Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutNC0000078_Wasteload Allocation_19881116NPDES DOCUHENT SCANNING COVER SHEET NPDES Permit: NC0000078 Document Type: Permit Issuance Wasteload Allocation Authorization to Construct (AtC) Permit Modification Complete File - Historical Report Speculative Limits Instream Assessment (67b) Environmental Assessment (EA) Permit History Document Date: November 16, 1988 This document is; printed an reuse paper - igiiore aay content on the re'rerrae aside State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor R. Paul Wilms S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary N:'vember. 16, 1988 Director Jim Greenfield USEPA Region IV 345 Courtland Street Atlanta, GA 30365 Dear Jim: Please find enclosed notes regarding the wasteload allocation derived for Ecusta Corporation (NPDES # NC0000078). Please feel free to call if you have questions or need additional information to review the allocation. Sincerely, ,aCt z.P.0 Randy Dodd RD/gh Enclosure cc: Dale Overcash Pollution Prevention Pays P.O. Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7687 Telephone 919-733-7015 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer FKcnLo a�oaP •Nr [8AC.K.VATER5 ^-6.0 PA 2z0 1 7 I6II N. 3.4 81b0aL 2.6 g2DcE 1.15 IIwA&c- C17.2 z 141.8 191.58 Obn 190.63 ?Arm. $RIDC{ PA &O.I I7/ra 34 1..7P 357'-' 4r0 1.6 L, A 7-i0 Qio •-_ 3 ill 74eo 141 I2C `6 gND6T._ PeNltosL. PA ..."9/ "IQ 0 !92- (83.7 31-4NTYRE 6RI7tfi-. uses G14&C_ 18o-Si Ero'-.» BKruvE. 177.1 Pic LCAnl SPIP'L Hori_sti or_ 17i.3 JontooN BRfDb . DA 1-9 b l 7Q,0 Z-01 L p/} ' 52C -�Q,o 23 MEMORANDUM T0: FROM: THRU: DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT October 3, 1988 Dale Overcash Randy Dodd Trevor Clements Steve Tedder. SUBJECT: Response to letter from Ecusta I have reviewed the attached letter (9/16/88). The instream sampling program (item 2) should be sufficient to document oxygen concentrations at the downstream station.. The proposed NH, sampling frequency (monthly) (item 6) should be sufficient to document effluent concentrations. I have no comment on the other items at this time. RD/gh Attachment State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary September 20, 1988 Mr. R.J. Gussman, Director Environmental Affairs Ecusta P.O. Box 200 Pisgah Forest, NC 28768 Dear Mr. Gussman: SUBJECT: DRAFT Permit Comments NPDES No. NC0000078 Ecusta Transylvania County R. Paul Wilms Director This letter is to acknowledge receipt of your letter dated September 16, 1988, containing comments on the subject DRAFT Permit. The Division of Environmental Management will consider your comments in making its decision on the issuance of the permit. If you feel that your comments are not addressed in the issued permit, you may request an adjudicatory hearing in accordance with Chapter 150b of the General Statutes of North Carolina within 30 days of issuance of the permit. If you have any questions, please contact me at (919) 733-5083. Sincerely yours, A M. Dale 0vercash, P.E. Supervisor, NPDES Permits Group cdb/ cc: Forrest Westall Trevor Clements Pollution Prevention Pays P.O. Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7687 Telephone 919-733-7015 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer P.O. BOX 200 • PISGAH FOREST. NORTH CAROLINA 28788 • TELEPHONE (704) 877-2211 Mr. A. Mouberry North Carolina Department Of Natural Resources And Community Development Division Of Environmental Management P. 0. Box 27687 Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7687 Dear Mr. Mouberry: September 16, 1988 SEP 19 1988 0ERMITS & ENGINEERING Mcusta 04.t4,t4A. � Mt)opqmjelf y ill (1 " 44* Subject: Draft NPDES Permit No. NC0000078 The receipt of the above subject draft for the Ecusta Division's Facility at Pisgah Forest was the result of the culmination of efforts of a number of people. I appreciate not only your assistance but, also, the assistance of your personnel both in Raleigh and in the region in the development of this permit. In particular, I appreciate the assistance of Mr. Gary Tweed of the Asheville office of the Division of Environmental Management with whom I have reviewed these comments. There are, though, still some concerns with this draft permit: 1. Under Section A, "Effluent Limitations and Monitoring Require- ments", we would appreciate it if the term "daily" under Measurement Frequency was defined. I understand from Gary Tweed in Asheville that daily means only five days per week. We would appreciate it if you could change the word "daily" to "5/week" both on the summer and winter effluent limitation monitoring page. I remind you again that this laboratory only operates five days a week, that our effluent from our waste- water treatment plant is discharged after a 12-i day retention period, and all previous permits have defined "daily" as five samples per week. 2. Under Measurement Frequency, we propose that the upstream and downstream sampling for temperature, dissolved oxygen, and conductivity be changed to three times per week during July, August, September, and October, once per week during April, May, and June and once per month during the remaining months of the year. This will combine the upstream and downstream monitoring to a schedule similar to that contained in the last NPDES permit and more efficient use of our resources. I: C v S T A CO R P O I( rA T ION . Page 2 3. At the bottom of the page of the "Effluent Limitations and Monitoring Requirements" for the discharges from Outfall Nos. 002 and 003, there is a note that "monitoring requirements only apply if chlorine is added to the cooling". From discussions with Mr. Gary Tweed on September 1st, it is my understanding that this would only apply if we add additional "chlorine" to the cooling water after it leaves our finished water plant. This is important since we do chlorinate all of our finished water so that it contains a residual chlorine level of between 0.2 and 0.5 milligrams per liter. 4. The last two paragraphs in Section H "Priority Pollutant Con- ditions" relate to log debarking processes, plywood manufacturing, and a phosphorus limitation. Neither of the former are done at this facility. The Ecusta Facility at Pisgah Forest manufactures only paper from either purchased wood pulp or flax fiber. In addition, there is no phosphorus limitation in the permit; there- fore, the third paragraph in this section is redundant. We propose that both of these paragraphs be omitted. 5. In relation to the actual priority pollutant analyses contained in Section H, even though you require all of the parameters listed in Table II and Table III of Appendix D of 40 CFR Part 122 to be analyzed of our effluent on an annual basis, you should be aware that the Environmental Protection Agency has exempted parts of the Paper Industry from those sections of Table II that relate to the base/neutral and the pesticides fractions. We also have some concerns about the statement that "other sig- nificant levels of synthetic organic chemicals must be identified". Our last priority pollutant analyses conducted in 1988 as well as the previous priority pollutant analyses conducted in 1983 only indicated the presence of three items detected above their detection limits. Because of this, I question the need for us to determine the largest 10% of the GC/MS peaks for other than the priority pollutants. This also seems redundant in light of Section G which would require a toxicity reduction program if the effluent fails the chronic toxicity test. Such a program would require such an analysis of the GC/MS peaks. I would, therefore, suggest that instead of analyzing for all of the items listed in Table II and Table III of Appendix D that we only analyze for all metals, cyanide, and phenol listed in Table III and the volatile and acid fractions listed in Table II on an annual basis. 6. Under Section A, "Effluent Limitations and Monitoring Requirements (Summer)", we propose that the "NH3 as N" measurement be conducted monthly rather than weekly. This request is based on: a. The lack of variability in our effluent. This is covered in detail in my letter to C. Wakilid of the DEM dated 7/14/88. b. Currently, the State of North Carolina monitors both upstream and downstream of our discharge. Among other parameters, samples are taken for NH.-N analyses on a regular basis. Results from this analysis indicate the very uniform impact that Ecusta has on the receiving stream. Page 3 c. We have never used and have no foreseeable plans to add NH3-N to our wastewater treatment as a nutrient. Currently, our only use of NH3 in our process is in the makeup of a starch solution used as a paper machine sizing agent. The total amount of NH3 used in 1987 was less than 13,195 gallons. Since this is used almost continuously, this is equivalent to an average discharge of 0.69 mg/1 of NH3-N into our primary wastewater treatment plant. This assumes that no NH3 is vented to the atmosphere. ,This usage has been constant for at least five years. Again, I appreciate this opportunity to review this draft permit and assure ou that Ecusta will continue to work with your department in developing a y which is fair and equitable and which accomplishes our joint objective of rmit protecting our valuable resources. Sincerely, ECUSTA DIVISION P. H. GLATFELTER COMPANY 7f . 4.44q1-1(.4.166. R. J. Gussman, Director Environmental Affairs /bh cc: D. W. Monk - Ecusta G. Tweed - Division Of Environmental Management, Asheville, N.C. State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Asheville Regional Office James G. Martin, Governor S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION September 29, 1988 MEMORANDUM To: Arthur Mouberry Permits and Engineering Through: Forrest R. Westall Regional Water Quaervisor From: Gary T. Tweed, P.E. Environmental Engineer Subject: Review and Comment Draft Permit No. NC0000078 Ecusta Transylvania County David R. Spain Regional Manager The requested changes to subject draft permit submitted by the Company on September 16, 1988, have been reviewed and comments are offered in order as address by the Company: 1. There is no objection to writing daily frequency as 5/week. This is consistent with regulations and the current permit. 2. The stream monitoring frequencies requested for temperature, dissolved oxygen, and conductivity .are acceptable and consistent with current permit. 3. Chlorination of finished water should not result in - monitoring on 002 and 003 unless chlorine is added in cooling water for later treatment processing. Therefore, Mr. Gussman's understanding is correct. 4. Since Ecusta does not have log debarking and phosphorus limitations the last two paragraphs of section H can be deleted. Interchange Building, 59 Woodfin Place, P.O Box 370, Asheville, N.C. 28802-0370 • Telephone 704-253-3341 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer Arthur Mouberry Memorandum September 29, 1988 Page Two 5. The request to only analyze for all metals, cyanide, and phenols listed in Table III Appendix D of 40 CFR and the volatile and acid fractions listed in Table II on an annual basis is acceptable since other compounds have not been identified by the priority analyses. A full priority pollutant analysis as required be regulation every five years as the permit is renewed is sufficient. 6. The requested change to monthly NH3-N monitoring is acceptable. Since the proposed changes are directed to monitoring it is recommended that the draft permit effluent pages be changed accordingly. Should there be any questions please contact this office. GTT NPDES WASTE LOAD ALLOCATION PERMIT NO.: NCOOOO V FACILITY NAME: (;cr s7-0.- .1)i05%61 of r, /7• f /QF 14-er CO. Facility Status: EXISTING_- PROPOSED (circle one) Permit Status:, RENEWAL MODIFICATION UNPERMrrIED NEW (circle one) Major Minor, Pipe No: CcI Design Capacity (MGD): Domestic (% of Flow): Industrial (% of Flow): Comments: RECEIVING STREAM: Irene Class: Sub -Basin• grand 7C;J2r � 0 _� —0/ v Reference USGS Quad: County: Regional Office: (circle ens) Requested By - Prepared By: Reviewed By: Trrir15ylVCA r; , '56-C) (please attach) Fa Mo Ra Wa Wi WS Date: C , /k'aiDate: `6 (2- I Te Modeler Date Rec. # - 3'3' SS 452.c Drainage Area (mil) 22( Avg. Streamfiow (cfs)- (cfs) 1 s7 Winter 7Q10 (cfs) t 1 30Q2 (cfs) Toxicity Limits: IWC Z( % (circle one) Acute Instream Monitoring: 'DO 1 Co,J.,cL Parameters Upstream L . Downstream sL lures (e -NJ I — O CC- .1o.., .(.� wee (= A- _r. l - .ivva e. 1 w •.. wao Je ws 64.:{✓t7. bAv.aseN Q.k GR. aR 'G rtt4 Location t= 42-�"' `a'` ;a8?-b. N R.4 15 Z Location L0(2-5k L4ef4TteeJ la IS %---.let b4.1e,0 4,0+11,1 Effluent Characteristics tkdi #0S1!u- Matt u Mew tATntei .4t_ BOD 5 y 5-97 /a 1174 iD e t n `1 1Vt, t Ss 3 `l t NH3 N (mg/I) c,c., ( weak() tM,o':�`�-o.rcI D.O. (mg/1) y 4 TSS (iu M 1t l5 lti s- SZ94% i►ss5- ?zLt L F. Col. (/100m1) pH (SU) 4 ..'k 1 _q G - G —� ere,e1".6de ii,oZ4tlt 11. b'2, `it phy.e'S "Or. e-L.to✓e e t.L y. 23 % 4. 1.3 'clan PL Comments: x.'c ,` `r�e v < 1-4-444-4. (s a c y -��/ FOR APPROPRIATE DISCHARGERS, LIST COMPLETE GUIDELINE LIMITATIONS BELOW Effluent Characteristics Month y Average ,f Daily Maximum Comments BADS 190.3•0 /1 c16,z. ,o QPl 753 // _5 , 'CO a 2, 4'44 � 0 4___._._ c .�-n-c-.^.. (_, J. . -.. �_.�,,_,� p Pr' I-r 50e qo Opt Ao L (Jo ft,rt4.0. rs y. Oa BAT Tr ► c,C,C( 1bel e.aS _ ((. z. 3 Prr Type of Product Produced Lbs/Day Produced Effluent uidelinenReference 110/,'iLtAlphce 044.' R 46 9 Iaa t k 1d ere P - coo. if o 114-R,Z,tea° r tp.4 ) ,/� .,..J .4/30 i / r CKe etA 143°' fe° Permit Number Facility Name Type of Waste Status Receiving Stream Stream Class Subbasin County Regional Office Requestor Date of Request Quad WASTELOAD ALLOCATION APPROVAL FORM NC0000078 ECUSTA IND.-PULP & P PER EXISTING/ U pNUQL FRENCH BROAD RIVER C 040301 TRANSYLVANIA ARO LULA HARRIS 3/3/88 F8SW wasteflow (mgd): 5-Day BOD (mg/1): Ammonia Nitrogen (mg/1): Dissolved Oxygen (mg/1): TSS (#/d) Fecal Coliform (#/100m1): pH (SU): 6-9 Pentachlorophenols (#/d): Trichlorophenols (#/d): RECOMMENDED Mon avg 27.5 20 E 4 Request No. :4520 Water Quality RECEIVED JUL e Iy�� PERMITS & ENGONEERING Draii ge Area (sq mi) Avera e Flow (cfs) Summer 7Q10 (cfs) Winter 7Q10 (cfs) 30Q2 (cfs) EFFLUENT LIMITS Da Max ( 4587#/d*) 40 Cgvo #,0,4 4 11585 22448 4.02 4.23 MONITORING JUN30988 Asheville I e,tii,S; i ('ice lshevi!!e, North Carolina : 11221 . : 552 : 157. : 191. wq wq bpt bpt/wq bat bat Upstream (Y/N): Y Location: DAVIDSON RIVER NR MOUTH AND RM 192 Downstream (Y/N): Y Location: AT CURRENT LOCATION COMMENTS RS-Gr"M••ENn EFFT UE* H3 _M^_N =T-Tay=. SEE ATTACHED TOXICITY REQUIRENMENTS, MEMO. Recommended by Reviewed by: Tech. Support Supervisor Regional Supervisor Permits & Engineering (1 e D,0 Date 61Z3 Date e Date Date RETURN TO TECHNICAL SERVICES BY JUL 28 1988 Facility Name L S r /) Permit # iN.-)L6o6o0-?S CHRONIC TOXICITY TESTING REQUIREMENT (QRTRLY) The effluent discharge shall at no time exhibit chronic toxicity using test procedures outlined in: 1.) The North Carolina Ccriodaphnia chronic effluent bioassay procedure (North Carolina Chronic Bioassay Procedure • Revised *February 1987) or subsequent versions. The effluent concentration at which there may be no observable inhibition of reproduction or significant mortality is j % (defined as treatment two in the North Carolina procedure document). The permit holder shall perform guarter(y monitoring using this procedure to establish compliance with the permit condition. The first test will be performed after burry days from issuance of this permit during the months of A(,r. v (, o c_E- e-Jh. . Effluent sampling for this testing shall be performed at the NPDES permitted final effluent discharge below all treatment processes. £#i s t . /S- -{o (,e. u ((e c{-eiQ a-d a q Rc$ All toxicity testing results required as part of this permit condition will be entered on the Effluent Discharge Monitoring Form (MR-1) for the month in which it was performed, using the parameter code TGP3B. Additionally, DEM Form AT-1 (original) is to be sent to the following address: Attention: Technical Services Branch North Carolina Division of Environmental Management P.O. Box 27687 - Raleigh, N.C. 27611 Test data shall be complete and accurate and include all supporting chemical/physical measurements performed in association with the toxicity tests, as well as all.dose/response data. Total residual chlorine of the effluent toxicity sample must be measured and reported if chlorine is employed for disinfection of the waste stream. Should any. test data from this monitoring requirement or tests performed by the North Carolina Division of Environmental Management indicate potential impacts to the receiving stream, this permit may be re -opened and modified to include alternate monitoring requirements or limits. NOTE: Failure to achieve test conditions as specified in the cited document, such as minimum control organism survival and appropriate. -environmental controls, shall constitute an invalid test and will require immediate retesting(within30.days of initial Monitoring event). Failure to submit suitable test results will constitute a failiriire of permit condition-. 7Q10 { �? .. cfs Permited Flow - 227 MGD .IWC96 . 21 Basin & Subbasin `0 4036) i Receiving Stream --re^cl_. County i �r2. -s Recommended by: Date • 30 t 5 sus **Chronic Toxicity (Ceriodaphnia) P/F at Z( %, Ar) ��I . o , See Part , Condition (-�- . Discharger : ECUSTA Receiving Stream'. : FRENCH BROAD RIVER MODEL RESULTS SUMMER NH3 RUN The End D.O. is 5.55 mg/1. The End CBOD is 7.72 mg/l. The End NBOD is 2.68 mg/1. Segment 1 Reach 1 Reach 2 Segment 2 Reach 1 Segment 3 Reach 1 WLA WLA WLA DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) 5.02 6.59 5.111 4.45 2 90.00 45.00 0.00 80.00 18.00 4.00 0.00 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 5.80 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.50000 27.00000 2.00000 0.00000 MODEL RESULTS Discharger : ECUSTA Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER SUMMER SUMMER WITH DUPONT The End D.O. is 15.30 mg/l. The End CBOD is 11.92 mg/1. The End NBOD is 2.43 mg/1. DO !Min WLA WLA WLA CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5. Reach 1 Reach 2 Segment 2 Reach 1 Segment 3 Reach 1 16 4.45 2 90.00 45.00 0.00 2.50000 80.00 9.00 4.00 27.00000 6.59 0.00 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 2.00000 5.'30 4.00 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 *** MODEL SUMMARY DATA *** Discharger : ECUSTA Subbasin : 040301 Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Stream Class: C Summer 7Q10 : 157. Winter 7Q10 : 191. Design Temperature: 23. 'LENGTH' SLOPE' VELOCITY I DEPTH' Kd # Kd 1 Ka 1 Ka 1 KN 1 KN 1 KHR 1 KHR # mile 1 ft/nil fps ( ft 'design # @20° 'design( @20° 'design! @200 'design' P20° I I I Segment 1 I 0.051 5,001 0,900 1 3.45 (0.57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 Reach 1 l I I I I I I I I # I I I I I I I I I# I I I Segment 1 # 4.401 5.001 0,900 (3.90 1 0.57 1 0.50 (2.13 ( 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 Reach 2 1 I I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1( 1 I Segment 2 1 8,501 40.001 0.933 1 1,53 1 0.60 1 0.52 135.06 1 32.851 0.63 1 0.50 1 0.63 1 0,00 Reach i t I # I I I I # # # I # I I # I # I # # # # # Segment 3 1 4,001 5.001 0,900 1 4.35 1 0,57 1 0.50,1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 (0.30 1 0.38 1 0,30 Reach 1 l I I I I I ! I 1 I I 1 Flow 1 CBOD 1 NBOD 1 D.O. I I cfs 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 1 Segment 1 Reach 1 Waste I 3.875 1 90.000 1 45.000 1 0.000 Headwatersl157.000 # 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary I 0.000 # 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 # 1.000 ! 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 Waste. 141.850 1 80.000 # 9.000 ( 4.000 Tributary I 0.000 1 2.000 # 1.000 I 7.720 * Runoff I 1.360 # 2.000 1 1.000 ( 7.720 Segment 2 Reach 1 Waste, I 3.100 1 63.000 1 9.000 1 0.000 Headwaters( 18.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary I 0.000 I 2.000 1 1.000 ! 7.720 * Runoff I 2.700 I 2.000 I 1.000 # 7.720 1 Segment 3 Reach 1 Waste I 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 Headwaters' 0.000 1 2.000 ! 1.000 ! 7.720 Tributary I 0.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 ' 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.500 1 2.000 1 1.000 I 7.720 • c - Ft * Runoff flow is in cfs/mile MODEL RESULTS Discharger : ECUSTA Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER ff (2, SUMMER SUMMER WITH DUPONT The End D.O. is 5.71 mg/1. The End CBOD is 7.72 mg/1. The End NBOD is 1.82 mg/1. WLA WLA WLA DO ,Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.16 Reach 1 Reach 2 Segment 2 6.59 Reach 1 Segment 3 5.27 Reach 1 4.45 2 90.00 45.00 0.00 80.00 9.00 4.00 0.00 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 5.60 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.50000 27.00000 2.00000 0.00000 DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT June 23, 1988 MEMORANDUM TO: File FROM: Randy Dodd 2C..D SUBJECT: Ecusta WLA An intensive survey was performed in 1978 to aid in the development of a WLA. The Horn Model was subsequently used for calibration and allocation. Verification was not performed. While previous documentation did not allow for straightforward review of methods used for choosing parameters, some useful information was obtained from the study. In particular, it was decided to use velocity, Ka, and Kd inputs from the study. New flow esti- mates were obtained from the USGS. Brevard and Dupont were input as inter- acting dischargers. Ambient data were used to estimate headwater and runoff inputs. Dupont's influence on the French Broad river is overestimated, since the hydropower reservoir below Dupont was modeled as a free flowing stream. After compiling input, the Level B software was used for modeling purposes. At current permitted conditions, the predicted DO minimum of 5.27 mg/1 occurs 10 miles below the outfall. Ambient and self -monitoring data indicate that upstream water quality is of high quality. One downstream value from self -monitoring data (out of 100 values collected during July -September) violated the DO standard of 5 mg/1 (4.6 mg/1). However, a systematic influence (besides temperature) resulting in lower DO was also observed: 98% of the values at the down- stream station had a lower % saturation than at the upstream station. Ambient data indicated a very slight increase (0.75 mg/1) in the mean summer BODS, and a 13% decrease in the 9 DO saturation when comparing upstream (Rosman) and downstream (Blantyre) values. No standards violations were observed at Blantyre. Benthic macroinvertebrate data at Rosman (1981, 1982, 1986) and Blan- tyre (1983, 1986) indicate a decrease in water quality. Besides potential non -point influences and small treatment plants, Ecusta, Brevard, and Dupont are the major dischargers above the Blantyre station. Monitoring Recommendations Since the predicted sag is expected to occur 10 miles below the discharge, it is recommended that self -monitoring continue at the current location 10.8 miles below the outfall. Monitoring should be 3/week July -October, weekly April -June, and monthly November -March. Other Issues The French Broad river has been reclassified as WS-III waters near Asheville. Since the facility has a bleached kraft line, dioxin is a potential concern. Water quality based limits for BOD5 should be issued in concentration and mass units. lrv`t9v� d ldt (4-6ad-V.aag Q A V ti N2RD 19 157 0 %wea V14-1-ge L . tt L w INNIS 1�-- z iaja 5,23 O , S 4k 0L 3 So N 2 2, S-- - ZS to Ct 18,5 1 is t-17•+- 6%1. s(6 t 4-5 -----> E 1 'M 2r•vAJZ C. sT A t'd _. --s /0 - eS... - — r2a�_z.0 ----�uOo.i— - - 1 4i (C Tyco ve Ate= 14.Si L t T'f"Li: e, VECk g;s - las fx M v-• -_ G3 Log A-,, o so -) U .�W►rJ�QIti.T tit L. �o h +n./ mot, Sia i• 9—c iv, r 21 N-: ctzo- -aQso = 3Z M 1 BLS �1v•1 E Seg # I Reach # I Seg Mi I D.O. I CBOD 1 1 0.00 7.53 4.12 1 1 0.05 7.53 4.11 1 2 0.05 6.80 19.77 1 2 0.25 6.69 19.59 1 2 0.45 6.57 19.42 1 2 0.65 6.47 19.25 1 2 0.85 6.36 19.07 1 2 1.05 6.27 18.90 1 2 1.25 6.17 18.73 1 2 1.45 6.08 18.57 1 2 1.65 6.00 18.40 1 2 1.85 5.92 18.24 1 2 2.05 5.84 18.07 1 2 2.25 5.77 17.91 1 2 2.45 5.70 17.75 1 2 2.65 5.63 17.59 1 2 2.85 5.56 17.44 1 2 3.05 5.50 17.28 1 2 3.25 5.45 17.13 1 2 3.45 5.39 16.97 1 2 3.65 5.34 16.82 1 2 3.85 5.29 16.67 1 2 4.05 5.25 16.52 1 2 4.25 5.20 16.38 1 2 4.45 5.16 16.23 2 1 0.00 6.59 10.96 2 1 0.10 6.96 10.81 2 1 0.20 7.26 10.65 2 1 0.30 7.49 10.51 2 1 0.40 7.67 10.36 2 1 0.50 7.81 10.22 2 1 0.60 7.93 10.08 2 1 0.70 8.02 9.95 2 1 0.80 8.09 9.82 2 1 0.90 8.14 9.69 2 1 1.00 8.19 9.57 2 1 1.10 8.22 9.45 2 1 1.20 8.25 9.33 2 1 1.30 8.28 9.21 2 1 1.40 8.29 9.10 2 1 1.50 8.31 8.98 2 1 1.60 8.32 8.88 2 1 1.70 8.33 8.77 2 1 1.80 8.34 8.66 2 1 1.90 8.35 8.56 2 1 2.00 8.35 8.46 2 1 2.10 8.36 8.36 2 1 2.20 8.36 8.27 2 1 2.30 8.37 8.17 2 1 2.40 8.37 8.08 2 1 2.50 8.38 7.99 2 1 2.60 8.38 7.90 2 1 2.70 8.38 7.82 2 1 2.80 8.38 7.73 2 1 2.90 8.39 7.65 2 1 3.00 8.39 7.57 SUMMER SUMMER WITH DUPONT NBOD 1 Flow 1 2.06 160.88 2.06 160.94 3.49 202.79 3.47 203.06 3.45 203.34 3.43 203.61 3.41 203.88 3.39 204.15 3.36 204.42 3.34 204.70 3.32 204.97 3.30 205.24 3.28 205.51 3.26 205.78 3.24 206.06 3.22 206.33 3.21 206.60 3.19 206.87 3.17 207.14 3.15 207.42 3.13 207.69 3.11 207.96 3.09 208.23 3.07 208.50 3.05 208.78 2.18 21.10 2.15 21.37 2.13 21.64 2.11 21.91 2.08 22.18 2.06 22.45 2.04 22.72 2.02 22.99 2.00 23.26 1.98 23.53 1.96 23.80 1.94 24.07 1.92 24.34 1.91 24.61 1.89 24.88 1.87 25.15 1.85 25.42 1.84 25.69 1.82 25.96 1.81 26.23 1.79 26.50 1.77 26.77 1.76 27.04 1.75 27.31 1.73 27.58 1.72 27.85 1.70 28.12 1.69 28.39 1.68 28.66 1.66 28.93 1.65 29.20 G 1 J.1U b.iJ r.4J 1.b4 �1-).4! 2 1 3.20 8.39 7.41 1.62 29.74 2 1 3.30 8.39 7.33 1.61 30.01 2 1 3.40 8.40 7.25 1.60 30.28 2 1 3.50 8.40 7.18 1.59 30.55 2 1 3.60 8.40 7.11 1.58 30.82 1 3.70 8.40 7.03 1.56 31.09 2 1 3.80 8.40 6.96 1.55 31.36 2 1 3.90 8.41 6.89 1.54 31.63 2 1 4.00 8.41 6.82 1.53 31.90 2 1 4.10 8.41 6.76 1.52 32.17 2 1 4.20 8.41 6.69 1.51 32.44 2 1 4.30 8.41 6.63 1.50 32.71 2 1 4.40 8.41 6.56 1.49 32.98 2 1 4.50 8.41 6.50 1.48 33.25 2 1 4.60 8.42 6.44 1.47 33.52 2 1 4.70 8.42 6.38 1.46 33.79 2 1 4.80 8.42 6.32 1.45 34.06 2 1 4.90 8.42 6.26 1.44 34.33 2 1 5.00 8.42 6.20 1.43 34.60 2 1 5.10 8.42 6.15 1.42 34.87 2 1 5.20 8.42 6.09 1.41 35.14 2 1 5.30 8.43 6.04 1.40 35.41 2 1 5.40 8.43 5.98 1.40 35.68 2 1 5.50 8.43 5.93 1.39 35.95 2 1 5.60 8.43 5.88 1.38 36.22 2 1 5.70 8.43 5.83 1.37 36.49 2 1 5.80 8.43 5.77 1.36 36.76 2 1 5.90 8.43 5.72 1.35 37.03 2 1 6.00 8.43 5.68 1.34 37.30 2 1 6.10 8.44 5.63 1.34 37.57 2 1 6.20 8.44 5.58 1.33 37.84 2 1 6.30 8.44 5.53 1.32 38.11 2 1 6.40 8.44 5.49 1.31 38.38 2 1 6.50 8.44 5.44 1.31 38.65 2 1 6.60 8.44 5.39 1.30 38.92 2 1 6.70 8.44 5.35 1.29 39.19 2 1 6.80 8.44 5.31 1.28 39.46 2 1 6.90 8.44 5.26 1.28 39.73 2 1 7.00 8.45 5.22 1.27 40.00 2 1 7.10 8.45 5.18 1.26 40.27 2 1 7.20 8.45 5.14 1.26 40.54 2 1 7.30 8.45 5.10 1.25 40.81 2 1 7.40 8.45 5.06 1.24 41.08 2 1 7.50 8.45 5.02 1.24 41.35 2 1 7.60 8.45 4.98 1.23 41.62 2 1 7.70 8.45 4.94 1.22 41.89 2 1 7.80 8.45 4.90 1.22 42.16 2 1 7.90 8.45 4.86 1.21 42.43 1 8.00 8.45 4.83 1.20 42.70 1 8.10 8.46 4.79 1.20 42.97 1 8.20 8.46 4.75 1.19 43.24 1 8.30 8.46 4.72 1.18 43.51 1 8.40 8.46 4.68 1.18 43.78 1 8.50 8.46 4.65 1.17 44.05 1 0.00 5.74 14.21 2.73 252.83 1 0.20 5.70 14.09 2.71 253.13 3 1 0.40 5.66 13.97 2.69 253.43 3 1 0.60 5.63 13.84 2.68 253.73 3 1 0.80 5.59 13.72 2.66 254.03 3 1 1.00 5.56 13.60 2.65 254.33 3 1 1.20 5.53 13.48 2.63 254.63 3 1 1.40 5.51 13.36 2.62 254.93 3 1 1.60 5.48 13.25 2.60 255.23 3 1 1.80 5.46 13.13 2.59 255.53 3 1 2.00 5.44 13.02 2.57 255.83 COW N(NJ fJNNrJ 3 . 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Seg # I I G . GV 0.q4 1G .:1V 1 2.40 5.40 12.79 1 2.60 5.38 12.68 1 2.80 5.37 12.57 1 3.00 5.35 12.46 1 3.20 5.34 12.35 1 3.40 5.33 12.24 1 3.60 5.32 12.13 1 3.80 5.31 12.03 1 4.00 5.30 11.92 Reach # 1 Seg Mi I D.O. I CBOD W.1-5,2) 4.Sb Lnb.li 2.54 256.43 2.53 256.73 2.51 257.03 2.50 257.33 2.48 257.63 2.47 257.93 2.45 258.23 2.44 258.53 2.43 258.83 NBOD I Flow 1 UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAM % SATURATION Notched Box Plots for columns: X1 ... X2 95- 90. 8 5- 8 0- 7 5- 70. 65. 60. 55. 50 Nt =- t c) 'D U - • UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAM DO Notched Box Plots for columns: Xi ... X2 STORET, RETRIEVAL DATE 88/06/09 E0150000 FRB003 04030100.1 03439000 35 08 32.0 082 49 28.0 1 FRENCH ;BROAD RIVER AT ROSMAN NC 37175 NORTH CAROLINA TRANSYLVANIA SOUTHEAST 040301 FRENCH BROAD 21NC01WQ 06010105040 0000.630 ON 0001 FEET DEPTH DATE FROM TO 82/07/ 08 82/08/11 82/09/15 82/10/05 83/07/10 83/08/16 83/09/16 83/10/20 84/07/11 84/08/20 34/09/07 84/10/25 85/07/10 85/08/06 85/09/11 85/10/22 86/07/28 86/08/11 86/09/09 86/10/20 87/07/29 87/08/28 87/09/28 87/10/30 00/00/00 STATION 99/99/99 0930 1110 1045 1020 1120 1040 0830 1100 1110 1400 1200 1030 1130 1145 1130 1026 1140 1130 1230 1230 1030 1140 1120 1515 NUMBER MAXIMUM MINIMUM MEAN 00300 00010 DO WATER TEMP MG/L CENT 8.00000 22.0000 8.40000 20.0000 9.00000 19.0000 9.00000 16.0000 8.80000 18.0000 9.10000 18.0000 8.70000 15.0000 8.3000U 14.0000 9.50000 20.0000 8.30000 19.0000 9.30000 14.0000 9.10000 16.0000 8.90000 20.0000 9.50000 18.0000 9.10000 19.0000 9.00000 14.0000 8.80000 23.0000 9.80000 21.0000 9.00000 18.0000 10.2000 8.00000 8.50000 20.0000 3.70000 20.0000 9.80000 16.0000 10.2000 12.0000 24 24 10.2000 23.0000 8.00000 3.00000 9.06249 17.5000 00301 00 SATUR PERCENT 91.0000 91.0000 96.0000 90.0000 93.0000 96.0000 85.0000 85.0000 103.261 88.2978 89.4230 91.0000 97.0000 100.000 97.0000 86.5384 101.149 108.389 94.7368 35.7143 92.3913 94.5652 98.0000 94.4444 24 108.889 85.0000 93.7253 /TYPA/AMBNT/STREAM STORET= RETRIEVAL DATE 88/06/09 E0850000 FRbOI1 040303004 03441000 35 16 23.0 082 42 21.0 1 DAVIDSON RIVER NEAR BREVARD NC 37175 NORTH CAROLINA TRANSYLVANIA SOUTHEAST 040303 FRENCH BROAD 21NC31Wc 06010105036 0001.730 ON 0001 FEET DEPTH DATE FROM TO 82/07/0a 82/08/11 82/09/15 82/10/05 83/07/10 83/08/16 83/09/16 83/10/20 8 4/0 7/ 11 84t/08/31 84/09/07 84/10/25 85/07/10 85/08/06 85/09/11 85/10/22 86/07/28 86/08/11 86/09/09 86/10/20 87/08/28 00/00/00 STATION 99/99/99 0900 1040 0945 0930 1030 0940 0800 0930 1040 1305 1235 1000 1040 1100 1030 0930 1110 1100 1145 1145 1105 NUMBER MAXIMUM MINIMUM MEAN 00300 00010 00 WATER TEMP MG/L CENT 3.00000 18.0000 8.60009 20.0000 8.80000 17.0000 9.00000 16.0000 8.90000 18.0000 9.10000 17.0000 8.80000 15.0000 8.70000 .14.0000 9.30000 19.0000 8.80000 18.0000 9.30000 15.0000 9.00000 16.0000 8.90000 19.0000 9.30000 17.0000 3.90000 18.5000 9.20000 12.0000 9.10000 23.0000 9.50000 20.0000 9.00000 17.0000 10.4000 8.00000 8.70000 20.0000 21 21 10.4000 23.0000 8.00000 8.00000 9.01428 17.0238 00301 DO SATUR PERCENT 94.0000 93.0J00 91.0000 90.0000 94.0000 94.0000 86.0000 84.0000 98.9351 92.6315 91.1764 90.0000 95.0000 96.0000 95.0000 85.1352 104.598 103.261 92.7835 87.3949 94.5652 21 104.598 84.0000 92.5014 /TYPA/AMBNT/STREAM SiURET'. RETRIEVAL DATE 88/06/09 E1270000 FRB017 040302006 03443000 35 17 56.0 082 37 27.0 1 FRENCH BROAD RIVER AT SLANTYRE NC 37175 NORTH CAROLINA TRANSYLVANIA SOUTHEAST 040302 FRENCH BROAD 21NCOIWQ 06010105034 0011.750 ON 0001 FEET DEPTH DATE FROM TO 82/07/08 1015 82/08/11 1200 8Z/09/15 1200 82/10/05 1100 83/07/10 1215 83/08/16 1115 83/09/16 0905 83/10/20 1030 84/07/11 1400 84/08/31 1345 84/09/07 1310 84/10/25 1320 85/07/10 1515 85/08/06 1545 85/09/11 1500 85/10/25 1400 86/07/28 1410 86/08/28 1445 86/09/25 1525 86/10/20 1515 87/07/29 1130 87/08/28 1415 87/09/28 1200 87/10/30 1430 00/00/00 STATION NUMBER MAXIMUM MINIMUM MEAN 99/99/99 00300 00010 00 WATER TEMP MG/L CENT b.60000 21.0000 7.10000 22.0000 7.20000 22.0000 7.00000 19.0000 7.30000 21.0000 6.50000 22.0000 7.50000 18.0000 7.80000 16.0000 8.00000 23.0000 7.50000 19.0000 8.10000 16.0000 7.80000 18.0000 7.00000 22.0000 7.90000 20.0000 7.40000 21.0000 7.50000 15.0000 b.60000 27.0000 6.70000 22.0000 7.50003 22.0000 8.40000 12.0000 7.00000 23.0000 b.90000 24.0000 8.10000 16.0000 9.20000 12.0000 24 24 9.20000 27.0000 6.50000 12.0000 7.44166 19.7083 00301 DO SATUR PERCENT 74.0000 81.0000 82.0000 74.0000 81.0000 74.0000 79.0000 78.0000 91.9540 79.7872 81.0000 82.1052 30.0000 86.0000 82.0000 73.5294 81.4814 76.1363 85.2273 77.7773 80.4598 81.1764 81.0000 85.1852 24 91.9540 73.5294 80.3258 /TYPA/AMBNT/STREAM dun SLoir I. vv-asc ar4L. ____142A4"-Ls) 2P / 4 a o 1 7-SS 6\ lille(f(2 \\ <rsL1 —Z.Sso44 /&-Istb4‘t>t-k• Dotz- --cos 4-1 L.. C6•'" cD ts 'Lev E-1_ s 11 So S Q-u-k-tte,A4 LT vs ez....A.44,s 1/4VID c.‘ S--4,2,15. oc_ kzos- Go- D vist, 0 ??As _ ery7.2_ e•-t+.12- 4-f) .32 =cu 0t.1-4 co c. 7 <<rLa Igis2. 1elgg tct • nowt • e i6 LA-L Rt 04, Ca C s : s,.�.a'e,� �- 0, to 240 . s% 1 1 'i00 3 6 s— ..�3 75-D 3,q ..'7rx 5-15-- Z.,C. . (7 x ts2 7. s- .^7I7 qq3 3.3 -7 40 Zi S C c o.i c. 3 - 157 1r ` c cs y0y Z( - 663 -+40) y,o 4� tSe t S' 3D $ t c sI.„,.� ,.s 3.25 2,-7 42.5".L7 • 04_ 6_02g 67Z , p - — - • e.C. oe7 oCR • .6r ‹. A1,-A '77 .400111111mmimmiliiiimub. N (7):34b7g/ —11111111%aiw \S1111444ivioci: L.. 51____-_-___1(1\t(ori— g to, I qv) L. Gvg"c-4. -3-17 l,a 2,a,� 2°, 2�,0 zt,a Zo t 20, 0 telIS- 19, 15 i IS, A 14, 17, '7, Sr 7,s 23, 0 Z.3, 0 Z3,o 2 3, 2ZiS 2?r0 22i 2(,S~ ton-roc+,r. icro C+-Ct_0(4..Z. A J 4 eb-10 ....- dc- 2i tir,6 4,5" -2- 2_. 6, I 1t,s- 7(7 -2.c en, 2, -/,2 2.,Z►s- 1. . IS, ?, 21 G, 9 71 6 Z3 s g 2v 7, ? 2.1, .5" G, Z z_"? , s si 4 7 r 'Z,Z 4' Z Z, 6 z.Z 4, 2 26 `?, ? '2:1 !,� g Zo ?t 9 21,S' 1, ( 23 (o , i , '3.,1 7, 6 22 .7 l f °La , s- `. 1 1, 3 -�o,s ► �3 1, 2. 2,1,5 , 3 ?., 2 -zz G , g z f' 1, 2. -2.2.1S- �, y 13 2. "2_ G,9 Zo IN 7,I,5- (,t 4,1 -2... t, `f 2-(, -t , 6 r2_2 6, '7 6, 53 I , 3 2.1,s -7, 3 2_2, s"' 6, a -?, 2 a.. y 4,.4 2J f.:- le Z 23,-T C. 2 ?, ( 2;, s 4.1 2? -710 2 , .5- ‘.`3 1 7, 2. `2� t , T 2 t _ -i, �, 23 c,, `f 6, `� ?, Zi �,Z 42.( 1 b 46, z 14S -7_ e z( _---i, i -'- 1, -? 22,s-- -7 t; 21 C, , C k t, -If - ea ,7 2 4 ‘ , 2t) 7, r 2:3 s,2 2-E. s- 7, 0 -c B' 20 ?I a 2.2..5- 6,,E 22,.5 Co,. ce, 1 2 0 7, ( 2`f 6- 2_ 4 , S , 8- t,Lf l 5" 7,4 'lee.' (,C 24, s-►g ,_ _)\ * co--+ : - 3 -? , 3 29 , Sr /=, J 2 22,5 7 2 2`1.5- `t4 23 13,44 2S" 6, 2 z) si -a. '2. 7,? t 2z 1 i 3 `$,4 21,5' ?lb MEMORANDUM T0: FROM: THRU : DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT August 4, 1988 Dale Overcash Randy Dodd Trevor Clements Steve Tedder +TN SUBJECT: Comments on Draft Permit - Ecusta The following comments are provided as a follow-up to correspondence with Ecusta. 1) An NH3 limit is included in the WLA because NH3 contributes a demand to the river - not because of data requirements for modeling purposes. The limit is, therefore, water quality based and not tech- nology based. Data from Ecusta are insufficient to document the NH3 loading to the French Broad River. NH3 data are only available for one day. TN data indicate, that if all the nitrogen is present as NH3, that a maximum of 6 mg/1 is possible. It is, therefore, recommended that a monitoring requirement be included. If NH3 values approach or exceed 4 mg/1 (monthly average), it is recommended that the permit be reopened and a limit included. 2) The information provided does not indicate that there is no var- iability in effluent toxicity. Toxicity data alone can demonstrate this point. Therefore, the monitoring recommendation (quarterly) should be retained. After a sufficient period of time, it is conceiv- able that this requirement can be changed, but it is not recommended that we commit to doing so without knowledge which data will provide. RD:gh State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Asheville Regional Office James G. Martin, Governor S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION MEMORANDUM TO: THROUGH: FROM: SUBJECT: July 22, 1988 Dale Overcash, Leader NPDES Group Forrest R. Westall Regional Water Qua upervisor del" Gary T. Tweed P.E., Environmental Engineer Water Quality Section David R. Spain Regional Manager 7;74.triprtoZ.7.1.?? r.k:e JUL 27 1988 Amonia Nitrogen Limitations Draft Permit Number NC0000078 Ecusta Corporation Transylvania County After reviewing the July 15, 1988, letter from Ecusta, this office has no objection to dropping proposed limitations for amonia nitrogen in NPDES Permit Number NC0000078. If there is insufficient data for modeling purposes than effluent monitoring should be retained for confirmation purposes. Should there be any questions, please advise. GTT:ls Interchange Building, 59 Woodfin Place, PA Box 370, Asheville, N.C. 28802-0370 • Telephone 704-253-3341 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer custa P.O. BOX 200 • PISGAH FOREST. NORTH CAROLINA 28768 • TELEPHONE (704) 877-2211 July 15, 1988 Mr. Dale Overcash Environmental Supervisor Water Quality Section Division of Environmental Management P. 0. Box 27687 Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-27687 Dear Mr. Overcash: Subject: NPDES Permit NC0000078 Renewal - Effluent Limit I have been recently advised by L. Harris of the D.E.M.'s NPDES Permitting Group that the above subject permit may contain an ammonia nitrogen effluent limitation. When this was discussed with Mr. Dodd, he advised me to express my concerns to you in writing. The Ecusta Facility is currently permitted to discharge treated wastewater into the French Broad River. This wastewater is produced during the manu- facture of cigarette papers and fine printing papers and is treated, after equalization, in two primary clarifiers and in an aerated stabilization basin. All domestic wastewater, approximately 100,000 gallons per day, is treated in an extended aeration wastewater treatment system prior to its introduction into the process wastewater treatment plant and the resulting flow, approximately 26 million gallons per day, is discharged to the French Broad River. The hydraulic detention time in our secondary wastewater treatment plant is in excess of 12-i days. We do not currently and have never added nitrogen or phosphorus to our wastewater treatment plant. We have, though, on a regular basis in the past monitored for nitrogen and phosphorus so as to determine if such additions would be needed. Attached is a graph showing the total nitrogen analysis contained in our discharge since mid-1985. You can see from this graph that even if all this nitrogen was in the form of ammonia, it would be impossible for us to violate the proposed guideline limit. To lend credibility to this, an analysis of five grab samples of the secondary wastewater treatment plant effluent discharged to the French Broad River between July 6 and July 12, 1988 indicates that the current ammonia level varies from less than the detectable limit of 1.0 ppm to a maximum value of 2.0 ppm. The average of samples above the detectable limit was 1.6 ppm ammonia nitrogen. It is our belief that these levels show negligible amounts of nitrogen and ammonia in our effluent and that we should have neither a monitoring nor a discharge limitation for ammonia nitrogen. ECUS T A CO R POR A T ION Page 2 From discussions with Mr. Dodd, it is my impression that ammonia analysis is needed by the State of North Carolina to fill in a blank on the assimilative capacity model of the French Broad River and the impact that Ecusta has on this model. If this is the case, we are more than willing to assist the Department in gathering data but would prefer to do this under a letter request. This will solve two problems. First, it will supply to the State of North Carolina the necessary data needed to make their assimilative capacity model of the French Broad River "fit" better. Secondly, it will give Ecusta an opportunity to work with the State without incurring the burden of an effluent limitation. I appreciate this opportunity to submit this information to you for use in our new proposed permit and assure you that we will do our utmost to assist you in developing a permit which is fair and equitable and which accomplishes the objective of protecting our valuable resources. If further information is desired or if you would like to meet with me to discuss this matter, I will be happy to present such additional data as necessary to support our position. Sincerely, ECUSTA DIVISION P. Ii. GLATFELTER COMPANY R. ./Gussman, Director Environmental Affairs /bh enclosures cc: Randall C. Dodd - Water Quality Section, Raleigh, N.C. R. M. Davis - D.E.M., Asheville, N.C. L. Harris - D.E.M., Raleigh, N.C. .D. W. Monk - Ecusta U Z W< t7v N . I-= Z Du' Wj ZI t, 100 90 80 70 b0 60 zn a � ar • bD O N 50 co co 40 O Ei 30 20 10 • _--'{�- -tom_ �_._ _ __.._.. - - •-1 arm-eraj�e=nxrage-u:__:_.: _ :: =__ -' - _-. _ r -;__ -_-::,ice= -:-_- ::•.:-:_,__;...•.; 1- 1T� =T'YAT` TTgOGEWA 3ALYSIS. -- . - - • • 1 _ »--tom___-Y•_ L 1 < w < L < 2 J f9 p t•. > f.i 19_ _85. 9 Z < Z 7 9 < w O 2 O 19_86 1 9 87 .J O a P > 2 .>. L9 � r f 2 2 T 2' C � Z < I q 7 < N O 2 C � I < S ' 7 7 < 19._88 j 19 � ofl 6,4 custa P.O. BOX 200 • PISGAH FOREST. NORTH CAROLINA 28768 • TELEPHONE (704) 877-2211 Mr. Charlie Wakilid Water Quality Chief Division Of Environmental Management Water Quality Section P. 0. Box 27687 Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7687 Dear Mr. Wakilid: 'July 14, 1988 Subject: JUL R 198`. DE.RMI S & E►, ;=INEERING Permit Renewal NPDES NC0000078, Ceriodaphnia Testing I have been recently advised by L. Harris of the D.E.M.'s NPDES Permitting Group that the above subject permit will contain a chronic toxicity testing requirement. This requirement will request Ecusta to conduct quarterly chronic toxicity tests using Ceriodaphnia at an effluent concentration of 21%. The Ecusta Facility is currently permitted to discharge 27.5 mgd of treated waste- water to the French Broad River. This wastewater is produced during the manufacture of cigarette papers and fine printing papers. It is treated, after equalization, in a primary clarifier and an aerated stabilization basin. All domestic wastewater is treated in an extended aeration wastewater treatment system prior to its intro- duction into the process wastewater treatment plant. The hydraulic detention time in our aerated stabilization basin is in excess of 12.5 days at a design flow of 27.5 mgd. At our current discharge rate of approximately 23 mgd, this retention time is 15 days. Our effluent characteristics, as monitored at the effluent discharge structure and in the receiving stream, are very uniform. Some examples are the daily dissolved oxygen, pH, and five-day biochemical oxygen demand as shown in Table A. This table was developed from current NPDES reports for 1987.- 1988. Graph A shows the effluent .flow pattern of this facility since 1979. Note the lack of variability which has occurred since January of 1987. The aerated stabilization basin at Ecusta contains a large population of biological organisms and normally operates with a BOD5 removal efficiency of in excess of 98%. Characteristics of the waste material entering this system have not materially changed in the last ten years and we project no change in the foreseeable future. In the early 1980's, we retained a student from the UNC-A to conduct studies of the effluent from our secondary wastewater treatment plant, aerated stabilization basin. A copy of her report is attached. We were particularly concerned with the biological portion of the effluent solids. These solids were tested for % protein, % carbohydrate, and DNA analyses. You will note not only the lack of variability in these analyses, but, also, the high level of cellular material present as measured by the protein and DNA concentrations. ECUSTA C ORPORATI 0 N Page 2 A side benefit of the above study was the observation and the later certification by a biologist of the presence of large quantities of Moina in the secondary treatment plant. This close cousin of the Daphnia causes us numerous problems in the BOD5 and total suspended solids tests. They are present basically year around and are a nuisance, particularly from May to October. As you are aware, their presence is partially temperature related. Because of the above points, we question our need to conduct chronic toxicity tests on a regular basis. As an alternative, I suggest we conduct such tests semiannually for the first year of our NPDES permit only. If we pass these tests, no further testing will be needed during the life of the permit as long as we certify that our manufacturing process and/or the influent characteristics of our wastewater- does not substantially change If it is decided that quarterly monitoring will be required of us, it is still proposed that after one year of tests with no failures, that no further testing would be required. Secondly, the current North Carolina chronic effluent bioassay procedure using Ceriodaphnia, revision dated June 1988, requires that two effluent 24-hour composite samples be provided for the bioassays. Considering the retention time in our secondary treatment plant (15 days), the type of treatment, and the con- sistency of the monitored parameters, it is proposed that grab samples be substituted for the composites. This will simplify the sampling protocol while having no effect on the quality of the sample. I appreciate this opportunity to submit this information to you and assure you that we will do our utmost to assist you in developing a permit which is fair and equitable and which accomplishes the objective of protecting our valuable resources. I would be pleased to meet with either you or any of your representatives to discuss this matter at a reasonable time and to present such additional data, as necessary, to support our position. /bh Sincerely, ECUSTA DIVISION P. H,.,GLATFELT COMPANY Gussman, Director Environmental Affairs enclosures cc: K. W. Eagleson - D.E.M., Raleigh, N.C. R. M. Davis - D.E.M., Asheville, N.C. L. Harris - D.E.M., Raleigh, N.C. D. W. Monk - Ecusta TABLE A Effluent Analysis 1987 - 1988 1987 1988 J F M A M J J A S 0 N D J F M A M ?arameter DO 8.7 8.8 8.0 7.3 7.0 6.4 6.3 6.4 6.7 7.5 7.7 8.2 8.6 8.3 7.8 7.1 7.2 pH 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.7 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.8 - 7.7 - 7.7 - 7.7 - 7.5 - 7.5 - 8.2 8.2 8.1 8.0 8.0 8.1 8.0 8.0 8.1 8.0 8.1 8.1 8.2 8.0 8.3 8.3 8.0 BOD5 15.1 16.4 11.4 11.5 8.2 6.1 6.3 8.9 9.9 8.7 13.8 16.0 24.0 19.0 16.6 16.3 10.3 Receiving Stream Analysis Upstream 1986 1987 0 N D J F M A M J J A S Parameter Conductivity, }tohms 21 23 ' 21 20 13 6 14 29 22 30 29 pH 6.6 6.8 6.9 6.8 6.3 6.9 6.6 6.6 6.5 6.4 Total Alk., mg/1 10 9 6 7 i 3 6 8 7 7 7 Downstream 1986 1987 0 N D J F M A M J J A S Parameter Conductivity, jtohms 54 36 35 40 26 27 45 55 70 110 83 pH 7.0 6.8 7.0 7.1 6.8 7.0 6.8 7.2 7.0 6.8 Total Alk., mg/1 28 19 11 12 8* 15 23 34 25 *Heavy Rain .ti 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 GRAPH A in'■CUICCirC MCCICn::a m::CCCC:�rii�i''CCCCn_::: CEa1 CCCCCErmaC:CCCCCCaam:CCC:CCCCCCC 1272222 m EC,.:CCCCCIE_L".ES::CE"■E1ii/__:C22:: 'D:C::SC" S::SE:ECECCECC:CCCC:CCCCC:CCCECCCC:CSC:CC1::mmimm mmam.mmi.mm/mm.■.■maaiwmin:=nmm:aEasSsEmmam . .■ .■.../.........mw ...■mnnm■.._. mama i ma// mrrmmmwiummi i m. i ammnimmmmi/mom mn nmm im///mmmm i■. mimwniiimman■/imma.mnmmma E11ESEa`11aa=sa EEs E Es11E€s m=aEsmnagEma 111111111111aa::1g1EoCs�9Se::C1� 1C==CCa:aaaCCi`� -- ma mm mmmmmmmmmmmi.m■//ma /::/a:Ca:/i�7mmmommimmma ■l Cm mamma ammo `2122_ mommommismo:�mommmmummummmm iEC�" mmamwwmimmmw.mmmmmmmmmmainmmwinaim/mama/mama... mama. ■ommo ww ■m .maim■ mnn imanimmm.w.■m■■mm■.mama.n.m .mnmmmmmw.mmmi ■om■mmmwmwmmmmmimiammmmn.nnw .mm ■m ■ p i pwmm■■.■.■ .■. ma ■■� ma.i�22ZaC:a:: 2 C'm:mCCCCCCCECC'CmCCCCCCCCC::::»SCE':E::C3Eas�liMMM'a=EE x= ��_•:••/mimCC�E=:iEE =asE1'C� E:,.mai . min.mnm . ■ . a sCCmnmmmmmmmimmCmimmmmmimmmmnmmimmmC/.mama oma/■ mCnnmm nmm ...mama./...mama■monmi m mamma sun ma //m miummm mm//mammmai moons m/imi mmn niiiiisi■ =5:: mn.nmi/imam mmnnmiii Ea .■,"�aamwmii ■.....■.mamama■mm.man.mmmriim■■■ a awnmi■■mw■aim im.nnm■miw.wa~imimmnn■■.. C:inr7y'm' -,-r- ',i m'aE1r'ru'nE:SS=i's"' I'iiaii■■■maimama'Cr■■ : im n■mnm■ ■ ■ma■■■ma■■■ma■■■mama■mama■■mama ■_MI �iCiaiamai::ai' maiia. mai'�iia r-i.■.C.ma■ . mi .ii ■.r�i■ ■ C■ ■ma .ma...■. ■ .. ..maa "'GC'�'i® .a mm.a.am nmma.maEaE ilidinnmmeieiQmaim*Em.=.nwnima=i=nu uaa a •-t-t..i- ■■.mama mw.mmmanmm n w mm ..imam ■mail m m■ nno mnnn w/.maim mi mm :=1: mmSCmMImo.am■innmw■mm=a=Cmmnw'r�i'�'rim■mm.■:.mimaCw:mam�iaCEmomm=mm.m'�' mronma mamar�m.�'a n r amm .mama mm mamma■■/mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm ma ■.mama■ ■■ma■■ mamaima■■■■■■ ■ ■■■...mama p mama. ■■■a mama ■ mall■ w■■ aC=a'::OC:C:ia�::C::C::CC:Ca:a:::::::CCC::CC:a:::C=S*C:C_::as:CCC::C:=E::CCCC:::CC::aC=:aC :C:C::G:::C'. /m.i.mmma////mmmmmmm.a//■/mmmmom////iimmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm////mama ..mama mmmmmmm aCi'ganiIrmu:::aiCma:i=CCC2CmM■CCCCCCCMCCCI �im'i+�ii CCCImmmaamma mmmm �iimaimama//ra'il■ama'mm'am':."E.'aaaiii u anma.mmmummmammimaili■■i//mamammmmomii■mommomi ...mama/i■■ma ommmm2■2Cm"Cimamaimaaiii isi.■si 111111111111 nmia.. ammmmamimmmmmmmmmmammmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmnmmmmi/maimmm/moss/mmmmmmmamammmmami m m ���rrr.ammo mimii■n con m i m i ii .■ ma n m riaz+1111r'rwEa-EmmiE1EEa:ECa Es111E15E11E1wB E E i =11m EE E=m 111111aimaal��i ii ii C o 9 E� �� =i�i� ii3 9E E ,,�� E Sl m:.a:ama.aimCE=.nSaC=SCC'C�:a=a_C_==*E:QC7�:CC'=�C n:=C=CEm Cg= MISS mi nai mar w mn:a'raC:m■ iinnnii■.m�i mmnmmminm MINIM mama■===m .na=:":/:E'i'mEgai Zm ow C nealuirgliiirailliFINIPPliriliPSFIRIEMIPVIM maiiii■immum ■n.mmmni.mm■Cm■■■mmr,.nn'riCu :: mom . om immi /mamma im .pmrraa ipp=�IEErar dE' ::::amamMEI ma..�..................=_C�jMIMMEs�MEM=M�i=mm�a_i:si_=_i.M=I:. ElEifi.-i��Cl ommo==mmom-mmu :' ::=5 _==A-�l�immm� m■i:ii■mmam■mimmma imam miiC`': m. R� ...i mii ■Cimamii■i.iiirn.iii■ mama ii iaa ammmaasmaiamamoansi�mmmm�'iaCamCim/mammmmiiii/i mmammmmiimiimmimots.Em/miiOGmmmmmmaa:iiimmm�iiima:i� ILr- iSESEM-iailiIEHRESEEEEESEEEESEESEEESSEEElirEE.ifflnz..:=EEmam//iii.=m�■i:.mmi.Cgs..�i./.m.=C.i.i�mm�SaCma=�Sa=EC=min m:::aCCC C :::CmC=. mCS ESER._SSSE :_ .ia : E. m i .... mmmmmmu�'=:==C=is' =C= =C= mu:mmam=S:===a= mmmmmmui*ammammam:mmmommimama=Cmmmmmmmm-mmmmommo.:m:m=maimmm'a mmamsammmmmmammmmmmmimmmmmimmaamm=mm■mmmmmmmmmiCmmmmamimmmmmimmm■mm■man.mmmmmmim■mmmimmmmmm�mrmmmm■mammmaimu:ammmmm mm ME:r'imrM'mM'am'm THEirm'aFEE EEESEEEEEEEEEESE='.'.ri'ir:r iarrEE�EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE====RE iCEE'm:maua`w' I ...........2..e........................1....""'.'..`Fiat w= ..........:iammi r'ri':=a::==a':mr'rm=a'...1a 'coma "ai"' sEsEm a�m s EEEEEEEE =sE�sess:�::: EEE::s�E EESEE_:E:3EE:g=m3�E===m.n.s=m:e:EsE�am�s .�E s „9.. m imam m. m. n i inn nimmn u miliranimpuT-n--::::::::::::12::::::::::: m'm //iimmmmm/'mmawmmm//imn mane ��na mm.mmn ma�maa;m�iam::imm:�mmm=mi■E_mmm*mm=m=rs ==E=mmimm pompoiC:===iiimumm=:QEbamama''w=m':�Cma=:aE=e6S:S:nA:osa�:z:a::::::S n ii- a �Y,• .mm■mmmamimmm■■mmmm mom ■ a mu m■m■■mamm mom aimmmmmm aimmmw aA 1111:1m mm:ar:aCZ:.�.mmmmmmmammai■mmm.ammm n mmmi{ai: n r mmmm Smm mt�inim maim ■mmmm rn �" r". :::C_::====m= WEE1.-::. HMS. I. M=:Evt .•�mE==:ES:C:•EC::=I: liziarlila a.mmmm/immmwwimm.i■mmnn m ..mist w mm n mmiimmaiamm.ianwm mmmm.nim �ammmmmauammmmammmmmmmmm■ coma mmmmn ♦r• L. mom. in mm■ mm lmmmmum■mmummmmm irrm limn A mSnmmmiw====m=:nimmmo'ii mmummgmmn c. .mom n.;�n �m mom mmmmm mmmmm�m�■�'�■!�mmmmamsr'iamammrr��lim::::a:iti:Si.�i:r'iiea3�liaman�.�Gi� ECia ', rm r =L�=E':=EEE�,`siitiiias���ilpar. L m..... nri=ml my l mmmm.m mmmimm.mmm r::aamma. },m -ami'Imimmm's �� •• �s�' -�_m '�-C wA�m � ir■m. �=i'""' � r�Immo . m ■ma. ... a... � /a��"' • -n �'� harm /ia o ►n maim m m■ *1 m mom i irmaE m ,aim mmiirr a cow vr. mint+, .mm QQ 4 ODO4r n 3 i�i�im=��a G um�Z� o of morn_ QGaamu (LO p tiit.A.<a, m•ii �o.� m our o umarr t�0 0 �n t04./mmt�mmm Finailrt r p im m mm■ mi�imm taro warm NJ mown O �o .itU-a�m 6tr 1� n 0a d a==': ^i. ...� cf O N' .l0'4 a � '� CE:C ►) i n malaria o VAi:wmmamiiimnmmm.n iltr diallap pram►iimnnn iEE:imor nn. m.w. iwnw. t pmaammaina.mmmisaum mm aitfiiG wimm .i�amam wow moms wmmiimmmmmma/immm .mmma mmmiannm imI` 'nwmnn......wwwwmm ■mmmmm nnmmnwnnnnwwnwnw mmmonommumminnummwmminmnimmunv.im'nm.. mama nnmmmmmwmmm a mmmilimmuummimmmommmnai imi ."� .m��::=Cam:Comm ::::EmmmmwnnwnmmnminnECC=a mmmmm■EECmw=�..■. wC.w.w...m.n....n,.�'g="mmn Cwwn.aw cow nmmnimmnmmmmnmmnnmmumn unamnmmimmmmmmiimmmuunnmmmmmm.warmmmmmmmom■minmmmnimmmmmmmmiwmmwmmmmmmmamimiimmmmmmn o n conKm ■mommmuamnanwnmwmomnmmmmwnommnmmmmwnomwnnwnnmm.m nmmmommummemmommmimmmmmimmimmmmmmimmommimmmemmommommommmmimmmm...................................r� pm mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm mmammmmmmamammmmmmmmmmimmmmmimmmmmmmmmmnmmmmnanmmommmmmnmmmmmmmnmmmimammmmmmmimmommmmmmmmmmam .wwmmmmmiimmmmumamm/mmmmmmmmmmnmmommnmimmnmmommnmmmmm mama wammwiiimmmommmum■immmninmim . ipmmmmimmmm s=mmmmmmmm:mmCn SammmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmCC"mmmmmm=Em:'m:a'mmmmmm=:'S=_mmmmmm:mwwwn=SmmmmCmImm E C aaawmnanwmmwmmnmmammwmmmwmmmmmmmwmnnnnn�ngn9wnmAm=Cmmmnnwmnm9m:Cmmmm wmnai mm mEimEEmmmmommmG . m sC R��R�Emm.a� . :,,11111111111111111111111111111 1Pr r1i1EEE EG E IEEE■Ewinor�ri■■GCCa?*_G'muuanmm......:.......Ewnm.wom■ww.m._E1*_E111a1 .m■Cm mrmnnw.C..w.m■mm.mm. o. 19 80 19 79 19_$._ 19_$2_ 19.83_ 19 84 19$SZ_ 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 O Monthly Average m Monthly Maximum "The Effects of Seasonal Te;1iper t.ure Changes On Characteristics of Dispersed Residual Solids In Biologically Treated Pulp and Paper Mill Effluents" INTRODUCTION The discharging of suspended solid material into streams has long been an environmental problem for the pulp and paper -making industry. These materials initially included bark, chips, knots, and fibers which. were discharged directly into the receiving stream. This procedure is practically non-existant in the industry today. Yost mills are equipped with treatment facilities which remove. fibrous solids. These secondary treatments result in a different type of discharge: a dispersed, light, flocculent material which does not settle during retention time. . This poses a new question, whether the environmental impact of these solids justifies the considerable effort and expense required to remove them. One important aspect of the non -settleable solids question has to do•primarily with the composition of these • materials. Investigations into the composition of the suspended material indicates that they are principally biological in nature. Since molecular, and therefore biological, activity varies with temperature fluctuations, it c be deduced that the biological activities of the solids, and therefore the entire system, should be dependent on seasonal cycles. Futhermore, the environmental consequences of the efluent solids depends heavily on the extent to which they are carried through or produced in the secondary treatment system. This study will attempt to verify the high percentage of biological material present in the solids, and given the nature of the aeration -stabilization treatment system, will postulate that the solids are harmonious with the natural seasonal cycles and may contribute to the overall energy flow and productivity of the receiving stream. EXPERIMENTAL SYSTEM For the purposes of this study, a wastewater treatment system at.a local kraft pulp and paper mill was employed. The treatment facilities at Olin Corporation -in Pisgah Forest, North Carolina consist of a primary waste treatment system (grit chamber and primary clarifers) for removing the majority of solids . emitted from the plant. Effluent from the clarifiers is diverted to the Aeration -Stabilization. Basin (ASB) which has a surface area of approximately 75 acres and provides 1.1.2 days of retention time. The.ASB is designed to remove soluble organic matter by biological action of microorganisms. This degradation process is most efficient if the organisms are supplied with sufficient dissolved oxygen to survive. Olin Corporation uses eleven, one hundred horsepower, floating, low -speed, surface aerators to maintain an adequate level of dissolved oxygen. The aerators are positioned such that approximately 9 days of retention time is in the active aeration zone, and 2.2 days of retention time is in the quiescent settling zone. This latter area provides an opportunity for additional settling of solids prior to discharge into the river. SaPLING For the purposes of analysis, effluent samples were taken from the aeration -stabilization basin. Samples were collected by an automatic composite sampler at the effluent flume, and refrigerated at 4° C to insure the stabilization of the samples. Analyses were conducted twice weekly beginning in August 1982. Samples will be analyzed throughout a three month period to determine the effect of seasonal temperature changes.on the biological nature of the solids. The samples were analyzed'for percent carbohydrate, percent protein, and biological fraction. -These analyse:; 1:c'.qui. reed l.is' per- . formance of additional supporting tests, such as BOD5 (5 day Bio- chemical Oxygen Demand), COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand), Suspended Solids, Volatile Solids, and Temperature. The analyses were'conducted for the most part on fresh(non-. stored) samples. It was determined, however, that stored samples • (5 days, 4.i.0 C) could be.used in the analysis and produce consistent results. Undiluted samples were called for .in the carbohydrate and protein tests. The DNA assay, however, required that the ef- fluent be concentrated as much as twenty times. Concentrating the effluent was performed using a Rotovap apparatus. The Rotovap ap- paratus consists of a vacuum mechanism attached to a rotating evap- oration -condensation unit. With this unit, it is possible to evaporate the liquid portion without using a damaging degree of heat. The percent carbohydrates was determined by the anthrone pro- cedure.(1 ) Color development was measured on a Bausch and Lomb Spectronic 20 spectrophotometer, at 625 nanometers, against a reagent blank. The reading was then plotted on a prepared standard curve to determine the amount of carbohydrates present in the suspended. solids. The percent protein of the suspended solids was determined by precipitation with phosphomolybdic acid and a modification of (2) the Biuret reaction. Color development was measured on the Spec- tronic 20 spectrophotometer, at 530 nanometers, against a distilled water blank. The reading was plotted on a prepared standard curve to determine the amount of protenaceous material present. The biological fration was determined by an assay of the DNA (deoxy- ribonucleic acid) concentration using a diphenylamine indicator.(3) „. Absorption -was measured on a Spectronic 20 spectrophotometer, at 600 nanometers, against a reagent blank and plotted on a prepared • standard curve. All additional tests including: BOD5, COD, Volatile and Suspended Solids and Kjeldahl Nitrogen analyses were performed using procedures outlined in Standard Methods for Examination of Water' and Wastewater, 15th Edition. . (1.) Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemical Analysis, vol.19. Interscience Publishers, New York. • (2) Ibid., vol. 7. (3) "Di A Concentration as an Estimate ofSludge Biomass", SW Missouri State College, Springfield. Water Quality Office, EPA, February 1971. • RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Some of the most descriptive characteristics of the suspended solids are presented in Tables I and II and the accompanying graphs. • MONTH TABLE I SUSPENDED PERCENT TOTAL SOLIDS SOLIDS VOLATILE TEMPERATURE January 1324.5 32.23 90.88 11.83 February 1294. 4 • It arch 1276.0 26.1.6 79.96 16.52 April 1. 259. 8 1. 9. 22 . 87.23 20.64 Fay 1946.0 1.4.65 76.74 23.93 June 1201 .6 10.24 77.10 26.48 July 1.1.56.0 9.40 76.55 28.46 August 1161 .8 9.32 82.54 28.44 September 1185.6 9.30 82.63 26.90 October 1254.7 1.1.46 73.92' 21.77 November 1273.2 .18.14 83.75 18.92 December 1291.4 27.92 83.60 1.5.00 'Iablo I inn composite of data col.locted over the past fivo yearn (January '77.- May '82). In these data noticeable seasonal patterns are present. Both total and suspended solids exhibit an inverse ..proportionality to the temperature readings. The decrease of solids in the summer months and subsequent increase in the winter months is due almost entirely to the fluctuations in biological activity which accompanies temperature changes. (See graph ,#2) . 30 SUSPENDED 2-5 SOLIDS 0 +-4. SS *-* T GRAPH 4 • I { T (°C) -- zv Jr - 30 M A •M J J A S 0• N D TABLE 1I TOTAL SUSPENDED MONTH SOLIDS 'SOLIDS PERCENT - (i i/TS ) Jan. 132LJ 32.32.44 •Feb. 1294.4 . .34.70 2.68 Mr. 1276.0 26.16 2.05 ' rir. i I. 12 59, 8 19.22 1,53 • May 2'L . 0 14. 6 i • _l.1 S June 1201 . � 10.24 - ti5 J u1 1.1 6.0 9.40 .81 Aug. 1161 .8 9.32 .80 pent . 11. 85. h 9.30 ^78 Oct. .1. 2 .Z1.1 _4 • 91• _.. Nov. 12 f .2 ' 8.14 1.42 Dec . 1291 .4 27.92 2.1 6 Jan . ' 77 -Fiay' 82 As Table II indicates not only the amount of solids fluctuates with the seasonal cycles, but the composition of the solids also change drastically. In a comparison of suspended solids and total solids over the same five year period several things become apparent. .During the summer months when the microbial population (and activity) is at its peak, the majority of the effluent solids are produced in the aeration -stabilization basin itself. The Major component of these solids are brachiopods (Daphnia) and copepods, bacterial species, and some small algal. colonies (blue -greens and greens). These "biological" solids are.not nearly as dense as the mill pro- duced organic solids which are prevalent in the winter months. Although the volume of solids remain3fairly constant all year round, the low density of the biosolids accounts for the nearly non-existant suspended solids weight during the summer months. During the winter months , the solids increase drastically in mass and in carbohydrate composition. The solids emitted in the winter ASB effluent are .largely materials which pass from the plant undigested through the system. The microbial. fraction of - tite •;;o L id:; is dd.':'::c-oo.sed to almost nothing, and the major component is clearly(organi))carbonaceous in nature. This implies that the solids are primarily mill -generated celluiosia solids. From data collected over the past five years and data collected for this study beginning August '82, it is ob- served that the percentage of volatile solids is slightly higher during the cooler winter months. (See graph; 3) This is consistent with the seasonal cycles, considering that since the microbial OR�1Pt-• ` �3 VCR{..El 100 90 - ./ So 7o population and activity are at low levels, greater amounts of soluble organic materials are able to pass through the ASB un- digested. This fluctuation can be further explained by examining the effluents major organic components - i.e. carbohydrates and proteins. Table III and IV show a rise in percent carbohydrates TABLE III MOUTH TEMPERATURE ANRGANIC . %PROTEIN J CARPOHYDRATE AUGUST (max) 29.5 86.82 40.0 14.22 67.85 22.79 7.74 (a.vg) 29.13 79.85 )5.37 • 11.27 SEPTEMB ER (max) 28.0 90.22 48.53 17.47 (min) 24.5 U.69 )5.6 8.34 (avvl 27.1 83.70 OCTOBER (max) 26. . 2043_5 40.07 . 12.62 46.29 20.08 min 18.• .79.63 33.24 14.73 (avg) 23.2. 84.31 39.08 17.21 TABLE IV MONTH TEIPERATURE ORGANIC _ nPROTEIN %CARBOHYDRATE Au:u;r 'Lt ew.; ,:,. , , ,r, 27. 3.7. ,�l�,.�l!'sh�a �.lZ 1 0 . OCTOBER .23.2 3q. 37 11.2Z 40.07 - 84.3 39.08 12.62 17.21 AVERAGE 26.48 82.62 ,38.17 1;�.70 accompanying the cooler temperatures. This,. in practice, reflects the large percentage of particles containing cellulose from the mill processes passing through the system undigested. The tables also indicate a slightdrop in percent protein which reflects a decrease in the cellular material. A serious drop in the percent protein, reflecting a large decrese in the cellular material, should occur when temperatures reach and remain at a level detrimental to microbial populations. For the first quarter of this study (months - August, September, and October) a percent of the biological organics was determined for the suspended solids.by DNA assay on the aeration-srabilization basin. effluent. This reading reflected directly the percentage .of biological material present in the effluent suspended solids. The organics reading has been fairly constant over these three months, because the temperatures have not reached and remained at a level low enough to seriously impair microbial activity. It is expected that the percent of biological organics created in the ASB will also decline with the arrival of winter temperatures. TABLE V LWAN1.C: .A;,I[ Z CARBOHYDRATE ,i, PROTEIN N IdGNIN * 82.6 17.4 13.7 38.2 30.7 * Ligni.n or o l;hc: r comb..lcA i. h I.o material Table V is a composite of the data from the analyses of the suspended solids emitted from the aeration -stabilization basin. The ash content is 17.4. of the dry weight of the solids. This ash is most likely composed of inorganic clay and coating materials used in paper production. The organic content averaged 82.6A over the three month period. The organic fraction contained 38.2,6 pro- tenaceous material as detected by the biuret method. This relatively .large amount of protein reflects a high percentage of cellular material. The anthrone analysis averaged 13.7% carbohydrates. • The balance of the volatile materials or 30.7% can be assumed to include any lignin or other combustible material. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS Based on data obtained during; this study, and on pre-existing data, it would be safe to deduce that the solids in the effluent of the aeration -stabilization basin are primarily biological in nature (68,6 - 91 /0. Given the high biological nature of the sus- pended solids in the. effluent and this study's supportof the direct dependence of the biological activity of these solids with seasonal temperature changes, it can be predicted that thes solids will and do contribute to the energy and productivity of the re- ceiving stream. The summer effluent which is heavily laden with microorganisms contributes to the stream by adding a potential food source, as well as a potential consumer. The winter effluent con- tributes to the stream by providing an additional source of car- UionaceouLi solids during an otherwise sparce *feeding condition. In conclusion, it can be deduced that the extensive effort and expense required to remove these solids is unwarranted. Karen Ann Carland Department of Biology University of North Carolina - Asheville February 22,.1982 ` r � LITERATURE 1. "A Characterization of Effluent Suspended Solids", by W.B. Stengle; TAPPI, vol.62, no. 7; July 1979. 2. "Characteristics and Use of Non -settleable Solids by an Aquatic Food Chain. Organism", by Eugene Zanella et.al.; The Institute of Paper Chemistry, TAPPI, 1978. 3. Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemical.Analysis, Ed. by Foster Dee Snell and Leslie S. Ettre;. Interscience Publishers, New York, vols.7 and 19.. 4. "DNA Concentration as an Estimate of Sludge Biomass", Water Pollution Control Series, by Southwest Missouri State College, Springfibld, Missouri EPA Project #17070 DHO, February, 1971. 5. APHA, ATJA,and WPCF, Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater. 15th edition, APHA, Washington, D.C. (1970 Conventinnal unitm for allocatimn 1i111itm unless nmted (*) Allocation Numbe,': 452O NPDES #: NC0000078 Modeler: ACD 1::*ari1itU Name: SKCUSTA DI OF P.H. QLATEFLETEA Demign Flmw/ 027.5 Stream: FQENCX-1 BAOAD AIVEA %Domea, stic%I11dustria1: 100 CmuntU: TFlow NSYVNIA AmQimnal Office: AAO Subbamin: 040801 Date Aequest Amceived: 03-03-88 Date Approva1 Form Sent6-29-8B Date Approval Apceived: 07-07.... 88 Date WLA Mailed tn Plea questmrEl-05-GS � Existing/Prnposed: E Awaiting Information: N ConfirmationN BOWS 20 TGS11585 #/d W7(410191 30Q2� NH34 ' pH� 6-9 G7Q10157 DA� 221 | DO4 � Cn1iQavg552 Aecmmmend Aemuval (Y,N): N T(axicitU LimitsCHAONIC <Acute,Chronic,Nmne> � Limits Change in Next Permit <Y,N): N CommentsAEOPE/sA CLAUSE FOA NH3-N IF CONCENTRATION ABOVE /I MQ/L Find: N)ext, P>revious, Q>uit? , 1 1 1 ti.. ... I I V 10w 1✓ v 1 .,i 1 ^► . v/ 1WZ f 1 . The End NBOD is 6.86 mg/1. WLA WLA WLA DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.66 4.50 2 Reach 1 45.00 90.00 0.00 2.50000 Reach 2 60.00 9.00 4.00 27.50000 Reach 3 2.00 1.00 7.72 6.45000 Reach 4 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 5 12.05 5.26 6.83 0.24000 Reach 6 1.97 1.05 8.07 41.50000 Reach 7 7.60 7.20 2.80 38.50000 Reach 8 123.00 9.00 0.00 4.00000 Reach 9 1.91 1.05 8.07 12.90000 Segment 2 6.72 19.00 4 Reach 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 2 8.77 12.78 6.55 21.70000 Reach 3 2.00 1.00 7.72 7.60000 Reach 4 150.00 90.00 0.00 40.00000 Discharger Receiving Stream MODEL RESULTS : BREVARD TO ABOVE ASHEVILLE : FRENCH BROAD RIVER SUMMER MODEL FROM BREVARD TO ASHEVILL The End D.O. is 7 . 13 mg/1. rr_ionn 4 J. n , / 1 *** MODEL SUMMARY DATA *** Discharger : BREVARD TO ABOVE ASHEVILLE Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Summer 7Q10 : 157.0 Design Temperature: 23.0 Winter 7Q10 : Subbasin : 040302 Stream Class: C !LENGTH' SLOPE' VELOCITY 1 DEPTH' Kd 1 Kd 1 Ka 1 Ka 1 KN 1 KN 1 KNR 1 KNR 1 S00 I S00 1 mile 1 ft/mil fps 1 ft 'design! @20° 'design l @20° 'design' @20° 'design' @20° 'design l @20° I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 I Segment 1 1 0.101 3.331 0.786 1 3.69 1 0.57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 10.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 1 1 4.401 3.331 0.943 1 3.82 1 0.57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 10.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 1 1 5.901 3.331 0.975 1 3.94 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 3.05 1 2.861 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 3 I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 1 1 1.901 3.331 0.973 1 4.06 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 3.04 1 2.851 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 4 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 l 1 1 1 I I Segment 1 I 9.601 3.331 0.969 1 4.19 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 3.03 1 2.841 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 10.00 1 0.00 Reach 5 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I Segment 1 1 0.601 3.331 1.137 1 4.42 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 3.56 1 3.331 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 6 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 I Segment 1 1 1.601 3.331 1.289 1 4.52 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 4.03 1 3.781 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 7 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 1 1 0.101 3.331 1.306 1 4.54 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 4.09 1 3.831 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 8 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 1 1 5.001 3.331 1.352 1 4.60 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 4,23 1 3.961 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 9 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 2 1 8.901 3.331 1.365 1 4.66 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 4.27 1 4.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 2 1 2.301 3.331 1.459 1 4.75 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 4.57 1 4.281 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I Segment 2 1 0.801 3.331 1.490 1 4.11 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 4.66 1 4.371 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 3 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1( I Segment 2 1 30.001 3.331 1.608 1 5.06 1 0.23 1 0.20 1 5.03 1 4.711 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 4 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 I 1 Flow 1 CBOD 1 NBOD 1 D.O. I 1 cfs I mg/1 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 I Segment 1 Reach 1 Waste I 3.875 1 45.000 1 9O.00O 1 0.000 Headwatersl157.00O 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 Waste 1 42.625 1 60.000 ( 9.000 4.000 Tributary ( 0.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 ( 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 3 Waste 1 9.998 1 2.000 ( 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary 1 0.000 I 2.000 ( 1.000 0.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 0.000 Segment 1 Reach 4 Waste 1 0.000 1 0.000 Tributary ( 3.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 1 2.000 Segment 1 Reach 5 Waste 1 0.372 1 12.050 Tributary 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 1 2.000 Segment 1 Reach 6 Waste 1 64.325 Tributary 0.000 * Runoff 1 1.000 Segment 1 Reach 7 Waste 1 59.675 Tributary ( 0.000 * Runoff 1 3.000 1.970 2.000 2.000 7.600 2.000 2.000 Segment 1 Reach 8 Waste 1 6.200 1123.000 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 3.000 1 2.000 Segment 1 Reach 9 Waste 1 19.995 Tributary 1 0.000 * Runoff 1 1.900 Segment 2 Reach 1 Waste 1 0.000 Headwaters f 0.000 Tributary 1 0.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 1.910 2.000 2.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 5.260 1.000 1.000 1.050 1.000 1.000 7.200 1.000 1.000 9.000 1.000 1.000 1.050 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 6.830 0.000 0.000 8.070 0.000 0.000 2.800 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 8.070 0.000 0.000 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 Segment 2 Reach 2 Waste 1 33.635 1 8.770 1 12.780 ( 6.550 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 ( 1.000 1 0.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 0.000 Segment 2 Reach 3 Waste 1 11.780 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 I FiI vw I W • W W W * Runoff 1 2.600 as. • W V W 1 . V V V 1 V • V W V 2.000 1 1.000 1 0.000 Segment 2 Reach 4 Waste 162.000 150.000 90.000 Tributary 1 0.000 2.000 1.000 * Runoff 1 3.000 2.000 1.000 * Runoff flow is in cfs/mile I Seg # 1 Reach # 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Seg Mi 1 D.O. 1 CBOD 0.00 7.53 3.04 0.01 7.53 3.03 0.02 7.53 3.03 0.03 7.53 3.03 0.04 7.53 3.03 0.000 0.000 0.000 SUMMER MODEL FROM BREVARD TO ASHEVILL NBOD 1 Flow I 3.14 160.88 3.14 160.88 3.14 160.88 3.14 160.88 3.14 160.88 1 1 0.06 7.53 3.03 3.14 160.88 •1 1 0.07 7.53 3.03 3.14 160.88 1 1 0.08 7.53 3.02 3.14 160.88 1 1 0.09 7.53 3.02 3.14 160.88 1 1 0.10 7.53 3.02 3.13 160.88 1 2 0.10 6.79 14.96 4.36 203.50 1 2 0.30 6.71 14.83 4.34 203.77 1 2 0.50 6.63 14.70 4.31 204.04 1 2 0.70 6.56 14.58 4.29 204.32 1 2 0.90 6.49 14.45 4.26 204.59 1 2 1.10 6.42 14.33 4.24 204.86 1 2 1.30 6.36 14.21 4.21 205.13 1 2 1.50 6.30 14.08 4.19 205.40 1 2 1.70 6.24 13.96 4.16 205.68 1 2 1.90 6.18 13.84 4.14 205.95 1 2 2.10 6.13 13.73 4.11 206.22 1 2 2.30 6.08 13.61 4.09 206.49 1 2 2.50 6.03 13.49 4.06 206.76 1 2 2.70 5.98 13.38 4.04 207.04 1 2 2.90 5.94 13.26 4.02 207.31 1 2 3.10 5.90 13.15 3.99 207.58 1 2 3.30 5.86 13.04 3.97 207.85 1 2 3.50 5.82 12.93 3.95 208.12 1 2 3.70 5.78 12.82 3.92 208.40 1 2 3.90 5.75 12.71 3.90 208.67 1 2 4.10 5.72 12.60 3.88 208.94 1 2 4.30 5.69 12.49 3.86 209.21 1 2 4.50 5.66 12.39 3.83 209.48 1 3 4.50 5.75 11.92 3.70 219.48 1 3 4.60 5.77 11.89 3.69 219.74 1 3 4.70 5.79 11.86 3.68 220.00 1 3 4.80 5.82 11.83 3.67 220.26 1 3 4.90 5.84 11.80 3.66 220.52 1 3 5.00 5.86 11.77 3.64 220.78 1 3 5.10 5.87 11.74 3.63 221.04 1 3 5.20 5.89 11.72 3.62 221.30 1 3 5.30 5.91 11.69 3.61 221.56 1 3 5.40 5.93 11.66 3.60 221.82 1 3 5.50 5.95 11.63 3.59 222.08 1 3 5.60 5.97 11.60 3.57 222.34 1 3 5.70 5.99 11.58 3.56 222.60 1 3 5.80 6.00 11.55 3.55 222.86 1 3 5.90 6.02 11.52 3.54 223.12 1 3 6.00 6.04 11.49 3.53 223.38 1 3 6.10 6.05 11.46 3.52 223.64 1 3 6.20 6.07 11.44 3.51 223.90 1 3 6.30 6.09 11.41 3.50 224.16 1 3 6.40 6.10 11.38 3.48 224.42 1 3 6.50 6.12 11.36 3.47 224.68 1 3 6.60 6.13 11.33 3.46 224.94 1 3 6.70 6.15 11.30 3.45 225.20 1 3 6.80 6.16 11.27 3.44 225.46 1 3 6.90 6.18 11.25 3.43 225.72 1 3 7.00 6.19 11.22 3.42 225.98 1 3 7.10 6.21 11.19 3.41 226.24 1 3 7.20 6.22 11.17 3.40 226.50 1 3 7.30 6.23 11.14 3.39 226.76 1 3 7.40 6.25 11.11 3.37 227.02 1 3 7.50 6.26 11.09 3.36 227.28 1 3 7.60 6.27 11.06 3.35 227.54 1 3 7.70 6.29 11.04 3.34 227.80 1 3 7.80 6.30 11.01 3.33 228.06 1 3 7.90 6.31 10.98 3.32 228.32 1 3 8.00 6.33 10.96 3.31 228.58 1 3 8.10 6.34 10.93 3.30 228.84 1 3 8.30 6.36 10.88 3.28 229.36 1' 3 8.40 6.37 10.85 3.27 229.62 1 3 8.50 6.39 10.83 3.26 229.88 1 3 8.60 6.40 10.80 3.25 230.14 1 3 8.70 6.41 10.78 3.24 230.40 1 3 8.80 6.42 10.75 3.23 230.66 1 3 8.90 6.43 10.73 3.22 230.92 1 3 9.00 6.44 10.70 3.21 231.18 1 3 9.10 6.45 10.68 3.20 231.44 1 3 9.20 6.46 10.65 3.19 231.70 1 3 9.30 6.47 10.63 3.18 231.96 1 3 9.40 6.48 10.60 3.17 232.22 1 3 9.50 6.49 10.58 3.16 232.48 1 3 9.60 6.50 10.55 3.15 232.74 1 3 9.70 6.51 10.53 3.14 233.00 1 3 9.80 6.52 10.50 3.13 233.26 1 3 9.90 6.53 10.48 3.12 233.52 1 3 10.00 6.54 10.45 3.11 233.78 1 3 10.10 6.55 10.43 3.10 234.04 1 3 10.20 6.56 10.40 3.09 234.30 1 3 10.30 6.57 10.38 3.08 234.56 1 3 10.40 6.58 10.36 3.07 234.82 1 4 10.40 6.49 10.25 3.04 237.82 1 4 10.50 6.51 10.23 3.04 238.08 1 4 10.60 6.52 10.20 3.03 238.34 1 4 10.70 6.53 10.18 3.02 238.60 1 4 10.80 6.54 10.16 3.01 238.86 1 4 10.90 6.55 10.13 3.00 239.12 1 4 11.00 6.56 10.11 2.99 239.38 1 4 11.10 6.57 10.09 2.98 239.64 1 4 11.20 6.58 10.06 2.97 239.90 1 4 11.30 6.59 10.04 2.96 240.16 1 4 11.40 6.60 10.02 2.95 240.42 1 4 11.50 6.61 9.99 2.94 240.68 1 4 11.60 6.61 9.97 2.93 240.94 1 4 11.70 6.62 9.95 2.92 241.20 1 4 11.80 6.63 9.92 2.92 241.46 1 4 11.90 6.64 9.90 2.91 241.72 1 4 12.00 6.65 9.88 2.90 241.98 1 4 12.10 6.66 9.86 2.89 242.24 1 4 12.20 6.67 9.83 2.88 242.50 1 4 12.30 6.68 9.81 2.87 242.76 1 5 12.30 6.68 9.81 2.87 243.13 1 5 12.40 6.68 9.79 2.87 243.39 1 5 12.50 6.69 9.77 2.86 243.65 1 5 12.60 6.70 9.75 2.85 243.91 1 5 12.70 6.71 9.72 2.84 244.17 1 5 12.80 6.72 9.70 2.83 244.43 1 5 12.90 6.72 9.68 2.82 244.69 1 5 13.00 6.73 9.66 2.81 244.95 1 5 13.10 6.74 9.64 2.81 245.21 1 5 13.20 6.75 9.61 2.80 245.47 1 5 13.30 6.75 9.59 2.79 245.73 1 5 13.40 6.76 9.57 2.78 245.99 1 5 13.50 6.77 9.55 2.77 246.25 1 5 13.60 6.78 9.53 2-.76 246.51 1 5 13.70 6.78 9.50 2.75 246.77 1 5 13.80 6.79 9.48 2.75 247.03 1 5 13.90 6.80 9.46 2.74 247.29 1 5 14.00 6.80 9.44 2.73 247.55 1 5 14.10 6.81 9.42 2.72 247.81 1 5 14.20 6.82 9.40 2.71 248.07 1 5 14.30 6.82 9.38 2.70 248.33 1 5 14.40 6.83 9.35 2.70 248.59 1 5 14.50 6.84 9.33 2.69 248.85 v• v . c.. . W W L ^T V. 1 1 1 5 14.70 6.85 9.29 2.67 249.37 Y 5 14.80 6.85 9.27 2.66 249.63 1 5 14.90 6.86 9.25 2.66 249.89 1 5 15.00 6.87 9.23 2.65 250.15 1 5 15.10 6.87 9.21 2.64 250.41 1 5 15.20 6.88 9.19 2.63 250.67 1 5 15.30 6.88 9.17 2.62 250.93 1 5 15.40 6.89 9.15 2.62 251.19 1 5 15.50 6.90 9.12 2.61 251.45 1 5 15.60 6.90 9.10 2.60 251.71 1 5 15.70 6.91 9.08 2.59 251.97 1 5 15.80 6.91 9.06 2.58 252.23 1 5 15.90 6.92 9.04 2.58 252.49 1 5 16.00 6.92 9.02 2.57 252.75 1 5 16.10 6.93 9.00 2.56 253.01 1 5 16.20 6.93 8.98 2.55 253.27 1 5 16.30 6.94 8.96 2.55 253.53 1 5 16.40 6.95 8.94 2.54 253.79 1 5 16.50 6.95 8.92 2.53 254.05 1 5 16.60 6.96 8.90 2.52 254.31 1 5 16.70 6.96 8.88 2.51 254.57 1 5 16.80 6.97 8.86 2.51 254.83 1 5 16.90 6.97 8.84 2.50 255.09 1 5 17.00 6.98 8.82 2.49 255.35 1 5 17.10 6.98 8.80 2.48 255.61 1 5 17.20 6.99 8.78 2.48 255.87 1 5 17.30 6.99 8.76 2.47 256.13 1 5 17.40 6.99 8.74 2.46 256.39 1 5 17.50 7.00 8.72 2.46 256.65 1 5 17.60 7.00 8.71 2.45 256.91 1 5 17.70 7.01 8.69 2.44 257.17 1 5 17.80 7.01 8.67 2.43 257.43 1 5 17.90 7.02 8.65 2.43 257.69 1 5 18.00 7.02 8.63 2.42 257.95 1 5 18.10 7.03 8.61 2.41 258.21 1 5 18.20 7.03 8.59 2.40 258.47 1 5 18.30 7.04 8.57 2.40 258.73 1 5 18.40 7.04 8.55 2.39 258.99 1 5 18.50 7.04 8.53 2.38 259.25 1 5 18.60 7.05 8.51 2.38 259.51 1 5 18.70 7.05 8.50 2.37 259.77 1 5 18.80 7.06 8.48 2.36 260.03 1 5 18.90 7.06 8.46 2.36 260.29 1 5 19.00 7.07 8.44 2.35 260.55 1 5 19.10 7.07 8.42 2.34 260.81 1 5 19.20 7.07 8.40 2.33 261.07 1 5 19.30 7.08 8.38 2.33 261.33 1 5 19.40 7.08 8.36 2.32 261.59 1 5 19.50 7.09 8.35 2.31 261.85 1 5 19.60 7.09 8.33 2.31 262.11 1 5 19.70 7.09 8.31 2.30 262.37 1 5 19.80 7.10 8.29 2.29 262.63 1 5 19.90 7.10 8.27 2.29 262.89 1 5 20.00 7.11 8.25 2.28 263.15 1 5 20.10 7.11 8.24 2.27 263.41 1 5 20.20 7.11 8.22 2.27 263.67 1 5 20.30 7.12 8.20 2.26 263.93 1 5 20.40 7.12 8.18 2.25 264.19 1 5 20.50 7.12 8.16 2.25 264.45 1 5 20.60 7.13 8.15 2.24 264.71 1 5 20.70 7.13 8.13 2.23 264.97 1 5 20.80 7.14 8.11 2.23 265.23 1 5 20.90 7.14 8.09 2.22 265.49 1 5 21.00 7.14 8.08 2.21 265.75 1 5 21.10 7.15 8.06 2.21 266.01 1 5 21.30 7.15 8.02 2.20 266.53 .1 • 5 21.40 7.16 8.01 2.19 266.79 1 5 21.50 7.16 7.99 2.18 267.05 1 5 21.60 7.16 7.97 2.18 267.31 1 5 21.70 7.17 7.95 2.17 267.57 1 5 21.80 7.17 7.94 2.16 267.83 1 5 21.90 7.17 7.92 2.16 268.09 1 6 21.90 7.35 6.77 1.94 332.42 1 6 22.00 7.36 6.76 1.94 332.52 1 6 22.10 7.37 6.75 1.93 332.62 1 6 22.20 7.37 6.74 1.93 332.72 1 6 22.30 7.38 6.73 1.93 332.82 1 6 22.40 7.39 6.72 1.92 332.92 1 6 22.50 7.40 6.71 1.92 333.02 1 7 22.50 6.70 6.84 2.72 392.69 1 7 22.60 6.72 6.83 2.71 392.99 1 7 22.70 6.74 6.82 2.71 393.29 1 7 22.80 6.75 6.81 2.70 393.59 1 7 22.90 6.77 6.80 2.70 393.89 1 7 23.00 6.79 6.79 2.69 394.19 1 7 23.10 6.81 6.78 2.68 394.49 1 7 23.20 6.82 6.77 2.68 394.79 1 7 23.30 6.84 6.76 2.67 395.09 1 7 23.40 6.85 6.75 2.67 395.39 1 7 23.50 6.87 6.73 2.66 395.69 1 7 23.60 6.89 6.72 2.65 395.99 1 7 23.70 6.90 6.71 2.65 396.29 1 7 23.80 6.92 6.70 2.64 396.59 1 7 23.90 6.93 6.69 2.64 396.89 1 7 24.00 6.94 6.68 2.63 397.19 1 7 24.10 6.96 6.67 2.62 397.49 1 8 24.10 6.85 8.46 2.72 403.69 1 8 24.11 6.85 8.45 2.72 403.72 1 8 24.12 6.85 8.45 2.72 403.75 1 8 24.13 6.86 8.45 2.72 403.78 1 8 24.14 6.86 8.45 2.72 403.81 1 8 24.15 6.86 8.45 2.72 403.84 1 8 24.16 6.86 8.45 2.72 403.87 1 8 24.17 6.86 8.45 2.72 403.90 1 8 24.18 6.86 8.45 2.72 403.93 1 8 24.19 6.86 8.44 2.72 403.96 1 8 24.20 6.86 8.44 2.72 403.99 1 9 24.20 6.92 8.13 2.64 423.99 1 9 24.40 6.95 8.11 2.63 424.37 1 9 24.60 6.98 8.09 2.62 424.75 1 9 24.80 7.01 8.07 2.61 425.13 1 9 25.00 7.04 8.05 2.60 425.51 1 9 25.20 7.07 8.02 2.58 425.89 1 9 25.40 7.09 8.00 2.57 426.27 1 9 25.60 7.12 7.98 2.56 426.65 1 9 25.80 7.14 7.96 2.55 427.03 1 9 26.00 7.16 7.94 2.54 427.41 1 9 26.20 7.19 7.91 2.53 427.79 1 9 26.40 7.21 7.89 2.52 428.17 1 9 26.60 7.23 7.87 2.51 428.55 1 9 26.80 7.25 7.85 2.50 428.93 1 9 27.00 7.27 7.83 2.49 429.31 1 9 27.20 7.29 7.81 2.48 429.69 1 9 27.40 7.30 7.79 2.47 430.07 1 9 27.60 7.32 7.76 2.47 430.45 1 9 27.80 7.34 7.74 2.46 430.83 1 9 28.00 7.36 7.72 2.45 431.21 1 9 28.20 7.37 7.70 2.44 431.59 1 9 28.40 7.39 7.68 2.43 431.97 1 9 28.60 7.40 7.66 2.42 432.35 . w ... ... . .. w r • -r ... r • v T L. . ^T 1 T J (w . 1 J 1. r 9 29.00 7.43 7.62 2.40 433.11 1'* 9 29.20 7.44 7.60 2.39 433.49 2 1 0.00 7.44 7.60 2.39 433.49 2 1 0.10 7.45 7.59 2.38 433.75 2 1 0.20 7.46 7.57 2.38 434.01 2 1 0.30 7.47 7.56 2.37 434.27 2 1 0.40 7.48 7.55 2.37 434.53 2 1 0.50 7.49 7.54 2.36 434.79 2 1 0.60 7.50 7.53 2.36 435.05 2 1 0.70 7.51 7.52 2.36 435.31 2 1 0.80 7.52 7.51 2.35 435.57 2 1 0.90 7.53 7.50 2.35 435.83 2 1 1.00 7.54 7.49 2.34 436.09 2 1 1.10 7.54 7.47 2.34 436.35 2 1 1.20 7.55 7.46 2.33 436.61 2 1 1.30 7.56 7.45 2.33 436.87 2 1 1.40 7.57 7.44 2.32 437.13 2 1 1.50 7.58 7.43 2.32 437.39 2 1 1.60 7.58 7.42 2.31 437.65 2 1 1.70 7.59 7.41 2.31 437.91 2 1 1.80 7.60 7.40 2.30 438.17 2 1 1.90 7.61 7.39 2.30 438.43 2 1 2.00 7.61 7.38 2.29 438.69 2 1 2.10 7.62 7.37 2.29 438.95 2 1 2.20 7.63 7.36 2.28 439.21 2 1 2.30 7.63 7.34 2.28 439.47 2 1 2.40 7.64 7.33 2.28 439.73 2 1 2.50 7.65 7.32 2.27 439.99 2 1 2.60 7.65 7.31 2.27 440.25 2 1 2.70 7.66 7.30 2.26 440.51 2 1 2.80 7.67 7.29 2.26 440.77 2 1 2.90 7.67 7.28 2.25 441.03 2 1 3.00 7.68 7.27 2.25 441.29 2 1 3.10 7.68 7.26 2.24 441.55 2 1 3.20 7.69 7.25 2.24 441.81 2 1 3.30 7.70 7.24 2.23 442.07 2 1 3.40 7.70 7.23 2.23 442.33 2 1 3.50 7.71 7.22 2.23 442.59 2 1 3.60 7.71 7.21 2.22 442.85 2 1 3.70 7.72 7.20 2.22 443.11 2 1 3.80 7.72 7.19 2.21 443.37 2 1 3.90 7.73 7.18 2.21 443.63 2 1 4.00 7.73 7.17 2.20 443.89 2 1 4.10 7.74 7.16 2.20 444.15 2 1 4.20 7.74 7.14 2.19 444.41 2 1 4.30 7.75 7.13 2.19 444.67 2 1 4.40 7.75 7.12 2.19 444.93 2 1 4.50 7.76 7.11 2.18 445.19 2 1 4.60 7.76 7.10 2.18 445.45 2 1 4.70 7.77 7.09 2.17 445.71 2 1 4.80 7.77 7.08 2.17 445.97 2 1 4.90 7.78 7.07 2.16 446.23 2 1 5.00 7.78 7.06 2.16 446.49 2 1 5.10 7.78 7.05 2.15 446.75 2 1 5.20 7.79 7.04 2.15 447.01 2 1 5.30 7.79 7.03 2.15 447.27 2 1 5.40 7.80 7.02 2.14 447.53 2 1 5.50 7.80 7.01 2.14 447.79 2 1 5.60 7.81 7.00 2.13 448.05 2 1 5.70 7.81 6.99 2.13 448.31 2 1 5.80 7.81 6.98 2.12 448.57 2 1 5.90 7.82 6.97 2.12 448.83 2 1 6.00 7.82 6.96 2.12 449.09 2 1 6.10 7.82 6.95 2.11 449.35 2 1 6.20 7.83 6.94 2.11 449.61 . w r w i • v v V • V J L . 1 V T T V • V 2, 1 6.40 7.84 6.92 2.10 450.13 2 1 6.50 7.84 6.91 2.10 450.39 2 1 6.60 7.84 6.90 2.09 450.65 2 1 6.70 7.85 6.89 2.09 450.91 2 1 6.80 7.85 6.88 2.08 451.17 2 1 6.90 7.85 6.87 2.08 451.43 2 1 7.00 7.86 6.86 2.07 451.69 2 1 7.10 7.86 6.85 2.07 451.95 2 1 7.20 7.86 6.84 2.07 452.21 2 1 7.30 7.86 6.83 2.06 452.47 2 1 7.40 7.87 6.82 2.06 452.73 2 1 7.50 7.87 6.81 2.05 452.99 2 1 7.60 7.87 6.80 2.05 453.25 2 1 7.70 7.88 6.79 2.05 453.51 2 1 7.80 7.88 6.78 2.04 453.77 2 1 7.90 7.88 6.77 2.04 454.03 2 1 8.00 7.89 6.76 2.03 454.29 2 1 8.10 7.89 6.75 2.03 454.55 2 1 8.20 7.89 6.75 2.03 454.81 2 1 8.30 7.89 6.74 2.02 455.07 2 1 8.40 7.90 6.73 2.02 455.33 2 1 8.50 7.90 6.72 2.01 455.59 2 1 8.60 7.90 6.71 2.01 455.85 2 1 8.70 7.90 6.70 2.01 456.11 2 1 8.80 7.91 6.69 2.00 456.37 2 1 8.90 7.91 6.68 2.00 456.63 2 2 8.90 7.82 6.82 2.74 490.26 2 2 9.00 7.82 6.81 2.73 490.52 2 2 9.10 7.82 6.80 2.73 490.78 2 2 9.20 7.81 6.79 2.72 491.04 2 2 9.30 7.81 6.79 2.72 491.30 2 2 9.40 7.81 6.78 2.71 491.56 2 2 9.50 7.81 6.77 2.71 491.82 2 2 9.60 7.81 6.76 2.70 492.08 2 2 9.70 7.81 6.75 2.70 492.34 2 2 9.80 7.81 6.74 2.69 492.60 2 2 9.90 7.81 6.73 2.69 492.86 2 2 10.00 7.81 6.72 2.68 493.12 2 2 10.10 7.81 6.71 2.68 493.38 2 2 10.20 7.81 6.70 2.67 493.64 2 2 10.30 7.81 6.70 2.67 493.90 2 2 10.40 7.81 6.69 2.66 494.16 2 2 10.50 7.81 6.68 2.65 494.42 2 2 10.60 7.81 6.67 2.65 494.68 2 2 10.70 7.81 6.66 2.64 494.94 2 2 10.80 7.81 6.65 2.64 495.20 2 2 10.90 7.81 6.64 2.63 495.46 2 2 11.00 7.81 6.63 2.63 495.72 2 2 11.10 7.81 6.62 2.62 495.98 2 2 11.20 7.81 6.62 2.62 496.24 2 3 11.20 7.81 6.51 2.58 508.02 2 3 11.30 7.81 6.50 2.58 508.28 2 3 11.40 7.81 6.49 2.57 508.54 2 3 11.50 7.81 6.48 2.57 508.80 2 3 11.60 7.81 6.48 2.56 509.06 2 3 11.70 7.81 6.47 2.56 509.32 2 3 11.80 7.81 6.46 2.55 509.58 2 3 11.90 7.82 6.45 2.55 509.84 2 3 12.00 7.82 6.44 2.54 510.10 2 4 12.00 6.97 22.00 12.02 572.10 2 4 13.00 6.89 21.70 11.79 575.10 2 4 14.00 6.83 21.41 11.57 578.10 2 4 15.00 6.79 21.13 11.35 581.10 2 4 16.00 6.76 20.85 11.14 584.10 2 4 17.00 6.74 20.57 10.93 587.10 2 2. 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Seg # 4 19.00 6.72 4 20.00 6.73 4 21.00 6.73 4 22.00 6.74 4 23.00 6.75 4 24.00 6.77 4 25.00 6.78 4 26.00 6.80 4 27.00 6.82 4 28.00 6.84 4 29.00 6.86 4 30.00 6.88 4 31.00 6.90 4 32.00 6.93 4 33.00 6.95 4 34.00 6.97 4 35.00 6.99 4 36.00 7.01 4 37.00 7.03 4 38.00 7.05 4 39.00 7.07 4 40.00 7.09 4 41.00 7.11 4 42.00 7.13 Reach # I Seg Mi I D.O. 20.03 19.77 19.51 19.25 19.00 18.75 18.51 18.27 18.03 17.80 17.57 17.34 17.12 16.90 16.68 16.47 16.26 16.05 15.85 15.64 15.45 15.25 15.06 14.87 CBOD 1 V . r c. 10.52 10.32 10.13 9.94 9.76 9.57 9.40 9.22 9.05 8.88 8.72 8.56 8.40 8.25 8.09 7.95 7.80 7.66 7.52 7.38 7.25 7.12 6.99 6.86 NBOD V V V. I V 593.10 596. 10 599.10 602.10 605.10 608.10 611.10 614.10 617.10 620.10 623.10 626. 10 629.10 632.10 635.10 638.10 641.10 644.10 647.10 650.10 653.10 656.10 659.10 662.10 Flow I MODEL RESULTS UMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS INC. ECUSTA,EREVARD,DUPONT UPS Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER The End D.O. is 6.50 gjl. The End CBOD is 5.56 mq/1. The End NEOD is 2.35 mg/1. DO Min (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # WLA WLA WLA CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5. 1 6 4.45 2 smAuhw Reach 1 90.00 45.00 0.00 2.50000 Reach 2 80.00 9.00 4.00 27.00000 ezosTA Segment 2 6.59 0.00 '1 pJ e•N'r Reach 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 2.00000 Segment 3 5.33 5.00 1 Reach 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 3 4,, 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 4 94.95 0.00 0.00 4.00000 Reach 5 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 ew•� .f 3/.6 s'„) (Q /36DS X 3 ** MODEL SUMMARY DATA )K** Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Subbasin : 040302 Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Stream Class: WSIII Summer 7Q10 : 316.0 Design Temperature: 23.0 Winter 7Q10 : 390.0 'LENGTH' SLOPE] VELOCITY 1 DEPTH' Kd 1 Kd I Ka 1 Ka 1 KN 1 KR 1 KNR 1 KNR 1 S00 1 SOD 1 mile 1 ft/mil fps 1 ft (design) @20° (design' @20° 'design@20° 'design' @20° Idesign' @20° I I I Segment 1 1 0,051 5.001 0.900 13.45 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2,13 1 2,001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 l I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I Segment 1 1 4,401 5.001 0.900 1 3.90 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I i l l Segment 2 1 8.501 40.001 0.933 1 1.53 1 0.60 1 0.52 135.06 1 32.851 0.63 1 0.50 1 0,63 ( 0.00 1 0.00 1 0,00 Reach 1 1 I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I Segment 3 1 18.001 5,001 0.900 1 4.52 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 i 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0,00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I I 1 1 1 1 ! 1 1 1 1 I { I I 11 1 I i l l l l l l Segment 3 1 0.101 5.001 0.900 1 4.95 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2,13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 ( 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 1 I ( I I I I I I I I I I I I! Segment 3 1 1.601 5.001 0.900 1 5.21 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 10,30 1 0,38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 3 I I i I I I I I I I I 1 I f Segment 3 1 0.021 5.001 0.900 1 5.33 1 0,57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 ( 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 4 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 3 1 5.001 4.001 0.900 1 5.41 1 0.51 1 0,50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 5 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 Flow 1 CBOD 1 NBOD 1 0.0 . 1 1 cfs 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 ! mg/1 I Segment 1 Reach 1 Waste 1 3.875 1 90.000 1 45.000 1 0.000 Headwaters1157.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 ( 7.720 Tributary 1 0,000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 Waste 1 41.850 1 80.000 1 9.000 1 4.000 I r I L'U Ldr'y 1 u. uuu 1 ..uuu 1 I .uuu 1 I. r 4U 4 Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 2 each 1 Waste 1 3.100 1 63.000 Headwatersl 18.000 1 2.000 Tributary I 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 2.700 1 2.000 Segment 3 Reach 1 Waste Headwaters Tributary * Runoff 0.000 0.000 0.000 2.600 Segment 3 each 2 Waste 0.000 Tributary 31.000 * Runoff 1.000 Segment 3 Reach 3 Waste j 0.000 Tributary 41.000 * Runoff 1 3.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 9.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1 0.000 9.500 1 14.900 2.000 1 1.000 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 Segment 3 Reach 4 Waste ( 6.200 194.950 1 0.000 ( 0.000 Tributary ( 0.000 j 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff ( 3.000 1 2.000 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 3 Reach 5 Waste ( 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 Tributary 1 16.200 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.900 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff flow is in cfs/mile SUMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS INC. ECUSTA,BREVARD,DUPONT UPS Seg # 1 Reach # 1 Seg Mi 1 D.O. I CBOD 1 NBOD I Flow I 1 1 0.00 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.88 1 1 0.01 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.89 1 1 0.02 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.90 1 1 0.03 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.92 1 1 0.04 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.93 1 1 0.05 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.94 1 2 0.05 6.80 19.77 3.49 202.79 1 2 0.25 6.69 19.59 3.47 203.06 1 2 0.45 6.57 19.42 3.45 203.34 1 2 0.65 6.47 19.25 3.43 203.61 1 2 0.85 6.36 19.07 3.41 203.88 1 2 1.05 6.27 18.90 3.39 204.15 1 2 1.25 6.17 18.73 3.36 204.42 1 2 1.45 6.08 18.57 3.34 204.70 1 2 1.65 6.00 18.40 3.32 204.97 1 2 1.85 5.92 18.24 3.30 205.24 1 2 2.05 5.84 18.07 3.28 205.51 1 2 2.25 5.77 17.91 3.26 205.78 1 2 2.45 5.70 17.75 3.24 206.06 1 2 2.65 5.63 17.59 3.22 206.33 1 2 2.85 5.56 17.44 3.21 206.60 1 2 3.05 5.50 17.28 3.19 206.87 1 2 3.25 5.45 17.13 3.17 207.14 1 2 3.45 5.39 16.97 3.15 207.42 1 2 3.65 5.34 16.82 3.13 207.69 1 2 3.85 5.29 16.67 3.11 207.96 1 2 4.05 5.25 16.52 3.09 208.23 1 2 4.25 5.20 16.38 3.07 208.50 1 2 4.45 5.16 16.23 3.05 208.78 2 1 0.00 6.59 10.96 2.18 21.10 2 1 0.10 6.96 10.81 2.15 21.37 2 1 0.20 7.26 10.65 2.13 21.64 2 1 0.30 7.49 10.51 2.11 21.91 2 1 0.40 7.67 10.36 2.08 22.18 2 1 0.50 7.81 10.22 2.06 22.45 2 1 0.60 7.93 10.08 2.04 22.72 2 1 0.70 8.02 9.95 2.02 22.99 2 1 0.80 8.09 9.82 2.00 23.26 2 1 0.90 8.14 9.69 1.98 23.53 2 1 1.00 8.19 9.57 1.96 23.80 2 1 1.10 8.22 9.45 1.94 24.07 2 1 1.20 8.25 9.33 1.92 24.34 2 1 1.30 8.28 9.21 1.91 24.61 2 1 1.40 8.29 9.10 1.89 24.88 2 1 1.50 8.31 8.98 1.87 25.15 2 1 1.60 8.32 8.88 1.85 25.42 2 1 1.70 8.33 8.77 1.84 25.69 2 1 1.80 8.34 8.66 1.82 25.96 2 1 1.90 8.35 8.56 1.81 26.23 2 1 2.00 8.35 8.46 1.79 26.50 2 1 2.10 8.36 8.36 1.77 26.77 2 1 2.20 .8.36 8.27 1.76 27.04 2 1 2.30 8.37 8.17 1.75 27.31 2 1 2.40 8.37 8.08 1.73 27.58 2 1 2.50 8.38 7.99 1.72 27.85 2 1 2.60 8.38 7.90 1.70 28.12 2 1 2.70 8.38 7.82 1.69 28.39 d.. OW 2.90 3.00 3.10 3.20 3.30 3.40 3.50 3.60 3.70 3.80 3.90 4.00 4.10 4.20 4.30 4.40 4.50 4.60 4.70 4.80 4.90 5.00 5.10 5.20 5.30 5.40 5.50 5.60 5.70 5.80 5.90 6.00 6.10 6.20 6.30 6.40 6.50 6.60 6.70 6.80 6.90 7.00 7.10 7.20 7.30 7.40 7.50 7.60 7.70 7.80 7.90 8.00 8.10 8.20 8.30 8.40 8.50 0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 1.40 O . J O 8.39 8.39 8.39 8.39 8.39 8.40 8.40 8.40 8.40 8.40 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.46 8.46 8.46 8.46 8.46 5.74 5.70 5.66 5.63 5.60 5.57 5.55 5.52 f . f 7.65 7.57 7.49 7.41 7.33 7.25 7.18 7.11 7.03 6.96 6.89 6.82 6.76 6.69 6.63 6.56 6.50 6.44 6.38 6.32 6.26 6.20 6.15 6.09 6.04 5.98 5.93 5.88 5.83 5.77 5.72 5.68 5.63 5.58 5.53 5.49 5.44 5.39 5.35 5.31 5.26 5.22 5.18 5.14 5.10 5.06 5.02 4.98 4.94 4.90 4.86 4.83 4.79 4.75 4.72 4.68 4.65 14.21 (( 14.08 13.94 13.81 13.68 13.55 13.42 13.30 1 • 00 1.66 1.65 1.64 1.62 1.61 1.60 1.59 1.58 1.56 1.55 1.54 1.53 1.52 1.51 1.50 1.49 1.48 1.47 1.46 1.45 1.44 1.43 1.42 1.41 1.40 1.40 1.39 1.38 1.37 1.36 1.35 1.34 1.34 1.33 1.32 1.31 1.31 1.30 1.29 1.28 1.28 1.27 1.26 1.26 1.25 1.24 1.24 1.23 1.22 1.22 1.21 1.20 1.20 1.19 1.18 1.18 1.17 2.73 2.71 2.69 2.67 2.66 2.64 2.62 2.61 G O • W W 28.93 29.20 29.47 29.74 30.01 30.28 30.55 30.82 31.09 31.36 31.63 31.90 32.17 32.44 32.71 32.98 33.25 33.52 33.79 34.06 34.33 34.60 34.87 35.14 35.41 35.68 35.95 36.22 36.49 36.76 37.03 37.30 37.57 37.84 38.11 38.38 38.65 38.92 39.19 39.46 39.73 40.00 40.27 40.54 40.81 41.08 41.35 41.62 41.89 42.16 42.43 42.70 42.97 43.24 43.51 43.78 44.05 252.83 253.35 253.87 254.39 254.91 255.43 255.95 256.47 3 , 1 1.80 5.48 13.04 2.57 257.51 •3 1 2.00 5.46 12.92 2.56 258.03 3 1 2.20 5.44 12.80 2.54 258.55 3 1 2.40 5.42 12.68 2.53 259.07 3 1 2.60 5.41 12.56 2.51 259.59 3 1 2.80 5.39 12.44 2.49 260.11 3 1 3.00 5.38 12.32 2.48 260.63 3 1 3.20 5.37 '12.21 2.46 261,15 3 1 3.40 5.36 12.09 2.45 261.67 3 1 3.60 5.35 11.98 2.43 262.19 3 1 3.80 5.35 11.87 2.42 262.71 3 1 4.00 5.34 11.75 2.40 263.23 3 1 4.20 5.34 11.64 2.39 263.75 3 1 4.40 5.33 11.54 2.37 264.27 3 1 4.60 5.33 11.43 2.36 264.79 3 1 4.80 5.33 11,32 2.34 265.31 3 1 5.00 5.33 11.21 2.33 265.83 3 1 5.20 5.33 11.11 2.31 266.35 3 1 5.40 5.33 11.01 2.30 266.87 3 1 5.60 5.33 10.90 2.28 267.39 3 1 5.80 5.33 10.80 2.27 267,91 3 1 6.00 5.34 10.70 2.26 268.43 3 1 6.20 5.34 10.60 2.24 268.95 3 1 6.40 5.35 10.50 2.23 269.47 3 1 6.60 5.35 10.40 2.21 269.99 3 1 6.80 5.36 10.31 2.20 270.51 3 1 7.00 5.36 10.21 2.19 271.03 3 1 7.20 5.37 10.12 2.17 271.55 3 1 7.40 5.38 10.02 2.16 272.07 3 1 7.60 5.39 9,93 2.15 272.59 3 1 7.80 5.40 9.84 2.13 273.11 3 1 8.00 5.41 9,75 2.12 273.63 3 1 8.20 5.41 9.66 2.11 274.15 3 1 8.40 5.43 9.57 2.09 274.67 3 1 8.60 5,44 9.48 2.08 275.19 3 1 8.80 5.45 9.39 2.07 275.71 3 1 9.00 5.46 9.30 2.06 276.23 3 1 9.20 5,47 9.22 2.04 276.75 3 1 9.40 5.48 9.13 2.03 277.27 3 1 9.60 5.50 9.05 2.02 277.79 3 1 9.80 5.51 8.97 2.01 278.31 3 1 10.00 5.52 8.88 1.99 278.83 3 1 10.20 5.53 8.80 1.98 279.35 3 1 10,40 5.55 8.72 1.97 279.87 3 1 10.60 5.56 8.64 1.96 280.39 3 1 10.80 5.58 8.56 1.95 280,91 3 1 11.00 5.59 8.48 1.94 281.43 3 1 11.20 5.61 8.40 1.92 281.95 3 1 11.40 5.62 8.33 1.91 282.47 3 1 11.60 5.64 8.25 1.90 282.99 3 1 11.80 5.65 8.18 1.89 283.51 3 1 12.00 5.67 8.10 1.88 284.03 3 1 12.20 5.68 8.03 1.87 284.55 3 1 12.40 5.70 7.95 1.86 285.07 3 1 12.60 5.71 7.88 1.84 285.59 3 1 12.80 5.73 7.81 1.83 286.11 3 1 13.00 5.75 7.74 1.82 286.63 3 1 13.20 5.76 7.67 1.81 287.15 3 1 13.40 5.78 7.60 1.80 287.67 3 1 13.60 5.79 7.53 1.79 288,19 3 1 13.80 5.81 7.46 1.78 288.71 3 1 14.00 5.83 7.39 1.77 289.23 3 1 14.20 5.84 7.33 1.76 289.75 3 1 14.40 5.86 7.26 1.75 290.27 3 1 14.60 5.88 7.19 1.74 290.79 .+ .•�. uu 3 ' 1• 15.00 " '3 1 15.20 3 1 15.40 3 1 15.60 3 1 15.80 3 1 16.00 3 1 16.20 3 1 16.40 3 1 16.60 3 1 16.80 3 1 17.00 3 1 17.20 3 1 17.40 3 1 17.60 3 1 17.80 3 1 18.00 3 2 18.00 3 2 18.10 3 2 18.20 3 2 18.30 3 2 18.40 3 2 18.50 3 2 18.60 3 2 18.70 3 3 18.70 3 3 18.80 3 3 18.90 3 3 '19.00 3 3 19.10 3 3 19.20 3 3 19.30 3 3 19.40 3 3 19.50 3 3 19.60 3 3 19.70 3 3 19.80 3 3 19.90 3 3 20.00 3 3 20.10 3 3 20.20 3 3 20.30 3 4 20.30 3 4 20.31 3 4 20.31 3 4 20.32 3 4 20.32 3 5 20.32 3 5 20.82 3 5 21.32 3 5 21.82 3 5 22.32 3 5 22.82 3 5 23.32 3 5 23.82 3 5 24.32 3 5 24.82 3 5 25.32 I Seg 4 I Reach # I Beg Mi v• u a r• 5.91 7.07 5.93 7.00 5.94 6.94 5.96 6.88 5.98 6.81 5.99 6.75 6.01 6.69 6.03 6.63 6.04 6.57 6.06 6.51 6.08 6.45 6.10 6.40 6. 1 1 6.34 6.13 6.28 6.15 6.23 6.16 6.17 6.31 5.78 6.31 5.76 6.32 5.73 6.33 5.71 6.34 5.69 6.34 5.66 6.35 5.64 6.36 5.62 6.51 6.04 6.51 6.02 6.51 5.99 6.51 5.96 6.51 5.94 6.51 5.91 6.51 5.89 6.51 5.86 6.51 5.83 6.51 5.81 6.51 5.78 6.51 5.76 6.51 5.73 6.51 5.71 6.52 5.68 6.52 5.66 6.52 5.63 6.41 7.08 6.41 7.07 6.41 7.07 6.41 7.07 6.41 7.07 6.47 6.86 6.46 6.72 6.45 6.58 6.45 6.44 6.45 6.31 6.45 6.18 6.46 6.05 6.47 5.92 6.48 5.80 6.49 5.68 6.50 5.56 D.O. I CBOD 1• 1 .7 d, .J 1• J I 1.72 1.71 1.70 1.69 1.68 1.67 1.66 1.65 1.64 1.63 1.62 1.61 1.60 1.59 1.58 1.57 1.52 1.52 1.51 1.51 1.50 1.50 1.50 1.49 2.97 2.96 2.95 2.94 2.93 2.92 2.91 2.91 2.90 2.89 2.88 2.87 2.86 2.85 2.84 2.83 2.83 2.78 2.78 2.78 2.78 2.78 2.71 2.67 2.63 2.59 2.56 2.52 2.48 2.45 2.41 2.38 2.35 NBOD 291.83 292.35 292.87 293.39 293.91 294.43 294.95 295.47 295.99 296.51 297.03 297.55 298.07 298.59 299.11 299.63 330.63 330.73 330.83 330.93 331.03 331.13 331.23 331.33 372.33 372.63 372.93 373.23 373.53 373.83 374.13 374.43 374.73 375.03 375.33 375.63 375.93 376.23 376.53 376.83 377.13 383.33 383.34 383.36 383.37 383.39 399.59 400.54 401.49 402.44 403.39 404.34 405.29 406.24 407.19 408.14 409.09 Flow MODEL RESULTS SUMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS (u 1/10 QW & 10X CB0P EFFLUENT Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER The End D.O. is 6.53 mg/1. The End CBOD is 5.64 mg/1. The End NBOD is 2.38 mg/1. WLA WLA WLA DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach 4k (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.16 4.45 2 Reach 1 90.00 45.00 0.00 2.50000 Reach 2 80.00 9.00 4.00 27.00000 Segment 2 6.59 0.00 1 Reach 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 2.00000 Segment 3 5.33 5.00 1 Reach 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 3 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 4 949.65 0.00 0.00 0.40000 Reach 5 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 *** MODEL SUMMARY DATA *** Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Subbasin : 040302 Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Stream Class: WSIII Summer 7Q10 : 316.0 Design Temperature: 23.0 Winter 7Q10 : 390.0 1LENGTHI SLOPE' VELOCITY 1 DEPTH' Kd 1 Kd 1 Ka 1 Ka 1 KN 1 KN I KNR 1 KNR 1 SOD 1 SOD 1 mile 1 ft/mil fps 1 ft 'design@20° 'design' @20° 'design' @20° 'design' @20° 'design' @20° I I I I I I I I l 1 1[ I Segment 1 1 0.051 5,001 0.900 1 3.45 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2,001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I ( I I I I I I I I I 1 Segment 1 1 4.401 5.001 0.900 1 3.90 1 0.51 1 0,50 1 2,13 1 2.00I 0.38 1 0,30 0.38 1 0,30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 1 I I I I I l ( I l I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I Segment 2 1 8.501 40.001' 0.933 1 1.53 1 0.60 1 0.52 135.06 1 32,851 0,63 1 0.50 1 0,63 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I 1 Segment 3 1 18,001 5,001 0.900 1 4,52 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2,001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0,00 Reach 1 1 1 I I { I I I 1 I I Segment 3 0,101 5.00 0,900 4.95 0,51 0,50 2.13 2.00 0,38 0.30 0.38 0.00 0.00 0.00 Reach 2 1 I I I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Segment 3 1 1,601 5.001 0.900 1 5.21 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2,001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0,38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0,00 Reach 3 l 1 I I I I I I I I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I Segment 3 1 0.021 5,001 0.900 1 5.29 1 0,51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2,001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 4 I 1 I I I I I I I I ( I I ( Segment 3 1 5.001 4,001 0.900 1 5.43 1 0,51 1 0,50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0,00 1 0.00 Reach 5 I 1 I I I I I I I I ( I I Flow 1 CBOD 1 NBOD 1 0.0. I 1 cfs 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 I Segment 1 Reach 1 Waste I 3.875 1 90.000 1 45.000 1 0.000 HeadwatersI157.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary I 0.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 I 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 Waste 141.850 1 80.000 1 9.000 1 4.000 t {J kJ 4, t7 l y '( Runoff V . UUU I G. UUU 1 I . IJUU 1 ! . 1 GU 1.360 1 2.000 I 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 2 each 1 Waste ( 3.100 1 63.000 Headwaters) 18.000 1 2.000 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 2.700 1 2.000 Segment 3 Reach 1 Waste 1 0.000 Headwaters j 0.000 Tributary 1 0.000 * Runoff j 2.600 Segment 3 Reach 2 Waste i 0.000 Tributary ( 31.000 * Runoff j 1.000 Segment 3 each 3 Waste 0.000 Tributary 41.000 * Runoff 3.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 9.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1 0.000 9.500 1 14.900 2.000 1 1.000 Segment 3 Reach 4 Waste 1 0.620 1949.650 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 3.000 1 2.000 Segment 3 Reach 5 Waste 1 0.000 Tributary 1 16.200 * Runoff 1 1.900 0.000 2.000 2.000 * Runoff flow is in cfs/mile 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 Seg # 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 9 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 7 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 7 SUMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS @ 1/10 QW & 10X CBOD EFFLUENT Reachll # { Seg Mi { D.O. { CBOD { NBOD I Flow 1 0.00 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.88 1 0.01 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.89 1 0.02 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.90 1 0.03 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.92 1 0.04 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.93 1 0.05 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.94 2 0.05 6.80 19.77 3.49 202.79 2 0.25 6.69 19.59 3.47 203.06 2 0.45 6.57 19.42 3.45 203.34 2 0.65 6.47 19.25 3.43 203.61 2 0.85 6.36 19.07 3.41 203.88 2 1.05 6.27 18.90 3.39 204.15 2 1.25 6.17 18.73 3.36 204.42 2 1.45 6.08 18.57 3.34 204.70 2 1.65 6.00 18.40 3.32 204.97 2 j 1.85 5.92 18.24 3.30 205.24 2 2.05 5.84 18.07 3.28 205.51 2 2.25 5.77 17.91 3.26 205.78 2 2.45 5.70 17.75 3.24 206.06 2 2.65 5.63 17.59 3.22 206.33 2 2.85 5.56 17.44 3.21 206.60 2 3.05 5.50 17.28 3.19 206.87 2 3.25 5.45 17.13 3.17 207.14 2 3.45 5.39 16.97 3.15 207.42 2 3.65 5.34 16.82 3.13 207.69 2 3.85 5.29 16.67 3.11 207.96 2 4.05 5.25 16.52 3.09 208.23 2 4.25 5.20 16.38 3.07 208.50 2 4.45 5.16 16.23 3.05 208.78 1 0.00 6.59 10.96 2.18 21.10 1 0.10 6.96 10.81 2.15 21.37 1 0.20 7.26 10.65 2.13 21.64 1 0.30 7.49 10.51 2.11 21.91 1 0.40 7.67 10.36 2.08 22.18 1 0.50 7.81 10.22 2.06 22.45 'I 0.60 7,93 10.08 2.04 22.72 1 0.70 8.02 9.95 2.02 22.99 1 0.80 8.09 9.82 2.00 23.26 1 0.90 8.14 9,69 1.98 23.53 1 1.00 8.19 9.57 1.96 23.80 '1 1.10 8.22 9.45 1.94 24.07 1 1.20 8,25 9.33 1.92 24.34 1 1.30 8.28 9.21 1.91 24.61 1 1.40 8.29 9.10 1.89 24.88 1 1.50 8.31 8.98 1.87 25.15 1 1.60 8.32 8.88 1.85 25.42 1 1.70 8.33 8.77 1.84 25.69 1 1.80 8.34 8.66 1.82 25.96 1 1.90 8.35 8.56 1.81 26.23 1 2,00 8.35 8.46 1.79 26.50 1 ' 2.10 3,36 8,36 1.77 26.77 1 2,20 8.36 8.27 1.76 27.04 1 2.30 8.37 8.17 1.75 27.31 1 2.40 8.37 8.08 1.73 27.58 1 2.50 8.38 7.99 '1 , 72 27.85 1 2.60 8.38 7.90 1.70 28.12 1 2.70 8.38 7.82 1.69 28.39 .... .. . e .� i . uv .a . vU 2 1 2.90 3.39 7.65 1.66 28.93 '2 1 3.00 8.39 7.57 1.65 29.20 2 1 3.10 8.39 7.49 1.64 29.47 2 1 3.20 8.39 7.41 1.62 29.74 2 1 3.30 8.39 7.33 1.61 30.01 2 1 3.40 8.40 7.25 1.60 30.28 2 1 3.50 8.40 7.18 1.59 30.55 2 1 3.60 8.40 7.11 1.58 30.82 2 1 3.70 8.40 7.03 1.56 31.09 2 1 3.80 8.40 6.96 1.55 31.36 2 1 3.90 8.41 6.89 1.54 31.63 2 1 4.00 8.41 6.82 1.53 31.90 2 1 4.10 8.41 6.76 1,52 32.17 2 1 4.20 8.41 6.69 1.51 32.44 2 1 4.30 8.41 6.63 1.50 32.71 2 1 4.40 8.41 6.56 1.49 32.98 2 1 4.50 8.41 6.50 1.48 33.25 2 1 4.60 8.42 6.44 1.47 33.52 2 1 4.70 8.42 6.38 1.46 33.79 2 1 4.80 8.42 6.32 1.45 34.06 2 1 4.90 8.42 6.26 1.44 34.33 2 1 5.00 8.42 6.20 1.43 34.60 2 1 5.10 8.42 6.15 1.42 34.87 2 1 5.20 8.42 6.09 1.41 35.14 2 1 5.30 8.43 6.04 1.40 35.41 2 1 5.40 8.43 5.98 1.40 35.68 2 1 5.50 8.43 5.93 1.39 35.95 2 1 5.60 8.43 5.88 1.38 36.22 2 1 5.70 8.43 5.83 1.37 36.49 2 1 5.80 8.43 5.77 1.36 36.76 2 1 5,90 8.43 5.72 1.35 37.03 2 1 6.00 8.43 5.68 1.34 37.30 2 1 6.10 8.44 5.63 1.34 37.57 2 1 6.20 8.44 5.58 1.33 37.84 2 1 6.30 8.44 5.53 1.32 38.11 2 1 6.40 8.44 5.49 1.31 38.38 2 1 6.50 8.44 5.44 1.31 38.65 2 1 6.60 8.44 5.39 1.30 38.92 2 1 6.70 8.44 5.35 1.29 39.19 2 1 6.80 8.44 5.31 1.28 39.46 2 1 6.90 8.44 5.26 1.28 39.73 2 1 7.00 8.45 5.22 1.27 40.00 2 1 7.10 8.45 5.18 1.26 40.27 2 1 7.20 8.45 5.14 1.26 40.54 2 1 7.30 8.45 5.10 1.25 40.81 2 1 7.40 8.45 5.06 1.24 41.08 2 1 7.50 8.45 5.02 1.24 41.35 2 1 7.60 8.45 4.98 1.23 41.62 2 1 7.70 8.45 4.94 1.22 41.89 2 1 7.80 8.45 4.90 1.22 42.16 2 1 7.90 8.45 4.86 1.21 42.43 2 1 8.00 8.45 4.83 1.20 42.70 2 1 8.10 8.46 4.79 1.20 42.97 2 1 8.20 8.46 4.75 1.19 43.24 2 1 8.30 8.46 4.72 1.18 43.51 2 1 8.40 8.46 4.68 1.18 43.78 2 1 8.50 8.46 4.65 1.17 44.05 3 1 0.00 5.74 14.21 2.73 252.83 3 1 0.20 5.70 14.08 2.71 253.35 3 1 0.40 5.66 13.94 2.69 253.87 3 1 0.60 5.63 13.81 2.67 254.39 3 1 0.80 5.60 13.68 2.66 254.91 3 1 1.00 5.57 13.55 2.64 255.43 3 1 1.20 5.55 13.42 2.62 255.95 3 1 1.40 5.52 13.30 2.61 256.47 u. w w u. .,1 u i .J. l r 4 .:J 'J L :J C] . J :J 3 '1 1.80 5.48 13.04 2.57 257.51 1 2.00 5.46 12.92 2.56 258.03 3 1 2.20 5.44 12.80 2.54 258.55 3 1 2.40 5.42 12.68 2.53 259.07 3 1 2.60 5.41 12.56 2.51 259.59 3 1 2.80 5.39 12.44 2.49 260.11 3 1 3.00 5.38 12.32 2.48 260.63 3 1 3.20 5.37 12.21 2.46 261.15 3 1 3.40 5.36 12.09 2.45 261.67 3 1 3.60 5.35 11.98 2.43 262.19 3 1 3.80 5.35 11.87 2.42 262.71 3 1 4.00 5.34 11.75 2.40 263.23 3 1 4.20 5.34 11.64 2.39 263.75 3 1 4.40 5.33 11.54 2.37 264.27 3 1 4.60 5.33 11.43 2.36 264.79 3 1 4.80 5.33 11.32 2.34 265.31 3 1 5.00 5.33 11.21 2.33 265.83 3 1 5.20 5.33 11.11 2.31 266.35 3 1 5.40 5.33 11.01 2.30 266.87 3 1 5.60 5.33 10.90 2.28 267.39 3 1 5.80 5.33 10.80 2.27 267.91 3 1 6.00 5.34 10.70 2.26 268.43 3 1 6.20 5.34 10.60 2.24 268.95 3 1 6.40 5.35 10.50 2.23 269.47 3 1 6.60 5.35 10.40 2.21 269.99 3 1 6.80 5.36 10.31 2.20 270.51 3 1 7.00 5.36 10.21 2.19 271.03 3 1 7.20 5.37 10.12 2.17 271.55 3 1 7.40 5.38 10.02 2.16 272.07 3 1 7.60 5.39 9.93 2.15 272.59 3 1 7.80 5.40 9.84 2.13 273.11 3 1 8.00 5.41 9.75 2.12 273.63 3 1 8.20 5.41 9.66 2.11 274.15 3 1 8.40 5.43 9.57 2.09 274.67 3 1 8.60 5.44 9.48 2.08 275.19 3 1 8.80 5.45 9.39 2.07 275.71 3 1 9.00 5.46 9.30 2.06 276.23 3 1 9.20 5.47 9.22 2.04 276.75 3 1 9.40 5.48 9.13 2.03 277.27 3 1 9.60 5.50 9.05 2.02 277.79 3 1 9.80 5.51 8.97 2.01 278.31 3 1 10.00 5.52 8.88 1.99 278.83 3 1 10.20 5.53 8.80 1.98 279.35 3 1 10.40 5.55 8.72 1.97 279.87 3 1 10.60 5.56 8.64 1.96 280.39 3 1 10.80 5.58 8.56 1.95 280.91 3 1 11.00 5.59 8.48 1.94 281.43 3 1 11.20 5.61 8.40 1.92 281.95 3 1 11.40 5.62 8.33 1.91 282.47 3 1 11.60 5.64 8.25 1.90 282.99 3 1 11.80 5.65 8.18 1.89 283.51 3 1 12.00 5.67 8.10 1.88 284.03 3 1 12.20 5.68 8.03 1.87 284.55 3 1 12.40 5.70 7.95 1.86 285.07 3 1 12.60 5.71 7.88 1.84 285.59 3 1 12.80 5.73 7.81 1.83 286.11 3 1 13.00 5.75 7.74 1.82 286.63 3 1 13.20 5.76 7.67 1.81 287.15 3 1 13.40 5.78 7.60 1.80 287.67 3 1 13.60 5.79 7.53 1.79 288.19 3 1 13.80 5.81 7.46 1.78 288.71 3 1 14.00 5.83 7.39 1.77 289.23 3 1 14.20 5.84 7.33 1.76 289.75 3 1 14.40 5.86 7.26 1.75 290.27 3 1 14.60 5.88 7.19 1.74 290.79 3 '1 .' `3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 4 3 4 3 4 3 4 3 4 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 5 3 a 3 5 Seg 4 I Reach # 1 15.00 5.91 7.07 1.72 291.83 15.20 5.93 7.00 1.71 292.35 15.40 5.94 6.94 1.70 292.87 15,60 5.96 6.88 1.69 293.39 15.80 5.98 6.81 1.68 293.91 16.00 5.99 6.75 1.67 294.43 16.20 6.01 6.69 1.66 294.95 16.40 6.03 6.63 1.65 295.47 16.60 6.04 6.57 1.64 295.99 16.80 6.06 6.51 1.63 296.51 17.00 6.08 6.45 1.62 297.03 17.20 6.10 6.40 1.61 297.55 17.40 6.11 6.34 1.60 298.07 17.60 6.13 6.28 1.59 298.59 17.80 6.15 6.23 1.58 299.11 18.00 6.16 6.17 1.57 299.63 18.00 6.31 5.78 1.52 330.63 18.10 6.31 5.76 1.52 330.73 18.20 6.32 5.73 1.51 330.83 18.30 6.33 5.71 1.51 330.93 18.40 6.34 5.69 1.50 331.03 18.50 6.34 5.66 1.50 331.13 18.60 6.35 5.64 1.50 331.23 18.70 6.36 5.62 1.49 331.33 18.70 6.51 6.04 2.97 372.33 18.80 6.51 6.02 2.96 372.63 18.90 6.51 5.99 2.95 372.93 19.00 6.51 5.96 2.94 373.23 19.10 6.51 5.94 2.93 373.53 19.20 6.51 5.91 2.92 373.83 19.30 6.51 5.89 2.91 374.13 19.40 6.51 5.86 2.91 374.43 19.50 6.51 5.83 2.90 374.73 19.60 6.51 5.81 2.89 375.03 19.70 6.51 5.78 2.88 375.33 19.80 6.51 5.76 2.87 375.63 19.90 6.51 5.73 2.86 375.93 20.00 6.51 5.71 2.85 376.23 20.10 6.52 5.68 2.84 376.53 20.20 6.52 5.66 2.83 376.83 20.30 6.52 5.63 2.83 377.13 20.30 6.51 7.18 2.82 377.75 20.31 6.51 7.18 2.82 377.76 20.31 6.51 7.18 2.82 377.78 20.32 6.51 7.18 2.82 377.79 20.32 6.51 7.17 2.82 377.81 20.32 6.56 6.96 2.74 394.01 20.82 6.54 6.82 2.71 394.96 21.32 6.52 6.67 2.67 395.91 21.82 6.51 6.53 2.63 396.86 22.32 6.51 6.40 2.59 397.81 22.82 6.50 6.26 2.55 398.76 23.32 6.50 6.13 2.52 399.71 23.82 6.51 6.00 2.48 400.66 24.32 6.51 5.88 2.45 401.61 24.82 6.52 5.76 2.41 402.56 25.32 6.53 5.64 2.38 403.51 Seg Mi I D.O. I CBOD I NBOD I Flow I MODEL RESULTS SUMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS @ DA. MAX. CBOD= 1 89 . 93 MG/L Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER The End D.O. is 6.32 mg/1. The End CBOD is 6.74 mg/1. The End NBOD is 2.35 mg/1. WLA WLA WLA DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.16 Reach 1 Reach 2 Segment 2 6.59 Reach 1 4.45 2 90.00 45.00 0.00 80.00 9.00 4.00 0.00 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 Segment 3 5.33 5.00 1 Reach 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 Reach 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 Reach 3 0.00 0.00 0.00 Reach 4 189.93 0.00 0.00 Reach 5 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.50000 27.00000 2.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 4.00000 0.00000 )K** MODEL SUMMARY DATA *** Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Subbasi n : 040302 Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Stream Class: WSIII Summer 7Q10 : 316.0 Design Temperature: 23.0 Winter 7Q10 : 390.0 (LENGTH' SLOPE' VELOCITY 1 DEPTH' Kd 1 Kd 1 Ka 1 Ka 1 KN 1 KN 1 KNR ( K11R 1 SOD 1 S00 1 mile 1 ftjmi l fps 1 ft 'design' @20° 'design l @20° 'design' @20° 'design l @20° [design' @20° I I I I l l l 1 l 1 1 l l l Segment 1 1 0.051 5.001 0,900 1 3,45 1 0.57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0.38 ( 0,30 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 l I I I I I I I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 1 1 4.401 5,001 0,900 1 3.90 1 0.57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.00 ( 0.00 Reach 2 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 l 1 1 I Segment 2 1 8,501 40,001 0.933 1 1.53 1 0.60 1 0.52 35.06 1 32.851 0.63 1 0.50 ( 0.63 1 0.00 1 0,00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I I 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I l l l l I I I I I I Segment 3 1 18.001 5.001 0,900 1 4.52 1 0,57 1 0.50 (2.13 1 2,001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I I 1 1 ! 1 1 1 1 1 1 l l 11 1 l l l l 1 I I I Segment 3 1 0.701 5,001 0.900 1 4.95 1 0,51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1[ Segment 3 1 1.601 5.001 0.900 1 5.21 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 10,30 1 0.38 1 0,00 1 0,00 1 0.00 Reach 3 I I I 1 1 ! 1 1 1 I 1 1 I I I I I I l l! I l l l Segment 3 1 0.021 5,001 0.900 1 5.33 1 0,51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0,00 1 0,00 Reach 4 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I Segment 3 1 5.001 4,001 0.900 1 5,47 1 0,57 1 0,50 1 2,13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0,30 1 0,38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 5 1 1 1 Flow 1 CBOD 1 NB0D 1 D.O. I 1 cfs 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 1 mg/1 I Segment 1 Reach 1 Waste 1 3.875 1 90.000 145.000 1 0.000 Headwatersl157.000 1 2.000 I 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 Waste 1 41.850 1 80.000 I 9.000 1 4.000 ,+-u7 1 v•vwu 1 ',•vvv 1 1•VWIJ j f •!LV _ Rurioff 1 1.360 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 2 each 1 Waste 3.100 63.000 Headwaters 18.000 2.000 Tributary 0.000 2.000 * Runoff 2.700 2.000 Segment 3 Reach 1 Waste 1 0.000 Headwaters 1 0.000 Tributary 1 0.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 0.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 9.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 Segment 3 Reach 2 Waste I 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 Tributary 1 31.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 3 each 3 Waste 0.000 Tributary 41.000 * Runoff 3.000 0.000 1 0.000 9.500 1 14.900 2.000 1 1.000 Segment 3 Reach 4 Waste 1 6.200 1189.930 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 3.000 1 2.000 Segment 3 Reach 5 Waste 1 0.000 Tributary 1 16.200 * Runoff 1 1.900 0.000 2.000 2.000 * Runoff flow is in cfs/mile 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 I Seg # 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Reach # j Seg Mi 1 0.00 1 0.01 1 0.02 1 0.03 1 0.04 1 0.05 2 0.05 2 0.25 2 0.45 2 0.65 2 0.85 2 1.05 2 1.25 2 1.45 2 1.65 2 1.85 2 2.05 2 2.25 2 2.45 2 2.65 2 2.85 2 3.05 2 3.25 2 3.45 2 3.65 2 3.85 2 4.05 2 4.25 2 4.45 1 0.00 1 0.10 1 0.20 1 0.30. 1 0.40 1 0.50 1 0.60 1 0.70 1 0.80 1 0.90 1 1.00 1 1.10 1 1.20 1 1.30 1 1.40 1 1.50 1 1.60 1 1.70 1 1.80 1 1.90 1 2.00 1 2.10 1 2.20 1 2.30 1 2.40 1 2.50 1 2.60 1 2.70 D.O. 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53 6.80 6.69 6.57 6.47 6.36 6.27 6.17 6.08 6.00 5.92 5.84 5.77 5.70 5.63 5.56 5.50 5.45 5.39 5.34 5.29 5.25 5.20 5.16 6.59 6.96 7.26 7.49 7.67 7.81 7.93 8.02 8.09 8.14 8.19 8.22 8.25 8.28 8.29 8.31 8.32 8.33 8.34 8.35 8.35 8.36 8.36 8.37 8.37 8.38 8.38 8.38 CBOD 4.12 4.12 4.12 4.11 4.11 4.11 19.77 19.59 19.42 19.25 19.07 18.90 18.73 18.57 18.40 18.24 18.07 17.91 17.75 17.59 17.44 17.28 17.13 16.97 16.82 16.67 16.52 16.38 16.23 10.96 10.81 10.65 10.51 10.36 10.22 10.08 9.95 9.82 9.69 9.57 9.45 9.33 9.21 9.10 8.98 8.88 8.77 8.66 8.56 8.46 8.36 8.27 8.17 8.08 7.99 7.90 7.82 SUMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS @ DA. MAX. CBOD= 1 89 . 93 MG/L NBOD I Flow I 2.06 160.88 2.06 160.89 2.06 160.90 2.06 160.92 2.06 160.93 2.06 160.94 3.49 202.79 3.47 203.06 3.45 203.34 3.43 203.61 3.41 203.88 3.39 204.15 3.36 204.42 3.34 204.70 3.32 204.97 3.30 205.24 3.28 205.51 3.26 205.78 3.24 206.06 3.22 206.33 3.21 206.60 3.19 206.87 3.17 207.14 3.15 207.42 3.13 207.69 3.11 207.96 3.09 208.23 3.07 208.50 3.05 208.78 2.18 21.10 2.15 21.37 2.13 21.64 2.11 21.91 2.08 22.18 2.06 22.45 2.04 22.72 2.02 22.99 2.00 23.26 1.98 23.53 1.96 23.80 1.94 24.07 1.92 24.34 1.91 24.61 1.89 24.88 1.87 25.15 1.85 25.42 1.84 25.69 1.82 25.96 1.81 26.23 1.79 26.50 1.77 26.77 1.76 27.04 1.75 27.31 1.73 27.58 1.72 27.85 1.70 28.12 1.69 28.39 2 1 2.90 8.39 7.65 1.66 28.93 2 1 3.00 8.39 7.57 1.65 29.20 2 1 3.10 8.39 7.49 1.64 29.47 2 1 3.20 8.39 7.41 1.62 29.74 2 1 3.30 8.39 7.33 1.61 30.01 2 1 3.40 8.40 7.25 1.60 30.28 2 1 3.50 8.40 7.18 1.59 30.55 2 1 3.60 8.40 7.11 1.58 30.82 2 1 3.70 8.40 7.03 1.56 31.09 2 1 3.80 8.40 6.96 1.55 31.36 2 1 3.90 8.41 6.89 1.54 31.63 2 1 4.00 8.41 6.82 1.53 31.90 2 1 4.10 8.41 6.76 1.52 32.17 2 1 4.20 8.41 6.69 1.51 32.44 2 1 4.30 8.41 6.63 1.50 32.71 2 1 4.40 8.41 6.56 1.49 32.98 2 1 4.50 8.41 6.50 1.48 33.25 2 1 4.60 8.42 6.44 1.47 33.52 2 1 4.70 8.42 6.38 1.46 33.79 2 1 4.80 8.42 6.32 1.45 34.06 2 1 4.90 8.42 6.26 1.44 34.33 2 1 5.00 8.42 6.20 1.43 34.60 2 1 5.10 8.42 6.15 1.42 34.87 2 1 5.20 8.42 6.09 1.41 35.14 2 1 5.30 8.43 6.04 1.40 35.41 2 1 5.40 8.43 5.98 1.40 35.68 2 1 5.50 8.43 5.93 1.39 35.95 2 1 5.60 8.43 5.88 1.38 36.22 2 1 5.70 8.43 5.83 1.37 36.49 2 1 5.80 8.43 5.77 1.36 36.76 2 1 5.90 8.43 5.72 1.35 37.03 2 1 6.00 8.43 5.68 1.34 37.30 2 1 6.10 8.44 5.63 1.34 37.57 2 1 6.20 8.44 5.58 1.33 37.84 2 1 6.30 8.44 5.53 1.32 38.11 2 1 6.40 8.44 5.49 1.31 38.38 2 1 6.50 8.44 5.44 1.31 38.65 2 1 6.60 8.44 5.39 1.30 38.92 2 1 6.70 8.44 5.35 1.29 39.19 2 1 6.80 8.44 5.31 1.28 39.46 2 1 6.90 8.44 5.26 1.28 39.73 2 1 7.00 8.45 5.22 1.27 40.00 2 1 7.10 8.45 5.18 1.26 40.27 2 1 7.20 8.45 5.14 1.26 40.54 2 1 7.30 8.45 5.10 1.25 40.81 2 1 7.40 8.45 5.06 1.24 41.08 2 1 7.50 8.45 5.02 1.24 41.35 2 1 7.60 8.45 4.98 1.23 41.62 2 1 7.70 8.45 4.94 1.22 41.89 2 1 7.80 8.45 4.90 1.22 42.16 2 1 7.90 8.45 4.86 1.21 42.43 2 1 8.00 8.45 4.83 1.20 42.70 2 1 8.10 8.46 4.79 1.20 42.97 2 1 8.20 8.46 4.75 1.19 43.24 2 1 8.30 8.46 4.72 1.18 43.51 2 1 8.40 8.46 4.68 1.18 43.78 2 1 8.50 8.46 4.65 1.17 44.05 3 1 0.00 5.74 14.21 2.73 252.83 3 1 0.20 5.70 14.08 2.71 253.35 3 1 0.40 5.66 13.94 2.69 253.87 3 1 0.60 5.63 13.81 2.67 254.39 3 1 0.80 5.60 13.68 2.66 254.91 3 1 1.00 5.57 13.55 2.64 255.43 3 1 1.20 5.55 13.42 2.62 255.95 3 1 1.40 5.52 13.30 2.61 256.47 -, I • V V .J • OU 1 .7 . i 1 s: s :3:.1 4717 . JV 3 1 1.80 5.48 13.04 2.57 257.51 '3 1 2.00 5,46 12.92 2.56 258.03 3 1 2.20 5.44 12.80 2.54 258.55 3 1 2.40 5.42 12.68 2.53 259.07 3 1 2.60 5.41 12.56 2.51 259.59 3 1 2.80 5.39 12.44 2.49 260.11 3 1 3.00 5.38 12.32 2.48 260.63 3 1 3.20 5.37 12.21 2.46 261.15 3 1 3.40 5.36 12.09 2.45 261.67 3 1 3.60 5.35 11.98 2.43 262.19 3 1 3.80 5.35 11.87 2.42 262.71 3 1 4.00 5.34 11.75 2.40 263.23 3 1 4.20 5.34 11.64 2.39 263.75 3 1 4.40 5.33 11.54 2.37 264.27 3 1 4.60 5.33 11.43 2.36 264.79 3 1 4.80 5.33 11.32 2.34 265.31 3 1 5.00 5.33 11.21 2.33 265.83 3 1 5.20 5.33 11.11 2.31 266.35 3 1 5.40 5.33 11.01 2.30 266.87 3 1 5.60 5.33 10.90 2.28 267.39 3 1 5.80 5.33 10.80 2.27 267.91 3 1 6.00 5.34 10.70 2.26 268.43 3 1 6.20 5.34 10.60 2.24 268.95 3 1 6.40 5.35 10.50 2.23 269.47 3 1 6.60 5.35 10.40 2.21 269.99 3 1 6.80 5.36 10.31 2.20 270.51 3 1 7.00 5.36 10.21 2.19 271.03 3 1 7.20 5.37 10.12 2.17 271.55 3 1 7.40 5.38 10.02 2.16 272.07 3 1 7.60 5.39 9.93 2.15 272.59 3 1 7.80 5.40 9.84 2.13 273.11 3 1 8.00 5.41 9.75 2.12 273.63 3 1 8.20 5.41 9.66 2.11 274.15 3 1 8.40 5.43 9.57 2.09 274.67 3 1 8.60 5.44 9.48 2.08 275.19 3 1 8.80 5.45 9.39 2.07 275.71 3 1 9.00 5.46 9.30 2.06 276.23 3 1 9.20 5.47 9.22 2.04 276.75 3 1 9.40 5.48 9.13 2.03 277.27 3 1 9.60 5.50 9.05 2.02 277.79 3 1 9.80 5.51 8.97 2.01 278.31 3 1 10.00 5.52 8.88 1.99 278.83 3 1 10.20 5.53 8.80 1.98 279.35 3 1 10.40 5.55 8.72 1.97 279.87 3 1 10.60 5.56 8.64 1.96 280.39 3 1 10.80 5.58 8.56 1.95 280.91 3 1 11.00 5.59 8.48 1.94 281.43 3 1 11.20 5.61 8.40 1.92 281.95 3 1 11.40 5.62 8.33 1.91 282.47 3 1 11.60 5.64 8.25 1.90 282.99 3 1 11.80 5.65 8.18 1.89 283.51 3 1 12.00 5.67 8.10 1.88 284.03 3 1 12.20 5.68 8.03 1.87 284.55 3 1 12.40 5.70 7.95 1.86 285.07 3 1 12.60 5.71 7.88 1.84 285.59 3 1 12.80 5.73 7.81 1.83 286.11 3 1 1 13.00 5.75 7.74 1.82 286.63 3 1 13.20 5.76 7.67 1.81 287.15 3 1 13.40 5.78 7.60 1.80 287.67 3 1 13.60 5.79 7.53 1.79 288.19 3 1 13.80 5.81 7.46 1.78 288.71 3 1 14.00 5.83 7.39 1.77 289.23 3 1 14.20 5.84 7.33 1.76 289.75 3 1 14.40 5.86 7.26 1.75 290.27 3 1 14.60 5.88 7.19 1.74 290.79 3 • .3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 Seg # ' 1 15,00 5.91 7.07 1.72 291.83 1 15.20 5.93 7.00 1.71 292.35 1 15.40 5.94 6.94 1.70 292.87 1 15.60 5.96 6.88 1.69 293.39 1 15.80 5.98 6.81 1.68 293.91 1 16.00 5.99 6.75 1.67 294.43 1 16.20 6.01 6.69 1.66 294.95 1 16.40 6.03 6.63 1.65 295.47 1 16.60 6.04 6.57 1.64 295.99 1 16.80 6.06 6.51 1.63 296.51 1 17.00 6.08 6.45 1.62 297.03 1 17.20 6.10 6.40 1.61 297.55 1 17.40 6.11 6.34 1.60 298.07 1 17.60 6.13 6.28 1.59 298.59 1 17.80 6.15 6.23 1.58 299.11 1 18.00 6.16 6.17 1.57 299.63 2 18,00 6.31 5.78 1.52 330.63 2 18.10 6.31 5.76 1.52 330.73 2 18.20 6.32 5.73 1.51 330.83 2 18.30 6.33 5.71 1.51 330.93 2 18.40 6.34 5.69 1.50 331.03 2 18.50 6.34 5.66 1.50 331.13 2 18.60 6.35 5.64 1.50 331.23 2 18.70 6.36 5.62 1.49 331.33 3 18.70 6.51 6.04 2.97 372,33 3 18.80 6.51 6.02 2.96 372.63 3 18.90 6.51 5.99 2.95 372.93 3 19.00 6.51 5.96 2.94 373.23 3 19.10 6.51 5.94 2.93 373.53 3 19.20 6.51 5.91 2.92 373.83 3 19.30 6.51 5.89 2.91 374.13 3 19.40 6.51 5.86 2.91 374.43 3 19.50 6.51 5.83 2.90 374.73 3 19.60 6.51 5.81 2.89 375.03 3 19.70 6.51 5.78 2.88 375,33 3 19.80 6.51 5.76 2.87 375.63 3 19.90 6.51 5.73 2.86 375.93 3 20.00 6.51 5.71 2.85 376.23 3 20.10 6.52 5.68 2.84 376.53 3 20.20 6.52 5.66 2.83 376.83 3 20.30 6.52 5.63 2.83 377.13 4 20.30 6.41 8.61 2.78 383.33 4 20.31 6.41 8.61 2.78 383.34 4 20.31 6.41 8.61 2.78 383.36 4 20.32 6.41 8.61 2.78 383.37 4 20.32 6.41 8.60 2.78 383.39 5 20.32 6.47 8.34 2.71 399.59 5 20.82 6.43 8.16 2.67 400.54 5 21.32 6.40 7.99 2.63 401.49 5 21.82 6.37 7.82 2.59 402.44 5 22.32 6.35 7.66 2.56 403.39 5 22.82 6.34 7.50 2.52 404.34 5 23.32 6.33 7.34 2.48 405.29 5 23.82 6.32 7.19 2.45 406.24 5 24.32 6.32 7.03 2.41 407.19 5 24.82 6.32 6.89 2.38 408.14 5 25.32 6.32 6.74 2.35 409.09 Reach # 1 Seg Mi I D.O. I CBOD I NEOD I Flow I MODEL RESULTS SUMMER MODEL FOR CRANSTON PRINT WORKS @ 1/10 QW & 10X DA. MAX. CBOD Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER The End D.O. is 6.35 mg/1. The End CBOD is 6.84 mg/1. The End NBOD is 2.38 mg/1. WLA WLA WLA DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Mi1epoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.16 Reach 1 Reach 2 Segment 2 6.59 Reach 1 4.45 0.00 2 90.00 45.00 80.00 9.00 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 2.50000 4.00 27.00000 0.00 2.00000 Segment 3 5.33 5.00 1 Reach 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 3 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 4 1899.30 0.00 0.00 0.40000 Reach 5 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 MODEL RESULTS SUMMER MODEL OF FRENCH BROAD & TRIB DISC., CRANSTON NOT INCLUDED Discharger• : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER The End D.O. is 6.72 mg/1. The End CBOD is 4.44 mg/1. The End NBOD is 2.38 mg/1 , W L A W L A W L A DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Mi lepoi nt Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.16 4.45 2 Reach 1 90.00 45.00 0.00 2.50000 Reach 2 80.00 9.00 4.00 27.00000 1 Segment 2 6.59 0.00 1 Reach 1 63.00 9.00 0.00 2.00000 Segment 3 5.33 5.00 1 Reach 1 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 2 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 3 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 4 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 Reach 5 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 *** MODEL SUMMARY DATA *** Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Stream Class: WSIII Summer 7Q10 : 316.0 Design Temperature: 23.0 Subbasi n : 040302 Winter 7Q10 : 390.0 !LENGTH' SLOPE' VELOCITY 1 DEPTH( Kd 1 Kd 1 Ka ( Ka 1 KN I KN 1 KNR 1 KNR 1 SOD 1 SOD ( mile 1 ft/mil fps 1 ft ldesignl @20° 'design l @20° 'design' @20° ldesign l @20° 'design l @20° I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 l l Segment 1 1 0,051 5,001 0.900 1 3.45 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2,13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Segment 1 1 4.401 5.001 0.900 1 3.90 1 0,51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.00 0.00 Reach 2 I 1 I ( 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ( I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 Segment 2 1 8.501 40.001 0.933 1 1,53 1 0,60 1 0.52 135.06 1 32.851 0,63 1 0.50 1 0,63 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I l l I I I I I I I 1 1 1 I Segment 3 18.001 5.001 0,900 4.52 0.57 0.50 2.13 2.001 0.38 0.30 0.38 0,30 0.00 0,00 Reach 1 I I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 3 1 0.101 5.001 0.900 1 4.95 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0,30 1 0.38 1 0,00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 I 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I ! 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I! Segment 3 1 1.601 5.001 0,900 1 5.21 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 3 I I I I I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I l l l l l l l Segment 3 1 0,021 5.001 0.900 1 5.29 1 0.51 1 0.50 1 2.13 ( 2.001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0,00 ( 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 4 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Segment 3 5.001 4,001; 0.900 5,43 0.57 0.50 2.13 2.001 0.38 0,30 0.38 0.00 0.00 0,00 Reach 5 I I 1 Flow 1 CBOD 1 NBOD 1 D. O. I 1 cfs 1 mg/1 1 m9/1 1 mg/1 I Segment 1 Reach 1 Waste 1 3.875 1 90.000 1 45.000 1 0.000 Headwaters 1 157.000 ( 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 Waste 1 41.850 1 80.000 1 9.000 1 4.000 ... • vvv E t• W V v 1 (•( e.. Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Segment 2 Reach 1 Waste I 3.100 1 63.000 Headwaters I 18.000 1 2.000 Tributary 0.000 1 2.000 * Runoff 1 2.700 1 2.000 Segment 3 each 1 Waste 1 0.000 Headwaters I 0.000 Tributary I 0.000 * Runoff 1 2.600 Segment 3 Reach 2 Waste I 0.000 Tributary 131.000 * Runoff 1 1.000 Segment 3 each 3 Waste 0.000 Tributary 41.000 * Runoff 3.000 Segment 3 each 4 Waste 0.000 Tributary 0.000 * Runoff 3.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 2.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 9.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 1 0.000 9.500 1 14.900 2.000 1 1.000 0.000 2.000 2.000 0.000 1.000 1.000 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 0.000 7.720 7.720 Segment 3 each 5 Waste 0.000 0.000 1 0.000 1 0.000 Tributary 16.200 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1.900 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff flow is in cfs/mil e SUMMER MODEL OF FRENCH BROAD & TRIB DISC., CRANSTON NOT INCLUDED 1 Seg # I Reach # 1 Seg M 1 D.O. 1 CBOD 1 NBOD 1 Flow 1 1 1 0.00 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.88 1 1 0.01 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.89 1 1 0.02 7.53 4.12 2.06 160.90 1 1 0.03 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.92 1 1 0.04 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.93 1 1 0.05 7.53 4.11 2.06 160.94 1 2 0.05 6.80 19.77 3.49 202.79 1 2 0.25 6.69 19.59 3.47 203.06 1 2 0.45 6.57 19.42 3.45 203.34 1 2 0.65 6.47 19.25 3.43 203.61 1 2 0.85 6.36 19.07 3.41 203.88 1 2 1.05 6.27 18.90 3.39 204.15 1 2 1.25 6.17 18.73 3.36 204.42 1 2 1.45 6.08 18.57 3.34 204.70 1 2 1.65 6.00 18.40 3.32 204.97 1 2 1.85 5.92 18.24 3.30 205.24 1 2 2.05 5.84 18.07 3.28 205.51 1 2 2.25 5.77 17.91 3.26 205.78 1 2 2.45 5.70 17.75 3.24 206.06 1 2 2.65 5.63 17.59 3.22 206.33 1 2 2.85 5.56 17.44 3.21 206.60 1 2 3.05 5.50 17.28 3.19 206.87 1 2 3.25 5.45 17.13 3.17 207.14 1 2 3.45 5.39 16.97 3.15 207.42 1 2 3.65 5.34 16.82 3.13 207.69 1 2 3.85 5.29 16.67 3.11 207.96 1 2 4.05 5.25 16.52 3.09 208.23 1 2 4.25 5.20 16.38 3.07 208.50 1 2 4.45 5.16 16.23 3.05 208.78 2 1 0.00 6.59 10.96 2.18 21.10 2 1 0.10 6.96 10.81 2.15 21.37 2 1 0.20 7.26 10.65 2.13 21.64 2 1 0.30 7.49 10.51 2.11 21.91 2 1 0.40 7.67 10.36 2.08 22.18 2 1 0.50 7.81 10.22 2.06 22.45 2 1 0.60 7.93 10.08 2.04 22.72 2 1 0.70 8.02 9.95 2.02 22.99 2 1 0.80 8.09 9.82 2.00 23.26 2 1 0.90 8.14 9.69 1.98 23.53 2 1 1.00 8.19 9.57 1.96 23.80 2 1 1.10 8.22 9.45 1.94 24.07 2 1 1.20 8.25 9.33 1.92 24.34 2 1 1.30 8.28 9.21 1.91 24.61 2 1 1.40 8.29 9.10 1.89 24.88 2 1 1.50 8.31 8.98 1.87 25.15 2 1 1.60 8.32 8.88 1.85 25.42 2 1 1.70 8.33 8.77 1.84 25.69 2 1 1.80 8.34 8.66 1.82 25.96 2 1 1.90 8.35 8.56 1.81 26.23 2 1 2.00 8.35 8.46 1.79 26.50 2 1 2.10 8.36 8.36 1.77 26.77 2 1 2.20 8.36 8.27 1.76 27.04 2 1 2.30 8.37 8.17 1.75 27.31 2 1 2.40 8.37 8.08 1.73 27.58 2 1 2.50 8.38 7.99 1.72 27.85 2 1 2.60 8.38 7.90 1.70 28.12 2 1 2.70 8.38 7.82 1.69 28.39 .2 '1 2.90 8.39 7.65 1.66 28.93 2 1 3.00 8.39 7.57 1.65 29.20 2 1 3.10 8.39 7.49 1.64 29.47 2 1 3.20 8.39 7.41 1.62 29.74 2 1 3.30 8.39 7.33 1.61 30.01 2 1 3.40 8.40 7.25 1.60 30.28 2 1 3.50 8.40 7.18 1.59 30.55 2 1 3.60 8.40 7.11 1.58 30.82 2 1 3.70 8.40 7.03 1.56 31.09 2 1 3.80 8.40 6.96 1.55 31.36 2 1 3.90 8.41 6.89 1.54 31.63 2 1 4.00 8.41 6.82 1.53 31.90 2 1 4.10 8.41 6.76 1.52 32.17 2 1 4.20 8.41 6.69 1.51 32.44 2 1 4.30 8.41 6.63 1.50 32.71 2 1 4.40 8.41 6.56 1.49 32.98 2 1 4.50 8.41 6.50 1.48 33.25 2 1 4.60 8.42 6.44 1.47 33.52 2 1 4.70 8.42 6.38 1.46 33.79 2 1 4.80 8.42 6.32 1.45 34.06 2 1 4.90 8.42 6.26 1.44 34.33 2 1 5.00 8.42 6.20 1.43 34.60 2 1 5.10 8.42 6.15 1.42 34.87 2 1 5.20 8.42 6.09 1.41 35.14 2 1 5.30 8.43 6.04 1.40 35.41 2 1 5.40 8.43 5.98 1.40 35.68 2 1 5.50 8.43 5.93 1.39 35.95 2 1 5.60 8.43 5.88 1.38 36.22 2 1 5.70 8.43 5.83 1.37 36.49 2 1 5.80 8.43 5.77 1.36 36.76 2 1 5.90 8.43 5.72 1.35 37.03 2 1 6.00 8.43 5.68 1.34 37.30 2 1 6.10 8.44 5.63 1.34 37.57 2 1 6.20 8.44 5.58 1.33 37.84 2 1 6.30 8.44 5.53 1.32 38.11 2 1 6.40 8.44 5.49 1.31 38.38 2 1 6.50 8.44 5.44 1.31 38.65 2 1 6.60 8.44 5.39 1.30 38.92 2 1 6.70 8.44 5.35 1.29 39.19 2 1 6.80 8.44 5.31 1.28 39.46 2 1 6.90 8.44 5.26 1.28 39.73 2 1 7.00 8.45 5.22 1.27 40.00 2 1 7.10 8.45 5.18 1.26 40.27 2 1 7.20 8.45 5.14 1.26 40.54 2 1 7.30 8.45 5.10 1.25 40.81 2 1 7.40 8.45 5.06 1.24 41.08 2 1 7.50 8.45 5.02 1.24 41.35 2 1 7.60 8.45 4.98 1.23 41.62 2 1 7.70 8.45 4.94 1.22 41.89 2 1 7.80 8.45 4.90 1.22 42.16 2 1 7.90 8.45 4.86 1.21 42.43 2 1 8.00 8.45 4.83 1.20 42.70 2 1 8.10 8.46 4.79 1.20 42.97 2 1 8.20 8.46 4.75 1.19 43.24 2 1 8.30 8.46 4.72 1.18 43.51 2 1 8.40 8.46 4.68 1.18 43.78 2 1 8.50 8.46 4.65 1.17 44.05 3 1 0.00 5.74 14.21 2.73 252.83 3 1 0.20 5.70 14.08 2.71 253.35 3 1 0.40 5.66 13.94 2.69 253.87 3 1 0.60 5.63 13.81 2.67 254.39 3 1 0.80 5.60 13.68 2.66 254.91 3 1 1.00 5.57 13.55 2.64 255.43 3 1 1.20 5.55 13.42 2.62 255.95 3 1 1.40 5.52 13.30 2.61 256.47 ..r i . uu Q . JU 1 .s . 1 ; L . J:;1 L''OU . JJ f. 3 1 1.80 5.48 13.04 2.57 257.51 3 1 2.00 5.46 12.92 2.56 258.03 3 1 2.20 5.44 12.80 2.54 258.55 3 1 2.40 5.42 12.68 2.53 259.07 3 1 2.60 5.41 12.56 2.51 259.59 3 1 2.80 5.39 12.44 2.49 260.11 3 1 3.00 5.38 12.32 2.48 260.63 3 1 3.20 5.37 12.21 2.46 261.15 3 1 3.40 5.36 12.09 2.45 261.67 3 1 3.60 5.35 11.98 2.43 262.19 3 1 3.80 5.35 11.87 2.42 262.71 3 1 4.00 5.34 11.75 2.40 263.23 3 1 4.20 5.34 11.64 2.39 263.75 3 1 4.40 5.33 11.54 2.37 264.27 3 1 4.60 5.33 11.43 2.36 264.79 3 1 4.80 5.33 11.32 2.34 265.31 3 1 5.00 5.33 11.21 2.33 265.83 3 1 5.20 5.33 11.11 2.31 266.35 3 1 5.40 5.33 11.01 2.30 266.87 3 1 5.60 5.33 10.90 2.28 267.39 3 1 5.80 5.33 10.80 2.27 267.91 3 1 6.00 5.34 10.70 2.26 268.43 3 1 6.20 5.34 10.60 2.24 268.95 3 1 6.40 5.35 10.50 2.23 269.47 3 1 6.60 5.35 10.40 2.21 269.99 3 1 6.80 5.36 10.31 2.20 270.51 3 1 7.00 5.36 10.21 2.19 271.03 3 1 7.20 5.37 10.12 2.17 271.55 3 1 7.40 5.38 10.02 2.16 272.07 3 1 7.60 5.39 9.93 2.15 272.59 3 1 7.80 5.40 9.84 2.13 273.11 3 1 8.00 5.41 9.75 2.12 273.63 3 1 8.20 5.41 9.66 2.11 274.15 3 1 8.40 5.43 9.57 2.09 274.67 3 1 8.60 5.44 9.48 2.08 275.19 3 1 8.80 5.45 9.39 2.07 275.71 3 1 9.00 5.46 9.30 2.06 276.23 3 1 9.20 5.47 9.22 2.04 276.75 3 1 9.40 5.48 9.13 2.03 277.27 3 1 9.60 5.50 9.05 2.02 277.79 3 1 9.80 5.51 8.97 2.01 278.31 3 1 10.00 5.52 8.88 1.99 278.83 3 1 10.20 5.53 8.80 1.98 279.35 3 1 10.40 5.55 8.72 1.97 279.87 3 1 10.60 5.56 8.64 1.96 280.39 3 1 10.80 5.58 8.56 1.95 280.91 3 1 11.00 5.59 8.48 1.94 281.43 3 1 11.20 5.61 8.40 1.92 281.95 3 1 11.40 5.62 8.33 1.91 282.47 3 1 11.60 5.64 8.25 1.90 282.99 3 1 11.80 5.65 8.18 1.89 283.51 3 1 12.00 5.67 8.10 1.88 284.03 3 1 12.20 5.68 8.03 1.87 284.55 3 1 12.40 5.70 7.95 1.86 285.07 3 1 12.60 5.71 7.88 1.84 285.59 3 1 12.80 5.73 7.81 1.83 286.11 3 1 13.00 5.75 7.74 1.82 286.63 3 1 13.20 5.76 7.67 1.81 287.15 3 1 13.40 5.78 7.60 1.80 287.67 3 1 13.60 5.79 7.53 1.79 288.19 3 1 13.80 5.81 7.46 1.78 288.71 3 1 14.00 5.83 7.39 1.77 289.23 3 1 14.20 5.84 7.33 1.76 289.75 3 1 14.40 5.86 7.26 1.75 290.27 3 1 14.60 5.88 7.19 1.74 290.79 3 1 15.00 5.91 7.07 1.72 291.83 3 1 15.20 5.93 7.00 1.71 292.35 3 1 15.40 5.94 6.94 1.70 292,87 3 1 15.60 5.96 6.88 1.69 293.39 3 1 15.80 5.98 6.81 1.68 293.91 3 1 16.00 5.99 6.75 1.67 294.43 3 1 16.20 6.01 6.69 1.66 294.95 3 1 16.40 6.03 6.63 1.65 295.47 3 1 16.60 6.04 6.57 1.64 295.99 3 1 16.80 6.06 6.51 1.63 296.51 3 1 17,00 6.08 6.45 1.62 297.03 3 1 17.20 6.10 6.40 1.61 297.55 3 1 17.40 6.11 6.34 1.60 298.07 3 1 17.60 6.13 6.28 1.59 298.59 3 1 17.80 6.15 6.23 1.58 299.11 3 1 18.00 6.16 6.17 1.57 299.63 3 2 18.00 6.31 5.78 1.52 330.63 3 2 18.10 6.31 5.76 1.52 330.73 3 2 18.20 6.32 5.73 1.51 330.83 3 2 18.30 6.33 5.71 1.51 330.93 3 2 18.40 6.34 5.69 1.50 331.03 3 2 18.50 6.34 5.66 1.50 331.13 3 2 18.60 6.35 5.64 1.50 331.23 3 2 18.70 6.36 5.62 1.49 331.33 3 3 18.70 6.51 6.04 2.97 372.33 3 3 18.80 6.51 6.02 2.96 372.63 3 3 18.90 6.51 5.99 2.95 372.93 3 3 19.00 6.51 5.96 2.94 373.23 3 3 19.10 6.51 5.94 2.93 373.53 3 3 19.20 6.51 5.91 2.92 373.83 3 3 19.30 6.51 5.89 2.91 374.13 3 3 19.40 6.51 5.86 2.91 374.43 3 3 19.50 6.51 5.83 2.90 374.73 3 3 19.60 6.51 5.81 2.89 375.03 3 3 19.70 6.51 5.78 2.88 375.33 3 3 19.80 6.51 5.76 2.87 375.63 3 3 19.90 6.51 5.73 2.86 375,93 3 3 20.00 6.51 5.71 2.85 376.23 3 3 20.10 6.52 5.68 2.84 376.53 3 3 20.20 6.52 5.66 2.83 376.83 3 3 20.30 6.52 5.63 2.83 377.13 3 4 20.30 6.52 5.63 2.83 377.13 3 4 20.31 6.52 5.63 2.83 377.14 3 4 20.31 6.52 5.63 2.82 377.16 3 4 20.32 6.52 5.63 2.82 377.17 3 4 20.32 6.52 5.63 2.82 377.19 3 5 20.32 6.57 5.48 2.75 393.39 3 5 20.82 6.58 5.36 2.71 394.34 3 5 21.32 6.59 5.25 2.67 395.29 3 5 21.82 6.60 5.14 2.63 396.24 3 5 22.32 6.61 5.04 2.60 397.19 3 5 22.82 6.63 4.93 2.56 398.14 3 5 23.32 6.64 4.83 2.52 399.09 3 5 23.82 6.66 4.73 2.49 400.04 3 5 24.32 6.68 4.63 2.45 400.99 3 5 24.82 6.70 4.54 2.42 401.94 3 5 25.32 6.72 4.44 2.38 402.89 Seg # I Reach it I Seg Mi I D.O. I CBOD I NBOD 1 Flow I MODEL RESULTS )L tiur3 red, UMMER 44 w�,ei :4i,3 pa r C�=3F'3/'e Discharger : CRANSTCON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER The End D.O. The End CBOD is 5.56 mg/1. The End NBOD is 2.35 mg/1. WLA WLA WLA DO Min CBOD NBOD DO Waste Flow (mg/1) Milepoint Reach # (mg/1) (mg/1) (mg/1) (mgd) Segment 1 5.16 4.45 2 Reach 1 Reach 2 Segment 2 6.59 0.00 Reach 1 Segment 3 5.33 5.00 1 Reach Reach 2 Reach 3 Reach 4 Reach 5 90.00 45.00 0.00 2.50000 80.00 9.00 4.00 27.00000 63.00 9.00 0.00 2.00000 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 94.95 0.00 0.00 4.00000 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00000 *** MODEL SUMMARY DATA >** Discharger : CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY Subbasin : 040302 Receiving Stream : FRENCH BROAD RIVER Stream Class: WSIII Summer 7Q10 : 316.0 Design Temperature: 23.0 Winter 7Q10 : 390.0 ILENGTHI SLOPE' VELOCITY 1 DEPTH' Kd 1 Kd 1 Ka 1 Ka I KN I KN 1 K11R 1 KNR 1 SOD 1 SOD l mile 1 ft/mil fps 1 ft Idesign l @20° 'design l @20° (design' @20° Idesign l @20° 'design l @20° I i I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 1 I 0.051 5,001 0.900 13.45 1 0,57 1 0.50 1 2,13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0.30 1 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 1 1 4.401 5.001 0.900 1 3,90 1 0,51 1 0,50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0,00 Reach 2 1 I I' I I Segment 2 1 8.501 40.001 0.933 1 1,53 1 0,60 1 0.52 135,06 1 32.851 0.63 1 0.50 1 0.63 1 0,00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I l I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 3 1 18,001 5.001 0.900 1 4,52 1 0,57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0.30 1 0.38 1 0.30 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I 1 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I Segment 3 1 0.701 5,001 0,900 1 4,95 1 0,57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0.38 1 0.00 1 0.00 1 0.00 Reach 2 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I Segment 3 1 1.601 5,001 0.900 1 5,27 1 0.57 1 0,50 12,13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0,38 1 0.00 1 0,00 1 0,00 Reach 3 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I' I l l l l l l l l l l Segment 3 1 0.021 5.001 0.900 1 5,33 1 0,57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0.38 1 0,30 1 0,38 1 0.00 10.00 1 0,00 Reach 4 I I I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I I 11 I i! 1 1 1 1 1 Segment 3 1 5,001 4.001 , 0.900 1 5.47 1 0,57 1 0.50 1 2.13 1 2.001 0,38 1 0,30 1 0.38 1 0,00 10,00 10.00 Reach 5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Flow 1 AGOG 1 N BOD I D.O. I 1 cfs mg/1 1 m9/1 1 mg/1 I Segment 1 'each 1 Waste I 3.875 I 90.000 1 45.000 I0.000 HeadtA+ater s 1 157.000 I 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Tributary 1 0.000 1 2.000 I 1.000 1 7.720 * Runoff 1 1.360 1 2.000 1 1.000 1 7.720 Segment 1 Reach 2 toast i 41.050 I 80.000 1 9.000 1 4.000 :•� �-� •..� 7 1 bJ • I C.. • V L! V I 1 . ll V ill 1 i ( c, ll .* Runoff I 1.360 j 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Segment 2 Reach 1 Waste 1 3.100 163.000 j 9.000 I 0.000 Headwaters' 18.000 I 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Tr•ilbutary 1 0.000 I 2.000 ( 1.000 j 7.720 * Runoff j 2.700 j 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Segpment 3 Reach 1 Waste j 0.000 Hea`,dwaters I 0.000 Tributary 1 0.000 * Runoff I 2.600 0.000 j 0.000 j 0.000 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 2.000 I 1.000 j 7.720 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Segment 3 Reach 2 Waste I 0.000 j 0.000 I 0.000 j 0.000 Tributary j 31.000 I 2.000 j 1.000 j 7.720 * Runoff I 1.000 I 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 1 , Segment 3 Reach 3 Waste I 0.000 ( 0.000 I 0.000 I 0.000 Tri i'?utary I 41.000 ! 9.500 I 14.900 I 3.850 * Rirnoff I 3.000 I 2.000 ( 1.000 j 7.720 Segment 3 Reach 4 Waste I 6.200 194.950 I 0.000 I 0.000 Tributary I 0.000 I 2.000 j 1.000 I 7.720 * Runoff 1 3.000 ( 2.000 I 1.000 I 7.720 Segment 3 Reach 5 Waste I 0.000 j 0.000 I 0.000 Tributary utary 11 6.200 I 2.000 I 1.000 * Runoff I 1.900 1 2.000 I 1.000 * Runoff flow is in cfs/mile 0.000 7.720 7.720 Seg * I Reach 4#: I Beg Mi 1 D.O. 1 1 0.00 7.53 1 1 0.01 7.53 1 1 0.02 7.53 1 1 0.03 7.53 1 1 0.04 7.53 1 1 0.05 7.53 1 2 0.05 6.80 1 2 0.25 6.69 1 2 0.45 6.57 1 2 0.65 6.47 1 2 0.85 6.36 1 2 1.05 6.27 1 2 1.25 6.17 1 2 1.45 6.08 1 2 1.65 6.00 1 2 1.85 5.92 1 2 2.05 5.84 1 2 2.25 5.77 1 2 2.45 5.70 1 2 2.65 5.63 1 2 2.85 5.56 1 2 3.05 5.50 1 2 3.25 5.45 1 2 3.45 5.39 1 2 3.65 5.34 1 2 3.85 5.29 1 2 4.05 5.25 1 2 4.25 5.20 1 2 4.45 5.16 2 1 0.00 6.59 2 1 0.10 6.96 2 1 0.20 7.26 2 1 0.30 7.49 2 1 0.40 7.67 2 1 0.50 7.81 2 1 0.60 7.93 2 1 0.70 8.02 2 1 0.80 8.09 2 1 0.90 8.14 2 1 1.00 8.19 2 1 1.10 8.22 2 1 1.20 8.25 2 1 1.30 8.28 2 1 1.40 8.29 2 1 1.50 8.31 2 1 1.60 8.32 2 1 1.70 8.33 2 1 1.80 8.34 2 1 1.90 8.35 2 1 2.00 8.35 2 1 2.10 8.36 2 1 2.20 8.36 2 1 2.30 8.37 2 1 2.40 8.37 2 1 2.50 8.38 2 1 2.60 8.38 2 1 2.70 8.38 A M i'1 E R CBOD I Neoo 4.12 2.06 4.12 2.06 4.12 2.06 4.11 2.06 4.11 2.06 4.11 2.06 19.77 3.49 19.59 3.47 19.42 3.45 19.25 3.43 19.07 3.41 18.90 3.39 18.73 3.36 18.57 3.34 18.40 3.32 18.24 3.30 18.07 3.28 17.91 3.26 17.75 3.24 17.59 3.22 17.44 3.21 17.28 3.19 17.13 3.17 16.97 3.15 16.82 3. 1 3 16.67 3.11 16.52 3.09 16.38 3.07 16.23 3.05 10.96 2.18 10.81 2.15 10.65 2.13 10.51 2.11 10.36 2.08 10.22 2.06 10.08 2.04 9.95 2.02 9.82 2.00 9.69 1.98 9.57 1.96 9.45 1.94 9.33 1.92 9.21 1.91 9.10 1.89 8.98 1.87 8.88 1.85 8.77 1.84 8.66 1.82 8.56 1.81 8.46 1.79 8.36 1.77 8.27 1.76 8.17 1.75 8.08 1.73 7.99 1.72 7.90 1.70 7.82 1.69 Flow I 160.88 160.89 160.90 160.92 160.93 160.94 202.79 203.06 203.34 203.61 203.88 204.15 204.42 204.70 204.97 205.24 205.51 205.78 206.06 206.33 206.60 206.87 207.14 207 .42 207.69 207.96 208.23 208.50 208.78 21.10 21.37 21.64 21.91 22.18 22.45 22.72 22.99 23.26 23.53 23.80 24.07 24.34 24.61 24.88 25.15 25.42 25.69 25.96 26.23 26.50 26.77 27.04 27.31 27.58 27.85 28.12 28.39 2 - 1 2• 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 'I 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 'I 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 'l 2 1 2 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2• 1 2 2 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 Tvw s w W W. .J V 2.90 3.00 3.10 3.20 3.30 3.40 3.50 3.60 3.70 3.80 3.90 4.00 4.10 4.20 4.30 4.40 4.50 4.60 4.70 4.80 4.90 5.00 5.10 5.20 5.30 5.40 5.50 5.60 5.70 5.80 5.90 6.00 6.10 6.20 6.30 6.40 6.50 6.60 6.70 6.80 6.90 7.00 7.10 7.20 7.30 7.40 7.50 7.60 7.70 7.80 7.90 8.00 8.10 8.20 8.30 8.40 8.50 0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00 1.20 1.40 8.39 8.39 8.39 8.39 8.39 8.40 8.40 8.40 8.40 8.40 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 8.41 �8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.42 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.43 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.44 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.45 8.46 8.46 8.46 8.46 8.46 5.74 5.70 5.66 5.63 5.60 5.57 5.55 5.52 ( f f a 7.65 7.57 7.49 7.41 7.33 7.25 7.18 7.11 7.03 6.96 6.89 6.82 6.76 6.69 6.63 6.56 6.50 6.44 6.38 6.32 6.26 6.20 6.15 6.09 6.04 5.98 5.93 5.88 5.83 5.77 5.72 5.68 5.63 5.58 5.53 5.49 5.44 5.39 5.35 5.31 5.26 5.22 5.18 5.14 5.10 5.06 5.02 4.98 4.94 4.90 4.86 4.83 4.79 4.75 4.72 4.68 4.65 14.21 14.08 13.94 13.81 13.68 13.55 13.42 13.30 1.66 1.65 1.64 1.62 1.61 1.60 1.59 1.58 1.56 1.55 1.54 1.53 1.52 1.51 1.50 1.49 1.48 1.47 1.46 1.45 1.44 1.43 1.42 1.41 1.40 1.40 1.39 1.38 1.37 1.36 1.35 1.34 1.34 1.33 1.32 1.31 1.31 1.30 1.29 1.28 1.28 1.27 1.26 1.26 1.25 1.24 1.24 1.23 1.22 1.22 1.21 1.20 1.20 1.19 1.18 1.18 1.17 2.73 2.71 2.69 2.67 2.66 2.64 2.62 2.61 G V • V U 28.93 29.20 29.47 29.74 30.01 30.28 30.55 30.82 31.09 31.36 31.63 31.90 32.17 32.44 32.71 32.98 33.25 33.52 33.79 34.06 34.33 34.60 34.87 35.14 35.41 35.68 35.95 36.22 36.49 36.76 37.03 37.30 37.57 37.84 38.11 38.38 38.65 38.92 39.19 39.46 39.73 40.00 40.27 40.54 40.81 41.08 41.35 41.62 41.89 42.16 42.43 42.70 42.97 43.24 43.51 43.78 44.05 252.83 253.35 253.87 254.39 254.91 255.43 255.95 256.47 3 1 1.80 5.48 13.04 2.57 257.51 3: 1j 2.00 5.46 12.92 2.56 258.03 3 1' 2.20 5.44 12.80 2.54 258.55 3 1 2.40 5.42 12.68 2.53 259.07 3 1 2.60 5.41 12.56 2.51 259.59 3 1 2.80 5.39 12.44 2.49 260.11 3 1 3.00 5.38 12.32 2.48 260.63 3 1 3.20 5.37 12.21 2.46 261.15 3 1 3.40 5.36 12.09 2.45 261.67 3 1 3.60 5.35 11.98 2.43 262.19 3 1 3.80 5.35 11.87 2.42 262.71 3 1 4.00 5.34 11.75 2.40 263.23 3 1 4.20 5.34 11.64 2.39 263.75 3 1 4.40 5.33 11.54 2.37 264.27 3 1 4.60 5.33 11.43 2.36 264.79 3 1 4.80 5.33 11.32 2.34 265.31 3 1 5.00 5.33 11.21 2.33 265.83 3 1 5.20 5.33 11.11 2.31 266.35 3 1 5.40 5.33 11.01 2.30 266.87 3 1 5.60 5.33 10.90 2.28 267.39 3 1 5.80 5.33 10.80 2.27 267.91 3 1 6.00 5.34 10.70 2.26 268.43 3 1 6.20 5.34 10.60 2.24 268.95 3 1 6.40 5.35 10.50 2.23 269.47 3 1 6.60 5.35 10.40 2.21 269.99 3 1 6.80 5.36 10.31 2.20 270.51 3 1 7.00 5.36 10.21 2.19 271.03 3 1 7.20 5.37 10.12 2.17 271.55 3 1 7.40 5.38 10.02 2.16 272.07 3 1 7.60 5.39 9.93 2.15 272.59 3 1 7.80 5.40 9.84 2.13 273.11 3 1 8.00 5.41 9.75 2.12 273.63 3 1 8.20 5.41 9.66 2.11 274.15 3 1 8.40 5.43 9.57 2.09 274.67 3 1 8.60 5.44 9.48 2.08 275.19 3 1 8.80 5.45 9.39 2.07 275.71 3 1 9.00 5.46 9.30 2.06 276.23 3 1 9.20 5.47 9.22 2.04 276.75 3 1 9.40 5.48 9.13 2.03 277.27 3 1 9.60 5.50 9.05 2.02 277.79 3 1 9.80 5.51 8.97 2.01 278.31 3 1 10.00 5.52 8.88 1.99 278.83 3 1 10.20 5.53 8.80 1.98 279.35 3 1 10.40 5.55 8.72 1.97 279.87 3 1 10.60 5.56 8.64 1.96 280.39 3 1 10.80 5.58 8.56 1.95 280.91 3 1 11.00 5.59 8.48 1.94 281.43 3 1 11.20 5.61 8.40 1.92 281.95 3 1 11.40 5.62 8.33 1.91 282.47 3 1 11.60 5.64 8.25 1.90 282.99 3 1 11.80 5.65 8.18 1.89 283.51 3 1 12.00 5.67 8.10 1.88 284.03 3 1 12.20 5.68 8.03 1.87 284.55 3 1 12.40 5.70 7.95 1.86 285.07 3 1 12.60 5.71 7.88 1.84 285.59 3 1 12.80 5.73 7.81 1.83 286.11 3 1 13.00 5.75 7.74 1.82 286.63 3 1 13.20 5.76 7.67 1.81 287.15 3 1 13.40 5.78 7.60 1.80 287.67 3 1 13.60 5.79 7.53 1.79 288.19 3 1 13.80 5.81 7.46 1.78 288.71 3 1 14.00 5.83 7.39 1.77 289.23 3 1 14.20 5.84 7.33 1.76 289.75 3 1 14.40 5.86 7.26 1.75 290.27 3 1 14.60 5.88 7.19 1.74 290.79 , .. -� > :� •, l a I l i - J 1. 3 1 3 1 15.00 5.91 7.07 1.72 291.83 3. 1 15.20 5.93 7.00 1.71 292.35 3 1 15.40 5.94 6.94 1.70 292,87 3 1 15.60 5.96 6.88 1.69 293.39 3 1 15.E0 5.98 6.81 1.68 293.91 3 1 16.00 5.99 6.75 1.67 294.43 3 1 16.20 6.01 6.69 1.66 294.95 3 1 16.40 6.03 6.63 1.65 295,47 3 1 16.60 6.04 6.57 1.64 295.99 3 1 16.80 6.06 6.51 1.63 296.51 3 1 17.00 6.08 6.45 1.62 297.03 3 1 17.20 6.10 6.40 1.61 297.55 3 1 17.40 6.11 6.34 1.60 298.07 3 1 17.60 6.13 6.28 1.59 298.59 3 1 17.80 6.15 6.23 1.58 299.11 3 1 18.00 6.16 6.17 1.57 299.63 3 2 1E.00 6.31 5.78 1.52 330.63 3 2 18.10 6.31 5.76 1.52 330.73 3 2 18.20 6.32 5.73 1.51 330.83 3 2 18.30 6.33 5.71 1.51 330.93 3 2 18.40 6.34 5.69 1.50 331.03 3 2 18.50 6.34 5.66 1.50 331.13 3 2 18.60 6.35 5.64 1.50 331.23 3 2 18.70 6._1 5.62 1.49 331.33 ,/10 3 3 18 _2t_-< 6.08 ->6.n4 2.97 3 2.33 po =2 z L� ab 3 3 18.80 5. J 6.02 2.96 372.63 6•.�/�� 3 3 18.90 6.09 5.99 2.95 372.93 3 3 19.00 6.10 5.96 2.94 373.23 3 3 19.10 6.11 5.94 2.93 373.53 3 3 19.20 6.11 5.91 2.92 373.83 3 3 19.30 6.12 5.89 2.91 374.13 3 3 19.40 6.13 5.86 2.91 374.43 3 3 19.50 6.13 5.83 2.90 374.73 3 3 19.60 6.14 5.81 2.$9 375.03 3 3 19.70 6.15 5.78 2.88 375.33 3 3 19.80 6.15 5.76 2.87 375.63 3 3 19.90 6.16 5.73 2.86 375.93 3 3 20.00 6.17 5.71 2.85 376.23 3 3 20.10 6.17 5.68 2.84 376.53 3 3 20.20 6.18 5.66 2.83 376.83 3 3 20.30 6.19 5.63 2.83 377.13 3 4 20.30 6.09 7.08 2.78 383.33 3 4 20.31 6.09 7.07 2.78 383.34 3 4 20.31 6.09 7.07 2.78 383.36 3 4 20.32 6.09 7.07 2.78 383.37 3 4 20.32 6.09 7.07 2.78 383.39 3 5 20.32 6.15 6.86 2.71 399.59 3 5 20.82 6.16 6.72 2.67 400.54 3 5 21.32 6.18 6.58 2.63 401.49 3 5 21.82 6.20 6.44 2.59 402.44 3 5 22.3'> 6.21 6.31 2.56 403.39 3 5 22.82 6.23 6.18 2.52 404.34 3 5 23.32 6.26 6.05 2.48 40529 3 5 23.82 6.28 5.92 2.45 4 0 6.. 2 4 3 5 24.32 6.30 5.80 2.41 407.19 3 5 24.82 6.33 5.68 2.38 408.14 3 5 25.32 6.35 5.56 2.35 409.09 Seg 1 I Reach ## I Seg Mi I D.O. I CBOD I NBOD I Flow State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Asheville Regional Office James G. Martin, Governor S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION MEMORANDUM TO: THROUGH: January 25, 1988 Arthur Mouberry, Supervisor Permits and Engineering Section Roy M. Davis, Regional Supervisor Division of Environmental Management Forrest R. Westall Regional Water Quality'(�,t+�€ir isor FROM: Gary T. Tweed F.E. ,: vironmcntai Engineer Water Quality Section SUBJECT: Modification of NPDES Permit Number NC0000094 Cranston Print Works Fletcher Division Henderson County, North Carolina JAq IS;til \'mm As you are aware, the Division has been working with Cranston Print Works over the past few years to resolve a permit adjudication of NPDES Permit Number NC0000094. The adjudication was handled through issuance of a SOC allowing time to study and develop recommendations covering phenols limitations as contained in the NPDES Permit. After many months, the Division, Cranston and the Division of Human Resources has reached agreement on phenols limitations and monitoring require- ments. These were transmitted to the Company on October 14, 1987 (copy enclosed). Cranston has agreed to these modifications (see January 8, 1988 response) and ask that the Division proceed with modification. Once issued Cranston will request the SOC to be voided and withdraw adjudication request. It is recommended that the Division reissue NPDES Permit Number NC0000094 with the proposed modifications. Should there be any questions, please advise. GTT:ls Enclosure Interchange Building, 59 Woodfin Place, P,O. Box 370, Asheville, N.C. 28802-0370 • Telephone 704-253-3341 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Employer L.. CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY CORPORATE OFFICES 1381 CRANSTON STREET, CRANSTON, R. I. 02920 TEL. 401-943-4800 January 8, '1988 Gary T. Tweed, P.E. Asheville Regional Office Dept. of Natural Resources and Community Development P.O. Box 370 Asheville, NC 28802-0370 SUBJECT: MODIFICATION OF NPDES PERMIT NUMBER NC0000094 CRANSTON PRINT WORKS - FLETCHER DIVISION HENDERSON COUNTY Dear Mr.. Tweed: Thank you for your letter of October 14, 1987 containing revisions to draft permit modifications. We agree with these modifications and agree that D.E.M. should proceed with their issuance. When we receive these modifications, we will request that the Special Order by Consent be voided. We appreciate thc efforts made by the Asheville Regional Office in securing these modifications to the phenol effluent limits. The enclosed table shows the results of GS analyses on three effluent samples taken in November and December 1987.. WFT/np CC. G. Shuster W. Perron H. Donaldson T. Rust file A. Palazzo J. Grant D. Greene Sincerely, r:%!7-- L, -, i -+- William F. Turner Senior Environmental Chemist CRANSTON PRINT WORKS COMPANY WEBSTER DIVISION PHENOLIC COMPOUNDS BY GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY Compound (Parameter) Proposed Permit Limits Effluent Samples 11/19/87 11/30/87 12/7/87 lbs/d ug/L lbs/d ug/L lbs/d ug/L lbs/d . Avg Max- 4-chloro-3-methyl phenol . 3.54 7.08 ND 5.4 0.6 ND 4-chloro-2-methyl phenol 3.54 7.08 ND ND ND 2,4-di methyl phenol 0.17 0.34 ND ND ND naphthol 5.5 0.08 4.0 0.04 ND "phenols" by amino antipyrene test method ND = Not Detected ' 2(' i. 7 State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Division of Environmental Management 512 North Salisbury Street • Raleigh, North Carolina 27611 James G. Martin, Governor R. Paul Wilms S. Thomas Rhodes, Secretary Director CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED Mr. R. J. Gussman, Director Environmental Affairs Ecusta Division P. H. Glatfelter Company P. O. Box 200 Pisgah Forest, North Carolina Subject: Dear Mr. Gussman: November 9, 1987 28768 NPDES Permit No. NC0000078 Groundwater Monitoring Modification Ecusta Division P. 11. Glatfelter Company Transylvania County, North Carolina I have before me your September 24, 1987, letter with attachment in which you request modification of the groundwater monitoring requirements contained in NPDES Permit No. NC0000078. After reviewing your letter and accompanying data, I am modifying the groundwater monitoring section of the permit to read as follows: The wells shall be sampled three times a year during the months of March, July, and November, for pH, total ammonia (TA), total dissolved solids (TDS), sulfate, and sodium. A measure- ment of water level must be made prior to sampling. The wells shall also be sampled once a year during the month of November for total organic carbon (TOC) and total organic halides (TOX). Pollution Prevention Pays PO. Box 27687, Raleigh, North Carolina 27611-7687 Telephone 9I9-733-7015 An Equal Opportunity Affirmative Action Empfoyer Mr. R. J. Gussman Page 2 November 9, 1987 The analytical methods used for TOX st b capable of detecting the total of all uhaloe genated organic compounds present at a concentration of 5.0 parts per billion (ppb) or greater. Any organic compound presentnatvad�ol halogenated at or above the method detection nlimita MDn must be identified, quantified, and re orted with the sampling results. P d If the conditions of this modification have the right to an adjudicatory hearing are unacceptable to you, order to request such a hearing before a hearing officer. you within 30 days of receipt of this you modific sendust In your request tot the Director issues being contended, modification, identifying the specific Unless such a request is made, c shall be final and binding. If this modification Don Linkyatou have any questions concerning (704) 253-3341, this matter, please contact Mr. Sincerely, ( • 6A-A/ R. Paul Wilms cc: Bob Cheek Dr. George Everett Roy Davis State of North Carolina Department of Natural Resources and Community Development Asheville Regional Office James G. Martin, Governor S. Thomas Rhodes, secrer:y DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT WATER QUALITY SECTION October 14, 1987 Mr. William Turner Senior Environmental Chemist Cranston Print Works 1381 Cranston Street Cranston, R. I. 02920 Subject: Modification to NPDES Permit Number NC0000094 Cranston Print Works - Fletcher Division Henderson County Dear Mr. Turner: In follow-up to our telephone conversation of October 14, 1987, please find enclosed revisions to draft permit modifications previously sent to you on September 10, 1987. Proposed limitations for the following phenolic compounds have been established at levels well below EPA developed taste and odor criteria yet sufficient to allow compliance based on sampling and analyses results to date: Compound. 4-chloro-3-methvl phenol 4-chloro-2-methyl phenol 2, 4-di methyl phenol Peak Sampling Taste and Odor Recommended Data Criteria Limitations 130 ug/1 130 ug/1 4 ug/1 Limitations have been established concentration and based on flow of 2.5 3000 ug/1 1800 ug/1 400 ug/1 in mass MGD and 170 ug/1 .17 ug/1 8 Ug/1 rather than will be as, follows: r =,102d0./0 u i. _;+1.•. 7ur1:. `•;i William Turner October 14, 1987 Page Two 4-chloro-3-methyl phenol 4-chloro-2-methyl phenol 2, 4-di methyl phenol KG/day(lbs/day) Daily Avg. Daily Max. 1.51(3.54) 3.22(7.08) 1.61(3.54) 3.22(7.08) 0.08(0.17) 0.16(0.34) Please review these modifications and advise this office if you are in agreement with the Divisions plan to proceed with issuance of permit modifications. Should there by any questions, please contact this office. GTT:is Enclosure xc: Bill Kreutzberger Ted Taylor Dick Casper Sincerely yours, Gary . Tweed, P.E. Environmental Engineer DIVISION OF ENViRONMENTAi, MANAGEMENT ASHEVII,l,E REGIONAL OFFICE GROIiNDWATER SECTION October 13, 1987 MEMORANDUM TO: R. Paul Wilms, Director Division of Environmental Manngement THROUGH: Bob Cheek, Supervisor Permit & Compliance Unit PC Groundwater Sect:ion Roy M. Davis, Regional Supervisor Division of Environmental Mnnngement FROM: Don Link, Hydr.ogeologicnl Reginttnl. Supervisor Groundwater Section SUBJECT: N1'I)E.S Permit_ No. N(:OI)(u)078 ('roandwnter 1.1oni torinn Ecusta Division P. H. Glatfelter Company Transylvania County, North Carolina on- ••• if/ 10f: After reviewing the attached letter and tint a from R. J. Gassman, Director of Environmental Affairs for the Ecusta Division, P. H. Glatfelter Compnny, it is my recommendation that- the changes in the groundwater monitor- ing requirements in NPDES Permit No. N(.0000078 as suggested by Mr. Cussman he adopted. 'These rhnnges delete n i trntes, phenols, chloroform, and methlyene chloride from the compliance pnrnmet-ers, reduce the frequency of TOC to once per year and ncld TOX as n sampling parameter once per year. The permit should be modified to rend "The wells shallhe sampled three times a year during the months of March, July, and November for pH, total ammonia (TA), total dissolved solids ('TDS), sulfate, and sodium. A measurement of wager levelmast he made prior to sampling. The wells shall also be sampled once a year during the month of November for tot:al orgnn i c carbon (TOC) and total organic hnl i Iles (TOX) . The an,nlvticnlmethods used for TOX mast be capable of detecting the total of all halogenated organic compounds present at a concentration of 5.0 parts per billion (pph) or greater. Any individualhalogenated organic compound present nt n concentration at or above the method detect ion 1. imi t (MDL) must he identified, quantified, and reported with the sampling results." • DL:ar Attachment • • I • MEMORANDUM TO: Doug Finan, NPDES Permits Group THROUGH: Roy M. Davis, Regional Supervisor Forrest Westal l , Regional Engineer FROM: SUBJECT: Gary T. Tweed, P.E., Z' '4f Environmental Engineer " /'' Adjudicatory Hearing Request Cranston Print Works Company NPDES Permit No. NC0000094 Henderson County, North Carolina DIVISION OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT ASHEVILLE REGIONAL OFFICE WATER QUALITY SECTION December 3, 1984 �cJ G/zvi5 On November 29, 1984, subject adjudication request was discussed with Mr. i:i1 i am. F. Turner of;C.-anstoh Print 4;.r,.:>. Items 2, 5, ano 4 ilr 1984, request referencing flow, pH, and fecal coliform have been resolved, yet will require slight modification and reissuance of the effluent limitations page of NPDES Permit No. NC0000094. An effluent page has been prepared with the re- quired modifications which are as follows: 1. Daily average flow has been established at 4.0 MGD. The Company, through its spill control procedures, will route some storm water flow to the wastewater system. The 4.0 MGD is necessary in order to manage this system properly. 4.0 MGD was contained in the previous permit. 2. phenols have been changed to mass limitations based on current waste - load allocation usinc 2.5 MGD. The pH stream monitoring frequency has been changed to monthly to match stream sampling for BOD and COD. 4 Effluent monitoring has been added for fecal coliform. The above items ha`: e been incorporated into Cranston's Permit, and settle adjudication request on these items. Reissuance can be acecmpl fi shed without ' public notice since mass limitations have not changed. Memorandum Page Two December 3, 1984 With respect to a time schedule to allow compliance with phenols limita- tions, this can be accomplished only through an SOC. The Company has been •'requested: to provide . i. s with a sch.du1 e . /I n SOC will hi? 0-afte', ar': once acreer upon by the Company, forwarded to the Raleigh staff to be issued. It is recommended that the revised effluent page be issued as -soon sas pos- sible. Should there be any questions, please advise. /pf Attachment