20140476 Ver 1_CAMA Permit Application_20140508

FROM. Jonathan Howell, NC DENR -DCM Assistant Mayor Permits Coordinator
400 Commerce Ave, Morehead City, NC 28557 (Courier 11- 12 -09)
SUBJECT. CAMA / D &F Mayor Permit Application Review
Applicant: Jimmy Creech
Project Location: 17 Beach Rd. S (Fig 8), adjacent to Banks Channel, in Wilmington, NH County
Proposed Project: to replace an existing bulkhead
Please Indicate below your agency's position or viewpoint on the proposed project and
return this form to Jonathan Howell at the address above by May 30, 2014. If you have
any questions regarding the proposed project, contact Tara MacPherson at (910) 796 -7425,
when appropriate, in -depth comments with supporting data is requested
REPLY:
SIGNED
This agency has no objection to the project as proposed.
This agency has no comment on the proposed project.
This agency approves of the project only if the recommended changes are
incorporated. See attached
This agency objects to the project for reasons described in the attached comments.
DATE
127 Cardinal Drive Ext , Wilmington, NC 28405
Phone 910 - 796 -72151 FAX 910 - 395 -3964 Internet www nccoastalmanagement net
An Equal Opportunity \ Affirmative Action Employer

DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
FIELD INVESTIGATION REPORT
APPLICANT'S NAME Jimmy Creech c/o Ed Flynn
2 LOCATION OF PROJECT SITE Site is located at 17 Beach Road South adjacent to Banks Channel
and Middle Sound on Figure Eight Island, New Hanover County
Photo Index — 2006: 24 -747 L -8 2000: 24 -312 M -18 1995: 24 -293 0-8
State Plane Coordinates - X 724951 Y 58089 GPS —O 042311A (uncorrected)
Lat: 34 016'01 46473 "N Long: 77 044'50 90700 "W
3 INVESTIGATION TYPE CAMA, D&F
4 INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURE Dates of Site Visit — 4/23/14
Was Applicant Present - No
5 PROCESSING PROCEDURE Application Received — 4/15/14
Office - Wilmington
6 SITE DESCRIPTION
(A) Local Land Use Plan— Wilmington - New Hanover County
Land Classification From LUP — Residential, Conservation
(B) AEC(s) Involved PT, EW, ES, CW
(C) Water Dependent Yes
(D) Intended Use Private
(E) Wastewater Treatment: Existing- Municipal Sewer
Planned- N/A
(F) Type of Structures Existing- Concrete driveway, private docking facility and aging asbestos
bulkhead
Planned- Timber bulkhead
(G) Estimated Annual Rate of Erosion N/A
7 HABITAT DESCRIPTION [AREA]
nRFnrFn FII I Fn OTHFR
(A) Vegetated Wetlands (Coastal)
100 sq ft
(B) Non - Vegetated Wetlands (Open
Water)
(C) Other - Highground disturbance
2,340 sq ft
(D) Total Area Disturbed 2,440 sq ft (0 05 acres)
(E) Primary Nursery Area No
(F) !dater Classification SA -ORW Open Yes
8 PROJECT SUMMARY The applicant proposes to construct 50 linear feet of new timber bulkhead
waterward of the existing deteriorating asbestos bulkhead

Jimmy Creech
Page 2
9 PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The project site is located at 17 Beach Road South on Figure Eight Island, adjacent to Banks Channel and
Middle Sound, in New Hanover County The island is accessed from the mainland at the end of Edgewater
Club Road (SR 1402), by private bridge over the Atlantic Intracoastal Waterway (AIWW) and an earthen
causeway, which traverses Middle Sound Heading east on the causeway, turn right on Beach Road South and
travel approximately 0 25 miles south to the vacant project site which will be located on the right side of the
road
Existing structures on the project site include a concrete driveway and private docking facility The project site
is approximately 0 34 acres in size and has an average elevation of approximately 6 ft above Normal High
Water (NHW) and is vegetated with domestic grasses The project site has approximately 100 feet of
shoreline frontage along Banks Channel The applicant is proposing to encapsulate the northeastern most 50
linear ft section of the existing asbestos bulkhead with a new timber bulkhead According to the application,
this asbestos bulkhead is approximately 40 years old Located waterward of the proposed bulkhead is an
approximately 27 ft wide band of coastal wetlands consisting primarily of Smooth Cordgrass (Spartina
altemlf/ora) except for an unvegetated 9 ft long area beneath the access stairs Normal High Water (NHW)
meets the existing bulkhead Extending in a westerly direction from the bulkhead towards Banks Channel is an
existing private docking facility, which consists of an access pier, platform and L- shaped floating dock The
previous property owner (Bass) obtained General Permit No 14230D for a private docking facility in 1995
State Permit 65 -00 was also issued to Mr Bass in April 25, 2000 for replacement of asbestos bulkheads on
lots 17 and 19 Beach Road South It appears that only 50 linear ft of the 100 ft asbestos bulkhead on lot 17
was replaced at that time under that State Permit
The Wilmington -New Hanover County 2006 Land Use Plan classifies adjacent waters and high ground portion
of the property as Conservation The waters of Banks Channel and Middle Sound are classified SA -ORW by
the Division of Water Resources They are NOT designated as a Primary Nursery Area (PNA) by the N C
Division of Marine Fisheries and they are OPEN to the harvest of shellfish
PROPOSED PROJECT
The applicant proposes to construct 50 linear feet of new timber bulkhead waterward of the existing asbestos
bulkhead The proposed bulkhead would be located no more than 2 ft waterward of the existing bulkhead and
would tie into the existing 50 linear feet of timber bulkhead on this property and the existing adjacent bulkhead
to the northeast The applicant states that this alignment is necessary to avoid impacts and disturbance to the
existing deteriorating asbestos bulkhead The application states that a new timber bulkhead (approximately 50
ft in length) would be constructed using a water het
10. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS
The proposed structure would incorporate approximately 100 sq ft of Estuarine Waters and Pubic Trust Area
and would result in the filling of a total of approximately 100 square feet of coastal wetland fill consisting of
primarily of Smooth Cordgrass (Spartrna altemlflora) located on the northeast end of the property The high
ground area would then be vegetated for stabilization in an area of approximately 2,340 sq ft within the
Estuarine Shoreline The applicant's proposal to construct the wall using a water het has the potential to
increase disturbance, sedimentation and turbidity into the adjacent marsh Minor increases in turbidity should
be expected during construction
Submitted by: Tara MacPherson Date: May 6, 2014 Office: Wilmington

-
(fast revised 12127106)
North Carolina DIVISION OF COASTAL MANAGEMENT
9. Primary Applicant/ Landowner Information
Bus ness Name ~^
i Prolec' Name !if aopt cable?
I I
Apolicant 1 First Name f
Ji ���
i MI j Last Name I
���
1 PO Box
_ - - -- - - -�
Applicant 2 First Name
MI
Last Name
if additional apphcarts please attach an additional pagefs) with names listed — -
rng Address
Mailing
�C �
Box — i State
City
,8�!.. \:
� C '1�R.L"`� e °�v •t��
,�E sf�'
yJ✓
E.�F�a"i e��„ r _�__�1
I .__ ._ - __—tom.
ZIP v Country
j Phone No
FAX No
ft,, eat I i
ext___—
Street Address (if different from above)
'—
i City
State
ZIP
t FAX No
onti
� Contractcr #
1
I F_rnai+ f ¢
I
j ilk
2. AgentlContractor Information
Bus,ress Name s
I `6 f 5i (����. }ks v L1d9� l��F+{"'R ( r 1✓� f� F �1 D i�
AgenU Contractor 1 First Name - - -
JM'f
AgenU Contractor 2 First Name
-- Mt
I
—1 MI
Last Name
j d
I Last Name
Malting Address
1 PO Box
-
City State
4i � � 1 r � � � g , /
I `
— --__ _ --
ZIP
Phone No
Phone No 2
ext___—
eXi
�_.._.__
'—
w!—
--_ -
t FAX No
onti
� Contractcr #
l—
i Street Address (,f caferent from above)
C,'v
State ;ZIP
I
Email r
- --
<Form continues on hacks 11r_M v° HOMING t tM NC
R 1 5 ?Di4

Form DCM MP -1 (Page 2 of s)
3, Project Location
APPLICATION f'or
Major Ceveloprnent Permit
County (can b multiplel Street Address j State rto w
Subdivision Name I City I State ? Zip {
Phone No 101, t Lit Nu (s) (/ many, attach additionaf page w.th Its.) _ I
Ai
1
a IIn1which NC river basin is the project iocateO I b Nane of body of water nearest to proposed protect
�•' (�` �� YO ,'� ^°' _.._. -. _____ I ( �ii /P4• i8 !
�IIN'atural water body identified m (b) above, natural or manmade _ a Name the closest major water body to the proposed project site
ly
❑fvianmada ❑Unknown
e is oposed work within City limits or planning jurisdiction? ` If aopl cable list the planning jurisdiction or city limit tha proposeo
',ark tails within
YPS ❑No
4. Site Description
a Total length of shoreune on the tract (ft)
i b Sze of entire tract (sq It
IUD
_N
c Size of individual lot(s) r s
D6 X//6 t
/attach
{ d Ap oximate elevation of tract above NHW (normal high water) or
NWL (normal water vet)
NHW pr ",L
(if many lot sizes please additional page with a list)
e Vegetation on tract
I
f Man -made features and uses now on tract
£4
g Identify and describe the existing land uses adjacent to the proposed project site
i
h How does local government zone the tract?
I i Is the roposed project consistent with the app ficable zonings
I
(Attath zoning compliance certmcate if appt able)
es ❑No CNA� _ -- –
I Is the proposed activity part of an urban Ovate front redevelopment
proposal, 01-es ,jNo
{
k Has a professional archaeulpgicai assessment been done for the trac'' If yes, attach a copy ❑Yes { , o ❑NA
I
If yes, by whom?_
- -- --- - -_R_—
_ -- --
I Is the proposed project located in a National Registered Historic District or does it involve a Yes No 'LltvA
i National Register listed or eligible property?
<Form continues on next page> C_�I`ill k1!iL%, VNGTC, N, NIC
APR 15 2014

Major Development Permit
n (+) Are there wetlands on the site? ~�
Ye ❑No
11 P
(it) Are there coastal wetlands on the sne
�
es VNo
I
(iii) If yes it, either (i) or (it) aoove, has a delineation been conducted?
❑'(es jo
(Attach documentation, if available)
kn
Al", a'�
Describe existing wastewater treatment facilities
f What is the approximate total disturbed lard area resulting from the proposed project'> t s
Sc, Ft or (]Acres
o Describe existing drinking water supply source
g Will the oroposed project encroach on any public easement, public accessway or other area ❑Yes
jo ON
—
p Describe exists storm water management or treatment systems
h Describe location and type of existing and proposed discharges to waters of the state
5. Activities and Impacts
r f ? `-,{ (--Am ❑Pibl+clGovernment t
I a 'Atilt the project be for commercial, public, or private use � I
j P.ivatetC'o gty
!) b Give a brief description of purpose, use, and daily operations of the project when cemp'e+e
l l ta'�yl �;' s d°cta i '�t "I ri
i`
c Describe the proposed construction methodology types of construction eouipment to be usea dur,ng ccnstrc'ct,on the number of each type
,oment and w per e it s to be stored }
<°.,�s °•'j;';-'
<Form continues on back>
i i-'—' =
0C-1 M IN1 -1 M,,INiCI, 3 0N, NC
APR 1 5 A'14
d List all development act.v ties you propose
'/Ja 1'G''%e # tilt fi'�Z'. I i A "; ;L' J l
I
e Are the proposed activities maintenance of an existing project new work or both?
+
Al", a'�
f What is the approximate total disturbed lard area resulting from the proposed project'> t s
Sc, Ft or (]Acres
g Will the oroposed project encroach on any public easement, public accessway or other area ❑Yes
jo ON
that the public has established use of?
h Describe location and type of existing and proposed discharges to waters of the state
I
it Will wastewater or stormwater be discharged into a wetland? ❑Yes
No ❑NA I
If yes, will this discharged water be of the same salinity as the receiving water? ❑Yes
❑N ❑NA
j j f} s there ,any mitigation proposed? []Yes
Ito ❑NA
i If yes, attach a mitigation proposal
t
<Form continues on back>
i i-'—' =
0C-1 M IN1 -1 M,,INiCI, 3 0N, NC
APR 1 5 A'14

Major Development Permit
�B.
JQdditiona! Information - -_._. - -- -- -------- --- --�
In
addition to this completed application form, (MP -1) the following items below, if applicable, must be submitted In order for the application �
package
to be complete Items (a) — (t] are always applrcaole to any major development application Please consult the application
instruction booklet on how to properly prepare the required items below
a
A project narrative
b
An accurate dated work plat (including plan view ano cross-sectional drawings) drawn to scale Please give the present status of the
proposed project Is any portion already complete? If previously authorized work, clearly indicate on maps, plats, drawings to distinguish l
'06(wee,r W& -carrtotadu-artu-proposdu
c
A site or location map that is sufficiently detailed to guide agency personnel unfamiliar with the area to the site
d
A copy of the deed (with state application only) or other instrument under which the applicant claims title to the affected properties
e
The appropriate application fee Check or money order made payable to DENR
f
A list of the names and complete addresses of the adjacent waterfront (riparian) landowners and signed return receiots as proof that such
owners have received a copy of the application and plats by certified mad Such landowners must be advised that they have 30 days in
which to submit comments on the proposed project to the Division of Coastal Management
Name Phone No+'1Fa, e1 mar"
Address f�r1
E3 fitr°ai��ctfl< (jrt�`t �[Ji1`E /tuffl`�� Ui1/
Name '��1 <r ` Phone No
f ),m'
f 3
,f
Aodr®ssJ�L /3lu��d$:'' ;lj a�Ji tCe° S.�fCif
^ — - - -- —
Name Phone No
j
Address
i g
l
A list of previous state or federal permits iesued for work on the project tract Irciude permit nurnters pan, ,ttae and isscin3 dates
�
I
t h
Signed consultant or agent authorization form if applicable
VVetland delineation, if necessary
r K \,(1l lf�lt Hrl rl:-I1 �lr(1 (`rli lr'E+ rir nrr lr c>r-rc in nr a�rrrr -nr � �. — Y .,��r= {:- _L+�}1 •j 'y..•y -� � -_,.__
k A statement of compliance with the N C Environmental Policy Act IN C G S 113A 1 -10), if necessary If the project involves expenditure
of public funds or use of public lands attach a statement documenting compliance with the North Carolina Env,ronmen•ai Pul,cy Act t
7. Certification and Permission to Enter on Land
I understand that any permit issued In response to this application will allow only the development described in the application
The project will be subject to the conditions and restrictions contained in the permit
I certify that I am authorized to grant, and oo in fact grant permission to representatives of state and feoeraj rev'ew agencies to
enter on the aforementioned lands in connection with evaluating information related to this permit application and follow -up
monitoring of the project
I further certify that the information provided in this application is truthful to the best of my knowledge
Date • i� J��� Print Name�'�
Signature /ZY
J s e indicate application attachments pertaining to your proposed project
M MP -2 Excavation and Fill Information ❑DCM MP -5 Bridges and Culverts
❑DCM MP -3 Upland Development
❑DCM MP -4 Structures Information
O 011LIVI NGTON, NO
A PR I i 2014

`Form ®Gib MP -2
EXCAVATION and FILL
(Except for bridges and culverts)
Attach th,s form to Jcint Appllcat,or, for CA ?v1,A P.talor Permit, Forn DCNI. titP -1 Be sure to complete all of ~er sections of the Joint
Application that reia:e to this proposed prciect Please inc,uce a'; supp,ementa. ir,ormat,on
Describe below the purpose of proposed eycavat;on andlor f „I a�:nvmes All values should be given in feet
Access I Other
Channel I Canal Boat Basin Boat Ramp Rock Groin j Rock i (excluding
( Breakwater ; shoreline
r.Wt_) I i stabilization
Length
i
Width
I
Avg Existing i I I NA ! NA
I Depth i i I
I Final Project i I NA I NA
Depth
1 EXCAVATION fffinis section not aoplica.ole
a Arrc„n' of material to c e excava -ed from r, or L in i ,pe c' mater a: to oe exca`.a.eo
cuC'c yaros
C rl; CoeS the area to be excava e.i. „, .Uce coastal ..e' ands, ma's^ d Ko'i- grourc exca.abCn -n cubic yards
(C0,1) s,.bMe—.ad ativa ;�c %,egeta Ion (SAS' }, she`! 00-,cm ,S3.
cr ,,,the* we'lards (W!-)'? I( any Coxes are cnecked ploviCe the
n-rr.oer of sy;,a,e ee! alfec ed
❑l':L Gone
(u} Gescr,ce Ire p.rcose of the excavation „ n ;nose areas
2. DISPOSAL OF EXCAVATED MATERIAL
IZThis seci,on not appr;cab,
a Loca:,cn of clscosat a "ea
b C mers,cns of d,soosai a•ea
C (i} `:'i'I a olsoosa' area oe available for'uture ma ^tenancer
c (I) Do ycu c aim :, e to olsaosal area?
Ves 3NZ) GvA
❑Yes ❑No []NA
(a) If no, attach a e"er grant'ng pe,mfsslor '.FO-.n the O�%ner
(i'1 ,f yes v.r,ere)
e (} Coes the c.sposal a-ea Incl�ce a-y coastal v e"ards -marsh
{ (; oces the crocsai Irc :-ce any a,ea 'n the 'r.a'e "?
(C'.V1 suome,cec acua',c vege'at�on (SAV), sreli bottorr ,SB)
iiYes ❑NO ENIA
or other'.Netlards it "', ;? if any coxes are cneckee provide ; ~e
n If es, ho .v much wata" area s a rec:ec�
y
nurs-,-;are a
'be' cr s.:are fee: alfeec
� ,
❑C;V t_S"\/ 7—SB
[]V,1L Ft\or,e
(,I} Cesc ce :ne ou'ocse Jf d sposal in these areas
R p"..CE iV E
DC-NI) VJ;! PAINGTON, NC

3. SHORELINE STABILIZATION D This section nct aaplfcacie
(If development is a wood gran, use MP -a — Structures)
a
T yl ofsnore4ne sfa!m,za;;or
,_B Ikhead ❑Riprap QBreak.vateriSo: ❑Other
c Average d;s'ance '.bate ^vard of NHW or NY. L
�l A
b Lerg•h
Jr'
bVIctf'
d fjaxim,!m
distance .vate ^maid of N-+W or N.VL
ry e
t
e Type of state z3'; on material t O Has ,here been shoreitre e•cs;on d ,ring preceding '2
yes V10
(,;) ll ,,es, sta a armo..nt c; erosicr ane so,,--e o` e•es or an ou
r ormai,on
g Numoer of square feet of ill 'o to claced below water level h Type of fill ma'enal
B !mead bact I' R;p'aD ell"
Break.vater /S it Otner
Source of f I material
RPIPM
4. OTHER FILL ACTIVITIES LdThis section not aoplicaole
! (Excluding Snoreline Stabilization) rJ
y b the tel 1 Yes NO NA b_ (,) v''t l `w • ..ate• a! De placed Ir coas'al weilandsima'Sh (C,V),
material e bro;.grt ,o s�',. �, U DNA
acuat,c vegetation (SAV) snel! bout•^ (S5; er
If yes c'her v.edanos ('A /L)? it any oores are cnecKed pro.;ce the
Amount of ma'ar at 'o be p'acec ;n the .,.a:er ^umoer of square fee', affectec
f n) r me ^,sic"s cf 6;t area CSAV use
(w) Purpose cf HI ❑: ^,L UNone
(..1 Descnoe 're purocse of 'I-;e f !I in , ese weas
15 GENERAL
a HJw ..'I' J mate' al Oe keD.. s to and eroS,Cn D '% is 'vice v ,o�s,r-C,cn eCuio rent wdl be ;se- ;e 9 ..'a:;
contmledl ca-,K -3e or nvd -a- c d-edge)?
(0 'Ail; -avicakai a ds be rec .,red as a esul' of the proleot
iL7Yes %o FINA
(n) ;f yes expla.n wna' vpe and Ina they ..;'I oe ;molemen,tec
d (;) �14-11 we'lands to — c, ssed n vansaer, ng eawpme ^t to orolec
vel '—ves
(u) ,f yes excla;r, stets tha! .vul Ce talon 'o 3,.0 ,d e' mm. ^;ze
erv;ro^mertat tmoacts
Cate Aunt har^e
rdi "
pub 044t�rr
Pro;ec! Name Ao.^.I,ca— S ature R EEC E 1 V E D
Di M ti UMIINGTON, NC:

Z
eGED LANDS
®® 5C511
(:.�ilS�rRG 1 h
lit Lit
'.Zh EPIC .,EFi
ell
° ° `3 30' CAM
Q ° G ,, c SETBACK
o F -- _
v I
ILn
OG
T
oc 51 I o 1
OC, 12
G
RAMP
pJrR
N 28-1
® 5C
5UBMERGED LAND5
G-5
J
6 15
MOO
C] J ??
V 'd
30' CAMH °G G
SETBACK
CO
® - - -- —`l
� I
1-11�
Ii /f011�
12
/ice
G 75
> O
OG
0
G 2G
G 251
u 0
vC:i7
G.7
0. 2'
--- G 3
Q
0
0
Gal
L �
HMh BEACH i
DEED BOOK 5
UNINIPR
j ee
°
I
I
s
i
I
1
~
Q
m
�r,
W
O
7 04
,
° Go I
%G2
0
vC:i7
G.7
0. 2'
--- G 3
Q
0
0
Gal
L �
HMh BEACH i
DEED BOOK 5
UNINIPR
j ee
^1
W
I
�^
Gl �LI : I�� i l�l t �`� ,C
I
W
O
7 04
LLJ
t
C)
I
I
o
0
m
cv
m
z
)
I
1
,d
I
P/
0,- `7
T)
- l_-- -- - ---
-- -- _
7
-03
C
CRETE PARKfNG PAD
G 4G
O;.0
J
L
"c-6
43
/
'
O 2
22
o
63
G
G 28
G 29
6 6
_
50DQ --- ------
_ _ _C
---- -5000'c
0
9G2 ` —`�OZ '171'—
NJJo�28� G` I G2G

f
I o®
m �
� o
c
,._
I
Q
a
e
d
1�
1
�r\
i
aVED
v IIita l ! ON, NO
APP, 1 a 20A 1
D\
ux�
v�
I
Q
a
e
d
1�
1
�r\
i
aVED
v IIita l ! ON, NO
APP, 1 a 20A 1

1 / �
8 /
D /
-f IFY \
E
I
i
I
I
i
me-2
4i
LOCATION MAP
tdOT TO Kt:
5URVEY REFERENCE
SEED 300K 1 735 =-,GC 1208
t, r%° 300K 3 Pr,rG 12
LEGEND
®
— 5 °7 RCN F-==
j1j1'J
SE
c
- ll/l0NlU,,'e`,,TDCM W11 110INCA1 ON NC/
f �j
APR I

f
P. 0 Box 868
Wrightsville Beach, N. C. 28480
Phone /Fax 910 - 256 -3062
1 April 2014
NOENR
Wilmington, N.C.
Cap t. Ed Flynn
Durwbod Sykes
email: eflydOmsn. com
The enclosed CAMA Major Permit application for Mr. Jimmy Creech, #17
Peach Road South, Wilmington, NC 28411, on Figure Eight Island, is to
install a new treated timber bulkhead two feet waterward of an existing old
asbestos bulkhead. The two foot offset is requested so as not to disturb,
remove, handle and have to dispose of the asbestos
The old asbestos bulkhead is approx. 40 years old, and is becoming weak and
brittle and we request to co ver it with clean fill sand and have it remain in
place.
RECEIVED
GCM WILMINGTON, NC
APR -1 52014