20071212 Ver 1_Mitigation Reports_20070803

\alw ~~I IZe~~ nnt~c
[Z~~t~n~tti~nt~~('„nk~i~~ui~m
August 3, 2007
North Carolina Department of Environment
And Natural Resources
Division of Water Quality
401 Oversight and Express Review Program
1650 Mail Service Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-1650
ATTENTION: Eric Kulz, Stream Mitigation Specialist
RE: Brown Marsh Swamp Stream and Wetland Mitigation Site -Full Delivery
Project; Response to DWQ Letter dated July 27, 2007; DWQ #07-1212
After discussing your concerns with our design consultant, we have modified the
proposed valley slope to conform to the existing valley slope for both tributaries. A
revised table of Morphological Characteristics is enclosed for your review.
We appreciate your response time in addressing our response to your July 24, 2007
review comments. We also appreciate the constructive technical criticism you are
providing on our projects. We all gain from your input. Thanks.
If you have any questions or need additional information, please do not hesitate to contact us
at Restoration Systems at 919.755.9490 (randy axestorationsystems.com) or Ko &
Associates at 919.851.6066 (rsmithr koassociates.com). Thanks for your time and
consideration.
Sincerely, ~,,,,~
M. Randall Turner
Cc: Cyndi Karoly, NCDWQ
Ryan Smith, Ko & Associates, P.C.
Kevin Williams, Ko 8c Associates, P.C.
Pilot Mill • 1101 Haynes St.. Suite 107 • Raleieh. NC 2760 • ww~ti~.restorationsystems.com • Phone [phone] • Eax 919.755.9=192

L
~ C (A
~ ~ ~
~ r
E S S
O
~ Gl
~y O ~ ~ t y
w w
~ ~ ~ Uj
N ~
c7 .0-- O
o 01 V
N C
~ ~ O
O O
O .'C O ~j N

G
a in
W ~
V N
OO f'1
O O
O ~!
O O ICJ
m n
~ O
O Of
N '
N
V '
n
V '
~ '
M '
00 '
n ~[l n
N 7
N '
O '
O N
~ n c7
~
O a0
0
0
t~
Ql
w
~
U Q
O
~ th f
N ( O C7 O
O O
O p
R
O O ~
~ •
•
7 N

U ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Y
N ~
r-
~
~
C N
~.. h
~J
~
~ N
i~. V
f0 m
N ~O
N ~
N Q
N ~
~0. ~ S
O O
c^i
.'C
~ ~
1"~ v
~U

`1 (5 iA
W
V c+~ ~
~ ~
(D O

N ~ c0
O
C1 tD
H
N O
O
O ~A
(D
N
n
M
+
n
0 '
`- '
fn c0
E
O (O
N
O
O
O
O N
''
f7 n ~(f
O ~
O
,p '
O
~ ~ ¢
b
O
N ~ n [
) Qj O 4J S
O

~

i
~ 4]
= t0
r
.K
.r
~ N
.~ N
~
L
~ N
n O
n
N O
N Qj
ltd n
In ~
~ ~
.~ O
O O
N
~
.~ ~j
m M
O
d
,~ `(~'
m L
CT• N
W ~
U th
O u"i
O aD
O (D
O~ C1
O cD
~C1 O
^
jS N
~ '
O '
r- '
n '
c') '
O '
m M
M n
O t+f
p '
N '
N O
tl7 fG O
~ n
O '
O '
m
1+ - ¢ O
N N N V t7 m N O O O O ~ M
O
d ~ r ~ v 0 0 0
~
..
Z
N `
l'
S O
N C
() O O
N ~
O
N
c
~

V m
R'
4
`~
cn
o
x
x ~

~ a
c F-
~ M

~
cv
~
a
~
'~
1O O
o ui
a
n
o
ri O
~
co
o
co

~
x
~
r
z'

Y m
o
n

m
1p ~
L U E i .K ~ ~.- i ~ ~ ~ c x .
_
~n o '
-
U "y
~ ~
y y
L
o n
W ~
V
¢ u~ c~
~ in
i~ so
A ~
O N
~ ~
O
O o
M N O O O O O rn
~ m
S o
O a
pOp v,
O n
~
M o
N O
N tD V
i
V a
•~ A
o ~
o

O
a
Z
N
M ~ ~'i ci
N CV c7
N cV
O
O O
O n
N fV
m
r
a ~,

H

~

o

r

o

~
rd Ez
N S
~ N c n O ~ N O M-
A
N c ~
~ ~
-
~
z
~
~
~
~ S
to 0
~ t~
o N
~ g
~O
N
~
~
~

~

~
~ .
w 0 p
U
C Z h
C7 . n
O N
W m
N n
QI ~
w
O ~-
N fp
E n
.-
N 0
N
S ^ ''
V7 '!
O
N S O
0 _O
0 S
0 O
0
0
N v `
n
O O
S '
(D
G
E C
h
EE
N
~f( C
~y Q
O
N N
u]
~
S p
O
(D ccpp
N
O
O
O p
S
M
3
3p ~ y ~
m` ~° z s W W N
m ~ a~ O
4 ~ .m ~ r ~ O J
LL z
° ~ p ~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ a a
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 w ,e r O O O ~ rn
~
c ~ ~
w ~ ¢
O O W x ~
` ~ E
v ~ ~ ~ a ~ ~ ? O
LL
v
¢ ~
p O
N
~ w
> ~
¢
x a
w
o ¢
~, ~
x
~ E
~ ~
¢
> $
3 4Q

x
~ in O
J
~ ~

F a
w
o b O

3 a O

~ x

w a
w ~
o z
a
w ~ ~
w
cn z
¢
w U
~n
~ o
a z~
w c~
Z o
~- n
x o
t-
~ r
O
W w
Q
O ~ J LL J a
O ~ J
O y
J J F'
pp o
YYLL h
¢ _
7i ~ x
F-
LL X ~ O ~ v
V ~
= ~ E
J U ~
~ = ~ v LLO J
N Ui
LL S
a w
p w
00
a =
H 0
LL 0 0~
LL
Z

~ F

¢ W

¢ J
J
W J
J
~
W
~
_ J
J
~ J
J
u=. J
J
LL J
J
LL
V
LL
U
w
~
o
lL
O LL
O
~
LL
O N
Q
~
~
w0
~
y J
(n
~.
W
C~
p
~
LL
O J
p
O J
LL J
O ~
~
~?
LL
O a

~ J
LL J
O ~

~
w ¢
U W
~ Z
Q Y
2 Y
Z '
-
O Y
Z Y
Z Y
Z Y
Z ~
p ~
F Z
¢ p
F ~
O O
H ~
J Z
¢ p
~ J
J ~
W J
O O d
1- O a
~ O Y
F- Z J
O O F
k- J
O O y
F- Z
~ ~ Q m m _
~ m m m m ~ w ~ ~ g ~ m ~ i > ¢ a ~v ~ g
m a ~3 a ~m
c o a n ~ a 2
~y
O
t~
l0
LUtl!
7
B
N
O
n
.L..
.C
CS
d
C
d
~c
U
t
C
r ~
c
3 ry
d ~
G
N
d ~
m$
0
~ _o
~i `~
~ $,
U ~
d
m
m ~
a ~
c m
o
U
a
m~
c
H ~
w E
d
0 0
Z y

L
N uJ ~ C ~ ~ ~
~

V 3
(n ~
O
O

~

~
b
a-
00
hU

,C

.~ o
O
n w
OD ~o
N
~ ~
~ o
(O

~
N
~
~
~
~
~ O
O
O
rn
O

r

.~ o
th
N ~-

fO
C
m
`y =

O 10
w ,
U
Q N
P') W
~
O Of
n aD th M
(V N
A:
O O
O
O O
(G
N ,
O'
N ,
N
M ,
C
O '
N
n
uJ '
~A O
N V
t0
O W
CO
~ '
O
~
O
O O l7
nj O
~
01
O ,
O
rn ,
7
N
a' ~
~ O
O
O
V O O ~
O
L ~
U ~ ,K ~ ~ 00 w
m
_
'R V
`7
O

C

R

r
N
~.-
y
~

~

~' O
~
N
~q
M f`')
~
.-
rn
~ V
O)
~
O
N O
O
O
O
O

~

~ tD
~
O
N
U
C
~ `-'
~ l!7
w ,
U N
O Lh
~ O
N N
N O N
O n
N O
O
` rn
iq ,
N
V ,
n ,
rn ,
t'1 ,
m ,
n N n
N V
N '
O '
O 10
n n c7
W O]
O
O
n
~ Q ~
J [
N N O th O O O O O ~
r ~ 0 0 0

N ~
~ ~ O

OC
V .
~ cp
N
A
t O
ti
~
7 ro o ~ ~ x ~ ~
O~
N C ~
O 5 ~
O
r
x
~
.~
v
,r 0
~ 0
~ v~
N
~ O
7
W
~
~
0.~
~
~ w
V
c0
M '-°
Y; U
~ N
w
V N
r rn
n N
rn rn
N rn
O rn
C ~ c
Q o
N
~fJ
O
O
O
O
O
N o
O ~
0 ~
0 o
O n
rn ,n
N o
N o
O
O ,
V
N N O Q O "' N fh N N N N O O O n a0 N
.` .a
C O UJ O
N N N O O O
'° O
a N
~ m
a
L H
~
a E i
U m y
• o
~
C F,
] cn
o 'r
~ N C
p O
U C
~ O .K G r ,.. U ~ ~ Y~' Y' ~ ~ ~ rn
'
O ~
(J
~ v~
w U co
N rn
o .-
N o
M m rn
V v
N
~ c c~
" o
8 rn
M
~ o
In
~ n
~ o
8 0
W
~ 0
O
~ o
N
S r>
O
o S
o o
O ~ o ~ rn
`~ '
n n
g o o ~ o
N ~ O O O
O C N
~ ~ O > Y
m ~ ~ ~ 1f
w
vi
C T 1. ~.
m ~ a a
O
d o~ Y
U ~
~ w w j f-
~
~ aUi ' ~ ~ Y Z
o U U ~_
'~ ~ ~ a '~
~ x _ > >
a a a
N

~
~
~

x
~ ?O,
E Q
a~ } N
~G
~ Y
~ ~
W
~ Q

O m

~ ~ (n
J
N
3 a ~ Z O w x
~ y 0 E ~ O ~
~ O z
U 0
ti
Q
'~ W
o O
f O
,_ W
> ~
a a
w Q
y ~ ~
x 3
~ ~
Q $

3 aq

~
~ O
J ,~ a
w p
a a
0

w
W
ry =
~
Q
w qa

x U
w
'? Z
Q
w x
U
~ o
~C
¢ c
Q
a te
Z
w r-
O
Z
O
t- >
~
~
O
F

w x
F
a
LLJ w
a
O ~
'mot' m
J
o x
~
w ox
J a
0
w
~ ~
J
O N
J

O ix
J F-
O ~

Z ~-
~ Q
W 3
J ~
J F-
W x
J ~
J o
J ~
J
~ ~
x w
~ E
J U
LL c~
~
~
a Y
} a
~ J
~ ui
a
O O
a
°
a 0
I2-
d
a '
a J

O
gq
Q J
LL J
LL
O J
LL J
LL J
w J
LL
LL U
W
~ LL
O O
N LL
O p
j.
>
O H
N fn
} W
C~
~ LL
O
Q LL J
O M ~
?f V-
O
~ LL J
O~

~
w Q
U W
~ Z

ad Y
z Y
z ~
p Y
z Y
z Y
z Y
z ~
o ~
~ Z
a
ui O
~ _~
~ O
~ ~
J Z
Q
w O
~
Z J
J ~
w J
0 O a
~ 0 a
Y-j O Y
i- z J
O O~
~ p J
0 O Y
i- z

~ O
J ~
N
~ a
m s
m
~ a
m c
m a
m a
m -
z z
w
.>
~
~ a
a w
m
~
~ a
> >
a O
a J
a~cn "~
~
~~ O
a
~~ O
a a
~m
m
A
Q
LC
S
C
N
d
C
N
d
c
`o m
C t
U
C ~
C C
(0 ~
L
U y
v £
~~
~ o°
r N
c ~
L_ ~
3 d
L ~
m ~
~~
N
">°.
~ U
O 0
D
d `O
c
p T
U E
d ~
f0 0
~ ~
v ~
j °c
m
o,
m o
~_( N
L y
~ ~
0
Z m