20060798 Ver 2_Staff Report_20070827

Staff Report
Project Num: 20060798 Version: 2
Name: Bill's Mountain
County: Rutherford
Location: UT Bills Creek & UT Broad River BRD basin Lake Lure
Latitude: +35°26'15"
SW Plan Location:
Owner: Wennerstrom, Stig
Contact Person: Wennerstrom, Stig Title:
Status: Received
Project Type: Other
Region: Asheville
Longitude: -82°08'34"
Phone: [phone]
Inspection Date: 08/27/2007 Entry Time: 08:00 AM Exit Time: 08:01 AM
Reason for Inspection: Routine Inspection Type: Staff Report
On-Site Representative(s):
Primary Inspector: Kevin H Barnett Phone: [phone] Ext.4657
Secondary Inspector(s):
Question Areas:
Site Visit
Inspection Summary:
ARO recommends denial based upon:
1) No data to show stream standard of Temperature would not be violated as required by 15A NCAC 15A 02H .0506.
2) No data to show that stream standard of dissolved oxygen would not be violated as required by 15A NCAC 15A 02H .0506.
3) Failure to prove "purpose and need" as required by application.
4) Failure to show "avoidance and minimization" as required by application.
5) NC DWR recommendation for denial.
Page: 1

Project Num: 20060798 Owner: Wennerstrom, Stig
Inspection Date: 08/27/2007 Inspection Type: Staff Report Reason for Visit: Routine
Site Visit Yes No NA NE
Do impacts described in the application differ those seen in the field? ^ ^ ^ ^
If yes, please describe differences:
Are the Intermittent/Perennial calls different in the application? ^ ^ ^ ^
If yes, please describe differences, and how mitigation ratios are affected:
Are there additional impacts not described in the application? ^ ^ ^ ^
If yes, please describe and quantify:
Were the impacts in place prior to the application for the 401 Certification? ^ ^ ^ ^
Additional conditions recommended for the Certification:
Recommended project modifications:
Is this a modification request to an existing Certification? ^ ^ ^ ^
Are there additional stromwater conditions that should be required due to the following classifications: ^ ^ ^ ^
# 303(d)list, Class WS, NSW, ORW, HQW
Describe:
Is this a subdivision or otherwise part of a larger project? ^ ^ ^ ^
# If yes, what phase is this?
Are there prior impacts from prior phases? ^ ^ ^ ^
If yes, what are the cumulative imacts for this project?
Possible secondary impacts noted:
Comment:
Page: 2