed by correlationanalysesusing -two ofher gaging stations having long periods of,record (station4d's 03443000 and 03451500). Then, using the difference in drainage areas between the request site and the Fletcher gage, low -flow characteristics at the request location were determined using the low -flow yields (expressed as flow per square mule drainage area) at the Fletcher gage, The estimated 1Q10 discharge is 282 fP/s-and is lower than the,estimated 7Q10 discharge. of306 f13 /s. Analyses of low- flowcharacteristics at all three gaging stations indicates,% decreasing trend inlow -flow yields between the gages at Blantyre and Asheville. Between these two locations, the river is affected by some diver- aions occurring in tributaries along with,regulation by small upstream reservoirs and a power plant located about 8'miles upstream of Blantyre. The analyses,indicate that most of the decrease in low -flow yields occurs between the Blantyre and Fletcher gages. A charge for accessing and processing information has boon assessed to`partially offset these•costs. Your requested data and an invoice covering,processing costs for these data are enclosed. Please forward the orig- inal bill with your check to the U.S. Geological Survey, 12201 Sunrise Valley Drive, MS 271-, Reston, Virginia 20192. These data are preliminary and subject to revision pending approval for publication by the Director of the U•S- Geological Survey,,and are made available through our cooperative,program of water - resources investigations with the North Carolina,Department of Environmentland Natural Resources. If you have any questions regarding this information, please contact us at (919) 571 -4000• Enclosures Sincere%ly %, , h Curtis Weaver drologist (919),571.4000• FAX (919) 5714041 Ma r. l b. 1U I U I :M-FM No. 1668 N. �ii1�"'S"AItY OF LAM OW ESTIMAM IN RESPONSE TD RE UEST REQUEST NO: , 1� SITE NO: 01 _ DATE: - 2/10/200 SOURCE..- - DEN . W'O) _ACTION: Now - STA'nON NUMBER: 0344784 STATION TYPE: Ungaged (20) STATION NAME: French Broad River at NC 280 near Skyland. NC LOCATION: -, At NC 8�g,Sh alb a brid je_). and 2 miles west of SIDL14nd- L-A7TI`UDE--' 35019'53" LONGITUYDE: Or 3128" _ QUANDRANGLE NAME AND NUMBER: Sky d M-8 -Mj COUNTY CODE: 'Henderson T0891 ,STA'T'E CODE: NC f37) DISTRICT CODE: NC ( 7„ 1 HYDROLOGIC UNIT CODE: _ 06010105 ENR BASIN CODE: 04 -0302 _ DRAINAGE AREA: 660 —mil Flow statistics 'as follows: AVERAGE FLOWN Estimated using 2.70 fp/s,/omiz 1,780 ft31s see note --A ANNUAL 7Q10 MINIMUM FLOW: 0.4634 ft3 /s/mi2 306 Vis seezote Lam, ANNUAL 30Q2 MINIMUM FLOW: 0.9570 fe/shni2 631 ft 3/9 see note LAJ WINTER 7Q10 MINIMUM.FLOW: 0.6198 f0/s/m12 409 0/$ see note I A ANNUAL 7Q2 MINIMUM FLOW: 0.8041 ft/ 2' 531 1ft3 /s see,note F A OTHER FLOW (specify): ^101 0,4258 ft%/W2 `282 fe /s see note r A Q • :+ [A) Estimate is based,on records collected „at or`near the request site. [B] Estimate is based entirely on runoff characteristics observed at nearby streams. [C) Estimate based on procedures given in USGS Water,Supply Paper 2403 "Low -flow Characteristics of,Streams,in North Carolina” (Giese and.Masons 190. [D]'Estlmate based on procedures given in USGS Water Supply Paper 2403 and in,conjunctiou with streamflow records collected at or near the request site. [E] See remarks. These data are considered provisional and subject to revision pending approval by, tilt Director, USGS. REMARKS; Low -flow estimates based on low -flow characteristics upstream gaging station 03447687 (Freach Broad River near Fletcher) during July 2001 through september 2003. 1Q10 flow requested by Progress Energy. Requested by Ms. Susan Wilson, KC. Division of Water, Quality # Ms. Louise England, Progress Energy ENTERED BY: I'LW FEE CHARGED: $ 150 Carolina Power & Light Company d /b /a Progress Energy,Carolinas, Inc. Asheville Steam Electric Plant National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit Number NC0000396 Attachment 9 Proposed conceptual relocation route of outfall 001 Proposed relocation of outfal 001 In order to facilitate enhancements to the 1964 ash ,pond -dam,, it will be necessary to relocate'the existing settling basin and discharge outfall 001. The Asheville Steam Electric Plant is located in close proximity to the French Broad River but has limited access to the river,because of Interstate 26. In order to relocate, outfall 001, it will be necessary to go north approximately 3000 feet to a point where existing access under the Interstate is located. This proposed discharge location is on property owned by Progress Energy The entire span of property between the existing outfall and the proposed outfall is also owned by Progress Energy. In addition to the current °flows from the 1982 ash pond, a "new" flow will be added to the relocated outfall. This flow will consists of stormwater and ground water, seepage that currently'flows into the 1964 ash pond. H tsi cas flow has been allowed to evaporate and /or infiltrate. The enhancements to the 1964 pond require that this water level be managed and maintained below a certain elevation. 'Therefore, it may °be necessary to periodically pump water from the 1964 ash pond to the combined, relocated settling basin and outfall 001 A sample of the water from the 1964 ash pond was taken as part of the preparation of this application Results from that sampling analysis are attached. a) P L) U 13) _0 _0 0 a) 0- 0 (3) bio c cr- 06 L N E _0 0 u 0 : fU 4- ro bjO L- 4- 4� co a) C: (1) CLO cl a) 4- Ln C) a) P L) U 13) _0 .r_ L) 0 a) 0- 0 (3) (A M cr- 06 L N E _0 u 0 : fU co a) C: C) x 0 bb uo -0 U L- m to W -C u S -2 -C u Z 0 z < 0 w T Ln rl N ro d Ln -1, +1 4 i (� IaceAnalytkal wwwpacelabxcwn April 23, 2010 Ms Crystal Diedrich Progress Energy 200 CP &L Drive Arden, NC 28704 RE Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project No 9267173 Dear Ms Diedrich Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225 Riverside'Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 Pace Analytical Services, Inc 9800'KinceyAve Suite 100 Huntersville, NC 28078 Enclosed are the analytical results for'sample(s) received by the laboratory on April 12, 2010 The results relate only to the samples included in this report Results reported herein conform to the most current NELAC standards, where applicable, unless otherwise, narrated in the body of the report Inorganic Wet Chemistry and Metals analyses were performed at our Pace Asheville laboratory and Organic testing was performed at�our Pace Huntersville laboratory unless otherwise footnoted All Microbiological analyses were performed at the laboratory where the samples were received If you have any questions concerning this report, please feel free to contact me Sincerely; C: X 0. 7 Lorn Patton torn' patton@pacelabs com Project Manager Enclosures REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc (704)875 =9092 Page 1 of 14 aceAnaljftal wwwpaoefab&com Project DUCK POND 04/12 ,Pace Project No 9267173 Asheville Certification IDs 2225 Riverside Dr Asheville, NC 28804 Connecticut Certification # PH -0106 Virginia Certification # 00072 Tennessee Certification # 2980 South Carolina Certification # 99030001 South.Carohna Bioassay Certification #,99030002 Pennsylvania Certification #,68-03578 North,Carolina Wastewater Certification# 40 Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225 Riverside Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 CERTIFICATIONS North Carolina Drinking Water Certification # 37712 North Carolina Bioassay Certification # 9 New Jersey Certification # NC011 Massachusetts Certification # M -NC030 LOWSIana/LELAP Certification # 03095 Florida /NELAP Certification # E87648 West Virginia Certification# 356 REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This,report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of'Pace Analytical Services, Inc //1C1CGpy� Pace Analytical Services, Inc 9800 Kincey Ave Suite 100 Huntersville, NC 28078 (704)875 -9092 Page 2 of 14 aceAnalytical wwwpaoelaftcarn Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project No 9267173 Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225 Riverside Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 SAMPLE ANALYTE COUNT Pace Analytical Services, Inc, 9800 Kincey Ave Suite 100 Huntersvtlle, NV28078 (704)875 -9092 REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not beireproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc Page 3,of 14 Analytes Lab ID Sample ID Method Analysts Reported Laboratory 9267173001 DUCK POND EPA 200 7 JMW 11 PASI -A EPA 245 1 SHB 1 PASI7A SM 5210B JDA 1 PAST -A 40CFWPART 503 SAJ 1 PAST -A EPA 351 2 EWS 1 PASI -A EPA 353 2 JDA 1 PASI -A EPA 365 1 JDA 1 PAST -A SW 5220D LEP 1 PASI -A REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not beireproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc Page 3,of 14 aceAnalytical wwwpeoelabstwm Project DUCK POND,04 /12 Pace Project No' 9267173 Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225 Riverside Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 ANALYTICAL RESULTS Pace Analytical Services, Inc 9800 KinceyAve , Suite 100 Huntersville, NC 28078 (704)875 -9092 Sample- DUCKPOND Lab,ID: 9267173001 Collected 04/121100906 Received 04/12/101240 Matrix Water Parameters Results Units Report Limit DF Prepa"red Analyzed CAS No Qual 200.7 MET ICP Analytical Method, EPA 200 7 Preparation Method EPA 200 7 Antimony ND ug /L 100 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19/10 12 28 7440 -36 -0 D3 Arsenic ND ug /L 100 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19%1612 28 7440 -38`2 D3 Beryllium ND ,ug /L 20 2 04/15/10 17 00 04119/10 12 28 7440 -41 -7 D3 Cadmium, ND ug /L 20 2 04/15/10 177 00 04/19/10 12 28 7440 =43 -9 D3 Chromium ND ug /L 100 2 04/15/101 - 7 00 04/19/10 12 28 7440 -47 -3 D3 Lead ND ug /L 100 2 04/15/10 1,, 00 04/19/10 12 28 7439 -92 -1 D3 Nickel 29.6 ug /L 100 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19/10 12 28 7440 -02 -0 D3 Selenium 21.4 ug /L 200 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19/10 12 28 7782 -49 -2 D3 Silver ND ug /L 100 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19/10 12 28 7440 -22 -4 D3 Thallium ND ug /L 200 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19/10 12 28 7440 -28 -0 D3 Zinc 37.6 ug /L 20,0 2 04/15/10 17 00 04/19/10 12 -28 7440 -66 -6 D3 245.1 Mercury Analytical Method EPA2451 Preparation Method EPA 245 1 Mercury ND ug /L 020 1 04/16/10 10 55, 04/16/10 18 01 7439 -97 -6 5210B,BOD, 5 day Analytical Method SM 5210B BOD, 5 day ND mg /L 2'0 1 04/13/1017 30 04/18/,10 14 50 B2 Total Nitrogen Calculation Analytical Method 40CFR PART 503 Nitrogen 0 73 mg /L 060 1 04/21/10'15 25 7727 -37 -9 351.2 Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen Analytical Method EPA 351 2 Nitrogen, Kjeldahl, Total 0.66 mg /L 050 1 04/22/10 13 30 7727 -37 -9 353 2 Nitrogen, NO2 /NO3 pros. Analytical Method EPA-353 2 Nitrogen,, NO2, plus NO3' ND mg /L 010 1 04/19/10 11 28 365.1 Phosphorus, Total Analytical Method EPA 365 1 Phosphorus ND mg /L 010 1 04/18/1011 33 7723 -14 -0 5220D COD Analytical Method SM 5220D Chemical Oxygen Demand ND mg /L 25`0 1 04/14/10 16 46 Date 04/23/2010 03 48 PM REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shalrnot be reproduced,, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc ,a,,„ •ccuyo �L ,_ Page 4 of 14 ® Pace Analytical Services, Inc aceAnalXical 2225 Riverside Dr w,N,pa��� Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 QUALITY CONTROL DATA Project DUCK POND,04 /12 429216 Units Spike Conc LCS Result Pace Project No 9267173 % Rec Limits Qualifiers Antimony ug /L 500 QC Batch MPRP /6150 95 Analysis Method EPA'2007 'QC Batch Method EPA 200 7 500 Analysis Description 200 T MET Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 Beryllium ug /L 500 METHOD BLANK 429215 99 Matrix Water Cadmium ug /L Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 479 96 85 -115 Chromium ug /L Blank Reporting 483 Parameter Units Result Limit ug /L Analyzed Qualifiers ,Antimony ug /L ND 50 04/16/10 17 25' Arsenic ug /L ND 50 04/16/1017 25 Beryllium ug /L ND 1 0 04/16/10 17 25 Cadmium ug /L ND 1 0 04/16/10 17 25 Chromium ug /L ND 56 04116/10 17 25 Lead ug /L ND 5 0 04/16/10 17 25 Nickel ug /L ND 5 0 04/16/10 17 25 Selenium ug /L ND 100 04/16/10 17 25 Silver ug /L ND 50 04/16/10 17 25 Thallium ug /L ND 100 04/16/1017 25 Zinc ug /L ND 100 '04/16/10 1,7 25 Pace Analytical Services, Inc 9800'Kincey Ave Suite 100 Hunterswile „NC 28078 (704)875 -9092 LABORATORY CONTROL SAMPLE” Parameter 429216 Units Spike Conc LCS Result LCS % Rec % Rec Limits Qualifiers Antimony ug /L 500 474 95 85 -115 Arsenic ug /L 500 480 96 85 -115 Beryllium ug /L 500 496 99 85 -115 Cadmium ug /L 500 479 96 85 -115 Chromium ug /L 500 483 97 85 -115 Lead ug /L '500 486 97 85 -115 Nickel ug /L 500 482 96 85 -115 Selenium ug /L_ 500 480 96 85 -115 Silver ug /L 250 224 90 85 -115 Thallium ug /L 500 468 94 85 -115 Zinc ug /L 500 490 98 85 -115 MATRIX SPIKE & MATRIX SPIKE,DUPLICATE 429217 429218, MS MSD 9267053001 Spike Spike MS MSD MS MSD % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Conc Result Result % Rec %' Rec Limits RPD Qual Antimony ug /L ND 500 500 491 488, 97 97 70 -130 1 Arsenic ug /L 00080 500 500 510 507 100 100 70 -130 1 mg /L Beryllium ug /L ND 500 500 503 499 101 100 70 -130 1 Cadmium ug /L 00013 500 500 476 474 95 95 70 -130 0 mg /L Chromium ug /L 0 034 500 500 519 514 97 96 70 -130 1 mg /L Lead ug /L 0 034' 500 500 511 506 95 94 70 -130 1 mg /L Date 04/23/2010 03 48 PM REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS Page 5 of'14 This report shall not,be reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc AO ® Pace Analytical Services, Inc Ma�ytical 2225 Riverside Dr wwwpacab68com Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 c. QUALITY CONTROL DATA Pace Analytical Services, Inc 9800 Kincey Ave Suite 100 'H u nterswlle,,N C`28078 (704)875 -9092 Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project No 9267173 MATRIX SPIKE &'MATRIX 'SPIKE DUPLICATE 429217 429218 MS MSD 9267053001 Spike Spike MS MSD MS MSD % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Conc Result Result % Rec % Rec Limits RPD Qual Nickel ug /L 053, 500 500 1010 987 95 91 70 -130 2 mg /L Selenium ug /L ND 500 500 489 480 98 96 70 -130 2 Silver ug /L ND 250 250 225 224 90 89 70 -130 0 Thallium ug %L ND 500 500 429 429 86 86 70 -130 0 Zinc ug /L 43 500 500 4790 4810 93 98 70 -130 0 mg%L SAMPLE DUPLICATE 429219 9266960001 Dup Parameter Units Result Result RPD Qualifiers Antimony ug /L 875 900 3 Arsenic ug /L 258 280 9 Beryllium ug /L 264 285 8 Cadmium ug /L 187 204 9 Chromium ug /L 1310 1400 7 Lead ug /L 3460 3500 1 Nickel ug /L 1260 1380 9 Selenium ug /L 193 195' 1 Silver ug /L 171 195 13 Thallium ug /L ND 28 6J Zinc ug /L 126000 138000, 9 Date 04/23/2010 03 48'PM REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc Page�6 of 14 I eAnalyfical wwwpawlaftcom Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project No 9267173 QC Batch MERP 12765 QC Batch Method EPA 245 1 Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 METHOD BLANK 428949 Associatedlab Samples 9267173001 Parameter Units ug /L Mercury Pace Analytical, Services;lnc Pace Analyticaf Services, Inc 2225 Riverside,Dr 9800 KinceyAve Surte 100 Asheville, NC 28804 Huntersville, NC 28078 (828)254 -7176 (704)875 -9092 QUALITY CONTROL DATA Analysis,Method EPA 2451 Ana lysis'Descnption 245 1 Mercury, Matrix Water Blank Reporting Result Limit Analyzed Qualifiers ND 0 20 04/16/10 21 21 LABORATORY CONTROL,SAMPLE 428950 Spike LCS LCS % Rec Parameter Units Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Mercury ug /L 25 25 100 85 -115 MATRIX SPIKE & MATRIX -SPIKE DUPLICATE- 428951 428952 MS MSD 9267110001 Spike Spike MS MSD MS MSD % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Conc Result Result % Rec % Rec Limits RPD Qual Mercury ug /L ND 25 25 ND 25 -2 97 70 -130 MO SAMPLE DUPLICATE 428953 Parameter Mercury Date 04/23/2010 03 48 PM 9267173001 Dup Units Result Result ug /L ND ND RPD Qualifiers REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be reproduced, except in',full, without the,written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc gnrrYY��«o,o. Page 7 of 14 aceAnalytical .pacelabs.com Project DUCK POND 04112 Pace Project No 9267173 QC Batch WET /12044 QC Batch Method SM 5210B Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 METHOD BLANK 428123 Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 Parameter Units BOD, 5 day mg /L LABORATORY CONTROL SAMPLE 428124 Parameter Units BOD, 5 day mg /L SAMPLE DUPLICATE 428137 Parameter Units BOD, 5 day mg /L Date ;04/23/2010 03 48 PM Pace Analytical Services, Inc Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225, Riverside' Dr 9800 KmceyAve Suite 100 Asheville, NC 28804 Hunterswlle, NC 28078 (828)254 -7176 (704)875 -9092 QUALITY CONTROL DATA Analysis Method SM 5210B Analysis Description 521-013WD „5,day Matrix Water Blank Reporting Result Limit Analyzed Qualifiers ND 2 0 04/18/10 14 50 Spike LCS L'CS % Rec Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers 198 174 88 84 -115 9267206001 Dup Result Result 1370 1370 RPD Qualifiers 0 REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc Page 8 of 14 aceAnalytical wwwpacelabs corn Project' DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project No 9267173 QC Batch WETA17196 QC Batch Method EPA 351 2 Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 METHOD BLANK 431150 Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 Parameter Units Nitrogen, Kjeldahl, Total mg /L LABORATORY CONTROL SAMPLE 431151 Parameter Units Nitrogen, Kjeldahl, Total mg /L MATRIkSPIKE'�SAMPLE 431152 Parameter Units Nitrogen, Kjeldahl', Total mg /L SAMPLE DUPLICATE 431153 Parameter Units Nitrogen, Kjeldahl, Total mg /L Date 04/23/2010 03 48 PM Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225'Riverside Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 QUALITY CONTROL DATA Analysis Method EPA 351 2 Analysis Description 351 2 TKN Matrix Water Blank Reporting Result Limit Analyzed Qualifiers ND 0 50 04/22/10 13 27 Pace Analytical Services, Inc 9800 IGncey Ave Suite 100 Huntersville, NC 28078 (704)875 -9092 Spike LCS LCS % Rec Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers 5 52 105 90 -110 9266978001 Spike Result Conc 60 5 9267173001 Dup Result Result 066 1 6 MS MS Result % Rec 97 74 RPD Qualifiers '82 R1 ,REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report'shall not'be reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc % Rec Limits Qualifiers 90 -110 Mo Page 9'of 14 ® Pace Analytical Services, Inc Pace Analytical Services, Inc aceMalXical 2225 Riverside Dr 9800 Kincey Ave Suite 100 wwwpacelabacam Asheville, NC 28804 Huntersville, NC 28078 QUALITY CONTROL DATA (828)254 -7176 (704)875 -9092 Protect DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project No 9267173 QC Batch WETA17183 Analysis Method EPA 353 2 QC Batch Method EPA 353 2 Analysis Description 353 2 Nitrate + Nitnte; preserved Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 METHOD BLANK 430324 Matrix Water Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 Blank Reporting Parameter Units Result Limit Analyzed Qualifiers Nitrogen, NO2 plus NO3 mg /L ND 0 10 04/18110 10 32 LABORATORY CONTROL SAMPLE 430325 Spike LCS LCS % Rec Parameter Units Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Nitrogen, NO2 plus NO3 mg /L 5 5'1 102 90 -110 MATRIX SPIKE SAMPLE 430326 9266802001 Spike MS MS % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Nitrogen, NO2 plus NO3 mg /L 041 5 52 96 75 -125 MATRIX'SPIKE SAMPLE 430328 9267367005 Spike MS MS % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Nitrogen, NO2 plus NO3 mg /L 76 5 11 7 81 75 -125 SAMPLE DUPLICATE 430327 9266805001 Dup Parameter Units Result Result RPD Qualifiers Nitrogen, NO2 plus NO3 mg /L 046 046 2 SAMPLE DUPLICATE 430329 9267367007 Dup Parameter Units Result Result RPD Qualifiers Nitrogen, NO2 plus'NO3 mg /L ND ND Date 04/23/2010 03 48;PM REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS Page 10 of 14 This report shall -not be reproduced, except in full, without the written consentof Pace Analytical Services, Inc /1±Y 11y {J� 1 ACCo# o, (�IaceAnalytical wwwpscebabs:cem Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace Project, No 9267173 QC Batch WETA[7175 QC Batch Method EPA 365 1 Associated Lab Samples- 9267173001 METHOD BLANK 429864 Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 Parameter Units Phosphorus mg /L LABORATORY CONTROL SAMPLE 429865 Parameter Units Phosphorus mg /L MATRIX SPIKE SAMPLE 429866 Parameter Units Phosphorus mg /L MATRIX SPIKE SAMPLE 429868 Parameter Units Phosphorus mg /L SAMPLE DUPLICATE 429867 Parameter Phosphorus SAMPLE DUPLICATE 429869 Parameter Phosphorus Date 04/23/2010 03 4&PM` Pace Analytical Services, Inc 2225 Riverside Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 QUALITY CONTROL DATA Analysis Method EPA 365 1 Analysis Description 365 1 Phosphorus, Total Matrix , Water Blank Reporting Result Limit Analyzed Qualifiers ND 010 04/18/10 11 26 Pace Analytical, Services, Inc 9800 KinceyAve Suite 100 Huntersvdle, NC 28078 (704)875 -9092 Spike LCS LCS % Rec Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers 1 10 101 90 -110 9267367015 Spike MS MS % Rec Result Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers 436 1 449 123 90 -110 MO 9266715001 Spike, 'MS MS % Rec Result Conc Result %,Rec Limits Qualifiers 3 2' 1 51 194 90 -110 M& 9266947001 Dup Units Result Result mg /L 34 34 9267067001 Dup Units Result Result mg /L 70 71 RPD Qualifiers 0 RPD Qualifiers 2 REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report'shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the,wntten consent,of Pace Analytical Services, Inc Page'11 of 14 ® Pace Analytical Services, Inc Pace Analytical Services, Inc a malytical 2225 Riverside Dr 9800 Kmcey Ave Suite 100 a*,pacelaftcom Asheville, NC 28804 Hunterswlle, NC 28078 (828)254-7176 (704)875-9092 QUALITY CONTROL DATA Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace ProjedNo 9267173 QC Batch WETAU144 Analysis Method SM 5220D QC Batch Method SM 5220D Analysis Description Z220D,COD Associated Lab Samples 9267173001 METHOD BLANK 428014 Matrix 'Water Associated Lab Samples 92.67173001 Blank Reporting Parameter Units Result Limit Analyzed Qualifiers Chemical Oxygen Demand mg /L ND 25'0 0464/10 16 46 LABORATORY CONTROL SAMPLE, 428015 Spike LCS LCS % Rec Parameter Units Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Chemical Oxygen,Demand mg /L- 750 716 95 90 -110 MATRIX,SPIKE °SAMPLE 428016 9266663008 Spike MS MS % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Chemical Oxygen Demand mg/L 700 750 804 98 75 -125 MATRIX SPIKE SAMPLE 428022 9266996001 Spike MS MS % Rec Parameter Units Result Conc Result % Rec Limits Qualifiers Chemical Oxygen Demand 'mg /L 179 750 890 95 75 -125 SAMPLE DUPLICATE 428021 9266750007 pup Parameter Units Result Result RPD Qualifiers Chemical ,Oxygen Demand mg /L 600 596 1 SAMPLE DUPLICATE 428023 9266758005 Dup Parameter Units Result Result RPD Qualifiers Chemical Oxygen Demand mg /L 2630 2580 2 Date 04/23/2010'03 48 PM REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This 'report shall not be reproduced, except'in, full, without the written consent of Pace Analytical Services, Inc o coo,,o �E \\ i�Ja Page 12 of 14 aceAnalytkal WW O6818bs cam QUALIFIERS Project DUCK'POND 04/12 Pace Project�No 9267173 T EFINITIONS Pace Analytic#Se_rvices;,lnc 2225' R iverside,Dr Asheville, NC 28804 (828)254 -7176 Pace Analytical,Services, Inc, 9800 KinceyAve Suite 100 Huntersville, NC 28078 ,(704)875 -9092 DF - DilutioniFactor, if reported, represents,the factor applied to,the reported data due to,changes in sample preparation,, dilution of the sample aliquot, or moisture content ,ND Not Detected at'or above ad) usted'reporting'ilmrt J Estimated, concentration above theaad)usted method detection limit and'below the adtusted,reportingHllmrt� MDL- Adjusted; Method Detection Limit S -Surrogate 1, 2- Diphenylhydrazine(8270,listed analyte)Aecomposes toAzobenzene Conslstent,withlEPA gwdehries;,unrounded'data aredisplayed'and have been used to,calculai6% recovery+and 'RFD values LCS(D) - Laboratory'Control,Samplei(C uplicate) MS(D) a MatnxlSpikel(Dupllcate) PUP - =Sample Duplicate RPD - Relative Percent Difference NC - Not Calculable Pace Analytical�is NELAP accredited >'Contact,yqur Pace,PMlor the currentlist;of accredited analytes U - Indicates'theicompound'was analyzed for „but not,detected LABORATORIES PASI -A Pace,Analytical Services -Asheville ANALYTEfQUALIFIERS ,B2' Oxygen usage is less than 2 O'for all'dilutions,set The reported valueris,an estimated less than value and, is; calculated for the dilution using the;mostamount of sample D3 Sample was dil tedtdue,to the`presence of high level&of non- tar`get=analgtes%or,oi er`mateix`interference MO Matrix spike recovery and /or matrix,spikerduplmate recovery was ,ioutside,laboratory,control limits �R1 RFD ^value wasloutside,control'hmits Date 04/23/20,1,003 48 PM REPORT OF LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be'reproduced, except in full, without the written consent of PaceAnalytical Services „Inc AO � a Page f3lof 14 ® Pace Analytical Services, Inc aceAnalytical 2225 Riverside Dr wwwpacelabscam Asheville, NC'28804 (828)254 -7176 QUALITY CONTROL DATA CROSS REFERENCE TABLE Project DUCK POND 04/12 Pace,Project No 9267173 Pace-Analytical Services,,lnc_ 9800 KinceyAve , Suite 100 Huntersvdle,'NC 28078 (704)875 -9092 Date 04/23/2010 03 48 PM REPORT OF' LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the wnttemconsent of Pace Analytical Services; tnc /1 1 ry CCpq� uL�r z Page 14 of 14 Analytical Lab ID Sample ID QC Batch Method OC Batch Analytical Method Batch 9267173001 DUCK POND EPA 200 7 MPRP /6150 EPA 200 7 ICP/5675 9267173001 DUCK POND EPA 2451 MERP /2765 EPA 2451 MERC /2731 9267173001 DUCK POND SM 52106 WET/12044 SM 5210B WET/12085 92671.73001 DUCK POND 40CFR PART 503 WET/12127 9267173001 DUCK POND EPA 351 2 WETAf7196 9267173001 DUCK POND EPA 353 2 WETA17183 9267173001 DUCK POND EPA 365 1 WETA/7175 9267173001 DUCK POND SM 5220D WETA/7144 Date 04/23/2010 03 48 PM REPORT OF' LABORATORY ANALYSIS This report shall not be reproduced, except in full, without the wnttemconsent of Pace Analytical Services; tnc /1 1 ry CCpq� uL�r z Page 14 of 14