20140398 Ver 1_More Info Received_20140620

Scarbraugh, Anthony
From:Brian Rubino <[e-mail]>
Sent:Friday, June 20, 2014 3:25 PM
To:Scarbraugh, Anthony; Barnes, Kyle W SAW; Trowell, Steve; Moye, David
Subject:RE: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)
Attachments:Oden Property Review Comment Responses 6-20-2014.pdf
Gentlemen,

Please see my responses and associated exhibits related to the federal and state review comments. Please let me know
if you have any questions at this time. I have met with Don Oden to discuss each of the comments.

Thanks,
Brian

Brian D. Rubino, P.G.
Vice President
Quible & Associates, P.C.
252.261.3300
[e-mail]
www.quible.com

-----Original Message-----
From: Scarbraugh, Anthony \[mailto:[e-mail]\]
Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2014 8:11 AM
To: Brian Rubino
Cc: Moye, David; Barnes, Kyle W SAW
Subject: RE: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)

Mr. Rubino,

This Office will grant the requested extension.

Thanks,
Anthony Scarbraugh

Anthony Scarbraugh
Environmental Senior Specialist
Washington Regional Office
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Division of Water Resources - Water Quality Regional
Operations Section
943 Washington Square Mall
Washington, NC 27889
[phone]

****************************************************************************
1

E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be
disclosed to third parties unless the content is exempt by statue or other regulation.
****************************************************************************

-----Original Message-----
From: Brian Rubino \[mailto:[e-mail]\]
Sent: Tuesday, May 20, 2014 8:03 AM
To: Scarbraugh, Anthony
Cc: Moye, David; Barnes, Kyle W SAW
Subject: RE: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)

Anthony,

Our proposed resubmittal date is June 20th. Please let me know if you need anything else at this time.

Thanks,
Brian Rubino

-----Original Message-----
From: Scarbraugh, Anthony \[mailto:[e-mail]\]
Sent: Monday, May 19, 2014 8:23 AM
To: Brian Rubino
Cc: Moye, David; Barnes, Kyle W SAW
Subject: RE: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)

Mr. Rubino,

Please provide the Division of Water Resources an anticipated submittal date.

Anthony Scarbraugh

Anthony Scarbraugh
Environmental Senior Specialist
Washington Regional Office
North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Division of Water Resources - Water Quality Regional
Operations Section
943 Washington Square Mall
Washington, NC 27889
[phone]

****************************************************************************
E-mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be
disclosed to third parties unless the content is exempt by statue or other regulation.
****************************************************************************

-----Original Message-----
From: Barnes, Kyle W SAW \[mailto:[e-mail]\]
Sent: Monday, May 19, 2014 8:19 AM
To: Brian Rubino
Cc: Scarbraugh, Anthony; Moye, David
Subject: RE: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)
2

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE

Brian,

I will include this correspondence in the file and extend the date for submittal of information until you can gather
information in June. Thank you for informing of your situation.

Kyle

-----Original Message-----
From: Brian Rubino \[mailto:[e-mail]\]
Sent: Wednesday, May 14, 2014 10:22 AM
To: Barnes, Kyle W SAW
Cc: Scarbraugh, Anthony; Moye, David
Subject: \[EXTERNAL\] RE: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)

Kyle,

I am in receipt of your email related to additional information needed. I also received a letter from DWR related to
additional information needed in relation to coastal wetland location (and the road) and avoidance and minimization
explanation. And, I spoke with David Moye on the phone related to coastal wetlands. I should be able to address these
issues satisfactorily, but I would like to meet with Don Oden before resubmitting information on his behalf. I'll be down
on Ocracoke the first weekend in June and am planning on meeting with Don at that time. Would it be okay to supply a
formal response to these items in June? Don is not on email and it will work best for this one to meet him in person. I
think that will help having to go back and forth with responses more than once.

Thanks,
Brian

Brian D. Rubino, P.G.
Vice President
Quible & Associates, P.C.
252.261.3300
[e-mail]
www.quible.com

-----Original Message-----
From: Barnes, Kyle W SAW \[mailto:[e-mail]\]
Sent: Monday, May 05, 2014 12:53 PM
To: Brian Rubino
Subject: Donald Oden Project-Ocracoke (UNCLASSIFIED)

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE

Brian,

3

This correspondence is to inform you that after reviewing the Nationwide Permit (NWP) 14/18 request for the Donald
Oden property I have determined that the PNC application is incomplete. Please provide information for the following
questions regarding this project:

1) Please provide information as to why the proposed impacts to jurisdictional wetlands cannot be reduced. According
to the Hyde County tax records Mr. Oden owns Oden Fish & Oil Company. This parcel abuts the proposed access
driveway and wetland impacts could be reduced if the access originates from this parcel instead of the.

2) The Division of Coastal Management (CAMA) has raised concerns that the access driveway will potentially impact
coastal wetlands. Please coordinate with CAMA and confirm if the project area includes coastal wetlands so they can be
quantified in the PCN application and mitigation detail.

3) Mitigation- The PCN application indicates that the wetland impacts will take place in non-riparian wetlands. The
location of the mitigation conservation area indicated on the map submitted with the application does not indicate if
there are non-riparian wetlands present. Please provide information indicating the percentage of the wetland types
within the 4.3 acre Conservation Area and indicate their location on a revised plat.

4) It appears that a portion of the driveway originating on the west end of the project is located within an existing
conservation easement. Please provide information that the project impacts are located outside of any existing
easements.

Please provide the requested information within 30 days of the receipt of this correspondence. If you have any
questions please contact me at this email address or 910-251-4584.

Kyle

Kyle Barnes
US Army Corps of Engineers
Wilmington District
Washington Field Office
910-251-4584

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE

Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE

4

Lzmf!Cbsoft-!VTBDF!Dpnnfout!
2/!Qmfbtf!qspwjef!jogpsnbujpo!bt!up!xiz!uif!qspqptfe!jnqbdut!up!kvsjtejdujpobm!xfumboet!dboopu!
cf!sfevdfe/!Bddpsejoh!up!uif!Izef!Dpvouz!uby!sfdpset!Ns/!Pefo!pxot!Pefo!Gjti!'!Pjm!
Dpnqboz/!Uijt!qbsdfm!bcvut!uif!qspqptfe!bddftt!esjwfxbz!boe!xfumboe!jnqbdut!dpvme!cf!
sfevdfe!jg!uif!bddftt!psjhjobuft!gspn!uijt!qbsdfm!jotufbe!pg!uif/!
Rvjcmf!Sftqpotf;!!
Qsjps!up!tvcnjttjpo!pg!uif!bqqmjdbujpo!qbdlbhf-!Ns/!Pefo!fyqmbjofe!up!vt!uif!jobcjmjuz!up!bddftt!
uif!qspqptfe!ipnftjuf!mpdbujpo!gspn!boz!puifs!sfbtpobcmf!ejsfdujpo!uibu!xpvme!dbvtf!mftt!
jnqbdut!up!kvsjtejdujpobm!xfumboet/!!Uif!gbdu!pg!uif!nbuufs!jt!uibu!fbdi!pg!uif!qspqfsujft!bmpoh!OD!
23!bekbdfou!up!uif!tvckfdu!bsfb!bsf!dpnqmfufmz!cvjmu!pvu!boe!bsf!eftjhobufe0vtfe!gps!puifs!
qvsqptft/!!Uifsf!bsf!fjuifs!qbsljoh!mput-!cvjmejoht-!dbnqtjuft-!gvfmjoh!bsfbt-!tvctvsgbdf!vujmjujft!
)ftqfdjbmmz!po.tjuf!tfqujd!tztufnt*!uispvhipvu!uif!qspqfsujft!pxofe!cz!Pefo!Gjti!boe!Pjm!ps!
puifst/!!Uif!dpnnfsdjbm!dpssjeps!bmpoh!OD!23!jt!uif!fousz!up!Pdsbdplf!Wjmmbhf-!xijdi!jt!b!
wjcsbou!upvsjtn!eftujobujpo!gspn-!uif!mbuf!Tqsjoh!uispvhi!fbsmz!gbmm/!!Pvs!tjuf!qmbo!tipxt!nvdi!pg!
uif!bcpwf!hspvoe!jnqspwfnfout!po!uiftf!bekbdfou!mput/!!Bopuifs!sfqsftfoubujpo!pg!uif!uzqjdbm!
dpoejujpo!)fyjtujoh!gfbuvsft!boe!vtf*!pg!uijt!dpssjeps!dbo!cf!tffo!jo!uif!bddpnqbozjoh!
ui
qipuphsbqit-!ublfo!po!Tbuvsebz!npsojoh!Kvof!8/!!Uifsf!jt!dvssfoumz!b!offe!gps!beejujpobm!
qbsljoh!boe!tfqujd!gps!uiftf!dpnnfsdjbm!qspqfsujft!xijdi!dboopu!cf!nfu!tp!ju!xpvme!cf!
jnqsbdujdbm!up!ublf!bxbz!gspn!uifjs!dvssfou!dbqbdjuz/!
Ju!jt!bmtp!jnqpsubou!up!opuf!uibu!xijmf!Ns/!Pefo!jt!pof!pg!uif!qsjnbsz!pxofst!pg!Pefo!Gjti!'!Pjm-!
uif!dpnqboz!jt!pxofe!cz!Epo!Pefo!boe!puifs!nfncfst!pg!ijt!fyufoefe!gbnjmz/!!Uijt!ibt!
bmxbzt!cffo!tfqbsbuf!gspn!uif!tvckfdu!usbdu!boe!puifs!ipmejoht!cz!Epo!Pefo/!!Uif!dpnqboz!jt!
dvssfoumz!jo!b!ofhpujbujpo!qibtf!up!tfmm!uif!Pefo!Gjti!'!Pjm!Qspqfsujft!jo!uifjs!fyjtujoh!
dpoejujpot/!!Uifsf!jt!opu!b!dpousbdu!up!tfmm!uiftf!qspqfsujft!jo!qmbdf!zfu-!cvu!ju!jt!mppljoh!mjlf!b!
usbotbdujpo!xjmm!pddvs!jo!uif!opu!upp!ejtubou!gvuvsf/!!Uif!qspqptfe!bddftt!esjwf!xjmm!fotvsf!uibu!
Ns/!Pefo!nbjoubjot!b!dmfbs!bddftt!esjwf!up!uif!ipnftjuf/!
Beejujpobmmz-!qmfbtf!voefstuboe!uibu!bt!gbs!bt!uif!tvckfdu!usbdu!hpft-!Ns/!Pefo!ibt!cffo!
tqfbljoh!up!OD!Dpbtubm!Mboe!Usvtu!)ODDMU*!boe!puifs!dpotfswbujpo!hspvqt!bcpvu!uif!usbotgfs!
pg!pxofstijq!pg!uif!foujsf!qspqfsuz-!njovt!uijt!tvckfdu!ipnftjuf!boe!bddftt!spbe/!!ODDMU!jt!
bxbsf!pg!uijt!qspqptfe!ipnftjuf!boe!bddftt!spbe!boe!uifz!ibwf!dpqjft!pg!uif!bttpdjbufe!qmbo/!!
ui
ODDMU!wjtjufe!uif!qspqfsuz!po!Gsjebz!Kvof!7!boe!J!ibwf!tqplfo!up!uifjs!sfqsftfoubujwft!cfgpsf!
boe!bgufs!uif!nffujoh/!!Ju!jt!nz!voefstuboejoh!uibu!uifz!ibwf!joufsftu!jo!uif!cbmbodf!pg!uif!
qspqfsuz!gps!qspufdujpo!jo!qfsqfuvjuz-!ftqfdjbmmz!uif!vqmboe!ibnnpdl!jtmboe!sjehf!xifsf!uifsf!
xfsf!tpnf!qsfwjpvt!qmbot!gps!tbmf!bt!b!efwfmpqnfou/!!J!ibwf!dpqjft!pg!b!sftjefoujbm!
efwfmpqnfou!qmbo!gps!uijt!bsfb!uibu!xbt!qsfqbsfe!tfwfsbm!zfbst!bhp!boe!J!bn!bwbjmbcmf!up!
qspwjef!b!dpqz!pg!uibu!jg!zpv!bsf!joufsftufe/!!!
3/!Uif!Ejwjtjpo!pg!Dpbtubm!Nbobhfnfou!)DBNB*!ibt!sbjtfe!dpodfsot!uibu!uif!bddftt!esjwfxbz!
xjmm!qpufoujbmmz!jnqbdu!dpbtubm!xfumboet/!Qmfbtf!dppsejobuf!xjui!DBNB!boe!dpogjsn!jg!uif!
2!

qspkfdu!bsfb!jodmveft!dpbtubm!xfumboet!tp!uifz!dbo!cf!rvboujgjfe!jo!uif!QDO!bqqmjdbujpo!boe!
njujhbujpo!efubjm/!
Rvjcmf!Sftqpotf;!
ODEDN!efmjofbufe!uif!nbkpsjuz!pg!uif!dpbtubm!xfumboet!jo!uif!tvckfdu!bsfb!jo!311:!boe!uif!
efmjofbujpo!xbt!tvswfzfe!jo!vqpo!dpnqmfujpo/!!Uijt!efmjofbujpo!xbt!qfsgpsnfe!cz!Tufwf!
Uspxfmm/!!Uif!xftu!tjef!pg!uif!xfumboe!efmjofbujpo!tupqqfe!kvtu!tipsu!pg!dspttjoh!uif!usbdu!
cpvoebsz!mjof!boe!pvs!DBNB!qmbo!epft!opu!sfqsftfou!boz!dpbtubm!xfumboet!mjof!cfzpoe!xibu!
xbt!efmjofbufe!boe0ps!tvswfzfe/!!Po!uif!buubdife!Fyijcju!B!)bfsjbm!pwfsmbz*!J!fyufoefe!uif!
dpbtubm!xfumboet!mjof!up!uif!usbdu!cpvoebsz!gps!ejtdvttjpo!qvsqptf!pomz!bu!uijt!ujnf/!!Uijt!
ui
fyufotjpo!jt!cbtfe!po!b!tjuf!fwbmvbujpo!cz!C/!Svcjop!po!Kvof!8/!!Uijt!xbt!b!wfhfubujpo!boe!
dpnqbsbujwf!bobmztjt!pg!xibu!xbt!qsfwjpvtmz!efmjofbufe!bt!Tfdujpo!515!opo.dpbtubm!wfstvt!
dpbtubm!xfumboet/!!J!ibwf!tqplfo!xjui!Tufwf!Uspxfmm!bcpvu!uijt!boe!if!sfdfjwfe!b!dpqz!pg!uif!
buubdinfou!gps!sfwjfx!uispvhi!fnbjm/!!!!!
4/!Njujhbujpo.!Uif!QDO!bqqmjdbujpo!joejdbuft!uibu!uif!xfumboe!jnqbdut!xjmm!ublf!qmbdf!jo!opo.
sjqbsjbo!xfumboet/!Uif!mpdbujpo!pg!uif!njujhbujpo!dpotfswbujpo!bsfb!joejdbufe!po!uif!nbq!
tvcnjuufe!xjui!uif!bqqmjdbujpo!epft!opu!joejdbuf!jg!uifsf!bsf!opo.sjqbsjbo!xfumboet!qsftfou/!
Qmfbtf!qspwjef!jogpsnbujpo!joejdbujoh!uif!qfsdfoubhf!pg!uif!xfumboe!uzqft!xjuijo!uif!5/4!bdsf!
Dpotfswbujpo!Bsfb!boe!joejdbuf!uifjs!mpdbujpo!po!b!sfwjtfe!qmbu/!!
Rvjcmf!Sftqpotf;!
Cbtfe!po!ejhjuj{bujpo!pg!bfsjbm!qipuphsbqiz!boe!qsjps!fybnjobujpo!pg!uijt!bsfb!evsjoh!uif!Tfdujpo!
515!efmjofbujpo-!uif!bqqspyjnbuf!qspqptfe!dpotfswbujpo!bsfb!csfblepxo!jt!bqqspyjnbufmz!bt!
gpmmpxt!)Tff!bmtp!Fyijcju!C.!zfmmpx!qpmzmjoft!pvumjof!Tfdujpo!515-!opo.dpbtubm!xfumboe!bsfbt*;!
Upubm!Bsfb;!297-419!tr/gu/!
Vqmboe!Ibnnpdlt;!4-438!tr/gu/!
Tfdujpo!515-!opo.dpbtubm!xfumboet;!48-2:8!tr/gu/!
Tfdujpo!515-!dpbtubm!xfumboet;!256-895!tr/gu/!
5/!Ju!bqqfbst!uibu!b!qpsujpo!pg!uif!esjwfxbz!psjhjobujoh!po!uif!xftu!foe!pg!uif!qspkfdu!jt!mpdbufe!
xjuijo!bo!fyjtujoh!dpotfswbujpo!fbtfnfou/!Qmfbtf!qspwjef!jogpsnbujpo!uibu!uif!qspkfdu!
jnqbdut!bsf!mpdbufe!pvutjef!pg!boz!fyjtujoh!fbtfnfout/!
Rvjcmf!Sftqpotf;!
Uif!gjstu!buubdinfou!)Fyijcju!B*!efqjdut!uijt/!!B!qpsujpo!pg!uif!qspqptfe!esjwfxbz!epft!dsptt!b!
qpsujpo!pg!mboe!uibu!jt!jo!b!Qspufdujwf!Dpwfobou!sfmbufe!up!dpnqfotbupsz!njujhbujpo!up!pggtfu!
jnqbdut!gps!uif!Pdsbdplf!Dpnnvojuz!Qbsl/!!Uif!njujhbujpo!gps!uibu!qspkfdu!jt!dpbtubm!xfumboet!
sftupsbujpo!jo!b!qpsujpo!pg!bo!fyjtujoh!qpoe/!!Uif!tvckfdu!esjwfxbz!dspttjoh!epft!usbwfstf!b!
qpsujpo!pg!uif!31!gu!xjef!tusjq!uibu!jt!nfbou!up!tfswf!bt!bo!bddftt!dpssjeps!up!uif!qpoe/!!J!
voefstuboe!uif!dpnqmjdbujpo!jo!uibu!uif!foujsf!bsfb!jefoujgjfe!po!uif!qspufdujwf!dpwfobou!Fyijcju!
gps!uif!qbsl!njujhbujpo!sfgfst!up!uijt!bt!b!qspufdufe!bsfb/!!Up!bddvsbufmz!beesftt!uijt-!xf!opx!
qspqptf!up!npejgz!uif!qspufdujwf!dpwfobou!up!tqfdjgjdbmmz!sfgfs!up!uif!31!gu!tusjq!bt!bo!bddftt!
3!

dpssjeps!up!uif!qspufdufe!ps!sftupsbujpo!bsfb/!!Uijt!tusjq!jt!joufoefe!up!bmxbzt!cf!bwbjmbcmf!up!
bddftt!uif!qpoe!evsjoh!boe!bgufs!njujhbujpo!xpsl!uifsf!jt!dpnqmfufe/!!
Bouipoz!Tdbscsbvhi-!ODEFOS!EXS!Dpnnfout!
2/!Qmbo!Efubjmt!
Qmfbtf!dppsejobuf!xjui!uif!Ejwjtjpo!pg!Dpbtubm!Nbobhfnfou!up!wfsjgz!uif!mpdbujpo!pg!uif!
dpbtubm!xfumboe!mjof!bmpoh!uif!opsuifso!fyufou!pg!zpvs!bddftt!spbe/!
Rvjcmf!Sftqpotf;!
Xf!bsf!xpsljoh!xjui!EDN!up!dpogjsn!b!dpbtubm!xfumboet!mjof!fyufotjpo!)tff!sftqpotf!2!bcpwf*/!!
3/!Bwpjebodf!boe!Njojnj{bujpo!
Qmfbtf!qspwjef!npsf!efubjmt!sfhbsejoh!bwpjebodf!boe!njojnj{bujpo!pg!)515!boe0ps!dpbtubm*!
xfumboe!jnqbdut!gps!uijt!qspkfdu!bttpdjbufe!xjui!zpvs!qspqptfe!bddftt!spbe/!
Rvjcmf!Sftqpotf;!
Qmfbtf!tff!sftqpotf!2!bcpwf/!
4!