HomeMy WebLinkAbout20181272 Ver 1_Yea 2 Monitoring Report_2021_20220105ID#* 20181272 Version* 1
Select Reviewer:
Erin Davis
Initial Review Completed Date 01/05/2022
Mitigation Project Submittal - 1/5/2022
Is this a Prospectus, Technical Proposal or a New Site?* O Yes O No
Type of Mitigation Project:*
Stream Wetlands Buffer Nutrient Offset
(Select all that apply)
Project Contact Information
Contact Name:* Email Address:*
Paul Wiesner paul.wiesner@ncdenr.gov
Project Information
........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
ID#:* 20181272 Version:* 1
Existing ID# Existing Version
Project Type: • DIMS Mitigation Bank
Project Name: Greenbrier Stream Restoration Site
County: Yadkin
Document Information
Mitigation Document Type:*
Mitigation Monitoring Report
File Upload: Greenbrier _100086_MY2_2021.pdf 6.79MB
Please upload only one PDF of the complete file that needs to be submitted...
Signature
Print Name: * Paul Wiesner
Signature: *
Year 2 Monitoring Report
FINAL
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Yadkin County, North Carolina
Monitoring Year 2
Data Collection Period:
July — October 2021
Submission Date:
December 2021
NCDEQ Contract No. 7616
DMS ID No. 100086
USACE Action ID No. SAW-2018-01755
NCDWR ID: 20181272
Yadkin River Basin
HUC 03040101
Prepared For: Prepared By:
INC Department of Environmental Quality Ecosystem Planning and Restoration
Division of Mitigation Services Ira
1150 SE Maynard Road, Suite 140
1652 Mail Service Center Cary, INC 27511
Mang°"°nser""' Raleigh, INC 27603
Mitigation mac ,
ECOSYSTEM
PLANNING &
RESTORATION
Mr. Paul Wiesner
NCDEQ— Division of Mitigation Services
5 Ravencroft Dr., Suite 102
Asheville, NC 28801
December 8, 2021
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration, LLC
1150 SE Maynard Road, Suite 140
Raleigh, NC 27511
Phone: (919) 388-0787
www.eprusa.net
RE: Response to Draft MY2 Monitoring Report Comments dated November 30, 2021
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Site
Yadkin River Basin — CU# 03040101- Yadkin County, North Carolina
NCDMS Project # 100086, Contract # 7616
Dear Mr. Wiesner,
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration (EPR) has reviewed the comments on the Draft MY2
Monitoring Report provided November 30, 2021. The comments have been addressed as described
below and the Final Baseline Report and electronic deliverables have been revised in response to
this review.
• Table 1. Project Mitigation Quantities and Credits: The thermal regime for the project
streams is "warm". Please update the table accordingly.
• Thermal Regime in Table 1 has been updated. The Microsoft Excel version of Table
1 in the electronic support files has been updated as well.
• Section 2.2.1 Vegetation Monitoring Data - Please discuss the average tree heights in the
vegetation plots assessed and (although early) note if the project vegetation appears to be
on track to meet the year 5 interim height success criteria.
• A discussion regarding plot height has been added to Section 2.2.1.
• CCPV Maps: The overview map is incorrectly labeled as MYO: 2020. The aerial orthoimagery
is from 2018. Please update the maps if more recent aerial imagery is available. Please
QA/QC the CCPV maps and update as necessary.
• The date on the overview maps has been updated. The 2018 aerial orthoimagery
shown in the CCPV is the latest aerial image available for the project area. EPR will
update these images in future monitoring years as new imagery becomes available.
• Table 4 (a-d) & Table 5 - Please include the date that the project was visually assessed at the
top of each table. This was an IRT request at the 2021 credit release meeting.
• The project assessment dates have been included in Tables 4 and 5.
""`�—j Providing ecosystem planning and restoration services to support a sustainable environment �—
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration, LLC
EcoSYSTEM 1150 SE Maynard Road, Suite 140
Raleigh, NC 27511
PLANNING 8c
RESTORATION Phone: (919) 388-0787
www.eprusa.net
• Appendix A. Monitoring Year 2 (2021) -Photo Point Logs: Please provide dates for all
project photo points. If exact dates cannot be provided, please include the month and year for
each photo.
• Dates have been included for all project photo points.
• Report Text and Appendix 8: In the revised report (Appendix B), please provide a planting
map and species list from the March 2021 supplemental planting effort reported in Section
2.2.1 Vegetation Monitoring Data. Please reference the planting map and species list in the
report text.Please also report what percentage of the initial planted area was supplementally
planted in MY2(2021). The supplemental planting area should also be included on the MY2
CCPV maps.
• A planting species list has been included in Appendix B, and the planted areas are
now shown on the CCPV. The map and species list are referenced in section 2.2.1
Vegetation Monitoring Data. The approximate percentage of the original planted
area has also been included in this section.
Table 7. Vegetation Performance Standards Summary Table: Please report the average
vegetation plot height in the summary table.
• Average height has been included in Table 7. The average height reported in the
document was calculated from the stem height in the input file for the vegetation
tool. The vegetation tool rounds these heights to whole numbers so that is why
they are presented this way in the tables.
Electronic Support File Comments:
The submitted input template for the DMS Veg tool cannot reproduce the tables included in the
report. Several issues were identified:
The fixed plot data for years 0 and 1 are not consistent with previously submitted veg data.
This is likely because not all dead stems were retained in the plot specific excel sheets.
• Fixed plot data for years 0 and 1 have been updated in the input file and the plot
data is now consistent from year to year. The draft submittal only included stems
that were still living in MY2, but all stems will be included in this data moving
forward.
• A formula was used to calculate stems per acre for fixed plot 4 in the Post Mitigation Plan
Performance Standard section, the Current Year Stem Count was changed, and species count
was changed.
• The formula was used to calculate the total stems per acre for plot 4 because of a
misunderstanding about what the Post Mitigation Plan Performance Standard row
""`�-j Providing ecosystem planning and restoration services to support a sustainable environment �-
ECOSYSTEM
PLANNING &
RESTORATION
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration, LLC
1150 SE Maynard Road, Suite 140
Raleigh, NC 27511
Phone: (919) 388-0787
www.eprusa.net
was meant to show. This has been corrected for the final submittal and only the
output that was produced by the DMS vegetation tool is included.
• One stem in the random plot 5 tab does not have a height.
• The stem in Random Plot 5 has been updated to include a height.
• Please do not edit the output of the tool — the logic used to calculate these output values is
based on the current IRT requirements. To ensure that output data is consistent for the
Vegetation Performance Standards Summary Table, be sure to maintain a record of each
stem in the input across monitoring years. If the stem dies, do not include a height in the
current monitoring year's height column but keep the record of the stem in the input. There
is an example dataset for reference that can be downloaded from the application. DMS has
also included an example using Greenbrier veg data for Fixed plot 1 and Random Plot Group
5.
• The output of the vegetation tool has not been edited for the final submission. This
practice will be used moving forward for future monitoring submittals.
Please include a feature representing the supplemental planting areas and display this in
the CCPV map/s.
• The shapefile Greenbrier _2021_Planting_Zones has been added to the electronic
submission CCPV folder. This shapefile has been included in the CCPV.
If you have any questions regarding the MY1 Monitoring Report, please contact me at 919-623-5411
or via email at alamesPeprusa.net.
Sincerely,
Amy James, PWS
"'`�—j Providing ecosystem planning and restoration services to support a sustainable environment �—
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 PROJECT SUMMARY..........................................................................................................1
1.1 Goals and Objectives...........................................................................................................................1
1.2 Performance Criteria...........................................................................................................................1
2.0 MONITORING DATA ASSESSMENT....................................................................................6
2.1 Stream Monitoring..............................................................................................................................6
2.1.1 Stream Profile.............................................................................................................................6
2.1.2 Stream Dimension......................................................................................................................6
2.1.3 Channel Stability.........................................................................................................................7
2.1.4 Stream Hydrology.......................................................................................................................7
2.2 Riparian Vegetation Monitoring..........................................................................................................8
2.2.1 Vegetation Monitoring Data.......................................................................................................8
3.0 REFERENCES....................................................................................................................13
TABLES
TABLE 1. PROJECT MITIGATION QUANTITIES AND CREDITS.........................................................................2
TABLE 2. SUMMARY: GOALS, PERFORMANCE AND RESULTS.......................................................................3
TABLE 3. PROJECT ATTRIBUTE TABLE............................................................................................................5
FIGURES
FIGURE 1. VICINITY MAP..........................................................................................................................................9
FIGURE 2A-213. CURRENT CONDITION PLAN VIEW: ASSET MAP......................................................................10
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Yadkin County, North Carolina
APPENDICES
Appendix A: Visual Assessment Data
Table 4a-4b. Visual Stream Morphology Stability Assessment Table
Table 5. Vegetation Condition Assessment Table
Monitoring Year 2 Vegetation Photo Log
Monitoring Year 2 Photo Log
Appendix B: Vegetation Plot Data
Table 6. Vegetation Plot Data
Table 7. Vegetation Performance Standards Summary Table
2021 Supplemental Planting Species List
Appendix C: Stream Geomorphology Data
Cross -Sections with Annual Overlays
Table 8a-8d. Baseline Stream Data Summary
Table 9. Cross -Section Morphology Data Table
Appendix D: Hydrologic Data
Table 10. Verification of Bankfull Events
Figure 3. Monthly Rainfall Summary Data
Year 2 Streamflow Data
Appendix E: Project Timeline and Contact Information
Table 11. Project Activity and Reporting History
Table 12. Project Contacts Table
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Ir Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Yadkin County, North Carolina
1.0 PROJECT SUMMARY
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration, PLLC (EPR) implemented the Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
(Project; Site) for the North Carolina Division of Mitigation Services (NCDMS) to provide 2,300 stream
mitigation credits (SMCs) in the Yadkin River Basin, Hydrologic Unit Code (HUC) 03040101. The Project
was instituted via NCDEQ-DMS RFP # 16-007406. The Project restored and enhanced 2,530 linear feet
(LF) of one perennial (UT1) and three intermittent (UT1A, UT1A-1, and UT1B) unnamed tributaries (UT)
to South Deep Creek within a 6.7-acre conservation easement. Mitigation assets are listed in Table 1.
The Site is located in DMS targeted local watershed 03040101130020. The Site was historically utilized
for agricultural and cattle practices. As such, streams and existing wetlands in the project area were
adversely impacted by direct cattle access, farming activities, and stream channelization. The Site is
situated on once active pastureland in a WS-III watershed that is approximately 49% agricultural land,
42% forest, and 8% developed land, including open space and low intensity development. Prior to
construction activities, project streams were incised, straightened, and suffered from significant damage
from cattle. The adjacent wetlands were small, but similarly trampled, and heavily grazed. Pre -
construction, or pre-existing, site conditions are provided in Table 8 of Appendix C. Photos and a more
detailed description of Site conditions before restoration are available in the Mitigation Plan (Final
version submitted December 2019).
1.1 Goals and Objectives
The Project goals were established based on an assessment of site conditions and restoration potential
with careful consideration of the stressors identified in the Upper Yadkin Pee -Dee River Basin
Restoration Priorities (RBRP) report (NCEEP, 2009) and Yadkin Pee -Dee Basinwide Water Quality Plan
(NCDWQ, 2008). These goals and objectives are presented in Table 2.
Site construction, planting, and baseline vegetation data collection were completed in April 2020 and
the as -built survey was completed in May 2020. A detailed timeline of the Project activity and reporting
history is provided in Appendix E.
1.2 Performance Criteria
Project success criteria were established in accordance with the NCDMS Mitigation Plan Template (ver.
06/2017), and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers — Wilmington District Public Notice: Notification of Issuance
of Guidance for Compensatory Stream and Wetland Mitigation Conducted for Wilmington District
(October 24, 2016). The monitoring plan for the site follows the guidance NCDMSAnnual Monitoring
Report Format, Data, and Content Requirements (October 2020). Table 2 details the United States Army
Corps of Engineers (USACE) success criteria that evaluate whether project goals have been met
throughout the monitoring period.
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Ir Yadkin County, North Carolina
Table 1. Project Mitigation Quantities and Credits
Original
Project
Mitigation
Original
Original
As -built
Component
Plan
Thermal Regime
Restoration
Mitigation
Mitigation
(reach ID, etc.)
(ft)
(ft)
Level
Ratio (X:1)
Credits
Notes/Comments
Full Channel Restoration,
Planted Buffer, Exclusion
UT1 Reach 1
843.00
852.00
Warm
R
1.00000
843.00
of Livestock, and
Permanent Conservation
Easement.
Bank stabilization,
Bioengineering, Planted
Buffer, Exclusion of
UT1 Reach 2
40.00
40.00
Warm
E2
2.50000
16.00
Livestock, and
Permanent Conservation
Easement
Full Channel Restoration,
Planted Buffer, Exclusion
UT1 Reach 3
1097.00
1141.00
Warm
R
1.00000
1097.00
of Livestock, and
Permanent Conservation
Easement.
Grade Control
Structures, Bank
Stabilization, Exclusion of
UT1A-1
153.70
145.00
Warm
E2
2.50000
61.48
Livestock, and
Permanent Conservation
Easement.
Full Channel Restoration,
UT1A
148.50
153.00
Warm
R
1.00000
148.50
Planted Buffer, Exclusion
of Livestock, and
UT1B
247.50
228.00
Warm
R
1.00000
247.50
Permanent Conservation
Easement.
Total Assets Summary:
2,413.48
Length
and Area Summations by Mitigation Category
Overall Assets Summary
Stream
Riparian Wetland
Non -riparian
Restoration
Wetland
Asset Overall
Level
(linear
(acres)
(acres)
Category Credits
feet)
Non -
Riverine
Stream 2,413.48
Riverine
Restoration
2,336
Enhancement
Enhancement I
Enhancement 11
193.7
Rehabilitation
Preservation
High Quality
Pres
riGreenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Yadkin County, North Carolina
GO
b0
c
b0 N w
U
N N to
Y m bc-D N O U
N a t -p V
f6 Q p>
m
m u
N j N N N
p m N O
O m c a Q m L O N Q 'U
u L
m
N p0 E �O m V
u m
N c N
,S N O c c
bcD m T w O Y N w
O IA
} Y y L N
N -p o� Y N
O m G N c� U Q� m W Y c N
U E N
C +'
C
p N u
o� by a u >i
N M
L �p N>
N O— Y
f6 >• w N to _ f6 '6
'� c (U >i m a) p
p
u
> t M Yvmi
O a+ - m
O N o y m N
-O O c}
O N U N � ON > w N Q gym''
E T c-} N > U m
-p
i+
f0
c N
E s m m
L fl_ Y N O
N
N N U L c� 7 m N N
i N Q m bO v O O
N
O c 'O c
N pO c E M
N m
m 7 0 0 U w U N tko 7 L
C�
G
N >• O
N m > O
} c Q E m > Q m N c N
V
C N X p •N
N m
F v E s N
pp
N O N U c m N Q p O E
L b0 O O s L_ O tj m
D_ c
in N
N
N a N
~ N N C N
-p
>
U
N N N Y
N N
N
N In m
p T
00
p> N c u a
a
m
v N} c f6 v
w a c ti
O
O 7
m
N
•� N 0 N
m lD M
ar
N
m N m
T 0 Q
w
> n 3 Q CL
N �n O
O m L c
C O m
ar
"
a'
N N (mu
do N}" m
E
N vNi
i� " Q a t
'6
fYj
u ri o
i
N
>
N 'y1 N L
r c Y N O •N N
p
a
_O N b0 n ,� b0
C
N N U O
00
t c
0 7 c t
m
N O i N O
O
v
c
C
N
N m
3
T O .-
c c
O
V N vNi a •--�
U N
O
m
E N b0 Q D U>
O n
7
o O w M
N bD N
N c Q Q
O N
c
Q
c Q> N
m
O i m
U
C
V m -`p
p cy O
N N U
M
tkO
} ( N N O
E N
4�+
b0 N O N> N L O 7 _O N N m O m
-co E(u c O c U N N N m T c c N O o N O Q O X 3 c fL6 N N p� m
YO
m N- O -p '~ a kO U p c U> c N m p 7 O N U U m m N m ON N E u p- w
.0
u
c
c p co _v Y m ai N m m m s (5 a a U 'o O O w c aci ai = N `> ai ai
O c � a m � E� m E o rn v� oc � t °D w a w c t l :E �� E 2 m N E O a
Yn a `p
m
m o m c c m "n p m E .� m t c O w .— N v c m m U m t �n O m Q y
O N N L! U 7 w L! '6 U N N .- C L! m e m Y m N Q! N N E E '6 m- N O O c '^ L u N c U m E
O E
O
O v N m O p U 7 N m E N E O C E N m >• j a O_ •c O E c w 2 '^ v` O v W O m
w Q Ou N Z> w N Y -O N> U N N Ln in F w N m> CO Q E o N N Y m m c-1 O b0 W w m U a4 N
a
U c Vi N
m
O
>i O w N m c Y Y to
N O O
0
Y
> m c �6 m Q m m m N N
.L
o o° vv E = m o m o m U v N
c L -p N p N m >i w N N N N .m m N
_
3 Q
LL
m p
O p c m T U N L' N j Q'p C N 7 L Q m
m
D
N o c v E O N m m o c
3 0 L m
O i Q 0
N
1
u E N av+ c m
E Y ro v N pL
w �' E c o a -m m v m m w m v m °�'
J
N= 7 •- E m m in =, . 3 N N O
m
t O Lp U >
F o o m u 3 m 0 3 o o=a ° m w
do m
c=
do m
c t
to m
c s
v
U -5; j
Lai
j
NT
Uo
O�
Q O
O m
O m
O Q b
CL s.
_(U
a Y
_
to
_ °E
E
YO
Q
EY
p E
vTai
o E oo
E
a
YE
o -wc3
C++
wN
>
w� a
-0
m E
c
do>
w
E-0L
o •> a
o ?
EL
m m a
-p CL
w
•
�—
y >
c m m m
>• aiUN
>_ m m
c ai >,
m m
m c m
m L
N �• n p c
m
N N c
m 3
W
3 C O
c 3 C
tDi
N
m m 6 O
i
ac ac
ai ai do c
E c m
c ac
w m ai do c L
c m
� o
ac
ai m ai to c
_ c m
o
°
> 3
m L
E-
a� ai m w
a^
m N.
a v ;> E uc
n m E
� ;> E v e
ax n m E 7
� � .> E ac
n m E
ac
� E
u
3 E u N
G:
ax u
N CL N
0o O U m
U
O N W Q N Q
O U m c
ax u
7 N W.
O u m
Q m W.
e Lp c m
O
N o
YO > `� p-0 L
do Y c w °
c m c
°c° E Y c w a m
° m= m
W E a N
c ° a c
m 0 o v
m c
do m m p- m_0
c c
o N
u N o
N
a N a
N
u a N°
y
a m a°
a m
v m c to v
W s v a o m m
E m m m a`
°� v v 0 m m c
2
F E cOi co m m a `o
ac v (u v o m m
a a N
�_ E" 3 m m m W
c> m
a o �
`O a (U W
ac v_ Y 6 v m
w m u W>
- E- O `p - m
m N E N fl' C
m N U
N N 'O N N �" C N
U
m m 'O N E N �" C
N U
N 'O c
O
m L! m N N m c
N N N
p_ i p
in in O m u
c ai m Q i p N
in K Q O m u
ai m Q L O
in Q o m u
N c O
m d U
> v O
in _ U
C
N
L
C
u a
u c
N
N
m m
c mY
W v
c
W
i
a E
a dm
v u a m
acY Yt
E— — N
E ',,,
i6
u E N a
�T3-0-2
u �N,
-0
u p
� ;�
p c m
m m
Yns oo
p-
u a u Y
CL m
bD 2 m
U'
N N c Y
N m
NCL
N O
oC U
N c N
K W O K
E Q m Q
M
N
•OL J
a Q
Z
O LL C
m O
,,a�_n n 000 v
O t
Oo O O
m c 2k Z
ram`+
f^ +_ �+ C
au auO .lu � = O
g o U
C N d E
N i Vc) Y
m C -0
(:% >- }
!D D1 >•
c
_
to
N c
N
c
N
c m 3 O Y p 0
O N
O` a o
N—
o
m^ N
c N N
c
g=
c
u m o
+
c
m o
i ° 72 L
c
cu
a aT ° v
_
i u
Dc O
E 2• m
N N E
o
-2!
m°
u v
u F v Y
aEi
a N s 3 7^
v o6 "
N
o c
a x a T o chi a6
'�
7
E C N +m-' ']
N N
a 7
p
'6 T
L a N m j
v
w j -c Q
E
6 u N ami
D� -°
aTi m
o
a
m b0 c O a c
ai a m o c °c°
m
wbD
cc
v c C
> c v�
v
E
x L .fl o 3
O m 7
U _°
U N
v
Q C 7
O O
a
N
fl_ F N m O 00
M O O_ m E s
to 7 O
- M N
p c o c —0 —_
(j
_�
c c N ry• c 7 m N
c IS-
O O O i Y N O W. W c N
C
U N> bD C >i U b0
(p
c c
C >• O O C D� >• o c E 0 0 Wc
E
E a m m E l m bD o E o E@°
7 OL N N y 7 Y N 7 c 7 N m U •c
UO -O UO
i
ar
bO bO O
N_ O p v m o
o f >> a o a Y E o -° V. v E
a
u u E v— E >
a -->�
O O v N O
C
c
O N N N m 00 c
i•+
3 bD t N
c YO Q U w
E c w Y c
y
u•_
c Q
° 2-1m ° —
Y
a(u L
fl_ b0
Y
LL
71
N m
c N N w c 3 Y L! N bD m L
O Q N U c w 7 N (u +T+ U N
c c7i °i v c m 3 a, p a�i
ii o cLi > �n m F �n cLi a , �"
C
C
c i0 ai aci
a,
t E
> E a m a
0 L o '
E °'QCL s
o a o
a m Q o 3
v v m w
Q
m \ ,° Ln E
a v ° = t o
O °- E m D
Q N O 'E N c
Q N c,m v E U L 0
a Y a v
>i O � N
5 c
N N N
OC L N OC m a S
u
O
n 000 v
cu
o t
to O O
c 2k Z
.O Q T
� � C
O
o u
N d E
L V) Y
ca 2 -0
>. }
Table 3. Project Attribute Table
Project Background Information
Project Name
Greenbrier Stream Restoration Project
County
Yadkin
Project Area (acres)
6.7
Project Coordinates (latitude and longitude)
latitude 36.1488 N, longitude 80.8289 W
Planted Acreage (Acres of Woody Stems Planted)
6.3
Project Watershed Summary Information
Physiographic Province
Piedmont
River Basin
Yadkin Pee -Dee
USGS Hydrologic Unit 8
digit
03040101
USGS Hydrologic
Unit 14-digit
3040101130020
Project Drainage Area (Acres and Sq. Mi.)
85 acres/ 0.13 Sq.Mi. (Total)
Project Stream Thermal Regime
Warm
Project Drainage Area Percentage of Impervious
Area
<1%
CGIA Land Use Classification
Agriculture/Pasture 49%, Forest 42%, 8%
Residential/Developed
Reach Summary Information
Parameters
UT1
UT1A-1
UT1A
UT1B
Length of reach (linear feet)
1958
154
115
195
Valley confinement (Confined, moderately
confined, unconfined)
Moderately
confined
Unconfined
Unconfined
Unconfined
Drainage area (Acres and Square Miles)
0.13 SgA.Mi., 85
0.01 Sq.Mi., 8 Ac
0.01 Sq.Mi., 8 Ac
0.02 Sq.Mi., 10 Ac
Perennial, Intermittent, Ephemeral
Perennial
Intermittent
Intermittent
Intermittent
NCDWR Water Quality Classification
WS-III
WS-III
WS-III
WS-III
Stream Classification (existing)
B4c/B4
B4
F4
G4
Stream Classification (proposed)
B4/C4
B4
B4
B4
Evolutionary trend (Simon)
IV
III
IV
III
FEMA classification
X
X
X
X
Regulatory Considerations
Parameters
Applicable?
Resolved?
Supporting Docs?
Water of the United States - Section 404
Yes
Yes
USACE NWP 27 - ID# SAW-2018-01755
Water of the United States - Section 401
Yes
Yes
DWR 401 WQC No. 4134 -- ID # 20181272
Division of Land Quality (Erosion and Sediment
Control)
Yes
Yes
General Permit NCG010000 -
ID # YADKI-2020-010
Endangered Species Act
No
Yes
Categorical Exclusion Document; Appendix 6 in
Mitigation Plan
Historic Preservation Act
No
Yes
Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA or
CAMA)
No
N/A
N/A
FEMA Floodplain Compliance
No
N/A
N/A
Essential Fisheries Habitat
No
N/A
N/A
rAGreenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Yadkin County, North Carolina
2.0 MONITORING DATA ASSESSMENT
Monitoring Year 2 (MY2) data was collected in July and October 2021. Current site conditions and
monitoring data are described in the following sections to evaluate whether the project is meeting the
success criteria established in the mitigation plan.
2.1 Stream Monitoring
Stream monitoring involves field data collection to assess the hydrologic and geomorphic functions of
UT1, UT1A, and UT1B. Monitored parameters, methods, schedule/frequency, and extent are
summarized in Table 2. These monitoring parameters follow USACE guidance but will also allow for
monitoring of other parameters to document site performance related to the project goals listed in
Table 2. The locations of the established monitoring cross sections and stream gauges are shown in
Figure 2 Current Condition Plan View (CCPV).
2.1.1 Stream Profile
A full longitudinal profile was surveyed for the entire length of the restored streams in May 2020 to
document as -built conditions. This survey was tied to a permanent benchmark and includes thalweg,
right bank, and left bank features. Profile measurements were taken at the head and tail of each riffle,
inverts of in -stream structures, and at the max depth of pools. The longitudinal profile will not be
surveyed during annual monitoring unless vertical channel instability has been observed during
monitoring and remedial actions or repairs are needed.
2.1.2 Stream Dimension
Eight (8) permanent cross sections were installed across the site; 6 on UT1 and 1 each on UT1A and
UT1B. Five (5) cross sections were installed in riffles and three (3) were installed in pools. Each cross-
section was marked using a length of rebar and steel t-posts on both streambanks. The location and
elevation of each pin was recorded to facilitate data comparison from year to year. Cross -sections were
surveyed using a Topcon RL-H5A Self Leveling Laser Level. Reported data includes measurements of
bankfull elevation (based on the as -built bankfull area), bank height ratio (based on the as -built bankfull
area), thalweg elevation, elevation of the low top of bank, maximum depth from the low top of bank,
and low top of bank cross -sectional area (Appendix C). Stream dimension measurements were made
using the NCDMS cross section tool (Version 5/11/2021). Reference photos were taken of both
streambanks to provide a visual assessment of any changes that may have occurred since the previous
monitoring year.
The Year 2 monitoring cross-section survey indicates that the project streams are stable and restored
channel dimensions have not changed significantly during Monitoring Year 2. Cross sections were shot in
October 2021 at the end of the growing season. At this time, portions of the stream channels still had
vegetation growing in them, which affected the cross-section plots slightly. Every effort was made to
survey the existing stream channel bottom and not the vegetation, but some of the cross -sections (XS3,
XS5, XS7, and XS8) indicate that the channels appear to be temporarily aggraded. EPR does not believe
this will be a long-term issue as the planted riparian trees and shrubs will begin to shade out the
herbaceous vegetation growing in the channels. The riffle cross -sections, apart from XS8, showed only
minor fluctuations compared to the as -built conditions and all restored streams meet the success
criteria for restored stream channels as established in the mitigation plan and shown in Table 2. The
cross-section plots, photos, and data summary (Table 9) are included in Appendix C.
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Ir Yadkin County, North Carolina
2.1.3 Channel Stability
Channel stability is assessed on a yearly basis using photographs to visually document the condition of
the restored project streams. Photographs are taken from the same location in the same direction each
year. Sixteen (16) photo points were established during baseline monitoring and are shown in Appendix
A. The locations of each permanent photo point are shown in the CCPV (Figure 2). Visual assessments of
channel stability and in -stream structure condition were also made regularly throughout Monitoring
Year 2.
Stream photo points and visual assessments indicate that all restored channels and in -stream structures
are in good condition and performing as intended. No significant stream problem areas were observed.
The minor floodplain rilling along UT1 Reach 1 that was noted in the MY1 report has mostly stabilized
and these areas are covered with dense herbaceous vegetation. Some sections of the restored channels
also contain this herbaceous vegetation as well; however, it does not appear to be causing any
significant problems. EPR believes this is a temporary issue and the vegetation should wash through the
channel during the dormant season and eventually be shaded out by streamside trees and shrubs.
2.1.4 Stream Hydrology
Three (3) pressure transducers were installed in UT1, UT1A, and UT1B to document stream flow and the
occurrence of bankfull events within the monitoring period. The locations of these gauges are shown in
the CCPV (Figure 2). All three gauges were installed in the downstream end of pools. The constructed
bankfull elevation at each gauge was recorded, as well as the elevation of the downstream controlling
grade. These elevations are compared with the gauge readings to determine whether the stream is
flowing and if a bankfull event has occurred.
This Project utilizes a tipping bucket rain gauge installed at another EPR-completed stream restoration
approximately 0.75 miles to the southeast (Meadowbrook, DMS project no. 100024) to accurately
document rainfall at the Site. The rainfall data can be compared to the flow gauge data to verify that
high flows at the Site are correlated with rainfall events. The monitoring gauges were downloaded
regularly throughout Monitoring Year 2. Rainfall data is presented in Figure 3. Monthly Rainfall Summary
Data and the precipitation and water level hydrographs are included in Appendix D. When the rain
gauge was downloaded during MY2 monitoring in October 2021, it was determined that the batteries in
the logger had expired around 9/2/2021. For this reason, no rainfall data was collected for September
and October. The batteries were replaced in early November 2021.
Flow gauge data from MY2 indicate that all three project streams met the established success criteria of
30 days or more of consecutive flow throughout the year. According to the gauge for UT1 (SG-1), the
stream had 294 days of consecutive flow and 1 bankfull event during Monitoring Year 2. SG-2, located in
UT1A, documented consistent flow throughout the year, though bankfull events were difficult to
accurately verify. The water level shown by SG-2 exceeds the bankfull elevation for the entirety of June
through October, which is likely not accurate. EPR believes that vegetation growing in the channel
combined with fine sediment accruing around the gauge artificially increased the pressure that was
recorded. Because UT1A is such a small channel, any minor change in channel conditions could
significantly influence the gauge readings. All stream gauges will be manually cleaned out prior to MY3
monitoring to prevent this from becoming an ongoing issue. SG-3, which is installed in UT1B,
documented 186 days of consecutive flow. SG3 did not record any bankfull events.
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Ir Yadkin County, North Carolina
2.2 Riparian Vegetation Monitoring
Riparian vegetation monitoring evaluates the growth and development of planted and volunteer
vegetation across the site. Monitored parameters, methods, schedule/frequency, and extent are
summarized in Table 2. These monitoring parameters follow USACE guidance but will also allow for
monitoring of other parameters to document site performance related to the project goals listed in
Table 2.
2.2.1 Vegetation Monitoring Data
Four (4) permanent vegetation monitoring plots were monitored across the site. The corners of the
permanent vegetation plots were marked using steel t-posts and the location of each plot was surveyed
during the as -built survey. The individual trees within each permanent plot were flagged and identified
to facilitate repeat monitoring each year. In addition to the 4 permanent plots, 2 randomly placed
vegetation plots are established each vegetation monitoring year and the location of these plots is
recorded using GPS. All vegetation plots for MY2 are shown in the CCPV (Figure 2). Annual vegetation
data was compiled and summarized using the DMS Vegetation Data Entry Tool (Version 8/23/2021).
The Greenbrier conservation easement area was supplementally planted in March 2021 in response to
areas of low growth and stem count in Monitoring Year 1. Vegetation across the majority of the site was
performing well in MY1 so these areas were only supplementally planted using a low stem density. Two
areas (the left terrace along UT1 Reach 1 and the floodplain along lower UT1 Reach 3) were replanted
using a higher number of stems because the trees in these areas had been smothered by dense
herbaceous vegetation in MY1. A total of 1.28 acres were replanted (500 stems per acre) and 3.19 acres
were supplementally planted (200 stems per acre). A total of 71% of the original planted area was
replanted in 2021, but most of this was done using a low stem density. The supplementally planted
areas are shown in the CCPV (Figure 2). A planted species list is provided in Appendix B and matches the
species in the approved mitigation plan that were originally planted after construction.
Year 2 vegetation monitoring occurred in July 2021 before leaf drop. Stem counts for the vegetation
plots (fixed and random) ranged from 10 trees per plot (405 trees per acre) in VP-4 F (Fixed) to 20 trees
per plot (810 trees per acre) in VP-6 R (Random). The average stem density from all 6 vegetation plots
(fixed and random) was 15 trees per plot (625 trees per acre). Therefore, the vegetation plot data
indicates that planted trees on the Site are meeting the interim success criteria of 320 stems/acre in
Monitoring Year 3. Average planted stem height for Monitoring Year 2 was 1.7 feet, which reflects the
fact that many of these trees were planted in early 2021 during the supplemental planting effort.
Success criteria for stem height does not take effect until MY5, but stem height will be continually
monitored for MY3 and MY5 to determine whether the site appears to be on track to meet the
performance criteria in MY5.
A small patch of Chinese privet (<0.1 acres) was observed on the right bank of UT1 Reach 2. This will be
sprayed and removed in early MY3. No other invasive species were found on the mitigation site.
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL
DMS Project ID #100086
Ir Yadkin County, North Carolina
n
F
�¢
e
c
N
eA
�• Caste ye ns Rd
rg
Rq
ha
«�
• ��5� �Brancn
Q
��Q
�`
G pd
tP
a:
o E
G
r
vI
W
U
�'
0 W
p W z co
W Q O z
m U Un 0
Z
W 0 4
a.
z
2 cb Q
m} a
O N z C)
W O Q U)
m V J FJS
Ld c- 01
W '
IL
rc
ow
Greek
�`
❑Mr
O
Pa 9�i �
C•4]nllla M4/I NEWt`•�'1f
�4'J �
�--'
r 1
ti+
c
R
IL
its Y
7O
�4
P,. �
"dial,
Nu,4etis !id a
_.
ILp
5Il1
�
B.Ck SroaK
2
Z
}
Ld f—
O
� r
�
-
�
z
U
LLJ-•
u Rn
O
z
O
��`2,
:. ❑
o
i
>
��a
Thy
LLLd
O
m
J p
�z�
U 00
Y/mdYO� ( •r
z
Ld
----
N
- -- - - --
co co
O N
W
- - �-
^satt1ry,"
d co 00
a --`--
--x'--.----_ __
V
-
„•y �
9d
- �yxY Spy R �
� ❑ � 5j '�y
J
i.
w
P� 3
�
W
CC
°�
a
W
Ld
m
U)
J
x`
W
rcc
N
ryT
Z
Clmpman Rd
a c k
•- �a �� ''�
~Q'
Lli
'o
v
Q
g 4 = 7.
W
LL
z
uLd
'
lWJ
z
t
N
0
63,
U
w CO
N
O
O
0
gdf4
E
o
O
U
W z c
co
Ld
>-
N
O
0
0
O
m
0 —
Li
W a-
O
h '
�p
W
lU�
0)�l
w.
Nco0
U
U)
d
-
j-- w
o
o
c
U)
d
EL
a�
>
c
c�
a
o
0
w
U
z
�
[d z N
d O
I>
z
LL
Q'
N
N
"
1
011
<o
:.
z
�
O
o�
j-- z
Q
U
U)
Ld z
O
w
m=
Z U
W
Y
C
0
C
U)
7
(0
L('yd'
r �y
�
CO
d
v
t
U
O
a
0
O
E
(0
N
O®
z�Q
o
cu
w
W
O LL
�
W
0
o
O
E
E
+=
N
cu
o
o
W
cu
cu
U
c
C�
U)
U)
Z
U
3.0 REFERENCES
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Mitigation Services (DMS). DMS
Vegetation Data Entry Tool, October 2020. https://ncdms.shinyapps.io/Veg Table Tool/
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Mitigation Services (DMS). DMS Cross
Section Tool V.1.0 2020. https://ncdms.shinyapps.io/XS APP/
North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Mitigation Services (DMS). Annual
Monitoring Report Format, Data, and Content Requirements, October 2020.
North Carolina Ecosystem Enhancement Program. 2009. Upper Yadkin Pee -Dee River Basin Restoration
Priorities.
North Carolina Division of Water Quality. 2008. Yadkin Pee -Dee Basinwide Water Quality Plan.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. October 2016. Wilmington District Public Notice: Notification of Issuance
of Guidance for Compensatory Stream and Wetland Mitigation Conducted for Wilmington
District.
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Year 2 Monitoring Report - FINAL 13
DMS Project ID #100086
Ir Yadkin County, North Carolina
Appendix A
Visual Assessment Data
Table 4. Visual Stream Morphology Stability Assessment Table
Table 5. Vegetation Condition Assessment Table
Vegetation Photo Log
Photo Log
2 �
cn
�a
o §
2
�
C %
k �
/
�
m 7
�
J
m
d
■ 3
a)
Q
k
MCO
/�
�£k
§ c
+
+
+
+
+
+
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
) 2
I §
0 2
/
CD
0
0
0
J\ uo
§
I
0E\
CN
CN
2
Im
_ — [ c
§2of
2 m $ —
CN
CN
a §
/$
/
og
j
Co
0
k /
E
°
S
� 5
e
6
=
/ §
\
\ co
]
0
co
=
��
0)aco
f
==
2 c
f
\
7 3
\
$
\§>
co
=
\ coo
g
/
o
2
/
_
82E
o
coA
= _ o
\
\
/ 7 2
7
x
/ / \
{ \
{ f \
\
\
7 U) /
�o
af%
\
%�
// Co
ƒ\
2 °
7
\ 7
E r=
/\/
E/
7\ k
I
0
o
7 a
o
0)0
=
ƒn m
k
\2
.0 x
\%
o o
0 3/
= 0
% E
2 e
S 0
§\ E
a=
\
3 =
f
>
o 2
=
0= E
g
\
§
Ĵ
7
§
m\
m\/
ok
m\R
a)
CU
L
§
/
\
\
2
a)
d
2
\
0
0
\
/ g
U
4
k
�
CO/
m
m
U
0
2
k
\
k
m
m
2</
\
_
�
§ /
§ o
2 d
2 m
k�
cn
Im
c
2 .
C %
o �p
E E
E E
§ 2
7 7
� �
n
)
m q
3
I Q
�
k
M/\�
�£k
§ c
+
+
+
+
+
+
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
) 2
I §
0 2
/
CD
0
0
0
J\ uo
§
I
k m \
®
\
cq
�
2
JIm
_ — [ c
\CN
§9of
2 Cl) $ —
a In
0
$
/
og
0
/k
0
k/
°
0
5
e /
6
=
co0
/ §
\
\ co
co
=
��
0)aco
f
==
2� c
f
\
7 3�
\
$
\ �
e
=
\ % o
E
@
/
;
o
0
e e =
o
%
&
_ _
o
\
0
/ 7 /
7
\
/ / \
{ \
{ f \
o
\
7 $ /
�o
af%
\
%�
//$
ƒPC2
r =
/\/
E/
7\ k
I
0
o
7 a
o
r_
=
" (1)
m
k
\ 2
0 x
. x
\%
o o
0 3/
= 0
% E
2 0
0�
§ 0 E
a=
\
3 =
5
U f
>
o 2
=
0= E
g
\
§
Ĵ
7
§
m\
m\/
ok
m\R
a)
cu
/
\
\
0
d
cn 2
\
L
a.
a)/
LU
k
�
�
�
/
/ m
/
m
m
U
0
2
k
\
k
m
m
2</
\
_
2 �
cn
�a
o §
2
�
C %
k �
/
�
m 7
� k
_
q
Q
■3
«f
k
Mk\\
�£k
§ c
+
+
+
+
+
+
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
) 2
I (n
0 2
/
CD
0
0
0
J\ uo
§
I
m
/ a) \
®
o
0
�
J 2
_ — [ c
§9of
2 Cl) $ —
o
0
§ a
0
$
/
og
Co
0
k /
0
°
e E
6
0
=
co0
5
/ §
\
\ co
=
��
0)acoco
f
==
2 c
f
E
7 3
\
$
e
=
\
/
\§>
0
/
coo
82E
g
o o
co
= _ _
o
\
\
/ 7 /
7
x
/ / \
{ 0
f
\
\
7 U) /
{ \
�o
afCo
\
%�
Co
//
ƒ\
2 °
7
\ 7
E r 0
E/
7\ k
I
0
o
7 a
/\/
o
\ \
� \
ƒ n—
0)
\ 2
S
x
$ 7
o=
° 0 S
0 2
7$
= E
£ o
0 �
§ 0§
a=
3
f
2
0= E
\
=
CCU
�
o
=
§ g
0
Ĵ
7
k
-0
m\
m\/
o
m
a)
CU
L
/
\
\
0
0
a)
d
2
0
0
\
\
/ g
U
4
k
�
/
/ m
/
U
0
2
k
\
k
m
m
2</
\
_
�
§ /
§ o
2 d
2 m
k�
cn
Im
c
2 .
C %
o �p
E E
E E
§ 2
7 7
k
>
§
d
e3
Q
�f
k
E4$d
w
Mn1_
�£k
§ c
+
+
+
+
+
+
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
) 2
I (n
0 2
/
CD
0
0
0
J\ uo
§
I
m
/ a) \
®
o
0
�
J 2
§9of
2 Cl) $ —
o
0
a In
0
$
/
og
0
Co
0
k /
°
0
5
e /
6
=
co0
/ §
\
\ co
=
��
0)acoco
f
==
2 c
f
E
7 3
\
$
co�
e
=
\ % o
E
@
/
;
o
0
e e =
o
%
&
_ _
o
\
0
/ 7 /
7
\
/ / \
{ \
f
o
\
7 $ /
{ \
�o
af%
\
%�
//$
ƒPC2
r =
/\/
E/
70 k
I
0
o
7 a
o
0)\
ƒf�\
0)
\2
\S\
$ 7
° R S
7$
£ o
x
o=
0 2 V)
= E
§ v
§ 0§
a=
\
3 =
f
�
o 2
=
0= E
C
0
Ĵ
7
§ 2
m\
m\/
ok
m\R
a)
CU
/
\
\
0
d
cn 2
\
L
a.
a)/
LU
�
/
/ m
/
m
m
U
0
2
k
\
k
m
m
2</
\
_
04
m �
w �
�
§
«
k
�
a
�
§
«
%
%
%
%
%
2
a
\
\
ca
�
«
=
o
g
0
g
0
g
0
g
0
g
2
0
0
0
0
0
�
E
0
2
�
�
2
0
0
§
CD
CDCD
2
a
E
C
\
\
U
2
g
=
7
k
\
\
\
tm
c
-0
3 E
D
/\
tm -0
tm
�
f /
> S
_
M _
Cl)
k
>
CD
\ /
o
-0E
= e
§
Cl)
q a
m
E \
§
\ \
/
\
7 2
E
\ can)
ƒ j
o
> E
�
\
0
2
a
2
0
U
§
cu
E
§
a
°
2
\
\
\
\ )
)
>
m
-i k
k
�
�
§
«
%
2
k
w
2
CD
a
\
2
m
2
E
LU
k
o
k
=
g
2
C)
�
E
0
0
/
k
/
(
E
'7
z
.&
6
2
_
a
=
•/
_
§ /
� \ E
\
( \ $
/ E$
7 0
=
a >
o== E E$
0
\
0 cl)-0
_
0-0
5 0
o° _
"
_ _
£ o
_ = E
�
CL=
co 2
_ = o
7 a n b=
_ ®
� E a
=
°� _ E _ _
_
= o
o
= .- � 7
2CD
§0=\
-\02
\.
_ \ _
_ %
2
y )'e = ° _
'3
7£
5 =
g±
_ _ �
E _
E E/\/
CL _ _ _ �'�
a
_
o )
E.2.§
-0
u =
_ E _ °CD = j
%
)c
-0E
\
t2\k/�»
¥ 2/
f{\[�
E a 3 E
t m
a E�/
8
2
0>
CD CD/ 3/\\
r°°
2
a
E E%=
S
\
.§
Cl)
E
8
s=
\ \ \
/
>
±
D
§ m
\
• §
J�_
==e===_
»
\
e e 7 2 D±%
%
> �
_ � o
u
uu_=tom=
= = o = = o
's
o e R=
R> 7 .§
e
w w = u=
e
o
7
0
«
ca
ca
k
«
2
°
0
z °
E §
4
> k
k
>
3 0
1
a
1 w w
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Monitoring Year 2 (7/22/2021) - Vegetation Photo Log
Veg Plot 1 — NE Corner (07/22/2021)
Veg Plot 3 — NW Corner (07/22/2021)
Veg Plot 5 R — W Corner (07/22/2021)
Veg Plot 2 — NW Corner (07/22/2021)
Veg Plot 4 — NW Corner (07/22/2021)
Veg Plot 6 R — N Corner (07/22/2021)
Appendix A
ECOSYSTEM
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project . PLANNING&
DMS No. 100086 RESTORATION
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Monitoring Year 2 (10/21/2021) - Photo Log
Photo Point 1 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 10+00
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 3 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 13+55
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 5 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 17+60
Facing Upstream (10/21/2021)
Appendix A
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
DMS # 100086
Photo Point 2 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 11+50
Facing Upstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 4 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 15+00
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 6 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 18+50
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Eco5Y5TEM
PLANNING &
RESTORAi70N
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Monitoring Year 2 (10/21/2021) - Photo Log
Photo Point 7 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 19+60
Facing Upstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 9 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 22+40
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 11 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 25+55
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 8 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 21+00
Looking Upstream at UT1A From UT1 (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 10 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 24+30
Facing Upstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 12 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 26+45
Looking Upstream at UT1B From UT1 (10/21/2021)
Appendix A
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project P; °NN NG&
DMS # 100086 A RESTORAi70N
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Monitoring Year 2 (10/21/2021) - Photo Log
Photo Point 13 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 27+55
Facing Upstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 15A — UT1 B, Sta. 11+90
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 16A — UT1A, Sta. 12+00
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 14 — UT1 Reach 3, Sta. 29+45
Facing Downstream (10/21/2021)
b
yy��
x �1
Ic
Photo Point 15B — UT1 B, Sta. 11+90
Facing Upstream (10/21/2021)
Photo Point 16B — UT1A, Sta. 12+00
Facing Upstream Towards UT1A-1 (10/21/2021)
Appendix A
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project P; °NN NG&
DMS # 100086 A RESTORAi70N
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
Monitoring Year 2 (211012021) - Photo Log
Photo Point 17 — UT1 Reach 1, Sta. 16+50
Facing Upstream (2/10/2021)
Appendix A
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project
DMS # 100086
ECOSYSTEM
PLANNING &
• REsTcRA?IoN
rye-•:,iaMl'� `¢-,":
�,.... k e t"i• P A
kfY P
c. 9k.
�_ .• 111,,, •� 'S3 ..
a
Site Overview
Facing Northeast(10/21/2021)
1
r e:,
Site Overview
Facing Southwest (10/212021)
E
Appendix A
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project ECOSYSTEM
g � AN
PLANING &
DMS # 100086 REsrcaArloN
Appendix B
Vegetation Plot Data
Table 6. Vegetation Plot Data
Table 7. Vegetation Performance Standards Summary Table
2021 Supplemental Planting Species List
a
00
0
0
0
0
Z c Ln m
V O c-I N
O Z O N
d 0 N N N O
U
Z
N
O
a
w O
m
rn g
a
FL
C T
0 C
_ N
N cL
E �
hp n
v v m S 3 v
> .L Q .- o Q
f0 Q O U N
N O
o
Ln
c-I
c-I
0
c-I
c-I
c-I
0
0
O
I,
O0
N
O
0
2
n
O
N
O
00
0
N
0
H
N
m
c-I
c-I
c-I
Ln
cm -I
cm -I
l0
�
N
O
cm -I
N
l0
�
N
O
Ln
N
>
LL
O
c-I
N
c-I
c-I
N
N
c-I
,y
O
N
O
2
Oon
r"
N
O
O
d
b0
N
-p
+N+
f0
d
y0
Ln
c-I
m
N
c-I
N
Ln
N
N
ll�
n
N
c-I
O
N
Cb
n
M
O
d
b0
N
-p
N
>
O
�
d
Lf1
c-I
m
N
c-I
N
Lf1
cm -I
c�-I
y0
ci
I�
ci
m
c-I
H
N
Ln
m
O
cm -I
N
Ln
Lnm
O
N
~
Ln
Ln
O
d
b0
N
-p
N
a
y0
Ln
c-I
N
c-I
c-I
Ln
N
N
ll�
n
N
N
O
N
�o
n
N
N
O
c-I
�
n
n
O
d
b0
N
-p
N
�
d
Ll1
cm -I
cm -I
O
U
d
U
Q
U
U
Q
U
a0
Q
U
� N
C
LL
�
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
O
L.L
L
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
to
N
N
E!
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
v
N
CO
C
-L'
z
`
a
O
N
a)vTi
U
N
me
O
N
U
00
�
�
N
O
3
3
O
3
o
0
O
+N+
O
Y
U
l
C
C
a
Y
o
u
3=
3
v
a
o
y
o
y
o_
U
N
E
v
¢E
a'
o
U
Q
s
o
U
Q
s
E=
,en
Ow
S
E=
.ew
v
Q
U
U
p
N
Q
U
U
p
p
N
N
C
E
C
-aa
o
o
Q
CL
o
Q
cL
N
E
a�
E
na
m
u
v
v
m
Z
�
O
b
y
'C
v
L
hp
in
a
L
N
i
S
t0
¢�
t0
¢�
U
E>
t
o
c
E
E
a)
'
n
U
U
u°
o
o
o
u-°
v
a'
o
0
Q
aa)
a`)
n
E
E
E
Iz
Q
0
0
U
to
N
O
O_
'6
m
cf
cr
p
E
O
U
U
O
m
j
a
d
0
_
d
d
0
O
O N
O N
O O
E
°.-° Q
E
4 E
E
U
-m
to
_
O
N
-m O
_
l� C Q
+m
c-I N
Q
0
m
E
E
O
f0
N
C
C
N
Z
� � 0
w�¢
Y z
0 Z F
0aw
m0-0�
w
w
o '�
O
O
O
o 'm
O
O
>
>
C
C
W
W
'U
'U
n
n
n
n
N
Li-
CL
CL
M
N
LO
N
a+
Xk
a+
Xk
O
O
a
a
bA
w
bA
w
w
--
w
>
m
Q
Q
U
U
Ol
00
Ol
O
N
E
E
0000
a)
w
w
N
N
W
W
'N
'N
m
O
O
O
m
O
O
�
C
C
O
O
N
N
L
'U
'U
w
Ln
Ln
w
w
Ln
LL
N
N
Ln
N
3
O
O
�n
on
w
bA
w
>
>
=
m
N
-i
=
N
N
�
R
Q
Q
U
U
N
\
Q
u
C
N
w
O
N
00
(Q
E
Ln
m
w
Ln
N
O
N
N
L
IA
w
IA
w
y
i
•m
i
•m
O
O
O
O
O
O
0
C
C
�
O
O
to
w
w
G/
U
U
n
00
m
w
n
m
LL
Q.
LL
O
O
a
a
bA
w
bA
w
w
w
>
>
=
N
N
N
Q
Q
Q
Q
�
Ol
Ln
Ol
Ln
N
00
E
n
0
0
0
0
0
to
w
w
w
w
w
w
a)
w
a)
w
a)
w
a)
w
w
a)
W
w
b0
b0
b0
b.0
b0
b0
b0
b0
b0
b0
b0
b0
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
`0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2!
2!
Z
2 co O
�Za
z
} z 0
0 J w
aa)
O
d
0
m
b0
Y
E
�o
w
Greenbrier 2021 Supplemental Plantinp, Species List
Trees and Shrubs
The following table lists bare -root vegetation selection for the 2021 replanting effort.
-Trees were planted in replanting areas at a total density of 500 stems per acre. Total replanting area
was approximately 1.28 acres.
-Trees were planted in supplemental planting areas at a total density of 200 stems per acre. Total
replanting area was approximately 3.19 acres.
Common Name
Scientific Name
Percent Planted byWetness
Species
Tolerance
Trees (75%) Planted 9' X 9' Spacing — 538 Trees/ Acre
River Birch
Betula nigra
20%
FACW
Sycamore
Platanus occidentalis
20%
FACW
Water Oak
Quercus nigra
10%
FAC
American Elm
Ulmus americana
10%
FACW
Persimmon
Diospryos virginiana
10%
FAC
Willow Oak
Quercus phellos
10%
FAC
Tulip Poplar
Liriodendron tulipifera
20%
FAC
Tree Total
100%
Shrubs (25%) Planted 16' X 16' Spacing -164 Shrubs/ Acre
Tag Alder
Alnus serrulata
20%
FACW
Spicebush
Lindera benzoin
25%
FACW
Redbud
Cercis canadensis
20%
FACU
Elderberry
Sambucus canadensis
15%
FAC
Silky Dogwood
Cornus amomum
200
FACW
Shrub Total
100%
Appendix C
Stream Geomorphology Data
Cross -Sections With Annual Overlays
Table 8. Baseline Stream Data Summary
Table 9. Cross -Section Morphology Data Table
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS1- UT1 Reach 1
Rosgen Stream Type - 134
Station 11+28 - Pool
XS1 looking upstream
XS1 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3
MY4
MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1127.92
1127.87
1128.35
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
1.09
0.8
Thalweg Elevation
1126.47
1126.23
1126.82
LTOB Elevation
1127.92
1 1128.02
1128.04
LTOB Max Depth
1.45
1.79
1.22
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
6.70
7.87
4.17
Entrenchment Ratio
-
-
-
XS1 Pool - 11+28
1133.0
As -Built - May
2020
MY1-2020 MY2-2021
1132.0
—
1131.0
—
1130.0
—
1129.0
—
c
O
1128.0
w
1127.0
1126.0
1125.0
1124.0
1123.0
0 5 10 15
20
25 30 35 40 45 50
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS2 - UT1 Reach 1
Rosgen Stream Type - 134
Station 13+91- Riffle
XS2 looking upstream
XS2 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3 MY4 MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1120.53
1120.61
1120.65
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
0.94
0.98
Thalweg Elevation
1119.35
1119.47
1119.50
LTOB Elevation
1120.53
1 1120.55
1120.63
LTOB Max Depth
1.18
1.08
1.13
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
3.97
3.59
3.86
Entrenchment Ratio
>10.12
>10.11
>10.17
XS2 Riffle- 13+91
1126
As -Built - May 2020
—MY1-2020 MY2-2021
1125
1124
1123
+,
1122
c
0
1121
w
1120
1119
1118
1117
1116
0 10 20
30
40 50 60 70
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS3 - UT1 Reach 3
Rosgen Stream Type - C4
Station 19+94 - Riffle
XS3 looking upstream
XS3 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3
MY4
MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1097.81
1097.90
1098.07
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
0.97
0.79
Thalweg Elevation
1097.18
1097.28
1097.35
LTOB Elevation
1097.81
1 1097.88
1097.92
LTOB Max Depth
0.63
0.60
0.57
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
2.99
2.84
2.05
Entrenchment Ratio
6.39
5.80
5.75
XS3 Riffle - 19+94
1104
As -Built - May 2020
MY1-2020
MY2-2021
1103
1102
1101
+,
1100
c
•°
1099
w
1098
1097
1096
1095
1094
0 10 20
30
40 50 60
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS4 - UT1 Reach 3
Rosgen Stream Type - C4
Station 22+48 - Pool
XS4 looking upstream
XS4 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3
MY4
MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1094.95
1094.80
1095.02
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
1.01
1.04
Thalweg Elevation
1092.34
1092.06
1092.65
LTOB Elevation
1094.95
1 1094.84
1095.10
LTOB Max Depth
2.61
2.78
2.45
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
16.41
16.85
17.51
Entrenchment Ratio
-
-
XS4 Pool - 22+48
1100
As -Built - May 2020 MY1-2020 MY2-2021
1099
1098
1097
1096
c
0
1095
w
1094
1093
1092
1091
1090
0 10 20 30
40 50 60 70
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS5 - UT1 Reach 3
Rosgen Stream Type - C4
Station 25+88 - Riffle
XS5 looking upstream
XS5 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3
MY4
MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1090.59
1090.64
1090.74
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
1.02
0.88
Thalweg Elevation
1089.85
1089.83
1090.07
LTOB Elevation
1090.59
1 1090.66
1090.66
LTOB Max Depth
0.74
0.83
0.59
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
3.08
3.26
2.46
Entrenchment Ratio
>9.39
>9.1
>9.84
XS5 Riffle - 25+88
1096
As -Built - May 2020
MY1-2020
MY2-2021
1095
1094
1093
+,
1092
c
•°
1091
�!
ru
>
w
1090
1089
1088
1087
1086
0 10 20
30
40 50 60 70
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS6 - UT1 Reach 3
Rosgen Stream Type - C4
Station 28+30 - Pool
XS6 looking upstream
XS6 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3 MY4 MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1086.63
1085.85
1085.82
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
1.32
1.42
Thalweg Elevation
1083.89
1083.24
1083.35
LTOB Elevation
1086.63
1 1086.70
1086.85
LTOB Max Depth
2.74
3.46
3.50
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
12.61
1 19.95
22.83
Entrenchment Ratio
-
-
XS6 Pool - 28+30
1091
As -Built - May 2020
MY1-2020
MY2-2021
1090
1089
1088
+,
1087
c
1086
w
1085
1084
1083
-
1082
1081
0 10 20
30
40 50 60 70
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS7 - UT1A
Rosgen Stream Type - 64
Station 12+44 - Riffle
XS7 looking upstream
XS7 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3
MY4
MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1097.98
1097.96
1098.11
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
0.91
0.71
Thalweg Elevation
1097.35
1097.23
1097.59
LTOB Elevation
1097.98
1 1097.89
1097.96
LTOB Max Depth
0.63
0.66
0.37
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
1.76
1.47
1
1.07
Entrenchment Ratio
4.90
4.98
3.25
XS7 Riffle - 12+44
1104
As -Built - May 2020
MY1-2020 MY2-2021
1103
1102
1101
+,
1100
c
•°
1099
m
-
w
1098
1097
1096
1095
1094
0 5 10
15
20 25 30 35
Distance (ft)
Cross Section Plot - MY2 - November 2021
XS8 - UT16
Rosgen Stream Type - 64
Station 11+71- Riffle
XS8 looking upstream
XS8 looking downstream
MYO
MY1
MY2
MY3
MY4
MY5
MY+
Bankfull Elevation - Based on AB Bankfull Area
1089.94
1090.00
1090.17
Bank Height Ratio - Based on AB-Bankfull Area
1.00
0.76
0.47
Thalweg Elevation
1089.59
1089.66
1089.72
LTOB Elevation
1089.94
1 1089.92
1089.93
LTOB Max Depth
0.35
0.26
0.21
LTOB Cross Sectional Area
0.87
0.59
0.19
Entrenchment Ratio
>5.26
>5.39
>5.69
XS8 Riffle- 11+71
1095
As -Built - May 2020
MY1-2020
MY2-2021
1094
1093
1092
+,
1091
1090
- --- — —
��
w
1089
1088
1087
1086
1085
0 5
10
15 20 25
Distance (ft)
O
V
V
V
V
V
-
0
0
O
-
rn
M
V
Oco
M
W
c
co
O
O
O
N
O
—
O
O
R
O
O
O
O
W
o
O
O
2
N
COp
N
W
V
O
N
O
M
0
0
0
0
.O
O
0]
LD
O
O
O
IDN
O
O
LO
O
ID
ul
N
O
O
N
V
O
N
V
m
(h
O
C
m
M
N
O
co
D
O
co
N
O
N
V
O
LO
Ln
O
V
CO
n
N
O
O
N
ON
m
Lb
c)
M
C
O
Oo
p
W
V,
r-
M
00
d)
C
O
N
LO
I�
O
Lfl
r
M
O
co
O
co
LMO
O
LO
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
CO
O
O
M
C
N
N
CO
V
M
I�
co
d)
M
M
M
I�
O
LO
CO
O
O
M
I�
O
LO
OO
V
r
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
w
O
m
O
O
M
Lb
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
O
co
fn
N
CO
O
O
O
O
O
LO
O
O
LO
�
0
co
co
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
LO
N
O
O
N
V
0
O
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
�
W
co
R
C
L
�
C
U
L
�
C
U
0�0
R
Q
co
�
N
�
N
O
co
N
W
N
O
d)
N
L
U
_
.�..
O
M
O
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
yL
O
M
O
O
M
N
o
O
o
M
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
N
U
F
O
CO
O
M
m
O
R
E
V
N
L
L
_
E (p
Eoo
N
N
6
N
N
co
r
O
o
O
m O
W
N
O
O
N
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
R
O
CO
0
0
(V
Ln
—
O
Q
r
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
O
O
O
O
p
O
E Z
C
I�
LO
I�
M
O
V
O
_
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
cc
c6
CO
O
O
N
N
00
M
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
� 0
t7
C
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
Z
N
Z
N
N
CO
V
V
CO
= N
N O`
mQ
N
N
N
Ln
M
N
M
Q
O
Q
O)
V
O
c
V
O
O
O
O
O
co
O
O
Z
p
Z
O
LLD
I�
L
N
O
O
� R
._
r
M
O--
M
O)
W
Q
O
M
Q
d)
O
O
O
O
V
O
V
O
G/ O)
C
S y
R
O
V
Ln
m
O
M
N
Z
p
Z
N
LO
N
I�
W
d)
~
cm
O
N
Ln
V
U
O
O
C
N
E
O
W
N
m
N
co
m
0
0
p
N
VI
'x
N
CO
V
LO
lo
co
O
m
O
m
N
V
CO
I�
N
Q
Z
M
O
Q
Z
M
O
W
O
o
LO
O
O)
O
c
N
V
co
W
y
O
(6
W
LO
co
d)
d)
V
I�
Q
M
Q
M
O
d
O
CO
O
V
o
O
O
N
CO
N
Z
p
Z
b
m
cd
O)
V
C
N
C=
co
O
LO
I�
O
O
O
Ln
Q
N
Q
CO
O
N
(�
O
cc
V
r,
O
O
N
LO
Z
p
Z
0
CO
M
r
c
s
N
LO
O
N
2
W
CO
O
co
N
co
U
O
LO
C
�
O
W
K
J
J
CO
N
V
O
CO
CO
N
n
w
w
w
.o
.o
.o
w
'"'
w
w
w
w
w
'"'
w
.00O
y
0
a
s
Q
N
N
C
L
C
Q
C
N
U
C
U
9
O
C
O
C
.�
N
(6
0]
Ow
Q
Q
Q
a)
N
O
N
O
N
-xO
(6
(6
a
N
a
C
(p
t/1
O
(6
N
N
C
O
m
y6
O
C
O
C
(6
(6
C
E L
S
N
O
O
(6
m
O
N
a
(6
N
U
N
N
U)
L
LL
Q
O
(6
.0
O
O
Q
N
O
L
a
C
C
ap
00
N
>D
>
O
a
E
.N
U
C>
m
U
m
C
Lu
S
O
y
0]
—
U
N
m
d'
�.
O o
d
C
O
C
O
U
Q
N
O
O—
�'
i
L_
O
O_
O
LL
O
C
C
w
d
U
O
m
m
U
a
N
cC
w
O
N
0
U)
a
OCie
L
.+—T'
9
0]
m
w
m
E
0]
m
LL
m
U
(n
(6
U
N
O
L
N
O
R
a
(n
O
C
7
C
y
w
a
o
(6
E
R
r
R
R
Q
N
X
6
>
w
O
C
R
W
V
E
m
R
,�
E
a
o
2 t 0
E
N
C)
a(D
C
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
O
O
O
O
O
N
O
O
N
p
O
M.0
LO
dl
CO
O
O
O
O
O
O
ID
O
N
N
O
O
O
VI
I�
N
LO
I�
O
O
N
N
mN
N
d)
O
m
O
Ln0
O
O
M
V
O
V
N
CO
M
M
�
Ln
O
W
O
V
V
O
N
V
O
V
O
CO
C
C
N
O
M
LO
I
O
O
d)
O
Lp
LO
O
O
N
O
V
LO
O
r
N
C)
V
O
O
CO
O
O
co
I�
N
p
O
N
N
V
M
N
M
Ln
O
C
(6
o
M
LO
I�
O
O
O)
O
p)
oo
O
N
Ln
LO
I�
O
CO
O
O
M
I�
N
O
O
N
N
V
M
N
M
Ln
C_
CO
M
LO
CO
O
V
O
N
O
M
CO
p
M
LO
O
V
cc
CO
O
O
M
CO
O
N
M
o)
N
x
(6
O
CO
d)
O
O
M
O
p
M
N
O
I�
M
O
O
O
O
O
CO
Codo
0
0
LO
W
r
V
O
O
M
LO
Cfl
N
M
O
CO
C
OI
O
O
LO
O
CO
V
LO
CO
V
CO
LO
N
O)
N
N
M
O_
'O
O
CO
O
CO
CO
LO
O
I�
O
O
LO
O
y
r
0
0
T
Ln
0
-
N
O
N
V
V
O
(V
Oro
Lo
0
o
0
(V
N
o
O
0
0
0
O
O
O
C_
O
V
I�
0
0
0
M
V
CO
O
LO
LO
cc
I�
0
0
r
N
V
O
N
moo
N
LO
(V
LO
M
�
C
L
L
W
�
C
�
r
N
C
N
�
O
R
❑
L
L
R
0
U)
U
2
U
(PD
M
2
X
N
CO
I�
O
Ln
r
O
r
M
's
O
M
N
O
O
M
O
LO
O
R
L
CO
CO
O
O
co
o
O
o
M
M
Lrj
co
co
co
G/
R
O
o
O
CO
O
O
V
O
M
V
[)
O
N
'O
R
E
U
c
N
L
L
C
CO
CO
LO
V
V
I�
O
f0
V%
w
W
O
N
O
N
LO
M
M.
Ln
M.
co
R O
w
V
I�
O
o
O
N
-
O
Q
N
N
N
V
Lo
R O
0
�
�
C
cc
co
CO
V
o
M
N
o
O
E O
O
�
p
O
I�
r
O
O
LO
O
M
Ln
M
I�
0
0
O
O
O
N
m
M
� 0
Q
Q
Q
O
O
O
O
O
C
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N N
N O
LO
V
d)
Q
N
Q
Q
O
CO
N
O
O
R
m Q
C
(n
M
LO
0
0
0
0
0
Z
O
Z
O
Z
LO
O
d)
Q O
._
R
S 0I oo
O
C
m
co
d)
O
r
Ln
Q
O
Q
Q
OM
,
r
o
co
O
O
V
N
co
Z
Z
Z
N
V
N
CO
LO
CO
F
O
O)
co
W
LO
N
m
0
M
E
O
W
m
M
N
0
0
0
0
R
N
M
M
LO
O)
M
O
r
O)
Q
M
Q
O
Q
O
O
CO
O
CO
O)
O
O
`
W
O)
L
0
0
V
o
N
Z
o
Z
Z
N
CO
N
�
C
(6
M
M
LO
d)
M
O
r
d)
Q
M
Q
O
Q
-.
O
�
r
N
�
d
S
w
m
0
0
V
N
Z
o
Z-
Z
co
CO
co
C
N
N
C
�
V
CO
��
CO
N
Q
O
Q
d)
Q
O
O
LO
O
d)
cc
I�
bib
V
N
N
Z
o
Z
O
Z
CO
c
M
O
CO
CO
N
�
2
W
CO
O
V
N
O
U
R
J
N
n
O
O
O
C
Z
O
O
O
W
K
J
J
N
O
N
O
M
O
w
w
w
.o
.o
'o
w
'"'
w
w
w
w
w
'"'
w
.00O
y
a
s
Q
N
C
L
C
Q
C
U
C
U
9
C
C
❑
❑
Q
Q
N
N
O
N
B
(6
(6
a
N
a
C
(p
t/1
O
m
N
N
C
O
(6
y6
O
C
O
C
(6
(6
C❑
L
S
N
O
O
(6f
�
N
a
(6
N
U
N
N
U)
L
LL
Q
O
m
.0
O
�'
O
Q
N
O
L
a
C
C
a0
00CD
>CD
>
O
a
E
.a)
U
C>
[)
m
C
W=
O
y
-
U
N
m
d'
W.
O
d
C
O
U
N
-i
L_
OOO
O
U)
o
C
W
d
0]
U
-O
N
to
O�'
E
D
0W
L
m
E
(r
m
m
(n
O
LL
9
m
C�
(n
E
(6
U
N
O
N
O
R
U)
O
o
C
(6
M
m
E
L
E
u
m<
v
m
R
Q-
N
X
(6
R
>
w
O
C
R
W
E
V
w
m
R
E
a
o
N
a`
E
N
C)
a C7
)
/
/
R
))
_
/
{§[®
§ \
±
~°°J
\
\
\
\
`
w
)
\-5
C)
=
/
j
Cie
)
)|®|~| |�|�| ||�|\|\|§
(|i|�| |�|^|�|�|\|�|\|\|(
111111111
([*I |-|-|-111d |\|\|)|-||�
LL
\\
\\\�\�
\�\(\\
°(
}27
\
°`2
\o
\\
)
CL
mE
/
_:
]�(
/
a
a
m
C L
o
O
Q
O
o
N
.0
m
a
m
L
a
L
a
L =
o
a)
o
O
a
X
4�
Z
a)
w
0
U
C C
a)
d'
'�-.
a
O
O
d
a)
C
O
e
�'
> a
C
Lu m
d
t
U
m
a N
C
Rl
co �l4d Iml-1 1 J 1 NONR2
O I z l O l I ml NI NI NI �I �I OI O I O
I I I I I I I I I
9
O
Q
—
—
—
O
(06
U>
a)
a)
a)
a)
U)
C
L
O
LL
a5
Q
0
(6
m
0
N
C—
O—>
m
-
U
m
C
W
O
9 O
N
—
L
a)
a5
Q
L_
O
O_
0
O
d'
a
m
0
U)
aO
O
(p
E ..
WC
a5
m
C
C
a)
LL
U
a5
a5
C
N O
N a
R
a
O
O
o
C
/
/
£
\o
{(\
o
)
y\ooN't
y\@\\::!
/
�
k /
o
§
§
\\�\\\\
2E\�\\��
, oo
TA
�\\�
\\�0\\�
\\
\ol
m
\m
!m§
-
u;g
ez!
\\\
\
\}}
Eo
CM
oc
42
2-0 t5
o
!/)
\Eom
\
\{\
))7
o
E
\\\
\
;o
a<
>
_\/
k
))\
\}E
\
10
(\(
�)\
}
m
0o
o
2f,
(
2
!
_
_
\
}
}\\}
\
a
z3:
f;
»/R
Appendix D
Hydrologic Data
Table 10. Bankfull Event Verification
Figure 3. Monthly Rainfall Data
Precipitation and Water Level Hydrographs
t0
00
O
O
O
T
L
II
Cl)
0
ti
N
O
04
N
O
04
LO
N
O
04
LO
M
N
O
04
O
>
>
M
}
W
�
Y
C
<C
i
T-
T
N
r
N
>
N
0 Q
�
�
N
N
N
N
0)
O
O
U) O
c O
O
O O N O 0 0
0 0 0 0
> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
N
CD
a) N N N N N
0 0 0 0
0 N N N N
0 0 0 0
N N N N N N N N N N N
O O O O O O O O O O
N
N N N pp N N N
N N N N N
N N N N N N N N N N
T
cu ti 0) 0)
c 0) LO
N
cu
i� ti 0) Lo ti 0) LO
N
}
N N N N
UN�O
N N
N N N N N N
OO
0- LO
���OOQ
(1)LOLOLOLOooc0)
N
U) rn
U)
o coo
C�
m
cn
m
T
(N
'
M
('
'^
'^
m
m
R
�
�
Q
m
N
U
01
N
O
Z
N
t
O
v
s
Y
c
N
N
Q
m
�
V
O
N
C
v
U
p0
01
(Op
Q
L
O
N
f0
Qi
Q
Y
4�
L mtl0
I
00
CL
Q
N
a�
N
a
H
O
01
00
f0 C
i
t O
cts
N
a
o E
L
t
O
c
G _
f0
O
M
��w
N
Y
},
}
dA
I
;
m
-o
O
.�
c
L C
L
!=
N
N
a1 (D
z
0
a
c
L
+'
c•l
O
b
O
N
a1 L L
2:
N
N
m
,Ln
V
O
QLLI
Z
'
w
-
v
N
O
Y
(6
�
O
}
C
O
�
N
N
N
�
�
a
W
E
O
w
i
N
C
t6
M
f0
m
m
w
O
O
O O O O O O O O
V
.O
00
to Ln 'T M N c-I O
(u1) jjejule�j AlglUOW
o
Z
lD
O
I
I
I
I
N
Ln
O
N
O
N
O
N
i
N
N
NE
C
E
N
7
N
}
M
Ln
M
0
C]
}
co
N
m
O
`i
Ln
M
N
61
l0
l0
O
(
4-1
4�
0O
~
O
Q
U
U
N
N
cCo
C
d
O
p
p
Z
c0
rn
n
�
to
H
to
H
Q
L!
LA
f+
U
cu
•O ra
L 4-J
a M
S= �
0 3
Z; 0
tw
E
G i
E++
N
M
CU
r-I
N
L O
L v
� N
^�^ M^,
^Y W
W
cu
`L
V
(/pep/ui) uoilelidi:)aad
a,
°D
O O
O O
O
O
0
f
0 0
O00
0
0
0
o
��-I �-i
-1 l0
Kt
N
O -1
N
O N In
1
O
N
O \
Q N O
1
1
N
\
O r
'D O u
1
O
♦— ns
1
1
.v
N N@ O
Y
1
ci
c-I
1
11
1
1
N
0
1
I
N
00
1
00
1
\
o
1
1
1
N
o
O N
•�,,
�
00
c
1
1
I
\
W
1
I
ou t
ikn Y
O O
O
1
1
1 1
I
1 I
1
I
N
00
1
1
1
1
1
1
li
I
o
1
1
Al
rn
'
> C
1
1
1
1
1
1
I
1
a1
W
i
C7
1
!
11
1
1
N
O
_ �
°J 0_
N
1
1
(,o c
i
1
1
\
m O
m
1
1
�
1
1
1
1
O
1 I
1
N
—
i
I
I
n
w
1
I 1
Ln
c c
1
N
ro
' t
4
_N
W
1
1
1
1
)
o
w
I
11
1
z
1
1
1
N
0 0
1
1
1
1
N
1
1
1
1
a
1
1
1
1
1
I i
I
ci
0
1
1
1
1
1IFEci
N
J z
1
ti
1
rlj 0
T
M
1
I
m
o
1
y
1
1
1
i
1
O
N
m ci rn
� Ll� m ci
rn
rl� Lq
cI
m\
00 00 rl
rl r, rl rl
k.0
t.0 �o
�6
N N N
c-I c-I c-I
N N N N
c-I c-I c-I c-I
N
c-I
N N
c-I c-I
N
c-I
c-I c-I c-I
c-I c-I c-I c-I
(11) u01jena13
c-I
c-I c-I
c-I
c
N
N
p
n
c
coO
N
N
\
\
c-I
0
0
E
—
m
i
_
3
O
71
Y
N
>
O
0
•j
IL
0
m
p
O
v
C
j
>
N
p
00
aj
0
ro
00
0�
N
j
N
Q
—
N
f6
O
f6
a
•f6
N
o
Q
>
pOp
0
>
-O
>
aJ
4)
r
LL
sue+
U
-O
LL
f6
(D
W
—
u
m
0
N
J
7
Y
u
N
v
3
u�
v
na
°�°
Y
a
6
o
a
M
m
in
a)
0
LL
K
—
0
c
m
u
0
u
0
nn
2
u
a)
a
V
0
Y
p W
V n
O vl
tlA
c
O
N
003
.E
u
a
r,
(0
E
K
M^
N
C O
b
oN
d
m '�-
o
v
� c
O
>_
m @
4!
0
aj
bD O
c
Ln
N
(7
a N
Q-m
F
m
O �
x n
v
a
�
Q
E Y
O 00
E
s
E>
w m
a
c
Z
@ 3
jn
aJ
f6
00
0
N
K
C a
n3 N
m
* t
Y
f+
U
GJ
�0fa
L 4-J
a M
S= �
0 3
Z; 0
,w E
G 4J
L
E-W
N
M
l�
i N
L O
� N
•� M L/1
CU
c1
>r
(/pep/ui) uollelldl:)aad
N
•�
O@C
O O O
O O O
NO
�O v
O O O
O1
O
O
C
YO
00 to �
N
O -1
N
5 E -
E V
v c O
'
0
T Q Y
! v
W 'n W C
1
N
- E
0) "O O
1
vOi
j aV+ C w
1
0
C O • -CM
1
O @ E
1
>
0)
r1i
O C 0
1
N
W
0 n
2 C m N
1
' I
1
0
v 3 P
Ot
I
V +' V
1 1 1
i
N
Z Q\i 0 c"o
�I
I
O
1
1
I
0
1
1I
1 1
C
o v
1 L
, 11
' 1
'
'
I
I --I
N
O
•a+
f6 •�'
> O
1 11
I
4
v u
W
; 11
9
1 I
1
Ol
N
U1
a
'
1 1
00
0k0 Y
o o^
11
0
I
1
11
\
0
1
4
rn
'
1
I�
N
o
N
; •
o
o\
rna,
>
I I
�
LJJ U
11
1
t
c �
m rM
II
i
i 1
rn
,
'
II
Lr)
1 I
1
'I•
O
-
II
'
1
1
i 1
1
In
O z
w
1
O
• \
O
1 11
1 it
'
1 1
a
w
c-I
N 0
1 1
o N
11
No
' •
' �1•
,
N
\
1
1
; 1
i
11
N
M
�i� 0
0
O
' (
I
1
1
ran
> ,�
J •,�
1 1
I
1
�
Y
f6
1 1
'
N
O
ra
O
�
N
M 00 M
00
M
O O
O
O
(11) u01jeA@13
c-I
N
c
ON
N
\
O
00
00
M
01
�t
01
m
M
N
N
N
>
C7
\
M
\
O
O
O
m
G
3
E
-
m
i
3
O
71
Y
VI
>
.--.
Y
C
O
^
L
C
to
m
to
p
O
v
j
C
j
0
>
N
N
f�T6
p
CO
N
O
ro
-0
sue+
PI
Q
—
N
io
a
ro
a
•io
>
o
Q
aj
>
u
OOa
0
0
>
awi
-O
>
>
a,
—_
N
r
7
m
>_
m
'6
C
sue+
'6
LL
f6
(D
LJJ
—
u
0
J
7
Y
u
71
U
CZ
oa
•-
a
a
°°
v
O
LL
aaj
JO
p
c
m
U
�
U
Q
c
2
N
.O
a
V
c
Y
V In
O n
No
O
fa E
rq
Y
fa Ln
O
^
C O
v
oNm
v
Y
N
—
Y In
o
v
Y C
O
m @
G!
Y
C
N
F O
VI
N
C7
a N
F
m@
O �
2 IYn
v
a
-1
Q
E O
O O
1=
s
Y
H
4m
a
u
c
O
Z
u
o
@ 30
in
v
E
@
0
N
aaj
� v
* L
Y
4-1
cu
�0fa
L }1
a M
s= �
m 0
Ctw E
G cu
L
E n
M
C
� N
N O
i
� N
L/1
^� M^,
Y W
cu
L
(/pep/ui) uoilelidi:)aad
v
bD
O
o
O
O
O
O 0 0 0
0
0 E
o
O-1
° O
Q
�-i
00 l0 -zT N
O
ci
N
Y
O N N
O
N
O \
N O
1
w
T, O N
1
O
F
1 1
.v
v@ o
\
v
1 1 1
c-I
1� 1
O
1
N
000
1 1 I
\
�
O
� I
1
1
1
1 I
0000
c
U
1 I I
a0 t
1
I I I
N
a0 0
O O
I
o
i
1
; I
1 1
I
00
i
.I
1
i
1
1 1 I
c-I
o
1 Irq
O
rn
C
O
1 I
^
> C
1
1 I
1 1
a1
M
1
I I
ci
w
i
I�1
V
1
1
I
N
O
N
— a
(n
1
1
11
N r6
\ o
Y
:
m
ra O
V
m M
1
1
1
�I 11
l0
I
1 I
o
i
1
fn
—
�
11
v
1
1
1 1 I
11
ci
o �
a
j
i I�
O
v
W C
1
1
1 1
)
O
w
z
1
N
N O
1 1
0
1
1
i
c-I
1
1
1
I 1 I
c-I
1 I
I
O
Ir
N
fn
1
1
o
J r6
1
1 1
ra
1
1 I
m
c-I
1
1
1 1
1 1 1 I
I
1
1
1
1 I I I
�
N
1
All
1
1
O
N
00 Il
l0
LPI V M N -I c-I Ol 00
cI
\
ci c-I
c-I
c-I c-I c-I c-I c-I 0) O O
O
O O
c-I c-I
c-I
O O O O O O `1 O O
c-I c-I c-I c-I c-I c-I c-I
(11) u01jena13
c-I
M
c
N
q
N
O
OM
M
O
n
l0
v
v(Di
m
-
N
•--�
•--�
•--�
00
ci
O
N
-
O
}
C7
\
rn
\
O
O
O
0
0
E
—
m
i
_
3
O
71
Y
N
.--.
C
0
^
LL
0
to
to
p
O
v•
j
C
j
>
N
r�Ta
p
00
UJ
0
ra
00
0
N
j
PI
Q
—
N
is
O
ra
a
•ia
>
o
Q
w
n°n
0>
awi
0
v
n
v—
v
a
r(D
0
'0
Y
w
ro
w
r}a
v
u
n
3
0
�
aA
cmY
_
p
YO
Co
N
0
LL
aUi
p
C
m
Uaj
is
0
u
0
on
2
y
a)
0
a
V
Y
0
0
V N
O vl
N
ci
oN
W
7 E
m
ci
O
4
oo
t
(D r,
N
^
C O
a
UFa
Y
O
N
3 O
m @
al
c
v
F o
VI
N
(7
a N
- =
m@
2 v�
-
a)
4
Q
E Y
00
E
s
Y
>
m
a
4
U
c
7
Z
U
a
N 30
N
N
6
N
@
O
v
c g
LL
ra N
* L
Y
I
Appendix E
Project Timeline and Contact Info
Table 11. Project Activity and Reporting History
Table 12. Project Contacts Table
Table 11. Project Activity and Reporting History
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project (NCDMS Project No. 100086)
Elapsed Time Since grading complete: 1 yrs 7 months
Elapsed Time Since planting complete: 1 yrs 7 months
Number of reporting Years': 2
Activity or Deliverable
Data Collection
Complete
Completion or
Delivery
Institution Date
--Jun-18
404 permi date
--_____7eb-20
Final Mitigation Plan
2018 - 2019
Dec-19
Final Design — Construction Plans
--
Feb-20
Site Earthwork
March - April 2020
Apr-20
Bare -root plantings
--
Apr-20
As -built Survey
May-20
May-20
As -built Baseline Monitoring Report
May-20
Jul-20
Year 1 Monitoring
Nov-20
Nov-20
Supplemental Bare -root plantings
--
Mar-21
Year 2 Monitoring
Oct-21
Nov-21
Year 3 Monitoring
2022
Nov-22
Year 4 Monitoring
2023
Nov-23
Year 5 Monitoring
2024
Nov-24
Year 6 Monitoring
2025
Nov-25
Year 7 Monitoring
1 2026
1 Nov-26
1 = The number of reports or data points produced excluding the baseline
Appendix E
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project ECOSYSTEM
PLANNING &
DMS # 100086 RESTORATION
Table 12. Project Contacts Table
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project (NCDMS Project No. 100086)
Designer
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration, PLLC
1150 SE Maynard Road, Suite 140, Cary, NC 27511
Primary project design POC
Kevin Tweedy, PE (919) 388-0787
Construction Contractor
North State Environmental
2889 Lowery St, Winston-Salem, NC 27101
Construction contractor POC
Darrell Westmoreland
Survey Contractor
Kinder Land Surveying
203 W. Lebanon St., Mount Airy, NC 27030
Survey contractor POC
Frank Kinder (336) 783-4200
Planting Contractor
North State Environmental
2889 Lowery St, Winston-Salem, NC 27101
Planting contractor POC
Darrell Westmoreland
Seeding Contractor
North State Environmental
2889 Lowery St, Winston-Salem, NC 27101
Contractor POC
Darrell Westmoreland
Seed Mix Source
Green Resource, Colfax, NC
336-855-6363
Nursery Stock Supplier
Dykes and Son Nursery, McMinnville, TN
931-668-8833
Live Stake Supplier
Foggy Mountain Nursery, Lansing, NC
336-384-5323
Monitoring Performers
Ecosystem Planning and Restoration, PLLC
Stream Monitoring POC
Jake Byers, EPR (828) 348-8580
Vegetation Monitoring POC
Amy James, EPR (919) 388-0787
Appendix E
Greenbrier Stream Mitigation Project ECOSYSTEM
PLANNING &
DMS # 100086 RESTORATION