Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20140407 Ver 1_Individual_2014042120140407 Elevation Church Mixed Use Commercial & Residential Charlotte, Mecklenburg County North Carolina Individual Permit Application Prepared For Mr. Josh Blackson Operations Pastor Elevation Church 11416 East Independence Blvd., Suite N Matthews, North Carolina 28105 Prepared By LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning 3714 Spokeshave Lane Matthews, NC 28105 (704) 904 -2277 April 15, 2014 APR � 20,- NR - iSUALITY LNetiand_,r &_ ,StaEr 3ra2ch LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant 3714 Spokeshave Lane Professional Wetland Scientist Matthews, NC 28105 Land Planning (704) 904 -2277 April 15, 2014 Mr. Steven Kichefski US Army Corps of Engineers - Reg. Field Office 151 Patton Avenue - Room 208 Asheville, NC 28801 - 5006 Ms. Karen Higgins Wetlands, Buffers, and Stormwater, Compliance and Permitting Unit NCDENR/Division of Water Quality - Wetlands and Stormwater Branch 1650 Mail Service Center Raleigh NC 27699 -1650 Mr. Alan Johnson NCDENR - Division of Water Quality 610 East Center Street, Suite 301 Mooresville, NC 28115 Re: Elevation Church Mixed -use Development, approximately 58 Acres, Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina Dear Madame and Sirs: On behalf of my client, Mr. Josh Blackson of Elevation Church, I am providing you with the following information concerning the Elevation Church mixed -use residential and commercial development for your consideration Project Information Applicant: Mr. Josh Blackson Operations Pastor Elevation Church 11416 East Independence Blvd., Suite N Matthews, North Carolina 28105 Name of project: Elevation Church Mixed -Use Residential & Commercial Development Location: Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina Property Identification Number: 22351103 & 22351101 Owner Information Name(s) on Recorded Deed Deed Book ad Page No Responsible Party (for LLC if applicable) Street Address City, State, Zip Telephone No. Fax No. Email address Agent /Consultant Information YFP Timber LLC DNK Elevation Church 11416 East Independence Blvd., Suite N Matthews, NC 28105 Name Leonard S. Rindner, PWS Business Name Leonard S. Rindner, PLLC Street Address 3714 Spokeshave Lane City, State, Zip Matthews, NC 28105 Telephone No. (704) 904 -2277 Fax No. Email Address len.rindner2wetlands -epg com Waterway and Location The site is located on the south side of Lancaster Highway, immediately west of its intersection with Johnston Road (US Hwy 521), in Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. The site contains stream channels known as Clems Branch and its unnamed tributaries. The site also contains wetlands and open water ponds that are adjacent to jurisdictional streams. Clems Branch is considered a relatively permanent water and ultimately drains to the Catawba River. The Catawba River is considered a Section 10 Navigable Water at the Mountain Island Lake Dam on Lake Wylie, in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. Latitude and Longitude 35.03180 °N and - 80.85563 °W Site Conditions The site is approximately 58 acres in size and is comprised of a mosaic open mowed lawns /landscaping, fragmented slopes and drainage areas covered with disturbed mixed/pine hardwoods. There are several buildings on the site including residential homes, livestock barns, and storage sheds. The land immediately surrounding the site is mixed use residential and commercial developments. 2 The mostly flat, open, turf grass lawn is comprised of cultivated Fescue (Festuca sp.) with typical shrub /small tree planting beds, and widely scattered larger trees. The wooded areas contain some mature trees with moderate sub -canopy strata. Canopy trees present include Shortleaf Pine (Pinus echinata), White Oak (Quercus alba), Red Oak (Q rubra), Sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua), Yellow Poplar (Liriodendron tuliperifa), Southern Red Oak, (Q falcate), Willow Oak (Q phellos), Mockernut Hickory (Carya tomentosa), and Red Cedar (Juniperus virginiana). The sub -canopy is composed of Flowering Dogwood (Cornus Florida), American Holly (Ilex opaca), Black Cherry (Prunus serotina), and Black Gum (Nyssa sylvatica). The shrub layer includes Chinese Privet (Ligustrum sinense), Blueberry (Vaccinium sp.) and Russian Olive (Elaeagnus umbellate) There are several soil types on the site to include Enon sandy loam (EnB and EnD), Helena sandy loam (HeB), Monacan loam (MO), Vance sandy loam (VaB) and Wilkes loam (WkE). Of these soil types, Monacan loam is considered hydric and located in the floodplain of Clems Branch. Identification and delineation of the jurisdictional waters on the site were determined using the Routine On -Site Determination Method according to the Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual, Technical Report Y -87 -1, 1987, with Appendices and the Eastern Mountains and Piedmont Regional Supplements. Data gathering included review and interpretation of topographic maps, USDA Soil Conservation Survey, aerial photographs, and site visits to selected areas. In order to make positive wetland determination indicators of hydrophytic vegetation, hydric soil, and wetland hydrology were identified as described in the manual and supplement. In addition, the extent of surface waters such as perennial and intermittent streams was also evaluated. The project area contains several jurisdictional waters of the U.S. to include stream channels, wetlands, and open water ponds. The jurisdictional areas were confirmed by USACE Corps representatives, William Elliot and Steve Kichefski on April 16, 2013. The jurisdictional features are summarized in the table below. The features listed below are only those located in/near proposed impact areas that have been delineated. Table 1: Summary of Jurisdictional Features Jurisdictional Feature Type Classification Label Size linear foot/acreage) Stream Seasonal RPW I1 2661f Stream Seasonal RPW B1 3071f Total 573 If Wetland Forested/ alustrine Al 0.01 ac Wetland Forested/ alustrine C/D 0.07 ac Wetland Emer ent/ alustrine E 0.23 ac Wetland Forested/ alustrine G 0.02 ac Wetland Forested/ alustrine J 0.03 ac 3 Total 0.36 acres Pond Open Water L 0.34 ac Pond Open Water K 1.57 ac Pond Open Water F 0.36 ac Total 2.27 acres The open water ponds are man -made and constructed in high ground with earthen berms. The stream channels are small, headwater intermittent channels with minimal aquatic habitat. Wetland E was formerly an open water pond excavated in high ground that has since been drained and now classifies as a wetland. There are also other jurisdictional features located on the property but they were not delineated/surveyed since they were outside the boundaries of the project area and they are being avoided. Clems Branch is a perennial stream that is located along the northern property line. Another unnamed perennial stream (HI) is located along the western property boundary and drains into Clems Branch. There are also wetlands (AA, AB, AC, and AD) located adjacent to Clems Branch in the flood zone. Project Purpose and Need The basic purpose of the project is to construct a mixed -use residential and commercial development. Specifically, the overall project purpose is to construct a mixed -use residential and commercial development to include a church and associated infrastructure, office retail, and multifamily residential housing units, on Lancaster Highway, in Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. The project has several components to include a 200,000 square foot church office, 42,000 square foot worship center, 22,000 square foot children's ministry, and 397 multi- family residential units with associated recreational amenities to include pool and clubhouse. Required parking associated with these components total 1,781 spaces. Stormwater treatment facilities are also required as part of this project. Project Description The site plan has been designed utilizing critical design criteria while taking into consideration the location of jurisdictional waters on the property. Most of the development on the site will occur in uplands and no development will occur in the flood zone of Clems Branch. However, due to the location and extent of jurisdictional waters on the property, not all of these features could be avoided. In order to construct the development as needed, approximately 85 linear feet of stream channel, 0.24 acre of wetlands, and 2.27 acres of open water pond will be filled /impacted as a result of this project. The table below provides a summary of proposed impacts. Table 2: Impacts to Jurisdictional Waters 4 Feature Impact linear feet or acreage) Stream B 1 851f Total Stream Impact 851f Pond K 1.57 acre Pond F 0.36 acre Pond L 0.34 acre Total Open Water Impact 2.27 acres Wetland A 0.01 acre Wetland E 0.23 Total Wetland Impact 0.24 acre Impacts are associated with placement of fill for road crossings, parking areas, residential building construction, and stormwater treatment facilities. Specifically, 85 linear feet of Stream B 1 and 0.01 acre of Wetland A will be filled in order to construct a main access road to traverse and connect the site. Pond L will be filled in order to construct the required parking for the church office and worship center. Impacts to Pond K, Pond F, and Wetland E are associated with the construction of the residential units and the required storm water treatment facility. There are no direct impacts to Stream I1 proposed as a result of the project. However, a small portion of the buffer will be disturbed associated with grading an adequate slope for parking/road access This buffer will be replanted with native species. A small portion of the buffer of Stream BI will also be disturbed downstream of the impact area which will also be replanted as well. To avoid any secondary /indirect impacts to Wetland C, D, and G that may result from draining the ponds and re- directing surface water, steps will be taken to direct water back into these wetlands from the discharge of the storm water facility. These wetlands will also be connected back to flow of Stream B 1 which appear to have been previously severed when the ponds were constructed. Maintaining and re- establishing hydrology through Wetlands C, D, and G will be accomplished by excavating a small channel from the terminal point of Wetland C & D to' Wetland G. Coir fiber logs and log step structures will be installed to direct water to Wetland G which will then flow into Clems Branch. The disturbed area will be stabilized with wetland seed mix. Avoidance and Minimization The applicant has been able to avoid and minimize impacts to a substantial portion of the jurisdictional features on the site. However, there are several critical design criteria required for this project that precluded the applicant from completely avoiding all impacts to jurisdictional features on the site. Specifically, the design criteria included the requirements to have parking slopes at 2% max for ADA spaces and 5% max for all other spaces, required road and parking connectivity throughout the site to be ADA compliant, and the requirement to maintain fire access to all portions of the buildings. Other constraints that limit site plan configurations are required tree save areas, required open space areas, required buffers, and required storm water treatment facilities. 5 Given these constraints and design criteria, the project will only impact 14% of stream channels and 67% of wetlands within the project area. However, when taking into consideration the stream and wetland features located on the property that were not delineated because they were outside the project area, the applicant has avoided an even greater percentage of jurisdictional waters on the site. Wetland A and a portion of Stream BI could not be completely avoided as it transects the central portion of the property and is located within the road corridor alignment needed to connect to an existing intersection/driveway point on Lancaster Highway. Impacts to stream channels were even further minimized by utilizing an existing road crossing on Stream B I. All of the open water ponds located on the site will be filled as a result of this project. Due to their location on the property (in a high ground setting and adjacent to the Lancaster Highway), these ponds could not be avoided while still meeting the project purpose. Given their man-made nature and lower value as aquatic resources in relation to natural stream channels and wetlands on the site, the design team determined that impacting these features were preferable to impacting stream channels and wetlands on the site. Wetland E, which is the largest wetland impact (0.23 acre), will be impacted in order to construct a required storm water treatment facility. Due to the fact that this wetland was created by draining a pond excavated in high ground, the design team determined that locating a storm water treatment facility here was preferable to impacting required tree save /open space and buffer areas. The applicant was also able to further minimize impacts to Wetlands C, D, and G by ensuring that the hydrology is restored to these areas from the discharge of the storm water facility and Stream BI as described above. Alternative Analysis The applicant selected this property due to its adequate size, availability, and desired location. There are no other properties available nearby that would suite a development of this size therefore no off -site alternatives are included. The applicant did consider an alternative site design in which the open water ponds were incorporated as aesthetic features into the development. However, due to the constraints listed above, this design would have impacted approximately all of Stream B1 (307 linear feet), StreamIl (266 linear feet), Wetland A (0.1 acre), and Wetland E (0.23 acre). Based on coordination with the regulatory agencies, the design team re- evaluated this plan and re- designed with an emphasis on avoiding and minimizing impacts to natural streams on the site. Compensatory Mitigation The applicant is proposing to offset impacts associated with this project by making payment into the North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement ( NCEEP) In Lieu Fee Program for 0.23 acre of wetland impact at a 1:1 ratio. NCEEP has agreed to accept this mitigation by letter dated February 17, 2014 in the expanded service area of the Lower Catawba Basin (HUC 03050103). 6 Federally Listed Endangered and Threatened Species Based on a field survey the proposed activity will not affect species, or their critical habitat, designated as endangered or threatened pursuant to the Endangered Species Act of 1973. The survey was conducted by Lisa Gaffney and is included in this report. Cultural Resources There are no indications of any existing structures or archaeological sites on listed on or potentially eligible for the National Register within the study area. According to the latest published version of the National Register of Historic Places for the presence or absence of registered properties, or properties listed as being eligible for inclusion therein, this site is not registered property or property listed as being eligible for inclusion in the Register. Stormwater Management The project falls within the jurisdiction of the City of Charlotte and therefore falls under Charlotte's development ordinances including the storm water Post Construction Ordinance. The City of Charlotte will review and approve the Storm Water Management Plan showing compliance with the Post Construction Ordinance as part of their land development review. This approval will not be given until the developer furnishes a 401/404 permit to the City. City of Charlotte's requirements for a Storm Water Management Plan meet or exceed the NCDENR requirements. The requirements set forth in the plans are the requirements of the Post Construction Ordinance that are specific to this site which include two wet ponds designed with a sediment forebay separated from the main storage area by a rip rap berm, a 10 -foot minimum littoral shelf with appropriate plantings around the permanent pools and outfalls will discharge into the adjacent wetlands in the floodplain. Aquatic Habitat The aquatic systems in the project area consist of headwater wetlands, intermittent and perennial tributaries of Clems Branch. A variety of wildlife is supported by these systems including mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, fish, insects, mollusks, and crustaceans. Therefore strict adherence to an approved erosion and sedimentation control plan will be maintained during the construction period in order to control degradation of water quality downstream and protect the areas to be preserved. Impacts from hazardous materials and other toxins to fish and aquatic life such as fuels will be avoided by not permitting staging areas to be located near surface waters. Conclusion The requested permit has considered an evaluation of the probable and cumulative impacts and its intended use on the public interest. Based on a comprehensive analysis 7 we believe that this proposal complies with the Environmental Protection Agencies' 404(b) (1) guidelines. The material economic benefits of this project have been balanced by a mitigation plan to minimize and balance the environmental consequences. The proposal reflects the national concern for both the protection and utilization of important resources. Relevant factors included in the proposal include general environmental concerns, wetlands, cultural values, fish and wildlife values, land use, water quality, considerations of property ownership, and in general, the needs and welfare of the people. The development will provide important economic benefits to the region in terms of job and investment that will increase tax base. Based on the value of the jurisdictional waters and wetlands on this site the developer has chosen to balance the site's economic viability with its environmental value. The goal of the proposed stormwater treatment and mitigation measures is to help balance the environmental consequences of this development. Please contact me if you have any questions or require additional explanation. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, 0,3,�" Leonard S. Rihdher, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist cc: 8 U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS APPLICATION FOR DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY PERMIT Ot4SB APPROVAL NO, 0710 -0003 EXPIRES: 28 FEBRUARY 2013 33 CFR 325 the proponent agency IS CECW -CO-R Public reporting for this colection of mformatron is estknated to average 11 hours per response. bdudling the Itme for reviewing ktaUuctiona, searchmg existing data sources, gatherm and meiritaming the data named and completing snd revrevang ft collection of kdorrnation. Send comments regarding flue burdan estimate or any other aspect of the collection of information. Ong suggestlaw for reducing this burden, to Department of Dalem. Washington Heafterters. Executive Services and Commute Directorate, Information Management DMstml and to the Office of Martegement and Budget, Paperwork Reduchon Pmleet (0710 -0003) Respandents dw-urld be aware tlanotwrthstem6ng any other provision of law. no person shelf be subject to any penalty for taMV to comply with a coileWan of information if it does not display a currently vshd OMB contrd number. Plesse DO -NOT RETURN your form to either of ttxise addresses. Completed app(ioallona must be a twinkled to the District Engineer having )tuisdic tim over the ktosborn M the proposed activity PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT Authorities. Wvers and Harbors Act, Section 10.33 USC 403: Clean Water Act. Section 404. 33 USC 1344. Mamie Prtstsdfori. Research, and Sanctim" Act, Section 103.33 USC 1413. Regulatory Programs of It* Carps of Engineers; Finai Rule 33 CFR 320. 332. Prlridpal Purpose: Mfarmalfan provktad on this form Wit be used in evaluating the application for a penult Routine Uses. This information may be shared with the Department of Jusdoe and o0w federal, state, and dotal government agencies. and the public, and may be made available as part of a public notice as required by Federal law. Submission of requested Information is voluntary. however. 9 information Is riot provided the permit application cannot be evaluated nor cart a permit be Issued. One set of original drawings or good repmduobie copies which slow the location and charecteirof the proposed activity must be attached to this application (am sample drawings andfor instnretra ms) and be submnced to the DISM Engineer havtrg jurisdiction over M loeatian of the proposed activity. An eppilcadon that is not completed to Hull will be returned. (ITEMS 1 THRU 4 TO BE FILLED BY THE CORPS) 1 APPLICATION NO 2 FIELD OFFICE CODE 3 DATE RECEIVED 4, DATE APPLICATION COMPLETE (lTERS BELOW TO BE RLLED BYAPPLICANT) 5 APPLICANTS NWE 8 AUTHORIZED AGENTS NAME AND TITLE (agent is not required) First - Iash Middle - Last - Blm*s on First - Leonard Middle -S Last - Rlndner Company - hlcvation Church Comparsy - Leonard S. Rtndner, PLLC Email Address - jhlacks*n@cIevatconchurch org E-meii Address - 1en.rinduer @wellande -epg com 8. APPLICANTS ADDRESS_ 9 AGENT'S ADDRESS. Address- 11416 East Independence Blvd., Spite N Address- 3714 Spoke8have Lane City - Matthews State - NC Zip-28105 Country- City - Matthews Side - NC Zip - 28105 Country - T APPLICANTS PHONE NOS. ovlAREA CODE 10 AGENTS PHONE NOS %!AREA CODE a Residenoe b Business c. Fax a Residence b. Business c. Fax 704 893 0063 704 -904 -2277 STATEMENTJOF AUTNOFMTIOX 11 1 hereby aWhrutae. Leonard S. Rindner. PLLC as my agot In the p oceesing of two appltea}ion and to ftrrdsK upon request. supplemental information in support R this psrndt f>p —/"V NATU E OF APPLICANT DATE NAME. LOCATION, AND DESCRiPTION OF PROJECT OR ACTIVITY 12 PROJECT NAME OR TITLE (see intruded) Elevation C'hulch mixed -use commercial and residentral develcpnent 13. NAME OF WATERBODY. IF KNOWN (If applicable) 14 PROJECT STREET A wictgu V/ L5 Clem Branch Address 15912 L ancaste way 's I COY - Charlotte S to RhIC ` i Zip 28227 15 LOCATION OF PROJECT Latitude: *N 35 03180 Lonlotudw -w -80 85563 i 16. OTHER LOCATION DESCRIPTIONS, IF KNOWN (see Instructions) ?-- -� ��(t4� ViIHT'Liy LlToi State Tax Parcel ID 22351103 & 22351101 Munrclpality Pineville wetiatidp g Slur aS�r r3rastch Salton . Township - Range - ENG FORM 4345, OCT 2012 PREVIOUS EDITIONS ARE OBSOLETE. Page 1 of 3 17 DIRECTIONS TO THE SITE The site is located on Lancaster Highway, immediately west of it's intersection with US Hwy 521, in Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. 18 Nature of Activity (Description of project, include all features) Project involves the construction of a mixed use residential and commercial development known as Elevation Church. Components of project include a church and associated infrastructure, office retail, multifamily residential housing units, storm water detention ponds, and buffer /open spaces 19 Project Purpose (Describe the reason or purpose of the project, see instructions) The basic purpose of the project is to construct a mixed -use residential and commercial development. Specifically, the overall project purpose is to construct a mixed -use residential and commercial development to include a church and associated infrastructure, office retail, and multifamily residential housing units, on Lancaster Highway, in Charlotte, Mecklenburg County, North Carolina USE BLOCKS 20 -23 IF DREDGED AND /OR FILL MATERIAL IS TO BE DISCHARGED 20 Reason(s) for Discharge The discharge of fill material is required to construct a road crossing to access the site, fill for grading to construct the required slopes for building pads, and fill for the construction of storm water detention ponds 21 Type(s) of Material Being Discharged and the Amount of Each Type in Cubic Yards Type Type Type Amount in Cubic Yards Amount in Cubic Yards Amount in Cubic Yards 30,085 22 Surface Area in Acres of Wetlands or Other Waters Filled (see instructions) Acres 2 27 acres of open water pond and 0 24 acre of wetland or Linear Feet 85 linear feet of stream channel 23 Description of Avoidance, Minimization, and Compensation (see instructions) The applicant has avoided a majority of wetlands and stream channels on the site Only minor impacts are proposed to access the site and construct stable slopes for building pads The majority of the impacts (2 27 acres) are to man -made open water ponds on the site which are unavoidable due to their location on the property A portion of the ponds will be converted to storm water detention ponds which is similar to the functions they are providing now The proposed mitigation plan of payment into NCEEP will offset any permanent impacts associated with the project ENG FORM 4345, OCT 2012 Page 2 of 3 24 Is Any Portion of the Work Already Complete? QYos gm, IF YES. DESCRIBE THE COMPLETED WORK 25. Addresses of Adiomtng Property Ovators, Lessees. Etc.. Whose Property Adjoins the Waterbody kN mme mm can to mum two. mm eamm a sumw maw aul a Address - Sec htttaclicd Itst City - State - Zip - b Address. City - State - ZIP - c Address - City - State. Zip - d Address - City - State - Zip - e Address Qty - State - ZIP - 26 List of Other Ceni tlites or ApprovafalDensals received from of m Federal. State. or Local Agerxiss for Work Described In This Applic Mm AGENCY TYPE APPROVAL" IDENTIFICATION DATE APPLIED DATE APPROVED DATE DENIED NUMBER I City of Charlotte Rezoning 2013 -04 2013 -02 -25 07!1512013 Would include but Is not reshlcted to zoning. building, and flood plain permits 27 Appticaton Is hereby made for perm* to permits to authorize the work described in this eppkCatorh. I oe irhkxmalmn in this appG�tlon is complete and accurate I certify that I possess the authority to undertake the work detseribed there am the dWy authori wd agent of the applicant Iq TGRATUR O APF ICAIVT DATE RE OF AGENT UATE The Application must be signed by the person who desires to undertake the tit activity (app) or it may be signed by a duly authorized agent if the statement in block 11 has been filled out and signed. 18 U.S.C. Section 1001 provides that Whoever, in any manner within the Jurisdiction of any department or agency of the United States knowingly and wiftfully falstfces, conceals. or covers up any trick, scheme, or dit guises a materW fact or makes any false, fktittous or freudufent statements or representations or makes or uses arty false writing or document know(rig same to contain any false, fictitious or fraudulent statements or entry, shall be fined not more than $10.000 or imprisoned not more than five years or both ENG FORM 4345 OCT 2012 Page 3 of 3 Ecosystem PROGRAM February 17,2014 George Macon Merrifield Patrick Vermillion 521 E Morehead St , Suite 400 Charlotte, NC 28202 Project: Elevation Church Expiration of Acceptance: August 17, 2014 County: Mecklenburg This is a conditional acceptance letter. The purpose of this letter is to notify you that the North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program (NCEEP) is willing to accept payment for compensatory mitigation for impacts associated with the above referenced project as indicated in the table below Please note that this decision does not assure that participation in the NCEEP will be approved by the permit issuing agencies as mitigation for project impacts It is the responsibility of the applicant to contact these agencies to determine if payment to the NCEEP will be approved. You must also comply with all other state, federal of local government permits, regulations or authorizations associated with the proposed activity including SL 2009 -337 An Act to Piomote the Use of Compensatory Miti €ration Banks as amended by S L 2011 -343 This acceptance is valid for six months from the date of this letter and is not transferable if we have not received a copy of the issued 404 Permit /401 Certification /CAMA permit within this time frame, this acceptance will expire. It is the applicant's responsibility to send copies of the permits to NCEEP Once NCEEP receives a copy of the permit(s) an invoice will be issued based on the required mitigation in that permit and payment must be made prior to conducting the authorized work The amount of the In- Lieu Fee to be paid to NCEEP by an applicant is calculated based upon the I-ee Schedule and policies listed at www nceep net Based on the information supplied by you in your request to use the NCEEP the impacts that may require compensatory mitigation are summarized in the following table The amount of mitigation required and assigned to NCEEP for this impact is determined by permitting agencies and may exceed the impact amounts shown below _ River CU Stream (feet) Wetlands (acres) Buffer I Buffer 11 Basin Location (Sq Ft ) (Sq Ft ) Cold Cool Warm Ri arian Non- Riparian Coastal Marsh Impact Catawba 03050103* 0 0 0 050 0 0 0 0 *The Catawba 03 Expanded Service Area will be utilized for this impact Upon receipt of payment, EEP will take iesponsibilrty for providing the compensatory mitigation The mitigation will be performed in accordance with the N C Department of Environment and Natural Resources' Ecosystem Enhancement Program in -Lieu Fee Instiument dated July 28, 2010 v Thank you for your interest in the NCEEP If you have any questions or need additional information, please contact Kelly Williams at (919) 707 -8915 Sincerely, JameU Stanfill Asset Management Supervisor cc Karen Higgins, NCDWR Wetlands /401 Unit Steve Kichefski, USACE - Asheville Alan Johnson, NCDWR - Mooresville Len Rindner,agent File R.P,storu2g... E ... Prot"' 0W hate, �� NCDENR North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program, 1652 Mail Service Center, Raleigh, NC 27699 -1652 / 919 - 707 -8976 / www nceep net Maps /Location Information LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning CL CL e c :)N '31101)NH: C c o oot .315 IIM1 GY3H3110W 15Y3 lZ5 �� c L 5311213dObd ndW Z g _ O x v A u` o :)N 'KIOI21 D F f- �! ` ` ° ° Y`o HJ2if1HJ N011�dn3�3 Goo u b b ry "a oV O w o 5 sod � � ta�ca5�� V� Yd n W 5 >- os c 64•r py a1e15 n' �rt 3OWto, Ad O S � 0 3 „ � d 4 o s 9 0 J`Ct` -yY V yJ N 4 r> a o � A W p� o�p�4or W U W a U 8.19.64 L VV 2U h� N w `aW A� ta�ca5�� V� Yd n W 5 >- os c 64•r py a1e15 n' �rt 3OWto, Ad O S � 0 3 „ � d 4 o s 9 0 J`Ct` -yY V yJ N a o W W U W � U 8.19.64 Pd h� e ?p ea i ,P46 �y Qqq .1 i3 Cif N 4 Q� �Q y� yO o I r 8 9 O C O cl O 9 C O I t i� 4.v; K � o ,7(2 g 5 b9 n« N o� r 'I�plufi Fvr � c Is��PS (N Y� v •; v� -53 �n um o '- r o� v v� D% E Cv �� a8 _H V L 91 dZ a V$ Co .0 Y ■ a e o� N Q Q a e ,� a PHBM �GO SSG ' n ON '31101MVH: a V g ���ifl7 E a 4 pC " S311'd3dO'dd AdVY Y •y- p Y 0 - a :)N '31LOI'VH:) �l Z b HadnHD NOIIVA313 v e G � u w ■ a o 3" P r qy 410 � PHBM �GO SSG ' n ON '31101MVH: V CL Q ���ifl7 DO9'31S'133211S OV3H3VOh 1SV3 HS a 4 pC O S311'd3dO'dd AdVY Y a :)N '31LOI'VH:) �l Z HadnHD NOIIVA313 v e G � u w o a o 3" P t.� C CE i v x a 9 R C E 75 d k E nt��$trcet o trSUert fan � ¢ x c ■ l,Dt�'o w 4 � ' [s v ¢ c V W x W U `a��ada rid- .orrt. � U S U�PudB s,J ;Ji oyc f z MAP t. n n� St dh van R Klge (h 1Q4lrt1 tal5Iuv.]jv V ���ifl7 a pC O a Y �l p v e ' pgter HWY 6 P qy 410 � . w Y JSG i Q X so !Q mOIA Adl6 bUf i l\ e r 2 p o W t V U 7 � y ¢ 4 9 ¢ c V W x W U `a��ada rid- .orrt. � U S U�PudB s,J ;Ji oyc f z MAP t. n n� St dh van R Klge (h 1Q4lrt1 tal5Iuv.]jv r B u � , 1 BndyeviewI n Nevr PIOVtjenoe %.; 4, johamplon Club G y °.a Nalk Z a ti /"- � g ">;h', �`31evk d a • b �c O 0 0 0 5 8 is O 0 a 0 0 0 N 3� a� E� a� cy O a o (J N T 0 v u c og pp; O So a° 6� na n� L a o d= c 0 c n o� a O O o � O U ar! ���ifl7 dl� a �l r B u � , 1 BndyeviewI n Nevr PIOVtjenoe %.; 4, johamplon Club G y °.a Nalk Z a ti /"- � g ">;h', �`31evk d a • b �c O 0 0 0 5 8 is O 0 a 0 0 0 N 3� a� E� a� cy O a o (J N T 0 v u c og pp; O So a° 6� na n� L a o d= c 0 c n o� a O O o � O U ar! O 8 G N 3N d 'IUOlaVH] o e Ou4'31S'iMIS OV3HROW iM IZS .� o CO 2 6 CO E $ `o z c _a °g e Q —� M Cr :)N'31- LOI"HJ O ? �! b V o HMnHD NOI- LVA313 z G YQ V V N v. h u = CY d O V Q Y G T v .G 0 i5 Oro W J W a a j O d W Z > N 0-0 Q V 0 JZni 8 H C) ryQ i I= a = z Dza_�v zw -j m i o 0 T 0 L `o O CpA YX ^� N O o � uo n. El v; o�v �a€ �n �p r o" vs li �E s� 0 v o N O � T O y O an L.0 F L e" 0. O dZ s V l C C a n m •� e o o� M Q-0 s ° 00 p� O ° V .ri 7 Q °o C 004 315 'l331ll5 aV3HROW 1543 125 n S311iJ3dMdd Adh q ® p C "" m c d b d v o c S u z d0u n ■ 7N '31101aVH7 Q 004 315 'l331ll5 aV3HROW 1543 125 g Q S311iJ3dMdd Adh �N '3110�21VH� "" HJ,*dnHD fVOSldn313 Gz'� o S u z d0u a 5 D d a D i 7 i t s S h i f C 0 m o c n m r , 0 m CL 8 d c :)N'311OIWH] _� d `c 0. 00t 'US '133b1S CWH31W 10 15V3 i ZS g Q r a e S311*d3dO'dd AdW A g p "p- 4 B e vi M p P Y N y C ; �g JN'3110111VH:) (� 3 t! �o HDmHD NOIIVA313 czo s � • s O It �. ,.� • `� -..`r 4 _ � s �� � � l` to %" tf t kI CIE a iF • - � Y ' � �; b T O a n v c 0 0 v m o -1 Z N a a O CL 0 N 0Q C3 _ t\ 0 r4 I Q LA _ c Oz a^ �v ° z0 Q0 ° T S 0 0 a N O 8' a� E� Fn€ S 68G uW 0 T 00 � V C � O V b� aCL my 0 dz S $ �o a 0 o` a o o$ M 00 S� Site Plans LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning CL C ,� o g DN'31101NVH:) °o V Z OOV 31S'133nS OV3HRIOW 15V3 tZ5 °o O 5311'OdOldd AM N Z O O CL a c o o< �N '3.11OnVH� v L/1 Z N b b 3 V HD,*dnHJ NOIIVA3-13 G=o � o a o .::..: 3W � � ro« tic\ W W cr LLJ U) Z W I O Q: V i, ZEN C'1n �Q �QO t ,ZN0 Wdcp _ W�N 4,'- � / ~err 3�0 g]Op hNLO Q I� QOM ., aNr'n 300 LO Zro ` EL tz o ; i i( 1 �-j /�l %�f 'j �/,' / /1/ ,;,� Lr, c~/) }t �1v`(ti��(( � O,i / i' nO `'f QQN I=) \• �0, CL IL \ \ Q tz W a � ill li I ` \ LJ Q V) m��� o w 00 NUS Z C14 0 o , r v o % LLJ Cr Cr 1 / _ O Vli. o g f cO �. `/ I tl��,�'t li' \ I�/ ` r �^�Z dry 2 i l I'\ k'jlttl i, // , ~'NOJ O N Z C; ZOO CL - Z iv, 4 O °o ` XoN Z OO Z Q �r 001, 31S'1BUS OV3H3TlOW 1SV3 I ZS rn °o F N -j 0 m P g ® N u c c rn� d A� 0p 'e p O p C v ro aw I 1 LLI <QW < 0 Z W O mQm�. JN'3110121VHJ ...... \�w5 IV'\ � „; I 'V) H�dnHD NOIIVA31 , 0 NJ00 w W N 1w N - Z iv, 4 ON '31LOlaVHJ °o ` XoN Z OO Z Q �r 001, 31S'1BUS OV3H3TlOW 1SV3 I ZS \ °o F N -j 0 k S311'OdO28d AM N , m 0:5 - I\ �oJ CL CL I 1 LLI <QW < 0 Z W O mQm�. JN'3110121VHJ � o \�w5 IV'\ � „; I 'V) H�dnHD NOIIVA31 , 0 NJ00 Q N N N z O 0 dou a w W N 1w N - Z iv, 4 O W XoN Z OO H Q �r W �; \ F N -j 0 k O O N , 0:5 - I\ �oJ CL CL I 1 LLI <QW < Z W O mQm�. C3 \�w5 IV'\ 30 I 'V) �O 0 NJ00 N N N O M • /I ;�:'A% - JJ� t���' ii�i'�U � � • - • �'I � I1 � r'�� 1 std. ' � , ``t `�� �� _ 1� . w W N 1w N - Z iv, 4 O W XoN Z OO H Q �r W �; \ F N -j 0 k O O N , 0:5 O O ~ t I\ �oJ CL CL I 1 LLI <QW < Z W O mQm�. C3 \�w5 IV'\ 30 I 'V) �O 0 NJ00 w W N 1w N � N Q LA 0 Z = ON V Z 2 0 1 O u1 I� T m b O O C_ 0 O O 0. 0. �4 V U m K O� O 0 a L m � C N i �a N V O � .2 � V � g at E8 -0 d oy a� n 0 m O TC o" 0 v� c o� mE c 3 � 0 L W `0 T o� na yv i 0 CLZ O C O N F d e �$ ec u c� o:5 N 0 v T � O m V r - Z QQZLLJ 4 O W XoN Z OO H Q �r W �; U Z w -j 0 1 J In N , amj O O ~ t cO LO LLI <QW < Z W O mQm�. C3 �ui �M W 30 OF JO: �O 0 NJ00 N N N O M � N Q LA 0 Z = ON V Z 2 0 1 O u1 I� T m b O O C_ 0 O O 0. 0. �4 V U m K O� O 0 a L m � C N i �a N V O � .2 � V � g at E8 -0 d oy a� n 0 m O TC o" 0 v� c o� mE c 3 � 0 L W `0 T o� na yv i 0 CLZ O C O N F d e �$ ec u c� o:5 N 0 v T � O m V r - Z QQZLLJ %/ b /sl �' �� XoN Z OO — �O `r' LLI Q tr N , Z O O ~ t cO LO 0 O � N Q LA 0 Z = ON V Z 2 0 1 O u1 I� T m b O O C_ 0 O O 0. 0. �4 V U m K O� O 0 a L m � C N i �a N V O � .2 � V � g at E8 -0 d oy a� n 0 m O TC o" 0 v� c o� mE c 3 � 0 L W `0 T o� na yv i 0 CLZ O C O N F d e �$ ec u c� o:5 N 0 v T � O m V r a 3 0 at IOALI 2 H I:I `W' i H D W H N 8 a � � c n r c c u C C W 0 v o, c c a m goo m v b w o - � 0� q ;Vo 5 ON '311olaVHJ a to LLJ 004 31S '133US OV3H3bOW 1SV3 l ZS c S311b3dOl8d AdW o u p V9 N :)N '3110'1'SVHJ w U LtJ HDiinHD NOIIVA313 CO Goo N Ulu a d U a w a Q V9 N to w U CO O a a a a a w H w O_ c. 0. 'n LLI Q V) Ul to N d Z> LL O O O � M n Q N F- Q w d 00 ch Lt) e-I W O Ln N > Q U LL Z w W N N W LNLJ a Z W W LL CC N O m z U Q Uj O W U J Z_ Uj or- Of w G G 0 Z Z V N CL I_ = CC W • U N Q Q N Z n' o = w N Z n cc U= W W d' N W 2 O= a a w w U U U w Q Q Q a Q to ~Q CA LL LL.� N N Ln ci 1 Z r-1 `� `� I- z O 0 o w O O O P O: O N' N B F- N Cf N M C7 V d Z w Z C7 } a W O N W LLJ d U M F_- • CC U L w W J 0 W x V N Z O_ V N Z Z p OCO w o 111 N ry �o in a a Q w CO O H w H N cc LLI Q O Q O C7 Z> LL O O Q Q = Q N F- Q w Uj W O Ln N > Q U LL Z w W N N W LNLJ a Z W W LL U O m z U Q Uj O W Z J OC Uj or- Of w G G 0 Z d V V w CL = UU = CC W • • • • • • W J 0 W x V N Z O_ V N Z Z p OCO w o 111 N ry �o in a O OW 0 N I&AJI wr;�' � Val, 8 o uj L'i M '0 Uj 7N'311018VH7 0 no > z V, C, 00t, 3lS'.L33NlSGV3H3'dOW1SV3 lZS 0" < 0 E 53112l3dO2ld AdN Z Li z m 0 Z M 0 0_0 < 0 C� 0<0 -Z z 0' �j < U Cl. 0 Z X a r ! 8 '6 :)N'3110111VH:) 'k F C*4 2 Q MO cc: Lu LLJ x 0 0 H D "d nHD NOIIVA313 V"" V) z 0 > �L—Ll < Lu F- - 5 ui / I 0 �i z > L, o x > 2G 0 z L'i LO z CN LLI w CL Cj t5LAJ . . . . . . w0 Xom LA ", "'WO LA V, 0 V) IN, Ln J 7; z 0 Lon Tzno 'o—C' < 0 < 10 A I k� L'J <' V m > 0 C) k�l ,cam l LLJ 0 > 0 io LLJ 0 n-- y/' 0 F- Ib z (z) 0 JC , // , / LLJ LLJ n z > 0 0 22 N X Z LLI (Lto Z Ld LL 0 LL) <0 < LO Lc) cli r\l C> Li uj L'i M '0 no m in w 0" < 0 no Of Z M Z Li z m 0 Z M 0 0_0 j X Ak k C� 0<0 -Z z 0' �j < U Cl. 0 CL 0 X Ilk I 'k F C*4 2 Q MO 0<0 z LLJ Lrn' x 0 x LL1 LLJ < V"" Lj- C14 . LAJ o m - (D 8 �j 0 �L—Ll < Lu F- - 5 ui / I 0 �i L, o x > 2G 0 z L'i LO z CN LLI w CL CL oox u) a- LLJ cr 0 D L) Cj t5LAJ . . . . . . w0 Xom LA ", "'WO LA V, 0 V) IN, Ln J 7; z 0 Lon Tzno 'o—C' < 0 < 10 A I k� L'J <' V m > 0 C) k�l ,cam l LLJ 0 > 0 io LLJ 0 n-- y/' 0 F- Ib z (z) 0 JC , // , / LLJ LLJ n z > 0 0 22 N X Z LLI (Lto Z Ld LL 0 LL) <0 < LO Lc) cli r\l C> Li CL 7 g d c e v�mo 5 c c 8� ® 0 yy 0 Ctf O g L y V b u C C v c n a p _ l c z� c a a � V H ■ I , LLI Uj ce Z W o C13 j OC / Li.l U f rn LLJ Ln \•_ `\ t > ` LLJ 'N ce J a Al 1 <u LLJ O o 1\ \ �\ /� O uj VV ° W / M W Q' 0 / // i / Ln co 0 1 /! ��yw� ?ti0 mQ % r �> w 1 ?i O ll/� bti d Q i SO4O�O b`{ i r' / / � ol l / Q�U ��v / Il ! �' /NLL \ �C z Q / ( 1 r,1 i J O \� gr \ 30 LLJ ce 1 F- \ \ \ z Lm � � \ LLI \ M 0 ■ ' O a v m m v O CL d 0 0 u 'o z c rn m `o 8- m m O C w2 p O N O O V r 'oo 4u v « Y M E� s 0.1 cy o� a€ �m o. V N O �c o" ° vu � e O$ °' E 0 c m O � c� 0 na N 9 i O dZ Q V m O � C iL am c� p0 e� r ®o a r la o °m U$ JN '31LOUVHO °oi LLU 004 31S'133L15 aV3H3NOW iSV3 lZS o � S3112i3d021d ndW X LQ f :)N'31101aVHJ ° o U HD2if1H' NOIl`dn313 JJ 03u CL N I , LLI Uj ce Z W o C13 j OC / Li.l U f rn LLJ Ln \•_ `\ t > ` LLJ 'N ce J a Al 1 <u LLJ O o 1\ \ �\ /� O uj VV ° W / M W Q' 0 / // i / Ln co 0 1 /! ��yw� ?ti0 mQ % r �> w 1 ?i O ll/� bti d Q i SO4O�O b`{ i r' / / � ol l / Q�U ��v / Il ! �' /NLL \ �C z Q / ( 1 r,1 i J O \� gr \ 30 LLJ ce 1 F- \ \ \ z Lm � � \ LLI \ M 0 ■ ' O a v m m v O CL d 0 0 u 'o z c rn m `o 8- m m O C w2 p O N O O V r 'oo 4u v « Y M E� s 0.1 cy o� a€ �m o. V N O �c o" ° vu � e O$ °' E 0 c m O � c� 0 na N 9 i O dZ Q V m O � C iL am c� p0 e� r ®o a r la o °m U$ 0 8 N �N'3LLOIHVH0 ° M c b o m 004 315'133N15 OV3H3NOW 15V3 HS 0 Z `- a_ S311213dOldd ndIN LL m x p m M 6��1 b v c :)N '31-LOI)dVH:) z a ro c A 2 yam HDd* nHD NOLLVAII3 J c=a .c c 2 A c CL a LLJ - \- d w \ cN \ m� \ p / m CL Qw w J \ / OA �RE LLJ W> C W CL N CO / i i m a O \w ~ ; Z jSe /� 009 0 9 up V w a 0 g yU/ Vf JN '31101NVHJ o V v rn b o Q E 004 31S'133t11S OV3FMOW L W SV3 IZS u ® c o g S311'd3dO'dd AM Y Y A cc c m c $' m9 LL n Q d C c ph m ° a v a o °„ =° JN '31-LOI'dVHD Q X Er u C] d ro b A V C W HJ21f1H' N011b'n313 Goa o aou ■ LL L \ w(.0 /// I % 1 N N r \ Z LLJ / O \ Q \ \ \ Q Ln - \ \ O \ \ u1 e 0 o L/1 N N c / ' v r d I �N I all I � O a � m 09 o� m O i €N 0w 0 \ �o \ y \ o� a€ V N O c� c'G rn� \ 5E Po 3L pl 90 aZ - L -• V C m� :m am IU$ ELEVATION CHURCH ENHANCEMENT VEGETATION PLAN 2 -14 -14 The enhancement area has three general areas which are depicted by the different native seed mixes; Stabilization, Wetland, and Preserved Wetlands. The stabilization area is a more intermittent with primary flow occurring around peak rain events. The wetland area is predominately wet year round with additional flow input during peak rain events. Preserved wetlands are not to receive any seeding. Native seed mixes are listed below. Coir fiber logs are to be installed to help maintain stable flow during peak events as well as to prevent any undesirable erosion surrounding the enhancement area. The coir fiber logs will receive live stakes to help stabilize the enhancement area. Live stake species list are listed below. Log steps are to be installed in one location to ensure the peak water flow follows the prescribed course. Log steps can be constructed from live trees found onsite. To ensure that the flow follows the prescribed course a shallow (3 "- 4" deep) ditch is to be dug. The entire enhancement area is to be mated with coir fiber erosion fabric. Native Stabilization Seed Mix (20 -25 Ibs. per acre): Elymus virginicus (Virginia wild rye), Tripsacum dactyloides (Eastern gammagrass), Panicum virgatum (Switchgrass), Agrostis scabra (Rough bentgrass), Carex vulpmoidea (Fox sedge), Tridens flavus (Purple top), Sch►zachynum scopanum (Little bluestem), Coreopsis lanceolata (Lance leaf tickseed), Sorghastrum nutans (Indian grass), Elymus hystnx (Bottlebrush grass) Festuca ovma var. durnuscala (Hard Fescue), Rudbeckia hirta (Blackeyed Susan) Native Wetland Seed Mix (20 -25 Ibs. per acre): Elymus riparius (Riverbank wild rye), Agrostis stolonifera (Creeping bentgrass), Carex vulpinoidea (Fox sedge), Panicum virgatum (Switchgrass), Poa palustns (Fowl bluegrass), D►chanthehum clandestinum (Deer tongue), Bidens aristosa (Bidens), Juncus effusus (Soft rush), Sag►ttana lat►folia (Duck Potato), Saururus cernuus (Lizard Tail) Live Stake Species (3' on center): Corpus amomum (Silky Dogwood), Salix caroliniano (Carolina Willow), Sal►xsencea (Silky Willow), Sambucus canodens►s (Elderberry), Physocarpos opulifolius (Ninebark) ELEVATION CHURCH ENHANCEMENT Charlotte, NC STABILIZATION SEED MIX WETLAND AREA "G" - �* 0.0213 AC TO REMAIN f �� ') • � WETLAND AREA "E" EXISTING % -'- WETLAND r 0 2787 AC TO BE REMOVED PRESERVED OVERFLOW PIPE OPENWATER POND "F' 0 3585 AC TO BE REMOVED �--� OPEN 1.572: FLOW WETLAND PATTERN SEED MIX DOUBLE _ . _� 4 (`, •� _ • "•j ~ LOG STEPS _ WETLANDS AREA "C &D" - ` 0.0675 AC TO REMAIN COIR FIBER EXISTING LOGS WETLAND PRESERVED " STREAM "B1' 222 LF TO REMAIN, _ ' ;z STREAN 85 LF TO BE-REMOVED �, I• Figure No. LEONARD S RINDNER PLLC Page. Wetlands & Environmental Planning Group 3714 Spokeshave Lane ENHANCEMENT Matthews, NC 28105 (704) 904 — 2277 Reviewed LEN RINDNER PWS @gmail com Sheet Page. ELEVATION CHURCH ENHANCEMENT Drawn Reviewed by NRN by LSR SKETCH MAP *Approximate Boundary Date: 2 14 -14 / Stormwater Plans LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning a 0 6 Im r U Gail sp- I 0 0 rn v M r 'tl rn „ -�dg ,y `w c c p C V N d p a 0 4 Z W W C W w w OW Z DN'31101NVHD z ^°o O W W 004 31S '133N1S OV3H3NOW 15V3 LZS V S311213dO'dd nd VY N N u ZQ 7N '3J- LOIWH:) a LY Q Z d N HD,*dnHD NOLLVA3�3 N J o ° o m rjr= = w OW � z Z Ln W O w a LY Q a N J O m 0C = = O Q O C Z LL N LLJ CC r14 O M Z w 0 w W Z N p L0 O Q Q w _ = O N c - O J W = w= J>- LU LL w > O CC a w o O N R < Z Z Z lZ CL r � W W Q Q � O w w m Z N w LY U LY LLJ Lu OJ O LY O Q a W O H a L H ._I Fv w J = 0 LL J CO V) (A N O w Q cc F- \ c F" C _ Z ,t 'g Z 0 Ln U n Ln 0 O D r, w OW N Z Ln Z g w d Z W Q m as C d w w O N O LL LLJ z M Q C7 _ V) W O U a J O m Z W CC N9 G W = J J J>- W J NZ Q = m aZ ma W jQ o O N R < O Z Z O , r � d U C9 N LL 0- H OC L U J LU w w _ Z z 3uw CO CO �w -O NN Z O Lu o� O 0- o d 0 W H a • a O 0 LL a 0 N Q N m� W LL z 0 V1 a � o I � G rn ro E ` 7 c C O W p fi ll d aroi a i c N O- ro u S v c n - C c ro N • • ' C ■ I 1 \\ I 7N 'lUO -DIVH7 °o•� 004 31S'13RUS OV3MHOW 1SV3 LZS c S31183dO'dd AdIN N JN '31101211+HJ ° °o HD"dnHJ NOIldn313 `W Gio Q Mo vVi ' o u w W Q c, m 0 h N c T 0 '0 m C m C_ m O O C O Q a CL n 0 m V 0 0 N m C O� m 0 O T O a m r m 0� w2 N 0 U r O V 0 N _ « L Cm ; U O Os v ; %.m. o" a€ �n U O C « O O v C O O O C_ E O O v`0 H T i7 O CL Cl m v Q « a 0 ,l z e 0 U °y 10 o � c Oc rz m c 'n °D u o` _ L o « N 0 a m ?� m G m 0 U ..t+ Jurisdictional Determination LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning �r Il ELEVATION CHURCH j( ej • t •,II r , 66b .tom / . / N1 651 C�. �l • 1 1•`• � • • N. C� Dyad '•. SITE B 40 0 • %li�J • i ,i f O �ty_ 685 . rip �0 )• �\ • ` `�j • // LOCATION: \\ $i1vr RUr► \, _,i Lam` LATITUDE LONGITUDE SCALE 1400 700 0 1400lFeeq cern i% \ • 35.0301 N 80.8587 W J {• ' M • HUC 03050103 �\ • 670 Lower Catawba FIGURE NO. LEONARD S. RINDNER PLLC Wetlands & Environmental Planning Group 3714 Spokeshave Lane Matthews, INC 28105 (704) 904 - 2277 LEN. RINDNER.PWS @gmail.com ELEVATION CHURCH MECKLENBURG COUNTY, NC USGS LOCATION MAP APPROXIMATE LOCATION WEDDINGTON NC -SC QUADRANGLE 1968 Revised 1984 SHEET. DRAWN JAL REVIEWED LSR BY BY DATE: PAGE 06 /05 /13 f d � x�1e� 1 Li I►[ � L' l� 13� Ii Come v R��i Service FIGURE NO. I LEONARD S. RINDNER PLLC Wetlands & Environmental Planning Group 3714 Spokeshave Lane Matthews, NC 28105 (704) 904 — 2277 LEN. RINDNER. PWS @gmail.com ELEVATION CHURCH CHARLOTTE, INC NRCS SOIL MAP APPROXIMATE LOCATION SHEET: 1 OF 2 DRAWN BY: REVIEWED 1-SR BY: BY: DATE: I PAGE 06 N5 /13 C). s CL r.� Cher/ 0 4. o + Py ✓� •i a CL •�� ; Pro VencP mom. V 3� 1 M. ,r *` Jk 1 i t 'd rte, •�f low ob Redstone M d J r - .�. Copper Mou,?r,,,� ro e �y *` Jk 1 i t 'd rte, •�f low ob Redstone M d J r - .�. Copper Mou,?r,,,� ro ¢� Qx0 Zso o z�z �W v i7 5�N f N_ rr.6 25 21 jN O SQf o � C y W U 2.r »laui onralo. � W t VI 'k / III!!!,! H:)bf1H:) NOLLVA313 3 - :'•I '^ mY -_ .. z d z >. JD g oz Z a .c J z� /.y Cam. _--- OZ a, OZ UJ� UJW o y y � I UQLL y �a, _ �+�,�. N v W i- a3 W N o a UHY'b��� a V W r , ' ' m W O wvusm� „amwr �p ^r Sat. a W - - v O -t- O -� it [ zee O ram 1 pZ m i U y W E 22 m r IL (/ 1 ![d J Z0 , S J in - O I uj y3 Z , , y \ -j WaU m 'n J m za J J D z� a o z as O OD Oa v Sz o J OF uj �a 3 �a �y -, y 1 ~' = I J < 3 1 a o a O H J U Q Q J Z O_Q� N Q 7 W �, W a3 ~ Z = °u, h Ix M CL WETLAND DETERMINATION DATA FORM — Eastern Mountains and Piedmont Region Project/Site Elevation Church City/County Charlotte /Mecklenburg County Sampling Date 04108113 Applicant/Owner State NC Sampling Point UPL 1 Investigator(s) LSR, PJK, JAL Section, Township, Range Landform (hillslope, terrace, etc ) Floodplain Local relief (concave, convex, none) Concave Slope ( %) 0 - 3% Subregion (LRR or MLRA) MLRA 136 Lat 35 03200 N Long 80 85603 W Datum WGS84 Soil Map Unit Name MO — Monacan loam, 0 — 2% slopes, frequently flooded NWI classification Are climatic / hydrologic conditions on the site typical for this time of year? Yes Y No (If no, explain in Remarks) Are Vegetation N Soil N or Hydrology N significantly disturbed? Are "Normal Circumstances" present? Yes X No Are Vegetation N Soil N or Hydrology N naturally problematic? (If needed, explain any answers in Remarks ) SUMMARY OF FINDINGS — Attach site map showing sampling point locations, transects, important features, etc. Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? Yes No X Is the Sampled Area ' Hydnc Sod Present? Yes No X within a Wetland? Yes No X Wetland Hydrology Present? Yes No X Remarks For the week of 04/07/13 through 04/13/13 Avg /Max/Min Temp(F) 67/84/42, Precip Total (in ) 0 66 Previous 48hrs Precip (in ) 0 00 HYDROLOGY Wetland Hydrology Indicators Secondary Indicators (minimum of two required) Primary Indicators (minimum of one is required, check all that aooly) _ Surface Sod Cracks (136) _ Surface Water (Al) _ True Aquatic Plants (614) _ Sparsely Vegetated Concave Surface (68) _ High Water Table (A2) _ Hydrogen Sulfide Odor (Cl) _ Drainage Patterns (610) _ Saturation (A3) _ Oxidized Rhizospheres on Living Roots (C3) _ Moss Trim Lines (816) _ Water Marks (B1) _ Presence of Reduced Iron (C4) _ Dry- Season Water Table (C2) _ Sediment Deposits (B2) _ Recent Iron Reduction in Tilled Sods (C6) _ Crayfish Burrows (C8) _ Drift Deposits (63) _ Thin Muck Surface (C7) _ Saturation Visible on Aerial Imagery (C9) _ Algal Mat or Crust (64) _ Other (Explain in Remarks) _ Stunted or Stressed Plants (D1) _ Iron Deposits (65) _ Geomorphic Position (D2) _ Inundation Visible on Aerial Imagery (B7) _ Shallow Agwtard (133) _ Water - Stained Leaves (B9) _ Microtopographic Relief (D4) _ Aquatic Fauna (1313) _ FAC- Neutral Test (135) Field Observations Surface Water Present? Yes No Depth (inches) Water Table Present? Yes No Depth (inches) Saturation Present? Yes No Depth (inches) Wetland Hydrology Present? Yes No X (includes capillary fringe) Describe Recorded Data (stream gauge, monitoring well, aerial photos, previous inspections), if available Remarks US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont — Version 2 0 VEGETATION (Five Strata) — Use scientific names of plants. Sampling Point, UPL 1 2 (A) 10 (B) 20% (A /B) 35 = Total Cover Prevalence Index worksheet Total % Cover of Multiply by 50% of total cover 17 5 20% of total cover 7 OBL species x 1 = Sapling Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Junlperus vlrglniana 15 Y FACU FACW species x 2 = 2 Ulmus alata 10 Y FACU FAC species x 3 = FACU species x 4 = 3 UPL species x 5 = 4 Column Totals (A) (B) 5 6 Prevalence Index = B/A = Absolute Dominant Indicator Dominance Test worksheet Tree Stratum (Plot size 30, ) % Cover Species? Status Number of Dominant Species 1 Junioerus ylrginiana 15 Y FACU That Are OBL, FACW, or FAC Total Number of Dominant Species Across All Strata 2 Pin us taeda 10 Y FAC 3 Ulmus alata 10 N FACU Y 4 — 3 - Prevalence Index is < -3 0' _ 4 - Morphological Adaptations' (Provide supporting data in Remarks or on a separate sheet) 2 Percent of Dominant Species 5 Problematic Hydrophytic Vegetation' (Explain) That Are OBL, FACW, or FAC 6 'Indicators of hydric soil and wetland hydrology must 5 2 (A) 10 (B) 20% (A /B) 35 = Total Cover Prevalence Index worksheet Total % Cover of Multiply by 50% of total cover 17 5 20% of total cover 7 OBL species x 1 = Sapling Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Junlperus vlrglniana 15 Y FACU FACW species x 2 = 2 Ulmus alata 10 Y FACU FAC species x 3 = FACU species x 4 = 3 UPL species x 5 = 4 Column Totals (A) (B) 5 6 Prevalence Index = B/A = 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 25 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 12 5 20% of total cover 5 Woody Vine Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Lonicera laponlca 15 Y FAC 2 3 4 5 15 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 75 20% of total cover 3 (Include photo numbers here or on a separate sheet ) Shrub - Woody plants, excluding woody vines, approximately 3 to 20 ft (1 to 6 m) in height Herb - All herbaceous (non- woody) plants, including herbaceous vines, regardless of size, and woody plants, except woody vines, less than approximately 3 ft (1 m) in height Woody vine - All woody vines, regardless of height Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? Yes No X US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont - Version 2 0 30 = Total Cover Hydrophytic Vegetation Indicators. 50% of total cover 15 20% of total cover 6 — 1 - Rapid Test for Hydrophytic Vegetation Shrub Stratum (Plot size 30' ) _ 2 - Dominance Test is >50% 1 Llgustrum sinense 10 Y FACU — 3 - Prevalence Index is < -3 0' _ 4 - Morphological Adaptations' (Provide supporting data in Remarks or on a separate sheet) 2 3 Problematic Hydrophytic Vegetation' (Explain) 4 'Indicators of hydric soil and wetland hydrology must 5 6 be present, unless disturbed or problematic 10 = Total Cover Definitions of Five Vegetation Strata 50% of total cover 5 20% of total cover 2 Tree -Woody plants, excluding woody vines, Herb Stratum (Plot size 30' ) approximately 20 it (6 m) or more in height and 3 in 1 Asplenlum platyneuron 10 Y FACU (7 6 cm) or larger in diameter at breast height (DBH) Sapling - Woody plants, excluding woody vines. 2 Llgustrum slnense 10 Y FACU 3 Ilex opaca 5 Y FACU approximately 20 ft (6 m) or more in height and less than 3 in (7 6 cm) DBH 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 25 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 12 5 20% of total cover 5 Woody Vine Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Lonicera laponlca 15 Y FAC 2 3 4 5 15 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 75 20% of total cover 3 (Include photo numbers here or on a separate sheet ) Shrub - Woody plants, excluding woody vines, approximately 3 to 20 ft (1 to 6 m) in height Herb - All herbaceous (non- woody) plants, including herbaceous vines, regardless of size, and woody plants, except woody vines, less than approximately 3 ft (1 m) in height Woody vine - All woody vines, regardless of height Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? Yes No X US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont - Version 2 0 SOIL Sampling Point UPL 1 Profile Description (Describe to the depth needed to document the indicator or confirm the absence of indicators ) Depth Matrix Redox Features (inches) Color (moist) % Color (moist) % Type' Loc Texture Remarks 0-20 10YR 6/4 100 Sandy Clay Loam 'Type C= Concentration, D= Depletion, RM= Reduced Matrix, MS= Masked Sand Grains 21-ocation PL =Pore Lining, M =Matrix Hydric Soil Indicators Indicators for Problematic Hydric Soils' _ Hlstosol (Al) _ Dark Surface (S7) _ 2 cm Muck (A10) (MLRA 147) Histic Epipedon (A2) _ Polyvalue Below Surface (S8) (MLRA 147, 148) _ Coast Prairie Redox (A16) Black Histic (A3) _ Thin Dark Surface (S9) (MLRA 147, 148) (MLRA 147, 148) _ Hydrogen Sulfide (A4) _ Loamy Gleyed Matrix (F2) _ Piedmont Floodplaln Soils (F19) _ Stratified Layers (A5) _ Depleted Matrix (F3) (MLRA 136, 147) _ 2 cm Muck (A10) (LRR N) _ Redox Dark Surface (F6) _ Very Shallow Dark Surface (TF12) _ Depleted Below Dark Surface (A11) _ Depleted Dark Surface (F7) _ Other (Explain in Remarks) _ Thick Dark Surface (Al2) _ Redox Depressions (F8) _ Sandy Mucky Mineral (S1) (LRR N, _ Iron - Manganese Masses (F12) (LRR N, MLRA 147, 148) MLRA 136) Sandy Gleyed Matrix (S4) _ Umbrlc Surface (F13) (MLRA 136, 122) 3Indicators of hydrophytic vegetation and Sandy Redox (S5) _ Piedmont Floodplain Soils (F19) (MLRA 148) wetland hydrology must be present, _ Stripped Matrix (S6) _ Red Parent Material (F21) (MLRA 127, 147) unless disturbed or problematic Restrictive Layer (if observed) Type Depth (inches) Hydric Soil Presenter Yes No X Remarks US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont - Version 2 0 WETLAND DETERMINATION DATA FORM - Eastern Mountains and Piedmont Region Project/Site Elevation Church City /County Charlotte /Mecklenburg County Sampling Date 04108113 Applicant/Owner State NC Sampling Point Wtld C/D Investigator(s) LSR, PJK, JAL Section, Township, Range Landform (hdlslope, terrace, etc ) Floodplain Local relief (concave, convex, none) Concave Slope ( %) 0 - 3% Subregion (LRR or MLRA) MLRA 136 Lat 35 03180 N Long 80 85563 W Datum WGS84 Sod Map Unit Name MO - Monacan loam, 0 - 2% slopes, frequently flooded NWI classification Are climatic / hydrologic conditions on the site typical for this time of year? Yes Y No (If no, explain in Remarks ) Are Vegetation N Sod N or Hydrology N significantly disturbed? Are "Normal Circumstances" present? Yes X No Are Vegetation N Sod N or Hydrology N naturally problematic? (If needed, explain any answers in Remarks ) SUMMARY OF FINDINGS - Attach site map showing sampling point locations, transects, important features, etc. Hydrophytic Vegetation Present? Yes X No Is the Sampled Area Hydrrc Soil Present? Yes X No within a Wetland> Yes X No Wetland Hydrology Present? Yes X No Remarks For the week of 04/07/13 through 04/13/13 Avg /Max/Min Tempfl 67/84/42, Precip Total (in ) 0 66 Previous 48hrs Precip (in ) 0 00 HYDROLOGY Wetland Hydrology Indicators Secondary Indicators (minimum of two required) Primary Indicators (minimum of one is reauired, check all that apply) _ Surface Sod Cracks (66) X Surface Water (Al) _ True Aquatic Plants (1314) _ Sparsely Vegetated Concave Surface (B8) X High Water Table (A2) _ Hydrogen Sulfide Odor (Cl) X Drainage Patterns (1310) X Saturation (A3) X Oxidized Rhizospheres on Living Roots (C3) _ Moss Trim Lines (1316) _ Water Marks (B1) _ Presence of Reduced Iron (C4) _ Dry- Season Water Table (C2) _ Sediment Deposits (132) _ Recent Iron Reduction in Tilled Sods (C6) X Crayfish Burrows (C8) _ Drift Deposits (63) _ Thin Muck Surface (C7) _ Saturation Visible on Aerial Imagery (C9) _ Algal Mat or Crust (B4) _ Other (Explain in Remarks) _ Stunted or Stressed Plants (D1) _ Iron Deposits (135) _ Geomorphic Position (D2) _ Inundation Visible on Aerial Imagery (67) _ Shallow Aqwtard (133) _ Water - Stained Leaves (69) _ Microtopographic Relief (D4) _ Aquatic Fauna (1313) X FAC- Neutral Test (D5) Field Observations Surface Water Present? Yes X No Depth (inches) 0 - 3 Water Table Present? Yes X No Depth (inches) 0 - 2 Saturation Present? Yes X No Depth (inches) 0 Wetland Hydrology Present? Yes X No (includes capillary fringe) Describe Recorded Data (stream gauge, monitoring well, aerial photos, previous inspections), if available Remarks US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont — Version 2 0 VEGETATION (Five Strata) — Use scientific names of plants Sampling Point- Wtld C/D 8 (A) 9 (B) 89% (A/B) 60 = Total Cover Prevalence Index worksheet Total % Cover of Multiply by 50% of total cover 30 20% of total cover 12 Sapling Stratum (Plot size 30' 1 Platanus occidentalis 10 2 Llquldambar stvraclflua 10 3 Fraxlnus pennsylvanlca 10 4 5 6 Absolute Dominant Indicator Dominance Test worksheet Tree Stratum (Plot size 30, ) % Cover Species? Status Number of Dominant Species 1 Platanus occidentalls 25 Y FACW That Are OBL, FACW, or FAC 2 liquidambar stvraclflua 25 Y FAC Y FACW UPL species Total Number of Dominant 3 Fraxlnus pennsylvanica 10 N FACW Species Across All Strata 4 Percent of Dominant Species 5 That Are OBL, FACW, or FAC 6 8 (A) 9 (B) 89% (A/B) 60 = Total Cover Prevalence Index worksheet Total % Cover of Multiply by 50% of total cover 30 20% of total cover 12 Sapling Stratum (Plot size 30' 1 Platanus occidentalis 10 2 Llquldambar stvraclflua 10 3 Fraxlnus pennsylvanlca 10 4 5 6 30 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 15 20% of total cover 6 Shrub Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Ligustrum sinense 15 Y FACU 2 3 4 5 6 Prevalence Index = B/A = Hydrophytic Vegetation Indicators. 1 - Rapid Test for Hydrophytic Vegetation X 2 - Dominance Test is >50% _ 3 - Prevalence Index is < -3 0' _ 4 - Morphological Adaptations' (Provide supporting data in Remarks or on a separate sheet) _ Problematic Hydrophytic Vegetation' (Explain) 'Indicators of hydnc sod and wetland hydrology must be present, unless disturbed or problematic 15 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 75 20% of total cover 3 Herb Stratum (Plot size 30' 1 Boehmena cylindrica 10 Y FACW OBL species x 1 = 3 FACW species x 2 = Y FACW 7 8 9 FAC species x 3 = Y FAC FACU species x 4 = Y FACW UPL species x 5 = — Column Totals (A) (B) 30 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 15 20% of total cover 6 Shrub Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Ligustrum sinense 15 Y FACU 2 3 4 5 6 Prevalence Index = B/A = Hydrophytic Vegetation Indicators. 1 - Rapid Test for Hydrophytic Vegetation X 2 - Dominance Test is >50% _ 3 - Prevalence Index is < -3 0' _ 4 - Morphological Adaptations' (Provide supporting data in Remarks or on a separate sheet) _ Problematic Hydrophytic Vegetation' (Explain) 'Indicators of hydnc sod and wetland hydrology must be present, unless disturbed or problematic 15 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 75 20% of total cover 3 Herb Stratum (Plot size 30' 1 Boehmena cylindrica 10 Y FACW Definitions of Five Vegetation Strata Tree -Woody plants, excluding woody vines, approximately 20 it (6 m) or more in height and 3 in (7 6 cm) or larger in diameter at breast height (DBH) Sapling - Woody plants, excluding woody vines, approximately 20 ft (6 m) or more in height and less than 3 in (7 6 cm) DBH Shrub - Woody plants, excluding woody vines, approximately 3 to 20 ft (1 to 6 m) in height Herb - All herbaceous (non- woody) plants, including herbaceous vines, regardless of size, and woody plants, except woody vines, less than approximately 3 ft (1 m) in height Woody vine - All woody vines, regardless of height 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 � 11 10 = Total Cover 50% of total cover 5 20% of total cover 2 Woody Vine Stratum (Plot size 30' ) 1 Lonicera laponlca 30 Y FAC 2 Toxicodendron radicans 10 Y FAC 3 4 5 Remarks (Include photo 50% of total cover 20 rs here or on a separate s 40 = Total Cover 20% of total cover 8 Hydrophytic Vegetation Present'7 Yes X No US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont - Version 2 0 SOIL Sampling Point Wtld C/D Profile Description (Describe to the depth needed to document the indicator or confirm the absence of indicators) Depth Matrix Redox Features (inches) Color (moist) % Color (moist) % Type Loc Texture Remarks —0-6 7 5YR 4/2 85 5YR 4/6 15 C PL tiny I nam 6-20 7 5YR 5/1 95 5YR 4/6 5 C PL c:iay i oam 'Type C= Concentration D= Depletion RM= Reduced Matrix MS= Masked Sand Grains 2Location PL =Pore Lining, M =Matnx Hydric Soil Indicators Indicators for Problematic Hydric Soils'- _ Histosol (Al) _ Dark Surface (S7) _ 2 cm Muck (A10) (MLRA 147) _ Histic Epipedon (A2) _ Polyvalue Below Surface (S8) (MLRA 147, 148) _ Coast Prairie Redox (A16) _ Black Histic (A3) _ Thin Dark Surface (S9) (MLRA 147, 148) (MLRA 147, 148) Hydrogen Sulfide (A4) _ Loamy Gleyed Matrix (F2) _ Piedmont Floodplain Soils (F19) Stratified Layers (A5) X Depleted Matrix (F3) (MLRA 136, 147) 2 cm Muck (A10) (LRR N) _ Redox Dark Surface (F6) _ Very Shallow Dark Surface (TF12) _ Depleted Below Dark Surface (A11) Depleted Dark Surface (F7) _ Other (Explain in Remarks) _ Thick Dark Surface (Al2) X Redox Depressions (F8) Sandy Mucky Mineral (S1) (LRR N, _ Iron - Manganese Masses (F12) (LRR N, MLRA 147, 148) MLRA 136) _ Sandy Gleyed Matrix (S4) _ Umbric Surface (F13) (MLRA 136, 122) 'Indicators of hydrophytic vegetation and _ Sandy Redox (S5) _ Piedmont Floodplain Soils (F19) (MLRA 148) wetland hydrology must be present, Stripped Matrix (S6) _ Red Parent Material (F21) (MLRA 127, 147) unless disturbed or problematic Restrictive Layer (if observed) Type Depth (inches) Remarks Hydric Soil Present? Yes X No US Army Corps of Engineers Eastern Mountains and Piedmont - Version 2 0 STREAM REACH EVALUATION FORM Seasonal RPW B Date 04/03/13 1 Evaluator I LSR, JAL, PJK Easting 80 85557 W Project Elevation Church Seasonal RPW B Northing 35 03127 N Total Points: 2 Stream is at least intermittent if > 19 or perennial if > 30* 28.5 (right-click the purple number and left -click Update Field to summarize points) 0 A. Geomorphology Absent Weak Moderate Strong SCORE 1a Continuity of channel bed and bank 0 1 2 3 3 2 Sinuosity of channel along thalweg 0 1 2 3 2 3 In- channel structure riffle- / step- pool sequence 0 1 2 3 1 4 Particle size of stream substrate 0 1 2 3 1 5 Active /relic flood lain 0 1 2 3 1 1 6 Depositional bars or benches 0 1 2 3 1 7 Recent alluvial deposits 0 1 2 3 2 8 Headcuts 0 1 2 3 1 9 Grade controls 0 05 1 1 5 1 10 Natural valley 0 05 1 1 5 1 11 Second or greater order channel No = 0 Yes = 3 0 Geomorphology Subtotal 140 a Man -made ditches are not rated see discussion in NCDWQ Manual B. Hydrology 12 Presence of Baseflow 0 1 2 3 1 13 Iron Oxidizing Bacteria 0 1 2 3 1 14 Leaf litter 1 5 1 05 0 1 15 Sediment on plants or debris 0 05 1 1 5 1 16 Organic debris lines or piles rack lines 0 05 1 1 5 5 17 Soil -based Evidence of high water table? No = 0 Yes = 3 3 Hydrology Subtotal 75 C. Biology 18 Fibrous roots in streambed 3 2 1 0 2 19 Rooted upland plants in streambed 3 2 1 0 3 20 Macrobenthos note diversity and abundance 0 1 2 3 1 21 Aquatic Mollusks 0 1 2 3 0 22 Fish 0 1 05 1 1 1 5 0 23 Crayfish 0 05 1 1 5 0 24 Amphibians 0 05 1 1 5 05 25 Algae 0 05 1 1 5 05 26 Wetland plants in streambed FACW= 0 75, OBL= 1 5, Other= 0 0 Biology Subtotal 60 * perennial streams may also be identified usinq other methods See page 35 of NCDWQ manual Notes Sandy substrate, Deeply incised Low, slow flow Adapted from NCDWQ Methodology for Identification of Intermittent and Perennial Streams and their (version 4 11) Ongins STREAM REACH EVALUATION FORM Seasonal RPW I Date 04/03/13 1 Evaluator T LSR, JAL, PJK [ffas:ting 80 8587 W Project Elevation Church Seasonal RPW I Northing 35 0301 N Total Points: 2 Stream is at least intermittent if > 19 or perennial if > 30* 23.5 (right-click the purple number and left -click Update Field to summarize points) 0 A. Geomorphology Absent Weak Moderate Strong SCORE 1a Continuity of channel bed and bank 0 1 2 3 2 2 Sinuosity of channel along thalweg 0 1 2 3 1 3 In- channel structure riffle- / step- pool sequence 0 1 2 3 1 4 Particle size of stream substrate 0 1 2 3 1 5 Active /relic flood lain 0 1 2 3 2 6 Depositional bars or benches 0 1 2 3 1 7 Recent alluvial deposits 0 1 2 3 1 8 Headcuts 0 1 2 3 1 9 Grade controls 0 05 1 1 5 5 10 Natural valley 0 05 i 1 5 1 11 Second or greater order channel No = 0 Yes = 3 0 Geomorphology Subtotal " _ 115 a Man -made ditches are not rated see discussion in NCDWQ Manual B. Hydrology 12 Presence of Baseflow 0 1 2 3 2 13 Iron Oxidizing Bacteria 0 1 2 3 0 14 Leaf litter 1 5 1 05 0 1 15 Sediment on plants or debris 0 05 1 1 5 5 16 Organic debris lines or piles rack lines 0 1 05 1 1 1 5 1 17 Soil -based Evidence of high water table? No = 0 Yes = 3 3 Hydrology Subtotal 0 C. Biology 18 Fibrous roots in streambed 3 2 1 0 2 19 Rooted upland plants in streambed 3 2 1 0 2 20 Macrobenthos note diversity and abundance 0 1 2 3 0 21 Aquatic Mollusks 0 1 2 3 0 22 Fish 0 05 1 1 5 0 23 Crayfish 0 05 1 1 5 0 24 Amphibians 0 05 1 1 5 0 25 Algae 0 05 1 1 5 05 26 Wetland plants in streambed FACW= 0 75, OBL= 1 5, Other= 0 0 Biology Subtotal 4 s * perennial streams may also be identified usinq other methods See paqe 35 of NCDWQ manual Notes Algae from high nutrient loading from adjacent development Larger substrate (large gravel & cobble) are recently deposited Adapted from NCDWQ Methodology for Identification of Intermittent and Perennial Streams and their (version 4 11) Ong►ns APPROVED JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION FORM U.S. Army Corps of Engineers This form should be completed by following the instructions provided in Section IV of the JD Form Instructional Guidebook SECTION I: BACKGROUND INFORMATION A. REPORT COMPLETION DATE FOR APPROVED JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION (JD): B. DISTRICT OFFICE, FILE NAME, AND NUMBER. ASHEVILLE REGULATORY FIELD OFFICE US Army Corps of Engineers 151 Patton Avenue, Room 208 Asheville, North Carolina 28801 -5006 APPLICANT- C. PROJECT LOCATION AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION: Elevation Church State NC County/parish/borough Mecklenburg City Charlotte Center coordinates of site (lat/long in degree decimal format) Lat 35 0301 ° N, Long 80 8587 ° W Universal Transverse Mercator 17 Name of nearest waterbody Cleans Branch Name of nearest Traditional Navigable Water (TNW) Into which the aquatic resource flows Catawba River Name of watershed or Hydrologic Unit Code (RUC) 03050103 Lower Catawba ® Check if map /diagram of review area and/or potential Jurisdictional areas is /are available upon request ❑ Check if other sites (e g , offsite mitigation sites, disposal sites, etc ) are associated with this action and are recorded on a different JD form D. REVIEW PERFORMED FOR SITE EVALUATION (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY). ❑ Office (Desk) Determination Date ® Field Determination Date(s) 04/16/2013 SECTION II: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS A. RHA SECTION 10 DETERMINATION OF JURISDICTION. There Are no "navigable waters of the US " within Rivers and Harbors Act (RHA) Jurisdiction (as defined by 33 CFR part 329) in the review area [Required] ❑ Waters subject to the ebb and flow of the tide ❑ Waters are presently used or have been used in the past, or may be susceptible for use to transport interstate or foreign commerce Explain B. CWA SECTION 404 DETERMINATION OF JURISDICTION. There Niel "waters of the U S " within Clean Water Act (CWA) jurisdiction (as defined by 33 CFR part 328) in the review area [Required] Waters of the U.S. a. Indicate presence of waters of U S in review area (check all that apply): i ❑ TNWs, including territorial seas ❑ Wetlands adjacent to TNWs ® Relatively permanent waters' (RPWs) that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs ❑ Non -RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs ® Wetlands directly abutting RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs ® Wetlands adjacent to but not directly abutting RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs ❑ Wetlands adjacent to non -RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs ® Impoundments of jurisdictional waters ❑ Isolated (interstate or intrastate) waters, including isolated wetlands b. Identify (estimate) size of waters of the U.S. in the review area: Non - wetland waters ( + / -) 2203 linear feet ( + / -) 3 - 15width (ft) and /or ( + / -) 0 6843 acres Wetlands ( + / -) 3 1344 acres ' Boxes checked below shall be supported by completing the appropriate sections in Section III below 2 For purposes of this form, an RPW is defined as a tributary that is not a TNW and that typically flows year -round or has continuous flow at least "seasonally" (e g , typically 3 months) Limits (boundaries) of jurisdiction based on 1987 Delineation Manual Elevation of established OHWM (if known) Non - regulated waters /wetlands (check if applicable):' 0 Potentially jurisdictional waters and/or wetlands were assessed within the review area and determined to be not jurisdictional Explain ' Supporting documentation is presented in Section III F SECTION iii. CWA ANALYSIS A. TNWs AND WETLANDS ADJACENT TO TNWs The agencies will assert jurisdiction over TNWs and wetlands adjacent to TNWs. If the aquatic resource is a TNW, complete Section III.A.1 and Section III.D.1 only; if the aquatic resource is a wetland adjacent to a TNW, complete Sections III.A.1 and 2 and Section III.D.1., otherwise, see Section III.B below 1. TNW Identify TNW Summarize rationale supporting determination 2. Wetland adjacent to TNW Summarize rationale supporting conclusion that wetland is "adjacent' B. CHARACTERISTICS OF TRIBUTARY (THAT iS NOT A TNW) AND ITS ADJACENT WETLANDS (IF ANY): This section summarizes information regarding characteristics of the tributary and its adjacent wetlands, if any, and it helps determine whether or not the standards for jurisdiction established under Rapanos have been met. The agencies will assert jurisdiction over non - navigable tributaries of TNWs where the tributaries are "relatively permanent waters" (RPWs), i.e. tributaries that typically flow year -round or have continuous flow at least seasonally (e.g., typically 3 months). A wetland that directly abuts an RPW is also jurisdictional. if the aquatic resource is not a TNW, but has year -round (perennial) flow, skip to Section III.D.2. If the aquatic resource is a wetland directly abutting a tributary with perennial flow, skip to Section III.D.4. A wetland that is adjacent to but that does not directly abut an RPW requires a significant nexus evaluation. Corps districts and EPA regions will include in the record any available information that documents the existence of a significant nexus between a relatively permanent tributary that is not perennial (and its adjacent wetlands if any) and a traditional navigable water, even though a significant nexus finding is not required as a matter of law If the waterbody° is not an RPW, or a wetland directly abutting an RPW, a JD will require additional data to determine if the waterbody has a significant nexus with a TNW. If the tributary has adjacent wetlands, the significant nexus evaluation must consider the tributary in combination with all of its adjacent wetlands. This significant nexus evaluation that combines, for analytical purposes, the tributary and all of its adjacent wetlands is used whether the review area identified in the JD request is the tributary, or its adjacent wetlands, or both. If the 3D covers a tributary with adjacent wetlands, complete Section III.B.1 for the tributary, Section III.B.2 for any onsite wetlands, and Section IIi.B.3 for all wetlands adjacent to that tributary, both onsite and offsite. The determination whether a significant nexus exists is determined in Section III.0 below. 1. Characteristics of non -TNWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNW (►) General Area Conditions: Watershed size (HUC 03050103 entire drainage) 1370 quare miles Drainage area (Wetland study drainage area) +/- 150 acres Average annual rainfall 43 inches Average annual snowfall inches (n) Physical Characteristics: (a) Relationship with TNW ❑ Tributary flows directly into TNW ® Tributary flows through 2 tributaries before entering TNW Project waters are 10 -15 river miles from TNW Project waters are 1 (or less) river miles from RPW Project waters are 5 -10 aerial (straight) miles from TNW Project waters are d (or t sse ) aerial (straight) miles from RPW Project waters cross or serve as state boundaries Explain No Identify flow route to TNW5 Seasonal RPW B1, which originates onsite, flows indirectly into Clems Branch, which continues offsite to flow into Sugar Creek, which flows directly into the Catawba River (TNW) ' Note that the Instructional Guidebook contains additional information regarding swales, ditches, washes, and erosional features generally and in the and West 5 Flow route can be described by identifying, e g , tributary a, which flows through the review area, to flow into tributary b, which then flows into TNW Tributary stream order, if known I" (b) General Tributary Characteristics (check all that apply) Tributary is ® Natural ❑ Artificial (man -made) Explain ❑ Manipulated (man - altered) Explain Tributary properties with respect to top of bank (estimate) Average width 8'- 15' feet Average depth 4' - 6' feet Average side slopes Vertical (1:1 or less). Primary tributary substrate composition (check all that apply) ® Silts ® Sands ❑ Cobbles ❑ Gravel ❑ Bedrock ❑ Vegetation Type /% cover ❑ Other Explain ❑ Concrete ❑ Muck Tributary condition/stability [e g , highly eroding, sloughing banks] Explain Some steep eroding banks Presence of run/riffle /pool complexes Explain few to none present Tributary geometry Meandermg Tributary gradient (approximate average slope) 1 -2 % (c) Flow Tributary provides for Seasonal wo Estimate average number of flow events in review area/year 20_(or greater) Describe flow regime Seasonal flows with input from stornm events Other information on duration and volume Surface flow is Discrete and'confined. Characteristics Subsurface flow Unkn wo nwo n Explain findings ❑ Dye (or other) test performed Tributary has (check all that apply) ® Bed and banks ® OHWM6 (check all indicators that apply) ® clear, natural line impressed on the bank ® changes in the character of soil ❑ shelving ® vegetation matted down, bent, or absent ® leaf litter disturbed or washed away ® sediment deposition ❑ water staining ❑ ❑ other (list) ❑ Discontinuous OHWM' Explain the presence of litter and debris destruction of terrestrial vegetation the presence of wrack line sediment sorting scour multiple observed or predicted flow events abrupt change in plant community If factors other than the OHWM were used to determine lateral extent of CWA jurisdiction (check all that apply) ❑ High Tide Line indicated by ❑ Mean High Water Mark indicated by ❑ oil or scum line along shore objects ❑ survey to available datum, ❑ fine shell or debris deposits (foreshore) ❑ physical markings, ❑ physical markings /characteristics ❑ vegetation lines /changes in vegetation types ❑ tidal gauges ❑ other (list) (iii) Chemical Characteristics - Characterize tributary (e g , water color is clear, discolored, oily film, water quality, general watershed characteristics, etc ) Explain Water was generally clear where present Identify specific pollutants, if known 'A natural or man -made discontinuity in the OHWM does not necessarily sever jurisdiction (e g , where the stream temporarily flows underground, or where the OHWM has been removed by development or agricultural practices) Where there is a break in the OHWM that is unrelated to the waterbody's flow regime (e g , flow over a rock outcrop or through a culvert), the agencies will look for indicators of flow above and below the break 'Ibid (iv) Biological Characteristics. Channel supports (check all that apply): ® Riparian corridor Characteristics (type average width) Forested, 100' +/- or greater ❑ Wetland fringe Characteristics ® Habitat for ❑ Federally Listed species Explain findings ❑ Fish/spawn areas Explain findings ❑ Other environmentally - sensitive species Explain findings ® Aquatic /wildlife diversity Explain findings Channel supports habitat for amphibians and macromverterbrates 2. Characteristics of wetlands adjacent to non -TNW that flow directly or indirectly into TNW (i) Physical Characteristics. (a) General Wetland Characteristics Properties Wetland size Pond's L = ( + / -) 0 3, K = ( + / -) 147, F = 0 3586, Wtld's A = ( + / -) 0 005, C/D = 0 0675, E = 0 2787, AD 0 016, AC = ( + / -) 0 012, AA = ( + / -) 0 5 acres Wetland type Explain Pond's L, K, F = openwater Wtld's A, C/D, AD, AC, AA = Forested Wtld E = herbaceous Wetland quality Explain Project wetlands cross or serve as state boundaries Explain No (b) General Flow Relationship with Non-TNW Flow is Ephemeral flow Explain Wetlands will discharge into the RPW's periodically during the growing season and during rain events Surface flow is. Dis terc e Characteristics Subsurface flow Unknown Explain findings ❑ Dye (or other) test performed (c) Wetland Adjacency Determination with Non -TNW ❑ Directly abutting ® Not directly abutting ❑ Discrete wetland hydrologic connection Explain ❑ Ecological connection Explain ® Separated by berm/barrier Explain Wetlands are seperated by man -made and natural riparian berms (d) Proximity (Relationship) to TNW Project wetlands are 10 -f15 river miles from TNW Project waters are 5- l0�aerial (straight) mules from TNW Flow is from Wetland to navigable w tea= Estimate approximate location of wetland as within the 2- 5 -year floodplam (ii) Chemical Characteristics: Characterize wetland system (e g, water color is clear, brown, oil film on surface, water quality, general watershed characteristics, etc ) Explain Water was clear, area was generally undisturbed Identify specific pollutants, if known (in) Biological Characteristics. Wetland supports (check all that apply). ® Riparian buffer Characteristics (type, average width) Forested, 100' +/- or greater ® Vegetation type /percent cover Explain Alluvial /Riparian +/- 85% ® Habitat for ❑ Federally Listed species Explain findings ❑ Fish/spawn areas Explain findings ❑ Other environmentally - sensitive species Explain findings ® Aquatic /wildlife diversity Explain findings Provides habitat for amphibians 3. Characteristics of all wetlands adjacent to the tributary (if any) All wetland(s) being considered in the cumulative analysis 112 Approximately ( 3 1344 ) acres in total are being considered in the cumulative analysis For each wetland, specify the following Directly abuts" (Y/N) Size (in acres) A (Y), C/D (N) 0005,00675 G (Y), J (Y) 0 0211, 0 0255 AB (Y), AC (N) 008,0012 F (N), K (N) 03586, 147 Directly abuts? (YIN) Size (in acres) E (N) 02787 AA (N) 05 AD (N) 0 016 L(N) 03 Summarize overall biological, chemical and physical functions being performed Adjacent and abutting wetlands provide habitat for herpetofauna and macro invertebrates The wetlands provide flood storage and ground water recharge The wetlands also trap and filter pollutants before reaching RPWs and the TNW (Catawba River) C. SIGNIFICANT NEXUS DETERMINATION A significant nexus analysis will assess the flow characteristics and functions of the tributary itself and the functions performed by any wetlands adjacent to the tributary to determine if they significantly affect the chemical, physical, and biological integrity of a TNW. For each of the following situations, a significant nexus exists if the tributary, in combination with all of its adjacent wetlands, has more than a speculative or insubstantial effect on the chemical, physical and /or biological integrity of a TNW. Considerations when evaluating significant nexus include, but are not limited to the volume, duration, and frequency of the flow of water in the tributary and its proximity to a TNW, and the functions performed by the tributary and all its adjacent wetlands. It is not appropriate to determine significant nexus based solely on any specific threshold of distance (e.g. between a tributary and its adjacent wetland or between a tributary and the TNW). Similarly, the fact an adjacent wetland lies within or outside of a floodplam is not solely determinative of significant nexus. Draw connections between the features documented and the effects on the TNW, as identified in the Rapanos Guidance and discussed in the Instructional Guidebook. Factors to consider include, for example: • Does the tributary, in combination with its adjacent wetlands (if any), have the capacity to carry pollutants or flood waters to TNWs, or to reduce the amount of pollutants or flood waters reaching a TNW? • Does the tributary, in combination with its adjacent wetlands (if any), provide habitat and lifecycle support functions for fish and other species, such as feeding, nesting, spawning, or rearing young for species that are present in the TNW) • Does the tributary, in combination with its adjacent wetlands (if any), have the capacity to transfer nutrients and organic carbon that support downstream foodwebs9 • Does the tributary, in combination with its adjacent wetlands (if any), have other relationships to the physical, chemical, or biological integrity of the TNW9 Note: the above list of considerations is not inclusive and other functions observed or known to occur should be documented below: 1. Significant nexus findings for non -RPW that has no adjacent wetlands and flows directly or indirectly into TNWs. Explain findings of presence or absence of significant nexus below, based on the tributary itself, then go to Section III D 2. Significant nexus findings for non -RPW and its adjacent wetlands, where the non -RPW flows directly or indirectly into TNWs. Explain findings of presence or absence of significant nexus below, based on the tributary in combination with all of its adjacent wetlands, then go to Section III D 3. Significant nexus findings for wetlands adjacent to an RPW but that do not directly abut the RPW. Explain findings of presence or absence of significant nexus below, based on the tributary to combination with all of its adjacent wetlands, then go to Section III D A significant nexus is present between the adjacent wetlands and downstream TNW's Openwater Pond (L) flows into a pipe /culvert which empties directly into a non - jurisdictional gully that empties directly into Wetland (A), which flows through a culvert into Seasonal RPW (B) Wetland (C /D) is seperated from Pond (F) and Wetland (E) by a man-made berm Wetland (E) connects to Wetland (G) through a pipe and Wetland (G) empties directly into Perennial RPW Clems Branch A riparian berm and berms along an adjaent sanitary sewer line exists between Wetlands (AA, AC, AD) and the Perennial RPW Clems Branch This riparian berm is the only seperation for the wetlands to flow to the Perennial RPW (either during rain events or through sub - surface flows) which flows in Sugar Creek, which empties directly into the Catawba River (TNW) The adjacent wetlands have the capacity to reduce pollutants through vegetation filtering, and reduce flooding by providing storage before reaching the TNW The wetland provides recharge to the RPW's during dry climate conditions The RPW's to which they flow have the capacity to carry pollutants and/or flood waters to the Catawba River (TNW) These features also provide habitat for amphibians and other wildlife D. DETERMINATIONS OF JURISDICTIONAL FINDINGS. THE SUBJECT WATERS/WETLANDS ARE (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY): 1. TNWs and Adjacent Wetlands. Check all that apply and provide size estimates in review area ❑ TNWs linear feet width (ft), Or, acres ❑ Wetlands adjacent to TNWs acres 2. RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs ® Tributaries of TNWs where tributaries typically flow year -round are jurisdictional Provide data and rationale indicating that tributary is perennial Perennial RPW's H1 and Clems Branch have the geomorphology, hydrology, and biology consistent with perennial streams The stream channels have persistent flow, riffle pool complexes, macro invertebrates, and fish ® Tributaries of TNW where tributaries have continuous flow "seasonally" (e g . typically three months each year) are jurisdictional Data supporting this conclusion is provided at Section III B Provide rationale indicating that tributary flows seasonally Seasonal RPWs BI and I1 have the geomorphology, hydrology, and biology consistent with seasonal RPW's and intermittent streams The channels had clear bed and banks, scour, and substrate sorting See Elevation Church _Stream Reach Evaluation Form_sRPW B_040313 and Elevation Church—Stream Reach Evaluation Form_sRPW I_040313 Provide estimates for jurisdictional waters in the review area (check all that apply) ® Tributary waters 2203 linear feet3 -15 width (ft) ❑ Other non - wetland waters acres Identify type(s) of waters 3. Non-RPWs' that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs. ❑ Waterbody that is not a TNW or an RPW, but flows directly or indirectly into a TNW, and it has a significant nexus with a TNW is jurisdictional Data supporting this conclusion is provided at Section III C Provide estimates for jurisdictional waters within the review area (check all that apply) ❑ Tributary waters linear feet width (ft) ❑ Other non - wetland waters acres Identify type(s) of waters 4. Wetlands directly abutting an RPW that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs. ® Wetlands directly abut RPW and thus are jurisdictional as adjacent wetlands ® Wetlands directly abutting an RPW where tributaries typically flow year -round Provide data and rationale indicating that tributary is perennial in Section III D 2, above Provide rationale indicating that wetland is directly abutting an RPW Wetland J empties directly into Wetland AB, which empties directly into and is not seperated by berm or barrier from Perennial RPW Clems Branch. Wetland G empties directly into and is not seperated by berm or barrier from Perennial RPW Clems Branch.. ® Wetlands directly abutting an RPW where tributaries typically flow "seasonally " Provide data indicating that tributary is seasonal in Section III B and rationale in Section III D 2, above Provide rationale indicating that wetland is directly abutting an RPW Wetland A empties flows through a culvert which empties directly into Seasonal RPW B Provide acreage estimates for jurisdictional wetlands in the review area 0.1316 acres 5. Wetlands adjacent to but not directly abutting an RPW that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs. ® Wetlands that do not directly abut an RPW, but when considered in combination with the tributary to which they are adjacent and with similarly situated adjacent wetlands, have a significant nexus with a TNW are jurisidictional Data supporting this conclusion is provided at Section III C Provide acreage estimates for jurisdictional wetlands in the review area 0.8742acres 6. Wetlands adjacent to non -RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs. ❑ Wetlands adjacent to such waters, and have when considered in combination with the tributary to which they are adjacent and with similarly situated adjacent wetlands, have a significant nexus with a TNW are jurisdictional Data supporting this conclusion is provided at Section III C Provide estimates for jurisdictional wetlands in the review area acres 7. Impoundments of jurisdictional waters.9 As a general rule, the impoundment of ajunsdictional tributary remains jurisdictional ❑ Demonstrate that impoundment was created from "waters of the US," or 'See Footnote # 3 ' To complete the analysis refer to the key in Section III D 6 of the Instructional Guidebook ® Demonstrate that water meets the criteria for one of the categories presented above (1 -6), or ❑ Demonstrate that water is isolated with a nexus to commerce (see E below) E. ISOLATED [INTERSTATE OR INTRA - STATE[ WATERS, INCLUDING ISOLATED WETLANDS, THE USE, DEGRADATION OR DESTRUCTION OF WHICH COULD AFFECT INTERSTATE COMMERCE, INCLUDING ANY SUCH WATERS (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY).10 ❑ which are or could be used by interstate or foreign travelers for recreational or other purposes ❑ from which fish or shellfish are or could be taken and sold in interstate or foreign commerce Q which are or could be used for industrial purposes by industries in interstate commerce ❑ Interstate isolated waters Explain ❑ Other factors Explain Identify water body and summarize rationale supporting determination: Provide estimates for Jurisdictional waters to the review area (check all that apply) ❑ Tributary waters linear feet width (ft) ❑ Other non - wetland waters acres Identify type(s) of waters ❑ Wetlands acres F. NON - JURISDICTIONAL WATERS, INCLUDING WETLANDS (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY): ❑ If potential wetlands were assessed within the review area, these areas did not meet the criteria in the 1987 Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual and/or appropriate Regional Supplements ❑ Review area included isolated waters with no substantial nexus to interstate (or foreign) commerce ❑ Prior to the Jan 2001 Supreme Court decision in "SWANCC." the review area would have been regulated based solely on the "Migratory Bird Rule" (MBR) ❑ Waters do not meet the "Significant Nexus" standard, where such a finding is required for Jurisdiction Explain ❑ Other (explain, if not covered above) Provide acreage estimates for non - jurisdictional waters in the review area, where the sole potential basis of Jurisdiction is the MBR factors (i e , presence of migratory birds, presence of endangered species, use of water for irrigated agriculture), using best professional Judgment (check all that apply) ❑ Non - wetland waters (i e , rivers, streams) linear feet width (ft) ❑ Lakes /ponds acres ❑ Other non - wetland waters acres List type of aquatic resource ❑ Wetlands acres Provide acreage estimates for non - jurisdictional waters in the review area that do not meet the "Significant Nexus' standard, where such a finding is required for Jurisdiction (check all that apply) ❑ Non - wetland waters (i e , rivers, streams) linear feet, width (li) ❑ Lakes /ponds acres ❑ Other non - wetland waters acres List type of aquatic resource ❑ Wetlands acres SECTION IV: DATA SOURCES. A. SUPPORTING DATA. Data reviewed for JD (check all that apply - checked items shall be included in case file and, where checked and requested, appropriately reference sources below) ® Maps, plans, plots or plat submitted by or on behalf of the applicant/consultant ® Data sheets prepared/submitted by or on behalf of the applicant/consultant ❑ Office concurs with data sheets /delineation report ❑ Office does not concur with data sheets /delineation report ❑ Data sheets prepared by the Corps ❑ Corps navigable waters' study ❑ U S Geological Survey Hydrologic Atlas ❑ USGS NHD data ❑ USGS 8 and 12 digit HUC maps 10 Prior to asserting or declining CWA jurisdiction based solely on this category, Corps Districts will elevate the action to Corps and EPA HQ for review consistent with the process described in the Corps /EPA Memorandum Regarding CWA Act Junsdiction Following Rapanos ® U S Geological Survey map(s) Cite scale & quad name 1 24K - Weddmgton (NC,SC) ® USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service Soil Survey Citation Natural Resources Conservation Service Web Soil Survey URL http //websoilsurvey nres usda gov ❑ National wetlands inventory map(s) Cite name ❑ State/Local wetland inventory map(s) ❑ FEMA/FIRM maps ❑ 100 -year Floodplam Elevation is (National Geodectic Vertical Datum of 1929) ® Photographs ® Aerial (Name & Date) Elevation Church—Aerial Map_060513 or ❑ Other (Name & Date) ❑ Previous deternimation(s) File no and date of response letter ❑ Applicable /supporting case law ❑ Applicable /supporting scientific literature ❑ Other information (please specify) B. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO SUPPORT JD: Endangered Species Survey Report LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning ENDANGERED /PROTECTED SPECIES SURVEY ELEVATION CHURCH MECKLENBURG COUNTY, NC LEONARD S. RINDNER PLLC Wetlands & Environmental Planning Group 3714 Spokeshave Lane Matthews, NC 28105 (704) 904 —2277 LEN.RINDNER.PWS @gmail.com Elevation Church —Endangered/ Protected Species Survey 2 Physical Setting: The Elevation Church property is located just west of Lancaster Highway and just south of Clems Branch in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina. It can be found on the Weddington USGS Topographic Quadrangle Map-, latitude is 35.0301 N, longitude is 80.8587 W. The topography is gentle to moderate slopes with the elevation ranging from 530 to 650 ft. (Figure 1). Figure 1: L' r I _ V \` ,4 J n` 6 � � � � � J �- - --. - �'•` .oho � /i 651 ly i LANCASTER ` .. i • ,' © fi` '9 HIGHWAY - ! SITE fi C =� N B 6 Ta •� C . ♦ - , 685 C� d silver Run ``� •� Cern O'i LISA R. GAFFNEY Elevation Church —Endangered/ Protected Species Survey Methods: The North Carolina Natural Heritage Program's online database http / /www.ncnhp.org/ was referenced to determine the occurrence of species of concern for the Weddington Quad (Table 1). Records indicate that three species with the Federal Protection Status of "Endangered" have been documented in this quad two vascular plant species - Schweinitz's Sunflower (Hehanthus schwern►tzn) and Michaux's Sumac (Rhus michauxrn), and one freshwater mussel species - Carolina Heelsplitter (Lasmigona decorata). One species with the status of "Candidate" is listed, Georgia Aster (Symphyotrichum georgianum). Four species with the status of "Federal Species of Concern" listed are freshwater mussel Carolina Creekshell (Villosa vaughantana), freshwater fish Carolina Darter (Etheostoma collis), and vascular plants Carolina Bird -foot Trefoil (Acm1spon helleri), and Tall Larkspur (Delphinium exaltatum). Of the listed species, all are chronologically current except for Michaux's Sumac and Tall Larkspur which are 'historical' historic occurrence meaning that the species are considered to have been extirpated from the Quad. Maps and aerial photographs were assembled and the site was investigated during the week of December 23, 2014. LISA R GAI INHY Elevation Church — Endangered / Protected Species Survey 4 Table 1: Taxonomic Common NC USA State Global Topo Scientific Name Topo Map Group Name Status Status Rank Rank MapStatus Carolina Vascular Acmispon helleri Birdfoot- SC -V FSC S3 G3 Weddington Current Plant trefoil Vascular Delphinium Tall Larkspur E FSC S2 G3 Weddington Historical Plant exaltatum Freshwater Carolina Etheostoma coltis SC FSC S3 G3 Weddington Current Fish Darter Vascular Helianthus Schweimtz's E Plant schweimtzn Sunflower Freshwater Lasmigona Carolina E Bivalve decorata Heelsplitter Vascular Michaux's Rhus michauxii E Plant Sumac Vascular Symphyotnchum Georgia T Plant georgianum Aster Freshwater Villosa Carolina E Bivalve vaughamana Creekshell LISA R GAFF NFY E S3 G3 Weddington Current E S1 G1 Weddington Current E S2 G2G3 Weddington Historical C S3 G3 Weddington Current FSC S2 G2 Weddington Current Elevation Church — Endangered / Protected Species Survey Results: This site is a mosaic of open mowed lawns and landscaping, and fragmented slopes and drainage areas covered with disturbed mixed pine /hardwoods. There are several buildings on the site including residential homes, gymnasium, livestock barns and storage sheds. There are also interior roads, fencerows and two open water ponds on the site. The mostly flat, open, turf grass lawn and landscaping are comprised of cultivated Fescue ( Festuca sp ) with typical shrub /small tree planting beds, and widely scattered larger trees. The wooded areas contain some mature trees with moderate subcanopy strata. Average diameter at breast height (dbh) for the canopy trees is 10 inches, with some larger trees present. The mix of species does not show an obvious dominant type of tree. Canopy trees present include Shortleaf Pine (Pinus echinata), White Oak (Quercus albs), Red Oak (Q rubra), Sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua), Yellow Poplar (Linodendron tuhpifera), Southern Red Oak (Q falcata), Willow Oak (Quercus phellos), Mockernut Hickory (Carya tomentosa) and Red Cedar (Juniperus virginiana). The subcanopy is composed of Flowering Dogwood (Corpus flonda), American Holly (Ilex opaca), Black Cherry (Prunus serotina), and Black Gum (Nyssa sylvatica). The shrub layer includes Chinese Privet (Ligustrum sinense), Blueberry (Vaccin►um sp.), and Russian Olive (Elaeagnus umbellata). Vines present are Japanese Honeysuckle (Lonicerajaponica), Virginia Creeper (Parthenocissus quinquefoha), Muscadine (Vitis rotundifoha), Catbrier (Smilax sp.), and Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron radicans) The herb layer has little diversity and is dominated by Japanese Stilt -grass (Microstegium vimineum). The roadsides and lawns are maintained by periodic mowing and the narrow ecotone at the woods edges are made up of Fescue (Festuca sp), Plume Grass (Erianthus contortus), Broomsedge (Andropogon virginicus), Dog fennel (Eupatonum spp.), Goldenrod (Sol►dago spp.), Blackberry (Rubus spp.), Groundsel Tree (Bacchans hahinifolia), Trumpet Creeper (Campsis radicans), and Multiflora Rose (Rosa multiflora). Endangered Species Results: Although potential habitat exists for Carolina Birdfoot- trefoil, Schweinitz's Sunflower, and Georgia Aster on the roadside, upon close examination of the site these species were not found. Tall Larkspur and Michaux's Sumac are both considered to have been extirpated from this Quad. Carolina Heelsplitter (Lasmigona decorata) has not been found in the Clems Branch watershed. LISA R GAPPNEY Elevation Church —Endangered/ Protected Species Survey 6 Recommendations: There are no species of concern on this site I have no recommendations for this site Respectfully submitted, Lisa R Gaffney Biologist LEONARD S. RINDNER PLLC Wetlands & Environmental Planning Group 3714 Spokeshave Lane Matthews, NC 28105 (704) 904 — 2277 LEN.RINDNER.PWS @grnail corn LISA R GA! l NLY Adjacent Property Owners LEONARD S. RINDNER, PWS Environmental Planning Consultant Professional Wetland Scientist Land Planning o� r c °o Z 1� N UWw !11 p Z ° M O� N p U a o v G s V,9 m z a °D M z i N .p ^• r' ,�_� \ \ �OnrvpO! OQ f YwNN wU \ \ \\.,� ���\+ ��• ` \���, %,� - i. jti ?: YmNzw\ �wONpO wwm20 vl zzWaoZs O z O m m O m ry w U m i O D d N 7 O m H a nOOEL N� =<0 zWf, O cN - + z Z �� �ONo° ��4a\ '\ `;.� _✓ f!t � j =�'� ter }Oa�� ' \l \71 -� - _ � � � \ .� � v t ` I r �._ _ � �C y,' a,.`�` \ t" ��, k} /�(r I �,' , I ! � / � • \, / Fi,a, , � I 2 g Q.t r y '.. \\ �i� \ `. /r .,_- O .a l m w oC a /'1 /(" `4D ^9i '- ! Y -- -- i , .''r I•` i , t- N > r. :v, n %,r I } , ..t� z flJo �rvoN /, \�4rf ck $ u_ga z Z:, > "\ i ✓; f ` ( N �7 - \✓ /" \ \ -/ / 6vaiN0 I Z-ON l 1 r i)�ii /� / ^�? _J,. `��1���_ Jt -r \ \L`7 t;'\ _ f4 -p�Nce - -- z v� j( -- �`,; a= J a'N'� 0li O LL .0 0 z /I /�f 1;11 \\ \\\ u f 7\ g k \ l z 4°` �.\ q'/ . fir, /` /i ,�"�''`\ •.__ /.!/yr'�,_`i /._ f f � i w pAV fN ry ii = z 10 1 aMo \ N O W V Z N y 7 m L � 8 0 1 2! E - o VH :)N '31101NJ o Y ° 004 31S'133111SOV3H3MOW1SV31ZS S311113dO'dd AdW ® c b � � � c o ucoP S�oa m b c n c V o m >N '31 LOlbVH� c Q > slb CVO H�2inHD NOIIVA313 c ■ o� r c °o Z 1� N UWw !11 p Z ° M O� N p U a o v G s V,9 m z a °D M z i N .p ^• r' ,�_� \ \ �OnrvpO! OQ f YwNN wU \ \ \\.,� ���\+ ��• ` \���, %,� - i. jti ?: YmNzw\ �wONpO wwm20 vl zzWaoZs O z O m m O m ry w U m i O D d N 7 O m H a nOOEL N� =<0 zWf, O cN - + z Z �� �ONo° ��4a\ '\ `;.� _✓ f!t � j =�'� ter }Oa�� ' \l \71 -� - _ � � � \ .� � v t ` I r �._ _ � �C y,' a,.`�` \ t" ��, k} /�(r I �,' , I ! � / � • \, / Fi,a, , � I 2 g Q.t r y '.. \\ �i� \ `. /r .,_- O .a l m w oC a /'1 /(" `4D ^9i '- ! Y -- -- i , .''r I•` i , t- N > r. :v, n %,r I } , ..t� z flJo �rvoN /, \�4rf ck $ u_ga z Z:, > "\ i ✓; f ` ( N �7 - \✓ /" \ \ -/ / 6vaiN0 I Z-ON l 1 r i)�ii /� / ^�? _J,. `��1���_ Jt -r \ \L`7 t;'\ _ f4 -p�Nce - -- z v� j( -- �`,; a= J a'N'� 0li O LL .0 0 z /I /�f 1;11 \\ \\\ u f 7\ g k \ l z 4°` �.\ q'/ . fir, /` /i ,�"�''`\ •.__ /.!/yr'�,_`i /._ f f � i w pAV fN ry ii = z 10 1 aMo \ N O W V Z N y 7 m L Lancaster BVS, LLC 25101 Chagrin Blvd #300 Beachwood OH 44122 Lancaster NPA, LLC 25101 Chagrin Blvd #300 Beachwood OH 44122 Lancaster Deville, LLC 25101 Chagrin Blvd #300 Beachwood OH 44122 Mecklenburg Land Development 172 Huntley Place Charlotte NC 28207 Goodwill Industries of Southern Piedmont PO Box 668768 Charlotte NC 28266 D G Kaperonis 1721 Delchester Drive Charlotte NC 28210 Mecklenburg Beverage Control Board 3333 North Tryon Street Charlotte NC 28206 Heide M Palmer 16220 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Mary M McNally 16222 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Bradley Venant 16224 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Vijay L Reddy 16228 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Arthur and Tamara Blue 16230 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Giovanni Cnmaudo and Rose Morreale 16232 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Kathryn A Ramstack 16234 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Rafael Corral and Gloria Flores 16238 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 James and Phyllis Bray 16240 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Michelle E Doss 16242 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Valerity Mnatsakanyan and Nina Yermakova 16244 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Mary S Edwards 16246 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Lindsay Clampitt and John Morgan 16248 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Andreas Ziozios 16250 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Carrie L Schmidt 16252 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Robert E O'Hoppe 16254 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Brandon and Victoria Spence 16256 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Glinda H Brewington 16258 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jessica A Clark 16260 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Ana and Richard Hamilton 16264 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Daniel C Dunham 1010 Van Buren Avenue Indian Trail NC 28079 Alan and Janice Pitt 16268 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 James L Combs 254 Streamside Place Mooresville NC 28115 Hope M Pierce 3031 Wavering Lane Middleburg FL 32068 Stephen Sullivan 16274 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 James and Kathy Galati 16276 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Andrew Brookshire 16278 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Barbara and Alan Bodman 16310 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Ann S Katz 16312 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Michele Sinka 16314 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Carol A Moak - Nelson 16316 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Edward and Doris Stevens 22109 E Tern Court Fort Mill SC 29707 Dickey C Polk 16320 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Suzanne M Fortune 16322 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Mgan Sarwar and Auravape Archvann 16324 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Eugenio Bonet and Mansol Lopez 16326 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 David E Papp 16328 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Courtney J Curry 16330 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Seth Allen McMurchie 16332 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Ronald A Jones 16334 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Elizabeth MacGregor and Nancy Peeples 16336 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Anneliese Griffith 16338 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Ronald and Susan Emerick 16340 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Anthony P Keitt 16342 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jennifer L Kolb 16344 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Virginia H Love 16346 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jerry J White 16348 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Brian Marconi 16350 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Roger S Boone Jr 16352 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Richard Wingo and Kelley Gates 9201 Belmont Lane Waxhaw NC 28173 Michelle Davis 16356 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Sherron Camp and Judy Phillips 16406 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Gregory and Beverly Stumler 16408 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Linwood and Ann Ricks 16410 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Louis and Patricia Russo 25 Fort Avenue, Unit 2 Boston MA 02119 Omar and Rossy Correal 69 Lawrence Avenue Lodi NJ 07644 Barbara Arce 16416 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jane A Sebastian 16418 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Shirley J Mitchell 16420 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Victor Procaccini 16424 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Robert and Katherine Price 16426 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Roderick and Sharron Hunter 16428 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Sheldon and Hilda Gathers 16430 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Leah and John Boone 16432 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Diane L Tuttle 16434 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Albert and Catherine Daniels 9000 Whirlaway Lane Waxhaw NC 28173 Don and Johanna Holsclaw 16438 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jonathan A McDonald 16440 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Dimitrqus and Enca Sazinas 16442 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Sarah and Mack Baker 16444 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jeffrey C Mohrwinkel 16446 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Andrea M Rothe 16450 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Knsti Kornahrens 16452 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Mark and Lisa Whetstone 16454 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 James and Elizabeth Sauls 16456 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Lisa R Johnson 16458 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Carl and Joanne Tkachuk 16460 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Robert H Crissman 16462 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Kathleen Palano, Trustee 16464 Redstone Mountain Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Chase and Peggy Obrikat 17104 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Brandi Lightner 17106 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Joyce Rolfsen 100 Riverside Place, Unit 405 Covington KY 41011 Ken and Donna Sholter 17110 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Derrick Cane 17112 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Deepa Ghosh 10718 Lederer Avenue Charlotte NC 28277 Chamar Jackson 17116 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Hollis Myers 17118 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Michael and Daniel Kummer PO Box 36 Poco Pines PA 18350 Dominian Holdings, LLC 17122 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Clifford Hicks Jr 17124 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Mdka Bapc 17126 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Milton A Peters 17130 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Julio Franco and Maria Bravo 17132 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Virginia R Livernois 17134 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Judith A Ancelli 17136 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Lynette Harris 17138 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Sharon Conley and Gregory Walker 17140 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Raquel Romero 17142 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Dung Thi Huynh 266 Long Leaf Drive Belmont NC 28012 Joseph Carlin 17146 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Philip Palmgren 17148 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Lynn Stevens 17150 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Vadim Avanesov 17152 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Patricia Cassidy 17156 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Pamela Roof 17158 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Terri Stagg 17160 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Deepa Ghosh 10718 Lederer Avenue Charlotte NC 28277 Maggie C Redmond 17164 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 J P Carlin 17166 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Elizabeth and Edward Cooper 17168 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Lawence Michlovich 17170 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Juliana Marques 17172 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Sara Pease 17174 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Denise McAvaney 17176 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Brian Theiler 17178 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Frances Babinat 17155 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Colin and Barbara Miles 17157 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Joseph Demato and Elaine Austin 17159 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Peter Todaro 17161 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Janet High 17163 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Inna Berezhnyak 17165 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Linda Russo 17167 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Kam Clark 17127 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Jeremy Walton 17129 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Stacie Lawrence 17131 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Wanda Trump 17133 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Christina Muckelvaney 17135 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Copper Ridge Owners Association, Inc 919 Norland Road Charlotte NC 28205 Aida Lipera 17139 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Kenya Mauldin 17141 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Candace Pride 17143 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Michael and Angela Reid 17145 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Carl Baker 17147 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Natalia Underwood 17149 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Leyla Rincon 17109 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Janet Clift 17111 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Susan Johnson 17113 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Yvonne Amato 17115 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Hegwig Stevens 17117 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Secretary of Housing & Urban Development 451 7th Street SW Washington DC 20410 Adam Morris 17121 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Brent and Jennifer Kasmer 17123 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Alice Reon 17153 Red Feather Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Lora Rendino 16409 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Ilya and Chantal Rubin 9019 Pine Laurel Drive Weddington NC 28104 Helen Black 16413 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 John and Raissa Typrin 16415 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Cynthia Juhasz 16417 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Sarah Clark 16419 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Michael Street 16421 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 John Conti 5388 East Mountain Street Stone Mountain GA 30083 Sherri Rader 16425 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jennifer Weidlich 1116 Scaleybark Road #303 Charlotte NC 28209 Anthony Tieu 6434 Grand Central Parkway #2C Forest Hills NY 11375 DL Ventures, LLC 337 East Markland Drive Monterey Park CA 91755 Gladys and William Duvall 16435 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Macy Creek 16437 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Marjorie Guzman 16439 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 William Anthony 16441 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Phyllis Bowen 16443 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Herbert Britt Jr 16445 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Jamie Boswell 16447 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Robin Wood 16449 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Julian and Jean Peker 16551 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 John McGrotha 16453 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Eric Marks 16455 Golden River Lane Charlotte NC 28277 Venkata Yelamanchili and Swetha Govada 116 Galway Drive #208 Mooresville NC 28117 Fred and Renee Hilowitz 12310 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 George Schwartzman and Susan Rheel PO Box 22 Central Valley NY 10917 Lorraine Dundee 12314 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Vicki Hopkins 12316 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Alicia Johnson 12318 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 James Burns 12320 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Eric McKay 12322 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Beverly Pernng 12324 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Hardy and Evelyn Braggq 12328 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Ruth Goodman 12332 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Cnstus Brown 12334 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Kimani and Pamela Long 12336 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Olya Mitchell 12338 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Colette Lowrie 12340 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Melissa Goodrich 12342 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Shari Booth 3110 Deercrest Court Cumming GA 30040 Tamra McCarter 12346 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Jennifer Ervin 12348 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Serhiy Duzhyk 12350 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Joyce and Javad Amirahmadi 12354 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Alexandre and Lucie Bellotti 12356 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Mary Meyers 12358 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Heide Invidiato 12360 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Elizabeth Bramblett 14243 Richmond Park Avenue Charlotte NC 28277 loana Olt 3343 Crescent Street #2F Astoria NY 11106 Robert and Patsy Gragg 12366 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Cheryl Pine 12368 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Albert and Claudia Patrone 12425 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Hazel Sdvera 12427 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Lila Koss 12429 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Stephanie Cherry 12431 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Carol Hampton 12433 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Matthew Trainum 12435 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Jonathan Bell 12437 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Colin and Barbara Miles 12439 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Zachary Spinks 12441 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Annette Baskin 12443 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Gareth and Bianca Lugg 11031 Woods Cormer Court Charlotte NC 28277 Christopher Caruso 12447 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Candis Sutherland 12451 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Kathy D'Amico 12453 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Adrian Jafn and Sana Adrian 12455 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Mary Patin 12457 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Danielle Hamberger 12459 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Aretha Brown 12461 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Barbara Jones 12463 Copper Mountaini Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Copper Ridge Owners Association, Inc 919 Noland Road Charlotte NC 28205 Donald and Nancy Morris 505 Deercross Lane Waxhaw NC 28173 Rebecca Quesnel 12469 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Tatyana Zalinov 512 Chadmore South Drive Charlotte NC 28270 Courtney and Nazim Benzerga 12473 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 John Jukoski 12321 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Thomas Yarr 12323 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 John Fish 6701 Thurmont Court Charlotte NC 28277 Lena Desimone 12327 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Maria and Angel Rodriguez 12329 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Richard and Joanne Zimmer 12331 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Jennifer Sullivan 12333 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Raven Baker 3638 Cusabo Lane Fort Mill SC 29707 Judith Wallace 12353 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Jean Odenbeck 12355 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Martin and Nancy Kornhauser 12357 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Susan Wenham 12359 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Kimberly Lecompte 12361 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Alina Sazinas 12363 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Doris Geis 12365 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Julia Mineiro 12367 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Timothy Pollock 11911 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Anna Martin 11913 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Frank and Ingeborg Falacara 11915 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 David Crenshaw 11917 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Jessica West 11919 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Heather Dolph 11921 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Nancy Mayer 11932 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Anait and Yermonia Balasanyan 11925 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Timothy Treharn 11927 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Charles Anderson Jr 11929 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Nikolina Bapc 11931 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Neale Bayly 11933 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Joyce Bloxam 11941 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Warren Giannelli and Brandon Watts 11943 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Bernard and June Rogers 11945 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Richard and Joanne Zimmer 11947 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Boutros Badawi 11526 Fernleigh Place Fort Mill SC 29707 Sandra Ewing and Joshua Heaberlin 11951 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Michael and April Rozell 11953 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Donna Morgan 11955 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Michael Zakely 11957 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Molly Boprey 11959 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Valerie Freeman 11961 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Ellen Seale 11963 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Patricia Lewis 11825 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Ingrid Valbuena and Andres Aranda 11827 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Olive Schwab 11829 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Deborah Kuhns 11831 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Shannon Denton 11833 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Keith Lago and Julie Munifo 11835 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Oscar and Wanda Lister 9928 Daufuskie Drive Charlotte NC 28278 Esther Duran 11839 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Gloria and Jairo Arango 6420 Rea Road Charlotte NC 28277 Hollman Gomez 11843 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Thiru and Suganya Govender 11845 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Daniel Fogarty 11847 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Laura Bailey 11851 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Lois Carter 11853 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Rodaldo and Veronica Rodriguez 11855 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 William and Nita McCormack 11857 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Lauren Trull 11859 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Susan Guay 11861 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Nirmala Patel 10611 Back Ridge Road Charlotte NC 28277 Jeffrey Strebler 11865 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Rebecca Wohler 11867 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Jose and Ingrid Valbuena 11869 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Joseph and Julie Kim 11871 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Susan Schmidt 11873 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Mark and Lisa Brock 11747 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Steven and Patricia Rendell One East Washington #1600 Phoenix AZ 85004 Lillian Bretzloff 11751 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 James and Deborah Rutkowski 11753 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Cambreia Freeman 11755 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Carolyn McRae 11757 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Amit Desai 11759 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Ricardo Gomez 2813 SW 130th Terrace Miramar FL 33027 Marie Loggie 11765 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Jeanette Lausterer 11767 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Thomas and Marie Fisher 11769 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Rey and Gina Coleman 11771 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Candy Buelvas 11773 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Linda Hunt 11775 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Guillermo Hidalgo and Sonia Velasco 11777 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 James and Jeanneth Algeciras 11779 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Harry B Heller 736 Norwich -New London TPKE Uncasvdle CT 06382 Carol Ann Konkle 11709 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Donald and Carol White 5981 Spout Spring Court Haymarket VA 20169 Angela Holns 11713 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Christopher and Jill Dremann 11715 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Julia Correal and Juan Garcia 826 Imperial Drive Baldwin Harbor NY 11510 Christine Taylor 11719 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Melissa Parks 11721 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 James and Terri Williams 11725 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Jane Myerly 11727 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Adrianus and Claudia Leeflang 11729 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Michael and Marlene Litzman 11731 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Percy and Veronica Cajahuanca 279 Neuton Avenue Ryebrook NJ 10573 Kathleen Tuss 11735 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Connie Clark 11737 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Howard Markwith and Susan Matuszek 11739 Ridgeway Park Drive Charlotte NC 28277 Elizabeth Giraldo 3119 Westnedhe Drive #1223 Charlotte NC 28226 Christine Hill and Sylvie Thory 12007 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Ramon Andino and Nubia Pulgar 4909 West Carmen Avenue Chicago IL 60630 James Croland 12011 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Lana Anker 12013 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Robert Miller 12015 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Trevor and Wendy Ginkel 12017 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Norman and Penny Boling 12019 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Margaret Carver 12025 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 David Rogers 12027 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Alfred and Daina Tang 12029 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Roger and Sherrill Suiter 12031 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Martha Roberts 12033 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Maryland Baker 12035 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Tony and Colleen Hsu 7400 Mockingbird Lane Waxhaw NC 28173 Robert and Barbara Miller 12039 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Richard Pusateri 12051 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Bobby and Shirley Crosby 12053 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Kim Pusateri 12055 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Patrice Mansueti and Victoria Uncoechea 235 Tradition Way Rock Hill SC 29732 Fabio and Karen Toledo 12059 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Garland and Vanessa Frazier 12061 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Racheal Roberts 12063 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Gloria and Jairo Arango 12065 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Eleanor Bristow 12071 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Joy Bale 12073 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Michelle Houston 12075 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Lavina Kamiske 12077 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Brian Fung 12079 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Anthony Aukskalms 12081 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 Florentino and Lillian Agosto 12083 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277 David and Concetta Fitts 12085 Copper Mountain Blvd Charlotte NC 28277