20051690 Ver 1_More Info Received_20140228

Strickland, Bev
From: Kulz, Eric
Sent: Friday, February 28, 2014 3:30 PM
To: Strickland, Bev
Subject: FW: [EXTERNAL] Google Earth files for minor trib to Big Gov and Trib 1 (UNCLASSIFIED)
Attachments: Carbonton Dam Credit Table 20140225.xlsx
Eric W. Kulz
Environmental Senior Specialist
401 and Buffer Permitting Unit
NCDENR - Division of Water Resources — Water Quality Permitting Section
1650 MSC
• ' ' .I MI
E -mail correspondence to and from this address may be subject to the North Carolina Public Records Law and may be
disclosed to third parties
From: Adam Riggsbee [ma i Ito: adamOriverbankecosystems.com]
Sent: Friday, February 28, 2014 3:23 PM
To: Kulz, Eric
Subject: Fwd: [EXTERNAL] Google Earth files for minor trib to Big Gov and Trib 1 (UNCLASSIFIED)
Eric-
Thanks for the call today. Please see the email below from Tugwell. It appears you were not copied.
I'll reach out to you in a couple of weeks about this.
Thanks,
Adam
Adam Riggsbee, PhD I Partner I RiverBank Ecosystems
P.O. Box 29921 ( AUstin, TX 8755 ( p. 5122413775 ( m. 512.. X0.3062
adam(a)riverbankecosystems.com I www.riverbankecosystems.com

Begin forwarded message:
From: "Tugwell, Todd SAW" <Todd.Tugwell(ausace.army.mil>
Subject: RE: [EXTERNAL] Google Earth files for minor trib to Big Gov and Trib 1
(UNCLASSIFIED)
Date: February 25, 2014 at 8 :40 :48 AM CST
To: Adam Riggsbee <adama- riverbankecosystems.com>
Cc: "McLendon, Scott C SAW" < Scott. C.McLendon(a)usace.army.miI >, "Wicker, Henry M JR SAW"
< Henry .M.Wicker.JR(a)usace.army.mil >, "Baumgartner, Tim" <tim.baumgartner(a)ncdenr.gov >,
"Haupt, Mac" <mac.haupt(a)ncdenr.gov>
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE
Thanks Adam. I have added the info you provided on the Big Governor's trib to the credit table and also made
some other changes to the spreadsheet to try and reflect an accurate credit picture based on our agreed lengths
(your shapefiles). I'm not sure if you purposefully mapped the Big Governor's tributary to measure 354', but if
not it's good sign that your estimate came out exactly the same as mine. Also, note on the table that I have
included an estimate of what the numbers would be if all the smaller tributaries (every trib except the Deep
River, McLendon's, and Big Governors) were assumed not to generate the 20% human values bonus. In this
case, the numbers come out just over the contract amount, assuming all tributaries meet at least 2 criteria and
the 20% is applied to length and not adjusted credit. Give me a call and we can discuss in more detail if you
have questions.
I am in the process of trying to get some feedback from IRT members on these numbers, so we can hopefully
reach a consensus soon.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Todd Tugwell
Special Projects Manager
Wilmington District, US Army Corps of Engineers
11405 Falls of the Neuse Road
Wake Forest, NC 27587
Office: 919- 846 -2564
Mobile: [phone]
- - - -- Original Message---- -
From: Adam Riggsbee [ mailto :[e-mail]]
Sent: Monday, February 10, 2014 5:48 PM
To: Tugwell, Todd SAW
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Google Earth files for minor trib to Big Gov and Trib
• 451
See attached, and let me know if you have questions.

Thanks,
Adam
Adam Riggsbee, PhD I Partner I RiverBank Ecosystems
P.O. Box 29921 1 Austin, TX 78755 1 p. 512.241.3775 1 m. 512.970.3062
[e-mail] I www.riverbankecosystems.com < http: / /www.riverbankecosystems.com/>
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Caveats: NONE

Length, below Length Credit Baseline 10% Recreation
Length Length beaver dams (from Adam's Credit (based on Adam's Credit
Tributary Name (Mitigation Plan) (Google Earth) (Google Earth) Shapefiles) Flow Regime Multiplier Shapefiles) (based to length)
10% Research
Credit
(based on length)
10% Recreation
Credit
(based to credit)
10% Research
Credit
(based on credit)
Total Credit with
20% Bonus
(based on length)
Total Credit with
20% Bonus
(based on credit)
Notes
Deep River Main
63223
59764
59764
58329
Perennial
0.7
40830.3
5832.9
5832.9
4083.03
4083.03
52496.1
48996.36
Mitigation Plan includes 2,000' below dam, Adam's shapefile inclu
McLendon's Creek
16329
15034
15034
14792
Perennial
0.7
10354.4
1479.2
1479.2
1035.44
1035.44
13312.8
12425.28
Big Governor's Creek
14084
12291
12291
12211
Perennial
0.7
8547.7
1221.1
1221.1
854.77
854.77
10989.9
10257.24
Mitigation Plan includes small side trib (354')
Big Governor's Creek Tributary
0
354
354
354
Perennial
0.7
247.8
35.4
35.4
24.78
24.78
318.6
297.36
Small side trib (354') included in Big Gov. in Mitigation Plan
Little Governor's Creek
5322
5003
5003
5237
Perennial
0.7
3665.9
523.7
523.7
366.59
366.59
4713.3
4399.08
Lick Creek
2204
2285
2285
2211
Perennial
0.7
1547.7
221.1
221.1
154.77
154.77
1989.9
1857.24
Line Creek
4540
3991
555
572
Perennial
0.7
400.4
57.2
57.2
40.04
40.04
514.8
480.48
Tributary 1
4222
4212
662
649
Perennial
0.7
454.3
64.9
64.9
45.43
45.43
584.1
545.16
Tributary 2
273
1099
1099
300
Perennial
0.7
210
30
30
21
21
270
252
Adam's shapefile stops at culvert
Tributary 3
1261
290
290
202
Perennial
0.7
141.4
20.2
20.2
14.14
14.14
181.8
169.68
Tributary 4
415
1373
1373
452
Intermittent
0.35
158.2
45.2
45.2
15.82
15.82
248.6
189.84
Adam's shapefile stops at beaverdam
Tributary 5
1724
1661
1661
1574
Perennial
0.7
1101.8
157.4
157.4
110.18
110.18
1416.6
1322.16
Tributary 6
3530
3730
3730
1395
Intermittent
0.35
488.25
139.5
139.5
48.825
48.825
767.25
585.9
Adam's shapefile stops at bridge below wetland
Tributary 7
5632
5787
5787
5673
Perennial
0.7
3971.1
567.3
567.3
397.11
397.11
5105.7
4765.32
Tributary 8
2007
1985
1985
883
Perennial
0.7
618.1
88.3
88.3
61.81
61.81
794.7
741.72
Adam's shapefile stops at beaverdam
Tributary 9
614
661
661
607
Perennial
0.7
424.9
60.7
60.7
42.49
42.49
546.3
509.88
Tributary 10
807
750
750
944
Perennial
0.7
660.8
94.4
94.4
66.08
66.08
849.6
792.96
Tributary 11
486
515
515
511
Perennial
0.7
357.7
51.1
51.1
35.77
35.77
459.9
429.24
Total
126673
120785
Total Potential Credit (from closeout summary) 101688
Total Contracted Credits (from closeout summary) 90494
113799 106896 74180.75 10689.6 10689.6 7418.075 7418.075 95559.95 89016.9
Total with Recreation & Research Credit applied to Big Governor's, McLendon's and Deep River Main Stem Only 91247.15 86127.23