Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout20060684 Ver 1_Year 3 Monitoring Report_20140425i City of Greensboro � North Carolina RE LJ lJLS Q (W �Q j u ti TO: NCDENR, DIV. OF WATER RESOURCES DATE: WINSTON -SALEM REGIONAL OFFICE PROJECT: 585 WAUGHTOWN STREET RE: WINSTON - SALEM, NC 27107 ATTENTION: SUE HOMEWOOD WE ARE SENDING YOU: ® ATTACHED THE FOLLOWING ITEMS: ❑ SHOP DRAWINGS ❑ CHANGE ORDER ❑ UNDER SEPARATE COVER VIA RECEIVED N C. Dept of ENR APR 2 5 2014 WINSTON -SALEM Engin sr1w%0Nb'gdt 0baE APRIL 22, 2014 DWQ #06 -0684 NEW GARDEN ROAD STREAM RESTORATION MONITORING RECORD ❑ PRINTS ❑ SPECIFICATIONS ❑ PLANS ❑ LETTER M OTHER COPIES DATE REVISION DESCRIPTION 1 04/22/2014 FOR YOUR USE LEVEL 1 STREAM RESTORATION MONITORING AS REQUESTED ❑ FOR REVIEW THIRD YEAR MONITORING REPORT, RESUBMITTED ❑ FOR DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL STABILITY OTHER THESE ARE TRANSMITTED AS CHECKED BELOW: ❑ FOR APPROVAL ❑ APPROVED AS SUBMITTED M FOR YOUR USE ❑ AS REQUESTED ❑ FOR REVIEW ❑ RESUBMITTED ❑ FOR DISTRIBUTION ❑ OTHER COPY To USACE. FILE ❑ APPROVED AS NOTED ❑ RETURNED FOR CORRECTIONS ❑ RETURNED AFTER LOAN SIGNED GUY B. INGLE PO Box 3136 Greensboro, NC 27402 -3136 - wwN-. greensboro -nc gov 336 -37 3 -CITY (2489) � TTY # 333 -6930 , F RECEIVED C. Dept, of ENR R Z 5"b �ISTON -SALEM ' ONAL OFFICE - GREENSBORO CITY OF GREENSBORO , ENGINEERING DIVISION NEW.GARDEN ROAD WIDENING, PHASE II . -PROJECT # P -3741 . ' CULVERT REPLACEMENT AND STREAM RELOCATION /RESTORATION HORSEPEN CREEK MAIN TRIBUTARY #2 AND TRIBUTARY,A ' - , LEVEL 1 STREAM RESTORATION MONITORING 'THIRD YEAR MONITORING REPORT ' ' CHANNEL STABILITY APRIL,22, 2014` , Prepared, By: OUS-a., �.L CWS� US Infrastructure of Carolina, Inc Carolina Wetland Services, Inc. 125 South Elm Street, Suite 510' _ '550 East Westinghouse Blvd. . Greensboro', -North Carolina,27401 _Charlotte,,NC 28273 ` r N C License #C -1950 . Level 1 Stream Restoration Monitoring Horsepen Creek Main Tributary #2 and Tributary A THIRD YEAR MONITORING REPORT Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II City of Greensboro, North Carolina Engineering Division Project No. P -3741 April 22, 2014 Prepared by US Infrastructure of Carolina, Inc 125 South Elm Street, Suite 510 Greensboro, North Carolina 27401 N C License #C -1950 -14'- 22 - /--I/ Carolina Wetland Services, Inc 550 East Westinghouse Blvd. Charlotte, NC 28273 USI �� III CWS Table of Contents Introduction Methods Photo Reference Sites Channel Stability Results Photo Reference Sites Channel Stability Main Tributary 42 ........ Tributary A Summary Comments Figures Figure 1 Site Location Map Figure 2. As -Built Cross Sections and Photo Location Map Appendix A .... ...... Photopage 1 — Third Year Monitoring Photographs Appendix B Main Tributary #2 Cross Sections Main Tributary #2 Longitudinal Profile Main Tributary #2 Pebble Count Main Tributary #2 Raw Data Appendix C Tributary A Cross Sections Tributary A Longitudinal Profile Tributary A Pebble Count Tributary A Raw Data Page 1 .. 1 .... 1 3 3 3 4 4 7 8 8 7 27 43 Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widenmg Phase II Project No P -3741 Introduction The New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project is located in Greensboro, North Carolina as shown on the Site Location Map (Figure 1) on the next page. Construction of this project necessitated the relocation of portions of two tributaries to Horsepen Creek, Main Tributary #2 (South) and Tributary A (North). The relocation of these stream reaches was completed in March 2011. The stream relocations were permitted through the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Action I.D SAW 2007 - 03980) and the North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DWQ Project #06 -0684) and required a Level 1 Stream Restoration Mitigation and Monitoring Plan for this project. This level of monitoring includes the establishment of photo reference sites, plant survival monitoring, and channel stability monitoring. The relocated stream reaches were assessed using Rosgen Level II Classification methods. The following end of third year survey was conducted to evaluate and document the conditions of the relocated stream channels following three years after the completion of construction. This data will be compared to the as -built survey which provided a baseline for these future monitoring events as well as the first and second year surveys. Methods Photo Reference Sites Photographs were taken during 1) Third Year Survey for Channel Stability on April land 17, 2014 In stream structures including rock vanes, root wads, and grade control sills were photographed facing upstream and downstream. Stream bed and banks were photographed for visual comparison of stability. Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 Legend 2,000 1,000 0 2,000 Feet Project Outer Boundary REFERENCE USGS 7 5' TOPOGRAPHIC MAP SERIES, GREENSBORO NC QUADRANGLE, DATED 1994 Carolina Wetland Services, Inc. 550E Westinghouse Blvd Charlotte, NC 28273 Figure 1. Site Location Map New Garden Road Widening As -Built Report Greensboro, North Carolina Applicant No: I Date: ISheet of 2 Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 Channel Stability A geomorphic survey was performed by engineers from USI with the assistance of a scientist from CWS on April 1, 2014 following three years after the construction of the new stream channels. The survey included a longitudinal profile, a cross sectional survey, substrate sampling (Wolman reach -wide pebble count), and photo documentation of each of the stream reaches. This data was used to classify each reach using the Rosgen Level II system. Bank pins were also checked on both reaches to monitor bank stability. Surveying methods (using a rod, level, and tape) followed the guidelines given in Stream Channel Reference Sates An Illustrated Guide to Field Technique, General Technical Report RM -245, United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service. A relative benchmark for the Third Year survey was established on the top of an existing sanitary sewer manhole immediately adjacent to New Garden Road. The surveys of both streams were tied together to the top of the sanitary sewer manhole with a given elevation of 100.00. The actual elevation of the existing sanitary sewer manhole as a permanent benchmark is 775.70. This is shown in the Raw Data portions of the Appendices. The Raw Data also shows the correction of the elevations taken during the survey to actual elevations. Results Photo Reference Sites As part of the Third Year survey for the project, all areas of the project were photo documented. In stream structures including rock vanes, root wads, and grade control sills were photographed facing upstream and downstream. Stream bed and banks were photographed for visual comparison of stability. Representative photographs are included in Photopage 1 (Appendix A). The locations and directions of each of these photographs are shown in Figure 2 (Page 5) As an aside, the same locations and directions were used for these photographs as those taken during the As- Built, First Year, and Second Year surveys. 3 Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 Channel Stability Main Tributary #2 Main Tributary #2 flows north through the project area and through the new culvert installed beneath the widened New Garden Road. The Third Year survey of Main Tributary #2 was conducted on April 1, 2014 by representatives from USI and CWS. The relocated stream channel exhibited substrate consisting of medium gravel (1)50 = 8.0 mm) The channel slope is 0.004 ft/ft with a sinuosity of 1.18. The average bankfull width and depth for this reach are 27 feet and 1.60 feet, respectively. The average bankfull cross sectional area for riffle portions of the stream is 43.25 ft2. The average flood -prone area width for Main Tributary #2 is approximately 55 feet The new stream channel has a Rosgen Level II classification of C5. Permanent cross sections were established during the As -Built survey and marked with rebar to allow future monitoring of the same locations. Figure 2 on page 5 shows the locations of these permanent cross sections. The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Main Tributary #2 (Cross Sections A and B) are summarized below in the following tables. Channel cross sections, the longitudinal profile, and pebble count data for Main Tributary #2 are included in Appendix B Provide the following data for each cross - section Crnss iectinn A Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Cross - section being measured A A A A Cross - sectional area as -built /present 60 01 sf 52 43 sf 50 09 sf 43 25 sf Bankfull width as- built/present 27 00 ft 27 00 ft 27 00 ft 27 00 ft Floodprone Width as- built/present 60 00 ft 60 00 ft 60 00 ft 55 00 ft Width/depth as- bui It/pre sent 12 15 13 90 1455 1686 Entrenchment ratio as- built/present 222 222 222 204 Stream Type as- built/present* C5 C5 C5 C5 I only reyt[tredJot rile ctovv- vections n Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 s O U r O Q O o N w M z K O U 0.W1 C7Uco � O � U U U� v N o Ir Q a 0 E z�U U ti rN a a U Q zw ate# R 3 a ) F C7 p x Ye w cn O u z W W "v" Q' .� O m Q d' a Oa z F Ov m / \ u VI 0: \ o F / 2 \ O / U 1 w / C co ` cA y O / N Q ^ U Oz I �> I \ CD o 0 1 O z z ) a O / U > am a a M N 3: w c')� o a 1 w 1 00 N 1 gz W ? O U I \ 3 w I i tr N O a O cj) U m N U a N N O2 > U 1 w m 1 m N U II O \ w 1 � 1 I 0 w \\ U OZ I U j N F s 1 O 0 a \ ° o \ w \ °° o o \ ; \ o W K W p a Q \\ \ > i O � 0 3 \ 4 F ¢ O Q \\ m w O N Q \ O j w O \\ Q a F O w 2 m \ w i 3 z w o \ O U z m ? a Z \ W W W C 5 Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Provide the followma data for each cross - section Cross Section B ect No P -3741 Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Cross - section being measured B B B B Cross - sectional area as- built/present 73 91 sf 68 42 sf 64 21 sf 65 28 sf Bankfull width as- built/present 27 00 ft 27 00 ft 27 00 ft 27 00 ft Floodprone Width as- built/present 70 00 ft 70 00 ft 70 00 ft 70 00 ft Width/depth as- built/present 986 1065 1135 11 17 Entrenchment ratio as- built/present 259 259 259 2.59 Stream Type as- built/present* C5 C5 C5 C5 * 0111}' i equn ed for riffle cross- secliofis The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Main Tributary #2 (Longitudinal Profile) are summarized below in the following table. The longitudinal profile for Main Tributary #2 is included in Appendix B. Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Avg slope riffles as- built/present 0 005 ft/ft 0 023 ft/ft 0 020 ft/ft 0 015 ft/ft Avg slope pools as- built/present 0 ft/ft 0 ft/ft 0 ft/ft 0 ft/ft Number of riffles as- built/present 1 1 1 1 Number of pools as- built/present 4 4 4 3 The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Main Tributary #2 (Pebble Counts) are summarized below in the following table The pebble count data for Main Tributary #2 is included in Appendix B. Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Cross - section being measured A and B A and B A and B A and B D16 as- built/present 0.125 0.125 0.25 025 D50 as- built/present 05 80 5.7 8.0 D84 as- built/present 11 3 160 160 226 The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Main Tributary #2 (Visual Inspection) are summarized below in the following table. Date Inspected 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Structure Type Cross Vane Cross Vane Cross Vane Cross Vane Is water piping through or around structure No No No No Head cut or down cut present? No No No No Bank or scour erosion present? No No No No Other problems noted9 No No No No 6 Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 Tributary A Tributary A is a minor tributary which flows west along the toe of the widened New Garden Road embankment to its confluence with Main Tributary #2. The Third Year survey of Tributary A was conducted on April 1, 2014 by representatives from USI and CWS. The relocated stream channel exhibited substrate consisting of medium gravel (D50 = 11.3 mm). The channel slope is 0.017 ft/ft with a sinuosity of 1.37. The average bankfull width and depth for this reach are 17 feet and 1 87 feet, respectively. The average bankfull cross sectional area for riffle portions of the stream is 31.76 ft2. The average flood -prone area width for Tributary A is approximately 45 feet. The new stream channel has a Rosgen Level II classification of E4. Permanent cross sections were established during the As -Built survey and marked with rebar to allow future monitoring of the same locations. Figure 2 on page 5 shows the locations of these permanent cross sections The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Tributary A (Cross Sections C and D) are summarized below in the following tables. Channel cross sections, the longitudinal profile, and pebble count data for Tributary A are included in Appendix C. Ar., Ao tho fnlln—na data fnr -nrh rrncc_certmn C'rncc Sertinn C Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Cross - section being measured C C C C Cross - sectional area as- built/present 32 45 sf 34 43 sf 26 85 sf 31 76 sf Bankfull width as- built/present 17 00 ft 17 00 ft 17 00 ft 17 00 ft Floodprone Width as- built/present 45 00 ft 45 00 ft 45 00 ft 45 00 ft Width/depth as- built/present 8.91 839 10.76 9.10 Entrenchment ratio as- built/present 265 265 265 265 Stream Type as- built/present* E4 E4 E4 E4 * only required fot r i fle dross - sections Prnv,rla tha fnllrnumo dntn fnr Path rrncs- cectinn C'rnsc Section n Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Cross - section being measured D D D D Cross - sectional area as- built/present 39 59 sf 44 76 sf 22 68 sf 39.25 sf Bankfull width as- built/present 19 00 ft 20 50 ft 20 50 ft 19 00 ft Floodprone Width as- built/present 55 00 ft 55 00 ft 55 00 ft 55 00 ft Width/depth as- built/present 912 939 1853 920 Entrenchment ratio as- built/present 289 268 2.68 289 Stream Type as- built/present* E4 E4 E4 E4 * only required for riffle cross - .sections 7 ri 1}. Third Year Monitoring Report Channel Stability New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Tributary A (Longitudinal Profile) are summarized below in the following table The longitudinal profile for Tributary A is included in Appendix C. Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Avg slope riffles as- built/present 0 023 ft/ft 0 023 ft/ft 0 034 ft/ft 0 030 ft/ft Avg slope pools as- built/present 0 ft/ft 0 ft/ft 0 ft/ft 0 ft/ft Number of riffles as- built/present 3 3 3 3 Number of pools as- built/present 4 4 4 4 The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Tributary A (Pebble Counts) are summarized below in the following table. The pebble count data for Tributary A is included in Appendix C. Date Measured 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Cross - section being measured C and D C and D C and D C and D D16 as- built/present 0 125 <0 062 0 062 0 062 D50 as- built/present 80 57 11 3 113 D84 as- built/present 226 320 320 640 The As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year conditions of Tributary A (Visual Inspection) are summarized below in the following table Date Inspected 6/28/2010 1/10/2012 3/19/2013 4/1/2014 Structure Type Cross Vane Cross Vane Cross Vane Cross Vane Is water piping through or around structure No No No No Head cut or down cut present9 No No No No Bank or scour erosion present9 No No No No Other problems noted? No No No No Summary Comments The channels (Main Tributary #2 and Tributary A) relocated as part of the New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project appear to be geomorphically and hydraulically stable with regard to pattern, profile, and dimension. Other than ongoing monitoring and observation there are no recommendations to perform any remediation at this time. 8 Third Year Monitoring Report Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No P -3741 Appendix A Photopage 1 — Third Year Monitoring Photographs Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Photo 1: Tributary A — permanent cross section, left bank looking upstream Photo 2: Tributary A — permanent cross section, left bank looking upstream H Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Photo 3: Tributary A — permanent cross section, left bank looking upstream Photo 4: Tributary A — Root Wad Area A, centerline looking upstream Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage I New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 !All A IN g , 1 r� Y �,. f fi• T1 � Photo 5: Tributary A — Grade Control Sill A, centerline looking upstream Photo 6: Tributary A — Cross Vane A, left bank looking downstream 12 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Photo 7: Tributary A — Root Wad Area A, centerline looking upstream Photo 8: Tributary A — Root Wad Area B, left bank looking downstream 13 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Z.4 � � 1 f Photo 9: Tributary A — Cross Vane A, left bank looking upstream ;.; Photo 10: Tributary A — Cross Vane A, left bank looking upstream 14 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 „� , ►: Vii, s ;, e Photo 11: Tributary A — Cross Vane B, left bank looking downstream Photo 12: Tributary A — Root Wad Area B, left bank looking upstream 15 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage I New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 xN4 •� .� i .r r i `tea U'"� C Photo 13: Tributary A — Confluence with Main Tributary #2, looking downstream Photo 14: Tributary A — Cross Vane B, left bank looking upstream 16 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 y tleak . ar�r 0 iF�- ♦ Y 4a a 4r Iniiierih4.�,'%.r..'. •4,, c- .c....a. -,. s 'L�.� �i Photo 15: Main Tributary 42 — permanent cross section, right bank looking upstream Photo 16: Main Tributary #2 — Root Wad Area D, right bank looking downstream 17 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 =r- g � =A"FCf•ss�r.•F,4 Photo 17: Main Tributary #2 — Root Wad Area D, centerline looking downstream Photo 18: Main Tributary #2 — permanent cross section, centerline looking upstream 18 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Photo 19: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane D, centerline looking downstream Photo 20: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane D, centerline looking downstream 19 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage I New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Photo 21: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane D, centerline looking downstream Photo 22: Main Tributary #2 — Root Wad Area D, centerline looking upstream 20 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage I New Garden Road Widening Phase I1 Project No. P -3741 Photo 23: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane D, left bank looking upstream Photo 24: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane C, left bank looking downstream 21 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 7!� 1 >.i 4{ l _ Es- Photo 25: Main Tributary #2 — Riffle Pool B, centerline looking upstream Photo 26: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane C, centerline looking downstream 0% Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 l sSky �. +r,`., o +, F Photo 27: Main Tributary 42 — Cross Vane C, right bank looking downstream Photo 28: Main Tributary 42 — Confluence with Tributary A, looking downstream 23 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 t W - UMISA 9'. -1.;ty;. J 1 � Photo 29: Main Tributary #2 — Cross Vane C, right bank looking upstream Photo 30: Main Tributary 92 — Miscellaneous, left bank looking downstream 24 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Photo 31: Main Tributary 42 — Root Wad D, left bank looking upstream showing both permanent cross sections Photo 32: Main Tributary #2 — Root Wad D, left bank looking downstream 25 Third Year Monitoring Report: Photo Documentation — Photopage 1 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 r i J i i i Photo 33: Main Tributary #2 — New Garden Road culvert, looking upstream s ,t 5 4 Photo 34: Main Tributary #2 — Downstream of New Garden Road, looking downstream 26 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Appendix B Main Tributary #2 Cross Sections Third Year Monitoring Comparison — As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year Main Tributary #2 Longitudinal Profile Third Year Monitoring Comparison — First Year, Second Year, and Third Year Main Tributary #2 Pebble Count Main Tributary #2 Raw Data Third Year Monitoring 27 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 28 LO Q p aa_ L 5 d C w O j I a` U) LO Y � U O I m LL I I I I C) LO V I a I ' o I I Y , � C) O U M ' N � m V I ' p e� M v> •L I , L/'1 I I N C I •� ,V I I V eQ O I I LO � C M L O r ,c V I I 3 as ' LO z a o 0) 1` LO M 0') CO 1` CD In (D ti ti ti ti ti 1` ti ti ('41) UOIIBA813 28 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 pill LO m O t L U N � � C O 3 L�1 — n/ `O .3 fn (0 O lL m I C= I co O O lf) LO a r✓ m O C LO O m LO � y 0 O ^ U m 4t LO C M N A L p r O M •L LO C N ' O N 'O O C L i O m 4) Z to m O CD 11;3- N O O CD 1q, CD N Cfl (':4) u01jena13 pill Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 30 N N •� 7 U-) m M N � O U/1 Q I`N m = p O L') AV W LO N O N LO ._. M v O � .N LO = N O N o LO O c� 3 LO a� C) f` LO M d7 I`.- LO (':U) uo1Jenal3 30 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 31 LO N [t O O N N M W O //O� cn O Q N CD O LO W V N O LO o L LO O v � � v � M N O 0 M = LO N O o N W LO C a� � O a� Z O O 11:1- N O 00 (D - N f` f� I� I� Cfl Cfl Cfl Cfl (•11) UOIIBA013 31 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 O � _ S C � D � C O N � � O �x G �z '? N O 00 IO 't (laa3) uo.IUA31a 32 O'SLZ O'OSZ O'SZZ O'OOZ 0'SL I a O'OSI .� `o 0'SZ I m Q) 3 r 1� 1 Y r.. 0'001 0'SL 0'OS 't a� 0'5Z m 0' 0 o CR N C Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Q W s C � r.• y Q N � �I C � CJ D ^C • � eC G 3 •S� G� I� l O O O C O O O O (Iaa3) UOIIRA3121 33 O'SLZ O'0SZ O'SZZ 0 00Z 0'SL I a> O'OSI a 0 O'SZI 0'001 0'SL 0'05 0'5z v 0 N 4J 3 m l� I co 0 N N f6 L F- 0 N 3 m m 0 N Y 41 M 0 N J O N N U (9 U) N (D Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Main Tributary #2 - Pebble Count 34 Metric mm Particle S A N D Count Tot # % Tot % Cum <0.062 Silt/Clay 12 100 12.0 12.00 0.062 - 0.125 Very Fine Sand 1 100 1.0 13.00 0.125 - 0.250 Fine Sand 3 100 3.0 16.00 0.25-0.5 Med. Sand 2 100 1 2.0 18.00 0.5 - 1.0 Coarse Sand 13 100 13.0 31.00 1.0-2.0 Very Coarse Sand 8 100 8.0 39.00 2-4 Ve Fine Gravel G R A V E L 0 100 0.0 39.00 4-5.7 Fine Gravel 1 100 1.0 40.00 5.7-8 Fine Gravel 5 100 5.0 45.00 8-11.3 Medium 7 100 7.0 52.00 11.3-16 Medium 21 100 21.0 73.00 16-22.6 Coarse 9 100 9.0 82.00 22.6-32 Coarse 7 100 7.0 89.00 32-45 Very Coarse 4 100 4.0 93.00 45-64 Very Coarse 2 100 2.0 95.00 64-90 Small c O n b e 1 100 1.0 96.00 90-128 Small 1 100 1.0 97.00 128-180 Large 0 100 0.0 97.00 180-256 Large 0 100 0.0 97.00 256-362 Small B 0 1 a e I 0 100 0.0 97.00 362-512 Small 0 100 0.0 97.00 512-1024 Medium 0 100 0.0 97.00 1024-2048 Large - Very Large 0 100 0.0 97.00 Bedrock jBedrock 1 3 1 100 1 3.0 100.00 34 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 N e� C O Q G D O U a� 5 s v �C c O i i %) ;uaaaad an .julnuina 0 c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 In o u o o � %) ;uaaaad 35 0 0 v; o 31a0apag BbOZ-bZOI bZol - ZIS ZIS-Z9£ Z9£-9SZ 9SZ-08I 08I-8ZI 8ZI-06 06-b9 t9-Sb Sb-Z£ Z£-9'ZZ TZZ-9I 9I-£'iI £'II -8 8 -L'S L'S -V h -Z 0'Z - 0' I 0'I -S'0 S'o - SZ'o OSVO - SZI'o SZI'0 - Z90'0 Z90'0> 8 a> c� as v L CC a Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 N O i. C C� C O a i. A a� N V it A ice+ O U a� a� a 3 s V 4� C i� 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O Q� 00 [- `D V1 't M N ( %) .IaUlA luaaaad 36 00001 0001 001 01 1'0 10'0 as v L CC a Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 F4 p4 ti fppi 4 h {i LL LL 0 C �6 Y • a Li 4 . tS" =°C F9 s v Oa 1q oaN b �i Y m F}• �� ,ji �� `o s y U 3 Y Z Y Y Y m e C 2L e m M 0- m F m N B C < +3 a� e � � c YO zz� o � E yZs vi u u U e e A t Q 6 9 R m g' w S v a u S r � 2 S x` 5 �m 37 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - - - a "I CO s O N I.L Of �t I I rd Q 37 "I CO Q O N I.L Of I I 7 U, Y f3 00 Q W ai lL I _0 I I I y O LO w� W � N LO O I � ' L U � I I O N I ' �• � +r I C O N 13 c ' LO N 1 � � O N O I C 4) I O 'cc V � I I Z LO Q O fl- O I�- LO h I- Cr) Il_ fl_ (D O 1- U) (D (0 tir`r`�titititi ('4) UOIIBA813 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 4 N fi L f m o Oa °3 e E z a°i o 3 � o zz c .g yZs U a D 9P 1 I S c e a e w a ma px.'' o�o ea Cie`_ ocF � W rxFL`os `�e'U Y a y y Y■ .3m�azm�m3fs��ua m $$R 6i 88 j$.-- -$ o - - e n _ - _. �., - a O Y Y O It K �.a.ppoVV,sesa�s�C�CC^C -�xnm� - - - - - - - - - - - - - - O E m 38 00 e a io `o r 9 .9 r� O � N 3 r8 r� e LO ti m O a I � U I LO e �, O av ; I o p u LL m m � O O I LO LO d N I CO) O L V LO 1 i i I I O ^a v LO m_ M I O C i M 'cc i g j N 1 I I I N O m c I Ul) L O 0 i 3 I I Z I I LO m O r- r- r- ti (•u) u01;ena13 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Water Surface - Main Tributary #2 Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase 11 Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 4/1/2014 WS Slope (ft. /ft.) 0.004 CIE BM 41 (ft.Y- 775.70 Height of Height Distance Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore -Sight Depth STATION B.S. ILL F.S. Elevation Corrected Elevation CONVENTS B.M. # 1 3.64 103.64 100.00 0.0 103.64 11.91 91.73 767.43 12.0 103.64 11.97 91.67 767.37 41.0 103.64 12.29 91.35 767.05 75.0 103.64 12.67 90.97 766.67 85.0 103.64 12.79 90.85 766.55 103.0 103.64 12.71 90.93 766.63 110.0 103.64 12.73 90.91 766.61 148.0 103.64 12.71 90.93 766.63 151.0 103.64 12.93 90.71 766.41 165.0 103.64 12.93 90.71 766.41 224.0 103.64 12.93 90.71 766.41 226.0 103.64 13.03 90.61 766.31 264.0 103.64 13.03 90.61 766.31 287.0 103.64 13.03 90.61 766.31 WS Slope (ft. /ft.) 0.004 CIE Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Thalweg - Main Tributary #2 Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase 11 Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 4/1/2014 Thalweg Slope (ft. /ft.) 0.005 Riffle Slope 0.015 40 BM # 1 (ft.)- 775.70 Height of Height Distance Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore -Sight Depth STATION B.S. H.1 ES. Elevation Corrected Elevation CON51I YTS B.M. # 1 3.64 103.64 100.00 0.0 103.64 12.14 91.50 767.20 12.0 103.64 12.22 91.42 767.12 HOR 41.0 103.64 12.57 91.07 766.77 75.0 103.64 13.17 90.47 766.17 TOR 85.0 103.64 13.40 90.24 765.94 103.0 103.64 14.41 89.23 764.93 PMD 110.0 103.64 14.63 89.01 764.71 128.0 103.64 13.88 89.76 765.46 PMD 148.0 103.64 13.02 90.62 766.32 CV 151.0 103.64 14.48 89.16 764.86 PMD 165.0 103.64 14.84 88.80 764.50 176.0 103.64 14.11 89.53 765.23 202.0 103.64 13.87 89.77 765.47 224.0 103.64 13.30 90.34 766.04 CV 226.0 103.64 14.74 88.90 764.60 240.0 103.64 15.88 87.76 763.46 PMD 264.0 103.64 14.48 89.16 764.86 PMD 287.0 103.64 13.61 90.03 765.73 HOR Thalweg Slope (ft. /ft.) 0.005 Riffle Slope 0.015 40 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Left Bankfut! - Main Tributary #2 Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 3/19/2013 BM # 1(ft.)== 775.70 41 Height of Height Distance; Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore-Sight Depth STATION B.S. ILL F.S. Elevation Corrected Elevation COMMENTS B.M. # 1 2.12 102.12 100.00 5.0 102.12 8.33 93.79 769.49 37.0 102.12 8.47 93.65 769.35 59.0 102.12 8.32 93.80 769.50 82.0 102.12 8.45 93.67 769.37 109.0 102.12 8.52 93.60 769.30 127.0 102.12 8.34 93.78 769.48 148.0 102.12 8.15 93.97 769.67 176.0 102.12 8.29 93.83 769.53 202.0 102.12 8.46 93.66 769.36 224.0 102.12 7.93 94.19 769.89 240.0 102.12 7.81 94.31 770.01 264.0 102.12 7.98 94.14 769.84 287.0 102.12 8.01 94.11 769.81 41 Third Year Monitoring Report: Main Tributary #2 New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Right Bankf iH - Main Tributary 42 Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 3/19/2013 BM #I (ft.)-- 775.70 42 Height of Height Distance; Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore-Sight Depth STATION B.S. ]ELL F.S. Elevation Corrected Elevation COMIMM'S B.M. # 1 2.12 102.12 100.00 5.0 102.12 7.88 94.24 769.94 37.0 102.12 7.61 94.51 770.21 59.0 102.12 8.04 94.08 769.78 82.0 102.12 8.07 94.05 769.75 109.0 102.12 8.65 93.47 769.17 127.0 102.12 8.19 93.93 769.63 148.0 102.12 8.22 93.90 769.60 176.0 102.12 8.51 93.61 769.31 202.0 102.12 8.52 93.60 769.30 224.0 102.12 8.31 93.81 769.51 240.0 102.12 8.27 93.85 769.55 264.0 102.12 8.74 93.38 769.08 297.0 102.12 8.55 93.57 769.27 42 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Appendix C Tributary A Cross Sections Third Year Monitoring Comparison — As- Built, First Year, Second Year, and Third Year Tributary A Longitudinal Profile Third Year Monitoring Comparison — First Year, Second Year, and Third Year Tributary A Pebble Count Tributary A Raw Data Third Year Monitoring 43 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 44 LO U I t L U O v N m C � I Y p C ca LO M I U ' I c o I v d o cle) N I o ' L II U I � ^ N Q I (D v I I C ca II O N N p � 1 N� I.L O V Z I Ln I I I I C) LO M 0') C.0 (.0 ti LO (.0 ti ti ti (•11) U014BA013 44 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 45 p 0 In O L `.' ^ l' Ui L O 3 r► 3 d U) Y O N N O 0 m LL o a o ! O � C 0 LO N p O ^ CM V d v Q C Lr) 4a N 3 O N C (1) O 3 a� z U') ° O In M O') 1` LO (-4) u01;eAG13 45 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 46 Ln CN U N N O m M Y 0 (n N Q N M ,^ LO `- J I.L V C p O CY) to ^ N Ln_ Cv O as L V (� QO v/ LO �L L_. r� 1 NO LO 0 W Z V O LO C'7 O I` LO co C�0 C�.0 ti I` I` (•jj) UOIIBA013 46 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 47 LO N d � r O O O N N } LO w �} M Y 0 Q N m IL O D O U C� U cn O `~ O M L U = Q N N � O � N 'L H � 0 � o 'Ln V ^^ ,, L J Z � O L C'J J '^ L J ('11) U O IIBA013 47 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 L �Ly C C �3 O C� L � rte. i. •r z O O O O O O O O (133;) uousnal'a 48 0'081 O'OL 1 0'091 O Os I 0 or1 0,0C I O'OZI O'OI I 0'001 0'06 o'o8 0'OL 0'09 O'OS 0'Ob O'0f O QZ oat 0'0 0 r m a� 3 L I LL Y co IY n a> U L9 7 N (O Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 0-0 I� 0 a � C CC � H 3 z 0.081 O*OL I 0'091 0'0S I 0'011 1 0'0£ 1 O'OZ I 0'011 0.001 w 0 0'06 0'08 0'OL 0'09 0'0S O'Or 0.0£ O.OZ 0'01 0'O O O O O O O O c O (laaj) u04en31:j 49 v 0 N m N 3 m L I♦T� I M r O N 0) N 3 L H I N O N cn (D 3 M L 0 N LL Y [0 c+) 0 N LL Y m J O N N U cz 7 U) N Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 Tributary A -Pebble Count W Metric mm Particle S A N D Count Tot # % Tot % Cum <0.062 Silt/Clay 16 100 16.0 16.00 0.062 - 0.125 Very Fine Sand 3 100 3.0 19.00 0.125 - 0.250 Fine Sand 11 100 11.0 30.00 0.25-0.5 Med. Sand 2 1 100 1 2.0 1 32.00 0.5 - 1.0 Coarse Sand 6 100 6.0 38.00 1.0-2.0 Very Coarse Sand 2 100 2.0 40.00 2-4 Very Fine Gravel G R A V E L 0 100 0.0 40.00 4-5.7 Fine Gavel 0 100 0.0 40.00 5.7-8 Fine Gavel 2 100 2.0 42.00 8 - 11.3 Medium 3 100 3.0 45.00 11.3-16 Medium 11 100 11.0 56.00 16-22.6 Coarse 8 100 8.0 64.00 22.6-32 Coarse 8 100 8.0 72.00 32-45 Very Coarse 8 100 8.0 80.00 45-64 Very Coarse 4 100 4.0 1 84.00 64-90 Small c O n b e 7 100 7.0 91.00 90-128 Small 1 100 1.0 92.00 128-180 Large 1 100 1.0 93.00 180-256 Large 0 100 0.0 93.00 256-362 Small e 0 1 d e r 0 100 0.0 93.00 362-512 Small 0 100 0.0 93.00 512-1024 Medium 0 100 0.0 93.00 11024-2048 Large - Very Large 0 100 0.0 93.00 Bedrock lBedrock 1 7 1 100 1 7.0 100.00 W Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 PPl--1 0 D H CC Q r.. O V a� n v ..O S v O ( %) ;uaa.'ad amleln=3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 R 0 R 0 R 0 v, o v, o vi o ( %);uaaaad 51 O O o 31ao1pag 860Z-bZOi vZOI - ZIS ZIS -Z9£ Z9£-9SZ 9SZ-081 081-8ZI 8ZI-06 06-b9 b9-St Sb-Z£ Z£-9'ZZ 9'ZZ-9I 9I-£'II £'ii -8 8 -L's L'S -t b - Z O'Z -0'I 0' I -S'0 S'0-SZ'O OSZ'0-SZl'0 SZ I'0 - Z90'0 Z90'0> a� c� u L CC a Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 PP---1 rlq ee r.+ D C O i. A N Cif V C� a O O O V a� a� a a� b 3 s O CC ►5 I 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (%) aaulA lua"ad 52 0000t 0001 001 O1 1'0 10'0 a� e� a Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II T 4 s w �pp.wpp�pp,w� �.pw we C Y i 3 ezYJE a wye +tG rIL G � lV fV lV fV fh N lV C R m g 5 � _ ob m?��sssssossoo�oo z �b e zz 4 12 NO e 0 E m u Q - v��cw O d N N N ^ O O - 4 4 � � 3 53 i N r GY ,� 0 �3 Project No. P -3741 LO 1 1 I W ' 1 I l , 1 I U I I � I r (Y� C I O I V I d i � ' 1 O M N 1 N ' O 1 L I 1 ' Q I N � i i � d v w ' Q �L O o I H ea o LO I 1 I d R O r � 1 I 3 ' d Z I I I 1 LO I v� I O LO M O') ti I- I LO (•11) uoileAOID Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase I1 0 N 9 R i m o� r}Ca a 9 3 o� o U daz acs �o Zd N L zz0;4 G 0 �t F Gal W u Z °x 'e "e U 0. 0. G E�!° u�pp riup.u,w� wry u,� � 3 Y Q a � S r e v m W N 00 8 9� o 1 8 O N C N O 8 O W N r� ]L W J4 .m7 a: o� a O t` r 40 a r V vii N b 800 o a n r 8P-v5 S a && R a a 118S8 o8o19 0002 o r o 0 o eo 0 0 m 54 8,$ p�n �0 n p G C Q W s ; u LO c vv�'i �°vv a � ,C Nt7 y o w v O O 3 a � "p r (D r r a o `v 3 Project No. P -3741 LO p i O O i i O LO L t� D ; 2 C C c o O i m m LL S ° 9 � 7I� I I O I I CO) I I N � N i U') M U I Q O � I Cl) v � 7 i LO N N p �L I I O V N � I O C I 1 T" O 'a 1 O f11 V I I r 3 I I I Z I LO O In CO O ti U) (D CD (74) UOIJBAal3 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Water Surface - Tributary A Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project Location Greensboro, NC Date: 4/1/2014 BM #I (ft.)= 775.70 WS Slope (ft./ft.) 0.017 Riffle Slope 0.030 iYi] Height of Height Distance; Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore-Sight Depth STATION B.S. ELL F.S. Elevation Corrected Elevation COMMENTS B.M. # 1 5.75 105.75 100.00 0.0 105.75 12.67 93.08 768.78 10.0 105.75 12.83 92.92 768.62 13.0 105.75 13.40 92.35 768.05 27.0 105.75 13.43 92.32 768.02 44.0 105.75 14.07 91.68 767.38 58.0 105.75 14.07 91.68 767.38 62.0 105.75 14.08 91.67 767.37 77.0 105.75 14.12 91.63 767.33 82.0 105.75 14.15 91.60 767.30 83.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 93.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 106.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 116.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 119.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 135.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 147.0 105.75 14.72 91.03 766.73 148.0 105.75 15.17 90.58 766.28 154.0 105.75 15.17 90.58 766.28 170.0 105.75 15.17 90.58 766.28 185.0 105.75 15.17 90.58 766.28 WS Slope (ft./ft.) 0.017 Riffle Slope 0.030 iYi] Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Tbah+eg - Tributary A Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 4/1/2014 BM # 1 (ft.)== 775.70 Height of Height Distance; Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore -Sight Depth STATION R.S. ILL Es. Elevation Corrected Elevation CObLNILNTS B.M. #I 0.0 10.0 13.0 27.0 44.0 58.0 62.0 77.0 82.0 83.0 93.0 106.0 116.0 119.0 135.0 147.0 148.0 154.0 170.0 185.0 Thalweg Slope (ft. /ft.) 5.75 105.75 100.00 105.75 12.90 92.85 768.55 HOR 105.75 13.09 92.66 768.36 TOR 105.75 14.05 91.70 767.40 PMD 105.75 13.81 91.94 767.64 HOR 105.75 14.22 91.53 767.23 TOR 105.75 14.85 90.90 766.60 PMD 105.75 14.67 91.08 766.78 HOR 105.75 14.41 91.34 767.04 105.75 14.24 91.51 767.21 CV 105.75 15.60 90.15 765.85 PMD 105.75 16.34 89.41 765.11 PMD 105.75 16.30 89.45 765.15 PMD 105.75 15.59 90.16 765.86 PMD 105.75 15.56 90.19 765.89 105.75 15.80 89.95 765.65 105.75 14.85 90.90 766.60 CV 105.75 16.77 88.98 764.68 PMD 105.75 16.72 89.03 764.73 PMD 105.75 15.54 90.21 765.91 HOR 105.75 16.32 89.43 765.13 TOR 0.013 56 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Left Bankfull - Tributary A Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 3/19/2013 BM # 1 (ft.)= 775.70 Height of Height Distance; Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore -Sight Depth STATION B.S. ILL F.S. Elevation Corrected Elevation CONrUff- IS B.M. # 1 2.56 102.56 100.00 0.0 102.56 7.00 95.56 771.26 10.0 102.56 7.51 95.05 770.75 27.0 102.56 7.38 95.18 770.88 44.0 102.56 7.65 94.91 770.61 62.0 102.56 8.06 94.50 770.20 77.0 102.56 8.45 94.11 769.81 82.0 102.56 8.45 94.11 769.81 119.0 102.56 9.45 93.11 768.81 135.0 102.56 8.82 93.74 769.44 147.0 102.56 8.75 93.81 769.51 170.0 102.56 8.86 93.70 769.40 57 Third Year Monitoring Report: Tributary A New Garden Road Widening Phase II Project No. P -3741 LONGITUDINAL PROFILE: Right Bankfull - Tributary A Project Name: New Garden Road Widening Phase 11 Project Location: Greensboro, NC Date: 3/19/2013 58 BM # 1 (ft.)= 775.70 Height of Height Distance; Point Back -Sight Instrument Fore -Sight Depth STATION B.S. RL F.S. Elevation Corrected Elevation COMDUN'i'S B.M. #1 2.56 102.56 100.00 0.0 102.56 7.19 95.37 771.07 10.0 102.56 6.97 95.59 771.29 27.0 102.56 7.40 95.16 770.86 44.0 102.56 7.33 95.23 770.93 62.0 102.56 8.30 94.26 769.96 77.0 102.56 8.07 94.49 770.19 82.0 102.56 8.14 94.42 770.12 119.0 102.56 8.84 93.72 769.42 135.0 102.56 8.93 93.63 769.33 147.0 102.56 8.66 93.90 769.60 170.0 102.56 9.08 93.48 769.18 58